8
London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

London

Hong Kong

Greenwich

New York

Geneva

Milan

New Haven

University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011

Pierre Valentin

Page 2: London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

Artist’s Committees

• Heirs to the artist’s moral rights

• Berne Convention – Article 6bis

• Narrow moral rights in the UK

• Paternity

• Integrity

• Broader moral rights in other European countries

• Magritte, Belgium

• Picasso, France

• de Chirico, Italy

Page 3: London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

Artist’s Committees

• Natural heirs

• Private foundation or artist’s estate

• Henry Moore Foundation

• Bacon Estate

• Recognised experts

• Wildenstein Institute

• Rodin Committee

Page 4: London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

Kees Van Dongen

Duménil v Wildenstein Institute and Others Tribunal de Grande Instance de Paris, 16 September 1999, (unpublished)

Challenge to artist’s committees

Page 5: London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

Sir Anthony Van Dyck

Drake v Thos Agnew & Sons Ltd 2002

Page 6: London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

Taylor Lynne Thomson v Christie Manson &

Woods  

High Court 2004

Court of Appeal 2005

Page 7: London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

Egon Schiele

De Balkany v Christie Manson & Woods 1997

Page 8: London Hong Kong Greenwich New York Geneva Milan New Haven University of Columbia Kernochan Center October 28, 2011 Pierre Valentin

George Stubbs

Luxmoore-May v Messenger May Baverstock 1986