Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and Women in Labour, 2006

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    1/121

    LAW COMMISSION OF INDIA

    201ST REPORT

    ON

    EMERGENCY MEDICAL CARE TO VICTIMS OF

    ACCIDENTS AND DURING EMERGENCY MEDICAL

    CONDITION AND WOMEN UNDER LABOUR 

    ( Draft Mod! La" A##$d %

    AUGUST 200&

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    2/121

    LatestLaws.com

    'USTICE M 'AGANNAD)A RAO LAW COMMISSION OF INDIA

    C)AIRMAN S)ASTRI B)AWAN NEW DEL)I*110001

    TEL+ 2,,-../FA+ 2,0/,-&. 2,,---/0E*MAIL+ 34!3567#838#RESIDENCE+ 1 'ANPAT) NEW DEL)I*110011TEL+ 2,019.&

    FNo&(,%12:200&*LC(LS% ,16t A;8ta!6 or to a @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r t4

    ar #ot ta# 3ar of for ra3t8t8o#r6 to >ro8d@rr6o#6 or >r6o#6 8# a @d83a! @rr6o#6 ar t;r#d o;t o# t4 o68t8o# to @a >a@#t 8@@d8at! or t4at t4 4a #o 8#6;ra#3 or t4at t4 ar #ot@@7r6 of a# 634@ "4834 #t8t!6 t4@ to @d83a! r8@7;r6@#tT4 S;>r@ Co;rt r8tratd 8t6 8"6 8# Pa6348@ Ba#r@ Co;rt 8# Par@a#a#d atara

    2

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    3/121

    LatestLaws.com

    I#d8ffr#3 to"ard6 83t8@6 of a338d#t6 a#d t4o6 8# @r3;!8ar to I#d8a 7;t 86 >ra!#t 8# ot4r 3o;#tr86 a!6o I# t4U#8td Stat6 t4r 86 a 6tat;t 3a!!d EMTALA (E@rtd 6ra! >ro868o#6 of EMTALA a#d @ad 6;8ta7!34a#ro8dd t4at #o 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 64a!! rf;6to >ro8d @r8ta!6 a#d @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6 4a to 8#8t8a!! 63r# t4 >r6o#6 to d38d 8f t4 >r6o#6 r;8r @rro868o#6 of t4 A3t "8!! #ota>>! If 8t 86 dtr@8#d t4at t4 >r6o#6 r;8r @rra3t8t8o#r do6 #ot 4a fa38!8t86for 63r#8#8ta! or to a @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 4a8#<fa38!8t86 A6 to "4at 6afr6o#6 64o;!d 7 ta# 3ar of d;r8#< tra#68t a!! t46 @attr6 ar

     >ro8dd 8# dta8! 8# t4 B8!! a##$d to t4 R>ort T4 4o6>8ta!6 a#d@d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6 4a to @a8#ta8# r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    4/121

    LatestLaws.com

    W 4a a!6o >ro8dd t4at t4 Stat6 @;6t >;7!864 a 634@ for r8@7;r6@#t of $>#d8t;r 8#3;rrd 7 4o6>8ta!6 @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6or for a@7;!a#36 a#d t4 Stat6 @;6t a!!o3at 6>arat f;#d6 for t486

     >;r>o6 T4 d;t of t4 Stat6 8# t486 74a!f 3a# 7 tra3d to Art 21 a6"!! a6 to D8r3t8 Pr8#38>!6 of Stat Po!83 #;#38atd 8# t4 Co#6t8t;t8o#of I#d8a

    W 4a >r>ard t4 R>ort a##$8#< a Mod! B8!! to 7 #a3td 7t4 Stat6 a6 " ar a"ar t4at t4 6;7=3t of H4o6>8ta!6 fa!!6 "8t48# E#tr of Stat L86t S#t4 S34d;! of t4 Co#6t8t;t8o# a#d t4rfor 8t "8!! 7 for t4 Stat L>! to @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6 8#38d#ta!!

    A !a" to 3o@>! 4o6>8ta!6 a#d @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6 to att#d o#

    83t8@6 of a338d#t6 t4o6 8# @r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    5/121

    LatestLaws.com

    INDE TO CONTENTS

    C4a>tr T8t! Pa

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    6/121

    LatestLaws.com

    C4a>tr I

    I#trod;3tor

    T4 La" Co@@8668o# of I#d8a 4a6 ta# ;> t4 6;7=3t of 

    HE@rr@ Co;rt a#d 3rta8# >ro868o#6 of t4 Motor 

    V483!6 A3t 19-- 8t 86 a fa3t of !8f t4at t4r 86 #o >ro>r >r*4o6>8ta!

    @d83a! 3ar a#d t4at >r8at 4o6>8ta!6 a#d @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6 "4o ar

    #ar6t to t4 >!a3 of a338d#t rf;6 to ad@8t 83t8@6 # for @r!a t4at t4 3a66 ar @d83o*!

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    7/121

    LatestLaws.com

    @d83a! 3ar 86 #366ar a#d @o6t 83t8@6 d8 8f #o 6;34 3ar 86 aa8!a7!

    or 86 #ot ;r>o6 of @rat8#t a#d t486 ;#fort;#at! 86 #ot do#

    I# t4 >;7!83 8#tr6t 3a6 f8!d 8# t4 S;>r@ Co;rt o# t4 #d for 

    @rr@ Co;rt of I#d8a 6tatd 8#

    Parmand Katra  Union of India + AIR 19-9 SC 20,9 a6 fo!!o"6+

    ?Er 8#=;rd 38t8# 7ro;ro3d;ra! 3r8@8#a! !a" 64o;!d 7 a!!o"d to o>rat 8# ordr to

    ao8d #d8@#t for a @d83a!

     >rof668o#a! "4# 4 86 3a!!d ;>o# or r;6td to att#d to a#

    8#=;rd >r6o# #d8#< 486 @d83a! a6686ta#3 8@@d8at! T4

    ffort to 6a t4 >r6o# 64o;!d 7 t4 to> >r8or8t #ot o#! of t4

    @d83a! >rof668o#a! 7;t # of t4 >o!83 or a# ot4r 38t8# "4o

    4a>>#6 to 7 3o##3td "8t4 t4 @attr or "4o 4a>>#6 to #ot83

    6;34 a# 8#38d#t or a 68t;at8o#

    ?Pr6rat8o# of 4;@a# !8f 86 of >ara@o;#t 8@>orta#3 T4at

    86 6o o# a33o;#t of t4 fa3t t4at o#3 !8f 86 !o6t t4 6tat;6 ;o a#t

    3a##ot 7 r6tord a6 r6;rr3t8o# 86 7o#d t4 3a>a38t of @a# T4

     >at8#t "4t4r 4 7 a# 8##o3#t >r6o# or 7 a 3r8@8#a! !8a7! to

     >;#864@#t ;#dr t4 !a"6 of t4 6o38t 8t 86 t4 o7!8!at dat4 7 #

    !;#864@#t A do3tor at t4 Gor#@#t 4o6>8ta! >o68t8o#d to

    /

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    8/121

    LatestLaws.com

    @t t4 Stat o7!8r6r8#< !8f Er do3tor "4t4r at a Gor#@#t

    4o6>8ta! or ot4r"86 4a6 t4 >rof668o#a! o7!8rof668o# T4

    o7!8ara@o;#t !a"6 of >ro3d;r

    "4t4r 8# 6tat;t6 or ot4r"86 "4834 "o;!d 8#trfr "8t4 t4

    d8634arro3d8#< to trat t4 8#=;rd 83t8@ o# 486 a>>ara#3

     7for 48@ 8t4r 7 48@6!f or 78#< 3arr8d 7 ot4r6 Ko#a!

    rrat a6 fttr6 8# t4

     >ro366 of d8634ar

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    9/121

    LatestLaws.com

    ?It 86 $>3td of t4 @@7r6 of t4 !rof668o# "4834 86

    t4 ot4r 4o#o;ra7! >rof668o# to 4o#o;r t4 >r6o#6 8# t4

    @d83a! >rof668o# a#d 6 t4at t4 ar #ot 3a!!d to 3td t4at

    "4r t4 fa3t6 ar 6o 3!ar 8t 86 $>3td t4at ;##366ar

    4ara66@#t of t4 @@7r6 of t4 @d83a! >rof668o# 8t4r 7

    "a of r;6t6 for ad=o;r#@#t or 7 3ro66 $a@8#at8o#

    64o;!d 7 ao8dd 6o t4at t4 a>>r4#68o# t4at t4 @# 8# t4

    @d83a! >rof668o# 4a "4834 >r#t6 t4@ fro@ d8634arr6o# "4o #d6 t48r a6686ta#3

    ;t@o6t 86 r@od a#d a 38t8# #d8#< t4 a6686ta#3 of a

    @a# 8# t4 @d83a! >rof668o# r386 8t

    I# Para@a#a#d atara U#8o# of I#d8a 19-9 SC 20,9 t4 S;>r@

    Co;rt o76rd t4at

    ?r 8#=;rd 38t8# 7ro;ro3d;ra! 3r8@8#a! !a" 64o;!d 7 a!!o"d to o>rat 8# ordr to

    ao8d #

    ?It 86 f;rt4r 6;7@8ttd t4at 8t 86 for t4 Gor#@#t of I#d8a to

    ta #366ar a#d 8@@d8at 6t>6 to a@#d ar8o;6

     >ro868o#6 of !a" "4834 3o@ 8# t4 "a of

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    10/121

    LatestLaws.com

    "8t4o;t "a8t8#< for t4 >o!83 r>ort a6 3o@>!t8o# of >o!83

    for@a!8t T4 64o;!d 7 fr fro@ far t4at t4 "o;!d 7

    ;##366ar8! 4ara66d or >ro63;td for do8#< t48r d;t

    "8t4o;t f8r6t 3o@>!8#< "8t4 t4 >o!83 for@a!8t86 It 86 f;rt4r 

    6;7@8ttd t4at a do3tor 64o;!d #ot f! 48@6!f 4a#d83a>>d 8#

    $t#d8#< 8@@d8at 4!> 8# 6;34 3a66 far8#< t4at 4 "o;!d

     7 4ara66d 7 t4 >o!83 or drar6#t

    to >ro t4 6a@ or 6;7=3t 48@6!f to 3ro66*

    $a@8#at8o#:4ara66@#t for !o#< >r8od of t8@

    I# Pa6348@ Ba#ara 9% t4at

    ?8# t486 3o#t$t S4r8 D4aa# 4a6 8#8td o;r att#t8o# to t4 r3#t

    d!o>@#t6 t4at 4a ta# 8# t486 f8!d 8# t4 U#8td Stat6 T4r

    8t "a6 fo;#d t4at >r8at 4o6>8ta!6 "r t;r#8#< a"a ;#8#6;rd

    8#d8r6o#6 8# #d or ;rat8#t6

    "r oft# tra#6frrd to or d;@>d o# >;7!83 4o6>8ta!6 a#d t4

    r6;!t8#< d!a or d#8a! of trat@#t 4ad 6o@t8@6 d86a6tro;6

    3o#6;#36 To @t t486 68t;at8o# t4 US Co#ra3t83 of d;@>8#< of >at8#t6 7 >r8at

    4o6>8ta!6 B t4 6a8d A3t a!! 4o6>8ta!6 t4at r38 @d83ar 7#f8t6

    10

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    11/121

    LatestLaws.com

    a#d @a8#ta8# @rrfor@ t"o ta66

     7for t4 @a tra#6fr or d8634ar8ta! @;6t >rfor@ a @d83a! 63r#8#< $a@8#at8o# of 

    a!! >ro6>3t8 >at8#t6 ra

    (88% 8f t4 4o6>8ta! dtr@8#6 t4at a >at8#t 6;ffr6 fro@ a#

    @rr6o#a! 4ar@ a6 a d8r3t r6;!t of a

     >art838>at8#< 4o6>8ta!6 8o!at8o# 3a# 7r8#< a 388! 6;8t for da@ar@ Co;rt f;rt4r 4!d (>ara 9% t4at

    ?t4 Co#6t8t;t8o# #86ao>!

    Pro8d8#< ad;at @d83a! fa38!8t86 for t4 >o>! 86 a# 66#t8a!

     >art of t4 o7!8ro8d @d83a! 3ar to t4 >r6o#

    11

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    12/121

    LatestLaws.com

    68#< to aa8! of t4o6 fa38!8t86 Art 21 8@>o66 a# o7!8r#t do3tor6 fro@ >ro@>t!

    att#d8#< o# 6r8o;6! 8#=;rd >r6o#6 a#d a338d#t 3a66 7for t4

    arr8a! of >o!83 a#d t4;6 ta8#< 8#to 3or>arat8o# of FIR a#d ot4r for@a!8t86 7 t4 >o!83 )o"r t4

    d>o##t @o6t 4;@7! 6;7@8t6 t4at t4 r6>o#d#t 64a!! a!"a6 a78d

     7 t4 d8r3t8o#6 a#d rot3td ;#dr 

    Part III of t4 Co#6t8t;t8o# (;#dr Art 21% a#d t4o;r@

    Co;rt d8r3t8o# t4at 8# a!! a338d#t 3a66 8rr6>3t8 of t4 >o!83

    3o@>!a8#t 8t 86 t4 f;#da@#ta! d;t o# t4 >art of t4 4o6>8ta!6 ("4r t4

    8#=;rd "r ta#% to att#d o# t4 >at8#t6 ;#fort;#at! #ot48#< 86 do#

    8# t4 @attr A6 a r6;!t @a# >o>! 4a 7# d8#< "8t4o;t a# 3ar

    or att#t8o#

    Do3tor6 >o8#t o;t t4at at !a6t 0 >r 3#t of t4 fata!8t 3a# 7

    artd 8f t4 83t8@6 ar ad@8ttd to a 4o6>8ta! "8t48# t4 f8r6t o# 4o;r

    12

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    13/121

    LatestLaws.com

    For a# a338d#t 83t8@ 8t 86 8@>orta#t t4at 4 86 >ro8dd 7a683 f8r6t a8d

    "4834 #a7!6 48@ to 6;r8 t8!! 4 ra346 t4 4o6>8ta!

    W8t4 8#3ra68#< 483! >o>;!at8o# t4r 86 a# r*8#3ra68#<

    #;@7r of a338d#t6 o# o;r road6 T4o;

    T4 Nat8o#a! Co#6;@r D86>;t6 Rdr66a! Co@@8668o# 8# Praat

    ;@ar M;4r= 6 R;7 G#ra! )o6>8ta! Ot4r6 (2.200%

    d3!ard t4at a 4o6>8ta! 86 d;t 7o;#d to a33>t a338d#t 83t8@6 a#d >at8#t6

    "4o ar 8# 3r8t83a! 3o#d8t8o# a#d t4at 8t 3a##ot rf;6 trat@#t o# t4

    o68t8o# to >a t4 f or @t t4

    $>#66 or o# t4 orat8o#

     7;6 48t 486 @otor33! T4 83t8@ "a6 ta# to t4 #ar6t 4o6>8ta! t4

    R;7 G#ra! )o6>8ta! T4 83t8@ "a6 3o#638o;6 "4# 4 ra34d t4

    4o6>8ta! a#d 64o"d t4 do3tor6 486 @d8*3!a8@ >o!83 8#6;r8#< 48@ for R6

    &000:* ) a66;rd t4 4o6>8ta! t4at a!! t4 78!!6 "o;!d 7 3!ard a#d

    r;6td t4at trat@#t 7

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    14/121

    LatestLaws.com

    T4 Nat8o#a! Co#6;@r Co@@8668o# "48! 8@>o68#< da@a8ta! o76rd t4at do3tor6 at t4 4o6>8ta!6

    3a##ot f8r6t d@a#d f6 7for aat8#t a#d t4 3a##ot

    a!6o 8#686t o# 3o#6#t of r!at86 of t4 83t8@ 7for 6tart8#< @rr@ Co;rt rfrrd to a7o It 4!d t4at t4 >r6rat8o# of 

    4;@a# !8f 86 of >ara@o;#t 8@>orta#3 T4at 86 a!6o 8# 3o#6o#a#3 "8t4 t4

    Cod of Md83a! Et4836 R3or of f6 3a# "a8t 7;t trat@#t 3a##ot 7

    d#8d

    T4 S;>r@ Co;rt 8# I#d8a# Md83a! A66o38at8o# 6

    VSS4a#ta+199(&% SCC &1 o76rd t4at a 4o6>8ta! 4a6 a a#d t4o6 "4o ar tratd fr t4

    fr >at8#t6 a3;8r t4 6tat;6 of 3o#6;@r6 73a;6 8t 86 d@d t4at t4

    trat@#t to fr >at8#t6 86 d@d to 7 @t 7 t4 >a8#< >at8#t6

    I# 8" of t4 a7o =;dr@ Co;rt a#d t4

     Nat8o#a! Co#6;@r Rdr66a! For;@ a#d t4 fa3t t4at t4r 86 #o

    a>>ro>r8at !6 of @r 8#3!;d8#< @otor f8r a#d ot4r a338d#t6

    "4834 ta >!a3 d;r8#< art4;a6 f!ood6 t3 It 3a# a!6o 7 8# r6>3t of 

    a "o@a# ;#dr !a7o;r

    1.

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    15/121

    LatestLaws.com

    Chapter II

    C;rr#t 6tat of @ro>! "r 8#=;rd Of t46 /- "r >r6o#6 8# t4

    ad6tr8a#6 t"o "4!r 

    r8dr6 a#d 7833!86t6 >a66#a>r 

    (200&% 6;7@8ttd 7 M6 S4radd D64@;4 ILS La" Co!!

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    16/121

    LatestLaws.com

    I#d8a to 6;ro>r8at @t4od6 of @rr6o#6 !oo6 t48r !86 a##;a!! d; to

    8#=;r86 #ar! / !a4 >r6o#6 ar 4o6>8ta!8d a#d t4r a#d 4a!f !a4

     >r6o#6 "4o r38 @8#or 8#=;r86 r6#t EMS a#d @ad a #;@7r of 

    r3o@@#dat8o#6 for 8@>!@#tat8o# 8# t4 64ort tr@ a#d 8# t4 !o#r8at 4o6>8ta!6 6>o#6or6 t3 O;t of t4 100 3#tr6 tar8ta!6 a#d 8#6t8t;t8o#6 "48! t4 r@a8#8#< ,& ar

     >art! 6>o#6ord 7 t4 Gor#@#t a#d >ro8d a @o#t4! 6;>>ort of 

    1&

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    17/121

    LatestLaws.com

    R6.0000:* or t4 a3t;a! $>#d8t;r 8#3;rrd 7 t46 6>o#6or6 (#ot

    $3d8#< R6 .0000:* D;r8#< t4 ar 200. "8t4 t8@! @d83a! a8d

    t46 3#tr6 ar 6a8d to 4a 6ad 199 !86 tratd &.00 6r8o;6

    8#=;rd 3a66 a#d 1,19 >r6o#6 "8t4 @8#or 8#=;r86 (878d Da#648

     N8=4ara6 Pa>r%

    T4 I#d8a# E@r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    18/121

    LatestLaws.com

    3o@>r4#68 66t@ of tra;@a 3ar 7 t4 M8#86tr of Road Tra#6>ort

    a#d )88ta!6 #ar t4 Nat8o#a! )8 ;a!8f83at8o# for t4 6taff to 7 d>!od o# t4@ T486 86 to #6;r

    t4at 6taff "o;!d 7 a7! to 6ta78!8 t4 3o#d8t8o# of 83t8@6 >r8or to

    4o6>8ta!8at8o#

    T4 @t8#< "a6 att#dd 7 6#8or off83r6 of t4 D>art@#t of 

    Road Tra#6>ort a#d )8art@#t of E3o#o@83 Affa8r6

    (I#6;ra#3 D8868o#% a#d M8#86tr of T!3o@@;#83at8o#

    T4 ot4r d3868o#6 8#3!;d !o@#t of 

    a@7;!a#36 to #at8o#a! 48

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    19/121

    LatestLaws.com

    I# Ta@8! Nad; Gor#@#t 4a6 6ta7!864d ;#dr 63t8o# 21 of t4

    Motor V483!6 A3t 19-- a#d a>>o8#td a Road Saft Co@@8668o#r "4o

    4a6 ar8o;6 d;t86 8#3!;d8#< a338d#t r!8f

    A Road Saft F;#d 4a6 7# 3ratd d;r8#< t4 ar 2000 to f;#d

    Road Saft A3t8at8o# A!!o3at8o#6 "8!! 7 @ad to t4 f;#d fro@

    3o@>o;#d8#< f6 a#d 6>ot f8#6 3o!!3td 7 Tra#6>ort a#d Po!83

    D>art@#t6 T4 f;#d "8!! 7 ad@8#86trd 7 a 3o@@8tt 34a8rd 7 t4

    )o@ S3rtar

    T4 )8o6t6 a#d !8#8#< "8t4 E@r4o# #ar a338d#t 6>ot A f;!! ;8>>d a@7;!a#3 "8t4 a

    tra8#d >ara@d83 86 a!"a6 o# 6ta#d7 to r6>o#d to 6;34 3a!!6 V83t8@6

    ar tra#6>ortd to t4 #ar6t 4o6>8ta!6 fr of 34ar+::"""t#ro>o6d

    19

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    20/121

    LatestLaws.com

    T4 Ba683 fat;r of t4 634@ 86 to 6ta7!864 100 @r! of 

     >;7!83*>r8at >art#r648> @od! T4 6tart8#< 8#fra6tr;3t;r !8 3;783!

    a@7;!a#3 t3 86 >ro8dd 7 t4 6>o#6or8#< a8ta! T4 !o3a!

    Rort off836 4!> 8# 4o# a#d "atr:E!3tr838t

    3o##3t8o#6 So@ C#tr6 ar f;!! 6>o#6ord "4r t4 f;!! @a8#t#a#3

    3o6t 8#3!;d8#< 6a!ar f;! @d838# t3 ar 7or# 7 t4 6>o#6or8#<

    4o6>8ta!6

    So@ C#tr6 ar 6>o#6ord "4r t4 6taff 86 >ro8dd 7 t4

    4o6>8ta!6 a#d @a8#t#a#3 $>#d8t;r 86 ro8d t4 @a8#t#a#3 $>#d8t;r A6 o# 2/1200. t4r ar /

    C#tr6 f;#3t8o#8#< a#d 2 @or C#tr6 ar >ro>o6d It 86 6tatd t4at a6

    o# 19200. 1&,2& !86 4a 7# 6ad

    A#d4ra Prad64 + Sata@ EMRI + To!! Fr No10- a#d A@7;!a#36+

    Sata@ "4o ar !adr6 8# 3o@>;tr t34#o!o t4

    E@rr8@ar o7=3t8 86 to a8d t4

    20

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    21/121

    LatestLaws.com

    #d 8# @rro8d8#< t8@!

    att#t8o# a#d 6;>>ort

    T4 Pro=3t "a6 6tr;3t;rd to 7 3arr8d o;t 8# >4a66 to fa38!8tat a

     >!a##d ro!!o;t of @r!83at8o#6 "8t4 NORTEL

    It "a6 d38dd to a# #o"# a6 GTL 4a6

    6t;d8d t4 7;68#66 34a!!#

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    22/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (2% Co@@;#83at8o# Srr 1000 M a#d S@>o68;@ Ca!! C#tr

    Srr "8!! ro;t t4 3a!! to t4 r6>3t8 aa8!a7! Aat34r !o3atd at )dra7ad 64a!! d86>at34 t4

    3a!!6 for r6>3t8 r>8#< a#d tra38#ro>o6a! to 6t ;> a# I#d8a# E@rro@ot8#< a#d #4a#38#< >;7!83

    6aft 7 >ro8d8#< !o!83 fra@"or

    It 86 6tatd t4at t4 3a!! 3#tr o# Md34a! Road (Brra=; Fo;#dat8o#%

    86 r388#< o# a# arar da fro@ ar8o;6 >art6 of t4 t"8#

    38t86 D;r8#< t4 f8r6t . da6 t4 r38d @or t4a# 100&00 3a!!6 a#d

    t4 6ad ,/ !86 T"o*t48rd6 of 3a!!6 "r a338d#t r!atd

    Pr6#t! .0 r6>o#dr6 "or 8# t4r 648ft6 at t4 3a!! 3#tr6

    22

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    23/121

    LatestLaws.com

    ,0 A@7;!a#36 a#d a# ;a! #;@7r of r6>o#dr6 (o# t"o*"4!r6%

    ar 6tat8o#d at a#tao8#t6 t4ro;>d "8t4 a;to@atd $tr#a!

    df8!!87rator "8t4 @;!t8*>ara @o#8tor6 o$>d "8t4 $tr83at too!6 f8r $t8# t4 83t8@

    C;rr#t L8t of t4 fa3t

    t4at ra64 a#d #r86o#@#t @a to 2 ar6 a338d#t6 d; to #

    6to>>d Of 3o;r6 8f 8t a@o;#t6 to 3;!>a7! 4o@838d or @;rdr ;#dr 

    63t8o# 299 rad "8t4 63t8o# ,00 t4 >;#864@#t ;#dr 63t8o#6 ,02 or 

    ,0. @a $t#d to !8f 8@>r86o#@#t or 10 ar6

    I#8t8a!! 8# 19/- a B8!! "a6 8#trod;3d 8# t4 Ra=a Sa74a a#d "a6

     >a66d o# 2,219/- "4834 rfrrd to a@#d@#t of 63t8o# ,0.*A It #ot

    o#! r3o@@#dd 8#3ra6 8# >;#864@#t fro@ 2 ar6 to ar6 8t

     >ro>o6d a #" 63t8o# ,0.B for dr8r6 "4o r;#a"a "8t4o;t 8#for@8#<

     >o!83 "8t48# a ra6o#a7! t8@ t4at t4 >;#864@#t @;6t 7 / ar6

    8@>r86o#@#t

    2,

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    24/121

    LatestLaws.com

    T486 B8!! "a6 #ot >a66d 7 t4 t4# Lo Sa74a o# a33o;#t of 8t6

    d866o!;t8o#

    Latr t4 B8!! "a6 rfrrd to t4 La" Co@@8668o# a#d 8# t4 1&t4

    R>ort t4 a7o a@#d@#t6 "r r8tratd So far a6 63t8o# ,0.B 86

    3o#3r#d 73a;6 a#ot4r 63t8o# "8t4 t4at #;@7r 4ad a!rad 7#

    8#6rtd t4 Co@@8668o# r3o@@#dd a 34a#ro868o# for #o fa;!t !8a78!8t 3;rr#t!

    f8$d at R60000:* 8f dat4 86 3a;6d or R62000:* 8f 8t 3a;66 8#=;r

    T486 86 8#t#dd to 4!> t8d or 8@@d8at f8#a#38a! >ro7!@6 T4r 86

    of 3o;r6 >ro868o# for 3o@>#6at8o# for #

     >r6o# T4r 86 a6t !;t8#<

    3o@>#6at8o# U#dr a# HA3t*>o!83 >ro868o# 3o#ta8#d 8# t4 6a8d A3t

    I#6;ra#3 Co@>a#86 "4834 866; >o!8386 4a to 3or 3rta8# @a#dator

    r866 Lo Ada!at6 a#d Motor A338d#t C!a8@ Tr87;#a!6 a!! or t4

    3o;#tr >ro8d r@d86 for >a@#t of 3o@>#6at8o# for dat4 or 8#=;r

    I# t4 1/-t4 R>ort of t4 La" Co@@8668o# (2001% a !a3;#a 8# t4

    !a" >o8#td 7 t4 )8#6at8o# d86 a6 a

    3o#6;#3 of t4 8#=;r "48! t4 3!a8@ 86 >#d8#< 7for t4 C!a8@6

    Tr87;#a! t4 >ro3d8#r6#td 7 486

    2.

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    25/121

    LatestLaws.com

    !r6#tat86 #d#3 of t4 !8t8>roa34d

    S3t8o# 1-/ 3rat6 a# off#3 8f 63 1,. 86 #ot 3o@>!8d "8t4 S3t8o# 1,.

    rad6 a6 fo!!o"6+

    ?S3t8o# 1,.+ D;t of Dr8r 8# 3a6 of a338d#t a#d 8#=;r to a >r6o#+

    W4# a# >r6o# 86 8#=;rd or a# >ro>rt of a t48rd >art 86

    da@a

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    26/121

    LatestLaws.com

     7 d;t of r rra3t8t8o#r or t4 do3tor 

    o# d;t 8# t4 4o6>8ta! 8@@d8at! to att#d to t4 8#=;rd

     >r6o# a#d r#dr @d83a! a8d or trat@#t "8t4o;t "a8t8#< for 

    a# >ro3d;ra! for@a!8t86 ;#!66 t4 8#=;rd >r6o# or 486

    o!83 #;@7r a#d >r8od of 8t6 a!8d8t

    (88% Dat t8@ a#d >!a3 of a338d#t

    (888% Part83;!ar6 of t4 >r6o#6 8#=;rd or 8!!d 8# t4

    a338d#t

    (8% Na@ of t4 dr8r a#d t4 >art83;!ar6 of dr88#< !83#3

    E$>!a#at8o#+ For t4 >;r>o66 of t486 63t8o# t4 $>r668o# ?dr8r

    8#3!;d6 t4 o"#r of t4 483!

    U#dr 63t8o# 1-/ of t4 6a8d A3t "4or fa8!6 to 3o@>! "8t4 t4

     >ro868o#6 of t4 ar8o;6 3!a;66 of 63t8o# 1,. 64a!! 7 >;#864a7! "8t4

    8@>r86o#@#t for a tr@ "4834 @a $t#d to t4r @o#t46 or "8t4 "4834

    @a $t#t to R600:* or "8t4 7ot4 If 8t 86 a 63o#d t8@ 6;34 a# off#3 86

    2&

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    27/121

    LatestLaws.com

    3o@@8ttd 7 a >r6o# t4 >;#864@#t 7 8@>r86o#@#t @a $t#d to 68$

    @o#t46 or "8t4 f8# "4834 @a $t#d ;> R6 1000:* or "8t4 7ot4

    B;t 8# a !arro868o#6 of t4 Motor V483!6 A3t do #ot 3or 

    a338d#t6 d; to ot4r tra#6>ort 483!6 !8 3art6 33! r8364a" t3 Nor 

    do6 8t 3or 83t8@6 of f8r f!ood t3

    I# add8t8o# >a66r6 7 "4o "8t#66 t4 a338d#t far 4ara66@#t 7

     >o!83 a#d ar #ot "8!!8#< to ta t4 83t8@ to a 4o6>8ta! or r>ort to t4

     >o!83 T4 do #ot "a#t to 7 3a!!d to t4 >o!83 6tat8o# or to t4 Co;rt

    for t48r 6tat@#t6 or 8d#3 to 7 r3ordd

    Pr*4o6>8ta! Car+ E;8>>d A@7;!a#36 a#d tra#6>ort

    T4 Br8t864 Md83a! 'o;r#a! #otd 8# o# of 8t6 r8"6 o# Htra;@a

    866;6 t4at 6o38t 6@6 to a33>t a !o"r 6ta#dard of 6aft for road ;6r6

    t4a# for ot4r @od6 of tra#6>ort I# I#d8a t4 >ro7!@ 86 @or a3;t d; to

    64orta

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    28/121

    LatestLaws.com

    8#fra6tr;3t;r 8# 8ta!6 a#d 73a;6 of r6o##!

    6taff8#< >rof668o#a! a@7;!a#3 6r836 "8!! @a a "or!d of d8ffr#3

    T4 Br8t864 'o;r#a! 6tat6 t4at for a338d#t 83t8@6 t4 ro366 7

    ? t4 34a#36 of 6;r8a! ar 7!a a6 " tr;! !a3 a# a"ar#66

    of t4 @o6t 8@>orta#t 6r83 t4 >r*4o6>8ta! 3ar

    H a# traorta#t d3868o#6 ar to 7 ta# It 86 4r t4at t4

    3o#3>t of t4 Go!d# )o;r 3o@6 8#to >!a T4 3o#3>t 3a# 7

     7ttr ;#dr6tood 8f o# "r to !ar# t4 >r8@ar (Tr8@oda!% 3a;66

    of dat4 8# @a=or a338d#t6 I# fa3t t4 Lo#do# 7!a6t6 48

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    29/121

    LatestLaws.com

    A7o;t t4 >r*4o6>8ta! fa38!8t86 aa8!a7! 8# U t4 a;t4or6 6a t4at

    8# t4 U#8td 8#>ort 66t@6 ar ;8t ff3t8 T4

     Nat8o#a! )a!t4 Sr836 4a6 "!!*;8>>d a@7;!a#36 "8t4 to> 3!a66

     >r6o##! (>ara*@d83a!6% to @a#aff3t8! art a# traro>r 

    a6666@#t of t4 8#=;r86 a#d t4 ;83! tra#6>ort t4 83t8@6 to t4

    #ar6t 4o6>8ta!6 B t4 t8@ t4 83t8@ ra346 t4 4o6>8ta! 4 or 64 86

    a!@o6t 6ad a#d 8# 73o@6 a6 for 6tart8#< df8#8t8 trat@#t

    I# I#d8a a33ord8#< to t4 a7o a;t4or6 t4 68t;at8o# 86 d8ffr#t

    W4#r a# a338d#t o33;r6 t4 fo3;6 o# 6a8#< t4 !8f of t4 83t8@6

    a;38t of >o>! "8t4 a# a"ar#66 of t4 8@>orta#3 of >r*4o6>8ta! 3ar

    W4at 86 r;8rd 86 a "!! @a8#ta8#d 6tat*of*t4*art a@7;!a#3 "8t4

    o$ara*@d83a! 6taff @;6t 7 aa8!a7! at a!! t8@6 8#

    t4 a@7;!a#3

    T4 ort (E$>r66 N"6!8# A;

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    30/121

    LatestLaws.com

    6>a38o;6 a#d 4a @d83a! fa38!8t86 f8ttd 8#68d t4 a@7;!a#36 T4

    ada#3d ;8>@#t 8# 78< a#6 6a6 a >ara@d83a! "r >r8o;6! #ot

    aa8!a7! 8# t4 O@#8 Va#6 or G>686 I# 3a6 t4r 86 a 6r8o;6 road

    a338d#t 8f t4 a@7;!a#3 86 #ot "!! ;8>>d a#d 8f >ara@d83a! >r6o##!

    ar #ot aa8!a7! 8# t4 a@7;!a#3 t4 tra#6>ort fa38!8t do6 #ot ;a!8f for 

     78#< r3or*4o6>8ta! 3ar fa38!8t

    )86 E$3!!#3 t4 Pr68d#t of I#d8a S4r8 AP' A7d;! a!a@ 8# 486

    8#a;

    A6 of #o" 8# I#d8a t4r 86 #o >ro>r !8ta!6

    to att#d a338d#t 83t8@6 a#d >ro8d a!! @d83a! fa38!8t86 for 6ta78!88#<

     >at8#t6 8# @rara@d836 for >r 4o6>8ta! 3ar

    ,0

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    31/121

    LatestLaws.com

    d;r8#< tra#6>ort (8% to a8d a#d 8@>!@#t tra;@a 3ar 66t@ rt a6686ta#3 o# a33o;#t

    of t4 !8!84ood of fa38#< to 3o@>! "8t4 !>d @d83a! fa38!8t86 or >ara*@d83a! 6taff 8t 86

    3!ar t4at t4 68t;at8o# #d6 to 7 r@d8d 7 3orr3t8 a3t8o# W ar

     >ro>o68#< draft ! 8# t486 d8r3t8o#

    It 86 f8r6t #366ar to 3rta8# !a"6 r!at8#< to @r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    32/121

    LatestLaws.com

    C(APT)* III

    )mer'en#& Medi#al Care pro#edure$ in (o$pital$ other +uri$di#tion$+

    I# t4 34a>tr*II " 4ad o33a68o# to rfr 7r8f! to t4 fa38!8t86

    aa8!a7! 8# t4 U#8td 8#!a36 8#

    I#d8a B;t 8t 86 #366ar to rfr to t4 @rro3d;r6 8# ot4r =;r86d83t8o#6 8# 6o@ @or dta8!

    U,S,A,-

    Prote#tion to tho$e .ho render emer'en#& #are of in/ured-

    I# t4 Stat of V8rr6o#

    "4o 8# ro8d6 a6686ta#3 ;>o# r;6t of a#

     >o!83 aart@#t r63; or @r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    33/121

    LatestLaws.com

    I# N" Yor a 68@8!ar >ro868o# $86t6 8# Art ,0 of t4 P;7!83 )a!t4

    La" E@rro8d6 t4at a# >r6o#

    "4o o!;#tar8! a#d "8t4o;t $>3tat8o# of a# @o#tar 3o@>#6at8o#

    r#dr6 f8r6t a8d or trat@#t at t4 63# of a# a338d#t or ot4r @r8ta! or to a >r6o# "4o 86 ;#3o#638o;6 8!! or 8#=;rd 64a!! #ot

     7 !8a7! for da@aro8d @rat8#t6

    "8t4 68@8!ar @d83a! 3o#d8t8o#6 @;6t 7 tratd 3o#686t#t! T4 !a"

    a>>!86 to 4o6>8ta!6 t4at a33>t Md83ar r8@7;r6@#t a#d to a!! t48r 

     >at8#t6 #ot =;6t t4o6 3ord 7 Md83ar

    ,,

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    34/121

    LatestLaws.com

    T4 G;8d for I#trfa38!8t Pat8#t Tra#6fr >;7!864d 7 t4 Nat8o#a!

    )88ta!6 4a t46

     7a683 o7!88ta!6 @;6t >ro8d a!! >at8#t6 "8t4 a @d83a!

    63r#8#< $a@8#at8o# to dtr@8# "4t4r a# @r38a!8d 3a>a78!8t86 ar o7!8t

    tra#6fr6 8f t4 4a t4 3a>a78!8t86 to trat t4@ Md83a!

    3ar 3a##ot 7 d!ad 7 ;6t8o#6 a7o;t @t4od6 of >a@#t

    or 8#6;ra#3 3ora>ro>r8at @d83a! 63r#8#< $a@8#at8o#

    8d#t8f86 t4at #o @rard8 t4 >at8#t6 4a!t4

    ,.

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    35/121

    LatestLaws.com

    T4 N)TSA G;8d f;rt4r 6tat6 t4at EMTALA at8#t 86 3o#68drd 6ta7! for tra#6fr 8f t4 trat8#< >46838a# dtr@8#6

    t4at #o @atr8a! dtr8orat8o# "8!! o33;r d;r8#< t4 @o@#t 7t"#

    fa38!8t86 a#d t4at t4 r388#< fa38!8t 4a6 t4 3a>a78!8t to @a#aat8#t6 @d83a! 3o#d8t8o# EMTALA do6 #ot 3o#tro! t4 tra#6fr of a

    6ta7! >at8#t 4o"r >at8#t6 "8t4 8#3o@>!t! 6ta78!8d @rat8#t (or 6o@o# a3t8#< o# t4 >at8#t6 74a!f% >ro8d6

    a "r8tt# r;6t for tra#6fr d6>8t 78#< 8#for@d of t4

    4o6>8ta!6 EMTALA o7!8ro8d trat@#t or 

    (7% a >46838a# 3rt8f86 t4at @d83a! 7#f8t6 ra6o#a7! $>3td

    fro@ tra#6fr o;t"8o8#t6 o;t t4

    G;8d% t4 fo!!o"8#< 6t>6 @;6t 7 ta#+

    (8% t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! @;6t >ro8d a!! @d83a!

    trat@#t "8t48# 8t6 3a>a38t "4834 @8#8@86 t4 r86 to

    t4 8#d88d;a!6 4a!t4

    (88% t4 r388#< fa38!8t @;6t a33>t t4 tra#6fr a#d @;6t

    4a 6>a3 aa8!a7! a#d ;a!8f8d >r6o##! to trat t4

    8#d88d;a!

    (888% t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! @;6t 6#d 3o>86 of a!! @d83a!

    r3ord6 r!atd to t4 @r46838a# o# 3a!! rf;66 or fa8!6 to a6686t 8# t4

    ,

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    36/121

    LatestLaws.com

     >at8#t6 3a6 t4 >46838a#6 #a@ a#d addr66 @;6t 7

    do3;@#td o# t4 @d83a! r3ord6 >ro8dd to t4

    r388#< fa38!8t

    (8% ;a!8f8d >r6o##! "8t4 t4 a>>ro>r8at @d83a!

    ;8>@#t @;6t a33o@>a# t4 >at8#t d;r8#< tra#6fr

    T4 tra#6frr8#< >46838a# 7 !a" 4a6 t4 r6>o#6878!8t

    of 6!3t8#< t4 @o6t a>>ro>r8at @a#6 of tra#6>ort to

    8#3!;d ;a!8f8d >r6o##! a#d tra#6>ort ;8>@#t

    U#dr EMTALA t4 >at8#t 3ar d;r8#< tra#6>ort 86 t4 r6>o#6878!8t of 

    t4 tra#6frr8#< >46838a#:4o6>8ta! ;#t8! t4 >at8#t arr86 at t4 r388#<

    fa38!8t T4 tra#6frr8#< >46838a# 86 a!6o r6>o#687! for t4 ordr6 a6 to

    tra#6fr a#d for t4 trat@#t ordr6 to 7 fo!!o"d d;r8#< t4 tra#6>ort

    T486 @a 3o#f!83t "8t4 (US% Stat 6tat;t6 "4834 8# 6o@ 8#6ta#36 a!!o"

    o#! a;t4or8d @d83a! >46838a#6 to r6o##!

    EMTALA do6 #ot rfr to t4 tra#6>ort 6r83 a#d 8t6 @d83a! d8r3t8

    !a8#< ;!t8@at @d83a! r6>o#6878!8t a#d 8t6 tra#68t8o# d;r8#< tra#6>ort

    o># for 8#tr>rtat8o#

    Crt8f83at of #3668t for tra#6fr 86 a r;8r@#t for 

    r8@7;r6@#t 7 t4 C#tr6 for Md83ar a#d Md83*a8d Sr836 (CMS%

    T4 CMS df8#8t8o# of H@d83a! #3668t 86 a6 fo!!o"6+

    HMd83a! #3668t 86 6ta7!864d "4# t4 >at8#t6 3o#d8t8o# 86 6;34

    t4at ;6 of a# ot4r @t4od of tra#6>ortat8o# 86 3o#tra*8#d83atd I#

    a# 3a6 8# "4834 6o@ @a#6 of tra#6>ortat8o# ot4r t4a# a#

    a@7;!a#3 3o;!d 7 ;t8!8d "8t4o;t #da#

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    37/121

    LatestLaws.com

    R8ta! (G;8d for 8#tr*fa38!8t >at8#t tra#6fr A>r8!

    200& N)TSA A>>#d8$ D E%

    EMTALA STATUTE+ (E@r8ta! t4at 4a6 a 4o6>8ta! @rart@#t 8f a# 8#d88d;a!

    ("4t4r or #ot !88ta! @;6t >ro8d for a#

    a>>ro>r8at @d83a! 63r#8#< $a@8#at8o# "8t48# t4 3a>a78!8t of t4

    4o6>8ta!6 @rart@#t 8#3!;d8#< a#38!!ar 6r836 ro;t8#!

    aa8!a7! to t4 @rart@#t to dtr@8# "4t4r or #ot a#

    @r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    38/121

    LatestLaws.com

    $86t6

    (7% NECESSARY STABILIKING TREATMENT FOR EMERGENCY

    MEDICAL CONDITIONS AND LABOR 

    1% IN GENERAL J If a# 8#d88d;a! ("4t4r or #ot !88ta! a#d t4 4o6>8ta! dtr@8#6 t4at t4

    8#d88d;a! 4a6 a# @r8ta! @;6t >ro8d

    8t4r J

    (A% "8t48# t4 6taff a#d fa38!8t86 aa8!a7! at t4 4o6>8ta! for 6;34 f;rt4r 

    @d83a! $a@8#at8o# a#d 6;34 trat@#t a6 @a 7 r;8rd to 6ta78!8 t4

    @d83a! 3o#d8t8o# or 

    (B% for tra#6fr of t4 8#d88d;a! to a#ot4r @d83a! fa38!8t 8# a33orda#3

    "8t4 6;763t8o# (3%

    (2% REFUSAL TO CONSENT TO TREATMENT J A 4o6>8ta! 86 d@d to

    @t t4 r;8r@#t of >ara4 (1%(A% "8t4 r6>3t to a# 8#d88d;a! 8f t4

    4o6>8ta! offr6 t4 8#d88d;a! t4 f;rt4r @d83a! $a@8#at8o# a#d trat@#t

    d63r87d 8# t4at >ara4 a#d 8#for@6 t4 8#d88d;a! (or a >r6o# a3t8#<

    o# t4 8#d88d;a!6 74a!f% of t4 r866 a#d 7#f8t6 to t4 8#d88d;a! of 6;34

    $a@8#at8o# a#d trat@#t 7;t t4 8#d88d;a! (or a >r6o# a3t8#< o# t4

    8#d88d;a!6 74a!f% rf;66 to 3o#6#t to t4 $a@8#at8o# a#d trat@#t

    T4 4o6>8ta! 6ta!! ta a!! ra6o#a7! 6t>6 to 63;r t4 8#d88d;a!6 (or 

     >r6o#6% "r8tt# 8#for@d 3o#6#t to rf;6 6;34 $a@8#at8o# a#d

    trat@#t

    ,-

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    39/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (,% REFUSAL TO CONSENT TO TRANSFER J A 4o6>8ta! 86 d@d to

    @t t4 r;8r@#t of >ara4 (1% "8t4 r6>3t to a# 8#d88d;a! 8f t4

    4o6>8ta! offr6 to tra#6fr t4 8#d88d;a! to a#ot4r @d83a! fa38!8t 8#

    a33orda#3 "8t4 6;763t8o# (3% a#d 8#for@6 t4 8#d88d;a! (or a >r6o#

    a3t8#< o# t4 8#d88d;a!6 74a!f% of t4 r866 a#d 7#f8t6 to t4 8#d88d;a!

    of 6;34 tra#6fr 7;t t4 8#d88d;a! (or >r6o# a3t8#< o# t4 8#d88d;a!6

     74a!f% rf;66 to 3o#6#t to t4 tra#6fr T4 4o6>8ta! 64a!! ta a!!

    ra6o#a7! 6t>6 to 63;r t4 8#d88d;a!6 (or >r6o#6% "r8tt# 8#for@d

    3o#6#t to rf;6 6;34 tra#6fr

    (3% RESTRICTING TRANSFERS UNTIL INDIVIDUAL STABILIKED J

    (1% RULE J If a# 8#d88d;a! at a 4o6>8ta! 4a6 a# @r8ta! @a #ot tra#6fr t4 8#d88d;a! ;#!66 J

    (A%(8% t4 8#d88d;a! (or a !o#687! >r6o# a3t8#< o# t4

    8#d88d;a!6 74a!f% aftr 78#< 8#for@d of t4 4o6>8ta!6 o7!83td fro@ t4 >ro868o# of 

    a>>ro>r8at @d83a! trat@#t at a#ot4r @d83a! fa38!8t o;t"8

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    40/121

    LatestLaws.com

    8#3ra6d r866 to t4 8#d88d;a! a#d 8# t4 3a6 of !a7or to t4 ;#7or#

    348!d fro@ ff3t8#< t4 tra#6fr or 

    (888% 8f a >46838a# 86 #ot >4683a!! >r6#t 8# t4 @rart@#t at

    t4 t8@ a# 8#d88d;a! 86 tra#6frrd a ;a!8f8d @d83a! >r6o# (a6 df8#d

     7 t4 S3rtar 8# rara4

    (2%% to t4at fa38!8t

    A 3rt8f83at8o# d63r87d 8# 3!a;6 (88% or (888% of 6;7>ara4 (A% 64a!!

    8#3!;d a 6;@@ar of t4 r866 a#d 7#f8t6 ;>o# "4834 t4 3rt8f83at8o# 86

     7a6d

    (2% APPROPRIATE TRANSFER J A# a>>ro>r8at tra#6fr to a @d83a!

    fa38!8t 86 a tra#6fr J 

    (A% 8# "4834 t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! >ro8d6 t4 @d83a! trat@#t "8t48#

    8t6 3a>a38t "4834 @8#8@86 t4 r866 to t4 8#d88d;a!6 4a!t4 a#d 8# t4

    3a6 of a "o@a# 8# !a7or t4 4a!t4 of t4 ;#7or# 348!d

    (B% 8# "4834 t4 r388#< fa38!8t *

    .0

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    41/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (8% 4a6 aa8!a7! 6>a3 a#d ;a!8f8d >r6o##! for t4 trat@#t of t4

    8#d88d;a! a#d

    (88% 4a6 at tra#6fr of t4 8#d88d;a! a#d to >ro8d a>>ro>r8at

    @d83a! trat@#t

    (C% 8# "4834 t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! 6#d6 to t4 r388#< fa38!8t a!!

    @d83a! r3ord6 (or 3o>86 t4rof% r!atd to t4 @r t4rof% >ro8dd ;#dr >ara4 (1%(A% a#d t4

    #a@ a#d addr66 of a# o#*3a!! >46838a# (d63r87d 8# 6;763t8o# (d%(1%

    (C% "4o "a6 rf;6d or fa8!d to a>>ar "8t48# a ra6o#a7! t8@ to >ro8d

    #366ar 6ta78!88#< trat@#t

    (D% 8# "4834 t4 tra#6fr 86 ff3td t4ro;r6o##! a#d

    tra#6>ortat8o# ;8>@#t a6 r;8rd 8#3!;d8#< t4 ;6 of #366ar a#d

    @d83a!! a>>ro>r8at !8f 6;>>ort @a6;r6 d;r8#< t4 tra#6fr a#d

    (E% "4834 @t6 6;34 ot4r r;8r@#t6 a6 t4 S3rtar @a f8#d

    #366ar 8# t4 8#tr6t of t4 4a!t4 a#d 6aft of 8#d88d;a!6 tra#6frrd

    (d% ENFORCEMENT J 

    .1

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    42/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (1% CIVIL MONETARY PENALTIES J 

    (A% A >art838>at8#< 4o6>8ta! t4at #

    63t8o# 86 6;7=3t to a 388! @o# >#a!t of #ot @or t4a# 0000 (or #ot

    @or t4a# 2000 8# t4 3a6 of a 4o6>8ta! "8t4 !66 t4a# 100 7d6% for a34

    6;34 8o!at8o# T4 >ro868o#6 of 63t8o# 112-A (ot4r t4a# 6;763t8o#6 (a%

    a#d (7%% 64a!! a>>! to a 388! @o# >#a!t ;#dr t486 6;7>ara4 8# t4

    6a@ @a##r a6 6;34 >ro868o#6 a>>! "8t4 r6>3t to a >#a!t or 

     >ro3d8#< ;#dr 63t8o# 112-A(a%

    (B% S;7=3t to 6;7>ara4 (C% a# >46838a# "4o 86 r6>o#687! for t4

    $a@8#at8o# trat@#t or tra#6fr of a# 8#d88d;a! 8# a >art838>at8#<

    4o6>8ta! 8#3!;d8#< a >46838a# o#*3a!! for t4 3ar of 6;34 a# 8#d88d;a!

    a#d "4o #

     >46838a# "4o J 

    (8% 683td fro@ a tra#6fr to a#ot4r fa38!8t o;t"88ta!6 o7!8#a!t

    of #ot @or t4a# 0000 for a34 6;34 8o!at8o# a#d 8f t4 8o!at8o# 86

    art838>at8o# 8# t486 t8t!

    a#d Stat 4a!t4 3ar >roro868o#6 of 63t8o# 112-A (ot4r t4a#

    t4 f8r6t a#d 63o#d 6#t#36 of 6;763t8o# (a% a#d 6;763t8o# (7%% 64a!!

    .2

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    43/121

    LatestLaws.com

    a>>! to a 388! @o# >#a!t a#d $3!;68o# ;#dr t486 6;7>ara4 8# t4

    6a@ @a##r a6 6;34 >ro868o#6 a>>! "8t4 r6>3t to a >#a!t $3!;68o#

    or >ro3d8#< ;#dr 63t8o# 112-A(a%

    (C% If aftr a# 8#8t8a! $a@8#at8o# a >46838a# dtr@8#6 t4at t4

    8#d88d;a! r;8r6 t4 6r836 of a >46838a# !86td 7 t4 4o6>8ta! o# 8t6

    !86t of o#*3a!! >46838a#6 (r;8rd to 7 @a8#ta8#d ;#dr 63t8o# 1-&&(a%

    (1%(I%% a#d #ot8f86 t4 o#*3a!! >46838a# a#d t4 o#*3a!! >46838a# fa8!6 or 

    rf;66 to a>>ar "8t48# a ra6o#a7! >r8od of t8@ a#d t4 >46838a#

    ordr6 t4 tra#6fr of t4 8#d88d;a! 73a;6 t4 >46838a# dtr@8#6 t4at

    "8t4o;t t4 6r836 of t4 o#*3a!! >46838a# t4 7#f8t6 of tra#6fr 

    o;t"846838a# a;t4or88#< t4 tra#6fr 64a!!

    #ot 7 6;7=3t to a >#a!t ;#dr 6;7>ara4 (B% )o"r t4 >r8o;6

    6#t#3 64a!! #ot a>>! to t4 4o6>8ta! or to t4 o#*3a!! >46838a# "4o

    fa8!d or rf;6d to a>>ar

    (2% CIVIL ENFORCEMENT J

    (A% PERSONAL )ARM J A# 8#d88d;a! "4o 6;ffr6 >r6o#a! 4ar@ a6 a

    d8r3t r6;!t of a >art838>at8#< 4o6>8ta!6 8o!at8o# of a r;8r@#t of t486

    63t8o# @a 8# a 388! a3t8o# aart838>at8#< 4o6>8ta! o7ta8# t4o6

    da@ar6o#a! 8#=;r ;#dr t4 !a" of t4 Stat 8# "4834

    t4 4o6>8ta! 86 !o3atd a#d 6;34 ;8ta7! r!8f a6 86 a>>ro>r8at

    (B% FINANCIAL LOSS TO OT)ER MEDICAL FACILITY J A# @d83a!

    fa38!8t t4at 6;ffr6 a f8#a#38a! !o66 a6 a d8r3t r6;!t of a >art838>at8#<

    4o6>8ta!6 8o!at8o# of a r;8r@#t of t486 63t8o# @a 8# a 388! a3t8o#

    .,

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    44/121

    LatestLaws.com

    aart838>at8#< 4o6>8ta! o7ta8# t4o6 da@a8ta! 86 !o3atd

    a#d 6;34 ;8ta7! r!8f a6 86 a>>ro>r8at

    (C% LIMITATIONS ON ACTIONS J No a3t8o# @a 7 7ro;ara4 @or t4a# t"o ar6 aftr t4 dat of t4 8o!at8o# "8t4 r6>3t to

    "4834 t4 a3t8o# 86 7ro;ara4 (1% t4 S3rtar 64a!! r;6t t4

    a>>ro>r8at ;t8!8at8o# a#d ;a!8t 3o#tro! >r r8" orara4 (1% a#d 64a!!

     >ro8d a >r8od of at !a6t &0 da6 for 6;34 r8"

    (% DEFINITIONS J I# t486 63t8o#+

    (1% T4 tr@ ?@rto@6 of 6;ff838#t

    6r8t (8#3!;d8#< 6r >a8#% 6;34 t4at t4 a76#3 of 8@@d8at @d83a!

    att#t8o# 3o;!d ra6o#a7! 7 $>3td to r6;!t 8# J 

    ..

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    45/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (8% >!a38#< t4 4a!t4 of t4 8#d88d;a! (or "8t4 r6>3t to a >rard

    (88% 6r8o;6 8@>a8r@#t of 7od8! f;#3t8o#6 or 

    (888% 6r8o;6 d6f;#3t8o# of a# 7od8! orart or 

    (B% "8t4 r6>3t to a >r8ta! 7for d!8r or 

    (88% t4at tra#6fr @a >o6 a t4rat to t4 4a!t4 or 6aft of t4 "o@a# or 

    t4 ;#7or# 348!d

    (2% T4 tr@ ?>art838>at8#< 4o6>8ta! @a#6 4o6>8ta! t4at 4a6 #trd 8#to a >ro8dr aro7a78!8t t4at #o @atr8a! dtr8orat8o# of t4 3o#d8t8o# 86 !8! to r6;!t

    fro@ or o33;r d;r8#< t4 tra#6fr of t4 8#d88d;a! fro@ a fa38!8t or "8t4

    r6>3t to a# @rara4 (1%(B% to

    d!8r (8#3!;d8#< t4 >!a3#ta%

    .

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    46/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (B% T4 tr@ ?6ta78!8d @a#6 "8t4 r6>3t to a# @rara4 (1%(A% t4at #o @atr8a! dtr8orat8o# of t4

    3o#d8t8o# 86 !8! "8t48# ra6o#a7! @d83a! >ro7a78!8t to r6;!t fro@ or 

    o33;r d;r8#< t4 tra#6fr of t4 8#d88d;a! fro@ a fa38!8t or "8t4 r6>3t to

    a# @rara4 (1%(B% t4at t4

    "o@a# 4a6 d!8rd (8#3!;d8#< t4 >!a3#ta%

    (.% T4 tr@ ?tra#6fr @a#6 t4 @o@#t (8#3!;d8#< t4 d8634ar8ta!6 fa38!8t86 at t4 d8r3t8o# of a# >r6o#

    @>!od 7 (or aff8!8atd or a66o38atd d8r3t! or 8#d8r3t! "8t4% t4

    4o6>8ta! 7;t do6 #ot 8#3!;d 6;34 a @o@#t of a# 8#d88d;a! "4o (A%

    4a6 7# d3!ard dad or (B% !a6 t4 fa38!8t "8t4o;t t4 >r@8668o# of 

    a# 6;34 >r6o#

    (% T4 tr@ ?4o6>8ta! 8#3!;d6 a r;ra! >r8@ar 3ar 4o6>8ta! (a6 df8#d 8#

    63t8o# 1-&1(@@%(1%%

    (f% PREEMPTION J T4 >ro868o#6 of t486 63t8o# do #ot >r@>t a# Stat

    or !o3a! !a" r;8r@#t $3>t to t4 $t#t t4at t4 r;8r@#t d8r3t!

    3o#f!83t6 "8t4 t4 r;8r@#t of t486 63t8o#

    (art838>at8#< 4o6>8ta! t4at 4a6 6>38a!8d

    3a>a78!8t86 or fa38!8t86 (6;34 a6 7;r# ;#8t6 64o3*tra;@a ;#8t6 #o#ata!

    8#t#68 3ar ;#8t6 or ("8t4 r6>3t to r;ra! ara6% r>ro>r8at tra#6fr of a# 8#d88d;a! "4o r;8r6 6;34 6>38a!8d

    .&

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    47/121

    LatestLaws.com

    3a>a78!8t86 or fa38!8t86 8f t4 4o6>8ta! 4a6 t4 3a>a38t to trat t4

    8#d88d;a!

    (4% NO DELAY IN EAMINATION OR TREATMENT J A >art838>at8#<

    4o6>8ta! @a #ot d!a >ro868o# of a# a>>ro>r8at @d83a! 63r#8#<

    $a@8#at8o# r;8rd ;#dr 6;763t8o# (a% or f;rt4r @d83a! $a@8#at8o#

    a#d trat@#t r;8rd ;#dr 6;763t8o# (7% 8# ordr to 8#;8r a7o;t t4

    8#d88d;a!6 @t4od of >a@#t or 8#6;ra#3 6tat;6

    (8% W)ISTLE BLOWER PROTECTIONS J A >art838>at8#< 4o6>8ta! @a

    #ot >#a!8 or ta adr6 a3t8o# ar6o#

    d63r87d 8# 6;763t8o# (3%(1%(A%(888% or a >46838a# 73a;6 t4 >r6o# or 

     >46838a# rf;66 to a;t4or8 t4 tra#6fr of a# 8#d88d;a! "8t4 a#

    @r!o 73a;6 t4 @>!o r>ort6 a 8o!at8o# of a

    r;8r@#t of t486 63t8o#

    EMTALA REGULATIONS

    ?R38a! r6>o#6878!8t86 of Md83ar 4o6>8ta!6 8#

    @r8ta! t4at 4a6 a# @rart@#t 8f a# 8#d88d;a! ("4t4r or #ot !8

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    48/121

    LatestLaws.com

    a#d r8ta! @;6t >ro8d for a# a>>ro>r8at

    @d83a! 63r#8#< $a@8#at8o# "8t48# t4 3a>a78!8t of t4

    4o6>8ta!6 @rart@#t 8#3!;d8#< a#38!!ar 6r836

    ro;t8#! aa8!a7! to t4 @rart@#t to dtr@8#

    "4t4r or #ot a# @r8ta! 7 !a" or r;!6 or r3t

    to a# 8#d88d;a! r;6t8#< $a@8#at8o# or trat@#t t4at

    t4 8#d88d;a! 86 o# 4o6>8ta! >ro>rt For >;r>o66 of t486

    63t8o# H>ro>rt @a#6 t4 #t8r @a8# 4o6>8ta! 3a@>;6

    8#3!;d8#< t4 >ar8#< !ot 68d"a! a#d dr8 "a a6 "!! a6

    a# fa38!8t or or8ta! 3a@>;6 7;t 4a6 7# dtr@8#d to 7 a d>art@#t

    of t4 4o6>8ta! HPro>rt a!6o 8#3!;d6 a@7;!a#36 o"#r 

    a#d o>ratd 7 t4 4o6>8ta! # 8f t4 a@7;!a#3 86 #ot o#

    4o6>8ta! 8ta! o"#d

    a@7;!a#3 o# 4o6>8ta! >ro>rt 86 3o#68drd to 4a 3o@

    to t4 4o6>8ta!6 @rart@#t # 8f a @@7r of 

    t4 a@7;!a#3 6taff 3o#ta3t6 t4 4o6>8ta! o# t!>4o# or 

    t!@tr 3o@@;#83at8o#6 a#d 8#for@6 t4 4o6>8ta! t4at t4

    "a#t to tra#6>ort t4 8#d88d;a! to t4 4o6>8ta! for 

    .-

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    49/121

    LatestLaws.com

    $a@8#at8o# a#d trat@#t I# t46 68t;at8o#6 t4 4o6>8ta!

    @a d# a3366 8f 8t 86 Hd863rt8o#ar 6tat;6 t4at 86 8t do6

    #ot 4a 6taff or fa38!8t86 to a33>t a# add8t8o#a! >at8#t6

    If 4o"r t4 a@7;!a#3 d86r8ta!6

    8#6tr;3t8o#6 a#d tra#6>ort6 t4 8#d88d;a! o# to t4 4o6>8ta!

     >ro>rt t4 8#d88d;a! 86 3o#68drd to 4a 3o@ to t4

    @rart@#t

    (B%T4 ra38t of a 4o6>8ta! a6 78#< 8t6

    a78!8t to a33o@@odat t4 8#d88d;a! r;6t8#<

    $a@8#at8o# or trat@#t of t4 tra#6frrd 8#d88d;a!

    Ca>a38t #3o@>a666 6;34 t48#@#t o# t4

    4o6>8ta!6 >a6t >ra3t836 of a33o@@odat8#< add8t8o#a!

     >at8#t 8# $366 of 8t6 o33;>a#3 !8@8t6

    (C% HE@rto@6 of 6;ff838#t

    6r8t (8#3!;d8#< 6r >a8# >6348atr83 d86t;r7a#36

    a#d:or 6@>to@6 of 6;76ta#3 a7;6% 6;34 t4at t4 a76#3

    of 8@@d8at @d83a! att#t8o# 3o;!d ra6o#a7! 7

    $>3td to r6;!t 8# J 

    (a% >!a38#< t4 4a!t4 of t4 8#d88d;a! (or "8t4 r6>3t toa

     >rard

    (7%6r8o;6 8@>a8r@#t to 7od8! f;#3t8o#6 or 

    (3% 6r8o;6 d6f;#3t8o# of a# 7od8! orart or 

    (2% W8t4 r6>3t to a >r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    50/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (a% t4at t4r 86 8#ad;at t8@ to ff3t a 6af tra#6fr to

    a#ot4r 4o6>8ta! 7for d!8r or 

    (7% t4at tra#6fr @a >o6 a t4rat to t4 4a!t4 or 6aft

    of t4 "o@a# or t4 ;#7or# 348!d

    (D% HSta78!8d @a#6 "8t4 r6>3t to a# H@r3t

    to a# H@r3t to a# H@rro8d 6;34 @d83a! trat@#t of t4 3o#d8t8o#

    #366ar to a66;r "8t48# ra6o#a7! @d83a!

     >ro7a78!8t t4at #o @atr8a! dtr8orat8o# of t4

    3o#d8t8o# 86 !8! to r6;!t fro@ or o33;r6 d;r8#< t4

    tra#6fr of t4 8#d88d;a! fro@ a fa38!8t or 

    (88% "8t4 r6>3t to a# H@r8ta! dtr@8#6

    0

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    51/121

    LatestLaws.com

    t4at t4 8#d88d;a! 4a6 a# @r8ta! @;6t >ro8d 8t4r J 

    (8% W8t48# t4 3a>a78!8t86 of t4 6taff a#d fa38!8t86

    aa8!a7! at t4 4o6>8ta! for f;rt4r @d83a!

    $a@8#at8o# a#d trat@#t a6 r;8rd to 6ta78!8

    t4 @d83a! 3o#d8t8o# or 

    (88% for tra#6fr of t4 8#d88d;a! to a#ot4r @d83a!

    fa38!8t 8# a33orda#3 "8t4 >ara (d% (7!o"% of t486

    63t8o#

    (2% Rf;6a! (7 83t8@% to 3o#6#t to trat@#t  + T486 >ro868o#

    6tat6 t4at aftr t4 4o6>8ta! "8t4 a# @rart@#t

    8#for@6 t4 >at8#t or >r6o# a3t8#< o# 486 74a!f of t4

    r866 a#d 7#f8t6 to t4 8#d88d;a! of t4 $a@8#at8o# a#d

    trat@#t 7;t t4 8#d88d;a! (or >r6o# a3t8#< o# 486 74a!f%

    rf;66 3o#6#t to t4 $a@8#at8o# a#d trat@#t t4

    @d83a! r3ord of t4 4o6>8ta! @;6t r3ord t4 rf;6a! a#d

    ta a!! ra6o#a7! 6t>6 to 63;r t4 8#d88d;a!6 "r8tt#

    8#for@d 3o#6#t (or t4at of t4 >r6o# a3t8#< o# 486 or 4r 

     74a!f% T4 "r8tt# do3;@#t @;6t 8#d83at t4at t4 >r6o#

    4a6 7# 8#for@d of t4 r866 a#d 7#f8t6 of t4

    $a@8#at8o# or trat@#t

    ?(,% D!a 8# $a@8#at8o# or trat@#t (#ot >r@86687!%+

    A >art83;!ar 4o6>8ta! (8 t4at 4a6 #trd 8#to a Md83ar

     >ro8dr aro8d8#< a# a>>ro>r8at @d83a! 63r#8#<

    $a@8#at8o# or f;rt4r @d83a! $a@8#at8o# a#d trat@#t

    1

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    52/121

    LatestLaws.com

    r;8rd 8# ordr to 8#;8r a7o;t t4 8#d88d;a!6 @t4od of 

     >a@#t or 8#6;ra#3 6tat;6

    (.%T486 3!a;6 da!6 "8t4 rf;6a! 7 t4 83t8@ or t4 >r6o#

    a3t8#< o# 486 74a!f for tra#6fr to a#ot4r @d83a! fa38!8t

    4a8#< r;8rd fa38!8t86 Wr8tt# rf;6a! @;6t 7

    o7ta8#d

    S3t8o# (d% R6tr83t8#< tra#6fr ;#t8! t4 8#d88d;a! 86 6ta78!8d+

    (1% If a# 8#d88d;a! at a 4o6>8ta! 4a6 a# @r8ta! @a

    #ot tra#6fr t4 8#d88d;a! ;#!66 J 

    (8% t4 tra#6fr 86 a# a>>ro>r8at tra#6fr a6 6tatd 8#

    63t8o# (d%(2% a#d

    (88% (A% t4 8#d88d;a! (or a !o#687! >r6o#

    a3t8#< o# 486 74a!f% r;6t6 t4 tra#6fr aftr 

     78#< 8#for@d of t4 4o6>8ta!6 o7!8

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    53/121

    LatestLaws.com

    T4 3rt8f83at8o# @;6t 3o#ta8# a 6;@@ar of t4 r86 

    a#d 7#f8t6 ;>o# "4834 8t 86 7a6d or 

    (C% 8f a >46838a# 86 #ot >4683a!! >r6#t 8# t4

    @rart@#t at t4 t8@ a# 8#d88d;a! 86

    tra#6frrd a ;a!8f8d @d83a! >r6o# (a6 dtr@8#d

     7 t4 4o6>8ta! 8# 8t6 7 !a"6 a#d r>ro>r8at

    o#! 8# t4o6 3a66 8# "4834 J 

    (8% t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! >ro8d6 @d83a!

    trat@#t "8t48# 8t6 3a>a38t t4at @8#8@86 t4

    r86 to t4 8#d88d;a!6 4a!t4 a#d 8# t4 3a6 of a

    "o@a# 8# !a7o;r t4 4a!t4 of t4 ;#7or# 348!d

    (88% T4 r388#< fa38!8t J 

    (A% 4a6 aa8!a7! 6>a3 a#d ;a!8f8d

     >r6o##! for t4 trat@#t of t4

    8#d88d;a! a#d

    (B% 4a6 at tra#6fr of t4

    8#d88d;a! a#d to >ro8d a>>ro>r8at

    @d83a! trat@#t

    ,

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    54/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (888% t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! 6#d6 to t4 r388#<

    fa38!8t a!! @d83a! r3ord6 (or 3o>86 t4rof%

    r!atd to t4 @r t4rof% r;8rd ;#dr t486 63t8o# a#d

    t4 #a@ a#d addr66 of a# o#*3a!! >46838a# "4o

    4a6 rf;6d or fa8!d to a>>ar "8t48# ra6o#a7!

    t8@ to >ro8d #366ar 6ta78!88#< trat@#t

    Ot4r r3ord6 (8ta!6 f8!6% @;6t 7 6#t a6 6oo# a6 >ra3t83a7!

    aftr tra#6fr a#d

    (8% t4 tra#6fr 86 ff3td t4ro;r6o##!

    a#d tra#6>ortat8o# ;8>@#t a6 r;8rd

    8#3!;d8#< t4 ;6 of #366ar a#d @d83a!!

    a>>ro>r8at !8f 6;>>ort @a6;r6 d;r8#< t4

    tra#6fr

    (,% a >art838>ator 4o6>8ta! @a #ot 8#8t8 do ta adr6

    a3t8o# a46838a# or a ;a!8f8d @d83a! >r6o#

    d63r87d 8# >ara d(1%(88%(C% a7o 73a;6 t4 >46838a#

    .

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    55/121

    LatestLaws.com

    or ;a!8f8d >r6o# rf;66 to a;t4or8 t4 tra#6fr of a#

    8#d88d;a! "8t4 a# @r!o

     73a;6 t4 @>!o r>ort6 a 8o!at8o# of a

    r;8r@#t of t486 63t8o#

    S;7* R38>8#t 4o6>8ta!6 r6>o#6878!8t86+63t8o# (%+

    A >art83;!ar 4o6>8ta! t4at 4a6 6>38a!8d 3a>a78!8t86 or 

    fa38!8t86 (8#3!;d8#>ro>r8at tra#6fr of a# 8#d88d;a!

    "4o r;8r6 6;34 6>38a!8d 3a>a78!8t86 or fa38!8t86 8f t4

    r388#< 4o6>8ta! 4a6 t4 3a>a38t to trat t4 8#d88d;a!

    S3t8o# (f%+ Tr@8#at8o# of >ro8dr a8ta! fa8!6 to @t

    t4 r;8r@#t of 63t8o# (a% to (% t4 )CFA @a tr@8#at

    t4 H>ro8dr a

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    56/121

    LatestLaws.com

    ot4r"86 d63r87d 8# 63t8o# (a% t4 4o6>8ta! 86 o7!8>ro>r8at @d83a! 63r#8#< $a@8#at8o# a#d a# #366ar

    6ta78!88#< trat@#t or a# a>>ro>r8at tra#6fr

    (1% Ca>a78!8t of t4 4o6>8ta!+

    T4 3a>a78!8t of t4 4o6>8ta! 8#3!;d6 t4at of t4

    4o6>8ta! a6 a "4o! #ot =;6t t4 3a>a78!8t of t4 off*3a@>;6

    d>art@#t E$3>t for 3a66 d63r87d 8# >ara (8%(,%(88% t4

    o7!88ta! ;#dr t486 63t8o# @;6t 7 d8634ar!ad

    8# a!! >;7!83 #tra#36 ra78!8t86 of t486 4o6>8ta!6 6taff a#d fa38!8t86%

    &

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    57/121

    LatestLaws.com

    AN APPROPRIATE MEDICAL SCREENING EAMINATION

     NECESSARY STABILIKING TREATMENT (8#3!;d8#< trat@#t

    for a# ;#7or# 348!d% a#d 8f #366ar AN APPROPRIATE

    TRANSFER to a#ot4r FACILITY EVEN IF YOU CANNOT PAY

    OR DO NOT )AVE MEDICAL INSURANCE or

    EVEN IF YOU ARE NOT ENTITLED TO MEDICARE OR 

    MEDICAID T)IS )OSPITAL DOES:DOES NOT PARTICIPATE

    IN T)E MEDICAID PROGRAM

    T4 a7o 68o8#t a#d >o6td 8# a @a##r !8! to 7 6#

    T46 >ro868o#6 of EMTALA a#d t4 R;r>o6 of #for38#< EMTALA 3a# 7 a @od! for 3o#68dr8#< a>>ro>r8at

    r3o#68drat8o# for a !a" 8# o;r 3o;#tr

    /

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    58/121

    LatestLaws.com

    C(APT)* I4

    A@7;!a#3 Sr836 8# ot4r ';r86d83t8o#

    I# ordr to 3t6 r!at8#< to a@7;!a#36 8# t4 B8!! atta34d to

    t486 R>ort%

    USA J A@7;!a#3 Sr836+T4 Stat of M8##6ota 8# USA 8# 38t 6tat;t6 of 200. da!6 "8t4

    A@7;!a#3 Sr836 I# 63t8o# 1.. E(1% to1.. E(2% t4r ar 6ra!

     >ro868o#6 "4834 3a# 7 a @od! for !ro>o6

    to rfr to a!! t4 >ro868o#6 $3>t t4 3r;38a! o#6

    So far a6 df8#8t8o#6 ar 3o#3r#d " 64a!! rfr to a f" of t4@

    "4834 ar 8@>orta#t+

    001(17% df8#6 HAd5an#ed life $upport6 a6 @a#6 Hr#dr8#< 7a683

    !8f 6;>>ort a#d r#dr8#< 8#tra#o;6 t4ra> dr;< t4ra>

    8#t;7at8o# a#d df87r8!!at8o#

    001(2% df8#6  7Ambulan#e6 a6 @a#6 Ha# 483! d68ro8d8#< a@7;!a#3 6r83 to 8!! or 8#=;rd >r6o#6 or $>3ta#t @ot4r6

    001(,%  7Ambulan#e $er5i#e6  @a#6 tra#6>ortat8o# a#d trat@#t

    "4834 86 r#drd or offrd to 7 r#drd >r!8@8#ar to or d;r8#<

    -

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    59/121

    LatestLaws.com

    tra#6>ortat8o# to fro@ or 7t"# 4a!t4 3ar fa38!8t86 for 8!! or 

    8#=;rd >r6o#6 or $>3ta#t @ot4r6 T4 tr@ 8#3!;d6 a!!

    tra#6>ortat8o# 8#o!8#< t4 ;6 of a 6trt34r ;#!66 t4 >r6o# to 7

    tra#6>ortd 86 #ot !8! to r;8r @d83a! trat@#t d;r8#< t4

    3o;r6 of tra#6>ort

    001,a+ Ambulan#e $er5i#e per$onnel @a#6 8#d88d;a!6 "4o ar

    a;t4or8d 7 a !83#6d a@7;!a#3 6r83 to >ro8d @r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    60/121

    LatestLaws.com

      (88% 8#6rt8o# of a# oro*>4ar#4ar#4a4ar6t o!ta>d 7at8#< or 

    86 f87r8!!at8#

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    61/121

    LatestLaws.com

    001/+ Li#en$e @a#6 a;t4or8t rat8o#

    of a# a@7;!a#3 6r83 8# t4 6tat of M8##6ota

    0019a+ Part8time ad5an#e life $upport @a#6 r#dr8#< 7a683 !8f

    6;>>ort a#d ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort for !66 t4a# 2. 4o;r6 of r da

    00197+ Ph&$i#ian @a#6

    00193+ Ph&$i#ian a$$i$tant @a#6

    0019d+ Pre8ho$pital #are data @a#6 8#for@at8o# 3o!!3td 7 a@7;!a#3

    6r83 >r6o##! a7o;t t4 38r3;@6ta#36 r!atd to a# @ro#6

    a#d >at8#t 3ar a3t88t86 >ro8dd 7 t4 a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##! 8# a

     >r*4o6>8ta! 6tt8#

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    62/121

    LatestLaws.com

      (1% ad@8#86tr a#d #for3 t4 >ro868o#6 of t486 34a>tr a#d ot4r d;t86

    a6 a668>!83a#t6 for 6tat or fdra! @r!a# "4834 @a 7 ;>datd 78##8a!! T4 "or >!a# @a 8#3!;d >ro868o#6 to+

    (1% >r>ar a# @rart@#t of P;7!83 Saft a

    6tat"8d 8#=;r a#d tra;@a >r#t8o# >ro

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    63/121

    LatestLaws.com

      (.% d68r8@ar 6r83 ara6 ;#dr "4834

    t4 7oard 64a!! d68r8@ar 6r83 ara or ara6

    ;;),!- Ambulan#e $er5i#e li#en$in',

    ;;),! Ambulan#e $er5i#e re@uirement$,

    1..E101*1+ Per$onnel- 

    (a% No >;7!83! or >r8at! o"#d a@7;!a#3 6r83 64a!! 7

    o>ratd 8# t4 6tat ;#!66 8t6 a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##! ar

    3rt8f8d a>>ro>r8at to t4 t> of a@7;!a#3 6r83 78#< >ro8dd a33ord8#< to 63t8o# 1..E2-  or @t t4 6taff8#<

    3r8tr8a 6>38f83 to t4 t> of a@7;!a#3 6r83

    &,

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    64/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (7% A# a@7;!a#3 6r83 64a!! 4a a @d83a! d8r3tor a6 >ro8dd

    ;#dr 63t8o# 1..E2&

    1..E:101*2+ Patient #are-  W4# a >at8#t 86 78#< tra#6>ortd at !a6t o#

    of t4 a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##! @;6t 7 8# t4 >at8#t 3o@>art@#t If 

    ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort >ro3d;r6 ar r;8rd a# EMT*P a r46838a# a6686ta#t ;a!8f8d ;#dr 63t8o# 1..E001 6;7d8868o# ,a 3!a;6

    (,% 8t@ (8% 64a!! 7 8# t4 >at8#t 3o@>art@#t

    1..E101*,+ Continual $er5i#e-  A# a@7;!a#3 6r83 64a!! offr 6r83

    2. 4o;r6 >r da r da of t4 ar ;#!66 ot4r"86 a;t4or8d ;#dr 

    6;7d8868o#6 - a#d 9

    S;7*d8# .+ Denial of $er5i#e prohibited-  A# a@7;!a#3 6r83 64a!!

    #ot 7 d#8d >r*4o6>8ta! 3ar to a >r6o# #d8#< @ra or 73a;6 of t4 6o;r3 of >a@#t for 

    6r836 8f t4 #d d!o>6 "8t48# t4 !83#66 >r8@ar 6r83 ara or 

    "4# r6>o#d8#< to a @;t;a! a8d 3a!! Tra#6>ort for t4 >at8#t @a 7

    !8@8td to t4 3!o66t a>>ro>r8at @r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    65/121

    LatestLaws.com

      (88% ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort

    (888% >art*t8@ ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort a#d

    (8% 6>38a!8d !8f 6;>>ort

    S;7*d8# &+ 3a$i# life $upport-

    (a% E$3>t a6 >ro8dd 8# >ara4 (% a 7a683 !8f 6;>>ort

    a@7;!a#3 64a!! 7 6taffd 7 at !a6t t"o a@7;!a#3 6r83

     >r6o##! at !a6t o# of "4834 @;6t 7 a# EMT "4o >ro8d

    a !! of 3ar 6o a6 to #6;r t4at+

    (1% !8f*t4rat#8#< 68t;at8o#6 a#d >ot#t8a!! 6r8o;6 8#=;r86

    ar r3oat8#t6 ar >rot3td fro@ add8t8o#a! 4aard6

    (,% 7a683 trat@#t to rd;3 t4 6r8o;6#66 of @rat8#t6 ar tra#6>ortd to a# a>>ro>r8at @d83a! fa38!8t

    for trat@#t

    (7% A 7a683 !8f 6;>>ort 6r83 64a!! >ro8d 7a683 a8r"a

    @a#a

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    66/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (3% B 'a#;ar 1 2001 a 7a683 !8f 6;>>ort 6r83 64a!! >ro8d

    a;to@at83 df87r8!!at8o# a6 >ro8dd 8# 63t8o# 1..E10,

    6;7d8868o# 1 >ara4 (7%

    (d% A 7a683 !8f 6;>>ort 6r83 !83#66 @d83a! d8r3tor @a

    a;t4or8 t4 a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##! to 3arr a#d to ;6

    @d83a! a#t864o3 tro;6r6 a#d to >rfor@ 8#tra#o;6 8#f;68o#

    8f t4 a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##! 4a 7# >ro>r! tra8#d

    (% Var8at8o# of fa38!8t86 7 Dr8r of a# a@7;!a#3 of 6r83+

      S;7*d8# /+ Ad5an#ed life $upport-

    (a% A# ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort a@7;!a#3 64a!! 7 6taffd 7 at !a6t+

    (1% o# EMT a#d o# EMT*P

    (2% o# EMT a#d o# rra3t838#< a6 a >46838a# a6686ta#t a#d 4a6

     >a66d a >ara@d83 >ra3t83a! 68!!6 t6t a>>rod 7 t4

     7oard a#d ad@8#86trd 7 a tra8#8#< >ro

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    67/121

    LatestLaws.com

      (7% A# ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort 6r83 64a!! >ro8d 7a683 !8f

    6;>>ort a6 6>38f8d ;#dr 6;7d8868o# & >ara4 (a%

    ada#3d a8r"a @a#a4ar@a3;t83a!6

    (3% I# add8t8o# to >ro8d8#< ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort a# ada#3d !8f

    6;>>ort 6r83 @a 6taff add8t8o#a! a@7;!a#36 to >ro8d

     7a683 !8f 6;>>ort a33ord8#< to 6;7d8868o# & W4# ro;t8#!

    6taffd a#d ;8>>d a6 a 7a683 !8f 6;>>ort 6r83 a33ord8#<

    to 6;7*d8868o# & a#d 63t8o# 1..E10, 6;7*d8868o# 1 t4

    483! 64a!! #ot 7 @ard a6 ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort

    (d% A# a@7;!a#3 6r83 >ro8d8#< ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort 64a!!

    4a a "r8tt# a46838a# d8r3t8o# of 

    a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##!

    (88% >at8#t tr8aort

    (8% ;6 of 6ta#d8#< ordr6 a#d

    &/

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    68/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (88% t4 @a#6 7 "4834 @d83a! 3o#tro! "8!! 7 >ro8dd

    2. 4o;r6 a da

    T4 aort t4

    a;t4or8t of a# EMT*P M8##6ota rat8#t 3ar >ra8!6 or t4 a;t4or8t of a# EMT

    S;7*d8# -+ Part8time ad5an#ed life $upport-

    (a% A >art*t8@ ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort 6r83 64a!! @t t4 6taff8#<

    r;8r@#t6 ;#dr 6;7d8868o# / >ara4 (a% >ro8d 6r83a6 r;8rd ;#dr 6;7d8868o# / >ara4 (7% for !66 t4a# 2.

    4o;r6 r da a#d @t t4 ;8>@#t r;8r@#t6 6>38f8d

    8# 63t8o# 1..E10,

    (7% A >art*t8@ ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort 6r83 64a!! 4a a "r8tt#

    ao!83 o# t4 ad@8#86trat8o# of @d83a! 3o#tro! for t4 6r83

    a#d addr66 t4 866;6 6>38f8d 8# 6;7*d8868o# / >ara (d%

    &-

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    69/121

    LatestLaws.com

    S;7*d8# 9+ Spe#ialied life $upport-  A 6>38a!8d >ort 6r83 >ro8d8#< ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort 64a!! 7 6taffd 7 at

    !a6t o# EMT a#d o# EMT*P r46838a#

    a6686ta#t A 6>38a!8d !8f 6;>>ort 6r83 64a!! >ro8d 7a683 or 

    ada#3d !8f 6;>>ort a6 d68rat8o# !66 t4a# 2. 4o;r6 of r da

    (2% d68;!at8o#

    (,% 3rta8# t>6 of @d83a! 3o#d8t8o#6 or

    (.% a8r a@7;!a#3 6r83 t4at 8#3!;d6 f8$d*"8#< or rotor*"8#o6666 a 3;rr#t

    dr8r6 !83#6 866;d 7 a# 6tat a#d @;6t 4a att#dd a# @r>rod 7 t4 !83#6 T4 @rr8#3

    S;7*d8# 11+ Per$onnel ro$ter and file$-

    (a% A# a@7;!a#3 6r83 64a!! @a8#ta8#+

    (1% at !a6t t"o a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##! o# a "r8tt# o#*

    3a!! 634d;!

    &9

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    70/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (2% a 3;rr#t ro6tr of 8t6 a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##!8#3!;d8#<

    t4 #a@ addr66 a#d ;a!8f83at8o#6 of 8t6 a@7;!a#3

    6r83 >r6o##! a#d

    (,% f8!6 do3;@#t8#< >r6o##! ;a!8f83at8o#6

    (7% A !83#6 64a!! @a8#ta8# 8# 8t6 f8!6 t4 #a@ a#d addr66 of 8t6

    @d83a! d8r3tor a#d a "r8tt# 6tat@#t 68ta#3 of t4 r6>o#6878!8t86 6>38f8d 8#

    63t8o# 1..E2& 6;7d8868o# 2

    S;7*d8# 12+ Mutual aid a'reement-  A !83#6 64a!! 4a a "r8tt#

    ar8@ar 6r83 ara T4 a38f t4 d;t86

    a#d r6>o#6878!8t86 of t4 aart86 A 3o> of a34 @;t;a! a8d

    aro8d 8t6 6r836 o;t68d of 8t6 >r8@ar 6r83 ara o#! 8f r;6td 7 a

    tra#6frr8#< >46838a# or a@7;!a#3 6r83 !83#6d to >ro8d 6r83 8#

    t4 >r8@ar 6r83 ara "4# 8t 3a# ra6o#a7! 7 $>3td t4at+

    /0

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    71/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (1% t4 r6>o#6 86 r;8rd 7 t4 8@@d8at @d83a! #d of a#

    8#d88d;a! a#d

    (2% t4 a@7;!a#3 6r83 !83#6d to >ro8d 6r83 8# t4 >r8@ar

    6r83 ara 86 ;#aa8!a7! for a>>ro>r8at r6>o#6

    ;;),!B )@uipment-

    S;7*d8# 1 1eneral re@uirement$,

    (a% Er a@7;!a#3 8# 6r83 for >at8#t 3ar 64a!! 3arr at a

    @8#8@;@+

    (1% o$

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    72/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (&% ;8>@#t to dtr@8# 8ta! 68@#t 3arr8d 8# a# a@7;!a#3 @;6t 7

    63;r! 6tord

    S;7*d8# .+ Safet& re$traint$-  A# a@7;!a#3 @;6t 7 ;8>>d "8t4

    6aft 6tra>6 for t4 6trt34r a#d 6at 7!t6 8# t4 >at8#t 3o@>art@#tfor t4 >at8#t a#d a@7;!a#3 >r6o##!

    ;;),- Ambulan#e $er5i#e appli#ation pro#edure- :

    /2

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    73/121

    LatestLaws.com

    ;;),

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    74/121

    LatestLaws.com

      W4# tra#6>ort8#< a >at8#t fro@ o# !83#6d 4o6>8ta! to a#ot4r a

    !83#6 @a 6;76t8t;t for o# of t4 r;8rd a@7;!a#3 6r83 >r6o##!

    a >46838a# a r46838a#6 a6686ta#t "4o 4a6 7# tra8#d

    to ;6 t4 ;8>@#t 8# t4 a@7;!a#3 a#d 86 #o"!droto3o!6

    ;;),B- Temporar& li#en$e

    ;;),;- Tran$fer of li#en$e or o.ner$hip

    ;;),=- *elo#ation of ba$e of operation$

    ;;),? *ule$ lo#al $tandard$-

    S;7*d8868o# 1+ R>a!d 1999 3 2. art 9 6 &&

      S;7*d8868o# 2+ R>a!d 1999 3 2. art 9 6 &&

      S;7*d8868o# ,+ R>a!d 1999 3 2. art 9 6 &&

    S;7*d8868o# .+ *ule$-  T4 7oard @a ado>t r;!6 #dd to r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    75/121

    LatestLaws.com

      (.% r6tr83td trat@#t6 a#d >ro3d;r6

    (% ;8>@#t 6ta#dard6

    (&% a@7;!a#3 6ta#dard6

    (/% 3o@@;#83at8o# 6ta#dard6 ;8>@#t >rfor@a#3 a#d

    @a8#t#a#3 a#d rad8o fr;#3 a6688rat8o# dat6 a#d

    /

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    76/121

    LatestLaws.com

      (1% "a8r6 a#d ar8a#36

    S;7*d8868o# + Lo#al 'o5ernmentE$ po.er$-

    (a% Lo3a! ;#8t6 of o6

    add8t8o#a! r;8r@#t6 ;>o# 6;34 6r836 Lo3a! ;#8t6 of 

    o6 add8t8o#a! r;8r@#t6 64a!!

    3o#68dr "4t4r a# 7#f8t a33r;8#< to t4 >;7!83 4a!t4

    "o;!d o;t"8!8a#3 "8t4

    63t8o#6 1..E001 to 1..E,, a#d r;!6 ado>td ;#dr t4o6 63t8o#6 T4

     7oard @a r8" at a# t8@ do3;@#tat8o# r;8rd to 7 o# f8! "8t4 a

    !83#6

    ;;),- Di$#iplinar& a#tion-

      S;7*d8868o# 1+  Su$pen$ion re5o#ation nonrene.al-

    /&

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    77/121

    LatestLaws.com

      T4 7oard @a 6;6>#d ro rf;6 to r#" or >!a3 3o#d8t8o#6

    o# t4 !83#6 of a !83#6 ;>o# f8#d8#< t4at t4 !83#6 4a6 8o!atd a

     >ro868o# of t486 34a>tr or r;!6 ado>td ;#dr t486 34a>tr or 4a6

    3a6d to >ro8d t4 6r83 for "4834 t4 !83#6 86 !83#6d

    S;7*d8868o# 2+ Noti#e #onte$ted #a$e,

    S;7*d8868o# ,+ Temporar& $u$pen$ion,

    ;;),

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    78/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (% >art838>at8#< 8# t4 d!o>@#t a#d o>rat8o# of 3o#t8#;o;6

    ;a!8t 8@>ro@#t >ro )MT8I> and )MT8P,

    /-

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    79/121

    LatestLaws.com

    *e@uirement$> )Gpiration Date$> *e#ipro#it&> Form$ of 

    di$#iplinar& a#tion> Denial> $u$pen$ion> re5o#ation> Temporar&

    $u$pen$ion> *ene.al> *ein$tatement,

    ;;), )Gpiration> Di$#iplinar& a#tion> Temporar&

    $u$pen$ion> Audit,

    ;;),

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    80/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (2% a34 a@7;!a#3 o>ratd 7 a !83#6 9& T4 !83#6 64a!!

     >a a# add8t8o#a! 9& f for t4 f;!! !83#68#< >r8od or . >r 

    @o#t4 for a# fra3t8o# of t4 >r8od for a34 a@7;!a#3 addd

    to t4 a@7;!a#3 6r83 d;r8#< t4 !83#68#< >r8od

    (,% 8#8t8a! a>>!83at8o# for a#d r#"a! of a>>roa! for a tra8#8#<

     >ro!83at of a# or8>roa! 2

    (7% W8t4 t4 $3>t8o# of >ara4 (a% 3!a;6 (.% a!! f6 ar for a

    t"o*ar >r8od A!! f6 ar #o#*rf;#da7!

    (3% F6 3o!!3td 7 t4 7oard 64a!! 7 d>o68td a6 #o#*dd83atd

    r38>t6 8# t4

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    81/121

    LatestLaws.com

      S;7*d8868o# 1+  4oluntar& reportin',

    S;7*d8# 2+  Mandator& reportin',

    S;7*d8# ,+ Immunit&- I@@;#8t for ort8#< fro@ 388!

    a3t8o#6 o# r>ort8#< I#d88d;a! L83#6 4a!t4 3ar fa38!8t 7;68#66

    or or

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    82/121

    LatestLaws.com

    S;7*d8868o# 2+ )$tabli$hment and purpo$e,

    I# ordr to d!o> @a8#ta8# a#d 8@>ro r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    83/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (/% 6ta7!8648#< a#d @a8#ta8#8#< tra8#8#< 6ta#dard6 to #6;r

    3o#686t#t ;a!8t of @rro8#< @rrat8o#6 or to >;r34a6 a# 483!6 or >art6 of 

    483!6 for a# a@7;!a#3 6r83 or a r63; 6r83

    S;7*d8# + Di$tribution-  Mo# fro@ t4 f;#d 64a!! 7 d86tr87;td

    a33ord8#< to t486 6;7*d8868o#

    (1% N8#t*f8 >r3#t of t4 f;#d 64a!! 7 d86tr87;td a##;a!! o# a

    3o#tra3t for 6r836 7a686 "8t4 a34 of t4 8

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    84/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (,%T4 7oard 64a!! 3o#tra3t "8t4 a rro>o6a! 6at86fa3tor8! addr666 >ro>o6d @rort8#< 66t@6 a#d to >ro8d ot4r r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    85/121

    LatestLaws.com

    T4 E@rro>r8atd fro@ t4 tr (C4a>tr*IV% " >ro>o6 to t to t4 $t#t tra#6fr 

    fro@ o# 4o6>8ta! to a#ot4r " ar #ot

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    86/121

    LatestLaws.com

    C(APT)* 4

    RECOMMENDATIONS FOR MANDATORY EMERGENCYMEDICAL CARE BY )OSPITALS AND MEDICAL

    PRACTITIONERS

    I# t4 !8tr6 I a#d II a#d t4 >r8#38>!6

    a>>!8d for @a#dator @r8ta!6 8# USA 8#

     >art83;!ar a6 d63r87d 8# 34a>tr III " >ro>o6 to 8#< 8# 8" t4 o76rat8o#6 of t4 S;>r@ Co;rt

    8# Par@a#a#d atara U#8o# of I#d8a AIR 19-9 SC 20,9 Pa6348@ Ba#r@ Co;rt It @a 7 #otd t4at H4o6>8ta!6 fa!!

    ;#dr E#tr & of Stat L86t 8# S34d;! VII of t4 Co#6t8t;t8o# of I#d8a T4

    rfr#3 to @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6 8# t486 B8!! 86 >;r! 8#38d#ta!

    D;t of )o6>8ta!6 a#d Md83a! Pra3t8t8o#r6+

    -&

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    87/121

    LatestLaws.com

    W 4a #ot83d t4 o76rat8o#6 of t4 S;>r@ Co;rt 8#

    Par@a#ad atara U#8o# of I#d8a + AIR 19-9 SC 20,9 t4at 4o6>8ta!6 a#d

    @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6 4a a d;t to >ro8d @rr6o#6

    64o;!d 7 t4 to> >r8or8t #ot o#! of t4 @d83a! >rof668o#a!6 7;t # of 

    t4 >o!83 or a# ot4r 38t8# "4o 4a>>#6 to 7 3o##3td "8t4 t4 @attr 

    or "4o 4a>>#6 to #ot83 6;34 a# a338d#t or a 68t;at8o# T4 Co;rt 6a8d

    ?8t 86 t4 o7!88ta! or 

    ot4r"86 4a6 t4 >rof668o#a! o7!8rof668o# T4 o7!8ara@o;#t !a"6 of >ro3d;r "4t4r 8# 6tat;t6 or 

    ot4r"86 "4834 "o;!d 8#trfr "8t4 t4 d8634ar

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    88/121

    LatestLaws.com

    ?B;t o# 74a!f of t4 @d83a! >rof668o# t4r 86 o# @or

    a>>r4#68o# "4834 6o@t8@6 >r#t6 a @d83a! >rof668o#a! 8#

    6>8t of 486 d68r to 4!> t4 >r6o# a6 4 a>>r4#d6 t4at 4 "8!! 7

    a "8t#66 a#d @a 4a to fa3 >o!83 8#trror#t6 a @d83a! >rof668o#a! "4o 86 #ot #tr;6td "8t4 t4

    d;t of 4a#d!8#< @d83o*!;7!864d 8# a!!

     =o;r#a!6 r>ort8#< d3868o#6 of t486 Co;rt a#d ad;at >;7!838t

    64o;!d 7

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    89/121

    LatestLaws.com

    W ar t4rfor of t4 o>8#8o# t4at 8t 86 #366ar to 8@>o6 a

    6tat;tor d;t o# 4o6>8ta!6 a#d @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6 to att#d o# a >r6o#

    "4o 4a6 @t "8t4 a# a338d#t or "4o 86 8# a# @r8ta!

    A>art fro@ t486 8#d of o7=3t8o#6 t4r ar ot4r 38r3;@6ta#36

    "4834 ar r3oo#687! for rf;6a! to trat >r6o#6

    @#t8o#d a7o O# 6;34 o7=3t8o# 86 t4at t4 >r6o# 86 #ot 8@@d8at!

    8# a >o68t8o# to @t t4 $>#d8t;r t4at @a 7 8#o!d 8# @r8ta!6 or do3tor6 "a#t 8@@d8at

     >a@#t So@ ot4r6 ar #ot >r>ard to ta ;> 3a66 "4r t4 >r6o#

    do6 #ot 4a 8#6;ra#3 or 4a6 #o fa38!8t for @d83a! r8@7;r6@#t 8t4r 

    fro@ 486 @>!or or ;#dr a# ot4r @d83a! r8@7;r6@#t 634@

    T46 a#d ot4r o7=3t8o#6 #3668tat t4at a 6>38f83 6tat;tor >ro868o#

    @;6t 7 @ad 8@>o68#< a @a#dator d;t o# 4o6>8ta!6 a#d do3tor6 to trat

     >r6o#6 "4o ar 8#=;rd 8# a338d#t6 or "4o ar 8# ot4r @d83a!

    @rat8#t 63r# 48@ 6ta78!8 48@

    a#d r#dr 6;34 @r8ta! or t4 3!8#83 of t4 @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r W ar a!6o >ro>o68#< a

    6tat;tor 634@ for r8@7;r6@#t 7 t4 Stat Gor#@#t6

    T4 f8r6t f" 4o;r6 ar #o"# a6 Hat8#t6

    for 8f t4r 86 #o @r>!d a#d 8!! 7o#d r>a8r for a!! t8@

    -9

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    90/121

    LatestLaws.com

    I# t4 U#8td Stat6 of A@r83a a6 6tatd 8# 34a>tr III !a3 of 

    8#tr6t o# t4 >art of 4o6>8ta!6 to att#d o# 83t8@6 of a338d#t6 t4o6 8# a#

    @rr6o#6 T4 A3t 3o#ta8#6 a#

    #t8r 634@ of 63r#8#>d

    to >ro8d 6ta78!8at8o# or @r8ta! 4a6 to tra#6fr t4 >r6o# to a#ot4r 4o6>8ta! I# 3rta8# 3a66 8t

    3a##ot tra#6fr ;#!66 t4 >at8#t 86 6ta78!8d A #;@7r of 6afro8dd 8# E@ta!a a6 to "4at 64o;!d 7 do# for tra#6fr of a >r6o# to

    a#ot4r 4o6>8ta! T4 E@ta!a a!6o 3rat6 off#36 atd 6o@ of t4 >r8#38>!6

    6tatd 8# E@ta!a a#d " 4a @ad 6;8ta7! 34a#;r>o66 8#

    I#d8a

    (A% W r3o@@#d 6tat;tor d;t86 o# 4o6>8ta!6 a#d @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6

    W t4rfor r3o@@#d a 63t8o# 8# t4 >ro>o6d !a" to @a 8t

    @a#dator to d8r3t @d83a! a6686ta#3 8# a338d#t6 a#d @rr3!;d8#< t4 4o6>8ta!6 or do3tor6 fro@ ra868#< a# o7=3t8o# o# t4

    fo!!o"8#<

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    91/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (a% t4at 8t 86 a @d83o*!r6o# 86 #ot 8@@d8at! 8# a >o68t8o# to @a

     >a@#t for 63r#8#< a#d @ra@#t 64o;!d 7 @ad a6 a 3o#d8t8o#

     >r3d#t for trat@#t or 

    (7% t4at t4 >r6o# do6 #ot 4a @d83a! 8#6;ra#3 or 86 #ot a

    @@7r of a# @d83a! 634@ >ro8d8#< for @d83a!r8@7;r6@#t

    I# add8t8o# " >ro>o6 t4at ?#o ot4r ;#ra6o#a7! o7=3t8o# 3a# 7

    ra86d for o6d 63t8o# , 86 a6 fo!!o"6+

    Dut& of dut& do#tor$ in ho$pital$ and pri5ate medi#al

    pra#titioner$

    , It 64a!! 7 t4 d;t of r 4o6>8ta! a#d r @d83a!

     >ra3t8t8o#r to 8@@d8at! att#d o# r >r6o# 8#o!d 8# a#

    a338d#t or "4o 86 >;r>ortd! 8# a# @r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    92/121

    LatestLaws.com

    6tatd 8# 63t8o# a#d afford t4@ 6;34 @d83a! trat@#t a6 @a 7

    ;rr6o# 86 8@@d8at! 8# a >o68t8o# to

    @a >a@#t for 63r#8#< a#d @rr6o# 4a6 @d83a! 8#6;ra#3 or 86 a

    @@7r of a# @d83a! 634@ of t4 >r6o#6 @>!or or to

    a 634@ "4834 ot4r"86 >ro8d6 for @d83a! r8@7;r6@#t

    a#d

    (8% "8t4o;t ra868#< a# ot4r ;#ra6o#a7! o7=3t8o#

     (B% HS3r#8#r6o# to dtr@8# 8f 4 86 8# a#@rat8#t d>art@#t of t4 4o6>8ta! E# a >r8at @d83a!

     >ra3t8t8o#r 3a# 3o#d;3t 6;34 a 63r#8#8ta! or do3tor 8# t48r rro8d6 for @a#dator 63r#8#< a6 fo!!o"6+

    92

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    93/121

    LatestLaws.com

    S#reenin' of the per$on

    . W4#r 6;34 a >r6o# rfrrd to 8# 63t8o# , 86 7ro;8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 8t 64a!! 7 t48r d;t to >ro8d a#

    a>>ro>r8at @d83a! 63r#8#< $a@8#at8o# "8t48# t4 3a>a78!8t of t4

    4o6>8ta! or t4 @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r a6 t4 3a6 @a 7 for t4 >;r>o6 of 

    dtr@8#8#< "4t4r or #ot a# @r8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r a6 t4 3a6 @a

     7 86 #ot 4a8#< 3a>a78!8t for 3o#d;3t8#< a>>ro>r8at @d83a! 63r#8#<

    $a@8#at8o# 8t 64a!! 7 t48r d;t to arra#r6o# to

    a 4o6>8ta! or to a#ot4r @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r "4834 or "4o 8# t48r o>8#8o#

    4a6 t4 #366ar 3a>a78!8t86 for 6;34 @d83a! 63r#8#< $a@8#at8o#

    O#3 t4 @a#dator 63r#8#< 86 do# 8t @a ra! t4at t4 >r6o# 86

    or 86 #ot 8# a# @ro6 to df8#% "

    @a# a @d83a! 3o#d8t8o# @a#8f6t8#< a3;t 6@>to@6 of 6;ff838#t 6r8t

    (8#3!;d8#< 6r >a8#% "4r t4 a76#3 of @r3td to r6;!t 8#

    (8% dat4 of t4 >r6o#

    (88% 6r8o;6 =o>ard 8# t4 4a!t4 of t4 >r6o# (or 8# t4 3a6 of 

    a >r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    94/121

    LatestLaws.com

    W >ro>o6 to add a# E$>!a#at8o# a6 to "4at 86 @rrr6o# to a#ot4r 4o6>8ta! 7for d!8r or t4

    tra#6fr @a >o6 a t4rat to t4 4a!t4 or 6aft of t4 "o@a# or 4r ;#7or#

    348!d

    (C% E@rr6o# "4o 86 8# @rr6o#+

    If a >r6o# 86 8# a# @r8#8o# of t4 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 7 #366ar for t4

     >;r>o6 of >r#t8#< ar

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    95/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (8% to >ro8d 6;34 @d83a! trat@#t of t4 3o#d8t8o# a6 @a 7

    #366ar to a66;r "8t48# ra6o#a7! @d83a! >ro7a78!8t t4at

    #o @atr8a! dtr8orat8o# of t4 3o#d8t8o# 86 !8! to r6;!t

    fro@ or o33;r d;r8#< t4 tra#6fr of t4 8#d88d;a! fro@ a

    fa38!8t or 

    (88%to >ro8d "8t4 r6>3t to a >r!a3#ta%

    a#d t4 "ord H6ta78!8d 64a!! 7 ;#dr6tood a33ord8#

    D;t of 4o6>8ta! a#d @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r to 6ta78!8 t4 @d83a!

    3o#d8t8o# 86 >ro8dd 8# 63t8o# (8%% of t4 B8!! a6 fo!!o"6+

    Stabiliin' the per$on and tran$fer

    W4rr 8# r6>3t of a >r6o# rfrrd to 8# 63t8o# , 63r#8#8ta!

    or "8t4 t4 @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 6;34 f;rt4r @d83a! $a@8#at8o#

    a#d 6;34 @d83a! trat@#t a6 @a 7 r;8rd to 6ta78!8 486

    @d83a! 3o#d8t8o# or 

    (88%

    (D% Aftr 6ta78!8at8o# tra#6fr "4r #366ar

    9

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    96/121

    LatestLaws.com

    B;t "4r t4 #366ar fa38!8t86 for 6ta78!8at8o# ar #ot aa8!a7!

    "8t4 a 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 8t 86 #366ar to arra#8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r "4o or "4834 8# t4 o>8#8o# of 

    t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 3a# 6ta78!8 t4 >r6o# a#d

     >ro8d f;rt4r @d83a! trat@#t

    T486 86 >ro8dd 8# 63t8o# (88% of t4 B8!! a6 fo!!o"6+

    Stabiliin' the per$on and tran$fer

    W4rr 8# r6>3t of a >r6o# rfrrd to 8# 63t8o# , 63r#8#

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    97/121

    LatestLaws.com

    8#3!;d8#< 6ta78!8at8o#% or for trat@#t aftr 6ta78!8at8o# t4 4o6>8ta! or 

    @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r @;6t 8ta! or "8t4 t4 @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r

    or "4r t4 >at8#t r;6t6 for tra#6fr 4 4a6 to 7 tra#6frrd to a#ot4r 

    4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r a#d t4 >r6o# rf;66 for tra#6fr t4

     >r6o#6 "r8tt# 8#for@d rf;6a! @;6t 7 o7ta8#d a#d 8f 6;34 >r6o#

    rf;66to 8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r a6

     >ro8dd 8# S3t8o# 64a!! 3a6 to $86t T486 86 >ro8dd 8# >ro86o to

    63t8o# Pro86o rad6 a6 fo!!o"6+

    ?Pro8dd t4at "4r 6;34 >r6o# rf;66 to 8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 64a!! 3a6 to $86t

    T486 86 >ro8dd 8# 63t8o# & of t4 Draft B8!!

    *efu$al b& the per$on to #on$ent for treatment or tran$fer

    & W4r 8# r6>3t of a >r6o# rfrrd to 8# 63t8o# , 8t 4a6 7#dtr@8#d t4at 4 r;8r6 @rro8d f;rt4r @rra3t8t8o#r 64a!! ta a!! ra6o#a7! 6t>6 to o7ta8# t4 >r6o#6

    9/

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    98/121

    LatestLaws.com

    "r8tt# 8#for@d 3o#6#t 8# r6>3t of 486 rf;6a! to 3o#6#t for 

    @r8ta! or t4 @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r a6 t4 3a6 @a 7 4a6

    offrd to tra#6fr 48@ to a#ot4r @d83a! fa38!8t 8# a33orda#3

    "8t4 63t8o# - a#d aftr 78#< 8#for@d of t4 r866 a#d 7#f8t6

    to 6;34 >r6o# of 6;34 tra#6fr t4 d;t off83r 8# 4o6>8ta! or t4

    @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 64a!! ta a!! ra6o#a7! 6t>6 to o7ta8# t4

     >r6o#6 "r8tt# 8#for@d 3o#6#t 8# r6>3t of 486 rf;6a! to

    3o#6#t to 6;34 tra#6fr

    (F% No tra#6fr 7for 6ta78!8at8o#+

    A6 >ro>o6d 8# 63t8o# / of t4 B8!! "4r a >r6o# r;6t6 for a

    tra#6fr rfrrd to 8# 63t8o# (88% 7;t 86 8# a# @rra3t8t8o#r 

    o;t"8r6o# a#d 8# t4 3a6 of a

    9-

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    99/121

    LatestLaws.com

     >ra8d

    f8r6t If #o a@7;!a#3 86 aa8!a7! t4 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 4a6

    to 6 t4 4!> of t4 >o!83 to r;868t8o# a# 483! for tra#6>ort T4

    tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! or do3tor @;6t >ro8d for @d83a! fa38!8t86 d;r8#< t4

    tra#6>ort S3t8o# - "4834 da!6 "8t4 t46 a6>3t6 ;#dr t4 4ad8#<

    Ha>>ro>r8at tra#6fr rad6 a6 fo!!o"6+

    Appropriate tran$fer

    - A tra#6fr to a#ot4r 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 64a!! 7

    tratd a6 a# a>>ro>r8at tra#6fr 8f 

    (a% t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! or t4 @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r >ro8d6

    @d83a! trat@#t "8t48# 8t6 or 486 3a>a38t "4834 @8#8@86 t4

    r866 to t4 4a!t4 of t4 >r6o# a#d 8# t4 3a6 of a >r

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    100/121

    LatestLaws.com

    (7% t4 r388#< 4o6>8ta! or t4 @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 4a6 aa8!a7!

    6>a3 ;a!8f8d >r6o##! a#d 8#fra6tr;3t;r for >ro8d8#<

    @rr6o# a#d t4raftr 8# 6o

    far a6 t4 6ta78!8at8o# a#d f;rt4r @d83a! trat@#t ar

    3o#3r#d t4 d;t86 3a6t ;#dr 63t8o# , 64a!! a>>! to t4

    r388#< 4o6>8ta! or t4 r388#< @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r

    (3% t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 6#d6 to t4

    r388#< 4o6>8ta! or r388#< @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 

    (8% a!! @d83a! r3ord6 (or 3o>86 t4rof% r!at8#< to t4

    63r#8#< a#d t4 @rr6o# "4834 ar aa8!a7! at t4 t8@ of 6;34 tra#6fr

    8#3!;d8#< r3ord6 r!at8#< to t4 >r6o#6 @d83a!

    3o#d8t8o# o76rat8o# of 68to@6 >r!8@8#ar

    d8aro8dd r6;!t6 of a# t6t6 a#d t4

    8#for@d "r8tt# 3o#6#t 8f a# a#d

    (88% a 3rt8f83at of t4 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r t4at

     7a6d ;>o# t4 8#for@at8o# aa8!a7! at t4 t8@ of 

    tra#6fr t4at t4 @d83a! 7#f8t6 ra6o#a7! $>3td

    fro@ t4 >ro868o# of a>>ro>r8at @d83a! trat@#t at

    t4 r388#< 4o6>8ta! o;t"8r6o# a#d 8# 3a6 of a

    "o@# ;#dr !a7or to t4 ;#7or# 348!d

    (d% t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r >ro8d6

    #366ar @d83a! fa38!8t86 8#3!;d8#< !8f 6;>>ort 66t@6 a#d

    ;a!8f8d >r6o##! "8t48# t4 3a>a38t of t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta!

    or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r to a33o@>a# t4 >r6o# d;r8#< t4

    100

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    101/121

    LatestLaws.com

     >r8od 3ord 7 tra#6>ort to t4 r388#< 4o6>8ta! or r388#<

    @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r

    (% t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r 4a6 8#for@d 7

    t!>4o# or ot4r"86 t4 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r to

    "4834 or to "4o@ t4 >r6o# 86 78#< tra#6frrd t4at a >r6o# 8#

    a# @rr6o#6 3o#d8t8o#

    Pro8dd t4at "4r a# a@7;!a#3 or ot4r tra#6>ort 483!

    86 #ot aa8!a7! "8t4 t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! or @d83a!

     >ra3t8t8o#r 8t or 4 64a!! 3a!! for t4 6r836 of a# a@7;!a#3 or 

    ot4r tra#6>ort 483! a#d 8# 3a6 of #o#*aa8!a78!8t t4rof

    64a!! 6 t4 a6686ta#3 of a# >o!83 a;t4or8t86 4a8#<

     =;r86d83t8o# or t4 ara "4r t4 tra#6frr8#< 4o6>8ta! or t4

    3!8#83 of t4 @d83a! off83r 86 !o3atd for r;868t8o#8#< a

    tra#6>ort 483!

    Pro8dd f;rt4r t4at "4# a# a@7;!a#3 or 483! 86 3a!!d

    for 7 6;34 4o6>8ta! or @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r or 7 >o!83

    a;t4or8t86 a6 afor6a8d t4 a

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    102/121

    LatestLaws.com

    ?Er 4o6>8ta! @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r ** 64a!! @a8#ta8# a 6>arat

    r;r>ortd! 8# @rr6o# 86 8# a >o68t8o# to 8ta! or do3tor 3o@>!8d

    "8t4 8t6 or 486 d;t86 ;#dr t4 A3t

    (% S;34 ot4r >art83;!ar6 a6 @a 7 >r63r87d

    (I% S34@ for r8@7;r6@#t to 4o6>8ta!6 a#d @d83a! >ra3t8t8o#r6

    a@7;!a#3 for tra#6fr t3 to 7 fra@d 7 Stat Gor#@#t6+ Stat6

    to a!!o3at F;#d6+

    102

    LatestLaws.com

  • 8/18/2019 Law Commission Report No. 201- Medical Treatment After Accidents and During Emergency Medical Condition and…

    103/121

    LatestLaws.com

    T4 Stat Gor#@#t @;6t fra@ a