Upload
gopinath
View
261
Download
5
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
International Review of Psychiatry, June 2009; 21(3): 218–223
Malayalam cinema and mental health
KORAVANGATTU VALSRAJ MENON1 & GOPINATH RANJITH2
1Department of Psychiatry, East London NHS Foundation Trust, London, and 2Department of Liaison Psychiatry,
St. Thomas’ Hospital, South London and Maudsley Foundation Trust, London, United Kingdom
AbstractThere is a tradition of using films to teach various aspects of psychiatry and we feel that Malayalam cinema can also be usedsuitably to teach effectively. These films can be an invaluable resource in cultural competency training as they depict theeffects of culture on psychopathology and cultural and regional influences on attitudes to mental illness and stigma. We alsonote that the portrayal is often far from reality but this is not a barrier for using the films as an effective alternative totraditional and didactic teaching methods. This method of teaching can stimulate interest and discussion and demystify themyths of novice students and others about mental health.
Kerala and Malayalam cinema
Kerala is the southern-most state of India. The state
has a population of 31.8 million. Malayalam is the
official language of the state of Kerala and the people
are referred to as Keralites or Malayalis. Malayalam
is a Dravidian language and is spoken predominantly
in the state of Kerala but a large population of
Malayalis live outside Kerala in other Indian states as
well as around the globe – particularly large groups of
Malayali diasporas are found in the Middle East,
North America, Western Europe and Australia. They
form their own communities in these places and a
popular form of entertainment is watching films in
Malayalam.
Malayalam cinema refers to films made in the
Indian state of Kerala in Malayalam. Malayalam
cinema forms a small but significant component of
Indian cinema and films have been produced since
the late 1920s. Currently there are between fifty and
hundred films released per year. Cinema is a popular
form of entertainment. Malayalam films have a wide
overseas distribution. These films are also easily
available as video, CD or DVD at south Indian
outlets and can be viewed on the Internet and other
regional subscription TV channels which are also
freely available across the globe.
Mental illness and Malayalam cinema
There has been a tradition of portraying mentally ill
patients and mental health professionals in movies
from the early part of last century (Gabbard &
Gabbard, 1999). This is true of Indian films
including ones in Malayalam. There is also an
impression that the portrayal changes with time and
is dependent on the year of release, suggesting that it
is influenced by the social, cultural, political and
economic context (Bhugra, 2005). Malayalam
cinema is known for tackling social issues and is
more realistic than the formulaic nature of commer-
cial films in Hindi popularly called Bollywood. Even
when some of the Malayalam movies portraying
mental illness are based on successful Hollywood
movies, they have been remade with suitable
adaptations to fit in with the regional cultural
context.
Psychiatric educators have long advocated teach-
ing psychiatry through cinema and we feel that
Malayalam cinema can also be suitably used to teach
effectively. In addition to points generally made
elsewhere and in other articles in this issue there may
be specific instances when Malayalam films may
prove useful:
1. In teaching undergraduate and postgraduate
students in Kerala aspects of psychiatric pre-
sentations, attitudes, etc. Most of the teaching
still relies on textbooks and teaching material
prepared in the west; the use of clips from
Malayalam films would provide a local flavour
and facilitate the educational process.
2. In areas where there are large Malayali dia-
sporas these films may be used to educate local
staff about issues related to mental health
Correspondence: Dr Gopinath Ranjith, Consultant Liaison Psychiatrist, Adamson Centre, St. Thomas’ Hospital, Westminster Bridge Road, London, SE1
7EH, UK. Tel: þ44 (0)20 7188 6008. Fax: þ44 (0)20 7188 6020. E-mail: [email protected]
ISSN 0954–0261 print/ISSN 1369–1627 online � 2009 Institute of Psychiatry
DOI: 10.1080/09540260902748043
Int R
ev P
sych
iatr
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
re.c
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Win
dsor
on
07/0
2/14
For
pers
onal
use
onl
y.
presentations, attitudes and beliefs in the
community.
3. These films could be used in public education
campaigns both in Kerala and in Malayali
communities elsewhere.
4. Malayalam films could prove handy in cultural
psychiatry seminars and cultural sensitivity
training.
The films we describe in this article may be used in
a variety of ways to suit the learning needs of the
target audience. Clips may be used to illustrate
points made in an educational lecture, scenes may be
used to facilitate a group discussion and an entire
film may be viewed before-hand and discussed in a
seminar. For teaching, the fact that the depiction of
psychiatric patients and professionals are often not
realistic is not a major problem as in such clips can be
used effectively to stimulate a small group discussion.
Methodology
We identified the films that portray mental illness by
contacting various experts by telephone, e-mail
correspondence and personal interview. We also
went through website links to get complete listings of
films and we then discussed with experts and chose
the films that depict mental illness. We also did a
literature search to identify any articles on
Malayalam cinema and mental illness.
We looked at the portrayal of mental illness,
mental health professionals, mental health institu-
tions, treatment modalities and issues relating to
stigma and discrimination. Our aim in this paper is
not to provide a comprehensive review of all films
that depict these issues. Instead we discuss films that,
in our opinion, best illustrate the issues that we
discuss in greater detail below. Our primary aim has
been to choose films and clips that could most
effectively be used as teaching tools. The films are
listed in the Appendix.
Portrayal of mental illness
Film makers are interested in delving into the depths
of a character, and mental illnesses provide an ideal
vehicle to do so. Malayalam film makers, like their
counterparts elsewhere, have made abundant use of
characters with mental illnesses as well as psychia-
trists. The portrayals do not always fit in with
psychiatrists’ notions of mental illness but may
reflect lay perceptions. In this section we look at
how films understand the development of mental
illness and their manifestation.
Thaniyavarthanam (Exact Repetition, 1987) the
illness is shown as hereditary, but this does not
necessarily imply a medical explanatory model or
treatment. The family and the entire village are
convinced beyond doubt that it is the result of a curse
from the goddess and is treated with religious ritual
and ceremonies. There is tension between the old
and new generation in a joint family with regard to
the customs, traditions, superstitious beliefs and the
belief in a religious cure. This film is a good example
of societal and familial influences on the develop-
ment and course of mental illnesses. Other films that
take a more psychological approach to aetiology seem
to subscribe to the notion of a single traumatic event
as responsible for the mental illness – good examples
are Ulladakkam (Content, 1991), where witnessing
her boyfriend’s brutal murder is the precipitating
event of the illness in the female lead character, and
Thalavattam (Circle of Rhythm, 1986) where the
death of the hero’s fiancee brings on the onset of the
mental illness. Aham (Self, 1992) stands out in this
respect by emphasizing a more rounded formulation
and may be described as an intensive case study –
childhood emotional deprivation and pre-morbid
personality traits are shown as predisposing to
delusional jealousy. The possession state of Ganga
in Manichitrathazhu (The Ornate Lock, 1993) is also
traced to a childhood characterized by parental
neglect.
We have noted that even for the movies released in
the last two decades directors prefer to stick to
stereotypes of portraying mental illness – one of the
commonest stereotypes is the patient who behaves in
hospital as if he were in his previous role. Examples
from Ulladakkam are the railway station master who
continues to wave his flag to stop trains and the
school headmistress who behaves as if others in the
hospital are her pupils. Even when the depiction of
the main character with mental illness is sympathetic
the bizarre behaviour of other patients are shown to
elicit cheap laughs from the audience. This corre-
sponds to the description of psychiatric patients as
zoo specimens (Hyler, Gabbard, & Schneider, 1991).
It is not clear whether such portrayals are a result of
the film makers’ lack of awareness of mental illness or
the need to give primacy to entertainment.
Psychopathology and diagnosis
The depiction of psychiatric symptoms, particularly
those not reflected in outward behaviour, has always
been problematic for film makers. Violence and
aggression are usually the main features of the
mental illness rather than symptoms such as delusions,
depression or anxiety. In films such as Ulladakkam and
Aham the patient, under the influence of a mental
illness, commits homicide. Films depicting a normal
person being labelled as mentally ill have been a staple
of Hollywood and it is Thaniyavarthanam where the
attached label becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. The
Malayalam cinema and mental health 219
Int R
ev P
sych
iatr
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
re.c
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Win
dsor
on
07/0
2/14
For
pers
onal
use
onl
y.
thin line between sanity and insanity is also the theme
of many films with the psychiatrist in Sesham
repeatedly referring to the patients as suffering from
distress rather than mental illness. Psychiatric symp-
toms shown in Malayalam films include hallucinations
(Aham), obsessions and compulsions (Aham), psycho-
genic amnesia (Innale-Yesterday, 1989), delusional
jealousy (Vadakkunokkiyanthram-Compass, 1989).
Culture has a pathoplastic effect on the expression
of psychiatric symptoms, and films made in non-
western contexts may be a good way of teaching
cultural differences. The fascination of western film
makers with dissociative disorders such as multiple
personality disorders in films such as The Three Faces
of Eve and Sybil has been much commented upon.
Manichitrathazhu depicts a dissociative disorder that
is not uncommon in that part of the world –
possession syndrome (Somasundaram, Thivakaran,
& Bhugra, 2007). There are scenes depicting self-
harm and suicide in films: self-harm by self-lacera-
tion and head banging are shown in Ulladakkam and
Sesham (Thereafter, 2002) respectively and Aham
ends with the main character committing suicide by
hanging. A homicide-suicide is depicted in
Thaniyavarthanam with the mother poisoning the
son who is labelled mentally unwell to relieve his
suffering and later ending her life; in Thalavattam it
is the friendly psychiatrist who performs the act of
mercy killing on the patient who has been made
comatose by psychosurgery.
Diagnoses used in films often do not correspond
with psychiatrists’ ideas or diagnostic manuals
(Hyler, 1988). In Vadakkumnathan (The Lord of
the North, 2006) the diagnosis of the main character
played by Mohanlal is supposed to be bipolar
disorder but apart from irritability and impulsive
aggression no characteristic symptoms of mania or
depression is shown. ‘Sea phobia’ is mentioned as
the diagnosis of the female patient in Ulladakkam,
but the behaviour and symptoms suggest a psychotic
rather than a neurotic disorder. Similarly possession
state is mentioned as a diagnosis in Manichitrathazhu
but conversations between the psychiatrist and the
traditional healer refers to a psychotic disorder. From
a psychiatric point of view the diagnosis of
Sidharthan in Aham might be considered to be
anakastic personality disorder with symptoms of
obsessive-compulsive disorder with the gradual
development of a psychotic disorder characterized
by auditory hallucinations and delusional jealousy. In
Sesham it is unclear if the main character has a
mental illness or lacks daily living skills as a result of
being institutionalized.
There are instances where films perform an
important role in drawing attention to a neglected
disease or disorder (Rao & Krishna, 2008). The
demographic changes associated with Kerala
have resulted in a life expectancy of about 75.
Epidemiological research has shown that dementia is
likely to be a major problem in Kerala but people
often consider it a natural part of the ageing process
(Shaji, Bose, & Verghese, 2005). In this context the
film Thanmatra (Molecule, 2005) which has a
sympathetic portrayal of a middle-class family
coping with early onset dementia in the bread
winner is likely to increase awareness about this
disease and perhaps lead to more resources for
psychosocial care. Scenes from this film are ideal for
public education sessions.
Mental health professionals
In most of the Malayalam movies the key mental health
professional is the consultant psychiatrist. The other
professionals shown are nurses and other auxiliary staff,
but their role seems confined to carrying out the
instructions of the psychiatrist. One good example is
Nurse Rachel in Thalavattam who, though clearly
modelled on Nurse Ratched from One Flew Over the
Cuckoo’s Nest, is a much less scary and authoritarian
character perhaps reflecting the role of nurses in the
traditional hospital hierarchy. Schneider, in the context
of Hollywood films, classified the portrayal of psychia-
trists in films as Dr Dippy, Dr Evil and Dr Wonderful
(Schneider, 1987). In Malayalam cinema we also note
the presence of a Dr Saviour who is desperate to save
the patient, in the process becoming emotionally
entangled. The best example of Dr Wonderful is the
psychiatrist played by Mohanlal in Ulladakkam. The
psychiatrist played by the same actor in
Manichitrathazhu may be described as a combination
of Dr Dippy and Dr Wonderful. Both these films also
perpetuate the notion of the psychiatrist as a detective, a
common trend in Hollywood. In the former film Dr
Wonderful’s image is built up by showing other
psychiatrists as rather ineffectual and looking up to
him – the scene showing him charming an aggressive
patient to give up a sharp weapon is ideal for
demonstrating to medical students and novice psychia-
trists how not to approach a dangerous patient!
Fortunately Dr Evil is not commonly encountered
in Malayalam films, the only exception being the
hospital director in Thalavattam. This film has three
psychiatrists, giving viewers a chance to compare and
contrast them. Dr Unnikrishnan is certainly
Dr Good if not quite Dr Wonderful and the female
psychiatrist is shown as an over-involved Dr Saviour.
It is also pertinent to note that when a female
psychiatrist makes a rare appearance the only inter-
vention she can offer is love. This may say something
about prevailing gender stereotypes.
There are several interesting observations in
general. Psychiatrists are mostly shown as well-
intentioned except in the examples shown above of
220 K. V. Menon & G. Ranjith
Int R
ev P
sych
iatr
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
re.c
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Win
dsor
on
07/0
2/14
For
pers
onal
use
onl
y.
the evil psychiatrist. When not played by one of the
main actors they are generally benevolent but
unspectacular characters. The popular perception
of psychiatrists as oddballs often finds mention
in Ulladakkam. The psychiatrist’s mother says
‘I shouldn’t have let you become a mind doctor’.
The viewers are invited to consider the antics of the
psychiatrist in Manichitrathazhu as an understand-
able part of his profession. In Sesham the film maker
tells the psychiatrist that the local public considers
him as mad as his patients. Such scenes could be
used to stimulate medical students to discuss
attitudes to the profession and to dispel myths.
Ulladakkam also examines the effects of a patient’s
violent behaviour on a psychiatrist. The psychiatrist
has shut himself off from society for seven years after
the murder of his wife on their wedding day by his
patient and is only able to move on once he has
forgiven her.
While most films with a central mentally ill
character depict a psychiatrist, there are some
exceptions. Professor Bharatha Pisharody, the char-
acter played by Mohanlal, in Vadakkumnathan is
shown as having received psychiatric treatment in the
past, but psychiatrists don’t make an appearance in
the film. Instead an Ayurvedic expert on mental
health is consulted for herbal medicines and advice.
It is common in Kerala context for patients to receive
traditional and modern treatments simultaneously.
In Thaniyavarthanam this is played out as a clash of
generations – the patient’s brother initates a consul-
tation with a psychiatrist while his uncle and older
relatives arrange religious rituals.
Boundary violations are as common in Malayalam
films as they are in Hollywood movies (Gharaibeh,
2005). In Ulladakkam the psychiatrist played by
Mohanlal admits his friend’s sister to his hospital and
treats her. He also goes beyond the call of duty and
spends a lot of time with her, though to the director’s
credit this issue is addressed by the senior psychia-
trist in the hospital. But the words used by the senior
psychiatrist, ‘You can be sympathetic but not
empathetic to your patient’, do not make much
sense. Transference is also explicitly mentioned in
the context of a conversation between the psychiatrist
and his fiancee. An even more serious boundary
violation happens in Thalavattam where the female
psychiatrist played by Karthika falls in love with the
patient she manages to cure. It is disturbing that the
senior colleague who supervises the treatment
accepts this state of affairs without censure.
Ethical issues related to consent and confidenti-
ality are also raised by other films such as Sesham in
which a student film-maker is shooting a diploma
film in a psychiatric hospital and in Aham in which a
psychiatrist hands over the tapes of a hypnosis
session to a researcher without the patient’s consent.
In the latter film the patient complains to the
psychiatrist that he had no right to do this.
Mental health institutions
Mental hospitals in films such as Thalavattam and
Sesham are depicted as large asylums with patients
wearing hospital clothes with a number. This may
just be a reflection of reality as large mental hospitals
still exist in the state sector in Kerala. In Thalavattam
the mental hospital is shown as a sinister place with
routine physical abuse of patients. There are other
more positive portrayals as well: in Aham the hospital
is a rehabilitation centre run by the Church and
patients are shown participating in a variety of
activities. The central character Sidhartha Swamy
has his own space with a private library. In
Ulladakkam patients are not generally locked up
and patients do spend time in music, outdoor
activities and go on short day trips. Patients leave
the hospital when they are better, thus conveying a
positive message about prognosis and recovery.
Sesham specifically addresses the issue of deinsti-
tutionalization. The central female character, a
student film maker, is challenged about her social
commitment by her fiance. Realizing that she needs
to do more than just make a film about mentally ill
people, she embarks on a project to rehabilitate one
of the inmates of the psychiatric hospital in the
community. In the end the patient is seen as
returning to the hospital conveying the message
that society is not ready yet to accommodate people
with mental illness. This film may be used in mass
education campaigns.
Many films give erroneous impressions of the
functioning of a psychiatric hospital. In Ulladakkam
the use of Rorschach inkblots (or a cinema version) is
shown as a routine interview technique used by a
psychiatrist in making a diagnosis. Techniques such
as hypnosis and drug-assisted interviewing used
rarely by psychiatrists are shown as routine and
mainstream techniques. The psychiatrist in
Manichitrathazhu comes to a diagnosis on the basis
of ‘psychic vibrations’. Such films could be used to
challenge popular perceptions about the work done
by psychiatrists.
Psychiatric treatments
In most films reviewed in this article psychiatric
disorders are depicted as treatable and various
treatments are shown, though there are some
exceptions. In Aham the nun running the rehabili-
tation centre states that in her centre the only
treatment given was ‘love therapy’. Administration
of psychiatric medications, as well as a common
problem on psychiatric wards, non-compliance with
Malayalam cinema and mental health 221
Int R
ev P
sych
iatr
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
re.c
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Win
dsor
on
07/0
2/14
For
pers
onal
use
onl
y.
medications, is handled with some humour in
Thalavattam. The effect of the medications is usually
to turn the patient into a ‘zombie’ – in
Thaniyavarthanam a mother is shown sobbing
uncontrollably on seeing the physical appearance of
her son who has just returned from a psychiatric
hospital. Herbal medications are prescribed by an
Ayurvedic practitioner in Vadakkumnathan.
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a favourite of
film makers worldwide, and the situation is the same
in India as well (Bhugra, 2006). Except Thalavattam
where ECT is used as a punitive treatment, in other
films such as Ulladakkam, Thaniyavarthanam and
Vadakkunokkiyanthram it is essentially therapeutic.
The objection, from a psychiatric point of view, is
that the indication for ECT is always aggression and
violence while in actual practice it is indicated in
severe depression and catatonia. In fact one would
walk away with the message that the only treatment
in the armamentarium of psychiatrists for aggression
is ECT. ECT is often shown as being given in an
unmodified form. Though it is given under anaes-
thesia in most hospitals there are still hospitals where
unmodified ECT is given (Andrade, 2003).
Psychosurgery, rarely used in contemporary psychia-
try, is shown as a punitive treatment.
While psychosocial factors are often mentioned as
causative factors sophisticated psychological treat-
ments are conspicuous by their absence in
Malayalam cinema. Cure is often instantaneous and
miraculous and occurs on uncovering the trauma. In
Thalavattam the attention and time lavished by the
female psychiatrist cures the hero, while in
Ulladakkam uncovering the trauma through abreac-
tion does the trick. Treatment of a phobia of water by
exposure to the sea (flooding in a literal sense!) in the
latter film is perhaps closer to reality. The most
dramatic cure is effected in Manichitrathazhu where
the psychiatrist collaborates with a faith healer to
recreate a historic scene where the heroine Ganga is
cured of her dissociative disorder once the alter
Nagavalli is tricked into thinking that she has
murdered her tormentor.
Stigma and discrimination
Many films show how having a mental illness results
in social stigma and discrimination towards the
mentally ill. In Vadakkumnathan the patient’s angry
outburst results in his sister’s arranged marriage
proposal being disrupted. In the end the bride-
groom’s family agrees to the marriage on condition
that the patient does not attend the wedding
ceremony. The effect of having a brother with a
mental illness on his sister’s marriage prospects leads
to the family concealing the existence of the mentally
ill person in Thaniyavarthanam. This may be a new
experience for western audiences who are used to
stigmatizing attitudes at an individual level, and
sensitizes them to considering stigma at the level of
the family (Littlewood, Jadhav, & Ryder, 2007). The
effects of mental illness on marital relationships
may have elements specific to cultures where
arranged marriages are the norm. Two films,
Thaniyavarthanam and Vadakkunokkiyanthram show
the wife being supportive of the husband, but her
family forcing her to leave him. In the former the
wife’s father says, ‘I don’t want my grandchildren to
grow up as the children of a mad man’.
Another film that depicts discriminatory attitudes
towards the mentally ill very well is Sesham.
Lonappan, having left the mental hospital, is put up
in her flat by the film-maker heroine. The members of
the housing association want him removed as he
accidentally caused two children to fall off a see-saw in
the playground. Later, when he gets a job in a school,
the members of the parent-teacher association force
the head teacher to sack him, calling him ‘mad’. That
even doctors are not immune to holding stigmatizing
attitudes is brought home by the scene in Ulladakkam,
where the patient’s brother, a doctor, is reluctant to
admit the patient to a psychiatric hospital.
It is a fact that many psychiatric hospitals have
long-stay patients who do not require hospitalization
but are there only because families refuse to accept
them back. This is forcefully stated by the psychia-
trist in Sesham. It is interesting to note that in
Thalavattam all patients wear numbered clothes and
are referred to by their number rather than their
name. Violence towards patients and unacceptable
methods of restraint are shown in many films. In
Thaniyavarthanam a chronically mentally ill patient
is shown chained in an isolated room of the house.
That such abuses of human rights still endure was
brought home by a tragedy that happened in Erwadi
in the neighbouring state of Tamil Nadu in 2001.
Twenty-seven mentally ill people who were chained
in a mental home run by a religious institution died
in an accidental fire (Sharma, 2003).
The issue of stigmatizing attitudes in movies raises
the question whether movies reflect such attitudes
prevailing in society or contribute to it. The answer is
most likely a combination of the above. Scenes
portraying stigma and discrimination force viewers to
confront and examine their own attitudes to mental
illness. On the other hand, films that equate mental
illness with odd and eccentric behaviour may per-
petuate such attitudes, preventing people from
accessing help in times of distress.
Conclusion
Most discussions of cinema and mental health have
so far concentrated on Hollywood films and
222 K. V. Menon & G. Ranjith
Int R
ev P
sych
iatr
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
re.c
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Win
dsor
on
07/0
2/14
For
pers
onal
use
onl
y.
European cinema and the research being done on
cinema from other parts of the world is encouraging
(Bhugra, 2005). In this article we have concentrated
on Malayalam cinema and examined its usefulness in
teaching in a variety of settings. Some of the findings
are universal in that depictions of psychiatric ill-
nesses, psychiatric professionals and psychiatric
treatments are far from reality. This need not
necessarily be a drawback in using movies as teaching
tools, as such distorted views are prevalent among lay
people as well as students new to psychiatry. Films
may thus be a very effective way of engaging
students, tapping into these attitudes and attempting
to educate them.
Given the globalized nature of today’s psychiatric
practice, it is incumbent on all practitioners to be
culturally competent. Films are a valuable resource
in cultural competence training (Lim, Diamond,
Chang, Primm, & Lu, 2008). We have identified
culture-specific issues in the films under review
including the influence of culture on psychopathol-
ogy, clashes between traditional and modern views
on healing practices and the influence of joint
families and arranged marriages on attitudes to
mental illness and stigma. We hope our review will
spur psychiatric educators to use Malayalam films in
teaching sessions.
Declaration of interest: The authors report no
conflicts of interest. The authors alone are respon-
sible for the content and writing of the paper. Both
authors are from Kerala and now reside in London.
References
Andrade, C. (2003). Unmodified ECT: Ethical issues. Indian
Journal of Medical Ethics, 11, 9–10.
Bhugra, D. (2005). Mad tales from Bollywood: The impact of
social, political, and economic climate on the portrayal of
mental illness in Hindi films. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica,
112, 250–256.
Gabbard, G. O., & Gabbard, K. (1999). Psychiatry and the
cinema - second edition. Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric
Press.
Gharaibeh, N. M. (2005). The psychiatrist’s image in commer-
cially available American movies. Acta Psychiatrica
Scandinavica, 111, 316–319.
Hyler, S. E. (1988). DSM-III at the cinema: Madness in the
movies. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 29, 195–206.
Hyler, S. E., Gabbard, G. O., & Schneider, I. (1991). Homicidal
maniacs and narcissistic parasites: Stigmatization of mentally ill
persons in the movies. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 42,
1044–1048.
Lim, R. F, Diamond, R. J., Chang, J. B., Primm, A. B., & Lu, F.
G. (2008). Using non-feature films to teach diversity, cultural
competence, and the DSM-IV-TR outline for cultural formu-
lation. Academic Psychiatry, 32, 291–298.
Littlewood, R., Jadhav, S., & Ryder, A. G. (2007). A cross-
national study of the stigmatization of severe psychiatric illness:
Historical review, methodological considerations and develop-
ment of the questionnaire. Transcultural Psychiatry, 44,
171–202.
Rao, T. S. S., & Krishna, V. S. T. (2008). Wake up call from
‘Stars on the Ground’. Indian Journal of Psychiatry, 50, 2–4.
Schneider, I. (1987). The theory and practice of movie psychiatry.
American Journal of Psychiatry, 144, 996–1002.
Shaji, S., Bose, S., & Verghese, A. (2005). Prevalence of dementia
in an urban population in Kerala, India. British Journal of
Psychiatry, 186, 136–140.
Sharma, S. (2003). Human rights of mental patients in India:
A global perspective. Current Opinion in Psychiatry, 16,
547–551.
Somasundaram, D., Thivakaran, T., & Bhugra, D. (2008).
Possession states in Northern Sri Lanka. Psychopathology, 41,
245–253.
Appendix: List of films discussed in the
article.
Film Year Director
Thalavattam 1986 Priyadarshan
Thaniyavarthanam 1987 Sibi Malayil
Vadakkunokkiyanthram 1989 Sreenivasan
Innale 1989 P. Padmarajan
Ulladakkam 1991 Kamal
Aham 1992 T. Rajeevnath
Manichitrathazhu 1993 Fazil
Sesham 2002 Rajeev Kumar
Thanmatra 2005 Blessy
Vadakkumnathan 2006 Shajoon Kariyal
Malayalam cinema and mental health 223
Int R
ev P
sych
iatr
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
re.c
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Win
dsor
on
07/0
2/14
For
pers
onal
use
onl
y.