45
TATA STEEL Introduction to Lean: Why is Lean Manufacturing or thinking so prevalent in the modern current economies of scale? To remain competitive, agile and the lowest cost producers, providers and streamlined business, getting rid of waste and being highly, consistently and sustainable is key for survival and thriving in this new economy. Lean manufacturing or thinking is exactly what the name sounds like - it is about 'cut to the bone', fat-trimmed, streamlining operation and organizations. Authors Womack and Jones define lean thinking as a set or collection of 'efficiency tools' that you can unleash in your business to save money, reduce cost and waste and deliver consistent and effective service that is affordable and pleasing to your customers. It is about vision and tools for reducing variability and cutting down on waste, being efficient and running a smooth and competitive, even profitable operation, well. The thinking was initially championed by pioneers like Toyota and it was eventually adopted by the Japanese automakers as the principle upon which they wanted to build, run and grow their businesses. Only a little later, will the Western world catch onto the value and potential of this approach to their respective organizations and operations. Some have referred to lean manufacturing as the TOYOTA PRODUCTION SYSTEM, or JIT (just-in-time) manufacturing, paying attention to things like flow productions, line operations, value streams, Kaizen (which we will get to later). In any lean manufacturing process and approach there Page | 1

LEAN Project

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: LEAN Project

TATA STEEL

Introduction to Lean:

Why is Lean Manufacturing or thinking so prevalent in the modern current economies of scale? To remain competitive, agile and the lowest cost producers, providers and streamlined business, getting rid of waste and being highly, consistently and sustainable is key for survival and thriving in this new economy.

Lean manufacturing or thinking is exactly what the name sounds like - it is about 'cut to the bone', fat-trimmed, streamlining operation and organizations.

Authors Womack and Jones define lean thinking as a set or collection of 'efficiency tools' that you can unleash in your business to save money, reduce cost and waste and deliver consistent and effective service that is affordable and pleasing to your customers. It is about vision and tools for reducing variability and cutting down on waste, being efficient and running a smooth and competitive, even profitable operation, well.

The thinking was initially championed by pioneers like Toyota and it was eventually adopted by the Japanese automakers as the principle upon which they wanted to build, run and grow their businesses. Only a little later, will the Western world catch onto the value and potential of this approach to their respective organizations and operations.

Some have referred to lean manufacturing as the TOYOTA PRODUCTION SYSTEM, or JIT (just-in-time) manufacturing, paying attention to things like flow productions, line operations, value streams, Kaizen (which we will get to later). In any lean manufacturing process and approach there are a couple of things to pay attention to. There is discipline, planning, rigor, scientific approach and statistically-based tools required and applied to make this business paradigm fit, work and last. Lean manufacturing will help you in your business take a serious look at visible causes and effects in your business. Aspects that could get some attention could include things like:

1. Inventory2. Movement/motion3. Waiting or queues4. Broken machines or tools (missing)5. Dirt and clutter6. Noise7. And many others....

Page | 1

Page 2: LEAN Project

Table 2. Five Steps of Lean Thinking Step Description Specify Value Value is defined by the end customer Identify the Value Stream: The set of all specific end-to-end and

linked actions, processes and functions necessary to transform information or raw materials into the product expected by the customer, and then provide post-delivery customer support. Actions either a.) create value; b.) create no value but are necessary or unavoidable; c.) creates no value and can be eliminated. Action focuses in minimizing non-value added activities.

Make Value Flow Continuously: With non-value added activities eliminated, next all bottlenecks to the smooth flow of information or material processing (indicated by work-in-process—WIP) are removed. Lean relentlessly pursues the elimination of such WIP.

Let Customers Pull Value: Deliver the value when it is expected by the customer (“just-in-time”), and use this to “pull” value from all “upstream” activities.

Pursue Perfection: Lean is not a “state”, but a “journey” in which continual improvement is sought to make processes better and better—as measured by their value delivery.

Page | 2

Page 3: LEAN Project

Company overview:

Tata Steel formerly known as TISCO and Tata Iron and Steel Company Limited is the world's seventh largest steel company with an annual crude steel capacity of 31 million tones. It is the largest private sector steel company in India in terms of domestic production. Currently ranked 410th on Fortune Global 500, it is based in Jamshedpur, Jharkhand, India. It is part of Tata Group of companies. Tata Steel is also India's second-largest and second-most profitable company in private sector with consolidated revenues of 132,110 crore (US$28.67 billion) and net profit of over 12,350 crore (US$2.68 billion) during the year ended March 31, 2008. Tata steel is the 8th most valuable brand according to an annual survey conducted by Brand Finance and The Economic Times in 2010.

Its main plant is located in Jamshedpur, Jharkhand, with its recent acquisitions; the company has become a multinational with operations in various countries. The Jamshedpur plant contains the DCS supplied by Honeywell. The registered office of Tata Steel is in Mumbai. The company was also recognized as the world's best steel producer by World Steel Dynamics in 2005. The company is listed on Bombay Stock Exchange and National Stock Exchange of India, and employs about 82,700 people (as of 2007).

The Tata Steel Group has always believed that mutual benefit of countries, corporations and communities is the most effective route to growth. Tata Steel has not limited its operations and businesses within India but has built an imposing presence around the globe as well. With the acquisition of Corus (now Tata Steel Europe) in 2007 leading to commencement of Tata Steel's European operations, the Company today is the tenth largest steel producer in the world .During the financial year 2009-10, the Group recorded deliveries of 24 million tonnes against 28 million tonnes in the previous year, the decline being a reflection of the global economic slowdown mainly in the UK and European operations. The Group recorded a turnover of Rs.102, 393 Crores in 2009 - 2010. The Company has always had significant impact on the economic development in India and now seeks to strengthen its position of pre-eminence in international domain by continuing to lead by example of responsibility and trust.

 Tata Steel’s overseas ventures and investments in global companies have helped the Company create a manufacturing and marketing network in Europe, South East Asia and the Pacific-rim countries. The Group’s South East Asian operations comprise Tata Steel Thailand, in which it has 67.1% equity and Nat Steel Holdings, which is one of the largest steel producers in the Asia Pacific with presence across seven countries.

Tata Steel has maintained the confidence to improve performance globally even in the face of a challenging economic climate in which the steel industry happens to be severely affected. One factor that contributes to this confidence is the Company’s adherence to Total Quality Management (TQM) to achieve its goals. Since the formal incorporation of

Page | 3

Page 4: LEAN Project

TQM for Business Excellence in the late 1980’s Tata Steel has adopted a number of improvement initiatives popular around the world. 

At Tata Steel’s European operations, Continuous Improvement activities are focused on providing Business Units with the ability to drive business through Lean Management, a common strategy deployment process, training of CI coaches and knowledge sharing through operations.

Tata Steel in Europe

Tata Steel is Europe's second largest steel producer with main steelmaking operations in UK and the Netherlands. We are a leading supplier to many of the most demanding markets around the world including construction, automotive, packaging, and mechanical and electrical engineering, metal goods, and oil & gas.

With innovation and continuous improvement at the heart of our business performance, we aim to create value by offering a differentiated product range supported by unrivalled customer service.

Tata Steel has manufacturing operations in many European countries with major plants located in the UK, The Netherlands, Germany, France and Belgium.

Tata Steel produces carbon steel by the basic oxygen steelmaking method at four integrated steel works at Port Talbot, Scunthorpe and Teesside in the UK and at IJmuiden in The Netherlands.

Engineering steels are produced at Rotherham, UK, using the electric arc furnace method.  A number of Tata Steel's rolling mills and process lines are on the same sites as the steelworks, but most of Tata Steel's operating sites do not have steelmaking facilities. These include:

the strip mills at Llanwern, South Wales the tinplate works at Trostre, South Wales the coating works at Tafarnaubach, South Wales, Shotton, North Wales and

Maubeuge, North France the electrical steel works at Newport, South Wales and Surahammer, Sweden the tube mills at Corby and Hartlepool, England and Oosterhout, Arnhem and

Maastricht, Netherlands the plate mill at Dalzell, Scotland the rail mill at Hayange, North-East France the narrow strip mills at Brinsworth, England, Düsseldorf & Trier, Germany and

Warren & Bethlehem, USA

Page | 4

Page 5: LEAN Project

NatSteel maintains a systematic approach towards improving productivity and enhancing quality while reducing cost at the same time. The Singapore operations concentrated on yield improvement, reduction in power consumption and a significant bottom line benefit. The Xiamen operations have also adopted measures to reduce vulnerability caused by price fluctuations.

Facilities

• One 80-tonne DC electric arc finger shaft furnace • One 80-tonne ladle furnace• One high-speed 5-strand continuous casting machine

•Two high speed rolling mills to produce a full range of deformed bars, round bars and wire rods

•The latest cut-and-bend (CAB) machines for accurate fabrication of reinforcement bars.

•State-of-the-art machines for production of cold rolled wires stretched wires and welded wire mesh.

Tata Steel set up the Performance Improvement Committee (PIC) in January 2008 to accelerate performance improvement on a continual basis. Seven (7) PI groups have started functioning under the PIC identifying Key Performance Indicators (KPI) to be improved and improvement projects to be undertaken.

 Lean Methodologies:

As the companies are giving more stress on cost reduction and process optimization so the need of finding better ways and techniques are getting crucial. The methodologies that will enable the companies to achieve their goal and sustain in the long run are,

The various improvement initiatives adopted by Tata Steel which are recognized as Aspire Tools are:

Value Engineering (VE): Value Engineering is an organized approach for identification and elimination of unnecessary cost.

QIP, QC & Benchmarking: Tata Steel adopted Juran Trilogy concept for undertaking Quality Improvement Projects (QIP). Quality Circles (QC) are small group activities which involves first-line employees who

Page | 5

Page 6: LEAN Project

continually control and improve the quality of their work, products and services. Benchmarking is a process of exploring for best practices and performances across the world and putting systematic efforts to bridge the gap.

Total Operational Performance (TOP): Total Operational Performance initiative was launched in 1998 with the help of McKinsey. Major focus of this initiative was on cost reduction, quality & throughput improvement.

Total Productive Maintenance (TPM): TPM is an approach to maintenance that optimises equipment effectiveness, eliminates breakdowns and promotes autonomous maintenance by operators through day to day activities involving the total workforce.

Knowledge Management (KM): Tata Steel decided to embark on formal KM initiative in the year 1999. The beginning was made in July ’99 to place a Knowledge Management (KM) program for the company and systematically as well as formally share and transfer learning concepts, best practices and other implicit knowledge.

Define-Measure-Analyze-Improve-Control (DMAIC): The fundamental objective of the DMAIC methodology is the implementation of a measurement-based strategy that focuses on process improvement and variation reduction.

Define-Measure-Analyze-Design-Improve-Control (DMADIC): This tool is based on Design for Six Sigma Philosophy. DMADIC focus is predominantly on design aspects. It is generally used for Task Achieving Projects like New Product Development, New Market Development etc.

TOP in Marketing: Launched in 2002 with the help of McKinsey, TOP in Marketing was the first new ASPIRE initiative launched with a focus on creating value through partnership with customers.

Supplier Value Management (SVM): This aims to reduce costs and resources in the entire value chain of supplier and Tata Steel. Value creation is focused through better understanding of customer (internal) requirements and supplier capabilities.

Quality Management Systems (QMS): Quality Management Systems as required, like ISO 9000,

Page | 6

Page 7: LEAN Project

TS16949, OSHAS, ISO 14000 etc. are adopted by various units to establish basic management systems.

Small Group Activities (SGA): Small Group Activities (SGA) are promoted under daily management through SGA teams who meet, identify, discuss and implement small improvements (Kaizens) in the area of work. QC circles and TPM circles are known as SGA teams.

Deming Assessment: This assessment is done by Japanese Union of Scientists and Engineers (JUSE) for the companies implementing TQM practices and applying for Deming Application Prize.

These are the tools that can make a company sustain in the long run.

Lean Practices those have been implemented in TATA STEEL

It may not make sense to many in the steel industry to invest in various quality control drives during such a tough time, but for Tata Steel, pursuing such goals has been a passion and the very essence of its existence. The company has recently won the Deming Application Prize for its excellence in total quality management (TQM), the only steel company in the world outside Japan to bag the award.

The steel major, which in earlier years had been saving around Rs 200-300 crore annually, would, aided by Deming this year (2008-09), target to save around Rs 600 crore.

"This is not because of the effect of market prices or impact of raw material costs going up or down, it is purely internal—from improvements in the work processes the company has brought about," said Avneesh Gupta, TQM chief of Tata Steel.

The steel major’s commitment to the best practices

can be gauged by the remarks of Tata Steel managing director B Muthuraman recently: "In every walk of life, whether it is in running a business, in sports or education, if you take care of the processes, the results will take care of themselves." He was speaking at the ‘JJ Irani award for excellence in education in Jamshedpur schools’.

Tata Steel, which expects to emerge strongly from the ongoing global recession, has already put in place a revised plan for the second half of 2008-09 (Oct onwards). The plan includes techniques/benefits learnt in Deming and the target has been set in crores.

Page | 7

Page 8: LEAN Project

Various items, right from the raw material side to marketing & sales, several daily management items which could be done better while bringing about cost reduction, cost-cutting contributions from its ‘Aspire’ projects (problem solving, Six Sigma application, etc), efforts from supply chain management by following inventory replenishment models... (while ensuring that whatever the customer was wanting was readily available to him) have been listed.

"It (Deming) is a very robust and a very involving process in which you cannot escape the enlightenment at the end of it," Gupta told FE here recently. It is only the application of the steps involved in Deming and the consequent effects that emerged gives one the real insight into its working, he added.

"Each key performance indicator (KPI) is being tracked by the company, like zinc consumption, coal rate, coke rate, etc, including whether any delays were taking place or not," Gupta said. Even the monthly performance improvement review of the company’s TQM efforts by chief operating officer HM Nerurkar ensures that things were moving in the right direction....

TQM is an integrated organizational approach in delighting customers (both external and internal) by meeting their expectations on a continuous basis through everyone involved with the organizational working on continuous improvement in all products/processes along with proper problem solving methodology.

“TO DELIVER HIGHEST VALUE AT LOWEST COST” is the main objective of TQM

• Total - The responsibility for achieving Quality rests with everyone a business no matter what their function. It recognizes the necessity to develop processes across the business, that together lead to the reliable delivery of exact, agreed customer requirements. This will achieve the most competitive cost position and a higher return on investment.

• Quality - The prime task of any business is to understand the needs of the customer, then deliver the product or service at the agreed time, place and price, on every occasion. This will retain current customers, assist in acquiring new ones and lead to a subsequent increase in market share.

• Management - Top management lead the drive to achieve quality for customers, by communicating the business vision and values to all employees; ensuring the right business processes are in place; introducing and maintaining a continuous improvement culture.

TQM is the foundation for activities, which includes:

Page | 8

Page 9: LEAN Project

• Commitment by senior management and all employees • Meeting customer requirements • Reducing development cycle times • Just In Time/ Flow Manufacturing • Improvement teams • Reducing product and service costs • Systems to facilitate improvement • Employee involvement and empowerment • Recognition and celebration • Challenging quantified goals and benchmarking • Focus on processes / improvement plans

This shows that TQM must be practiced in all activities, by all personnel, in Manufacturing, Marketing, Engineering, R&D, Sales, Purchasing, HR, etc.

• The journey of TQM in the company began on September 15, 1995 with the setting up of the TQM Cell.

• To meet the quality planning requirements as well as to facilitate continuous improvement, the company has established, documented, implemented and maintained the Quality Management System (QMS) in accordance with the requirements of the International Standards.

• In order to verify and determine the effective implementation and maintenance of the QMS, quality audits were carried out at regular intervals by the Internal Quality Auditors.

• The company also implemented a number of TQM tools such as• Formation of Quality Improvement Projects (QIPs ), • Signing of MOUs• ISO certification• Benchmarking• Employee involvement schemes• House keeping

• The company embarked upon both external and internal benchmarking for improving its production, commercial, and financial performance.

• It benchmarked with British Steel Co., South Korea Steel Plant (POSCO)1 SAIL, for reduction in the rejection rate, off ore station, and improving manpower productivity respectively.

• Annual improvement action plans were implemented involving techniques like Kaizen cycle time reduction for further improvement in delivery and technological

Page | 9

Page 10: LEAN Project

process up gradation, leading to improvement in quality of products and enhanced customer focus.

Tangible benefits of implementing TQM

• Increase in sales per year from Rs. 3263.66 cr to Rs. 7867.6 cr • Reduced manufacturing expenses from Rs. 3,94,706.6 cr to Rs. 3,46,158.86 cr

• Reduced net loss incurred by the company from Rs. 6,97,525.90 cr to Rs. 4,00, 94.58 cr

• Reduced the defective products from 5.76% to 1.2%• Accident rates reduced from 113 to 107 (both fatal and non-fatal)• Customer complaint rates from 0.27 to 0.13 (of total sales)• Increased productivity rate (tonnes per man year) from 176 to 194 from the pre-

TQM to post-TQM period. • Image of the organization has improved.• Reduction in inventory.• Shorter lead time in design, manufacturing, procurement service etc.,• Reduction in rejections and complaints.• Customer satisfaction.• Quality cost % to turnover reduction.• Lower manufacturing cost.• Reduction in deviation.• Continuous improvement.• Drastic reduction in defectives and number of defects.

Proposed Implementation Plan for TPMOn the basis of surveyed literature following points were considered to implementduring TPM implementation programme in the cold rolling unit (CR unit) andadopted in the system step by step;- Focused improvement (Kobetsu Kaizen),- Autonomous Maintenance (Jishu Hozen),- Education & Training,- Planned maintenance,

- Overall Equipment effectiveness

TPM development program

The ten TPM development programme steps were taken as described inStep Key point1. Formally announce decision to introduce TPM Top management announcement at in house

Page | 10

Page 11: LEAN Project

meeting publish in any company magazine.2. Conduct TPM introductory education & grouptraining for specific employees.Senior management level.3. Create a TPM promotion organization,committee and specialist sub committees.Steering TPM promotion Office.4. Establish basic TPM policies and goals Set baseline and targets.5. Draft a master plan for implementing TPMfrom preparation stage to applicationForecast effects.6. Kick off TPM initiatives Invite customers, affiliates& subcontractors7. Build a corporate constitution designed pursuethe ultimate in production effectiveness tomaximize production effectiveness.Conduct Focused improvement activities,Project-team activities and workplace smallgroup activities, Establish and deployautonomous maintenance proceed Step by step,with audits and pass certificates.8. Implement planned maintenance, corrective,shutdown, and predictive maintenance. Conductoperation and maintenance group education.Training to members by identifying their needsthrough skill evaluation form.9. Build an early management system. Develop equipments/products that are easy touse.10. Build a quality maintenance system. Establish, maintain and control conditions for

zero defects, zero accidents.

Step by Step Procedure for Focused Improvement.Step Activity Detailed action plan1. Select Improvement topic Select and register topic on topic registration form.Form project team. Plan activity.2. Understand situation Identify bottleneck processes.Measure failures, defects and other losses.Use base lines to set targets.3. Expose and eliminateabnormalitiesPainstakingly expose all abnormalities.Restore deterioration and correct minor flaws.Establish basic equipment conditions.

Page | 11

Page 12: LEAN Project

4. Analyze causes Stratify and analyze losses.Apply analytical technique (why-why analysis, FTA, P-M analysis).5. Plan Improvement Draft improvement proposals and prepare drawings. Comparecost effectiveness of alternate proposals and compile budgetProvide instructions on improved equipment, operatingmethods etc.6. Implement improvement Carry out improvement plan. Practice early management(perform test operation and formal acceptance)7. Check Results Evaluate results with time as improvement project proceeds8. Consolidate gain Draw up control standards to sustain results.Formulate work standards and manualsFeed information back to maintenance prevention programme9. Rewards for Kaizen Spot award given for every kaizen submitted, implementedwill be rewarded 10% of the annual saving made by thatimprovement after implementation.Good KAIZENS rewarded and addressed at common forums by

ED/Department/Unit heads to boost the morale of employees.

Tata Steel India

Tata Steel's management approach to sustainability is to integrate consideration of the ‘triple bottom line' – economic, environmental and social performance - into the Company's thinking and business practice. At Tata Steel, the purpose of the organisation is to go ‘beyond business', to invest and develop for the benefit of society. This is achieved

through the principles of Corporate Citizenship and Inclusive Growth.

 “We aspire to be the global steel industry benchmark for Value Creation and Corporate Citizenship”

The Vision places equal emphasis on economic performance and corporate citizenship through social and environmental performance, thus truly integrating sustainability into the ethos and aims of the Tata Steel Group. One of the main goals is to reduce CO2 emissions to less than 1.7 tonnes per liquid tonne of steel (t/tls)

Reduce Emissions

Continuous process improvements, for example increasing energy efficiency of process units and maximising the recovery and utilisation of by-product gases.

Invest in breakthrough technologies. Responsible product development. Employee engagement. Proactive role in global steel sector initiatives.

Page | 12

Goal 2012

Page 13: LEAN Project

Implement identified Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) projects.

During FY 2009-10, the Jamshedpur Steel Works benchmarked its activities with the IJmuiden Steel Works in the Netherlands and has undertaken several energy efficiency measures like maximising the utilisation of by-product gases, efficient operations of blast furnaces, etc. In addition, a number of other Indian divisions of the Company too, undertook the Carbon Foot Print exercise to assess the base levels and formulate a plan for setting targets and actions. Tata Steel has implemented a variety of control measures to improve the working environment at the shop floor. The objective has been to create an atmosphere that respects both nature and community at the same time. The Jamshedpur works is the first in the world to be conferred the SA 8000 for work conditions and improvements in workplace. All its operations have achieved the ISO-14001 certification for environment management.

 During this year, specific water consumption including power and steam generation in the Indian operations reduced by 18.3% to the level of 5.57 m3/tcs mainly driven by recovery of wastewater from the drains of the Steel Works. Solid waste utilisation increased by 1.55% in 2009-10 to the level of 91.1%.

Tata Steel Europe

Environmental protection being integral to Corus' Business strategies, the company is committed to bringing down greenhouse gas emissions and progressively reducing any negative impact of its operations through the adoption of sustainable practices. Continuous improvement initiatives for improved environmental performance may be categorized in the following ways:

 Effective environment management systems are in place to ensure awareness and responsibility of the workforce with regard to environment.

Continuous research and development of new technologies improve the performance of processes and products through prevention and reduction of emissions, releases, waste and pollution.

Sustainable development is ensured by using energy, water and raw materials more efficiently and through optimum utilization of all available resources.

Product reuse and recycling is promoted through a better understanding of environmental impact on the product life cycle.

Corus is always committed towards responding to the concerns of local communities and attaches respect to the environment and wildlife habitats in and around its sites.

Page | 13

Page 14: LEAN Project

Steel Recycling:

Tata Steel is the largest steel recycler in the UK. Tata Steel Packaging Recycling (TSPR) promotes steel packaging recycling to consumers, local authorities and the commercial sector, and offers an established end market for recovered used steel packaging.

Steel is 100% recyclable, and can be recycled over and over without loss of quality. It is easy to collect, using kerbside collections, can banks and magnetic extraction, and is now the most recycled packaging material in Europe.  

Recycling steel has major environmental benefits. By recycling steel, we can:

Help preserve natural resources and protect the environment. Comply with landfill and packaging directives. To reach the recycling target of 69% by 2010.

The value of used steel cans in the waste stream is approximately £117 million a year.

Tata Steel Packaging Recycling works with local authorities, waste management companies, the ferrous scrap industry and community and charity schemes to increase the amount of this steel packaging that is recovered and recycled.

Our activities include:

Providing advice and technical information on how to recycle steel packaging. Offering advice on setting up and promoting recycling schemes. Providing recycling equipment and support for recycling initiatives nationwide. Recycling steel at all our steelmaking plants: every steel plant is a recycling plant. Generating Packaging Waste Recovery Notes (PRN's) to enable obligated

companies and the UK to reach national recycling targets. Providing communication support for recycling schemes. Undertaking technical studies and strategic research to promote future steel

recycling.

All steel packaging is 100% recyclable.

Steel food, pet food and drinks containers account for about 60% of recyclable steel packaging in the household. However, the other 40% includes many equally recyclable containers, such as aerosols, household and DIY product containers, tins for biscuits, sweets and spirits, and steel caps and lids.

Page | 14

Page 15: LEAN Project

Most commonly recycled products in the UK

Corus research in 2005 showed the types of steel packaging that people actively recycle:

Drinks cans – 57% Food cans – 53% Lids for glass jars and bottles – 22% Pet food cans – 21% Paint cans – 7% Aerosols – 7%

Raise awareness of the full range

To meet the Government’s target of recycling 71% of steel packaging in 2011, we need to increase people’s knowledge of recyclable steel containers. By informing householders about the full range of recyclable steel packaging, local authorities and collectors can:

Help achieve the recycling targets for household waste. Improve the economics of household collection schemes

There are several cost-effective ways to collect packaging steel for recycling. The variety of methods available means that steel packaging is particularly easy to collect.

  Kerbside collections

As the UK Government increases its household waste recovery targets, kerbside ‘recycling box’ or ‘recycling bag’ schemes operated by local authority contractors are now widespread.

'Bring' schemes

With thousands of can banks or multi-material banks collecting steel cans across the UK, 'bring' schemes play an important role in supporting local authorities’ recycling strategies.

Magnetic extraction

Magnetic recovery is the most efficient and cost effective way of extracting steel packaging from non-sorted domestic waste, achieving recovery rates of up to 85%.

Page | 15

Page 16: LEAN Project

Magnetic recovery at EFW plants

Conventional magnetic extraction technology at Energy From Waste (EFW) plants recovers steel packaging present in the domestic waste stream after the incineration of domestic waste.

Tata Steel Thailand

Tata Steel Thailand (TSTH) is wholeheartedly committed to the Group's environment policies and goes beyond merely complying with norms and duties to actively participate in stakeholders' concerns. Managing environmental impacts are the Company's responsibility and it is subject to assessment and scrutiny.

Some of the main areas of focus of TSTH's environment initiatives are:

To bring down Carbon Dioxide (CO2) emissions to less than 1.0 tonnes/tonne of liquid steel after commissioning of the Mini Blast Furnace Project

Focus on plant efficiency improvement. Create good citizenship by promoting environment friendly activities in

communities around the plants.

Page | 16

Page 17: LEAN Project

Investment in dust reduction projects. Investment in Continuous Emission Monitoring systems (CEMs).

Tata Steel NatSteel

NatSteel Holdings (NSH) has adopted and implemented an environmental management system, which is certified to ISO 14001:2004 and complies with relevant local and international environmental regulations and good practices. Activities are regularly reviewed to identify significant impacts on the environment, and environment pollution issues. As a responsible corporate citizen, NSH has opted for different measures to limit adverse impacts caused by production. All activities are subject to assessment and apart from monthly reviews, Environment, Safety and Health (ESH) Management Committee meetings are held bi-annually.

NatSteel Holdings takes a multi-pronged approach to caring for our environment. We encourage our staff to take responsibility for the environment, and optimise the production life cycle to reduce waste, conserve energy and prevent pollution.

Over the past two decades, more than $20 million has been invested in pollution-control equipment and barriers to protect the environment.

RadioactiveScrapMonitoringSystemWe were the regional pioneers in radiation detection for our steel scrap operations back in 1994. Our steel products are certified as compliant with the safety standards of the International Atomic Energy Agency.

ReutilisationofSteelSlagBy effectively converting steel slag (a major by-product from the melting of steel scrap) into slag premix for road construction, NatSteel Holdings achieved waste minimisation, cost reduction, the conservation of natural resources and landfill space, and more durable roads.

FingerShaftFurnaceBy investing in the finger shaft furnace to replace the conventional electric arc furnace, we reduced energy usage by 25 percent.

Page | 17

Page 18: LEAN Project

Steel scrap is melted in batches at the furnace. The energy available in the exhaust gases (also known as flue) from the melting process can be recovered by passing the hot flue through the next batch of steel scrap, thus preheating it. The finger shaft forms the preheating chamber for the passage of the hot flue.

HotChargingIn the late 1990s, our engineers modified the production process at the rolling mill by linking the operation of the Meltshop directly to the reheating furnace at the rolling mill via an automated conveyor system.

To roll billets into rebars or rods, the billets need to be at a temperature of around 1,100 degrees Celsius. Instead of reheating billets from room temperature, the automated conveyor system enabled the billets to arrive at the reheating furnace at temperatures of 700 to 750 degrees Celsius, thus saving reheating costs.

As a result, fuel consumption was reduced by more than 40 percent. There were manpower and time savings too with the automated conveyor system as the billets need not be trucked from the Melt shop to the reheating furnace.

WaterRecyclingWe built a drainage system to collect and recycle water used for cooling down billets as they pass through the rolling mill.

Tata has taken various measures to optimize its process and practice lean to a greater extent. Some of the measures taken by Tata are:

Green house Gas:

Of the six Greenhouse gases, Carbon Dioxide is most relevant for the steel industry. Tata Steel has reduced the CO2 emission by 35% in the last 12 years.Following specific measures to address Greenhouse gas emissions, there is a steady downward trend in CO2

emissions from the Steel Works. In 2007-08, CO2 emissions were reduced by 4.2% to 2.04t/tcs, equating to 2 t/tls. CO2 emissions calculations are based on GHG protocol guidelines. Carbon Dioxide Emission ( t / tcs )

Page | 18

Page 19: LEAN Project

Tata Steel India Water discharges, runoff and the receiving ecosystems:

The Company discharges its treated effluent from the works and treated domestic sewage from township to the rivers Subernarekha and Kharkai. Studies carried out by NEERI in the year 1993-95 and 2000 to assess impact on ecosystems/ habitats of rivers have found no significant impact on the aquatic eco-system. Noamundi and Joda Iron Ore Mines as well as West Bokaro and Jharia Collieries have all achieved zero discharge. The domestic effluent is discharged through the septic tank - soaking pit route at the mines and collieries. Sewage treatment plants have been provided for the entire township at Jamshedpur. 100% effluent water is treated before being discharged upstream.

Water Pollutant Discharge ( kg / tcs )

 

Page | 19

Page 20: LEAN Project

Tata Steel Europe

There has been a steady reduction in absolute emission to water since 2000. Most of the water used in the processes is for non-contact cooling and thus it is returned directly to the source with no tampering in quality at all. An advanced range of biological, chemical and physical effluent treatment technologies are employed at many of the plants to minimize the impact of process effluents, and to adhere to emission limits. Pollution causing materials that are used at Corus facilities are stored in contained systems and a large number of pollution control measures are also deployed.

NatSteel Holdings

The discharge from the various cooling towers is treated to reduce the concentration of oil and grease before they are discharged in the sewers. A certified laboratory is engaged annually to take samples of the discharge for analysis. The analyzed results meet stringent criteria set forth in the Sewage and Drainage (Trade Effluent) Regulations 1999.

Tata Steel India

Waste Handling:

89.6% of solid waste generated from Steel Works is recycled or reused. 17% of the solid waste generated, amounting to approximately 6,12,300 tonnes in 2008-09 was used to fill low-lying areas and for peripheral road construction around Jamshedpur.

Page | 20

Page 21: LEAN Project

Effluent Management:

Wastewater from the steel making process is being treated with the best available physio-chemical methods and being recycled as well. Wastewater from the coke plant is treated biologically where organic pollutants are oxidised and decomposed by micro-organisms. The Company has reduced the levels of total pollutant discharge in wastewater streams from 0.211kg/tcs in 1999-2000 to 0.128 kg/tcs in 2008-09.

Solid Waste Management: Tata Steel generates around 659 kg of various kinds of solid wastes (excluding fly ash) for every one tonne of crude steel produced. About 85% of these wastes are utilised either through recycling and reuse in own processes or sold as input materials to other industries. Remaining wastes are sent for safe land filling.

Solid Waste Utilisation (%)

Stack Emission - SPN ( kg/tcs )

Page | 21

Page 22: LEAN Project

 

Tata Steel Europe

In spite of having an efficient energy conversion mechanism in place, some waste generation in manufacturing processes is inevitable. The waste materials at Corus plants are reused, recycled or otherwise recovered for use in other sectors of industry. The objective of sustainable consumption is met in a symbiotic way in which secondary materials arising in other sectors of industry are used in Corus processes. Granulated slag from the blast furnaces is used as a clinker substitute in the concrete sector. Steel making slags are used in well-established civil engineering and agricultural applications, ferrous chloride solution is used in water treatment and tar and benzene are used within the chemicals sector. 

 

NatSteel Holdings

To conserve resources, remnants from production process (cut ends) and rejected products (cobbles) are recycled by adding to the scrap for melting. EAF slag is collected by a third party to be treated and used for roads and aircraft runway paving.

A few initiatives taken by Nat Steel towards effective utilisation of wastes include:

Seggregation of all waste in production centres under “General”, “Electrical”, “Waste Oil & Grease” & “Waste Chemicals” to facilitate waste control.

Selling “Electrical”, “Waste Oil” & “Waste Chemicals” waste to licensed collectors for recycling. Sending “General” & “Waste Grease” via proper channel for proper disposal. Monitoring amount of waste generated. Reviewing processes and implementing measures to reduce the amount of waste generated. Use of Electric Arc Furnace slag as road stones to surface roads. Disposing toxic waste by licensed contractors as stipulated by Environmental Public Health (Toxic Industrial

Waste) Regulation 1988.

Page | 22

Page 23: LEAN Project

Raw material:

Tata Steel has made great strides in its effort to reduce the use of natural resources per tonne of steel manufactured by it. The Company has reduced raw material consumption from a level of 5 t/tss to nearly 3 t/tss in the last 12 years.

Tata Steel India

Steel is 100% recyclable. However, the current rise in demand cannot be met by recycling steel alone. Hence, recycling both steel and iron ore is required in order to meet this demand. The manufacturing process utilises raw materials such as minerals and semi-processed materials. Tata Steel receives its raw materials from its captive mines and collieries in the states of Jharkhand and Orissa. The only waste material from external sources that is sometimes used by Tata Steel is the iron or steel scrap purchased from the market and used in the steel melting shops.

Specific Raw Material Comsumption ( t/tcs)

 Tata Steel Europe

Committed to conserving all raw materials, particularly those that are non-renewable, processes at Corus have been refined over many years to ensure optimum consumption of available resources. This is a positive step towards creating a sustainable environment, in addition to being commercially profitable. Systems such as briquetting have been advantageously utilised at manufacturing facilities to enable re-circulation of any residue materials that contain valuable components, within processes.

 

NatSteel Holdings

At NSH the usage of oxygen had increased temporarily with the installation of the Virtual Lancing Burner (VLB) but after the system stabilised, the consumption rate was effectively controlled and improved. The raw material usage per tonne of billets is generally constant.

Two initiatives taken by NSH in optimising raw material usage are:

Page | 23

Page 24: LEAN Project

Minimising remnant generation in Rolling Mill by tailoring billet lengths to diameter and lengths of bars produced.

Minimising scrap generation in Downstream through material optimisation and second order recycling of remnants from both Rolling Mill & CAB.

Energy:

Tata Steel utilises many forms of energy for the purpose of steel production. The Company, through its Energy Policy is committed to conserving the scarce energy resources of the earth. Through an intensive energy saving campaign, the specific energy consumption of the Company has seen a drop of more than 36 % in the last 12 years and now it is at a level of 27.580 G. Joules/ tonne of crude steel in 2008-09.

Tata Steel India

Tata Steel's energy conservation initiatives include:

Tata Steel continually develops and implements energy conservation and efficiency measures. Its initiatives under implementation for the reduction of energy consumption include:

Design, installation and commissioning of rotary hearth furnace where power consumption is expected to reduce from 3,500 KWh/tonne to 2,800 KWh/tonne.

Installation of top recovery turbine at ‘G' & ‘H' Blast Furnaces.

Recovery of sensible heat of coke by installation of Coke Dry Quenching system in Batteries 5, 6 & 7 at Coke Plant.

Enhancement of waste heat recovery at Sinter Plants.

BF Gas fired re-heating furnace at Hot Strip Mill.

Improvement in LD Gas recovery.

Renewable energy & product energy efficiency initiatives

 

Page | 24

Page 25: LEAN Project

Use of renewable energy is highly limited in the main steel making process, due to techno-commercial non-viability. However, Tata Steel encourages and promotes the use of renewable energy in the form of solar electricity, biogas etc. In the Renewable Energy for Rural Livelihood Project, deprived villagers have been assisted to adopt solar lighting and bio-gas plants; this has reduced the use of wood as fuel thereby enabling farmers to switch from fertilizers to biogas manure in the future.

Additionally, Tata Steel is considering energy sourcing

and energy efficiency very carefully in its product development. It is developing and producing a range of high specification product solutions with attractive, more sustainable qualities – for example products that are lighter, stronger and more durable. These products meet customer needs and will allow them to develop better, cheaper and more environment-friendly products for the end user. Stronger and more durable products will facilitate more advanced uses and less frequent replacement (reducing further impacts of production) whilst other features, such as lighter weight, can mean that the end product is more energy-efficient or effective. For example, lightweight steel designed for cars allow automotive customers to produce a lighter-weight vehicle that will have greater fuel efficiency and will be less polluting to the atmosphere.

Specific Energy Comsumption ( Gcals/tcs )

Page | 25

Page 26: LEAN Project

Tata steel Europe:

Adhering to its commitment towards creating a sustainable environment, Corus focuses on finding energy efficient solutions for the construction, packaging, transport and other industries. Corus' Electrical steels are supplied to various markets where they are used to generate, transmit or facilitate the use of electrical power. It's small energy dissipation per cycle helps reduce CO2 emission by reducing energy losses. Electrical steels are gradually being incorporated into renewable energy technologies, and the Company is collaborating with customers to develop more energy efficient transformers, traction motors of hybrid vehicles and wave power generators.

By using recovered fuel oil as a chemical reductant in the blast furnace at Teesside Cast Products, Corus has achieved a substantial reduction in annual consumption of coke, with an associated CO2 saving equivalent to more than 25,000 tonnes per annum.

Corus' priority is to utilise gases arising at its blast furnaces, coke ovens and steel plants as efficiently as possible, thereby curtailing the use of supplementary fossil fuels and electricity imports to the site. The Company has achieved very high levels of on-site electricity generation.

Tata steel Thailand:

TSTH has undertaken many initiatives to improve energy use. By installing a new cooling tower for indirect water, TSTH saved energy consumption upto 5%. The company has also applied Natural Gas (NG) to its Electric Arc Furnace consequently saving energy by 3% (or 17-kWh/tonne billets).

NatSteel Holdings:

Actions to reduce electricity consumption at NatSteel's operations include substitution of cheaper chemical energy for electrical energy by operating the Virtual Lancing Burners and closing all outlets during operation to retain heat. This is evidenced by the decreasing consumption rate of electricity per tonne of billets produced.

Some of the initiatives undertaken to minimise energy consumption are:

Keeping scrap dry and clean to minimise inclusion of soil when scrap is charged into the furnace, reducing electricity consumption and increasing steel-making yield.

Preheating scrap in shaft furnace before each change. Charging hot billets from Continuous Caster to Rolling Mill. Installing Virtual Lancing Burners to introduce chemical energy to replace

electricity and fuel in electric arc furnace.

Page | 26

Page 27: LEAN Project

Water:

Tata Steel has taken various actions for optimum use of water. The increased emphasis on water re-circulation in all process units has contributed to considerable reduction in water consumption. Specific water consumption (including that of power generation) has reduced by more than 60% over the last decade. Close monitoring of water losses, recycling of processed waste water and treated sewage water for steel making and treated effluent recovery from works drain have resulted in use of much less water for every tonne of steel produced.

The Company does not use any ground water source for industrial or domestic use. The entire domestic consumption of the city of Jamshedpur is ~65 million metric cube/annum of water and is supplied and managed by the hundred percent subsidiary Company JUSCO (Jamshedpur Utility Services Company). The potable water supplied by JUSCO to the city meets all national and international standards.

The total water withdrawal during the period was 36.67 million metric cube for Jamshedpur Steel Works, which also includes water used for expansion activities. Water re-circulation and conservation efforts are in place at process units and the new processes that will come online in the coming years are likely to reduce specific water consumption.

  Water for industrial and domestic usage at Jamshedpur is drawn from river Subarnarekha. This river is perennial in nature and water abstraction does not have any adverse impact on the eco system. The other source of water at Jamshedpur is a 92.6 square kilometer captive reservoir at Dimna with a capacity of 34.224 million metric cube.

Gross make-up water requirement for the Steel Works was an average of 105200 m cube/ day during 2008-09.

Page | 27

Page 28: LEAN Project

Water Consumption in Steel Works including Power Generation

 

The Missing Link:

For the case study the biggest company on the Polish steel market, ArcelorMittal Poland, has been chosen. In 2006 it commenced the introduction of the TPM concept and the 5S method. The basis for the TPM implementation was the so-called Single Minute Exchange of Die (SMED). SMED makes it possible to shorten the productionline changeover time. At ArcelorMittal Poland SMED was carried out together with the Kaizen Institute coordinators. The whole process of machinery changeover was filmed, and the duration of each activity timed. Next, together with the workers, the material wasanalyzed and finally new standards for particular production changeovers were established. The pilot 5S program was introduced in the Sosnowiec branch of Arcelor Mittal Poland (at cold-rolled strip mill). The 5S principle was applied to all devices of the mill. In February last year it was introduced to precision winders andglow furnace, and in May to preliminary drawing machines and grindery in the welding wire unit. In September works on the introduction of Kaizen to other steelworks

Page | 28

Page 29: LEAN Project

departments started – the upgraded quality steel wire rod mill. As part of the program workers tidy their work area and improve work organization at theirworkplaces. The purpose behind both TPM and the 5S method is to increase efficiency through the expansion of knowledge and skills of the workers, and their responsibility.Workers become more committed to their work, they are able to properly understand a given situation and make the right decisions. The company runs aspecial incentive program called the "Idea of the Month". A special team composed of the management of a given department and the CEO, award a financial prize to the authors of best work organization improvement solutions. The "Idea of the Month" program atArcelorMittal Poland has contributed to:

– the installation of a drainpipe to prevent oil from dripping on the floor in the assembly room,– the use of a special pallet for a narrow production line so that it stays fixed and does not wobble,– improvement in guidance of scrap case on cuttern° 2.

Let us have a closer look at the specific elements of the 5S method. In the Sosnowiec branch of ArcelorMittal (cold rolling mill) a crane for lifting andinstalling rings on the spooling machine was disassembled, the floor in the assembly room was renovated (any bumps or signs of unevenness were removed) and thepackaging line was equipped with oil mist ventilation to protect the worker’s health. The cold rolling mill branch has already managed to dispose of around 80 percent ofall items marked with red cards. More over team leaders are responsible for checking workplaces both before and after work to ensure that workers maintain order. Thecontrol checks also take place during work. In 5S standardization and compliance with procedures is needed. Standards may concern the item marking methods, theuse of colors, codes, marking models of the floor around the workplace, marking models of tools access zones, etc. The whole system is subject to periodic and running138 METALURGIJA 48 (2009) 2, 137-140B. GAJDZIK: INTRODUCTION OF TOTAL PRODUCTIVE MAINTENANCE IN STEELWORKS PLANTS controls. In addition, a cross control by workers holdingthe same posts at different departments or branches of the company takes place _6_.SAFETY OF WORK IN STEELWORKSThe Value statement of the ArcelorMittal concern is: “We are committed to the health and safety of all employees, both on and off the job in order to become themost admired steel company”. The marketing slogan of the company is: “We build a safe organization. We are not as strong as our products and therefore health andsafety issues are "our priority" whereas its strategic goal is "Zero accidents". In 2003 there were 184 accidents in four steelworks plants of the company. In 2005 therewere 99 accidents. In 2006 there were 119 accidents and in 2007 there were 74 accidents. Approximately 64,7% of all accidents are caused by human errors and routine,

Page | 29

Page 30: LEAN Project

whereas 35,3%of accidents are due to bad work organization, the majority of which means lack of compliance with safety regulations concerning work organizationand the remaining part a consequence of inattention, forgetfulness or lack of knowledge. Accidents are most frequent at toolmaker, smelter and electrician workstations.The company organizes periodical health and safety trainings, courses and drills on e.g. first aid to improve work. Besides all accidents are discussed with workers and analyzed. The company wants to reduce the accident rate to 3,0 in 2008 (currently the accident rate is 3,6). The accident rate = number of accidents x 1 000 000 / worked man-hours _7_.THE ASSESSMENT SYSTEM FOR WORKERAND SUPERVISOR POSITION – CASE STUDYDue to organizational development of ArcelorMittal Company on the Polish steel market, the company has decided to implement the Assessment System. The primarygoal for the implementation of the Current and Periodic Assessment system for worker and supervisor positions is to ensure objectivity and comparability of resultsand skill assessment for particular employees. The key components of the system are: an assessment interview with a superior (it will provide an opportunity topresent mutual expectations, exchange comments on results and quality of work as well as set the path of professional development for each employee); appointment of a steering committee and a review of workplaces and results achieved at individual workplaces, the reviewwill be based on the analysis of organizational documents and information gathered by consultants during their visits at particular workplaces; identification of criteriaused for current and periodical assessment of employees; preparation of assessment rules and tools to which employees holding a supervision position will beintroduced during trainings; assessment of employees and their work.

WORKERS’ AWARENESS

There are various types of awareness. There is ecological awareness, marketing awareness, market awareness, productivity, work efficiency or work safety awareness,etc. What is work safety awareness then? It is all the information and beliefs on how to work not to cause an accident and the ability to see the link between efficiencyand working conditions and a worker’s health and life. Work safety awareness is combination of the health and safety system and the TPM concept. Worker’s awarenessin the TPM system consists of their expertise, views and opinions on safe work methods, work organization improvement, care for the machines, etc. It is also the assessmentof workers’ results and attitude at individual workplaces. It is also the adopted approach to work and safe behavior models. The particular elements overlapand blend creating a whole. The higher the level of worker’s TPM awareness, the higher quality of organizational culture and the more efficient and safer the work is.Lack of awareness invariably has a negative impact.

Page | 30

Page 31: LEAN Project

CASE STUDY – WORKERS’ AWARENESSMANAGEMENT PROJECTIn 2008 ArcelorMittal Poland commenced work on the development and introduction of a project called ’management of workers’ awareness on health andsafety at work’. The project can be divided into the following stages:

1. Development of a planning document i.e. the so-called "Corporate Health and Safety at Work Strategy". The document is based on the "photography" of the actual state of health and safety and the identified workers’ awareness on safe work methods (interviews,observations, surveys).

2. Dividing the strategy into action programs. Currently workshops for team leaders are being organized at the company. Team leaders will be members of theso-called project support teams. Team leaders participate in workshops during which they learn about methods and courses of action that influence workers’ awarenessand, as a result, the change of their attitude to safety. The support teams also include representatives of trade unions, supervision employees and public labor inspectors. These teams play, first of all, an advisory role in the company. Team members hold regular meetings with workers and explain them what awareness management is about. The first workshops are also attended by management staff which is to set a good example.The next workshops are attended by the remaining company workers.METALURGIJA 48 (2009) 2, 137-140 139B. GAJDZIK: INTRODUCTION OF TOTAL PRODUCTIVE MAINTENANCE IN STEELWORKS PLANTS

3. Continuous improvement of the safety management system and implementation of new methods for raising workers’ awareness on TPM and work safety.

BENEFITS OF TPMIn the companies that have implemented TPM the following can be seen: growth of employees’ involvement, new skills learned and creativity released, formany people participation in the TPM program provides the first opportunity to actively engage in corporate life and feel ownership at a workplace; increase in work efficiency(by as much as 150 %, experts say); breakdown reduction (drop by 90%or even 99 %); drop in the number of accidents at work (62888 persons injured in accidentsat work in industry in 1995, 42871 persons in 2006, drop by 20017 persons); reduction of internal waste (by 90 %); improvement of work quality and reductionof complaints (by cca. 75 %); reduction of production costs by 30 %; reduction of materials kept on-stock by 50 %; drop or lack of environment-relatedbreakdowns; increase in the number of proposals for new organizational solutions, development of workers’ initiative in search of innovation.

Page | 31

Page 32: LEAN Project

These are the techniques that should be implemented in TAAT STEEL to be a global leader in operation and process in the production of steel.

CONCLUSIONThe adjustment of a steelwork company activity to the new rules of global economy requires the application of modern work organization solutions. The aim ofTPM and 5S is to increase worker’s efficiency through the improvement of their skill and knowledge as well as the extension of their responsibilities. Workers becomemore committed to their work, they are able to understand and interpret a given situation correctly and make the right decisions, which altogether contributes to,among others, higher productivity and improvement of working conditions. In the paper attention was paid to the modern methods – TPM - Total Productive Maintenanceand "5 S". These methods are customer oriented and help to obtain permanent competitive advantage. The process of introduction of these methods is long andrequires organizational and other changes.

Page | 32