Upload
animate-projects
View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
1/10
Interview with Alec Finlay on NavigationsWe talked to Alec Finlay in January 2013, when he was part way through
his Navigations 'residency' at the Beatson West of Scotland Cancer Centre,
Glasgow.
Navigations is supported by a Wellcome Trust Arts Award and is a collaboration
between Animate Projects, Paintings in Hospitals, and Professor Anthony
Chalmers and his teams at Beatson West of Scotland Cancer Centre and Beatson
Institute for Cancer Research.
Your practice takes different forms, different media, some of it is even ephemeral.
How do you talk about it? How do you describe it?
I dont. But the area I work in is shared consciousness. So that can exist in a poetic form
a formal quality that we might be able to recognise together.
In a circle poem, for instance, a space that we could both occupy, in looking at. We
would have a relationship to it, and that might be a bit more confidently shared than a
solipsistic, confessional poem, say.
Or I might make a building and that might be about sharing the quality of light. Or an
investigation into the characteristics of a woodland. So it does not matter to me what the
object is, or whether it is poetry or art.
I approve of what Ad Reinhardt says: There is only one art. He is speaking as a
painter, and I am sure he means it in a very different way to me, but I still think that is
true. There is only one art.
And is that shared consciousness between you and another individual?
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
2/10
Yes. And it depends on the context: a public squareor in a hospital. It will differ
according to the social situation, but I try and make it appropriate to that.
A lot of the formal resolution comes from thinking about how people will physically be
when they experience it. Will they be walking through a wood? Or sitting on a bench?
Or reading a book? Or looking at a blog? Again, what is appropriate?
That sharing happens when you have made a work - and you are removed from
where the work is - so it is an engagement with the work itself. But in this project,
and Im sure in others, there is that process that leads to the creation of an
object. Do think of that process as being part of the work?
Yes, and again that differs. I did another hospital project in Aberdeen that defined itself
immediately as there are walls what will be on the walls? And that puts you into a
certain mindset. If there is a weakness in that situation, it is that you solve that problem
very quickly, because that is your job as an artist, to solve problems.
Whereas what we began with in Glasgow was a social situation, and one in which I felt
we were all consciously trying to be open in our response to that situation.
We set down some parameters!
But the parameters were subtly aware of the human dynamic of, for instance, the
inherent qualities in staff, patient, and artist as roles. The staff have been figured here
as really part of the project. Whereas at Aberdeen, the staff were gatekeepers to the
patient experience, and not particularly strongly engaged in that process.
This process, by having a subtle brief, asking the right people, creating the right
moment to begin - we sat round a table, we had tea allows a space such that the work
is made a bit more slowly. That is always helpful.
I was meaning to praise the brief as not over-anticipating. We did all know there would
be something on a wall, and there would be an animation. But we did not all start talking
about that.
2
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
3/10
Well, thank you. But having said that, nevertheless, there are times when you
simply make work, and then there are times, as in this project, where there is a
commission, there are parameters, there are obligations, even. I wondered what
made you interested in responding to the invitation in the first place?
Most of my work is made, to be honest, through commission. But I quite often extend
those commissions beyond the immediate boundaries they set. I will bring something
previously part of my interest to it. More and more, I find I am overlapping projects. I will
often do more than I am asked, but that will be to further my own work. It will be, if you
like, because that work has taken on a dynamic, or an interest for me.
But with this project, and essentially a context of illness, I knew I needed to start writing
about my illness, about illness, about that experience. I had a body of work secretly -
even to me - sitting there ready to be manifested. So that was one of the excitements
(and terrors).
Also, coincidentally I had met Anthony socially, and liked him a lot. Also the challenge of
working in a hospital - I have had very bad experiences of healthcare myself, and I did
not want to bring that, but I wanted to go into that context, and I felt I might have
something to give.
You are at a stage now where you have done a lot of preparatory work, and now
going to do some work with patients...
I would not put it quite that way. I do not think it is helpful, particularly in this project, for
me to try and think of it, or set it out in a linear narrative. A lot of artists talk about, I am
doing research. Here is my formal proposal. Now I make the work. Now we show the
work. Pretty well everything in this project has been upside down, back to front. It is
easier to think of it as some kind of circulatory mechanism.
So things have intervened. I got ill again. I could not go to the hospital. I ended up
finding these poems that I had had about illness, and then re-writing them, and greatly
extending them. I wrote a lot of the poems when I was very ill in bed. So they were a
really deep reflection on the experience, the consciousness, of illness.
3
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
4/10
Some are just from things friends have said, or about people I know who have died,
people I know who have been ill, people who talk about illness, lovers, comrades, if you
like. I have deliberately let all the poems hang in a quite unidentified space, where they
are not just about me. But I do not say who they are about. They are just about the
experience of time and illness.
I have ended up doing quite a deep reflection on illness, which actually became the
complete work. I have got an idea for the animation, which will be quite easy to achieve,
but I like that there will be a blog of poems, a book of poems, an animation, a gift of a
little card to the patient, and they are all part of the same thing.
Well, what is the plan for the patients?
You could say that in this project, instead of making the physical, sculptural object, or
the film the ultimate outcome, I have ended up making the encounter with the patient
the ultimate outcome. Again, for two reasons: that it goes against what we might have
expected, that I would go and meet patients, and then write.
Also, I was worried very early on that I would not want to be necessarily writing from
what they were telling me. I did not want to burden my meeting with them with any
expectation of an outcome. Also, my illness delayed me going there. I felt that the most
crucial, sensitive part of the process was meeting the patients, and I mean especially
meeting the patients in that hospital - it is not like being in a Maggies Centre. There is
not particularly a space for the meeting.
No, it remains a hospital.
Yes. They have done their best, but we are challenging what they are used to providing,
what the state allows them to provide. So I wanted to let the meeting be completely free
to be whatever it was. I will offer people a poem if they want one; give them a
handkerchief with a poem label on it, if they want one. But I just wanted to know that in
that moment, we would just be two people, equal. If we wanted to not say anything, that
is fine. That is just my way of trying to bring awareness to the situation.
4
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
5/10
So I am very comfortable with how it has evolved. It has been very natural. I think it is a
really strong piece, because it is so simple, very appropriate to being ill. I have shown
the poems to some people, and they are very touched by them.
But you could say that we have all allowed the fact that outcome is not necessarily the
engine driving the train. That is quite an interesting thing, which not many projects allow.
Those less tangible outcomes, which are part of that process, are your
interaction, if you like, with the patients. But youve also spent time at Beatson
with the clinical team. How has that been?
I have met the staff, I think three times, and from the very beginning, I just felt very
comfortable in that conversation. I really admired them, and liked them as people. I
really like the quality of the dialogue, particularly the level of reflection about words and
the social setting, and what they could and could not provide. They are professional
people who are trained to work, in terms of biochemistry. But they also have to do a lot
of counselling, and that is a harder thing to do. That is where I meet them in terms of the
skill set, if you like, although I am very different and I am not professional.
But I felt very moved and touched, and admiring of the way they talked. I enjoyed
sharing the poems I have written with them. If you like, that was a test - a sense of a
witness to the fact they could have a use. There was a sense on their part of, Gosh, I
wonder how some patients will respond to this?
The main thing that we had talked about was that I would be giving the poems to people
if they wanted them. If I sit on a sofa, have a cup of tea, offer someone a poem, they
were playing over how different people would react. They were interested by that. I think
they would, in shorthand, see it as a Maggie Centre type thing, done in their setting, and
they embrace that.
A therapeutic thing then?
The Maggie Centres are so radical, I think, and so political. Because they have created
a model of a space that is patient led, and that is reflective, and that is not driven by the
5
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
6/10
delivery of care, per se. You go into a Maggie Centre, into a particular room, you cannot
necessarily say that that persons being treated. It seems to me one of the most radical
things in our culture. It solely seems to come out of the power of the cancer community.
I do not know if you agree, but it seems to me we have had two powerful illness lobbies,
we have had cancer and AIDS, HIV. They both manage to alter the way that patients
are treated. The cancer issue has become, specifically this architectural, spiritual, very
real thing. The people at the Beatson are, I felt, intrigued, open, curious, welcoming,
aware of that. And the wee space they have made me, well, it is not a clinical thing, and
that is unusual for them. Nor is it a pretty painting on a wall.
I feel there is something quite powerful there. But it is so simple, it is quite challenging to
everyone. I think I have left meeting patients till last because it is quite terrifying.
Also, they are dealing with a very particular kind of cancer. Remember at our first
meeting, Marie said, Your brain is who you are? I wonder, have you reflected on
that at all?
No, not directly. My poems are about illness per se. The power in this situation is the
radical strangeness that any illness is. Right at the beginning we talked about Tom
Lubbocks account of his cancer, and the idea of investigating that, and the loss of
language. But I ended up not pursuing that.
I have approached more this idea of today; that what all of us share is today. Every
word is weighted differently; in terms of the likelihood of death, well, mortality, and that
one has a stronger weight than some. So I ended up translating that to its simplest
factor, not its outcome.
I have ended up writing a poem that might say, The size of a plum, peach or apple, as
that is how people describe their tumour. But I have not chosen to show what an artist
might make with the shadow of the tumour. I just wanted to say the words, the image. I
have used speech a lot in this project. How is it a patient would be told? So, well look,
this is your tumour, and it is the size of a walnut. So I have chosen those identifiers.
Again, like shared consciousness.
6
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
7/10
Potentially then, in meeting patients, there is a space there for them to say and reflect
on what they have been told, and how they have been told to someone who is not a
clinician.
How they have told themselves. And how they tell their friends. Because the poems
value the non-professional speech; a lot of them come out of speech. They are about
the dialogue that we have, not with the doctor. I found that very interesting to write into.
When talking about illness, immediately Susan Sontag pops into your head. It
seems to me that what you are doing is as far away from any idea of metaphor as
you could get.
I think that is true, or maybe my metaphor was to melt that, or dissolve it into today.
Many of the poems say, Okay, today, what is today? How do I feel today? There is
one poem that says, All I can do today is write these few words. Well, that was real, to
me, that was my achievement that day. That was all I had outside of me, and yet, there
it was. To say that that is a work of art - I feel that there is a resilience in that, that it is
very different to the Sontag model.
And is there a parallel, however loose, with the way that clinicians work, in that
their relationship with patients is very in the present, is it?
I think that is true. This is a roundabout point, but I was shocked and struck by the fact
that in effect, the patients come to them, have a series of days, months, they are
treated, and then that they let go of the patient before he or she dies. That really broke a
myth in my mind, that I had imagined you would see someone to their death. I found
that fascinating.
Yes, what shocked me in our first meeting was that they do not see people to
their death, but they are dealing with people who are going to die. I had assumed
that they were making people better.
Yet I found it the most positive language about illness that I had encountered.
7
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
8/10
I had had such a negative experience before. I talked a moment ago about how certain
illnesses seem to me to have been able to fight to empower themselves. I have the kind
of illness that is the opposite of that. When you have something like ME, you are in a
very contested space. You are in a situation where a doctor will quite frequently seem to
actively not be listening to your symptoms, because they have a doubtful picture in their
mind.
So when you ask about the today thing, what I take from it is one of the main ways we
have always had of administering medicine is a conversation. An expert, speaking to a
non-expert. But the non-expert has, is, the body.
Doctors of all kinds have conversations, and a lot depends on the quality of that
conversation. Not just in terms of perception, but also actively healing. Certain words
might trigger a diagnosis.
The situation of the staff at the Beatson is one where quite frequently, at a certain point,
you are beginning to shift someone from treatment to ideas about their own mortality.
That is moving into a different language stream. I do not claim the poems would be
instructive towards that, but I think that they speak within a similar frame.
I am not going to suggest my poems are a way to tell someone that their life maybe
coming to an end. But if the book was lying around in the hospital, and someone could
take it away, it reminds them that it is our common human fate.
It is not quite telling them, is it? They already know.
We know, but how do we tell ourselves what we know? I felt that the staff were deeply,
humorously, but with a great sincerity, all open to that question.
And the language, just simply language. We did not engage about, What is theanimation going to be? What are you going to make? Theymight not put it exactly this
way, but we were talking about language. I respected them on the level of language,
and liked everything I heard from all of them.
But their language and your language, how have
8
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
9/10
Well I do not know how they speak to their patients.
All I have is the evidence of their interest, curiosity and openness, the fact that they
allowed all the poems but one. The one they did not want was simply for a professional
concern they had, about the poem that talked about We lived dying.
That was all, to me, a level of valuable conversation you do not always get. Certain
times in the past, I have had people say, You cannot say that. People will be surprised
how often that happens.
The staff should have the final authority, because they do know about their patients. But
I was very impressed. I think the poems had a use to them, and they saw a use for them
with patients. When you asked me in and I was excited, it was because I felt there was
a job I could do.
What is that job?
That is it. It is recognition that anyone can look, and go, I recognise that. If the patient
and a doctor can both do it
Are you in between or...?
Well, I do not want to use the word advocate. If I were cleverer, I would think of a better
word. But I am an ordinary person who happens to have skill in listening, writing down
words. That means I am a professional amateur. I am professional at listening to
speech. The doctors are also, but they could not write it down the way I do. But they
recognise it, so it is just that really.
It is so complicated, because anything starts to weaken the role of the poem itself. It is
the poem that allows shared recognition.
I think understanding is a key word. With Iain as well, working with the lab, it is
about different disciplines approaches to trying to reach an understanding.
9
7/30/2019 Interview with Alec Finlay on Navigations
10/10
Yes. There is as much skill and discipline in the clinic, but it is more a part of a social
discourse, whereas the labs is technical. It is creative, but that is the difference, as I
see it. I just think there is an interest from me in this very simple level of speech.
Yes, I think that is discipline.
It is, yes.
Links
Navigations - http://www.animateprojects.org/films/by_project/residencies/navigations
Alec Finlay - http://www.animateprojects.org/films/by_artist/f/a_finlay
Animate Projects
Experiments in animation - http://www.animateprojects.org
Connect with us:
Facebook - http://www.facebook.com/AnimateProjects
Twitter - http://twitter.com/animateprojects
10
http://www.animateprojects.org/films/by_project/residencies/navigationshttp://www.animateprojects.org/films/by_artist/f/a_finlayhttp://www.animateprojects.org/http://www.facebook.com/AnimateProjectshttp://twitter.com/animateprojectshttp://www.animateprojects.org/films/by_project/residencies/navigationshttp://www.animateprojects.org/films/by_artist/f/a_finlayhttp://www.animateprojects.org/http://www.facebook.com/AnimateProjectshttp://twitter.com/animateprojects