1
TABLE 1: OUTCOME MEASURES Parent Measures Parent Fidelity Behavioral rating during parent-child interaction (10- min Play and Snack Routine) Parent Self-Efficacy Parent Sense of Competence Scale Parenting Stress Family Impact Questionnaire - Negative and Social Impact subscale items Positive Perceptions of Child Family Impact Questionnaire - Positive Impact subscale items Child Measures Expressive Language Targets Frequency of language targets during parent-child interaction Expressive Vocabulary MacArthur-Bates Communicative Development Inventory Functional Communication Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales-2 nd Edition (VABS-II) – Communication Domain Social Skills Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales-2 nd Edition (VABS-II) – Social Domain BACKGROUND Parent-mediated intervention for children with ASD can improve both parent and child functioning. Access to parent-mediated intervention services is often limited in rural and under-resourced areas. Telehealth, the provision of health information over the internet, can increase service access at a reduced cost. There is growing interest in expanding telehealth to parent training for ASD, but research is limited and little is known regarding the relative benefits of self- directed vs. therapist-assisted models. OBJECTIVES Pilot RCT to compare the effect of self-directed and therapist-assisted formats of ImPACT Online, telehealth-based parent-mediated intervention on parent and child outcomes. Comparison of a Self-Directed and Therapist-Assisted Telehealth Parent Training Intervention for Children with ASD Kate Shannon, MS, Natalie Berger, MA, Katherine Pickard, MA, Nikki Bonter, MSW, & Brooke Ingersoll, Ph.D. Department of Psychology, Michigan State University Supported by grant #RC063462 from the Department of Defense’s Autism Research Program METHOD Participants 27 children between 19 and 73 months and their mothers. ASD diagnoses provided by community providers and confirmed using DSM-IV-TR criteria and ADOS-2. Procedure Assessments of child and parent functioning, and a parent-child interaction were administered at pre-treatment (see Table 1). Children were matched on expressive language age on Mullen and randomly assigned to the self-directed or therapist-assisted group (see Table 2). Parents in both groups received ImPACT Online for up to 6 months (see Table 3). Self-directed group: Parents completed 12 internet modules on their own over the course of 4 months. Therapist-assisted group: Parents completed 12 internet modules plus 2, 30- min remote coaching sessions per week from coach for 12 weeks. Assessments were re-administered at post-treatment. Data Analysis ITT analysis (missing data was carried forwarded) Mixed model, repeated-measures ANOVA to compare the effect of self-directed and therapist-assisted ImPACT Online on parent and child outcomes. CONCLUSIONS Both approaches show promise for increasing parents’ use of evidence-based intervention techniques to promote their child’s social communication. The self-directed program was effective for improving parent fidelity of implementation, parent self-efficacy, parenting stress, and child language. However, therapist assistance via remote coaching provided an added benefit for improving parent fidelity and some aspects of child language. Gains in parent positive perceptions of their child and child social skills were only observed in the therapist-assisted group. A full scale efficacy trial with a control group is warranted. Additional research that can identify parents who are most likely to need remote coaching would assist in the development of a stepped care model that can increase parent access to evidence-based services in underserved communities. Adapted from Project ImPACT (Ingersoll & Dvortcsak, 2010) TABLE 3: ImPACT ONLINE TABLE 2: PARTICIPANT CHARACTERISTICS a Mullen Scales of Early Learning Narrated Slideshow Manual Self-Check Quiz Video-Based Exercises Homework Plan Reflection Questions Video Library Moderated Forum Self-Directed Interactive Modules Remote Coaching RESULTS – CHILD OUTCOMES Main effect of time, F(1, 25)=31.33, p<.01, η p 2 =.56. Both groups improved. Marginal interaction, F(1, 25)=3.38, p=.078, η p 2 =.12. Therapist-assisted group had marginally greater gains than self-directed group. Expressive Language Targets (PCI) Review and Problem-Solving Coaching and Feedback Parent Characteristics Self-Directed (n=13) Therapist-Assisted (n=14) Gender (% Female) 92% 100% Education (% Less than College Degree) 54% 36% Residence (% Rural and/or MUA/P area) 77% 64% Child Characteristics Self-Directed (n=13) Therapist-Assisted (n=14) Gender (% Female) 39% 21% Chronological Age (Months) 46.08 (13.18) 41.57 (12.24) Nonverbal Mental Age a (Months) 25.42 (13.92) 24.29 (9.38) Verbal Mental Age a (Months) 19.15 (9.63) 21.64 (10.74) RESULTS – PARENT OUTCOMES Main effect of time, F(1, 25)=65.78, p<.01, η p 2 =.72. Both groups improved. Interaction, F(1, 25)= 10.76, p<.01, η p 2 =.30. Therapist-assisted group made greater gains than self- directed group. Main effect of time, F(1, 25)= 10.98, p<.01, η p 2 =.31. Both groups improved to similar degree. Parent Self-Efficacy (PSOC) Parent Fidelity (PCI) 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 Pre Post Average Fidelity Rating Self-Directed Therapist-Assisted 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 Pre Post Total Score Self-Directed Therapist-Assisted 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 Pre Post Average Rating Self-Directed Therapist-Assisted Main effect of time, F(1, 25) =6.53, p<.05, η p 2 =.21. Both groups improved to similar degree. Parenting Stress (FIQ) 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 Pre Post Average Rating Self-Directed Therapist-Assisted Main effect of time, F(1, 25)=13.31, p<.01, η p 2 =.35. Interaction, F(1, 25)=8.27, p<.01, η p 2 =.25. Therapist-assisted group made gains, but self-directed group did not. Positive Perceptions of Child (FIQ) 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 Pre Post Rate per minute Self-Directed Therapist-Assisted 0 100 200 300 400 Pre Post Number of Words Produced Self-Directed Main effect of time, F(1, 25) =18.53, p<.01, η p 2 =.43. Both groups improved to a similar degree. 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 Pre Post Standard Score Self-Directed Therapist-Assisted Main effect of time, F(1, 25) =6.10, p<.05, η p 2 =.20. Both groups improved to a similar degree. 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 Pre Post Standard Score Self-Directed Therapist-Assisted Interaction, F(1, 25) =4.97, p<.05, η p 2 =.17. Therapist-assisted group made gains, but self-directed group did not. Expressive Vocabulary (MCDI) Functional Communication (VABS-II) Social Skills (VABS-II)

Kate Shannon - Comparison of a Self-Directed and Therapist-Assisted Telehealth Parent Training Intervention for Children with ASD

  • Upload
    aucd

  • View
    27

  • Download
    5

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

This project is a pilot RCT comparing the benefits of a self-directed and therapist-assisted telehealth parent training program for young children with ASD.

Citation preview

  • TABLE 1: OUTCOME MEASURES Parent Measures

    Parent Fidelity Behavioral rating during parent-child interaction (10-min Play and Snack Routine)

    Parent Self-Efficacy Parent Sense of Competence Scale

    Parenting Stress Family Impact Questionnaire - Negative and Social Impact subscale items

    Positive Perceptions of Child Family Impact Questionnaire - Positive Impact subscale items

    Child Measures

    Expressive Language Targets Frequency of language targets during parent-child interaction

    Expressive Vocabulary MacArthur-Bates Communicative Development Inventory

    Functional Communication Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales-2nd Edition

    (VABS-II) Communication Domain

    Social Skills Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales-2nd Edition

    (VABS-II) Social Domain

    BACKGROUND

    Parent-mediated intervention for children with ASD can improve both parent and child functioning.

    Access to parent-mediated intervention services is often limited in rural and under-resourced areas.

    Telehealth, the provision of health information over the internet, can increase service access at a reduced cost.

    There is growing interest in expanding telehealth to parent training for ASD, but research is limited and little is known regarding the relative benefits of self-directed vs. therapist-assisted models.

    OBJECTIVES

    Pilot RCT to compare the effect of self-directed and therapist-assisted formats of ImPACT Online, telehealth-based parent-mediated intervention on parent and child outcomes.

    Comparison of a Self-Directed and Therapist-Assisted Telehealth Parent Training Intervention for Children with ASD Kate Shannon, MS, Natalie Berger, MA, Katherine Pickard, MA, Nikki Bonter, MSW, & Brooke Ingersoll, Ph.D.

    Department of Psychology, Michigan State University Supported by grant #RC063462 from the Department of Defenses Autism Research Program

    METHOD Participants

    27 children between 19 and 73 months and their mothers. ASD diagnoses provided by community providers and confirmed using DSM-IV-TR

    criteria and ADOS-2. Procedure Assessments of child and parent functioning, and a parent-child interaction were

    administered at pre-treatment (see Table 1). Children were matched on expressive language age on Mullen and randomly

    assigned to the self-directed or therapist-assisted group (see Table 2). Parents in both groups received ImPACT Online for up to 6 months (see Table 3).

    Self-directed group: Parents completed 12 internet modules on their own over the course of 4 months.

    Therapist-assisted group: Parents completed 12 internet modules plus 2, 30-min remote coaching sessions per week from coach for 12 weeks.

    Assessments were re-administered at post-treatment. Data Analysis ITT analysis (missing data was carried forwarded) Mixed model, repeated-measures ANOVA to compare the effect of self-directed

    and therapist-assisted ImPACT Online on parent and child outcomes.

    CONCLUSIONS Both approaches show promise for increasing parents use of evidence-based intervention techniques to promote their childs social communication. The self-directed program was effective for improving parent fidelity of implementation, parent self-efficacy, parenting stress, and child language. However, therapist

    assistance via remote coaching provided an added benefit for improving parent fidelity and some aspects of child language. Gains in parent positive perceptions of their child and child social skills were only observed in the therapist-assisted group. A full scale efficacy trial with a control group is warranted.

    Additional research that can identify parents who are most likely to need remote coaching would assist in the development of a stepped care model that can increase parent access to evidence-based services in underserved communities.

    Adapted from Project ImPACT (Ingersoll & Dvortcsak, 2010)

    TABLE 3: ImPACT ONLINE

    TABLE 2: PARTICIPANT CHARACTERISTICS

    aMullen Scales of Early Learning

    Narrated Slideshow Manual

    Self-Check Quiz Video-Based Exercises

    Homework Plan Reflection Questions

    Video Library Moderated Forum

    Self-Directed Interactive Modules

    Remote Coaching

    RESULTS CHILD OUTCOMES

    Main effect of time, F(1, 25)=31.33, p