Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page1of21
INTERNATIONALPAPERCO(IP)EarningsReport:Q12016ConferenceCallTranscriptThefollowingINTERNATIONALPAPERCOconferencecalltookplaceonApril27,2016,10:00AMET.Thisisatranscriptofthatearningscall:
CompanyPart icipants
JayRoyalty;InternationalPaper;InvestorRelationsMarkSutton;InternationalPaper;Chairman&CEOCarolRoberts;InternationalPaper;CFOTimNicholls;InternationalPaper;SVP,IndustrialPackagingMikeAmick;InternationalPaper;SVPofN.A.Papers,PulpandConsumerPackaging
OtherPart icipants
AdamJosephson;KeyBancCapitalMarkets;AnalystMarkWilde;BMOCapitalMarkets;AnalystSteveChercover;D.A.Davidson&Company;AnalystPhilipNg;JefferiesLLC;AnalystMarkWeintraub;BuckinghamResearchGroup;AnalystGeorgeStaphos;BoAMerrillLynch;AnalystLarsKjellberg;CreditSuisse;AnalystMarkConnelly;CLSALimited;AnalystJohnDunigan;BarclaysCapital;AnalystDebbieJones;DeutscheBank;AnalystChrisManuel;WellsFargoSecurities,LLC;AnalystChipDillon;VerticalResearchPartners;AnalystDannyMoran;MacquarieResearch;Analyst
MANAGEMENTDISCUSSIONSECTION
Operator :
Atthistime,IwouldliketowelcomeeveryonetotheInternationalPaperfirst-quarter2016earningscall.
(OperatorInstructions)
IwouldnowliketoturnthecallovertoMr.JayRoyalty,VicePresidentofInvestorRelations,tobegin.
JayRoyalty(InvestorRelations):
Thanks,Operator.Goodmorning,everyone.ThankyouforjoiningInternationalPaper'sfirstquarter2016earningsconferencecall.
OurkeyspeakersthismorningareMarkSutton,ChairmanandChiefExecutiveOfficer;andCarolRoberts,SeniorVicePresidentandChiefFinancialOfficer.
Duringthiscall,we'llmakeforward-lookingstatementsthataresubjecttorisksanduncertaintieswhichareoutlinedonslide2ofourpresentation.Wewillalsopresentcertainnon-USGAAPfinancialinformation.
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page2of21
AreconciliationofthosefigurestoUSGAAPfinancialmeasuresareavailableonourwebsite.Ourwebsitealsocontainscopiesofthefirstquarter2016earningspressreleaseandtoday'spresentationslides.
Lastly,relativetotheIlimJV,slide4providescontextaroundthejointventure'sfinancialinformationandstatisticalmeasures.Withthat,I'llnowturnthecallovertoMarkSutton.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Thankyou,Jay.Goodmorning,everyone.Thankyouforjoiningourcall.
I'mgoingtostartonslide5.InternationalPaperdeliveredasolidfirstquarter,drivenbycontinuedstrongperformanceinourNorthAmericanIndustrialPackagingbusiness,alongwithimprovedresultsinourGlobalPapersbusiness.Demandacrossourbusinesseswasatorslightlybetterthanexpectations.Ouroperationsperformedwellandinputcostswerefavorable.
TheRiegelwoodconversiontofluffpulpwascompletedseveraldaysagoandwehavecommencedstartupandqualifications.TheIlimJVhadanotherstrongquarterofresults.Andweannouncedacoupleofimportantstrategicmoves,bothofwhichwillbenefitIP'sreturnsandarereallyallaboutmakingourbestbusiness,ourIndustrialPackagingbusiness,evenbetter.
WereachedadefinitiveagreementtosellourAsiaIndustrialPackagingbusiness,whichisexpectedtocloseinthesecondquarter.Wealsoreachedanagreementtoacquireastate-of-the-artnewsprintmillinSpainfromHolmenPaper,whichweplantoconverttohighperformancerecycledlinerboardtostrengthenourvaluepropositiontoourcustomersandenhancetheresultsforourEuropeanIndustrialPackagingbusiness.Weplantouseallofthatcontainerboardinsideofourconvertingsystem.
Turningtoslide6.Justliketogiveyoualittlemorecoloronourfinancialperformance.IP'srevenuedeclinedyear-over-year.It'sprimarilyduetothesaleoftheSunjointventureinChina,whichtookplaceinthefourthquarterof2015.Wealsoincurredcostsofabout$45million,exclusiveofoutageexpenses,associatedwiththeRiegelwoodconversion,andthiswasasignificantdragtoearningsinthequarter.Marginswouldhavebeenabout100basispointsbetter,absentthisimpact.Ourfreecashflowof$311millionwasonparwithlastyear'sfirstquarter.
Atthispoint,whatI'dliketodoisturnitovertoCarolandshe'llwalkusthroughtheperformanceofourindividualbusinessesandthesecondquarteroutlook.
AndI'llreturntowrapitupandwe'llopenitupforyourquestions.Carol?
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Thanks,Mark.Goodmorning,everyone.AsMarkmentioned,IPdeliveredasolidfirstquarterat$0.80EPS,withfavorableoperationsandinputcostsoffsetbylowerprices,seasonallylowervolume,andheavymaintenanceoutages,includingtheRiegelwoodconversion.ThepositiveswingatIlimisFXrelated,primarilyduetothestrengtheningoftherubleasitrelatestotheJV'sUSdollardenominatednetdebt.
Turningtothebusinessesonslide8.IndustrialPackaging,asMarksaid,hadastrongquarter.Wehadfavorableoperationsandlowerinputcosts,buttheyweremostlyoffsetbylowerexportandboxpricing,seasonallylowerboxvolume,asexpected,andhigherplannedmaintenanceoutageexpense.Exportvolumedidreboundfromaweakfourthquarter.
TheNorthAmericanbusinesstook212tonsofeconomicdowntimetobalanceoursupplywithourdemandandadjustourneedstomatchamoreefficientsupplychain.InputcostswerepositivelyimpactedbylowercostofOCCanddieselfuel.
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page3of21
Turningtoslide9.IP'sNorthAmericanboxdemandcameingenerallyasexpected,withyear-over-yearvolumeup1.3%forthefirstquarter,whichwasinlinewiththeindustry.ThequarterfinishedstronginMarchandthatmomentumhascontinuedthroughApril.
Asyoucanseeinthetable,whichhighlightsseveralofIP'skeycustomersegments,weseeseveralencouragingtrends.Wecontinuetoseestronggrowthinonlineretail,whichhasbecomemoremeaningfulforoveralldemand.Thelargeprocessedfoodsegmentisbeginningtoshowsomepositivesigns,asthemajorcompaniesaremakingmovestoadjusttochangingconsumerpreferences.
Theagriculturalsegment,towhichIPisamajorsupplier,isenjoyingthemostfavorableweatherconditionstheregionshaveseeninafewyears,andthispointstosolidgrowthfor2016.Andtheoutlookfortheimportantproteinsegmentisimproving.Sonet-net,afairlyfavorableoutlookforthebusiness.
TurningtoEurope,asMarkmentioned,werecentlyannouncedastrategicmovetoacquireauniqueassetthatcanbeconvertedtoveryeffectivelycomplementourcorrugatedpackagingnetworkintheregion.
Thistransactionwillcreatesignificantvaluefrombothacustomerofferingandafinancialstandpoint,asitwillenableIPtoproducehighperformance,light-weightrecycledcontainerboardinregion.Wewillacquirethemill,alongwithassociatedrecyclingoperationsandHolmen'sownershipposition,inanon-siteco-generationfacility.
Uponclosingofthedeal,wewillinitiateplansfortheconversionofthestate-of-the-artnewsprintmachinetoafirstquartiletestlinermachine,whichweexpecttocompleteinlate2017.
Oncereconfigured,themachinewillproduce420,000shorttonsofrecycledcontainerboard,whichwillenableIPtointegrateamajorityofourtestlinerneeds.Thetotalinvestmentfortheacquisitionandconversionisexpectedtobeapproximately$160million,withanexpectedIRRofmorethan15%.
Ifyouturntoslide11,inadditiontotheattractiveageandtechnologyofthemachine,aswellasthemill'sconfiguration,thelocationofthemillinrelationtothemajorityofourboxnetworkisveryattractive.
Thegradesofhighperformancetestlinerthatweintendtoproduceonthismachinehavethegreatestapplicationforourbroadbaseofindustrialcustomers,andmostoftheseareservedoutofourboxplantsinSpain,FranceandNorthernItaly,asshownonthehighlightedareaofthemap.Soonceagain,we'reexcitedabouttheprospectsofthismoveandwhatitcandoforourcustomersandInternationalPaper.
Turningtoslide12,letmetalkaboutConsumerPackaging,wherewesawaseasonallyslowerquartercombinedwithsomepricepressures,alessfavorablemix,andheavieroutageexpense,resultedinlowerearningsforthebusinessinthefirstquarter.Mostofthepricingpressurewasfeltinthecommodityplatesegment.Thetimingofvolumeandhighervaluemixinthefoodservicebusinesswasslowertomaterializethanwehadexpected,aswell.Additionally,thesaleandexitoftheCoatedBristolsbusinessnegativelyimpactedresultsinthequarter.
Movingtoslide13andtalkingaboutourPrintingPapersegment.Theslideshowsthesequentialbridgefortheentiresegment,whichdoesincludeourPulpbusiness.
Aswasmentionedearlier,thecostimpactoftheRiegelwoodconversion,alongwithasuboptimizedoperationatRiegelwoodastheconversionofPM18wasunderway,significantlyimpactedsegmentresultsforthefirstquarterbyapproximately$45millionintotal.
Wewillcontinuetoseecostimpactfromtheconversioninthesecondquarter,alongwithstartupandqualificationcoststhatwillcontinuetoimpactresultsinthesecondquarterandthesecondhalfof2016.ThisisconsistentwiththeoutlookweprovidedlastquarterandisfullycapturedintheoutlookthatI'll
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page4of21
sharewithyoushortly.
Slide14showstheresultsoftheGlobalPapersegment,excludingPulpandtheimpactoftheconversion.Volumewasseasonallyweaker,asweexpected,largelyinBrazil,whiledemandinNorthAmericawassolid.Goodoperationsandlowerinputcostscontributedfavorablytotheresults,asdidlowerplannedmaintenanceoutageexpense.
PriceswerelowerinNorthAmerica,buthigherinEurope,RussiaandBrazil,aswebegantoseethebenefitoftheimplementationofpreviouslyannouncedpriceincreases.AndpriceincreasesareannouncedinNorthAmericaandarebeingimplementedinthesecondquarter.
LetmegivealittlemorecoloronRiegelwood.AsMarksaid,wearepleasedthattheconversionhasbeencompletedontimeandonbudgetinthemonthofApril,andstartupandqualificationofthemachinehascommenced.Productionofsoftwoodmarketpulpisunderway,andthenwe'llmovetothequalificationoffluffpulp.Weexpecttobeginflufftrialsinthethirdquarter.
Thecurrentpricingenvironmentforsoftwoodmarketpulp,whichisusedforpapertowelandtissueproducts,isunderpressureinthenearterm.AswerampupandproduceSBSKonthenewmachinethroughtherestof2016,thesecurrentconditionswilladverselyaffectearnings.Thiswillimproveaswequalifyfluffpulponthenewmachineandoptimizeproductionacrossoursystem.
TurningnowtotheIlimJV.TheJVhadanotherverystrongquarter,withoperationalEBITDAof$176million,asstrongmanufacturingperformancepartiallyoffsetlowerpulppricesandseasonallylowervolume.Overthecourseofthefirstquarter,therublestrengthenedslightlyagainstthedollar,whichresultedinafavorablenon-cashFXgainontheJV's$600millionofUSdenominatednetdebt,andthatimpactedourfirstquarterearningsfavorablyby$0.03pershare.Lowerpulppricesandseasonallyhigherwoodcosts,alongwithplannedmaintenanceoutagesattheBratskand[Quorioshlin]mills,areexpectedtonegativelyimpactsecondquarterresults.
BeforeIturnitbackovertoMark,letmegiveyouthesecondquarteroutlook.Earningswillincrease,duetoseasonallyhighervolumeinNorthAmericanboxandBrazilpapers.TheadditionalboxvolumeisexpectedtofavorablyimpactNorthAmericanIndustrialPackagingearningsbyroughly$40million.TheimpactofseasonallystrongerdemandinBrazilisexpectedtopositivelyimpactearningsby$10million.
MovingontopricinginNorthAmerica.Theexpectedimpactoflowerpulppricesandalessfavorablemixassociatedwiththeramp-upofRiegelwoodonsoftwoodpulpinthesecondquarterisaboutanegative$20million.ThisisnetofthebenefitsofthepreviouslyannouncedpriceincreasesinuncoatedfreesheetinNorthAmerica.
PricingforNorthAmericanIndustrialPackagingwillbeimpactedbylowerexportpricing,alongwiththeflow-throughoftheJanuaryPPWindexchangethatwillmovethroughtoboxes.Combined,thisisexpectedtonegativelyimpactearningsintherangeof$25millionto$30million.
PricesareexpectedtoimproveinBrazilpapers,asthepreviouslyannouncedpriceincreasesareimplemented.Thiswillfavorablyimpactearningsbyabout$10million.
OperationalcostsinNorthAmericanIndustrialPackagingareexpectedtoimproveasaresultofseasonallystrongerdemandandutilization,alongwithothercostreductionandimprovementinitiatives.Thiswillbeabenefitofroughly$30million.Operationalcostsacrosstheotherbusinessesareexpectedtoremainfavorableandinputcostsareexpectedtoremaingenerallyfavorable,aswell,althoughwedoexpectsomeslightpressureinEurope.
Maintenanceoutageexpenseswillcontinuetobeheavyinthesecondquarter,butareexpectedto
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page5of21
decreasebyatotalof$22million,asshownontheslide,mainlyduetotheloweroutagecostsatRiegelwood.AndrelativetotheIlimJV,theitemsyouseeonthechartareexpectedtonegativelyimpactIPequityearningsbyapproximately$10millionto$15million.
Andadditionally,weareassumingstableFXcomingoutofthequarter.Asyouknow,wedon'tattempttoforecastcurrency.Sotheoutlookassumesanon-repeatofthe$0.03gainfromthefirstquarter.
Sowiththatoverview,letmeturnitbackovertoMark.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Thanks,Carol.Soletmewrapthingsupbeforewetakeyourquestions.Ifeelreallygoodaboutourexecutionandresultsfromthefirstquarter,andI'mencouragedthatdemandfeelsmorefavorableacrosstheprimarymarketsthatweserve.
Ourfocusremainsonexecution,andwesawbenefitfromoureffortsinthefirstquarterintermsofgoodoperationalperformanceandlowercost.TheconversionatRiegelwoodwentwell,wasontimeandonbudget,andourteamisnowrampingupandqualifyingthenewcapabilities.AllofthiswillenableInternationalPapertocontinuetogeneratestrongfreecashflow,whichwewillallocatetocreateadditionalvalue.
We'vealsomadesomekeydecisionsthatwillimproveIP'sportfolioandmakeitstrongerandfurtherimprovereturnsoninvestedcapital,namely,ourdecisionsinAsiaandMadrid.Andyou'llseemoreofthisaswemoveforward,whereitmakessenseforInternationalPaperandourstakeholders.
Wehavewinningstrategiesintherightmarketsandourfocusisclear,asyou'reseeinginthemoveswearemaking.We'refocusedonproducingproductswherewehaveadistinctadvantage,withgoodaccesstofiberandlowcostmanufacturing.We'reconcentratingoureffortsonthemarketsandproductlinesthatgiveIPthegreatestpotentialtogeneratemeaningfulearningsandattractivereturns.
Sowiththat,I'llturnitbackovertotheoperatorandwe'llbehappytotakeyourquestions.
QUESTIONS&ANSWERS
Operator :
(OperatorInstructions)
AdamJosephsonofKeyBancCapitalMarkets.
AdamJosephson (Analyst-KeyBancCapitalMarkets):
Thanks.Goodmorning,everyone.MarkandCarol,two-partquestionformyfirstquestion.DoyoustillexpectD&Aexpensesof$1.3billionthisyear,justgiventhattheyfellabitbelowwhatIwasexpectingthisquarter?Andrelatedly,yourEBITDAwasdown14%inthefirstquarter.
Doyoustillthinkyoucanbeclosetoflatthisyear?Orifnot,whatdoyouthinkreasonableexpectationsarealongthoselinesforEBITDA?
Thankyou.
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Adam,thisisCarolandI'lltakethefirstone,ontheD&A.Yes,wedostillexpecttobeintherangeof$1.3billion.Whathappensisthere'ssomevariabilitytoit.Whenyouhavemillsdownforoutages,youstopyourdepreciationforthatperiodoftime.Soit'sreallyjustsomelumpinessinit.Butoverall,$1.3
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page6of21
billionisstillagoodnumberfortheyear.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Adam,onEBITDA,yourquestionabouthowwefeelaroundtheflatyear-over-year.It'sobviouslygotsomestretchinit,withsomeofthepricingheadwindsthathaveoccurred.Butatthesametime,asImentionedinmycomments,wefeelreallygoodaboutourexecutionandourabilitytomakeimprovementinourbusinesses,bothcommerciallyandoperationally.SoIthinkwe'reverymuchstillintherangeofbeingabletoaccomplishthat.We'vegotalotoftheyearleftandwe'vegotsomerealpositivetrendsonourcommercialfront,andwe'reoperatingvery,verywell.SoweareallaboutfocusedonhittingthatEBITDAthatwetalkedabout.
AdamJosephson (Analyst-KeyBancCapitalMarkets):
Thanks,Mark.Andjustoneoncontainerboardexports.Canyoujustcomment--forgivemeifImissedthis--onwhatyourexportvolumesweresequentiallyandyear-over-year.Obviously,thetradepresshastalkedaboutexportpricesfallingtocashcostsforsomeofthehighercostmillsintheUS.I'mjusthopingyoucanaddressthisissue.Andthanksverymuch.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Hello,Adam,it'sTim.Demandactuallyisholdingupreasonablywell.Inthefourthquarter,Ithinkwecalledoutourvolumewasdown.Wecalledoutsomereasonsaroundthatthatweresituationalandwethoughttemporary.Andinthefirstquarter,wesawareboundinexportvolumes.Wewerestillalittlebitlowerintotalthanwewereinthefirstquarterlastyear.
Partofthat--infact,abigpartofit--isreallyTurkeyandthedumpingtariffthathasbeenimposedandjustsimplyhowwe'rethinkingaboutourparticipationinthemarket.It'sstillaverykeymarketforus,butnoteveryaccountthereisequal.Andsowemadesomedecisionsintermsofhowweweregoingtopositionourselvesinthefirstquarterandgoingforward.
I'dsaydemandisgood.Pricegetswrittenaboutalot.Itdoesn'tfeellikeourexperienceisquiteasnegativeasallthethingsthatiswrittenaboutit.Butthere'snodoubtthere'ssomecompetitivesituationsoutthereandthereisalittlebitofpricepressure.Thatwillprobablycontinueaswegothroughthesecondquarter.
AdamJosephson (Analyst-KeyBancCapitalMarkets):
Thanksverymuch,Tim.Appreciateit.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Sure.
Operator :
Dr.MarkWildeofBMOCapitalMarkets.
MarkWilde (Analyst-BMOCapitalMarkets):
Goodmorning.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Goodmorning.
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page7of21
MarkWilde (Analyst-BMOCapitalMarkets):
Mark,Iwonderedifyouguys,maybeyouandTim,couldjusthelpusalittlebitaswethinkaboutthesePPWadjustmentsbackinFebruaryandhowtheyrollthroughfirstquarter,secondquarterandintothesecondhalf.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Mark,I'llletTimtakethat.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Goodmorning,Mark.Carolspottedyouanumber.Itwasfairlyminimalinthefirstquarter.We'redealingcustomerbycustomerandcontractbycontractandtheydon'tallworkexactlythesameway.AndgiventhetimingofthePPWadjustmentinthefirstquarter,notverymuchofthatflowedthroughinthequarter.Itwillrampupinthesecondquarter,andCarolpointedoutacombinationofPPWandexportbeingbetween$25millionand$30million.Thebulkofthat,wethink,isbecauseofthepriceadjustmentwiththeindex.Andwe'lltalktoyouaboutthirdandfourthquarteraswegothroughtheyear,aswecontinuetoworkthroughallofthecustomercontracts.Butyou'llseeafairlysignificantstep-upfirsttosecond.
MarkWilde (Analyst-BMOCapitalMarkets):
Okay.AndTim,aswethinkabouttryingtomodeloutthethirdandfourthquarter,woulditbefairtoassumesomeadditionalbleed-throughcarryingintothirdandfourthquarter?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Possibly.It'shardtosay,Mark.I'dratherusdotheworkandgetthroughitandthentalktoyouaboutwhatwethinkitwillbeinthethirdquarteraswefinishthesecondquarter,thesamewaywedidgoingintothisquarter.
MarkWilde (Analyst-BMOCapitalMarkets):
Okay.Allright.That'sfair.AndjuststayingonthecontainerboardandIndustrialPackagingbusiness,you'vetakenabout440,000tonsofeconomicdowntimeoverthelastsixmonths.Iwonderedifyoucantalkabouthowyou'retakingthat.Areyouslowingback?Areyouactuallyidlingmachinesforaweekortwohereorthere?Andisthereapointwhereyouneedtoconsideralongertermmoveonthesupplyside?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Well,we'llsee.Ithinkthepowerofwhatwe'redoing,itjustshowsthepowerofthesystemandtheflexibilitythatwe'vebuilt.Andsomeoftheinvestmentsthatwe'remaking,it'sallaroundbuildingcapabilityandflexibilityinthesystem.Weknowthatwhenyou'restretchingthesystemintermsofutilizationrate,thingsdon'talwaysworkoutthewayyouwantthemto.Andwe'vebuiltatremendousamountofflexibilityinaverystrongsystem.
SoIcan'tsaywhatitwillbegoingforward.WhatIcansayiswelookoveramulti-period,multipleperiods,outmonthsatatime,notjustwithinaquarter,andwetargetwherewethinkweneedtobeintermsofhowwerunthesystem,andthenweadjustthatalmostdaytodaytodayandweektoweek,basedonavarietyoffactors.
Onethingthathappenedinthefourthquarter,reallylatethird,andcontinuestobeafactorisjusthowefficientlythesupplychainnetworkisrunningrightnow.Andsowhatit'smeantforusatamomentintimeiswejustneedlessinventory,andsowe'veadjustedourproductionaccordinglytomatchthat.We'll
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page8of21
havetomonitorthatovertime.Thingsdon'tstaythesame.Theyhaveatendencytomovearound.Sowe'llhavetoseehowsupplychainperformsthroughtherestoftheyear.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Mark,ifIcouldjustaddtoTim'scomment.Oneofthethingswe'velearnedasoursystemhasbeenoptimizedandit'sgottenaslargeasit'sgotten,isweclearlycreatemorevalueinourcontainerboardandboxsystemwhenthereisabitofflexibilityinthesystemandwecreatelessvaluewhenwetrytoruneverythingtoitslimits.AndImeancommercialvalue,inourabilitytorespondtocustomers,runanefficientboxnetwork,andalsoactualcostvalueinproperlymaintainingtheequipmentbeforetheexpensivefailuresoccur.Andsothatfewpercentonmaintenanceandthatfewpercentoneconomicflexibility,economicdowntime,reallyendsupcreatingthebestopportunityforustogeneratethehighestmargin.Soit'ssomethingthatwedon'tlooktosolvetozero;becauseIthinkifitwaszero,wewouldhaveaverydifficultcommercialpropositionforourcustomers.
MarkWilde (Analyst-BMOCapitalMarkets):
Allright.That'sreallyhelpful,Mark.Goodluckinthesecondquarterandthroughthebalanceoftheyear.I'llturnitover.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Thankyou.
Operator :
SteveChercoverofD.A.Davidson.
SteveChercover (Analyst-D.A.Davidson&Company):
Thankyouandgoodmorning,everyone.
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Goodmorning,Steve.
SteveChercover (Analyst-D.A.Davidson&Company):
Firstquestion.Hello,Carol.IwantedtoaskabouttheannouncementofanewfluffpulpmillinArkansasatacostof$1.3billion.Willthatseriouslyupsetthesupply/demanddynamic,andwhatdoesitsayaboutthevalueoffluffpulpassets,perhaps?
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Steve,wesawthat.Wehavealittlebitofknowledgeaboutthebackgroundthere.It'shardtopredictwhatthatfacility'sgoingtodoandwhen.Ithinkfluffpulpisahighlytechnicalproduct.Youhavetohaveacustomerlistandatrackrecord.Soitwillbeanopenquestionaboutwhetherornotamillthat,intheory,canmaketheproductactuallyendsupwithalargebookofbusinessinthat.Andtherearedifferentdegreesofabsorbentproductsthatarelooselylumpedintofluff.Whatweconcentrateonisthehigherend,highperformanceproductsthataremedicaldevicetypeofproducts.
Socan'tspeculateonwhatthatparticularcompany'sgoingtotrytodo.Butobviously,there'salottobeingsuccessfulinfluffpulpoverthelongterm,primarilybecauseofthebrandednatureoftheconsumerproductthatitgoesinto.Andwe'vebeenatitforawhileandhaveapremiumcustomerlistthatwantsustocontinuetoprovidethemnewmaterial.
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page9of21
SteveChercover (Analyst-D.A.Davidson&Company):
Didyouwanttotakethebaitonthevalueoffluffpulpassetsingeneral?
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Imustnothave,becauseIdidn't.(Laughter)No,Ithinkmycommentsonallfluff'snotcreatedequalandtheirtypesofproductsshouldcharacterizethevalueoffluffpulpisahighlyvaluableproduct,giventhetechnicalnatureofitandtheconsumerbrandedequitythat'sbehindthoseproductsthatitgoesinto.
SteveChercover (Analyst-D.A.Davidson&Company):
Great.Thankyou,Mark.AndthenaquickoneforCarol.Weknowthattheaveragesharesoutstandingwas414million.Wastheendingsharecountsignificantlydifferent?Didyoumayberampuptherepoasyourconfidencegrewthroughthequarter?
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Ithinkwe'llshowthattherepointhequarterwas$100million.AndI'mlookingatmycolleagueshereonthefinalsharecount,butIthinkyoucanfactorinthe$100millionpurchaseandthat'swhatwedidinthequarter,Steve.Soit'scontinuingtomovedownandourintentistocontinuetobeopportunisticwithourbuyback.
SteveChercover (Analyst-D.A.Davidson&Company):
Thankyouverymuch.Iappreciateit.
Operator :
thelineofPhilipNgofJefferies.
PhilipNg (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):
Hello,guys.PostRiegelwood,Iwouldimagineaverylargechunkofyourbusinessismoreonthefoodserviceside,whichisholdingupokay,Iwouldimagine,especiallyonthecupside.ButwiththePBWcutonSBS,isitabout40%ofyourbusinessthatgetsimpacted?AndthenhowshouldwethinkaboutthelagintermsofitflowingthroughyourP&L?
MikeAmick(SVPofN.A.Papers,PulpandConsumerPackaging):
Hello,Philip.ThisisMikeAmick.Thenumber'sgoingtoberoughly30%to35%ofourbusinesscouldpotentiallybeimpactedbythatin2016.Andweprimarilyseethisbeingasecondhalfphenomenon.
PhilipNg (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):
Andhowwouldyouguyscharacterizesupply/demandinthebleachboardmarket?Certainly,Riegelwoodshouldhelp.ButIguessoneofyourcompetitorsdidbringbackanidledmill,andthenyou'vegotsomeofthatpotentialcapacitymakingitswayintotheUSmarketfromtheEuropean.Howdoyouguysthinkaboutsupply/demandmediumtolongerterm?Thanks.
MikeAmick(SVPofN.A.Papers,PulpandConsumerPackaging):
Philip,thisisMikeagain.Iwouldcharacterizethedemandasokay.Idon'tknowthatI'dusethetermreallystrong.Butthroughthequarter,we'veseenimprovingbacklogsandorderbacklogsbyalmost50%aswemovedthroughthequarter.SoIthink--Iknowrightnow,sittingwhereareinthefirstpartofApril,we'reaboutwherewewerethistimelastyear.
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page10of21
PhilipNg (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):
Okay.Andjustonelastonefromme.Mark,youtalkedabouthowdemandinthequarterforcontainerboardfirmedupwithagpickingupande-commercecertainlyseeingalift,aswell.Canyouremindushowyou'rethinkingaboutboxshipmentsforthefullyearnow,inlightofsomeofthestrengthyou'veseenin1Q?
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
I'llletTimtakethat.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Lastquarter,wesaidwethoughtitwouldbeforthefullyearfortotalmarket,1%to1.5%.Idon'tthinkourviewhaschangedthatmuch.Iwouldsaythatwedidseethequarterstrengthenaswewentthroughthefirstquarter,andMarchwasverystrongforus.Aprilcontinuestobeverystrongforus.Rightnow,monthtodate,we'reintheup2%range.Someofthesesegmentsthathavebeenweighingagainstusoverthepastfewquartersarestartingtoturn,hopefully,andwe'llseeifitholdsup.Butwefeelprettygoodrightnow.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
IthinkTim'spoint,Philip,abouteveryorganizationhasamix,acustomermix,andwelikewhatwe'veseeninsomeofthetrendsofthemixthat'sparticularlyheavyforInternationalPaper.Sothatshouldleadustotrackingalotmoreconsistentwithwhattheoverallmarket'sdoingversusmaybeourpastexperience.Sowefeelgoodaboutthat.
PhilipNg (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):
Andthemixdynamicwithproteinpotentiallypickingupinthebackhalf,withthebeefcycleturning,thatshouldbeapositiveforyouguys,aswell.Arewethinkingaboutthatright?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Yes,Ithinkso.Proteinhopefullyhasstabilizedandwe'llseehowitplaysouttherestoftheyear.Processedfood,actuallyforus,themixofcustomersthatwehave,trendedprettyfavorablyduringthefirstquarterandlookslikeit'sholdingupinthesecondquarter.I'mnotgoingtogointospecifics,butwesawindividualnamesbeingup2%,3%,4-pluspercentinthequarteranditgotstrongeraswewentthroughthequarter.
Soit'sag.California'sgettingrain,that'sagoodthing.Sowe'rewellpositionedinthatpartofthemarket.Andtheneverybodytalkse-commerce,butit'sreallydistribution.We'vegotamixofcustomersacrossthee-commercespace,aswellasdistribution,andit'sshowingprettygoodstrengthacrosstheboard.
PhilipNg (Analyst-JefferiesLLC):
Okay.Thanksalot.Appreciatethecolor.
Operator :
MarkWeintraubofBuckinghamResearch.
MarkWeintraub(Analyst-BuckinghamResearchGroup):
Thankyou.Onequickfollow-upontheDD&Aquestionfrombefore.IsawthattheConsumerPackagingbusinesswasdownquiteabit.WasthatallRiegelwood?AndInoticedthatthepulphadn't
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page11of21
goneup.Doesthatgouponcetheconversion'stakenplace?
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Yes,Mark.Whatwedidiswemovedthatmill,Riegelwood,whichwasasharedmillbetweenthetwosegments,boththeCoatedPaperboardsegmentandthePapersegment,andthat'snowmovedallthewayoverintoNAPP.Soit'slesscoatedpaperboard,hencethechangethere.Andwiththemilldownmostofthequarterfortheconversionandtheiractualannualoutage,that'swhatyousaw.SothatwillnowshowupintheNAPPsegment.
MarkWeintraub(Analyst-BuckinghamResearchGroup):
Okay.SotheConsumerPackagingrunsatthis$25millionaquarternowinNorthAmerica,insteadofthe$45millionithadbeenforDD&A?
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Yes.
MarkWeintraub(Analyst-BuckinghamResearchGroup):
Okay.Andthenonuncoatedfreesheet,isitfairtosaythatyouarenotreflectingalotofimpactfromthepriceincreasewhichisjustcurrentlyunderwayinthesecondquarter,andsosuccessonthat,ifitcomesthrough,wouldlargelyshowupinthethirdquarterandmaybeifyoucouldmodifyalittlebit?
MikeAmick(SVPofN.A.Papers,PulpandConsumerPackaging):
Well,Mark,you'reaccurateinyourstatement.Itwillbe--westartedtoseealittlebit--we'llstarttoseealittlebitinthesecondquarter,butitwillprimarilybeasecondhalfevent.Andyes,primarilysplitbetweenthethirdandlatterpartofthirdquarter,maybealittleinthefourth.
MarkWeintraub(Analyst-BuckinghamResearchGroup):
Okay.Thankyou.
Operator :
thelineofGeorgeStaphosofBankofAmerica.
GeorgeStaphos (Analyst-BoAMerrillLynch):
Hello,everyone.Goodmorning.Congratulationsontheperformance,especiallyinIndustrial.Hadacouplequestions.Firstofall,inIndustrial,canyouupdateusonyourthoughtsastohowyoumightbeabletoincreaseyourverticalintegration?Areyouseeingopportunitiesforinvestment,eitherorganicallyorthroughM&A,tobeabletoacceleratethat,ifthat'sstillagoal?
Andtherelatedpointoncontainerboard,doyouhaveaneedforanysimilarmoveslikeyoudidwithHolmen,andwhataretheimplicationsofthatinvestmentrelativetoyoursupplychaininNorthAmerica?AndIhadaquickfollow-on,ifpossible.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Yes,onyourfirstquestion,George,it'sTimhere,onintegration,Iwouldsaywelikeallofthechannelsthatwe'rein.Weoperateinmultiplechannels.Obviously,theIntegratedchannelisthelargestandit'sveryimportanttous.It'sgoingtocomedowntohowwewinaccountsinthemarketplaceandalignourselveswithcustomerswithinsegments.Sothere'snostatedspecificgoalthatwehavetoreacha
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page12of21
certainintegrationlevel.
Acquisitions,wedon'tcommentonspeculationbutwelookatalotofthings.Andsowe'llcontinuetodothatandifonemakessense,thenwe'llbetalkingtoeveryoneaboutwhatitisandwhywethinkitmakessense.
IntermsofHolmen,Idon'texpectabigimpactfromoneregiontoanotheratall.Buttherelatedquestionaroundaretherethingslikethat,Ithinkthat'swhatyouseeusdoingwithsomeoftheseinvestmentsthatwe'remaking.We'vetalkedaboutincreasingcapacityandaddingflexibility.It'snotthatallcapacityisthesame.Whatwe'redoingiswe'readdingcapabilityaroundcertainproductsthatwethinkaregrowingthroughoursegmentsandthatwethinkweneed,andwe'rebuildingthatcapability.Soit'ssimilartoHolmen.It'sjustdifferent.We'vegot16millswherewecanlookattheproductmixthatweneedandmakeinvestmentsaccordingly.
GeorgeStaphos (Analyst-BoAMerrillLynch):
Okay,Tim.I'llturnitover,sinceIhadmytwo,andI'lltrytocomeback.Thankyou.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Thanks,George.
Operator :
LarsKjellbergofCreditSuisse.
LarsKjellberg (Analyst-CreditSuisse):
Hello.JustaquestionactuallyontheHolmentransaction.WhenI'mlookingatyourIndustrialPackagingbusinessinEurope,theproblemsseemtobethatyouhaveverylowmarginsinyourboxbusiness.Thisdoesn'tnecessarilyfixthatproblem.Sohowdowe--areyouthinkingaboutaddressingthatbusinessinitself,becausejustaddingupstreamintegrationdoesn'tnecessarilyfixwhatseemstobealowmarginbusiness.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Lars,hello.ThisisMark.Theway,buildingonTim'scommentaboutchannels,thewaywelookatourEuropeancorrugatedbusiness,it'saveryfocusedbusiness.Welookatitasoneofourchannelstomarket.Wemoveveryhighquality,highperformancecraftlinerthroughthatsystem.Ifyoulookatthegeography,we'resouthernfocusedaroundfreshfoods.
Andsoourviewofthatbusinessisaspartofourintegratedchanneltomarket.AndtheintegrationofhighperformancerecycledlinercoupledwithourUSproducedhighperformancecraftlinermakesthatwholevaluepropositionbetter.Itallowsustoimproveourcustomermixand,asyouknowfromtheEuropeantheater,therecycledboardthat'savailableisgeographicallyavailable.Soyouhavetohavewhatyouneed,whereyouneedit,inareliablewaytobuildoutyourofferingforyourcustomers.Andthat'swhatthisdoestoimprovethatbusiness.SowhatwefocusoninourEuropeancorrugatedbusinessisverygoodfortheCompany.AndwhenyoutakeitbackandlookatthewaywethinkaboutIndustrialPackagingglobally,it'sareallygoodbusinessforIP.
LarsKjellberg (Analyst-CreditSuisse):
Justafollow-uponthat.There'satremendousamountofconversionsthathitsthemarkettailend2017,early2018.We'retalkingaboutalmost2milliontons.Isthataconsiderationatallforyouasanon-integratedsystemtoday?Isthistherighttimetodoit?
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page13of21
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Well,thatphenomenon,Lars,hasbeensortofafixtureintheEuropeanmarket.There'sbeenacoupleofmilliontonsoverhang.Theproblemwiththatstatementisit'sonaverage.Andagain,recycled,highperformanceliner,it'snotallcreatedequal.Therearethreetofourgradelevels,includingmedium.
AndsowhathastohappenisaconverterlikeInternationalPaperhastohavewhatweneedwhereweneedit.Soifit'sinthenorthofEurope,it'stheoretical.Evenifit'sanoverhang,itdoesn'treallyaffect.Sowhatyouhavetolookatisregionalcapacity.Andwe'vebeenalargeopenmarketbuyerforalongperiodoftimeandwewillstillbuysome.That'showwelookatit,regionalboardfortheconversionthatyouneedandthemarketsegmentsthatyou'refocusedon,nottheaverageofcontainerboardsupplyanddemandforallofEurope,whichisaverydiversemarket,especiallyfortherecycledliner.
LarsKjellberg (Analyst-CreditSuisse):
Verygood.Thankyou.I'llturnitover.
Operator :
MarkConnellyofCLSA.
MarkConnelly(Analyst-CLSALimited):
Thanks.Justtwoquickthings.Canyougiveusanupdateonthetimingofthe250,000tonsofnewcontainerboardcapacitythatyou'readdinghere?We'vetalkedaboutitasagradualramp.I'mjustwonderingifyoucangiveussomesignpostsandtelluswhenthatwouldbeupandrunning.Andsecond,itlookslikeyou'vecutyourcontainerboardmaintenancenumbers.Isthatachangeinscopeorjustimprovedefficiency?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Hello,Mark.It'sTim.Onthefirstquestion,thecapacity,there'sreallynodifferencethanwhatwesaidatthetimeweannouncedit.Wesaiditwasgoingtobea2016-2017setofactions.SoIdon'tknowifit'shalf,half.Butyou'llseesomeofitcomethroughthisyearandyou'llseealittlebitmorecomethroughinthefirsthalfofnextyear.
Andthenonmaintenance,maintenancevariesmillbymillandperiodtoperiod.Sothere'saplan.There'saschedulethatgoesoutyears.Andyoulookatit,pieceofequipmentbypieceofequipmentanditjusthappensthatyouwillhitperiodswhenthethingsthatneedtobetendedtoinanannualoutagecostsmorebecauseofthenatureoftheworkinagivenperiodthaninothers.
CarolRoberts (CFO):
AndIwouldaddtothat,Mark--thisisCarol--iswhileyoudoseethereductionfromthelasttimeweforecastedthesecondquarterdownisweknowasaCompanythatwe'vegotheadwinds,andsowhatwe'vebeentryingtodo,ofcourse,isyou'vegottofindotherleverstopull.Sowe're,asTimsaid,he'slookingathissystemveryhardtomakesurehe'sdoingwhatheneedstodo,andifthere'sanopportunitytotrimsomethingsuptogetmoremoneytothebottomline,that'swhatwe'reattemptingtodo.Andwe'llcontinuetodisclosethateachquartersoyoucanfollowandtrackthosechanges.
MarkConnelly(Analyst-CLSALimited):
That'sreallyhelpful.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page14of21
Mark,thisisMarkSutton.Justthequestion,thefirstquestionyouasked,justtotieitbacktoanearlierquestionaroundhowwerunoursystem,thatincrementalcapacitycapabilitythat'scomingfromtheseinvestment,asTimmentioned,isreallyaboutmakingsomeproductsdifferentlythanwe'vemadebefore,makingoursystemmoreflexible,meaningwecanmakesimilarproductsatthesamemilloradifferentmill,sowecanimproveoursupplychain.
Sotheissueofcapacitycomingonlineisonlywhenandifweneeditforthedemandenvironment.It'sreallythedriverisreallymakingmoreofthisandlessofthatfortheboxesthatweneedtomakegoingforward.Andasanoutcomeofimprovingthosefacilities,wehavemorecapacityifweneedmorecapacity.Sothat'sthewaytothinkaboutthat,asopposedtothisiscomingonatthisdateandthisiscomingonatthatdate.It'scomingonasanewproduct,anewbasisweight,anewdesign.Andnetcapacitycomesonifwehavetheordersforitanddoesn'tcomeonifwedon'thavetheordersforit.
MarkConnelly(Analyst-CLSALimited):
Okay.That'shelpful.Thankyou.
Operator :
ScottGaffnerofBarclays.
JohnDunigan (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):
ThisisactuallyJohnDuniganfillinginforScottGaffner.Goodmorningandcongratsonastrongquarter.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Thankyou.
JohnDunigan (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):
Mostofmyquestions,unfortunately,havebeenasked,butIdidjusthaveacouple.Inparticular,IwantedtoaskaboutwhatyouguysareseeingintheOCCpricesandhowthelowerinputshavehadanimpactonyourfirstquarterandthenwhatyou'reexpectingintermsofanoutlookgoingforwardforthatandhowitcouldaffectIP?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
IthinkourforecastisthatwecouldseesomemodestpressureinOCCpricingaswegothroughthesecondquarter.Wedon'texpectit,atthispoint,tobeamajorfactor.Andyes,inthefirstquarterinputswereabitofatailwindforus,whichwe'reoperatinginacertainenvironmentandtryingtotakeadvantageoftheenvironmentthatwehave.
JohnDunigan (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):
Okay.Andsomeofyourpeershaddiscussedsomeofthefreightbenefitsthatthey'vebeenenjoying,particularlygettingsomediscountsandevenbuildinguponsomeinventorytomeetsomejustintimedemand.CouldyoujusttouchuponwhatIP'sseeingintermsofthosecostsandhowyouguysaremaybetakingadvantage,particularlyinyourIndustrialandPackagingsector?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Well,Ithinkpartofwhatyou'veseen,justinwhatwe'veseenintermsofoursupplychainnetworkisrailandtruckavailabilityhasimproveddramaticallyinthelastpartoflastyear,earlythisyear,comparedtowherewewere,say,ayearago.Sothat'sobviouslyhavinganimpactonthediscussionsyouhavewith
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page15of21
carriersaboutratestructures.It'sstillaverychallengedenvironment,insomecases,intermsofthosediscussions,butwethinkwearehavingsomemeasureoftractionaswehavethosediscussions.
Thebiggerimpactinthemomentisjustwhatitmeanstohowwethinkaboutourstockingpositionsacross200-plusfacilities,andit'smeaningatthemomentthatweneedlessinventoryandwecanrunamuchmoreefficientsupplychain.Sothere'sbenefitinthat.Ithinkwhatweworryaboutishowitchangesovertimeandwilltherebeasnapbackofutilizationratesaroundcarrierslaterthisyear.
JohnDunigan (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):
Andyougenerallythinkintheneartermherethatyoucanstillenjoythebenefits,withpossiblyasnapbacklatethisyearormaybeearlynextyear?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Idon'tknowwhenit'sgoingtohappenorifitwillhappen.Ijustknowthatthingsdon'tstaystatic.Peopletakeactions.Andsowedon'tcountonanythinglasting.Ithinkitgoesbacktothepowerofthesystem.Wehavetremendousflexibility,andwe'retryingtocreatemoreflexibilitythroughtheseinvestmentssothatwecanpullbackwhenweneedtoandwecanrecoverquicklywhenweneedto.
JohnDunigan (Analyst-BarclaysCapital):
Understood.Thankyouverymuch.
Operator :
DebbieJonesofDeutscheBank.
DebbieJones (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
Hello.Goodmorning.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Goodmorning,Debbie.
DebbieJones (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
IwaswonderingifyoucouldtalkaboutthechangeyoumadetoyourmanagementincentiveplaninearlyFebruary.Itlookslikeyouswitcheditupbasedon50%operatingcashflowsto50%EBITDA,withROICbeingtheremainder.Isthereanythingweshouldreadintothataboutyourcashoperatingexpensesinthecomingyears?
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Hello,Debbie.ThisisMark.No,Ithinkwhatwe'reattemptingtodothereiscashflowisstillfrontandcenter.Whatwe'vegotisthatparticularannualplanisfocusedonthemajorityofouremployeeswhoarerunningouroperations,that'sthelevelandtypeofjob.AndwealltalkinEBITDAintheCompany.That'swhatourplansarebasedon.That'swhatpeoplearemeasuredon.Andwe'vehadalittlebitofslippageinourEBITDAprogressoverthelastcoupleyears.Soit'sjustanattempttorefocus.
Intheoverallschemeofthings,obviouslycashfromopsstartswithgood,strongEBITDAandthenyougotothecashflow,freecashflow.Andourcapitalallocationstrategy'sclearlyunderstoodcommitmenttothedividend.SonomessageotherthanfocusingthepeoplewhoareactuallyonthatplantolookatwayswecanimproveourEBITDAandbreakthroughtheflatnatureofitoverthelastcoupleofyears.Sothat'soneplanforoneyearforacertaingroupofemployees.
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page16of21
DebbieJones (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
CanIjustask,doyoustillexpectnopensioncontributionin2016and2017?
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Debbie,whatIwouldsayiswehavenorequiredpensioncontributionsfor2016and2017.Howwegoforward,we'llobviouslynavigatethataswemoveforward.
DebbieJones (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
Okay.Andmylastquestion,Ijustwantedtoask,wetalkalotaboutthesubstitutionpotentialfromcraftlinertorecycledlinerandwhetherornotthere'sroomtogo,giventhesustainablylowOCCprices.Andyouseethisfrombothvantagepoints,havingexposuretobothmarkets.Iwaswonderingifyoucouldcommentonthis,andthenalsohowthismightimpactyourlongertermcapacityplans.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Hello,Debbie,it'sTim.Weseeincertainregions,incertainareas,there'seithermoreorlesscompetitionfromacertaintypeofproductrange.Ithinkthewaywethinkaboutitiswe'relookingwithourcustomersatbestfitandbestuseforthepackagingtheyneed,anditincludesavarietyofsubstrates,somevirgin,somerecycled,fitforuse.Butitalsoincludescapability,geography,servicelevels.Andsowe'resellingthemmorethanjustisitrecycledorisitvirgin.We'resellingthematotalproduct.Andwe'vegotthebreadthofproductstodoitlikenoother.Sothere'salwaysgoingtobecompetition.It'saverycompetitivemarket,butwefeelgoodaboutthevaluepropositionswehave.
DebbieJones (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
Andthenthequestionaboutthecapacityplansinthefuture,justthinkingaboutthetonnagethatyou'readdinginthecomingyears.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Yes,Idon'twanttospeculateonwhatwewilldoorwon'tdo.We'vegotlowOCCinputcostatthemoment.It'samomentintime.Wethinkthere'sprobablyadifferenttrendovertimeandwe'llmakedecisions.It'slikeItalkedaboutthesecapacityadditions,we'renotjustaddinggenerictons.We'readdingproductsandgradesandbasisweightsforwhereweseegrowthinourchannelsandthetypesofproductsthatweneedtosupportthatgrowth.Andthenwerunitaccordingly,aswe'vesaid,towhatourdemandis.Soweconstantlylookatwhatarethoseproducts,whatdotheyneedtobe,whereshouldweaddthem.Anditwillbeanongoingevaluation.
DebbieJones (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
Okay.Thanksverymuch.Goodluckinthequarter.
Operator :
ChrisManuelofWellsFargoSecurities.
ChrisManuel(Analyst-WellsFargoSecurities,LLC):
Goodmorningandcongratulationstoagreatstarttotheyear.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Thanks,Chris.
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page17of21
ChrisManuel(Analyst-WellsFargoSecurities,LLC):
TwotopicsIwantedtotouchon.First,alittlebitmorearound--you'reprobablytiredoftalkingaboutit--butsomeofthedynamicsherewithNorthAmericancontainerboard,andthesecondtopicbeingIlim.Withrespecttothefirsttopic,Ihearhowyou'veansweredDebbieandMark'sandafewothers'questionsaroundthings.ButifIlooktodowntimeyoutookin4Qand1Q,onequarterdoesn'tmakeatrend,butit'snowbeentwoinarowthatit'sbeensolidlynorthof200,000tons.Ifweannualizethat,that'slargerthanamachine,closetoamill,900-ishthousandtonsonanannualbasisofdowntime,marketdowntime.Youalsoreferencedyouhadsomeinventoriescomingdown.Somaybeyoucouldhelpus,giveusasenseastowhenIlookatinventory--orI'msorry,industryinventories--theyhaven'treallymovedmuchthelastfewmonths,butmaybeyourshas.Couldyougiveusasense,maybeeitherintonsorinweekssupplyorhoweveryouthinkaboutit,yourinventorieshavechanged3Qto4Qto1Q?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Iwouldsaywerunaverytightsupplychainyearroundandwemakeadjustmentsaswego.Sono,I'mnotgoingtobreakouttonsorweeksofsupply.I'mjustgoingtosaythatwe'reconstantlylookingoutfour,fivemonthsinadvance,targetingwherewethinkweneedbasedonourdemandsignal,andthenwemakeadjustmentsaswerunthesystem.
Sothedowntimethatwetookinthefourthquarterandfirstquarter,averylargecomponentofthatgoesbacktosupplychainefficienciesandjustnotneedingasmuchinventorythroughourchain.Thatcouldchangeovertime.Andmaybewe'retakingalittlebitofriskonthedownsideintermsofhowitmightchangeandwhatwemightdotobeabletodotorespondit.Butwejustliketorunaverytightsupplychain,andwe'llcontinuetodoso.
ChrisManuel(Analyst-WellsFargoSecurities,LLC):
SoifIreadintothatalittle,itsoundslikeyourinventorylevelsoverthelastcouplequartershavecomedownagoodchunkthenandthey'renotflat.
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
No,they'renotflat.Andalotofthingsgointotargetinginventorylevels.Werunhundredsandhundreds,ifnotthousandsofgrades,200locations.Andsowe'relookingproductbyproduct,basisweights,grades,locationsandstockinglevelsacrossallofthose,andthenwe'readjustingthesystemquarterly.Andifitjusttakeslesstimetogetproductfrommillstoboxplantbecausethevelocityhasincreased,thenweobviouslydon'tneedasmuchinventoryinthesystem.
ChrisManuel(Analyst-WellsFargoSecurities,LLC):
Okay.Thankyou.AndwithrespecttoIlim,I'vereadseveralplacesitlookslikeyou'regoingtodoaprettysizableexpansionthere.Couldyoumaybegiveusalittlecolorastowhat'shappeningintimingandthingsofthatnature,andaswellaswhilethat'sgoingon,whatwewouldprobablyexpectoutof--woulddividendsstopforawhileorhowmightthatwork?
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
SoChris,ontheIlim,Ithink,releasethatyou'rereferencing,theyputoutafive-yearplananditwasacapitalplantoimprovethebusiness.AbigportionofthatisinclusiveoftheirnormalmaintenanceandregulatoryCapEx.That'sabout$325millionannually.Sotheincrementalthatwasinthatannouncementoverthatfive-yearperiodwasabout$700million.
Andit'splannedonlyastheprojectsaredevelopedandastheyhavetherightreturnstoimprovethe
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page18of21
currentbusinessthattheyhaveandtoimprovethequalityoftheproductand,ifnecessary,tomakemoreproductatasecondfacility.AndtheplanforthatwouldbetoorganizethefundingthesamewaythepriordevelopmentofIlimwasdone,whichisontheIlimbalancesheet,andwedon'tseeanyeffectonthedividendchangingorgoingdownoranythinglikethat.
Sowethinkthere'ssomegoodopportunitiesforimprovingIlim.AnditgoestothatcommentImadeonmyclosingstatementaroundmakingproductsthatareneededinthemarket,mainlyintoconsumer-orientedenduses,andmakingthemintherightplaceintheworldforyouradvantage,fiber,coststructure,andworkforce.Andthisisaperfectexampleofthat.
CarolRoberts (CFO):
AndChris,I'lljustaddon.Weactuallyaregoingtogetadividendpayment,I'mlookingatmycolleagueswhoareontheBoard,istheIlimjointventurelastweekapprovedthedividendpaymentfor2016.Sowe'llreceivebetween$50million,$55millionthisyearandanotherrecommitmenttothedividendflowoutofthebusiness,giventhatit'sgeneratingsignificantcash.Andalsoifyoulookattheirdebtbalance,theirdebthasactuallycomedown,aswell.Sothefinancialconditionofthatbusinessisgreatandwe'recountingondividendsoutofthatbusinessaspartofthevaluecreationequationforInternationalPaper.
ChrisManuel(Analyst-WellsFargoSecurities,LLC):
Okay.Thankyouverymuch.Goodluck.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Thankyou,Chris.
Operator :
ChipDillonofVerticalResearch.
ChipDillon (Analyst-VerticalResearchPartners):
Yesandgoodmorning.
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
Goodmorning,Chip.
ChipDillon (Analyst-VerticalResearchPartners):
IjustwantedtomakesureIunderstood.Yougavealotofmovingpartsearlierinthecall.AndIknowyousaidthatthepriceimpactofmainlypulpwouldbeabout,ontheNorthAmericanPaperbusiness,wouldbesomewherearound$20million.ButthenIthinkyousaidthatthere'sabenefitinBrazilofabout$10million.SoIguessforthatsegment,lookingatjustpricing,thedifferencewouldbejust$10million,isthatright,negative?
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Yes,thosearetwodiscreteitemsthatwecalledout.Sothatwouldbetherightwaytolookatit,Chip.
ChipDillon (Analyst-VerticalResearchPartners):
Okay.AndjustsoIunderstand,ontheslides,itlookslikethetotalbenefitfromlessmaintenanceinthesecondquarter,Ithinkaddsupto$42million,butthenyoucalledoutsomeother$30millionswingfromoperations.Couldyoujustclarifythat,please?
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page19of21
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Yes,Chip,IthinkwhatIcalledoutwas$22millionontotaloutageexpensefromfirsttosecond.
ChipDillon (Analyst-VerticalResearchPartners):
Okay.
CarolRoberts (CFO):
SoI'mnotsurewherethenumberthatyousaid.WhatwedidcalloutisRiegelwoodwasabigdriver,butifyouadditallup,ifyougoallthewayacrossthelinethereandadditallup,it'sa$22millionimprovementfirsttosecond.
ChipDillon (Analyst-VerticalResearchPartners):
Gotyou.
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Thesecondpartofyourquestion--I'mnotsureI--thesecondpartofyourquestionthenstillhasapplication.
ChipDillon (Analyst-VerticalResearchPartners):
Theoperations,Ithinkyousaidthereweresome$30millionbenefitfromjustoperationsthatyoureferredto.
CarolRoberts (CFO):
Yes,andyouknow,thesecondquarter'salwaysabetteroperationsquarterthanthefirst.It'snotascold.Justhavealotbehindyou.It'sgenerallyagoodoperationalquarter,forlotsofreasons.Andweanticipatethattohappen.
ChipDillon (Analyst-VerticalResearchPartners):
Okay.Andthenjustasafollow-up,youmentioned,Ithinkthisisveryapropos,giventheopportunityinMadrid,andyousayyouhavealotofexposureinthefruit,vegetablearea.Myunderstandingisthatmostorallofthefruitsandvegetablesneedtobepackagedinvirgin-basedcraftlinerbecauseofthecondensationissue.Andhastechnologychangedtoallowcertaintypesofrecycledboardtobeintroducedthere?Isthereanykindofachangethathastakenplaceoristakingplace?Andthenisthat,inpart,behindyourmoveinMadrid?
MarkSutton (Chairman&CEO):
No,themoveinMadridisreallytocomplementwhatwedowithcraftliner.Andyourassessmentisaccurate.There'sbeenlotsofattemptstomakeproductswithmixedsubstratesinthatfield.Itreally,reallyisdrivenbythesupplychain.Thereareprobablysomeshortsupplychainsthatcanbeardifferentproducts.Butthehumidityfromtheharvestallthewaythroughthesupplychaintothemarketiswhatdrivestheperformancecharacteristicsoffreshfoodpackagingforneedingcraftlinerorcraft-likeperformancecharacteristics.
Theindustrialbusiness,thehighendindustrialbusinessthatcomplementsyourmixandyourplant--becauseobviously,agricultureisseasonalandyouwanttorunyourplantandrunasuccessfulbusinessovertheyear--that'swherethehighperformance,lightweightrecycledcomesin.Anditallowsustoperformbetterinsomeofthebestindustrialsegmentsversususingboardthatisnotthathigh
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page20of21
performance,thatyou'vegottousemoreofitandthingsofthatnature.Youendupnotbeingcompetitiveintheindustrialsegmentsthatyoureallywanttobein.
ChipDillon (Analyst-VerticalResearchPartners):
Thatmakesalotofsense.Thanksverymuch.
Operator :
YourfinalquestioncomesfromthelineofDannyMoranofMacquarie.
DannyMoran (Analyst-MacquarieResearch):
Hello.Goodmorning.Thanksfortakingmyquestions.Ijustwanttoclarifysomethingonyourheatmapthatyouprovidedinyourearningspresentation.Doyouanticipatecontinuedhigheryear-over-yearexportshipmentsin2Qandfortheyear?Andthendoyoualsoexpectfurtherpriceerosiontotheexportmarkets?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Hello,Danny.I'massumingyou'retalkingaboutcontainerboard.Wefeelprettygoodaboutthedemandsignalthatwe'vegottenfromthemarkets.Marginstakeahit.Demandseemstobeholdingup,whichsaystousthere'saneedforthetypeofproductthatwe'resupplyingtotheexportmarkets.Andwe'vebeenastrategicsuppliertothosemarketsfordecades.Sowehavelong-termrelationshipsthatwestickwithquartertoquarter,yearin,yearout.
Wefeelprettygoodaboutourbacklogsforthesecondquarter.Themarket'sverycompetitive.Idon'twanttoforecastprice,butI'lljustleaveitthatit'scompetitiveandthetypesoferosionthatwe'veseenprobablycontinueintothequarter.Sowe'llmanageitaccordingly.Butwestillmakedecentmoneyonexportandwelikeitalot,onaverage,throughthecycle.
DannyMoran (Analyst-MacquarieResearch):
Okay.That'shelpful.Thanks.Andthenonelastonefromme.WithallthemovingpartsinyourNorthAmericanIndustrialPackagingbusiness,witheconomicdowntimeandsomecapacitycreep,onanetbasisdoyouexpecttoproducemoreorlessboxesthisyear?
T imNicholls (SVP,IndustrialPackaging):
Well,I'mnotgoingtoforecastwhatwe'llproduce.We'vesaidthatovertimeourgoalisthatwepositionourselveswiththerightsegmentsandwiththerightcustomersandwewouldexpecttoperforminlinewithmarket,asourchoicesaroundcustomermixgrowovertime.Andwe'veseenalittlebitofbothhereoverthepastyear.Lastyear,wewereunderperformingbecauseofsomeofthatexposure.Andinthefirstquarterofthisyear,wewererightontopofit.Sotous,it'saboutcustomerchoicesandhowwealignourselvesintherightspots.
DannyMoran (Analyst-MacquarieResearch):
Gotit.Okay.Thanksandgoodluckfortherestoftheyear.
Operator :
Thankyou.Iwillnowturnthe--
JayRoyalty(InvestorRelations):
CompanyName:InternationalPaperCoCompanyTicker:IPSector:ConsumerGoodsIndustry:ConsumerNon-Durables
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:17.62BPriceasofEventDate:44.18
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page21of21
Thanks,everyone.
Operator :
Thankyou.IwillnowturnthecallbackovertoJayRoyaltyforanyclosingcomments.
JayRoyalty(InvestorRelations):
Sorry,Operator.Ijumpedthegunalittle.That'sallthetimewehavetoday,folks.Thanksforjoining.Andasalways,MichelleandIareavailableafterthecall.Haveagreatday.
Operator :
Thankyou.Thatdoesconcludetoday'sconferencecall.
Allrightsreserved(c)2014TheStreet,Inc.
Pleasefeelfreetoquoteupto200wordspertranscript.Anyquoteshouldbeaccompaniedby"ProvidedbyTheStreet"andalinktothecompletetranscriptandwww.thestreet.com.Anyotheruseormethodofdistributionisstrictlyprohibited.
THEINFORMATIONCONTAINEDINEACHWRITTENORAUDIOTRANSCRIPT(the"TRANSCRIPT")ISAREPRODUCTIONOFAPARTICULARCOMPANY'SCONFERENCECALL,CONFERENCEPRESENTATIONOROTHERAUDIOPRESENTATION.THETRANSCRIPTSAREPROVIDED"ASIS"AND"ASAVAILABLE"ANDTHESTREETISNOTRESPONSIBLEINANYWAYNORDOESITMAKEANYREPRESENTATIONORWARRANTYREGARDINGTHEACCURACYORCOMPLETENESSOFTHETRANSCRIPTSASPRODUCED,NORTHESUBSTANCEOFAPARTICULARCOMPANY'SINFORMATION.
THETRANSCRIPTSAREPROVIDEDFORINFORMATIONALPURPOSESONLY.THESTREETISNOTPROVIDINGANYINVESTMENTADVICEORENDORSINGANYPARTICULARCOMPANY.