77
'H VRFLDOH LPSDFW YDQ JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ 6WDQG YDQ ]DNHQ PHWLQJ PDDUW

JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

'H�VRFLDOH�LPSDFW�YDQ�JDVZLQQLQJ�LQ�*URQLQJHQ

6WDQG�YDQ�]DNHQ��PHWLQJ�PDDUW�����

Page 2: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�KHKBKJ�¾»�FQJE�½»½»�

�J@ANVKAG�R=J�@A��EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ�EJ�O=IAJSANGEJC�IAP��K?E==H��H=J>QNA=Q�NKJEJCAJ�AJ���NKJEJCAJ���EP�KJ@ANVKAG�SKN@P�QEPCARKAN@�EJ�KL@N=?DP�R=J�@A��=PEKJ==H��KmN@EJ=PKN�NKJEJCAJ��

�QPAQNO�

�N���=PDANEJA��PNKA>A���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��NKB��@N���KI��KOPIAO���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��NO�� QOPEJ��E?D=N@OKJ���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��NO���=>AP��=JEO���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��NO���=NHKJ�@A� KJC���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��NO���=NFKHAEJ��KAJ@ANI=GAN���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��NO���EAGA��?DKQPAJO���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ�

�ACAHAE@EJCO?KIIEOOEA�

�N���AH=JEA��=GAI=���AEHECDAE@ONACEK�NKJEJCAJ��N�� =J��KAN��NKJEJCAN�=O>AN==@��NO���NEO��EFGOPN=��AIAAJPA�NKJEJCAJ��NO�� KHE=JJA��AHHAI=JO����NKJEJCAJ��NO��AKNCA��A@AJ@KNL���LAJ>=NA��N@A�AJ��AEHECDAE@��AIAAJPA��AP��KCAH=J@��N���ANI=J�R=J��O���=PEKJ==H��KmN@EJ=PKN�NKJEJCAJ��NKB��@N���K>��AEFAN���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��N���==NPFA��EAL��NKJEJCAN��KNLAJ��S���=NEJ��KCCAJ���NKREJ?EA�NKJEJCAJ��DN�� KQGA��?D==BOI=���EF@AHEFGA��KIIEOOEA��EFJ>KQSO?D=@A�NKJEJCAJ��NO���ANSEJ��?DKNNAJ��NKJEJCAN��K@AI��ASACEJC��NKB��@N���=NEAGA��E?DANO�������� �±� �½»½»�� ��EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ���QPAQNONA?DPAJ�RKKN>ADKQ@AJ���EAPO�QEP�@EP�N=LLKNP�I=C�SKN@AJ�RANRAAHRKQ@EC@�AJ�KB�KLAJ>==N�CAI==GP�@KKN�IE@@AH�R=J�@NQG��BKPKGKLEA��IE?NKBEHI��@ECEP=HA�RANSANGEJC�KB�=J@ANOVEJO��VKJ@AN�RKKN=BC==J@A�

O?DNEBPAHEFGA�PKAOPAIIEJC�R=J�@A��EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��� �

¼�

Page 3: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�KKNSKKN@�

NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�KJ@ANVKAGP�OEJ@O�½»¼Á�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@��RAEHECDAE@O>AHAREJC�AJ�DAP�PKAGKIOPLANOLA?PEAB�R=J�NKJEJCANO���AP�KJ@ANVKAG�SKN@P�QEPCARKAN@�@KKN�@A��EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��EJ�O=IAJSANGEJC�IAP�DAP��K?E==H��H=J>QNA=Q�NKJEJCAJ�AJ�@A���NKJEJCAJ���A��=PEKJ==H��KmN@EJ=PKN�NKJEJCAJ� ��¡�EO�KL@N=?DPCARAN���

�JO�KJ@ANVKAG�>AOPAA@P�==J@=?DP�==J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���EP�@KAJ�SA�RE=�LANEK@EAGA�RN=CAJHEFOPAJ�IAP�DAP�NKJEJCAN��=JAH�R=J�DAP��K?E==H��H=J>QNA=Q�NKJEJCAJ�AJ�RE=�EJPANREASO�IAP�LNKBAOOEKJ=HO�AJ�>ASKJANO���AAN@ANA�GANAJ�LAN�F==N�LQ>HE?ANAJ�SA�KRAN�@A�QEPGKIOPAJ��

�EP�N=LLKNP�>AOLNAAGP�KJ@AN�=J@ANA�@A�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�EJ�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@��NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA��RANPNKQSAJ��CAVKJ@DAE@�AJ�AIKPEAO�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�@EA�OEJ@O�½»¼Á�EJ�KJO�KJ@ANVKAG�?AJPN==H�OP==J���A�N=LLKNPANAJ�AAJ�RAN@EALEJCOKJ@ANVKAG�J==N�@A�OEPQ=PEA�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�NACEK���KG�GKIP�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�?KNKJ=I==PNACAHAJ�GKIP�==J�>K@���AJOHKPPA�>AOLNAGAJ�SA�@A�GKLLAHEJC�R=J�@A�@=P=�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�==J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�AJ�>AOPA@AJ�SA�==J@=?DP�==J�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ�AJ�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���

�EF�@A�QEPRKANEJC�R=J�KJO�KJ@ANVKAG�SANGAJ�SA�IAP�RAAH�L=NPJANO�O=IAJ���A�VEFJ�RAAH�@=JG�RANO?DQH@EC@�==J�KJVA�>ACAHAE@EJCO?KIIEOOEA�>AOP==J@A�QEP�RANPACAJSKKN@ECANO�R=J�@A��=PEKJ==H��KmN@EJ=PKN�NKJEJCAJ��@A��EF@AHEFGA��KIIEOOEA��EFJ>KQSO?D=@A�NKJEJCAJ��NKJEJCAN��KNLAJ��@A�NKJEJCAN��K@AI��ASACEJC��DAP�NKJEJCAN�=O>AN==@��RANPACAJSKKN@ECANO�R=J�CAIAAJPAJ� NKJEJCAJ�AJ��AP��KCAH=J@¡��@A�LNKREJ?EA�NKJEJCAJ��@A��AEHECDAE@ONACEK�NKJEJCAJ��@A���NKJEJCAJ�AJ�PSAA�SAPAJO?D=LLANO���EF�>AS=GAJ�@A�GKANO�AJ�@A�KJ=BD=JGAHEFGDAE@�R=J�DAP�KJ@ANVKAG���A�J=IAJ�R=J�@A�?KIIEOOEAHA@AJ�VEFJ�SAANCACARAJ�EJ�@A�?KHKBKJ���A�@=JGAJ�DAJ�RKKN�DQJ�EJVAP�AJ�>APNKGGAJDAE@���==NJ==OP�C==P�KJVA�@=JG�QEP�J==N�@A�>ASKJANO�EJ�@A�GH=JG>KN@CNKAL�R=J�DAP�KJ@ANVKAG��@EA�IAA@AJGAJ�KRAN�KJ@ANSANLAJ�AJ�RN=CAJ�R=JQEP�DAP�LANOLA?PEAB�R=J�>ASKJANO���

�A�@=JGAJ�@A�L=JAHHA@AJ�R=J�DAP�NKJEJCAN��=JAH�RKKN�DAP�EJRQHHAJ�R=J�@A�RN=CAJHEFOPAJ��VKJ@AN�FQHHEA�EJRAOPANEJC�S=O�@EP�KJ@ANVKAG�JEAP�IKCAHEFG���A�?KmN@EJ=PEA�AJ�DAP�>ADAAN�R=J�DAP�NKJEJCAN��=JAH�EO�EJ�D=J@AJ�R=J�DAP��K?E==H��H=J>QNA=Q�NKJEJCAJ���A�@=JGAJ�AIGA�@A��==J���=JO��HODKB���SKQP�R=J��LEFGAN�AJ��RKJJA��QNAJDKQP�RKKN�@A�CKA@A�O=IAJSANGEJC�@==N>EF���=JQEP�@A��Q�DA>>AJ��KQPAN��@=IO���AHEJA�R=J��AH@AJ�AJ��JJ=��=N>ANO�AAJ�>EF@N=CA�CAHARAN@�==J�DAP�KJ@ANVKAG���

�KKN�@A�PKPOP=J@GKIEJC�R=J�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�DA>>AJ�SA�CAOLNKGAJ�IAP�AAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO=@REOAQN��AAJ�KJ@ANJAIANORANPACAJSKKN@ECAN�AJ�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�

½�

Page 4: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�NACEK���A�@=JGAJ�DAJ�RKKN�@A�S==N@ARKHHA�EJGEFG�@EA�VEF�KJO�C=RAJ�@A�OEPQ=PEA�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�LNKREJ?EA��

�=PDANEJA��PNKA>A�AJ��KI��KOPIAO��J@ANVKAGOHAE@ANO�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�� �

¾�

Page 5: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�JDKQ@OKLC=RA��

�=IAJR=PPEJC��?KJ?HQOEAO�AJ�==J>ARAHEJCAJ� ¿�

¼�� �JHAE@EJC�AJ�IAPDK@A � ¼¼�

½�� �AEHECDAE@�AJ�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA� ¼Á�

¾�� �ANPNKQSAJ� ¼Ä�

¿��� AVKJ@DAE@� ½¿�

À��� �?D=@ANACEOPAN� ½Ã�

Á��� �JRHKA@��KRE@�¼Ä� ¾¾�

Â�� �IKPEAO�AJ�?KLEJC� ¿¿�

Ã�� �=IAJD=JC�AJ�O=IAJSANGEJC� À¼�

Ä�� �J@ANJAIANO� ÀÄ�

�ABANAJPEAO� �

�EFH=CA�¼��N=CAJHEFOPAJ���EFH=CA�½��J=HUOA�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ���EFH=CA�¾��ANJOP=PEOPEAGAJ�LAN�CAIAAJPA�

� �

¿�

Page 6: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�=IAJR=PPEJC��?KJ?HQOEA�AJ�==J>ARAHEJC�

�J�@EP�N=LLKNP�VEFJ�@A�NAOQHP=PAJ�KLCAJKIAJ�R=J�KJVA�IAAOP�NA?AJPA�IAPEJC� I==NP�½»½»¡�AJ�AAJ�==JP=H�>AREJ@EJCAJ�QEP�KJVA�IAPEJC�EJ�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä���K=HO�EJ�AAN@ANA�N=LLKNPAJ�C==J�SA�EJ�KL�AAJ�==JP=H�PANQCGANAJ@A�GANJKJ@ANSANLAJ� RAEHECDAE@�x�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA��RANPNKQSAJ��CAVKJ@DAE@��AIKPEAO¡�AJ�CARAJ�SA�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�KRAN�@A�PEF@�SAAN���

�J�@A�DQE@ECA�RN=CAJHEFOP�VEFJ�AAJ�==JP=H�JEAQSA�KJ@ANSANLAJ�PKACARKAC@��VK=HO�@A�EIL=?P�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä��EO�@EP�AAJ�ATPN=�OPNAOOKN�RKKN�>ASKJANO���KG�KJ@ANVKAGAJ�SA�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�KL�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�KJO�L=JAH���A�GKLLAH@AJ�@A�@=P=�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�==J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN���J�SA�@A@AJ�RAN@EALAJ@�KJ@ANVKAG�J==N�@A�NKH�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�DKA�@EP�RAN>=J@�DKQ@P�IAP�CA@N=C� VK=HO�KJ@ANHEJCA�OKHE@=NEPAEP¡���

�A�KLAJAJ�IAP�AAJ�LQJPOCASEFVA� �O=IAJR=PPEJC�R=J�@A�>AH=JCNEFGOPA�NAOQHP=PAJ���

�AEHECDAE@�AJ�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�

Ɣ �NR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�JAAIP�OEJ@O�@A�H==POPA�IAPEJCAJ�SAAN�PKA�RKKN�=HHA�>ASKJANO���RAJAAJO�JAIAJ�=HHA�>ASKJANO�IEJ@AN�NEOE?K�S==N��

Ɣ �=HEJCAJ�EJ�RAEHECDAE@�AJ�PKAJ=IAO�EJ�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�VEFJ�S==NO?DEFJHEFG�CANAH=PAAN@�==J�DAP�IAAI=GAJ�R=J�OAEOIE?EPAEP��VA�GKIAJ�KRANAAJ�IAP�CNKPANA�==N@>AREJCAJ���

�ANPNKQSAJ�

Ɣ �ANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A��AEHECDAE@ONACEK��>QQNP>ASKJANO�AJ�@A�NKJEJCAN��K@AI��ASACEJC�EO�DAP�DKKCOP���N�EO�IEJ@AN�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����AJ�@A������AP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����EO�DAP�H==COP�� �

Ɣ �KASAH�AN�IEJ@AN�RANPNKQSAJ�EO�EJ�����AJ����@=J�EJ�@A�IAAOPA�=J@ANA�EJOP=JPEAO��VEAJ�SA�SAH�@=P��KRAN�@A�PEF@�DAAJ��DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�����AJ����EO�PKACAJKIAJ���AVA�OPEFCEJC�EO�RKKN�DAP�CNKKPOPA�@AAH�DAP�CARKHC�R=J�AAJ�PKAJ=IA�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ�KJ@AN�>ASKJANO�@EA�NA?AJP�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ���JVA�=J=HUOAO�OQCCANANAJ�@=P�@A�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�VK@=JEC�EO�RAN>APAN@�@=P�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�R=J�>ASKJANO�PKAJAAIP���

Ɣ �AJOAJ�IAP�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�IEJ@AN�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�KRANDA@AJ� CAIAAJPAJ��LNKREJ?EA�AJ��EFGOKRANDAE@¡�I==N�IAAN�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�EJOP=JPEAO�@EA�KLGKIAJ�RKKN�@A�>AH=JCAJ�R=J�NKJEJCANO�IAP�O?D=@A�@KKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJC� NKJEJCAN��K@AI��ASACEJC��NKJEJCAN�=O>AN==@¡��

À�

Page 7: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

AVKJ@DAE@�

Ɣ �EJ@O�½»¼Á�SAN@�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@O=?DPANOP=J@�R=J�>ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�OPAA@O�CNKPAN���==N�ANCAJO�EJ�½»¼Ã�EO�AN�AAJ�GAJPANEJC���=J=B�FQJE�½»¼Ä�EO�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@O=?DPANOP=J@�R=J�>ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�@QE@AHEFG�GHAEJAN��

Ɣ �ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�JKC�OPAA@O�AAJ�IEJ@AN�CKA@A�CAVKJ@DAE@�@=J�>ASKJANO�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���KG�SKN@P�@A�CNKAL�@EA�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�DAABP�PAHGAJO�CNKPAN���==NKI�EO�AN�JKC�OPAA@O�==J@=?DP�JK@EC�RKKN�@AVA�CNKAL��

�IKPEAO��Ɣ �KG�RKKN�AIKPEAO�VEAJ�SA�KRAN�@A�CADAHA�HEJEA�AAJ�HE?DP�LKOEPEARA�KJPSEGGAHEJC��

NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�RKAHAJ�VE?D�DKKLRKHHAN��IEJ@AN�I=?DPAHKKO��ANR=NAJ�IAAN�?KJPNKHA��IEJ@AN�S=JDKKL�AJ�IEJ@AN�>KKODAE@���KASAH�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�AN�JKC�OPAA@O�DAP�IEJOP��CKA@�==J�PKA�VEFJ���EO�@A�RAN>APANEJC�PAJ�KLVE?DPA�R=J�RKNECA�GAAN� FQJE�½»¼Ä¡�DAP�@QE@AHEFGOP�KJ@AN�@AVA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ��

�K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�Ɣ �J�FQHE�½»¼Ä�N=LLKNPAAN@AJ�SA�GANJEJ@E?=PKNAJ�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�KL�>=OEO�

R=J�BK?QOCNKAL�>EFAAJGKIOPAJ���EAN�EO�JQ�AAJ�>APNKQS>=NA�RN=CAJHEFOP�R=J�CAI==GP��

Ɣ �K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�EJ�AAJ�@KNL�>QQNP�EO�CANAH=PAAN@�==J�DAP�JAIAJ�R=J�IAAN�OKHE@=NEPAEP�CAKNEbJPAAN@A�=?PEA�J=�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ� >EFRKKN>AAH@�DAP�>EA@AJ�R=J�AAJ�DAHLAJ@A�D=J@¡��

�A�EIL=?P�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä�

Ɣ �EF@AJO�DAP�=BJAIAJ�R=J�KJVA�RN=CAJHEFOP�SAN@AJ�AN�RANC==J@A��KRE@�¼Ä�I==PNACAHAJ�CAJKIAJ���A�OPAH@AJ�==J�?EN?=�AAJ@AN@A�R=J�KJO�L=JAH�RN=CAJ�KRAN�@A�EIL=?P�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä�EJ�?KI>EJ=PEA�IAP�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG���AH=JCNEFG�DEAN>EF�EO�@=P�@EP�DAP�>ACEJ�R=J�@A�HK?G@KSJ�LANEK@A�S=O��AN�S=O�KL�@=P�IKIAJP�@QO�JKC�CAAJ�OLN=GA�R=J� IKCAHEFGA¡�?DNKJEO?DA�OPNAOO�@KKN��KRE@�¼Ä��

Ɣ �QEI�»Î�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�IAP�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�PA�I=GAJ�DA>>AJ��@AJGP�@=P�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�NKJ@KI��KRE@�¼Ä�PAJ�IEJOPA�AJECA�CARKHCAJ�C==P�DA>>AJ�RKKN�DQJ�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC��

Ɣ �EN?=�À»Î�R=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�PA�I=GAJ�DA>>AJ�IAP�RANOPANGEJC�@AJGP�@=P��KRE@�¼Ä�IKCAHEFG�CARKHCAJ�G=J�DA>>AJ�RKKN�@A�RANOPANGEJC�R=J�DQJ�DQEO�KB�>A@NEFBOL=J@��

Á�

Page 8: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

Ɣ �KNCAJ�KIPNAJP��KRE@�¼Ä�VEFJ�CA=OOK?EAAN@�IAP�AAJ�RANIEJ@AN@�CARKAH�R=J�RAEHECDAE@�KIPNAJP�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�AJ�RANIEJ@AN@A�CAVKJ@DAE@���AVA�EIL=?P�>AOP==P�J==OP�@A�>AOP==J@A�EIL=?P�R=J�O?D=@A�KL�RAEHECDAE@�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@���

Ɣ �EP�>APAGAJP�@=P�AN�RKKN�>ASKJANO�@EA�VAHB�=H�O?D=@A�==J�DQJ�SKJEJC�DA>>AJ��AAJ�ATPN=�OPNAOOKN�EO�>EFCAGKIAJ�@EA�AAJ�EIL=?P�DAABP�KL�DQJ�SAHVEFJ���N�EO�OLN=GA�R=J�AAJ�OP=LAHEJC��S==N>EF�>ASKJANO�IAP�O?D=@A�JQ�JKC�GSAPO>==N@AN�VEFJ�S=JJAAN�VA�VE?D�KKG�VKNCAJ�I=GAJ�KI��KRE@�¼Ä���

ARKHCAJ�C=OSEJJEJC�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�

Ɣ �J@ANJAIANO�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�AAJ�>NAA@�O?=H=�==J�QEP@=CEJCAJ�AJ�LNK>HAIAJ�=HO�CARKHC�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG���==OP�O?D=@A�==J�L=J@AJ�C==P�DAP�KI�NALQP=PEAO?D=@A��RANIEJ@AN@A�GNA@EAPS==N@ECDAE@��RANOHA?DPAN@�EJRAOPANEJCOGHEI==P��KJVAGANDAE@���PEF@RANHEAO��KIVAP@=HEJC�@KKN@=P�>ASKJANO�IEJ@AN�QEPCARAJ��KIVAP@=HEJC�@KKN�PEF@AHEFGA�OHQEPEJC�R=JSACA�RANOPANGEJC����AVA�@ERANOEPAEP�==J�RKNIAJ�R=J�O?D=@A�PAGAJP�@A�?KILHATEPAEP�R=J�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO���

Ɣ �=J�@A�NQEI�¿»»�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�L=JAH�ANR==NP�¿ÀÎ�AJECA�I=PA�R=J�J=@AAH�@KKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���EP�EO�� �IAP�J=IA�DAP�CAR=H�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAP�AAJ�AECAJ�>A@NEFBOL=J@ AJ¡��»Î�R=J�DAJ�ANR==NP�J=@AHAJ���KG�EO�DAP�LAN?AJP=CA�KJ@ANJAIANO�@=P�J=@AHAJ�ANR==NP�DKCAN�J==NI=PA�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@E?DPAN�>EF�DAP�?AJPNQI�R=J�DAP�==N@>AREJCOCA>EA@�VEFJ�CARAOPEC@���

Ɣ �A�CNKKPOPA�J=@AHAJ�@EA�KJ@ANJAIANO�ANR=NAJ�VEFJ��

ż �=OPCKA@CANAH=PAAN@A�KJGKOPAJ� @KKN�O?D=@A¡��� ��?D=@A���KAP�PK?D�KLCAHKOP���=J�JEAP�S=?DPAJ�KL�LNK?A@QNAO���QO�HKOOAJ�SA�DAP�VAHB�KL��

ż �==N@A@=HEJC�� ����==N@A�R=J�CA>KQSAJ�CA@==H@��A>KQSAJ�VEFJ�KKG�JKC�IEFJ�LAJOEKAJ ���

ż �EF@OEJRAOPANEJC�AJ�RANOPKKN@A�>A@NEFBORKANEJC��� ��JKNI�RAAH�PEF@�GSEFP�IAP�KRANHAC��RANC=@ANEJCAJ��=@IEJEOPN=PEARA�H=OP��PEF@�AJ�CAH@�KLHAE@EJC�LANOKJAAH��OPAA@O�RAN=J@ANAJ@A�NACAHCAREJC�AJ�EJOP=JPEAO��H=JCA�S=?DPPEF@AJ�RKKN@=P�AN�EAPO�R=J�@A�CNKJ@�GKIP�VK=HO�>R�RANOPANGEJC�R=J�SKJEJCAJ���

Ɣ �J@ANJAIANO�@EA�AJECA�I=PA�R=J�RKKN@AAH�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�@KKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJC� ¼ÀΡ��VEAJ�=HO�RKKN@AHAJ�KIVAPOPEFCEJC�KB�JEAQSA�EJRAOPANEJCOG=JOAJ��>EFRKKN>AAH@�EJ�RAN>=J@�IAP�RAN@QQNV=IEJC��

Ɣ �AAH�NACAHEJCAJ�RKKN�L=NPE?QHEANAJ�IAP�O?D=@A�VEFJ�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�JEAP�PKAC=JGAHEFG�KB�JEAP�L=OOAJ@���AJ�@AAH�R=J�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�SKN@P�RKHCAJO�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�SEF�OLN=GAJ��SACCAVAP�=HO��NACQHEAN�KJ@ANJAIANONEOE?K��PANSEFH�

�

Page 9: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

@=P�@KKN�DAJ�JEAP�VK�S==NCAJKIAJ�SKN@P���A�RKAHAJ�VE?D�KJRKH@KAJ@A�CAGAJ@�AJ�CAOPAQJ@�EJ�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�@EA�VEF�ANR=NAJ�PAJ�CARKHCA�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���J@ANJAIANO�IAP�AAJ�AECAJ�>A@NEFBOL=J@�ANR=NAJ�@A�IAAOPA�J=@AHAJ���EAN�IKAP�IAP�>APNAGGEJC�PKP�OPAQJI==PNACAHAJ�KKG�==J@=?DP�RKKN�VEFJ��

Ɣ �J@ANJAIANO�DA>>AJ�>ADKABPA�==J�@A�RKHCAJ@A�I==PNACAHAJ��?KILAJO=PEA�R=J�O?D=@A��BEJ=J?EbHA�OPAQJ��>ARKN@ANEJC�R=J�SANGCAHACAJDAE@�AJ�KKG�@A�ANGAJJEJC�R=J�DQJ�LNK>HAIAJ��

�JVE?DPAJ�QEP�@A�GKLLAHEJC�==J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�Ɣ �A�>AH=JCNEFGOPA�>AREJ@EJC�EO�@=P�@A�GKLLAHEJC�==J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�JEAP�VK�

DAAH�RAAH�JEAQSA�EJVE?DPAJ�>EA@P���=P�EO�CKA@�JEAQSO��S=JP�DAP�>ARAOPECP�@=P�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�KRAN�O?D=@A�@EA�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�=H�OEJ@O�F=NAJ�CA>NQEGP�EJ�D==N�N=LLKNPAJ�AAJ�DAAH�>APNKQS>=NA�EJ@E?=PEA�CARAJ�R=J�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�O?D=@ALNK>HAI=PEAG�KL�>ASKJANO��

Ɣ �A�K>FA?PEAB�CANACEOPNAAN@A�O?D=@A� @KKN����������AJ�����OEJ@O�½»¼½¡�GKIP�OPANG�KRANAAJ�IAP�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�R=J�>ASKJANO��ANACEOPNAAN@A�O?D=@A�AJ�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�DA>>AJ�AAJ�RANCAHEFG>=NA�EIL=?P�

Ɣ �ACAJAJ�@EA�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�>EF�����O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ��DA>>AJ�RAAH�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�������EF�>ASKJANO�@EA�``J�AAN@ANA�O?D=@AIAH@EJC�@A@AJ�>EF�����KB�����EO�AN�KKG�AAJ�PKAJ=IA�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ���==N�KJ@AN�>ASKJANO�@EA�IAAN@ANA�GANAJ�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ�>EF�@A�����AJ�DAP������EO�AN�C``J�PKAJ=IA�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ�=HO�VEF�VE?D�>EF�����IAH@AJ���KG�KL�=J@ANA�I=PAJ�HEFGAJ�IAJOAJ�IAP�AAJ�H=JCANA�O?D=@ACAO?DEA@AJEO�IEJ@AN�PA�DANOPAHHAJ� KB�=J@ANOKI��HEFGAJ�VA�JKC�OPAA@O�IAAN�H=OP�PA�ANR=NAJ¡�� �

Ɣ �B�O?D=@A?H=EIO�SAH�KB�JEAP�SKN@AJ�PKACAGAJ@��DAABP�AAJ�GHAEJ�ABBA?P�KL�QEPGKIOPAJ�VK=HO�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@��=HO�O?D=@A�JEAP�SKN@P�PKACAGAJ@��RKAHAJ�>ASKJANO�VE?D�EAPO�IEJ@AN�RAEHEC��

�KJ?HQOEAO�AJ�==J>ARAHEJCAJ�

�A�JEAQSOPA�NAOQHP=PAJ�>AR=PPAJ��HE?DPLQJPAJ���EJ�KJO�RKNECA�N=LLKNP�?KJOP=PAAN@AJ�SA�@=P�@A��GHKKB�EJ�CAVKJ@DAE@ ��RKKN�>ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�EJ�RANCAHEFGEJC�IAP�>ASKJANO�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A��IEJ@AN ��HAAG�PA�SKN@AJ���==N�VKQ�@EA�PNAJ@�@KKNVAPPAJ���AP�=JPSKKN@�EO�RKKN�JQ�F=��RKKN�CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�SKN@P�@A�GHKKB�VAHBO�JKC�IEJ@AN�CNKKP���KG�VEAJ�SA�AAJ�HE?DPA�PKAJ=IA�EJ�LKOEPEARA�AIKPEAO�AJ�EJ�RANPNKQSAJ���EAN>EF�PSAA�� �G=JPPAGAJEJCAJ���¼���A�V=CAJ�KKG�EJ�DAP�RANHA@AJ�BHQ?PQ=PEAO�EJ�CAVKJ@DAE@��DAP�EO�>AH=JCNEFG�KI�EJ�@A�C=PAJ�PA�DKQ@AJ�KB�@A�PNAJ@�EJ�@A�PKAGKIOP�@KKNVAP��½���A�CNKAL�>ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�EO� �EJ�@A�HKKL�@AN�F=NAJ�OPAA@O�CNKPAN�CASKN@AJ���==NIAA�EO�@A�KIR=JC�R=J�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG�R=J�@AVA�CNKAL�EJ�VEFJ�PKP=HEPAEP�KKG�CACNKAE@���QE@AHEFG�IKCA�VEFJ�@=P�>ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�JKC�OPAA@O�==J@=?DP�>ADKARAJ��

�

Page 10: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

��AJ�=J@AN�HE?DPLQJP�EO�@=P� �O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC��RKKN�RAHAJ��>APAN�HEFGP�PA�RANHKLAJ ���SA�VEAJ�AAJ�OPEFCEJC�EJ�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ������IAP�J=IA�@KKN@=P�>ASKJANO�@EA�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�O?D=@A�IAH@AJ�AJ�RKKNDAAJ�CAAJ�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAD=@��RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�����DA>>AJ���AP�C==P�DEAN�@QO�KI�AAJ�CNKAL�@EA�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�EJ�==JN=GEJC�GKIP�IAP�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC���EP�HEFGP�ANKL�PA�SEFVAJ�@=P�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�EJ�EA@AN�CAR=H�RKKN�AAJ�@AAH�R=J�@A�>ASKJANO�>APAN�>ACEJP�PA�RANHKLAJ���A�QEPVKJ@ANEJC�KL�@AVA�PNAJ@�EO�@A�CNKAL�IAJOAJ�@EA�IAAN@ANA�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�@AA@�EJ�DAP�RANHA@AJ��PKAJ�����AJ�����JKC�RAN=JPSKKN@AHEFG�S=NAJ�RKKN�@A�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC���EF�>HEFRAJ�=?DPAN�>EF�@A�LKOEPEARA�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ���KKN�@AVA�CNKAL�EO�ATPN=�==J@=?DP�JK@EC����ACAHEFGANPEF@�H==P�KJO�N=LLKNP�@QE@AHEFG�VEAJ�@=P�AN�>ASKJANO�VEFJ�@EA��GSAPO>==N ��VEFJ��

¼� �=P�VEFJ�@ACAJAJ�@EA�RAAH�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ��I==N�KKG�JKC� �VKNCAJ�DA>>AJ�KRAN��KRE@�¼Ä ���AN�EO�AAJ�OP=LAHEJC�R=J�LNK>HAI=PEAG�RKKN�>ASKJANO�@EA�=H�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�AJ�VE?D�KKG�JKC�VKNCAJ�I=GAJ�KI��KRE@�¼Ä���AP�G=J�@=P��KRE@�¼Ä�@QO�RKKN�OKIIECAJ�@A�AIIAN�@KAP�KRANHKLAJ���EAN>EF�DA>>AJ�SA�DAP�QEP@NQGGAHEFG�KRAN�VKNCAJ�KIPNAJP��KRE@�¼Ä��DAP�DKABP�JEAP�PA�>APAGAJAJ�@=P�EAI=J@�VAHB�@==@SANGAHEFG�EJ�==JN=GEJC�EO�CASAAOP�IAP��KRE@�¼Ä� >EFR��VAHB�VEAG��=J@ANAJ�VEAG¡�� ��AP�EO�>AH=JCNEFG�@=P�EJOP=JPEAO� >EFR��SAHVEFJOSANG��DQEO=NPOAJ¡��KKC�DA>>AJ�RKKN�@AVA�CAGKLLAH@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG���

�½� �EP�@A�=J=HUOAO�R=J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�R=HP�>KRAJ@EAJ�KL�@=P�JEAP�=HHAAJ�DAP�

DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A�AAJ�OPNAOOKN�EO��I==N�KKG�DAP���JEAP�PKAGAJJAJ��R=J�O?D=@A����ASKJANO�==J�SEA�O?D=@A�JEAP�EO�PKACAGAJ@��RKAHAJ�VE?D�IEJ@AN�RAEHEC���J��AAN@AN�KJ@ANVKAG�HEAPAJ�SA�VEAJ�@=P�RAEHECDAE@OCARKAHAJO�IA@A�>AL==H@�SKN@AJ�@KKN�KJVAGANDAE@���=JQEP�@EP�KKCLQJP�EO�PA�>ACNEFLAJ�@=P�@AVA�CNKAL�VE?D�IEJ@AN�RAEHEC�RKAHP��AN�EO�EIIANO�CAAJ�KLHKOOEJC�RKKN�DQJ�LNK>HAIAJ��VA�>HEFRAJ�VEPPAJ�IAP�AAJ�DQEO�IAP�O?D=@A���

�¾� �AAH� �KJ@ANJAIANO ��KJ@ANREJ@AJ�H=OP�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC��¿ÀÎ�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�

CAABP�==J�J=@AHAJ�PA�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�EJ�DQJ�SANG��@KKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���AP�J=IA�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAP�AECAJ�R=OPCKA@�HEFGAJ�R=P>==N�RKKN�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG���QE@AHEFG�SKN@P�KKG�@=P�DAP� �KJP>NAAGP�==J�VKSAH�ANGAJJEJC�R=J�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�@EA�KJ@ANJAIANO�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�=HO�==J�BHATE>AHA�NACAHEJCAJ��KI�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�PA�RANDAHLAJ���A�>ARAHAJ�==J�KI�EJ�@A�PKAGKIOP�IAAN�KKC�PA�DA>>AJ�RKKN�@A�RANO?DAE@AJDAE@�AJ�?KILHATEPAEP�R=J�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�S==N�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAA�PA�I=GAJ�GQJJAJ�GNEFCAJ���AJ�HEFGP�JEAP�EJ�OP==P�KI�KJ@ANJAIANO�AAJ�L=OOAJ@A�NACAHEJC�PA�>EA@AJ�KI@=P�DQJ�OEPQ=PEAO�R==G�RAAH�EJCASEGGAH@AN�VEFJ�@=J�@EA�R=J�SKJEJC>AVEPPANO��I==N�DAP�HEFGP�KJO�GKNPVE?DPEC�KI�@=J�I==N�CAAJ�RKKNVEAJEJCAJ�PA�PNABBAJ�RKKN�@AVA�CNKAL���J@ANJAIANO�VEFJ�?NQ?E==H�RKKN�DAP�RKNICARAJ�R=J�@A�PKAGKIOP�R=J�NKJEJCAJ���

�

Page 11: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�AJOHKPPA�IANGAJ�SA�KL�@=P�KKG�EJ�@EP�N=LLKNP�SAAN�@QE@AHEFG�SKN@P�DKARAAH��LKPAJPEA�AN�VEP�EJ�DAP�>ARKN@ANAJ�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�EJ�@KNLAJ�AJ�>QQNPAJ����A�DA>>AJ�AAJ�I==P�RKKN�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�KJPSEGGAH@�@EA�KKG�@KKN�>AHAE@OI=GANO�CA>NQEGP�VKQ�GQJJAJ�SKN@AJ���K=HO�SA�=H�R=GAN�DA>>AJ�KLCAIANGP�OP==P�@A�O=IAJD=JC�EJ�@KNLAJ�>QQNPAJ�KJ@AN�@NQG�@KKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG��AJ�IAP�J=IA�@A�RANOPANGEJCOKLAN=PEA���==N�KJO�KJ@ANVKAG�H==P�KKG�VEAJ�@=P�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AAJ�OPANG�RAN>=J@�DAABP�IAP�@A�I=PA�S==NEJ�>ASKJANO�LNK=?PEAB�VEFJ�AJ�AAJ�CAV=IAJHEFGA�REOEA�KJPSEGGAHAJ�KL�@A�QEP@=CEJCAJ�EJ�DQJ�>QQNP�KB�@KNL���AP�EO�>AH=JCNEFG�KI�VKRAAH�IKCAHEFG�@A�� �OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�PA�>ARKN@ANAJ�� >EFR��@KKN�>QQNPAJ�J=QSAN�PA�>APNAGGAJ�>EF�@A�RANOPANGEJCOKLAN=PEA��@A�KJPSEGGAHEJC�R=J�PKAGKIOPLH=JJAJ�RKKN�@KNL��>QQNP�KB�LNKREJ?EA��AP?�¡���L�@EP�IKIAJP�EO�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AAJ�EJCASEGGAH@�LNK>HAAI�RKKN�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�EJOP=JPEAO���EA@AN�ANGAJP�@=P�DAP�>AH=JCNEFG�EO���ACAHEFGANPEF@�C==J�RANOPANGEJCOKLAN=PEAO�RAAH=H�CAL==N@�IAP�PKACAJKIAJ�PACAJOPAHHEJCAJ�EJ�>QQNPAJ�S==NQEP�?KJBHE?PAJ�O?DEFJAJ�PA�KJPOP==J����A�CNKPA�QEP@=CEJC�RKKN�@A�GKIAJ@A�LANEK@A�EO�KI�@KNLAJ�AJ�>QQNPAJ�PA�RAN>KQSAJ�VKJ@AN�@A�O=IAJD=JC��EJ�@AVA�@KNLAJ�AJ�>QQNPAJ�PA�RANHEAVAJ��

� �

¼»�

Page 12: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

¼���JHAE@EJC�AJ�IAPDK@AJ�

�J�@EP�N=LLKNP�@KAJ�SA�RANOH=C�R=J�@A�NAOQHP=PAJ�R=J�KJVA�IAAOP�NA?AJPA�IAPEJC� I==NP�½»½»¡�KJ@AN�@A�HA@AJ�R=J�DAP�NKJEJCAN��=JAH���AP�C==P�@==N>EF�KJ@AN�IAAN�KI�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�KL�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB��J=IAHEFG�RAEHECDAE@��NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA��RANPNKQSAJ��CAVKJ@DAE@�AJ�AIKPEAO���==NJ==OP�>AOPA@AJ�SA�EJ�@EP�N=LLKNP�>EFVKJ@ANA�==J@=?DP�==J�@A�OEPQ=PEA�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�CA>EA@��CAVEAJ�@A�OLA?EBEAGA�EIL=?P�@EA�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�GQJJAJ�DA>>AJ���J@ANA�KJ@ANSANLAJ�@EA�==J�>K@�GKIAJ�VEFJ�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�?KNKJ=I==PNACAHAJ�=HO�ATPN=�OPNAOOKN��@A�==JRQHHAJ@A�S==N@A�R=J�@=P=�QEP�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN��?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ�AJ�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���KKN�@EP�H==POPA�PDAI=�O�EO�CA>NQEG�CAI==GP�R=J�>AREJ@EJCAJ�QEP�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä��S==NKRAN�JKC�JEAP�EJ�AAN@ANA�N=LLKNPAJ�EO�CALQ>HE?AAN@�� �

�=JAH�AJ�NAOLKJO�

�KKN�DAP�IKJEPKNAJ�R=J�@A�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�KL�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�AJ�DAP�EJ�G==NP�>NAJCAJ�R=J�@A�OEPQ=PEA�KL�@A�@ERANOA�=J@ANA�PDAI=�O��I=GAJ�SA�CA>NQEG�R=J�DAP�NKJEJCAN��=JAH�R=J�DAP��K?E==H��H=J>QNA=Q�NKJEJCAJ���EP�L=JAH�>AOP==P�QEP�AAJ�NALNAOAJP=PEARA�RANPACAJSKKN@ECEJC�R=J�@A�EJSKJANO�R=J�NKJEJCAJ�R=J�¼Ã�F==N�AJ�KQ@AN�AJ�PAHP�NQEI�Â�»»»�HA@AJ���EPCA>NAE@A�EJBKNI=PEA�KRAN�@A�O=IAJOPAHHEJC�R=J�DAP�NKJEJCAN��=JAH�EO�PA�REJ@AJ�EJ�@A� �RAN=JPSKKN@EJC��R=J�DAP��K?E==H��H=J>QNA=Q�NKJEJCAJ���

�L�@KJ@AN@=C�¼½�I==NP�EO�AAJ�RN=CAJHEFOP�QEPCAOPQQN@�J==N�DAP�L=JAH���KNP�@==NJ=��KL�VKJ@=C�¼Á�I==NP��SAN@AJ�@KKN�@A��A@ANH=J@OA�NACANEJC�EJCNEFLAJ@A�I==PNACAHAJ�==JCAGKJ@EC@�KI�@A�RANOLNAE@EJC�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä�PA�>APAQCAHAJ���A�DA>>AJ�PKAJ�>AOHKPAJ�KI�@A�=H�KLAJOP==J@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�==J�PA�RQHHAJ�IAP�AJGAHA�RN=CAJ�KRAN�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�@AVA�I==PNACAHAJ���AVA�RN=CAJ�VEFJ�KL�RNEF@=C�½»�I==NP�==J�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�PKACARKAC@���AOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�R=J=B�@=P�IKIAJP�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�DA>>AJ�EJCARQH@��DA>>AJ�@QO�KKG�@AVA��KRE@�¼Ä�RN=CAJ�RKKNCAHAC@�CAGNACAJ���A�RN=CAJHEFOP�GKJ�PKP�¼½�=LNEH�SKN@AJ�EJCARQH@���A�NAOLKJO�KL�>AE@A�RANOEAO�R=J�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�EO�KLCAJKIAJ�EJ�P=>AH�¼�¼�� � �

¼¼�

Page 13: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�=>AH�¼�¼����AOLKJO�KL�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�¼½�I==NP�½»½»� �ÓÂ�¾¾Á¡�

� �N=CAJHEFOP�VKJ@AN��KRE@�¼ÄRN=CAJ�

�N=CAJHEFOP�IAP��KRE@�¼ÄRN=CAJ�

�KP==H�

J�� � � ¾�»Ä�

Î�R=J�L=JAH� � � À¼Î�

J� ?KILHAAP ¡�¼ ½�½ÄÁ� ¼�»»Á� ¾�¾»½�

Î�R=J�L=JAH� ¾¼Î� ¼¿Î� ¿ÀÎ�

�=IAJOPAHHEJC�RN=CAJHEFOP��

�EANKJ@AN�C==J�SA�EJ�KL�@A�O=IAJOPAHHEJC�R=J�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�R=J�I==NP�½»½»���KG�>AOLNAGAJ�SA�GKNP�@A�RN=CAJ�QEP�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä��S==NR=J�@A�QEPGKIOPAJ�EJ�@EP�N=LLKNP�==J�@A�KN@A�GKIAJ���AJ�KRANVE?DP�R=J�=HHA�RN=CAJ�EO�KLCAJKIAJ�EJ���EFH=CA�¼���

�N=CAJHEFOP�I==NP�½»½»�

�J�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�R=J�I==NP�½»½»�VEFJ�KI�PA�>ACEJJAJ�AJGAHA�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�==J�@A�KN@A�CAGKIAJ��PA�SAPAJ�RAEHECDAE@��NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA��RANPNKQSAJ��CAVKJ@DAE@�AJ�AIKPEAO���==N>EF�EO�CA>NQEG�CAI==GP�R=J� O?D==H�¡RN=CAJ�@EA�KKG�EJ�AAN@ANA�IAPEJCAJ�VEFJ�CA>NQEGP���L�@EA�I=JEAN�G=J�@A�KJPSEGGAHEJC�EJ�@AVA�R=NE=>AHAJ�SKN@AJ�R=OPCAOPAH@���J�==JRQHHEJC�KL�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�EO�EJ�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�==J@=?DP�>AOPAA@�==J�I=JEAN�S==NKL�IAJOAJ�GQJJAJ�KIC==J�IAP�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC� ?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ¡���ARAJO�EO�EJ�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�AAJ�==JP=H�RN=CAJ�KLCAJKIAJ�OLA?EBEAG�>A@KAH@�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�L=JAH���KI�@==NIAA�VE?DP�PA�GNEFCAJ�KL�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�NACEK���

�K=HO�DEAN>KRAJ�EO�==JCACARAJ�DA>>AJ�SA���KL�DAP�IKIAJP�@=P�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�?EN?=�AAJ�SAAG�KLAJ�OPKJ@���JKC�AJGAHA�RN=CAJ�PKACARKAC@�KRAN�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�NKJ@��KRE@�¼Ä���L�>=OEO�R=J�@A�=JPSKKN@AJ�KL�@AVA�RN=CAJ�DA>>AJ�SA�GQJJAJ�J=C==J�EJ�DKARANNA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�VE?D�RAEHEC�RKAHAJ�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�EJ�DKARANNA�DAP�PEF@AHEFG�OPEHHACCAJ�R=J�@A�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�AJ�@A�RANOPANGEJC�CARKHCAJ�RKKN�DAJ�DAABP���

¼��KIIECA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�OP=NPAJ�IAP�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�I==N�OHQEPAJ�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�RNKACPEF@EC�=B���EAN@KKN�G=J�DAP�VEFJ�@=P�@AVA�IAJOAJ� AAJ�@AAH�R=J¡�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�JEAP�DA>>AJ�EJCARQH@���A� �J�?KILHAAP ��CAABP�DAP�==JP=H�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�==J�@=P�EJ�EA@AN�CAR=H�=HHA�RN=CAJ�KJ@AN�KCAJ�DAABP�CAGNACAJ�AJ�@A�=JPSKKN@AJ�DAABP�RANOPQQN@��

¼½�

Page 14: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�N=CAJ�IAPEJC�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä�

�==OP�@A�=J=HUOAO�R=J�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�R=J�I==NP�½»½»�VEFJ�EJ�@EP�N=LLKNP�PARAJO�AJGAHA�=J=HUOAO�KLCAJKIAJ�R=J�CACARAJO�@EA�VEFJ�RANV=IAH@�EJ�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä��@EA�EJ�AAN@ANA�N=LLKNPAJ�JKC�JEAP�S=NAJ�KLCAJKIAJ���AP�C==P�KI�RN=CAJ�KRAN�OK?E=HA�KICAREJC�AJ�SAAN>==NDAE@���

�J=HUOAIAPDK@AJ�

�S=JPEP=PEARA�=J=HUOAO�

�A�NAOQHP=PAJ�KL�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�AJ�KRANECA�O?D==HRN=CAJ�EJ�@EP�N=LLKNP�VEFJ�CNKPAJ@AAHO�CA>=OAAN@�KL�NACNAOOEA=J=HUOAO��PAJVEF�=J@ANO�RANIAH@���J�@AVA�=J=HUOAO�>ANAGAJAJ�SA�@A�CAIE@@AH@AJ�R=J�@A�@AO>APNABBAJ@A�QEPGKIOPI==P� >EFR��ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@¡��S==N>EF�SA�?KJPNKHANAJ�RKKN�HAABPEF@��CAOH=?DP�AJ�KLHAE@EJCOJERA=Q���

�J�@A�=J=HUOAO�I=GAJ�SA�CA@QNAJ@A�@A�DAHA�HKKLPEF@�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�=H�CA>NQEG�R=J�AAJ�KJ@ANO?DAE@�EJ�CNKALAJ�IAJOAJ�KL�>=OEO�R=J�DAP�==JP=H�GANAJ�VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A� CAAJ�O?D=@A��``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�AJ�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A¡���AVA�I==P�R=J�O?D=@A�SKN@P�EJ�AHGA�IAPEJC�KLJEAQS�QEPCARN==C@��S==N>EF�@A�CNKALAJ�PAHGAJO�KLJEAQS�SKN@AJ�EJCA@AAH@�KL�>=OEO�R=J�@A�IAAOP�NA?AJPA�IAPEJC���EAN@KKN�EO�DAP�IKCAHEFG�@=P�IAJOAJ�SEOOAHAJ�R=J�CNKAL��IAJOAJ�@EA�EJ�AAJ�AAN@ANA�IAPEJC�==JC=RAJ�CAAJ�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ��GQJJAJ�EJ�AAJ�H=PANA�IAPEJC�==JCARAJ�@=P�SAH�PA�DA>>AJ�KI@=P�VEF�EJ�@A�PQOOAJPEF@�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAGNACAJ�KB�DA>>AJ�CA?KJOP=PAAN@���A�CNKALAJ�RAN=J@ANAJ�DEAN@KKN�R=J�O=IAJOPAHHEJC���KP�JQ�PKA�D=@@AJ�@AVA�RAN=J@ANEJCAJ�R=J�O=IAJOPAHHEJC�R=J�@A�CNKALAJ�CAAJ�CARKHCAJ�RKKN�@A�QEPGKIOPAJ��IAJOAJ�I`P�O?D=@A�O?KNAJ�?KJOEOPAJP�H=CAN�KL�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�QEPGKIOPI=PAJ�@=J�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���

�J�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�I==NP�½»½»�VEAJ�SA�A?DPAN�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�@=P�DAP�SEOOAHAJ�R=J�CNKAL�@A�QEPGKIOPAJ�R=J�@A�=J=HUOAO�>AfJRHKA@P��@A�IAJOAJ�@EA�NA?AJP�SEOOAHAJ�R=J�CAAJ�O?D=@A�J==N�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A��VKNCAJ�RKKN�AAJ�KJCA>NQEGAHEFG�L=PNKKJ�EJ�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�IAP�J=IA�@A�������I�@EP�L=PNKKJ�J=@AN�PA�KJ@ANVKAGAJ�VEFJ�AJGAHA�==JRQHHAJ@A�=J=HUOAO�QEPCARKAN@��S==NKRAN�EJ�DAP�DKKB@OPQG�KRAN�RANPNKQSAJ� DKKB@OPQG�¾¡�SKN@P�CAN=LLKNPAAN@���ANCAHEFG>=NA�=J=HUOAO�VEFJ�PARAJO�QEPCARKAN@�RKKN�@A�=J@ANA�R=NE=>AHAJ�@EA�EJ�@EP�N=LLKNP�SKN@AJ�>AOLNKGAJ��KI�J=�PA�C==J�KB�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�SEOOAHAJ�R=J�CNKAL�KKG�@==N�EJRHKA@�DA>>AJ�KL�@A�QEPGKIOPAJ�R=J�@A�HKJCEPQ@EJ=HA�=J=HUOAO���=P�>HEFGP�JEAP�DAP�CAR=H�PA�VEFJ���

�=P=�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�

�J�@EP�N=LLKNP�EO�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�CA>NQEG�CAI==GP�R=J�@=P=�QEP�DAP�NACEOPAN�R=J�@A�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�@EA�>EF�@A������DAP�����AJ�@A�����VEFJ�CA@==J���EP�I==GP�DAP�IKCAHEFG�KI�R=J�@A�EJ�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�CAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�PA�RANCAHEFGAJ�IAP�@A�

¼¾�

Page 15: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

CANACEOPNAAN@A�O?D=@A�EJ�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN��AGAGAJ�EO�EJ�DKARANNA�VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�AJ�@A�EJBKNI=PEA�EJ�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�KRANAAJGKIAJ��EJ�DKARANNA�@AVA�CACARAJO�O=IAJD=JCAJ�IAP�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�AJ�SAHG�R=J�>AE@AJ�@A�>AOPA�EJ@E?=PKN�EO�KI�PA�CA>NQEGAJ�EJ�KJ@ANVKAG��

�J=HUOAO�KLAJ�RN=CAJ�

�A�RN=CAJHEFOP�R=J�I==NP�½»½»�>AR=P�RKKNJ=IAHEFG�CAOHKPAJ�RN=CAJ���EF�AJGAHA�RN=CAJ�KRAN�KJ@ANJAIANO?D=L�AJ��KRE@�¼Ä�GNACAJ�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EJ�AAJ�KLAJ�=JPSKKN@RAH@�@A�CAHACAJDAE@�KI�DQJ�CAGKVAJ�=JPSKKN@AJ�PKA�PA�HE?DPAJ���RAN�KJ@ANJAIANO?D=L�EO�>KRAJ@EAJ�``J�RKHHA@EC�KLAJ�RN==C�KLCAJKIAJ���EF�DAP�=J=HUOANAJ�R=J�@AVA�PKAHE?DPEJCAJ�AJ�@A�=JPSKKN@AJ�KL�@A�KLAJ�RN==C�DA>>AJ�SA�KI�PA�>ACEJJAJ�CAGAGAJ�SAHGA�PDAI=�O�==J�@A�KN@A�GKIAJ�EJ�@A�=JPSKKN@AJ���L�>=OEO�R=J�@AVA�PDAI=�O�EO�AAJ�?K@AANO?DAI=�KLCAOPAH@���ANRKHCAJO�VEFJ�==J�AHG�CACARAJ�=JPSKKN@�``J�KB�IAAN@ANA�?K@AO�PKACAGAJ@��>ADKNAJ@A�>EF�@A�PDAI=�O�@EA�EJ�DAP�=JPSKKN@�CAJKAI@�SKN@AJ���I�ANRKKN�PA�VKNCAJ�@=P�@A�?K@ANEJC�R=J�=JPSKKN@AJ�VKNCRQH@EC�AJ�?KJOEOPAJP�CA>AQNP��VEFJ�@A�?K@AO�QEPCA>NAE@�>AOLNKGAJ�IAP�@A�?K@AQNO�AJ�PKACAHE?DP�IAP�@ERANOA�RKKN>AAH@AJ�R=J�=JPSKKN@AJ�@EA�PKP�@AVA�?K@AO�>ADKNAJ���EF�=JPSKKN@AJ�@EA�JEAP�AAJ@QE@EC�VEFJ��EO�@A�?K@ANEJC�@KKN�PSAA�KJ@ANVKAGANO�>AGAGAJ�AJ�>AKKN@AAH@���

�==GRAN@AHEJC�KJ@ANVKAG�AJ�N=LLKNP=CA�

�N���=PDANEJA��PNKA>A�AJ�LNKB��@N���KI��KOPIAO�R=J�@A�B=?QHPAEP�A@N=CO��AJ��==PO?D=LLEFSAPAJO?D=LLAJ�R=J�@A��EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ� �Q¡�CARAJ�HAE@EJC�==J�DAP�KJ@ANVKAG���==OP�DAJ�I=GAJ�@NO���=>AP��=JEO��@NO�� QOPEJ��E?D=N@OKJ��@NO���=NFKHAEJ��KAJ@ANI=GAN��@NO���=NHKJ�@A� KJC��@NO���EAGA��?DKQPAJO�AJ�@NO���=NEAHHA��KRAJDKBB�AJ�R=JQEP�@A��Q�@AAH�QEP�R=J�DAP�KJ@ANVKAGOPA=I���A�?KmN@EJ=PEA�R=J�DAP�>ASKJANOL=JAH�EO�EJ�D=J@AJ�R=J�DAP��K?E==H��H=J>QNA=Q�NKJEJCAJ��EJ�DAP�>EFVKJ@AN�@N���=JO��HODKB��@NO��AIGA�@A��==J�AJ�@NO���SKQP�R=J��LEFGAN��KJ@AN�HAE@EJC�R=J�@NO���RKJJA��QNAJDKQP��

�A�KJ@ANVKAGANO�VEFJ�RKHHA@EC�KJ=BD=JGAHEFG�EJ�@A�QEPRKANEJC�AJ�@A�N=LLKNP=CA�R=J�DAP�KJ@ANVKAG���HHA�N=LLKNPAJ�VEFJ�KLAJ>==N�AJ�VEFJ�RE=�@A�SA>OEPA��CNKJEJCOLANOLA?PEAB�JH�PKAC=JGAHEFG�RKKN�>ASKJANO�AJ�CAfJPANAOOAAN@AJ��

�AP�KJ@ANVKAG�SKN@P�>ACAHAE@�@KKN�AAJ�>ACAHAE@EJCO?KIIEOOEA�IAP�RANPACAJSKKN@ECANO�R=J�@A��=PEKJ==H��KmN@EJ=PKN�NKJEJCAJ��NKJEJCAN��KNLAJ��@A�NKJEJCAN��K@AI��ASACEJC��DAP�NKJEJCAN�=O>AN==@��CAIAAJPAJ� NKJEJCAJ�AJ��AP��KCAH=J@¡��@A�LNKREJ?EA�NKJEJCAJ��@A��AEHECDAE@ONACEK�NKJEJCAJ��@A���NKJEJCAJ��@A��EF@AHEFGA��KIIEOOEA��EFJ>KQSO?D=@A�NKJEJCAJ�AJ�PSAA�SAPAJO?D=LLANO���EF�>AS=GAJ�@A�GKANO�AJ�KJ=BD=JGAHEFGDAE@�R=J�DAP�KJ@ANVKAG���==NJ==OP�EO�AAJ�GH=JG>KN@CNKAL�R=J�>ASKJANO�>EF�DAP�KJ@ANVKAG�>APNKGGAJ��@EA�IAA@AJGP�KRAN�KJ@ANSANLAJ�AJ�RN=CAJ�R=JQEP�DAP�LANOLA?PEAB�R=J�>ASKJANO��

¼¿�

Page 16: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�AAOSEFVAN�

�J�DKKB@OPQG�½�PKP�AJ�IAP�À�C==J�SA�EJ�KL�@A�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�KL�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB��S==N>EF�=?DPANAAJRKHCAJO�RAEHECDAE@�AJ�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA� DKKB@OPQG�½¡��RANPNKQSAJ� DKKB@OPQG�¾¡�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@� DKKB@OPQG�¿¡==J�@A�KN@A�GKIAJ���A�GANJOP=PEOPEAGAJ�LAN�CAIAAJPA�VEFJ�KLCAJKIAJ�EJ��EFH=CA�¾���J�DKKB@OPQG�À�C==J�SA�EJ�KL�@A�CACARAJO�QEP�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN���ANRKHCAJO�SKN@P�EJ�DKKB@OPQG�Á�==J@=?DP�>AOPAA@�==J�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�?KNKJ=I==PNACAHAJ�=HO�ATPN=�OPAOOKN�AJ�C==J�SA�EJ�DKKB@OPQG�Â�EJ�KL�AIKPEAO�AJ�?KLEJC���J�DKKB@OPQG�Ã�>AO?DNEFRAJ�SA�@A�QEPGKIOPAJ�R=J�@A�RN=CAJ�KRAN�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�O=IAJSANGEJC����A�OEPQ=PEA�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�GKIP�==J�@A�KN@A�EJ�DKKB@OPQG�Ä���

� �

¼À�

Page 17: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

½���AEHECDAE@�AJ�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA��J�AHGA�IAPEJC�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�SKN@P�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHA��ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@��IAACAJKIAJ���AOLKJ@AJPAJ�GKJ@AJ�KL�AAJ�O?D==H�R=J�¼�PKP�À�==JCARAJ�DKA�RAEHEC�VA�VE?D�@A�=BCAHKLAJ�REAN�SAGAJ�DA>>AJ�CARKAH@�EJ�RAN>=J@�IAP�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�KL�@A�LHAG�S==N�VEF�SKJAJ��S==N>EF�AAJ�DKCANA�O?KNA�AAJ�RAEHECAN�CARKAH�==JCAABP��

�AEHECDAE@�ECQQN�½�¼�H==P�RAEHECDAE@O>AHAREJC�CA@QNAJ@A�@A�PEF@�VEAJ�RKKN�@NEA�CNKALAJ�EJSKJANO��IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A�==J�DQJ�SKJEJC��IAJOAJ�IAP�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A��AJ�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A���K=HO�BECQQN�½�¼�H==P�VEAJ��JAAIP�@A�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�OEJ@O�FQJE�½»¼Ä�SAAN�PKA���EP�CAH@P�RKKN�=HHA�@NEA�@A�CNKALAJ�EJSKJANO� CAAJ��AAJI==H��KB�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A¡���LR=HHAJ@�EJ�@A�CN=BEAG�EO�@=P�AN�PAHGAJO�SAAN�@=HEJCAJ�VEFJ�EJ�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@���A�VEAJ�VK�J�@=HEJC�EJ�KGPK>AN�½»¼Á�EJVAPPAJ��I==N�KKG�EJ�KGPK>AN�½»¼Â�AJ�BA>NQ=NE�½»¼Ä�����A�@AJGAJ�@=P�@A�ANR=NEJCAJ�IAP��AJ�DAP�IAAI=GAJ�R=J��==N@>AREJCAJ�@A�@=HEJC�R=J�@A�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�=HO�CARKHC�DAABP���AP�@ENA?PA�RAN>=J@�PQOOAJ�DKCANA�OAEOIE?EPAEP�AJ�AAJ�H=CANA�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�DA>>AJ�SA�EJ�AAN@ANA�N=LLKNPAJ�R=OPCAOPAH@� �PNKA>A�AP�=H���½»¼Ä¡���J�@A�DQE@ECA�CN=BEAG�VEAJ�SA�>EFRKKN>AAH@�@=P�AN�EJ�BA>NQ=NE�½»¼Ä�RKKN�DAP�H==POP�AAJ�@=HEJC�EO�EJ�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@��S==NO?DEFJHEFG�KJ@AN�=J@ANA�RANKKNV==GP�@KKN�@A�>AREJC�R=J��AOPANSEFPSAN@� ½½�IAE�½»¼Ä��I=CJEPQ@A�¾�¿¡���A�RANIKA@AJ�@=J�KKG�@=P�DAP�QEP>HEFRAJ�R=J�>AREJCAJ�IAP�AAJ�@ANCAHEFGA�I=CJEPQ@A�RANGH==NP�S==NKI�SA�SAAN�AAJ�PKAJ=IA�EJ�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�VEAJ��

¼Á�

Page 18: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�½�¼����AN=J@ANEJCAJ�R=J�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�KL�AAJ�O?D==H�R=J�¼�PKP�À�EJ�@A�PEF@��=HO�BQJ?PEA�R=J�DAP�=H�@=J�JEAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H�

�EOE?KLAN?ALPEA�

�J�ECQQN�½�½�H=PAJ�SA�DAP�VEAJ�DKA�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�VE?D�CA@QNAJ@A�@A�PEF@�KJPSEGGAHP�DAABP��QEPCAOLHEPOP�EJ�@A�@NEA�AAN@AN�CAJKAI@A�CNKALAJ� CAAJ��AAJI==H��KB�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A¡���A�DA>>AJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CARN==C@�DKA�CNKKP�VA�@A�G=JO�=?DPAJ�@=P�VEF�EJ�@A�PKAGKIOP�AAJ�==N@>AREJC�IAAI=GAJ��@=P�DQJ�AECAJ@KIIAJ�SKN@AJ�>AO?D=@EC@�=HO�CARKHC�R=J�AAJ�==N@>AREJC�AJ�@=P�VEF�CASKJ@�N=GAJ�=HO�CARKHC�R=J�AAJ�==N@>AREJC���AOLKJ@AJPAJ�GKJ@AJ�KL�AAJ�O?D==H�R=J�¼�PKP�À�==JCARAJ�DKA�DKA�CNKKP�VA�@AVA�G=JOAJ�=?DPAJ��S==N>EF�AAJ�DKCANA�O?KNA�AAJ�CNKPANA�S==NCAJKIAJ�G=JO�==JCAABP���A�@NEA�EPAIO�VEFJ�O=IAJCARKAC@�PKP�AAJ�AJGAHA�I==P�R=J�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA��

ECQQN�½�½�H==P�VEAJ�@=P�@A�DKA�IAAN�O?D=@A�IAJOAJ�DA>>AJ��DKA�DKCAN�VEF�DAP�NEOE?K�=?DPAJ���AP�VK=HO�>EF�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�DAP�CAR=H�EO��HEFGP�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�PKA�PA�JAIAJ�S=JJAAN�AN�AAJ�==N@>AREJC�EO�CASAAOP� >EFR��EJ�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�FQJE�½»¼Ä�J=�@A�

¼Â�

Page 19: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

==N@>AREJC�R=J��AOPANSEFPSAN@�R=J�IAE�½»¼Ä¡���AP�@ENA?PA�RAN>=J@�PQOOAJ�DKCANA�OAEOIE?EPAEP�AJ�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEAO��AJ�DAP�RAN>=J@�PQOOAJ�O?D=@A�AJ�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEAO��DA>>AJ�SA�EJ�AAJ�AAN@AN�N=LLKNP�H=PAJ�VEAJ� �PNKA>A�AP�=H���½»¼Ä¡���A�VEAJ�@=J�KKG�@=P�PQOOAJ�FQJE�½»¼Ä�AJ�FQJE�½»½»��AAJ�LANEK@A�S==NEJ�AAJ�>AREJC�R=J�AAJ�I=CJEPQ@A�NKJ@�@A�DKKCPA�R=J��AOPANSEFPSAN@�JEAP�IAAN�DAABP�LH==POCARKJ@AJ��@A�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�=BJAAIP��

ECQQN�½�½�����AN=J@ANEJCAJ�R=J�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�KL�AAJ�O?D==H�R=J�¼�PKP�À�EJ�@A�PEF@��=HO�BQJ?PEA�R=J�DAP�=H�@=J�JEAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H�

� �

¼Ã�

Page 20: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

¾���ANPNKQSAJ��

�J�@EP�DKKB@OPQG�>AOLNAGAJ�SA�@A�NA?AJPA�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�EJ�RANPNKQSAJ�R=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EJ�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�EJOP=JPEAO�AJ�LANOKJAJ���ANPNKQSAJ�EO�VAO�GAAN�CAIAPAJ�PQOOAJ�FQJE�½»¼Á�AJ�I==NP�½»½»���

�ANPNKQSAJ�EJ�I==NP�½»½»�

ECQQN�¾�¼�PKKJP�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�EJOP=JPEAO�AJ�LANOKJAJ�PEF@AJO�@A�H==POPA�IAPEJC� I==NP�½»½»¡���==N>EF�EO�KJ@ANO?DAE@�CAI==GP�J==N�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A��IAJOAJ�IAP�AJGAHRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�AJ�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A���

ECQQN�¾�¼����ANPNKQSAJ�EJ�LANOKJAJ�AJ�EJOP=JPEAO��I==NP�½»½»�

¼Ä�

Page 21: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�RAN�DAP�CADAAH�CAJKIAJ�CAH@P�@=P�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A��AEHECDAE@ONACEK��>QQNP>ASKJANO�AJ�@A�NKJEJCAJ��K@AI��ASACEJC�DAP�DKKCOP�EO���AP�IEJOPA�RANPNKQSAJ�DA>>AJ�IAJOAJ�EJ�@A������@A�����AJ�@A�������KKN�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�KRANDA@AJ� CAIAAJPAJ��LNKREJ?EA�AJ��EFGOKRANDAE@¡�CAH@P�@=P�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�R=J�IAJOAJ�=BJAAIP�J==NI=PA�VA�IAAN�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ���AP�PACAJKRANCAOPAH@A�CAH@P�RKKN�EJOP=JPEAO�@EA�KLGKIAJ�RKKN�@A�>AH=JCAJ�R=J�NKJEJCANO�IAP�O?D=@A�@KKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJC��DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�NKJEJCAN��K@AI��ASACEJC�AJ�DAP�NKJEJCAN�=O>AN==@�EO�DKCAN�KJ@AN�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�@=J�KJ@AN�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���EF�@A�EJOP=JPEAO�@EA�VE?D�>AVECDKQ@AJ�IAP�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�AJ�RANOPANGEJC��J=IAHEFG�����AJ�����VEAJ�SA�@=P�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�DAP�DKKCOP�EO�KJ@AN�>ASKJANO�IAP�AJGAHRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A���=PAN�EJ�@EP�DKKB@OPQG�VQHHAJ�SA�QEPCA>NAE@AN�OPEHOP==J�>EF�IKCAHEFGA�RANGH=NEJCAJ�DEANRKKN���

�A�KJPSEGGAHEJC�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ�PQOOAJ�½»¼Á�AJ�½»½»�

�J�@A�CN=BEAGAJ�R=J�ECQQN�¾�½�SKN@P�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�R=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EJ�RANO?DEHHAJ@AJ�LANOKJAJ�AJ�EJOP=JPEAO�KL�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�IAAPIKIAJPAJ�PQOOAJ�FQJE�½»¼Á�AJ�I==NP�½»½»�SAANCACARAJ��KKG�DEAN�QEPCAOLHEPOP�J==N�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A�AJ�IAJOAJ�IAP�AJGAHRKQ@ECA�AJ�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A� ��KKN�@A�NAOQHP=PAJ�R=J�@A�½

RANO?DEHHAJ@A�IAPEJCAJ�IAP�AHG==N�PA�RANCAHEFGAJ�G=J�AAJ�>AAH@�SKN@AJ�CACARAJ�R=J�@A�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�EJ�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�HKKL�@AN�PEF@�� �

�==N>EF�?KJOP=PANAJ�SA�KI�PA�>ACEJJAJ�@=P�DAP�DEAN>KRAJ�>AO?DNARAJ�RAN>=J@�PQOOAJ�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J� IAANRKQ@ECA¡�O?D=@A�AJ�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�HKG=HA��NACEKJ=HA�AJ�H=J@AHEFGA�KRANDA@AJ�OP=>EAH�EO�KRAN�@A�PEF@���==NJ==OP�VEAJ�SA��VK=HO�SA�EJ�AAN@ANA�LQ>HE?=PEAO�=H�N=LLKNPANAJ��AAJ� PEF@AHEFGA¡�=BJ=IA�EJ�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�EJOP=JPEAO�@EA�>APNKGGAJ�VEFJ�>EF�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�AJ�RANOPANGEJC� ���AJ����¡�AJ�EJ�@A��EFGOKRANDAE@�KL�DAP�IKIAJP�R=J�@A�==N@>AREJC�R=J��AANEFL� F=JQ=NE�½»¼Ã¡���

�=P�RAN@AN�KLR=HP�EO�@=P�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A��EFGOKRANDAE@�AJ��EJ�IEJ@ANA�I=PA��CAIAAJPAJ�OEJ@O�FQJE�½»¼Ä�EAPO�HEFGP�PA�VEFJ�CAOPACAJ��S==NJAAI>==N�EJ�=HHA�CNKALAJ���

½��KKN�@NEA�EJOP=JPEAO�� �����NKJEJCAN��K@AI��ASACEJC�AJ�NKJEJCAN�=O>AN==@¡�CAH@P�@=P�RANPNKQSAJ�@NEA�GAAN�AAN@AN�EO�CAIAPAJ��J=IAHEFG�EJ�FQJE�½»¼Ã��FQJE�½»¼Ä�AJ�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä��

½»�

Page 22: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�¾�½����AN=J@ANEJCAJ�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�LANOKJAJ�AJ�EJOP=JPEAO�EJ�@A�PEF@��=HO�BQJ?PEA�R=J�DAP�=H�@=J�JEAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H

½¼�

Page 23: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�AP�J=IA�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����H==P�AAJ�KLR=HHAJ@�L=PNKKJ�VEAJ��NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�HEFGAJ�EJ�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�I==NP�½»½»�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�IAAN�RANPNKQSAJ�PA�DA>>AJ�EJ�@A�����@=J�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���AJVAHB@A�KJPSEGGAHEJC�EO�VE?DP>==N�>EF�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����VEF�DAP�@=P�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ�PQOOAJ�RANPNKQSAJ�R=J�IAJOAJ�IAP�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�AJ�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A�DEAN�JEAP�OECJEBE?=JP�EO���

�AVA�KJPSEGGAHEJC�EO�KLR=HHAJ@�KI@=P�SA�EJ�=HHA�=J=HUOAO�KRAN�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�QEPGKIOPI=PAJ�PKP�JQ�PKA�?KJOEOPAJP�REJ@AJ�@=P�IAJOAJ�IAP�O?D=@A�FQEOP�IEJ@AN�RANPNKQSAJ�DA>>AJ�EJ�EJOP=JPEAO�>APNKGGAJ�>EF�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�@=J�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���I�@EP�L=PNKKJ�>APAN�PA�>ACNEFLAJ��DA>>AJ�SA�AJGAHA�==JRQHHAJ@A�=J=HUOAO�QEPCARKAN@���

�=PNKKJ�RKKN�����

�J�@AVA�==JRQHHAJ@A�=J=HUOAO�DA>>AJ�SA�EJCAVKKI@�KL�@A�EJ@AHEJC�EJ�@NEA�O?D=@ACNKALAJ� CAAJ��``J�GAAN��IAANRKQ@EC¡�@EA�SA�CA@QNAJ@A�@A�DAHA�HKKLPEF@�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�=H�CA>NQEGAJ���AVA�CNKALAJ�SKN@AJ�>EF�AHGA�IAPEJC�KLJEAQS�EJCA@AAH@�KL�>=OEO�R=J�VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A���EAN@KKN�EO�DAP�IKCAHEFG�@=P�IAJOAJ�SEOOAHAJ�R=J�CNKAL��IAJOAJ�@EA�EJ�AAJ�AAN@ANA�IAPEJC�==JC=RAJ�CAAJ�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ��GQJJAJ�EJ�AAJ�H=PANA�IAPEJC�==JCARAJ�@=P�SAH�PA�DA>>AJ�KI@=P�VEF�EJ�@A�PQOOAJPEF@�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAGNACAJ�KB�CA?KJOP=PAAN@���A�CNKALAJ�RAN=J@ANAJ�DEAN@KKN�R=J�O=IAJOPAHHEJC���KP�JQ�PKA�D=@@AJ�@AVA�RAN=J@ANEJCAJ�R=J�O=IAJOPAHHEJC�R=J�@A�CNKALAJ�CAAJ�CARKHCAJ�RKKN�@A�QEPGKIOPAJ��IAJOAJ�I`P�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�?KJOEOPAJP�IEJ@AN�RANPNKQSAJ�@=J�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���

�J�DAP�CAR=H�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�����VEAJ�SA�>EF�@A�H==POPA�IAPEJC�A?DPAN�S`H�AAJ�@QE@AHEFGA�=BSEFGEJC���JVA�RAN@EALAJ@A�=J=HUOAO�H=PAJ�VEAJ�@=P�@A�CNKAL�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�EJ�FQJE�½»¼Ä�==JC=RAJ�CAAJ�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ��I==N�@A�H==POPA�IAPEJC�==JCARAJ�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ��AAJ�>KRAJCAIE@@AH@�RANPNKQSAJ�D=@@AJ�AJ�DA>>AJ�EJ�������AP�HEFGP�AN�@QO�KL�@=P�@AVA�IAJOAJ�R=J�CNKAL�VEFJ�CASEOOAH@��I==N�@=P�@AVA�SEOOAHEJC�JEAP�DAABP�CAHAE@�PKP�IEJ@AN�RANPNKQSAJ���EF�PNAGGAJ�DAP�CAIE@@AH@A�RANPNKQSAJ�R=J�@A�CNKAL�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�KIDKKC��NAOQHPANAJ@�EJ�DAP�KJCA>NQEGAHEFGA�L=PNKKJ���AJVAHB@A�KJPSEGGAHEJC�VEAJ�SA�>EF�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����VEF�DAP�EJ�RAAH�HE?DPANA�I=PA��

�A�NA@AJ�@=P�@AVA�SEOOAHAJ@A�CNKAL�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�=J@ANO�NA=CAANP�@=J�SA�AAN@AN�V=CAJ�>EF�@A�CNKAL�IAP�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A��EO�JEAP�IAP�VAGANDAE@�R=OP�PA�OPAHHAJ���AH�SEFVAJ�@A�NAOQHP=PAJ�ANKL�@=P�DAP�C==P�KI�IAJOAJ�@EA�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CA?KJOP=PAAN@�AJ�@EP�IAH@AJ�>EF�������N�EO�AAJ�==JP=H�NA@AJAJ�@AJG>==N�RKKN�@EP�ABBA?P��DAP�VKQ�GQJJAJ�@=P�@EP�DQJ�AJECA�AJ�AANOPA�?KJP=?PIKIAJP�IAP�AAJ�EJOP=JPEA�RKKN�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�EO�AJ�@=P�@EP�?KJP=?P�CKA@�EO�RANHKLAJ���KCAHEFG�EO�KKG�@=P�DQJ�RANPNKQSAJ�JKC�OPAA@O�DAP�IAAOP�SKN@P�EJCACARAJ�@KKN�@A�LANEK@A�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���N�

½½�

Page 24: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

VEFJ�CAAJ�==JSEFVEJCAJ�@=P�DAP�RANDKKC@A�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����G=J�SKN@AJ�RANGH==N@�@KKN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�R=J�@A�OPQSIAANNACAHEJC�CA>NQEG�DA>>AJ�CAI==GP�� �

�A�DEAN>KRAJ�>AO?DNARAJ�QEPGKIOPAJ�R=J�@A�==JRQHHAJ@A�=J=HUOAO�SKN@AJ�EJ�ECQQN�¾�¾�CAREOQ=HEOAAN@���A�BECQQN�PKKJP�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A������S==N>EF�OQ>CNKALAJ�SKN@AJ�KJ@ANO?DAE@AJ�KL�>=OEO�R=J��DAHAI==H�CAAJ�O?D=@A��PA�DA>>AJ���=H@KKN�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A��PA�DA>>AJ���=H@KKN�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A��PA�DA>>AJ�KB��RKKN�DAP�AANOP�O?D=@A��PA�DA>>AJ�CA@QNAJ@A�@A�LANEK@A�FQJE�½»¼Ä���I==NP�½»½»���==N>EF�EO�@QE@AHEFG�VE?DP>==N�@=P�@A�CNKAL�IAJOAJ�@EA�EJ�I==NP�½»½»�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�O?D=@A�N=LLKNPANAJ��RAAH�RANPNKQSAJ�DAABP�EJ�@A�������

�==NJ==OP�>HEFGP�QEP�@A�BECQQN�@=P�@A�CNKAL�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�>EF�@A�IAPEJC�EJ�FQJE�½»¼Ä�`J�>EF�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�I==NP�½»½»�==JC=B�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ��?KJOEOPAJP�DAP�H==COP�O?KNAJ�KL�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�������=JJAAN�SA�AAJVAHB@A�==JRQHHAJ@A�=J=HUOA�QEPRKANAJ�KL�=J@ANA�QEPGKIOPI=PAJ��NALHE?AANP�@EP�NAOQHP==P���AVA�?KJ?HQOEA�OPNKKGP�IAP�S=P�SA�EJ�AAN@ANA�N=LLKNPAJ�?KJOP=PAAN@AJ��IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A��IAP�J=IA�=HO�VA�=H�H=JCA�PEF@�EJ�==JN=GEJC�VEFJ�IAP�O?D=@A�PN=FA?PAJ��VEFJ�OPAAR=OP�DAP�OHA?DPOPA�=B�AJ�O?KNAJ�OECJEBE?=JP��OHA?DPAN��KL�=HHANHAE�QEPGKIOPI=PAJ�� �

ECQQN�¾�¾ ����ANPNKQSAJ�EJ������QEPCAOLHEPOP�J==N�OQ>CNKALAJ�R=J�O?D=@A� �

½¾�

Page 25: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

¿��AVKJ@DAE@���EJ@O�@A�OP=NP�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�IAPAJ�SA�@A�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�EJ�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@�R=J�NKJEJCANO�==J�@A�D=J@�R=J�@NEA�CAVKJ@DAE@OI=PAJ��J=IAHEFG�CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@��OPNAOOCANAH=PAAN@A�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�AJ�ANR=NAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@� ��A�¾

NAOQHP=PAJ�R=J�@A�IAPEJC�EJ�I==NP�½»½»�SKN@AJ�DEAN�SAANCACARAJ�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP�@A�AAN@ANA�IAPEJCAJ���RAN�@A�PEF@�VEAJ�SA�OPAA@O�DAPVAHB@A�L=PNKKJ��IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�O?KNAJ�KL�@A�@NEA�I=PAJ�KL�RNEFSAH�=HHA�IAAPIKIAJPAJ�OECJEBE?=JP�H=CAN�@=J�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���A�HEAPAJ�A?DPAN�EJ�KJO�RKNECA�N=LLKNP�KKG�VEAJ�@=P�>EF�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�FQJE�½»¼Ä�DAP�RANO?DEH�PQOOAJ�@A�CNKALAJ�EAPO�HAAG�=B�PA�JAIAJ���AVA�=BJ=IA�VAP�EJ�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�I==NP�½»½»�CA@AAHPAHEFG�@KKN��>ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�OP==J�EAPO�IEJ@AN�KL�=?DPANOP=J@���A�VEAJ�IAP�J=IA�AAJ�OECJEBE?=JPA�RAN>APANEJC�R=J�CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�KJ@AN�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�PAJ�KLVE?DPA�R=J�@A�IAPEJC�EJ�FQJE�½»¼Ä���A�CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@OO?KNAO�R=J�@A�CNKALAJ�HECCAJ�OPAA@O�@E?DPAN�>EF�AHG==N���AVA�RAN>APANEJC�VEAJ�SA�EJ�IEJ@ANA�I=PA�KKG�>EF�ANR=NAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ���

�NR=NAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�

ECQQN�¿�¼�H==P�VEAJ�DKA�@A�ANR=NAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�R=J�IAJOAJ�IAP�AJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A�VE?D�KJPSEGGAHP��A@QNAJ@A�½»¼Á�AJ�½»¼Â�C=B�AAJ�OPAA@O�CNKPAN�@AAH�R=J�@A�CNKAL�>ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�==J�VE?D�JEAP�CAVKJ@�PA�RKAHAJ���A�CAVKJ@DAE@�R=J�@EA�CNKAL�CEJC�@QO�=?DPANQEP���EA�PNAJ@�EO�KICA>KCAJ��DAP�C==P�OPAA@O�EAPO�>APAN�IAP�@AVA�CNKAL���AH=JCNEFGA�G=JPPAGAJEJC�EO�A?DPAN�@=P�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�JKC�OPAA@O�OECJEBE?=JP�KJCAVKJ@AN�VEFJ�@=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���EP�RANO?DEH�EO�JKC�OPAA@O�BKNO���

�=J�>AH=JC�EO�RAN@AN�@=P�SA�CKA@�DA>>AJ�CAGAGAJ�J==N�@A�KKNV=GAJ�R=J�@AVA�RAN>APANEJC�EJ�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@OPKAOP=J@�R=J�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A���KQ�DAP�GQJJAJ�GKIAJ�@KKN@=P�@A�CNKALAJ�IAP�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�AJ�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�@AAHO�>AOP==P�QEP�@A�IAAN�PARNA@AJ��EJOPNKIANO��@EA�PEF@AJO�@A�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�@KKN�@A�����AAJ�IAAN�LKOEPEARA�ANR=NEJC�D=@@AJ���BC==J@�KL�@A�NAOQHP=PAJ�R=J�DKKB@OPQG�¾�KRAN�RANPNKQSAJ��HEFGP�DAP�HKCEO?D�@=P�VEF�IEJ@AN�OPNAOO�ANR=NAJ�AJ�VE?D�CAVKJ@AN�RKAHAJ�@=J�@A�CNKAL�@EA�=H�H=JCA�PEF@�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�G=ILP���JVA�=J=HUOAO�H=PAJ�@EP�L=PNKKJ�A?DPAN�JEAP�VEAJ���A�CNKAL�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�>AOP==P�EJ�KRANCNKPA�IAAN@ANDAE@�QEP�IAJOAJ�@EA�EJ�AAJ�RAN@AN�RANHA@AJ�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAHA@AJ���@A�CNKAL��EJOPNKIANO��EO�NAH=PEAB�GHAEJ���A�?KJ?HQOEA�EO�@=J�KKG�@=P�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@�KKG�>EF�@AVA�

¾�AAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�EO�CAIAPAJ�@�I�R��@A�����À�KL�AAJ�O?D==H�R=J�»�PKP�¼»»��S==N>EF�AAJ�DKCANA�O?KNA�@QE@P�KL�AAJ�>APANA�CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@���A�OPNAOOCANAH=PAAN@A�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�@EA�DEAN�VEFJ�SAANCACARAJ�VEFJ�D=NPGHKLLEJCAJ��@QEVAHECDAE@�KB�HE?DP�EJ�DAP�DKKB@��LNEGGAH>==N�KB�ENNEP=PEA�AJ�IKADAE@���?KNAO�KL�@AVA�I==P�R=NEbNAJ�R=J�¿� JKKEP�H=OP�R=J�@AVA�GH=?DPAJ¡�PKP�½¿� =HPEF@�H=OP�R=J�=HHA�GH=?DPAJ¡���NR=NAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�EO�CAIAPAJ�KL�AAJ�O?D==H�R=J�¼� VAAN�OHA?DP¡�PKP�À� VAAN�CKA@¡���EA�KKG��PNKA>A�AP�=H��� ½»¼Ä¡���

½¿�

Page 26: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

CNKAL�@EA�=H�H=JCAN�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�DAABP�EO�RAN>APAN@���==N>EF�IANGAJ�SA�KRANECAJO�KL��@A�CNKAL�DAABP�JKC�OPAA@O�AAJ�OECJEBE?=JP�OHA?DPANA�CAVKJ@DAE@��

ECQQN�¿�¼����NR=NAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�=HO�BQJ?PEA�R=J�PEF@�AJ�DAP�=H�@=J�JEAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H

AAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�

ECQQN�¿�½�H==P�VEAJ�DKA�@A�CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�R=J�IAJOAJ�IAP�AJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A�VE?D�KJPSEGGAHP���AP�L=PNKKJ�EO�RANCAHEFG>==N�IAP�@=P�R=J�ANR=NAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@��IAP�``J�RANO?DEH��CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�GAJP�AAJ�EAPO�CNEHHECAN�RANHKKL���EA�CNEHHECDAE@��VK�HEAPAJ�SA�EJ�AAN@ANA�N=LLKNPAJ�VEAJ��EO�JEAP�IAP�CNKPA�VAGANDAE@�PA�RANGH=NAJ��I==N�VA�HEFGP�PA�I=GAJ�PA�DA>>AJ�IAP�@A�==J@=?DP�@EA�AN�EO�RKKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG��EJ�LANEK@AO�@=P�DAP�KJ@ANSANL�RANKJ=?DPV==I@�HEFGP�PA�SKN@AJ��EO�AN�>EFRKKN>AAH@�IAAN�>KKODAE@�AJ�I=?DPAHKKODAE@� VEA�DKKB@OPQG�¡���EP�SANGP�IKCAHEFG�@KKN�KL�@A�CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�� �

½À�

Page 27: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�¿�½���AAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�=HO�BQJ?PEA�R=J�PEF@�AJ�DAP�=H�@=J�JEAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H

AVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�

ECQQN�¿�¾�H==P�VEAJ�DKA�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ� @EA�OPNAOOCANAH=PAAN@�GQJJAJ�VEFJ¡�VE?D�KJPSEGGAHAJ���KG�DEAN�VEAJ�SA�@=P�@A�GH=?DPAJ�EJ�@A�H==POPA�IAPEJC�OPANG�=BJAIAJ���AP�EO�KJ@QE@AHEFG�S==N�@AVA�RANO?DQEREJC�==J�EO�PKA�PA�O?DNEFRAJ���AP�HEFGP�KJS==NO?DEFJHEFG�@=P�DAAH�NKJEJCAJ�KLAAJO�HE?D=IAHEFG�CAVKJ@AN�EO�CASKN@AJ� SA�VEAJ�>EF�@A�=J@ANA�CAVKJ@DAE@OIAPEJCAJ�@=J�KKG�CAAJ�OQ>OP=JPEbHA�RAN>APANEJC�R=J�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@�EJ�@A�CNKAL�@EA�CAAJ�O?D=@A�DAABP¡�AJ�DAP�EO�>AH=JCNEFG�KI�PA�>AJ=@NQGGAJ�@=P�@A�RN=CAJHEFOPAJ�@KKN�DAPVAHB@A�L=JAH�SKN@AJ�>A=JPSKKN@��@AVAHB@A�LANOKJAJ�DA>>AJ�@QO�EAPO�IEJ@AN�GH=?DPAJ���=P�OQCCANAANP�@=P�DAP�KI�AAJ�EJ?E@AJPAHA�BHQ?PQ=PEA�G=J�C==J���KIIECA�GH=?DPAJ�GQJJAJ�>EFRKKN>AAH@�OAEVKAJOCA>KJ@AJ�VEFJ���==N�SAHHE?DP�OLAAHP�KKG�@A�J=@ANAJ@A�?KNKJ=?NEOEO�AAJ�NKH�>EF�@A�S==N@ANEJC�@EA�IAJ�CAABP�==J�@A�AECAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ���A�RN=CAJHEFOP�SAN@�=BCAJKIAJ�EJ�I==NP�½»½»�AJ�@EP�S=O�@A�LANEK@A�@=P�@A�L=J@AIEA�@EA�VE?D�SANAH@SEF@�RANOLNAE@@A��@=P�EJ��P=HEb�VAAN�RAAH�IAJOAJ�VEAG�SAN@AJ�AJ�KRANHA@AJ�AJ�@=P�@A�L=J@AIEA�KKG�EJ�AECAJ�H=J@�OH=?DPKBBANO�>ACKJ�PA�I=GAJ���EP�S=O�jjG�AAJ�LANEK@A�@=P�IAJOAJ�DQJ�>AVKAG�==J�DQEO=NPOAJ�KLO?DKNPPAJ��SAHHE?DP�@=P�IAJ�AECAJ� HE?DPANA¡�GH=?DPAJ�NAH=PERAANP�EJ�RANCAHEFGEJC�IAP�@A�VAAN�ANJOPECA�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä�L=PEbJPAJ�@EA�RKHKL�EJ�DAP�JEAQSO�S=NAJ��

½Á�

Page 28: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�==N�@=P�EO�=HHAI==H�OLA?QH=PEA��DAP�AJECA�@=P�VAGAN�EO��EO�@=P�IAJ�EAPO�IEJ@AN�GH=?DPAJ�N=LLKNPAANP��

�J@=JGO�@A�@=HEJC�EJ�@A�DAHA�LKLQH=PEA�VEFJ�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ�PQOOAJ�@A�CNKALAJ�IAP�AJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A�NAH=PEAB�OP=>EAH���KG�R=HP�KL�@=P�@A�CNKAL�IAP�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�OECJEBE?=JP�IAAN�GH=?DPAJ�DAABP�@=J�@A�CNKAL�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���AVA�CNKAL�IAJOAJ�C==P�AN�@A�H==POPA�IAPEJCAJ�OECJEBE?=JP�KL�=?DPANQEP�PAJ�KLVE?DPA�R=J�@A�CNKAL�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���=P�EO�NAHAR=JP�RKKN�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�O?D=@ALNK>HAI=PEAG�KL�@A�RKHGOCAVKJ@DAE@��S=JP�DAP�==JP=H�LANOKJAJ�@=P�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�DAABP��EO�EJ�=>OKHQPA�VEJ�CNKKP���AP�EO�KKG�KLR=HHAJ@��S=JP�DAP�H==P�VEAJ�@=P�@A�LKOEPEARA�ABBA?PAJ�@EA�SA�EJ�@AVA�CNKAL�VEAJ�S=P�>APNABP�DAP�PKAJAIAJ@�RANPNKQSAJ�CAL==N@�>HEFGP�PA�C==J�IAP�AAJ�HE?DPA�PKAJ=IA�R=J�@A�OPNAOOCANAH=PAAN@A�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ���=P�HEFGP�L=N=@KT==H�I==N�SA�>AJ=@NQGGAJ�@=P�DAP�ABBA?P�JEAP�@KKN�@AVAHB@A�LANOKJAJ�RANKKNV==GP�DKABP�PA�SKN@AJ���AJ�@AAH�G=J�LKOEPEARA�ANR=NEJCAJ�DA>>AJ�AJ�@==N�RANPNKQSAJ�==J�KJPHAJAJ��AAJ�=J@AN�@AAH�G=J� >EFRKKN>AAH@�@KKN�?KILHATANA�O?D=@A�KB�H=JCA�S=?DPPEF@¡�OPNAOO�ANR=NAJ�� �

ECQQN�¿�¾���AVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�=HO�BQJ?PEA�R=J�PEF@�AJ�DAP�=H�@=J�JEAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H

� �

½Â�

Page 29: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

À���?D=@ANACEOPAN��J�KJVA�=J=HUOAO�I=GAJ�SA�IAAOP=H�CA>NQEG�R=J�@KKN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ� �VAHB�CAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A����EP�DAABP�AAJ�OPANG�RAN>=J@�IAP�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ���AHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�D=JCP�OPANG�O=IAJ�IAP�NEOE?K�AJ�ANR=NAJ�KJRAEHECDAE@��DAP�RANGH==NP�I==N�HEABOP�¾ÂÎ�AJ�¼ÂÎ�R=J�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ�PQOOAJ�LANOKJAJ� S=P�RKKN�RN=CAJHEFOPKJ@ANVKAG�>EFVKJ@AN�RAAH�EO¡���?D=@A�RANGH==NP�KKG�½�¾Î�R=J�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ�PQOOAJ�LANOKJAJ�EJ�@A�I=PA�S==NEJ�VA�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�ANR=NAJ�@EA�CANAH=PAAN@�GQJJAJ�VEFJ�==J�OPNAOO��VK=HO�OH=LAHKKODAE@�KB�D=NPGHKLLEJCAJ���=P�EO�RANDKQ@EJCOCASEFO�SAHEOS==N�RAAH�IEJ@AN�@=J�RKKN�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�AJ�RAEHECDAE@��I==N�CAVEAJ�@A�RAHA�B=?PKNAJ�@EA��CAVKJ@DAE@OQEPGKIOPAJ�GQJJAJ�>AfJRHKA@AJ�PK?D�AAJ�BKNO�ABBA?P���AP�EO�>EFRKKN>AAH@�CNKPAN�@=J�@A�EJRHKA@�R=J�>AGAJ@A�B=?PKNAJ�VK=HO�KLHAE@EJCOJERA=Q��CAOH=?DP�AJ�HAABPEF@��

�AP�EO�@=J�KKG�R=J�>AH=JC�KI�PA�SAPAJ�EJ�DKARANNA�@AVA�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�>APNKQS>==N�VEFJ���AP�VKQ�GQJJAJ�VEFJ�@=P�@A��K>FA?PEARA��CACARAJO�QEP�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN� JEAP�=HHAAJ�KRAN�DAP�IAH@AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��I==N�KKG�KRAN�@A�PKAGAJJEJC�ANR=J¡�RAAH�>APNKQS>==N@AN�VEFJ���==NKRAN�C==P�@EP�DKKB@OPQG���

�KKN�DAP�N=LLKNP�� ��KKN�O?D=@A�SEFVAN��DAP�LNK?AO�R=J�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�AJ�D==N�CAO?DEA@AJEO�� ��KOPIAO�AP�=H���½»½»¡��DAABP�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�>AO?DEGGEJC�CAGNACAJ�KRAN�DAP�NACEOPAN�R=J�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�@EA�>EF�@A������DAP�����AJ�@A�����VEFJ�CA@==J���EP�I==GP�DAP�IKCAHEFG�KI�R=J�@A�EJ�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�CAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�PA�RANCAHEFGAJ�IAP�@A�CANACEOPNAAN@A�O?D=@A�EJ�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN���J�@A�=J=HUOAO�EJ�@EP�DKKB@OPQG�OP==P�@A�RN==C�?AJPN==H�EJ�DKARANNA�VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�AJ�@A�EJBKNI=PEA�EJ�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�KRANAAJ�GKIAJ��EJ�DKARANNA�@AVA�CACARAJO�O=IAJD=JCAJ�IAP�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�AJ�SAHG�R=J�>AE@AJ�@A�>AOPA�EJ@E?=PKN�EO�KI�PA�CA>NQEGAJ�EJ�KJ@ANVKAG��

AN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�RANOQO�CANACEOPNAAN@A�O?D=@A�

�J�@A�=J=HUOAO�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�SKN@P�CA>NQEG�CAI==GP�R=J�VAHB�CAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A��==J�@A�D=J@�R=J�DAP�=JPSKKN@�KL�@A�RN==C����KA�R==G�DAABP�Q�O?D=@A�@KKN�C=OSEJJEJC�CAD=@�����AP�=JPSKKN@�KL�@AVA�RN==C�EO�QEPAN==N@�CAAJ�K>FA?PEARA�R=OPOPAHHEJC�R=J�@A�@==@SANGAHEFGA�DKARAAHDAE@�O?D=@A�@EA�EAI=J@�DAABP�AJ�EO�KJ@ANDAREC�==J�EJPANLNAP=PEA�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJP���AJ�VKQ�>EFRKKN>AAH@�RANS=?DPAJ�@=P�DAP�==JP=H�O?D=@AO�@=P�AAJ�NAOLKJ@AJP�N=LLKNPAANP�CAHEFG�>HEFBP�KB�PKAJAAIP�IAP�@A�PEF@���KKN�@A�IAAOPA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EO�@=P�KKG�VK���==N�>EF�AAJ�GHAEJA�CNKAL�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�HEFGP�@A�O?D=@A�FQEOP�=B�PA�JAIAJ��S==N�VA�EJ�AAN@ANA�RN=CAJHEFOPAJ�VACCAJ�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ��CARAJ�VA�EJ�H=PANA�RN=CAJHEFOPAJ�==J�CAAJ�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ�KB�IEJ@AN�@=J�VA�AAN@AN�==JC=RAJ���=P�SEFOP�IKCAHEFG�KL�DAP�>AOP==J�R=J��NQEO��EJ�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO��I==N�G=J�KKG�@QE@AJ�KL�RAN=J@ANAJ@A�EJPANLNAP=PEAO�R=J�S=P�SAH�AJ�JEAP�

½Ã�

Page 30: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

==N@>AREJCOO?D=@A�EO� >EFRKKN>AAH@�KL�>=OEO�R=J�DAP�KKN@AAH�R=J�AAJ�ATLANP¡���AP�H=OPECA�R=J�@EP�OKKNP�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�EO��DAP�>HEFBP�CEOOAJ�DKA�>APNKQS>==N�VA�VEFJ���

�KKN�@A�RN=CAJHEFOPAJ�PA�GKLLAHAJ�==J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�DA>>AJ�SA�A?DPAN�AAJ�QJEAGA�G=JO�KI�@A�>APNKQS>==NDAE@�R=J�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�PA�PKAPOAJ���EANRKKN�DA>>AJ�SA�KI�PA�>ACEJJAJ�DAP�==JP=H�O?D=@AO�@=P�@KKN�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EO�CAN=LLKNPAAN@��RANCAHAGAJ�IAP�DAP�==JP=H�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�@=P�@KKN�@A�F=NAJ�DAAJ�>EF�@AVA�EJOP=JPEAO�EO�CA@==J���==N>EF�EO�DAP�KRANECAJO�CKA@�KI�ANKL�PA�SEFVAJ�@=P�KKG�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�JEAP�VKJ@AN�NQEO�EO���K�OP==P�EJ�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�=HHAAJ�@A�O?D=@A�@EA�SKN@P�CAIAH@���KJCARAAN�AAJ�GS=NP�R=J�@A�>ASKJANO�IAH@P�O?D=@A�JEAP���KG�EO�O?D=@A�RKKN�@A�>AREJC�R=J��QEVEJCA� =QCQOPQO�½»¼½¡�KJRKHHA@EC�CANACEOPNAAN@���J�DKASAH�SA�AN�R=JQEP�C==J�@=P�@A�IAAOPA�IAH@EJCAJ�OEJ@O@EAJ�CKA@�VEFJ�CANACEOPNAAN@��SAAO�AAN@AN�KJ@ANVKAG�QEP�@=P�@=P�JEAP�=HPEF@�DAP�CAR=H�EO� �KOPIAO�AP�=H���½»½»���QCPEC�AP�=H���½»¼Â¡���J@=JGO�@AVA�G=JPPAGAJEJCAJ�EO�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�@A�IAAOP�K>FA?PEARA�OP=J@==N@�KI�@A�R=HE@EPAEP�R=J�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�IAA�PA�AR=HQANAJ���

�L�>=OEO�R=J�=@NAOCACARAJO�QEP�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�AJ�=@NAOCACARAJO�@EA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�==J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�DA>>AJ�RANOPNAGP��VEFJ�@A�PSAA�@=P=OAPO�CAGKLLAH@��QEPOHQEPAJ@�RKKN�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�@==N�PKAOPAIIEJC�PKA�C=RAJ��¿�»½½�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�D=@@AJ�AAJ�PA�GKLLAHAJ�=@NAO�EJCARQH@���=J�@AVA�CNKAL�DA>>AJ�½�¿Ã¼�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@A�RN==C���KA�R==G�DAABP�Q�O?D=@A�@KKN�C=OSEJJEJC�CAD=@���PEF@AJO�@A�H==POPA�IAPEJC�EJCARQH@���J�@A�H==POPA�CNKAL�S=O�AN�AAJ�?KNNAH=PEA�R=J�»�ÂÃ�PQOOAJ�DAP�PKP==H�==JP=H�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�@=P�KL�DAP�=@NAO�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EO�CA@==J�AJ�CAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�CAIAPAJ�IAP�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP���A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�AJ�@A��K>FA?PEARA��NACEOPN=PEA�EJ�DAP�NACEOPAN�GKIAJ�@QO�OPANG�KRANAAJ��KJ@=JGO�DAP�BAEP�VKSAH�DAP�NACEOPAN�=HO�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�==J�AJECA��NQEO��AJ�RANPAGAJEJC�KJ@ANDAREC�VEFJ� VEA��KOPIAO�AP�=H���½»½»¡���=P�EO�>AH=JCNEFG��S=JP�DAP�PKKJP�==J�@=P�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�AAJ�>APNKQS>=NA�EJ@E?=PKN�VEFJ�RKKN�@A�SANGAHEFG�CAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A��

�HDKASAH�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�@QO�RNEF�>APNKQS>==N�VEFJ��EO�DAP�IKCAHEFG�@=P�@A�CACARAJO�R=J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�JKC�>APNKQS>==N@AN�VEFJ�AJ�KB�IAAN�RKKNOLAHHAJ@A�S==N@A�DA>>AJ�RKKN�@A�=JPSKKN@AJ�R=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KL�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP���I�@EP�PA�KJ@ANVKAGAJ��VEFJ�>AE@A�R=NE=>AHAJ�PKACARKAC@�==J�@A�IK@AHHAJ�@EA�KJ@ANVKAGAJ�SAHGA�B=?PKNAJ�O=IAJD=JCAJ�IAP�@A�=JPSKKN@AJ�R=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KL�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ���

�KKN�=HHA�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ� RANPNKQSAJ��CAVKJ@DAE@OI=PAJ��ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�AJ�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA¡�VEAJ�SA�@=P�>AE@A�I=PAJ�R=J�O?D=@A�AAJ�RANCAHEFG>==N�ABBA?P�H=PAJ�VEAJ���NR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�EO�>EFRKKN>AAH@�H=CAN�=HO�IAJOAJ�AAJO�KB�IAAN@ANA�I=HAJ�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@���=P�@EP�O=IAJD=JCP�IAP�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�R=J�O?D=@A�@EA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CARAJ�KL�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�SEOPAJ�SA�=H���A�JEAQSA�=J=HUOAO�SEFVAJ�QEP�@=P�@A�CANACEOPNAAN@A�O?D=@A�@AVA�R=NE=JPEA�jjG�RANGH==NP� ��==N>EF�EO�DAP�@KKNC==JO�VK�@=P�¿

¿��A�IK@AHHAJ�H=PAJ�>EFRKKN>AAH@�VEAJ�@=P�VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�¼Â�¼Î�R=NE=JPEA�EJ�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�RANGH==NP���?D=@ACACARAJO�QEP�DAP�NACEOPAN�RANGH=NAJ�¼½�»Î�R=NE=JPEA���AJ�IK@AH�IAP�VKSAH�@A�

½Ä�

Page 31: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�JAP�EAPO�I``N�R=NE=JPEA�RANGH==NP�@=J�CANACEOPNAAN@A�O?D=@A�AJ�@==NIAA�@QO�JAP�EAPO�>APAN�RKKNOLAHP�DKA�DKKC�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�O?KNAJ�KL�@AVA�R=NE=>AHAJ���EP�HEFGP�ANKL�PA�SEFVAJ�@=P�@A�S==N@A�@EA�IAJOAJ�PKAGAJJAJ�==J�O?D=@A� =B�PA�HAVAJ�==J�@A�O?D=@A�@EA�VA�V`HB�N=LLKNPANAJ�EJ�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�PAJ�KLVE?DPA�R=J�@A�CANACEOPNAAN@A�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ¡�R=J�EJRHKA@�EO�KL�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@��CAVKJ@DAE@�KB�AAJ�R=J�@A�=J@ANA�R=NE=>AHAJ�@EA�SA�DA>>AJ�CAIAPAJ���

�J�DAP�CAR=H�R=J�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�VEAJ�SA�DAPVAHB@A���EAN�RANGH==NP�VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�VAHBO�QEPVKJ@ANHEFG�RAAH�R=NE=JPEA��J=IAHEFG�¾ÂÎ���==N�KKG�@A�O?D=@A�@EA�EJ�DAP�NACEOPAN�EO�KLCAJKIAJ�RANGH==NP�¾½Î���JKC�OPAA@O�VAAN�RAAH�@QO���AV=IAJ�RANGH=NAJ�@A�CACARAJO�QEP�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�AJ�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�¾ÄÎ�R=J�@A�R=NE=JPEA���H�IAP�=H�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�SA��VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�EO�AAJ�EAPO�OPANGANA�RKKNOLAHHAN��I==N�KRAN�DAP�CADAAH�CAJKIAJ�GKIAJ�DAP�NACEOPAN�AJ�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�OPANG�KRANAAJ���

�KKNOLAHHAJ@A�S==N@A�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�

�AP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�>AR=P�JEAP�=HHAAJ�@=P=�KRAN�DAP�KLPNA@AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��I==N�KKG�@A�@=PQI�S==NKL�O?D=@A�EO�CAIAH@�AJ�DAP�ARAJPQAAH�PKACAGAJ@A�O?D=@A>A@N=C���A@AN�R=J�@AVA�R=NE=>AHAJ�G=J�O=IAJD=JCAJ�IAP�DAP�S==NCAJKIAJ�NEOE?K��RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�EJOP=JPEAO�AJ�IAP�RAEHECDAE@OCARKAH���

�ANPNKQSAJ�

�AN@AN�EJ�@EP�N=LLKNP�SAN@�=H�==JCACARAJ�@=P�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����AAJ�KLR=HHAJ@�L=PNKKJ�H==P�VEAJ�@=P�=BSEFGP�R=J�@A�PNAJ@O�@EA�SA�EJ�@A�RKKNC==J@A�N=LLKNPAJ�DA>>AJ�CA?KJOP=PAAN@���N�EO�OLN=GA�R=J�AAJ�PKAJ=IA�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ�KJ@AN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�>EF�RKKNC==J@A�IAPEJCAJ�==JC=RAJ�@=P�VA�CAAJ�O?D=@A�D=@@AJ��I==N�@EA�PEF@AJO�@AVA�IAPEJC�S`H�==JC=RAJ�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ���AP�C==P�DEAN�@QO�KI�AAJ�CNKAL�@EA�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�EJ�==JN=GEJC�GKIP�IAP�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC���J�RKKNC==J@A�N=LLKNPAJ�V=CAJ�SA�@=P�@A�AANOPA�GAJJEOI=GEJC�IAP�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�CAL==N@�CEJC�IAP�AAJ�=BJ=IA�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�EJOP=JPEA�S==N�VEF�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ���EP�GAAN�EO�AN�AAN@AN�OLN=GA�R=J�AAJ�PKAJ=IA�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ���

�HO�SA�KJO�>APAN�RAN@EALAJ�EJ�@AVA�CNKAL��CA>NQEG�I=GAJ@�R=J�@A�@=P=�QEP�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN��SEFVAJ�@A�=J=HUOAO�QEP�@=P�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�O?D=@A�IAH@AJ�>EF�@A������VAHBO�I``N�RANPNKQSAJ�DA>>AJ�EJ�@A�����@=J�SAHGA�=J@ANA�CNKAL�KKG� EJ?HQOEAB�@A�CNKAL�IAJOAJ�@EA�JKC�JKKEP�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ¡���AVA�PKAJ=IA�R=J�RANPNKQSAJ�EO�EJ�IEJ@ANA�I=PA�KKG�VE?DP>==N�KJ@AN�@A�@AAHCNKAL�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�=H�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�D=@�CAIAH@�>EF�@A���������AJ�@EA�JQ�RKKN�DAP�AANOP�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ�>EF�@A�������AP�PKACAJKIAJ�RANPNKQSAJ�EO�AN�JEAP�RKKN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�=H�R=GAN�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@�>EF�@A�����������N�VEFJ�CAAJ�==JSEFVEJCAJ�@=P�DAP�RANDKKC@A�

VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�=HO�@A�NACEOPAN@=P=�RANGH==NP�¼Â�¿Î�R=NE=JPEA��CACARAJO�QEP�DAP�BAEPAHEFGA�NACEOPAN�RKACAJ�@QO�OHA?DPO�VAAN�>ALANGP�EJVE?DP�PKA�==J�S=P�SA�QEP�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CAO�GQJJAJ�=BHAE@AJ�� �

¾»�

Page 32: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����G=J�SKN@AJ�RANGH==N@�@KKN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�R=J�@A�OPQSIAANNACAHEJC�CA>NQEG�DA>>AJ�CAI==GP���AH�VEAJ�SA�IAAN�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����KJ@AN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA� IAANRKQ@EC¡�>A@N=CAJ�KJPREJCAJ�R=J�@A�����AJ�KB�@A����������PANSEFH�DAP�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�����>EF�AAJ�JAC=PEARA�QEPGKIOP�@==HP���

�EOE?KLAN?ALPEA�

�K=HO�AAN@AN�@EP�N=LLKNP�=H�>AOLNKGAJ��EO�@A�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�OEJ@O�FQJE�½»¼Ä�KRAN�DAP�CADAAH�CAJKIAJ�HE?DP�=BCAJKIAJ���EP�EO�S==NO?DEFJHEFG�KI@=P�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�JEAP�=HHAAJ�OPANG�O=IAJD=JCP�IAP�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A���=�AAJ�CNKPANA�>AREJC�JAAIP�IAJ�LHKPO�IAAN�NEOE?K�O�S==N���==NJ=�PNAA@P�AAJ�CAHAE@AHEFGA�@=HEJC�KL��DAP�NEOE?K�JAAIP�CAHAE@AHEFG�=B��PKP�DAP�KJCARAAN�Á�PKP�¼»�I==J@AJ�J=�@A�>AREJC�PANQC�EO�KL�DAP�KQ@A�JERA=Q� �KOPIAO�AP�=H���½»¼Ä?¡���A�=BJ=IA�R=J�DAP�S==NCAJKIAJ�NEOE?K�OEJ@O�FQJE�½»¼Ä�L=OP�>EF�@EP�L=PNKKJ��AN�DA>>AJ�VE?D�OEJ@O�@A�>AREJC�R=J��AOPANSEFPSAN@� IAE�½»¼Ä¡�PKP�==J�DAP�IKIAJP�R=J�@A�IAPEJC�EJ�I==NP�½»½»�CAAJ�CNKPA�>AREJCAJ�RKKNCA@==J��

�A�GKLLAHEJC�IAP�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�RKACP�DEAN==J�AAJ�JEAQS�EJVE?DP�PKA���EP�AAN@AN�KJ@ANVKAG�SEOPAJ�SA�=H�@=P�@A�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�DKCAN�EO�KJ@AN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ���Q�VEAJ�SA�@=P�@EP�ABBA?P�OPANGAN�EO�RKKN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�R=GAN�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@�AJ�RKKN�IAJOAJ�@EA�KL�¼¼�JKRAI>AN��DAP�EFGLQJP�R=J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN��EJ�AAJ�LNK?A@QNA�V=PAJ���A�RANDKCEJC�HEFGP�@QO�EJ�OPANGANA�I=PA�KL�PA�PNA@AJ�KJ@AN�À

IAJOAJ�@EA�NA?AJP�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ�@=J�>EF�DAJ�@EA�H=JCAN�CAHA@AJ�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ���EP�@QE@P�ANKL�@=P�KKG�DAP�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�O?D=@A�HAE@P�PKP�AAJ�PKAJ=IA�R=J�S==NCAJKIAJ�NEOE?K�O�@EA�J=�AJECA�PEF@�SAAN�=BJAIAJ�� �

�J�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�OP==J�KKG�@A�QEPCAGAAN@A�>A@N=CAJ���AVA�>A@N=CAJ�CARAJ�AAJ�EJ@E?=PEA�R=J�@A�ANJOP�R=J�O?D=@A�@EA�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�==J�AAJ�SKJEJC�DAABP�RANKKNV==GP���A�VEAJ�@=P�@A�DKKCPA�R=J�@A�PKACAGAJ@A�>A@N=CAJ�EAPO�O=IAJD=JCP�IAP�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA���AOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�AAJ�DKKC�PKACAGAJ@�>A@N=C��ANR=NAJ�EAPO�IAAN�NEOE?K�KL�DAP�IAAI=GAJ�R=J�AAJ�==N@>AREJC��DAP�>AO?D=@EC@�N=GAJ�R=J�DQJ�AECAJ@KIIAJ�AJ�DAP�VAHB�CASKJ@�N=GAJ�@KKN�AAJ�==N@>AREJC���EAN>EF�IKAPAJ�SA�SAH�AAJ�G=JPPAGAJEJC�I=GAJ��O?D=@A?H=EIO�@EA�>EF�����VEFJ�=BCASAVAJ�AJ�S==N�@QO�CAAJ�>A@N=C�EO�PKACAGAJ@��NAOQHPANAJ�jjG�EJ�AAJ�DKCANA�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA���

�NR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�

�RAN�DAP�=HCAIAAJ�RKAHAJ�>ASKJANO�@EA�EJ�@A�VAHBN=LLKNP=CA�==JCARAJ�IAAN�O?D=@A�PA�DA>>AJ�VE?D�IEJ@AN�RAEHEC���A�NACEOPN=PEA�EJ�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�SEFOP�DAPVAHB@A�QEP���AOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�O?D=@A�IAH@@AJ��RKAHAJ�VE?D�IEJ@AN�RAEHEC���EP�CAH@P�RKKN=H�RKKN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�>EF�@A���������O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@�KB�IAANRKQ@EC�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@�>EF�@A�������==NJ==OP�VEAJ�SA�@=P�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�SEAJO�O?D=@A?H=EI�JEAP�SAN@�PKACAGAJ@� ``J�GAAN�KB�R=GAN¡�VE?D�KJRAEHECAN�RKAHAJ�@=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�SEAJO�O?D=@A?H=EI�SAH�SAN@�PKACAGAJ@���=JJAAN�AN�O?D=@A�EO�PKACAGAJ@�EO�@A�DKKCPA�R=J�DAP�

À��J�@A�=J=HUOA�VEFJ�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�PKP�¼¼�JKRAI>AN�½»¼Ä�IAACAJKIAJ��

¾¼�

Page 33: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

PKACAGAJ@A�>A@N=C�AAJ�RKKNOLAHHAN�R=J�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@���HO�AN�AAJ�DKKC�PKP==H>A@N=C�EO�PKACAGAJ@�=HO�RANCKA@EJC�R=J�O?D=@A��RKAHAJ�IAJOAJ�VE?D�IEJ@AN�RAEHEC���

AVKJ@DAE@�

�KKN�@A�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�VEAJ�SA�AAJ�RANCAHEFG>==N�L=PNKKJ�R=J�NAOQHP=PAJ�=HO�SA�>EF�NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�V=CAJ���ASKJANO�@EA�R=GAN�EJ�DAP�O?D=@ANACEOPAN�RKKNGKIAJ��DA>>AJ�IAAN�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ���EP�EO�RKKN=H�VE?DP>==N�>EF�NA?AJPA�AJ�>EF�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A��NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�``J�GAAN�KB�R=GAN�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@�>EF�@A������DA>>AJ�IAAN�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�AJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�IAANRKQ@EC�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@�>EF�@A����������DA>>AJ�IAAN�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�@=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@�>EF�@A�����KB�@EA�JKC�JKKEP�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ�CAIAH@��� �

¾½�

Page 34: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

Á���JRHKA@��KRE@�¼Ä��AP�RKHCAJ@A�DKKB@OPQG�EO�CAO?DNARAJ�KI�EJVE?DP�PA�GNEFCAJ�EJ�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�DQE@ECA�?NEOEO�NKJ@KI��KRE@�¼Ä��EJ�?KI>EJ=PEA�IAP�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�C=OSEJJEJC�EJ�@A�LNKREJ?EA�NKJEJCAJ���AJ�==JP=H�ATPN=�RN=CAJ�EO�PKACARKAC@�==J�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�KL�½»�I==NP�½»½»���A�RN=CAJHEFOP�S=O�PKAJ�=H�AAJ�PEF@�KLAJ���=P�>APAGAJP�@=P�JEAP�EA@ANAAJ�@A�G=JO�DAABP�CAD=@�KI�@AVA�RN=CAJ�EJ�PA�RQHHAJ�AJ�@=P�@A�NAOLKJO�KL�@A�ATPN=�RN=CAJ�H=CAN�EO�@=J�KL�@A�CA>NQEGAHEFGA�RN=CAJ���AP�DKKB@OPQG�V=H�=JPSKKN@�CARAJ�KL�@A�RKHCAJ@A�RN==C��EJ�DKARANNA�RKAHAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�VE?D�RAEHEC�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�EJ�DKARANNA�DAABP�DAP�OPEHHACCAJ�R=J�@A�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�AJ�RANOPANGEJC�CARKHCAJ�RKKN�DAJ��

�A�OPAH@AJ�EJ�PKP==H�VARAJ�RN=CAJ�KRAN��KRE@�¼Ä���A�RKHHA@ECA�RN=CAJHEFOP�EO�EJCARQH@�@KKN���Ó�¾�¾»½� ?KILHAPA@�?=OAO¡�S==NR=J���Ó¼�»»Á�@A��KRE@�¼Ä�RN=CAJ�DA>>AJ�>A=JPSKKN@���

�KRE@�¼Ä��I==PNACAHAJ�AJ�RAEHECDAE@�

�A�OPAH@AJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@A�RN==C�KB�VA�@=?DPAJ��KRE@�¼Ä�PA�DA>>AJ�AJ�KB�@EP�CA@E=CJKOPE?AAN@�S=O���A�==JP=HHAJ�VEFJ�EJ�ECQQN�Á�¼�PA�VEAJ���==N�``J�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EJ�KJO�L=JAH�C=B�==J�@A�@E=CJKOA�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä�PA�DA>>AJ�CAGNACAJ���HA?DPO�¼¿�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CARAJ�==J�@=P�VA�RANIKA@AHEFG�DAP�RENQO�DA>>AJ� CAD=@¡��I==N�@=P�@=P�JEAP�EO�R=OPCAOPAH@���QEI�»Î�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�@A�ATPN=�RN=CAJ�EJRQH@AJ��C=B�==J�DAP�RENQO�JEAP�PA�DA>>AJ� CAD=@¡��

¾¾�

Page 35: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Á�¼����=JP=H�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@=P�==JCAABP��KRE@�¼Ä�PA�DA>>AJ

�J�==JRQHHEJC�KL�@A�RN==C�KB�IAJOAJ�VAHB��KRE@�¼Ä�DA>>AJ��OPAH@AJ�SA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KKG�@A�RN==C�KB�EAI=J@�EJ�DQJ�J==OPA�KICAREJC��KRE@�¼Ä�DAABP���A�==JP=HHAJ�DEANR=J�VEFJ�SAANCACARAJ�EJ�ECQQN�Á�½���KG�DEAN�VEAJ�SA�@=P�AAJ�IAAN@ANDAE@�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CAAJ�IAJOAJ�GAJP�IAP��KRE@�¼Ä���KASAH�I==N�``J�NAOLKJ@AJP�VAHB�@A�@E=CJKOA�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä�DAABP��VEAJ�SA�SAH�@=P�¿¾�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EAI=J@�GAJJAJ�IAP�@EA�@E=CJKOA��

¾¿�

Page 36: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Á�½�� ��=JP=HHAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@=P�EAI=J@�GAJP�IAP��KRE@�¼Ä

�J@=JGO�DAP�JEAP�CA@E=CJKOPE?AAN@�VEFJ�IAP��KRE@�¼Ä�KB�DAP�JEAP�GAJJAJ�R=J�IAP�DAP�RENQO��G=J�@A�?KNKJ=?NEOEO�=HOJKC�R=J�EJRHKA@�VEFJ�KL�EAI=J@O�HARAJ���EF�RNKACAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@==NKI�EJ�DKARANNA�VEF�@=?DPAJ�@=P��KRE@�¼Ä�DQJ�HARAJ�DAABP�RAN=J@AN@��ECQQN�Á�¾�H==P�VEAJ�EJ�DKARANNA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@AJGAJ�@=P��KRE@�¼Ä�EJRHKA@�V=H�DA>>AJ�KL�DQJ�HARAJ���=P�SA�VEAJ�EO�@=P�AAJ�NQEIA�IAAN@ANDAE@� �ÓÁÁ»��ÁÀ�ÃΡ�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�==JCAABP�@=P�@A�DQE@ECA�?NEOEO�NKJ@KI��KRE@�¼Ä��DQJ�HARAJ�OPANG�DAABP�RAN=J@AN@���AHHE?DP�JEAP�DAAH�RANN=OOAJ@��GQJJAJ�SA�DEANQEP�RKKNVE?DPEC�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�@=P��KRE@�¼Ä�KKG�AAJ�CNKPA�EIL=?P�DAABP�S=JJAAN�IAJ�VAHB�JEAP�VEAG�EO�CASAAOP��

¾À�

Page 37: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Á�¾�� ��=JP=HHAJ�@=P�==JCAABP�@=P�@A��KRE@�¼Ä�DQJ�HARAJ�DAABP�RAN=J@AN@

�=J�@A�Äü�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�==JCARAJ�@=P�DQJ�HARAJ� AAJ�>AAPFA�KB�OPANG¡�RAN=J@AN@�EO��I=GAJ�û�CA>NQEG�R=J�@A�IKCAHEFGDAE@�DQJ�=JPSKKN@�PKA�PA�HE?DPAJ���J�@AVA�PKAHE?DPEJC�>AO?DNEFRAJ�VEF�R==G�``J�KB�IAAN@ANA�B=?APPAJ�QEP�DQJ�@=CAHEFGO�HARAJ�@EA�@KKN�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�SKN@AJ�>AfJRHKA@���QEI�@A�DAHBP�R=J�DAJ� À¾Î¡�>AO?DNEFBP�DEAN>EF�@A�EJRHKA@�R=J�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�KL�DQJ�OK?E=HA�?KJP=?PAJ��VK=HO�DAP�JEAP�GQJJAJ�=BOLNAGAJ�IAP�B=IEHEA�AJ�RNEAJ@AJ�AJ�DAP�IKAPAJ�IEOOAJ�R=J�GEJ@ANAJ�AJ�GHAEJGEJ@ANAJ���KG�SKN@P�@A�RAN=J@ANEJC�R=J�SANG��AJ�KB�O?DKKHOEPQ=PEA�@KKN�RAAH�IAJOAJ� ¿¾Î¡�CAJKAI@��VK=HO�DAP�PDQEO�IKAPAJ�SANGAJ�AJ�DAP�?KI>EJANAJ�R=J�SANG�IAP�PDQEOKJ@ANSEFO�RKKN�@A�GEJ@ANAJ���EN?=�``J�KL�@A�REFB�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CAABP�EJ�@A�PKAHE?DPEJC�==J�@=P�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�NKJ@��KRE@�¼Ä�>ALANGEJCAJ�KLHARANAJ�RKKN�DQJ�RNEFAPEF@O>AOPA@EJC��>EFRKKN>AAH@�@KKN�@A�=JJQHANEJC�R=J�CALH=J@A�R=G=JPEAO��DAP�=BCAH=OPAJ�R=J�OLKNP>EFAAJGKIOPAJ�AJ�DAP�OPKLLAJ�R=J�@A�GANGC=JC���KKN�ÁÎ�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�SKN@P�KLCAIANGP�@=P�VEF�@KKN�@A�?KNKJ=?NEOEO�VKNCAJ�DA>>AJ�KRAN�EJGKIAJ�KB�DAP�EJGKIAJ�R=J�@ENA?PA�B=IEHEAHA@AJ���

¾Á�

Page 38: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�A�RNKACAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KKG�J==N�DQJ�CARKAH�R=J�RAEHECDAE@�IAP�>APNAGGEJC�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�@EA�@==N�DAP�CARKHC�R=J�VEFJ��ECQQN�Á�¿�H==P�VEAJ�@=P�AAJ�IAAN@ANDAE@�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�VE?D��JEAP�KJRAEHEC�JEAP�RAEHEC��RKAHP���K�J�½ÀÎ�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�RKAHP�VE?D��VAAN�KJRAEHEC��KB��KJRAEHEC��AJ�NQEI�¾»Î�RKAHP�VE?D��RAEHEC��KB��VAAN�RAEHEC���

ECQQN�Á�¿����AEHECDAE@OCARKAH�I�>�P���KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�@A�I==PNACAHAJ

��

�=J�@A�¾¼Ä�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�==JCARAJ�VE?D� � VAAN¡�RAEHEC��PA�RKAHAJ�IAP�>APNAGGEJC�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�@A�I==PNACAHAJ��CARAJ�½¾¼�DEANKL�AAJ�PKAHE?DPEJC���QEI�@A�DAHBP�R=J�DAJ�CAABP�==J�VE?D�RAEHEC�PA�RKAHAJ�KI@=P�VA�VE?D�==J�@A�NE?DPHEFJAJ�DKQ@AJ� À¿Î¡�AJ�KB�KI@=P�VA�IANGAJ�@=P�IAJOAJ�KI�DAJ�DAAJ�VE?D�CKA@�==J�@A�NE?DPHEFJAJ�DKQ@AJ� ¼¼Î¡���==NJ==OP�VACCAJ�RAAH�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ� ½¾Î¡�@=P�VEF�VE?D�RAEHEC�RKAHAJ�KI@=P�VEF�RANPNKQSAJ�DA>>AJ�EJ�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�?�M��KI@=P�DAP�NEOE?K�>ALANGP�EO�VKH=JC�EA@ANAAJ�VE?D�==J�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�DKQ@P���J@ANA�NA@AJAJ�RKKN�CARKAHAJO�R=J�RAEHECDAE@�@EA�@KKN�IAAN@ANA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�SKN@AJ�CAJKAI@��VEFJ�@A�CANEJCA�RANOLNAE@EJC�R=J�DAP�RENQO�EJ�

¾Â�

Page 39: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

@A�NACEK�PKP�@QORANNA� ¼¾Î¡�AJ�JEAP�>=JC�VEFJ�KI�VEAG�PA�SKN@AJ�AJ�KB�JEAP�PKP�AAJ�NEOE?KCNKAL�PA�>ADKNAJ� ÄΡ��

�=J�@A�½¿Â�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�==JCARAJ�VE?D� � VAAN¡�KJRAEHEC��PA�RKAHAJ�IAP�>APNAGGEJC�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�@A�I==PNACAHAJ��CARAJ�NQEI�½»»�AAJ�PKAHE?DPEJC�KL�DQJ�CARKAH�R=J�KJRAEHECDAE@���=J�DAJ�VACP�@A�DAHBP� À»Î¡�VE?D�KJRAEHEC�PA�RKAHAJ�KI@=P�VA�>=JC�VEFJ�@=P�VEF�KB�DQJ�@EAN>=NAJ�>AOIAP�N=GAJ�IAP�DAP�RENQO���AJ�GS=NP�R=J�@AVA�CNKAL�CAABP�@==N>EF�==J�@=P�VEF�KB�DQJ�@EAN>=NAJ�PKP�AAJ�NEOE?KCNKAL�>ADKNAJ���

�EN?=�AAJ�GS=NP� ½¾Î¡�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�VE?D� VAAN¡�KJRAEHEC�RKAHAJ�@KKN��KRE@�¼Ä��RANSEFOP�EJ�@A�PKAHE?DPEJC�J==N�@A�KJVAGANDAE@�@EA�VA�ANR=NAJ���A�KJCNEFL>==NDAE@�R=J�DAP�RENQO�AJ�@A�KJVAGANDAE@�KRAN�DKA�@A�OEPQ=PEA�VE?D�@A�GKIAJ@A�PEF@�C==P�KJPSEGGAHAJ��CARAJ�DAJ�AAJ�KJRAEHEC�CARKAH���AJ�RANCAHEFG>==N�==JP=H�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CAABP�==J�VE?D�KJRAEHEC�PA�RKAHAJ�KI@=P�JEAP�EA@ANAAJ�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�OANEAQO�HEFGP�PA�JAIAJ���A�RKAHAJ�VE?D�KJRAEHEC�KI@=P�IAJOAJ�KI�DAJ�DAAJ� >EFRKKN>AAH@�EJ�@A�OQLANI=NGP¡�VE?D�JEAP�==J�@A�RKKNO?DNEBPAJ�DKQ@AJ���

�J@ANA�NA@AJAJ�RKKN�CARKAHAJO�R=J�KJRAEHECDAE@�@EA�@KKN�RAAH�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CAJKAI@�SKN@AJ��VEFJ�AAJ�CA>NAG�==J�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ�@A�I==PNACAHAJ� ¼ÃΡ�AJ�AAJ�SANGOEPQ=PEA�S==NEJ�IAJOAJ�AAJ�RANDKKC@�NEOE?K�HKLAJ� ¼ÀΡ��

�KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�C=OSEJJEJC�

�A�@=P=�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�>EA@AJ�EJ�?KI>EJ=PEA�IAP�RN=CAJ�KIPNAJP��KRE@�¼Ä�@A�IKCAHEFGDAE@�KI�PA�KJ@ANVKAGAJ�S=P�DAP�ABBA?P�R=J�@A�?KNKJ=?NEOEO�EO��>KRAJKL�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�O?D=@A�@KKN�C=OSEJJEJC���A�GEFGAJ�AANOP�J==N�@A�OLA?EBEAGA�RN=CAJ�@EA�SA�ATPN=�OPAH@AJ�KRAN��KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�C=OSEJJEJC���ANRKHCAJO�C==J�SA�EJ�KL�DKA�@AVA�EJ@E?=PKNAJ�=H�@=J�JEAP�O=IAJD=JCAJ�IAP�B=?PKNAJ�NKJ@KI�C=OSEJJEJC��

�A�CARKHCAJ�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä�

�A�RNKACAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KB�VEF�@=?DPAJ�@=P�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�NKJ@KI��KRE@�¼Ä�CARKHCAJ�VKQ@AJ�DA>>AJ�RKKN�DQJ��O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC ���ECQQN�Á�À�H==P�VEAJ�@=P�NQEI�»Î�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�S==NKL�@AVA�RN==C�R=J�PKAL=OOEJC�EO ��@AJGP�@=P�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�NKJ@KI�Á

�KRE@�¼Ä�PAJ�IEJOPA�AJECA�CARKHCAJ� C==J¡�DA>>AJ�RKKN�DQJ�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC���AJ�LAN?AJP=CA�R=J�AAJ�GHAEJA�¾»Î�CAABP�==J�DAHAI==H�JEAP�PA�RANS=?DPAJ�@=P�DAP�CARKHCAJ�V=H�DA>>AJ��

Á��ASKJANO�@EA�JEAP�PA�I=GAJ�DA>>AJ�IAP�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC�KB�>EF�SEA�O?D=@A�=H�EO�=BCAD=J@AH@��GKJ@AJ�==JCARAJ�@=P�@AVA�RN==C�KL�DAJ�JEAP�R=J�PKAL=OOEJC�EO��

¾Ã�

Page 40: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Á�À�� �ARKHCAJ�R=J�@A��KRE@�¼Ä�I==PNACAHAJ�RKKN�O?D=@A=BD=J@AHEJC

�=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�RANS=?DPAJ�@=P�@A�O?D=@ADANOPAH�>AfJRHKA@�SKN@P�@KKN��KRE@�¼Ä��DA>>AJ�NQEI�DKJ@AN@�IAJOAJ�DEANKL�AAJ�PKAHE?DPEJC�CACARAJ���KKN�?EN?=�AAJ�@AN@A�R=J�DAJ�SKN@AJ�EJ�@A�PKAHE?DPEJC��?KJ?NAPA�RKKN>AAH@AJ� �CACARAJ�R=J�RANPN=CEJC�EJ�DQJ�AECAJ�OEPQ=PEA��VK=HO�=BCAVAC@A�=BOLN=GAJ�RKKN�KLJ=IA�KB�DANOPAH���RAJAAJO�?EN?=�AAJ�@AN@A�>AJKAIP�IAAN� �EJ�DAP�=HCAIAAJ ��@=P��=HHAO�H=JCAN�@QQNP��KB��=HHAO�OPEH�HECP��@KKN��KRE@�¼Ä���==NJ==OP�VACP�?EN?=�``J�KL�@A�PEAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�PA��RANS=?DPAJ�KB�PA�RNAVAJ�@=P�DQJ�O?D=@ALNK?A@QNA�@KKN�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�SKN@P�RANPN==C@���

�A�RNKACAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KKG�EJ�DKARANNA�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�NKJ@KI��KRE@�¼Ä�CARKHCAJ�VKQ@AJ�DA>>AJ�RKKN�@A��RANOPANGEJC�R=J�DQJ�DQEO�AJ�KB�>A@NEFBOL=J@����J�ECQQN�Á�Á�EO�PA�VEAJ�@=P�KJCARAAN�@A�DAHBP�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KL�SEA�@AVA�RN==C�R=J�PKAL=OOEJC�EO ��Â

==JCAABP�@=P�@EP�IKCAHEFG�CARKHCAJ�G=J�DA>>AJ�RKKN�@A�RANOPANGEJC�R=J�DQJ�DQEO�KB�>A@NEFBOL=J@���A�=J@ANA�DAHBP�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CAABP�==J�@=P�VEF�@AJGAJ�@=P�DAP�

��ASKJANO�@EA�JEAP�PA�I=GAJ�DA>>AJ�IAP�@A�RANOPANGEJCOKLAN=PEA��GKJ@AJ�==JCARAJ�@=P�@AVA�RN==C�JEAP�KL�DAJ�R=J�PKAL=OOEJC�S=O��

¾Ä�

Page 41: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

CARKHCAJ�G=J�DA>>AJ��I==N�VEFJ�SAH�ANC�RAN@AAH@�KRAN�@A�I=PA�S==NEJ�DAP�CARKHCAJ�DAABP��

ECQQN�Á�Á�� �ARKHCAJ�R=J�@A��KRE@�¼Ä�I==PNACAHAJ�RKKN�RANOPANGEJC

�=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�RANS=?DPAJ�@=P�@A�I==PNACAHAJ�NKJ@��KRE@�¼Ä�CARKHCAJ�DA>>AJ�RKKN�@A�RANOPANGEJC�R=J�DQJ�DQEO��CARAJ�?EN?=�REFBPEC�IAJOAJ�DEANKL�AAJ�PKAHE?DPEJC���RAJ=HO�>EF�O?D=@A�RANSEFOP�KKG�DEAN�?EN?=�AAJ@AN@A�R=J�DAJ�J==N�?KJ?NAPA�RANPN=CEJC��VK=HO�DAP�=BCAH=OPAJ�R=J�GAQGAJP=BAHCAOLNAGGAJ���==NJ==OP�CAABP�?EN?=�``J�@AN@A�EJ�=HCAIAJA�VEJ�==J�@=P�@A�RANOPANGEJC�RKKN�RANPN=CEJC�VKNCP� �EO�=HHAI==H�KLCAO?DKNP���KB��JKC�IAAN�=BS=?DPAJ�¡��

�KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�O=IAJD=JC�IAP�B=?PKNAJ�NKJ@KI�C=OSEJJEJC�

�J�@A�NACQHEANA�IAPEJCAJ�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�SKN@P�=HPEF@�AAJ�==JP=H�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�KLCAJKIAJ��KJ@AN�=J@ANA�RAEHECDAE@�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@���AP�>ADQHL�R=J�NACNAOOEAIK@AHHAJ�GQJJAJ�SA�J=@AN�KJ@ANVKAGAJ�S=P�DAP�RAN>=J@�EO�PQOOAJ�DAP�CARKAH�R=J�RAEHECDAE@�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä�AJ�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�QEP�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB���HHA�

¿»�

Page 42: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

IK@AHHAJ�DKQ@AJ�NAGAJEJC�IAP�=?DPANCNKJ@GAJIANGAJ� ?KJPNKHAR=NE=>AHAJ¡��VK=HO�HAABPEF@�AJ�KLHAE@EJCOJERA=Q���AN�=J=HUOA�>KQSAJ�SA�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�IK@AHHAJ�S==N>EF�SA�EJ�AHG�IK@AH�AAJ�JEAQSA�R=NE=>AHA�PKARKACAJ��

�A�=J=HUOAAN@AJ�AANOP�S=P�AN�CA>AQNP�IAP�DAP�ABBA?P�R=J�O?D=@A�KL�@A��RAEHECDAE@�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP�C=OSEJJEJC �� DEANJ=��C=OSEJJEJCORAEHECDAE@�¡��KL�DAP�IKIAJP�@=P�SA�KKG�DAP�RAEHECDAE@OCARKAH�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä� DEANJ=��?KNKJ=RAEHECDAE@�¡�IAAJAIAJ�EJ�DAP�IK@AH���AVA�PSAA�RKNIAJ�R=J�RAEHECDAE@�D=JCAJ�AJECOVEJO�IAP�AHG==N�O=IAJ� N�Ó��½À¡��I==N�@A�IK@AHHAJ�IKAPAJ�H=PAJ�VEAJ�EJ�DKARANNA�VA�=BVKJ@ANHEFG�R=J�AHG==N�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�>AfJRHKA@AJ��

�==N>EF�VEFJ�AN�CHK>==H�PSAA�IKCAHEFGDA@AJ��

¼� �A�@NAECEJC�R=J��KRE@�¼Ä�G=J�@A�>A@NAECEJC�@KKN�O?D=@A�@KAJ�=BJAIAJ���J�@=P�CAR=H�JAAIP�DAP�CARKAH�R=J�KJRAEHECDAE@�@KKN�C=OSEJJEJC�EAPO�=B��KI@=P�OKIIECA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAAN�IAP��KRE@�¼Ä�@=J�IAP�==N@>AREJCOO?D=@A�>AVEC�VEFJ���EP�VKQ�>APAGAJAJ�@=P�DAP�ABBA?P�R=J�O?D=@A�KL�C=OSEJJEJCORAEHECDAE@�RANIEJ@ANP��=HO�SA�?KNKJ=RAEHECDAE@�==J�DAP�IK@AH�PKARKACAJ���B��

½� �N�EO�OLN=GA�R=J�AAJ��OP=LAHEJC��R=J�@A�@NAECEJC�@KKN�O?D=@A�AJ�@A�@NAECEJC�@KKN��KRE@�¼Ä��>ASKJANO�ANR=NAJ�KJRAEHECDAE@�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP�C=OSEJJEJC��AJ�@==N�>KRAJKL�RKAHAJ�VA�VE?D�KKG�JKC�KJRAEHEC�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä���EP�VKQ�>APAGAJAJ�@=P�DAP�ABBA?P�R=J�O?D=@A�KL�C=OSEJJEJCORAEHECDAE@�KJRAN=J@AN@�>HEFBP��=HO�SA�?KNKJ=RAEHECDAE@�==J�DAP�IK@AH�PKARKACAJ���

�J�ECQQN�Á�Â��VEAJ�SA�NAOQHP=PAJ�R=J�DAP�H==POPA��IAAOP�?KILHAPA�IK@AH���J�@EP�IK@AH�GEFGAJ�SA�J==N�@A�EIL=?P�R=J�?KNKJ=RAEHECDAE@��@A�EIL=?P�R=J�O?D=@A�� Ó��C=OSEJEJCOOPNAOOKN�¡�AJ�?KJPNKHAR=NE=>AHAJ�KL�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���EP�IK@AH�RANPAHP�KJO�@=P�AN�EJ@AN@==@�OLN=GA�HEFGP�PA�VEFJ�R=J��OP=LAHEJC��R=J�@A�@NAECEJC�@KKN�O?D=@A�AJ�@A�@NAECEJC�@KKN��KRE@�¼Ä���A�PSAA�ABBA?PAJ�KJ@AN==J�@A�BECQQN�CARAJ�==J�@=P�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�KB�DAP�KJRAEHECA�CARKAH�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä��>AE@A�AAJ�JAC=PEAB�RAN>=J@�DKQ@AJ�IAP�DAP�RAEHECDAE@OCARKAH�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���

� �

¿¼�

Page 43: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Á�Â�� ��AEHECDAE@�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP�C=OSEJJEJC�IAP�PKARKACEJC�R=J�?KNKJ=RAEHECDAE@��EIL=?P�R=J�O?D=@A� ÓC=OSEJJEJCOOPNAOOKN¡�AJ�?KJPNKHAR=NE=>AHAJ� CAOH=?DP��HAABPEF@��KLHAE@EJC¡

�A�=J=HUOAO�@EA�SA�RKKN�RAEHECDAE@�QEPRKAN@AJ��RKAN@AJ�SA�QEP�RKKN�CAVKJ@DAE@��CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@� ����À¡��=HCAIAJA�ANR=NAJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�AJ�OPNAOOCANAH=PAAN@A�OUILPKIAJ���J�ECQQN�Á�Ã��VEFJ�@A�NAOQHP=PAJ�SAANCACARAJ�R=J�@A�@NEA�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�CAVKJ@DAE@OI=PAJ��VK=HO�VA�J==N�RKNAJ�GS=IAJ�EJ�DAP�?KILHAPA�IK@AH���

� �

¿½�

Page 44: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Á�Ã�� �AVKJ@DAE@�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP�?KNKJ=RAEHECDAE@��EIL=?P�R=J�O?D=@A� ÓC=OSEJJEJCOOPNAOOKN¡�AJ�?KJPNKHAR=NE=>AHAJ� CAOH=?DP��HAABPEF@��KLHAE@EJC¡�

�J�ECQQN�Á�Ã��VEAJ�SA�@=P��?KNKJ=RAEHECDAE@��EJ�AHG�IK@AH�O=IAJD=JCP�IAP�AAJ�>APANA�CAVKJ@DAE@���J�=J@ANA�SKKN@AJ��IAJOAJ�@EA�VE?D�RAEHECAN�RKAHAJ�EJ�RAN>=J@�IAP��KRE@�¼Ä��DA>>AJ�KKG�AAJ�>APANA�CAVKJ@DAE@���AP�@AN@A�IK@AH�H==P�JAP�=HO�>EF�ANR=NAJ�RAEHECDAE@�@KKN�C=OSEJJEJC BECQQN�Á�¡�VEAJ�@=P��>KRAJKL�DAP�ABBA?P�R=J�O?D=@A���?KNKJ=RAEHECDAE@��KKG�OECJEBE?=JP�RAN>=J@�DKQ@P�IAP�AAJ�PKAJ=IA�EJ�CAVKJ@DAE@OOUILPKIAJ���AOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�VE?D�KJRAEHECAN�RKAHAJ�EJ�NAH=PEA�PKP��KRE@�¼Ä��DA>>AJ�IAAN�CAVKJ@DAE@OOUILPKIAJ�>KRAJKL�@A�ABBA?PAJ�R=J�O?D=@A���AP��OP=LAHEJCOABBA?P��VEAJ�SA�JEAP�RKKN�CAAOPAHEFGA�CAVKJ@DAE@�AJ�=HCAIAJA�CAVKJ@DAE@���

¿¾�

Page 45: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

���IKPEAO�AJ�?KLEJC�

�IKPEAO�

�EJ@O�½»¼Á�RN=CAJ�SA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�NACAHI=PEC�==J�PA�CARAJ�EJ�DKARANNA�VA�>KKODAE@��DKKL��S=JDKKL��I=?DPAHKKODAE@�AJ�?KJPNKHA�ANR=NAJ���KJ?NAAP�SKN@P�CAIAPAJ�DKA�R==G�AAJ�AIKPEA�EO�CARKAH@�EJ�@A�=BCAHKLAJ�REAN�SAGAJ�KL�AAJ�O?D==H�R=J�¼�Ó��JKKEP��PKP�Á�Ó��RKKNP@QNAJ@����A�KJPSEGGAHEJCAJ�EJ�@AVA�AIKPEAO�KRAN�@A�PEF@�SKN@AJ�SAANCACARAJ�EJ�ECQQN�Â�¼��S==N>EF�KJ@ANO?DAE@�SKN@P�CAI==GP�PQOOAJ�IAJOAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A��IAJOAJ�IAP�AJGAHRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�AJ�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A���KG�>EF�@AVA�=J=HUOAO�DA>>AJ�SA�CA?KJPNKHAAN@�KB�IAJOAJ�@EA�PQOOAJ�IAPEJCAJ�R=J�O?D=@ACNKAL�VEFJ�CASEOOAH@�EJRHKA@�DA>>AJ�KL�@A�NAOQHP=PAJ��VK=HO�DAP�CAR=H�S=O�>EF�RANPNKQSAJ� VEA�DKKB@OPQG�¾¡���

�A�VEAJ�>EF�=HHA�AIKPEAO�AAJ�HE?DP�LKOEPEARA�KJPSEGGAHEJC� VEA�ECQQN�Â�¼¡��NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�RKAHAJ�VE?D�EJ�I==NP�½»½»�DKKLRKHHAN��IEJ@AN�I=?DPAHKKO��ANR=NAJ�IAAN�?KJPNKHA��IEJ@AN�S=JDKKL�AJ�IEJ@AN�>KKODAE@�@=J�EJ�@A�RKNECA�IAPEJC���EP�RANO?DEH�PAJ�KLVE?DPA�R=J�RKNECA�IAPEJC� FQJE�½»¼Ä¡�HEFGP�DAP�OPANGOP�PA�VEFJ�RKKN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A���KASAH�@EP�AAJ�LKOEPEARA�KJPSEGGAHEJC�EO��O?KNAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�JKC�OPAA@O�OECJEBE?=JP�JAC=PEARAN�@=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���

� �

¿¿�

Page 46: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Â�¼�� ��AN=J@ANEJCAJ�R=J�DKKL��I=?DPAHKKODAE@��?KJPNKHA��S=JDKKL�AJ�>KKODAE@�EJ�@A�PEF@��=HO�BQJ?PEA�R=J�DAP�=H�@=J�JEAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H

¿À�

Page 47: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�KLEJC�

�==OP�AIKPEAO�VEFJ�SA�KKG�CAfJPANAOOAAN@�EJ�CA@N=CEJCAJ�AJ�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ���J�@A�HEPAN=PQQN�SKN@P�KJ@ANO?DAE@�CAI==GP�PQOOAJ�>AJ=@ANAJ@A�KB�KJPSEFGAJ@A�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ�EJ�DAP�KIC==J�IAP�OPNAOOKNAJ��VK=HO�EJCNEFLAJ@A�HARAJOCA>AQNPAJEOOAJ� VEA��=UHKN�x��P=JPKJ��½»»Â�RKKN�AAJ�KRANVE?DP¡���AJ=@ANAJ@A�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ�LKCAJ�@A�OPNAOOKN�PA��RANSEF@ANAJ���PA�RANIEJ@ANAJ�KB�EJ�EA@AN�CAR=H�AN�CNEL�KL�PA�GNEFCAJ���JPSEFGAJ@A�OPN=PACEAbJ�DKQ@AJ�EJ�@=P�IAJ�@A�OPNAOOKN�LNK>AANP�PA�JACANAJ��PA�KJPSEFGAJ�KB�VE?D�ANR=J�PANQC�PA�PNAGGAJ���J�@A�OPNAOO�?KLEJCHEPAN=PQQN�SKN@P�AAJ�>AJ=@ANAJ@A�OPN=PACEA�KRAN�DAP�=HCAIAAJ�CAVEAJ�=HO�@A�OQ??AORKHHANA�I=JEAN�KI�IAP�AAJ�OPNAOOKN�KI�PA�C==J� �AO�x��ACANOPNKI��½»»Á���=UHKN�x��P=JPKJ��½»»Â¡���AP�EO�SAH�@A�RN==C�KB�@EP�KKG�CAH@P�RKKN�AAJ�?DNKJEO?DA�OPNAOOKN��AAJ�OPNAOOKN�@EA�JEAP�AAJI=HEC� >EFRKKN>AAH@�DAP�KRANHEF@AJ�R=J�EAI=J@¡�I==N�RKKNP@QNAJ@� >EFRKKN>AAH@�CARKHCAJ�R=J�C=OSEJJEJC¡�==JSAVEC�EO���

�J�@A�DQE@ECA�?KJPATP�GQJJAJ�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�AJ�D==N�CARKHCAJ� >EFRKKN>AAH@�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A¡�=HO�?DNKJEO?DA�OPNAOOKN�CAVEAJ�SKN@AJ���A�SEH@AJ�KJ@ANVKAGAJ�EJ�DKARANNA�AN�OLN=GA�EO�R=J�@AVA�IKCAHEFGA�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ���A�DA>>AJ�@==NPKA�EJ�@A�H==POPA�IAPEJC�PEAJ�OPAHHEJCAJ�KLCAJKIAJ�KRAN�IKCAHEFGA�I=JEANAJ�KI�KI�PA�C==J�IAP�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG���AVA�RN=CAJ�DA>>AJ�SA�=HHAAJ�CAOPAH@�==J�IAJOAJ�@EA�==JC=RAJ�KL�AJECA�SEFVA�EJ�DQJ�LANOKKJHEFGA�KB�LNKBAOOEKJAHA�HARAJ�PA�I=GAJ�PA�DA>>AJ�IAP�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���J�DAP�DQE@ECA�DKKB@OPQG�KJ@ANVKAGAJ�SA��

¼� �J�DKARANNA�SA�EJ@AN@==@�AAJ�KJ@ANO?DAE@�GQJJAJ�I=GAJ�PQOOAJ�>AJ=@ANAJ@A�AJ�KJPSEFGAJ@A�CA@N=CEJCAJ�KB�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ���

½� �B�AN�AAJ�NAH=PEA�EO�PQOOAJ�@AVA�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ�CA@N=CEJCAJ�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@��OPAHHAJ�>AJ=@ANAJ@A�KB�KJPSEFGAJ@A�D=J@AHEJCAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�>APAN�EJ�OP==P�KI�IAP�@A�OPNAOOKN�O?D=@A�KI�PA�C==J��

�ANO?DEH�PQOOAJ�>AJ=@ANAJ@A�AJ�KJPSEFGAJ@A�OPN=PACEAbJ�

�E=�AAJ�B=?PKN=J=HUOA�EO�CAPKAPOP�EJ�DKARANNA�AN�OLN=GA�EO�R=J�KJPSEFGAJ@A�RANOQO�>AJ=@ANAJ�CA@N=CEJCAJ� ��J=HUOAO�HEAPAJ�AAJ�RNEF�@QE@AHEFG�RANO?DEH�PQOOAJ�@AVA�B=?PKNAJ�Ã

VEAJ��

¼� �AJ=@ANAJ@A ��I=JEAN�R=J�KIC==J�IAP�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG��PAIO�@EA�DEAN>EF�DKNAJ��

� �G�LNK>AAN�VKRAAH�IKCAHEFG�KKG�DAP�LKOEPEARA�PA�VEAJ�EJ�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG��

� �G�I==G�CN=LFAO�KRAN�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG��

��J�@AVA�B=?PKN=J=HUOA�HEAPAJ�SA�DAP�EPAI��EG�>AJ�DAP�>AQ��>QEPAJ�>AO?DKQSEJC��DAP�>AQ�VEFJ�EO�SAH�AAJ�CARKHC�R=J��I==N�CAAJ�I=JEAN�R=J�KIC==J�IAP�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG���AP�EPAI�KRAN�OPAQJ�REJ@AJ�EJ�OLENEPQAHA�KRANPQECEJC�KB�CAHKKB�>HAAG�OP=PEOPEO?D�CAVEAJ�>EF�CAAJ�R=J�>AE@A�B=?PKNAJ�PA�L=OOAJ�AJ�DA>>AJ�SA�EJ�@A�=J=HUOAO�SACCAH=PAJ���

¿Á�

Page 48: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

� �G�DA>�IAP�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG�HANAJ�HARAJ���

½� �JPSEFGAJ@A ��I=JEAN�R=J�KIC==J�IAP�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG���PAIO�@EA�DEAN>EF�DKNAJ��

� �HO�=BHAE@EJC�RKKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG�NE?DP�EG�IA�KL�SANG��DK>>U�O�KB�=J@ANA�V=GAJ�S==N�EG�LHAVEAN�EJ�DA>��

� �HO�EG�IA�RANRAHAJ@�RKAH�KRAN�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG�@=J�@NEJG�EG�SAH�AAJO�=H?KDKH�KB�CA>NQEG�EG�=J@ANA�IE@@AHAJ��

� �G�DA>�@KKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG�OKIIECA�@KAHAJ�EJ�IEFJ�HARAJ�IKAPAJ�HKOH=PAJ��

� �G�KRANSAAC�KI�R=JSACA�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG�@A�NACEK�PA�RANH=PAJ��

� �G�RANIEF@�CAOLNAGGAJ�KRAN�C=OSEJJEJC��==N@>AREJCAJ��O?D=@A��RANOPANGEJC�AP?��

�A�CARAJ�AANOP�@A�@A�CAIE@@AH@A�O?KNAO�KL�@A�EPAIO�LAN�O?D=@AJERA=Q�SAAN� ECQQN�Â�½¡���=P�KLR=HP�EO�@=P�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�RKKN�=HHA�EPAIO� KJCA=?DP�KB�VA�>AJ=@ANAJ@�KB�=BSEFGAJ@�VEFJ¡�==JCARAJ�@AVA�CA@N=CEJCAJ�IAAN�PA�RANPKJAJ���EP�EO�IAP�J=IA�DAP�CAR=H�RKKN��@KAHAJ�IKAPAJ�HKOH=PAJ����

�KKN�PSAA�EPAIO�VEAJ�SA�CAAJ�RANO?DEHHAJ�IAP�>APNAGGEJC�PKP�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A�AJ�DAP�QEPKABAJAJ�R=J�@AVA�CA@N=CEJCAJ���DAP�LKOEPEARA�EJ�LNK>ANAJ�PA�VEAJ��AJ��AN�IAA�HANAJ�HARAJ����

¿Â�

Page 49: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Â�½�� ��KLEJCEPAIO��CAIE@@AH@AJ� PA�VEAJ�KL�VKSAH�@A�U�=O�=HO�>KRAJ�@A�OP=RAJ¡�AJ�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=HHAJ�

�=P�KLR=HP�S=JJAAN�SA�KL�EPAIJERA=Q�J==N�ECQQN�Â�½�GEFGAJ��EO�@=P�>ASKJANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�IAP�J=IA�DKCAN�O?KNAJ�KL�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ�@EA�RKKN�DAJ��J=@AHEC��VEFJ��VA�CARAJ�IAAN�@=J�>ASKJANO�VKJ@AN�KB�IAP�``J�GAAN�O?D=@A�==J�@=P�VA�@KAHAJ�DA>>AJ�IKAPAJ�HKOH=PAJ��@=P�VA�KRANSACAJ�@A�NACEK�PA�RANH=PAJ�AJ�@=P�VA�DAP�>AQ�VEFJ���HO�SA�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ@�PQOOAJ�@A��O?D=@ACNKALAJ��ARAJ�HKOH=PAJ�@=J�VEAJ�SA�@=P�AECAJHEFG�EA@ANAAJ�DKKC�O?KKNP�KL�DAP�EPAI��EG�>AJ�DAP�>AQ����EP�>APAGAJP�@=P�EA@ANAAJ�@EA�LNKBAOOEKJAAH�KB�LNER`�IAP�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�PA�I=GAJ�DAABP� KKG�@ACAJAJ�IAP�CAAJ�KB�IEJ@AN�O?D=@A¡�DAP�>AOP�>AQ�EO� =H�VEFJ�@ACAJAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�DAP�JAP�S=P�IAAN�>AQ¡���

�ANRKHCAJO�DA>>AJ�SA�>AGAGAJ�EJ�DKARANNA�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A�CA=OOK?EAAN@�EO�IAP�>AJ=@ANAJ@A�AJ�=BSEFGAJ@A�CA@N=CEJCAJ�KRAN�DAP�CADAAH�CAJKIAJ� =HHA�EPAIO�>EF�

¿Ã�

Page 50: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

AHG==N¡���EP�DA>>AJ�SA�CA@==J�@KKN�RANO?DEHHAJ�EJ�VKCAJ==I@A�B=?PKNO?KNAO�PA�>ANAGAJAJ� ��J�ECQQN�Â�¾�VEAJ�SA�@=P�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�DKCAN�O?KNAJ�KL�Ä

@A�KJPSEFGAJ@A�I=JEAN�R=J�KIC==J�IAP�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG�@=J�@A�=J@ANA�CNKALAJ���EP�RANO?DEH�EO�JEAP�PA�VEAJ�>EF�@A�>AJ=@ANAJ@A�I=JEAN�R=J�KIC==J�IAP�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG��

ECQQN�Â�¾�� �=?PKNO?KNAO �Ä��R=J�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�O?D=@AJERA=QO�KL�@A�PSAA�I=JEANAJ�R=J�KIC==J�IAP�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=HHAJ

�AH=PEA�?KLEJCOPN=PACEAbJ�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�

�ANRKHCAJO�=J=HUOANAJ�SA�KB�AN�AAJ�NAH=PEA�EO�PQOOAJ�@A�I=JEAN�R=J�KIC==J�IAP�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@���A�NE?DPAJ�KJO�DEAN>EF�OLA?EBEAG�KL�@A�CNKAL�IAJOAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�KI@=P�VEF�EJ�RANCAHEFGEJC�IAP�@A�=J@ANA�CNKALAJ�R=GAN�SKN@AJ�CA?KJBNKJPAAN@�IAP�@A�OPNAOOKN��O?D=@A����

�J�ECQQN�Â�¿�VEAJ�SA�@=P�AN�>EF�@AVA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�EJ@AN@==@�AAJ�NAH=PEA�EO�PQOOAJ�?KLEJC�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�� �>AJ=@ANAJ@A ��?KLEJC�CA@N=CEJCAJ�VEFJ�CA=OOK?EAAN@�IAP�>APANA�CAVKJ@DAE@���AP�KICAGAAN@A�L=PNKKJ�VEAJ�SA�>EF�@A� �KJPSEFGAJ@A� �>AJ=@ANEJC��KJPSEFGAJ@A�CA@N=CEJCAJ�VEFJ�CA=OOK?EAAN@�IAP� �IAAN ��CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ���

�AP�EO�DEAN>EF�SAH�>AH=JCNEFG�KI�KL�PA�IANGAJ�@=P�SA�JEAPO�GQJJAJ�VACCAJ�KRAN�?=QO=HEPAEP��DAP�G=J�VEFJ�@=P�RKKN�EAI=J@�IAP�AAJ�OHA?DPA�CAVKJ@DAE@�KJPSEFGEJC�@A�AJECA�I=JEAN�EO�KI�JKC�KI�PA�C==J�IAP�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG���APVAHB@A�CAH@P�RKKN�>AJ=@ANEJC��S=JJAAN�IAJ�AAJ�CKA@A�CAVKJ@DAE@�DAABP�EO�DAP�IKCAHEFG�I=GGAHEFGAN�KI�>AJ=@ANAJ@�CA@N=C�PA�RANPKJAJ��

��KKN�EA@ANA�@AAHJAIAN�SKN@P�==J�@A�D=J@�R=J�VEFJ�=JPSKKN@AJ�KL�@A�EJ@ERE@QAHA�EPAIO�EJ�?KI>EJ=PEA�IAP�@A�B=?PKNH=@EJCAJ�R=J�@EA�EPAIO��>ANAGAJ@�EJ�SAHGA�I=PA�@A�@AAHJAIAN�KL�@A�B=?PKN�O?KKNP���A�B=?PKNO?KNAO�VAHB�VEFJ�JEAP�EJPANLNAP=>AH��SAH�GQJJAJ�VA�CA>NQEGP�SKN@AJ�KI�CNKALAJ�IAP�AHG==N�PA�RANCAHEFGAJ���

¿Ä�

Page 51: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Â�¿�� �AVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ�=BCAVAP�PACAJ�B=?PKNO?KNAO�Ä��RKKN�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A��IAP�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=HHAJ

� �

À»�

Page 52: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

Ã���=IAJD=JC�AJ�O=IAJSANGEJC� ��EP�AAN@ANA�N=LLKNPAJ�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�>HEFGP�DKA�>AH=JCNEFG�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�O=IAJSANGEJC�>EJJAJ�>QQNPAJ�AJ�SEFGAJ�RKKN�>ASKJANO�EO���PANGAN�JKC��DAND==H@AHEFG�EO�CA>HAGAJ�@=P�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�IAP�>QNAJ�AAJ�>QBBAN�RKNIP�RKKN�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ��J==NI=PA�>ASKJANO�VE?D�IAAN�RAN>KJ@AJ�RKAHAJ�IAP�DQJ�@KNL�KB�>QQNP��DA>>AJ�VA�IEJ@AN�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ���KG�SAPAJ�SA�@=P�@AVA�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�PKAJAAIP�=HO�>ASKJANO�IAAN�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ���EP�C==P�CAL==N@�IAP�OKHE@=NEPAEP�CAKNEbJPAAN@A�D=J@AHEJCAJ��IAJ�@AAHP�EJBKNI=PEA�AJ�DAHLP�AHG==N�KIC==J�IAP�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG� �PNKA>A�AP�=H���½»¼Ä=¡����I�>APAN�PA�>ACNEFLAJ�SAHGA�NKH�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�O=IAJSANGEJC�EJ�@A�>QQNP�OLAHAJ��DA>>AJ�SA�EJ�½»¼Ä�BK?QOCNKAL>EFAAJGKIOPAJ�IAP�>ASKJANO�CADKQ@AJ���AJPN==H�OPKJ@�DEANEJ�@A�RN==C����==NKI�RANO?DEHHAJ�@KNLAJ�AJ�CAIAAJO?D=LLAJ�EJ�@A�I=PA�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�O=IAJSANGEJC����EP�N=LLKNP�HARAN@A�AAJ�==JP=H�GANJEJ@E?=PKNAJ�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�KL��VK=HO�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�AAJ�CA@AAH@�>AH=JC�AJ�CAV=IAJHEFGA�REOEA��==JSAVECDAE@�R=J�AAJ�?AJPN=HA�KJPIKAPEJCOLHAG��AAJ�B=?EHEPANAJ@A�CAIAAJPA�AJ�DAP�S==N@ANAJ�R=J�@ERANOEPAEP����J�@A�IAPEJC�R=J�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä�DA>>AJ�SA�@AVA�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�RAN@AN�KJ@ANVK?DP�@KKN�AJGAHA�RN=CAJ�DEANKRAN�KL�PA�JAIAJ�EJ�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP���A�SEH@AJ�@A�RKHCAJ@A�RN=CAJ�>A=JPSKKN@AJ� �

¼� �QJJAJ�SA�@A�EJ@E?=PKNAJ�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC��@EA�QEP�@A�BK?QOCNKALAJ�J==N�RKNAJ�GS=IAJ��RANP=HAJ�J==N�AAJ�RN=CAJHEFOP� GS=JPEP=PEARA�EJ@E?=PKN¡��

½� �L�SAHGA�I=JEAN�@N==CP�@AVA�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�>EF�==J�DAP�KIC==J�IAP�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ��

�K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�

�A�I=PA�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�EO�CAIAPAJ�IAP�VARAJ�RN=CAJ� SAANCACARAJ�EJ��=>AH�Ã�¼¡��@EA�CA>=OAAN@�VEFJ�KL�@A�GANJLQJPAJ�@EA�EJ�@A�BK?QOCNKALAJ�IAP�>ASKJANO�RAAHRQH@EC�CAJKAI@�SAN@AJ���AVA�VARAJ�RN=CAJ�VEFJ�O=IAJCARKAC@�PKP�AAJ�O?D==H�@EA�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�GS=JPEP=PEAB�IAAP��KBSAH�AAJ�?EFBANI=PECA�EJ@E?=PKN�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���I�PA�>AL=HAJ�DKA�>APNKQS>==N�AAJ�CNKAL�RN=CAJ�O=IAJ�EO��I=GAJ�SA�CA>NQEG�R=J�@A�OP=PEOPEO?DA�I==P����NKJ>=?D�O��HLD=����=JJAAN�@A�S==N@A�R=J�@AVA�I==P�PQOOAJ�@A�»�Â�AJ�@A�¼�HECP��IKCAJ�SA�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�@=P�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�RN=CAJ�>APNKQS>==N�O=IAJCAJKIAJ�GQJJAJ�SKN@AJ���JVA�EJ@E?=PKN�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�D=@�AAJ��NKJ>=?D�O�=HLD=�R=J�»�ÃÀ���EANQEP�IKCAJ�SA�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�@=P�SA�KL�>=OEO�R=J�@A�VARAJ�RN=CAJ�QEP�P=>AH�Ã�¼�O=IAJCAJKIAJ��AAJ�>APNKQS>=NA�GS=JPEP=PEARA�EJ@E?=PKN�DA>>AJ�KJPSEGGAH@�RKKN�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���

À¼�

Page 53: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�=>AH�Ã�¼�����N=CAJ�KL�>=OEO�S==NR=J�GS=JPEP=PEARA�EJ@E?=PKN�RKKN�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�EO�O=IAJCAOPAH@���

�J�IEFJ�@KNL�KB�>QQNP����

�VEFJ�AN�RAAH�CAV=IAJHEFGA�EJEPE=PEARAJ�

�VKNCAJ�IAJOAJ�RKKN�AHG==N�

�VEFJ�AN��G=NPNAGGANO��@EA�DAP�EJEPE=PEAB�JAIAJ�

�DKKNP�EA@ANAAJ�AN>EF� KJCA=?DP�=BGKIOP��EJVAP�RKKN�DAP�@KNL�>QQNP¡�

�@AJGP�@A�CAIAAJPA�IAA�KRAN�E@AAbJ�AJ�SAJOAJ�R=J�>ASKJANO�

�VEFJ�AN�KJPIKAPEJCOLHAGGAJ�RKKN�>ASKJANO�

�VEFJ�SA�DAP�AAJO�KRAN�@KNLOV=GAJ�>QQNPV=GAJ�

�EP�KJ@ANVKAG�SAPAJ�SA�@=P�@A�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�EJ�AAJ�>QQNP�>EF@N==CP�==J�@A�SAAN>==NDAE@�R=J�IAJOAJ���KG�PNAGGAJ�IAJOAJ�FQEOP�J==N�AHG==N�PKA�S=JJAAN�VA�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ�IAAI=GAJ��VK=HO�AAJ�PANNKNEOPEO?DA�==JOH=C�KB�AAJ�=J@ANA�=?QPA�N=IL� VEA�KJ@AN�IAAN��NQNU��½»¼¼�AJ��KNNEO���PARAJO���BABBAN>=QI���U?DA��x��BABBAN>=QI��½»»Ã¡���J�DKARANNA�@N==CP�AAJ�IAAN�?DNKJEO?DA�N=IL��VK=HO�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�EJ�NKJEJCAJ��ARAJAAJO�>EF�==J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���AJ�AANOPA�EJ@E?=PEA�REJ@AJ�SA�S=JJAAN�SA�GEFGAJ�J==N�@A�NAH=PEA�PQOOAJ�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A�AJ�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���J�ECQQN�Ã�¼�VEAJ�SA�@=P�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�IAP�O?D=@A� ``J�GAAN�AJ�IAANRKQ@EC¡��OECJEBE?=JP�DKCAN�O?KNAJ�KL�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC��@=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�VKJ@AN�O?D=@A���AP�EO�AAJ�GHAEJ�ABBA?P��I==N�DAP�H==P�VEAJ�@=P�IAJOAJ�IAP�O?D=@A�VE?D�EAPO�IAAN�IAP�=J@ANAJ�RAN>KJ@AJ�RKAHAJ��VEF�PNAGGAJ�J==N�AHG==N�PKA���EP�EO�@AAHO�AAJ�=JPSKKN@�KL�KJVA�PSAA@A�RN==C��SA�VEAJ�@QO�@=P�IAJOAJ�@EA�EAPO�EJCNEFLAJ@O�IAAI=GAJ��KKG�IAAN�J==N�AHG==N�PKAPNAGGAJ���

À½�

Page 54: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Ã�¼�� ��K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC��IAPEJC�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä��AO?D=PPA�CAIE@@AH@AJ�AJ�ÄÀÎ�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H

�K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ�

�A�OPAH@AJ�R=OP�@=P�AN�AAJ�PKAJ=IA�HEFGP�PA�VEFJ�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�KJ@AN�IAJOAJ�IAP�O?D=@A���N==CP�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�KKG�>EF�==J�SAAN>==NDAE@�R=J�>ASKJANO���A�KJ@ANVK?DPAJ�KB�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�CA=OOK?EAAN@�EO�IAP�@A�I=PA�S==NEJ�>ASKJANO�KKG� CAV=IAJHEFG¡�KIC==J�IAP�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ���=J�>ASKJANO�EO�CARN==C@�EJ�DKARANNA�VA�EJ�DAP�RANHA@AJ�KB�NA?AJP�=HO�@KNL�KB�>QQNP�AAJ�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEO�DA>>AJ�IAACAI==GP���ANRKHCAJO�GKJ@AJ�VA�==JCARAJ�S=P�RKKN� �CA@N=C�VA�RANPKKJ@AJ�J==N�==JHAE@EJC�R=J�@AVA�VAHB�CAGKVAJ�CA>AQNPAJEO ���J�@A�=J=HUOAO�EO�@==NJ=�¼»

KJ@ANO?DAE@�CAI==GP�PQOOAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�AAJ�C=OSEJJEJCO�CANAH=PAAN@A�CA>AQNPAJEO�JKAI@AJ�AJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�@EP�JEAP�@A@AJ���

¼»��EF�@EP�OKKNP�KJ@ANVKAG�EO�DAP�>AH=JCNEFG�@=P�@A�R=NE=>AHAJ�@EA�FA�KJ@ANVKAGP��EJ�@EP�CAR=H�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�CA@N=C��SAH�PSAA�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�KJ@ANHECCAJ@A�?KJ?ALPAJ�SAANCARAJ��GQJ�FA�OP=PEOPEO?D�CAVEAJ�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�KJ@ANO?DAE@AJ�R=J�CA@N=C�@=P�DEANIAA�PA�I=GAJ�DAABP�VK=HO�DQHL�>EA@AJ�KB�EJBKNI=PEA�VKAGAJ���EP�DA>>AJ�SA�AANOP�RE=�B=?PKN�=J=HUOAO�AJ�?KNNAH=PEAO�CAPKAPOP���EP�@AVA�=J=HUOAO�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�SA�@=P�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�CA@N=C�EJ@AN@==@�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�?KJ?ALPAJ�IAPAJ��

À¾�

Page 55: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�ANOPA�EJDKQ@AHEFGA�=J=HUOAO�R=J�@A��EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ �� VEA�>EFH=CA�½¡�H=PAJ�VEAJ�@=P�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�AAJ�CNKPA�RANO?DAE@AJDAE@�==J�KJ@ANSANLAJ�JKAIAJ�S=JJAAN�SA�DAJ�RNKACAJ�KRAN�@A�IAAOP�EJCNEFLAJ@A�RAN=J@ANEJC�EJ�DQJ�@KNL�KB�>QQNP��VK=HO�@A�OHQEPEJC�R=J�AAJ�O?DKKH��@A�LH==POEJC�R=J�SEJ@PQN>EJAO�KB�CAIAAJPAHEFGA�DANEJ@AHEJC���=P�DEAN>EF�KLR=HP�EO�@=P�@A�IAAOPA�R=J�@AVA�KJ@ANSANLAJ�PA�I=GAJ�DA>>AJ�IAP�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�NAH=PEAO�IAP�=J@ANAJ��DAP�RAN@SEFJAJ�R=J�==JPNAGGAHEFGA�KJPIKAPEJCOLHAGGAJ��HARAJ@ECDAE@�R=J�DAP�@KNL��RAN=J@AN@A�NAH=PEAO�AJ�CAOLNAGGAJ�PQOOAJ�>QQNPCAJKPAJ�@KKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG��AJ�RANHEAO�R=J�E@AJPEPAEP�@KKN�CAIAAJPAHEFGA�DANEJ@AHEJCAJ���==N>EF�VEAJ�SA�@=P�RAN=J@ANEJCAJ�@EA�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�RAN>APANAJ��>EFRKKN>AAH@�@KKN�DAP�PKARKACAJ�R=J�LQ>HEAGA�KJPIKAPEJCOLHAGGAJ��=HO�LKOEPEARA�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ�SKN@AJ�CAJKAI@���A�EJOP=J@DKQ@EJC�AJ�>ARKN@ANEJC�R=J�NAH=PEAO�AJ�RAN>KJ@AJDAE@�IAP�=J@ANAJ�>EJJAJ�AECAJ�>QQNP�KB�@KNL�SKN@AJ�@QE@AHEFG�=HO�>AH=JCNEFG�ANR=NAJ���

�QHL�>EA@AJ�AJ�EJBKNI=PEA�@AHAJ�

�AJ�R=J�@A�IAAOP�RKKN�@A�D=J@�HECCAJ@A�RKNIAJ�R=J�CA@N=C�@=P�VKQ�GQJJAJ�RKKNPRHKAEAJ�QEP�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�EO�DAP�CARAJ�R=J�DQHL�AJ�DAP�@AHAJ�R=J�EJBKNI=PEA���A�HAC@AJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�PSAA�OPAHHEJCAJ�RKKN�KRAN�@A�I=PA�R=J�DQHL�@EA�VA�>EA@AJ�==J�=J@ANAJ��J==N�==JHAE@EJC�R=J�@A�@KKN�DAJ�>AO?DNARAJ�CA>AQNPAJEO���A�SEH@AJ�SAPAJ�EJ�DKARANNA�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC��VK=HO�CAIAPAJ�IAP�@A�AAN@AN�CAJKAI@A�VARAJ�EPAIO��CA=OOK?EAAN@�EO�IAP�DAP�>EA@AJ�R=J�DQHL�AJ�DAP�@AHAJ�R=J�EJBKNI=PEA��ECQQN�Ã�½�PKKJP�@A�QEPGKIOPAJ�R=J�@AVA�=J=HUOA��S==NEJ�KKG�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�O?D=@A�AJ�AAJ�==JP=H�?KJPNKHAR=NE=>AHAJ��VK=HO�HAABPEF@�AJ�CAOH=?DP�VEFJ�KLCAJKIAJ� ��A�BECQQN�H==P�VEAJ�@=P�¼¼

DAP�>EA@AJ�R=J�DQHL�AJ�DAP�@AHAJ�R=J�EJBKNI=PEA�DAP�OPANGOP�VEFJ�CANAH=PAAN@�==J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���EF�EAI=J@�@EA�``J�LQJP�DKCAN�O?KKNP�KL�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC��OPEFCP�DAP�CAIE@@AH@A�R=J��DQHL�>EA@AJ�AJ�EJBKNI=PEA�@AHAJ����AP�PKP=HA�IK@AH�RANGH==NP�AAJ�GHAEJA�¼ÃÎ�R=J�@A�R=NE=JPEA�EJ��DQHL�>EA@AJ�AJ�EJBKNI=PEA�@AHAJ����=P�>APAGAJP�@=P�SA�IAP�@AVA�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�B=?PKNAJ�>EFJ=�AAJREFB@A�R=J�@A�RANO?DEHHAJ�EJ�=JPSKKN@AJ�GQJJAJ�RANGH=NAJ���A�GQJJAJ�DEANQEP�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�@=P�S==NCAJKIAJ�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�OPANG�O=IAJD=JCP�IAP�DAP�KL�C=JC�>NAJCAJ�R=J�DQHL�AJ�DAP�@AHAJ�R=J�EJBKNI=PEA��PAJ�PEF@A�R=J�AAJ�CA>AQNPAJEO���=IAJR=PPAJ@��>APAGAJP�@EP�@=P�SA�GQJJAJ�VACCAJ�@=P�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�EJ@AN@==@�AAJ�CAIAAJO?D=L�DAHLP�IAP�DAP�KIC==J�IAP�AAJ�CA>AQNPAJEO��IAJ�RANHAAJP�IAAN�DQHL�==J�AHG==N�AJ�@AAHP�IAAN�EJBKNI=PEA��

�ICAGAAN@�>APAGAJP�@EP�@=P�IAJOAJ�@EA�H==C�O?KNAJ�KL�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC��IEJ@AN�CAJAEC@�VEFJ�KI�DQHL�PA�>EA@AJ�AJ�EJBKNI=PEA�PA�@AHAJ���==N�@=P�DKQ@P�JEAP�EJ�@=P�VA�

¼¼��J�@AVA�=J=HUOA�I==GPAJ�SA�AAJ�NACNAOOEAIK@AH�IAP�=HHAND=J@A�?KJPNKHA�R=NE=>AHAJ�VK=HO�HAABPEF@�AJ�CAOH=?DP��VAHBCAN=LLKNPAAN@A�O?D=@A�AJ�KJVA�O=IAJCAOPAH@A�I==P�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���A�=BD=JGAHEFGA�R=NE=>AHA�@EA�SA�LNK>ANAJ�PA�RKKNOLAHHAJ�EO�DEAN��DQHL�>EA@AJ�AJ�EJBKNI=PEA�@AHAJ����A�=BD=JGAHEFGA�R=NE=>AHA�EO�O=IAJCAOPAH@�QEP�PSAA�EPAIO��S==NKRAN�AAJ�CAIE@@AH@A�EO�CAJKIAJ���A�CAP=HHAJ�EJ�@A�BECQQN�VEFJ�KJCAOP=J@==N@EOAAN@A�ABBA?PAJ�AJ�@A�OPANNAPFAO�CARAJ�==J�KB�AAJ�ABBA?P�OECJEBE?=JP�EO���RANECA�L=N=IAPANO�EJ�DAP�IK@AH�SKN@AJ�DEAN�JEAP�SAANCACARAJ��I==N�SKN@AJ�SAH�>AJKAI@�EJ�@A�PAGOP�EJ@EAJ�JK@EC���

À¿�

Page 56: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

L=OOEAB�>HEFRAJ�AJ�JEAPO�@KAJ���J@ANA�=J=HUOAO�H=PAJ�J=IAHEFG�VEAJ�@=P� RANIEJ@AN@A¡�O=IAJD=JC�JEAP�EO�CANAH=PAAN@�==J�JEAPO�@KAJ�EJ�NA=?PEA�KL�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ���L�>=OEO�DEANR=J�HEFGP�DAP�@=P�IAJOAJ�@EA�SAEJEC�O=IAJD=JC�N=LLKNPANAJ��SAHHE?DP�KL�AAJ�=J@ANA�I=JEAN�NA=CANAJ�KL�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ���

ECQQN�Ã�½�H==P�KKG�VEAJ�@=P�AN�AAJ�ABBA?P�HEFGP�PA�VEFJ�R=J�DAP�=H�@=J�JEAP�>AJKAIAJ�R=J�AAJ�C=OSEJJEJCO�CANAH=PAAN@A�CA>AQNPAJEO���AJOAJ�@EA�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�JKAIAJ��VEFJ�IAAN�CAJACAJ�KI�DQHL�PA�>EA@AJ�AJ�EJBKNI=PEA�PA�@AHAJ�@=J�IAJOAJ�@EA�=J@ANA�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ�JKAIAJ���EP�ABBA?P�DAABP�A?DPAN�AAJ�DAAH�>NAA@�>APNKQS>==NDAE@OEJPANR=H��S=P�>APAGAJP�@=P�@EP�ABBA?P�IEJ@AN�=??QN==P�EO���EP�GKIP�@KKN@=P�OHA?DPO�AAJ�NAH=PEAB�GHAEJ�==JP=H�IAJOAJ�AAJ�C=OSEJJEJCO�CANAH=PAAN@A�CA>AQNPAJEO�JKAI@A��S==N@KKN�AJECA�RKKNVE?DPECDAE@�>EF�@A�EJPANLNAP=PEA�JK@EC�EO���

ECQQN�Ã�½����K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�=HO�RKKNOLAHHAN�R=J�DQHL�>EA@AJ�AJ�EJBKNI=PEA�@AHAJ��AOP=J@==N@EOAAN@A�ABBA?P�?KbBBE?EbJPAJ�

ÀÀ�

Page 57: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

AV=IAJHEFGA�REOEA�

�J�==JRQHHEJC�KL�DAP�RAN>=J@�PQOOAJ�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�AJ�DQHL�EJBKNI=PEA��>HEFGP�@=P�KKG�DAP�DA>>AJ�KB�KJPSEGGAHAJ�R=J�AAJ��CAV=IAJHEFGA�REOEA�� ��A�S=NAJ�DAP�IAP�AHG==N�AAJO�DKA�SA�IAP�@AVA�RAN=J@ANEJC�IKAOPAJ�KIC==J�¡�RAN>=J@�DKQ@P�IAP�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC� ECQQN�Ã�¾¡���EP�>APAGAJP�@=P�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�KKG�H=JCO�@AVA�SAC�AAJ�>AH=JCNEFGA�NKH�G=J�OLAHAJ�>EF�DAP�PKP�OP=J@�GKIAJ�R=J�KLHKOOEJCAJ�RKKN�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEOOAJ���=IAJD=JC�G=J�I=GAJ�@=P�AN�AAJDAE@�R=J�CA@=?DPA�EO��AAJ�RKKNS==N@A�RKKN�AAJDAE@�R=J�D=J@AHEJC���

ECQQN�Ã�¾����K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�=HO�RKKNOLAHHAN�R=J��CAV=IAJHEFGA�REOEA�

�BBE?=?U�

�J�==JRQHHEJC�KL�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�AAJ�CAV=IAJHEFGA�REOEA��VEAJ�SA�@=P�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�RAN>=J@�DKQ@P�IAP��DAP�CARKAH�DA>>AJ�KI�EAPO�CAV=IAJHEFG�==J�PA�GQJJAJ����A�@QE@AJ�@EP�KKG�SAH�==J�=HO��ABBE?=?U����BBE?=?U�RKNIP�AAJ�>AH=JCNEFGA�B=?PKN�@EA�>EF@N==CP�==J�=?PEA>ANAE@DAE@�R=J� CNKALAJ¡�IAJOAJ�AJ�@EA�>AL==HP�KB�SA�ANCAJO�CAV=IAJHEFG�@A�O?DKQ@ANO�KJ@AN�VAPPAJ���A�@AJGAJ�@==NKI�@=P�RE=�AAJ�CARKAH�R=J�ABBE?=?U��OK?E=HA�

ÀÁ�

Page 58: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

O=IAJD=JC�>EF@N==CP�==J�DKA�IAJOAJ�IAP�AAJ�EJCNEFLAJ@A�CA>AQNPAJEO�KIC==J��ECQQN�Ã�¿��H==P�VEAJ�@=P���NAGAJEJC�DKQ@AJ@�IAP�=HHAND=J@A�B=?PKNAJ���OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�EJ@AN@==@�AAJ�OPANGA�RKKNOLAHHAN�EO�R=J�ABBE?=?U���A�NAOQHP=PAJ�OQCCANAJ�@=P�KI�O=IAJ�KI�PA�C==J�IAP�AAJ�CA>AQNPAJEO�KB�CNKPA�RAN=J@ANEJC��IAJOAJ�?KHHA?PEAB�DAP�CARKAH�IKAPAJ�DA>>AJ�@=P�DAP�VA�@==@SANGAHEFG�EAPO�==J�@A�OEPQ=PEA�GQJJAJ�RAN>APANAJ���

ECQQN�Ã�¿�� ��K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�=HO�RKKNOLAHHAN�R=J��ABBE?=?U�

�@AJPEBE?=PEA�=HO�>AH=JCNEFGA�B=?PKN���

�J�@A�SAPAJO?D=LLAHEFGA�HEPAN=PQQN�VEFJ�RAAH�NAOQHP=PAJ�>AO?DNARAJ�@EA�J=QS�KRANAAJGKIAJ�IAP�@A�NAOQHP=PAJ�KL�CA>EA@�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�@EA�SA�DEAN>KRAJ�N=LLKNPANAJ� >EFR���H@NE?D��½»¼½���NQNU���NKSJ��KJVXHAV��x��EN=J@=��½»¼Á¡����KG�EJ�RAAH�=J@ANA�OEPQ=PEAO�H==P�KJ@ANVKAG�VEAJ�@=P�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�HAE@P�PKP�IAAN�O=IAJSANGEJC�AJ�OK?E=HA�OPAQJ���KKN�@=P�ABBA?P�VEFJ�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�RANGH=NEJCAJ�IKCAHEFG��DAP�G=J�GKIAJ�@KKN@=P�@A�>QNAJ�AHG==N�DAHLAJ� AAJ�HAPPANHEFG�OKKNP�JK=>ANO?D=L�PQOOAJ�>QNAJ��S==N>EF�IAJ�AHG==N�SA@ANGANEC�KJ@ANOPAQJP¡�KB�@KKN@=P�IAJ�VE?D�RAN>KJ@AJ�RKAHP�IAP�DAP�CNKPANA�CADAAH� AAJ�RKNI�R=J�E@AJPEBE?=PEA�IAP�@A�

ÀÂ�

Page 59: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

LHAG�S==N�IAJ�SKKJP��@EA�SA�EJ�NEAOH=J@�DANGAJJAJ�EJ�@A�NKH�@EA�@A��IEAJOGEL��OLAAHP�EJ�DAP�HARAJ�R=J�>ASKJANO¡���A�AANOPA�RKNI�C==P�IAAN�?KJ?NAAP�KRAN�QEPSEOOAHEJC�PQOOAJ�EJ@ERE@QAHA�>QNAJ�AJ�GAJJEOOAJ� KJ@ANHEJCA�OPAQJ�PQOOAJ�>QNAJ¡�@A�PSAA@A�KRAN�RAN>KJ@AJDAE@�AJ�DAP�ANR=NAJ�R=J�AAJ�SEF�CARKAH� E@AJPEBE?=PEA�IAP�@A�>QQNP¡�� �

�EPAN==N@�VEFJ�>AE@A�RKNIAJ�R=J�RAN>KJ@AJDAE@�J=QS�IAP�AHG==N�RANSARAJ�AJ�@QO�KKG�OPANG�==J�AHG==N�CANAH=PAAN@���==N�=HO�SA�EJ�==JRQHHAJ@A�=J=HUOAO�LNK>ANAJ�@AVA�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�RKNIAJ�R=J�RAN>KJ@AJDAE@�PA�KJ@ANO?DAE@AJ��@=J�>HEFGP�@=P�E@AJPEBE?=PEA�IAP�HKPCAJKPAJ� ��A�RKAH@AJ�KJO�KL�@=P�IKIAJP�RAN>KJ@AJ�IAP�AHG==N�¡�EJ�=HHA�IK@AHHAJ�@A�IAAOPA�R=NE=JPEA�EJ�CA@N=C�RANGH==NP� PKP�SAH�¾ÄΡ���EP�H==P�VEAJ�@=P�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�AAJ�CA@AAH@A�E@AJPEPAEP�AAJ�OPANGAN�RAN>=J@�DKQ@P�IAP�@A�CA@N=COQEPGKIOPAJ�@EA�SA�KJ@ANVK?DPAJ� DQHL�>EA@AJ�EJBKNI=PEA�@AHAJ��CAV=IAJHEFGA�REOEA��ABBE?=?U¡�@=J�=HHA�=J@ANA�B=?APPAJ�R=J�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC���VAHBO�@=J�@A�O=IAJCAOPAH@A�O?D==H�>AOP==J@A�QEP�=HHA�B=?APPAJ�ANR=J�@EA�SA�DEAN�LNAOAJPANAJ���

�==N�KI@=P�=H�@EA�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�B=?APPAJ�VK�J=QS�O=IAJD=JCAJ��EO�DAP�PK?D�PA�GKNP�@KKN�@A�>K?DP�KI�PA�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�@=P�E@AJPEBE?=PEA�DAP�AJECA�EO�@=P�AN�PKA�VKQ�@KAJ��EJ�KJVA�KCAJ�OLAHAJ�KJ@ANHEJCA�NAH=PEAO�AJ�JAPSANGAJ�SAH�@ACAHEFG�AAJ�?NQ?E=HA�NKH�EJ�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC��I==N�@QE@AHEFG�EO�@=P�LOU?DKHKCEO?D�CAVEAJ�DAP� �E@AA� �R=J��KJO��=HO�CAIAAJO?D=L�AAJ�?AJPN=HA�NKH�OLAAHP�EJ�DAP�CA@N=C�@=P�IAJ�FACAJO�=J@ANAJ�RANPKKJP���A�>=J@�IAP�DAP�CNKPANA�CADAAH�RKNIP�VK�EJ�>AH=JCNEFGA�I=PA�DAP�CA@N=C�FACAJO�@A�>QQNPCAJKPAJ�@EA�AN�KJ@AN@AAH�R=J�QEPI=GAJ���

�KNPKI��=HO�FA�J=�SEH�C==J�EJ�DKARANNA�>ASKJANO�AAJ�DA?DPA�CAIAAJO?D=L�RKNIAJ��@=J�GQJ�FA�@=P�R=OPOPAHHAJ�@KKN�@A�I=PA�R=J�E@AJPEBE?=PEA�PA�IAPAJ� EG�RKAH�IA�RAN>KJ@AJ�IAP�>QQNP>ASKJANO¡�KB�@KKN�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�PA�LAEHAJ� IAP�@A�Â�EPAI�O?D==H�@EA�SA�LNAOAJPANAJ¡���@AJPEBE?=PEA�>HEFGP�AAJ�S=P�>APANA�RKKNOLAHHAN�RKKN�?KHHA?PEAB�CA@N=C�PA�VEFJ��=H�RKKNOLAHP�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�KKG���KKN�>AHAE@OI=GANO�EO�@A�OK?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC�O?D==H�D=J@V=IAN��DAP�CAABP�?KJ?NAPA�==JSEFVEJCAJ�RKKN�O=IAJD=JC� >EFR��EO�AN�AAJ�?AJPN=HA�KJPIKAPEJCOLHAG¡���

� �

ÀÃ�

Page 60: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

���J@ANJAIANO�

�=JHAE@EJC��

NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�DAABP�RAAH�==J@=?DP�>AOPAA@�==J��>ASKJANO� �R=J�@A�LNKREJ?EA�NKJEJCAJ���J@AN�@AVA�>ASKJANO�EO�AAJ�OLA?EBEAGA�CNKAL�@EA�J==OP�>ASKJAN�KKG�KJ@ANJAIAN ��EO�EJ�@A�LNKREJ?EA���KKN�HA@AJ�R=J�KJVA�GH=JG>KN@CNKAL�AJ�@A�>ACAHAE@EJCO?KIIEOOEA�SAN@AJ�SA�ANKL�CASAVAJ�@=P�@A�OEPQ=PEA�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�==J@=?DP�RAN@EAJP��CAVEAJ�@A�OLA?EBEAGA�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO���KG�EJ�KJVA�RN=CAJHEFOPAJ�SAVAJ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KJO�NACAHI=PEC�KL�@A�EJCASEGGAH@A�LNK>HAIAJ�S==N�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAA�PA�I=GAJ�GQJJAJ�GNEFCAJ��

�I�AAJ�>APAN�>AAH@�PA�GNEFCAJ�R=J�@A�OEPQ=PEA�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO��@A�ARAJPQAHA�LNK>HAIAJ�S==NIAA�VA�G=ILAJ�AJ�DQJ�PKAGKIOPLANOLA?PEAB��DA>>AJ�SA�EJ�@A�=BCAHKLAJ�IAPEJC� I==NP�½»½»¡�AAJ�==JP=H�OLA?EBEAGA�RN=CAJ�CAOPAH@�==J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�KJO�>ASKJANOL=JAH���?DPANHECCAJ@A�RN==C�EO�KB�AJ�DKA�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�==N@>AREJCOCA>EA@�RANO?DEHHAJ�R=J�@EA�R=J�>ASKJANO�VKJ@AN�KJ@ANJAIEJC���

�NEbJPANAJ@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�

�I�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�L=JAH�@A�FQEOPA�RN=CAJ�PA�OPAHHAJ�DA>>AJ�SA�>ACEJ�½»½»�AJGAHA�KNEbJPANAJ@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�CARKAN@�IAP�IAJOAJ�@EA�CKA@�KL�@A�DKKCPA�VEFJ�R=J�@A�OEPQ=PEA�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�C=OSEJJEJCOCA>EA@���AP�C==P�KI�AAJ�RANPACAJSKKN@ECAN�R=J�DAP�NKJEJCAN�=O>AN==@��AAJ�=@REOAQN�R=J�@A����AJ�AAJ�VAOP=H�KJ@ANJAIANO�@=P�SA�OLN=GAJ�PEF@AJO�AAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO>EFAAJGKIOP�CAKNC=JEOAAN@�@KKN�@A�NKJEJCAN��K@AI��ASACEJC��

�J�@AVA�CAOLNAGGAJ�SKN@P�PAJ�AANOPA�@QE@AHEFG�@=P�O?D=@A�==J�@A�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ�@KKN�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�JEAP�AJGAH�BUOEAGA�O?D=@A�>APNABP��I==N�KKG�@ERANOA�=J@ANA�RKNIAJ�R=J�O?D=@A��NALQP=PEAO?D=@A��RANIEJ@AN@A�GNA@EAPS==N@ECDAE@��RANOHA?DPAN@�EJRAOPANEJCOGHEI==P��KJVAGANDAE@���PEF@RANHEAO��KIVAP@=HEJC�@KKN@=P�>ASKJANO�IEJ@AN�QEPCARAJ��KIVAP@=HEJC�@KKN�PEF@AHEFGA�OHQEPEJC�R=JSACA�RANOPANGEJC��>KAGDKQ@GQJ@ECA�LNK>HAIAJ��AP�?APAN=���AVA�@ERANOEPAEP�==J�RKNIAJ�R=J�O?D=@A�PAGAJP�@A�?KILHATEPAEP�R=J�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO���

�A�LHQNEBKNIEPAEP�R=J�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG�R=J�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ�I==GP�DAP�KLOPAHHAJ�AJ�PKAL=OOAJ�R=J�CAJANEAGA�NACAHO�AJ�NACAHEJCAJ�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�H=OPEC��VK�SKN@P�EJ�@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�KLCAIANGP�� ��AAH�NACAHEJCAJ�RKKN�L=NPE?QHEANAJ�IAP�O?D=@A�VEFJ�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�JEAP�PKAC=JGAHEFG�KB�JEAP�L=OOAJ@� ���A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�SA�OLN=GAJ�IANGAJ�@==NKRAN�KL�@=P�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DQJ�KCAJ�@A�=BCAHKLAJ�F=NAJ�EO�RANS==NHKKO@�AJ�@=P�AN�RKKNN=JC�EO�CACARAJ�==J�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG�R=J�L=NPE?QHEANAJ��IKCAHEFG�KI@=P�RKKN�KRANDA@AJ�AJ�EJOP=JPEAO�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�PA�

ÀÄ�

Page 61: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

?KILHAT�VEFJ���AP�CANEJCA�==JP=H�NACAHEJCAJ�@=P�AN�EO�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�GKIP�RKHCAJO�DAJ�IKAEHEFG�R=J�@A�CNKJ@���A�IANGAJ�>KRAJ@EAJ�KL�@=P�AAJ�@AAH�R=J�LNK>HAIAJ�S==NIAA�VEF�G=ILAJ�@KKN�EJOP=JPEAO�SKN@AJ�SACCAVAP�=HO��NACQHEAN�KJ@ANJAIANONEOE?K����A�RKAHAJ�VE?D�KJRKH@KAJ@A�CAGAJ@�AJ�CAOPAQJ@�EJ�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�@EA�VEF�ANR=NAJ�PAJ�CARKHCA�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC��

ARN==C@�J==N�@A�ARAJPQAHA��RKKN@AHAJ ��R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�SKN@P�EJ�@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�KLCAIANGP�@=P�@AVA��>ALANGP ��VEFJ���KKN�OLA?EBEAGA�>N=J?DAO�EO�DAP�IKCAHEFG�KI�PA�LNKBEPANAJ�R=J�@A�OEPQ=PEA��S==N>EF�@A�RAN@QQNV=IEJCO>N=J?DA��=HO�RKKN>AAH@�SKN@P�CAJKAI@���AH�RN==CP�@EP�RKHCAJO�>APNKGGAJAJ�AAJ�BHATE>AHA�DKQ@EJC�R=J�@A�>APNABBAJ@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�AJ�@A�>ANAE@DAE@�`J�@A�BEJ=J?EbHA�IE@@AHAJ�KI�>AL==H@A�NEOE?K�O�PA�JAIAJ��>EFRKKN>AAH@�EJ�@A�RKNI�R=J�KIO?DKHEJC���Q>OE@EANACAHEJCAJ�AJ�=J@ANA�OPEIQHANEJCOCAH@AJ�@EA�>A@KAH@�VEFJ�KI�DAP�KJ@ANJAIEJCOGHEI==P�EJ�@A�NACEK�PA�RAN>APANAJ��>EA@AJ�RKHCAJO�>APNKGGAJAJ�RKKN=H�LANOLA?PEAB�RKKN�JEAQSA�KJ@ANJAIANO�AJ�RKKN�CNKPANA�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ���AOP==J@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�VEAJ�SAEJEC�IKCAHEFGDA@AJ�KI�R=J�@A�>AO?DEG>=NA�IE@@AHAJ�PA�LNKBEPANAJ��

�EP�@EP�=HHAO�OLNAAGP�AAJ�CNKPA�>ADKABPA�==J�IAAN�==J@=?DP�RKKN�@A�LNK>HAIAJ�>EF�KJ@ANJAIANO���==N�PACAHEFG�CARAJ�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�SEF�OLNAGAJ�==J��@=P�DAP�RKKN�DAJ�H=OPEC�EO�KI�@AVA�LNK>HAIAJ�==J�PA�G==NPAJ�>EF�KJ@ANJAIANOKNC=JEO=PEAO�AJ�KRANDA@AJ���==N>EF�OLAAHP�AAJ�NKH�@=P�IAJ�>AOP==J@A�LNK>HAIAJ�HEARAN�JEAP�KLAJHEFG�>AJKAIP�AJ�>AOLNAAGP���AJ�EO�>ARNAAO@�@=P�@A��NALQP=PEA ��R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIEJC�DEANKJ@AN�G=J�HEF@AJ���A�J=@NQG�HECP�EJ�@A�?KJP=?PAJ�IAP�EJOP=JPEAO�AJ�KRANDA@AJ�@=J�KKG�KL�@A�G=JOAJ�AJ�@A�PKAGKIOP��

�RAN�@A� �NKH�R=J�HKG=HA�AJ�NACEKJ=HA�KRANDA@AJ ��VEFJ�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�SEF�OLNAGAJ�JEAP�PARNA@AJ��AIAAJPAJ�@KAJ�EJ�DQJ�KCAJ�JEAP�VK�RAAH���A�NAHAR=JPEA�R=J�@A�LNKREJ?EA�EO�DQJ�JEAP�@QE@AHEFG��IAJ�SAAP�JEAP�CKA@�S=P�IAJ�R=J�@A�LNKREJ?EA�G=J�RANS=?DPAJ���

�L>KQS�RN=CAJHEFOP�

�L�>=OEO�R=J�@A�EJBKNI=PEA�QEP�@A�KNEbJPANAJ@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�DA>>AJ�SA�EJ�@A�OQNRAU�KI�PA�>ACEJJAJ�AJGAHA�RN=CAJ�KLCAJKIAJ�KRAN�@A� �I=PA�S==NEJ�KJ@ANJAIANO�J=@AHAJ�AJ�RKKN@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@AJ ��R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���A�DA>>AJ�>EF�DAP�KLOPAHHAJ�R=J�=JPSKKN@?=PACKNEAbJ�RKKN�@AVA�RN=CAJ�CA>NQEG�CAI==GP�R=J�@A�RKKN��AJ�J=@AHAJ�@EA�EJ�@A�KNEbJPANAJ@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�@A�NARQA�S=NAJ�CAL=OOAAN@��I==N�PARAJO�NQEIPA�CA>K@AJ�KI�@EP�==J�PA�RQHHAJ�IAP�=J@ANA�RKKN��AJ�J=@AHAJ����A�DA>>AJ�@A�L=JAHHA@AJ�>KRAJ@EAJ�CARN==C@�AAJ�GKNPA�PKAHE?DPEJC�PA�CARAJ�KL�@A�CAGKVAJ�=JPSKKN@?=PACKNEAbJ���

�A�>APNKGGAJAJ�C=RAJ�EJ�@A�KNEbJPANAJ@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�>KRAJ@EAJ�==J�@=P�DAP�R=J�>AH=JC�EO�VE?DP�PA�GNEFCAJ�KL�@A� �PKAGKIOPREOEA ��R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�NACEK��DKA�VEAJ�VEF�@A�PKAGKIOP�R=J�DQJ�>A@NEFB���J�DKARANNA�SKN@P�@EP�PKAGKIOP>AAH@�>AfJRHKA@�@KKN�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���KG�EO�DAP�RKHCAJO�>APNKGGAJAJ�R=J�>AH=JC�KI�PA�SAPAJ�S=P�@A�>ADKABPA�EO�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO��IAP�SAHGA�N�ACAHEJCAJ�KB�I==PNACAHAJ�V�KQ@AJ�

Á»�

Page 62: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

KJ@ANJAIANO�CADKHLAJ�VEFJ���KG�@AVA�RN=CAJ���KRAN�PKAGKIOP�AJ�KRAN�I==PNACAHAJ���VEFJ�KLCAJKIAJ�EJ�@A�OQNRAU���

�KP�OHKP�DA>>AJ�SA���KL�>=OEO�R=J�KLIANGEJCAJ�R=J�@A�>APNKGGAJAJ�KRAN�DAP�>AH=JC�R=J�@AVA�CNKAL���AJGAHA�RN=CAJ�PKACARKAC@�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�EJ�@A�=BCAHKLAJ�F=NAJ�VEFJ�CAOPKLP�IAP�DQJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC ����=J�DAJ�SEH@AJ�SA�CN==C�SAPAJ�KB�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�AAJ�NKH�DA>>AJ�CAOLAAH@�>EF�DAP�OPKLVAPPAJ�R=J�DQJ�>A@NEFB�KB�LN=GPEFG���A�RKHHA@ECA�RN=CAJHEFOP�EO�KLCAJKIAJ�EJ�>EFH=CA�¼���

�EPGKIOPAJ�OQNRAU�

�A�OQNRAURN=CAJ�VEFJ�EJ�I==NP�½»½»�QEPCAVAP�KJ@AN�@A�L=JAHHA@AJ�AJ�VEFJ�EJCARQH@�@KKN�¿»Â�KJ@ANJAIANO��

�AO?DNEFREJC�GAJIANGAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO�

�=>AH�Ä�¼�CAABP�AAJ�KRANVE?DP�R=J�@A�GAJIANGAJ�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�DA>>AJ�@AAHCAJKIAJ�==J�@A�OQNRAU���NEA�GS=NP�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ� ÁÂΡ�EO�AAJ�VAHBOP=J@EC�KJ@ANJAIAN�VKJ@AN�LANOKJAAH� ���¡��PANSEFH�AAJ�REFB@A� ½»Î¡�LANOKJAAH�EJ�@EAJOP�DAABP���A�KRANECA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�DA>>AJ�EJCARQH@��SANGAJ�=HO�IAASANGAJ@�CAVEJOHE@�EJ�DAP�>A@NEFB�KB�@A�LN=GPEFG�R=J�AAJ�B=IEHEAHE@� ¼¾Î¡���KKN�NQEI�@A�DAHBP�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ� À¿Î¡�CAH@P�@=P�@A�@ENA?PA�NACEK�DQJ�RKKNJ==IOPA�=BVAPI=NGP�RKNIP���

¾ÃÎ�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�SANGP�R=JQEP�DQJ�AECAJ�SKKJDQEO���AJ�RANCAHEFG>==N�==J@AAH�SANGP�R=JQEP�>A@NEFBOL=J@AJ���AVA�VEFJ�JEAP�EJ�=HHA�CAR=HHAJ�AECAJ�>AVEP�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIEJC��RKKN�½ÀÎ�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�CAH@P�@=P�AN�``J�KB�IAAN@ANA�>A@NEFBOL=J@AJ�EJ�DAP�>AVEP�VEFJ�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIEJC���

�J�DAP�L=JAH�VEPPAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO�QEP�@A�CADAHA�LNKREJ?EA���=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�DA>>AJ�EJCARQH@��DAABP�ÂÄÎ�AAJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC�@EA�CARAOPEC@�EO�EJ�DAP�CA>EA@�@=P�@KKN�@A�����EO�==JCAIANGP�=HO�CA>EA@�S==N�IAJOAJ�O?D=@A�GQJJAJ�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���¿ÄÎ�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�DAABP�AAJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC�>EJJAJ�@A�RKKNI=HECA�>EJJAJ?KJPKQNAJ�R=J�@A�������S=P�NQSSAC�G=J�SKN@AJ�>AO?DKQS@�=HO�DAP�VS==NOP�CAPNKBBAJ�CA>EA@�� �¼½

�A�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�L=JAH�RANPACAJSKKN@ECAJ�AAJ�CNKPA�@ERANOEPAEP�==J�OA?PKNAJ���AP�==J@AAH�KJ@ANJAIANO�QEP�@A�OA?PKN�=@REOANEJC��KJ@ANVKAG�AJ�V=GAHEFGA�@EAJOPRANHAJEJC�EO�IAP�¼ÃÎ�DAP�CNKKPOP��CARKHC@�@KKN�=GGAN>KQS�AJ�RAAPAAHP� ¼½Î¡�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@OVKNC�AJ�SAHVEFJ� ARAJAAJO�¼½Î¡���J@ANA�RAAH�RKKNGKIAJ@A�OA?PKNAJ�VEFJ�?QHPQQN��OLKNP�AJ�NA?NA=PEA�� ¼¼Î¡��@AP=EHD=J@AH�AJ�CNKKPD=J@AH� ¼»Î¡�AJ�@A�>KQSOA?PKN� ÄΡ��

¼½��KKN�AAJ�PKAHE?DPEJC�KL�@AVA�?KJPKQNHEFJAJ��VEA�DAP�N=LLKNP� ���KKN�O?D=@A�SEFVAN��DAP�LNK?AO�R=J�O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�AJ�D==N�CAO?DEA@AJEO�� � �KOPIAO�AP�=H���½»½»¡�

Á¼�

Page 63: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�=>AH�Ä�¼����AJIANGAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO� �Ó¿»Â¡�

�ULA�KJ@ANJAIEJC� � � �A?PKN� �

�AHBOP=J@ECA�VKJ@AN�LANOKJAAH� ���¡�ÁÂÎ� � �@REOANEJC��KJ@ANVKAG�AJ�

V=GAHEFGA�@EAJOPRANHAJEJC�¼ÃÎ�

�AHBOP=J@ECA�IAP�LANOKJAAH� ½»Î� � �GGAN>KQS�AJ�RAAPAAHP� ¼½Î�

�AASANGAJ@�CAVEJOHE@� ¼¾Î� � AVKJ@DAE@OVKNC�AJ�SAHVEFJ� ¼½Î�

�BVAPI=NGP� � � �QHPQQN��OLKNP�AJ�NA?NA=PEA� ¼¼Î�

�ACEK� À¿Î� � �AP=EH��AJ��CNKKPD=J@AH�� ¼»Î�

�A@ANH=J@� ¿½Î� � �KQS� ÄÎ�

�QEPAJH=J@� ¿Î� � �AGOP��KJPSANL��RKNICAREJC� ÀÎ�

�K?=PEA�SANGV==IDA@AJ� � � �KNA?=� ¿Î�

�ECAJ�SKKJDQEO� ¾ÃÎ� � ���� ¾Î�

�J�>A@NEFBOL=J@ AJ¡� ¾ÂÎ� � �N=JOLKNP� ½Î�

�EF�GH=JPAJ� ½ÀÎ� � �=LLANO�AJ�LA@E?QNAO� ½Î�

�ECAJ�>A@NEFBOL=J@�� � � �RANECA�@EAJOPRANHAJEJC� ¼Î�

=� ½ÀÎ� � �ERANOAJ� ¼»Î�

�AA� ÂÀÎ� � � �

�A@NEFBOHK?=PEA� � � � �

�EJJAJ�>EJJAJ?KJPKQNAJ����� ¿ÄÎ� � � �

�QEPAJ�@A�>EJJAJ?KJPKQNAJ������I==N�>EJJAJ�@A�����?KJPKQNAJ�

¾»Î� � � �

�QEPAJ�=HHA�?KJPKQNAJ� ¼ÀÎ� � � �

�J>AGAJ@� ÁÎ� � � �

�ANCAHEFGEJC�KJ@ANJAIANO�AJ�JEAP�KJ@ANJAIANO�

�A�DA>>AJ���KL�>=OEO�R=J�@A�>AO?DEG>=NA�@=P=�QEP�OALPAI>AN�½»¼Ä�AJ�I==NP�½»½»���KI�PA�>ACEJJAJ�CAGAGAJ�J==N�@A�O?KNAO�KL�@A�RAEHECDAE@��NEOE?KLAN?ALPEA�AJ�CAVKJ@DAE@�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�KJO�L=JAH���==N>EF�>HEFGP�@=P�VEF��NAGAJEJC�DKQ@AJ@�IAP�=HHA�=J@ANA�B=?PKNAJ��VE?D�IEJ@AN�RAEHEC�RKAHAJ�@=J�JEAP�KJ@ANJAIANO���==N>EF�EO�AN�>KRAJ@EAJ�AAJ�OECJEBE?=JP�EJPAN=?PEA�ABBA?P�PQOOAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO?D=L�AJ�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A���A�NAOQHP=PAJ�H=PAJ�VEAJ�@=P�IAP�J=IA�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A�VE?D�KJRAEHECAN�RKAHAJ�@=J�JEAP�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAP�IAANRKQ@ECA�O?D=@A���=JCAVEAJ�ANR=NAJ�KJRAEHECDAE@�EJ�KJO�KJ@ANVKAG�R==G�O=IAJD=JCP�IAP�KJVAGANDAE@�KRAN�@A�PKAGKIOP��SEFOP�@EP�AN�IKCAHEFG�KL�@=P�@A�OEPQ=PEA�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJCASEGGAH@AN�AJ�LNA?=EN@AN�EO�@=J�RKKN�JEAP�KJ@ANJAIANO���EP�@A�=J@ANA�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�>HEFGP�@=P�KJ@ANJAIANO�CAAJ�IEJ@ANA�CAVKJ@DAE@�DA>>AJ�AJ�@=P�VEF�KKG�CAAJ�DKCAN�NEOE?K�S==NJAIAJ��

Á½�

Page 64: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�=P�>APNABP�@A�GANJR=NE=>AHAJ�R=J�NKJEJCO��ANOLA?PEAB�GQJJAJ�SA�@QO�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�@=P�KJ@ANJAIANO�@AVAHB@A�NEOE?K�O�S==NJAIAJ��@=P�VEF�IAAN�GKLVKNCAJ�DA>>AJ�KRAN�DQJ�RAEHECDAE@�I==N�@=P�@AVA�VKNCAJ�VE?D� JKC¡�JEAP�I=JEBAOPANAJ�EJ� OPNAOOCANAH=PAAN@A¡�CAVKJ@DAE@OGH=?DPAJ��

�=@AHAJ�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIEJC�

�A�DA>>AJ�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�OQNRAU�CARN==C@�EJ�DKARANNA�VEF�J=@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�EJ�@A�NACEK��S==N>EF�VA�GKJ@AJ�GEAVAJ�QEP�VAO�=JPSKKN@KLPEAO�R=NEbNAJ@�R=J��CAAJ�J=@AHAJ��PKP��DAAH�RAAH�J=@AHAJ��AJ��SAAP�EG�JEAP����=J�@A�NQEI�¿»»�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�L=JAH�ANR==NP�?EN?=�¿ÀÎ�AJECA�I=PA�R=J�J=@AAH� ECQQN�Ä�¼¡��

ECQQN�Ä�¼����A�I=PA�S==NEJ�KJ@ANJAIANO�J=@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�RKKN�DQJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC��EJ�Î� �Ó¿»À¡

�=@ANA�=J=HUOAO�H=PAJ�VEAJ�@=P�DAP�LAN?AJP=CA�KJ@ANJAIANO�@=P�J=@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@P�R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�==JVEAJHEFG�DKCAN�EO�KJ@AN�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAP�``J�KB�AJGAHA�AECAJ�L=J@AJ�@=J�KJ@AN�KJ@ANJAIANO�VKJ@AN�AECAJ�L=J@��»Î�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAP�AECAJ�L=J@�IAH@P�J=@AHAJ��RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�VKJ@AN�AECAJ�L=J@�EO�@=P�I==N�¾ÂÎ���A�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�DEANQEP�@=P�DAP�DA>>AJ�R=J�AAJ�>A@NEFBOL=J@�AAJ�NEOE?K�EO�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�==N@>AREJCOCA>EA@��

�A�I=PA�S==NEJ�KJ@ANJAIANO�J=@AHAJ�ANR=NAJ��R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�D=JCP�>KRAJ@EAJ�O=IAJ�IAP�@A�RAOPECEJCOHK?=PEA�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIEJC���AP�LAN?AJP=CA�KJ@ANJAIANO�@=P�J=@AHAJ�ANR==NP�EJ�@A�>EJJAJ?KJPKQN�R=J�@A�������DAP�CA>EA@�@=P�NQSSAC�G=J�SKN@AJ�>AO?DKQS@�=HO�VS==NOP�CAPNKBBAJ�CA>EA@���EO�DKKC� ÀÁΡ���J@ANJAIANO�>QEPAJ�@A�>EJJAJ?KJPKQN�I==N�>dJJAJ�DAP�ABBA?PCA>EA@�R=J�@A����� AAJ�

Á¾�

Page 65: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

NQEIANA�NEJC�KI�@A�GANJ�R=J�DAP�==N@>AREJCOCA>EA@��S==NKJ@AN�KKG�@A�OP=@�NKJEJCAJ�R=HP¡�CARAJ�KKG�EJ�AAJ�BKNO�==JP=H�CAR=HHAJ�==J�J=@AHAJ�PA�KJ@ANREJ@AJ� ¿¼Î¡���EF�KJ@ANJAIANO�SEAJO�KJ@ANJAIEJC�EO�CARAOPEC@�>QEPAJ�@EP�ABBA?PCA>EA@� EJ�OKIIECA�CAR=HHAJ�VAHBO�>QEPAJ�@A�LNKREJ?EA¡�CAABP�½¿�Î�==J�J=@AHAJ�PA�KJ@ANREJ@AJ��

�A�=BVAPI=NGP�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIEJC� RKKNJ=IAHEFG�>EJJAJ�@A�NACEK�KB�RKKNJ=IAHEFG�@==N>QEPAJ¡�HEFGP�CAAJ�RANO?DEH�PA�I=GAJ�RKKN�@A�I=PA�S==NEJ�IAJ�J=@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@P��R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�RKKNJ=IAHEFG�>EJJAJ�@A�NACEK�V=GAJ�@KAJ�ANR==NP�¿¾Î�J=@AHAJ��PANSEFH�@EP�>EF�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�RKKNJ=IAHEFG�>QEPAJ�@A�NACEK�V=GAJ�@KAJ��RKKN�¿ÃÎ�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�CAH@P��

�A�RNKACAJ�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�J=@AHAJ�VACCAJ�PA�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�KI�==J�PA�CARAJ�KI�SAHG�PULA�J=@AHAJ�DAP�C==P���A�GKJ@AJ�@==N>EF�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�=JPSKKN@KLPEAO�GEAVAJ�AJ�DEANKL�AAJ�PKAHE?DPEJC�CARAJ��ECQQN�Ä�½�PKKJP�@A�RAN@AHEJC�R=J�@AVA�PULA�J=@AHAJ���EANKJ@AN�SKN@P�EJCAC==J�KL�@AVA�J=@AHAJ��S==N>EF�CA>NQEG�SKN@P�CAI==GP�R=J�?EP=PAJ�QEP�@A�PKAHE?DPEJC�@EA�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CARAJ��

ECQQN�Ä�½����ULA�J=@AHAJ�@EA�KJ@ANJAIANO�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�EJ�Î� �Ó�¼Ã¿¡

�=OPCKA@CANAH=PAAN@A�KJGKOPAJ ��>HEFGAJ�DAP�IAAOP�RKKNGKIAJ@A�J=@AAH��@EP�=JPSKKN@�SKN@P�==JCAREJGP�@KKN�À»Î�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�J=@AHAJ�ANR=NAJ���J�@A�PKAHE?DPEJC�@==N>EF�RANSEFVAJ�VA�@KKNC==JO�J==N� GKOPAJ�R=J¡�O?D=@A�==J� >A@NEFBO¡L=J@AJ��

Á¿�

Page 66: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

��AAH�O?D=@A�==J�>A@NEFBOL=J@AJ�S==N@KKN�VA�KJRANGKKL>==N�VEFJ������?D=@A���KAP�PK?D�KLCAHKOP���=J�JEAP�S=?DPAJ�KL�LNK?A@QNAO���QO�HKOOAJ�SA�DAP�VAHB�KL������AOPGAH@AN�EO�HAG�AJ�@==N@KKN�PA�SAEJEC�IAOPKLOH=C�AJ�@QO�IAAN�IAOP�=BRKANAJ�RKKN�DKCA�P=NEARAJ���

�KASAH�O?D=@A�==J�R=OPCKA@�DEANIAA�SAHEOS==N�DAP�IAAOP�CAJKAI@A�J=@AAH�EO��>APAGAJP�@EP�KKG�@=P�ARAJAAJO�@A�DAHBP�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�R=OPCKA@CANAH=PAAN@A�KJGKOPAJ�EJ�DAP�CADAAH� �JEAP� �DAABP�CAJKAI@��PANSEFH�VA�SAH�==JCARAJ�J=@AHAJ�PA�ANR=NAJ�R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���AVA�QEPGKIOP�KJ@ANO?DNEFBP�DAP�>AAH@�@=P�QEP�@A�KNEbJPANAJ@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�J==N�RKNAJ�GS=I��BUOEAGA�O?D=@A�==J�L=J@AJ�EO�OHA?DPO�``J�R=J�@A�RKNIAJ�R=J�O?D=@A�@EA�KJ@ANJAIANO�KJ@ANREJ@AJ���KG�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�CAAJ�BUOEAGA�O?D=@A�DA>>AJ��GQJJAJ�J=@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���K�SKN@AJ�KKG�S==N@A@=HEJC��ATPN=�EJRAOPANEJC�R=J�PEF@��AAJ�RANOPKKN@A�>A@NEFBORKANEJC��DAP�JEAP�GQJJAJ�EJRAOPANAJ�AJ�KIVAP@ANREJC�@KKN�RAAH�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�=HO�J=@AAH�CAJKAI@��R=NEbNAJ@�R=J�½Â�PKP�¿»Î���EP�SKN@P�CAfHHQOPNAAN@�@KKN�KJ@ANOP==J@A�?EP=PAJ�R=J�KJ@ANJAIANO�QEP�@A�DKNA?=��@A�>KQS�AJ�@A�I=GAH==N@EF��

�ANOPKKN@A�>A@NEFBORKANEJC���IVAP@ANREJC�����==N@A@=HEJC����TPN=�EJRAOPANEJC�R=J�PEF@�������TPN=�EJRAOPANEJC�R=J�PEF@���ANOPKKN@A�>A@NEFBORKANEJC���EAP�GQJJAJ�EJRAOPANAJ���==N@A@=HEJC��

���?D=@A�@KAP�=B>NAQG�==J�DAP�CAVE?DP�AJ�?KIBKNP�R=J�¢IEFJ�>A@NEFB£���==G�=JJQHANEJCAJ�KI@=P�AN�O?D=@A�CAP=TAAN@�KB�DANOPAH@�IKAP�SKN@AJ���JVAGANDAE@�KRAN�@A�?KJPEJQfPAEP�R=J�@A�EJGKIOPAJ������=J@AJ�VEFJ�IEJ@AN�S==N@�CASKN@AJ�EJ�RANCAHEFGEJC�IAP�CA>EA@AJ�VKJ@AN�@AVA�LNK>HAI=PEAG������JKNI�RAAH�PEF@�GSEFP�IAP�KRANHAC��RANC=@ANEJCAJ��=@IEJEOPN=PEARA�H=OP��PEF@�AJ�CAH@�KLHAE@EJC�LANOKJAAH��OPAA@O�RAN=J@ANAJ@A�NACAHCAREJC�AJ�EJOP=JPEAO��H=JCA�S=?DPPEF@AJ�RKKN@=P�AN�EAPO�R=J�@A�CNKJ@�GKIP�VK=HO�>R�RANOPANGEJC�R=J�SKJEJCAJ�������AP�GKOP�CASKKJ�PEF@���JRAOPANEJCAJ�>HEFRAJ�QEP�KI@=P�DAP�KJVAGAN�EO�S=P�AN�IAP�DAP�L=J@�IKAP�CA>AQNAJ� RANOPANGAJ¡������==N@A�R=J�CA>KQSAJ�CA@==H@��A>KQSAJ�VEFJ�KKG�JKC�IEFJ�LAJOEKAJ��

ÁÀ�

Page 67: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

��ANOPKKN@A�>A@NEFBORKANEJC��

���=J�>QEPAJ�@A�LNKREJ?EA�NKJEJCAJ�VEAJ�SA�CAAJ�GH=JPAJ�IAAN��NKJEJCAJ�DAABP�AAJ�OHA?DP�EI=CK�@KKN�@A�>AREJCAJ���AN@AN�D=@@AJ�SA�RAAH�GH=JPAJ�@EA�@A�NQOP�R=J�NKJEJCAJ�GS=IAJ�KLVKAGAJ���

�AJ�GHAEJAN�@AAH�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�ANR==NP�LNK>HAIAJ�IAP�RANVAGANEJC�KB�BEO?QO� ÄΡ�KB�SANGJAIANOCANAH=PAAN@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG� ¿Î¡�� �

��JNKANAJ@AV==G>AH=OPEJC�DKQ@�CAAJ�NAGAJEJC�IAP�S==N@A@=HEJC�DEAN@KKN�IKAP�FA�OPAA@O�PEF@�RNEF�I=GAJ�KI�>AVS==N�EJ�PA�@EAJAJ���EAN�VKQ�KL�RKKND=J@�NAGAJEJC�IAA�IKAPAJ�SKN@AJ�CADKQ@AJ�VK@=P�@A�==JOH=C�L=OOAJ@�EO�AJ�>AVS==N�JEAP�JK@EC�EO���A�KJ@ANJAIEJC�EO�IEJ@AN�?KQN=JP�RKKN�KRANJ=IAO�� A�IKAP�=HHA�NACEOPANO�KLAJ�PNAGGAJ�NE?DPEJC�LNKREJ?EA�AJ�IAP�J=IA�KKG�@A�AECAJ�CAIAAJPA� ���¡�����ANOKJAAH�IKAP�DAAH�R==G�RNEF�JAIAJ�RKKN�O?D=@A�KLJ=IA�KB�DANOPAH��AJ�KKG�RKKN�AEJ@AHKKO�KRANHAC�I>P�RANOPANGEJC�R=J�DQJ�SKJEJC���

�=P�VEFJ��=HO�SA�@A�>=H=JO�KLI=GAJ��@A�>AH=JCNEFGOPA�?KJ?HQOEAO�KRAN�@A�J=@AHAJ�@EA�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ�KJ@ANREJ@AJ���JCARAAN�@A�DAHBP�KJ@ANREJ@P�AJECA�J=@AHAJ��IAP�J=IA�EJ�@A�GANJ�R=J�DAP�CA>EA@�AJ�@A�NEJC�ANKIDAAJ���EA�J=@AHAJ�VEFJ�AN�RKKN=H�>EF�KJ@ANJAIANO�IAP�AECAJ�>A@NEFBOL=J@ AJ¡���J@ANJAIANO�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�AAJ�>NAA@�OLA?PNQI�R=J�J=@AHAJ��PAV=IAJ�>ARAOPECAJ�VEF�DAP�>AAH@�QEP�@A�RANGAJJEJC�@=P�KJ@ANJAIANO�PA�I=GAJ�GQJJAJ�GNEFCAJ�IAP�?KILHATA�LNK>HAI=PEAG���

�KKN@AHAJ�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIEJC�

�KASAH�DAP�IANAJ@AAH�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�� ÂÄΡ�VACP�CAAJ�RKKN@AHAJ�PA�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC��ANR==NP�¼ÀÎ�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO� Á»�KJ@ANJAIANO¡�EJ�AJECA�I=PA�RKKN@AHAJ� SAEJEC�RKKN@AHAJ��ÁÎ��JEAP�RAAH��JEAP�SAEJEC�RKKN@AHAJ��ÁÎ��RAAH�RKKN@AHAJ��¾Î¡� ECQQN�Ä�¾¡����A�NAOPANAJ@A�ÁÎ�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CAABP�==J�JEAP�PA�SAPAJ�KB�VEF�RKKN@AHAJ�ANR=NAJ���A�SANGAJ�@AVA�NAOQHP=PAJ�DEANKJ@AN�RKKN�@A�RKHHA@ECDAE@�QEP��I==N�@A�?KJ?HQOEA�HEFGP�CANA?DPR==N@EC@�@=P�OHA?DPO�SAEJEC�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ�RKKN@AAH�DA>>AJ��J==N�AECAJ�VACCAJ���A�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ�@EA�==JCARAJ�S`H�RKKN@AAH�PA�DA>>AJ�VEFJ�KJ@AN�=J@ANA�==JJAIANO>A@NEFRAJ��>A@NEFRAJ�EJ�RAN@QQNV=IEJC�R=J�L=J@AJ��=@REOANEJC�KB� V=GAHEFGA¡�@EAJOPRANHAJEJC��

ÁÁ�

Page 68: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

ECQQN�Ä�¾����A�I=PA�S==NEJ�KJ@ANJAIANO�RKKN@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A��C=OSEJJEJC�RKKN�DQJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC��EJ�Î� �Ó¿»¾¡

ECQQN�Ä�¿����KKNP�RKKN@AHAJ�@=P�KJ@ANJAIANO�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�EJ�Î� �Ó�Á»¡

ECQQN�Ä�¿�PKKJP�@A�RAN@AHEJC�R=J�DAP�OKKNP�RKKN@AHAJ�@EA�VEF�KJ@ANREJ@AJ���AP�IAAOP�CAJKAI@�EO�KIVAPOPEFCEJC��¼Ã�KJ@ANJAIANO� ¾»Î�R=J�DAJ�@EA�RKKN@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@AJ¡�JKAIAJ�@EP���KKN�AHB�KJ@ANJAIANO� ¼ÃΡ�DA>>AJ�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�CAHAE@�PKP�JEAQSA�EJRAOPANEJCOG=JOAJ���

ÁÂ�

Page 69: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

��AJOAJ�@EA�DQJ�DQEO�RANOPANGAJ�C==J�@=P�R==G�@QQNV==I�@KAJ�AJ�@=J�GKIAJ�VA�EJ�IEFJ�OA?PKN������HHA�KNC=JEO=PEAO�@EA�VE?D�>AVECDKQ@AJ�IAP�KLHKOOEJCAJ�RKKN�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG�I=GAJ�KKG�AAJ�@ECEP=HA�PN=JOEPEA�@KKN�S==N�EG�VA�EJ�G=J�DAHLAJ �����

�LR=HHAJ@�EO�@=P�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@EA�==JCARAJ�RKKN@AHAJ�PA�KJ@ANREJ@AJ��NQEI�@A�DAHBP�PARAJO�J=@AHAJ�KJ@ANREJ@P���EP�H==P�VE?D�CKA@�EHHQOPNANAJ�@KKN�DAP�RKHCAJ@A�RKKN>AAH@�R=J�AAJ�AECAJ==N�R=J�AAJ�PN=JOLKNP>A@NEFB��

�KAHE?DPEJC�ANR=NAJ�J=@AAH�����AAH�IAJOAJ�S=?DPAJ�=B�IAP�@EJCAJ�PDQEO�PA�KJ@ANJAIAJ��VK=HO�RAN>KQSAJ�KB�PQEJ�==JL=GGAJ���A�SAPAJ�JEAP�S=P�AN�IAP�DQJ�DQEO�C==P�CA>AQNAJ��RANOPANGAJ�KB�JEAP�KB�JEAQS>KQS���G�HARAN�V=J@�AJ�CNKJ@�AJV��RKKN�==JHAC�R=J�PQEJ�A�@�����KAHE?DPEJC�ANR=NAJ�RKKN@AAH����AJ�AJGAHA�GAAN�I=C�EG�@EAJOPAJ�QEPRKANAJ�RKKN�>KQS>A@NEFRAJ�@EA�DQEVAJ�RANOPANGAJ��IAAOP=H�SKN@P�@EP�@KKN�>A@NEFRAJ�>QEPAJ�@AVA�NACEK�CA@==J���

�EP�@EP�=JPSKKN@�>HEFGP�>KRAJ@EAJ�@=P�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�NACEK�JEAP�R=JVAHBOLNAGAJ@�LNKBEPANAJ�R=J�@A�SANGCAHACAJDAE@�@EA�KJPOP==P�@KKN�@A�O?D=@A�AJ�RANOPANGEJC���J@ANOP==J@A�?EP==P�R=J�AAJ�AECAJ==N�R=J�AAJ�>KQS>A@NEFB�EHHQOPNAANP�@A�BNQOPN=PEA�@EA�@EP�RKKN�DAJ�IAP�VE?D�IAA>NAJCP��

��A�DA>>AJ�CAHQGGEC�RKH@KAJ@A�SANG��@AAHO�KKG�EJ�RANOPANGEJCAJ�@=JGVEF�IKJ@ECA�>ASKJANO���?DPAN�@A�OPNEF@�@EA�SEF�=HO�HKG=HA�KJ@ANJAIAN�IKAPAJ�RKANAJ�KI��AAJ�CN==JPFA�IAA�PA�LEGGAJ��EO�KJAANHEFG���AOPQQN@ANO� ��¡�KL�CAIAAJPAHEFG��LNKREJ?E==H�AJ�H=J@AHEFG�JERA=Q�VEAJ�KJO�JEAP��LN=PAJ�JEAP�IAP�KJO�I==N�JACANAJ�KJO���EP�EO�VK�RANO?DNEGGAHEFG�BNQOPNANAJ@���==NJ==OP�HEF@AJ�SEF�KJ@AN�@A�AJKNIA�>QNA=Q?N=PEO?DA�NKILOHKIL�R=J�@A������A�DA>>AJ�R=J@==C�L=O�EJOPNQ?PEAO�KJPR=JCAJ�KRAN�DKA�SA�IKCAJ�B=?PQNANAJ� ¼½�I==NP¡���?D=J@AHEFG��SEF�BEJ=J?EANAJ�=HHAO�RKKN���==NJ==OP�DAABP�AAJ�==JP=H�=I>PAJ=NAJ�AAJ�@A=H�CAOHKPAJ�IAP�AAJ�Á�P=H�CNKPA�==JJAIANO�AJ�VEAJ�AJ�DKNAJ�SEF�DEANKRAN�DAHAI==H�JEAPO����AVA�ANCANJEOOAJ�EJ�?KI>EJ=PEA�IAP�DAP�VAAN�OHA?DPA�SAAN�I==GP�IEF� AJ�RAHA�=J@ANAJ¡�AN�JEAP�CAHQGGECAN�KL����

ÁÃ�

Page 70: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�KAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�

�I�PA�KJ@ANVKAGAJ�EJ�SAHGA�I=PA�AJ�KL�SAHGA�SEFVA�DAP�PKAGKIOP>AAH@�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�NACEK�SKN@P�>AfJRHKA@�@KKN�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC��RNKACAJ�SA�KJ@ANJAIANO�KB�DQJ�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�OEJ@O�@A�OP=NP�R=J�@A�>AREJCAJ�LKOEPEARAN�KB�JAC=PEARAN�EO�CASKN@AJ�KB�DAPVAHB@A�EO�CA>HARAJ���A�NAOQHP=PAJ�DEANR=J�SKN@AJ�SAANCACARAJ�EJ�ECQQN�Ä�À���

ECQQN�Ä�À�� ��KAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�OEJ@O�>ACEJ�R=J�@A�>AREJCAJ�EJ�Î� �Ó¿»¾¡�

�KKN�NQEI�@A�DAHBP�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO� ÀÃΡ�>HEFGP�@=P�DQJ�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�OEJ@O�@A�OP=NP�R=J�@A�>AREJCAJ�JEAP�EO�RAN=J@AN@���LR=HHAJ@�EO�@=P�AAJ�==JVEAJHEFG�@AAH�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ� ¾¼Î¡�@EA�CAAJ�EIL=?P�KL�DQJ�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�==JCARAJ��EJ�AAN@ANA�RN=CAJ�S`H�DAABP�==JCACARAJ�J=@AHAJ�PA�KJ@ANREJ@AJ�R=J�@A�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���KKN�DAJ�HEFGAJ�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�KJ@=JGO�@AVA�J=@AHAJ�DQJ�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�JEAP�PA�>AfJRHKA@AJ���EP�SKN@P�CAfHHQOPNAAN@�@KKN�@A�RKHCAJ@A�?EP=PAJ��

��J@ANA�B=?PKNAJ�IAAN�R=J�EJRHKA@������A�D=J@AH�C==P�CASKKJ�@KKN����� A�HAANP�HARAJ�AJ�SANGAJ�IAP�@A�KJCAI=GGAJ�AJ�=?D��IAP�O?DAQNAJ�EJ�@A�IQQN�KJ@ANJAAI�FA�KKG�SAH���

ÁÄ�

Page 71: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�AJ�GS=NP�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�CAABP�==J�@=P�DQJ�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�OEJ@O�@A�OP=NP�R=J�@A�>AREJCAJ�JAC=PEARAN� ¼ÃΡ�KB�RAAH�JAC=PEARAN� ÂΡ�EO�CASKN@AJ���HA?DPO�AAJ�GHAEJ�@AAH�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ� ½Î¡�DAABP�AAJ�LKOEPEARANA�RANS=?DPEJC�R=J�@A�PKAGKIOP�CAGNACAJ�@KKN�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC���EP�>APNABP�RKKNJ=IAHEFG�>KQS>A@NEFRAJ��@EA�DANOPAH��AJ�RANOPANGEJCOSANGV==IDA@AJ�RANNE?DPAJ���

�=J�@A�ÄÄ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�SEAJO�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�OEJ@O�@A�OP=NP�R=J�@A�>AREJCAJ� RAAH¡�JAC=PEARAN�EO�CASKN@AJ��CARAJ�ÁÁ�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�DEANKL�AAJ�PKAHE?DPEJC����EF�JKAIAJ�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�B=?PKNAJ�@EA�RKKN�DAJ�AAJ�NKH�OLAHAJ�>EF�@AVA�JAC=PEARA�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC� ECQQN�Ä�Á¡���

ECQQN�Ä�Á����KAHE?DPEJC�R=J�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�KL�@A�JAC=PEARA�EJRHKA@�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�KL�@A�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�RKKN�DQJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC� �ÓÁÁ¡�

�AVA�B=?PKNAJ�RANPKJAJ�HKCEO?DANSEFO�KRANH=L�IAP�@A�J=@AHAJ�@EA�AAN@AN�EJ�@AVA�L=N=CN==B�==J�@A�KN@A�VEFJ�CAGKIAJ���K�SKN@AJ�O?D=@A�==J�L=J@AJ��KIVAP@ANREJC�AJ�S==N@A@=HEJC�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIEJC�CAJKAI@�@KKN�NAOLA?PEARAHEFG�½ÂÎ��½¼Î�AJ�¼½Î�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�@EA�DQJ�JAC=PEARA�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�PKAHE?DPAJ���

�K?D�>HEFGAJ�KKG�=J@ANA�B=?PKNAJ�AAJ�NKH�PA�OLAHAJ�>EF�JAC=PEARA�EJRHKA@�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�KL�@A�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�R=J�@AVA�KJ@ANJAIANO���K�NAH=PANAJ�

»�

Page 72: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

RANO?DEHHAJ@A�R=J�@AVA�KJ@ANJAIANO� ¼ÂΡ�DQJ�JAC=PEARA�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�==J�DQJ�CANEJCA�RANPNKQSAJ�EJ� @A�I==PNACAHAJ�R=J¡�@A�KRANDAE@���

��G�VEA�PA�SAEJEC�=?PEA�KL�@A�>AREJCAJ�AJ�RANS=?DP�@=J�KKG�JEAP�@=P�@EA�=?PEA�=HOJKC�V=H�GKIAJ���

��A�SKN@AJ�RKHGKIAJ�EJ�@A�OPAAG�CAH=PAJ��S=P�JKQ�NQEID=NPEC�O?D=@A�RANCKA@AJ���

�==NJ==OP�CARAJ�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�R=J�@AVA�KJ@ANJAIANO� ¼¿Î¡�==J�@=P�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�DQJ�>AAH@�R=J�@A�PKAGKIOP�JAC=PEAB�DAABP�>AfJRHKA@�KI@=P�VA�DAP�CARKAH�DA>>AJ�@=P�DQJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC�@KKN�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�EJ�@A�S=?DPOP=J@�OP==P���

��PEHOP=J@�EO�=?DPANQEPC=JC���

��KKN@=P�@A�KLHKOOEJC�KL�VE?D�H==P�S=?DPAJ�GQJJAJ�SA�KKG�JEAP�EJRAOPANAJ�KI�RKKNQEP�PA�GKIAJ���

�KP�OHKP�SKN@AJ�OPNAOO�KB�OL=JJEJC�AJ�DAP�RANOHA?DPAN@A�EI=CK�R=J�@A�NACEK�=HO�CADAAH�@KKN�AJGAHA�KJ@ANJAIANO�CAJKAI@�=HO�NA@AJAJ�RKKN�AAJ�JAC=PEARA�EJRHKA@�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�KL�@A�PKAGKIOPRANS=?DPEJC�R=J�DQJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC��

��EFJ�LANOKKJHEFG�BQJ?PEKJANAJ�HEF@P�KJ@AN�@A�PKAOP=J@���EFJ�SANGH=OP�EO�DKKC� ����¡��G�G=J�CAAJ�@=C�EJ�@A�SAAG�>AOPA@AJ�==J�O?D=@A�AJ�RANOPANGEJC��I==N�@=P�IKAP�SAH���G�C=�AN�OPQG�R=J��KRANSAAC�VAHBO�IAP�DAP�>A@NEFB�PA�OPKLLAJ��SA�HARAJ�I==N�¼T���

��A�NACEK�EO�CAAJ�==JPNAGGAHEFGA�RAOPECEJCOLH==PO� IAAN¡�RKKN�>ASKJANO�AJ�IE@@AJOP=J@ANO���

�AV=IAJ�OPAQJAJ�@AVA�NAOQHP=PAJ�DAP�>AAH@�@=P�@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�@A�KNEbJPANAJ@A�CAOLNAGGAJ�O?DAPOAJ�R=J�DQJ�DQE@ECA�OEPQ=PEA���EJ@O�DAP�>ACEJ�R=J�@A�==N@>AREJCAJ�EO�DAP�IAP�AAJ�@AAH�R=J�@A�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ�IEJ@AN�CKA@�CAC==J���N�VEFJ�I==N�VAAN�SAEJEC�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ�S==N�DAP�>APAN�IAA�C==P���

�AbEJ@EC@A�KJ@ANJAIEJCAJ�

�A�DEAN>KRAJ�>AO?DNARAJ�QEPGKIOPAJ�VEFJ�CA>=OAAN@�KL�@A�RN=CAJHEFOP�@EA�EO�RKKNCAHAC@�==J�@A�� �KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�NKJEJCAN��=JAH���N�VEFJ�KKG�½¾»�L=JAHHA@AJ�@EA�EJ�@A�=BCAHKLAJ�¼»�F==N�DQJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC�DA>>AJ�>AbEJ@EC@���A�RNKACAJ�@AVA� �RKKNI=HEC�

¼�

Page 73: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

KJ@ANJAIANO�KB�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�AAJ�NKH�DA>>AJ�CAOLAAH@�>EF�@A�>AbEJ@ECEJC�R=J�DQJ�>A@NEFB�KB�LN=GPEFG���EP�>HEFGP�RKKN�¼¿�R=J�DAJ�DAP�CAR=H�PA�VEFJ��

�AJ�==JP=H�R=J�DAJ�CAABP�==J�@=P�VEF��CAVEAJ�@A�VKNCAJ��@A�PEF@OEJRAOPANEJC�AJ�KRANH=OP�NKJ@�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG�DA>>AJ�>AOHKPAJ�KB�DA>>AJ�IKAPAJ�>AOHQEPAJ�DQJ�>A@NEFB� AAN@AN�@=J�CALH=J@¡�PA�>AbEJ@ECAJ�KB�RANGKLAJ���`J�R=J�DAJ�CAABP�==J�@KKN�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�=HHAO�PA�VEFJ�RANHKNAJ��VKSAH�VEFJ�>A@NEFB�=HO�VEFJ�CAVEJ�AJ�VEFJ�SKJEJC���

�J�=J@ANA�CAR=HHAJ�>HEFGP�QEP�@A�PKAHE?DPEJC�@=P�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�JEAP�@A�==JHAE@EJC� �RKNI@AJ�RKKN�@A�>AbEJ@ECEJC�R=J�DQJ�>A@NEFB��I==N�@=P�@A�C=OSEJJEJCOLNK>HAI=PEAG�DAP ��RANHKKL��R=J�@A�>AbEJ@ECEJC�SAH�EJ�OPANGA�I=PA�DAABP�>AfJRHKA@���KKN�@AVA�KJ@ANJAIANO�CAH@P�@=P�@A�KRANJ=IA�R=J�DQJ�KJ@ANJAIEJC�@KKN�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�IKAEV=IAN�EO�RANHKLAJ�AJ�KB�IEJ@AN�DAABP�KLCAHARAN@�@=J�VKJ@AN�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�DAP�CAR=H�VKQ�VEFJ���JGAHA�R=J�DAJ�CARAJ�==J�@=P�@EP�RKKN�DAJ�CNKPA�BEJ=J?EbHA�LNK>HAIAJ�DAABP�KLCAHARAN@��>EFRKKN>AAH@�KI@=P�VEF�DEANIAA�DQJ�LAJOEKAJ�V=CAJ�RAN@=ILAJ�KB�KI@=P�@KKN�@A�BEJ=J?EbHA�O?D=@A�AAJ�DANOP=NP�JEAP�IKCAHEFG�S=O��

�==PNACAHAJ�

�A�RNKACAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO� VKSAH�@A�DQE@ECA�KJ@ANJAIANO�=HO�@A�RKKNI=HEC�KJ@ANJAIANO¡�IAP�SAHGA�NACAHEJCAJ�KB�I==PNACAHAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO�EJ�DAP�C=OSEJJEJCOCA>EA@�RKHCAJO�DAJ�CADKHLAJ�VKQ@AJ�GQJJAJ�SKN@AJ���AVA�RN==C�EO�@KKN�¾ÁÄ� RKKNI=HEC¡�KJ@ANJAIANO�>A=JPSKKN@���

�AJ�CNKKP�@AAH�R=J�@A�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ� ¿ÀΡ�CAABP�==J�@=P�KJ@ANJAIANO�CADKHLAJ�VEFJ�IAP� �DANOPAH�AJ�KB�RANCKA@EJC�R=J�@A�O?D=@A ��@EA�@KKN�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�@A�C=OSEJJEJC�EO�KJPOP==J���J�OKIIECA�CAR=HHAJ�JKAIAJ�VA�@==N>EF�ATLHE?EAP�DANOPAH�R=J�O?D=@A�==J�CA>KQSAJ��PANSEFH�EJ�AAJ�=J@ANA�@AAH�R=J�@A�=JPSKKN@AJ�FQEOP�ATLHE?EAP�SKN@P�CANABANAAN@�==J�?KILAJO=PEA�R=J�=J@ANA�RKNIAJ�R=J�O?D=@A��VK=HO�S==N@A@=HEJC���J�DAP�IANAJ@AAH�R=J�@A�=JPSKKN@AJ�SKN@P�A?DPAN�JEAP�CAbTLHE?EPAAN@�SAHGA�O?D=@A�DANOPAH@�KB�CA?KILAJOAAN@�IKAP�SKN@AJ��I==N�SKN@P�EJ�=HCAIAJA�VEJ�CAOLNKGAJ�KRAN�DAP�RANCKA@AJ�R=J�@A�O?D=@A���JAHDAE@�AJ�NA?DPR==N@ECDAE@�VEFJ�@==N>EF�NACAHI=PEC�PANQCGANAJ@A�PDAI=�O��

��ANCKA@EJC�R=J�=HHA�@ENA?PA�AJ�EJ@ENA?PA�O?D=@A��KKG�RANIKCAJOO?D=@A�@KKN�S==N@A@=HEJC�>EF�RANGKKL�KB�KL�@A�>=H=JO����

��JAHHANA�ANGAJJEJC��AJ�QEPGANEJC�R=J�CAH@�RKKN�DANOPAH�R=J�@A�O?D=@A��

��ANHEFGDAE@��CKA@A�NACAHEJCAJ�RKKN�EA@ANAAJ�@EA�O?D=@A�DAABP���QEVAJ�KLJEAQS�KL>KQSAJ��@A�>ASKJANO�JEAP�==J�DAP�HEFJPFA�DKQ@AJ��

½�

Page 74: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

��?D=@A�DANOPAHHAJ� J==N�NA@AHEFGDAE@¡���

��JAHHANA�=BD=J@AHEJC�R=J�@A�@KKN�C=OSEJJEJC�KJPOP=JA�LNK>HAI=PEAG���

��QEID=NPECA�OPAQJ�==J�=HHA�OH=?DPKBBANO��@A�LKNPAIKJJAA�PNAGGAJ�VK=HO�>EF�?KNKJ=���

�==OP�DAP�?KILAJOANAJ�R=J�@A�O?D=@A�JKAIP�?EN?=�``J�KL�@A�REFB�NAOLKJ@AJPAJ�I==PNACAHAJ�AJ�NACAHEJCAJ�@EA�VEFJ�PA�?=PACKNEOANAJ�=HO� �BEJ=J?EbHA�OPAQJ� �==J�KJ@ANJAIANO��EJ�@A�NACEK����AP�C==P�@=J�>EFRKKN>AAH@�KI�OPAQJ�EJ�@A�RKNI�R=J�OQ>OE@EAO��JKK@BKJ@OAJ��OPEIQHANEJCOBKJ@OAJ��CQJOPECA�HAJEJCAJ�KB�>AH=OPEJCRKKN@AHAJ���

��AJAJ�KJ@AN�CQJOPECA�?KJ@EPEAO���

��QEID=NPECA�BEJ=J?EbHA�KJ@ANOPAQJEJC���

��=CAN������EJ�?KI>EJ=PEA�IAP�ATPN=�@QQNV==IDAE@OEJRAOPANEJCO=BPNAG���

��JRAOPANEJCOI==PNACAHAJ�VK=HO�>KQSAJ�VKJ@AN�������

�==NJ==OP�OQCCANANAJ�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�KJ@ANJAIANO�@=P�I==PNACAHAJ�PAN�>ARKN@ANEJC�R=J�@A� �SANGCAHACAJDAE@��EJ�@A�NACEK�SAHGKI�VEFJ���AAH�R=J�DAJ�JKAIAJ�@==N>EF�@=P�KL@N=?DPAJ�RKKN�O?D=@ADANOPAH�AJ�RANOPANGEJC�==J�HKG=HA�KJ@ANJAIANO�CACQJ@�VKQ@AJ�IKAPAJ�SKN@AJ���

��AP�LNKIKPAJ�R=J�=N>AE@OLH==POAJ���

��KRAAH�IKCAHEFG�>A@NEFRAJ�QEP�@A�NACEK�SANGV==IDA@AJ�H=PAJ�QEPRKANAJ���Q>OE@EAO�DEANRKKN���

��KG=HA�>A@NEFRAJ�CA>NQEGAJ�>EF�LNKFA?PAJ���Q�VEFJ�DAP�CNKPA��>QEPAJ�@A�NACEK�CARAOPEC@A�>A@NEFRAJ���

��KJOAMQAJPANA�HEFJ�P�=�R��EJO?D=GAHAJ�HKG=HA�>A@NEFRAJ�EJ�@A�C=OSEJJECOCASAOPAJ�I�>�P��DANOPAH�O?D=@A�C=OSEJJEJC���

�EP�@A�NA=?PEA�R=J�RAAH�KJ@ANJAIANO�KL�@A�RN==C�J==N�OQCCAOPEAO�RKKN�I==PNACAHAJ�AJ�NACAHEJCAJ�OLNAAGP�AAJ�@QE@AHEFGA��SAJO�RKKN�ANGAJJEJC�R=J�@A�LNK>HAI=PEAG���

¾�

Page 75: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

��EFJ�CARKAH�EO�@=P�AN�KL�@EP�IKIAJP�SAH�RAAH�==J@=?DP�EO�RKKN�O?D=@A�==J�SKJEJCAJ��I==N�@=P�O?D=@A�==J�>A@NEFBOCA>KQSAJ�IEJ@AN�==J@=?DP�GNEFCP���EAP�VKVAAN�AAJ�I==PNACAH��IAAN�==J@=?DP�==J�O?D=@A�==J�>A@NEFBOCA>KQSAJ��AJ�KJ@ANCNKJ@OA� IAOP¡GAH@ANO�VKQ�SAJOAHEFG�VEFJ���

��NGAJJEJC�@KKN��AJ��==C�AJ�R=J�@==NQEP�CAI==GPA�=BOLN=GAJ�J=GKIAJ���

��AAN�PKAJ=@ANEJC�R=JQEP�@A�����CAIAAJPAO�AJ�LNKREJ?EA���AAN�>ACNEL�AJ�KLHKOOEJCAJ�==J@N=CAJ�RKKN�HKG=HA�KJ@ANJAIANO���

��ACNEL�AJ�OPAQJ�AJ�CAAJ�H=GOA�>AOHQEPAHKKODAE@��

��QE@AHEFGDAE@���AJ�KRANDAE@� H=J@AHEFG��LNKREJ?E==H��CAIAAJPAHEFG¡�@EA�OPKLP�IAP�PN=EJANAJ�AJ�D==N�=BOLN=GAJ�J=GKIP���

�K=HO�>HEFGP�QEP�@A�H==POPA�PSAA�?EP=PAJ��CARAJ�KJ@ANJAIANO�PARAJO�==J�>ADKABPA�PA�DA>>AJ�==J�@QE@AHEFGDAE@��VKSAH�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�=HO�>ASKJANO�?KJOQIAJPAJ���`J�R=J�DAJ�VACP�DEANKRAN�DAP�RKHCAJ@A��

��AEHECDAE@�AJ�VAGANDAE@�>EA@AJ�==J�>ASKJANO�EJ�DAP�CAPNKBBAJ�CA>EA@���=JJAAN�IAJOAJ�RANPNKQSAJ�GNEFCAJ�AJ�SAAN�IAAN�LANOLA?PEAB��SKN@P�AN�KKG�SAAN�IAAN�>AOPAA@��@AJG�EG���

�A�?KJ?HQ@ANAJ�@=P�KJ@ANJAIANO�RANO?DEHHAJ@A�I==PNACAHAJ�VKQ@AJ�RANSAHGKIAJ�KI�DQJ�OEPQ=PEA�PA�RAN>APANAJ���AJ�CNKKP�@AAH�DAABP�>APNAGGEJC�KL�@A�RANCKA@EJC�R=J�O?D=@A��VKSAH�O?D=@A�==J�CA>KQSAJ��DAP�>A@NEFBOR=OPCKA@�EO�@QE@AHEFG�AAJ�VKNC�RKKN�KJ@ANJAIANO�S==N�VEF�VE?D�KJRKH@KAJ@A�EJ�CAOPAQJ@�RKAHAJ���==N�KKG�?KILAJO=PEA�R=J�=J@ANA�RKNIAJ�R=J� >A@NEFBO¡O?D=@A�GKIAJ�==J�>K@� >EFRKKN>AAH@�S==N@A@=HEJC�>EF�RANGKKL¡���KRAJ@EAJ�JKAIAJ�AJGAHA�KJ@ANJAIANO�=J@ANA�OPAQJI==PNACAHAJ�KB�>ARKN@ANEJC�R=J�SANGCAHACAJDAE@���JVA�EJ@NQG�EO�@=P�RAHAJ�VE?D�EJ�@A�OPAAG�CAH=PAJ�RKAHAJ��VEF�SEHHAJ�@=P�AN�==J@=?DP�EO�RKKN�@AVA�CNKAL�AJ�DQJ�?KILHATA�LNK>HAI=PEAG���

� �

¿�

Page 76: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�ABANAJPEAO�

�H@NE?D�������� ½»¼½¡�� ��QEH@EJC�NAOEHEAJ?A���K?E=H�?=LEP=H�EJ�LKOP�@EO=OPAN�NA?KRANU ����DE?=CK��

�����JERANOEPU�KB��DE?=CK��NAOO��

�NQNU�� �� ½»¼¼¡���KHHA?PERA�NAOEHEAJ?A�EJ�I=OO�AIANCAJ?EAO�=J@�@EO=OPANO����OK?E=H�

E@AJPEPU�IK@AH���J� �� APPAJ������=OH=I��x��������=OH=I� �@O�¡�� ��DA�OK?E=H�?QNA��

�@AJPEPU��DA=HPD�=J@�SAHH�>AEJC� ��¼ÄÀ�½¼Á���KRA���JCH=J@���OU?DKHKCU��NAOO��

�NQNU�� ����NKSJ������KJVXHAV������x��EN=J@=����� ½»¼Á¡���IANCAJP�OK?E=H�E@AJPEPU�=J@�

K>OANREJC�OK?E=H�OQLLKNP�LNA@E?P�OK?E=H�OQLLKNP�LNKRE@A@�>U�OQNRERKNO�EJ�=�

@EO=OPAN���KHE@=NEPU�EJ�PDA�½»¼»��DEHA�A=NPDMQ=GA����QNKLA=J� KQNJ=H�KB��K?E=H�

�OU?DKHKCU���¿Á��½»Ä�½½¾��@KE�¼»�¼»»½�AFOL�½¼¿Á�

�QCPEC��� ������PAN��KNO�AJ� ���APDHADAI� ½»¼Â¡���AP�IAPAJ�R=J�@A�CARKHCAJ�R=J�

==N@>AREJCAJ�KL�@A�HAAB>==NDAE@�EJ�NKJEJCAJ���AJ�IAPDK@KHKCEO?DA�NAREAS�

J==N�HAAB>==NDAE@OKJ@ANVKAGAJ���=PEKJ==H��KKN@EJ=PKN�NKJEJCAJ��

�AO�������AJ�������ACANOPNKI� ½»»Á¡���EOLKOEPEKJ=H��LPEIEOI�=J@��KLEJC�����AP=��J=HUPE?�

�AREAS����ANOKJ=HEPU�=J@��K?E=H��OU?DKHKCU��AREAS� �¼» ¾¡��½¾À�½À¼��

�KNNEO�������������PARAJO������BABBAN>=QI�������U?DA�AJ�������BABBAN>=QI� ½»»Ã¡��

�KIIQJEPU�NAOEHEAJ?A�=O�=�IAP=LDKN��PDAKNU��OAP�KB�?=L=?EPEAO��=J@�OPN=PACU�BKN�

@EO=OPAN�NA=@EJAOO����IANE?=J� KQNJ=H�KB��KIIQJEPU��OU?DKHKCU��¿¼��¼½Â�¼À»��

�KOPIAO��������@A� KJC����������?DKQPAJO���� ���@=IO�������R=J��AH@AJ�������

�KAJ@ANI=GAN������=JEO�AJ�����PNKA>A� ½»½»¡�� ��KKN�O?D=@A�SEFVAN���AP�LNK?AO�R=J�

O?D=@AIAH@EJCAJ�AJ�D==N�CAO?DEA@AJEO����AUI=JO��JOPEPQPA���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�

NKJEJCAJ���KSJHK=@>==N�RE=���DPPLO���SSS�CNKJEJCOLANOLA?PEAB�JH��

�PNKA>A����������KOPIAO������?DKQPAJO������KAJ@ANI=GAN������=JEO�� ���E?D=N@OKJ�����

�KRAJDKBB�� ���NKAN�AJ���NARAJ� ½»¼Ä?¡�� ��A�I==PO?D=LLAHEFGA�EIL=?P�R=J�@A�

>AREJC�R=J��AOPANSEFPSAN@ ����AUI=JO��JOPEPQPA���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ��

�KSJHK=@>==N�RE=���DPPLO���SSS�CNKJEJCOLANOLA?PEAB�JH��

ÂÀ�

Page 77: JDVZLQQLQJ LQ *URQLQJHQ · ==j@aah kj@anjaiano qep @a oa?pkn =@reoanejc kj@anvkag aj v=gahefga @eajopranhajejc eo iap ¼ÃÎ dap cnkkpop carkhc@ @kkn =ggan>kqs aj raapaahp ¼½Î¡

�PNKA>A����������KOPIAO������KAJ@ANI=GAN������=JEO�� ���E?D=N@OKJ������KRAJDKBB�� ���NKAN�

AJ���NARAJ� ½»¼Ä>¡�� �=OSEJJEJC�AJ�RANOPANGEJC��@A�OK?E=HA�EIL=?P�RKKN�

NKJEJCANO����AUI=JO��JOPEPQPA���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�NKJEJCAJ���KSJHK=@>==N�RE=��

DPPLO���SSS�CNKJEJCOLANOLA?PEAB�JH��

�PNKA>A����������KOPIAO������KAJ@ANI=GAN�� ���E?D=N@OKJ������KRAJDKBB�AJ�����=JEO�

 ½»¼Ä=¡����K?E=HA�O=IAJD=JC��O=IAJSANGEJC�AJ�RAANGN=?DP�EJ�DAP�NKJEJCOA�

C=OSEJJEJCOCA>EA@�� ��AUI=JO��JOPEPQPA���EFGOQJERANOEPAEP�

NKJEJCAJ� �DPPLO���SSS�CNKJEJCOLANOLA?PEAB�JH��

�=UHKN���������x��P=JPKJ�������� ½»»Â¡���KLEJC�NAOKQN?AO��?KLEJC�LNK?AOOAO��=J@�IAJP=H�

DA=HPD����JJQ=H��AREAS�KB��HEJE?=H��OU?DKHKCU��� �¾ ���¾ÂÂ�¿»¼��

ÂÁ�