2
Vaclav Smil I n July 1853, Commodore Matthew Perry’s small flotilla cast its anchors off Uraga at the entrance to Edo (Tokyo) Bay. Its mission was to end Japan’s quarter of a millennium of isolation under the Toku- gawa shogunate. The black ships returned the next spring, when Perry signed the treaty. The shogunate was persuaded not just by the ships’ large guns but also by the demonstrations of American technical superiority that included the telegraph and a miniature steam locomotive. Mission accomplished, Perry returned bearing samples of Japanese products. As well as the predictable silks, lacquer boxes and exquisite porcelain, these included white and red soy beans. Several months later the US Patent Office was offering the seeds to American farmers, but there were few takers. Three decades later, Lewis Sturtevant noted in his exhaustive survey of edible plants that soy beans had begun to appear as a novelty item in US seed catalogues. In China their cultivation is ancient: nearly 5,000 years ago the legendary Emper- or Shennong made soy beans the only legume of his five life-sustaining grains, and millennia of culinary evolution have pro- duced an enormous range of soy-based foodstuffs throughout East and Southeast Asia. Immature pods are eaten as a vegetable. Mature seeds are sprouted or milled to make flour. Protein in milled soy beans can be pre- cipitated by coagulants, usually calcium and magnesium sulphate, to make bean curd — Japanese tofu and Chinese dòufu. Seeds are ground or boiled and then fermented to pre- pare soy sauces and pastes such as Japanese miso and natto and Indonesian tempeh. And the seeds, which are nearly 20% lipids, make an excellent cooking oil consisting of 85% unsaturated fatty acids. Modern processing has also added an array of flavoured drinks to traditional soy bean milk. The West was slow to adopt soy beans: in the 1920s American farmers still devoted more land to sweet potatoes. Soy beans final- ly took off in the 1930s, but it was the pros- perity following the Second World War, with its rising demand for cheaper meat, that made them a major crop. Corn has only 10% protein, but most soy bean cultivars have about 36%, nearly twice as much as other legumes. Mixtures of corn, a high-yielding source of carbohydrates, and highly pro- teinaceous (44%) soy bean meal, produced by first extracting oil with organic solvents, have come to dominate feeding formulas around the world. American cattle, German broilers, Japanese pigs — and Chinese carp — all yield more meat thanks to Glycine max. The US soy bean harvest passed 10 million tonnes (Mt) in the early 1950s. It is now 70–75 Mt a year — almost half of the global total. Soy beans are the country’s second most valuable crop, close behind corn and worth nearly three times as much as wheat, and grow on more than 15% of all arable land. Brazilian production, geared to exports, has grown even faster. The area planted with soy beans has expanded more than 60-fold since the late 1950s; Brazil now produces about 30 Mt. Argentina harvests about half as much as this, relegating the Chinese harvest to fourth place. The Japanese now grow a mere 3% of what they consume. Boiled tofu served in the temple precincts of Kyoto’s Higashiyama or tofu-based nouvelle cuisine in Tokyo’s Ginza now come from seeds harvested, and often organically grown, in Iowa or North Carolina. The symbiotic relationship between soy beans and the Rhizobium bacteria in nodules attached to the plant’s roots can provide as much as 100 kg of nitrogen per hectare per year. So it may come as a surprise to learn that at least a fifth of the US crop now regularly receives nitrogen fertilizers. This is because a higher proportion of the biomass of modern cultivars is in the seed, which is removed from the field. So, even with minimal losses to leaching or erosion, more nitrogen is extracted than is fixed by bacteria. In con- trast, Brazilian soy beans receive no extra nitrogen. Perhaps the most important envi- ronmental downside of soy beans’ rise is that, as with all other crops grown in rows, their cultivation can lead to higher soil erosion. The world’s diet is unthinkable without soy beans, but they remain a fringe foodstuff in the West. Only soy sauce has become a uni- versal condiment — bean curd, although readily available, is still a culinary oddity. A change would serve women particularly well. Soy bean foods contain very high con- centrations of isoflavones, particularly genistein. These phytoestrogens can alleviate the symptoms of menopause, and their con- sumption has been linked to reduced risks of breast cancer in East Asia. Soy proteins also lower levels of blood cholesterol, and some, although not all, epidemiological studies link their intake with a reduced risk of car- diovascular diseases. Greater enthusiasm for the subtle taste of tofu could thus have highly cost-effective health benefits. Vaclav Smil is at the University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba R3T 2N2, Canada. Magic beans The Japanese invader that’s good for you. millennium essay NATURE | VOL 407 | 5 OCTOBER 2000 | www.nature.com 567 S oy beans are the second most valuable US crop, and grow on more than 15% of all arable land. Soy ahoy: the beans reached the West via Perry’s ‘black ships’, shown here arriving off Tokyo in 1853. BRITISH MUSEUM/BRIDGEMAN ART LIBRARY

Magic Beans

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Vaclav SmilPaper"Magic Beans"

Citation preview

  • Vaclav Smil

    In July 1853, Commodore MatthewPerrys small flotilla cast its anchors offUraga at the entrance to Edo (Tokyo) Bay.Its mission was to end Japans quarter of amillennium of isolation under the Toku-gawa shogunate. The black ships returnedthe next spring, when Perry signed thetreaty. The shogunate was persuaded notjust by the ships large guns but also by thedemonstrations of American technicalsuperiority that included the telegraph anda miniature steam locomotive.

    Mission accomplished, Perry returnedbearing samples of Japanese products. Aswell as the predictable silks, lacquer boxesand exquisite porcelain, these included whiteand red soy beans. Several months later theUS Patent Office was offering the seeds toAmerican farmers, but there were few takers.Three decades later, Lewis Sturtevant notedin his exhaustive survey of edible plants thatsoy beans had begun to appear as a noveltyitem in US seed catalogues.

    In China their cultivation is ancient:nearly 5,000 years ago the legendary Emper-or Shennong made soy beans the onlylegume of his five life-sustaining grains, andmillennia of culinary evolution have pro-duced an enormous range of soy-basedfoodstuffs throughout East and SoutheastAsia. Immature pods are eaten as a vegetable.Mature seeds are sprouted or milled to makeflour. Protein in milled soy beans can be pre-cipitated by coagulants, usually calcium andmagnesium sulphate, to make bean curd Japanese tofu and Chinese dufu. Seeds areground or boiled and then fermented to pre-pare soy sauces and pastes such as Japanesemiso and natto and Indonesian tempeh. Andthe seeds, which are nearly 20% lipids, makean excellent cooking oil consisting of 85%unsaturated fatty acids. Modern processinghas also added an array of flavoured drinks totraditional soy bean milk.

    The West was slow to adopt soy beans: inthe 1920s American farmers still devotedmore land to sweet potatoes. Soy beans final-ly took off in the 1930s, but it was the pros-perity following the Second World War, withits rising demand for cheaper meat, thatmade them a major crop. Corn has only 10%protein, but most soy bean cultivars haveabout 36%, nearly twice as much as otherlegumes. Mixtures of corn, a high-yieldingsource of carbohydrates, and highly pro-teinaceous (44%) soy bean meal, producedby first extracting oil with organic solvents,have come to dominate feeding formulas

    around the world. American cattle, Germanbroilers, Japanese pigs and Chinese carp all yield more meat thanks to Glycine max.

    The US soy bean harvest passed 10 milliontonnes (Mt) in the early 1950s. It is now 7075Mt a year almost half of the global total. Soybeans are the countrys second most valuablecrop, close behind corn and worth nearlythree times as much as wheat, and grow onmore than 15% of all arable land. Brazilianproduction, geared to exports, has growneven faster. The area planted with soy beanshas expanded more than 60-fold since the late1950s; Brazil now produces about 30 Mt.Argentina harvests about half as much as this,relegating the Chinese harvest to fourthplace. The Japanese now grow a mere 3% ofwhat they consume. Boiled tofu served in thetemple precincts of Kyotos Higashiyama ortofu-based nouvelle cuisine in Tokyos Ginzanow come from seeds harvested, and oftenorganically grown, in Iowa or North Carolina.

    The symbiotic relationship between soybeans and the Rhizobium bacteria in nodules

    attached to the plants roots can provide asmuch as 100 kg of nitrogen per hectare peryear. So it may come as a surprise to learn thatat least a fifth of the US crop now regularlyreceives nitrogen fertilizers. This is because ahigher proportion of the biomass of moderncultivars is in the seed, which is removedfrom the field. So, even with minimal lossesto leaching or erosion, more nitrogen isextracted than is fixed by bacteria. In con-trast, Brazilian soy beans receive no extranitrogen. Perhaps the most important envi-ronmental downside of soy beans rise is that,as with all other crops grown in rows, theircultivation can lead to higher soil erosion.

    The worlds diet is unthinkable withoutsoy beans, but they remain a fringe foodstuffin the West. Only soy sauce has become a uni-versal condiment bean curd, althoughreadily available, is still a culinary oddity. Achange would serve women particularlywell. Soy bean foods contain very high con-centrations of isoflavones, particularlygenistein. These phytoestrogens can alleviatethe symptoms of menopause, and their con-sumption has been linked to reduced risks ofbreast cancer in East Asia. Soy proteins alsolower levels of blood cholesterol, and some,although not all, epidemiological studieslink their intake with a reduced risk of car-diovascular diseases. Greater enthusiasm forthe subtle taste of tofu could thus have highlycost-effective health benefits. Vaclav Smil is at the University of Manitoba,Winnipeg, Manitoba R3T 2N2, Canada.

    Magic beansThe Japanese invader thats good for you.

    millennium essay

    NATURE | VOL 407 | 5 OCTOBER 2000 | www.nature.com 567

    Soy beans are thesecond mostvaluable US crop, andgrow on more than 15%of all arable land.

    Soy ahoy: the beans reached the West via Perrys black ships, shown here arriving off Tokyo in 1853.

    BR

    ITIS

    H M

    USE

    UM

    /BR

    IDG

    EM

    AN

    AR

    T L

    IBR

    AR

    Y