Let's Make Castables

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    1/16

    Elkem Materials Page 1

    Lets make a castable!!Bjrn Myhre

    Elkem Materials, P.O. Box 8126, Vaagsbygd, 4675 Kristiansand Norway

    Since the beginning of the 1980s, Elkem Materials has been manufacturing microsilica for refractory purposes.

    During these years, in spite of numerous attempts to link performance in castables and chemical analyses, no

    definitive correlations have been found that could replace the sometimes tedious testing of new microsilica in

    castables. Over the years the test castable developed to what we now use, a low-cement composition based on

    white fused alumina. Since our task is to test variability of components in the castable, it is a point that the

    castable should consist of well-defined ingredients from reliable suppliers.

    There are a number of decisions that have to be made before making the castable; first of all, one must decide

    what is the intention of making this castable?.

    In our case, the intention is to produce a castable in which new ingredients could be tested for performance in the

    laboratory. For us this is normally microsilica, but could just as well be one of the other ingredients, such as

    cement, calcined alumina, dispersants, etc.

    Mixing equipment:Since we like to do the testing in our laboratory, wewould probably like to use a relatively small batch

    size, e.g. 3 kg. In many castable laboratories the

    mixer equipment consists of Hobart mixers capable

    of mixing approximately 3.5 kg of dense castable.

    This is a paddle-type mixer with a revolving paddle

    that rotates at a speed determined by fixed gears.

    Normally a speed of approximately 60rpm is

    chosen. The paddle and bowl must be of stainless

    steel. Quite often the paddle is made from

    aluminium, which wears out quickly and also, moreimportantly, influences set time of the castable. So,

    use stainless steel. The size of the mixer makes use

    of particles larger than 4-5mm difficult, so the test

    mix is restricted to aggregates smaller than e.g.

    4mm by the mixer. Larger particles will jam the

    motion of the paddle and make lots of squealing

    noises when the aggregates get trapped between the

    bowl and paddle. Better avoid that

    Hobart Mixer.

    A few words about ambient conditions:

    The testing should be performed in a room with moderate temperature and humidity that should be kept as

    constant as possible. This is not essential, although it may make interpretation and comparison of the results

    easier. The components of the mix should be stored though, in this environment.

    The ingredients:We have already indicated that such a test castable should be based on reproducible and well-defined raw

    materials like white fused alumina, tabular alumina, etc. The most important parameters here are absence of

    water solubles, or at very low and constant levels, and a defined internal porosity and shape of the aggregates.

    We need several sizes of aggregates, from the top size and down to milled fractions, additionally cement,

    calcined alumina, microsilia and dispersant. Sometimes retarder or accelerator are also needed to adjust set time

    to within acceptable limits. Below follows a short description of desired characteristics and suggestions for the

    various ingredients of the test castable.

    Aggregates: Fractions from 5mm and down to 200mesh (-74micron). The aggregates should be dense and have

    a minimum amount of open porosity. Shape should approach equiaxed or rounded which will impart flow. No or

    insignificant content of leachable components is desired.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    2/16

    Elkem Materials Page 2

    Cement: This is one of the components frequently tested in such mixes. We need a reference though, and a good

    choice is to use a well-known international grade without additives from one of the major international

    manufacturers. Recommendations are Secar 71 from Kerneos and CA14M from Almatis.

    Calcined alumina: Used to fill up the gap between the milled fraction (-74micron) of the aggregate and

    microsilica which is essentially submicron. Look for particle sizes between 1-10 micron. Ease of dispersion is

    important here, so also use a well-known supplier. Almatis has some qualities that work well, like CT9FG, HVASG and CT800FG. There are also many other qualities available from other suppliers that can be used.

    Microsilica: This is another component that is commonly tested. Microsilica is the finest fraction in the castable

    make-up and is probably, together with the cement, the component that influences properties the most. More

    than 50% of the surface area of a mix is normally found originating from the microsilica. When water is added to

    the castable, microsilica and the other fine ingredients join into a liquid slurry-phase of which amount and

    properties form the origin of the desired flow-properties of the castable. The extremely small size of the

    individual microsilica particles fills voids down to nano-scale and provides proper dispersion, ensuring a castable

    with the expected properties. The state of dispersion is however extremely complex and is easily influenced by

    any impurities in the system. Any leachable component may cause the delicate balance to be disturbed and cause

    a rapid coagulation, resulting in loss of flow or even solidifying. Such loss of flow is a normal initiation of the

    setting of a castable, but is a problem when it starts at an undesired time, either too soon or too late. Here we are

    aiming to make a test castable, and need to pay particular attention to the choice of the microsilica in thereference mixture. There are only a few high-grade microsilicas commonly available, 971U from Elkem

    Materials is here the preferred choice.

    Dispersants: If microsilica and cement are mixed in an aqueous media, immediate coagulation will be seen.

    Microsilica coagulates in contact with water soluble ions like calcium and aluminate from cement. Without

    control of this coagulation, microsilica-containing, cement-bonded castables would not have been viable without

    use of excessive amounts of water. This is why we use dispersants. A well-working dispersant prevents the

    microsilica and the other fines from coagulating, but also influences setting time. Proper use of additives requires

    the correct addition level, and there is a range of additives available today that works well. Some of them are

    easily available and cheap, others are more sophisticated and more expensive. The correct dosage is somewhat

    dependent on the mixture and has to be tested individually. Good examples working in WFA-mixes with

    microsilica and high-grade cement are:

    Sodium hexametaphosphate ( approx. 0.2% by weight addition). Brand name Calgon; many producers, cheap.Polyacrylates: Darvan 811D from Vanderbilt is recommended. Approximately 0.05% by weight

    Polycarboxylate ethers : Castament FS20 from BASF gives good results at 0.05% by weight

    Other additives: Retarders are frequently necessary. One easy and good example is citric acid at levels

    1%).

    The making of a castable:When we have chosen our ingredients, it is time to compose the castable. Elkem Materials has, since the

    beginning of the 1990s, used Particle Size Distribution analyses in the making of new mixes based on new raw

    materials. The reason for doing this is that it saves us a lot of testing in the laboratory while enabling us to

    predict flow properties of the finished castable.The methodology is based on the perception that with perfect packing of the individual particles, a minimum

    amount of water is needed to make it a castable. During the last 100 years or more, quite an extensive amount of

    work has been undertaken in order to make theoretical packing models, but we have chosen to use the one that

    was proposed by Andreasseniin 1930, due to its simplicity and proven results. Below is the equation given:

    Andreassen:CPFTd

    D

    q

    =

    100

    CPFT: Cumulative Percent Finer Than

    d: Particle size

    D: maximum particle size

    q: distribution coefficient (q-value)

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    3/16

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    4/16

    Elkem Materials Page 4

    Figure 2: Screen print of the dialogue window of LISA, showing distribution to the left and recipe to the right.

    Because of a q-value of 0.25 at a top size of 4mm, this castable is, according to Figure 1, expected to show asemi-self-flowing behaviour at 8% microsilica and 4.15 wt% water.

    Comments on top-size and density: It will always be possible to add coarser particles to a well-working matrix.

    The use of larger aggregates is one of the variations commonly used to make impressively low water additions.

    If we take the above castable as an example, one may add up to 25% coarser material like Tabular alumina to the

    mix with 4.15 wt% water. Thereby we have 125% dry matter. By doing this small operation the water addition

    has decreased from 4.15% to 3.32% (4.15/1,25). Looks much more impressive, doesnt it?

    Another trick is to use high density aggregates like zirconia. If aggregate density gets 50% higher, then

    seemingly only 2/3 of the water is needed. In volume% it is the same, though. That is why we have been

    focusing on volume in our work with packing; it is the volume that fills voids, not the weight.

    Then, to the lab!

    Figure 3: Our test recipe, - which we have to modify slightly.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    5/16

    Elkem Materials Page 5

    The recipe we developed in the LISA software contains both BACO MA95 and 6% cement. BACO is no longer

    existing,- at least the product MA95 no longer exists, so we replace that with CT9 FG from Almatis which has a

    PSD very close to MA95. In the following, we will play around with the castable so it is unwise to let it contain

    cement this time. We replace the cement with the milled -75micron fused alumina. But before starting playing

    around, a few words about general procedure:

    General procedure when making test mixes in the laboratory:1) Always make a reference mixture based on known ingredients and with known properties if new

    components are to be tested. Use cement from the same bag, properly stored inside a closed plastic bag

    at even temperatures. The same applies for the microsilica and additives. Use microsilica from one

    particular bag. Do always use the same microsilica for the reference, since there are differences between

    lots and sometimes between bags. As there are slight variations from day to day, always make a

    reference mix. The results should be judged considering the score of the reference.

    2) When preparing the mixes, it is best (but not mandatory) to weigh every fraction directly into the bowlplaced on a scale. By using the tare function weighing is simple and accurate. This ensures correct

    amount of all ingredients going into the mix. Total amount is normally 3500g. Additive has to be

    separately weighed on a finer scale due to small amounts and need for precision. All ingredients should

    be room tempered!!

    3) After all dry ingredients have been added, dry mixing is performed for 4 minutes. This duration may be

    reduced, but be consistent!

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    6/16

    Elkem Materials Page 6

    4) A stopwatch is an indispensable tool in doing this testing. Use it to keep track of time!

    5) During the 4 minutes dry-mixing, potable, tempered water are weighed to a pre-determined amount.

    We use 4.15 wt% or 13 vol% in these mixes.

    6) After water has been added, mixing continues for another 4 minutes. Things to note are wet-out time,loss of flow during mixing, flash set, jammed mixer, etc. In case of heavy loading, it is better to lower

    bowl in order to ease the movement of the paddle than to break the gear.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    7/16

    Elkem Materials Page 7

    7) Flow testing: For the flow testing we use a flow cone as described in ASTM C230. Its base is 100mmand height 50mm. The measurement is performed on a vibration table connected to a timer so that

    accurate vibration can be undertaken. The castable is placed into the cone and after the cone has beenremoved, the castable is allowed to spread out by gravity alone. When spreading stops, the diameter of

    the patty is regarded as free-flow value; after subsequent vibration (15 seconds) one obtains the vibra-

    flow value. The flow value may be expressed either as percentage increase of the diameter, or in mm.

    Then the mm reading minus 100 will equal to the flow value in %.

    ASTM flow cone (height 5cm, base 10cm):

    This flow-cone is probably the most wide-spread

    cone, but in Europe (PRE), for testing self-flowing

    castables, another cone may be used. The European

    cone has a height of 8cm as opposed to ASTMs

    5cm,and the volume is some 40% higher. Free-flow

    values obtained by using this cone will therefore behigher, one can expect some 40% more. OutsideEurope, the use of the tall cone has not become

    common. For simplicity most users tend to stay to

    one cone in order not to mix up.

    The effect of microsilica on flow of a castable:We have carefully followed the instructions given in items 1 though 6 above and have weighed the recipe given

    by LISA. BACO MA95 is replaced with CT9 FG and this time the cement has been replaced by unreactive,

    milled alumina. The microsilica has been omitted for the time being, and dispersant has been added (0.05wt%

    Castament FS20). An amount equivalent to 4.15 wt% water has been added and the mix has been mixed for 4

    minutes. In this experiment we will investigate what effect microsilica has on the flow.

    1) 0% microsilica Castable mixture mixed with the water but without microsilica.

    There is no self-flow whatsoever

    During vibration, the castable starts to slide over

    the table while disintegrating and crumbling. One

    more second of vibration and it would have fallen

    down from the table. No flow with or without

    vibration. This is not a castable.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    8/16

    Elkem Materials Page 8

    Let us look at the PSD:

    Figure 4: PSD of the microsilica-free castable composition. Andreassen distribution with q=0.30 and D=4000 as

    straight line.

    In Figure 4, we see that particularly in the lower size classes there is a big deviation from ideality represented by

    the Andreassen distribution, even at a q-value of 0.30. We are facing a situation where there is a lack ofmicrosilica, and this creates a situation where there is an undersupply of liquid to fill the internal pore system

    and promote flow. The castable appears as moist sand.

    3 wt% microsilica. The above castable gets 3% microsilica addition

    After the testing depicted above, the castable was placed into the bowl, mixing was continued and 3 wt%

    microsilica was added. The appearance changed, the castable got stickier and started looking more like a

    castable. No self-flow was recorded however, but under vibration a decent flow was obtained. Vibra-flow

    values were close to 60% or so.

    No self-flow with 3 wt% microsilica either But with vibration, flow is attained.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    9/16

    Elkem Materials Page 9

    Figure 5: PSD of Castable with 3 wt% microsilica addition together with Andreassen distribution with q=0.30

    and D=4000

    The flow of this castable shows approximately what we could expect from the results shown in Figure 1,

    although vibra-flow is lower than can be read from that graph. The main lesson here is that we may get

    acceptable vibration flow, and no self-flow, with low microsilica contents; i.e. high q-values. In terms ofpacking, we here have an aggregate structure where there is just enough liquid phase to fill voids in the structure,

    but not enough to make the individual particles slide relatively to each other (flow) without help(vibration).

    Internal friction due to particle-particle contact is too high.

    8 wt% microsilica add another 5 wt%!The procedure of collecting the castable into the bowl and mixing in another dose of microsilica was repeated.

    This time the castable with 3 wt% microsilica had an additional 5 wt% added so that it contained a total of 8

    wt% microsilica. Already during mixing after adding the extra 5 wt% dry microsilica, it became clear that great

    things were happening. The surface became shiny and the whole castable looked loose in structure. This is

    shown in the pictures below that have been made during mixing. The shiny surface indicates the ease at whichthe mixer mixes this easy flowing substance with no hints of dilatancy or thixotropy.

    The test castable with 8 wt% microsilica. The

    picture is taken during mixing, and there is no hint

    whatsoever of the dryish appearance that would be

    attributed to dilatancy and thixotropy

    Another close-up of the same castable during

    mixing.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    10/16

    Elkem Materials Page 10

    The cone is removed and the castable allowed to

    spread out by gravity alone. Free-flow value attains

    some 80%

    15 seconds vibration brings the patty to flow almost

    out of its edges. Vibra-flow around 160%!

    If we compare the obtained flow values of 80% self-flow and 160% vibra-flow with those shown in Figure 1,

    there is a remarkably good agreement. Even though the results were obtained with similar materials, the results

    span some 10 years in time. If we take a look at the particle size distribution shown in Figure 6, together with the

    Andreassen distribution for q=0.25, first of all what we note is a very good match, down to approximately

    1micron. Such a good match together with a non-dilatant viscous matrix phase makes full utilisation of the liquid

    phase that is confined in this system. With 8 wt% microsilica there is excess of the liquid that facilitates self-

    flow.

    Based on earlier investigationsiii

    the below mechanism attempts to explain the phenomena of vibra and self-flow:

    The dependence of the flow on microsilica content is a two-stage process. The first step is depicted in Figure 7i).

    If microsilica is added to a castable mixture without (or deficient in) superfines, the first step is that microsilica

    enters the void structure and replaces water on a volume-to-volume basis. One volume of microsilica replaces

    one volume of water. However as the aggregates touch, some external energy input is still needed to make them

    move relatively to each other. This energy is normally vibration, and what we have is typical vibratable.

    Figure 7ii) shows the next step. Substitution of the water proceeds up to a certain limit, when the liquid of

    microsilica and water reaches a critical density, or crowdedness is perhaps a better term. When the microsilica

    addition exceeds this limit (normally around 10 vol% or 5 wt%microsilica), the total volume of the liquid system

    starts to increase, it is not possible anymore to replace water by microsilica and still maintain flow. An increased

    volume of liquid phase increases the total volume of the castable. Because of the increased volume of the liquid

    phase, the particles move apart and become free to move relatively to each other. This is when free-flow

    commences (and it happens at around 5-6 wt% microsilica and higher).

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    11/16

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    12/16

    Elkem Materials Page 12

    Part 2: The use of a castable in QC/QA.

    If we accept the perception that by using impeccable ingredients, the expected properties will be gained in

    an industrial mix, then it should be ok to test each individual ingredient in a castable that is intended to

    detect deviations from normal.

    The quest is then to make a test-mixture and to execute the testing in a fashion that will detect allundesired deviations.

    What if we want to make comparative tests?Then we follow the recipe given in Figure 3, and perhaps add other additives than dispersants. Normally we try

    to avoid adding too many chemicals though, and often dispersant alone does the trick if room temperature is

    around 20C. At higher temperatures, retarder has to be added in order to not lose flow too early. What we do in

    practise, is to make up two (ore more) castables according to the procedure described earlier. One of these is the

    reference sample that is made out of a mixture of well-known ingredients. This is there to detect variations due

    to humidity and small deviations in aggregate quality, etc. The reason for having the reference is in other words,

    to detect any deviation from normal. The other castables have each one component replaced. If we have 5

    cement qualities to test, we make 6 castables, 1 with the known cement and the other 5 containing the different

    cements to test. Likewise with microsilica, additive or any other component we would like to test.

    Test elements:Additional to flow, free-flow and vibra-flow, a few other items are essential to test in this kind of testing. A

    controlled flow is essential for a castable, and so is the setting or hardening.

    Wet-out: An important measurement is the wet-out time. Wet-out indicates the duration of mixing it takes for

    the castable to become plastic after water is added. The measurement itself is subjective and the precision is

    perhaps not so good, but a long wet-out time indicates that dispersion may be a problem. With no wet-out the

    problem is bigger. An acceptable wet-out time is depending on the mix, but in general, the faster the better. If a

    castable needs a long mixing time at a site, the chances of extra (too high) water additions increase significantly.

    No one likes to wait for a castable to get wet, particularly if you have 20 more mixes waiting for you during the

    job. The properties of the castable will of course suffer by this extra water. So, short wet-out time is preferred. In

    our mixes we like them to be shorter than approximately 30 seconds.

    Flow measurements: We have touched flow measurements earlier, we measure the diameter (mm or %

    increase) of the cone after spreading by gravity alone (free-flow) and after subsequent 15 second of vibration

    (vibra-flow). The measurements are best performed making 4 cross-sections of the patty, and then average the

    number. This would adjust for incircularity of the patty. The tool for this is frequently a ruler, but better is a

    special calliper as described in ASTM C230. What flow one should aim for is a matter of discussion, but free-

    flows in the range 40-80% (140-180mm) should be adequate for most applications and vibra-flows around 90-

    130% should give good results. Very high flow values are normally not sought for as this will impart

    segregation.

    Set time: Besides flow, this is perhaps the most important property for a castable. In modern refractory castable

    it is a requirement that set time is controlled to within predetermined limits, and deviations are frequently

    causing problems for both end-user and manufacturer. Setting can be judged in many ways, by simple touch, so

    called squeeze tests where a plastic beaker or bag of sample is squeezed from time to time by the operator to

    judge setting, by Vicat needle and similar instruments. The latter are based on measuring the resistance when a

    thin needle is pressed into the setting castable, but is best suited for mortars without aggregates. Recently devices

    calculating Youngs modulus by sonic measurements have come into use as well. Although all of these give

    acceptable results, they are not easy to use, particularly for a multitude of samples, and particularly the latter gets

    prohibitively expensive in standard quality control.

    At Elkem Material we have been using the exothermic reactions of the castables to monitor set.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    13/16

    Elkem Materials Page 13

    The test equipment consists of a multi-channel strip-chart recorder (left), connected by cheap thermocouple leads

    to a number of insulated plywood boxes (seen to the right here).

    An appropriate amount of sample to be tested isplaced into a plastic bag after measuring flow A thermocouple is made by removing insulationand twisting the leads of the cable (thermocouple

    type K), connecting the recorder to the plywood

    box.

    The thermocouple is inserted into the plastic bag

    with the castables and the sample is placed into the

    insulated plywood box. The lid gets properly into

    place and temperature measurements can start.

    This is how the recording may look like after

    testing. After a certain induction period, the

    temperature of the sample starts increasing; when

    we have a temperature increase of 1C we record

    the time and name it TTS (Time To Start) Time ToMaximum temperature is also recorded (TTM)

    After measurement is finished, the thermocouple lead is simply cut and a new thermocouple may be twisted for

    use next time.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    14/16

    Elkem Materials Page 14

    Comments to the method: The physical and chemical significance of TTS is not well understood, but TTM is

    associated with the formation of hydrates that are responsible for the strength of the castable.

    TTS is normally associated with end of working time and TTM with final set. Not uncommonly, castables

    harden to some extent before TTS and one may be misled to believe that the castable is ready for demoulding.

    Demoulding before TTM is reached is however a risky business, because the strengthening processes, i.e. the

    formation of hydrates, have not finished or may not even have started,, and special care should be taken before

    demoulding or moving shapes before TTM is attained.We have chosen to use TTS as set time for two reasons. One is that at TTS there is normally no way to reverse

    setting, the second is that we have discovered that once TTS is reached, the time to TTM is quite constant in our

    system. It takes approximately 6 hours from TTS to TTM.

    One drawback with this method is that it cannot be used on ultralow cement castables. There is not enough

    cement to generate the required amount of heat necessary for our system. Perhaps with better insulation, one

    could go lower on cement, but presently the practical lower limit seems to be 4-5% cement. The use of a multi-

    channel strip chart recorder is also outdated; nowadays one would set up a data logger and do the measurements

    through a computer.

    Further tests: Occasionally, the test sample is cast into shapes for strength testing. Earlier, cold compressive

    and flexural strength were tested as an integrated part of the set-up, but when it was realised that we never got

    deviations unless setting or flow was out of specification, it was decided to omit this labour-intensive part of the

    testing.

    Reporting: After wet-out, flow and set are measured, the results are reported and stored electronically for later

    look-up. Below an example of such a test report is given:

    ELKEM MATERIALS

    To :BM 18.03.2007

    FRom : rh

    Testing : 968

    Ref. 1 2 3

    Microsilica wt% : 8 8 8 8

    :

    Grade : 971U 968U 968D 968U

    Lot.nr 3032985 3040080 3040080 3040058Seq 19590 19590 19591

    Cont. APLU890533-0 APLU888732-3 DBOU512204-5

    CA-14 % : 6 6 6 6

    Fused Al. 3-5mm % : 10 10 10 10

    Fused Al. 0,5-3 mm % : 35 35 35 35

    Fused Al. 0-0,5mm % : 20 20 20 20

    Fused Al. -74 mic % : 12 12 12 12

    CT 9FG : 9 9 9 9

    Castament FS20 % : 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05

    Water wt% : 4,15 4,15 4,15 4,15

    Weight (g) : 3500 3500 3500 3500

    Free-flow % : 84 40 44 48

    Vibra-flow % : 128 98 116 120

    Wet-out time (seconds) : 15 15 15 15

    TemperaturesStart temperature (C) : 23,4 24,2 23 23,7

    Time to start TTS(h:min) : 02:00 05:30 06:00 06:30

    Time to max. Temp TTM(h:min) : 06:30 12:30 12:30 12:45

    Max temperature (C) : 30 31 30,2 29,6

    TTS corrected to 22C(hours) 2,98 7,04 6,7 7,69

    TTS is normally adjusted to 22C, in order to be able to compare more accurately. 22C is chosen because that is

    the temperature the castable most often attain during mixing at 20C room temperature. The temperature

    increase comes from the mixing energy imposed on the castable. Empirically, we have found that the

    temperature sensitivity of our castable is approximately 0.7hour/C for TTS, and the correction is done

    accordingly.

    Five Guidelines:

    Now as we have obtained results, we might sometime in the future want to compare old and new results? If theobject is to compare results, the following guidelines may help to produce results that have lasting qualities.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    15/16

    Elkem Materials Page 15

    1) Compare apples with apples. Do not try to compare results obtained with different ingredientswithout having full control. Do not change more than one ingredient at a time (typical if one has to

    change source of aggregates). If the aggregates have to be changed, then compare with a reference

    based on the old aggregate. In Elkem Materials we frequently find deviations in the results when a

    new supply of fused alumina arrives. We may then adjust the recipe somewhat (mostly based on careful

    PSD analyses) to gain same results as with the old aggregates, or choose to continue with the old

    recipe but with lower (flow) values. The flow of the castable system is sometimes remarkably sensitiveto variations in aspects like PSD of the finest fraction, porosity, and (possibly) soluble elements.

    2) Use synthetic raw materials in your test mix. Be particularly cautious with using fines based on naturalraw materials. If it cannot be avoided using some natural raw materials, then at least try to use synthetic

    fines. The fines of natural raw materials are often loaded with impurities that influence flow, in bauxite,

    aluminium carbide and other carbides may be found; in fines of uncalcined natural minerals, residue

    from flotation aids can be found, and so on. Our preferred choice is to use white fused alumina in the

    milled fraction as this has given best results for us.

    3) Use calcined alumina. Use a good quality calcined alumina that fits the gap between the milled fraction(-75micron) and microsilica (submicron). Do not use natural, milled, raw materials as the risk of

    contamination is high. With microsilica it should not be necessary to use sub-micron alumina (reactive)

    in this test mix, unless reactive alumina is to be tested.

    4) Always pay attention to the PSD. You cannot interchange microsilica and reactive alumina unless the

    volumes are taken into consideration. Alumina is 1.8 times more dense than is microsilica (S.G. of 3.9and 2.2 g/cc respectively) and in order to fill the same volume, 1.8 times as much should be used (based

    on weight). Think volume!

    5) Obtaining best values is not a competition. The mix is there to be able to do a sober comparisonbetween alternative sources of additives, microsilica, calcined alumina, cement etc. Also the aggregates

    can undergo similar treatise but do not change more than one component each time. It must be admitted

    though, that for use in an industrial environment, this treatise is dependent on the perception that any

    castable composed of impeccable components performs according to expectations.

    Five ways of fooling yourself:In case you are dissatisfied with your results, particularly the flow and the water addition, the following

    variations have tremendous effects:1. Decrease your water addition by adding coarser grains. If you add 25% coarse, the relative water

    addition drops by almost 25%. E.g. from 4 wt% to 3 wt%. Expanding your PSD to bigger top sizes

    is very effective, but may be hard for the mixer. Industrial mixes normally do contain larger

    aggregates (up to 10-12mm) to impart properties like thermoshock resistance and slag resistance,

    etc. but here we are dealing with a laboratory mix for testing flow and set.

    2. Add some really heavy aggregates or fines. Addition of zirconia or other heavy minerals decreasesyour water requirement significantly. At least it looks so in weight%. The volumes remain the same

    though, but the numbers look more impressive.

    3. Improve free-flow by using the PRE-cone of 8cm instead of the ASTM-cone of 5cm height. Asignificantly improved free-flow may be attained, and if you are addicted to free-flow values in the

    range of 100% or more, you have succeeded. A free-flow of 100% for the ASTM cone is probablya bit too high, though. 80% is more desirable if segregation should be avoided.

    4. Add more water. This is quite effective. Earlier, unpublished results have indicated that increasedwater addition by 1 volume%, increases flow by approximately 25% (or mm). For a castable like

    that described above (density 3.2g/cc), 1 more weight% water could result in up to 75-80% extra

    flow. That much water would possibly result in separation and segregation though, together with

    increased porosity (by approximately 3%).

    5. Do a combination of the above. A combination of all elements above will certainly boost yournumbers and make your mixture look invincible. It does not improve your basic castable though,

    only makes it look more attractive.

  • 8/6/2019 Let's Make Castables

    16/16

    Elkem Materials Page 16

    References: Most of these and many others may be found and downloaded fromhttp://www.materials.elkem.com, Look under Refractories

    i A.H.M. Andreassen and J. Andersen: Kolloid Z. 50 (1930) 217-228ii B. Myhre and K. Sunde, "Alumina based castables with very low contents of hydraulic compound. PartI: The effect of binder and particle-size distribution on flow and set.", in Proc. UNITECR95, Kyoto, Japan,

    Nov. 19-22 1995, p. II/309-16iii B. Myhre: "Particle size distribution and its relevance in refractory castables", in Proc.2nd India

    Internat. Ref. Con., New Delhi Feb. 8-9, 1996, p. I/47-56.