16
CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck Phitak, Peraphan Pothacharoen, and Prachya Kongtawelert* Thailand Excellence Center for Tissue Engineering and Stem Cells, Chiang Mai University, Chiang Mai 50200, Thailand *Corresponding author. E-mail: [email protected] https://doi.org/10.12982/CMUJNS.2018.0011 ABSTRACT M. pruriens seeds are a natural product with health benefits, including treating erectile dysfunction (ED). However, the active compounds and their mechanisms of action are unclear. In this study, we used polarity gradient extraction to isolate four fractions from the crude extract of M. pruriens seeds using hexane, EtOAc, BuOH, and water. All fractions were used to treat three cell lines: C6, Ea.hy926, and HCT-15. The water fraction significantly promoted nitric oxide (NO) production in C6 cells via neuronal nitric oxide synathase (nNOS) gene upregulation. M. pruriens fractions with high polarity promoted NO production in Ea.hy926 through the upregulation of endothelial NOS (eNOS) and inducible NOS (iNOS) genes. The BuOH and water fractions of M. pruriens extract were involved with cyclic GMP specific-phosphodiesterase (PDE5) and iNOS gene upregulation in HCT-15, which might result in maintenance of intracellular cGMP. According to the NIST library, 2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol, a phytochemical, may play a role in nNOS upregulation; this was only found in the water fraction. Protocatechuic acid, methyl ester, and γ-sitosterol were also found in the high-polar fractions of M. pruriens extract and might be involved with eNOS gene upregulation. The ability of M. pruriens extract to provoke NO production in neurons indicated the potential for using M. pruriens seeds as an alternative medicine for erectile dysfunction therapy. Keywords: Mucuna pruriens, Erectile dysfunction, Nitric oxide, GC/MS INTRODUCTION Erectile dysfunction (ED), or the failure to achieve or maintain sufficient penile erection for sexual intercourse (NIH, 1993), is one of the most common forms of deteriorating organ function among aging men (Prins et al., 2002). The trigger includes impaired function of vascular arteries and the smooth muscles or neurons within the penile tissues (Dean and Lue, 2005; Gratzke et al., 2010). In the cellular mechanism of a penile erection, nitric oxide (NO), which is produced by endothelial cells and neurons, plays an important role in cellular stimulation through activation via the NO/cGMP pathway; but NO is reduced in ED

In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 145

In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction

Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck Phitak, Peraphan Pothacharoen, and Prachya Kongtawelert*

Thailand Excellence Center for Tissue Engineering and Stem Cells, Chiang Mai University, Chiang Mai 50200, Thailand

*Corresponding author. E-mail: [email protected]

https://doi.org/10.12982/CMUJNS.2018.0011

ABSTRACT

M. pruriens seeds are a natural product with health benefits, including treating erectile dysfunction (ED). However, the active compounds and their mechanisms of action are unclear. In this study, we used polarity gradient extraction to isolate four fractions from the crude extract of M. pruriens seeds using hexane, EtOAc, BuOH, and water. All fractions were used to treat three cell lines: C6, Ea.hy926, and HCT-15. The water fraction significantly promoted nitric oxide (NO) production in C6 cells via neuronal nitric oxide synathase (nNOS) gene upregulation. M. pruriens fractions with high polarity promoted NO production in Ea.hy926 through the upregulation of endothelial NOS (eNOS) and inducible NOS (iNOS) genes. The BuOH and water fractions of M. pruriens extract were involved with cyclic GMP specific-phosphodiesterase (PDE5) and iNOS gene upregulation in HCT-15, which might result in maintenance of intracellular cGMP. According to the NIST library, 2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol, a phytochemical, may play a role in nNOS upregulation; this was only found in the water fraction. Protocatechuic acid, methyl ester, and γ-sitosterol were also found in the high-polar fractions of M. pruriens extract and might be involved with eNOS gene upregulation. The ability of M. pruriens extract to provoke NO production in neurons indicated the potential for using M. pruriens seeds as an alternative medicine for erectile dysfunction therapy.

Keywords: Mucuna pruriens, Erectile dysfunction, Nitric oxide, GC/MS

INTRODUCTION

Erectile dysfunction (ED), or the failure to achieve or maintain sufficient penileerection for sexual intercourse (NIH, 1993), is one of the most common forms of deteriorating organfunctionamongagingmen(Prinsetal.,2002).Thetriggerincludesimpairedfunctionof vascular arteries and the smooth muscles or neurons within the penile tissues (DeanandLue,2005;Gratzkeetal.,2010).Inthecellularmechanismofapenileerection,nitricoxide(NO),whichisproducedbyendothelialcellsandneurons,playsanimportantroleincellularstimulationthroughactivationviatheNO/cGMPpathway;butNOisreducedinED

Page 2: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2)146

(Burnett,2002).CurrentEDtherapeuticguidelinessuggestmaintainingintracellularcyclicGMP(cGMP)usingacGMP-specificphosphodiesterase(PDE5)inhibitor,suchassildenafil(Viagra®) (Andersson, 2011). However, sildenafil has serious, even life-threatening, sideeffects,includingseverehypotensionandcardiacarrhythmia(Chamsi-Pasha,2001).EffectiveandsafertreatmentoptionsforEDtherapyarestillrequired. Mucuna pruriens, or the velvet bean, is a tropical plant that has been described inancient Ayurvedic literature as a medically beneficial plant (Kavitha and Thangamani,2014).Itsseedisrichinlevodopa(L-DOPA),andhasbeenusedtotreatParkinson’sdisease(Pulikkalpuraetal.,2015).TheextractofM. pruriensseedshavealsobeenshowntoreduceserumglucoselevelsindiabeticrats(Majekodunmietal.,2011).Itsseedextractshavealsobeenshownto improvesexualbehavior inratswithbothnormalanddiabetic-inducedED(Suresh et al., 2009;Suresh andPrakash, 2012).Ketkar et al. (2011) attributed this effectto L-DOPA in the seed extract. However, Both et al. (2005) showed that while L-DOPA increasedsexualappetite,itwasnotinvolvedwiththegenitalorgansorsexualarousal.Theseeds of M. prurienshavebeenreportedtocontainanumberofphytochemicals,includingalkaloids,phenoliccompounds,andsaponins(Adebowaleetal.,2005).SomeofthesenaturalsubstancesarereportedtopossessvariousbiologicalactivitiesthatmightbeusefulfortreatingED. This study used polarity gradient extraction to extract the phytochemicals in M. pruriens seedsandthenconductedaninvitroinvestigationoftheirpossibleroleintreatingerectile dysfunction.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Materials Sildenafilcitrate(Viagra®)100mgtabletswerepurchasedfromPfizer(Thailand)Ltd.Griess’s reagent and 2,2-Diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH) were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich® Inc.,Singapore. cGMPParameterAssayKitwaspurchased fromR&DSystems,Inc., USA. Illustra RNAspin Mini RNA Isolation Kit was purchased from GE MedicalSystems(Thailand)Ltd.TetrocDNASynthesisKitandSensiFASTTMSYBR®Lo-ROXKitwerepurchasedfromBiolineSingapore.ReagentsusedincellculturingwereacquiredfromGibco®,ThermoFisherScientificCo.,Ltd.,Thailand.Allchemicalsusedinthisstudywereofanalytical grade.

M. pruriens seed extract preparation M. pruriens seeds were harvested from Mae Taeng District, Chiang Mai Province, Thailand betweenMarch andMay, 2014.TheM. pruriens plants used in this studyweredeposited at the herbarium at the Faculty of Pharmacy, ChiangMai University (vouchernumber023155).The seedpods andhairswere completely removed from the specimens.The seedswere thenwashed thoroughlywith tapwater anddriedat60ºCovernight, afterwhich they were blended into a fine powder using an industrial blending machine. Onekilogramofpowderwasmaceratedwith4Lofmethanolatroomtemperatureforsevendayswith occasional stirring.Themethanolic solutionwas filteredwithWhatman’sNo.1 filtermembraneandevaporatedusingavacuumevaporator.Theextractionwasrepeatedfourtimesandall theextractswerepooled.Anappropriateamountofwarmdistilledwaterwasused

Page 3: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 147

toreconstitutetheextract.Diethyletherinavolumeequaltothedistilledwaterwasusedtoeliminateexcessfattymatter.Thewaterlayerwascollectedandevaporatedtoeliminateanyremainingorganicsolventandtheresiduewasdriedusinglyophilization.Theextractfromthewaterlayerwasdesignatedasthe‘crudefraction’.Thecrudefractionwasthenreconstitutedwithanappropriateamountofdistilledwaterandtransferredtoaseparatingfunnel. Weusedpolaritygradientextractiontosegregatetheconstituentphytochemicalsbasedontheirpolarities(Sasidharanetal.,2011),usnghexane,ethylacetate,andbutanolinavolumeequaltothedissolveddistilledwater.Eachsolventwasusedtoextractthecrudefractionforthreerounds.Eachfractionwaspooledandthesolventeliminatedusingarotaryevaporator. The antioxidant activity of each fraction was determined using DPPH assay as previouslydescribed (Jing et al., 2012).Briefly, the solutionofM. pruriens fractions was mixedwithDPPHsolutionfor24hoursandtheabsorbancewasmeasuredat515nm.

Phytochemical identification using GC/MS All M. pruriens seed extracts were dissolved in methanol to produce a 1 mg/mlsolution.Oneµlofeachsamplewas injectedinasplitlessmodeintoaGC-FIDapparatus(GC 7890A Agilent Technology) attached to a MS instrument (MSD 5975C (EI) Agilent Technology) located at the 1stRegionalMedicalSciencesCenter,ChiangMai,Thailand.ThechromatographicsystemwasoperatedaccordingtoKarunanithietal.(2012).AllpeakswereidentifiedusingtheMSspectralibraryprovidedwiththeAgilentGC/MSsoftware.

Cell culturing and treatment Thisstudyusedthreecelllines,representingthecellsofinterest:ratgliomacelllineC6(ATCC®numberCCL-107),torepresentneuronalcells;humanendothelialhybridcelllineEa.hy926(ATCC®numberCRL-2922)substitutingforendothelialcells;andhumancolorectalcarcinoma cell line HCT-15 (ATCC®numberCCL-225),wherePDE5ishighlyexpressed,andwhichhasbeen studied in relationSildenafil (Meiet al., 2015).Ea.hy926wascultured inDulbecco’sModifiedEagleMedium(DMEM)complementedwith10%fetalbovineserum,2%HATmedium,100U/mlpenicillinGsodium,and100µg/mlstreptomycin.C6andHCT-15were cultured inRPMI1640mediumusing the complements similar toEa.hy926, butwithouttheHATmedium.Thecellswerestoredinanincubatorwith5%CO2 at 37°C; the experimentswere not conducted until their densities reached 80% confluence in a 6-wellplate.PhytochemicalsatindicatedconcentrationsfromtheMTTassaywereusedtotreatthecells.Sildenafil,ataconcentrationof25µM,wasusedasthepositivecontrol.Aftertreatingfor24hours,celllysateswerecollectedtodeterminegeneexpressionandintracellularcGMPlevels;culturesupernatantswerecollectedandNOmeasured.

MTT assay TheappropriatedosesoftheM. pruriensextractsweredeterminedbyMTTassay.TheM. pruriens extracts, at concentrations of 1-1,000 µg/ml, were used to treat each cell line for 24hours,afterwhichtheculturesupernatantswereremoved.Cellswerewashedtwiceby1xPBS.MTTdyewasaddedandthecellsincubatedforafurtherfourhoursbeforeremovingtheMTT-containingmedia.DMSOwasaddedandtheabsorbancewasmeasuredat540nm.The extract concentrations at which the cell survival rate exceeded 80% was consideredappropriate.

Page 4: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2)148

Nitric oxide determination Aftertreatment,1mlofculturesupernatantwasimmediatelycollectedandmixedwithGriess’sreagent(0.1%N-(1-naphthyl)ethylenediaminedihydrochloride,1%sulfanilamide,and2.5%H3PO4)inanequalvolume.Themixturewasincubatedatroomtemperaturefor10minutes and thenmeasured at an absorbance of 540 nmusing amicroplate reader.Atvaryingconcentrationsofsodiumnitrite(1-100µM),thestableformofNOinthesampleswas measured to generate a standard curve (Bryan and Grisham, 2007).

Intracellular cGMP determination A ParameterTM cGMP Competitive ELISA Kit was used to determine intracellularcGMPlevels.ThetreatedHCT-15cellswerelysedusingthelysisbufferprovidedwiththetestkitand100µlofeachsamplewasappliedtotheanalyticalplate.ELISAfollowedthemanufacturer’s guidelines. After ELISA, absorbance was measured at UV 450 nm. TheconcentrationvalueofcGMPinthesampleswasmeasuredandcomparedtothestandardcurvegeneratedfromstandardcGMPataconcentrationrangeof0-500pmol/mlusing4-parameter-logisticscompatiblesoftware.

Gene expression analysis using real-time reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (real-time RT PCR) Total RNA was extracted from the treated cells using an Illustra RNAspin MiniRNAIsolationKit.TheextractedRNA(1.0µg)wasusedasatemplatetosynthesizecDNAusingaTetrocDNASynthesisKit.Real-timeRT-PCRwasperformedusingaSensiFASTTM SYBR®Lo-ROXKit,followingthemanufacturer’smanual.PCRprimerswereobtainedfromInvitrogenTM.Thereactionswereoperatedona7,500FastReal-TimePCRinstrument.Thedatawerecollectedand the foldchanges in thegeneexpressionwerecalculatedusing the2-ΔΔCTmethod (Schefeet al.,2006). iNOS,eNOS,andPDE5were thegenesof interest inhumancells;themurinegenesinthisstudywereiNOSandnNOS.β-actinofbothspecieswasusedasthereferenceconstitutivegene.Weusedthefollowingprimersequences:

Homo sapiens nitric oxide synthase 2 (NOS2): Forward 5’-CTGCTTGAGGTGGGCGG-3’ Reverse 5’-GTGACTCTGACTCGGGACGCC-3’Homo sapiens nitric oxide synthase 3 (NOS3): Forward 5’-TGGACCTGGATACCCGGAC-3’ Reverse 5’-TGGTGACTTTGGCTAGCTGG-3’Homo sapiens phosphodiesterase 5A (PDE5A): Forward 5’-GAAAAGGACTTTGCTGCTT-3’ Reverse 5’-TGATTTTGTTTGCATCATGT-3’Homo sapiens actin beta (ACTB): Forward 5’-CGTGAAAAGATGACCCAGATCA-3’ Reverse 5’-CACAGCCTGGATGGCTACGT-3’Rattus norvegicus nitric oxide synthase 1 (NOS1): Forward 5’-ACTGACACCCTGCACCTGAAGA-3’ Reverse 5’-GTGCGGACATCTTCTGACTTCC-3’

Page 5: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 149

Rattus norvegicus nitric oxide synthase 2 (NOS2): Forward 5’-CAGCTGGGCTGTACAAACCTT-3’ Reverse 5’-CATTGGAAGTGAAGCGGTTCG-3’Rattus norvegicus actin, beta (Actb): Forward 5’-TTCAACACCCCAGCCATGT-3’ Reverse 5’-TGGTACGACCAGAGGCATACAG-3’

Statistical analysis The statistically significant differences between the groups were determined usingone-wayANOVA test.All results are displayed asmean±SEMof triplicate independentexperiments.Statisticalsignificancewasassumedat p < 0.05.

RESULTS

Qualitative analysis of M. pruriens seed extract Theextractionprocesswithmethanolproduced106.46gofmethanolicextract(10.65%w/w).Theextractwasthendefattedusingdiethylether;36.31goffattymatterwaseliminated(3.63%w/w).Theremainingfraction(70.22g)wasdesignatedasthecrudefraction(7.02%w/w)andusedasthesourceforpolaritygradientextraction.Thepolaritygradientextractionofthehexane,EtOAC,BuOH,andwaterfractionsyielded13.38,12.34,14.26,and28.61g,respectively(1.34,1.23,1.43,and2.86%w/w,respectively). ThephytochemicalcomponentsofeachfractionweredeterminedusingGC/MS(Figure1).Table1showstheGCpeaksthatmatcheddatafromtheMSspectralibrary,withprobabilitypercentagesandtheirpeakresponses.FromtheMSspectralibrary,polarsubstancesappearinthefirstportionofthechromatogramsandnonpolarsubstancesinthesecond.Interestingly,wedidnotfindL-DOPAinanyofthefractionsinthisstudy,despitepreviousreportsthatitisamajorcomponentofM. pruriens seedsandcorrespondinglyshouldbefoundinthelipophilicfractions. AllpeaksthatcouldbeidentifiedbytheMSspectradatabasewerecontainedinthecrudefraction(Figure1A).Fattyacidsandlipidderivatives,includingn-Hexadecanoicacid[6], 9,12-Octadecadienoic acid (Z,Z)-, methyl ester [7], Octadecanoic acid [8], Glycerol1-palmitate [9],andOctadecanoicacid,2-hydroxy-1-(hydroxymethyl)ethylester [11]werefoundinallfractionsindifferingamounts.γ-sitosterol[10]wastheonlylipidderivativefoundinBuOHandthewaterfraction.Theonlyhydrophiliccomponentfoundinallfractionswas7,9-di-tert-butyl-1-oxaspiro(4,5)deca-6,9-diene-2,8-dione [5]. The phytochemical diethylphthalate[3]wasfoundinallfractions,althoughitwasmostclearlyobservedinthehexaneandEtOAcfractions(Figures1Band1C).Sucrose[1]andprotocatechuicacid,methylester[4]werefoundinsmallamountsintheBuOHfraction,aswellthewaterfraction(Figures1Dand1E).Thephytochemical2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol[2]wasfoundonlyinthewaterfraction(Figure1E).

Page 6: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2)150

Figure 1. GC chromatogram of all fractions of M. pruriensseedextracts:crude(A),hexane(B), ethylacetate(C),butanol(D),andwater(E). Note:ThemajorpeaksareidentifiedinTable1.

Page 7: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 151

Table 1. IdentificationofGCpeaksinthechromatogramsoffractionsbyMSspectralibrary.No.

Retention time

PhytochemicalProbability

(%)Correlated peak area (Abs*s)

Crude Hexane EtOAc BuOH Water1 11.49 Sucrose 66.8 305310 0 0 76240 4262302 12.58 2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol 95.0 207960 0 0 0 2675603 13.96 Diethyl Phthalate 60.5 2038150 2440290 4141300 105810 5060704 15.57 Protocatechuic acid, methy ester 91.2 375030 0 0 97320 1222005 17.18 7,9-Di-tert-butyl-1-oxaspiro(4,5)deca-6,9-diene-2,8-dione 99.0 1452130 345140 409750 336670 4680406 17.58 n-Hexadecanoic acid 98.0 1575880 1402450 1194820 1924120 16442507 18.93 9,12-Octadecadienoicacid(Z,Z)-,methylester 95.0 1541460 1866970 1429560 2059000 32710108 19.42 Octadecanoic acid 97.4 321650 751050 597940 1479720 10322909 22.48 Glycerol1-palmitate 85.5 1577260 425180 329800 571500 114529010 23.90 γ-sitosterol 71.0 392140 0 0 100560 10267011 24.51 Octadecanoic acid, 2-hydroxy-1-(hydroxymethyl)ethyl ester 91.0 2058280 658080 526060 1204780 2828030

Note:Probability percentagesweremeasured by comparing to theMS spectra in theNIST library. Peakresponsesofeachfractionaredisplayedasthecorrelatedpeakarea.

Antioxidant properties of M. pruriens fractions TheantioxidantactivitiesofeachfractionwererelatedtothecomponentsfoundintheGCchromatogram(Figure2).Thefractionswithhighpolaritydisplayedhigherantioxidantactivitythanthelowpolarityfractions.Thewaterfractionshowedthebestantioxidantactivityamong the M. pruriens fractions.

Figure 2. AntioxidantpropertiesofM. pruriensseedfractionsasmeasuredbyDPPHassay. Antioxidantproperties,orTroloxequivalentantioxidantcapability(TEAC),arein TroloxEquivalents(TE)pergramofdryweightofextract.

Page 8: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2)152

Cytotoxicity of M. pruriens fractions Prior to the in vitroexperiments,wedeterminedtheappropriateconcentrationoftheM. pruriensfractionstoapplytothetestedcelllinesusingtheMTTassay.TheMTTresultsrevealedthatatconcentrationshigherthan125µg/ml(Figures3Ato3C),cellsurvivalratesineachexperimentalgroupwerelessthan80%.Atconcentrationsoflessthan62.5µg/ml,cellviabilityexceeded80%;wethusselectedaconcentrationof50µg/mlforallM. pruriens fraction for further study. The toxicity of the extracts did not involve the DMSO, which was usedataconcentrationof0.05%v/vintheculturemediumtodissolvethefractions.TheIC50

valuesfromthecytotoxicitytestsofeachfractionaredisplayedinTable2.

Figure 3. Cytotoxicityofcelllinesusedinthisstudy(A)C6,(B)Ea.hy926,and(C)HCT-15. Atconcentrationof62.5µg/mlorless,survivalratesexceeded80%inallfractions, so the concentration of 50 µg/ml was chosen for further studies.

Table 2. IC50 value of M. pruriens fractions on cell lines.

Type of cell lineIC50 (µg/ml)

Crude Hexane EtOAc BuOH WaterC6 247.6±2.5 >1000 450.2±6.9 234.3±3.4 86.7±2.7Ea.hy926 258.4±3.0 >1000 506.6±4.7 239.1±2.6 94.6±1.5HCT-15 248.7±6.2 >1000 496.5±9.8 245.9±3.8 96.7±2.8

Page 9: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 153

In vitro effect of M. pruriens fractions on penile erection related gene expression and biomolecules Wesimulated, in vitro, thecellularsituationofapenileerectionanddeterminedtheeffects ofM. pruriens fractions on NOS and PDE5 gene expression, NO synthesis, andintracellularcGMPremaininginthecellsusingthreecelllines(C6,Ea.hy926,andHCT-15),comparedto25µMSildenafilasthepositivecontrol. After24hoursoftreatment,SildenafilsignificantlystimulatedtheproductionofNOinC6cells(Figures4C).However,SildenafildidnotpromotetheupregulationofthenNOSgene(Figure4A),andonlyslightlyincreasediNOSgeneexpression(Figure4B).Thecrudefractions of M. pruriens showed more potential for stimulating NO in C6 cells than theSildenafil(Figure4C).TheincreaseinthewaterfractionwassignificantcomparedtoboththecontrolandSildenafil-treatedgroups.TheincrementalincreaseinNOwasrelatedtothepolarityofthesubstances.Interestingly,thewaterfractionoftheM. pruriens seed extract was theonlyfractionthatsignificantlyupregulatednNOSandiNOSgeneexpressioninC6cells(Figures4Aand4B).

Figure 4. The in vitroeffectofM. pruriensfractionsonC6cells:(A)nNOSgeneexpression, (B)iNOSgeneexpression,and(C)releasedNOlevel. Note: The statistical significance of the differences between groups was determined using one-wayANOVAtest.StatisticalsignificanceisassumedatP<0.05;*whencomparedtothe controlgroup,and#whencomparedtotheSildenafil-treatedgroup.

IntheEa.hy926cellline,SildenafilsignificantlypromotedNOproduction(Figure5C)throughupregulatingtheeNOSandiNOSgenes(Figures5Aand5B).ThecrudeextractofM. prurienssignificantlypromotedthereleaseofNOintheEa.hy926cellline(Figure5C),andrelatedtotheupregulationoftheeNOSgene(Figure5A).ThispotencywasassociatedwiththepolarcompoundsintheM. pruriensextract,astheupregulationofeNOSexpressiongraduallyincreasedastheextractwastreatedwithhigherpolarfractions.However,itspotentialwasnotcomparabletothatofSildenafil.PhytochemicalscontainedintheEtOAC,BuOH,andwaterfractionsaffectedtheupregulationoftheiNOSgeneinEa.hy926cells(Figure5B).Thewaterfraction of the M. pruriensextractsignificantlyenhancediNOSgeneexpressioncomparedtoboththecontrolandtheSildenafil-treatedgroups.

Page 10: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2)154

Figure 5. The in vitroeffectofM. pruriensfractionsontheEa.hy926cellline.(A)eNOS geneexpression,(B)iNOSgeneexpression,(C)releasedNOlevel. Note: The statistical significance of the differences between groups was determined using one-wayANOVAtest.StatisticalsignificanceisassumedatP<0.05;*whencomparedtothe controlgroup,and#whencomparedtoSildenafil-treatedgroup.

As expected, Sildenafil displayed the potential to maintain the intracellular cGMPlevels in HCT-15 cells (Figure 6C). Sildenafil acted as an inhibitor that consequentlypromoted PDE5 gene expression (Figure 6A). Moreover, Sildenafil substantially affectedthe upregulation of the iNOSgene inHCT-15 cells (Figure 6B).The crude extract ofM. pruriens seeds significantly retained the intracellular cGMP level, but its efficacywasnotequivalenttothatofSildenafil(Figure6C).TheeffectoftheM. pruriens fractions on restored intracellularcGMPlevelswasassociatedwith thepolarityof the fractions.However,onlytheBuOHandwaterfractionswerefoundtopotentiallyupregulatePDE5geneexpression(Figure6A),withnosignificantdifferencebetweenthem.ThesetwofractionssignificantlyinducediNOSgeneexpressioninHCT-15cells.ThewaterfractionoftheM. pruriens seed extractpartiallyelevatedtheproductionofNOfromHCT-15cellscomparedtoBuOHandSildenafil.Hydrophobic fractions ofM. pruriens did not affect gene expression or cGMPlevels in HCT-15 cells.

Figure 6. The in vitro effect ofM. pruriens fractions on HCT-15 cells: (A) PDE5 gene expression,(B)iNOSgeneexpression,(C)intracellularcGMPlevel. Note: The statistical significance of the differences between groups was determined using one-wayANOVAtest.StatisticalsignificanceisassumedatP<0.05;*whencomparedtothe controlgroup,and#whencomparedtotheSildenafil-treatedgroup.

Page 11: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 155

DISCUSSION

NOisanimportantmoleculeinbothphysiologicalandpathologicalfunctions,includingpenile erections (Lundberg et al., 2008). In penile erections,NO is produced by two celltypes:neuroncells,inwhichnNOStriggerspenileerection,andvascularendothelialcells,inwhicheNOSplaysaroleinmaintainingpenileerection(ForstermannandSessa,2011).NOpenetratesintotargetcells,includingendothelialcellsandsmoothmusclecells,andactivatessolubleguanilylcyclase(sGC),whichstimulates thesynthesisof intracellularcGMPfromGTP within target cells, leading to smooth muscle relaxation. This cellular mechanism is balancedthroughthefunctionofthePDE5enzyme,whichisspecifictocGMP(Todaetal.,2005). Therefore, NO levels of the target organs; the activity of nNOS, eNOS, and/or sGC in thetargetcells;andrestorationofintracellularcGMPandPDE5enzymeinhibitionarepossibletherapeutictargetsforerectiledysfunctiontherapy(WilliamsandMelman,2012).Althoughmostphysiciansprefer inhibitingPDE5, incrementalmeasurementsofNOproductionandrelatedNOSenzymeactivity isanalternative therapeutic targetforEDtherapy.Anumberofnaturalproducts,includequercetin,resveratrol,andotherphenoliccompounds,havebeenreportedtohelptreatEDviatheupregulationoftheeNOSgene(BaurandSinclair,2006;SchmittandDirsch,2009;Zhangetal.,2015).SildenafilhasalsobeenreportedtoelevatetheexpressionoftheeNOSgeneinanin vitro study (Mammi et al., 2011). This information supportsactivatingorupregulatingtheeNOSgeneinEDtherapy. Mucuna pruriensseedextracthasbeenreported tobeeffective in improvingsexualbehaviorinanimalmodels(Sureshetal.,2009;Ketkaretal.,2011;SureshandPrakash,2012).However,theactivecompoundsandtheirmechanismsofactionareunclear.WecollectedM. pruriens seedsfromplantscultivatedinMaeTaengDistrict,ChiangMaiProvinceandobtainedextractsusingthepolaritygradientextractionmethodtodeterminetheactiveingredientsbypolarity. Ourresultsshowedthatthederivedsubstanceswerenotlikelytoprovideantioxidantproperties to the M. pruriens extract. The only hydrophobic substance we found wasγ-sitosterol[10],intheBuOHandwaterfractionsonly.YoshidaandNiki(2003)reportedontheantioxidantactivityofthisphytosterol.Surprisingly,L-DOPA,whichhasbeenobtainedfrom M. pruriens usingpolarsolvents,suchaswaterandethanol(Ketkaretal.,2011),wasnotdetected in any of the fractions of M. pruriensinourstudy;weconfirmedthisbycomparingour resultswith theGC/MSresults fromanL-DOPAstandard.Thisfinding indicated thattheremightbephytochemicalvariationsbetweenthecultivarusedinthisstudyandthoseusedinpreviousstudies. ThedifferencesthatexistamongthefractionscanbeclarifiedbythepolarsubstancesatpeaksdisplayedinthefrontregionoftheGCchromatogram.7,9-Di-tert-butyl-1-oxaspiro(4,5)deca-6,9-diene-2,8-dione[5],whichwasdistributedinalloftheM. pruriens fractions in our study,isalsofoundinotherplantswithantioxidantproperties(Sharifetal.,2015).Diethylphthalate[3]wasclearlyfoundintheindicatedregionofthehexaneandEtOACfractions.Protocatechuicacid,methylester[4]wasfoundinsmallamountsintheBuOHandthewaterfractions.Thisprotocatechuic acidderivativehasbeen reported tobe apotent antioxidant(KakkarandBais,2014),whichcould,eveninsmallquantities,provideantioxidantactivitytotheBuOHandwaterfractions.Sucrose[1]preferredthehydrophilicfraction,andwasthus

Page 12: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2)156

foundinsmallamountsintheBuOHfractionandwasobviouslyfoundinthewaterfraction.Interestingly, 2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol [2] was found only in the water fraction.2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenolhasbeenfoundinotherplantseedsandhasbeenreportedtopossesspotentantioxidantproperties(Kuschetal.,2011).Thisphenolicsubstancemightprovidepotentantioxidantactivitytothewaterfractionandoverpowerotherfractions.Asfewstudieshavefullyinvestigated2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol,itisofsignificantinteresttoinvestigatetheexactchemicalstructureofthesecompoundstoidentifythesubstancesandtomeasuretheirspecificbiologicalactivities. WeexaminedtheeffectsoftheM. pruriens seed extracts on three cell lines of interest overa24-hourperiodinordertorepresent,in vitro,theacuteeffectofthesesubstancesonthecells.TheMTTresultsshowedthatallcelllinessurvivedafterbeingtreatedwithappropriateconcentrations (50 µg/ml) of M. pruriens seed extracts for 24 hours. These results ensured the non-toxicityofthetestedextractsduringtheobservationperiod. Fromthein vitroresults,wesuggestedthatthemajoractionofSildenafilwastoinhibitthePDE5enzymeand to restore intracellularcGMPlevels. ItsactionasaPDE5 inhibitorsubsequentlyelevatedPDE5geneexpressioninHCT-15,whichrespondedtoahighlevelofcGMP.SildenafilmightalsoenhanceNOproductionthroughtheupregulationoftheeNOSgeneinEa.hy926cells,whichsubsequentlyincreasecGMPproductionandtheupregulationofthePDE5gene.AlthoughSildenafilstimulatedNOproductioninC6cells,thiseffectmightbemoreinvolvedwithiNOSgeneexpressionthanwiththenNOSgene. ThehighlypolarM. pruriensfractionsincreasedNOproductioninC6cells.Thewaterfractiondisplayed significantNOstimulation; thiswas clearly an effectof stimulating thenNOSgene.AccordingtotheGC/MSresult,thismightbedueto2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol[2],whichwasfoundonlyinthewaterfraction.TheabilityofthewaterfractiontoupregulatenNOSgeneexpressioninC6cellswaspromising,asitseffectwasstrongerthansildenafil.iNOSgeneexpressiongraduallyincreasedwhentreatmentwasappliedwithhigherpolar fractions.This resultsuggested that thesubstances found in thehighpolar fractions,includingsucrose [1],protocatechuicacid,methylester [4],andγ-sitosterol [10]mightbeinvolvedintheeffectontheiNOSgene. The same tendency was also found in Ea.hy926, in which the fractions with highpolaritypromotedNOproduction.Phytochemicalswithin thehighpolar fractions, sucrose[1],protocatechuicacid,methylester[4],andγ-sitosterol[10],mightstimulateeNOSgeneexpression.Diethylphthalate[3],whichwasfoundinthehexaneandBuOHfractions,mightbeinvolvedwiththiseffect,butalargequantityofthissubstancewasneededtostimulatetheexpression.Thisresultwassimilartotheeffectofpolyphenols,whichhasbeenpreviouslyreportedtostimulatetheexpressionoftheeNOSgene(Greseleaetal.,2011).Wesuggestedthatprotocatechuicacid,methylester[4]mightbeinvolvedwitheNOSgeneexpression,astheresponseoftheeNOSgenewascorrelatedtotheamountofthissubstancefoundintheBuOHandwater fractions. iNOSgeneexpressionwasconsiderablyelevatedwhen treatedwiththewaterfraction,whichindicatedtheeffectof2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol[2]onthe iNOS gene in endothelial cells. In HCT-15 cells, all M. pruriens seedfractionssignificantlymaintainedtheintracellularcGMPlevel,althoughSildenafil’seffectwassignificantlystronger.ThisresultshowedthatM. pruriens seed fractions stimulated the HCT-15 cells. Although the results demonstrated acorrespondenceofPDEgeneexpressionbetweentheSildenafil-treatedandwaterfraction-

Page 13: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 157

treatedgroups,furtherinvestigationoftheeffectoftheM. pruriens fraction on PDE5 activity isrequiredtofullyexplainitseffect.TheeffectoftheM. pruriensfractionsmightbeduetotheupregulationof the iNOSgene thatconsequentlypromotedNOproductionandcGMPsynthesis(Vaninietal.,2015).ThisupregulationofiNOSmightbetheeffectofhydrophiliccompounds in theM. pruriens extract, especially 2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol. Thisfinding indicated that M. pruriens seeds could stimulate the expression of NOS genes,especiallynNOS,whichhasbeen found todiminish inED (Dashwoodet al., 2016).Thisstudyhasshownthatsuchaneffectmightinvolvethepresenceof2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol[2]. Takentogether,ourresultsindicatedthattheactive,beneficialingredientspresentinM. pruriensseedsfortreatingerectiledysfunctionmightbethepolarcomponentsthathavethecapabilitytostimulateNOproductioninbothendothelialandneuroncells throughtheupregulationofNOSgenes. Thisstudyhadsomelimitations.WeonlyidentifiedthephytochemicalsusingtheNISTlibrarydatabase,whichmayhaveledtoinaccuracies.Thein vitro model was only tested for 24hours,whichwasnotlongenoughtodeterminethelong-termeffectsortoxicityofeachfraction.Inaddition,ourstudywasinvitroonly;furtherstudyofanimalmodelsarerequiredtoensurethepotencyoftheM. pruriens fraction in living creatures. To address these limiations, all active compounds found in theM. pruriens seeds extracts, especially in the water fraction, should be verified using further advancedidentificationtechniques,suchasnuclearmagneticresonancespectroscopy(NMR)orX-raycrystallography. Furthermore, prolonged in vitro experiments and in vivo studies of M. pruriensseedextractsshouldbeconductedtoconfirmtheeffectivenessandtoxicityofthesenaturalcompoundsbeforeconsideringtheiruseinhumans.

CONCLUSION

Of the active compounds in, the hydrophilic substances offered the most likelypotentialtoeffectivelytreatED.Theseincludedprotocatechuicacid,methyester,γ-sitosterol,andespecially2,4-bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)-phenol;thesewerepresentinthewaterfractionofthe M. pruriens extractobtainedfromthepolaritygradientextractionprocess.Theseactivecompounds displayed potent antioxidant activity and increasedNOproduction in neuronsand endothelial cells in vitroandwere likely involvedwith theupregulationofNOSgeneexpression.ThewaterfractionoftheM. pruriensseedextractwasmorepowerfulthanthepositive control, Sildenafil, at upregulating the expression of the nNOS gene in neurons,showingitspromiseasanaturalproductfortreatingerectiledysfunction.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The Thailand Excellence Center of Tissue Engineering and Stem Cells, FacultyofMedicine,ChiangMaiUniversity supported this research.We also thank theGraduateSchool,ChiangMaiUniversity,forprovidingacademicanddocumentationsupportandthe1stRegionalMedicalSciencesCenter,ChiangMaiforuseoftheGC/MSinstrument.

Page 14: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2)158

REFERENCES

Adebowale,Y.A.,Adeyemi,A.,andOshodi,A.A.2005.Variabilityinthephysicochemical,nutritionalandantinutritionalattributesofsixMucunaspecies.FoodChemistry.89:37–48.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2004.01.084

Andersson, K.E. 2011. Mechanisms of penile erection and basis for pharmacologicaltreatmentoferectiledysfunction.PharmacologicalReviews.63:811–859.https://doi.org/10.1124/pr.111.004515

Baur,J.A.,andSinclair,D.A.2006.Therapeuticpotentialofresveratrol:theinvivoevidence.NatureReview:DrugDiscovery.5:493-506.https://doi.org/10.1038/nrd2060

Both,S.,Everaerd,W.,Laan,E.,andGooren,L.2005.Effectofasingledoseoflevodopaonsexualresponseinmenandwomen.Neuropsychopharmacology.30:173–183.https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.npp.1300580

Bryan,N.S.,andGrisham,M.B.2007.Methodstodetectnitricoxideanditsmetabolitesinbiologicalsamples.FreeRadicalBiologyandMedicine.43(5):645-657.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.freeradbiomed.2007.04.026

Burnett, A.L. 2002. Nitric oxide regulation of penile erection: biology and therapeutic implications. Journal ofAndrology. 23(5): S20-S26. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1939- 4640.2002.tb02292.x

Chamsi-Pasha,H.2001.Sildenafil(Viagra)andtheheart.JournalofFamilyandCommunityMedicine.8(2):63-66.

Dashwood,M.R.,Crump,A.,Shi-Wen,X.,andLoesch,A.2016.IdentificationofneuronalNitricOxideSynthase(nNOS)inhumanpenis:apotentialroleofreducedneuronally-derived nitric oxide in erectile dysfunction. Current Pharmaceutical Biotechnology. 12(9):1316-1321.https://doi.org/10.2174/138920111798280965

Dean,R.C.,andLue,T.F.2005.Physiologyofpenileerectionandpathophysiologyoferectiledysfunction.TheUrologicClinicsofNorthAmerica.32(4):379-395.https://doi.org/ 10.1016/j.ucl.2005.08.007

Forstermann, U., and Sessa,W.C. 2011. Nitric oxide synthases: regulation and function.EuropeanHeartJournal.33(7):837a-837d.https://doi.org/10.1093/eurheartj/ehr304

Gratzke,C.,Angulo,J.,Chitaley,K.,Dai,Y.T.,Kim,N.N.,Paick,J.S.,SimonsenU.,Ückert,S.,Wespes,E.,Andersson,K.E.,etal.2010.Anatomy,physiology,andpathophysiologyoferectiledysfunction.JournalofSexualMedicine.7(1pt2):445-475.https://doi.org/ 10.1111/j.1743-6109.2009.01624.x

Greselea, P., Cerlettib, C., Guglielminia, G., Pignatellic, P., Gaetanob, G., and Violic, F.2011. Effects of resveratrol and other wine polyphenols on vascular function: anupdate. Journal ofNutritionalBiochemistry. 22: 201-211. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnutbio.2010.07.004

Jing,P.,Zhao,S.J.,Jian,W.J.,Qian,B.J.,Dong,Y.,andPang,J.2012.Quantitativestudiesonstructure-DPPH•scavengingactivityrelationshipsoffoodphenolicacids.Molecules.17:12910-12924.https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules171112910

Kakkar, S., and Bais, S. 2014.A review on protocatechuic acid and its pharmacologicalpotential. International Scholarly ResearchNotices: Pharmacology. 952943. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/952943

Page 15: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2) 159

Karunanithi, M., Raj, C.D., Jegadeesan, M., and Kavimani, S. 2012. Comparative GC-MS analysis and in vitro screening of four species of mucuna. Asian Journal ofPharmaceuticalandClinicalResearch.5(4):239-243.

Kavitha,C.,andThangamani,C.2014.Amazingbean“Mucuna pruriens”:Acomprehensivereview.JournalofMedicinalPlantsResearch.8(2):138-143.https://doi.org/10.5897/JMPR2013.5036

Ketkar, S., Gopu, C.L., Badgujar, L., Paradkar,A., and Mahadik, K. 2011. Male sexualbehaviour improving effect of lipid based extract of Mucuna pruriens in rats. Pharmacologyonline.1:1-14.

Kusch,P.,Deininger,S.,Specht,S.,Maniako,R.,Haubrich,S.,Pommerening,T.,Lin,P.K.,Hoerauf,A.,andKaiser,A.2011.In vitro and In vivo antimalarial activity assays of seeds from Balanites aegyptiaca:compoundsoftheextractshowgrowthinhibitionandactivityagainstplasmodialaminopeptidase.JournalofParasitologyResearch.368692.https://doi.org/10.1155/2011/368692

Lundberg, J.O., Weitzberg, E., and Gladwin, M.T. 2008. The nitrate–nitrite–nitric oxidepathwayinphysiologyandtherapeutics.NatureReview:DrugDiscovery.7:156-167.https://doi.org/10.1038/nrd2466

Majekodunmi,S.O.,Oyagbemi,A.A.,Umukoro,S., andOdeku,O.A.2011.Evaluationoftheanti-diabeticpropertiesofMucuna pruriensseedextract.AsianPacificJournalofTropicalMedicine.4(8):632-636.https://doi.org/10.1016/S1995-7645(11)60161-2

Mammi,C.,Pastore,D.,Lombardo,M.F.,Ferrelli,F.,Caprio,M.,Consoli,C.,TesauroM.,Gatta L., FiniM., FedericiM., et al. 2011. Sildenafil reduces insulin-resistance inhuman endothelial cells. PLoSONE. 6(1): e14542. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0014542

Mei,X.L.,Yang,Y., Zhang,Y.J., Li,Y., Zhao, J.M.,Qiu, J.G., Zhang,W.J., Jiang,Q.W.,Xue,Y.Q.,Zheng,D.W.,etal.2015.Sildenafilinhibitsthegrowthofhumancolorectalcancer in vitro and in vivo.AmericanJournalofCancerResearch.5(11):3311-3324.

NIH.1993.Consensusdevelopmentconferencestatement.Impotence.December7-9,1992.InternationalJournalofImpotenceResearch.5(4):181-284.

Prins,J.,Blanker,M.H.,Bohnen,A.M.,Thomas,S.,andBosch,J.L.H.R.2002.Prevalenceoferectiledysfunction:a systematic reviewofpopulation-basedstudies. InternationJournalofImpotenceResearch.14(6):422-432.https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.ijir.3900905

Pulikkalpura,H.,Kurup,R.,Mathew,P.J.,andBaby,S.2015.LevodopainMucuna pruriens anditsdegradation.ScientificReports.5(11078).https://doi.org/10.1038/srep11078

Sasidharan,S.,Chen,Y.,Saravanan,D.,Sundram,K.M.,andLatha,L.Y.2011.Extraction,isolation and characterization of bioactive compounds fromplants extracts.AfricanJournalofTraditionalComplementaryandAlternativeMedicines.8(1):1-10.

Schefe, J.H., Lehmann, K.E., Buschmann, I.R., Unger, T., and Funke-Kaiser, H. 2006.Quantitative real-timeRT-PCRdata analysis: current concepts and the novel “geneexpression’sCTdifference”formula.JournalofMolecularMedicine.84(11):901-10.https://doi.org/10.1007/s00109-006-0097-6

Schmitt,C.A.,andDirsch,V.M.2009.Modulationofendothelialnitricoxidebyplant-derivedproducts.NitricOxide.21:77–91.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.niox.2009.05.006

Page 16: In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens to Treat ... · 2018 172 145 In vitro Investigation of Mucuna pruriens Seed Extracts to Treat Erectile Dysfunction Natthachai Duangnin, Thanyaluck

CMU J. Nat. Sci. (2018) Vol. 17(2)160

Sharif,H.B.,Mukhtar,M.D.,Mustapha,Y.,andLawal,A.O.2015.Preliminaryinvestigationof bioactive compounds and bioautographic studies of whole plant extract ofEuphorbia pulcherrima on Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus, Salmonella typhi, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa.AdvancesinPharmaceutics.485469.https://doi.org/10.1155/2015/485469

Suresh, S., and Prakash, S. 2012. Effect ofMucuna pruriens (Linn.) on sexual behaviorandspermparametersinstreptozotocin-induceddiabeticmalerat.JournalofSexualMedicine.9:3066–3078.https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1743-6109.2010.01831.x

Suresh,S.,Prithiviraj,E.,andPrakash,S.2009.Dose-andtime-dependenteffectsofethanolicextract of Mucuna pruriensLinn.seedonsexualbehaviourofnormalmalerats.JournalofEthnopharmacology.122:497–501.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jep.2009.01.032

Toda, N., Ayajiki, K., and Okamura, T. 2005. Nitric oxide and penile erectile function.Pharmacology & Therapeutics. 106: 233–266. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pharmthera. 2004.11.011

Vanini,F.,Kashfi,K.,andNath,N.2015.ThedualroleofiNOSincancer.RedoxBiology.6:334-343.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.redox.2015.08.009

Williams, S.K., andMelman,A. 2012. Novel therapeutic targets for erectile dysfunction.Maturitas.71:20-27.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.maturitas.2011.11.004

Yoshida,Y.,andNiki,E.2003.Antioxidanteffectsofphytosterolanditscomponents.JournalofNutritionalScienceandVitaminology.49(4):277-280.

Zhang,Y.,Huang,C.,Liu,S.,Bai,J.,Fan,X.,Guo,J.,Jia,Y.,Zhang,Z.,Chen,X.,Jia,Y.,etal.2015.Effectsofquercetinonintracavernouspressureandexpressionofnitrogensynthase isoforms inarterialerectiledysfunction ratmodel. International JournalofClinicalandExperimentalMedicine.8(5):7599-7605.