Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
h"p://www.molso,.com/images/icm/image036.jpg
“Tounderstandasystem,youneedtoperturbit.”
MoleculargeneCcstechniquesMutaConsKnock‐outsKnock‐insRNAiSmallmolecules
ChemicalgeneCcs
TheuseofsmallmoleculestomodulatespecificfuncConsofaprotein
h"p://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glivec
Ex:ImaCnib(Gleevec)
InhibitsreceptortyrosinekinaseacCvityofbcr‐ablfusiongene
AdvantagesofchemicalgeneCcs
PerturbspecificfuncConsoftargetprotein
Temporalcontrol
Reversible
Drugdevelopment
Twomethodsofsmallmoleculescreening
ExperimentalscreeningBindingandphenotypeassaysTime‐consuming,expensive
Structure‐basedvirtualscreeningComputerprogramsesCmatebindingmatchesLowsuccessrate
BothrequirecharacterizaConofproteinclasses
Chemicallibraries
Diversity‐orientedlibrariesMoleculesdonotcloselyresembleeachother
FocusedlibrariesSimilarcoretomolecules
TwoapproachesarecomplementaryStockwell.Nature432,846‐854,2004
Howdowedefinediversity?
Differencesinchemicalstructure
DifferencesinbiologicalacCvity
WhichismoreusefulforchemicalgeneCcsstudies?
Stockwell.Nature432,846‐854,2004
Hu,et al.Nature Reviews Cancer 7,23‐24,2007
Methodsofexperimentalscreening
Protein‐bindingassaysProtein+moleculeinteracConbiologicalacCvity
“ReversechemicalgeneCcs”
PhenotypicacCvityassaysMolecule+organismphenotypeprotein
“ForwardchemicalgeneCcs”
Protein‐bindingassays
LabeledFluorescenceorradioacCvityHighthroughputTimeconsumingLabelinterference
UnlabeledLowthroughputMoreprotein/moleculetouseCosteffecCve
Labeledprotein‐bindingassays
Smallmoleculemicroarray
Findtargetmoleculeforaspecificprotein
Testthousandsofcompounds
Stockwell.Nature432,846‐854,2004
Labeledprotein‐bindingassays
Proteinmicroarray
Findwhichproteinsamoleculewillbind
Stockwell.Nature432,846‐854,2004
Labeledprotein‐bindingassays
DNAexpressionplasmidarrays
Chiphasplasmidsthataretakenupbyplatedcells
Testsbindingofmoleculeinalivecell(physiological)
Stockwell.Nature432,846‐854,2004
Labeledprotein‐bindingassays
Threehybridsystem
Bindingofcompoundtoproteinallowsexpressionofareportergene
Stockwell.Nature432,846‐854,2004
Unlabeledprotein‐bindingassays
Surfaceplasmonresonance
Similartosmallmoleculemicroarray,butmeasurerefracCvityofsurface
Stockwell.Nature432,846‐854,2004
PhenotypicacCvity
Characterizedbasedon:
Cellularphenotype
Organismalphenotype
PhenotypicacCvityassays
Lowthroughput*Mostmustbecalculatedbyhand*ThereareexcepCons
MicroarraysalsousedExaminephenotypicspecificgeneexpression
Stockwell.Nature432,846‐854,2004
PhenotypeacCvityassays
ImagingAutomatedmicroscopes
RNAandproteinexpressionMaybeadvantageousoverDNAmicroarraydataforspecificproteins
Tendstobeashi,towardslessbiasedtechniques
Lackofspecificity—problems
Toxicity
Confoundingresults
Unexpectedresults
Dose‐dependenteffects
Lackofspecificity—soluCons
Useofpotentchemicals
Runlargescaleprotein‐bindingassays
ComplementresultswithRNAitechniques
Useseveralsmallmoleculeswithredundancy
StudyeachmoleculeatarangeofconcentraCons
Goal:UsesmallmoleculeandRNAitechniquestoidenCfyproteinsimportantincytokinesisusingDrosophila
Screens
RNAi19,470dsRNAsscreenedintriplicate
Smallmolecule51,000moleculesscreened(intriplicate?)
QuanCficaConbyautomatedfluorescencemicroscopyforbinucleatecellsDouble‐checkedvisually
Smallmoleculescreen
25compoundsidenCfiedasmostpotentBinucleines1‐25
TestedagainatvaryingconcentraConsIniCalscreenat25μM
100μM30μM10μM
Eggert,et al.PLoS Biology 2(12),2135‐43,2004
Smallmoleculescreen
Alsotestedbinucleines1‐25inothercellsHeLa 16/25(64%)BSC‐1 13/25(52%)S. cerevisiae 12/25(48%)
TestedeffectsonacCnpolymerizaConInhibiConbybinucleines4,6,24,and25Binucleines24and25werecontrolsknowntodisruptmicrofilamentpolymerizaCon
RNAiscreen214genesfoundEffectswereweakeroverallthanthesmallmolecules
Onenewgenefound
Eggert,et al.PLoS Biology 2(12),2135‐43,2004
Cytokinesis
Nucleicacidsynthesisanddegrada;on
Uncharacterized
Comparingphenotypes
RNAi Smallmolecule
Eggert,et al.PLoS Biology 2(12),2135‐43,2004
b=binucleatelc=binucleatewithlowcellcountd=binucleatewithlarge,diffuseDNAMT=binucleatewithmicrotubuleextenCons
Comparingphenotypes
A:binucleateB:binucleatewithlarge,diffuseDNAC:binucleatewithlowcellcountD:binucleatewithmicrotubuleextensions
RNAi
Comparingphenotypes
SmallmoleculeAddiConalphenotypes,includingappearanceofcleavagefurrow
Timing
GainoffuncCon
Pathwaystargetedbysmallmolecules
AcCncortexintegrityAssociatedwithmicrotubuleextensionphenotype
AuroraBpathwayAssociatedwithlarge,diffuseDNAphenotypeMitoCcdefect
AuroraBpathway
RNAiidenCfiedAuroraB,INCENP,andSurvivininvolvementinphosphorylaCnghistoneH3andchromosomea"achmenterrorinmitosis
Foundinthechromosomalpassengercomplex
ThenewgeneidenCfiedbyRNAiscreenlocalizestothechromosomepassengercomplexCG4454,orBorealin‐related(Borr)SequencesimilaritytohumanBorealin
AuroraBpathway
Arrowsindicateabsenceofphospho‐histoneH3
Summary
StrongerphenotypesidenCfiedwithsmallmolecules
PhenotypeswereverysimilarbetweensmallmoleculeandRNAiscreens
CouldidenCfypathwaysdisturbedbysmallmoleculesbycomparingtoknownRNAitargetphenotypes
CouldnotdirectlyidenCfyspecifictargetsofsmallmoleculeswithmethodsused
WherechemicalgeneCcshasgo"enus
TaxolScreenforanC‐canceracCvity
Bindsandstabilizesmicrotubules,prevenCngcelldivision
AstemizoleOriginallyusedasananC‐histamine
Foundtoinhibitmalaria‐causingmicrobe
h"p://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Taxol(Paclitaxel)3D.png
h"p://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Astemizole.svg
Websitestocheckout
h"p://www.hhmi.org/biointeracCve/index.htmlHowardHughesMedicalInsCtuteBiointeracCve
GreatvideosandanimaCons
h"p://www.drugbank.ca/search/seqqueryDrugBanksequencequery
Searchdrugsknowntobindtoyourproteinofinterest
h"p://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/PubChemcompoundsearchBestforfindingmoreinformaConaboutknowncompounds
DrugBank
Inputsequencehere—nucleoCdeorprotein
Changematrix…PAMandBLOSUMused
DrugBank
Easytofindreferences!!
Resultsshouldshowuphere,butnoluckformyproteinyet
Reminderofwhichmatrixyouchosetouse
PubChem
Entryfoundbysearching“imaCnib”—searchesforbcr‐ablgivesonlyoneresult,however,andwasnotthisentry
StudentquesCons
ThereviewsuggeststhatchemicalgeneCcscanhaveadvantagesovermutaConalapproachesinthatwithmutaConsyoulooseallfuncConsofaprotein,whilewithchemicalgeneCcsyoucana"ackspecificfuncCons.Isthisalwaystrue?Wouldn'titbepossibletoknock‐outonlyaspecificfuncConthroughselecCvedeleCons,orsinglebasepairmutaCons?
Notalwaystrue:canintroducemissensemutaConsinanacCvesiteforexample
StudentquesCons
IntheEggertpaper,theytalkedabouthowtheconcentraConandCmingofthetreatment(whetherRNAiorsmallmolecule)canaffecttheoutcome,specificallywithrespecttotheAuroraBpathway.HasthisinformaConhelpedinunderstandingtheclinicaltrialresultsfromcancercellstreatedwithAurorainhibitorsastheypredicted?
Thismaybeagoodtheory,butgenerallyifatreatmenthasharmfuleffectsinaclinicaltrial,itiso,enabandonedaltogether.
StudentquesCons
TheyalsomenConthattheythinkanaturalproductextractfromCowaniamexicanacausedagain‐of‐funcConeffectbecausenodsRNAcausedthesamephenotype.Doyouthinkthisisareasonableconclusionbasedonthis,inlightofthevariabilityinRNAiresultswehaveseenandthefactthatitisthoughtthatsuppressionofagenebyRNAimayresultinanincreaseinexpressionofothergenes?
StudentquesCons
Seeingashowthecellisacomplexanddynamicenvironment,itwouldseemtometobeimpossibletoknowifthemoleculethatyouthinkyouareusing(fromyourchemicalgeneCclibrary),isactuallywhatyouareusing.Couldn'titbemodifiedbythecellanditscomponentswithoutusknowingit?
Yes!!SomedrugswetakemustbemetabolizedinourbodiesbeforetheyareactuallyacCve.
StudentquesCons
CanchemicalgeneCctechniquesbeespeciallyusefultoepigeneCcstudiessincemajorepigeneCcregulatorymethodsincludemethylaCon,acteylaCon,andotherchemicaladdiConstoDNA?
OneexampleofstudyofchemicalgeneCcsinepigeneCcs:genisteinfoundinsoyproductsisassociatedwithlowincidenceofcancers