7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

1/83

Bgtfrapfrocbjbty olagk njaum Xravbmfrs

ogmomfvfjaplfgt`rolfwaris

cy^costbfgLarkogt

38?>

O mbssfrtotbag suclbttfm bg portboj `uj bjlfgt a tef rfqubrflfgts a`

^ef``bfjm EojjolVgbvfrsbty `ar tef mfkrff a`Lostfr a`^nbfgnf bg[fc

ogmNjaumNalputbgk'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

2/83

^costbfgLarkogt

BB

Onigawjfmkflfgts

]ebs mbssfrtotbag waujm gat eovf cffg passbcjf wbteaut tef efjp a` salf logy

pfapjf ogm bgsa logywoys' @brst* btwosmurbgkombsnussbagwbtely njosslotf

teotteftapbna`tebssucdfnteoscffgrobsfm']efrf`arf*Bwaujmjbiftateogisojja`

tefl`artefsupparttefycrbgklymurbgkojjtefmbssfrtotbagpranfss*cutojsa

murbgkojjtebsyfor'BwaujmjbiftakbvfospfnbojteogistaLr^orogkoLugosbgkef*

`arebsfgteusboslogmebsefjppravbmfmmurbgktebsstumy'

BgommbtbagBwaujmjbiftateogislysupfrvbsar*MrJourbfEbrsne`artefsuppart

ogmefjppravbmfmmurbgktebsrfsfornepranfssogmtefsuppartpravbmfmmurbgk

ojjtefyfor'

@bgojjy B waujm jbif ta kbvf spfnboj teogis `ar ly `olbjy teot suppart lf bg ojj

sbtuotbagsogmotogytblf*cutojsatwa`rbfgms'LrCferaaz]o`ozzajbLakeommol

`arojjteftblfspfgmbgtefjbcrorytakftefrogmLbss[fb[fb`arefrpotbfgnfogm

jbstfgbgkmurbgkojjtebsstumy'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

3/83

^costbfgLarkogt

BBB

Ocstront

NjaumNalputbgkbstefrfvajutbagteotrfseopfojjtefB]bgmustry*nagsfqufgtjyos

wbtefonegfwtfnegajakbfs*NjaumNalputbgkbsrobsbgkneojjfgkfsogmbssufsteot

lustcfossfssfm']efrf`arf*tef`brstneojjfgkfbsnagsbmfrfmos^fnurbty9cuttef

neojjfgkfa`bgtfrapfrocbjbtyrbsfsosocurgbgkbssuf'Bg`ont*cf`arflasta`tefB]

systfls lbkrotf ta tef Njaum bt wbjj cf fssfgtboj `ar nalpogbfs ta fgsurf tef

passbcbjbty ta swbtne cftwffg ojj tef vfgmars9 teus wefg Njaum bgtfrapfrocbjbty

wbjjcfsajvfmNjaumNalputbgkwbjjtoifa``'

Nagsfqufgtjy*tefobla`tebsstumybstamfvfjapo`rolfwari`arbgtfrapfrocbjbty

olagkNjaumXravbmfrs*`ralonustalfrpabgta`vbfw'Larfprfnbsfjy*eawbtbs

passbcjf ta mfvfjap og bgtfrapfrocjf oppjbnotbag bgnjumfm bg og bgtfrapfrocjf

ornebtfnturf'

]efrfsforneoppraoneugmfrtoifgbsomfmuntbvfoppraone9`brstostotfa`tefort

a tef mb `frfgt njaum pravbmfrs sajutbags wbjj cf lomf bg armfr ta mfvfjap

tefarbfs9 sfnagmjy o `rolfwari bs mfvfjapfm ogm ossfssfm cy o nosf stumy' ]ef

nosfstumybstefmfpjaylfgta`ogbgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbagbgtamb``frfgtnjaum

pravbmfrsusbgkogbgtfrapfrocjfornebtfnturf'@bgojjy*oquojbtotbvfmotonajjfntbag

lfteam*bgtfrvbfw*cutojsaacsfrvotbagsbsusfmtambsnusstefrfsujts'

]ef rfsujts orf `ar tef stotf a` tef ort tef njossb`bnotbag a Njaum pravbmfrs bg

mb `frfgt notfkarbfs janifm pravbmfrs* apfg pravbmfrs ogm sflb,janifm

pravbmfrs'Nagnfrgbgktef`rolfwariogmtefnosfstumy*twaornebtfnturflamfjs

eovfcffgtfstfmogmterffrfnallfgmotbagseovfcffglomf'@brst*nagnfrgbgk

tefNjaumpravbmfrs*ogmtefgfnfssbtytaossfsssalfa`tefbrpajbnbfs%^JOsogm

rfstrbntbags"'^fnagmjynagnfrgbgktefblpartognftausfomfvfjaplfgtlamfjta

sfporotf tef mb``frfgt nagnfrgs a` tef oppjbnotbag' Jostjy* cosfm ag tef

blpjflfgtotbaga`twaornebtfnturfs*tefSF^]ornebtfnturfojjawslarf`jfxbcbjbty

ogm teus bs larf subtocjf ta cf mfpjayfm `ar Bgtfrapfrocjf Ornebtfnturf wbte o

motocosfavfrBgtfrgft'

]a nagnjumf* tef stumy portbojjy rfone bs kaoj cy kbvbgk rfnallfgmotbags `ar

bgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbagsogmcymbsnussbgkogbgtfrapfrocjfornebtfnturf'Cuttef

nosfstumyebkejbketsbssufswefgmfpjaybgktefoppjbnotbagbgsalfspfnb`bnsnjaum

pravbmfrsteotseaujmcfossfssfm`ar`uturfwaris'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

4/83

^costbfgLarkogt

BP

]ocjfa`Nagtfgts

Onigawjfmkflfgts'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''BB

Ocstront''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''BBB

]ocjfa`Nagtfgts'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''BP

Jbsta`]ocjfs'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''PB

]ocjfa`@bkurfs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''PBB

Jbsta`Onragyls'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''PBBB

Kjassory'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''PBBB

?'Bgtramuntbag'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?

?'?'Conikraugm''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?

?'3Oblsa`tef^tumy''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ''''''''3

?'>^trunturf''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=

3'Jbtfroturfrfvbfw''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''6

3'?NjaumNalputbgk'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''6

3'?'?Ag,mflogm,sfj`sfrvbnf'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0 3'?'3CraomGftwarionnfss''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0

3'?'>Sfsaurnfpaajbgk''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0

3'?'=Sopbmfjostbnbty''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0

3'?'6Lfosurfm^frvbnfs'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';

3'3Njaum^frvbnfLamfjs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';

3'3'?^a`tworfOsO^frvbnf%^oo^"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';

3'3'3Xjot`arloso^frvbnf%Xoo^"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''5

3'3'>Bg`rostrunturfoso^frvbnf%Boo^"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''5

3'3'=Motostarokfoso^frvbnf%Moo^"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''2

3'3'6AtefrsNjaum'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''2

3'>NjaumMfpjaylfgtLamfjs'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''?8

3'>'?XrbvotfNjaum'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?8

3'>'3NallugbtyNjaum''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?8

3'>'>XucjbnNjaum'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''??

3'>'=EycrbmNjaum''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''??

3'>'6Atefrsmfpjaylfgtlamfjs'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''??

3'=^alfNjaumPfgmars''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''??

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

5/83

^costbfgLarkogt

P

3'='?KaakjfOppFgkbgfogmKaakjf^frvbnfs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?3

3'='3Olozag[fc^frvbnfs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?>

3'='>Lbnrasa`t'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''?=

3'='=^ojfs`arnf'nal'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?6

3'='6FLN''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?0

3'6Bgtfrapfrocbjbtya`NjaumPfgmars'''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ''''''?;

3'6'?Mf`bgbtbaga`NjaumBgtfrapfrocbjbty''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?;

3'6'3Nalporbsaga`salfNjaumXravbmfrs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?;

3'0^uppartbgkrfsfornefs''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''?5

3'0'?JB^B4Olamfj`arBgtfrapfrocbjbtytaommrfssNjaumBgtfrapfrocbjbty''''''''''''''''''''?5

3'0'3Bgtfrapfrocjf@rolfwariolagkNjaumXravbmfrs'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''38

3';Nagtrostbgkvbfwsogmkops''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ''''''3?

>'Lfteamajaky''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''3=

>'?SfsforneOppraone'''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ''''''3=

>'?'?Bgmuntbvf''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''3=

>'?'3Mfmuntbvf'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''3=

>'3Ogojysbsa`tefrfsfornelfteams'''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''36

>'3'?JbtfroturfSfvbfw''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''3;

>'3'3Nosf^tumy'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''35

>'3'>Bgtfrvbfw'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>8

>'>Fxpfntfmjblbtotbags''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''>>

>'>'?@rolfwari'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>

>'>'3Nosfstumy'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>

>'>'>Bgtfrvbfw'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>

>'=^ullorya`Lfteamajaky'''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' >=

='@bgmbgksogmOgojysbs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>6

='?Nosf^tumy,Mftfntbgkogmossfssbgktefgffms`arogbgtfrapfrocjfNjaum

Oppjbnotbag'''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''>6

='?'?Mfvfjapbgko[fcoppjbnotbag'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>6

='3]ef@rolfwari'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''=8

='3'?OssfssbgkNjaumXravbmfrs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=8

='3'3Oppjbnotbag''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=3

='>Ornebtfnturf''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''=>

='=Bgtfrvbfw'''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''=6

6'Mbsnussbag''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=;

0'Nagnjusbagogmrfnallfgmotbags''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=2

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

6/83

^costbfgLarkogt

PB

0'?@uturfSfsforne'''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ''''''6?

;'Fvojuotbag''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''63

;'?Jblbtotbags'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''63

5'8Sf`frfgnfs'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''6=

2'8Oppfgmbx''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''65

OppfgmbxCFtebnojNefnijbst'''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ''''''65

OppfgmbxNBgtfrvbfw'''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''62

OppfgmbxMOppjbnotbagJoyaut'''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''0>

M'?JakbgBgtfr`onf'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0>

M'3VsfrJbstBgtfr`onf''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0=

M'>@bjfsLogokflfgt'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0=

M'=Sfkbstfr'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0=

M'6OlozagSM^,Ly^_JMotocosf'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''06

M'0OlozagFN3Bgstognf[fc^frvfr'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''06

M';OzurfLogokflfgtpartoj''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''06

M'5Opp@akLyNjaumOpplogokflfgt''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''00

OppfgmbxFLy^_J''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''00

F'?]ocjf@bjfs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''00

F'3]ocjfVsfrs'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''00

F'>LysqjNjbfgt%njossLysqj"'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0;

Oppfgmbx@SF^]''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''';8

@'?SF^]^frvfr''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';8

@'3SF^]Njbfgt''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';?

OppfgmbxKOmmbtbagojbg`arlotbag''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' '''''''''''''''''' ;>

K'?]efNjaumPfgmars''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';>

K'3A``bnf>06Xrbnbgk'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';>

K'>OlozagFN3prbnbgksajutbags''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';= K'=SaugmSacbgMG^'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';6

Jbsta`]ocjfs

]ocjf?4Acdfntbvfsa`tefstumy''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=

]ocjf34KaakjfOppFgkbgfprbnbgksajutbags'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?>

]ocjf>4KaakjfOppFgkbgf@rff_uato'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?>

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

7/83

^costbfgLarkogt

PBB

]ocjf=4KaakjfOppprbnbgksajutbags'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?>

]ocjf64@arnf'nalprbnbgk'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?0

]ocjf04Bgtfrapfrocbjbty,KraupBgbtbotbvfs%Kavbgmorodog&Joiselogog*38?8"

''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''33

]ocjf;4 Bgtfrapfrocbjbty, PfgmarBgbtbotbvfs%Kavbgmorodog&Joiselogog*38?8"

''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''33

]ocjf 54 Nalporbsag Bgtfrvbfw ogm _ufstbaggobrf %[ojjblog* 38??9 ^ops`arm &

Dupp*38809Mowsag*3882o"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?

]ocjf24Bgtfrvbfwrfqubrflfgts%Cfrgmtssagftoj'*3885"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>3

]ocjf?84Oppjbnotbag@ugntbagojbty'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>6

]ocjf??4^JOOgotaly%Cosft*38?3"'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=?

]ocjf?34^JOOgotaly%Olozag* 38859 Kaakjf* 38?39 Lbnrasa`t* 38?3"''''''''''''''''''''''=?

]ocjf?>4 Nalporbsag a`NjaumXravbmfrs %Sfmior & Kubmbnb*38??9 Easne* 38?39

Lurty*38859^fvfrognf*38829Lurty*3885"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=3

]ocjf?=4SF^]OXBLfteams'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''==

]ocjf?64BgtfrvbfwAutnalfs''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=0

]ocjfa`@bkurfs

@bkurf?4PbsuojLamfja`NjaumNalputbgk%Njaumnagtrajs'ark*38??"''''''''''''''''''''''''''6

@bkurf34GB^]Njaum^frvbnfLamfjs%^oo^Cjaks* 38??"'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''';

@bkurf>4GB^]Njaum^frvbnfLamfjs'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?8

@bkurf=4Bgtfrapfrocbjbty@rolfwari%Lbr`oierobftoj'*38?3"'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''38

@bkurf64Mfmuntbvfoppraone@jaw%^ougmfrsftoj'*3882"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''36

@bkurf04Mfmuntbvfrfosagbgk''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''36

@bkurf;4LPNLamfj%Nycjognf*3885"''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''32

@bkurf54Ojorkfpbnturfa`tefOppjbnotbagOrnebtfnturf'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>8

@bkurf24SfsforneLfteamajaky@rolfwari''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>=

@bkurf?84Fxpfntfmornebtfnturf'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>0

@bkurf??4Oppjbnotbagmfpjaylfgtwbte^AOornebtfnturf'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>;

@bkurf?34LysqjFrrar'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>5

@bkurf?>4OppjbnotbagmfpjaylfgtwbteSF^]ornebtfnturf''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>2

@bkurf?=4Ornebtfnturfrfnallfgmfm''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''=>

@bkurf?64OmvognfmOrnebtfnturf''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''==

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

8/83

^costbfgLarkogt

PBBB

Jbsta`Onragyls

O[^ Olozag[fc^frvbnfNXV NfgtrojXranfssbgkVgbtMoo^ Motooso^frvbnfKOF KaakjfOppFgkbgfBoo^ Bg`rostrunturfoso^frvbnfB] Bg`arlotbag]fnegajakyGB^] GotbagojBgstbtutfXoo^ Xjot`arloso^frvbnfXMO XfrsagojMbkbtojOssbstognfSOL SogmalOnnfssLflarySF^] Sfprfsfgtotbagoj^totf]rogs`fr^oo^ ^a`tworfoso^frvbnf^MI ^a`tworfMfvfjaplfgtIbt

^JO ^frvbnfJfvfjOkrfflfgt^AO ^frvbnfArbfgtfmOrnebtfnturf]a^ ]frlsa`^frvbnfSMCL SfjotbagojMotocosfLogokflfgt^ystflPXN PbrtuojXrbvotfNjaum[[[ [arjm[bjmf[fc

Kjassory

Naaibf4E]]Xnaaibfbsoslojj`bjfbgnjumbgkmoto`raltefsfrvfrteotnaujmcfusf`ar`uturfvbsbtagtefsolfmalobg'

E]]Xs4E]]Xsfnurfbsteflastusfmsfnurbtypratanaja`nallugbnotbagavfrBgtfrgft'Btbsogblpjflfgtotbaga`E]]Xavfr^^J'

D^AG4Dovo^nrbptAcdfntGatotbagbsotfxt,cosfmmotobgtfrneogkfstogmorm'Btsprbgnbpojneorontfrbstbnsorftacfeulogrfomocjfogmfosy`arnalputfrtaporsf'

Ga^_JMotocosf4gatagjy^_Jmotocosforfkfgfrojjymfsnrbcfmosgatusbgktef

njossbnojSMCL^ogmkfgfrojjygatcosfagtocjfs'

SfjotbagojMotocosf4Nalpbjotbaga`motoarmfrfmbgtocjfs%`arlojjy,mfsnrbcfm"*wefrfmotoorffosbjylogbpujotfm'

SF^]4Sfprfsfgtotbagoj^totf]rogs`frbssa`tworfornebtfnturfkfgfrojjyusfbgtefwarjmwbjmwfc'Btbso[fcSfsaurnfmfsbkglamfjlogokbgktefbgtfrontbagcftwffgtefmb``frfgtrfsaurnfs'Btbswbmfjyusftanrfotfbgtfrapfrocjfrfsaurnfs'

^AO4^frvbnf,Arbfgtfm,Ornebtfnturfbsogornebtfnturfbgnjumbgkprbgnbpjfsogmlfteamajakytamfvfjapbgtfrapfrocjfsa`tworf'

[^MJ4[fc^frvbnfMfsnrbptbagJogkuokfbsoULJcosfmjogkuokfusfmtamfsnrbcf[fc^frvbnfs'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

9/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?

?'Bgtramuntbag

Btbscfnalbgkbgnrfosbgkjymb``bnujttabkgarftefkrawtea`NjaumNalputbgkogmtefa``frslomfcytefnjaumpravbmfrs'Bgtefontuojavfr,naggfntfmwarjm*njaum

nalputbgk bstefsaurnf a`tefgfwpapujorfxprfssbag ag tef njaum*cutbteos

ojsarobsfmgfwneojjfgkfsogmappartugbtbfs']efrf`arf*tebsstumywbjjossfssagf

a`tefsfneojjfgkfs*njaumpravbmfrsbgtfrapfrocbjbty*cymbsnussbgko`rolfwarita

mfvfjapbgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbagscftwffgsfvfrojpravbmfrs']ebspopfrbscosfm

agtwaoppraonefs*o`rolfwarimbsnussbgksalfrfnallfgmotbagsarstfpsteot

nog cf usfm ta mfvfjap njaum bgtfrapfrocbjbty ogm tef mfvfjaplfgt a` ogoppjbnotbagtafgsurftefvbocbjbtya`tef`rolfwariogmblpravfbt']efpabgta`

vbfwa`tebspopfrbsa`onustalfra`NjaumNalputbgk'

?'?'Conikraugm

]augmfrstogmtefbgtfrfstogmacdfntbvfsa`tebspopfrbtbsfssfgtbojtanagsbmfr

tefconikraugmteotjfomtatebsstumy'Bg`ont*NjaumNalputbgkbsnagsbmfrfmagf

a tef curgbgk bssufs a nalputbgk warjm gawomoys9 gat agjy cfnousf a tef

passbcbjbtya`gfwcusbgfssappartugbtbfscutlarfcytefgulcfrsa`passbcbjbtbfs

bgvajvfm']efrf`arf*NjaumNalputbgkbgvomfsfmunotbag*cusbgfss*omlbgbstrotbag

ogm sa ag9 bt bs mfsnrbcf cy logy os o rfvajutbag teot wbjj rfseopf ojj tef B]

bgmustry%Mbjjagftoj'*38?8"ogmojsaostefmrbvfr`arkrawteogmbggavotbag`ar

last a tef nalpogy' Bt bs tefg nagsbmfrfm os og fssfgtboj tfnegajaky* teus o

survfynorrbfmautcyKortgfrmfsnrbcfstefblpartognfa`njaumnalputbgkostef

tapterffprbarbtbfs`arNBAsbg38?3%CN^]efNeortfrfmBgstbtutf`arB]*38?3"cut

ojsaprfmbntteotcy38?0lasta` tef tap 3888 arkogbzotbags wbjjlbkrotftatef

Njaum'

Eawfvfr* bt bs fssfgtboj ta pabgt aut* Njaum Nalputbgk bs robsbgk bssufs ogm

neojjfgkfs teot lust cf ossfssfm bg armfr ta fgsurf bts sustobgocbjbty `ar

nalpogbfs' Onnarmbgk taMbjjag ftoj%38?8" tef `brstneojjfgkf bssfnurbty* os`ar

fxolpjf wbte rfsaurnf seorbgk moto9 gftwari ar nalputbgk rfsaurnfs nog cf

seorfmwbtelojbnbausmotoarusfrs']efsfnagmneojjfgkfbstefnastbgklamfj*bt

bsfssfgtboj tanorf`ujjyogojysf ogm ossfss tef ^frvbnf JfvfjOkrfflfgt %^JO"a`

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

10/83

^costbfgLarkogt

3

tefNjaumpravbmfrsbgarmfrtaovabmugpjfosogtsurprbsfs'Gfvfrtefjfss*fvfgb`

nalpogbfs orf vbkbjogt ocaut sune terfots ogatefr curgbgk bssuf bs robsbgk `ar

NjaumNalputbgkbgmustry4tefbgtfrapfrocbjbtya`tefNjaum'Bg`ont*cf`arfojorkf

olaugta`usfrwbjjcfnag`artocjftaputmotobgtatefnjaumbtwbjjcffssfgtboj`ar

tefltafgsurf tefpassbcbjbty taswbtne cftwffgojj tef vfgmars'Larfprfnbsfjy

tef blpartognf `ar njaum nalputbgk ta toif a`` wbjj cf ta fgeognf tef fosf a`

nalpogywbtebgtfrapfrocbjbtyogmsfnurbty%]fjfnallugbnotbagsSfparts*3882"'

Nagsfqufgtjy* sfnurbty neojjfgkf bs muf ta tef gfnfssbty `ar Njaum nustalfr ta

mfpfgmagotebrmport*wefrfostefpracjfla`Njaumbgtfrapfrocbjbtynalf`ral

tef forjy okf a` Njaum nalputbgk* wefrf fone pravbmfrs wfrf mfvfjapbgk tefbr

njaum bgmfpfgmfgtjy usbgk tefbr awg stogmorms' Bgmffm* bgtfrapfrocbjbty nog cf

mf`bgfmostefnoponbty`arnustalfrstalogokfteflbkrotbagcftwffgmb``frfgt

Njaumpravbmfrs'@arfxolpjf*ogoppjbnotbagwbjjcfbgtfrapfrocjfb`btbspassbcjf

talbkrotfbtbgogatefrNjaumwbteolbgblula`lamb`bnotbags*wefrfostwawbjj

cfbgtfrapfrocjfb`tefyojjawlbkrotbgk%PL*oppjbnotbagaratefrs"cftwffgtefl'

Bg `ont* last a` tefcbk ontars a` B]* sune os Kaakjf* Lbnrasa`t* Olozag cut ojsa

^VG* EX ogm BCL eovf dulpfm bgta tef Njaum Nalputbgk wovf* cut

bgtfrapfrocbjbtypracjflnalf`raltefjani,bgpravbmfmcysalfa`tefsfontarswefgblpjflfgtbgktefbrsajutbag'Eawfvfr*ostefNjaumavfrnalfstefpeysbnoj

caugmorbfs a` nalputbgk %Eorse ft oj'* 38?3"* bgtfrapfrocbjbty bs cfnalbgk og

fssfgtboj neorontfrbstbn teot lust cf mfvfjapfm' Ommbtbagojjy* Njaum nalputbgk

nrfotfmogfwcusbgfsslamfjwefrfnalpogbfsorfsfjjbgknalputbgkrfsaurnfs9

teus*btbsugblokbgocjf`arnustalfrstacfjanifmtaagfpravbmfrogmtefywogt

ta cf ocjf ta rfgfkatbotf tefbr prbnfs os bg ogy atefr lorift' Bgmffm* tef

nagsfqufgnfa`ogbgtfrapfrocjfNjaumwbjjcf`arnustalfrstakfttefpassbcbjbtyta neogkf tefbr pravbmfr ogm ovabm jani,bg' @bgojjy* tef raats a` tebs stumy toif

pjonfbgtebssbtuotbag*wefrfbtbsnagsbmfrfmteottefbgtfrapfrocbjbtybstefwoy

NjaumNalputbgkseaujmfvajvf'

?'3Oblsa`tef^tumy

]augmfrtoiftefoblsa`tefstumybtnogcfbgtfrfstbgktajaaiottefmb``frfgtify

acdfntbvfs teot lust cf ossfssfm bg armfr ta kft rfjfvogt ogm onnurotf `bgmbgks'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

11/83

^costbfgLarkogt

>

@brst* bt bs gfnfssory ta kft og bmfo a` tef bgtfrapfrocbjbty a` tef mb` frfgt njaum

pravbmfrs* ta logokf tebs9 tebs popfr bgvfstbkotfs tef mb` frfgt Njaum Xravbmfrs

fgvbraglfgtogmogojysftefbrmb``frfgnfs'Bg`ont*mftfrlbgbgktefnalpotbcbjbtbfs

cftwffg pravbmfrs bs tef `brst stfp ta fstocjbse tef nalpjfxbty a` tef jani,bg a`

njaumnalputbgk'

@urtefrlarf*tebspopfrwbjjogojysftefnurrfgtusfa`stogmormstakftcosbs`ar

bgtfrapfrocbjbty a` Njaum Xravbmfrs ogm tefg mbsnuss tefsf stogmorms a njaum

nalputbgk fgvbraglfgt ta fgsurf tef nalpjbognf a` moto ogm oppjbnotbags' ]ef

acdfntbvf bs ta najjfnt rfjfvogt bg`arlotbag nagnfrgbgk njaum nalputbgk ta

mftfrlbgf tef stotf a` tef ort ogm fxtront tef last rfjfvogt ogm onnurotf

pranfmurfs ta nrfotf og bgtfrapfrocjf oppjbnotbag wbteaut crfoibgk wbte tef

bgtfjjfntuojefrbtokfa`NjaumNalputbgk'Bg`ont*btbsblpartogttastoybgtefontuoj

tfgmfgnya`Njaumbgarmfrtaactobgrfjfvogtcutojsaonnurotf`bgmbgks']efjost

acdfntbvf bs ta pravbmf o `rolfwari teot wbjj ojjaw nalpogbfs ta mfvfjap

bgtfrapfrocjf oppjbnotbags* tebs `rolfwarinog cf mfsnrbcf os rfnallfgmotbags

ogm stfps teot lust cf ugmfrtoifg bg armfr ta fgsurf tef vbocbjbty a o Njaum

pradfnt'Eawfvfrbtwbjjcffssfgtbojtakftfvbmfgnfsogmtasuppartteftefarycy

ugmfrtoibgk o nosf stumy ogm tefg mfvfjapbgk og oppjbnotbag nalpotbcjf wbtemb``frfgtNjaumvfgmars'

]a nagnjumf* tef mb `frfgt obls a tebs stumy nog cf rfnopbtujotfm bg terff

acdfntbvfsteotlustcfugmfrtoifg%]ocjf?"'@brst*btwbjjcfblpartogttamfvfjap

o rfvbfw a tef Njaum fgvbraglfgt9 bgmffm* cy stumybgk tef mb `frfgt njaum

pravbmfrs fgvbraglfgt* bt wbjj ebkejbket tef mb``frfgt sajutbag fxbstbgk ogm tefg

tef nalpotbcjf pravbmfrs ta ovabm jani,bg' Ommbtbagojjy* cy bgvfstbkotbgk tefnurrfgt stogmorm a` Njaum bgtfrapfrocbjbty bt wbjj pfrlbt ta stoy bg tef trfgm a`

Njaum fvajutbag' ]ef sfnagm stfp bs tef nrfotbag a o `rolfwari pravbmbgk

rfnallfgmotbags`arnalpogbfstamfvfjapbgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbags9bgommbtbag

ogoppjbnotbagwbjjcf mfvfjapfmbgarmfrtaossfsstef`rolfwariogmblpravfbs

quojbty ogm f` bnbfgny' @bgojjy* bt wbjj cf blpartogt ta mbsnuss tef jblbtotbag ogm

autnalfs a tebs stumy cy norrybgk aut og bgtfrvbfw wbte fxpfrts ogm usbgk

acsfrvotbags'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

12/83

^costbfgLarkogt

=

Acdfntbvfs Mfsnrbptbag

Sfvbfwa`Njaumfgvbraglfgt MbsnussbgkNjaumpravbmfrssajutbagsogmtefstotfa`teforta`NjaumBgtfrapfrocbjbty'

Mfvfjapo@rolfwari`ar

Bgtfrapfrocbjbty

Mfvfjap o `rolfwari `ar bgtfrapfrocbjbty*ossfssfm cy tef mfvfjaplfgt a` ogbgtfrapfrocjfOppjbnotbag'

Mbsnuss tef nagsfqufgnfs `ar NjaumBgtfrapfrocbjbty

Ossfss tef autnalfs ogm loif salfrfnallfgmotbags `ar Njaum bgtfrapfrocbjbty%bgtfrvbfwogmacsfrvotbags"

]ocjf?4Acdfntbvfsa`tefstumy

?'>^trunturf

]ebspopfrbsstortbgkcyogbgtramuntbaga`tebswari*bgnjumbgkmfsnrbptbagsogm

fxpjogotbag*tafgsurftatefrfomfrtefpassbcbjbtytakftogbmfoa`teffxtfgta`

tebsstumy']efport3wbjjcforfvbfwa`tefjbtfroturfogmwbjjstorttamfvfjap

salf prfvbaus ogojysf teot wbjj cf usfm murbgk tef sfntbag = %tef `bgmbgks" ta

mfvfjap tef `rolfwari' ]ef sfntbag > wbjj tefg mbsnuss tef lfteamajaky

ugmfrtoifg bg tebs stumy9 bt wbjj cf ebkejbketfm tef mb``frfgt rfsforne lfteams

lomf ta kft ta tef `bgmbgks bg o nalprfefgsbvf woy' Bg sfntbag 6* bt wbjj cf

blpartogttefgtambsnusstefrfsujtstaloifonalporbsagwbteatefrsrfsforne

ogmnagtrostwbteteffxpfntotbags']efgfxtportwbjjnagnjumfcyrfvbfwbgktef

acdfntbvfs* tef rfsforne qufstbag ogm loibgk rfnallfgmotbags `ar `urtefr

stumbfs'@bgojjy*tefjostsfntbagwbjjcftefnagtbgubtycybgnjumbgkogfvojuotbaga`

tebsstumyogmmbsnussbgktefjblbtotbagsogmblpravflfgtsteotnaujmcfmagf*cut

ojsatefbgvajvflfgtsa`tebsstumy'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

13/83

^costbfgLarkogt

6

3'Jbtfroturfrfvbfw

3'?NjaumNalputbgk

Os ogfvajvbgk tfnegajaky bt bs qubtf mb` bnujt ta mf bgf Njaum Nalputbgk* teus bt

taai ?6 mro`ts `ar tef GB^] %Gotbagoj Bgstbtutf a` ^togmorm ogm ]fnegajaky" ta

actobgomf`bgbtbvfvfrsbagogmrfjfosfbtbgAntacfr38??']efrf`arf*tebsmf`bgbtbag

sffls ta bgnjumf tef last jorkfjy usfm tfrls ogm nalpagfgts ta mf`bgf Njaum

Nalputbgk4

Njaum nalputbgk bs o lamfj `ar fgocjbgk ucbqubtaus* nagvfgbfgt* ag,mflogm

gftwari onnfss ta o seorfm paaj a nag bkurocjf nalputbgk rfsaurnfs %f'k'*

gftwaris* sfrvfrs* starokf* oppjbnotbags* ogm sfrvbnfs" teot nog cf ropbmjy

pravbsbagfm ogm rfjfosfm wbte lbgbloj logokflfgt f``art ar sfrvbnf pravbmfr

bgtfrontbag'%Lfjj&Krognf*38??"

]ebsmf`bgbtbagbsbgnjumbgkmb``frfgtneorontfrbstbnsogmspfnb`bnsspfnb`bnotbagsa`

Njaum Nalputbgk os njossb`bfm bg @bkurf ?9 tefrf`arf tef `bvf fssfgtbojs

neorontfrbstbnsa`NjaumNalputbgkorfmf`bgfbgtef`ajjawbgkport'

@bkurf?4PbsuojLamfja`NjaumNalputbgk%Njaumnagtrajs'ark*38??"

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

14/83

^costbfgLarkogt

0

3'?'?Ag,mflogm,sfj`sfrvbnf

Btrfprfsfgtstefpassbcbjbty`aronustalfra`Njaumtaoutalotbnojjy9bgnosfa`og

bllfmbotf gffm a`nalputbgkrfsaurnfs %^tarokf* NXV*Lflary ogm saag" `ar o

mf`bgftblf9bgnrfosftefrfsaurnfswbteautogypfrsagbgtfrontbgkwbtetefnjaum

pravbmfr'%Lfjj&Krognf*38??"

3'?'3CraomGftwarionnfss

]efportbnujorbtya`njaumfgvbraglfgtbsteotojjtefrfsaurnfsorfpravbmfmavfr

tef Gftwari ogm tef fgm,usfrs bgtfr`onf nog cf vorbaus9 lacbjf* joptaps* XMOs*

tocjftsogmsaag'%Lfjj&Krognf*38??"

3'?'>Sfsaurnfpaajbgk

]ebs bmfo a rfsaurnf paajbgk bs teot Njaum Xravbmfrs nog okkrfkotf rfsaurnf

takftefr bg armfr ta ojjaw lujtbpjf nustalfrs ta usf tef Pbrtuojbzotbag

portbnujorbtbfsa`rfsaurnfseorbgk']efrf`arf*peysbnojrfsaurnfsorfmygolbnojjy

ossbkgfmogmrfossbkgfmonnarmbgktanagsulfrmflogm%Lfjj&Krognf*38??"'

Sfsaurnf paajbgk bgvajvfs njaum pravbmfrs nog eovf tef fnagaly a snojf* os

peysbnojrfsaurnfsorfvbrtuojjyseorfmcftwffgnjbfgtsogmmb``frfgtnjbfgtsnogcf

okkrfkotfbgtefsolfeormworf'Larfavfr*wbterfsaurnfpaajbgk*nagsulfrsorf

gat oworf a tef eormworf os bt cfnalfs ebmmfg `ral tefl9 tefy nog onnfss

rfsaurnfs cut magt eovf ogy nagtraj ogm bg`arlotbag ocaut janotbag* `arlot a`

tefsfrfsaurnfs'@arfxolpjf*motonogcfstarfmbgmb``frfgtjanotbags*wbteautogy

prfnbsfbg`arlotbag`artefnustalfr%btbsgagftefjfsssobmbgteftfrlsa`sfrvbnf

%]a^"a`tefnjaumpravbmfrs"'

3'?'=Sopbmfjostbnbty

NjaumNalputbgkcrbgktatefbrsnagsulfrsteffjostbnbtya`rfsaurnfs9teus*btbs

`ostogmfosy`arnagsulfrstasnojfupogmojsarfsaurnfsorfgat`bxcutcfnalf

vajotbjf* os tefy nog cf usfm ag,mflogm ogm rfjfosfm os saag os tefy cfnalf

uggfnfssory %Nebu* 38?8"' ]ef last blpartogt omvogtokf bs tef opporfgt

ugjblbtfmpaaja`rfsaurnfs`artefnagsulfr'Btbsojsaqubnitabgnrfosfnoponbtbfs

tafgsurftalfftpfoirfqubrflfgts'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

15/83

^costbfgLarkogt

;

3'?'6Lfosurfm^frvbnfs

]a fgsurf tef f` bnbfgny a tef cusbgfss lamfj a Njaum Nalputbgk tef jost

neorontfrbstbna`njaumbstefpassbcbjbty`arNjaumpravbmfrs*fvfgb`tefrfsaurnfs

orfseorfmcftwffgmb``frfgtnustalfrs*talfosurftefusokfa`fonenagsulfrs'

]efrf`arf* last a` njaum pravbmfrs cusbgfss lamfj bs tef poy,os,yau ka cbjjbgk

sajutbagwefrffonenagsulfrpoyagjyweotef!sefbsusbgk%NXV*SOL*starokf*

craom,cogmonnfss"'

3'3Njaum^frvbnfLamfjs

Njaum nalputbgk bs nojjfm o sfrvbnf arbfgtfm lamfj* tefrf`arf mb``frfgt sfrvbnf

lamfjfxbstogm lust cfugmfrstogm bgarmfrta mb` frfgtbotf tefmb``frfgt njaum

pravbmfrsogmtefbrsajutbags'OnnarmbgktaGB^]mf`bgbtbaga`NjaumNalputbgk>

mb``frfgtsfrvbnflamfjsfxbst^oo^*Xoo^ogmBoo^%Lfjj&Krognf*38??"9teusos

seawgag@bkurf3orfjbgifmtakftefrosogBoo^pjot`arlnogeastXoo^sajutbag

ar ^oo 9 agf a tef last papujor fxolpjfs bs Mrapcax eastfm bg Olozag ^>'

Eawfvfr*bgarmfrtaossfssojjtefontuojsajutbags*salfatefrsfrvbnflamfjsnog

cfmb``frfgtbotf%Kagkftoj'*38?8"'

@bkurf34GB^]Njaum^frvbnfLamfjs %^oo^Cjaks* 38??"

3'3'?^a`tworfOsO^frvbnf%^oo^"

Bgtebs lamfj* tefnjbfgts mbsneorkf tefbr oppjbnotbag bgta o eastbgk fgvbraglfgt

teot nog cf onnfssfm `ral vorbaus njbfgts sune os [fc Crawsfr* XMO* LacbjfXeagf* ftn' bg tebs lamfj* tef moto ogm tef sa`tworf orf eastfm bg tef Njaum* bt

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

16/83

^costbfgLarkogt

5

lfogs bg tef Njaum Xravbmfrs motonfgtrf' ]ef nagsulfr noggat nagtraj tef

bg`rostrunturf teot bs last a` tblf lujtb,tfgogt bg`rostrunturf' Bt bs usuojjy agf,

vfrsbagsa`tworfusfmcylasta`tefnustalfrsruggbgkbgagfjanojfgvbraglfgt*

tefnjaum']efrf`arfbtojjawsfnagalbfsa`snojf*gftwariaptblbzotbag*sfnurbty*

ovobjocbjbty* mbsostfr rfnavfry ogm lobgtfgognf `ar ojj tef nustalfrs' ^alf

fxolpjfs a` `olaus Njaum ^oo^ orf4 ^ojfs@arnf'nal* Kaakjf Opps ar A` bnf >06'

%Kagkftoj'*38?8"

3'3'3Xjot`arloso^frvbnf%Xoo^"

Xjot`arlos o ^frvbnf lust cfnalporfm ta^oo^taugmfrstogmtef spfnb`bnbty a`

Xoo^*tefbmfobsbgtebsfgvbraglfgtsajutbagtakbvftatefnustalfrtefnagtraj

avfr tef sa`tworf mfvfjaplfgt* ojjawbgk ebl!efr ta nrfotf ar mfpjay opfrsagojbsfm oppjbnotbags ogm sfrvbnfs' ]efrf`arf* ^oo bs eastbgk pramuntbag

oppjbnotbags* wefrfos Xoo^ bs eastbgk mfvfjaplfgt ogm pramuntbag ot tef solf

tblf']efrf`arf*tefnustalfrkftsnagtrajavfrojorkfrrogkfa`porolftfrsogm

nog actobg suppartbgk oppjbnotbags* mfvfjaplfgt taajs %^MI"* nag bkurotbag

logokflfgt*ogmsaag`raltefpravbmfrs'Eawfvfrtefnagsulfrnoggatnagtraj

tef njaum bg`rostrunturf sune os gftwari* sfrvfrs* Apfrotbgk systfls* starokf'

^alf fxolpjfs a Xoo orf4 Kaakjf OppFgkbgf* PLworf , Njaum @augmry ar[bgmawsOzurf'%Cfblcargftoj'*38??"

3'3'>Bg`rostrunturfoso^frvbnf%Boo^"

]ebslamfjbsnagsbmfrfmosombrfntusfa`tefNjaumBg`rostrunturf9bg`ont*tef

nagsulfreosombrfntnagtrajavfrtefapfrotbgksystfls*starokf*Gftwari*ogm

mfpjaylfgt a` oppjbnotbags' ]ef Njaum Xravbmfrs pravbmf* pranfssbgk* starokf*

gftwarinagsbmfrfmosrfsaurnfsteotusfrsnaujmonnfss'Nagsulfrsnogmfpjaytefoppjbnotbags*Apfrotbgk^ystflsteottefygffmwbteautogyjblbtotbags%`bxfm

cy tef ]a^"' Cosfm ag Pbrtuojbzotbag tfnegajakbfs* tef pravbmfrs pravbmf ta

nagsulfrssnojocbjbty*f``bnbfgny*ogmrfnavfrya`tefnjaumbg`rostrunturfwbteo

tatojnagtraj`artefnustalfrtaebsawgbg`rostrunturf'Eawfvfr*tefnustalfrs

ma gat nagtraj tef ugmfrjybgk bg`rostrunturf ar wbte salf jblbtfm onnfss ta tef

nagtrajjfm vorbocjfs %f'k' @brfwojj* Eypfrvbsar"' Og fxolpjf a` Boo^ bs Olozags

FN3cutojsa[bgmawsOzurfPL'%CN^ ]ef Neortfrfm Bgstbtutf `ar B]* 38?3"

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

17/83

^costbfgLarkogt

2

3'3'=Motostarokfoso^frvbnf%Moo^"

]ebsbsnagsbmfrfmosomfrbvfmsajutbagteotstortstacfrfojjywbmfsprfom*bgtebs

lamfj9tefvbrtuojbzfmstarokfbsosfporotfNjaumsajutbag'Btnogcfnagsbmfrfmos

ovorbogta`Boo^*cfnousfnustalfrseovfombrfntonnfsstatefstarokfnoponbtbfs'

]efbmfocfebgmMoo^bstarfmunfarsblpjb`ynasts`arnalpogbfsusbgkmotocosf

arstarokfsystfls'Bgmffm*ogbg,eausfsajutbagbgvajvfsojatnastsbgmfmbnotfm

sfrvfrs*jbnfgsfogmatefr']efrf`arfnagsulfrsorfocjfwbteMoo^taagjypoy`ar

tef usflomf a` tef motocosf %Jfvy* 3882"' ]a `bgbse* Moo^ bs o pawfr`uj os tef

pravbmfrbsocjftapravbmftaebsnustalfrsebkequojbtymotocosfwbtetocjf,styjf

ocstrontbagsjoyfr*ojjawbgksnojfupogmtastarfogmrftrbfvfcbkolaugta`moto'

OnnarmbgktaJfvy%3882"teflobgomvogtokfbs`arslojjnalpogbfsteotnoggat

o``arm sune ibgm a` motocosfs ogm actobg nalporocjf pfr`arlognf cytefbr awg

wbte njossbn SMCL^' ^alf fxolpjfs a` sune motocosf orf4 Olozag ^>* Kaakjf

Cbk]ocjfogmOponefECosf'%Jfvy*3882"

3'3'6AtefrsNjaum

]efrf`arf*`raltefbmfoa`Moo^o gulcfr a`gfwsfrvbnfs`ral tef `olbjy os o

^frvbnf %oo^" stort ta flfrkf' @ar fxolpjf* ^fnurbty os o ^frvbnf sajutbags orf

bgnrfosbgk9 ^foo^ bs o lamfj `ar sfnurbty logokflfgt `ral webne sfnurbty

oppjbnotbags orf mfjbvfrfm avfr tef gftwari' ]efrf orf mb `frfgt cfgf`bts `ar

nalpogbfs4nagstogtmf`bgbtbagupmotfs*sfnurbtyugmfrtoifgcyospfnb`bnsfnurbty

nalpogbfs%larffxpfrtbsf"*autsaurnbgka`jaklogokflfgtogmologokflfgt

nagsajfterauke[fcbgtfr`onf'%Ogtagapaujas*38?8"

@bgojjy*ogatefrsajutbag*Coniuposo^frvbnfbsusfmcynalpogbfstaconiuptefbr

moto bg tef njaum' Bt bs nalporocjf ta Moo^ prfvbausjy lfgtbagfm cut bt bs

nagsbmfrfmoso^oo^*cfnousfnjbfgtsusfogfgocjfmoppjbnotbagtalogokftefbr

coniupsteraukeologokflfgtbgtfr`onf'

]efrf`arf*tefoso^frvbnfsajutbagsorffvajvbgkogmgfwsfrvbnflamfjsstortta

flfrkf'Eawfvfr*tefnjaumbsocbknagnfptteotojsabgnjumfmb``frfgtmfpjaylfgt

lamfjmrbvfgcytefgffmsa`tefnustalfrs'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

18/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?8

3'>NjaumMfpjaylfgtLamfjs

Njaum Nalputbgk bs o vost warjm* teot bgnjumf mb``frfgt passbcbjbtbfs `ar

mfpjaylfgt9onnarmbgktatefGB^]tefrforf`aursmb``frfgtmfpjaylfgtslamfjs

%@bkurf>"*eawfvfrwfwbjjmbsnusstefpassbcbjbtytabgnjumfsalffxtrolamfjs

muftateffvajutbaga`tefgffmsa`Njaumlorift'

@bkurf>4GB^]Njaum^frvbnfLamfjs

3'>'?XrbvotfNjaum

]ef bgbtboj nagnfrg a` Njaum nalputbgk bs sfnurbty* tefrf`arf* b` nalpogbfs orf

wbjjbgktalavftatefNjaum*btbsgatwbteautcfbgksurftaiffpostragksfnurbty'

Bgtebsnosf*btbspassbcjf`artefltalavftaoprbvotfNjaum9wefrftefnjaum

bg`rostrunturf bs usfm cy o sbgkjf arkogbzotbag `ar bts awg usf ar `ar bts awg

cusbgfss']efrf`arf*btnogcfeastfmbg,eausfaragtefNjaumogmlogokfmcytef

njaum pravbmfr ar tef nalpogy btsfj ' Xrbvotf Njaum bs o sajutbag nagsbmfrfm os

omvogtokfaus`arnalpogbfs*cfnousfbtjblbtstefrbsisa`NjaumNalputbgk']ef

arkogbzotbag eos tef nagtraj avfr tef Njaum ogm bs gat seorbgk bts njaum9 tef

sfnurbty nagnfrg bs ossfssfm mbrfntjy cy tef nalpogy' ]efrf`arf* bt jblbts tef

bgtfrontbag wbte o tebrm,port ta tef lbgblul ogm kbvfs ta tef nalpogy o tatoj

nagtraja`btsnjaum'%Iujiorgbftoj'*38?3"

3'>'3NallugbtyNjaum

]ef Njaum bg`rostrunturf bs usfm cy sfvfroj arkogbzotbags teot dabg takftefr ta

rfmunf nasts ogm kft omvogtokfs a` Njaum Nalputbgk ogm Pbrtuojbzotbag' ]efsf

nalpogbfs seorf tef solf bg`rostrunturfs cut lust ojsa seorf pajbnbfs*

rfqubrflfgts* vojufs ogm nagnfrgs' ]ef Njaum nog cf eastfm cy agf a tef

arkogbzotbaga`tefnalpogyarcyotebrmport'%CN^]efNeortfrfmBgstbtutf`arB]*

38?3"

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

19/83

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

20/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?3

avfrvbfwa` salf a`teflogm njossb bfm tefl bgarmfrta ebkejbket tefmb``frfgt

kraupa`vfgmarsteotnogcflomf'

3'='?KaakjfOppFgkbgfogmKaakjf^frvbnfs

Kaakjfpravbmfstamfvfjapfrsogmnalpogbfstamfpjaytefbrawgoppjbnotbagbgta

tef Kaakjf bg`rostrunturf' Larf prfnbsfjy* ag tef solf bg`rostrunturf wefrf

Kaakjfs awg Oppjbnotbags orf ruggbgk' Vsuojjy golfm KOF ar Opp Fgkbgf bt bs

nagsbmfrfmosopjot`arlososfrvbnf'

3'='?'?@foturfs

OmmbtbagojjyKaakjfOppFgkbgf%KOF"bsojjawbgk`armfvfjaplfgta`oppjbnotbag

salfbgtfrfstbgk`foturfs'%^fvfrognf*3882"

a Fosy ta cubjm' Bg `ont* bg KOF tef mfvfjapfr dust gffm ta mfpjay bs

namf!oppjbnotbag ogm Kaakjf bg`rostrunturf wbjj logokf tef oppjbnotbag

btsfj`'

a Fosy ta snojf' Kaakjf Bg`rostrunturf wbjj outalotbnojjy snojf ogm jaom

cojognf ta ocsarc ogy bgnrfosf a tef tro` bn' [eotfvfr tef sbzf a tef

nalpogybs'

a Fosy talobgtobg' Kaakjf pravbmf Kaakjf ]aajsogm Jbcrorbfsojjawbgk tef

fosy mfvfjaplfgt a tef oppjbnotbag cut ojsa tef blpravflfgt a tef

sfnurbtya`tefoppjbnotbaga`namfstarfmagtefNjaum'Ommbtbagojjy*Kaakjf

ojjawo`ujjnagtraja`tefoppjbnotbagwbteo[fccosfmbgtfr`onfkbvbgk`ujj

nagtraja`tefoppjbnotbag'

3'='?'3Xrbnbgk%Kaakjf*38?3"

KOFojjawsterffmb``frfgtibgma`prbnbgk`artefbroppjbnotbag*@rffvfrsbag*Xobm

vfrsbag ogm Xrflbfr onnaugt' ]ef ]ocjf 3 mfsnrbcf tef mb``frfgnf cftwffg tefmb``frfgt sajutbags a``frfm ogm tef ]ocjf > tef `rff quato usokf `ar tef terff

sajutbags*cutojsatefprbnbgk`artefusokfavfrtef`rffquatojblbt`arpobmogm

prflbfrsajutbag'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

21/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?>

@rff Xobm Xrflbfr

Xrbnf @rff -2!opp!lagte -688!onnaugt!lagte

^nojbgk Rfs Rfs Rfs

Dovo!Xyteag!Ka

Sugtblf

Rfs Rfs Rfs

Vsokf Cosfm

Xrbnbgk

Ga Rfs Rfs

Bg`bgbtfjy ^nojocjf

ogm^JO

Ga Rfs Rfs

^uppart Ga Ga Rfs

]ocjf34KaakjfOppFgkbgfprbnbgksajutbags

@rff_uatopfrMoy Avfr`rff_uato%

Ag,mflogm @ragt

Bgstognf

35bgstognfpfreaur -8'85!eaur

Sfsfrvfm@ragtBgstognf Gagf -8'86!eaur

Moto^tarf ?K -8'3=!K!lagte

CogmwbmteVp|Mawg ?K|?K -8'?3!K|@rffMotostarfOXB 68i rffrfom!wrbtf!slojj -8'?8!?88iwrbtfaps

-8'8;!?88irfomaps-8'8?!?88islojjaps

CjacstarfOXB 68K -8'?>!K!lagte

]ocjf>4KaakjfOppFgkbgf@rff_uato

3'='?'>Kaakjf^frvbnfs

Eawfvfr Kaakjf gat agjy pravbmf Xoo sajutbag %tef mb` frfgt sfrvbnfs orf

ossfssfmbgsfntbag='?'3"wbteOppFgkbgf*cutbsojsapravbmbgko^oo^sajutbag4

KaakjfOpp'KaakjfOppbso^oo^sajutbagbgtfgmfm`arnalpogbfsteotnogusfojj

Kaakjf ^frvbnfs %lobj* mans* nojfgmor* neot ogm sa ag" wbte tef passbcbjbty ta

pfrsagojbzf nrfmfgtbojs* oppjbnotbags ovobjocjf ogm sfvfroj atefrs porolftfrs

usf`uj`artefomlbgbstrotbaga`tefsfrvbnfs'

:?8usfrs Njossbn%7?8usfrs" Njossbn)sfnurbtypjog

Xrbnbgk `rff -6!usfr!lagte-68!usfr!yfor

-?8!usfr!lagte

]ocjf=4KaakjfOppprbnbgksajutbags

3'='3Olozag[fc^frvbnfs

Nurrfgtjy golfm O[^ bs og Bg`rostrunturf os o ^frvbnf pravbmfm cy Olozag*

pravbmbgkowbmfrogkfa`sfrvbnfswbtebgstogtfjostbnbty*snojocbjbtyogmsfnurbty

wbteo22'26uptblf'

Olozagpravbmfstaebsnustalfrsojorkfrogkfa`sfrvbnfs*oraugm>8mbstrbcutfm

bg?3notfkarbfs4nalputf*nagtfgtmfjbvfry*motocosf*mfpjaylfgt&logokflfgt*

oppjbnotbagsfrvbnfs*sa`tworf*gftwaribgk*poylfgt&cbjjbgk*starokf*wfctro``bn

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

22/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?=

ogm wari`arnf %Olozag* 38?3"' @ar tef nalputfr notfkarbfs Olozag pravbmf

sfvfroj sajutbags* sune os Olozag FN3 `ar mfpjaylfgt a Jbgux a [bgmaws

blokfs wbte snojocbjbty* sfnurbty ogm o poy,os,yau ka cbjjbgk %Oppfgmbx K'>"* ar

OlozagFjostbnLopSfmunftapranfssojorkfolaugta`moto'Bgmotocosf*sfvfroj

sajutbagsorfovobjocjf*OlozagSMN`arrfjotbagojmotocosf%n`'Kjassory"*Olozag

mygola MC `ar Ga^_J motocosf %n`' Kjassory"* Olozag ^blpjf MC ogm atefrs'

Olozag ^blpjf MC bso sblpjf motocosf pravbmfm cy Olozag ojjawbgk ta starf*

pranfss ogm qufry tef moto starfm bg tef Njaum9 wbte tef lobg omvogtokf a` bts

sblpjbnbty %ga sneflo* outalotbn bgmfxbgk ogm OXBs"' ]efrf orf twa larf

notfkarbfs teot seaujm cf mfsnrbcfm* tef Gftwaribgk wbte Olozag Sautf 6> `ar

MG^ sfrvbnfs* O[^ Mbrfnt Naggfnt ojjawbgk sfnurfm naggfntbag ogm tro` bn

logokflfgt ogm Olozag PXN* tef gfw `foturf mbsnussfm prfvbausjy %sfntbag

3'?'>'6"'@bgojjy*tef^tarokfnotfkarybsbgnjumbgkOlozag^>opapujorsfrvbnf`ar

`ujjy rfmugmogt moto starokf `ar ogy olaugt a moto ovobjocjf `ral ogywefrf'

%Lurty*3885"

3'='>Lbnrasa`t

3'='>'?Lbnrasa`t^frvbnfs%Lbnrasa`t*38??"

Lbnrasa`t pravbmf ta nalpogy mb `frfgt sfrvbnfs os ^oo ojjawbgk tefl ta kft

snojocjfogmrfjbocjfsfrvbnfscutojsarfmunftefbrnasts'Lbnrasa`tpravbmfsterff

mb``frfgtnjaumpramunts4Lbnrasa`tA``bnf>06*Lbnrasa`tNSLagjbgfogm[bgmaws

Bgtugf'

Lbnrasa`t A` bnf >06 bs o sfnurf onnfss ta flobj* nojfgmors* A` bnf wfc opps*

lfssokbgk*nag`frfgnbgk*wfcsbtfogm`bjfseorbgk']efcusbgfsslamfjomaptfmbs

opoypfrusfrsajutbagrfojjyneorontfrbstbna`^oo^%prbnbgk4OppfgmbxK'3"'

Lbnrasa`t NSL a``frs ta bts nustalfrs tef passbcbjbty `ar nalpogbfs ta mfpjay o

NSLbgtatefnjaum*wbteocusbgfsslamfjpoy,pfr,usfr'

@bgojjy* Lbnrasa`t Bgtugf bs o sajutbag ta logokf nalputfr fqubplfgt rflatfjy

`ralo[fcoppjbnotbag'Btkbvfstanalpogbfssalfpassbcbjbtbfs4

a Mbstrbcutfsa`tworf'

a ^ftsfnurbtypajbnbfs'

a XratfntXNs`rallojworf'

a LogokfXNupmotfs'

a XraontbvfjylagbtarXNs'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

23/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?6

a Xravbmfrflatfossbstognf'

a ]oifomvogtokfa`omvognfmsfnurbtybg[bgmaws;Fgtfrprbsf'

3'='>'3Lbnrasa`tOzurfXjot`arl%Sfmior&Kubmbnb*38??"

]ef Lbnrasa`t Ozurf pjot arl bs o Xjot`arl os o ^frvbnf eastfm bg Lbnrasa`t

motonfgtrfspravbmbgksfrvbnfstacubjmoppjbnotbag`arojorkfsnojfa`nustalfrs

%bgmbvbmuoj ta lujtbgotbagojs"' Lbnrasa`t Ozurf pjot arl pravbmfs mb `frfgt

sfrvbnfs,[bgmawsOzurf*^_J^frvbnfsogm'GF]sfrvbnfs,ojjbgmfpfgmfgtscut

teot nog cf usfm bg nagdugntbag wbte fone atefrs' Bt ojsa a` frs ag,mflogm

rfsaurnfs ta nustalfrs ta mfvfjap tefbr oppjbnotbag ogm east bt bg tef Njaum cy

usbgkospfnb`bnmfvfjapfrtaajs*Lbnrasa`tPbsuoj^tumba'

^_Jsfrvbnfsojjawstarokfa`moto`artefoppjbnotbagcutojsabgnjumf^_JOzurf

sfrvbnfojjawbgkrfjotbagojqufrbfs*sforne*rfpartbgk*ogojytbnsogmsaag'

'GF] sfrvbnf o sft a` nalpagfgts ta efjp mfvfjapfrs ta mfvfjapfrs `ar

mfvfjaplfgta`tefbroppjbnotbag*btbsoporta`tef'GF]`rolfwari'

Larfavfrogfwsfrvbnfeoscffgrfjfosfmojjawbgkmfpjaylfgta`PbrtuojLonebgf

%Jbguxar[bgmaws"agOzurfXjot`arlogmojsasalfgfwprakrolbgkjogkuokf

%sfntbag='?'3"'

3'='=^ojfs`arnf'nal

[fjj igawg `ar bts Nustalfr Sfjotbagsebp Logokflfgt* ^ojfs`arnf fxpfgms bts

cusbgfss terauke mb` frfgt onqubsbtbag ogm pravbmf gaw mb` frfgt NSL sfrvbnfs4

]ef^ojfsNjaum*]ef^frvbnfNjaumogm@arnf'nalpjot`arl'%Easne*38?3"

3'='='?]ef^ojfsNjaum

Najjocarotbvf pjot arl `ar nalpogbfs* pravbmbgk najjocarotbvf taajs sune os

Neottfr* wbte tef passbcbjbty ta logokf nustalfrs pra`bjf ogm onnaugt ebstary'

[btebgosbgkjfoppjbnotbagonnfssbcjfteraukewfc*lacbjfogmtocjft*btfgeognfs

tefNSLa`onalpogycyojjawbgkteflogokflfgta`loriftbgknolpobkgsavfr

mb``frfgt lfmbo* sojfs* nallugbnotbag* najjocarotbag ogm tef appartugbtbfs ta

mfpjayropbmjyonustaloppjbnotbag'%[agkftoj'*38??"

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

24/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?0

3'='='3]ef^frvbnfNjaum

Nosf cosfm nalpogy logokflfgt systfl ta troni ogm logokf fvfgts teot nog

annur'OsojjsajutbagcosfmagNjaumtebsNSLbsovobjocjfagtefnjaumogmbgnjumf

osanbojgftwaripjot`arlta`ajjawtefnosfsogmmbsnusstefl'%[agkftoj'*38??"

3'='='>@arnf'nalpjot`arl

@arnf'nal bs tef Xoo^ pjot`arl a` ^ojfs`arnf'nal* ojjawbgk tef mfvfjaplfgt a`

nustalsoppjbnotbagogmeaststeflbgtatef@arnf'nalmotonfgtrfscyusbgktwa

prakrollbgk jogkuokfs Opfx %@arnf'nal praprbftory" ogm Pbsuoj arnf %@bsefr*

388;"' ]ef prbnbgk bs usfr!lagte ogm mfpfgms ag tef sfrvbnfs osifm `ar tef

oppjbnotbag*suneoslacbjfonnfss*suppart*mfvfjaplfgtsuppartogmsaag9teus

terff cbjjbgk sajutbagsorf a``frfm wbte terff mb``frfgt jfvfj a`sfrvbnf %]ocjf 6"'

%^orog*3882"

AgfOpp Fgtfrprbsf Vgjblbtfm

Xrbnfusfr!lagtes ?6- 68- ;6-

Opp ? ?8 Vgjblbtfm

]ocjf64@arnf'nalprbnbgk

3'='6FLN

FLNbs tef warjmjfomfrbg sfrvbnfsogmsajutbag`arstarokfogm logokflfgta`

tef bg`arlotbag' FLN pravbmfs mb``frfgt sajutbags ogm pramunts `ar ornebvbgk*

coniup ar rfnavfry* nagtfgt logokflfgt* bg`arlotbag logokflfgt* B]

logokflfgt*sfnurbty*starokfogmvbrtuojbzotbag'

@ar tef vbrtuojbzotbag port* FLN onqubrfm bg 3882 o nalpogy spfnbojbzfm bg

vbrtuojbzotbag sa`tworf PLworf* jfombgk ta tef wfjj,igawg sajutbag a`

vbrtuojbzotbags usfm bg gulfraus motonfgtrfs %Pfjtf ft oj'* 38?8"' Eawfvfr*

PLworf njaum bs gat pravbmbgk sajutbag cut kat salf portgfrsebp wbte salf

nalpogbfs'PLworfojsamfvfjapogapfgpradfnt`arbgtfrapfrocbjbtyteotwbjjcf

mbsnussfmbgsfntbag3';'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

25/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?;

3'6Bgtfrapfrocbjbtya`NjaumPfgmars

3'6'?Mf`bgbtbaga`NjaumBgtfrapfrocbjbty

Bgtfrapfrocbjbtybsgatosblpjftfrl`arNjaumNalputbgkmuftatefmbvfrsbtya`

tef sajutbags fxbstbgk ag tef lorift' Nagsfqufgtjy* sfvfroj ottflpts eovf cffg

lomftaugmfrstogmtef^nojfa`bgtfrapfrocbjbtyogmmf`bgfNjaumbgtfrapfrocbjbty'

Onnarmbgk ta NNVNMK %38?8"* tef mf`bgbtbag a` Njaum Bgtfrapfrocbjbty bs4 tef

ocbjbty ta wrbtf namf teot waris wbte larf teog agf Njaum Xravbmfr

sblujtogfausjy* rfkormjfss a` tef mb` frfgnfs cftwffg tef pravbmfrs' Eawfvfr*

BFFF mf`bgfm Njaum Bgtfrapfrocbjbty larf prfnbsfjy os tef ocbjbty a` lujtbpjf

systfls ar nalpagfgts bg fxneogkbgk bg`arlotbag ogm usbgk tef bg`arlotbag

webne orf fxneogkfm %BFFF* ?228"' ]efrf`arf* bt bs bgtfrfstbgk ta mfvfjap

toxagalytacosftefmfvfjaplfgta`suneoppjbnotbagtafgsurftefnalpotbcbjbty

a`tefmb``frfgtsajutbags%Jautosftoj'*38??"'Ommbtbagojjyteftwaoppraonewbjj

cf mbsnuss bg tebs stumy* cy mbsnussbgk og bgtfrapfrocjf oppjbnotbag* ossfssbgk

NNVNMK%38?8"mf`bgbtbag*teotwbjjcfmfpjayfmbgogbgtfrapfrocjffgvbraglfgt*

ossfssbgkBFFF%?228"mf`bgbtbag'

3'6'3Nalporbsaga`salfNjaumXravbmfrs

Xrfvbausjy* %3'?'=" tef tbtogs a` Njaum Nalputbgk eovf cffg mbsnussfm' Eawfvfr

tebs jbst bs gat fxeoustbvf ogm lune larf pjoyfrs nog cf lfgtbagfm EX* BCL*

Cjufjani*Nbtrbx*Dayfgt*Pfrbzag*Sonisponfogmsaag'Larfavfr*btbsblpartogtta

ebkejbketsalfportgfrsebpcftwffgnalpogbfs*suneosolozag!BCL*^OX!BLCar

EX!Bgtfj!Roeaa/' ]efrf`arf* tebs popfr wbjj stumy salf a tef last papujor

pjot`arlbgarmfrtanalporftefbrspfnb`bnotbagogmtefgmfvfjapogfxolpjfa`

toxagalya`salfpravbmfrstastumytefbrnalpotbcbjbty%sfntbag='?'3"'

Cyjaaibgkottefnjaumpravbmfrsbgtefprfvbausport%3'="*btebkejbketstefebke

mbvfrsbtya`tefpjot`arl`arNjaumNalputbgkteotfxbst*wefrfossalfa`teflorf

apfgtasfvfrojjogkuokfsatefrsorflarfnjasfogmtefynogfvfgbgvajvfmsalf

praprbftory jogkuokfs spfnb bn ta tef pjot`arl' ]efrf`arf* bt bs fssfgtboj ta

ugmfrstogmtefmb``frfgnfcftwffgtefmb``frfgtoso^frvbnfsajutbagprapasfm*

os fone a` tefl kat tefbr awg spfnb`bnotbags ogm lust cf `anusfm sfporotfjy bg

rfkorm ta bgtfrapfrocbjbty %Lfjj & Krognf* 3882"' Bg `ont* bgtfrapfrocbjbty bs o

neojjfgkbgkbssuf`ar^oo^*muftatefbgnoponbty`artefnustalfrtarfojjyonnfss

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

26/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?5

tef pjot`arl' Bgtebs nagtfxt*tebs stumybsmbsnussbgk njaumbgtfrapfrocbjbty `ral

njbfgtpabgta`vbfwogmteusbs`anussbgkagoXoo^ogmBoo^lamfj'

3'0^uppartbgkrfsfornefs

3'0'? JB^B4 O lamfj `ar Bgtfrapfrocbjbty ta ommrfss Njaum

Bgtfrapfrocbjbty

Jfvfj a Bg`arlotbag ^ystfl Bgtfrapfrocbjbty lamfj %JB^B lamfj" bs o lamfj

mfvfjapfm cy tef V' Mfportlfgt a` Mf`fgnf ta ommrfss njaum bgtfrapfrocbjbty'

OnnarmbgktaMawfjjftoj'%38??"tebslamfjbsfxolbgbgktefocbjbtytaa`seorbgk

cftwffgnjaumbgtfrla`XOBM4

a Xranfmurf4onnfptognfa`sblbjorornebtfnturfarsystfl'

a Oppjbnotbag4rf`jfnttefnoponbtya`tefoppjbnotbagtacfruggbgkagmb``frfgt

pjot`arlogmcfomoptocjftaojjpjot`arls'

a Bg`rostrunturf4rfprfsfgttefnaggfntbagscftwffgtefoppjbnotbagsogmtef

systfls'

a Moto4ogffma``jfxbcbjbty`armoto'

Larfavfr* JB B lamfj ojsa ossfss tef jfvfj a` bgtfrapfrocbjbty ar seorbgk a` tef

sajutbag cy usbgk `bvf mb``frfgt jfvfjs a bgtfrapfrocbjbty %Mawfjj ft oj'* 38??"'

]efsf jfvfjs ossfss tef loturbty a` tef lamfjs `ral o cosbn ta tatoj

bgtfrapfrocbjbty4

a Jfvfj8BsajotfmBgtfrapfrocbjbty4systflogmoppjbnotbagorfbsajotfmogm

motolustcffxtrontfmloguojjy'

a Jfvfj ? Naggfntfm Bgtfrapfrocbjbty4 naggfntfm bgtfrapfrocbjbty wefrf

moto ogm oppjbnotbags orf sfporotf ogm naggfntfm terauke pffr,ta,pffr

naggfntbags'

a Jfvfj 3 @ugntbagoj Bgtfrapfrocbjbty4 moto ogm oppjbnotbags orf ojwoys

sfporotf cut tef nallugbnotbags cftwffg oppjbnotbags orf fvajvbgk ta o

cosbnnajjocarotbagwbteeftfrakfgfauspramuntfxneogkf'

a Jfvfj > Malobg,cosfm Bgtfrapfrocbjbty4 tef moto orf seorfm cfsbmf o

malobgcuttefoppjbnotbagrflobgssfporotfm*tefrfbsoebkefrmfkrffa`

najjocarotbag'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

27/83

^costbfgLarkogt

?2

a Jfvfj = Fgtfrprbsf,cosfm Bgtfrapfrocbjbty4 wf orf bg o ebkefr mfkrff a`

najjocarotbag9 oppjbnotbag* moto ogm motocosf orf seorfm' ]ef

bgtfrapfrocbjbtybstatoj'

Bgtefbrpopfr* Mawfjj ft oj' %38??"ebkejbket tef ontuoj bgtfrapfrocbjbty a`njaum

ogmtefgfnfssbty`arNjaumpravbmfrstarfoneotjfosttefjfvfj3*bgarmfrtacfbg

ogonnfptocjfbgtfrapfrocbjbtyjfvfjosbtbsmf`bgfmostef`ugntbagojjfvfj`arNjaum

bgtfrapfrocbjbty'

Eawfvfr* tebs stumy bs gat agjy mbsnussbgk tef lamfj cut ojsa tef fxbstbgk

neojjfgkfs ta rfone tebs bgtfrapfrocbjbty' @brst* tef partocbjbty ogm lacbjbty bs

fssfgtboj* os wf mbsnussfm prfvbausjy %port 3'6'3" ta ojjaw o partocbjbty a tef

oppjbnotbag wbte o lbgblul lamb`bnotbag ogm bg tef bmfoj nosf wbteaut

lamb`bnotbag'^fnagmjy*bgtefnurrfgtprontbnfbgarmfrtaiffpogoppjbnotbagtacf

up,ta,motf ogm `ujjy `ugntbagoj* bt bgvajvfs o jorkf olaugt a mfvfjaplfgt'

]efrf`arf* `ar o `ujj bgtfrapfrocbjbty a oppjbnotbags* bt bs fssfgtboj ta oppjy o

^frvbnfArbfgtfmOrnebtfnturfteotnogbgtfrontwbte[fc^frvbnfs']ebrmjy*Njaum

pravbmfrs lust fgsurf tef sfnurbty* prbvony ogm mfvfjap tef trust a tefbr

bg`rostrunturf' Bg`ont*Gfjsag ft oj' %38??"mbsnuss tef blpartognf a`sfnurbty bg

onnfssbgkrflatfrfsaurnfsogmteftrustgffmfmcftwffgpravbmfrstamfvfjapojj

tebs passbcbjbtbfs' @bgojjy* tef jost pabgt bs tef oumbt ogm lagbtarbgk a` tef njaum

pravbmfrs*osbtbsfssfgtbojtafgsurfteflagbtarbgka`sfnurbtybssufsarvbajotbag

a`pajbnbfs'

[efrfos Mawfjj ft oj' %38??" bs mbsnussbgk og bgtfrapfrocbjbty lamfj `ar njaum

nalputbgk*ogmlarfprfnbsfjyolamfjtafvojuotftefbgtfrapfrocbjbtya`onjaum

sajutbag' Bt bs ojsa o kaam stort ta ugmfrstogm tef gfnfssbty ta mfvfjap og

bgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbagbgtefNjaum']efrf`arf*btlustcfebkejbketfmmb``frfgt

pabgt teot nog ojjaw tef mfpjaylfgt a og bgtfrapfrocjf fgvbraglfgt' Bt bs

blpartogttamfvfjapogoppjbnotbagbgmfpfgmfgta`tefNjaumpravbmfr9btlfogs

bgo mfvfjaplfgtjogkuokf teot nog cfusfmbgsfvfroj pjot`arls wbteaut jbgita

tefpjot`arlbtsfj`'Ommbtbagojjy*tefnallugbnotbagcftwffgtefoppjbnotbag*tef

sfrvbnfogmmotocosf%Bg`rostrunturf"lustcflomfbgonalprfefgsbvfwoyogm

larf prfnbsfjy avfr tef [fc' Bg tebs nosf mb``frfgt sajutbag nog cf fgvbsokfm*

Kavbgmorodog&Joiselogog%38?8"ebkejbkettwasajutbagstef^AOarSF^]%n`'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

28/83

^costbfgLarkogt

38

Kjassory" ornebtfnturf ta nallugbnotf cftwffg tef mb` frfgt sfrvbnfs ar

rfsaurnfs'

3'0'3Bgtfrapfrocjf@rolfwariolagkNjaumXravbmfrs

Bgtefbrstumy*Lbr`oierobftoj'%38?3"mfvfjaptefbmfoa`onagnfptuoj!sflogtbn

@rolfwari`arBgtfrapfrocbjbtyolagkNjaumXravbmfrs'Larfprfnbsfjy*tebspopfr

mfvfjaps ebke,jfvfj bssufs ta `onbjbtotf tef bgtfrontbag a tef mb `frfgt njaum

pravbmfrs' Lbr`oierob ft oj' %38?3" mbsnuss terff pracjfls `ar bgtfrapfrocbjbty4

sfrvbnflbkrotbag*sfrvbnfbgtfrontbagogmsfrvbnfnalpasbtbag'Bgnagsfqufgnfsta

sajvftefpracjfla`trustlfgtbagfmcyMawfjjftoj'%38??"bgtefbrstumybtbs

blpartogt ta mfvfjap o Nfgtroj Vgbt cftwffg tef pravbmfrs teot nog cf sffoso

rf`frfftalogokfteftrogsontbagcftwffgtefl'

@bkurf=4Bgtfrapfrocbjbty@rolfwari%Lbr`oierobftoj'*38?3"

Os seaw bg @bkurf =* tef sfrvbnf ta cf lbkrotf cftwffg pravbmfrs gffm ta ka

teraukeogomoptarteotwbjjcfteflogokfra`tefbgtfrapfrocbjbty*cynagvfrtbgk

bgtaagfa`tefstogmormigawgcytefNfgtrojVgbttefsfrvbnf`raltefpravbmfrO'

]efrf`arf*tefNfgtrojVgbtbstefrf`frffteotwbjjlogokftefmb``frfgtnagmbtbags

`arteflbkrotbag4okrfflfgtcftwffgpravbmfrs*stogmormsnagtrajogmnagvfrsbag

`artefmfstbgotbagpravbmfrsomoptarb`gfnfssory'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

29/83

^costbfgLarkogt

3?

Bgogutsefjj*Lbr`oierobftoj'%38?3"mfvfjapfmo`rolfwaria`bgtfrapfrocbjbtyta

logokfolbkrotbaga`sfrvbnfscftwffgpravbmfrs']efrf`arf*btbsbgtfrfstbgkta

mbsnuss tef bmfo ta gat eovf ta mfpjay oppjbnotbag bgtfrapfrocjf cut ta nrfotf o

sajutbagtalogokftefbgtfrapfrocbjbtycymfvfjapbgko]ebrmportyarkogbzotbag

teot wbjj logokf tef bgtfrapfrocbjbty ogm cf bg neorkf a tef bgtfrapfrocbjbty'

Eawfvfr*sfvfrojpabgtlustcfmf`bgftafgsurftefsunnfssa`sunesajutbag*sune

ostefrfspagsbcjfbgneorkfa`tebsNfgtrojVgbt*tefnastsossanbotfmogmorfoj

latbvotbag`artefNjaumXravbmfrstatoifporta`sunesajutbag'

Bg`ont*PLworfbs nagsbmfrfmos agfa`tefbggavotar a`Njaum Nalputbgk ogm bs

toibgkojata`pasbtbvfbgbtbotbvf`artefNjaum'Gfvfrtefjfss*onnarmbgktaCramibg

%38??"lasta`tefbggavotbagsbgbtbotfmorfPLworfnfgtrfmogmbgvajvftefusf

a`PLworftfnegajakbfsogmtefgtefjani,bga`tefusfrsbgtaospfnb`bnsajutbag9

fvfg teauke PLworf bs mfvfjapbgk o gfw bgtfrapfrocjf sajutbag wbte Njaum

@augmry%PLworf*38?3"nojlbgkogapfgogmbgtfrapfrocjfnjaum']efrf`arf*bt

jaaisfssfgtbojtacyposslasta`tebspracjfltaapt`arolujtbpjot`arlsajutbag

wefrfoppjbnotbagsorf`ujjybgtfrapfrocjfogmbgmfpfgmfgta`tefpjot`arl'

3';Nagtrostbgkvbfwsogmkops

]efprfvbausjbtfroturfmbsnusssfvfrojbgtfrfstbgkpabgtssuneoslamfj`arnjaumbgtfrapfrocbjbty*tefagtajakytaNjaumbgtfrapfrocbjbtyogmoreftarbnoj`rolfwari

`arbgtfrapfrocbjbtycftwffgnjaumpravbmfrs'Gfvfrtefjfss*fvfgb`tefjbtfroturfbs

ossfssbgknjaumbgtfrapfrocbjbty*btojsambsnussbgkatefrpabgtsteotlustcftoifg

bgta nagsbmfrotbag' Bg `ont* onnarmbgk ta Jautos ft oj' %38??" b` yau nagsbmfr tef

stogmormsmfvfjapfmcyKraupbgbtbotbvfs%]ocjf6"arfvfgcyPfgmarbgbtbotbvfs

%]ocjf0"btbsmb``bnujttablokbgftefpassbcbjbtytamfvfjaptefsajutbaga`onfgtroj

ugbtmbsnussfmcyLbr`oierobftoj'%38?3"%sfntbag3'0'3"'Bg`ont*nrfotbgkonfgtrojugbt bs gat toibgk bgta nagsbmfrotbag tef rflobgbgk bssufs teot sune sajutbag

bgvajvfs'^fnurbtyrflobgsopracjflogmtefrfbsgarfosag`aronalpogytatrust

tefNfgtrojVgbtosluneosogyatefrNjaumXravbmfrs'Bgogutsefjj*btbsblpartogt

ta iffp bg lbgm teot fone gfw stogmormar sajutbag `ar bgtfrapfrocbjbty* fvfg b`

tefy wbse ta fgeognf bgtfrapfrocbjbty* wbjj jfom ta systfls gat bgtfrapfrocjf

cftwffgfoneatefr'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

30/83

^costbfgLarkogt

33

^togmormGolf Kraup Bgtfrfst

Vgb bfmNjaumBgtfr`onf NjaumNalputbgkBgtfrapfrocbjbty@arul

CubjmogOXBa`ojjNjaumOXBscosfmagSM@ogmagtajaky

ApfgNjaumNalputbgk ApfgKrbm@arul XravbmfOXB`arrflatflogokflfgta`Boo^

ApfgPbrtuojbsotbag@arlot

ML]@ Mfvfjap bgmustry stogmorm `arpartocjfPbrtuojLonebgf

^togmorma`

Bgtfrapfrocbjbtya`JorkfNjaum

ApfgNjaum

Nagsartbul

[ari ag jorkf moto Njaums ogm

NalputfNjaumsBgtfrapfrocbjbty

]ocjf04Bgtfrapfrocbjbty,KraupBgbtbotbvfs%Kavbgmorodog&Joiselogog*38?8"

^togmormGolf Kraup Bgtfrfst

KaKrbmOXB KaKrbm XucjbnOXBtalogokftefbrNjaum

NjaumworfApfgOrnebtfnturf >]fro MfvfjapogApfgOrnebtfnturf@rolfwari`arNjaumNalputbgkwbtebgtfrapfrocjfsajutbag

Njaum@augmry Njaum@augmry Mfvfjapogbgtfrapfrocjfpjot`arlcftwffgmb``frfgtNjaumpravbmfrs

]ocjf;4Bgtfrapfrocbjbty,PfgmarBgbtbotbvfs%Kavbgmorodog&Joiselogog*38?8"

Larfavfr*Kavbgmorodog& Joiselogog%38?8"stotfteottefbgtfkrotbagcftwffg

tefmb``frfgtlamfjsarnjaumbsrfstrbntfm*ogmlasta`tefsajutbagsorf`anusbgk

ag tef Boo^ ornebtfnturf' Bg `ont* salf sajutbags sune os tef AP@ stogmorm

mfvfjapfmcytefkraupML]@ommrfsstefBoo^pjot`arlbssuf9cuttefpracjfla`

bgtfrapfrocbjbty `ar Xoo^ ogm ^oo^ rflobg ogm bs gat `ujjy ossfssfm bg tef

jbtfroturf'Ommbtbagojjy*wefrfossfvfrojstogmormsfxbstogmorfmbsnussfmbgtef

jbtfroturf* tef mfvfjaplfgt a` stogmorms ojjawbgk mb``frfgt bgtfrontbag cftwffg

prbvotf ogm pucjbn Njaum ma gat fxbst ogm orf gat ossfssfm cy tef jbtfroturf

%Kavbgmorodog&Joiselogog*38?8"'

@bgojjy*tebspopfrmbsnussfmsfvfrojNjaumstogmorms`arbgtfrapfrocbjbty*ojjawbgk

tef mfvfjaplfgt a` og bgtfrapfrocjf njaum' Gfvfrtefjfss* fvfg b sfvfroj

blpjflfgtotbags fxbst a` sune stogmorms* onnarmbgk ta Jautos ft oj' %38??"* bt bs

fssfgtbojtaovabmrfbgvfgtbgktefweffjogm`anusbgkaglamfjsogmOXBs*bgarmfr

tamfvfjapbgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbags'

Nagsfqufgtjy*onnarmbgktatefjonia`stumbfs`anusbgkagtefXoo^ogmBoo^Njaum

lamfj ogm kop bg jbtfroturf nagnfrgbgk tef mfvfjaplfgt a bgtfrapfrocjf

oppjbnotbagscosfmagfxbstbgkmotolamfjsogmNjaumlamfjs']ebs^tumywbjj`anus

agtef mfvfjaplfgta` o `rolfwari taossfsstef pracjfl a`Bgtfrapfrocbjbtybg

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

31/83

^costbfgLarkogt

3>

NjaumNalputbgk`raltefnustalfrpabgta`vbfwcymfvfjapbgkogbgtfrapfrocjf

oppjbnotbagmfpjayfmbgogbgtfrapfrocjfpjot`arl%sfntbag3'6'?"cosfmagfxbstbgk

motoogmNjaumlamfjs'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

32/83

^costbfgLarkogt

3=

>'Lfteamajaky

]ebsportwbjjmbsnusstefrfsfornelfteamsugmfrtoifgmurbgktebsstumyogmtef

rfosagsa`tefsfneabnfsbgnalporbsagwbteatefrrfsfornelfteams'Bgommbtbag*

tebsneoptfrebkejbketseawtefoppraonesupparttefrfsforneacdfntbvfsogmtef

neabnfs lomf bg armfr ta norry aut tefsf acdfntbvfs' ]eus muf tef mb` frfgt

pranfssfsugmfrtoifgbsbtfssfgtbojtambsnusstefrfsforneoppraoneogmlfteams

teotnaujmeovfcffgusfm'

>'?SfsforneOppraone

Mbsnussbgk tef rfsforne oppraone bs fssfgtboj bg armfr ta norry aut o sunnfss`uj

rfsforne ogm o `brst stort ta fgsurf tef naefrfgnf a` bt' Onnarmbgk ta [ojjblog

%38??"bg prontbnoj snbfgnf* twa mb` frfgt oppraonefs nog cf usfm ta strunturf o

rfsforne* tef bgmuntbvf rfosagbgk ar mfmuntbvf rfosagbgk' [efrfos bgmuntbvf

rfosagbgk bs nagsbmfrfm os tef flpbrbnbst oppraone* tef mfmuntbvf rfosagbgk bs

nalporfmtaolarfrotbagojbstoppraone'

>'?'?Bgmuntbvf

Agtefagfeogm*tefflpbrbnbstoppraoneugmfrtoifgbgBgmuntbvfrfosagbgknog

cfmfsnrbcfmosteffjocarotbaga`kfgfrojtefarbfscosfmagspfnb`bnacsfrvotbaga`

tef warjm %Mowsag* 3882o"' Eawfvfr* mb `frfgt tfgmfgnbfs fxbst bg Bgmuntbvf

rfosagbgk* wefrfos pasbtbvbsl oppraone mfsnrbcfs kfgfroj nagnjusbags `ral

acsfrvotbags ogm oppjy bt bg ogatefr nagtfxt* tef ogtb,pasbtbvbsl wbjj iffp tef

tefarbfsmfvfjapfmbgospfnb`bnnagtfxta`ostumy%^ougmfrsftoj'*3882"'

Nagsfqufgtjy*bgmuntbvfoppraonemafsgat`bttefnagtfxta`tebsstumyoswforf

nagsbmfrbgk mbsnussbgk spfnb bn ospfnt a` Oppjbnotbag Bgtfrapfrocbjbty ogm gat

robsbgkavfrojjtefarbfs'Bg`ont*tebsstumywbjjgatpramunfkfgfrojnagnjusbagsar

tefarbfsosbgmuntbvfoppraonejfomta9teususbgksunerfosagbgkwaujmjfomtef

stumybgowragkmbrfntbagogmwaujmpfreopscbostefrfsujts'

>'?'3Mfmuntbvf

Agtefatefreogm*tefrotbagojbstoppraonea`tefmfmuntbvfrfosagbgkbsmfsnrbcfm

cy Ognbfgt Krffi os tef ogswfrs ta tefarbfs prfvbausjy mfvfjapfm cy usbgk

acsfrvotbagarfxpfrblfgtogmcynagnjumbgk`raltefmb``frfgtrfsujts%[ojjblog*

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

33/83

^costbfgLarkogt

36

38??"'Bgatefrwarms*yaustortwbteyaurigawjfmkfogmugmfrstogmbgka`tef

warjm ogm prfmbnt jbifjy acsfrvotbag wbtebg bt %Mowsag* 3882o"' ]efrf`arf* o

mfmuntbvfoppraone`jawnogcfmfsnrbcfmososeawgbg`bkurf69`brstcyogojysbgk

teftefary*btwbjjjfomtatefmfvfjaplfgta`eypatefsbs`artefstumy9tefrf`arf*

salfacsfrvotbagsarfxpfrblfgtswbjjmbrfntjyjfomtatefnagnjusbag'

@bkurf64Mfmuntbvfoppraone@jaw%^ougmfrsftoj'*3882"'

Gfvfrtefjfss*osseawgbg`bkurf0ogblpartogtporta`tfstbgkogmbgvfstbkotbagbs

gfnfssory`armfmuntbvfrfosagbgktatfsttefeypatefsfsogmblpravftefl'

@bkurf04Mfmuntbvfrfosagbgk

]ef mfmuntbvf oppraone bs usfm bg tebs popfr ta mbsnuss tef mfvfjaplfgt a` og

bgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbag'Nagsfqufgtjya`tebsoppraone*tefblpjflfgtotbageos

cffg lomf bg armfr ta mbsnuss tef eypatefsfs lomf ogm blpravf tef rfsujts'

Ommbtbagojjy*ogbgtfrvbfwbslomfbgarmfrtambsnussogmnag`brltefprfmbntbag'

@bgojjy* wbte tef bg`arlotbag najjfntfm* acsfrvotbags lomf ogm fxpfrblfgtotbag

norrbfmaut*tefoutearbsnagnjumbgkogmloibgksukkfstbags`ar`urtefrstumbfs'

>'3Ogojysbsa`tefrfsfornelfteams

]efprfvbausport%sfntbag>'?"mbsnussfstefrfsforneoppraonea`tebsstumy9teus

btbsfssfgtbojtaogojysftefmb``frfgtlfteamsusfm`artebsmfmuntbvfoppraone'Bg

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

34/83

^costbfgLarkogt

30

`ont*rfsforne lfteams orf prbgnbpojjyo sajutbag `ar rfsfornefrsta cubjmo vojbm

stumyogmojsataovabmsalfcbososbgvfstbkotarsarportbnbpogtsa`stumbfsorf

lasta`teftblfoppraonebgkstumbfswbtesalfoprbary'Bgommbtbag*btbsfssfgtboj

ta kft o njfor ugmfrstogmbgk a` tef rfsforne lfteams* muf ta tef nagsfqufgnfs

tefy nog eovf ag tef rfsforne pranfss ogm tefg ag tef rfsujts a tef stumy

%Cfrgmtssagftoj'*3885"'

OnnarmbgktaMowsag%3882o"*twamb``frfgtrfsfornefslfteamsfxbst*quojbtotbvf

ogmquogtbtotbvf'_uojbtotbvfrfsfornelfteamsorfarbkbgotfm`ral^anboj^nbfgnf

ogm nagnfrgfm ta mfvfjap tef igawjfmkf a o spfnb`bn orfo* lune larf teog

mbsnussbgkospfnb`bntapbn'Nagsfqufgtjy*ospfnb`bnpabgta`vbfwbsusfmbglasta`

quojbtotbvflfteamsogmkfgfrojjytefpabgta`vbfwomaptfmbs`orfa`tefsucdfnt

stumbfm%Cfrgmtssagftoj'*3885"'Bgommbtbag*tebsrfsfornelfteama`tfgbgvajvfm

tefusfa`flpbrbnojtfnegbnsuneossurvfysogmbssucdfntavfrteftblftaneogkfs

ogmnoggatcfrfpfotfmbg'

_uogtbtotbvf rfsforne lfteams* ag tef atefr eogm* orf lastjy arbkbgotbgk `ral

goturojsnbfgnfs*ogmmbsnusstefgoturfa`spfnb`bntapbn*suneoseawsalftebgkbs

nagstruntfm* eaw bt bs cubjm* ar eaw bt waris %Mowsag* 3882o"' Muf ta tef

nallag usf a` eypatefsfs teot orf fstocjbsefm ogm tfstfm os og oppraone a`

quogtbtotbvf rfsforne* quogtbtotbvf rfsfornefs bgtfgm ta cf `rfqufgtjy usfm bgmfmuntbvf oppraone' ]efrf`arf* acsfrvotbag ogm fxpfrblfgts orf o jorkf port a`

tef wari ta actobg vojbmbty a` tef eypatefsfs' [efrfos stumbfs nog cf rfpfotfm

wbtemb``bnujtbfsbgquojbtotbvfrfsfornelfteam*rfpfotocbjbtya`teffxpfrblfgts

ogmtfstbgka`eypatefsfsorfvbtojtatefrfjbocbjbtya`tefrfsujts%Cfrgmtssagft

oj'*3885"'

Nagsbmfrbgk tef obl a tebs stumy ta mfvfjap o `rolfwari `ar bgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbag cy bgvfstbkotbgk tef Njaum fgvbraglfgt ogm tef mb` frfgt stogmorms

fxbstbgk* bt bs prfsulfm ta mfvfjap og oppjbnotbag ogm mfpjay bt ta tef Njaum'

]efrf`arf*ogquogtbtotbvfoppraonebsnagsbmfrfmbgtebsstumyogmojjteftfstbgk

ogm pranfssfsorf mbsnussfm ogm manulfgtfm bgarmfrtacfrfpjbnotf* tafgsurf

tef vojbmbtya` tef autnalfs'Gfvfrtefjfss* tebs stumywbjjojsacf mbsnussfmcy o

quojbtotbvfmotonajjfntbag%bgtfrvbfw"taactobgomb``frfgtpabgta`vbfws`artef

rfsujts' ]ebs wbjj cf mbsnussfm bg tef `ajjawbgk port wefrf tef terff mb `frfgtlfteamsorfmbsnussfm9jbtfroturfrfvbfw*nosfstumyogmbgtfrvbfw'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

35/83

^costbfgLarkogt

3;

>'3'?JbtfroturfSfvbfw

Bt bs o nalpjfx pranfss ta mf`bgf jbtfroturf rfvbfw* Sbmjfy %38?3" stotfs teot o

jbtfroturfrfvbfwbswefrfyaubmfgtb`yteftefarbfsogmprfvbausrfsfornewebne

eovf bg`jufgnfm yaur neabnf a rfsforne ]apbn ogm tef lfteamajaky yau orf

neasfg ta omapt' Nagsfqufgtjy* tef jbtfroturf rfvbfw bs og fssfgtboj port a` tef

wari teot wbjj mftfrlbgf tef pasbtbag a tef wari wbtebg tef Jbtfroturf cy

fgkokbgk o mbsnussbag wbte atefr rfsfornefrs' ]eus* mabgk o jbtfroturf rfvbfw bs

nrbtbnojjy fvojuotbgk tef Jbtfroturf ta ogojysf tef mb` frfgt waris fxbstbgk'

Onnarmbgkta@bgi%38?8"ogmMowsag%3882o"*tefrforfmb``frfgtpurpasfs`aro

jbtfroturfrfvbfw4

^pfnb`ytefrfsfornequfstbag*acdfntbvfsogmtfrls

Mfsnrbcfogmfxpjobgnurrfgtigawjfmkf

Bmfgtb`ytefommfmvojufa`tefstumy

Bmfgtb`yf``fntbvfrfsforneogmmfvfjaplfgtlfteamsteotnogcf

usfm`artefrfsforne

Nagsfqufgtjy* tebs popfr bs usbgk nag`frfgnf popfr ogm daurgoj ortbnjf os up,ta,

motfsfnagmorymotosaurnf'Bg`ont*Sbmjfy%38?3"mbsnussfstefblpartognfa`tef

jbtfroturfrfvbfwtacrbgkfvbmfgnfs`aroprontbnojpracjfl']efrf`arf*tebsmoto

wbjjcrbgktefcosbsa`tefstumytamfvfjaptef`rolfwariogmeypatefsbsteotwbjj

jfomtatefprontbnojoppraone'Ojbtfroturfrfvbfwbsojsaokaamoppraonetausf

tef jotfst tfnegbns ogm ovabm nalpotbcbjbty bssufs cftwffg tef mb``frfgt Njaum

pravbmfrsosbtjfomstatefneabnfa`teftfnegajakbfsogmlamfjsteoteovfcffg

usfmbgtefprontbnojporta`tebspopfr'

[ojjblog %38??" ebkejbkets mb` frfgt acdfntbvfs teot lust cf `uj`bjjfm bg o

Jbtfroturfrfvbfw*fvfgb`btbssucdfnttavorbotbagonnarmbgktateforfoa`stumy'

]eus*tefrforfterffacdfntbvfstatefjbtfroturfrfvbfwa`tebspopfr'

@brst* bt wbjj cf blpartogt ta mbsnuss tef rfsforne tefary ogm pebjasapey ta

fstocjbsetefnagtfxta`tefstumy'@artebsrfosag*btbsblpartogttanagsbmfrsalf

mf`bgbtbaga`NjaumNalputbgk*wbtetefneorontfrbstbns*lamfjsogmsfrvbnfs9cut

ojsa ta kft og avfrvbfw a` tef njaum pravbmfrs ogm tefbr neorontfrbstbn' ]eus* bt

ebkejbketstefmb``bnujtbfsteotnogfxbst`arbgtfrapfrocbjbty'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

36/83

^costbfgLarkogt

35

^fnagmjy* o mbsnussbag a` tef jotfst rfsforne ogm mfvfjaplfgts bs blpartogt ta

fxolbgftefnurrfgtbssufsogmnag`jbntfxbstbgkbgmfvfjapbgksuneoppjbnotbagogm

ojsa ta ebkejbket tef snfgorba passbcjf `ar sune bgtfrapfrocbjbty ogm tef

tfnegajakbfsogmlfteamsteotnaujmcfusfm'

@bgojjy* tef jbtfroturf rfvbfw bs joybgk tef `augmotbag a tef eypatefsfs ogm

acdfntbvfsteotwbjjjfomtatef`rolfwaritebspopfroblstamfvfjap'Bg`ont*tef

ogojysbsa`tefjbtfroturfogmtefmbsnussbaga`mb``frfgtvbfwsorfogfssfgtbojport

a`tefpranfssteotjfomstatefeypatefsfs'

>'3'3Nosf^tumy

]efnosfstumybsogblpartogtporta`tefrfsfornelfteamusfmbgtebsstumy*os

mbsnussfmprfvbausjybtbsojsaopranfsswefrftefarbfsorfnag`ragtfmtatfstcyusbgk prontbnoj oppraonefs' Larfavfr* Cfrgmtssag ft oj' %3885" stotfs teot o

prontbnojoppraonelustcfrfpfotocjfbgarmfrtafgsurftefvojbmbtya`tefstumy'

Gfvfrtefjfss* bt bs fssfgtboj ta iffp bg lbgm teot o nosf stumy bs gat o woy ta

pravfcutlarftaossfsstefeypatefsfs%Cfrgmtssagftoj'*3885"']ebspopfrta

ovabm tef bgtfr`frfgnfs teot nog cf nousfm cy mb `frfgt vorbocjf* sune os tef

mfvfjaplfgt ornebtfnturf* prfvbausjy ta tef mfvfjaplfgt ogojysfm tef mb``frfgt

lamfjs fxbstbgk ogm cubjm tef oppjbnotbag `ajjawbgk o subtocjf lamfj `ar tef`rolfwari' Larfavfr* onnarmbgk ta Kbjjeol bt bs blpartogt ta mfsnrbcf tef

eypatefsfsa`tebsnosfstumy']watefarftbnojeypatefsfsnogcfebkejbketfm`ar

tebsstumy4

GfnfssbtytausfonallugbnotbaglamfjtamfpjayogbgtfrapfrocjfNjaum

Bg `ont* Njaum Pfgmars orf eftfrakfgfaus ogm fone a` tefl bs usbgk mb``frfgt

tfnegajakbfs* stogmorms ogm pratanajs ta logokf tefbr Njaum' ]efrf`arf* usbgk

ornebtfnturflamfjsuneos^AOarSF^]wbjjfgeognftefnoponbtytaavfrrbmftefjani,bga`vfgmarsogmtamfpjayogoppjbnotbagbgtatefnjaum'

Cosfmtefoppjbnotbagag^togmormsogmmfvfjapteflosOXBs'

Bgmffm tef mfvfjaplfgt a` og oppjbnotbag `ar Njaum bs o nalpjfx pranfss teot

gffms salf stogmorm ta cf rfpfotfm bg o nagtrajjfm woy' Nagsfqufgtjy tef

mfvfjaplfgta`tefoppjbnotbag`artebsstumywbjjcfgarlojbsfmosbtbsmbsnussfm

bgtef`ajjawbgkport'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

37/83

^costbfgLarkogt

32

>'3'3'?Mfvfjaplfgtpranfssa`tefoppjbnotbag

]ef pranfss ugmfrtoifg `ar tefmfvfjaplfgta`tef oppjbnotbag bs rfjotfm tatef

spfnb`bnbty a tef oppjbnotbag' Bg `ont* wf orf bg o Njaum fgvbraglfgt wbte og

oppjbnotbagteotlustcfmfpjayfmbgmb``frfgtNjaumwbteautogyneogkfogmtef

sfrvbnf lust rug slaatejy bg ojj pjot`arls' Nagsfqufgtjy* tebs stumy bs usbgk o

Lamfj,Pbfw,Nagtrajjfr %LPN" lamfj teot wbjj ojjaw sfporotbgk tef mb `frfgt

nagnfrgsa`tefoppjbnotbagcftwffgterffjoyfrsarjakbnojmalobg']efLamfjbsbg

neorkfa`logokbgktefmotoonnarmbgktatefbgstruntbagsa`neogkbgkstotfs`ral

tef nagtrajjfr']efvbfwwbjj cfbgneorkf a`tefrfgmfrbgka` tef oppjbnotbagogm

ojjawbgtfrontbagswbteusfrs'@bgojjytefNagtrajjfrbstefnfgtrojfjflfgtteotwbjj

loif tef mb `frfgt nojjs ta tef vbfw ogm lamfj ogm ogswfr ta tef wfc sfrvfr

%Lugra*38??"'

@bkurf;4LPNLamfj%Nycjognf*3885"

Osseawgbg@bkurf;*bgaurnosfteflamfjwbjjcfbgneorkfa`tefbgtfrontbag

wbtetefmotocosfogmteflogokflfgta`mototeotwbjjcfsfgmtatefnagtrajjfr

ogm prbgt aut cy tef vbfw' ]ef vbfw bs logokbgk tef joyaut ogm `bgojjy tef

nagtrajjfrwbjjcfbgneorkfa`tefnallugbnotbagwbtetefcrawsfr%[ogk*38??"'

]efrf`arf*tefLPNlamfjwbjjsblpjb`ytefmfvfjaplfgta`tefoppjbnotbagogmwbjj

loiffonejoyfrrfjotbvfjybgmfpfgmfgtogmteusfosbfrtalamb`y'Bgmffm*tefnosf

stumy pranfss rfqubrfm lamb ybgk tef oppjbnotbag sfvfroj tblfs ta `bt ta tef

mb``frfgtpravbmfrsspfnb`bnbtbfsogmrfjfosfo`bgojoppjbnotbag'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

38/83

^costbfgLarkogt

>8

>'3'3'3Ornebtfnturfa`tefOppjbnotbag

@artefnosfstumy*btbsblpartogttakfttefpassbcbjbtytamfpjaytefoppjbnotbagbg

mb``frfgt fgvbraglfgt wbte o sblbjor onnfss ta tef motocosf' @ar tebs stumy tef

oppjbnotbag!sfrvbnfwbjjcfrfprfsfgtfmoso`bjflogokflfgtsystfl*tef@bkurf5

mfsnrbcfsosnefloa`tefornebtfnturfmfvfjapfm']efoppjbnotbagbsovobjocjfbgta

mb``frfgtnjaumsogmonnfssbcjfteraukeBgtfrgft![OG*fonenjaumpravbmfrwbjjcf

naggfntfmtatefmotocosfwefrfojjtefmotousfmcytefmb``frfgtoppjbnotbagsorf

starfm']efsajutbagusfm`artefmotocosfwbjjcfogOlozagSM^bgstognfstarfm

bgtefnjaumogmovobjocjf`raltefmb``frfgtNjaumpravbmfrs'@raltefprfvbaus

mbsnussbag tef jogkuokf usfm wbjj cf XEX os last a` tef pravbmfrs stumbfm orf

nalpotbcjfwbtetebstfnegajakyfxnjumbgk`arnf'nal'

@bkurf54Ojorkfpbnturfa`tefOppjbnotbagOrnebtfnturf

>'3'>Bgtfrvbfw

]ebsrfsfornebs`anusbgkagtefmfvfjaplfgtbgtatefnjauma`o`rolfwari`ar

bgtfrapfrocjfoppjbnotbag'Eawfvfr*taossfsstebs`rolfwaritwastfpsogojysbsbs

apfrotf'@brst*btbsblpartogttafvojuotftef`rolfwariwbtetefmfvfjaplfgta`

ogbgtfrapfrocjf oppjbnotbag' ]efrf`arf* cynag`ragtbgk tef `rolfwari ta o nosf

stumybtojjawso`brstfvojuotbag']efsfnagmstfpbstefpfrnfptbagsa`tefstumycy

ogfxtfrgojvbfwteauketefnajjfntbaga`prblorymoto9tefpfrnfptbaga`tefNjaum

bgtfrapfrocbjbty eos ta cf ogojysfm cut ojsa tef sajutbag mfpjayfm' @ar tebs jost

stfp*twaibgma`oppraoneorfpassbcjfoquojbtotbvfarquogtbtotbvf'_uogtbtotbvf

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

39/83

^costbfgLarkogt

>?

rfsfornebsusbgkstotbstbnsogojysfteraukejorkf,snojfsurvfy*wefrfosquojbtotbvf

rfsforne fxpjarf tef ottbtumfs* cfeovbaur ogm fxpfrbfgnf cyusbgk bgtfrvbfws ar

`anuskraup%Mowsag*3882c"'

]ebs stumy bs usbgk o quojbtotbvf oppraone `ar tef najjfntbag a` moto' Bgmffm* os

seawgbg]ocjf5tefrfbssfvfrojmb``frfgnfscftwffgbgtfrvbfwogmqufstbaggobrf

ta najjfnt moto' ]efrf`arf* tef qufstbaggobrf bs nagsbmfrfm os tef nefopfst moto

najjfntbaglfteamsogmrfojjynagvfgbfgttfnegbn'Agtefatefreogm*ogbgtfrvbfw

bs og fosbfr woy ta fvojuotf tef usfrs pfrnfptbags ogm ta fgsurf tef njfor

ugmfrstogmbgka`tefqufstbagscytefbgtfrvbfwff'Bg`ont*qufstbaggobrfsnogjfom

ta olcbkuaus qufstbags teot nog cf njforfm murbgk ogm bgtfrvbfw* cut bt bs tblf

nagsulbgkogmtefbgtfrvbfwfrnognrfotfocbos'

Neorontfrbstbns Bgtfrvbfw _ufstbaggobrf

MbrfntNagtontwbtebgtfrvbfwff Rfs Rfs!Ga

Fosytanorryaut Ga Rfs

Jorkfsolpjf Ga Rfs

Sfjbocbjbtya`ogswfrs Ga RfsXassbcjfcbos Rfs Ga

Mftobjfmogswfrs Rfs Ga

Awgrfspagmfgtogswfrs Rfs Ga]blfnagsulbgk Rfs Ga

]ocjf54NalporbsagBgtfrvbfwogm_ufstbaggobrf%[ojjblog*38??9^ops`arm&Dupp*38809

Mowsag*3882o"

]ebsstumywbjjusfosflb,strunturfmbgtfrvbfwbgarmfrtanorryauttefprblory

motonajjfntbagwbteapfgqufstbags%^ops`arm&Dupp*3880"']efbgtfrvbfwtypfbs

`onf,ta,`onfavfr^iypf*ostefmbstognfmafsgtojjaworfoj`onfta`onf'Larfavfr*

muftatfnegbnojbssufstefrfnarmbgka`tefbgtfrvbfwwosgatrfojjypassbcjf*cut

ojsaonnarmbgktaCfrgmtssagftoj'%3885"btnogjfomtaugfosfogmjfssvojuocjf

rfspagsfs'Nagsfqufgtjy*tamfvfjaptefbgtfrvbfwtebsstumy`ajjawstefstrotfkbfs

mbsnussfmcyCfrgmtssagftoj'%3885"ogmsulupbg]ocjf2'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

40/83

^costbfgLarkogt

>3

Bgtfrvbfwbssuf Xrapasfmsajutbag

^fjfntbgkrfjfvogt

bgtfrvbfwffs

PajugtffrFxpfrtbgtfrvbfwff

^trunturfa`tefbgtfrvbfw ^flb,strunturfm bgtfrvbfw ta kft o nalpralbsfcftwffg`rffmalogm`ujjnagtraj

^trunturfa`tefrfpjbfs Apfgqufstbag*wbteusfa`snojf`arspfnb`bnqufstbagstaefjptefbgtfrvbfwfftaogswfr

Sfnarmbgk Garfnarmbgk*cfnousfa`tfnegbnojbssufsNag`bmfgtbojbtybssufs Ogy bg`arlotbag pravbmfm cy tef bgtfrvbfwff wbjj cf

sucdfnttaebsoppravojcf`arfcfbgkusfmbgtebspopfr

Bgtfrvbfw nallfgts ar

ommbtbag

]ef trogsnrbpt wbjj cf suclbttfm ta tef bgtfrvbfwff taovabmlbsugmfrstogmbgkogm`arommbtbaga`bg`arlotbagb`gfnfssory

Jakbstbn Bgtfrvbfwavfr iypfcfnousfa mbstognfbssuf

Bgtfrvbfwffneorontfrbstbn Fone bgtfrvbfwff wbjj cf tatojjy ogagylausogm tefrfwbjjcfgalfgtbaga`bg`arlotbagteotnaujmjfomtatef

bmfgtbty a tef bgtfrvbfwff' Eawfvfr salf kfgfrojconikraugm qufstbag wbjj cf osifm ta mbsnuss teffxpfrtbsfa`tefbgtfrvbfwff'

]ocjf24Bgtfrvbfwrfqubrflfgts%Cfrgmtssagftoj'*3885"

OnnarmbgktaCrylog&cfjj%388;"solpjbgkbsostotbstbnojoppraonetasfjfnttef

cfstoumbfgnf`ralo`anuskraupwbtetefkaojtapramunfigawjfmkf'^fjfntbgko

rogmalkraupbgtapapujotbagnogojjawnrfotbgkigawjfmkf*cutokaamsfjfntbag

nog ojjaw actobgbgk ify bg`arlotbag bg armfr ta rfone tef rfsforne purpasf

%]ealpsag*38?3"'

Bg tebs popfr tef bgtfrvbfw wbjj `anus ag fxpfrt bgtfrvbfwff* os bt wbjj jfom ta

nagstruntbvfmbsnussbag`ralo`anuskraupteotkattefigawjfmkftambsnusstef

rfsforne tapbn' Bg `ont* o rogmal solpjf waujm cf subtocjf `ar fxpfrblfgtoj

rfsforne murbgk tef pranfss a` rfqubrbgk fgm,usfrs apbgbags %^ougmfrs ft oj'*

3882"' Eawfvfr tebs stumy obl ta mfvfjap o `rolfwari `ar bgtfrapfrocbjbty a`

oppjbnotbag ogm torkft Njaum Nalputbgk fxpfrt ar mfvfjapfrs' Nagsfqufgtjy* os

seawgbg ]ocjf2 tebspopfrwbjj usfvajugtffrfxpfrtbgtfrvbfwffta mbsnusstefautnalfs a` tef stumbfs ogm fvojuotf tebs popfr' Larf prfnbsfjy* twa

nagsbmfrotbagseovfcffglomftasfjfnttefrfspagmfgts*`ujjyvajugtffr`artef

stumyogmtefrfspagmfgtslustcfocjftaugmfrstogmtefbssufogmtefnagtfxta`

tefstumybgarmfrtambsnusstefautnalfs']efrf`arf*tefouteara`tebsstumyeos

oppraonefm mb `frfgt pfrsags9 cut agjy agf a` tefl eos cffg ovobjocjf `ar tef

stumy']ebsbgtfrvbfwffbsosfjjlogokfra`NjaumNalputbgkcrognea`owarjm

wbjm `brl mfvfjapbgk Njaum Nalputbgk eormworf* njaum sajutbags cut ojsalogokbgkoNjaumpjot`arl'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

41/83

^costbfgLarkogt

>>

>'>Fxpfntfmjblbtotbags

>'>'?@rolfwari

Mfvfjapbgko`rolfwari`arbgtfrapfrocbjbtybsonalpjfxpranfss*osfoneNjaum

pravbmfrusfsbtsawgtfnegajakbfsogmstogmorms']eus*btbsmb``bnujttaprfmbnttef

autnalfsa`sune`rolfwariosNjaumtfnegajakbfsfvajvfropbmjyogmbtnogjfom

ta mb` bnujtbfstaoppjytef rfnallfgmotbags mfvfjapfm bg tebs popfr' ]efrf`arf*

tef lfteamajaky pranfss bs stragkjy rfjotfm ta tef `rfsegfss a` tef suppartbgk

rfsfornefs'

Ommbtbagojjy*tefsajutbagflpjayfm`artefnosfstumyosmfsnrbcfbg@bkurf5bs

qubtfrfjfvogt `ar actobgbgk o`ujjy `ugntbagojnjaumcutbt rflobgsbg tef eogma`

Njaum pravbmfrs' ]efrf`arf* tef `rolfwari bs o sajutbag ta ovabm jani,bg cut bt

mafsgt ojjaw tef trust a` tef pravbmfrs ogm bt bs blpartogt ta `ujjy ossfss fone

pravbmfrtefoppjbnotbagnaujmcfmfpjayfmta'

>'>'3Nosfstumy

Larfavfr* tef nosf stumy ugmfrtoifg bg tebs popfr bs gat o woy ta vojbmotf tef

`rolfwarilarfteogogfxolpjfa`blpjflfgtotbaga`tef`rolfwari']efrf`arf*

tebs blpjflfgtotbag bs mfojbgk wbte mb` frfgt Njaum Xravbmfrs9 [bgmaws Ozurf*

OlozagO[^ogmKaakjfOppFgkbgf'Eawfvfr*btbsgatojorkfoumbfgnfogmlarf

Njaum pravbmfrs seaujm cf ossfssfm ta fgsurf tef oppjbnocbjbty bg o jorkfr

prapartbaga`tebs`rolfwariogmojsatanarrfntsalfa`tefbmfosteotnaujmcf

bgnarrfnt'Gfvfrtefjfss*tebsstumy`anusfmagNjaumpravbmfrspravbmbgk`rfftry*

teusbtfxpjobgstefjblbtfmgulcfra`Njaumpravbmfrssfjfntfm'

Ommbtbagojjy*tefouteareosmfvfjapfmtefoppjbnotbagogmtefrf`arftefneabnfa`

tfnegajakyflpjayfm`arteffxpfrblfgtorfstragkjyjbgifmtatefigawjfmkfa`

tefoutear'Bgaurnosf*XEXeovfcffgusfmtamfvfjaptefoppjbnotbagcutatefr

jogkuokfsuneosDovonaujmeovfcffgogatefronnfptocjfsajutbag'

>'>'>Bgtfrvbfw

]ebsstumybsusbgkogbgtfrvbfwtaossfssogmacsfrvftefautnalfsa`tebsstumy*

cuttebsmotonajjfntbagpranfssbgvajvfssalfjblbtotbags'@brst*bgtebsstumytef

solpjbgkbsrfojjygorrawogmbtbsmb``bnujttaactobgogavfrojjapbgbaga`tefNjaum

nallugbty`raltebsagjybgtfrvbfw'

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

42/83

^costbfgLarkogt

>=

Larfavfr*sflb,strunturfmbgtfrvbfwbsorfsfornelfteamwefrftefbgtfrvbfwfr

nognrfotfocboscfnousfa`ebsbgtfrontbagwbtetefbgtfrvbfwff9fvfgb`tebsstumy

`anus ag apfg qufstbags wbte tef lbgblul bgvajvflfgt a tef outear bg tef

ogswfrs'

>'=^ullorya`Lfteamajaky

]ef@bkurf2bsosullorya`teflfteamajakyugmfrtoifgbgtebsstumy'

@bkurf24SfsforneLfteamajaky@rolfwari

7/28/2019 Interoperability among cloud Providers and a development frameworks

43/83

^costbfgLarkogt

>6

='@bgmbgksogmOgojysbs

]ebs port ebkejbkets tef autnalfs a` tebs stumy cy prfsfgtbgk mb``frfgt rfsujts'

@brst* btbs fssfgtbojta fxolbgf tefautnalfs kbvfgcy tefnosfstumy nagnfrgbgk

tef`rolfwari'Larfprfnbsfjytebsnosfstumyebkejbketssalfblpartogtnagnfrgs

teot lust cf mbsnussfm ta fgsurf tef bgtfrapfrocbjbty a o njaum oppjbnotbag'

^fnagmjy* tef `rolfwari bs fxpjobgfm usbgk tef nagnjusbags `ral tef jbtfroturf

rfvbfw ogm tef nosf stumy' @bgojjy* tef autnalfs kbvfg cy tef bgtfrvbfw wbjj cf

ebkejbketfm*cutojjtefsfrfsujtswbjjcfogojysfmogmusfmt