69
IeMRC Flagship Project: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics Power Electronics

IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

IeMRC Flagship Project:IeMRC Flagship Project: Power ElectronicsPower Electronics

Page 2: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

OverviewOverview

Introduction to power electronics•

Overview of IeMRC activities in power electronics

Flagship project in power electronics•

Industrial perspective

Summary

Page 3: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

What Does Power Electronics Do?What Does Power Electronics Do?

Efficient, flexible control and conversion of electrical energy

AC DC

DCAC

Typically involves change of voltage level and/or frequency•

Characterised by 4 processes

AC sources: single phase or three phase AC e.g. from AC generators

DC sources: batteries, solar panel, power supply output

Rectification

Inversion

AC-AC conversion

DC loads: electrical/electronic circuits, machines, industrial processes

AC loads: machines, industrial processes, power transmission and distribution systems

DC-DC conversion

Page 4: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Why Power Electronics?Why Power Electronics?

Enabling technology throughout the energy supply chain

Primary energy extraction &

transport

Energy conversion & concentration

Energy transmission

and distribution

Energy delivery

Electricity39%

Transport21%

Other40%

IT14%

Lighting19%

HVAC16%

Motion51%

Heat

Work

~16,000 TWh/annum global electricity

Page 5: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Benefits of Power ElectronicsBenefits of Power Electronics

Energy saving •

Cost and space saving

Reduced maintenance•

Improved reliability

Sustainability Supply security

Energy Efficiency

Productivity Quality of life

Longer life•

Better performance

Better control•

Flexibility

Low environmental impact

Page 6: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Power Electronics ApplicationsPower Electronics Applications

1 cm1 W

200 m2 GW

Power

electronics

inside

Page 7: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

What is Driving Future Power Electronics?What is Driving Future Power Electronics?

Electrical power increasingly adopted as an energy delivery medium: emission free at point of use–

Transport applications: rail traction, automotive (HEV and EV) and aerospace electronic systems

High efficiency electric drives in industrial applications and HVAC

Increased use of power electronics in transmission and distribution systems–

Renewable energy sources (PV, wind, wave etc.) require power electronics based interfaces

Distributed generation requires control based on power electronics

Lightweight, efficient, high performance products such as mobile computing, home entertainment and power tools

Power electronics holds the key to projected annual global energy savings of around 1000 TWh or 1 G tonne CO2 by 2020: equivalent to 50 large coal-fired power stations

Page 8: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Common ThemesCommon Themes

Increased power densities•

Lower electromagnetic emissions

Extreme operating environments

Plug-and-go systems•

Higher levels of integration

Lower cost

Page 9: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Why Manufacture Power Electronics Why Manufacture Power Electronics in the UK?in the UK?

UK based technology and manufacturing capability is currently relatively strong

UK is internationally competitive across the whole supply chain

Many systems are application specific, highly customised and tend to have a relatively high added value

Suited to a technologically advanced manufacturing base and can absorb the relatively high UK labour costs

Page 10: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

WhatWhat’’s in a Power Electronic System?s in a Power Electronic System?

SA+

SA-

DA+

DA-

PA

600

V

CDC20μF, 1000V

PB

PC

Half-bridge sandwich (one per phase)

GDUA GDUB GDUC

DC+

DC-

Passive components

Gate drives and control

Power semiconductor

module

Thermal management

Page 11: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Power Electronic Performance LimitationsPower Electronic Performance Limitations

Packaging–

Thermal cycling (reliability)

Power density (thermal management, reliability)–

Environmental (extreme environments)

Passive devices–

Capacitors have limited temperature range (electrolytic ~105°C, ceramic ~150°C)

Semiconductor devices–

Silicon max. power device die temperatures from 125°C to 200°C

Page 12: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

IeMRC Projects in Power ElectronicsIeMRC Projects in Power Electronics

Aim:Enhance competitiveness of the UK power electronics industry through improvements to the design and manufacturing capability for high power density systems and in particular those intended for high reliability applications and challenging environments.

Technology Drivers

Technology Limiters

Technology Opportunities

Market/customer Aspirations

Research & Development Requirements

Page 13: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

IeMRC Power Electronics ClusterIeMRC Power Electronics Cluster

Design for qualification

Advanced packaging

Flagship Project

DTI-funded research into improved bonding technology (IMPECT & NEWTON)

EPSRC-funded research in SiC: Platform grant & responsive mode

DTI-funded programmes in power electronics (TULIP & PEATE)

Power electronics roadmap

DTI-funded research into modelling of power modules (MPM)

Other IeMRC projects onAdvanced Capacitors, Prognostics & Diagnostics

EU-funded research within MOET project

Reliability and Physics of Failure

IeMRC SiP Design

EPSRC Grand Challenge:

3-D Mintegration

Cluster approach maximises gearing and mutual coupling between projects

Page 14: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Flagship Project in Power ElectronicsFlagship Project in Power Electronics

Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance–

Road mapping

Reliability (understanding, physics of failure models for components, interconnect etc.)

Partial discharge effects in power electronics–

Thermal management (enhanced passive and active methods)

Advanced materials and assembly methods–

Capacitor technologies

Programme started 1st July 2005•

Duration 42 months

Total IeMRC funding £811 k, 5 directly-funded academic partners, 11 industrial partners

Page 15: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Academic PartnersAcademic Partners

power electronics, module design and failure analysis

point analysis tools, physics-of- failure reliability predictions, multi-physics modelling and numerical optimisation

partial discharge effects high-permittivity

dielectrics and Silicon Carbide device fabrication

heat transfer and thermal management

metallography and microscopy

wire bonding

Page 16: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Industrial PartnersIndustrial Partners

Dynex Semiconductor•

Goodrich

International Rectifier•

Morgan Technical Ceramics

QinetiQ•

Raytheon Systems

Rolls-Royce•

SELEX

Semelab•

SR-Drives

TRW Automotive

Page 17: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Road MappingRoad Mapping

Page 18: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Road MappingRoad Mapping•

Experience gained and techniques for data capture developed and refined

Face to face meetings are good for engaging attention and maximising return on time invested

On-line meetings/surveys potentially useful but forms etc. must be carefully designed

General data collection templates offer greatest flexibility but encounter greatest user resistance–

Big differences between user interaction with “paper” and “computer-based” implementations

Structured questionnaires useful for known issues/topics but poor at collecting “strategic” thoughts

Leaving people to complete “in their own time” does not work well:–

Always something more important to do!

Need to assess “company confidential” information

Page 19: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Road Mapping Workshop 31Road Mapping Workshop 31stst OctoberOctober

Joint event by Electronics Enabled Products KTN and IeMRC•

To be held 31st October 2007 at PERA, Melton Mowbray

Theme is “Power Electronics: Energy Management for the 21st Century”

Aim is to identify barriers and limitations in current technologies and provide priorities for future work.

Internally, the EEP KTN and IeMRC will use the output from the roadmap to:–

Provide input into other technology strategy documents.

Help define Technology Watch reports–

Guide the technical areas supported by EPSRC Industrial CASE and other studentship allocations.

Define call areas for SPARK awards.•

Externally, we will present these challenges as the voice from our community and to stimulate support measures for them from the Technology Strategy Board and the Research Councils.

Page 20: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Reliability and Physics of FailureReliability and Physics of Failure

Page 21: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Power Electronic ModulesPower Electronic Modules

Physical containment for one or more basic component building blocks e.g. semiconductor dies, resistors, (capacitors, inductors)

Can include control and protection functions•

Protection from environment e.g. ingress of liquids, dust etc.

Circuit interconnections (internal and external)•

Electromagnetic management – EMC issues

Thermal Management

Semiconductor dies

Passive components

Power Module

Page 22: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

HeatsinkThermal GreaseCopper baseplate

Anatomy of Typical Package and Anatomy of Typical Package and HeatsinkHeatsink

SolderDirect bonded copperCeramicDirect bonded copper

Lead-out interconnect

SolderDieBond wire

EncapsulationHousing

Thermal stack has 9 layers, 8 interfaces!

Page 23: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Thermal Cycling LimitationsThermal Cycling Limitations

Copper baseplateSolderDirect bonded copperCeramicDirect bonded copperSolderDieBond wire

CTE mismatch causes fatigue failure (de-bonding) at heel

CTE mismatch causes fatigue failure at interfaces

Repeated heating and cooling of assembly leads to repetitive mechanical stress and eventual failure

Page 24: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Combined Modelling and Accelerated Life Testing carried out by academic and industrial partners

Identify Root Cause (Physics) of Failures•

Develop Physics of Failure models

Apply validated models to–

assess design options (MPM project)

prognostics and health management (IeMRC prognostics and diagnostics project)

Reliability and Physics of FailureReliability and Physics of Failure

0.1

1.0

10.0

100.0

1000.0

10000.0

10 100 1000

delta T (K)

Thou

sand

s of

Cyc

les

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

num

ber o

f cyc

les

to fa

ilure

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

substrate tile number

-60 to 150 C air-to-air

-60 to 150 C

No failure

K

ref

M

refref T

TTTNN

−−

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

ΔΔ

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛= 11

1

Page 25: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Experimental Reliability ProgrammeExperimental Reliability ProgrammeReliability issue Coupon designations

Die issues high temp metallization,metal stack

Wire bond lift-off through thermal cycling, corrosion

W1, W2, W3, W4, W5, W6, W7, W8, W9, W10, H1

Solder die attach high temp failure, thermal cyclingincreased Rth

W1, S1, S2

Substrate Thermal cycling, delamination, cracking

T1, T2, T3

Partial discharge Substrate, encapsulation, frequency dependence

Housing plastic degradation

Encapsulation temperaturemoisture

Substrate mount down Thermal cycling, increased Rth M1Bus-bars thermal cycling B1Baseplate-heatsink degradation in Rth

Whole module plus decoupling caps

bench-marking of different modules types

Huge number of experiments required•

Time and resource hungry

Page 26: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Wire bond reliabilityWire bond reliability

Large number of experiments underway–

Standard production using 2 types of wire and 4 thermal cycling ranges (different ΔT and mean T)

Enhanced bonding concepts (see poster from Wei-Sun Loh):

High temperature bonding•

Post annealing

Effect of overlayer

metal thickness•

Ribbon bonding

Resistance to thermal cycling is main concern•

Gather data to guide physics of failure model

Assessment by bond shear strength and cross- sectional analysis including micro-structure (see poster from Simon Hogg)

Page 27: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

High Temperature WearHigh Temperature Wear--OutOut

Conventional models (e.g. Coffin Manson) predict reduced life with increased mean temperature and temperature range

Experimental results show that higher ΔT does not always give reduced life

Fastest degradation for lowest maximum temperature •

Evidence of annealing at highest temperatures?

Further cycling and microstructural studies ongoing

min max delta mean

-55 125 180 35

-35 145 180 55

-40 190 230 75

-60 170 230 55

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

49s -55+125

49s -35+145

49s -40+190

49s -60+170

K

ref

M

refref T

TTTNN

−−

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

ΔΔ

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛= 11

1

High ΔT

Low ΔT

Page 28: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Physics of Failure - Greenwich

Page 29: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

#1: Wire Bond Interconnect Design

Al-wire

Si

Al metallization

Al layer thickness:–

ranges from 5 to 25μm

Thermally Cycled•

Stress concentrated at interface

Stress distribution Plastic Strain distribution

Page 30: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Al thickness 5 10 15 25

Plastic strain 0.044 0.035 0.032 0.029

0.025

0.027

0.029

0.031

0.033

0.035

0.037

0.039

0.041

0.043

0.045

5 10 15 25

Al thickness

plas

tic s

train

Strain distribution. Al thickness=5μm

Al thickness has a significant effect on the plastic strain in Al metallization.

#1: Wire Bond Interconnect DesignImpact of Al Metallisation thickness on Damage

Page 31: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

#2: The Effect of Dimples on the Isolation Substrate Reliability

Curamik Test Results

W/WO Dimples

Page 32: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

#2: The Effect of Dimples on the Isolation Substrate Reliability

Cu thickness(T2) 0.3

AlN thickness(T1) 0.25

Dimple depth 0.24

Pitch 0.45

tile dimension 7.8x3.3

Edge distance (E) 0.5

dimensions

Single conductor on top side•

Stresses Analysis –

With Dimples

Without Dimples•

Impact on Reliability

Dimple shape

Symmetry leads to ¼

model Thermal load dT=230°C

The mesh

Page 33: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

#2: The Effect of Dimples on the Isolation Substrate Reliability

With Dimples

No dimple

Average in a 40μm layer of ceramic

Maximum absolute stress value decreased by about 20%

Page 34: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Solder Joints Lifetime Prediction•

Solder joint failure is one the major failure mechanisms

Three types of solder joints are investigated–

A: Substrate solder joint

B: Chip mount-down solder joint–

C: Busbar

solder joint

B

A

C

Page 35: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Lifetime Model for Solder Interconnect

Solder joints are thermal cycled–

crack length L after N cycles

Experiments–

Different solder joint geometry + Load Profiles give different L/N values

Simulations–

Run under the same conditions

Predict Plastic strain per cycle ∆εp

.•

Lifetime Model

( )bpL

L aN

ε= Δ

crack

Cycles NCra

ck le

ngth

L Test 1 Test 2

Test N

Test i

Test NoD

amag

e ∆ε

p

Test 1

Test 2Test i

Test N

Lifetime model

L is in mm

Calculate L

LN

Page 36: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Lifetime Model of SnAg Solder

( )1.0230.00562 p

L

LN

ε= Δ

By using the experimental lifetime data and the modelled damage distribution under the same test conditions, an empirical

lifetime model can be derived.

This model has been used in railway traction control lifetime prediction

Page 37: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Railway Traction Control Application

Extreme conditions–

Temperature Moisture

Vibration High power

Page 38: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Traction Control Mission Profiles

Status Tmin Tmax Cycles/day

Shed stops -40°C +80°C 1

Station Stops +80°C +100°C 1080

Cruise +80°C +81°C 6E6

Status Tmin Tmax Cycles/day

Shed stops -40°C +80°C 1

Station Stops +80°C +100°C 20

Speed Control +80°C +85°C 3240

Cruise +80°C +81°C 6E6

Traction Application: High Speed.

Traction Application: Mass TransitThere are 4 unique load profiles

Shed stop:

over night storage in extremely cold environment

Station stops:

stop at station during service

Speed control:

action of the automated speed control system

Cruise:

Power ripples when trains are running.

Failure definition:

crack length= 2.8mm, this is equivalent to about 20% area crack.

Page 39: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Traction Control PEM Lifetime prediction

SolderThickness shed speed Station

0.1 mm 6.94E+03 1.25E+09 2.24E+05

0.2 mm 8.26E+03 1.50E+09 2.64E+05

0.3 mm 8.99E+03 1.61E+09 2.84E+05

Predicted lifetime for each single load temperature profile.

solder thickness high speed (years) mass transit (years)

0.1 mm 11.61 0.55

0.2 mm 13.76 0.65

0.3 mm 14.93 0.70

Calculated lifetime for railway traction control applications

High speed Application > Mass Transit–

because of the number of station stops.

Solder thickness has significant impact.

y = 3.0306Ln(x) + 18.601

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3solder thickness (mm)

Life

time

(yea

rs)

Page 40: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

05 September 2007 The 2nd Annual IeMRC Conference

Conclusions•

Conclusions–

Reliability (PoF)

Design Rules•

Linked Projects–

Dti: Design Environment for PEM’s

PoF

Models•

Uncertainty Analysis

Risk Assessment/Mitigation

IeMRC: Prognostics•

In-line monitoring

PoF

Based•

Bayesian Analysis

Page 41: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Partial Discharge In Power ElectronicsPartial Discharge In Power Electronics

Ian Cotton, Ningyan Wang, Mike BarnesUniversity of Manchester

Page 42: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Partial Discharge In Power ElectronicsPartial Discharge In Power Electronics

Power electronics operating at high voltages can generate partial discharges, small sparks that do not completely bridge the gap between electrodes

Over time, the cumulative effect of partial discharges can cause insulation to fail.–

In some insulation systems such as paper-oil, times to failure of thousands of hours are common

In some tests of power electronic modules, times to failure of a few minutes have been observed

Qualification testing on production can detect partial discharge during manufacture but this can lead to high rejection rates

Page 43: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Work Package FocusWork Package Focus

This work package has focused on:

Understanding the weak points of a power electronic module in terms of the areas where partial discharge form

Developing an understanding of the impact of material ageing and environmental conditions on PD activity

Developing a solution to improve yields of high voltage power electronic devices

Producing a physics of failure model

Page 44: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

GelGel--Substrate Interface TestingSubstrate Interface Testing

The weakest area of a power electronic module has been shown to the interface between the substrate and the gel at the edge of the substrate metallisation.

This is the location of the highest electric field in the module as shown by the red/yellow colours in the FEA plot

Page 45: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

GelGel--Substrate Interface TestingSubstrate Interface Testing

The picture below shows a substrate under test. The pattern of the metallisation can be seen. The two bright areas circled are partial discharge as seen by the night vision camera. These would cause failure within a maximum of tens of minutes.

Page 46: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Current WorkCurrent Work

Ageing tests are underway to thermally cycle test samples in humid and dry conditions.–

Initial results from the samples cycled in dry conditions show that gels are stable but there is some degradation in performance of gel-substrate interfaces once cycled

Based on literature from other researchers, it is thought that humid conditions will show higher levels of degradation

A solution to the problem of high levels of partial discharge at the edges of the substrate has been proposed and will shortly undergo production trials to confirm if laboratory work shows promise in a manufacturing environment

Page 47: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Thermal ManagementThermal Management

Rob SkuriatTom Povey

University of Oxford

Page 48: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Current ResearchCurrent Research

Passive Cooling–

Closed Loop Pulsating Heat Pipes

Active Cooling–

Jet impingement

Baseplate•

Directly onto substrate tile

Turbulator induced vortex cooling•

Cooler efficiency–

Complete system

Page 49: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Thermal Management OptionsThermal Management Options

Target overall reductions in weight and volume for liquid-cooled systems

Comparison of cooler options:–

Conventional base-plate and separate cooler

Integrated base-plate cooler–

Direct cooler (no base-plate)

Base-plate (1-3mm)

Cold plate Integrated base-plate cooler Direct substrate cooler

9 layers8 interfaces

7 layers6 interfaces

5 layers4 interfaces

Page 50: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Theoretical Performance ComparisonTheoretical Performance Comparison

Comparison based on an IGBT switch of 4 parallel 13mm x 13mm dies on a 34mm x 56mm substrate (400A, 1200V)

For base-plate designs the area is 53mm x 60mm•

Figure of Merit (FoM) = 1/(Rth x weight)

Other factors e.g. cost, Si area not considered

Option Cooling MethodLayers, Interfaces

Rth

(K/W) @ h=20kW/m^

2K

Relative FoM

Base-line (separate cooler) Indirect cold-plate 9, 8 0.139 1.0Cu BP, alumina 0.2/0.3/0.2 Integrated base-plate 7, 6 0.084 3.3Cu-alumina 0.2/0.3/0.2 Direct substrate 5, 4 0.083 8.9

Page 51: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Impingement CoolingImpingement Cooling

Impingement cells with array of holes <1mm diameter

6 x 8 arrangement of jets within a cell•

Cells arranged in a serpentine pattern

Spray water jets onto flat surface•

Jet impingement reduces thermal gradient and thermal resistance

Heat transfer coefficient increases

Heat-exchanger

Substrate tileDies

Page 52: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Impingement CoolingImpingement Cooling

Baseplate cooler manufactured in Stainless Steel (17-4 PH SS) using the Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS) rapid prototyping process

Grooves machined into the baseplate to improve sealing between adjacent cooling cells

Cooler mounts directly onto the baseplate

Page 53: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Direct CoolingDirect Cooling

Cool back of substrates directly

No baseplate required–

Reduces thermal resistance path

Reduced mechanical stress on components induced by difference in CTE between DBC components and baseplate

Reduced total system mass

Page 54: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

High Temperature Metal-Insulator-Metal Capacitor for Power Electronics

Bing Miao, Alton Horsfall, Nick Wright

Newcastle University

Page 55: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

High temperature MIM CapacitorsHigh temperature MIM Capacitors

Disadvantages of conventional discrete surface mount capacitors-

significant parasitic inductance

-

large area•

Advantages of MIM capacitors developed on sapphire substrate-

placed inside the power package

-

low parasitic inductance-

less space

-

multiplied

blocking voltage

with the multilayer process

Page 56: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Capacitor Structure Capacitor Structure

Sapphire

100nm Al35nm HfO2

65nm Pt5nm Ti

Single layer structure for high temperature MIM capacitor on sapphire substrate.

Page 57: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

CC--V Characteristics of CapacitorV Characteristics of Capacitor

-4 -3 -2 -1 -0 1 2 3 4Bias (V)

480500520540560580600620640660680700

Cap

acita

nce

(pF)

1 MHz100 kHz10 kHz

Capacitance density as a function of voltage at 3 different frequencies. The capacitance density at zero bias ranges from 476 to 638 nF/cm2, measured at 1M, 100k and 10k respectively.

0 50 100 150 200 250 300Temperature (oC)

380

400

420

440

460

480

500

520

540

560

Cap

acita

nce

Den

sity

(A c

m-2

)Capacitance density as a function of temperature, ranging from 458 nF/cm2 at room temperature to 662 nF/cm2 at 300 Celsius.

Page 58: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

II--V characteristics of capacitorV characteristics of capacitor

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8Bias (V)

10-7

10-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

100

101

102

Leak

age

CU

rren

t Den

sity

(A c

m-2

)

50oC100oC200oC250oC300oC

10 60 110 160 210 260 310Temperature (oC)

7

8

9

10

11

12

Brea

kdow

n Vo

ltage

(V)

Leakage current density as a function of applied voltage measured up to 300 Celsius.

Breakdown voltage as a function of temperature measured up to 300 Celsius. The blocking voltages are 12 Volts at room temperature and 8.3 Volts at 300 Celsius.

Page 59: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Future planFuture plan

Step 1: Fabrication of single-layer capacitor with larger size to achieve larger capacitance value.

Step 2: Fabrication of capacitor directly to one side of sapphire substrate to reduce connection inductance.

Step 3: Fabrication of dual layer capacitor on sapphire substrate to increase blocking voltage.

Bottom electrode: 65nm Pt

35nm HfO2

Top electrode: 100nm Al Diode

Capacitor

200nm Au

JFETTop electrode: 100nm Al

Bottom electrode: 65nm Pt

35nm HfO2

Based on the fabrication of the capacitors with small size on sapphire substrate:

Page 60: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Industrial PerspectiveIndustrial Perspective

Paul TaylorDynex Semiconductor Ltd

Page 61: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Dynex Semiconductor LtdDynex Semiconductor Ltd•• Dynex designs and manufactures Dynex designs and manufactures

high power and high reliability high power and high reliability electronic semiconductor electronic semiconductor components.components.

•• Semiconductor production started in Semiconductor production started in Lincoln England in 1957 Lincoln England in 1957

•• Prior trade names:Prior trade names: AEI Semiconductors Ltd : AEI Semiconductors Ltd : AEIAEI Marconi Electronic Devices Ltd: Marconi Electronic Devices Ltd: MEDLMEDL GECGEC--Plessey Semiconductors Ltd: Plessey Semiconductors Ltd:

GPSGPS

•• Turnover Turnover 2005: 2005: ££10.3m10.3m2006: 2006: ££11.3m11.3m2007 plan: 2007 plan: ££13.5m13.5m

•• 220 employees220 employees•• ISO9001 & ISO14001 approvedISO9001 & ISO14001 approved

•• Subsidiary of Dynex Power IncSubsidiary of Dynex Power Inc

–– Ticker symbol DNX on TSX Ticker symbol DNX on TSX Venture ExchangeVenture Exchange

–– More at More at www.dynexsemi.comwww.dynexsemi.com

Page 62: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Four Product GroupsFour Product Groups

•• Integrated circuits , siliconIntegrated circuits , silicon--onon--sapphiresapphire•• Dynex manufactures and supplies radiation tolerant Dynex manufactures and supplies radiation tolerant

integrated circuits to the nuclear and space industry integrated circuits to the nuclear and space industry based on well proven GEC based on well proven GEC --Marconi technology.Marconi technology.

• Power electronic assemblies• Design, build and refurbishment of high power

electronic assemblies. Sub-contract build and test of very sophisticated sub-assemblies for our major Projects Customers.

• Power IGBT and diode modules to 3,600A & 6,500V• Specialising in the high voltage power market: e.g.

industrial drives, renewable energy, marine drives, aircraft, electric vehicle and rail transport. & next generation T&D

• Power bipolar devices to 11,000A & 8,500V• Thyristors, GTOS and diodes for high-power

applications (>100kW) for electric utilities, rail transport, marine drives, industrial processing drives and power supplies

•• Power IGBT and diode modules to 3,600A & 6,500VPower IGBT and diode modules to 3,600A & 6,500V•• Specialising in the high voltage power market: e.g. Specialising in the high voltage power market: e.g.

industrial drives, renewable energy, marine drives, industrial drives, renewable energy, marine drives, aircraft, electric vehicle and rail transport. & next aircraft, electric vehicle and rail transport. & next generation T&Dgeneration T&D

Page 63: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Power ModulesPower Modules

Demand for Power Demand for Power Modules is forecast to Modules is forecast to grow above 15% per year grow above 15% per year over the next five years over the next five years driven bydriven by

Energy SavingsEnergy Savings Electric Vehicles, andElectric Vehicles, and Renewable Energy.Renewable Energy.

Page 64: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Dynex Letter of Support for the ProjectDynex Letter of Support for the Project

……………….. our UK and overseas customers look for .. our UK and overseas customers look for suppliers with access to leading edge technology suppliers with access to leading edge technology and therefore we continually seek opportunities for and therefore we continually seek opportunities for collaborative R&D.collaborative R&D.

Access to overseas R&D can be difficult due to local Access to overseas R&D can be difficult due to local alliances between industry and academia, and so as alliances between industry and academia, and so as a UK based manufacturing facility we are highly a UK based manufacturing facility we are highly dependent on the UK to generate our new dependent on the UK to generate our new technologies. In particular we welcome the focus of technologies. In particular we welcome the focus of the proposed Flagship Project on [module] the proposed Flagship Project on [module] packaging, reliabilitypackaging, reliability……..

Page 65: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Flagship alignment to Dynex interestFlagship alignment to Dynex interest•• The Project contains four Work packages. These are all of The Project contains four Work packages. These are all of

relevance to Dynexrelevance to Dynex–– WP1. Roadmap for Power Electronic ModulesWP1. Roadmap for Power Electronic Modules–– WP2. Power Module Technology QualificationWP2. Power Module Technology Qualification–– WP3. Design for QualificationWP3. Design for Qualification–– WP4. Advanced Manufacturing TechnologiesWP4. Advanced Manufacturing Technologies

•• We have seen the most benefit from the 3rd work package , and We have seen the most benefit from the 3rd work package , and the least from WP1 and WP2the least from WP1 and WP2

•• WP3 is most strongly aligned with our other Projects on power WP3 is most strongly aligned with our other Projects on power module reliability and with our business objectivesmodule reliability and with our business objectives

•• We aim to give a rapid response to our customers when assessing We aim to give a rapid response to our customers when assessing the reliability & life of our power electronic products under ththe reliability & life of our power electronic products under their eir application conditions.application conditions.

•• On reaching its goal, we are looking forOn reaching its goal, we are looking for–– Acceleration curves for reliability assessmentAcceleration curves for reliability assessment–– An understanding of physics of failureAn understanding of physics of failure–– Better design guidelines and the effects of changing materialsBetter design guidelines and the effects of changing materials–– Ultimately, reliability models to replace time consuming testingUltimately, reliability models to replace time consuming testing

Page 66: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

SummarySummary•• The flagship is building a solid platform and a focus for power The flagship is building a solid platform and a focus for power

module manufacturing researchmodule manufacturing research

•• Well aligned to UK Industrial Products & Market ApplicationsWell aligned to UK Industrial Products & Market Applications

•• Increasing the understanding of power module requirements Increasing the understanding of power module requirements

across UK academia, and enhancing R&D networksacross UK academia, and enhancing R&D networks

•• Linked to other EPSRC and DTI projectsLinked to other EPSRC and DTI projects

•• Linked to Dynex PV R&D projects and manufacturing Linked to Dynex PV R&D projects and manufacturing

developmentsdevelopments

•• Physics of Failure work is critically important, but may need Physics of Failure work is critically important, but may need

more time to reach a useful conclusionmore time to reach a useful conclusion

Page 67: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

SummarySummary

IeMRC Flagship project now well established with a comprehensive research programme

Excellent working relationship with industrial partners•

A power electronics cluster has been formed around the flagship with total funding exceeding £9 M

Project results show substantial potential benefit to UK power electronics manufacturing

Experimental reliability programme is revealing gaps in current knowledge

Ambition of integrated reliability-based design and health management will require expanded programme

Page 68: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements

Paul Taylor, David Newcombe, Kim Evans

Chris Bailey, Tim Tilford, Hua Lu

Simon Hogg

Ian Cotton, Ningyan Wang, Mike Barnes

Bing Miao, Alton Horsfall, Nick Wright

Mark Johnson, Cyril Buttay, Pearl Agyakwa

Rob Skuriat, Tom Povey

Wei-Sun Loh, Martin Corfield

Page 69: IeMRC Flagship Project: Power Electronics · Flagship Project in Power Electronics • Investigate technologies and techniques to improve power module performance – Road mapping

Diary DateDiary Date

Power Electronics Road Mapping Event•

Wednesday 31st October 2007

PERA Melton Mowbray•

Further information:

www.technologywatch.org.uk/EEP_KTN_RSS/news.html

Registration:

www.technologywatch.org.uk/Forms/EEPworkshop.html