LAEDC Economic Impact of Measure R Projects 10Feb10

8/9/2019 LAEDC Economic Impact of Measure R Projects 10Feb10

1/19

!!!"#$"%&'()*"#+*))+,"-!+."%&''*""!"""/'0"123)&)0,"41""56678"""!"""9:::;"!4)D)&'EB)2+"4'*E'*F+C

!"#$!%&'(")*%"+&'!+,-.%"!&/!,$")&0(!!,$.(*)$!)!").'(-&)"."+&'!-)&1$%"(!!

233452367!!!!!!

!!!!!!!

!!!

February 10, 2010

!!

!


2/19

! !

!


3/19

! ! !

"!

$8$%*"+9$!(*,,.):!!#$%! &'(! )*+%,%(! -'.*/0! 1%/2'3',4/5*! #25*(3'2/5/4'*! )./$'24/0! 61%/2'7! $5(! 32'3'(%8! 5!(%24%(!'9!/25*(3'2/5/4'*!4:32';%:%*/!32'.(4*%((!2%;%*.%(7J! %:3,'0:%*/! 5*8! %52*4*+(! 4*!K'./$%2*!-5,49'2*45!5(('=45/%8! L4/$! /$%! 32'3'(%8!='*(/2.=/4'*! 5=/4;4/4%(! ';%2! /$%! *%?/! GM! 0%52(B! ),,! '9! /$%! 32'4/!>%,'L!(.::524T%(!'.2!94*84*+(B!!

"#$%$&'#!%!'+#,!&.#/!$0!12/3$!4$%+/35#/'$%!63$72#/+ !

! -;?@!";AF>!

C2'(7! VMIJVMM! "WJYMM!

D52*4*+(!6F!:4,,4'*(7! F!!!!UUJGIW! F!!!!!!IHW!

".8+%/%8! /'! %?=%%8! FGHBI! >4,,4'*J! L4,,! +%*%25/%! FWXBX! >4,,4'*! 4*! %='*':4=!'./3./! 6:%5(.2%8! >0! >.(4*%((! 2%;%*.%(7! 4*! /$%! 94;%='.*/0! K'./$%2*! -5,49'2*45! 2%+4'*J!5884*+!VMIJVMM!4,,4'*!';%2!/$%!/$42/0!0%52!3%24'8J!'2!5*!5**.5,!5;%25+%!'9!"WJYMM!4,,4'*J!'2!5*!5**.5,! 5;%25+%!'9!FG"M!:4,,4'*B!)332'?4:5/%,0! IM! 3%2=%*/! '9! /$%! /'/5,J! '2! FWBW! >4,,4'*J! L4,,! >%! %52*%8! 5/! /$%! 9%8%25,! ,%;%,B!1'2%!/$5*!FUBG!>4,,4'*!4*!(/5/%!/5?%(!L4,,!>%!3548!';%2!/$%!/$42/0!0%52!3%24'8B!!


4/19

! ! !

U!

,$.(*)$!)!").'(-&)"."+&'!-)&1$%"(!!Budgeted Spending

#$%! &'(! )*+%,%(! -'.*/0! 1%/2'3',4/5*! #25*(3'2/5/4'*! )./$'24/0! 61%/2'7! $5(! 32'3'(%8! 5!(%24%(!'9!/25*(3'2/5/4'*!4:32';%:%*/!32'.8+%/! ='*(4(/(! '9! $4+$L50! 5*8! 92%%L50!4:32';%:%*/(J!5*8!GH!3%2=%*/!9'2!/25*(4/!='2248'2!%?/%*(4'*(!5*8!4:32';%:%*/(B!!!!Excluded Spending

A4+$/'9L50!5=].4(4/4'*!4(!%?=,.8%8!92':!%='*':4=!4:35=/!5*5,0(4(!(4*=%!/$4(!4(!5*!%?=$5*+%!'9!5((%/(!5*8!8'%(!*'/!+%*%25/%!%='*':4=!5=/4;4/0B!K4:4,52,0J!(4*=%!/$%!3.2=$5(%!'9!;%$4=,%(!4(!%?3%=/%8!/'!'==.2!'./(48%!'9!/$%!94;%='.*/0!K'./$%2*!-5,49'2*45!2%+4'*J!/$4(!(3%*84*+!4(!5,('!%?=,.8%8B!O.2!:%/$'8','+0!4(!9.,,0!8%(=24>%8!4*!/$%!)33%*84?B!E',,52!;5,.%(!52%!%?32%((%8!4*!UMMX!8',,52(!/$2'.+$'./!/$4(!2%3'2/B!!


5/19

! ! !!! ! !

G

Economic Impact

#$%!%?$4>4/!>%,'L!(.::524T%(!/$%!%='*':4=!4:35=/!4*!/$%!94;%='.*/0!K'./$%2*!-5,49'2*45!2%+4'*!8.%!/'!/$%!='*(/2.=/4'*!5=/4;4/0B!!

"89':'/!A!12/3$!4,,4'*B! #'+%/$%2J! /$4(! (3%*84*+! L4,,! +%*%25/%!%='*':4=!'./3./!6:%5(.2%8!>0!>.(4*%((!2%;%*.%(7!'9!FWXBX!>4,,4'*!4*!/$%!94;%='.*/0!2%+4'*(!'9!K'./$%2*!-5,49'2*45!64*!UMMX!8',,52(7B!#$%!32'4,,4'*!4*!/'/5,!(5,524%(J!'2!5*!5**.5,!5;%25+%!'9!""JGXM!L50!%?/%*(4'*(J!!

5*8! /$%! ='*(/2.=/4'*!'9! >.(! 25348! /25*(4/! ,4*%(J!L4,,! +%*%25/%! FUUBV! >4,,4'*! 4*! /'/5,! 6842%=/J!4*842%=/!5*8!4*8.=%87!'./3./!9'2!/$%!K'./$%2*!-5,49'2*45!2%+4'*5,!%='*':0!';%2!/$%!='.2(%!'9!GM!0%52(B!`'2a!'*!/$%(%!32'


6/19

! ! !!! ! !

H

Industry Breakdown!#'/5,!'./3./J!%:3,'0:%*/!5*8!%52*4*+(! 4:35=/(!52%!84(5++2%+5/%8!>0! 4*8.(/20!(%=/'2!4*!/$%!%?$4>4/!>%,'LB!#$4(!5,,'L(!5*!%(/4:5/4'*!5*8!4*8.(/20!48%*/494=5/4'*!'9!b9',,'L'*c!%! 4*/%232%/%8! 5(! 4,,.(/25/4;%! '9! /$%!

4*8.(/20!%99%=/(!25/$%2!/$5*!32%=4(%!+4;%*!:'8%,!5*8!85/5!,4:4/5/4'*(B!!!!

"89':'/!B!12/3$!(! +%*%25/%8B! \'L%;%2J! '/$%2! 4*8.(/24%(! 52%! 5,('! (4+*494=5*/,0! 4:35=/%8J!4*=,.84*+[! :5*.95=/.24*+N! 2%5,! %(/5/%N! 2%/54,! /258%N! 5=='::'85/4'*! 5*8! 9''8! (%2;4=%(N!32'9%((4'*5,!5*8! (=4%*/494=! (%2;4=%(N! 94*5*=%! 5*8! 4*(.25*=%N!5*8! $%5,/$!=52%B!D5=$! '9!/$%(%!4*8.(/24%(!L4,,!(%%!5*!4*=2%5(%!4*!>.(4*%((!2%;%*.%(!5*8!4*!/$%!*.:>%2!'9!


7/19

! ! !!! ! !

V

#'!3./! /$%! ,%7! %:3,'0:%*/! 4*! /$%! ='*(/2.=/4'*! 4*8.(/20! 4*! K'./$%2*! -5,49'2*45! L5(! GY"JHWH!3%2('*(J!5*8!/$%2%!L%2%!WBG!:4,,4'*!3%'3,%!4*!/$%!/'/5,!L'2a9'2=%B!!

!#$%! /'/5,! %(/4:5/%8! !=2%5/4'*!4(!%?3%=/%8!/'!>%!U"XJXWI!';%2!/$%!32'


8/19

! ! !!! ! !

W

"89':'/!C!"&.,$&2%/!D2%23/'$%!:!12+532!E!!"#$%&'(F.2%'%>!

%5+/3!?32G$(%!:!4$5%/!

+CJ@;Y! ^B>J! &;ACF>!(AC!

>;CA;C;J>! 9>C@;A!

)+24=.,/.2%! "XM! "UM! GHM! IM! WHM!14*4*+! "YM! GM! UM! GM! VM!d/4,4/4%(! VWM! "IM! IM! "IM! HM!-'*(/2.=/4'*! WUJHGM! GXJXXM! UGJHYM! "VJHUM! IJMIM!

15*.95=/.24*+! "GJMMM! VJ"IM! "JHHM! "JIHM! "JMIM!

`$',%(5,%!/258%! VJ"UM! UJM"M! HIM! IYM! UYM!

A%/54,!/258%! "YJMGM! IJ"MM! GJXHM! GJXGM! "JWXM!

#25*(3'2/5/4'*!5*8!L52%$'.(4*+! HJXMM! XIM! W"M! "JHMM! "XM!S*9'2:5/4'*! GJHIM! HYM! "GM! "UM! YM!Z4*5*=%!5*8!4*(.25*=%! VJUIM! UJVVM! HUM! VGM! V"M!A%5,!%(/5/%! GJYUM! "JXHM! HYM! HHM! UGM!

C2'9%((4'*5,J!(=4%*/494=!5*8!/%=$*4=5,!!

""JHHM! HJYGM! XIM! XHM! WXM!

15*5+%:%*/!'9!=':35*4%(! UJ""M! YWM! "GM! UHM! "WM!)8:4*4(/25/4;%!h! 5(/%!

!IJHUM! GJWUM! YXM! "JVUM! V"M!

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a%2(!L$'(%!%52*4*+(!52%!(.(/54*%8!>0!/$%!/25*(3'2/5/4'*!32'0!,%;%,!'9!+';%2*:%*/!52%!(.::524T%8!4*!/$%!D?$4>4/!'*!/$%!9',,'L4*+!35+%B!!`%!%(/4:5/%!/$5/!842%=/J!4*842%=/!5*8! 4*8.=%8!L'2a%2(!L4,,!350!FGBU!>4,,4'*!4*! 9%8%25,!4*=':%!/5?%(J!FUBX!>4,,4'*!4*!('=45,!(%=.24/0!/5?%(!5*8!FYHM!:4,,4'*!4*!-5,49'2*45!(/5/%!4*=':%!/5?%(J!/'+%/$%2!=':324(4*+! 5,:'(/! /$2%%].52/%2(!'9!5,,!/5?! 2%;%*.%(B!K5,%(!/5?%(!+%*%25/%8! '*!5,,!3.2=$5(%!L4,,!%?=%%8!F"BV!>4,,4'*J!:'2%!/$5*!(4?/%%*!3%2=%*/!'9!/$%!/'/5,!94(=5,!4:35=/B!!


9/19

! ! !!! ! !

I

),,! /'+%/$%2J! 5/! ,%5(/! FYBG! >4,,4'*! 4*! /5?! 2%;%*.%(! L4,,! >%! +%*%25/%8! 4*! 2%,5/4'*! /'! /$%!/25*(3'2/5/4'*!='*(/2.=/4'*!32'%!%52*%8!5/! /$%!9%8%25,! ,%;%,J! UV!3%2=%*/! 5/! /$%! (/5/%! ,%;%,J!5*8! /$%! 2%:54*8%2! ($52%8!>%/L%%*! ='.*/0! 5*8!,'=5,! +';%2*:%*/(B!O.2!%(/4:5/%(! '9! /'/5,! /5?! 2%;%*.%(! +%*%25/%8! >0!='*(/2.=/4'*2%,5/%8!5=/4;4/4%(!52%!,'LJ!(4*=%!8.%!/'!85/5!,4:4/5/4'*(!L%!8'!*'/!5=='.*/!9'2!;524'.(!9%8%25,!5*8!

(/5/%!/5?%(!(.=$!5(!9.%,!/5?%(J!>.(4*%((!+2'((!2%=%43/(!/5?%(J!5*8!='23'25/%!4*=':%!/5?%(N!*'2!8'!L%!5=='.*/!9'2!,'=5,!3%2:4/(!5*8!9%%(!3505>,%!'*!/$%!32'>C>!Y!"Y>!4/!W!'*!/$%!9',,'L4*+!35+%!($'L(!/$%!%(/4:5/%8!%='*':4=!4:35=/!>0!94(=5,!0%52J!5=='284*+!/'!/$%!>.8+%/%8!(3%*84*+B!!!K4:4,52,0J!D?$4>4/!I!'*!35+%!Y!($'L(!/$%!5**.5,!94(=5,!4:35=/!9'2!%5=$!,%;%,!'9!+';%2*:%*/B!!!K%3525/%!94(=5,!0%52!D?$4>4/(!9'2!/$%!$4+$L50!5*8!92%%L50!32'


10/19

! ! !!! ! !

X

"89':'/!J!12/3$!


11/19


12/19

! ! !

)"!

.--$'+8!!!!Methodology!

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`%!.(%8!85/5!(.33,4%8!>0!1%/2'!9'2! 4*4/45,! (3%*84*+J!5*8!%(/4:5/%8!/$%!842%=/J! 4*842%=/!5*8!

4*8.=%8!%99%=/(!.(4*+!:.,/43,4%2(!92':!/$%!A%+4'*5,!S*3./O./3./!1'8%,4*+!K0(/%:!6AS1K!SS7!8%;%,'3%8!>0!/$%!P.2%5.!'9!D='*':4=!)*5,0(4(!5/!/$%!dBKB!E%352/:%*/!'9!-'::%2=%B!S*!5,,! =5(%(J!L%! $5;%! 32'=%%8%8! 5(! 49! /$%! (3%*84*+!L4,,! /5a%! 3,5=%! L4/$4*!5! (4*+,%! 0%52J! 5(! 4(!=.(/':520!L$%*! .(4*+! AS1K! SS!:.,/43,4%2(J! 5,/$'.+$!:5*0! '9! /$%! 32'3'(%8! 32'5(%8! '*! (3%*84*+! L4/$4*! /$%! 94;%='.*/0! K'./$%2*!-5,49'2*45! 2%+4'*J! L$4=$! 4*=,.8%(! /$%! ='.*/4%(! '9! &'(! )*+%,%(J! O25*+%J! A4;%2(48%J! K5*!

P%2*5284*'! 5*8!Q%*/.25B!#$4(! 2%+4'*!4(! =$'(%*!5(!:'(/! 2%32%(%*/5/4;%!'9!/$%! 2%+4'*!:'(/!599%=/%8!>0!1%/2'R(!32'%!4*!&'(!)*+%,%(!-'.*/0J!L%!%?3%=/!/$5/!/$%!L'2a9'2=%J!/$%!:5/%245,(!3.2=$5(%8J!5*8!/$%!>.(4*%((!/$5/!L4,,!>%!4:35=/%8!>0!1%/2'R(!(3%*84*+!52%!,'=5/%8!/$2'.+$'./!/$%!94;%='.*/0!K'./$%2*!-5,49'2*45!2%+4'*B!!!E5/5!,4:4/5/4'*(!32%;%*/!.(!92':!%(/4:5/4*+!$'L!:.=$!'9!/$%!';%25,,!='*(/2.=/4'*!(3%*84*+!L4,,! /5a%!3,5=%!'./(48%!'9!/$%!2%+4'*N! 9'2!%?5:3,%J!='*(/2.=/4'*!:5/%245,(!:4+$/!>%!!,'=5,,0!>./!>%!:5*.95=/.2%8!%,(%L$%2%B!S*!(':%!4*(/5*=%(J!(3%*84*+!2%,5/%8!/'!5!32'


13/19

! ! !!! ! !

)U

i'>! =2%5/4'*! 6'2! %52*4*+(7! %(/4:5/%(! 52%! >5(%8! '*! *5/4'*5,! 5;%25+%! 2%,5/4'*($43(! >%/L%%*!'./3./!5*8!%:3,'0:%*/!6'2!%52*4*+(7B!`$%2%!(.=$!2%,5/4'*($43(!5/!/$%!2%+4'*5,!,%;%,!8499%2!92':! /$%! *5/4'*5,! 2%,5/4'*($43(J! /$%!4:35=/(!:50!>%!:52+4*5,,0! .*8%2(/5/%8!'2!';%2(/5/%8B!i'>!=2%5/4'*!%(/4:5/%(!52%!:%5(.2%8!'*!5!5(4(!9'2!>'/$!L5+%5*8(5,520!L'2a%2(!5*8!32'324%/'2(!2%+528,%((!'9!/$%!*.:>%2!'9!$'.2(!L'2a%8B!

!


14/19

! ! !!! ! !

)G

Supplemental Exhibits

"89':'/!MN;!"&.,$&2%/!D2%23/'$%!:!12+532!E!F.2%'%>!

%5+/3!?32G$(%!:!4$5%/!

+CJ@;Y! ^B>J! &;ACF>! (AC!>;CA;C

)>;J>! 9>C@;A!

)+24=.,/.2%! UWM! "XM! V"M! ""M! YWM!14*4*+! UXM! HM! GM! HM! IM!d/4,4/4%(! XGM! UVM! ""M! UWM! WM!-'*(/2.=/4'*! YUJIIM! VIJIXM! GHJYMM! UUJY"M! "MJVMM!

15*.95=/.24*+! "YJGUM! IJWXM! UJ"GM! UJVYM! "JVYM!

`$',%(5,%!/258%! IJW"M! UJYXM! WYM! "J"XM! HGM!

A%/54,!/258%! UXJUXM! "MJVHM! VJI"M! VJWYM! UJVMM!#25*(3'2/5/4'*!5*8!L52%$'.(4*+! IJ"HM! "JUYM! Y"M! UJMXM! UIM!S*9'2:5/4'*! VJ"WM! IGM! "YM! "IM! "GM!Z4*5*=%!5*8!4*(.25*=%! IJXGM! GJXMM! WUM! IXM! IVM!A%5,!%(/5/%! VJXGM! UJIGM! IGM! WVM! GVM!

C2'9%((4'*5,J!(=4%*/494=!5*8!/%=$*4=5,!!

"WJYYM! IJGGM! "JGMM! "JUHM! "JM"M!

15*5+%:%*/!'9!=':35*4%(! GJ"HM! "JHGM! "YM! GVM! UHM!

)8:4*4(/25/4;%!h! 5(/%!!

""JMGM! VJGXM! "JHWM! UJUWM! IVM!

D8.=5/4'*!(%2;4=%(! HJYYM! "J"WM! UXM! H"M! UUM!\%5,/$!=52%!5*8!('=45,!5((4(/5*=%! "WJMWM! VJ"HM! UJ""M! UJWMM! "JMXM!)2/(J!%*/%2/54*:%*/!5*8!2%=2%5/4'*! HJ"GM! UJ"UM! WMM! GHM! GMM!)=='::'85/4'*!5*8!9''8!(%2;4=%(! "VJHXM! WJVXM! UJYVM! UJHHM! "JUVM!O/$%2!(%2;4=%(! "MJYGM! UJ""M! "JM"M! "JUVM! HVM!

\'.(%$',8(! UJMVM! IWM! G"M! UGM! "IM!"


15/19

! ! !!! ! !

)H

"89':'/!MNA!"&.,$&2%/!D2%23/'$%!:!12+532!E!)*&+,"-!F.2%'%>!

%5+/3!?32G$(%!:!4$5%/!

+CJ@;Y! ^B>J! &;ACF>!(AC!

>;CA;C;J>! 9>C@;A!

)+24=.,/.2%! YM! WM! "IM! HM! G"M!14*4*+! YM! "M! "M! "M! UM!d/4,4/4%(! UIM! XM! HM! XM! UM!-'*(/2.=/4'*! GMJGHM! "XJYMM! ""JH"M! IJHYM! GJHHM!

15*.95=/.24*+! WJGUM! UJV"M! IMM! XVM! VUM!

`$',%(5,%!/258%! UJHYM! YXM! UGM! GXM! "HM!

A%/54,!/258%! YJUVM! GJHVM! "JXIM! "JXWM! XUM!

#25*(3'2/5/4'*!5*8!L52%$'.(4*+! UJGGM! HUM! GMM! WXM! YM!S*9'2:5/4'*! "JWYM! UHM! WM! WM! HM!Z4*5*=%!5*8!4*(.25*=%! UJVWM! "JUHM! UMM! UWM! UVM!A%5,!%(/5/%! "JY"M! XYM! UHM! U"M! ""M!

C2'9%((4'*5,J!(=4%*/494=!5*8!/%=$*4=5,!!

VJVWM! UJHMM! HUM! H"M! GGM!

15*5+%:%*/!'9!=':35*4%(! "JMGM! HIM! WM! ""M! XM!)8:4*4(/25/4;%!h! 5(/%!

!GJW"M! "JIWM! HXM! IHM! UVM!

D8.=5/4'*!(%2;4=%(! "JWGM! GXM! YM! "GM! IM!\%5,/$!=52%!5*8!('=45,!5((4(/5*=%! VJUVM! "JWXM! WYM! XVM! GVM!)2/(J!%*/%2/54*:%*/!5*8!2%=2%5/4'*! "JGVM! WYM! "YM! ""M! "MM!)=='::'85/4'*!5*8!9''8!(%2;4=%(! VJMWM! UJ"VM! YIM! XMM! H"M!O/$%2!(%2;4=%(! GJVXM! WYM! GGM! H"M! "VM!\'.(%$',8(! WIM! UVM! "MM! XM! VM!"


16/19

! ! !!! ! !

)V

"89':'/!MNB!O'>9(!%!322(!&.3$2&2%/!63$72#/+!

"#$%$&'#!&.#/!:!'+#,!K23!

/J?AB!:>A;!-;?@!(>CCF!K!GBBCCF! '>@!(>CCF!

&@@!K!GBB


17/19

! ! !!! ! !

)W

"89':'/!MNC!O'>9(!%!322(!&.3$2&2%/!63$72#/+!

'+#,!&.#/!:!'+#,!K23!

/J?AB!:>A;!/J?AB!+GA?@!K!GBB>;AB! (@A@>! %J! "


18/19

! ! !!! ! !

)I

!

"89':'/!MN)!@!(>CCF!&@@!

K!GBB


19/19

! ! !!! ! !

) X

"89':'/!MNJ!

Documents

LAEDC Economic Impact of Measure R Projects 10Feb10