39

home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

��� ��������� � �������� �� ��������� ������� ����� � ������"!"#$ � ��% ��& & �����'�(������ �� )�!*���+�������,�.-/���'� 0��,!������

1/24365 798 :�24;4<=5�>?A@CBEDCF=G*HJI�BEKLDM@CNPO4QCRS@UTLQV@"WYXZT\[JR]TL@C@CN^R]T\[\_\`PTLRSa=F/HcbZG�dcefRSbgHcNhTLR]did�DPO4dcT�?jRS@C[cH

kmlonUprq sEtcpJuwv.x R]yABEd�B9@CNPRfTzDMN{H4|LKLQV@UyPdmT\@C}~d�BLBLN{HJdcQ x DMH�KEyM@CNPRfTzDM@CN{b�dcQV@�|\@Uy{RS[JT�dcTL|�N{@Ue]d�DM@U|�d�N{@UdcyU_�QCdce]eS@U|������� �V�M�������U�V�,���J�����C� F v.x @�d�BLBLN{HJdcQ x R]yi�EdcyM@U|�HJT d�T\HcD{RSHJT�Hcb �h�S�c� _�} x R]Q x dce]eSHr}Ay�QVHJI�BEeS@V� x RS@CN^d�N^Q x R]QCdceyMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@�dcTE|�R]TEQVHcN{B9HcN^d�DM@Uy�D x @�R]TEy{RS[ x D���@UI�B x dcy^RS�C@U|��/��O4dcKEy{y{K\N{@ �,D x d�Dmy^RS[JTLymQVHJI�@�RfT �6� �V���V�i� _PdcTL|y x HJKEe]|��=@�y{D{KL|LRS@U| d�D�D x d�D�eS@Cac@Ue¡_jN^d�D x @CN�D x dcT¢R]TL|ERSa/Rf|LKLdce]eS�cF¤£¥KLy{@CN�R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@¦QCdcT¢�9@�QVHJTLy{R]|\@CN^@U|¢dcyd �{�¨§=�M�V�C�V�©�ª�c�����c� Hcb*D x @(KLTL|L@CN^eS�4R]T\[mb�KLTEQVD{RSHJTLdce]RSD¨��DMH�} x R]Q x RSD'BEN{Hra4R]|\@Uy«dcQCQV@Uy{yC_¬dcTL|�D x KLy«KLyM@CN"R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@|\@Uy{R][JT�QCdcT­�9@�QVHJTLy{R]|\@CN^@U|�d'QVN^d�b�D�Hcb=QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVD{R]TL['y{KLQ x N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyU_z} x @CN^@*�9HcD x D x @.R]TzDM@CN^b�dcQV@®dcTE|�D x @KLTL|L@CN^eS�4R]T\[�b�KLTLQVD{RSHJTLdcefRSD���d�N{@�QVHJTLy^R]|\@CN{@U|�dcy­��yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@U|©�®y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yCFj¯°T�D x R]yAy{@CDMD{R]T\[\_±N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLyd�BLB9@Ud�N²dcy*I­d�BLB©R]T\[JyC_cHcN �­���ª§©³z�f�6�i� _\�9@CD�}*@C@UT(y^RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yU_z} x RfQ x y x HJKLe]|�BLN^@UyM@CN{ac@®dcy*I«KEQ x yMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@®dcyB9HJy{y{RS�©eS@cF v.x R]y�I�HcD{RSa�d�DM@Uy�|\@Cac@UeSHcBERfT\["d"QCdcefQCKLe]KLy x dUa4R]T\[«y{�/yMDM@UI�d�D{R]Q.}�dU�4y*DMHiQVHJI«�ER]T\@Ay{RS[JTLyC_/y{RS[JT(yM�/y{DM@UI­yC_dcTL|�N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyCF�´�T\@«R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzDPI�H/|L@"HcbZQVHJI�B9HJy{R]D{RSHJT�Rfy �V�]�V�=µ��g�/� _±R]T�DMN{H/|EKLQV@U|��/��¶LdcKLQVHJTETLRS@CN�dcTL|v K\N^T\@CNU·4}*@�N{@Ue]d�DM@�D x Rfy�DMH­QV@CN{D{dcR]T�QVHJTLQV@CBED{y�bgN^HJI¸D x @�ac@CN{��d��EyMDMN^dcQVD.d�N^@Ud�Hcb¹I�d�D x @UI­d�D{R]QCy.QCdcefeS@U|ºQCd�DM@C[cHcN{�D x @CHcN{�cFA£®BLB©e]R]QCd�D{RSHJTLy.bgHcNPdceS[c@C�LN^dcR]Q«yM@UI­RSHcD{RfQCy®R]TLQCefKL|\@'T\HcDAHJTLeS�ºKLyM@CNjR]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@i|\@Uy{RS[JT�_L�EK\DPdce]yMH�QVHc[JTLR]D{RSac@e]R]TL[JKLR]yMD{R]QCyU_\@UyMB9@UQCR]dce]eS�ºI�@CD{d�B x HcNAD x @CHcN^��dcTL|�QVHc[JTLRSD{RSac@«B=H/@CD{R]QCyCF v.x @«I�dcR]T�QVHJT�DMN^RS�©K\D{RSHJT�Hcb¬D x R]y®B©d�B=@CNPR]yD x @iBLN{@UQCR]y^RSHJT�RSDjQCdcT��EN^R]T\[­DMH�y{KLQ x d�N{@UdcyCFj»*KER]e]|LR]TL[iHJT�dcT�R]TLy{R][ x D.b�N{HJI¼QVHJI�BEK\DM@CN�y{QCR]@UTLQV@c_©D x d�DP|LRfy{QVN{@CDM@yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@UyPQCdcT��9@i|\@Uy{QVN^RS�9@U|�����dceS[c@C�EN^dcR]Q«D x @CHcN^RS@UyC_ nr½�¾©¿¢nCÀ�nCprÁ4ÂÃn d�N{@,|\@CÄETL@U|�DMH��9@«dceS[c@C�LNhdcR]Q'D x @CHcNhRS@Uy}®RSD x @V�/DMN^d¦yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@c_*dcTE| nUÁ4¦½�ÅEp ½�t�¦ÅEq�ƹǹ½�nr¦n d�N{@�|\@CÄ©T\@U| DMHÃ�9@�I�d�BLBER]T\[Jy,Hcb�dceS[c@C�EN^dcR]QºD x @CHcNhRS@UyD x d�D���DMHÈyMHJI­@�@V�4DM@UTzDh�­BLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@�D x @�@V�/DMNhd¦yMDMNhKLQVD{K\N{@cF¢£Py(dcT�dcR]|Éb�HcNmBLN^dcQVD{R]QCdceA|\@Uy{RS[JT±_�}*@�y x Hr}ÊD x d�DD x @iË�KLdcefRSD���HcbÌN{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyAR]yAQCeSHJyM@UeS��N{@Uefd�DM@U|�DMH�D x @"BLN{@Uy{@CN{a�d�D{R]HJT�BLN{HcB9@CN{D{R]@Uy�Hcb�yM@UI­RSHcD{RfQ'I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yC·D x @UyM@,I�@Udcy{KLN{@Uy®Hcb²Ë�KLdcefRSD���dce]y{H�BLN{H a/Rf|\@"D x @iHcN^|\@CNhR]T\[Jy®TL@C@U|\@U|��/��HJK\NjQCd�DM@C[cHcN{��D x @CHcN{@CD{R]Q«bgHcNhI«KLefd�D{RSHJT�Hcb�EeS@UTE|LR]T\[\F

Í ÎLÏjÐ=ѱÒ'Ó­Ô,չбÖ{ÒAÏ£PTLdceSHc[c�c_®I�@CD{d�B x HcNU_�N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJT�dcTL|�KLyM@CNmR]TzDM@CN^b�dcQV@ x dUac@�I«KEQ x R]T�QVHJI­I­HJT±×�@UdcQ x R]T�acHJeSac@Uy(y^RS[JTLyC_I�@UdcTLRfT\[\_�HJT\@­HcN«I�HcN{@­B9@CHcBEeS@c_odcTL|�yMHJI�@�QVHJT�DM@V�4DC_ÌRfTLQCe]KL|LRfT\[(QCKLe]D{K\N{@c·oI­HcN{@CHrac@CNi@UdcQ x QCdcT��9@­eSH/HcØc@U|�d�D|LKLdcefeS�ºbgN^HJIÊ@UR]D x @CN�dm|L@Uy{RS[JT�HcN'dmKEyM@«B9@CN^y{B=@UQVD{R]ac@cF'Ù.@UQV@UT�D�N{@UyM@Ud�N^Q x R]T�yM@Cac@CN^dce¬|LR]y^QCRSBEe]R]TL@Uy�R]yjQVHJTzac@CN{[JRfT\[HJTÈd�[c@UT\@CN^dce*d�N{@Ud�D x d�DiRfTLQCe]KL|\@UyjD x @�b�HJK\N"DMHcBERfQCy«R]T�D x @�ÄLNhyMD«yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@�d��9Hrac@c·�D x @Uy{@(|LR]y^QCRSBEe]R]TL@UyPRfTLQCe]KL|\@��dcyMB9@UQVD{y.Hcbh�*y{H/QCRSHJe]Hc[c�c_EQVHc[JTLRSD{RSac@«e]R]T\[JKLRfyMD{R]QCyC_/QVHJI�BEK\DM@CN®y^QCRS@UTLQV@c_Le]RSDM@CNhd�N{�(QVN^R]D{R]QCR]y{Iº_\KLy{@CN.R]TzDM@CN^b�dcQV@"|L@Uy{RS[JT±_BEyM�4Q x HJeSHc[c�c_'yM@UI­RSHcD{RfQCyC_PdcTE| B x R]e]HJyMHcB x �cFw´PbiD x @UyM@c_�yM@UI­R]HcD{R]QCyºD{d�Øc@Uy�B9@CN x d�BEy�D x @�I�HJyMDº[c@UTL@CN^dce�a4RS@C}'_dceSD x HJKL[ x IiKLQ x Hcb�D x @(N{@UyM@Ud�N^Q x RfT�D x R]y«d�N{@Ud x dcy"�9@C@UT�Nhd�D x @CN«a�d�[JK\@cF�£w[cHJdceZHcb.D x @�N{@UyM@Ud�NhQ x N{@CB9HcN{DM@U|x @CN{@�Rfy,DMHÃ|\@Cac@UeSHcB�d�I�d�D x @UI­d�D{R]QCdce]e]�¦BLN^@UQCR]yM@�D x @CHcN{�ÈHcb�yM@UI­RSHcD{R]QCyU_²QCdce]eS@U| s©Úg¾©Á�l¹q�sE½�t�nUÁ4ÂȽgÅEp ½�tJn _²D x d�DdUacHJRf|Ly�D x @º@CN{N^HcN�Hcb q�Á/½gÛÌtJs\p ½�Å=¿ _²D x d�D­R]yC_²HcbAR]|\@UT�D{RSb��/RfT\[�R]D{y�d��EyMDMN^dcQVD{RSHJTEy,}®RSD x N{@Udce�}*HcN^e]|ÈB x @UTLHJI�@UTLd4_I­d�Ø4R]T\[ºHJTLe]��D x @­I�HcN^@�I�H4|\@UyMD'QCe]dcR]IÜHcb�|\@Cac@UeSHcB©R]T\[�B9HcDM@UTzD{R]dcefeS��KLy{@Cb�KLe¬I­H/|\@UefyCF v.x R]yPBEd�B9@CN�b�H/QCKLy{@Uy�HJTd�BLBEefR]QCd�D{RSHJTLy®DMHmKLy{@CNAR]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@i|\@Uy^RS[JT±_E�©K\D®D x @iI­d�D x @UI­d�D{RfQCdceob�HcN^I­dcefR]y{IÝdce]y{Hmd�BLB©e]RS@Uy�DMHmD x @iHcD x @CNPd�N^@UdcyI�@UT�D{RSHJT\@U|�d��9H ac@c_E@UyMB9@UQCR]dce]e]��I�@CD{d�B x HcNAD x @CHcN{��dcTL|�QVHc[JTLR]D{RSac@'B9H�@CD{RfQCyC_\}®RSD x RfTmQVHc[JTERSD{RSac@'e]R]TL[JKLR]yMD{R]QCyUF

v.x @¬ÞMHc�mHcb�KEyM@CN*RfTzDM@CN{b�dcQV@�|\@Uy{RS[JTL@CN^yZR]y²DMHi�EKLR]e]|­[cH�H4|(I­@CD{d�B x HcN^y���N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLyC_4DMN^dcTLy{efd�D{RSHJTLyC_�@CD{Q�Fß�hF¯°T,D x R]y¬d�N{@Ud4_�D x @.|\HJI­dcR]TEyoDMH"�=@�N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�DM@U|­d�N{@�Hcb�DM@UT�ac@CN{�,QCeS@Ud�NU_zD x HJK\[ x BLN{HJy{dcRfQ�_JD x @.|\@Uy{R][JT\@CN^yÌd�N{@�Hcb�DM@UT@UT\[JR]TL@C@CN^yC_LD x @«R]TzDM@UTE|\@U|ºKLyM@CN^y®d�N{@'Hcb�DM@UT�I­dcy^y.I­d�N{Øc@CDPQVHJTLy{KLI�@CNhyC_EdcTL|�Ë/KLdce]R]D���QCdcT�Hcb�DM@UT��9@�DM@UyMDM@U|±_©@cF�[\FS_�/��e]d��9HcN^d�DMHcN{�º@V�4B=@CNhR]I�@UT�D{y®dcTL|�yMD{d�D{R]yMD{R]QCyUF v.x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@iKLyM@CNARfTzDM@CN{b�dcQV@,|\@Uy{RS[JT�BLN{Hra4R]|\@UyAd­[cH/H/|�e]d��9HcN^d�DMHcN{�b�HcN�y{D{KL|\�4R]T\['D x @P[c@UT\@CN^dce=d�N{@UdiD x d�D*}²@ x drac@jRf|\@UTzD{R]ÄL@U|±F¹¯¨D�R]y*R]TzDM@CN^@UyMD{R]T\[«DMH,QVHJT�DMN^dcyMD�KLy{@CN*R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@P|L@Uy{RS[JT}®RSD x ��y^dU�L��B9H�@CDMN^�c_\} x @CN{@�D x @"Hc�4Þ°@UQVD{y®Hcb¹RfTzDM@CN{@Uy{D®d�N{@'KLTLRfË�K\@j�LNhR]e]e]R]dcT�D²QVN^@Ud�D{RSHJTLyC_EdcTE|�dcTLdceS�4y{R]y�R]y�|ERSà�QCKLeSD���EK\D,N{@C}�d�N^|LRfT\[��hFÃáA@Cac@CN{D x @UeS@Uy{yU_ZD x @C� x dUac@�IiKLQ x R]T¦QVHJI�I�HJT±_²RfTLQCe]KL|LRfT\[�D x @ºd�BLBEefR]QCd��ER]e]R]D���HcbAyM@UI�RSHcD{R]QI�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�dcTL|��EeS@UTL|LyUF

â

Page 2: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

`PyM@CNoRfTzDM@CN{b�dcQV@²|L@Uy{RS[JT\@CN^y x dUac@�eSHJT\[.}�dcT�DM@U|"D x @²y{dcI�@²QCd�B©d��ER]e]RSD¨�Pdcyo@UeS@UQVDMN^RfQCdcezdcTL|'I­@UQ x dcTLRfQCdcez@UT\[JRfT\@C@CN^yDMH�I­d�Øc@�I�H4|\@Ue]y*dcTL|�N^@UdcyMHJT�d��=HJKLD²D x @UI�_4RfTLyMDM@Udc|(Hcb x dUa4R]T\[iDMHi�EKLR]e]|­BLN{HcDMHcD��/B9@Uy�dcTL|(DM@UyMD�D x @UIº_4�9@UQCdcKLyM@BLN{HcB9@CN�@V�4B9@CN^R]I�@UT�D{y­QCdcTÉ�9@º�9HcD x D{R]I­@�QVHJTLy{KLI­RfT\[�dcTL| @V�4B9@UTLy{RSac@cF�G�eS@Ud�N^eS�¦D x R]y,N{@UË/KLRSN{@Uy�dcT @��=@UQVD{R]ac@KLTL|L@CN^yMD{dcTL|LRfT\[.HcbE} x d�D¬KLyM@CN¬R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@Uy¬d�N^@.dcTL|i} x d�D¬I­d�Øc@Uy¬yMHJI�@��9@CDMDM@CN¬D x dcT,HcD x @CNhyCF¬£�I­d ÞMHcN¬|LR��9@CN{@UTLQV@b�N{HJIÝD x @«I�HcN{@'@UyMD{d��©e]R]y x @U|�@UT\[JR]T\@C@CN^RfT\[­|LR]y{QCR]BEe]R]T\@Uy*R]y�D x d�DAyMH4QCR]dce±b�dcQVDMHcN^yPI«KLy{D®�9@�D{d�Øc@UT�RfTzDMHmdcQCQVHJKLTzDPR]TyM@CDMD{R]TL[�K\BÈD x @�I�H4|\@Ue]yCF v.x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@(BEK\N{@UeS��I­@UQ x dcTLRfyMD{R]Q­BEN{H/QV@U|EK\N{@Uyid�N{@mKETLe]RSØc@UeS��DMH��9@(dcQ x RS@Cac@U| R]T¦D x @T\@Ud�N�b�K\D{K\N{@cF�����QCe]dcR]I­yjd�N{@�D x d�DjKEyM@CN'R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@Uy"d�N{@,N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyU_�D x d�DjD x @URSN'Ë/KLdce]RSD¨��R]yj|\@CDM@CN^I�R]T\@U|�/�(} x d�D.D x @C�mBLN{@UyM@CN{ac@c_©dcTL|ºD x d�D.D x R]y�QCdcT��9@�dcT�@��9@UQVD{RSac@"�©dcy{R]y�b�HcN®|\@Uy{RS[JT�F

`PyM@CN­R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@�Rfy{y{K\@Uyid�N{@�@V�4QV@C@U|ER]T\[JeS�ÃQVHJI�I�HJT±_²|L@UyMBERSDM@md�B9@CN^y^R]yMDM@UT�D«DM@UTL|L@UTLQV�ÃDMH�RS[JT\HcN^@(D x @UI�_�DMH|\H }®T\BEe]dr��D x @UR]N'R]I�B9HcN{D{dcTLQV@c_±HcN�DMH�I�R]TLR]I­R]�C@"D x @URSN'|ERSà�QCKLeSD¨�cF«£ QVH��=@C@(QCK\B�R]y�dcT�R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@��=@CD¨}²@C@UTÃD x @QVH��9@C@,dcTE|�D x @iQVH��9@C@�|\N^R]T\Øc@CNr·©Ë/K\@UyMD{RSHJTLyPe]RSØc@«D x R]Q^Ø/T\@Uy^yC_9acHJe]KLI�@c_9dcTL| x dcTL|LeS@iy x d�B9@"d�N{@�R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@i|L@Uy{RS[JTR]y{y^K\@UyCFj£Y�9H�HcØ�QCdcT��9@iQVHJTLy{R]|\@CN^@U|�dmKLyM@CN�R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@,DMH�R]D{yAQVHJT�DM@UTzDCFi»�KLR]e]|LRfT\[Jy.QCdcT��9@iyM@C@UT�dcyjBLN^Hra4R]|LR]T\[R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@UyoDMHjKLyM@CNhy } x H®}�dcTzD¹DMHPTEdUa4RS[Jd�DM@�}®RSD x R]T'D x @UIº_�@cF�[\FS_zd®|ERSN{@UQVDMHcN{�'R]T"D x @�eSHc�L�/�c_��©K\DMDMHJTLyoHJK\D{y{R]|\@*dcTL|R]TLy^R]|\@iD x @�@UeS@Ca�d�DMHcN^yC_���� ������y{R][JTLyC_�|\H/HcN{Ø4T\Hc�EyC_ y{D{dcRSN{}�dU�4yC_ dcTL|�@Cac@UT¦QVHcN{N^R]|LHcN^y­���cHJK�I­d�Øc@�Q x HJR]QV@Uy"}®RSD x�cHJK\N¬�9H4|\�c_cT\HcDÌ�cHJK\N�I�HJKLyM@ �hF¬£�DM@UQ x TLRfQCdce4N{@UyM@Ud�N^Q x BEd�B9@CN¬QCdcT,�=@�yM@C@UT�dcy�djKLy{@CNÌRfTzDM@CN{b�dcQV@c_JD x d�D¬DMH'y^KLQCQV@C@U|IiKLyMDiD{d�Øc@�dcQCQVHJKETzD,Hcb®RSD{y,R]T�DM@UTL|\@U|¦KLyM@CN,QVHJI­IiKLTLRSD¨�cF�Ù®@CD{K\N^TLRfT\[�DMH�D x @(Hc�/a4RSHJKLyC_�I�@U|ER]QCdce²RfTLyMDMN^KLI­@UTzD{yx drac@�KEyM@CN«R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@Uyº��bgHcN�|\H4QVDMHcN^yC_�T/K\N^yM@UyU_¹dcTL|¦@Cac@UTÈBEd�D{RS@UT�D{yh�'D x d�DiQCdcT x drac@�@V�/DMN{@UI­@mQVHJTLy{@UË�K\@UTEQV@UyiR]b�Edc|Le]�,|L@Uy{RS[JT\@U|±F¬»*��B9@CN x d�BEy²yMDMN{@CD{Q x R]T\[id"�ER]DC_/dce]I­HJyMD²dcT���D x R]T\[«QCdcTm�9@®yM@C@UT�dcy*d«KEyM@CN*RfTzDM@CN{b�dcQV@c·\|\HJR]T\[iyMH}®R]efe x RS[ x efRS[ x D�QV@CN^D{dcR]T(Rfy{y{K\@UyZHcb�|\@Uy{RS[JT(dcTL|�N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT(D x d�D*I�RS[ x D²HcD x @CN{}®[email protected]{@UI­dcRfT­Hc�Ey{QCKLN{@c_�D x HJK\[ xHcb¬QVHJK\N^yM@'R]D�}®R]e]e9T\HcD.R]TEQCe]KL|\@jdce]e±B9HJy{y{R]�EeS@PN{@UeS@Ca�dcTzD.R]y^y{K\@UyCF

`PyM@CN®R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@"R]y{y^K\@Uy�d�N{@"dce]yMH­RfI�B9HcN{D{dcTzD�R]TºI�d�D x @UI­d�D{R]QCyC_©dcTL| x dUac@"�=@C@UT�[JRSac@UTºBEd�N{D{RfQCKLe]d�N�d�DMDM@UTzD{R]HJTR]T�N{@Uefd�D{RSHJTºDMH�Q x HJR]QV@'HcbÌT\HcD{d�D{RSHJT�dcTL|ºDMH­@U|LKEQCd�D{RSHJT±FZ£Py���@UR]�ETLRS�PBEK\D.RSDC_

¯°T�y{R][JTLyC_\HJT\@iyM@C@Uy®dcT�dc|\a�dcT�D{d�[c@"b�HcNA|ER]y{QVHrac@CN^�mD x d�D®R]y�[cN{@Ud�DM@Uy{DA} x @UTºD x @C��@V�/BEN{@Uy{y�D x @"@V�4dcQVDTEd�D{K\N{@,Hcb*d�D x R]T\[m�LN^RS@��L��dcTE|±_�dcy'RSDj}*@CN{@c_�BER]QVD{KLN{@iR]DC·�D x @UT±_ RfTL|\@C@U|±_9D x @�e]d��9HcNjHcb²D x HJK\[ x D'Rfy}*HJTL|\@CN^b�KLefeS��|LR]I�R]TLR]y x @U|±F

£ [cH�H4|�@V�\dcI�BEeS@(R]y�D x @�|ER��=@CN^@UTLQV@­R]T�BEe]dcTL@�[c@CHJI�@CDMN{���9@CD�}*@C@UT¦|LHJR]T\[�BLN{H/Hcb�y'}®RSD x |LRfd�[cN^dcI­y'dcTL|Ã|\HJR]T\[BLN{H/Hcb�y }®R]D x d��\RSHJI­y���yM@C@�dce]yMHj£®BLB9@UTL|ER �j?'�hF v.x @*d��9Hrac@�Ë�KLHcD{d�D{RSHJT,dce]yMHj|\N^dU}Ayod�DMDM@UT�D{RSHJT,DMH �h�S�c�\� dcTL|«D x @URSNKLyM@c_©dcTL|�R]TL|L@C@U|±_\HJK\N®BEN{@Ca/R]HJKLy�|LR]y{QCKEy{y{RSHJTºd��9HJK\D.QVH��9@C@iQCKLBEyC_L@UeS@Ca�d�DMHcN®�©K\DMDMHJTLyC_L@CD{Q�F9QCdcT��9@�N{@��ª@V�4BLN{@Uy^yM@U|ac@CN{��TLR]QV@UeS��R]T�D x @,e]dcT\[JKEd�[c@iHcb �C�C�i�¡�c���¡�V� _±} x R]Q x Rfy®D x @�yMD{KE|\��Hcb²y^RS[JTLyCF"O4RS[JTEyAd�N{@,@Cac@CN{�/} x @CN^@c×PT\HcDZÞ{KLyMDR]QVHJTLyAHJT�QVHJI�BEK\DM@CNjy{QVN{@C@UTLyPdcTL|�QVHcN{B9HcN^d�DM@,eSHc[cHJy®HJT v ��y x RSN{D{y.HcNPN^dcQCR]TL[(QCd�N^yC_=�EK\DPI�HcN{@iy{RS[JTLRSÄ©QCdcTzD{eS�c_©D x @HcN{[JdcTLR]�Ud�D{RSHJT�Hcb±y{RS[JTLy¬Rfy¬D x @�ac@CN{��TLd�D{K\N^@�Hcb9efdcT\[JKLd�[c@c_�TEd�D{K\N^dce x KLI­dcT�e]dcT\[JKEd�[c@.�9HcD x yMB9HcØc@UT­dcTL|�}®N^RSDMDM@UT±_d�N{D{RSÄ©QCR]dce©QVHJI­BEK\[email protected]]dcT\[JKEd�[c@UyC_\dcTL|ma/R]y^KLdce©efdcT\[JKLd�[c@UyC_\dcy�R]Tmd�N^Q x RSDM@UQVD{K\N{@'dcTL|�d�N{DC_4�9HcD x ÄET\@jdcTL|mB9HcBEKLe]d�NU_R]TLQCefKL|LR]T\[iQCR]T\@UI­d4F��@«}®R]e]e=yM@C@'D x d�D®D x @'b�HJe]eSHr}AR]T\[�R]|\@Udcy.d�N^@��Edcy{R]QjDMH­HJKLN.[c@UT\@CN^dce±D x @CHcN{�©×� O\RS[JTLy�d�BLB9@Ud�N®dcyAI�@UI"�9@CN^y�Hcb �6� �J���6� �V���V�i��� _LT\HcD®R]TºR]y{HJe]d�D{RSHJT±F� ��HJyMDPy{RS[JTLy�d�N{@«QVHJI�BEeS@V��Hc�4ÞM@UQVD{yC_EQVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDM@U|�b�N{HJI¸HcD x @CNr_LeSHr}*@CNAeS@Cac@Ue y{RS[JTLyCF� O\RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yAd�N{@'�9@CDMDM@CN®a4RS@C}*@U|�dcy ��³\�{���6�¡�V��� D x d�DARfyC_Ldcy®|\@UQCefd�N^d�D{RSHJTLy�b�HcNAy{�/I«�9HJe]y�BEe]KEy�yM@UTzDM@UTEQV@UyC_

QCdcefeS@U|��Md��\RSHJI­yC_���D x d�D.N{@UyMDMN^RfQVD�D x @URSN®KLy{@ � D x dcT�dcy"��y{@CD��ª�EdcyM@U|©�.I�H/|L@Ue]yCF� Ù®@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLy«R]T�[c@UT\@CN^dce¡_¹dcTL|�KLyM@CN'RfTzDM@CN{b�dcQV@Uy"RfT�BEd�N{D{R]QCKLefd�NU_±d�N{@ �MI�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�����I­d�BEBER]T\[Jyh�®�9@��

D¨}²@C@UT�y{RS[JTºy{�/yMDM@UI�yCFG x d�N^eS@UymO\dcTL|\@CN^y"!o@UR]N^QV@$# %'&)(ª_AdÃTLR]TL@CDM@C@UTzD x QV@UTzD{KLN{�ÉeSHc[JR]QCR]dcT�dcTL|ÉB x R]eSHJyMHcB x @CN­}*HcN{Ø/RfT\[ÃR]T�»²HJy{DMHJT±_

QVHJR]T\@U|�D x @.}*HcN^| �My{@UI­RSHcD{R]QCy�"dcTL|­R]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@U|­I­dcT��,Hcb±RSD{y��Edcy^R]Q�QVHJTLQV@CBLD{yCF+*A@®@UI­B x dcy{RS�C@U|­D x d�D²I�@UdcTER]T\[Jyd�N{@ÃTLHcD�|LRSN{@UQVD{eS��d�DMD{dcQ x @U| DMHÉy{RS[JTERSÄL@CN^yC_A�EK\DºD x d�D�RfTLyMDM@Udc|±_�I�@UdcTLRfT\[ R]y ���{µ��¡�c���{µ D x N{HJKL[ x @Cac@UTzD{y���HcNBLN{H4QV@Uy{yM@Uy6��Hcb nUÁ4¦½�ÅEn ½gn _J@UdcQ x RfTzacHJeSa4R]T\[Pd nr½�¾©¿¹½gÛ¹Á/q ��R¡F�@cFS_�dADMHcØc@UT�Hcb©yMHJI­@*Ø4R]TL|=�h_�d nr½�¾=¿o½gÛÌÁ-, ��dcT.�°Hc�4ÞM@UQVD�Hcb yMHJI­@AØ4R]TL| � @cF�[\FS_\dcT�R]|\@Udz�h_4dcTL|mdcT ½�¿=prÁ/q�Æoq�Ázp sE¿=p0/ D x d�D�e]R]TLØ/yZD x @UyM@PD�}*H\·\D x @UyM@PD x N{@C@PD x R]T\[Jy*d�N{@jQCdce]eS@U|13254769836;:=<?>A@7:CBED9F)GCHJILK :CH34�H36M83NE:=O7PQG�PQR�I�4769836QSTH3476 U)478V>�<W6�XJ<W6�NE:�PYH3:�D <ZI0<ZH36�NE[A<WPQF7O�@0<�H3P�P+\083P�>Q@^]�K 4):�G�6_XJ<W:�RQO�<ZI0<ZH36�NE[`N�>�I

<WPQF7O�@aH3P�PLO�>�8W83PbKA]0<W:�O)D�6c:CH5:�<5:�O�H36�O�@06b@�H3Pd:�O7D�G�F�@76Lef@769<WD983:�U7H3:�PQO7<5PYgVhiD�PQO7D�6�U7H3F)>YG�<WU)>YD�69<�])>�<�K569G=G'>�<�<ZI0<ZH36�NE<�P�gjU74�I7<W:�Db>�Gk<W:�RQO)<�lm92547:�<d:�<LnT6�:C83D�6Qo <�P�83:�RQ:�O�>�G?H36983NE:�O)PYG�PQRYI^p+X�:=O�H36983U08369HV>YO�H3[q<W47PQF7Gr@sO)PYHL\k6aD9PQO7gtF)<W6b@�K :CH34uX�:�OvH36M83U78369H3698b] [w>Y<+:CH+8369g�6M83<LH3PxH3476

G�:�O)y�:CH3<W6�GCgJl

z

Page 3: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

d �My{RS[JT�_��'dcTL|�DMH'eS@Uy^yM@UT�QVHJT\b�KLy{RSHJT x [email protected]�DM@UT��9@C@UT�QCdce]eS@U|�d �C�C�,���c���¡�j���6���Jµ ·4dcefe�D x N{@C@�H/QCQCKLN�} x @CN{@Cac@CNZD x @CN{@R]y«I�@UdcTLR]T\[\F�O4RS[JTEyC_oI�@UdcTER]T\[JyC_¹dcTL|�N{@Cb�@CN{@UT�D{y"HJTEeS��@V�\R]yMD«bgHcNid�BEd�N^D{R]QCKLe]d�N"y{@UI­RSHJy{R]yU_ } x RfQ x IiKLyMD"RfTLQCe]KL|\@RSD{y,yMH4QCR]dce�QVHJTzDM@V�4DC·�D x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@ºI�@UdcTLRfT\[�Rfyidce]}*dr�/y �C�­�h�{µJµ��{µ dcTL| �C���{�Uµ��ª�{µ Fï°T¦[c@UTL@CN^dce¡_ZD x @my{R][JTLRSÄL@U|ÈR]yT\HcD'[JR]ac@UT±_o�©K\D'I«KEyMD'�9@­R]T\b�@CN{N{@U|��/��yMHJI�@­B9@CN^yMHJT�HcN'B9@CN^yMHJTLy'RfTzacHJeSac@U|�F(?P@Uy{RS[JT\@CNhy'}*HcN{Ø�R]T�D x @­N{@Cac@CNhyM@|LRSN^@UQVD{RSHJT±_�QVN{@Ud�D{R]T\[Èy{RS[JTLy�b�HcN(d�[JRSac@UT�y^RS[JTLRSÄL@U|�F !¹@URSN^QV@ � y�d�BEBLN{HJdcQ x I­dr�ÉyMHJKLTL|Éy^R]I�BEeS@c_²�EK\D­RSD(R]y­ac@CN{�|LR��9@CN{@UT�D�b�N{HJI I­HcN{@�QVHJI­I­HJT�dcTE|�TLdcRSac@�d�BLBLN{HJdcQ x @UyC_®y^KLQ x dcy�D x @�KLy{@�Hcb'|\@UT\HcD{d�D{R]HJTLdceAy{@UI­dcTzD{RfQCy�b�HcNBLN{Hc[cNhdcI­I­R]T\[ie]dcT\[JKLd�[c@UyUF+!o@UR]N^QV@ � y*D x @CHcN{��Hcboy{RS[JTLy*R]y*T\HcD*d �{�¨§©�{�6�U�V�E�ª�c���¡���©�c�o��³4�^���h�m���j�­�^���L����� _LRfT­} x RfQ xd�y^RS[JT x dcyid�|L@UT\HcD{d�D{RSHJT±·ZRfTLyMDM@Udc|±_¹D x @(RfTzDM@CN{BEN{@CD{dcTzDiI­d�Øc@Uy,RSD«d �M�C� �J�������=������³4�{���6���������^���L����� F !¹@URSNhQV@ � yR]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D²TLHcD{RSHJTLy*Hcb R]QVHJT±_4R]TL|L@V��dcTL|(y{�/I«�9HJe©d�N{@�|LRfy{QCKLy{yM@U|��9@UeSHr} R]TºO/@UQVD{RSHJT %\F¬¯ Tmdc|L|LR]D{RSHJT±_z}*@�KLyM@PD x @DM@CN^I n ½g¾=¿ s©Ú bgHcN®d­B x �4y{R]QCdce±QVHJTLÄL[JK\N^d�D{RSHJT�D x d�D®I­dr�mHcNAI­dU�ºT\HcD.�9@�d­y{R][JT±F

¶\@CNh|LR]TLdcTL|�|\@iO4dcKEy{y{K\N{@ #��)%k(¹}�dcyPd�e]d�DM@,TLR]T\@CDM@C@UT�D x QV@UT�D{K\N{��O/}®R]y{y®e]R]T\[JKLRfyMDC_\} x HJyM@«}²HcN^Ø�R]TLyMBER]N{@U|�D x @N{@UQV@UT�D"¶\N{@UTEQ x y{DMN^KLQVD{K\N^dcefR]yMD�dcTL|�B9HJyMD{yMDMNhKLQVD{K\N^dce]RfyMDPI­Hrac@UI�@UT�D{yC·�RSb x @�}*@CN{@�d�N{HJKLTE|�DMH/|Ldr�c_ x @�I­RS[ x D'T\HcD}®R]y x DMH«�9@®QCdcefeS@U|�d«yM@UI­RSHcD{R]QCRfyMDCF¬á®@Cac@CN{D x @UeS@Uy{yC_ x @ x dc|�dcTmR]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�DZR]TLy{R][ x D¬D x d�D*R]y�B9@CN x d�BEy�I�HJyMD�QCeS@Ud�N^e]�@V�4BLN{@Uy{yM@U|�KLy^R]T\['D x @�e]dcTL[JKLd�[c@jHcb y{RS[JTLyU×¹RSD�R]y*D x d�D�y{RS[JTLy*d�N{@�dceS}�dU�4y�BEd�N{D{y*Hcb nr½�¾=¿ nCÀ�nCprÁ4¦n F+*®@�dce]y{H«[Jdrac@B9@CN x d�BEy*D x @�ÄEN^yMDC_\dcTL|�QV@CN{D{dcRfTLeS�­HJT\@�Hcb¹D x @'I�HJy{D.R]T �EK\@UT�D{R]dce=@V�\dcI�BEeS@Uy�HcbÌd�y{RS[JTºyM�4yMDM@UIº_\}ARSD x�x R]y�D x @CHcN{�D x d�D²B x HJT\@UI�@UyU_zD x @Py{I­dce]eS@Uy{D�N{@UQVHc[JTLRS�C@U|mKLTLR]D{y¬Hcb�yMB9HcØc@UT�e]dcTL[JKLd�[c@c_/d�N^@®HcN{[JdcTLR]�C@U|(R]T�DMH"yM�4yMDM@UI­y²Hcb±�ER]TEd�N{�HcBLB9HJy{RSD{R]HJTLy��U_�} x R]Q x I­dr�i�9@�D x HJKL[ x D²Hcb9dcyZbg@Ud�D{KLN{@UyCF+��HcN^@AQVHJI�BEe]@V�,e]RfT\[JKLR]yMD{RfQ²y{R][JTLy�d�N{@.D x @UT�QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDM@U|b�N{HJI eSHr}*@CN�eS@Cac@Ue4y{RS[JTLyU×�}²HcNh|Ly����MeS@V�/@UI­@Uy�z�¹d�N{@�yM@UË/K\@UTLQV@UyÌHcbLB x HJT\@UI�@UyC·JyM@UT�DM@UTLQV@Uy�d�N^@�y{@UË�K\@UTEQV@UyÌHcbL}²HcNh|LyC·dcTL|ºDM@UTEyM@c_E[c@UTL|L@CNU_ET/KLI"�9@CN.@CD{Q�F=d�N{@«RfTL|LR]QCd�DM@U|��/��a�d�N^R]HJKLy.yM�4TzD{dcQVD{RfQ'b�@Ud�D{K\N{@UyCFj��Ù.@UQV@UT�DAN{@Uy{@Ud�N^Q x Ë�KEdce]RSÄL@UydcTL|,I�H4|LRSÄL@Uy D x R]y¹QCe]dcy{y{RfQCdce�a4RS@C}�R]T«a�d�N^R]HJKLy }�dU�4yC_J�©K\D¹R]DoR]yÌdPKLyM@Cb�KLe�I­H/|\@Ueª_�y{D{R]e]eJ}AR]|\@UeS��KLyM@U|iR]Tie]R]T\[JKER]yMD{R]QCyCFß�

G*HJI­B=HJy^R]T\[­y{RS[JTEy�bgN^HJI¸HcD x @CNjy{RS[JTLy.Rfy.d�b�KLTL|LdcI�@UT�D{dce�yMDMNhd�DM@C[c��bgHcNPI­dcTLd�[JR]TL[­D x @"QVHJI�B©eS@V�4R]D���Hcb¬T\HJTT�DMN^RSa4R]dce=QVHJI­IiKLTLR]QCd�D{RSHJT�_�N{@C[Jd�Nh|LR]T\[,QVHJI�BEeS@V��y{RS[JTLy*d�D�HJT\@�eS@Cac@Ue±dcy�R]TL|ERSa/Rf|LKLdce\y{RS[JTEy²d�D.d x RS[ x @CN*eS@Cac@UeªF v.x R]yR]y²R]e]e]KLy{DMN^d�DM@U|,���,D x @Pe]R]T\[JKER]yMD{R]Q�eS@Cac@Ue]y²|LR]y{QCKEy{yM@U|�d��9Hrac@cFZ£ y^R]I�BEeS@�QVHJI�B©K\DM@CN²[cNhd�B x R]QCy¬@V�\dcI�BEe]@®I­RS[ x D x drac@dcy�RSD{y�eS@Cac@Uefy«B©R �/@Uefy���RfTL|LRSa4R]|LKLdce �M|LHcD{y��HJTÈD x @�y{QVN{@C@UT=�h_²Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^yC_*}²HcNh|LyC_Zy{RfI�BEeS@([c@CHJI�@CDMN^R]QCdce�ÄL[JKLN{@UyC_dcTL|m}®R]TE|\Hr}®yU_�} x R]Q x d�N{@'QVHJe]eS@UQVD{R]HJTLy*Hcboy{RS[JTEy*d�D�eSH }²@CN.e]@Cac@Ue]y�BEe]KLy²HcD x @CN�}®RfTL|\Hr}AyC·�@UdcQ x y{RS[JT�d�D�@UdcQ x eS@Cac@Uex dcy�d�DMDMN^R]�EK\DM@Uy�b�HcN.eSH/QCd�D{R]HJTºdcTL|ºy{RS�C@c_LdcTL|�B9@CN x d�BEyZb�HcN.QVHJeSHcN®dcTE|ºR]TzDM@UTEy{RSD��cF v®x R]y²} x HJeS@� BEd�N^D x RS@CN^d�N^Q x R]QCdceyMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@"B©K\D{y®@UdcQ x y{RS[JT�R]T�dmQVHJT�DM@V�/D�Hcb�HcD x @CNjy^RS[JTLy.}ARSD x } x R]Q x RSD®b�HcN^I­yjyMD{Rfe]e x RS[ x @CNPeS@Cac@Ue¹y{RS[JTEyCFAáAHcDM@D x @'N^@UQCK\N^y{RSa4RSD¨�(R]T�D x @'|L@CÄETLRSD{RSHJTmHcbÌ}®R]TE|\Hr}®yUF��HcN{@�N{@UQV@UT�D®KLyM@Uy�HcbÌy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yU_\bgHcN.@V�\dcI�BEe]@jRfT(D x @'QCe]dcy{y{R]Qje]R]DM@CN^d�N{��yMD{KE|\�� ���º����Ù.HJe]dcTE|m»�d�N{D x @Uy

# %k(ª_LDM@UTE|ºDMH­�9@'eS@Uy{y�NhRS[JR]|mD x dcT�D x @'e]R]T\[JKLRfyMD{R]QCy*HcbZO4dcKLy{y{KLN{@jHcN.D x @"dcT�D x N{HcB9HJeSHc[c�mHcbA��@Ca4R�� O/DMN^dcKLy^yCF¬¯ TEyMDM@Udc|HcbZ�©R]TLd�N{��HcBLB9HJy{RSD{R]HJTLyC_=D x @CN{@,d�N{@�I«KLe]D{R��ªa�dcefK\@U|±_E@Cac@UT�QVHJT�D{R]T/K\HJKLyC_�y^QCdceS@UyC·�R]TLy{DM@Udc|�Hcb²QVHJTLyMDMN^KLQVD{RfT\[ x RS[ x @CNeS@Cac@Ue�y{RS[JTEy«�/�ÃyM@UË/K\@UT�D{R]dce�QVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{RSHJT�_¬D x @CN{@ºd�N{@ºI�HcN{@ºQVHJI�BEe]@V�ÃN{@Ue]d�D{RSHJTEy«HcbAR]TzDM@CN^B=@UTL@CDMN^d�D{RSHJT�dcTL|�R]TT��EK\@UTEQV@c·²dcTL|¦B9@CN x d�BEy«I�HJyMD�R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D{eS�c_ÌD x @CN{@�R]yid�IiKLQ x [cN^@Ud�DM@CN­yM@UTLy{RSD{R]a/RSD¨��DMH�QVHJT�DM@V�4DCF�¯ TL|L@C@U|±_¬D x @�MyMDMN^KEQVD{K\N^dce]R]y{D��DM@UTE|\@UTLQV�ÈHcbPQCe]dcy^y{R]QCdce.yM@UI�RSHcD{R]QCy x dcy��9@C@UT yM@Cac@CN^@UeS� QVN^RSD{R]QCRS�C@U|È�/�¦D x @�B9HJyMD���yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN^dce]R]yMDdcTL|�|L@UQVHJTLyMDMN^KLQVD{R]HJTLR]yMD�y{Q x H�HJefy�bgHcNPRSD{y�e]R]I�RSDM@U|ºd��ER]e]R]D��­DMHm|\@Udce±}®RSD x QVHJT�DM@V�4DCF*£PeSD x HJK\[ x � �cHcD{d�N^|±_E?P@CN{NhR]|Ld4_»�dcKL|\N^Rfe]e]d�N^|±_=dcTL|�D x @,N{@UyMD�d�N{@­y^K\N{@UeS��QVHcN{N^@UQVD"R]T�y{KLQ x QVNhRSD{R]QCR]y{I�yC_9D x @CN{@�R]yjdº|LdcT\[c@CN�Hcb²D x N{Hr}AR]T\[mHJK\D�D x @�Ed��/�ºHcb�yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@"}®R]D x D x @,|LRSN{D¨�m�©d�D x }�d�DM@CNjHcb�|\@UQVHJTzDM@V�4D{KLdce]R]�Ud�D{RSHJT±FA£PeSD x HJKL[ x I�@UdcTLRfT\[\_©dcy x KEI­dcT�@V�j�B9@CN^RS@UTLQV@c_=QV@CN{D{dcR]TLe]��|LH�@UyAT\HcDPQVHJTLÄET\@"RSD{y{@UeSbÌDMH(N^R][JR]|�yM�4yMDM@UI­yAHcb¬bg@Ud�D{KLN{@UyC_ x Hr}*@Cac@CN'QVHJI�BEeS@V�\eS�ºyMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@U|±_RSD.R]y�@UË/KLdce]e]�(KLTL|L@UTLR]d��EeS@PD x d�D.}*@"yM@C@«yMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@�@Cac@CN{��} x @CN{@c_EdcTL|ºTLHcD®eS@UdcyMD®RfTºe]dcT\[JKLd�[c@cF

O/DMNhKLQVD{K\N{@ZRfy±BEd�N{D�Hcb\HJKLN�@V�/B9@CN^R]@UTLQV@c_�dcTE|'D x HJK\[ x yM@C@UI­R]TL[JeS�PI­HcN{@²d��Ey{DMN^dcQVD D x dcT«R]I­I�@U|ER]d�DM@�yM@UTLy{d�D{R]HJTLyC_@UI�HcD{RSHJTEyC_�@Ca�dce]KLd�D{RSHJTLyU_±@CD{Q�FS_oD x @CN^@,Rfy�yMDMN{HJT\[º@Ca4R]|\@UTLQV@,D x d�D«RSDjDMH�HºBEefdU�4y�dºQVN^KLQCR]dceÌN{HJe]@,RfT�D x @,bgHcN^I�d�D{RSHJTHcb�y{KLQ x @V�/B9@CN^RS@UTEQV@Uy���@cF�[\FS_¹QVHJTEy{R]|\@CN x H }¤I�H a/R]@Uy'd�N{@�yMDMNhKLQVD{K\N{@U|©�hF(G�HJTzDM@V�4DC_o} x R]Q x b�HcN"yMB9HcØc@UT�efdcT\[JKLd�[c@}*HJKLe]|ÃRfTLQCe]KL|\@�D x @myMB9@Ud�Øc@CNU_¬QCdcTÈ�9@�d�D,eS@UdcyMD,dcy«R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzD«bgHcN,I�@UdcTLR]TL[�dcy«D x @my^RS[JTLy"RfTzacHJeSac@U|�F�¶\HcN�dcT@V�4DMN{@UI�@"@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_d����@Uy�mQCdcT�I­@UdcT�dce]I­HJyMD®dcT���D x RfT\[­[JRSac@UT�dcT�d�BLBEN{HcBLN^R]d�DM@«QVHJTzDM@V�4DCF_��HcN^@CHrac@CNU_±}*HcN{غR]T��� <W:=RYOE<ZI0<ZH36�NuH34�>H?4)>Y<��ZF7<ZH�PYO)6 6�G�6�NE6�O�HiDb>�O-o HiD�PQO���69I�>YO�IL:�O7gtPY83N�>�H3:�PYO-]�\k6�D�>YF)<W6 H34769836 >�836 O)P+@0:��^69836�O)D96�<�l��)P�8?6��)>�NEU)G�6Q]

:�N�>YRY:=O76�:Cg n >�F)G��;6���69836Y]-:�Os@76�<WDM83:=\7:�O)Rx47PbK.G=>YNEU)< :=O H34)6LDV40F083DM4 H3PbK56M8AK5PQF7G=@w:�O�@0:�Db>�H36 �?83:CH3:=<W4s:�O!�Y>Y<W:�PYOsU7Gr>�O)<`gtPY8"��PY<ZH3PQO-]4�>Y@q<3>Y:=@ X$# O76L:Cgi\�IxG=>�O�@ >YO)@qPQO76L:Cgi\�Ix<W6�>0l [�:�O7<ZH36b>Q@qP�gdX%# O)6+:Cgi\vI�G=>YO)@w>�O�@�H�K5P�:Cgi\vI�<W6b>vl ['&xPY836+H36�DV4)O):�Db>�G�G�I�])K :�H34(�JF)<ZHPQO76+<W:=RYO-]kH3476")04�>�O)O7PQOq:�O7gtPY83N�>H3:=PYO D�PQO�H36�O�H;PYg?>ENE6�<W<3>YRY6+:=<+*�6983P0l-,�g H34)6M836d>836LH�K5PEP�8`NEPY836A<W:�RYO)< :�O >E<ZI0<ZH36�Nq]0H34)69836+N�F7<ZH\k6 <WPYNE6`<ZI0<ZH36�N�>�H3:�D;K >�IEH3Pa@0:=<ZH3:�O7RQF):�<W4x>YNEPQO7RLH3476�Nql.#c8 >�<0/c836�RQP�8WI1�5>�H36�<WPYOq<3>Y:=@^]7:�O0g�PY83N�>H3:�PQOx:�< >d@7:��^69836�O7D�6 H34�>H N�>YyQ6�<>a@0:2�^6M836�O)D�6Yl

3

Page 4: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

d�N{D{RSÄ©QCR]dce�R]T�DM@Ue]e]RS[c@UTEQV@ x dcy�b�HJKLTL|�QVHJT�DM@V�/D{KEdceoQCK\@UyA@Uy{yM@UT�D{R]dce±b�HcNA|ER]y{dcI«�ERS[JKLd�D{RSHJTºRfT�yMB9@C@UQ x KLTL|\@CN^y{D{dcTL|LR]T\[\_I­dcQ x R]T\@�a4R]y{RSHJT�_4dcTE|º@Ue]yM@C} x @CN{@cF

v.x @iacH }²@Ue²yM�4yMDM@UI­y�Hcb*a�d�NhRSHJKLyjdcQCQV@UTzD{y«}®RSD x R]T�D x @­y{dcI�@­e]dcT\[JKEd�[c@­y x Hr} D x d�D�D x @­y{dcI�@­y^RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UIQCdcT��9@�N{@UdcefRS�C@U|�R]T�|ER��=@CN^@UTzD�}�dU�4yC·©e]@CD®KLy.QCdce]e�D x @UyM@«|ER��=@CN^@UTzD ¦Š,oÁ4Ú�n HcbÌD x @"y{R][JT�yM�4yMDM@UIºF²¶LHcNPQVHJI�B©K\DM@CNy{QCRS@UT�D{R]yMD{yU_.RSDmI�dU�É�9@ x @UeSBLb�KLe�DMH�a/RS@C}¼y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­y�dcy sElonCp q sLtJp�,os\p s p6À�Æ�Á/n _.�9@UQCdcKLyM@�D x R]y(dceSN{@Udc|\�R]TLQCefKL|\@Uy�D x @"Rf|\@Ud�D x d�D.D x @«y{dcI�@«R]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{RSHJTºQCdcT��9@�N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�DM@U|�RfT�|LR��9@CN{@UT�D.}*dr�/yU·Eb�HcN®@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_E|Ed�DM@UyC_D{R]I�@UyU_EdcTL|�yMB9HcN{D{y®y{QVHcN{@Uy.@UdcQ x�x dUac@,I«KLe]D{RSBEeS@Pb�dcI�R]e]R]d�N�N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyCF v.x @��PN{@C@CØ=_©Ù®HJI­dcT�dcTE|�G*�/N^R]e]e]RfQdceSB x d��=@CD{y«y x H }¤D x d�DiD x @�yM@CD{yiKLTL|\@CN^e]�/R]TL[�I�H/|L@Ue]y"QCdcT¦Hrac@CN^efd�B�·ZD x Rfy'@V�\dcI�BEeS@mdce]yMH�y x Hr}®yiD x d�Did�y^RS[JTLdceD x d�D.R]y�I�@UdcTER]T\[cb�KLe©RfT(HJTL@'y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UIÝI­dr�mT\HcD��9@�R]T�dcT\HcD x @CNU_\@Cac@UT�D x HJK\[ x D x @C�my x d�N{@�d�I�@U|LRfKLIºF v.x @y{dcI�@�y{RS[JTEdceZR]T�d�|LR��9@CN{@UT�D«dceSB x d��9@CD"R]y"d�|LR��9@CN{@UT�D"y{RS[JT�_o�9@UQCdcKLyM@�RSD"Rfy«R]T¦d�|LR �=@CN{@UT�D«y^RS[JTÃyM�4yMDM@UIºF v.x @acHr}*@UeZy{�/yMDM@UI @V�4dcI�B©eS@�dce]yMH�y x H }®yjD x d�D"|ER��=@CN^@UTzD�I�H4|\@Ue]yPHcb*D x @­y{dcI�@­y{R][JT�yM�/y{DM@UI QCdcT�KLyM@,@V�\dcQVD{eS��D x @y{dcI�@iy{RS[JTLdcefy.R]T�|LR �=@CN{@UT�D.}�dU�4yC·=D x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@"RSD®Rfy x H } @UeS@UI�@UT�D{yPd�N{@«KLy{@U|ºD x d�DAI�d�Øc@UyAD x @"I�H4|\@Ue]y.|LR �=@CN{@UT�DC_T\HcD.D x @�@UeS@UI�@UT�D{y.D x @UI­y{@UeSac@UyCFL*A@CN{@"d�N{@'y{HJI�@'b�K\N{D x @CN.KLy{@Cb�KLe±QVHJTEQV@CBLD{yC×� £ ÂÃÁj,̽��¹Â @V�4BLN{@Uy{yM@Uy¬|ER]I�@UTLy{R]HJTLy�}®R]D x R]T'} x R]Q x y{R][JTLyoQCdcT,a�d�N{�=·Jb�HcN¬@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_JyMD{dcTL|Ld�Nh| v�� R]y¹djD�}*H

|ER]I�@UTLy{R]HJTLdce B©R �/@Ue¹d�N{N^dr��}ARSD x QV@CN{D{dcR]T�B9HJy{y{RS�©eS@"N^dcTL[c@UyjHcb*R]T�DM@UTLy{R]D���dcTL|�QVHJe]HcNU_±BEe]KLyjd�I�HJT\HcB x HJTLR]QdcKE|LRSH­Q x dcTLT\@Ue±}®R]D x d�QV@CN{D{dcR]T�B9HJy{y^RS�EeS@PN^dcT\[c@�HcbÌb�N{@UË�KL@UTLQV�c_\@CD{Q�F

� £ ¾EÁ4¿ q�Á RfyodjQVHJe]eS@UQVD{R]HJT«Hcb=QVHJTzac@UT�D{RSHJTLyÌb�HcN�KLy{RfT\[AdjI�@U|LRfKLIº·�D x @UyM@�QCdcT,�9@²yM@C@UT�dcyÌb�K\N{D x @CN¹|\@UefR]I­RSD{R]TL[dmy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UIºFA¶LHcN�@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_ED x @,|LdcR]e]��TL@C}®yMBEd�B9@CNARfy®d([c@UT\N{@i}®RSD x R]T�D x @iI�@U|ER]KLIÝHcb�IiKLeSD{RfyM@UQVD{RSHJTQVHJefeS@UQVD{RSHJTLy¬Hcb=e]d�N{[[email protected]{R]�C@�BEd�[c@UyCFZO/HJd�B­HcB9@CN^dcy�d�N^@.dj[c@UT\N{@�b�HcN v�� F�´j��a4RSHJKLy{e]�c_c[c@UT\N{@Uy x drac@®y{K\�E[c@UT\N{@UyC·@cF�[\FS_=yMHJd�B�HcB9@CN^dcy®d��=HJKLD�N^R]Q x b�dcI­Rfe]RS@UyCF

��� �¹Úgp ½�ÂÃÁj,¹½�s d�N{@,Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CNhRS�C@U|�����I«KLe]D{RSBEeS@'y{RfI«KLe]D{dcT\@CHJKLy.B9@CN^QV@CBED{KLdceoQ x dcTLT\@UefyCFjO/H v�� R]yPIiKLeSD{R��I­@U|LR]d4_LdcTL|�y{H���R]Tºd�}*@Ud�غyM@UTLyM@ ��d�N^@'QCd�N{DMH�HJTEyC_©dcy�}*@Ue]e�dcy.�=H/HcØ4y�}®RSD x BERfQVD{K\N{@UyCF

� ¿=p Á�q�sLtcp ½��=Á�ÂÃÁj,̽gs dce]e]Hr}¢R]T\B©K\D{y²dcy�}*@Ue]e9dcy�HJK\DMB©K\D{yCF²O/H !*G�y*d�N^@���B=HcDM@UT�D{R]dce]e]�\�ZR]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{RSac@'IiKLeSD{R��I­@U|LR]d4F v.x @�}*@C��BEN{Hra4R]|\@Uy'��d�D®e]@UdcyMD.HJT\@ �*[c@UTLN{@'}®RSD x R]T�D x R]y.I�@U|LRfKLIº·/@UI­dcR]e�R]y�dcTLHcD x @CNUF

��@jQCdcT(@Cac@UTmy{dr�­D x d�D�d'�9H�HcØ­RfyZR]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{RSac@c_4�9@UQCdcKLyM@PKLyM@CN^y²QCdcT(I­d�N^Ø­dcTL|�D{KLN^T�BEd�[c@UyC_\dcTL|mQCdcT([cH«DMH,dcTz�BEd�[c@iD x @C��}®Rfy x ·©RfTL|LR]QV@UyC_E[JeSHJy{y{d�N^R]@UyC_©@CD{Q�F9d�N{@,dce]yMH�KLyM@U|�R]T�dcT�R]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{RSac@,I­dcTLT\@CNrF���dcT���IiKLyM@UKLI�y x drac@R]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{RSac@"IiKLeSD{RfI�@U|LR]d«@V� x RS�ERSD{yC_\dcTL|�@Cac@CN{�ºI«KLy{@UKLIÝR]y�R]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{RSac@«R]Tºd­I�HcN{@"BLN{HJy{dcR]QjyM@UTEyM@cF

v.x R]yPBEd�B9@CNPBEN{HcB9HJyM@Uy�d�BLN{@UQCR]y{@ib�N^dcI�@C}*HcN{Ø�bgHcN"y{D{KL|\�4R]T\[(y^RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­y�dcTL|�D x @UR]N�N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyU_ dcy}*@Ue]e�dcy.b�HcN®yMD{KE|\�/RfT\[�} x d�D.I­d�Øc@UyPyMHJI�@"N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLy®�9@CDMDM@CN®D x dcT�HcD x @CN^yC_EdcTE| x Hr} DMH(QVHJI«�ER]T\@�N^@CBLN{@��yM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyCF v.x @²b�N^dcI�@C}*HcN{Ø"R]yÌR]T�DM@UTL|\@U|«b�HcNÌd�BEBEe]R]QCd�D{RSHJT«DMH�dcyMB9@UQVD{y¹Hcb©QVHJI­IiKLTLR]QCd�D{R]HJTidcTE|iQVHc[JTERSD{RSHJT±_cy{KLQ xdcyP|\@Uy{RS[JTLRfT\[�dcTL|�KLTE|\@CN^yMD{dcTL|ER]T\[,R]TzDM@CN^b�dcQV@UyC_9QVH/HcN^|LR]TLd�D{RfT\[­R]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{RSHJTºRfT�|LR��9@CN{@UT�D®I�@U|LR]d4_©dcTL|�Q x H�HJy^R]T\[@��9@UQVD{RSac@�N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLy­R]T±_Z@cF�[\FS_�TEd�D{K\N^dce�e]dcT\[JKEd�[c@c_²a4R]|\@CH�QCe]RSB©yC_ZR]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{RSac@�I�@U|ER]d4_Z@CD{Q�F�´jTL@º[cHJdce.R]yDMH�[c@CD­d�QCdce]QCKLefd�D{RSHJTLdce�d�BLBLN{HJdcQ x DMH�KLyM@CN�R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@�|\@Uy{RS[JT±_²e]RSØc@mD x d�D�bgHJKETL|¦RfT¦HcD x @CN­@UT\[JR]T\@C@CNhR]T\[�|ER]y{QCR��BEe]RfT\@UyCF.£PeSD x HJK\[ x HJK\NAHcà(QCR]dceoTEdcI�@«b�HcNPD x R]y®d�BEBLN{HJdcQ x R]y sEÚ�¾EÁ/loq�sE½�t�nUÁ4¦½�ÅLp�½gtzn _=R]DAI­RS[ x Djdce]yMH��9@iQCdce]eS@U|nCprq �otcp��oq sEÚ�nUÁ4¦½�ÅLp�½gtzn DMHÈ@UI�B x dcy{R]�C@�D x d�D(I­@UdcTLR]T\[ÃRfy�yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N^dce¡_*HcN���RfTÉRSD{y­B x R]eSHJyMHcB x R]Qm[JKLR]yM@ �,@Cac@UT¦ÅEq�ƹǹ½�t�nrÁ/ÂȽ�ÅLp ½�tJn _±DMH�@UI�B x dcy{RS�C@iD x d�D�I�@UdcTLR]TL[(R]yj|\�4TLdcI­R]Q�_9QVHJT�DM@V�/D{KLdceª_�@UI"�9H4|LRS@U|�dcTL|�yMH/QCRfdce¡Fj¯ T�dyM@UTLy{@c_zD x R]y�BEd�B9@CN¬BLN{HcB9HJyM@Uy�d"[c@UT\@CN^dceLD x @CHcN{�,Hcb9I­@UdcTLR]T\[\_zdce]D x HJK\[ x RSD²|\@UTLRS@UyÌD x @®B=HJy^y{RS�ER]efRSD��'Hcb9DMN^dc|ERSD{RSHJTLdceQVHJT�DM@V�/D���R]TE|\@CB9@UTL|\@UT�DAI�@UdcTLRfT\[\F v.x @"yMH4QCR]dceoTLd�D{K\N{@'Hcb�RfT\bgHcNhI­d�D{RSHJT�R]yA|LR]y{QCKEy{yM@U|�R]T # z4â (ª_©KEy{R]T\[­R]|[email protected]�N{HJI@CD x T\HJI­@CD x H/|LHJeSHc[c� #�� 3 (ªF

¶LdcI�R]e]R]d�N^R]D���}®RSD x ��d�e]RSDMD{e]@��ERSD'Hcbh�«´j»�� 3 dcTE|ÃdceS[c@C�LNhdcR]Q�yMB9@UQCRSÄ©QCd�D{RSHJT�R]y«T\@C@U|\@U|¦bgHcN«D x @�@V�\dcI�BEeS@Uy«R]T£ABLB9@UTL|LR �,£"_/dcTL|­b�dcI­R]e]Rfd�N^RSD��i}®RSD x �Edcy{R]Q.QCd�DM@C[cHcN^�­D x @CHcN{�­R]y²T\@C@U|\@U|�bgHcN*£®BLB9@UTL|ER �i»P·/N{@Cbg@CN^@UTLQV@UyZb�HcNZD x @UyM@D�}*H�DMHcBERfQCy�d�N{@ # z�� (®dcTL| # 3 3 _ â�� _ â�� (ª_²N{@UyMB9@UQVD{RSac@UeS�cF ��HJyMD�B x R]eSHJyMHcB x R]QCdceZ|ER]y{QCKLy{y^RSHJT x dcy,�=@C@UTÈ�EdcTER]y x @U|DMH�£®BLB9@UTL|ER ��Gj_¹} x R]eS@�£ABLB9@UTL|LRS��?ÊR]y"dcTÈ@Uy{y{dr��HJTÈD x @(y{H/QCR]dce*TLd�D{K\N^@(Hcb�BLN^H�Hcb�yC_Ì} x R]Q x BLN^Hra4R]|\@UyiI�HcN{@QVHJTLQVN{@CDM@iR]e]e]KEyMDMN^d�D{RSHJTLy²Hcb¬yMHJI�@�B9HJR]T�D{y.R]Tº£ABLB9@UTL|LR �mGjF

����� ����� ��!�"#��$&%'!)(#*,+,��- �.-

´jT\@�Hcb=D x @.[cN^@Ud�DZR]TLy{R][ x D{yÌHcb9D�}*@UT�D{RS@CD x QV@UT�D{K\N{��I­d�D x @UI�d�D{R]QCyC_z}ARSD x QVHJTLyM@UË/K\@UTLQV@UyZD x d�DZd�N{@.yMD{Rfe]e\KLT\b�HJe]|LR]TL[\_R]yPD x d�D'yMDMNhKLQVD{K\N{@iBLN{@UyM@CN^a/R]TL[mI�HcN^B x R]y{I�yAd�N{@,Hcb�DM@UT�d�D�eS@UdcyMD'dcy�R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzDjdcy�D x @�yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@UyPD x @UI­yM@Ue]ac@UyCF

%

Page 5: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

¶\HcNj@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_=e]R]T\@Ud�N®dce][c@C�LN^d�Rfy®I�HcN{@«b�KETL|LdcI�@UT�D{dce]eS��QVHJTLQV@CN^T\@U|�}®RSD x e]R]T\@Ud�NAI­d�BEy«��Hcb�DM@UT�N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzDM@U|����I­d�DMN^RfQV@Uyh���9@CD�}*@C@UT�ac@UQVDMHcNjy{BEdcQV@UyC_ED x dcT�}®RSD x ac@UQVDMHcNjy{BEdcQV@Uy®D x @UI­yM@UeSac@Uy,��D x HJK\[ x D x @«e]d�DMDM@CNPd�N{@"Hcb�QVHJKLN^yM@T\HcD�DMHº�9@�|\@UyMBERfyM@U|©�h·�}®R]D x HJK\Dj[JRSa4R]T\[�|\@CD{dcR]e]yC_±D x @CN{@­d�N{@­dce]yMH�QVHJI­BEK\D{d��EeS@,b�KLTLQVD{RSHJTEyPRfT�N{@UQCK\N^y{R]HJT�D x @CHcN{�c_@UI«�=@U|E|LR]T\[Jy�dcTL|�D{dcT\[c@UT�D®I­d�B©y.R]Tm[c@CHJI�@CDMN{�c_=dcTLdceS�/D{R]Q�dcTL|ºI�@CN{HJI­HcN{B x R]QPb�KLTLQVD{RSHJTEy*RfTºQVHJI�BEeS@V��dcTLdceS�4y{R]yC_QVHJT�D{R]T�KLHJKLy.I­d�BEy®R]T�DMHcB9HJeSHc[c�c_EdcTL|�IiKLQ x I�HcN{@ � dce]e9HcbÌD x @UIÝyMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@�BLN{@Uy{@CN{a/RfT\[�I­d�BEyCF

v.x R]yÌQVHJTLQV@CBLD{KLdce4N{@CacHJefK\D{RSHJT,DMH/HcØid�I�HcN^@�|L@CÄETLRSDM@�dcTL|�yM�4yMDM@UI­d�D{RfQ�bgHcN^I }ARSD x D x @�R]Tzac@UT�D{RSHJT,Hcb9QCd�DM@C[cHcN{�D x @CHcN{�'RfT�D x @Z@Ud�NheS� â &)%�� � yo�/�'XZRfeS@UTz�9@CN{[�dcTL|���dcQ�� dcTL@c·JyM@C@x# % â (ªF v @UQ x TLRfQCdcez|\@Cac@UeSHcB©I�@UTzD{yo}®RSD x R]T�QCd�DM@C[cHcN{�D x @CHcN{� x drac@�R]TÈD{K\N^T y{BEK\N{N{@U|Èb�K\N{D x @CN­dcTE|É|\@C@CB9@CN­KLyM@Uy�HcbjI�HcN{B x R]y{I­y«}®RSD x R]T�I­d�D x @UI­d�D{R]QCyU_*dcTL|�I�HcN{@N{@UQV@UT�D{eS��R]T�d�BLBEefRS@U|,ÄL@Ue]|Ly¬efRSØc@�QVHJI�BEK\DM@CN*y{QCRS@UTLQV@cF v.x RfyÌBLN{H4QV@Uy{y x dcy�TLHcDZQV@UdcyM@U|±_4dcTL|­d�BLB©e]R]QCd�D{RSHJTLy¬QVHJT�D{R]T/K\@DMH�R]TLy{BERSN{@iT\@C}~D x @CHcN{�c_ y^KLQ x dcyjD x @ � / ��QCd�DM@C[cHcNhRS@Uy"dcTL| � / �ªB©KLy x HJK\D{yPD x d�D'd�N^@­|LR]y{QCKLy^yM@U|�RfT�£ABLB9@UTL|LRS��» HcbD x R]y�B©d�B=@CNrF

O/@UI�RSHcD{R]QCy x dcy.@Uy{QCd�B9@U|�D x R]y�BEd�N^D{R]QCKLe]d�N.N^@CacHJe]K\D{RSHJT±_EBLN{Hc�Ed��Ee]�mR]T�BEd�N{DA|EK\@'DMH(R]D{y®R]TLQVN^@Udcy{R]T\[­dce]R]@UTLd�D{RSHJTb�N{HJI b�HcN^I­dcefRS�Ud�D{RSHJT"|EK\N^R]T\[�D x @ZN{@UeS@Ca�dcT�DoB9@CN^RSH4|±F »�K\Do¯�QCe]dcR]I D x @CN{@�R]y IiKLQ x DMHP�=@²[JdcR]T\@U|«bgN^HJI¢D x R]yoKLTLe]R]Øc@UeS�I­d�N{NhR]d�[c@"Hcb�yM@UI�RSHcD{R]QCyPdcTL|�QCd�DM@C[cHcN^��D x @CHcN{�Ã��}ARSD x QVHc[JTLR]D{RSac@iefR]T\[JKLR]y{D{R]QCy�dcy®�EN^R]|\@Uy{I�dcR]|©�h_ET\HcDAD x @«e]@UdcyMDAHcb} x RfQ x R]y²d«D x @CHcN{��Hcb�N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJT�D x d�D*QCdcTm�9@Pd�BEBEe]RS@U|�DMH«DMHcBERfQCy²HcboQCK\N{N{@UT�D*RfTzDM@CN{@Uy{DC_4efRSØc@AKLy{@CN*R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@|\@Uy{R][JT±_�I�@CD{d�B x HcN«D x @CHcN{�c_¹dcTL|�TLd�D{K\N^dce¬efdcT\[JKLd�[c@�KLTE|\@CN^yMD{dcTL|ER]T\[\F v®x @�@Uy{yM@UT�D{R]dce�R]|L@UdmRfy�D x d�D'R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@UyC_N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLyC_EI�@CD{d�B x HcN^yC_LR]T�DM@CN{BLN^@CD{d�D{RSHJTLyC_\@CD{Q�F=d�N{@'I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y*b�N{HJI¸HJT\@"y^RS[JTºyM�4yMDM@UIÝDMH�dcTLHcD x @CNUF

£�KLyM@CN¬R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@�b�HcN�djQVHJI�BEK\DM@CN¬yM�4yMDM@UI~QCdcT,�9@*y{@C@UT�dcy¬dPy{@UI­RSHcD{R]Q*I�HcN{B x R]y{I¢b�N{HJI¸��D x @�D x @CHcN^�'Hcbh�oD x @KLTL|L@CN^eS�4R]T\[�d��EyMDMN^dcQVDPI­dcQ x R]T\@(��} x d�D®D x @iyM�/y{DM@UIÊ|\H/@Uyh��DMH(d�y^RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yAb�HcN®}®R]TE|\Hr}®yU_L�EK\DMDMHJTLyU_EI�@UT/KLyC_@CD{Q�Fc# 34â (ªF�£ }*@C�º�LN{Hr}[email protected]º�9@�yM@C@UTºdcy.d�I­d�Bºb�N{HJI�� ��������BEe]KLy��Jdra�dzO\QVN^RSBLDC_4@CD{Q�Fß��R]T�DMH,D x @'QCd�BEd��ERfe]RSD{RS@UyHcbod,B©d�N{D{R]QCKLe]d�N�QVHJI�B©K\DM@CN�HJT�} x R]Q x RSD�R]y*N^KLTLTLRfT\[�rFL��@CD{d�B x HcN^y®QCdcT��=@�yM@C@UTºdcy®yM@UI­RSHcD{R]QjI�HcN^B x R]y{I�y�b�N{HJIHJT\@�yM�4yMDM@UIÜHcb²QVHJTEQV@CBLD{yjDMH�dcT\HcD x @CN # â �L_ âvz _-� � (ªF"£ [JRSac@UT�DM@V�/D���y{B=HcØc@UT�KLDMDM@CN^dcTLQV@c_�@CD{Q�Fß�PQCdcT��9@,yM@C@UT�dcyD x @iR]I­d�[c@«KETL|\@CN®d­I­HcN{B x R]y^I¸bgN^HJI yMHJI�@���KLy{KLdcefeS�(KLTLØ/T\H }®T©��y{DMN^KLQVD{K\N{@«R]TzDMH�D x @«y{R][JT�yM�4yMDM@UI Hcb¬}®N^RSDMDM@UTXZTL[Je]R]y x ��HcN'y{B=HcØc@UT�XZTL[Je]R]y x _EHcNP} x d�DM@Cac@CN6�hF«G*HJT�ac@CN^yM@UeS�c_9}*@iI�dU���9@i[JRSac@UT�y{HJI�@�y{RSD{KLd�D{RSHJT�_©dcTL|�}�dcTzDPDMHÄETL|iD x @��9@UyMDÌ}�dU�,DMH'|\@Uy{QVN^R]�=@�RSD¬R]T,TLd�D{K\Nhdce/efdcT\[JKLd�[c@c_JHcNZRfTiy{HJI�@�HcD x @CN�I�@U|LRfKLI HcN�QVHJI"�ERfTLd�D{RSHJT,Hcb©I­@U|LR]d4_y{KLQ x dcy.DM@V�4D.}®R]D x B x HcDMHJyC_LHcNAQCd�N{DMH�HJT�yM@UË/K\@UTLQV@UyC_LHcN®a/R]|L@CH\_LHcN.HJTLe]RfT\@ x �/B9@CN{DM@V�/D�HcN x �/B9@CN^I�@U|LR]d # z#� (ªF

¯°T�D x @UyM@«dcTL|�I­dcT��ºHcD x @CN�QCdcyM@UyC_=N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyPd�N^@«y{RS[JTEy®R]T�HJT\@iy{�/yMDM@UIÊD x d�DPN{@Ue]d�DM@iyM�/y{DM@UI­d�D{R]QCdce]eS�DMH�y{RS[JTLyiR]TÈdcT\HcD x @CN�yM�4yMDM@UIºF �P@UT\@CNhdce]eS��RSD,R]y.ÞMKLy{Didcyib�N^KLRSD{eS@Uy^y'DMH�yMD{KL|\��N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyiHcb®y{RfT\[JeS@(y^RS[JTLydcyPDMHºyMD{KL|\��y^R]T\[JeS@iR]yMHJe]d�DM@U|�y{RS[JTLyUFP¶\HcN�N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyjdce]yMH�H4QCQCK\N�R]T�yM�/y{DM@UI­yC_�ÞMKEyMDAdcy�y{R][JTLyA|LH\×®KLy{KLdcefeS�D x @CN{@,d�N{@�yM�4yMDM@UI­d�D{R]QiN{@C[JKEe]d�N^RSD{RS@UyAR]T x Hr}Yy{R][JTLy®HcbZHJT\@�yM�/y{DM@UI¼d�N^@iN^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�DM@U|�dcyPy^RS[JTLyAHcb²dcT\HcD x @CNrFq� @CDKLyAKLyM@'D x @«T\HcD{d�D{RSHJT� × ���������,bgHcNjd­I�HcN^B x R]y{Iwb�N{HJIÊy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI����«DMH(y{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI�����F.´jbÌQVHJKLN^yM@c_R]T�dce]e¹�EK\DPD x @­I�HJy{DPDMNhRSa/Rfdce¹QCdcy{@UyC_�D x @CN{@�R]y�TLH�KETLR]Ë/K\@«I�HcN^B x R]y{I�� � ��� � F v®x R]T\Ø=_©b�HcN�@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_±Hcb*D x @|LRSà(QCKLeSD{RS@Uy�HcbZDMN^dcTLy{e]d�D{RfT\[�b�N{HJIÊHJT\@iefdcT\[JKLd�[c@iDMH�dcTLHcD x @CNUF ��HcN{@CH ac@CN"R]T�[c@UT\@CN^dce¡_±I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y®d�N{@«B©d�N{D{R]dce¡_D x d�D,R]yC_ÌT\HcD,|\@CÄET\@U|�b�HcN,dce]eZD x @(y{RS[JTEy"R]TÃD x @(yMHJKLN^QV@my{�/yMDM@UI�·ZyMHJI�@my{RS[JTLyiI­dU���9@mKLTzDMNhdcTLy{e]d�D{d��Ee]@c_oHcN,d�DeS@UdcyMDC_©T\HcD�DMN^dcTLy{efd�DM@U|��/�md�[JR]ac@UT�I�HcN{B x R]y{IºF*A@CN{@'d�N{@'yMHJI­@�ac@CN{�my^R]I�BEeS@A@V�4dcI­BEeS@UyCF+� @CD����'�9@AD x @�b�dcI­Rfe]R]d�N�|\@UQCR]I­dce±£AN^d��ER]QjT/KLI�@CN^dcefy*dcTE|ºeS@CD����

�9@­D x @�Ù.HJI­dcTÈT/KLI�@CN^dce]yUF v®x @UT�D x @CN^@(R]y«d�TLd�D{KLN^dceZI�HcN^B x R]y{I� ×�� � � � � �EKLD«RSD"Rfy"KLTL|L@CÄET\@U|�b�HcN£AN^d��ER]Q��4_oy^R]TLQV@,D x @­Ù.HJI�dcTLy'|LR]|�T\HcD x dUac@­D x @­QVHJTEQV@CBLD'Hcb*�C@CN{H\F ��@�QCdcT�dcefyMH�QVHJTLy{R]|L@CNPDMNhdcTLy{e]RSDM@CNhd�D{RSHJTLy�9@CD�}*@C@UT,D x @.XZTL[Je]R]y x dcTL| �PN{@C@CØ,dceSB x d��9@CD{yC×�D x @UT�QV@CN{D{dcR]T,eS@CDMDM@CN^y©Þ{KLyMD¬|\HJT � DÌI­d�B�FZO4RfI­R]e]d�N^e]�c_�O4QCdcTL|ER]TLdUa4R]dcTdceSB x d��=@CD{y*I­d�Øc@'yMHJI­@j|ER]yMD{R]TLQVD{R]HJTLyZD x d�D*D x @jX²T\[Je]R]y x dceSB x d��=@CD�|\H/@Uy�T\HcDC·©G x R]TL@UyM@AdcTL|�O\dcTLyMØ/N^RSDZNhdcR]yM@jyMD{R]e]eHcD x @CNÌBLN{Hc�©eS@UI­yCF¬G�RSB x @CNhyZ��R¡F�@cFS_ �MyM@UQVN{@CD�QVH4|\@Uy�z� d�N{@�dce]yMHAN{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyC_Jy{R]I�B©eS@ZR]T"D x @URSNÌR]T\BEK\DodcTL|"HJKLDMBEK\DdceSB x d��=@CD{yU_/�©K\D.|\@Ue]RS�9@CN^d�DM@Ue]��QVHJI�BEeS@V�ºR]T�D x @UR]N®dceS[cHcN^RSD x I­R]QjQVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVD{RSHJT±F

¶LKLN{D x @CN�@V�4dcI­BEeS@Uy*dcTL|�|\@CD{dcR]e]y*d��9HJK\D²D x @PyM�4yMDM@UI­d�D{RfQAHcN^[JdcTLRS�Ud�D{RSHJTmHcb y{R][JTLy²d�N^@P|LRfy{QCKLy{yM@U|(e]d�DM@CNU_4�EK\D*RSDy x HJKEe]|,T\Hr}É�[email protected]@Ud�NZD x d�DZdcT­dcI«�ERSD{RSHJKEyÌ@UTzDM@CN{BEN^R]yM@�R]yÌ�9@UR]T\[jBLN^HcB=HJy{@U|±_cD{d�Ø/RfT\['d�}®R]|L@�RfTzDM@CN{BEN{@CD{d�D{RSHJT,Hcb9D x @T\HcD{RSHJT�Hcb y{RS[JT�_�dcTL|�DMN{@Ud�D{R]T\[iy{RS[JT�y{�/yMDM@UI�y²dcTL|(D x @URSN*I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yÌ}®R]D x [cN{@Ud�D*N^RS[cHcNUFA*AHr}*@Cac@CNU_\�9@UQCdcKLyM@AD x R]y@UT�DM@CN{BLN^R]y{@"R]y®y{D{R]e]e�d�DjdcT�@Ud�NheS�ºyMD{d�[c@c_9HJK\NA@V�\dcI�BEe]@Uy®QCdcTLT\HcDP�9@'�9HcD x QVHJI�B©eS@V��dcTL|�|\@CD{dcR]eS@U|±FE*AHcBER]T\[�D x d�DN{@Udc|\@CNhyZ}®Rfe]e4bgHcN^[JRSac@®D x @jdcI«�ERSD{RSHJT(dcTL|­@��9N{HJT�DM@CN{�­Hcb�QVHJI«�ER]TLR]TL['y{KLQ x |LRSac@CNhyM@.@UeS@UI�@UT�D{yC_4¯¬dcQ{Ø4T\Hr}AeS@U|\[c@jD x @ 25476�<W6aHJK�Pq6��7>YNEU7G�6�<A4):�RQ47G�:=RY4�HLH3476a:�NEUkPY8WHV>�OvH+\7F7HA<WF7\7H3G�6EUkPQ:�O�HAH34�>HAH34)6�P�8WIwNEPY83U)47:�<WNE<`RQP :�OsH3476aPQU7UkPQ<W:CH36�@7:C836�DMH3:=PYO

gt83PYN H3476cN�>�U)<�PYg-NEPv@769G=<�H34�>H?H34769Ia:�O)@7F)D96Qp�H34):�<?@7F�>�G�:�H�Ia:�<�6��7U7G=>Y:�O)6b@�>H >YO�>�\)<ZHW8V>�D9H5G�6���69G�\�I�H34)6 H3476�PY8WI�PYg':�O)<ZH3:CH3F7H3:�PQO7<"! #%$'& ]\)F0H :�< K�6�G�GjPYF7H3<W:=@76`H3476`<WD�PQUk6AP�g H34):�< U�>�Uk698bl

Page 6: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

|\@C@CBºR]TL|L@C�LDM@U|LT\@Uy{yZHcb�D x R]y²}*HcN{Ø­DMH�RSD{y*BLN{@UQV@U|\@UT�D{yC_\dcTL| x HcB9@ADMH x drac@jD x @ x @UeSB(Hcb N{@Udc|\@CN^y*Hcb�D x RfyZBEd�B9@CN�R]T|\@Cac@UeSHcB©R]T\[�RSD{y�B9HcDM@UT�D{R]dce¡F

����� ��! � ��� ����� "���� !)(��£PT�dc|\@UË�KEd�DM@­y{K\N{ac@C��Hcb*N{@Ue]d�DM@U|�}*HcN{Ø�R]T�y{@UI­RSHcD{R]QCyC_�QVHc[JTERSD{RSac@�y{QCRS@UTLQV@c_oe]R]T\[JKLRfyMD{R]QCyC_=KLyM@CN�R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@­|L@Uy{RS[JT±_e]RSDM@CNhd�N{�mQVNhRSD{R]QCR]y{I�_\@CD{Q�FE}*HJKLe]|�QVHJTLy^KLI�@"I­dcT��ºacHJe]KLI­@UyCFL��@ x dUac@idceSN{@Udc|\�ºI�@UT�D{RSHJT\@U|�D x @'}*HcN{Ø�Hcb+!¹@URSN^QV@# %'&)(9dcTL|mO4dcKEy{y{K\N{@w#��)%^(ª_z} x HJy{@AR]T �©K\@[email protected]]y¬B9@CN{a�dcy{RSac@c·�D x R]yZ�LN^RS@Cb9y{K\�Ey{@UQVD{RSHJT�HJTLeS��yMØc@CD{Q x @Uy�d'b�@C}�@UyMB9@UQCR]dcefeS�QCeSHJyM@Ue]� N{@Ue]d�DM@U|�RSDM@UI­ymHcb'I�HcN{@�N{@UQV@UT�D(a4R]T�D{d�[c@cF ¶ÌRSN^y{D(R]y'Þ°HJRfTzD(}²HcN{Ø�}®RSD x �oR]TL|\@��=@C[JKET�I�HcN{@�D x dcT â ��c@Ud�N^yid�[cH$# z#� (ª_¹} x RfQ x QVHJT�D{dcR]TLy«D x @�yM@C@U|Ey'b�HcN"D x @�I�dcR]T�R]|\@Udcy"Hcb�D x R]y�BEd�B9@CNUFm£ATEdceSHc[JRS@Uy"dcTE|�ÄEeS@­TEdcI�@Uy}*@CN{@Py{D{KL|LRS@U|���� �j@UTzD{T\@CN # â %k(±dcTL|ºG�d�N{N{HJefec# � (9N{@UyMB9@UQVD{RSac@UeS�c_4KLy{RfT\["yM@CD��ª�Edcy{@U|�bgHcN^I�dce]R]y{I­y�D x d�D�QCdcTmQCd�BED{K\N{@yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@c_4�EK\D²}®RSD x HJK\D�d��\RSHJI­yC_\eS@Cac@Ue]y*HcN�QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDMHcN^yC·©O4dcQ^Ø/y � @CD x T\HJI�@CD x H4|\HJeSHc[JR]QCdce9T\HcD{R]HJT(Hcb��MQCd�DM@C[cHcN{�yM�4yMDM@UI � #�� z (²yM@C@UI­y«y{R]I­R]efd�NPDMH�HJK\N"T\HcD{RSHJT�Hcb�y^RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UIº_¹�EK\D'R]yjac@CN{��R]TLbgHcN^I�dce¡F ��@��EKLRfe]|�HJT�}²HcN^Ø�HcbQVHc[JTLRSD{R]ac@�efR]T\[JKLR]y{D{y � d�ØcH��Ì_ �cH x TLyMHJTidcTL|"HcD x @CN^y�# %���(4HJTiI­@CD{d�B x HcN^yC_JdcTE|«¶LdcKEQVHJTLTLRS@CN¬dcTL| v K\N^T\@CN � y @V�4QCR]D{R]T\[BLN{HcB9HJy{dce¹Hcb*�EeS@UTL|ER]T\[���dcefyMH�QCdce]eS@U| �MQVHJTLQV@CBLD{KEdceZR]T�DM@C[cN^d�D{RSHJT��z�Pdcy"d�b�KLTE|LdcI�@UT�D{dce¹QVHc[JTERSD{RSac@�HcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJT�b�HcNI�@CD{d�B x HcNU_4[cN^dcI­I­d�NU_4@CD{Q�F;# âcâ _ âvz (ª·LyM@C@�dce]y{H #�� � (ªF�O x T\@UR]|L@CN^I­dcT #�� �k(9R]y�d«[cH�H4|�DM@V�4DM�=H/HcØ­HJTºKLy{@CN*R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@|\@Uy{R][JT±_JdcTL|­áAHcN^I­dcT # % � (L[JRSac@UyZdj[cH/H/|­Hrac@CN{a4RS@C}�Hcb=�LN{HJdc|L@CNZ|\@Uy{RS[JT�Rfy{y{K\@UyCF � d�DMHJK\Nx# % 3 (L[JRSac@Uy�d'b�dcy{QCRfTLd�D{R]T\[QCdcyM@�yMD{KL|L�­Hcb |\@Uy{R][JT�@UI�B x dcy{RS�UR]TL['D x @�R]I�B9HcN{D{dcTLQV@AHcboyMH4QCR]dce=QVHJTzDM@V�4DC_EdcTL|u# 3�� (�QVHJT�D{dcR]TLy�d,T�KLI«�9@CN²HcboQCdcyM@yMD{KL|ERS@Uy�R]T�D x @®d�N{@Ud'Hcb�QVHJI­BEK\DM@CN²y{�/yMDM@UI�yZ|\@Uy{R][JT±F¹£PTL|\@CNhyM@UT # z ( x dcyZ|\HJTL@®yMHJI�@.b�dcy{QCR]TEd�D{R]T\['}*HcN{Ø�d�BLBEeS�4R]T\[yM@UI­R]HcD{R]QCy.dcTL|�QCd�D{dcy{DMN{HcB x @'D x @CHcN{��DMH­D x @"|\@Uy^RS[JT�Hcb¹RfTzDM@CN^dcQVD{R]ac@«yM�4yMDM@UI­yCF

���� ����� ! ( ����������� "���!��O4d�BER]N�y{dcR]| �������h���6���C�«�*�S�^��� · x @¬}*dcyoN{@Cb�@CN{N^R]T\[�DMHAD x @�b�dcQVD D x d�D¹T\H.[cN^dcI­I�d�D{R]QCdcezyM�4yMDM@UI x dcy�@Cac@CNÌy{KLQCQV@Uy{y{b�KLefeS�QCd�BLD{K\N^@U|ºd,N{@Udce±TLd�D{K\N^dce9e]dcTL[JKLd�[c@c_\�EK\D�RSD�R]y�TLd�D{K\Nhdce©DMH�[c@UTL@CN^dce]RS�C@ x R]y�y{e]Hc[JdcT�DMH�D x @�bgHcNhI­dce]RS�Ud�D{RSHJTmHcbÌdcTz�QVHJI�BEe]@V��TLd�D{K\N^dcePy{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UIºF v.x @CN{@�d�N{@�dceS}�dU�4y �MeSH�HJy{@�@UTL|Ey�4·�yMHJI�@�|\@C@CB�N^@UdcyMHJTLy(bgHcN�D x R]yU_ x dUa4R]T\[DMHÃ|\H�}ARSD x D x @�yMH4QCR]dce�TLd�D{K\N^@mHcb�QVHJI­IiKLTLRfQCd�D{RSHJT±_²d�N^@�|LR]y{QCKLy^yM@U|�R]T # z4â (ªF v.x KLy,}*@�QCdcTLT\HcD­@V�4B9@UQVD�HJK\NyM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q'I�H4|\@Ue]y®DMH(�9@'B9@CN{b�@UQVDCF�*®H }²@Cac@CNr_9d�BLN{@UQCR]y{@«|\@Uy{QVNhRSBLD{RSHJT�D x d�DjR]yAyMHJI�@C} x d�DA}.N{HJT\[(R]y.�9@CDMDM@CNPD x dcTd�|L@Uy{QVN^RSBLD{R]HJT�yMH�a�d�[JK\@�D x d�DiT\H�HJT\@(QCdcT�DM@Ue]e²RSb*R]D � y'}.N{HJTL[\F ��@(|LH�T\HcD«y{@C@CØ�DMH�bgHcNhI­dce]RS�C@�dcQVD{KEdceZe]RSa4R]T\[I�@UdcTLRfT\[JyC_��EKLD«N^d�D x @CN�DMH�@V�/BLN^@Uy{y,HJK\N,BEd�N{D{R]dce�KLTE|\@CN^yMD{dcTL|ER]T\[JyiI�HcN{@�@V�4dcQVD{e]�cF$!ZN{@UQCR]y{RSHJT�R]y,dce]y{H�TL@C@U|\@U|DMHº�EKLRfe]|�QVHJI�B©K\DM@CN�BLN{Hc[cN^dcI�yAD x d�D'KLyM@,D x @,D x @CHcN{�cFi¯®|\HºT\HcD��9@Ue]RS@Cac@iD x d�D�I�@UdcTLRfT\[ºR]T�D x @ x KLI�dcT�y{@UTLyM@QCdcT��9@�QCd�BLD{K\N{@U|��/��b�HcN^I­dce¬y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yU· x Hr}*@Cac@CNU_ x KLI�dcT�dcTEdceS�/y{D{yPQCdcTÃT\HcDM@,D x @�@V�/DM@UT�D�DMHº} x RfQ x D x @I�@UdcTLRfT\[Jy�D x d�DAD x @C�ºyM@C@«R]T�yMHJI�@"y{R][JT�yM�4yMDM@UI d�N^@'BLN{@UyM@CN^ac@U|��/��|ER��=@CN^@UTzD.N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyCF v.x KLy�}*@"yM@C@CØDMHÃb�HcN^I­dcefRS�C@�BEd�N{D{RfQCKLe]d�N�KLTE|\@CN^yMD{dcTL|ER]T\[Jy,Hcb'dcTLdceS�4yMD{yC_�}®R]D x HJK\D­QCe]dcR]I�R]T\[�D x d�Dmy{KLQ x KLTL|L@CN^yMD{dcTL|LRfT\[Jy�d�N{@T\@UQV@Uy{y^d�N^R]eS�mQVHcN{N{@UQVDC_EHcN x dUac@iyMHJI�@'Ø4R]TL|mHcb¬R]|\@Udce !²e]d�DMHJTLR]Qj@V�\R]yMDM@UTLQV@cF

� $���� !�������� �)� � ��� "�-v.x @ºBEN{H�Hcb�y­R]T £ABLB9@UTL|LRS�¦»w}²@CN^@�BLN{H a/R]|L@U| ��� �PN^R][cHcN{@�Ù.H"!y^K±_*dcTE| D x @��Edcy^R]Qº|\@CÄETLR]D{RSHJTLyi}²@CN^@�}²HcN^Øc@U|HJK\D®RfTºQVHJe]e]d��9HcN^d�D{RSHJT�}®R]D x �PN^RS[cHcN^@'Ù.H"!y{K�dcTE|�Ù$#d��Ca�dcT�?jR]dcQVHJTL@Uy{QCK±FZ¶LKLN{D x @CN®N^@Uy{KLeSD{y�HJT �/ ��QVHJe]R]I­RSD{y�y x HJKLe]|@Cac@UT�D{KLdce]eS��d�BEB=@Ud�N�R]Tmd«y{@CBEd�N^d�DM@jBEd�B9@CNUF̯¬}®R]y x DMH,D x dcT\Ø�D x @�yMD{KL|L@UTzD{y*R]TmI"� � R]T�DM@CN â &k& � QCefdcy{y.G.O4X z#�/âHJTmKLyM@CN�R]TzDM@CN^b�dcQV@j|\@Uy{RS[JT�_zb�HcN²D x @UR]N²BEd�D{R]@UTLQV@c_�@UT�D x KLy{R]dcy{I�_/dcTL|mË/K\@UyMD{RSHJTLyUF¹¯�dcefyMH"D x dcTLØ �jR]e]eS@Uy²¶LdcKLQVHJTLTERS@CNU_��dcy{d�ØcH *PRSN^d�[Jd4_²dcTE| ��d�N{Ø v K\NhT\@CN,bgHcN�D x @UR]Nia�dce]KLd��©eS@mQVHJI�I�@UTzD{y­HJT�@Ud�N^e]RS@CN�|\N^d�b�D{yiHcb®D x Rfy«B©d�B=@CNr_ZdcTL|��R]Q x d�@Ue�Ù.@U|L|L�Ab�HcN R]T�DM@UTLy{RSb��4R]T\[�I"��R]T�DM@CN{@UyMD RfT�I�@CD{d�B x HcNU_�dcy�¯9y{K\B9@CN{a4R]yM@U| x Rfy ! x ?�D x @Uy^R]y±d�D D x @²`ATLR]ac@CN^y{RSD¨�HcbZG x R]QCd�[cH\F

Page 7: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

� �«Ö��AÏ������EÐ�� �

O4RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­y�KEy{KLdce]eS� x dUac@­d�QCe]dcy{y{R]ÄEQCd�D{RSHJT�Hcb²y^RS[JTLyjR]T�DMH�QV@CN^D{dcR]T nUÅEq prn�� _�dcTE|�y{HJI�@�N^KLeS@UyPb�HcN�QVHJI"�ERfTLR]T\[y{RS[JTEy®HcbZd�BEBLN{HcBLN^Rfd�DM@iyMHcN^D{yADMH�[c@CD�d�T\@C} y{RS[JT�Hcb²dcT\HcD x @CN�yMHcN^DC·±}²@�QCdce]eoD x @UyM@,N^KLe]@Uy®D x @ tJÅ=¿ nCp q �otcprÅ©q n HcbD x @�y{�/yMDM@UI�FºG*HJTEyMDMN^KLQVDMHcN^y"I­dU� x drac@ ƹsLq�sEÂÃÁ�prÁ/q n F�¶\HcNi@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_od �MQCd�D��y{R][JT�HJTÃd�QVHJI­BEK\DM@CN«y^QVN{@C@UTI­dr� x dUac@PBEd�N^dcI�@CDM@CNhyZb�HcN²D x @Ay{RS�C@AdcTL|�eSH4QCd�D{RSHJT�Hcb�RSD{yZK\BEB=@CN²eS@CbgD x dcTL|­QVHcN^T\@CNr·/Q x dcT\[JR]T\[«D x @UyM@Aa�dce]KL@UyZ|\H/@UyT\HcD®Q x dcT\[c@'D x @"R]|\@UT�D{RSD��mHcb¹D x @"QCd�DCF

G*HJTEyMDMN^KLQVDMHcN^y¬I�dU� x dUac@�} x d�D¬}²@.QCdcefe Æoq�½�ÅEq�½fp6À ×Ìd Æoq�½�ÂÃsLq À�tJÅ©¿onCprq � tJprÅEqjx dcyÌ[cN{@Ud�DM@Uy{D�BLN^RSHcNhRSD��=· nUÁ/t��Å©¿c,¹sLqrÀ QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDMHcN^y x dUac@'eS@Uy{y*BLNhRSHcN^RSD¨�­D x dcT�D x @jBLN^RfI­d�N{�­QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDMHcN��EK\D�I�HcN{@jD x dcTºdcT��(TLHJTT�ªBLN^R]I�d�N{�HcNZT\HJT ��yM@UQVHJTL|Ld�N{��QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDMHcNU· prÁ�q p ½�sLq À QVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVDMHcN^yC_z@CD{Q�F�bgHJefeSHr}ÉD x @.y{dcI�@.BEd�DMDM@CNhT±FA!�N^RSHcNhRSD��iR]y�d §4�c�6���¡���HcN^|\@CNhR]T\[\_�TLHcD*DMHcD{dceªF�X¬�4B=@CNhR]I�@UT�D{yZHcb��jHc[JK\@UT�dcTL|"�oR]TL|\@ # z#� (���DM@UyMD{R]T\[,y{K\�4ÞM@UQVD{y�d�bgDM@CN�IiKLeSD{R]I­@U|LR]d'R]TEyMDMN^KLQQ�D{RSHJT�RfT�a�d�NhRSHJKLy�b�HcN^I­d�D{y«d��=HJKLD'd�y{R]I�B©eS@,@UeS@UQVDMN{HJTLR]Q�|\@Ca/RfQV@ �jy{K\BLB9HcN{DjD x @ x �/B9HcD x @Uy{R]yjD x d�D«D x @�N{@UdcyMHJTER]T\[|LR]y^QVHJK\N^yM@jD��/B9@"# 3kz ( x dcyAd,BLN^R]I�d�N{�(QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDMHcN®D x d�D®QVHJT�ÞMHJR]TLy�N{@UdcyMHJTEy.y{K\BLB9HcN{D{RfT\[id�yMD{d�DM@UI�@UT�D��cF

O/@UI�RSHcD{R]QCyiy x HJKLe]|�bgH4QCKLy«HJTÃD x @�yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@�Hcb.y^RS[JT¦y{�/yMDM@UI�y"N^d�D x @CNiD x dcTÃHJT �Jµ�³/�r� BLN{HcB9@CN{D{RS@Uy'Hcb®R]TT�|LRSa4R]|LKEdce¬y{RS[JTLyidcTL|¦D x @URSN,yM@CDMD{R]T\[JyC_=Þ{KLyMDidcy,I�H/|L@CN^TÃ�©RSHJeSHc[c��b�H/QCKLy{@Uy"HJT�I�HJeS@UQCKEe]d�Niy{DMN^KLQVD{K\N{@Uyie]RSØc@m?jáA£N^d�D x @CN�D x dcT(HJT�|\@Uy{QVN^R]BLD{RSac@AQCefdcy{y{RSÄEQCd�D{R]HJT�y{Q x @UI�@UyCFZ¶LHcN*@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_/b�HcN^I­dcefRS�UR]T\['D x @ x dcTE|\}.N^RSDMDM@UT(eS@CDMDM@CN �Mdk���HcNjD x @,yMB9HcØc@UT�y{HJKLTL| �Md x �z�AR]T�RfyMHJe]d�D{RSHJT±_=R]yA�=HcD x b�d�N x d�N^|\@CNjdcTL|�eS@Uy{yPKLyM@Cb�KLe�D x dcT�b�HcN^I­dce]R]�UR]T\[­N{@Uefd�D{RSHJTLy�9@CD�}*@C@UT�}.NhRSDMDM@UTºeS@CDMDM@CN^yAdcTL|º}*HcN^|Ly"��HcN.B x HJT\@UI�@Uy.dcTE|�yMB9HcØc@UTº}*HcN^|Lyh�hF

¯ D�R]yÌTLd�D{K\N^dce4DMH�D x R]T\Ø"Hcb=d�y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UIYdcy¬d�y{@CD¬Hcb=y{R][JTLyC_c[cN{HJK\B9@U|,R]T�DMH'yMHcN{D{y�dcTE|�eS@Cac@Ue]yC_JT\HcD�TL@UQV@Uy{y{d�N^R]e]�|LR]y�Þ°HJR]T�DC_�}®R]D x �MQVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVDMHcN���b�KLTLQVD{RSHJTEy'd�D'@UdcQ x eS@Cac@Ue�D x d�D"�EKER]e]|�T\@C} y{R][JTLy�b�N{HJI HJe]|�HJT\@UyCF�»*KLD"y{KLQ x dyM@CD��ª�Edcy{@U|ºd�BLBLN{HJdcQ x |\H�@Uy�T\HcD�QCd�BLD{K\N^@PD x @AHcB9@UTLT\@Uy^y²Hcboy{RS[JTmyM�/y{DM@UI­yC_4D x d�D�D x @CN{@�I­RS[ x D*�=@PHcD x @CN�y{RS[JTEyZ}*@|\HJT � DP�c@CD�Ø4T\Hr}Yd��9HJK\DC_9HcN x dUac@UT � D�}*dcT�DM@U|�DMHºR]TLQCe]KL|L@c_©�9@UQCdcKLyM@i}*@,d�N^@,dce]}*dr�/y�R]T�acHJeSac@U|�R]T�QVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVD{R]T\[HJTLeS� §4�c�6���¡��� KLTE|\@CN^yMD{dcTL|ER]T\[JyCF±¯ DoR]y D x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@ZBEN{@Cbg@CNhd��EeS@�DMHAa/RS@C}Èy{RS[JT«yM�/y{DM@UI­yodcy ��³4�^���h�ª�6� D x dcT«dcy BLN^@��ª[JRSac@[email protected] x @CHcN{@CD{R]Q�Hc�4ÞM@UQVD{yCF v®x R]y�I�HcD{RSa�d�[email protected] x @'bgHJefeSHr}®RfT\[\×� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿��Lu £ nr½�¾©¿�nCÀ�nCprÁ4Â�� QVHJTLy{R]y{D{y�Hcb¨×

â F®d�yM@CD � Hcb nUÅ©qrprn bgHcNAy{RS[JTLyC_\T\HcDAT\@UQV@Uy{y{d�N^RfeS�(|LRfy�Þ°HJRfTzDC·z F®d­BEd�N{D{R]dce9HcN^|L@CN^R]T\[,HJT � _LQCdce]eS@U|ºD x @ n�� l¹nUÅEq p N^@Ue]d�D{RSHJT�dcTL|�|\@UT\HcDM@U|���·3 F®d�yM@CD��YHcb ,¹s\prs�nrÅEq prn _Lb�HcN®R]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{R]HJTºd��=HJKLD.y{RS[JTLyC_Ly^KLQ x dcy®QVHJeSHcN^yC_Ee]H/QCd�D{RSHJTEyC_LdcTL|ºDMN^KLD x a�dce]KL@UyC·%\F®d«BEd�N{D{RfdceLHcN^|\@CNhR]T\['Hcb y{HcN{D{yZ�/� Ú�Á �=Á/Ú _4y{KLQ x D x d�D�|Ld�D{diyMHcN{D{y�d�N{@PeSHr}*@CN�D x dcT(y^RS[JT�yMHcN^D{yC_\dcTL|�y{KEQ x D x d�D

D x @CN{@"R]y�d­KETLR]Ë/K\@Py{HcN{D.Hcb¬I­d��\R]I­dce±eS@Cac@Ue¡_LQCdcefeS@U|ºD x @ prÅ©Æ�nrÅEq p ·�/F®dÈyM@CD�����Hcb'eS@Cac@Ue! tJÅ©¿onCprq �otcprÅEq�n KLyM@U|�DMH¦�©KLR]e]|Ée]@Cac@Ue! y^RS[JTLy(bgN{HJI y{RS[JTLy(d�Dme]@Cac@Ue]y" HcNme]@Uy{yC_

dcTE|¦}®N^RSDMDM@UT$#�×&% �(')')' %+*-, ��')')' ,/.�� %z_ZR]TL|LRfQCd�D{R]T\[�D x d�D�RSD{y10�D x d�N^[JKLI�@UT�D,IiKLyMD x drac@�yMHcN{D2%+3¨_�RSD{y54JD xB©d�N^dcI�@CDM@CNA|Ed�D{d­yMHcN{D!,-6c_LdcTL|�RSD{y�N{@Uy{KEeSD�yMHcN{D®R]y7%z·LQVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{y�8o× �9%"d�N^@"dce]yMH­dce]e]Hr}*@U|±·

� F®d Æoq�½�ÅEq�½fp6À ��BEd�N^D{R]dceg� ÅEq),¹Á�q�½�¿ ¾ HJTº@UdcQ x ���E·� F®y{HJI�@'N{@Ue]d�D{R]HJTLy�dcTL|ºb�KLTLQVD{RSHJTEy�HJT�y{RS[JTLyU·LdcTL|� F®d�yM@CD!: HcbÌy{@UTzDM@UTLQV@Uyi��R]TºD x @'y{@UTLyM@'HcbÌeSHc[JR]Qr�h_EQCdcefeS@U| s<; ½�ũ¦n _\D x d�DAQVHJTLyMDMN^dcR]T�D x @'B9HJy{y{RS�Ee]@Py{R][JTLyCF

=��@iQCdcT�R]efe]KLyMDMN^d�DM@�yMHJI­@"BEd�N{D{y®HcbÌD x R]y.|\@CÄ©TLRSD{RSHJT�}®R]D x d�ac@CN{��y{RfI�BEeS@ �����­�­���«µJ��� y{R][JT�yM�4yMDM@UIºF*¯¨D x dcy

Þ{KLyMDZHJTL@AyMHcN{DC_\TLdcI­@UeS�,D{R]I�@c_4dcTL|�Þ{KLyMD²D�}*HiQVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVDMHcN^yU_/HJTL@®D x @jQVHJTLyMD{dcT�D²D{RfI�@�����bgHcN�I­Rf|LTLRS[ x Dh�h_zdcTL|(D x @HcD x @CN.d,y{KLQCQV@Uy^yMHcN�HcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJT>%J_4} x @CN{@Ab�HcN�diD{R]I�@@?h_A%/�B?M�²R]y²D x @�T\@V�4D�I­R]T/K\DM@cF v.x @CN{@jd�N{@�T\H�y{K\�Ey{HcN{D{yC_4|Ld�D{dyMHcN{D{yU_EeS@Cac@Ue]yC_\HcN®BLN^RSHcN^R]D{RS@UyCFÌ»*KLD.D x @CN{@"Rfy�HJT\@"R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D�d��4R]HJIº_

% � � ��C �B?{�EDF?�GHJI�6`@06�G�:=\k6M8V>�H36�GCIx>��QPQ:=@�H3476 NEP�836 g >�NE:=G�:=>�8 K�PY8V@ X�HJI0Uk6�[d\k6�Db>�F)<W6`:CH 4�>�<54�>Y@�<WPdN�>YO�I�@7:��^698369OvH5F)<W6�< :�O_D�PQNEU7F7H3698 <WD9:=69O)D�6Ql

254)6A<WP�Db>YG�G�6b@qU�>8WH3< PYg <WUk6�69DM4q:�O�<ZI7O�HV>��']0<WF7DM4 >�< O)PQF7Oq>�O�@1�Q6983\-]7>�836+PYO)6`6��7>�NEU)G�6`PYg�<WP�8WH3< :=O�H34)6`<W6�O7<W6`H34�>H;K�6A:�OvH369O�@'lK 25476aU783:�N�>8WI D�PQO7<ZHW83F)D9H3P�8APYg5>�RY: �Q6�O�@0:�<WD�PQF083<W6�HJI0Uk6L:=<A:CH3<qXJ@769g�>YF7G�H3[xD�PQO7<ZHW83F)D9H3P�8b]j: l 6Ql�]-H3476�D�PYO)<ZHW83F7D9H3PY8+>�<W<WF)NE6b@ K 4)69O

H34)6M836A:=<;O)P�6��0U)G�:�D�:CH N�>83y�698 :�OqH34)6`H36��vHbl�,JO�O�>�8W8V>H3:2��6Q]k:Cg�PQO76A<W6�O�H36�O)D96`g�PQG�G�PbK <A>YO7PYH347698cK�6L>Y<W<WF)NE6`H34769I�>�836+D�PYO)O)69D9H36b@x\�Ix>LNM+O/PQM+RQS�M D9PQO)<ZHW83F7D9H3PY8bp7H34):�< :�<cD�>YG�G�6b@�H34)6�TVUXWJWYUXZ)[]\X^`_�Wa^cbad�_e_+fXba[gZ)[hf�T ! ikj%& l

Page 8: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

} x @CN^@�% � � ��C R]TE|LR]QCd�DM@Uy â %k%���d�BEBEe]R]QCd�D{RSHJTEy�Hcb %z_\HcN®I�HcN^@'BLN{HJy{dcRfQCdce]eS� � _% � � ��C � �z� D � '

v.x @Uy{@"d��4R]HJI­y®QCd�BLD{KLN{@"D x @iQV�/QCefR]Q'TLd�D{K\N^@'Hcb¬D{R]I�@'H ac@CN�d�|Ldr�©·9dcTz��N{@Udcy{HJTLd��EeS@«N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT�bgHcNPD{R]I�@'Hcb|Ldr��IiKLyMD.y^d�D{R]yMb��(D x Rfy�QVHJTL|LRSD{RSHJT�F`� @CD � y®|\@UTLHcDM@'D x R]y.y^RS[JTºyM�4yMDM@UI����2��F

£PT�@V�\dcI�BEeS@«R]e]e]KLy{DMN^d�D{R]T\[�yMHJI�@"b�K\N^D x @CN.BEd�N{D{yAHcb¬?P@CÄETLRSD{RSHJT â R]y.d z %(e]RfT\@���� � �mQ x d�NhdcQVDM@CNj|ER]yMBEe]dr��b�HcNd,y{R]I�B©eS@ � �g�=���°�c�h�ª�V�E���^µ�����J�Z�^µ����ª�c� F v.x @jI­dcR]TmyMHcN{D{y*HcboR]T�DM@CN{@UyMD x @CN{@jd�N{@c×� ��������b�HcN.Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CNV�h_���� ���L_4dcTL|� ������� � F v.x @(yMHcN{D� ����� x dcyiD�}*H�R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�Diy^K\�EyMHcN{D{yU×�� �"! �#�"� $&% ��dceSB x dcT/KLI�@CN^RfQr��dcTL|(')!���¦��yMB9@UQCR]dceg�h·dcTL|*� �"! �#�"� $&% x dcy«y{KL�EyMHcN{D{y+���"! �#��dcTL|,��$�% F�£PI�HJT\[�D x @(yMB9@UQCR]dce�Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^y�y x HJKLe]|��9@�Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^yib�HcNyMBEdcQV@(dcTL|�BEKLTEQVD{KLd�D{RSHJT±_�R]TEQCe]KL|LR]TL[(QVHJI­I­d4_oB9@CN^RSH4|±_±@CD{Q�F v.x @,y^K\�EyMHcN{D�N^@Ue]d�D{RSHJTLy�R]T�acHJeSac@U| x @CN{@ x dUac@(D x @b�HJe]eSHr}AR]T\[,[cN^d�B x _

��#�-�. /

� �"!����"� $&% '�!���. /

� �"!���� � $&%

} x @CN^@�Hcb*QVHJK\NhyM@�� �"!�����dcTE|0� $&%�d�N^@­dce]yMH�y{K\�©yMHcN{D{yjHcb1��#�-�=F v.x @UyM@­y{HcN{D{y x drac@�eS@Cac@Ue]y'RfT�d�TLd�D{K\N^dceÌ}�dU�=×� ������� � R]y*D x @�I�HJyMD�R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzD*dcTL|mD x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@)2 x dcy�eS@Cac@Ue â _���� ��� x dcy�eS@Cac@Ue z _���#�-� x dcy�eS@Cac@Ue 3 _�� �"! �#�"� $&%dcTL|3')!��4 x drac@AeS@Cac@Uei%\_/dcTL|�� �"! �#�"dcTL|5��$�% x drac@PeS@Cac@Ue �­��HcN*}²@PQVHJKLe]|�[JRSac@Pdce]eLy{KL�EyMHcN{D{y¬Hcb6 �����,eS@Cac@Ue�%\_/HcN@Cac@UT 3 ·zy{KLQ x Q x HJR]QV@UyÌQCdcT«�=@*d.�ER]Dod�N{�ER]DMN^d�N{��KLT�D{R]ecD x @C�"d�N^@²b�HcN^QV@U|«���'yMHJI­@*|\@CÄ©TLRSDM@Zd�BLB©e]R]QCd�D{RSHJT©�hF v.x @CN{@*d�N{@a�d�N^RSHJKLy¬Q x HJR]QV@Uy²bgHcN�D x @®QVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVDMHcN^y¬Hcb9D x R]y¬y{R][JT­yM�4yMDM@UIºFZO4R][email protected]]T\@UyÌd�N{@®yMDMNhR]T\[JyÌHcb±Q x d�NhdcQVDM@CN^yC_/HJT\@®Q x HJR]QV@R]y�dcT�HcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJT�7�D x d�DZQVHJTLQCd�DM@UTEd�DM@Uy�d'Q x d�NhdcQVDM@CN*}ARSD x d'e]RfT\@�DMH'[c@CD�d'eSHJT\[c@CN*e]R]T\@c_JdcTL|(dcT\HcD x @CN²HcB=@CNhd�D{RSHJT±_dce]yMH�|\@UT\HcDM@U|*7�_¬D x d�D,QVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�DM@Uy�d�e]RfT\@�dcTL|Èd�}AR]TL|\H } DMH�[c@CD,dcTLHcD x @CN,}®R]TL|\H }'·¬D x @CN{@�IiKLyMD«dcefyMH��9@QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D'QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDMHcN^yjb�HcN�D x @,@UI�BLD���e]R]T\@idcTL|�D x @,@UI�BLD¨��}®RfTL|\Hr}"F�� v®x @�QVHJTLyMDMN^dcR]T�D{yjHJT�D x @�eS@UT\[cD x yAHcbe]R]TL@Uy�dcTL|�}®R]TE|\Hr}®y�d�N^@­[JRSac@UT��/��d��4R]HJI­y�D x d�D"d�N^@�|LR]y{QCKEy{yM@U|��9@UeSHr}"Fß� ¶\HcN«@UdcQ x yMHcN{DC_¹D x @­QVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�D{RSHJTHcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJTLy x dUac@'BEN^RSHcN^RSD¨��H ac@CNAD x @'QVHJTEyMD{dcTzDAHcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJTLyCF

v.x R]yÌ@U|LRSDMHcNZdcefyMH x dcy ,¹s\prsºnrÅEq prn b�HcNZÄ\�4@U|­|Ld�D{d'D��/B=@UyZD x d�D²d�N^@®KLyM@U|­RfT�dcT�dcK4�\R]e]R]d�N^�'}*dr�­R]T�|\@Uy{QVNhRS�ER]T\[RSD{y*y{RS[JTLyU×oD x @Uy{@AR]TLQCefKL|\@.d�D�eS@UdcyMD*D x @ATLd�D{KLN^dceET/KLI«�=@CNhyC_�dcTL|(B9HJy{y{RS�©eS�«QVHJeSHcNhyC_�b�HJT�D{yC_�@CD{Q�FS_L|L@CB=@UTE|LR]T\[�HJT(D x @QCd�BEd��ERfe]RSD{RS@Uy�}*@"}�dcT�DADMHm[JRSac@iHJK\NAe]R]DMD{eS@'@U|LRSDMHcNrF.¶LKLTLQVD{RSHJTEyAR]TEQCe]KL|\@ � ������� � �"� 8&��dcTL| � � �4��� � � �"��9 8��±_LdcTL|D x @CN{@iQVHJKLe]|�dce]yMH­�9@'BLN^@U|LR]QCd�DM@UyAbgHcNAD x @«y{KL�EyMHcN{D{yC_©y{KLQ x dcyAd:� $&%����#� ,BLN{@U|ER]QCd�DM@'HJT�Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CNhyCF v.x @UT�D x @QVHJTLyMDMNhdcR]TzD{y.HcbÌe]@UT\[cD x QCdcTº�9@�@V�4BLN{@Uy{yM@U|����mD x @'b�HJe]eSH }®R]T\[�d��\RSHJI­yC×

�<;>=�×?�4�����z� � � �4��� � �-�&8&�=�@=*� � z %�F�<;BA × � � �4��� � � � � ����� � � �-�49 8��=�CA � � � ��F

��@CDAKLy.|\@UT\HcDM@�D x R]y.y{RS[JTºy{�/yMDM@UIED¥F¯ b�}²@m}*dcT�D"DMH�yMD{KL|L� x H } ����J��� QCdcTÃ�9@�|LRfyMBEe]dr�c@U|�R]T�D x R]y�}®R]TE|\Hr}'_o}²@my x HJKLef|�|\@CÄET\@(d�y{RS[JT¦yM�4yMDM@UI

b�HcN«DM@V�4D{yCF�´�T\@(y{RfI�BEeS@�}�dU��DMH�|\H�D x R]y x dcy«yMHcN^D{y� �����=_ � �����©_F'-�"�48É��yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@ �h_ZdcTL|G8�� H 8©_ÌR]TÃdc|E|LRSD{RSHJTDMH�D x @�|Ld�D{d�yMHcN{D{y(dcTL| D x @�y{KL�EyMHcN{D{y,HcbI �����¦dcy­RfT*D d��9H ac@c·.D x @�yMHcN^D:8�� H&8ÈR]y­eS@Cac@Ue â _1'-�"�48¦e]@Cac@Ue z _� ������e]@Cac@Ue 3 _¹dcTE|*��#����eS@Cac@UeL%\F v.x @CN^@­d�N{@�yM@Cac@CN^dce²Q x HJRfQV@Uy'b�HcN«QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDMHcN^yC_oHJT\@­Hcb�} x R]Q x |\@CÄETL@Uy'dcTz�QVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�D{R]HJT�Hcb¬dceSB x dcT/KLI�@CNhR]QAQ x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^y®DMH­�9@�d�}²HcNh|±_LdcTz��QVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�D{R]HJT�Hcb¹}²HcN^|Ey�DMH­�9@�d�yM@UTzDM@UTEQV@c_dcTL|�dcTz�ºQVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�D{R]HJT�Hcb�y{@UTzDM@UTLQV@UyADMH��9@"d­DM@V�/DCF�� @CDAKLy.|L@UT\HcDM@"D x Rfy.y{RS[JT�y{�/yMDM@UIJ�+KL��F=G�e]@Ud�N^eS�mD x @CN{@d�N{@"I�dcTz��|LR �=@CN{@UT�D�}�dU�4y®DMHm|LR]yMBEefdU��DM@V�4D{yPR]Tºd­}®RfTL|\Hr}"_LdcTL|º@UdcQ x HJT\@"Rfy®d­|LR �=@CN{@UT�D.yM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q'I�HcN{B x R]y{Iº·}*@'}®R]e]e9yM@C@«yMHJI�@�HcbÌD x @UyM@"efd�DM@CNUF

£Ýy{HJI�@C} x d�Di|LR��9@CN{@UTzDiy{RS[JTÈyM�4yMDM@UI¥Rfy"[JRSac@UT¦�/��y{R]I�BEe]@ §4���h�C�^µ��C�C�E���V�=�h�6� _�R¡F�@cFS_¬yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@Uy,}®RSD x D x @URSN�°BEd�N{DjHcb*yMB9@C@UQ x ����HcN�yM�4TzD{dcQVD{R]Q�QCd�DM@C[cHcN^�\�P@V�4BEe]RfQCRSD{eS��[JRSac@UT±F v.x @iI�HJy{DPb�dcI­R]efR]d�N®}�dU��DMHº|\@Uy{QVN^RS�9@«D x @UyM@�R]yBLN{Hc�©d��EeS��}®RSD x d�QVHJTzDM@V�4D,bgN{@C@�[cN^dcI�I­d�N�e]RSØc@�D x d�Di�9@UeSH }'_Ì} x @CN{@NML_PO�Q©_6R�Q©_PO©_PS4�&8=_TR©_6Q Q�dcTE|GQ�y{D{dcTL|b�HcN*yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@c_LT\HJKET­B x NhdcyM@c_�ac@CN^�(B x N^dcyM@c_4T\HJKLT±_/|\@CDM@CN^I­R]TL@CNU_zac@CN{� _�BLN^@CB=HJy^RSD{RSHJTLdce\B x N^dcyM@c_/dcTL|�BEN{@CB9HJy{RSD{RSHJT±_N{@UyMB9@UQVD{RSac@Ue]�©×

U�� Oq>Y@)@7:CH3:�PQO)>YGj>Y<W<WF)NEU0H3:�PQO�H34)>�H :�< 6��0U)G=>Y:�O76b@xG=>�H3698;:�<;O)6�6b@06b@_H3P�<W4)PbK H34)6`6WV�F7: �Y>YG�6�O7D�6`P�g H34)6�<W6`H�K5PE>��7:�PYNE<�lX�2547:�< >�<W<WF)NE6�<5H3476APY8V@76M83:=O7RaPYgT<WPY8WH3<;\vI�G�6��Q6�G'HV>�y�6�<TY+>�< H3476AN�> �0:�N�F7N G�6���69Gfl

Page 9: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

M � � O�Q R QO Q�� � OO Q�� � S���8 OR Q�� � RR Q�� � R Q�QQ Q�� � Q O�Q

���������

v.x @��°BEd�N{D{yÌHcbEy{B=@C@UQ x � M\_ O Q=_ R Q=_r@CD{Q�F�d�N{@*D x @ �V���V��� HcbLD x R]y¹y{RS[JTiyM�4yMDM@UIº_JdcTL|«D x @*N^KLeS@Uy¹d�N{@�RSD{y¹QVHJTLyMDMN^KLQVDMHcNhyCF¶\HcNA@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_\D x @'ÄLNhyMD�N^KLeS@�y{dr�/y®D x d�D®d�yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@iQCdcT��9@�QVHJTLyMDMN^KLQVDM@U|�bgN^HJIÝd:O�Q(dcTL|�d�R Q=F v.x @CN{@'y x HJKLe]|dce]yMH��9@'yMHJI­@"QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{y.HcbÌD x @�a�d�N^RSHJKLy®yMHcN{D{yC_Ey^KLQ x dcy

O�� � 8#�)%#�O�� � ������� �R�� ��� �4�-��'S4�&8�� � � �S4�&8�� � 8����Q�� � �4��4�

�����������

v.x @CN^@'R]y.d­yM�4yMDM@UI­d�D{RfQ�}*dr�ºDMH­a4RS@C} QVHJT�DM@V�/DAbgN{@C@"N^KLeS@Uy�dcy®HcB=@CNhd�D{RSHJTLy�D x d�D"�MQVHJTLyMDMN^KLQVD��D x R]T\[Jy.bgN{HJIÝD x @URSNBEd�N{D{y«��R]TzDMN^H/|LKEQV@U|ºR]T # â �)(��h_E} x R]Q x RfT�D x R]y�QCdcyM@'[JR][email protected] x @'b�HJe]eSH }®R]T\[\×

'"�-��LO�Q R Q�� � M� ��!�LO � � O�Q� ! LO S���8�� � O��� !�LR � � R�Q� ! LR Q�Q � � R�Q! ! LQ O�Q � � Q�Q

���������8#��%�� � � O� �4�-��'� � � R

���������

¯ DjRfyAdºI�HcN^@«@UeS@C[JdcT�D'KLyM@,Hcb�D x @,I�dcQ x R]TL@CN{��}*@ x dUac@­dUa�dcR]e]d��©eS@«DMHºN^@C[Jd�N^|0O�dcyjd�y{K\�EyMHcN^DAHcbFO Q=_=dcTE| R�dcyd�y^K\�EyMHcN{D®HcbTR Q=_LD x dcT�DMH x drac@iI­HJTLdc|LR]Q�HcB9@CN^d�D{R]HJTLy O�� � O�Q�dcTE|NR�� � R Q=F?� @CD � yAQCdce]e D x @"N^@Uy{KLeSD{R]TL[­y{RS[JTyM�4yMDM@UI����ÌF±¯¨D�[JR]ac@Uy�} x d�D�QVHJI�BEKLDM@CN'y{QCRS@UT�D{R]yMD{y�QCdce]e �z�V�6���M�J�U�®�h���E�ª�)� b�HcN'yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_�}®R]D x HJK\D�y{dU�4R]T\[ x H }D x @C��d�N{@'DMH­�9@jN{@Udce]R]�C@U|±FA��@"QCdcTºHcb¬QVHJK\N^y{@'yMD{R]e]e=[c@CD �°N{@Udce �­yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_Ey{KEQ x dcy �°D{RfI�@ �ERS@Uy�efRSØc@�dcT�d�N{N{H }_�4_�EK\DiD x R]yiDMN^dc|ERSD{RSHJTLdce*e]R]T\@Ud�Nib�HcN^I b�dcRfe]y"DMH�y x Hr}wD x @ºyM�4TzD{dcQVD{RfQºyMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@c_�} x R]Q x Rfy«D¨��B©R]QCdce]eS�Ã|LHJT\@mKEy{R]T\[DMN{@C@UyC_©dcy®R]T

M. /

O Q R�Q. . /

O R Q�Q. � . /

8��)%�� � �4�-��' Q O Q. . /

�4����� �"� ��� �4� �

&

Page 10: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

£PT\HcD x @CN�d�BLBLN{HJdcQ x R]yPDMH�a/RS@C} d�yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@­dcyjd$�°DM@CNhI �ºR]T�acHJeSa/RfT\[�D x @iHcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJTLyjd��9Hrac@���DM@CNhI­yjd�N{@�QVHJI �B9HJy{RSD{RSHJTEy²Hcb¬QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDMHcN^yh�h· x @CN{@ � y x H } HJK\NAe]RSDMD{eS@�yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@«e]H�HcØ4y�R]T�D x d�D®TLHcD{d�D{RSHJT±×

'-�-��� 8��)%���� � !�� � �4�-��'���!�!�� �4������� ��!�� �"��� ��� �4� ������ FO/HÈQCdce]eS@U|��LN^dcQ{Øc@CD���HcN��LN^dcQ^Øc@CD��ª}®RSD x ��y^K\�Ey{QVN^R]BLDh��T\HcD{d�D{R]HJT±_®dcy�KLyM@U|�R]T�efR]T\[JKLR]y{D{R]QCyC_�dce]yMH�y x Hr}Ay(yM�4T�D{dcQVD{R]QyMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@c·LRSD.R]y�y^K\N{@UeS�md��ERSD x d�Nh|\@CN�DMH­N{@Udc|±_©dcTL|ºeSH/HcØ/y.efRSØc@�D x R]yC×

# # ? 0 ����(���# #����B0�� %�(���# # �B0�����(��+# # �/ 5(�� � !�# �/#-##"%$�(�� (��&�?(����(�����(('(F��£PT\HcD x @CN*@V�4dcI�B©eS@®Hcb9�LN^dcQ^Øc@CD�T\HcD{d�D{RSHJTmd�BLB9@Ud�N^yZR]TmO/@UQVD{RSHJT"%��hF¬¯ T�D x R]yZy{@CDMD{R]T\[\_/}²@PQCdcT(dce]y{H«KLyM@®@UË�KLd�D{R]HJTLyDMHi@V�/BLN^@Uy{y²QVHJTEyMDMN^dcR]T�D{y*HJT(yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_4b�HcN�@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_�D x d�D²D x @PT�KEI"�9@CN*Hcb±D x @Py^K\�4ÞM@UQVD²dcTL|(Hcb�D x @Aac@CN{�ºd�[cN{@C@��R¡F�@cFS_L�9HcD x d�N^@'y{R]T\[JKLefd�N�HcN.�9HcD x d�N{@�BEe]KLN^dceg�hF

X²dcQ x Hcb*D x @UyM@­QVHJTLQVN^@CDM@­}*dr�/y'DMH�N{@Udce]RS�C@�d��Ey{DMN^dcQVD'yM�4TzD{d��É��DMN{@C@UyC_oDM@CN^I­yC_��EN^dcQ{Øc@CD"TLHcD{d�D{RSHJT±_ dcTL|�efR]yMD{yh�QCdcT��=@�QVHJTLy{R]|\@CN^@U| DMHÃ[JRSac@�d �­�Uµz�C� Hcb�D x @�y^RS[JTÉyM�4yMDM@UIº_�BLN^Hra4R]|LR]T\[�d �C�C� Hcb'y^RS[JTLy�b�HcN�@UdcQ x y{HcN{DC_.dcTL|HcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJTLy"HJT�D x HJy{@�yM@CD{y«} x R]Q x �EKLR]ef|�TL@C}¤y{RS[JTEy�bgN^HJI HJe]|�HJTL@UyCF ��HJKÃI­RS[ x D x drac@(@V�4B9@UQVDM@U|�D x Rfy'DMH��9@D x @º|\@CÄETERSD{RSHJT¦HcbAy{RS[JTÈyM�4yMDM@UIº_*R]TLyMDM@Udc|ÈHcb®} x d�D,}²@�[JdUac@c_*} x RfQ x R]y,d � ���/�#)L�U��� b�HcN�D{dceSØ/RfT\[�d��9HJK\D,y{KLQ xI�H4|\@Ue]yCFj´jK\Njy{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI­yAd�N^@ ��³\�{���6�¡�V� Nhd�D x @CNjD x dcT�I­H/|\@UefyCF v.x @«|LR]y{D{R]TLQVD{RSHJT�Rfy®D x d�DjdmI�H/|L@Ue BLN^Hra4R]|\@UyQVHJTLQVN{@CDM@ ���E���C�ª§©�{�C�ª�J�������L� bgHcN�D x @iD x R]T\[JyjR]T�D x @,D x @CHcN{�=×PyMHcN^D{y�d�N{@­R]T�DM@CN{BLN{@CDM@U|�dcy�yM@CD{yC·oQVHJTLyMD{dcT�D'yM�/I«�9HJe]yd�N{@PR]TzDM@CN^BLN{@CDM@U|�dcyZ@UeS@UI�@UT�D{yC·\QVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVDMHcN^yZd�N{@PR]T�DM@CN{BLN{@CDM@U|(dcy�b�KLTLQVD{RSHJTLyU_J@CD{Q�F v.x Rfy�dce]eSH }®y�IiKLQ x �L@V�\RS�ER]e]R]D��b�HcN.} x d�D.QCdcT��=@'d�I�H/|L@Ue¡F��@�HcbgDM@UT�}®R]y x DMH¦@V�4QCefKL|\@�I�H4|\@Ue]y,} x @CN{@�D¨}²HÈ|LR��9@CN{@UTzD�DM@CN^I­y�|L@UT\HcDM@�D x @�y{dcI�@�D x R]T\[\·�HcD x @CN{}AR]yM@c_

b�HcN"@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_¹D�}*H�|ER��=@CN^@UTzD'D{RfI�@Uy'Hcb�|Ldr��I­RS[ x D'�9@­N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzDM@U|ÃD x @(y{dcI­@�}�dU�+*�F v®x R]y'R]y"QCdce]eS@U|�D x @ ¿oÅtJÅ=¿-, � nr½�Å=¿ QVHJTE|LRSD{RSHJT±·�I­HcN{@,BLN{@UQCR]yM@Ue]�c_9R]Djy^dU�4y�D x d�D'RSb�D¨}²H�DM@CN^I­y�QCdcTLT\HcD��9@iBLN{H ac@U|�@UË�KEdce¬KLy{R]T\[md��4R]HJI­yR]T¦D x @mD x @CHcN{�c_�D x @UTÈD x @C�¦I«KLy{Di|\@UTLHcDM@m|LR �=@CN{@UT�Di@UeS@UI�@UT�D{yiRfTÃD x @�I�H4|\@Ue¡F�£AefyMH�R]D«R]y«HcbgDM@UT |L@Uy{RSN^d��Ee]@­DMHN{@UyMDMNhR]QVD�DMH,I�H/|L@Ue]y¬} x @CN^@Adce]eLy^RS[JTLyZd�N^@A|\@UT\HcDM@U|(�/�iDM@CNhI­y²RfT�D x @URSN²D x @CHcN{�=·/D x @UyM@Ad�N{@PQCdce]eS@U|�D x @ q�Á�sEt�ÇosLlÌÚgÁI�H4|\@Ue]y � C F�£PT­R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D¬B9HJR]TzD¬�EN{HJK\[ x D�HJK\DZR]T,D x @®T\@V�4DZyM@UQVD{RSHJT(R]y¬D x d�D*yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q�I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y¬|\H�D x @Py{dcI�@QVHJTLQV@CBLD{KEdce�}*HcN{ØmdcyAI�H4|\@Ue]yC_4�EK\D.RfTºd,}*dr�ºD x d�D®R]y�I�HcN^@"QVHJTzac@UTERS@UTzD®bgHcN®I�dcTz��BEK\N^B=HJy{@UyCF

¯ D x dcyj�9@C@UT�y x H }®T�D x d�D'dcT���QVHJI�B©K\D{d��EeS@�I�H4|\@Ue¬QCdcT��9@�|\@CÄET\@U|�KLy^R]T\[mHJTLeS��@UË/KLd�D{RSHJTEy�dcy'd��4R]HJI­y �b� Fv.x @CN^@CbgHcN{@�}²@�eSHJyM@�T\HÃ[c@UTL@CN^dce]RSD¨� ���ÉKLy^R]T\[�@UË/KLd�D{RSHJTLdcePeSHc[JR]Q�bgHcNm@V�\dcI�BEeS@UyC_.dcy x dcy(�9@C@UT�dc|\acH4QCd�DM@U| R]TD x @�y{RSD{KLd�DM@U|�d��EyMDMNhdcQVDm|Ld�D{d¦D��/B9@�d�BEBLN{HJdcQ x |\@Uy{QVNhRS�9@U|�R]T # z ��(ªF ��HcN{@�BLN{@UQCR]yM@Ue]�c_*HJKLN(@V�\dcI�BEeS@Uy���R]T�D x @d�BLB9@UTL|LRfQV@Uyh�.KEyM@,HcN^|\@CN�yMHcN{DM@U|�@UË/KLd�D{RSHJTLdce¬e]Hc[JR]QiHrac@CN"d�Ä\�4@U|�|Ld�D{dºdceS[c@C�LNhdu# â�� _ z &)(ª_�dceSD x HJK\[ x D x @iN^@Udc|\@CN|\H/@Uy.T\HcD®TL@C@U|ºDMH­�9@�b�dcI�R]e]R]d�N�}®RSD x D x @�DM@UQ x TLRfQCdce]RSD{RS@Uy�Hcb¹D x R]y®eSHc[JR]Q�F

owner

rideown

boat

resident owner

house

live-in own

passenger

¶¹R][JK\N{@ â × v }*HmO4RfI�BEeS@'G*HJTLQV@CBLD{KEdceoO/BEdcQV@Uy

� x d�D�¶LdcKLQVHJTLTERS@CN'dcTL| v KLN^T\@CN # â �\_ âvz (�QCdce]e tJÅ©¿otJÁ/Æ p��osEÚAnUƹsLtJÁ/n d�N{@�dce]yMHºy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yC_9Hcb*d(Nhd�D x @CNy{R]I­BEeS@PØ/R]TE|±_�} x @CN{@jD x @CN{@'d�N{@���KEy{KLdce]eS�L�ZT\H�QVHJTLyMDMN^KLQVDMHcNhy�@V�4QV@CBED®QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{yC_EdcTL|�} x @CN{@�R]T�dc|L|LRSD{R]HJT±_4D x @CN{@d�N{@�y{HJI�@�N{@Ue]d�D{R]HJTLy�|\@CÄET\@U| dcI­HJT\[�D x @UyM@�QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{yCF v �/BER]QCdce�QVHJTLQV@CBLD{KEdce®yMBEdcQV@Uy�d�N{@�e]RSDMD{e]@ºD x @CHcN^RS@Uy�Hcb. �?F7H;<W6�6`H34)6FY #�4)PYF78;>�O�>YG�PYRED�G�P�DMy�836�U78369<W6�O�HV>�H3:�PQO @06�O)P�H36b@0/ \k6�G�PKA]7K 4)69836`H347:�<Eb ^a^�1 bcH3Pa4�>�U)Uk6�O'l1�2b2547:�< :=<;>�G=<WP�Db>YG�G�6b@_H347643576983+: D�PQO)@7:CH3:�PQO'l�,�H :�< O)PbK >�Ox:�O�H369836�<ZH3:�O)Rd6��06983D�:�<W6 H3P�U083P���6cH34)>�H H34)6;HJK�Pa@7:��^698369OvH56WV�F�>�H3:�PYO)<U7836��0:�PYF)<WGCIxRY:2��6�O�gtPY8c6��0U7836�<W<W:�O7R�H34)6`DMI7D9G=:�DAO)>�H3F7836AP�g�@)>�I0< >�836+6WV�F7: �Y>YG�6�O�H5gtPY8;836b>YDV4�>�\)G�6ANEPv@769G=<�l1W1 � GCH34)PQF7RQ4_>YO_>Y@)@7:CH3:�PQO)>YG�H36�DV4)O7:�Db>YGkD�PYO�@0:�H3:�PYO_D�>YG�G�6b@_:�O7:�H3:=>�G=:CH�I�:=<�O)6�6b@06b@'pv<W696 ! $<; &kg�PY8 >+<WF08 ��69I�PYg'H34):�< >YO)@�836�G=>�H36b@E836�<WF7G�H3<�l

â �

Page 11: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

yMHJI�@�@Cac@CN{�/|EdU��QVHJTLQV@CBLDC_ÌR]TLQCe]KE|LR]T\[(HJTLeS��dcy"IiKLQ x |L@CD{dcR]e�dcy'R]y"T\@C@U|\@U|�DMH�dcTEdceS���C@(yMHJI�@­BEd�N^D{R]QCKLe]d�N�DM@V�4DCF¶\HcN­@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_Zd�D x @CHcN{�ÃHcb x HJKLyM@Uy�I�RS[ x D x drac@�QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{y5���"$ '"�E_ � � �����ÃdcTE|G�4��'&�-���-�48©_Ì}®RSD x N{@Uefd�D{RSHJTLy� � �mdcTE|3��� � � �4���(I­d�Ø4R]T\[,D x @jHc�/a/R]HJKLy�dcy{yM@CN{D{R]HJTLyCFZO4R]I­Rfe]d�N^eS�c_/d«�9HJd�D�D x @CHcN^�(I­RS[ x D x dUac@'QVHJTEyMD{dcTzD{y�������8©_� � �����(dcTL|�!���'�'"�-�49��&�©_�}®RSD x N{@Ue]d�D{R]HJTLy � � ��dcTL|L�#�-���EF v.x @UyM@jD�}*H�yMB©[email protected]�N{@'R]e]efKLyMDMN^d�DM@U|mR]Tº¶ÌRS[JK\N{@ â F�áAHyMHcN{D{yAd�N{@«y x Hr}®T�_E�EK\D�b�HcN®D x R]y®y{RfI�BEeS@j@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_©HJT\@"R]y®@UT\HJK\[ x _=y{dU���&��� ��9EF v.x d�D®d�N{@Ue]d�D{RSHJT�y{KLQ x dcy � � �9_x HJe]|Ey HcbLD¨}²HjD x RfT\[JyoRfy [JRSac@UTi�/�"dPe]R]T\@*R]T"D x @²ÄL[JKLN{@c_cdcTL|«RfT"D x @�QVHcN{N{@Uy{B=HJTE|LR]T\[®e]Hc[JR]QCdce/D x @CHcN{�"R]yo[JRSac@UTi�/�"dcTd��\RSHJIº_J@cF�[\FS_�� � ��� � � ������� ���-$>'-� � F9¯ DÌRfy¬KLy{KLdce]e]�'dcy{y{KLI�@U|iD x d�D¬N^@Ue]d�D{RSHJT,R]TLyMD{dcTEQV@UyÌD x d�D�d�N{@.T\HcD¬y x H }®T���y{KLQ xdcyF���-���4�������-8�� � � ���&� � � |\H«TLHcD x HJe]|�_zR¡F�@cFS_4d�N{@Ab�dce]yM@i��HJT\@A}�dU��DMH"b�HcN^I­dce]RS�C@AD x R]yC_z} x R]Q x R]yZN{@Ue]d�DM@U|(DMH«D x @PyMHQCdce]eS@U| �6�°�c�­��§=�°�z�C�S�C� R]Tid�N{D{RSÄ©QCR]dce4R]TzDM@Uefe]RS[c@UTLQV@c_cR]y¹[JRSac@UT�R]T­G x d�BLDM@CN � Hcb # z 3 (��hFA��@CD�KEy¹QCdcefe�D x R]y¹D x @ ,oÁ,�s �¹Úgp¿oÁ�¾©s\p ½�Å©¿ dcy^y{KLI�BLD{R]HJT±F�»�K\D«y{HJI�@CD{R]I�@Uyi} x @CD x @CN«HcN�T\HcD,d�N^@Ue]d�D{RSHJT x HJe]|LyiI­dU���9@mKLT\Ø4T\Hr}®T�F *AKEI­dcTLy[c@UT\@CN^dcefeS��|\Hºd�[cH/H/|(ÞMHc��Hcb²ÄL[JKLN^R]T\[mdce]e¹D x R]yPHJK\DC_�KLy{RfT\[(} x d�D�R]yjQCdce]eS@U| �MQVHJI­I�HJT�y{@UTLyM@v�4Fs*AHr}*@Cac@CNU_¹D x @|\@U|LKEQVD{RSHJTLy®RfTzacHJeSac@U|�QCdcT�dcQVD{KLdce]eS�º�9@«@V�/DMN{@UI­@UeS��QVHJI�BEeS@V�9·±yMHJI�@ x R]T�D{y.Hcb�D x R]y®QVHJI�B©eS@V�4R]D���I­dr���9@"b�HJKLTL|R]T�D x @«|LR]y{QCKLy^y{RSHJT(Hcb¹D x @��EeS@UTL|LRfT\[«@V�\dcI�BEe]@Uy.R]T�O/@UQVD{RSHJT �/F

¶\HcNhI­dce]R]y{I+dcTL|�N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJT�b�@Ud�D{K\N{@�R]T�IiKLQ x N{@UQV@UT�D�}²HcN^Ø�R]T�y{H/QCRSHJe]Hc[c�ÉHcb'y{QCRS@UTLQV@c_A}®RSD x I­dcTz�b�dcy{QCR]TLd�D{R]TL[�@V�\dcI�BEeS@UyCF�¶\HcN�@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_5�od�DMHJK\N # % z (�y x H }®y x Hr} N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJT��/��QCd�N{DMHc[cNhd�B x R]Q,I­d�BEyP}�dcy@Uy{yM@UT�D{R]dce\b�HcNZX²K\N{HcB9@UdcT�QVHJeSHJTLRS�Ud�D{R]HJT±_zdcTL|­»*H }²@CN^yq# � (©|LRfy{QCKLy{yM@Uy¹D x @®B=HJefRSD{R]QCy¹Hcb©b�HcN^I­dcefR]y{Iº_JR]TEQCe]KL|LR]TL[������yM�4yMDM@UI­yCF+�od�DMHJK\N®eS@[email protected]{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTºKLTL|\@CÄ©T\@U|±_/} x R]eS@P»*Hr}*@CN^y x dcy�d�y^e]RS[ x D{eS�­b�HcN^I­dce±T\HcD{RSHJT�HcbobgHcNhI­dce��R]y{I�F¹¯Z�=@UefRS@Cac@AD x d�D�y^KLQ x |LR]y^QCKLy{y{RSHJTEyZQVHJKLe]|m�9@®[JR]ac@UT�[cN{@Ud�[email protected]{@UQCRfy{RSHJT­�/�(KEy{R]T\[«D x @jbgN^dcI­@C}²HcN{Ø�BLN{HcB9HJyM@U|R]T�D x Rfy�BEd�B9@CNUF

� ���� Ö{Ò.Ð9Ö^Õ� ÒAÑ�����Ö�� � �

v.x @�BEKLN{B9HJyM@�Hcb=yM@UI�RSHcD{R]Q�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y � / R]yÌDMH'BEN{Hra4R]|\@�dj}�dU�,DMH"|\@Uy{QVNhRS�9@²D x @.I­Hrac@UI�@UT�DP��I­d�BEBER]T\[\_cDMN^dcTEy{e]d)�D{RSHJT±_�R]TzDM@CN^BLN{@CD{d�D{RSHJT±_cN^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT©�oHcb9y{RS[JTLy¬RfT,HJT\@.yM�4yMDM@UI~DMH'y{RS[JTEy¬R]T,dcT\HcD x @CNZyM�4yMDM@UIºF v.x R]yÌR]y¬R]T�DM@UTL|\@U|DMH­R]TLQCefKL|\@AI­@CD{d�B x HcN^y�dcy�}*@Ue]e9dcy�N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLy�R]TmD x @'I�HcN^@Pb�dcI­R]efR]d�N*[email protected]]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@'|L@Uy{RS[JT�yM@UTLyM@cF,�j@UTT�@CN^d�D{R]TL[�d�[cH/H4|�R]QVHJT±_±ÄEeS@�TLdcI­@c_�@V�/B©e]dcTLd�D{RSHJT�HcN'I�@CD{d�B x HcNU_�HcN'd�N{N^dcTL[JR]T\[�DM@V�/D'dcTE|�[cN^d�B x R]QCyPDMHc[c@CD x @CNiR]TdcT�d�BLBLN{HcBLNhR]d�DM@"}�dU�c_9@UdcQ x RfTzacHJeSac@UyPI�H a/R]TL[(y{RS[JTEy®b�N{HJIÝHJTL@iyM�4yMDM@UI¼DMH�dcT\HcD x @CNUF �JKLyMDAdcyA}*@,|\@CÄET\@U|�y{RS[JTyM�4yMDM@UI­y�DMH��9@jD x @CHcN^R]@Uy�N^d�D x @CN.D x dcTºI­H/|\@UefyC_\yMH�D x @URSN.I�HcN^B x R]y{I�y²d�N{@��9@CD¨}²@C@UTºD x @CHcN^RS@UyC_\DMN^dcTEy{e]d�D{R]T\[ib�N{HJID x @ �S����� )\�r��� Hcb²HJTL@�y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI DMHºD x @�e]dcT\[JKLd�[c@�Hcb�dcT\HcD x @CNr_oR]TLy{DM@Udc|�Hcb�Þ{KLyMDjDMN^dcTLy^e]d�D{R]T\[�D x @­QVHJTLQVN^@CDM@y{RS[JTEy"R]T�D x @(I�H4|\@Ue]yCF v.x R]y'I­dr��yMHJKLTL|¦d��ERSD«R]TL|LRSN^@UQVDC_ �EK\D«RSD x dcy«R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D"dc|\a�dcTzD{d�[c@Uy,H ac@CN�d�I�H4|\@Ue�EdcyM@U|�d�BLBLN{HJdcQ x ·EI�HcN{@CH ac@CNU_ED x @CHcN^[email protected]|�D x @URSN.I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�|\@CDM@CNhI­R]T\@'I�H4|\@Ue]y�dcTE|ºD x @URSN.I­d�BEBER]T\[JyCF

£¼[cH/H/|�yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q�I�HcN{B x Rfy{I y x HJKLef|�BLN{@UyM@CN{ac@�dcy�IiKLQ x Hcb�D x @�yMDMNhKLQVD{K\N{@�RfTÉRSD{y­yMHJKLN^QV@�y{R][JTÉyM�4yMDM@UIdcy�B9HJy{y{R]�EeS@cFÈG*@CN^D{dcR]TLeS�ÃR]D,y x HJKLe]|�I­d�BÉyMHcN^D{y,DMHÃyMHcN{D{yC_*y{K\�Ey{HcN{D{y,DMH�y{K\�Ey{HcN{D{yC_Z|Ld�D{d�y{HcN{D{y�DMH�|Ld�D{d�y{HcN{D{yC_QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{yiDMH�QVHJTLy{D{dcTzD{yC_�QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVDMHcN^y"DMH�QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVDMHcN^yU_o@CD{Q�F�»�K\DiRSD'D{K\NhTLy�HJK\D«D x d�D«R]TÃI­dcTz��N^@Udce�}*HcN^e]|@V�\dcI�BEeS@UyC_²T\HcD,@Cac@CN{��D x R]T\[�R]yiBLN{@UyM@CN^ac@U|±F�O/H�D x @Uy{@�IiKLyMD�dce]e*�9@ §4���V�����c� I�d�BEyCFã®�4R]HJI­y,y x HJKLe]|�dce]y{H��9@BLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@U|�� �EKLD.d�[JdcR]T�R]T�BLNhdcQVD{R]QV@c_EyMHJI�@CD{RfI�@Uy®T\HcD.dcefe�d��4R]HJI­y.d�N{@�BLN^@UyM@CN{ac@U|±F� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿��9u �jRSac@UT�y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­y � � G � / _�d nUÁ4ÂȽgÅEp ½�t ÂÃÅ©q ÆÌÇo½�nrÂ × � � � � / _�bgN^HJI � � DMH � / _QVHJTLy{RfyMD{y�Hcb¹D x @'b�HJe]eSHr}AR]T\[,BEd�N{D{R]dce9b�KLTLQVD{R]HJTLy'��dce]e�|\@UTLHcDM@U| �h×

â F®y{HcN{D{y.Hcb � � � yMHcN^D{y�Hcb � / _z F®QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVDMHcN^y®Hcb � � � QVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVDMHcN^y.Hcb � / _LdcTL|3 F.BEN{@U|LR]QCd�[email protected]|ºb�KETLQVD{RSHJTLy�Hcb � � �+BLN^@U|LR]QCd�[email protected]|�b�KLTEQVD{RSHJTLy�Hcb � / _y{KLQ x D x d�Dâ F®R]b %�� %��9D x @UT�¤�Y%�� � �Y%��f�h_z F®R]b 8¹×7% �e')')' % * � %,R]y®d(QVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVDMHcN,��HcNjb�KLTLQVD{RSHJT©��Hcb � � _ED x @UT���RSb¬|\@CÄET\@U|=��¤� 8U�©× �Y% � � ')')' �Y%+*J� � �Y%���R]y�d­QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDMHcNi��HcNAb�KETLQVD{RSHJT©�ZHcb � / _

3 F®R]b��«×�% �(')')' % *�R]y*d'BLN{@U|ER]QCd�DM@®Hcb � � _/D x @UT���RSb±|\@CÄET\@U|=� ���9�©× �Y% � � ')')' �Y%+*c�ZR]yZd«BLN{@U|LRfQCd�DM@®Hcb � / _\dcTL|1�m � GCH34)PQF7RQ4_H34)6 83P�P�H�X�NEPY83U74)[LPYgTH3476`O)PYF)O X�NEPY83U74):�<WNE[dNE6�>YO)<EX g�P�83Nq] [dH34):�<5K5P�8V@x4�>�<5836�D�6�O�H3GCI�>YG�<WPE\k6�D�PYNE6`> ��6M83\_H34)>�HNE6b>�O)<EX�H3P�DM4)>YO)RY6`g�P�83Nql [

âcâ

Page 12: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

%\F� R]y�D x @"R]|\@UT�D{RSD��mHJT�dce]e±y{HcN{D{y.dcTL|ºHcB9@CN^d�D{R]HJTLy�b�HcN®|Ld�D{d­R]T � � F��HcN{@.[c@UT\@CN^dcefeS�c_zd�yM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q�I�HcN{B x R]y{I QCdcT�I­d�B­yMHJKLN^[email protected]�4yMDM@UIYQVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDMHcN^yZdcTE|,BLN{@U|LR]QCd�DM@Uy�DMH'QVHJI�B9HJKLTL|DM@CN^I­y®|\@CÄET\@U|ºR]T�D x @'D{d�N{[c@CDAy{�/yMDM@UI � ��F =£ yM@UI­RSHcD{RfQ'I�HcN{B x R]y{I � � � � / [JRSac@Uy®N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyAR]T � / b�HcNAy^RS[JTLy.R]T � � F²¯ bo}*@"Ø4T\H } x H } d­yM@UI�RSHcD{R]QI�HcN{B x R]y{I I­d�BEymQVHJTLyMDMN^KLQVDMHcNhyC_®D x @UT�}*@�QCdcT QVHJI�B©K\DM@ x Hr} RSDmI­d�BEy�QVHJI�BEeS@V��y{RS[JTLyCF ¶\HcNº@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_®R]b � �4�ED � �BG%¤� � ��D � � G% � 8U�V��� G��L��D 8 �¡��� G���� â ��� â _EdcTL| � ���V��� G��L�ED������ â _LD x @UT

� 8c� � G �¬� 3 G � �M�M� D 8 � � � � G � � � �J��� â F��@­T\H }~QVHJTLy{R]|\@CNjyMHJI�@,@V�\dcI�BEeS@UyUF'¶¹R]N^yMDC_9y{K\BLB9HJyM@«}²@,}�dcTzDjDMH�N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzDjD{R]I�@iHcbZ|Ldr�c_P���&��_9R]T�D x @

e]RSDMD{e]@�}®R]TL|\H }'_�D F4G�e]@Ud�N^eS�iD x @CN{@Ad�N^@®I­dcT���}*dr�/y²DMHi|LH'D x R]yC·�@UdcQ x Hcb±D x @UI I«KLy{DZI­d�B�D x @AyMHcN{DZD{R]I�@®DMH«D x @yMHcN{D¬}AR]TL|\H }'_cI­d�B�D x @.QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDMHcN �jDMH'yMHJI�@.y{DMN^R]T\[jHcb¬��eS@Uy{yÌD x dcT z �J�Ìy{DMN^R]T\[Jy¹Hcb¬��eS@Uy{yÌD x dcT �4â �ÌQ x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^yU_dcTL|�I�d�B�D x @�QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDMHcN«y'DMH�dºb�KLTLQVD{RSHJT�yM@UTE|LR]T\[�@UdcQ x y{KLQ x yMDMN^RfT\[�Hcb�y{DMN^R]T\[JyjDMH�yMHJI�@­HcD x @CN«yMDMN^R]T\[ºHcbyMDMN^RfT\[JyCF v.x @CN^@(R]y{T � D"dcTz�/D x R]TL[�@Ue]yM@(DMH�BEN{@UyM@CN{ac@�R]T�D x R]y'ac@CN{��y^R]I�BEeS@�@V�4dcI�B©eS@­@V�\QV@CBLD,D x @(d��\RSHJIº_Ì} x RfQ xx H }²@Cac@CNjR]y�ac@CN{�ºR]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D x @CN{@cF

Ù®@UQCdce]e9D x d�D�D x @�RSDM@UI­y�Hcb¹d��EyMDMN^dcQVD.yM�4T�D{d��mR]T ���&�¼d�N{@'yMDMNhR]T\[Jy²Hcb¹K\BmDMH â % 3 &L' � y�bgHJefeSHr}*@U|m���mdiy^R]T\[JeS@�4F­´jT\@�y{R]I�B©eS@«N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT(Þ{KLyMD�I­d�BEyjD x @Uy{@­yMDMN^R]T\[Jyj|LR]N{@UQVD{eS��DMH�y{DMN^R]T\[JyPHcb�yMDMN^R]T\[JyPHcb ' � yjB©e]KLyPd�ÄETLdce�4_Ìy{KLQ x D x d�D'D x @­DMHcD{dce*T/KLI"�9@CN�Hcb ' � y"R]yjD x @(y{dcI�@c·ÌD x R]y'Rfy'dºØ4R]TL|�Hcb�KLTLd�N{��T\HcD{d�D{RSHJT±F ��@CD� È�B?{�P�9@�D x @T/KLI"�[email protected]�' � y®R]T�yMHJI�@"D®bgN{HJI �:�2��Fi� @CD��­�B?{��dcTE|��­�B?{�*�9@'D x @"Ë/K\HcD{RS@UT�D®dcTL|�N{@UI­dcR]TL|L@CN®d�bgDM@CNP|LRSa4R]|LR]TL[ ��B?M�"�/� � �4F v.x @UTÈD x @CN{@m}®R]efe��9@����B?M�"e]R]TL@Uy"Hcb � � ' � yibgHJe]e]Hr}*@U|¦�/�ÃHJTL@me]RfT\@�Hcb��­�B?{� ' � y,dcTL|�d�ÄETLdce �4Fv.x Rfy*Rfy�[JKLd�N^dcT�DM@C@U|�DMH�ÄLD.R]TmHJK\N®}®R]TL|\H } �=@UQCdcKEyM@��­� â % 3 &J��D â�� R]y�eS@Uy^y�D x dcT z %\_EdcTL|��­�B?{��� â � � �4FZ¶LHcNx KLI­dcTLyC_\D x R]y�N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJT�R]y.yMH­|\@CD{dcRfeS@U|ºD x d�D.RSD.Rfy.I�HcN{@�HcNPeS@Uy{y�dcTLdceSHc[\×Z¯²D x RfT\Ø(d�b�DM@CN®[c@CDMD{R]TL[­b�dcI�R]e]R]d�N}®RSD x R]DC_Ld�KLyM@CN�}*HJKLe]| x drac@"d �°b�@C@Uef�,bgHcN®D x @'d�BLBLN{Hr�4RfI­d�DM@"T/KLI"�9@CN�Hcb.��D x @UyM@'yMDMNhdcT\[c@ � �­I­RfT�K\DM@ � x HJKLN^y�R]Td�}®RfTL|\Hr} dcTL|ºHcb¬I­R]T/K\[email protected]]T�D x @"e]dcyMD®efR]T\@c_�Þ{KLyMD�b�N{HJI RSD{y®d�BLB9@Ud�N^dcTLQV@cFd� @CDAKLy®QCdce]e±D x R]y.N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT��«F¶ÌRS[JK\N{@ z y x Hr}Ay�D x @�D{R]I�@�D x d�D.}²@"}²HJKLef|ºQCdce]e�� â × â ��B©I ��R]TºRSDCF

����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������¶¹R][JK\N{@ z ×Z£YO/DMN^dcTL[c@ �M`ATLd�N^�j�(G�eSH/Q^Ø

£PT\HcD x @CN�Hc�/a/R]HJKLyj�EK\D�TLdcRSac@,N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT(ÞMKEyMD�|LR]yMBEefdU�4y� ��B?M�PRfT�|L@UQCR]I­dceÌT\HcD{d�D{RSHJT±_ [JRSa/RfT\[mdºy{DMN^R]T\[Hcb â DMH %­|L@UQCR]I­dce9|LRS[JRSD{yUF v®x R]y�R]y*ac@CN{��|LR��9@CN{@UTzD�b�N{HJIwHJK\N.KLy^KLdceEN^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyC·\�©K\D�}²@'QVHJKLef|mRfI­d�[JR]T\@�dQCKLeSD{KLN{@�D x d�DZ|LRSa4R]|\@UyÌRSD{yZ|LdU�4yZR]T�DMH â % � x HJK\N^y�j@UdcQ x�x dra/R]TL[ â ��"I­R]T/K\DM@UyC_z@V�4QV@CBLDZD x @®e]dcyMD x HJK\NU_J} x R]Q x HJTLe]�x dcyx%�����D x R]yPR]yPeS@Uy{yjyMDMN^dcT\[c@iD x dcT�} x d�DP}*@,|LH(}®R]D x HJK\N�I�HJT�D x yC_9}®RSD x D x @URSNPa�d�N{�/RfT\[(T/KLI«�=@CNhy®HcbZ|EdU�4y �ß�hF*A@CN{@� �� �z�AR]y �4_9dcTE| 'jÞ{KLyMDPdc|L|Ly â _9@V�4QV@CBLDjD x d�D5'\� â % 3 &J�7D �4F�¶ÌRS[JK\N{@ 3 y x Hr}®yjË/KLd�N{DM@CN�d�bgDM@CNjHJT\@,R]T�D x @d�b�DM@CN^T\H/HJT�R]T�D x Rfy�N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT±·ED x @"e]dcyMD�D¨}²Hm|LRS[JRSD{y�[JR]ac@"D x @'T/KLI«�=@CN®Hcb¹I­RfT�K\DM@UyU_LdcTL|ºD x HJyM@"DMH­D x @"eS@Cb�DHcbÌD x d�D.[JRSac@�D x @"T�KEI"�9@CN�Hcb � x HJK\N^y��4F+��@CD®KLy®QCdce]e9D x R]y�N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT! ¦F

� & �¶ÌRS[JK\N^@ 3 ×Z£ áPdcRSac@"?jRS[JR]D{dceoG�eSH4Q{Ø

£¼I�HcN{@ºb�dcI­R]e]Rfd�NiN^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTÉR]y�QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVDM@U|Édcy­bgHJe]e]Hr}®yC× � @CD" â dcTE|# z �9@�D x @�Ë/K\HcD{RS@UT�D�dcTL|N{@UI­dcRfTL|\@CN�Hcb� |LRSa4R]|\@U|È��� � �4_��9HcD x R]T �Edcy{@ â �4_�}®RSD x � � ymdc|L|\@U|ÉR]T�b�N{HJT�D�RSbPT\@UQV@Uy{y{d�N{�Éy{H�D x d�D�@UdcQ xx dcy�@V�\dcQVD{eS� z |LRS[JR]D{yCF�á®H } b�HcN^IÜD x @�yMDMNhR]T\[�Hcb*Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^y � O%$ O'&'�4F v.x R]y�RfyjD x @­yMH���QCdce]eS@U| �MI­R]e]RSD{d�N^�j�N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTÃHcb.D{RfI�@c·�eS@CD � yi|\@UT\HcDM@�RSD"�/� YF v.x @UT ¤� �z� D)(*( +(*(L_ÌdcTL|¦Hcb.QVHJK\N^yM@(�cHJK¦Ø4T\H } x H }�'[cH/@UyCFZ¶ÌRS[JK\N{@ %(y x Hr}Ay�HJK\N®KLy^KLdce±d�bgDM@CNhT\H�HJT�D{R]I�@'R]Tºd­y^e]RS[ x D�a�d�N^RfdcTzD�Hcb¹D x R]y�N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT±F1 �b2547:�<c:�< :�G=G�F7<ZHW8V>�H36b@x\�I�,.e.-bh5:�< H3476`6��7>YNEU7G�6 �ZF7<ZHc\k69G=PbK H34):�< @760/�O):CH3:�PQO'l

âvz

Page 13: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

â�3 â �¶ÌRS[JK\N{@ %\×Z£ ��R]e]RSD{d�N{� v R]I�@"G�e]H/Q^Ø

áAHcD{R]QV@(D x d�DiD x R]y'N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT x dcy"�9@C@UTÈ|\@CÄET\@U|¦dcy,d�QVHJI�B9HJy{R]D{RSHJT�Hcb }ARSD x d�N{@��ªN{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJT¦Hcb���&� DMH�RSD{y{@UeSb¨F v.x @(yMB9HcØc@UT�a�d�N^R]dcT�D"Hcb.I�R]e]RSD{d�N{��D{R]I�@ x dcy'D x @(b�HcN^I �� â x KLTE|\N{@U|� z x HJKLN^y�Ã��KLTEeS@Uy{y z D ( (L_*R]T�} x R]Q x QCdcyM@� / R]y,HJI­RSDMDM@U|©�hF v.x @�KLyM@ºHcb � x KLTL|\N^@U|���dcTL| � x HJK\Nhy��I­dU� yM@C@UI H/|E| x @CN{@c_�9@UQCdcKLyM@­RSD�R]y^T � D x KLTE|\N{@U|LyjdcTL|�RSD�R]y^T � D x HJK\N^y � � �EKLDjd�D'e]@UdcyMD'RSD � y'QCeS@Ud�N � dcTL|�D x d�D � y�D x @�B=HJRfTzDCF !Ìd�N{DHcb¹D x R]y�QCe]d�N^R]D��(y{DM@UI­y�b�N{HJIwD x @�B x HJTLHJeSHc[c�©×¬D x @'dcyMBERSN^d�DM@U| � x ��yMHJKLTL|�d�D.D x @��=@C[JRfTLTLR]T\[«Hcbx� x KLTL|LN{@U|��,dcTL|� x HJK\NY�P|LH�@Uy¬T\HcDÌH4QCQCK\N�R]T,dcT��«Hcb©D x @�T�KLI­@CN^dce]yC_JdcTL| x @[email protected]­d�Øc@Uy�dP[cH�H4|�yM@CBEd�Nhd�DMHcNU_z@UyMB9@UQCR]dcefeS��Hrac@CN�Nhdc|LRSH\_} x @CN^@'RSD�[c@CD{y.@V�\d�[c[c@CN^d�DM@U|±F

Ù®@Udc|\@CN^y�y x HJKLe]|�T\H }Ý�9@�d��EeS@ºDMHÃQVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVD�HcD x @CN(N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLy­HcbPD{RfI�@�dcy­yM@UI­R]HcD{R]QºI�HcN{B x R]y{I­yC_R]TLQCefKL|LR]T\[i@Cac@UT�D x @ �MdcTLdce]Hc[^��N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT�Hcb¬d(QCeSH/Q^غb�dcQV@cF�*®@CN{@�� x dcy®�9HcD x�x dcTL|Ey.K\B�_Ey^d�D{R]yMb�dcQVD{RSHJT�HcbD x @�d��\RSHJIwbgHJefeSHr}®y*�9@UQCdcKLyM@�yMHJI­@CD x R]T\[,@Cac@UT�yMDMN^HJT\[[email protected]]y*DMN^K\@c_LTLdcI­@UeS�N'\� �/â &J� D �4_\} x R]Q x R]y*�EKLRfeSD²R]T�DMH,D x @QCRSN^QCKEe]d�N"TLd�D{K\N^@­Hcb�D x R]y'[c@CHJI­@CDMN^R]QCdce²N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT±F v.x Rfy'R]y'dcT¦@V�4dcI­BEeS@­} x @CN{@­T\H�QVHJTLb�KLy^RSHJT�yM@C@UI­y"DMHb�dcR]e � �EK\D�|\H/@Uy®R]D*N^@Udce]eS� � � � ��@CD � yAQCdce]e±D x Rfy�N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT :"F

áAHr}~eS@CD � yjQVHJTLy{Rf|\@CNP|ER]yMBEe]dr�/RfT\[�BEd�N^yM@U|�yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_9b�N{HJI D x @iy{R][JT�yM�4yMDM@UI ���Ì_=RfT�D x @i}®R]TL|LHr} D ·=D x R]yI�@UdcTLy�QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVD{R]TL[,d�y{@UI­RSHcD{R]QjI�HcN{B x R]y{I��~b�N{HJI ����DMH:D¥FE´jT\@�R]y^y{K\@jR]y*BEe]dcQCR]T\[,yMBEdcQV@Uy®yMH�D x d�D�}²HcNh|Lyd�N{@�dceS}�dU�4y(yM@CB©d�N^d�DM@U|±F v®x @�|\@Uy^RS[JT\@CN�}AR]e]e�dce]yMH x drac@�DMH�|\H¦y{HJI�@CD x R]T\[Èd��9HJK\D�}*HcN^|Ly�D x d�D(}�dcT�D(DMHÈ[cHBEdcyMDPD x @i@UTL|�HcbZd�e]R]T\@c·9Q x HJR]QV@Uy�R]TLQCe]KE|\@�}.N^d�BLB©R]T\[�d�N{HJKETL|±_ x �/B x @UTLd�D{RfT\[\_=dcTE|�Ä©e]e]R]T\[­RfT�}®R]D x yMB©dcQV@UyC·±D x @e]R]I�RSD.Hcb z %ºe]RfT\@Uy®}AR]e]e dcefyMH(B9HJyM@,BLN^Hc�EeS@UI­yCF v.x RfyAQCdcT�QCeS@Ud�NheS�º[c@CD'QVHJI�BEeS@V�9F v.x @,|\@Uy{R][JT\@CNPI�dU��dce]yMHm}*dcT�DDMH�QVHJTLy{Rf|\@CN�I�HcN{@ºyMHcB x RfyMD{R]QCd�DM@U| R]y{y^K\@UyC_�y{KLQ x dcy�dcK\DMHJI­d�D{R]QºRfTLyM@CN{D{RSHJTÈHcbPQVHJI­I­dcy�DMH�y x Hr}ÝyMHJI�@�HcbPD x @yM�4TzD{dcQVD{RfQ'yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@cF

��������������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������������

�������������������������������������������������������

�������������������������������������������������������

����������������������

����������������������

�������������������������������������������������������

�������������������������������������������������������landlord

own rent

house

renter

��

owner

useown

object

user

¶ÌRS[JKLN{@ �/×Z£~G*HJTLQV@CBLD{KLdce¹O/BEdcQV@s��HcN{B x Rfy{I

��HcN{B x Rfy{I­y¹Hcb©QVHJTLQV@CBED{KLdceLyMBEdcQV@UyZd�N{@�N{@Ue]d�D{RSac@Ue]�«y{R]I­BEeS@c·c}*@.I­d�B­yMHcN{D{yÌDMH"y{HcN{D{yC_zQVHJTLy{D{dcTzD{y¬DMH«QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{ydcTL|«N{@Ue]d�D{RSHJTEy DMHjN{@Ue]d�D{R]HJTLyC_�yMH�dcyoDMHPBLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@²D x @*yMHcN^D{yoHcb©QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{y¬dcTL|"N^@Ue]d�D{RSHJTLyCFÌ»*@UQCdcKLyM@�dcy{yM@CN^D{RSHJTLyoD x d�DN{@Ue]d�D{R]HJTLy x HJe]|�d�N{@,[JRSac@UT�����d��4RSHJI�yC_9BLN{@UyM@CN{a�d�D{RSHJT�Hcb²d��\RSHJI­yjR]I­BEe]RS@Uy®BLN{@UyM@CN{a�d�D{RSHJT�HcbZD x @�QVHcN{N^@UyMB9HJTL|LR]T\[N{@Ue]d�D{R]HJT�R]TEyMD{dcTLQV@UyC_9B9HJy{RSD{RSac@«HcN�T\@C[Jd�D{RSac@cFj¯¨b²T\Hmd��\RSHJIÜR]yA[JRSac@UT�bgHcN�yMHJI­@«N{@Uefd�D{RSHJT�RfTLyMD{dcTLQV@,R]T�D x @iy{HJK\N^QV@D x @CHcN{�c_¬D x @UTÃ@URSD x @CN«a�dce]K\@�Rfy"B9HJy{y{R]�EeS@c_odcTE|Ãy{R]TEQV@�D x @CN{@�R]y«T\HcD x R]T\[�DMH�BLN^@UyM@CN{ac@c_¬D x @my{dcI�@ x HJe]|Ly"bgHcNiD x @D{d�N{[c@CDAD x @CHcN{�cF v.x @�BEdcRSNhy�Hcb¬QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{yC_EHJT\@"bgN{HJIÝD x @"yMHJK\NhQV@"dcTL|�HJTL@'bgN^HJI¸D x @'D{d�N{[c@CDC_=D x d�D®d�N^@"I­d�BLB9@U|�/�,d«yM@UI­RSHcD{RfQ.I�HcN{B x R]y{I~d�N{@®QCdcefeS@U| tJÅ=¿o¿oÁ/tcprÅEq�n ����¶LdcKEQVHJTLTLRS@CN*dcTL| v K\N^T\@CNx# â �\_ âvz (ªF�¶\HcN*@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_�D x @CN{@R]y²d"QVHJTLT\@UQVDMHcN*b�N{HJI � ������ 8iDMH ���"$ '-�(��D x HJKL[ x }*@ x drac@PTLHcD²|\N^dr}®T­RSDC_/dcy²¶EdcKLQVHJTLTLRS@CN*dcTL| v K\N^TL@CNZ}*HJKLe]|©�hF

£~TLd�D{KLN^dce�D{dcyMØ�R]T�D x @«@V�/B9@CN^RfI�@UTzD{y®Hcb_# z#� (¬R]y.DMH�|\@Uy{QVN^R]�=@�D x @«QVHJTL|LR]D{RSHJT�Hcb¬b�HJK\NAefRS[ x D{yAHJT�D x @«b�dcQV@«HcbdcTº@V�4B9@CN^R]I�@UT�D{dce�|\@Ca4R]QV@cF v.x R]y�R]T�[email protected]{R]T\[­d­y{@UË�K\@UTEQV@'Hcb¬QCe][email protected]�N^N^dcT\[c@U|�R]T�TLd�N{N^d�D{RSac@�HcNh|\@CNU_dcTL|�QCdcT��9@�yM@C@UT�dcy�dºyM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q,I�HcN{B x Rfy{I b�N{HJI¼D x @­y{R][JT�y{�/yMDM@UIÜHcb*e]RS[ x D{yjDMHºD x d�DjHcb*X²T\[Je]R]y x ·±d(D¨��B©R]QCdceyM@UT�DM@UTLQV@"}*HJKLe]|���RfT�BEd�N{Dh� x drac@'D x @'b�HcN^I �°D x @'ÄLN^yMD�e]R][ x D.R]y�HJT�_LD x @"yM@UQVHJTE|�R]y�H��Ì_�FSFSF��4F1 b2547:�O)yE>�\kPQF7H?K 4�I�>LD9G=P�DVyENEPv@7F7G�P�; #��LNE:�RQ4�H?K�PY83yk]v\)F0H`e <3>�I)hiNEPv@0F)G�P Y #��+PY85NEPv@7F)G�PEi����LK�PQF7Gr@EO7PYH5K�PY83ykp�K 4�>H >Y\kPYF7HNEPv@7F7G�P i�������I 4�I���� :�O�HbS D�PYO)<W:=@7698 H3476`D�PQO�H36��vH :�O�K 47:�DM4xH3476 836�U0836�<W6�O�HV>�H3:�PQOx:=< H�I7U7:�Db>YG�GCI_F)<W6b@^l � O)<ZK�6983< H3PdH3476�<W6A6��06983D�:�<W6�<>YU7Uk6b>�8;:�O )v6�D9H3:�PQO�$7l

â�3

Page 14: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

¶\HcN�dcT\HcD x @CNP@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_=dmyMHJK\N^QV@iy{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI¼I�RS[ x DPQVHJTzD{dcRfT�RfTLyMDMN^KLQVD{R]HJTLy�b�HcNAN{@CB©dcRSN^R]T\[(yMHJI�@"B©RS@UQV@«Hcb@UË/KLRSBEI�@UT�DC_E}ARSD x D{d�N{[c@CD�y{R][JT�yM�4yMDM@UI¼d(T\HJT ��QVHJeSHcNA[cNhd�B x R]QCyAy{QVN{@C@UT�BEe]KLy.dmyMB9@C@UQ x Q x RSB�FE��@,QCdcT�D x @UT�dcyMØx H }¢DMH�[c@UT\@CNhd�DM@"R]TLyMDMNhKLQVD{RSHJTLdce9I­d�DM@CN^Rfdce�KLy{R]TL[iD x @UyM@'BEd�N{D{RfQCKLe]d�N.QCd�BEd��ERfe]RSD{RS@Uy�R]T�D x @«I�HJyMD�@��9@UQVD{RSac@"}�dU�cF

O/D{d�N #�� � (�R]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@U|�D x @,T\HcD{RSHJT�Hcb l�Å �o¿c,osEqrÀ ÅEl��rÁ�tcp _=} x R]Q x ��b�HcN�HJK\NjBEK\N{B9HJyM@Uyh��QCdcT��=@,yM@C@UT�dcy�dy{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UIÝD x d�DPR]y.R]T�DM@CN{BLN{@CDM@U|�R]T�|LR��9@CN{@UT�D.}�dU�4y®�/�º|LR��9@CN{@UTzD.y{H/QCR]dce�[cN{HJK\BEyCF v.x @UyM@«R]TzDM@CN^BLN{@CD{d�D{RSHJTLyAQCdcT�9@(yM@C@UTÈdcy,yM@UI­RSHcD{RfQ�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y'bgN{HJI¥D x @�y{RS[JT¦yM�/y{DM@UI¥Hcb�D x @(�9HJKLTL|Ed�N{��Hc�\Þ°@UQVD�R]T�DMH�D x @�I�HcN{@myMB9@UQCRSÄEQy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yjHcb²@UdcQ x [cN^HJK\B�F"¶\HcN�@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_±�ERSN^|�y{RS[ x D{R]T\[JyPd�N{@�D{d�Øc@UT�R]T�|LR��9@CN{@UT�Dj}*dr�/yj�/��dcI­d�DM@UKLN"dcTL|BLN{Hcb�@Uy{y{R]HJTLdceEHcNhTLRSD x HJeSHc[JRfyMD{yC·4D x @jbgHcNhI�@CN.I­d�Øc@'e]R]y{D{yC_�@UI­B x dcy{RS�URfT\[«Nhd�N{@j�ERSN^|Ly*R]Tmb�N^RS@UTL|Le]�,QVHJI­B=@CD{R]D{RSHJTm}®RSD xHcD x @CN¬dcI­d�DM@UK\NhyC_�} x @CN{@UdcyoD x @�e]d�DMDM@CN¬R]TzDM@C[cNhd�DM@*y{R][ x D{R]TL[Jy }®R]D x IiKLQ x e]d�N{[c@CNÌ|Ld�D{dcyM@CD{yÌDMHjQVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVD¹I­R][cN^d�D{RSHJTBEd�DMDM@CN^TEyC_LB9HcBEKLe]d�D{R]HJTº|\@UTLy{RSD{R]@UyC_\eSHJT\[­DM@CN^IÝDMN{@UTL|LyC_E@CD{Q�F*£ y{RS[ x D{R]T\[­I�dU��ÄLN^yMD.d�BEB=@Ud�NAdcy®d�ÄL@Uef|�T\HcDM@C�9H�HcØ@UT�DMN{�c_EdcTL|ºD x @UT�I�Hrac@iR]T�DMH�D x @'D�}*H�ac@CN^�m|LR �=@CN{@UT�D.QVHJT�DM@V�/D{yCF���£ y{R]I­R]efd�N*@V�\dcI�BEe]@'R]y�[JRSac@UT�RfT #�� � (ªFß�

��� � � ( -�" � "�� *,- !�� ��� ����$�� ��� - !� � � * (#��-��"�)" � "#� !��O/@UI­R]HcD{R]Q®I�HcN^B x R]y{I�yZQCdcTm�9@PQVHJI�B9HJyM@U|�·/D x R]y²Rfy²R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzD²�=@UQCdcKEyM@PR]D*R]y²ac@CN{�mQVHJI­I�HJTmDMH�QVHJI�B9HJyM@AN^@CBLN{@��yM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyC_\b�HcN�@V�4dcI­BEeS@c_\R]T(BLN{H4QV@Uy{yM@Uy*HcboRSDM@CNhd�D{RSac@�|\@Uy{RS[JT±_/} x @CN^@P|\@CD{dcRfe]y²d�N^@jdc|E|\@U|�R]T�BEN{Hc[cN{@Uy{y{R]ac@PyMD{d�[[email protected] @AQVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{RSHJT�Hcb�y{@UI­RSHcD{R]Q.I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y¬y{d�D{R]yMÄE@Uy²yMHJI­@Ay{R]I­BEeS@�@UË�KEd�D{RSHJTLyC_�} x R]Q x y x H }�D x d�D*y{RS[JT(yM�/y{DM@UI­yDMHc[c@CD x @CNA}®RSD x yM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y²bgHcNhI¸} x d�D.R]y�QCdcefeS@U|ºd �^�c�����z���6� R]TºI­d�D x @UI�d�D{R]QCyC·Ey{KLN{BLN^R]y^R]T\[JeS�c_JD x R]y�R]y@UT\HJK\[ x DMH�|\@CÄET\@"y{HJI�@«R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzDPQVHJTLQV@CBLD{yPdcTL|�|L@CN^RSac@'D x @UR]NPI­dcRfT�BLN{HcB9@CN{D{R]@Uy"��I«KEQ x I�HcN{@,R]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{RSHJTHJTºD x @«QCd�DM@C[cHcN{�ºHcb¬y{RS[JTºyM�4yMDM@UI­yAR]y�[JRSac@UT�R]Tº£ABLB9@UTL|LRS�(».�hF�jR]ac@UT¦yM@UI�RSHcD{R]Q�I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y × � � � � / dcTL| � × � / � � � _¬D x @UT¦D x @URSN tJũ¦Æ�ÅEn ½fp�½gÅ=¿ _¬} x R]Q x R]y

|\@UT\HcDM@U| � � ·% � × � � � � � _\R]y*bgHcN^I­@U|«ÞMKLy{D²�/�(QVHJI�B9HJy{RfT\[«D x @jQVHJI­B=HJTL@UTzD�b�KLTLQVD{RSHJTLy²Hcb @UdcQ x I�HcN{B x R]y{Iº_T\HcD�b�HcN{[c@CDMD{R]T\[,D x d�D�D x @Uy{@jd�N^@PB©d�N{D{R]dce=b�KETLQVD{RSHJTLyC_4yMH,D x d�D�D x @jN{@Uy^KLeSD²Rfy*dcefyMH,BEd�N{D{R]dce¡F¬¶\HcN®@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_4D x @�yMHcN{[email protected]�KLTLQVD{R]HJT�bgHcN� ·% �9Rfy�D x @"QVHJI�B9HJy{RSDM@�Hcb¹D x @"y{HcN{[email protected]�KLTLQVD{RSHJTEy�Hcb dcTL| �gF v.x @UTºRSD.R]y�@Udcy{�mDMH(yM@C@D x d�D� ·% � Rfy.dce]yMH­d­y{@UI­RSHcD{R]Q�I�HcN^B x R]y{I�_/dcTL|�D x d�D®RSb¹R]Tºdc|L|LRSD{R]HJT�}²@"d�N^@�[JRSac@UT� � � × � � � � � _\D x @UT

� ·% �]�h·% � � D ·r� ��·% � �f�P_R¡F�@cFS_ QVHJI­B=HJy^RSD{RSHJT�Hcb�yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q�I­HcN{B x R]y^I­yARfy sLnUnUűtz½�s\p�½ �=Á F ��HcN{@CH ac@CNU_ÌbgHcN'@Cac@CN^��y{R][JT�yM�/y{DM@UI � _ D x @CN{@­R]ydcT ½�,¹Á4¿=p ½gphÀ y{@UI­RSHcD{R]Q«I�HcN{B x Rfy{I â� × � � � _=} x RfQ x R]yA|\@CÄET\@U|�DMH x dUac@,dcyARSD{yAQVHJI�B9HJT\@UT�D®b�KLTLQVD{RSHJTLy®D x @R]|\@UT�D{RSD{RS@UyAHJT�@UdcQ x yM@CDjb�N{HJI � F v.x R]y®DMN^RSa4R]dce¹I�HcN{B x Rfy{IÝR]yPN^d�N{@Ue]��KLyM@Cb�KLe R]T�BLN^dcQVD{RfQCdce¹|L@Uy{RS[JT±_=�EK\DjRSD®B©e]dU�4ydcT�R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzDjN{HJeS@­RfT�D x @­D x @CHcN{�c_LÞMKLy{Djdcy"|\H�R]|\@UT�D{RSD���@UeS@UI�@UT�D{y'R]T�dce][c@C�LN^d4F�¶\HcN«dcT�� × � � � � / _oD x @b�HJe]eSHr}AR]T\[,@UË�KEd�D{RSHJTLy.d�N{@«y{d�D{R]yMÄL@U|�_

â� 1 ·% D _ · â� m D F

G*HJI­B=HJy^RSD{RSHJT�HcbLyM@UI�RSHcD{R]Q�I�HcN^B x R]y{I�y�QCdcT"�9@ZKEyM@U|'DMHAb�dcQVDMHcN¬|\@Uy{R][JT'BLN{Hc�©eS@UI­yC_�R¡F�@cFS_�DMHAyM@CBEd�Nhd�DM@*QVHJTLQV@CNhTLyR]T�DMH�|LR��9@CN{@UT�D.yMD{d�[c@UyCF�¶\HcN®@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_E|\@Uy{RS[JTER]T\[�d�DM@V�4D®@U|LRSDMHcNAKLy{R]T\[,D x @"}®R]TL|\H } D R]TzacHJe][email protected]^KEQVD{R]T\[d�y{@UI­RSHcD{R]Q«I�HcN{B x Rfy{I � bgN{HJI � K � DMH�D¥F©¯ T�dc|L|LRSD{RSHJT�DMH(D x @iR]y{y{[email protected]{@Udc|\��I­@UTzD{RSHJTL@U|�b�HcNA|LR]y{BEe]dU�4R]T\[yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_L}*@"T\@C@U|�DMH(I­d�N{ØmD x @��9HJKLTL|Ld�N^R]@UyZHcb¬yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_L@cF�[\FS_E}®RSD x d,B9@CN^RSH4|mbgHJe]e]Hr}*@U|º���mD�}*H�yMB©[email protected]�DD x @�@UTL|�F¬¯ y{y^K\@Uy�D x d�D.QVHJTLQV@CNhT�yM@CBEd�Nhd�D{R]T\[­KLTLR]D{yC_�@cF�[\FS_=dc|L|LR]TL[,y{[email protected]|ºB9@CN^R]H/|LyU_/QCdcTº�9@'yM@CB©d�N^d�DM@U|ºb�N{HJIR]y{y^K\@Uy'D x d�D�QVHJTLQV@CNhT¦D x @my{R]�C@�Hcb.D x @m}®R]TE|\Hr}'_¹@cF�[\FS_ x ��B x @UTLd�D{RSHJT±_Ì�/� �°b�dcQVDMHcN^R]T\[^��D x @�I�HcN{B x R]y{I � R]T�DMHD�}*H�I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­yC_ � â × �+K � � �B� � dcTL| � z ×�� ��� � D _=} x @CN{@ �B���ÜR]yAd�y{R][JT�yM�4yMDM@UI Hcb¬yMDMNhR]T\[Jy.HcbQ x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^yC_=dcTL| � Rfy�D x @'QVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{R]HJT � â · � z F

G*HJI­B=HJy^RSD{RSHJT,dcTL|­R]|L@UTzD{RSD¨�«Hcb9yM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yÌdce]eSH }�KLyÌDMH"|L@CÄET\@�D x @.T\HcD{R]HJT�Hcb ½�nUÅ=ÂÃÅ©q ÆÌǹ½gn  b�HcNy{RS[JTºy{�/yMDM@UI�yC_Edcy.d­I­HcN{B x R]y^I × � � � � / y{KLQ x D x d�D.D x @CN{@�@V�\R]yMD{y®dcT ½�¿ �©Á/q nUÁ I�HcN^B x R]y{I� � × � / � � �y{KLQ x D x d�D ·% � D â� 1 dcTL| ��·% D â� m FZ¯ yMHJI­HcN{B x R]QPy{RS[JTºy{�/yMDM@UI�y�|\@CÄET\@j@V�\dcQVD{eS�(D x @'y{dcI�@'yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@c_dcTL| x dUac@mD x @my{dcI�@�I�H/|L@Ue]yCF�Ù.@UI�d�N{Ø�d��©eS�c_¬RSD«T\H }¤b�HJe]eSH }®y'b�N{HJIÝÞMKEyMD"D x @mdcy{yMH4QCR]d�D{RSac@�dcTL|ÈR]|\@UT�D{RSD���e]dr}®yD x d�DPD x @,R]Tzac@CNhyM@«R]yAKLTLR]Ë/K\@"R]bÌR]D®@V�\R]yMD{yC_9dcTL|�D x d�DAD x @"N{@Ue]d�D{R]HJT�Hcb ½�nUÅ=ÂÃÅ©q ÆÌÇ=À ��RªF�@cFS_=HcbZ�=@URfT\[�R]yMHJI­HcN{B x R]Qr�1 H I�6dF7<W6LH3476d<ZI0Nd\kPQG`XVp [_g�P�8AD�PQNEUkPY<W:CH3:=PYO-]^H3P�:�O�@7:�Db>H36dH3476dPYU)UkPQ<W:CH36dPY8V@76M8`gt83PYN H34�>HA>�<W<WP�D�:=>�H36b@ K :�H34 H3476dF7<WF�>YG <ZI0Nd\kPQGX��[��EH34�>H :�<�]5X��-p��v[dNE6b>YO7<�/)83<ZHc@7P��-])H3476�Ox@0P��k]7>Y< K :CH34qD�PQNEN�>�O�@0<5:�Oq>�U083PQRY8V>�NENE:�O)R�G=>�O)RQF)>YRY6Ql

â %

Page 15: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

HJT�y^RS[JTºyM�4yMDM@UI­y®Rfy�N{@��L@V�\RSac@c_EyM�4I­I�@CDMNhR]Q�dcTL|ºDMN^dcTEy{RSD{RSac@cF�¯ bÌ}²@"}.N^RSDM@��D b�HcN®D x @'R]yMHJI�HcN{B x �mN{@Ue]d�D{RSHJT�_\D x @UTD x @UyM@"b�dcQVD{yAI­dU���9@�}.N^RSDMDM@UT

� �D � _� � �D � / R]I�BEefRS@Uy � / �D � � _� � �D � / dcTL| � / �D � � R]I�BEe]R]@Uy � � �D � � F

��HcN{@CHrac@CNU_©RSb±}²@�|\@UTLHcDM@AD x @�R]T�ac@CN^yM@PHcb� �/� �� � _�D x @UT(D x @Pb�HJe]eSH }®R]T\["@UË�KLd�D{R]HJTLy�d�N{@PdcefyMH,@Udcy{R]eS��BLN^Hrac@U|±_� â� � � � D â� _� �� � ��� � D _�dcTL|� ·% �]� � � D � � � ·% � � F

v.x @ºe]dcy{Di@UË/KLd�D{RSHJTÈBEd�N^D{R]QCKLe]d�N^e]� x dcy�yMHJI�@�T\HcD,@UT�D{RSN{@UeS�ÃDMN^RSa4R]dce²QVHJT�DM@UT�DC_�dcTE|ÈQCdcTÉ�=@�KLyM@Cb�KLe*R]TÈD x R]T\Ø4R]T\[d��9HJK\D�D x @"QVHJI­B=HJy^RSD{RSHJT�HcbÌR]yMHJI�HcN{B x R]y{I N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLyCF

� � �1�� Ô��hÖ°Ð � Ò� �� �¥Ö{Ò�бÖ{Õ� Ò®Ñ�����Ö��� �

v.x @"[cHJdce�Hcb�KLyM@CNAR]TzDM@CN^b�dcQV@i|\@Uy{RS[JT�Rfy�DMH�BLN^H/|LKEQV@ x RS[ x Ë/KLdce]RSD¨��N{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyU·EKLT\b�HcN{D{KLTLd�DM@Ue]�c_ERSD x dcyAT\HcD�9@C@UT�ac@CN{��QCeS@Ud�N x Hr} DMH(|\@CDM@CNhI­R]T\@iË�KLdcefRSD��cF®£Pe]yMH\_=dcyjR]T�HcD x @CNjd�N{@UdcyPHcb¬@UT\[JR]TL@C@CN^R]T\[\_=|\@Uy{RS[JT�R]y®y{KL�4Þ°@UQVDADMHQVHJTLyMDMNhdcR]TzD{yU_zdcTL|�D¨��BERfQCdce]eS�«RfTzacHJeSac@Uy�DMN^dc|\@CH��±yC_�R¡F�@cFS_/QVHJI�BLN{HJI�R]yM@UyÌ�9@CD�}*@C@UT�QVHJI�B9@CD{R]TL[jI­@Udcy{K\N{@Uy¬Hcb9y{KLQCQV@Uy^yC_y{KLQ x dcy�QVHJyMDC_4y{RS�C@c_�QVHJI�BEeS@V�\RSD��,dcTL|�N^@UyMB9HJTLyM@�D{R]I�@cFA� RfI­RSD{yÌHJT x KLI­dcT�QCd�BEd��©R]e]RSD¨�"b�HcNZ|\@Udce]R]TL[P}ARSD x QVHJI�BEeS@V�|LR]y{BEe]dU�4y�R]I­BEe]RS@Uy¹D x d�D*yMHJI�@ARfT\bgHcNhI­d�D{RSHJT­I­dr� x dUac@PDMH"�9@®QVHJI­BLN{@Uy{yM@U|�_�|\@UeS@CDM@U|�_zHcN²I­Hrac@U|m@Ue]yM@C} x @CN{@cF v.x R]yR]T�D{K\NhTºR]I�BEe]R]@Uy²D x d�D.}²@«T\@C@U|ºDMH�KLTE|\@CN^yMD{dcTL|mBLNhRSHcN^RSD{RS@Uy*HJT�} x d�D.y x HJKEe]|m�=@�BEN{@UyM@CN{ac@U|±F

¯°T |\@CDM@CN^I­RfTLR]T\[�} x d�D­I­d�Øc@Uy­HJT\@�N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJT��=@CDMDM@CN�D x dcTÉdcT\HcD x @CNr_²D x @º@UT�D{RSN{@ºyMDMNhKLQVD{K\N{@ºHcbPD x @y{RS[JT�y{�/yMDM@UI�y�R]TzacHJe]ac@U|�y x HJKLef|��9@�QVHJTLy{Rf|\@CN{@U|±F v.x @­yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@,D x d�D'R]yjBLN^@UyM@CN{ac@U|��/��yM@UI�RSHcD{R]Q,I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yBLN{H a/Rf|\@Uy²dcTºRfI�B9HcN{D{dcTzD²}*dr�(DMH�QVHJI�B©d�N{@jD x @URSN�� � s©Ú�½gp6À F�¶ÌRSN^yMDC_4T\HcD{R]QV@jD x d�D��9@UQCdcKLyM@jd,yM@UI­RSHcD{R]QPI�HcN{B x R]y{I × � � � � / TL@C@U|�TLHcDA�9@"DMHcD{dceª_�yMHJI�@,y{RS[JTLyPR]T � � I­dr� x drac@�T\H(N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT�R]T � / ·9I­HcN{@CHrac@CNU_oyMHJI�@Hcb�D x @�QVHJI�BEeS@V��R]T�DM@CN^TLdce²yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@�Hcb.y{R][JTLy"R]T � � QVHJKLef|��9@(eSHJy{DCF v.x R]y"I­RS[ x D«yM@C@UI KLTL|\@Uy^RSN^d��EeS@c_o�EK\D"R]bN{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLyZR]T � / [c@CD�DMH�HiQVHJI�BEeS@V�9_JD x @C�,}®Rfe]e4T\HcD��[email protected]@Cb�KLe\R]T,BLNhdcQVD{R]QV@cF¬¶\HcN²@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_zRSb � � R]y¬XZTL[Je]R]y xyM@UT�DM@UTLQV@Uy®dcTE| � / R]y��LNhdcQ{Øc@CDATLHcD{d�D{RSHJT±_LD x @UT�D x @'N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTÃ��bgN^HJI¸D x @"|Ld�D{d­Hcba# z#� (��# # # # ?��&��(������Y# �B0����A?V(��_(�� �E# # "- 5("!$#���% # # ?��&��(������Y# �]�%�V� (��E(�� �c(��&�c(�� �E# # 8 " ��� %�(�'_# " 5("!)(�#*�Z(,+-�c( �J�&�

R]y,T\HcD­dcy�KLy{@Cb�KLe²b�HcN x KLI�dcT QVHJI­I«KETLR]QCd�D{RSHJT�dcy�D x @ºe]RfT\@Ud�N«N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT }*HJKLe]|È�9@cF�¯°T¦b�dcQVDC_*}²@ºac@CN{�Hcb�DM@UT�}*dcT�D,} x d�D � d�DMHJK\N # % z (�QCdce]e]y,d �M���¨�{�¨§©�{�6�U�V�E�ª�J������� _²} x R]Q x QVHJTLQV@UT�DMN^d�DM@Uy�HcN�d��EyMDMN^dcQVD{y�RfT\bgHcNhI­d�D{RSHJT±F¶\HcN­@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_ZD x @ºN{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT �v#/.�01020�(-320q��R]y�I­HcN{@�KLyM@Cb�KLe²D x dcT D x d�D­d��9Hrac@ºb�HcN�yMHJI­@ºBEK\N{B9HJyM@UyC_BLN{@UQCRfyM@UeS�i�=@UQCdcKEyM@ARSD ���,����� yMHJI�@PR]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{RSHJT±F�O/D{d�D{R]y{D{R]QCyC_�y^KLQ x dcyZD x @PI�@UdcTmdcTL|�I�@U|ER]dcT­Hcb�d"B=HcB©KLe]d�D{RSHJT±_d�N{@"dcefyMH�N{@��ªN{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLy®R]T�D x R]y�yM@UTLyM@c_©dcy.d�N{@"QCd�N{DMHc[cNhd�B x R]Q'I�d�BEyCF!¹@URSN^QV@ # %'&�(oR]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@U|ºd�}²@Ue]e �ªØ/T\H }®T�D x N{@C@��ªb�HJe]|�QCe]dcy{y{RSÄ©QCd�D{RSHJTºHcb¬y{RS[JTLy®R]TzDMH(R]QVHJT±_ER]TE|\@V�=_LdcTE|�yM�4I"�9HJe¡F

v.x @Uy{@­DM@CN^I­y x dUac@mBLN{@UQCR]y{@­DM@UQ x TER]QCdceZI�@UdcTER]T\[Jy�D x d�Di|LR��9@CN'b�N{HJI D x @UR]N'@Cac@CN{�4|LdU�ÃKEyM@cF !¹@URSNhQV@(|\@CÄETL@U|�dcT½�tJÅ©¿ dcy�d.�My{RS[JTm} x R]Q x N{@Cb�@CN^y*DMH�D x @«´P�4ÞM@UQVD�D x d�D�RSD�|\@UT\HcDM@Uy�I�@CN^@UeS���/��a4RSN{D{K\@PHcboQ x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^y®HcboRSD{y*H }®T�FSFSFy{KLQ x dcy®d�eS@Udc|T�ªB9@UTLQCR]e9yMDMN{@Ud�غN^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{R]T\[­d�[c@CHJI­@CDMN^R]QCdce efR]T\@cF���¯°T�QVHJTzDMNhdcyMDC_©d­y^RS[JT���R]y�dcT ½�¿c,oÁ/; b�HcN®dcTHc�4ÞM@UQVD ��RSb ��dcTL|���d�N{@«N^@C[JKLe]d�N^eS�ºQVHJTLTL@UQVDM@U|±_±R]T�D x @«yM@UTLy{@ �°D x d�D�dceS}�dU�4yPHcN�KLy{KLdce]e]�(} x @UT�D x @CN^@iR]yAdcT � _D x @CN{@jR]y²dce]yMH,d ��R]T(yMHJI�@jI�HcN{@AHcN�e]@Uy{yZ@V�\dcQVD{eS��y{B=@UQCR]ÄEd��[email protected]©d�D{RSH��ªDM@UI�B9HcN^dce©N{@Ue]d�D{RSHJT(DMH«D x @��ºR]T(Ë�K\@Uy{D{RSHJT��# â (ªF �^O4KLQ x _¹bgHcNiR]TLyMD{dcTLQV@c_ÌR]y«dºBERS@UQV@(Hcb.I�HJKLe]|�}®R]D x dº�EKEe]eS@CD�� x HJeS@­RfT�RSD"dcyiy{RS[JT�Hcb.d�y x HcD�$# %'&)(ªF�¯ TÃD x R]y@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_�D x @�yMBEd�D{RSH��ªDM@UI­B=HcNhdceÌN{@Ue]d�D{RSHJT�Rfy�d�QCdcKLy{dce¬HJTL@c_ } x RfQ x d�BLBEefRS@UyP}®RSD x [cN{@Ud�D'[c@UTL@CN^dce]RSD¨�cF *®H }²@Cac@CNI­dcT���R]TL|LRfQV@Uy�HJTLeS��}*HcN{ØÃR]T�ac@CN^��BEd�N{D{R]QCKEe]d�N"yMBEd�D{R]H��ªDM@UI�B9HcN^dce²QVHJT�DM@V�4D{yC_¬@cF�[\FS_�D x @mKLyM@�Hcb�ÄEN^yMD"TLdcI­@Uy"b�HcNB9@CN^yMHJTLyUF²¶ÌR]TLdce]e]�c_�!o@UR]N^QV@«|\@CÄ©T\@Uy.d nUÀ Â�l�Å©Ú dcyPd �My{RS[JT�} x R]Q x R]yAQVHJTLyMD{RSD{K\DM@U|�d­y{RS[JT�I�@CN{@UeS�mHcNjI­dcR]TLeS�(���D x @ib�dcQVD�D x d�DPRSDjR]yPKLyM@U|�dcTL|�KLTL|L@CN^yMDMH/H/|�dcyPy^KLQ x F�� ¯°T�dc|L|LRSD{RSHJT�_©}*@iKEyM@«D x @iDM@CNhI n ½g¾=¿ s©Ú b�HcN�d�B x �4y{R]QCdceQVHJT\ÄL[JKLN^d�D{RSHJTºD x d�DAI­dU��HcN®I­dr�ºT\HcD.�9@�d­y{RS[JT±F

v.x KLyC_JdcT�R]QVHJTLR]Q*N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJT,BLN{@UyM@CN{ac@UyZyMHJI�@.R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D §©�M�h§\�V�V���ª�6� Hcb9y{RS[JTERSÄL@U|iy{RS[JTLyC·zbgHcN�d�yM@UI�RSHcD{R]QI�HcN{B x R]y{Iº_�D x @UyM@�I­R][ x D¬d�BLB9@Ud�N¬dcy¬d��4R]HJI­y¬dcTL|�� HcN¬|Ld�D{dja�dce]K\@U|ib�KLTLQVD{RSHJTLy���b�HcN¬} x R]Q x D x @*}*HcN^|u�Md�DMDMN^RS�©K\DM@v�

â �

Page 16: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

R]y¬QVHJI­I­HJTLeS�«KEyM@U|,R]T,D x @�Hc�4ÞM@UQVD�HcN^RS@UT�DM@U|�QVHJI­IiKLTLRSD¨�\�hF¬£PT�R]TL|\@V�\R]QCdce/N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJT,B©d�N{D{R]QCRSBEd�DM@Uy¬RfT�yMHJI�@e]d�N{[c@CNiy{RSD{KLd�D{R]HJT���R¡F�@cFS_ÌD x @CHcN{�L�j}ARSD x R]T�} x R]Q x }*@(QCdcTÈ|\@U|LKEQV@�D x @�QVHJTET\@UQVD{RSHJT¦�=@CD¨}²@C@UT¦D x @my{RS[JTLRSÄE@U|�dcTL|y{RS[JTERSbg�4R]T\[�y^RS[JTLyCF�¶LHcN­d�yM�4I«�=HJeª_¹D x @CN{@(R]yiT\H�y{KLQ x I�HcN^@(�Edcy^R]Q­N{@Uefd�D{RSHJTLy x R]B��9@CD�}*@C@UTÈy{HJK\N^QV@�dcTL|ÃD{d�N^[c@CDy{RS[JTEyCF

¶\HcN�B©K\N{[email protected]*|\@Uy{RS[JT�_©HcD x @CNjD x RfT\[Jy®�9@UR]TL[�@UË/KLdce¡_9D x @CN{@,R]yPdmTEd�D{K\N^dceoHcN^|\@CN^R]TL[�DMH�D x @UyM@,D x N{@C@iØ4R]TL|LyHcb²y^RS[JT±×ARfQVHJTLy�d�N{@,�9@CDMDM@CN�D x dcT�R]TL|LRfQV@UyC_=dcTE|�R]TL|LR]QV@UyPd�N{@,�9@CDMDM@CN'D x dcT�yM�4I"�9HJe]yUFw*®H }²@Cac@CNr_ D x R]TL[JyPd�N^@ �=�c�dceS}�dU�4y,@UË�KEdce¡F�¶LHcN�@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_¬�EdcyM@ â T\HcD{d�D{RSHJTÈbgHcN�TLd�D{KLN^dce²T/KLI«�9@CN^y«Rfy«R]QVHJTER]Q�_Ì@cF�[\FS_L%�R]yiN{@CBLN{@UyM@UT�DM@U|�dcy������� _ 3 dcy ����� _LdcTL|�}²@"[c@CD®D x @URSN.y^KLI Þ{KLyMD����ºQVHcB/�/RfT\[­dcTL|�d�BLB9@UTL|ER]T\[\_

��������� ������� ������������� _} x RfQ x R]y�R]QVHJTLR]Q�F¬»�K\D��Edcy{@PHJTL@jTLHcD{d�D{RSHJTºR]y*ac@CN{��R]T\@Cà�QCRS@UT�D*bgHcN�N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{R]T\[,e]d�N{[c@�T�KEI"�9@CN^yCF`� RSD x £AN^d��ER]QT/KLI�@CN^dce]yU_*D x @�KLyM@�Hcb â b�HcN �°HJT\@v�ÈR]y�RfQVHJTLR]QÃ��HJT\@�yMDMN{HcØc@ �h_.�©K\D­D x @�HcD x @CN^ymd�N{@�yM�4I«�=HJefR]Q � �rF¢`Py{R]TL[�D x @�Ee]dcTLØmQ x d�N^dcQVDM@CNjbgHcN �°�C@CN{H^�(}²HJKLef|º�9@"R]QVHJTLR]Q�_E�EK\D�Hcb�QVHJK\N^y{@'D x R]y�}*HJKLe]|�KLTL|\@CN^I�R]T\@jD x @'B9HJy{RSD{R]HJTLdce±dcyMB9@UQVDHcbZ|\@UQCRfI­dce T\HcD{d�D{R]HJT�dcTE|�R]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@"dcI«�ERS[JKERSD{RS@UyCFPG x R]T\@UyM@«T\HcD{d�D{RSHJT�bgHcN�yM@Cac@CN^dceoHcb�D x @,y{I­dcefe T/KLI�@CN^dce]yAR]yR]QVHJTLRfQ�F!¹@URSN^QV@ � yÌD x N{@C@�QCe]dcy{yM@Uy¹Hcb©y^RS[JT"H ac@CN^e]d�B�_�yMH�yMHJI�@�y{RS[JTLyo}®R]efeJ�9@ x d�N^|"DMH'QCefdcy{y{RSb��cFo£Pe]yMH\_JQVHJI�B©eS@V�«y{RSD{KEd�D{RSHJTLy

I­dr�mR]T�acHJeSac@'dce]e9D x N{@C@�Ø/RfTL|Ly*Hcb¹y^RS[JT±_\R]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{R]T\[­R]T�QVHJI�B©eS@V�m}�dU�4yC·ERfTL|\@C@U|±_4|LR��9@CN{@UT�D.dcyMB9@UQVD{y�HcboD x @'y{dcI�@y{RS[JT(QCdcT��9@PR]QVHJTLR]Q�_/R]TL|\@V�\R]QCdce¡_JdcTL|myM�4I"�9HJe]RfQ�Fo¯ D²R]yZHcbgDM@UTmT\@UQV@Uy{y^d�N{�­DMH«QVHJTEy{R]|\@CN²D x @AQVHJT�DM@V�/D�Hcb�d«y{RS[JT±_�@cF�[\FS_x H } R]y�RSD�KLyM@U|�RfT�BEN^dcQVD{R]QV@c_odcTE|�Hcb*QVHJK\NhyM@­RSD{yjN{@Ue]d�D{R]HJT�DMHºHcD x @CN"y{RS[JTEy�R]T�D x @�y{dcI�@�y{�/yMDM@UI�F­O4@C@ # â &4_ 3 �)(b�HcN®b�K\N{D x @CN�@V�\dcI�BEeS@UyAdcTL|�|LRfy{QCKLy{y{R]HJT±_4D x @'b�HcN^I�@CN®I­dcRfTLeS��b�N{HJIÊQVHJI�BEK\DM@CNPy{QCRS@UTLQV@c_EdcTE|ºD x @«efd�DMDM@CNAI­dcR]TEeS�b�N{HJIÝe]dcT\[JKEd�[c@cF

v.x @�bgHJe]e]Hr}®R]TL[,|L@CÄETLRSD{RSHJTm[JRSac@UyAyMHJI�@�BLN^@UQCR]yM@�}�dU�4y.DMH�QVHJI�B©d�N{@'D x @"Ë/KLdce]R]D���HcbÌN{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyC×� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿��±u �jRSac@UT�d�yM@UI­RSHcD{RfQ�I�HcN{B x Rfy{I� × � � � � / _LD x @UT±×� â � Rfy Ú�Á �=Á/Ú�ƹq Á/nUÁ/q�� ½�¿o¾ R���D x @'BEd�N{D{Rfdce±HcN^|\@CN^RfT\[�HJT�eS@Cac@Uefy®R]y�BEN{@UyM@CN{ac@U|���� _ER]TºD x @«yM@UTLy{@'D x d�DAR]b

y{HcN{D %«R]y�eSHr}*@CNAe]@Cac@Ue±D x dcT�yMHcN^D %��9R]T � � _LD x @UT ¤�Y%�� x dcy.e]Hr}*@CNi��HcN®@UË/KLdceg�*e]@Cac@Ue±D x dcT �Y%��f�*R]T � / F� z � R]y ƹq�½gÅ©q�½gp6ÀÉÆoq�Á/nUÁ�q�� ½�¿ ¾ R�� 8�� 8 �±R]T � � R]I�BEefRS@Uy�¤� 8U��� � 8 �f��R]T � / F� 3 � Rfy s<; ½�Å©Â Æoq�Á�nrÁ�q�� ½�¿ ¾ R�� b�HcN(@UdcQ x d��\RSHJI ��Hcb � � _.RSD{y­DMNhdcTLy{e]d�D{RSHJT ¤� �\�­DMH � / Rfy�dÃe]Hc[JR]QCdceQVHJTEyM@UË�KL@UTLQV@'HcbÌD x @"d��\RSHJI­y.RfT � / F�J%�� ��RSac@UT�dce]y{H � × � � � � / _LD x @UT� � R]y"��d�DPeS@UdcyMDh� sEn ,¹ÁzÛ¬¿ Áj,�sLn _L}.N^R]DMDM@UT � � _ER ��b�HcN®@UdcQ xQVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVDMHcN�8jHcb � � _ �¡� 8C�.R]y�|\@CÄETL@U|�} x @UT\@Cac@CN ¤� 8U��R]yUF

�$�J� ��RSac@UT�dce]yMH ��× � � � � / _±D x @UT� � ƹq Á/nUÁ/q��=Á�n�s©Ú�Ú®s<; ½�ũ¦nmp Ç sLp |\H/@UyC_9}.N^RSDMDM@UT� �g_�R �} x @UT\@Cac@CN BLN{@Uy{@CN{[email protected]�d��\RSHJIº_\D x @UT�yMH�|\H/@Uy � F

� � � ��RSac@UT dce]yMH � × � � � � / _®D x @UT � R]y���d�D�eS@UdcyMDh� sLn�½�¿otzÚ � n ½ �=Á sLn R�� ���9� D � RfI�BEe]RS@Uy �ª���9�ED ��b�HcN.@UdcQ x y{RS[JT���Hcb � � F� � � ��RSac@UT�dcefyMH � × � � � � / _�D x @UT � Æoq�Á/nUÁ�q��©Á/n ��d�D(eS@UdcyMDh� sLn Â&� t�ÇwtJÅ=¿=prÁ/¿=p sLn Y_�}®N^RSDMDM@UT � _�R�� � R]y�dcy(|\@CÄET\@U| dcy dcTL| � BLN{@UyM@CN^ac@Uy�@Cac@CN{�ÉyM@UeS@UQVDMHcN(D x d�D |\H/@UyC_²} x @CN{@�dI­HcN{B x R]y^I × � � � � / ƹq�Á�nUÁ/q��©Á/n d nUÁ4ÚgÁ/tcprÅ©q � � Hcb � � R���D x @CN^@'R]y�d�yM@UeS@UQVDMHcN � / b�HcN � / y{KLQ x D x d�Db�HcN.@Cac@CN{��y^RS[JT ��Hcb � � } x @CN^@ Rfy�|\@CÄET\@U|±_4D x @UT � / � ���9�M��D � � ���9�h_L} x @CN{@

� � ��d nUÁ4ÚgÁ/tcprÅ©q b�HcNAd�y^RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI � R]yAd­b�KLTLQVD{RSHJT �«× %�� ,L_©} x @CN{@ %,R]y.d�y^RS[JT�yMHcN^DAdcTL| ,md(|Ld�D{dmyMHcN{DHcb � _=y^KLQ x D x d�D®D x @CN{@id�N^@«d��\RSHJI­y�: � y^KLQ x D x d�Djdc|L|LR]T\[ ��dcTL| : �±DMH � R]y®QVHJTLy^R]yMDM@UT�DPdcTL|�|\@CÄET\@UyPdKETLR]Ë/K\@Aa�dce]K\@ �¬���±�²bgHcN®@UdcQ x y^RS[JT ��Hcb¬yMHcN{D!%zF�¶\HcNA@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_\@UdcQ x BEd�N^dcI�@CDM@CN®HcbÌd�QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVDMHcN x dcy.dQVHcN^N{@UyMB9HJTL|LR]TL[,y{@UeS@UQVDMHcN®DMH­@V�4DMN^dcQVDPRSD{y�a�dcefK\@cF

=v.x @AR]TzD{KERSD{RSHJT�b�HcNj� � �ZR]yZD x d�D*QVHJT�DM@UT�D�Rfy�BLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@U|�RSb9D x @CN^@PR]y²yMHJI�@A}*dr�­DMH«N^@CDMN^RS@Cac@®@UdcQ x |Ld�D{d"a�dce]K\@AHcb±D x @yMHJK\NhQV@«y{RS[JT�bgN^HJI RSD{yPR]I­d�[c@iR]T�D x @«D{d�N{[c@CDjy{RS[JT�y{�/yMDM@UI�·©D x @i|\@CÄETLR]D{RSHJTºHcb�yM@UeS@UQVDMHcN�R]T¦� � �.R]yAKLT\b�HcN{D{KLTLd�DM@Ue]�N^d�D x @CN®DM@UQ x TLRfQCdce¡F1 Kb2547PQF7RQ4xH34769836A:�<c>LHW83:=DVyEg�P�8c836�RQ>�8V@0:=O7Ra<W6���6M8V>YGjP�gTH34)6 <WN�>YG�G � 8V>Y\7:=DAOvF7NE698V>YG�< >Y< <ZI0N�\kPYG�:=DYl

�

Page 17: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

¯ D'I­dU���9@,D x d�D'T\@URSD x @CN� T\HcN � BLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@Uy'yMDMN^RfQVD{eS��I�HcN{@�D x dcT�D x @�HcD x @CNU·obgHcN�@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_" I­RS[ x DBLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@(I�HcN^@(QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDMHcN^yi} x R]e]@ � BLN^@UyM@CN{ac@UyiI�HcN{@(QVHJT�DM@UT�DCF�£Pe]yMH\_Ì@UdcQ x Hcb�D x @Uy{@�HcN^|\@CNhR]T\[Jy"Rfy"RSD{yM@Ue]bBEd�N{D{Rfdce¡_zT\HcD²DMHcD{dce¡F²O/D{R]e]e/HcD x @CN*HcN^|\@CNhR]T\[Jy¬HJT(I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­yÌD x dcT�D x HJyM@®|\@CÄ©T\@U|­d��9Hrac@jI­dU�,�9@®KLy{@Cb�KLeLbgHcN*yMHJI�@d�BLBEefR]QCd�D{RSHJTLyC·/b�HcN�@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_LyMB9@UQCR]dce9I�@Udcy{K\N^@Uy�I­dU���9@PRfI�B9HcN{D{dcTzD�d�D.QV@CN{D{dcRfT�eS@Cac@Ue]y�Hcb¹yMHJI�@'y{RS[JTEy�yM�/y{DM@UI­yC_y{KLQ x dcy�B x HJT\HJeSHc[JR]QCdceEQVHJI�BEeS@V�\RSD�����} x R]Q x R]y�D x @.@��9HcN{DZHcb9BLN{HJT/KLTLQCRfd�D{RSHJT©� bgHcN*yMB9HcØc@UT­e]dcT\[JKEd�[c@cF¬¯ T�[c@UTL@CN^dce¡_yMB9@UQCRSÄEQ �M|\@Uy^RS[JT\@CN®HcNh|\@CN^R]T\[Jy��«} x R]Q x QVHJI"�ERfT\@�a�d�NhRSHJKLy�BLN^@UyM@CN{a�d�D{RSHJTºBLN{HcB9@CN{D{R]@Uy�R]Tºd­yMB9@UQCRSÄEQj}�dU�c_=I­dU�º�9@T\@C@U|\@U|�DMHmN{@��L@UQVD®D x @i|\@Uy^RS[JT�DMN^dc|L@CH��9yAHcb�yMB9@UQCRSÄEQ'd�BEBEe]R]QCd�D{RSHJTEy«��@cF�[\FS_±yM@C@iD x @"@UTL|�HcbZ£ABLB9@UTL|LR ��»��hFA£AyjdN{@Uy{KEeSDZHcb±D x RfyC_�[JR]ac@UTmy^RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­y � � G � / _/}*@PQCdcT�dcy{y{KEI�@Pd«BEd�N{D{RfdceLHcN^|\@CNhR]T\["HJT(D x @jQVHJe]eS@UQVD{RSHJT(Hcb yM@UI�RSHcD{R]QI�HcN{B x R]y{I­y*b�N{HJI � � DMH � / _Ldcy®R]y�T\@C@U|L@U|ºbgHcN®D x @ �/ ��QCd�DM@C[cHcN^RS@UyAHcb¬£®BEB=@UTE|LR �(»PF��@ÃQCdcT yM@C@ÃyMHJI�@�HcbiD x @ÃQVHJI­BEeS@V�\RSD{RS@Uy�R]T�acHJeSac@U|¢R]T QVHJI�B©d�N^R]T\[�D x @�Ë/KLdce]RSD¨��HcbiN{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyº���

QVHJTLy{Rf|\@CN^R]T\[�y{RfI�BEeS@j@V�\dcI�BEeS@Uy®} x @CN{@�D x @CN^@"R]y.T\HcDAac@CN{�ºI«KEQ x y{DMN^KLQVD{K\N{@"DMH­BLN{@UyM@CN^ac@cF*¶\HcNP@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_ERfTºD x @D{R]I�@ZHcb4|EdU�jN{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyC_�y^R]I�BEe]RfQCRSD��c_rKETLRSb�HcN^I­RSD¨�c_ dcTL|�BEN{@UQCR]y{RSHJTjHcb\D x @Z|LR]yMB©e]dU�Pd�N{@ZR]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�DC×�D x @²TLdcRSac@|\@UQCR]I�dce©N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT� efdcQ{Ø4y�KLTLRSb�HcN^I­RSD¨��R]TmD x @�y{RS�C@jHcboRSD{y � x HJKLN^y�4·\D x @�yMDMN^dcTL[c@jKETLd�N{�­N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT�¸e]dcQ{Ø4y'BLN^@UQCR]y{RSHJTÉ��d�DieS@UdcyMD'b�HcN x KLI­dcTLy'} x HºN{@Cb�KLyM@­DMH�QVHJKLTzD«ac@CN{��QCd�N{@Cb�KLe]eS�L�Pdcy'}*@Ue]e�dcy«y{R]I�BEefR]QCRSD���dcTL|��DMH,dcT­@V�4DM@UTzDh�²KLTLR]bgHcN^I�RSD��cF v.x @.N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyZD x d�D*d�N^@AI�HJyMD*yMDMN^dcRS[ x DMb�HcN{}*d�Nh|�I­d�D x @UI�d�D{R]QCdce]eS��I­dr��T\HcD�9@'ac@CN{��QCe]HJyM@"DMHmD x @"HJTL@Uy®}*@«KLy{@"@Cac@CN{��|EdU�=·©b�HcNA@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_©I­R]efRSD{d�N{�mD{R]I�@"dcTL|�dcTLdceSHc[mQCeSH4Q{Ø�D{R]I­@'N{@UË/KLRSN{@I­d�D x @UI�d�D{R]QCdce]eS��I­HcN{@iQVHJI­BEeS@V��HcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJTEy®b�HcNjD x @URSNj|\@CÄETLRSD{R]HJT�D x dcT�|\HmD x @,|\@UQCR]I­dce¹dcTL|�yMDMN^dcT\[c@�KLTLd�N^�N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLyCF

áAHr}¸eS@CD � y,QVHJTLy{Rf|\@CN"D x @�T\H�QVHJT\b�KEy{RSHJTÃQVHJTE|LRSD{RSHJT¦R]TÃN^@C[Jd�N^|ÃDMH�D x @�QV�/QCefR]QCRSD���HcbAQCeSH/Q^Ø/yUF v.x @mI­R]e]R]D{d�N{�QCeSH4Q{Ø y{d�D{R]y{ÄL@Uy­D x @�QVHJTL|LRSD{RSHJT�F�»�K\D­b�HcN�D x @�yMD{dcTL|Ld�Nh| âvz x HJKLN(dcTLdceSHc[¦QCeSH/Q^Ø :"_�}*@�QVHJKLef|Éy{dU�ÉR]D�R]yHJTLeS��� x dceSbZy{d�D{R]y{ÄL@U|±_��(�=@UQCdcKEyM@«HJTL@i@V�4DMN^dm�ERSDC_9dcyPbgHJKETL|�HJT�I�HJy{DA}�d�D{Q x @UyU_�DMHmRfTL|LR]QCd�DM@u�MdcI �mHcN �°BEIº_���R]yT\@UQV@Uy{y^d�N{��dcTL|�y^K\à�QCRS@UT�D.DMH(dracHJR]|�QVHJT\b�KEy{RSHJT±F.´Pb¬QVHJK\N^yM@"D x R]y.@V�4DMN^d��ERSD.R]y®HcbgDM@UT�dUa�dcR]e]d��Ee]@�ÞMKEyMD.�/��e]H�HcØ4R]T\[HJK\D�D x @j}®R]TE|\Hr} DMH�yM@C@'RSb R]D � y*|EdU�mHcN.TLRS[ x DC·/�©K\D*R]b��cHJKºe]RSac@U|�KLTL|L@CN{[cN{HJKLTL|�bgHcN.dib�@C} }²@C@CØ4y�}®R]D x Þ{KLyMD�d âvzx HJK\N�QCeSH4Q{Ø�dcTL|�T\H�HcD x @CN«R]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{RSHJT ��y{KLQ x dcy�N^dc|LR]H��h_±�cHJK�I­RS[ x Dj}²@Ue]eÌeSHJy{@iDMNhdcQ{Ø�Hcb²D x d�D�HJT\@,�ERSDCF«£ �x HJK\N²dcTLdceSHc[«QCe]H/Q^Ø�}²HJKLef|�HJTLeS��y{d�D{R]y{bg�,D x @®TLH«QVHJT\b�KLy{RSHJT�QVHJTL|LRSD{RSHJT­HJTLeS�u�°HJT\@AË/KLd�N{DM@CNU_��«�9@[email protected]¨}²Hi@V�4DMN^d�ERSD{yPd�N{@�T\@C@U|\@U|�Fj£ �(HcN � HcN â�� x HJK\N�dcTLdceSHc[ºQCeSH4Q{Ø�}²HJKLef|��9@iI«KLQ x }²HcNhyM@c_9�=@UQCdcKEyM@,D x @UyM@�T�KEI"�9@CN^yPd�N{@N{@Ue]d�D{R]ac@UeS��BLN^R]I�@jDMH z %\F.£AT�dceSDM@CN^TLd�D{RSac@"}*dr�ºDMH(D{dceSغd��9HJK\D.D x R]y.R]y�DMHmy{dU�ºD x d�DAd�y{@UeS@UQVDMHcNAb�HcN®D x @"T�KEI"�9@CNHcb¬@Ue]d�BEy{@U|�I­RfT�K\DM@Uy®bgN^HJIÊI­Rf|LTLRS[ x D.QCdcT��=@i|\@CÄET\@U|�D x d�DjR]y®T\HcDABLN{@UyM@CN^ac@U|±FjO/HmdceSD x HJK\[ x D x @i[c@UT\@CN^dceoN^KLeS@R]y®D x d�DAD x @«I�HcN{@iBLN{@Uy{@CN{a�d�D{R]HJT�D x @i�9@CDMDM@CNU_©yMHJI­@CD{R]I�@UyP}²@iQCdcT�N{@UQVHrac@CN'eSHJy{DAR]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{R]HJT�yMHJI�@iHcD x @CNP}*dr�c_dcTL|ºD x @UT�eS@Uy{y�BEN{@UyM@CN{a�d�D{RSHJTºI­dr�m�9@��9@CDMDM@CNU_L�9@UQCdcKLy{@'RSD.dce]eSH }®y�b�HcN®d�I�HcN{@"QVHJI­BEdcQVD®N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT±F

¶\HcN�dcT\HcD x @CNº@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_PeS@CD � yºQVHJTLy{R]|L@CN(N{@CBEN{@UyM@UT�D{R]T\[ ��d��EyMDMN^dcQVDh�mDM@V�4D{yºdcyºyMDMN^RfT\[JyC_ARªF�@cFS_AeS@CD � yºQVHJTLy^R]|\@CNyM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q,I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­y × � K �����B����F v®x @�y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI �+KL� x dcy�yMHcN{D{yjb�HcN'yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_o}²HcN^|EyC_�dcTL|Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^yC_9} x RfeS@�D x @«y^RS[JT�y{�/yMDM@UI��B� � HJTLeS� x dcyPyMHcN{D{yAb�HcNPyMDMNhR]T\[Jy.dcTL|�Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^yCFP»²@UQCdcKEyM@iQ x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^yd�N{@ºd�|Ld�D{d�yMHcN{DC_*dcTz�ÈI�HcN{B x R]y{I� ×��+KL� � �B� � IiKLyMDiBLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@�D x @ºyMHcN{DL �����©_�dcTE|¦D x @CN{@ºR]y,dce]yMHT\H�Q x HJRfQV@­d��=HJKLD x H } DMH�I�d�B�D x @iHcD x @CN'yMHcN{D{yPHcb?�+K �­×=D x @C��IiKLyMD�dce]eo[cH�DMHmD x @,y{HcN{D5' 8���� ��9EF v.x @iDMHcBeS@Cac@Ue¬QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDMHcN'Hcb�� K �¸b�HcN^I­yjDM@V�4D{y��/��QVHJTLQCd�DM@UTEd�D{R]T\[�yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_o} x R]e]@«RSD{y�yM@UQVHJTE|�eS@Cac@Ue¬QVHJTLyMDMN^KEQVDMHcNQVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�DM@UyA}*HcN^|Ly�DMH­b�HcN^I¸yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyC_EdcTE|ºRSD{y�D x RSN^|�eS@Cac@Ue QVHJTLyMDMN^KLQVDMHcNAQVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�DM@UyPQ x d�N^[email protected]�b�HcN^I}*HcN^|LyCFZO4R]TEQV@®D x @AHJTLeS�­QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVDMHcN²b�HcN � ���ÝQVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�[email protected] x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^y�DMHib�HcN^I¤y{DMN^R]T\[JyC_�D x @®Hc�/a4RSHJKLy²D x R]T\[DMHº|\H�R]yAI�d�B�@UdcQ x QVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�D{RSHJT�HcbF� K �wDMH�D x @,QVHJTLQCd�DM@UTLd�D{R]HJT�Hcb��B� ��F�*AHr}*@Cac@CNU_�D x @�y{R][JT�N{@Uy^KLeSD{R]T\[b�N{HJI d�DM@V�4D*}²HJKLef|­T\Hr}��9@ÌÞMKEyMD¬HJT\@ x K\[c@PK\[JeS�,yMDMN^R]T\[�} x R]Q x �MI«KLy x @Uy�'@Cac@CN^��D x RfT\['DMHc[c@CD x @CNUF²£AyZ}²@AØ/T\H }'_RSD�R]y�KLy{KEdce©DMH­RfTLyM@CN{D�yMBEdcQV@Uy��9@CD¨}²@C@UTº}*HcN^|LyU_4dcTE|ºd,B=@CNhRSH/|mdcTL|mD�}*H�yMB©[email protected]�bgDM@CN�@UdcQ x yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@cF²¯¨D�R]y*@UdcyM�DMH�|\@CÄ©T\@'d�I�HcN{B x R]y{I D x d�D®|\H/@Uy.D x R]yC_4D x HJK\[ x R]D.R]y�I�HcN{@"QVHJI­BEeS@V��D x dcTºD x @ �MIiKLy x R]T\[^�iN{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJT�F

»*HcD x D x @Uy{@­I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­yABLN{@UyM@CN{ac@,D x @�yMDMNhKLQVD{K\N{@,Hcb � K ��F9»�K\Dj} x d�DP}*HJKLe]|�RSD�I�@UdcT�bgHcN'd�I�HcN{B x R]y{I ×1� K � � �B� � �©�J� DMH�BLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@,D x R]yPyMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@ � v.x @CN^@id�N{@�I­dcT���B9HJy{y{R]�ER]e]RSD{R]@UyC_LR]TLQCe]KE|LR]T\[­|\N^HcBLBER]T\[yMHJI�@�Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CN^yC_o}²HcNh|LyC_�dcTL|�� HcN'y{@UTzDM@UTLQV@UyU_ dcTL|�B9@CN^I«KLD{R]T\[�D x @UI R]T�d�N^dcTL|\HJI¼HcN^|\@CNrFw! x @UTLHJI�@UTLd�e]RSØc@D x @UyM@"}®R]e]e9QCeS@Ud�N^e]��BLN{H4|LKLQV@�d­e]Hr} Ë/KLdce]RSD¨�m|ER]yMBEe]dr�cF

X��/B9@CN^R]I­@UTzD{y®N{@CB9HcN{DM@U|�RfT$# z#� (¬y x H } D x d�DABEN{@UyM@CN{a4R]T\[ x RS[ x e]@Cac@Ue]yARfyAI�HcN^@iR]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzDAD x dcT�BEN{@UyM@CN{a4R]T\[BLN^R]HcN^RSD{RS@UyC_�} x R]Q x R]T­D{K\N^T�R]y�I­HcN{@.R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D¬D x dcT�BLN^@UyM@CN{a4R]T\[�QVHJTzDM@UT�DCF v.x @C�idce]y{H"y x H }�d'yMDMN{HJTL['DM@UTL|\@UTLQV�DMHPBLN{@UyM@CN{ac@ x RS[ x @CNoeS@Cac@Ue]y¹d�DÌD x @*@V�/B9@UTLyM@²HcbLeSHr}*@CN¬eS@Cac@Ue]yo} x @UTiyMHJI�@�yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@²IiKLyMD¹�9@Z|\N{HcBLB9@U|±F v.x R]y I­dU��9@«y{KLN{BLN^R]y^R]T\[\_\�9@UQCdcKLyM@«Hcb�@UI�B x dcy^R]y.�/��QVHc[JTLRSD{R]ac@«BEy{�/Q x HJeSHc[JR]yMD{yAHJT�D x @ �°�©dcy{R]QieS@Cac@Uef�(HcbZeS@V�\R]QCdce QVHJTLQV@CBED{y

�

Page 18: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

��@cF�[\FS_�Ù.HJy^Q x #�� �\_ � â (��hFA¶\HcN�TLd�D{K\Nhdceoe]dcTL[JKLd�[c@c_©D x @iyM@UT�DM@UT�D{R]dceoe]@Cac@Ueo}�dcyPeSHJT\[(QVHJTEy{R]|\@CN{@U|�DMH(�9@«�Edcy{R]Q�_=�EK\DN{@UyM@Ud�NhQ x e]RSØc@�D x d�D(Hcb # z#� (Py x Hr}®y�D x d�DmD x @�|LR]y^QVHJK\N^yM@�e]@Cac@Ue®R]y x RS[ x @CN�RfT HJK\N�DM@UQ x TLR]QCdcePyM@UTLy{@c_�dcTE|ÉD x KLyI�HcN{@(R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�DCF v.x R]y�R]y"QVHJTLy{R]yMDM@UT�D�}®RSD x D x @­R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D�[c@UT\@CN^dceZBLN^R]TLQCR]BEeS@"D x d�D"yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@ x dcy'BEN^RSHcN^RSD¨�Hrac@CN«QVHJTzDM@UT�DC_oR¡F�@cFS_ �C���6� �f�,�­���{�­���A§4���V�ª���E�P��³/��� �^���©���V�E� ��RSbZy{HJI�@CD x R]T\[�IiKLyMDj�9@iy{dcQVNhRSÄEQV@U|�DMHºe]R]I­RSDAD x @QVHJI�BEe]@V�4RSD¨�(HcbÌD x @'|ER]yMBEe]dr�\�hF��KLQ x I�HcN{@º|\@CD{dcR]eS@U|�@UI­BERSN^R]QCdce²}*HcN{ØÈRfyiTL@C@U|\@U|�DMH�|\@CDM@CN^I­RfT\@ºI�HcN{@ºBLN{@UQCRfyM@UeS��D x @�DMN^dc|L@CH��9y­dcI­HJT\[

a�d�N^RSHJKLy,BLN^@UyM@CN{a�d�D{RSHJT dcTL|�HcD x @CN­HcBED{R]I­dce]RSD¨�¦QVN^R]DM@CN^R]d�bgHcN­y{@UI­RSHcD{R]QºI�HcN^B x R]y{I�yCFã�D­yMD{d�N{D(R]y,�9@UR]T\[�I­dc|\@�/��dcy{y{@UI"�EefR]T\[�d�QVHJe]e]@UQVD{RSHJT�Hcb�@V�4dcI­BEeS@Uy�Hcb*�Edc|�|\@Uy^RS[JT�d�N^R]y^R]T\[�bgN^HJI b�dcRfe]K\N{@UyPHcb�yM@UI­RSHcD{RfQ�I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­yPDMHb�KLe]eS��BEN{@UyM@CN{ac@�y{DMN^KLQVD{K\N{@­RfT�D x @ �°}*HcN^e]|T�ªb�dcI�HJKLy� � � `�GYO4dcTÃ?PR]@C[cH�O/@UI­R]HcD{R]Q��=H/H\F�£Ae]D x HJK\[ x T\HcD'dcefe¬D x @@V�4BEe]dcTLd�D{RSHJTEy�d�N{@"dUa�dcR]e]d��©eS@��c@CDC_ED x @'dcTER]I­dce]y�QCdcT��=@ja4R]y{RSDM@U|ºd�DAdcTz� x HJK\N�HcbÌD x @«|LdU�mHcNATLR][ x DC_Ld�D

�48 8&! .�. ����� � �' � $��' � � �&��$ . $ ' �&�#' . 9��&9-$��-� .�� � � .} x @CN^@�I«KEQ x dc|E|LRSD{RSHJTLdce®R]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{RSHJT ��dcTE|�yMHJI�@��Edc|�ÞMHcØc@Uymd��=HJKLD­�CH�HJy6�­QCdcT�dce]yMHÃ�9@�b�HJKLTL|�F ��HJyMD(HcbD x @«@V� x R]�ERSD{y�D x @CN{@iR]T�acHJeSac@«QVHJeSHcNPdcTL|�� HcNjR]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{RSac@"[cNhd�B x R]QCyC_©dcTL|�yMHmQCdcTLT\HcDA@Udcy{R]eS�m�9@"|LR]y{QCKEy{yM@U|�R]T�D x R]yDMN^dc|LR]D{RSHJTLdce±I�@U|LRfKLI Hcb¹BEN^R]T�DCF

v.x @(D{d�D{dcI­R�BEN{H�Þ°@UQVD�d�D�`�G.O4? Rfy«d�BLB©eS�/RfT\[�yM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q(I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y"dcTL|¦D x @URSN,HcN^|L@CN^R]T\[Jy«DMH�|\@Uy{RS[JT¦D x @KLyM@CN�R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@AHcb d,yM�4yMDM@UI DMH,y{K\BLB9HcN{D{y²QVH�HcB9@CN^d�D{RSac@�|LRfyMDMN^RS�EKLDM@U|,BLN{H/Hcb�y²Hrac@CN�D x @P}*HcN^e]|(}®R]|\@A}²@C�.# 34â _ z �7(ªF��@PbgHJKLTE|­D x d�D*QV@CN{D{dcR]T(}*dr�/y²}²@ x dc|(KLyM@U|­DMHiN{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzDZBLN{H/Hcb�yZ}²@CN{@jT\HcD*yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q®I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­yC_J} x R]Q x D x @UTeS@U|�KLyjDMH�QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDj�9@CDMDM@CN'N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyC·�}*@­dce]yMHºKLyM@U|�yM@UI­R]HcD{R]Q,I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­yADMH�|\@CDM@CN^I­R]TL@idcyMB9@UQVD{y�Hcb}®R]TE|\Hr} efdU�cHJK\DC_©�EK\DMDMHJT�e]H/QCd�D{RSHJT�_L@CD{Q�F�?A@CD{dcRfe]y®QCdcT��=@"bgHJKLTE|º@UyMB9@UQCR]dce]eS�mR]T # zkz _ z �)(ª_©dcTL|�HcbÌQVHJKLN^yM@"HJT�D x @BLN{H�ÞM@UQVD.}*@C�Ey{RSDM@

�48 8&! .�. ����� � �' � $��' � � �&��$ . 9 ���-$ !>' . 84�-84� %B� .} x RfQ x y x HJKEe]|�dceS}*dr�/y x dUac@«D x @'ac@CN{��e]d�DM@UyMDAR]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{RSHJT±F

� � ��ZÏ,Ó­ÖhÏ1����� ��Ö��AÔ�ÖMÐ � .Ï,Ó���Ô1� �,ÒPÔ«Ð�¶LdcKLQVHJTETLRS@CN®dcTL| v K\NhT\@CNw# â �L_ âvz (¹yMD{KL|\�mD x @ �°�EeS@UTE|LR]T\[^�iHcb¬QVHJTLQV@CBLD{KLdceoyMBEdcQV@UyC_EDMH­Hc�LD{dcR]T�TL@C} yMBEdcQV@Uy®D x d�DQVHJI«�ER]T\@AD x @AB©d�N{D{y*Hcb±D x @PRfT\BEK\DZy{BEdcQV@UyCF�»�eS@UTL|Ly*d�N{@jQVHJI­I�HJT�R]T(TLd�D{K\N^dce=e]dcT\[JKLd�[c@c_4b�HcN²@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_/R]T�}²HcNh|Lye]RSØc@ � x HJKLyM@C�9HJd�D�mdcTL| �°N{HJdc|\Ø4R]e]e¡_��(dcTL|�RfT�B x NhdcyM@UyAefRSØc@ �Md�N{D{R]ÄEQCR]dce efRSbg@v�(dcTL| �MQVHJI�BEK\DM@CNja4RSN^KLyC_���dcyA}*@Ue]e¹dcyR]TºI�@CD{d�B x HcN^y�D x d�D x dUac@iI�HcN{@�D x dcTºHJTL@"yMDMN^dcTL|¦��dcy®R]y�KLy^KLdce]eS�­D x @"QCdcyM@ �hF

v.x @mI�HJy{Di�©dcy{R]Q­Ø4R]TL|¦Hcb.�Ee]@UTL|¦I�dU���9@ma/R]y^KLdce]RS�C@U|¦KLy{R]T\[�D x @�|LR]d�[cN^dcI �9@UeSHr}"_¬} x @CN{@� � dcTL|� / d�N{@QCdce]eS@U|ÈD x @ ½�¿ Æ � prn _��ÊD x @ ¾EÁ4¿oÁ�q�½�t _²dcTL|�� D x @ lÌÚ�Á/¿c, � 2�F ��HcN{@�BLN^@UQCR]yM@UeS�c_Ì}*@�|L@CÄET\@�d lÌÚ�Á/¿c, HcbPy{RS[JTyM�4yMDM@UI­y� � dcTL|� / Hrac@CN��¼��KLy{RfT\[�[JRSac@UT�yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q«I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�� �� � dcTL|�� �� / ��DMH(�9@"dmy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI� }ARSD x I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­y� � � �m_� / � �m_�dcTL|���� �(_Z} x R]Q x d�N^@�dcefe*QCdcefeS@U| ½�¿ �UÁ/tcp ½�Å=¿ n _*y{KLQ x D x d�D�D x @|LR]d�[cNhdcI�� Á/s���ÚgÀ¦tJÅ=¦Â&� prÁ/n _/RfT(D x @PyM@UTEyM@jD x d�D��=HcD x D x @jQVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{R]HJTLy � �! � �!�¤dcTL|"� �! / �!�d�N{@#� Á/s���ÚgÀ Á � �osEÚ DMH�D x @�I�HcN{B x Rfy{I$� � �m_¬R]T�D x @myM@UTEyM@�D x d�Di@UdcQ x y^RS[JTÃR]T�� [c@CD{y�I­d�BLB9@U|�DMH�D x @y{dcI�@my{RS[JT¦R]T%� KLTL|L@CN'D x @UIº_ÌBLN{H a/Rf|\@U|�D x d�D«�=HcD x I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�d�N{@m|\@CÄET\@U|ÃHJTÃRSD � * F�¯ D"b�HJe]eSH }®y�D x d�DiD x @QVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{R]HJTLy&� �' � �(�ÊdcTL|)� �' / �(�¼d�N{@�dce]yMH�}*@Ud�Ø/e]��@UË/KLdceÌ} x @UT%� �(�¼R]yPDMHcD{dce]eS��|L@CÄET\@U|±_�EK\D.TLHcD®T\@UQV@Uy{y{d�NhR]eS�mHcD x @CN{}®R]y{@cF v.x @'yMB9@UQCR]dce±QCdcy{@"} x @CN^@'dce]e�y{RS[JTºy{�/yMDM@UI�y®d�N{@"QVHJTEQV@CBLD{KLdce y{BEdcQV@Uy®R]y®QCdce]eS@U|d tzÅ©¿otJÁ�Æop��osEÚ�lÌÚ�Á/¿c, F�¯°T�[c@UT\@CNhdce¡_E}*@«y x HJKLe]|�@V�4B=@UQVDAD x @«I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y�DMH�D x @«�EeS@UTL|�DMHmBLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@"dcyPI«KLQ xdcy.B9HJy{y^RS�EeS@PbgN^HJIwD x @"R]T\B©K\D{y�dcTL|º[c@UT\@CN^RfQ�F1 U �7PY8�<WPQNE6q836b>�<WPQO-];H34)6q836�>YG )0>YO�* :=69RQP,+^P�P0] K 4):�DM4 836�>YG�GCI :�<_K�PY83G=@ g >�NEPQF7<�] >�G�NEPQ<ZHx>YGCK >�I0<�U0836�D�6b@06�<_:�H3<_O�>�NE6qK :CH34X�K�[email protected]�>YNEPQF7<�] [aK :�H34�H34)6`4�I0U)476�O-l1<Xb25476;gtPY83N PYg^H34):�<5@0:=>YRY8V>�N$:�<�X�F)U7<W:r@06 @0PbK O)[Agt83PYN H34�>H�F7<W6b@a\�I(��>�F)D�PYO)O7:=6M8 >YO)@E2jF783O7698b]�:�OEH34�>H�PYF78 >8W83PbK <5RQPLF)U']�K :CH34H34)6cRQ6�O76983:�D0/ PYO_H3476 \kP�HWH3PQNq]0>YO)@aH34)6 \7G�6�O�@21.PQO�H34)6;H3PQU-p�H347:�<5:�< D�PQO7<W:=<ZH369OvH�K :�H34_H34)6;NE69HV>YU74)P�8`e PY8�X�:�N�>YRQ6c<WDM476�NE6�[ ! $��'&thH34�>H_XJF)Ux:=<;NEPY8369[E>Y< K56�G�Gj>Y< K :�H34 D9PQO���6�O�H3:�PQO7< gtPY8 @08V>�K :�O)RE<WF7DM4x@7:=>YR�8V>YNE<;:=OxN�>�H34)69N�>�H3:�D�<�l � G�<WP7] ��>YF7D�PQO7O):�698c>YO)@q2jF783O7698@7P�O)PYH :�O7D�G�F�@76`H3476`N�>YU3/"451El1�.�)�HW83:�D9H;D�PQNENdF7HV>�H3:2�v:CHJI�]�K 47:�DM4q:�< F)<WF)>YG�GCIxD�>YG�G�6b@ �ZF7<ZH76 598:8 8<;>=?;A@CBD@C;FE�]�NE6�>YO)<5H34)>�H H3476AD�PQNEUkPY<W:�H3:�PYO)<;>�836A<ZHW83:�D9H3GCI�6WV�F�>YG l

�

Page 19: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

��� ���

��

�� �

��� ����

��� ��

� /

��d�D x @UI­d�D{R]QCdce]e]�c_=RSDAR]y®I�HcN^@"B9@CN^yMBERfQCK\HJKLy�DMHmD x R]T\ØmHcb¬�EeS@UTL|ER]T\[,D x @iD�}*HmI�HcN^B x R]y{I�y � 3/× � � e3¬D x dcT�D x @D�}*HÃyMB©dcQV@Uy � G / _²dcTL|�b�HcN­D x Rfy,N{@UdcyMHJT }*@º}®R]e]e*yMHJI�@CD{RfI�@Uy­KLyM@ºD x @�T\HcD{d�D{RSHJT � ��� � / DMH¦yMD{dcTL|�b�HcN�dcTd�N{�ER]DMN^d�N{���Ee]@UTL|ÃHcb � � dcTL| � / ·²D x Rfy«}AR]e]e��9@�@UyMB9@UQCR]dce]e]� x @UeSBLb�KLeZRfT¦}®N^RSD{R]T\[�bgHcNhI«KLefd�@(b�HcN�HJK\N�QCdce]QCKLe]KEy«Hcb�EeS@UTE|LR]T\[\F

»�eS@UTL|Ey x dUac@,d�BLBEefR]QCd�D{RSHJTLy�R]T�QVHJI�BEK\DM@CNjR]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@i|\@Uy{RS[JT�_LyMHJI�@"HcbÌ} x R]Q x d�N{@"|\@Uy{QVNhRS�9@U|ºR]T # 34â (ªF�¶\HcN�dy{R]I­BEeS@"@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_ y{K\BLB9HJyM@i}*@i}�dcT�D'DMH�|LR]yMB©e]dU�º�9HcD x DM@UI�B9@CN^d�D{K\N^@,dcTE|�D{R]I�@,Hcb²|Ldr��HJT�D x @­y{dcI�@­|\@Ca4R][email protected] Rfy®R]yAdcT�@V�\dcI�BEe]@"Hcb�D x @iBLN{H4|LKLQVD®HcbZy{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI­yC×.RSb ���Q�Rfy®dmy{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI b�HcNjDM@UI�B9@CN^d�D{K\N{@c·=D x @UT�D x @y{RS[JT,yM�4yMDM@UI~b�HcN¬HJK\N�|\@Ca4R]QV@�R]y ��"S � ���Q=FÌ»²@Cb�HcN{@.[JR]a/R]TL[AD x @�DM@UQ x TLR]QCdce\|L@CÄETLRSD{RSHJT�_�e]@CD��i|\@UTLHcDM@�D x @ �°DMN^RSa4R]dcef�y{RS[JT(yM�4yMDM@UI D x d�D x dcyZHJTLe]�iHJTL@PyMHcN^DP��RSD{y²DMHcBºyMHcN{Dh�¬dcTE|(T\H«HcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJTLyj��@V�4QV@CBED²D x HJy{@Ab�HcN*|Ed�D{dz�hFZá®H } [JRSac@UTy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­y � � dcTL| � / _±D x @UR]N ƹq�Å ,��otcp _ |L@UT\HcDM@U| � � � � / _�R]yPD x @,�EeS@UTE|�Hcb � � dcTE| � / H ac@CN���}®RSD x D x @Hc�/a/RSHJKEy«��dcTL|�HJTLeS�L��I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�� � �3 _Eb�HcN^I�@U|����ºD{d�Ø4R]T\[�D x @«|LRfy�Þ°HJRfTzD.KLTERSHJT / CPHcb � � dcTL| � / _©dcTL|�D x @UTR]|\@UT�D{RSb��/RfT\[«D x @URSN�DMHcB�yMHcN^D{y�DMH­[c@CD®d­TL@C}¢yMHcN{D®QCdce]e]@U|�D x @�BLN{H4|LKLQVD�yMHcN{DCF²»²HcD x R]T�ÞM@UQVD{RSHJTLy�d�N{@«R]T�ÞM@UQVD{RSac@'dcTL|�9HcD x DMN^R]dcTL[JeS@Uy�yMDMN^R]QVD{e]�(QVHJI­IiK\DM@cF

¯ D R]y�TLHcD x d�N^|'DMH®BLN{H ac@²yMHJI­@Zy{R]I�B©eS@ÌBLN{HcB9@CN{D{RS@Uy±Hcb4BLN^H/|LKEQVDC_ R]TLQCefKL|LR]T\[*D x @�b�HJe]eSH }®R]T\[\_ } x @CN{@ � G � � G � / G � �d�N{@"d�N^�ERSDMN^d�N{�my{RS[JTºyM�4yMDM@UI­yU_� ��� �D � _��� � �D � _� � � � / �D � / � � � _� � �¦� � / � � � � �D � � � � � / ��� � � F

v.x @Uy{@�d�N^@mHJTEeS�Ãd�I�H4|\@UyMD�dc|L|LR]D{RSHJTÃDMH�HJKLN,QCdcefQCKLe]KLyiHcb®N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJT±_��©K\D,D x @ºT\HcD{RSHJTÈHcb®BLN^H/|LKEQVD«�9@��QVHJI�@Uy'I­HcN{@­R]T�DM@CN{@UyMD{R]T\[ºe]d�DM@CN"HJT±_±} x @UT�@V�4DM@UTL|\@U|�b�N{HJI y{RS[JT�y{�/yMDM@UI�y�DMHºN{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyCFi¶LHcN^I­y�Hcb*D x @QVHJI­IiK\D{d�D{RSac@idcTL|�R]|\@UT�D{RSD¨�me]dr}®y.dce]y{H x HJe]|�b�HcN.�EeS@UTL|EyC_\dcTL|ºI­dU���9@�}.N^R]DMDM@UT�dcy

� ��� � / D � / � � � _� � â�� D ��_â � � �2D ��_

} x @CN^@AD x @jÄLNhyMD*y x HJKLe]|(�9@AN{@Udc|�dcy�y{dr�/RfT\[,D x d�D�dcTz�(�EeS@UTL|(Hcb-� � G � / R]y�dce]yMH�di�EeS@UTL|�Hcb�� / G � � _\dcTL|mD x @�T\@V�4DD�}*H(dcy®y{dU�4R]T\[­D x d�D.HJT\@��EeS@UTE|�Hcb¹dcT��ºyMBEdcQV@'}®R]D x RSD{y�[c@UT\@CN^RfQ�yMBEdcQV@"R]y�D x @"yMBEdcQV@"R]D{yM@UeSb F

»*@Cb�HcN{@�|\HJR]T\[md(y{efRS[ x D{e]��I­HcN{@iQVHJI­BEeS@V��@V�\dcI�BEeS@iR]T�yMHJI�@,|\@CD{dcR]e¡_=}²@i[c@UT\@CN^dcefRS�C@«D x @iQVHJTLQV@CBEDPHcbZ�EeS@UTL|DMH�dºe]d��9@UeS@U|�[cN^d�B x _�}®RSD x y^RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­y�HJT�R]D{y�T\H/|L@Uy�dcTL|�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yAHJT�RSD{y'@U|\[c@UyC_oy^KLQ x D x d�D«RSb���R]y�dcT@U|\[c@'b�N{HJI C DMH2 � _\D x @UT�D x @"I�HcN{B x R]y{I HJT�� x dcy.dcy®R]D{y.yMHJK\N^QV@�D x @"y{RS[JTºyM�4yMDM@UI¸HJT� C dcTL|ºdcy®RSD{y�D{d�N^[c@CDD x @iHJT\@iHJT � Fq��@,}®R]e]e QCdce]e D x R]yAefd��=@Ue]@U|�[cN^d�B x D x @ l¹sLnUÁ�¾©q sLÆÌÇ F�O/HJI­@iI�HcN^B x R]y{I�y®R]T�D x @«�©dcyM@«[cNhd�B xI­dr���9@P|L@Uy{RS[JTLd�DM@U|�dcy s � ; ½�Ú�½�sLq À / � _\R]TL|LRfQCd�D{R]T\['D x d�D�D x @jN{@Uefd�D{RSHJTLy x R]BEy�D x d�D�D x @C��@UI"�9H4|\��|\H,T\HcD�T\@C@U|mDMH�9@,BLN{@UyM@CN{ac@U|�F v.x @UT�d lÌÚ�Á/¿c, b�HcN"d�[JRSac@UT��©dcyM@�[cN^d�B x R]yjyMHJI­@­y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UIº_�DMHc[c@CD x @CN«}®RSD x dºI�HcN{B x R]y{IQCdce]eS@U|¦dcT ½�¿ �UÁ/tcp ½�Å©¿ DMH�RSD«bgN{HJI¥@UdcQ x y{R][JTÃyM�4yMDM@UI R]T�D x @([cN^d�B x _Ìy{KLQ x D x d�DidcT���DMN^R]dcT\[Je]@­Hcb.I�HcN{B x R]y{I­ym 2 2547:�< :=O���PYG2��6�<?8369O�>YNE:�O7RL<WP�8WH3< >YO)@�PYUk698V>�H3:�PYO)<�]7:�g-O)69D�6�<W<3>�8WI�]0<WP+H34�>H�H34)6M836`>�836cO)PLP���6983G=>YU7<56��0D�6�U0H�g�P�8 H34)6c@)>HV>L<WP�8WH3< >YO)@PQUk6M8V>�H3:�PQO7<�l5254vF)<5H347:�<;\7G�6�O�@_:=<;>�<WP�8WH;PYgAXJ>YN�>YG�RQ>YN�>�H36�@x<WF)NE[dPYg :CH3< HJK�Pa:�O)U)F0H3<Ae�H34):�< U)408V>Y<W6A:�< F)<W6b@_:�O >YG�RQ69\78V>Y:�DAH3PQUkPYG�PQRYI�]>YNEPYO)REP�H34)698;U)G=>�D�6�<VhMl *`F76`H3PaH34)6+@7F)>YG�:CHJIx\k69HJK�6�6�OqH34)69PY83:�6�<c>YO�@qNEPv@06�G�<+ef>Y< g�PY83N�>�G�: *96b@ :=OqH3476`H34)6�P�8WIqP�g�:=O7<ZH3:CH3F7H3:�PQO7< ! #%$'&�hM]H34):�< D�P�8W836�<WUkPQO)@7< H3P�HV>Yyv:�O)R�U783Pv@7F7D9H3< PYg�NEPv@06�G�<�lmM1�&xP�836�H36�DV4)O7:�Db>YG�GCI�]�:CH�:=<LH34)6 ^����(^cb�H34)>�Ha>�836�@76�<W:�RQO)>�H36b@ >Y<a>YF�0:�G�:=>�8WI�]i\k6�Db>�F)<W6x:CH�:=<�UkPQ<W<W:�\)G�6�H34)>�HdH34)6_<3>YNE6_NEPY83U)47:�<WN>YU7Uk6b>�83< PYOqNEPY836 H34)>YO�PQO)6A6�@7RQ6Y])K 4)6M836AO)PYH;>�G�Gj:�O)<ZHV>�O)D�6�< P�g�:�H;>836L>YF�0:�G�:=>�8WI�l

â &

Page 20: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

R]T�acHJeSa4R]T\[ºD�}*H�RfT�Þ°@UQVD{R]HJTLy'dcTL|�HJTL@(T\HJTT��dcK\�4R]efR]d�N{��I�HcN^B x R]y{I RfT�D x @­�Edcy{@­[cN^d�B x }²@Ud�Ø4eS��QVHJI­IiK\DM@UyCF v.x @@V�\QCe]KLy{RSHJT�Hcb'dcK\�4R]efR]d�N{�ÃI�HcN^B x R]y{I�y�R]y­R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�DC_*�=@UQCdcKEyM@�QVHJI­IiK\D{d�D{RSa4RSD�� y x HJKLe]| T\HcD­�9@�@V�4B9@UQVDM@U|Éb�HcNdcK4�\R]e]R]d�N^��RfT\bgHcNhI­d�D{RSHJT±·9D x R]yPR]yjR]e]efKLyMDMN^d�DM@U|�R]T�D x @«@V�\dcI�BEe]@i�9@UeSH }'F v.x @i�EdcyM@,[cN^d�B x b�HcNjD x @,�Edcy{R]Q«Ø/RfTL|�Hcb�EeS@UTE|�QVHJTLy{R]|L@CN{@U|�d�DPD x @"�9@C[JR]TLTER]T\[,Hcb¬D x R]yAyM@UQVD{RSHJT x dcy®d � � �my x d�B9@c·©e]@CDAKLyAKLyM@'D x @«DM@CN^I�� �^lÌÚ�Á/¿c,¹n b�HcND x R]y®QCdcyM@cF.£AefyMH\_©eS@CDAKLy®QCdce]eod�T\H4|\@'R]T�D x @"�Edcy{@"[cN^d�B x�s � ; ½�Ú�½�sLq À RSbÌdce]e I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y�DMH(dcTL|�bgN^HJI RSD®RfTºD x @�EdcyM@"[cN^d�B x d�N{@"dcK\�4R]efR]d�N{�T/b/rF

£ABLB9@UTL|LR ��» |\@Cac@UeSHcBEyAD x @"d��9H ac@iR]|[email protected]�HcN{@«BLN{@UQCR]yM@Ue]�c_EdcTL|ºBEKLD{y.�EeS@UTE|LR]T\[�R]TºD x @'N^R]Q x I­d�D x @UI�d�D{R]QCdceb�N^dcI�@C}*HcN{Ø(HcbÌQCd�DM@C[cHcN{��D x @CHcN{�c_EN{@Ue]d�D{R]T\[ � �ª�EeS@UTL|Ey²DMH�} x d�D�d�N{@"QCdce]e]@U| �°BEKLy x HJKLD{y�4_\dcTL|�D x @'I�HcN{@�[c@UTL@CN^dce�EeS@UTE|�Hcb�d��Edcy{@�[cN^d�B x DMH�} x d�D'd�N{@­QCdce]eS@U|ÃQVHJe]R]I­RSD{yUF«¯°T�dc|L|LR]D{RSHJT±_�£ABLB9@UTL|LR ��»~|\@Cac@Ue]HcBEy�d�yMB9@UQCR]dceÌØ4R]TL|HcbZQCd�DM@C[cHcN{�c_oQCdce]eS@U|�d �/ ��QCd�DM@C[cHcN{�c_odcTL|�y x Hr}®yPD x d�D���} x d�DP}*@«D x @CN^@iQCdce]e�� �/ �ªBEKLy x HJK\D{yPdcTL| �/ ��QVHJefR]I­RSD{y®[JRSac@�EeS@UTE|LyÌD x d�D²d�N^@ �°�9@UyMD�B9HJy{y{RS�©eS@v�jR]T­d'QV@CN{D{dcRfT­BLN{@[email protected]@UTLyM@®D x d�D²R]T�acHJeSac@UyZHcN^|\@CN^R]TL['yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q®I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­y¹���Ë/KLdce]RSD¨�c_©@cF�[\FS_9D x d�DPD x @C��y x HJKEe]|º�9@«dcyP|\@CÄET\@U|�dcyPB=HJy^y{RS�EeS@c_Ly x HJKLe]|�BLN{@UyM@CN{ac@idcyAI�dcTz��d��\RSHJI­yPdcyAB=HJy^y{RS�EeS@c_dcTL|�y x HJKLe]|m�9@'dcy®R]TEQCe]KLy{RSac@jdcy�B9HJy{y{R]�EeS@���yM@C@«?P@CÄETLR]D{RSHJT 3 �hF

boat

on

water

ride

pasngr

hsbt

on

water

live-in

resident

bths

on

land

live-in

boat

house

on

land

live-in

resident

medium

on use

person

object

¶ÌRS[JK\N^@ � × v }*H­?PR �=@CN{@UT�D®»�eS@UTL|Ey�Hcb v }²H�¯°T\BEK\D®O/B©dcQV@Uy

��@.T\H } y x Hr} yM@Cac@CNhdce4}*dr�/yÌDMHj�EeS@UTE|«yMB©dcQV@UyÌbgHcNÌD x @*}²HcNh|Lyq� x HJKLyM@v�jdcTL|u�°�9HJd�D�4·�yM@C@�¶ÌRS[JK\N^@ � _JR]T«} x RfQ xD x @.[c@UTL@CN^R]Q.yMB©dcQV@®R]y�dcK4�\R]e]Rfd�N{�cF;��@P|\H'T\HcDZdcyMB©RSN{@�DMH"[cN^@Ud�D²dcQCQCK\N^dcQV��R]T�e]R]T\[JKLRfyMD{R]Q*I�H/|L@Ue]R]T\[ x @CN{@c·4QV@CN{D{dcR]TLe]�IiKLQ x I�HcN{@"|\@CD{dcRfe QVHJKLe]|��=@'dc|E|\@U|ºDMH�D x @"a�d�N^RSHJKLy.y{BEdcQV@UyC_©dcTE|�yMHJI�@"|L@CD{dcR]e]y®QVHJKEe]|º�9@'Q x dcefeS@UT\[c@U| / � F.´jK\NR]T�DM@CN{@UyMD'R]yjNhd�D x @CN'DMH�R]e]efKLyMDMN^d�DM@,D x @­I­d�D x @UI­d�D{R]QCdce�I­dcQ x R]T\@CN^��R]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@U|�R]T�D x R]y�y{@UQVD{RSHJT�}®RSD x d�y^R]I�BEeS@c_mWm�,?H34�>YO7y /c83:�RQPY836 �;P��<WFxgtPY8 H34)6A<WF7RQRY6�<ZH3:�PQOqH3PaRY6�O)698V>�G�: *96+gr83PQN >YF!�0:=G�:=>�8WI�O)Pv@06�< H3Pa>�F�0:�G=:=>8WIq6b@0RQ6�<�lm%�b2547:�<c:�< D�PQO7<W:�<ZH36�O�H;K :CH34qPYF78;\k6�G�:�69gTH34)>�H;F)O7: V�F76 \k6�<ZH;UkPQ<W<W:�\7G=6AH3476�PY83:�6�<;@7P�O)PYH;6��0:�<ZH g�P�8 NEPY<ZH 836b>YG'K5P�83Gr@�D�PQO7D�6�U7H3< ! #)Y & l

z �

Page 21: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

R]T�D{KLRSD{RSac@º@V�\dcI�BEe]@cF v.x @�[c@UT\@CN^R]Q�y{BEdcQV@ x dcy�D x N{@C@�QVHJTLy{D{dcTzD{yC_ � � � �� 8=_T%#� ��� $&%�_*dcTL| !�����'"�-�±_ZBEe]KEy�D�}*HN{@Ue]d�D{R]HJTLyC_ �-�ÉdcTE| $ '"�EF v.x @ x HJKLy{@�R]T\B©K\D x dcymQVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{y�bgHcN ���-$ '"�E_ � �"�4�©_.dcTL| ����'&�-���"�48©·AD x @UyM@�d�N{@I­d�BLB9@U|�HJTzDMHº�/�0� � � �� 8=_�%�� ��� $�% _9dcTL|3!��&�#'-�-��bgN{HJIÜD x @«[c@UT\@CNhR]Q,yMBEdcQV@c_±N{@UyMB9@UQVD{RSac@Ue]�©·±D x @,N{@Uefd�D{RSHJTLyjd�N{@�4� � ���4� �9_\dcTL|N�-�9_\} x @CN{@�D x @�ÄLNhyMD.R]y�I­d�BLB9@U|�HJT�DMH­�/� $ '-�L_\dcTL|º} x @CN{@�D x @ ���"$ '-�­R]y �-� � �"���EF²O4RfI­R]e]d�N^e]�c_D x @��9HJd�DmRfT\BEK\D�y{BEdcQV@ x dcy�QVHJTLyMD{dcT�D{yºbgHcN ������8=_ � ��84���=_.dcTL| !���'�'"�-�49��&�©_�} x RfQ x d�N{@�I­d�BLB9@U|�HJT�DMH����� �����4"8=_�%#� ��� $&%�_zdcTE|I!��&��'"�-�9_cN^@UyMB9@UQVD{RSac@UeS�=·�dcTL|(RSD x dcy�N^@Ue]d�D{RSHJTLyT�#�-���«dcTL| �-�9_�} x @CN{@�D x @.ÄLN^yMD�Rfy�I­d�BLB9@U|HJT�DMHm�/�L$ '"�E_9dcTL|�} x @CN{@iD x @ �����-8ºR]y �"� � ��8��&�=F®¯°T�b�HcN^I­R]TL[�dm�EeS@UTL|±_©D x @CN{@,R]yPd(QVHJT �©R]QVDA�9@CD¨}²@C@UT��9@UR]T\[HJTm}*d�[email protected]|(�9@UR]TL["HJT�e]dcTL|±_/dcTL|mbgHcN � x HJKEyM@C�9HJd�D�4_\}*d�DM@CN�}®RfTLyCF`*®@CN{@�dce]e©DMN^R]dcTL[JeS@Uy²QVHJI�I«K\DM@cF v.x @P�EeS@UTL|b�HcN­�9HJd�D x HJKLyM@�Q x H/HJyM@Uy�e]dcTE|ÉR]TLyMDM@Udc|�Hcbj}�d�DM@CNUF�»�K\D�D x @�I�HJyMD(R]TzDM@CN^@UyMD{R]T\[�D x RfT\[Jy,DMH¦T\HcD{RfQV@�d��=HJKLD­D x @�9HJd�D x HJKLyM@��EeS@UTL|�d�N{@�D x d�D"D x @��=HJd�D"�=@UQVHJI­@Uy'D x @(N{@Uy{R]|\@UT�DC_ dcTL|ÃD x d�D'D x Rfy'eS@Udc|Ly"DMH�d�T\HJT ��QVHJI­I«KLD{d�D{RSac@DMN^R]dcTL[JeS@�Hcb¹I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y*HJTºD x @'N^R][ x D.y{Rf|\@cF

v.x @CN{@­d�N{@�dce]y{H�yMHJI�@­HcD x @CNU_¹I­HcN{@­y{K\N{BEN^R]y{R]TL[\_=�©eS@UTL|LyPb�HcN"D x @UyM@�D�}*H�QVHJTLQV@CBLD{KEdceZyMBEdcQV@UyU×"HJT\@­[JR]ac@Uy"d�9HJd�DAb�HcNjDMN^dcTLyMB9HcN{D{RfT\[ x HJKLy{@UyC_=dcTE|�dcTLHcD x @CNj[JRSac@UyjdcT�dcI­B x RS�ER]HJKLy x HJKLy{@ ��O/@C@,¶ÌRS[JK\N{@ � F v.x @iÄLN^yMDA�EeS@UTL|��DMH�D x @,eS@CbgDjR]T�¶¹R][JK\N{@ � �.R]yP|LKLdceoDMH x HJKLyM@C�9HJd�DC×.R]TEyMDM@Udc|�HcbZD x @,�=HJd�DP@UTL|LRfT\[�K\B�R]T�D x @ x HJKLyM@c_=D x @ x HJKLyM@@UTL|Ly«K\BÃHJT¦D x @(�=HJd�DC·ZD x @CN{@ � y,T\HcD x R]TL[�yMDMN^dcT\[c@md��9HJK\D"D x Rfy'@V�\QV@CBLD«D x d�D"}*@m|\HJT � D x drac@mdcT���@UyMD{d��EefR]y x @U|}*HcN^|ºb�HcNARSDC_LdcTL|�RSD.|\H/@Uy{T � D®QVHcN{N^@UyMB9HJTL|�DMH(dcT���D x R]T\[­R]T���I�HJy{D.B9@CHcBEeS@ � yh�²@V�4B9@CN^RS@UTLQV@ / �cF v®x @'yM@UQVHJTL|��EeS@UTL|��DMH­D x @"N^RS[ x D�RfTº¶¹R][JK\N{@ � ��R]y�I­HcN{@�@V�/HcD{RfQ�_Ey{R]TLQV@�D x @�N{@Uy{KLeSD{RfT\[«Hc�\Þ°@UQVD®QCdcT��9@P@UR]D x @CN.HJT�e]dcTE|�HcN.HJTº}�d�DM@CNU_dcTL|mD x @'KLy{@CN*�9HcD x N^R]|L@Uy*dcTE|ºe]RSac@Uy�R]T�RSDCF¬£Ae]D x HJK\[ x T\H�y{KLQ x D x R]T\[i@V�4RfyMD{y�R]TmHJK\N�}²HcNhe]|�T\Hr}'_\}*@�QCdcTº@Udcy{R]e]�R]I­d�[JRfT\@�yMHJI�@'I­dc|�@UT\[JRfT\@[email protected]{�4R]T\[,DMH��EKLRfe]|�HJTL@cFZá®H } RSD.R]y�R]T�DM@CN{@UyMD{RfT\[�DMH­yM@C@�} x RfQ x DMN^R]dcTL[JeS@Uy�QVHJI­IiK\DM@b�HcN²@UdcQ x Hcb±D x @UyM@c_\dcTL|­D x @UT(DMH«QVHJI­BEd�N{@PD x @ATLd�D{KLN^dce]T\@Uy{yZHcb±@UdcQ x �EeS@UTE|�}®RSD x RSD{y²|L@C[cN{@C@®Hcb QVHJI�I«K\D{d�D{R]a/RSD¨�cFv.x @�eS@Cb�D�DMN^R]dcT\[Je]@AHcboD x @�ÄLN^yMD*�EeS@UTE|�b�dcR]e]y*DMH­QVHJI­IiK\DM@���d�[JdcR]TiÞ{KLyMD�|LKLdce=DMH �°�9HJd�D x HJKLy{@v�z�hFZ¶\HcN.D x @'y{@UQVHJTL|±_dceSD x HJKL[ x �=HcD x RSD{y�DMN^R]dcT\[Je]@Uy�QVHJI­I«KLDM@c_LD x @'y{RSD{KEd�D{RSHJT x @CN{@'R]y�dcQVD{KEdce]eS��}*HcN^yM@"D x dcTºRSb D x @C�m|LRf|LT � DC_4�9@UQCdcKLyM@D x @�R]T�ÞM@UQVD{RSHJTLyob�dcR]ezDMH�BEN{@UyM@CN{ac@�yMHJI�@�HcbED x @*N^@UeS@Ca�dcT�D¬yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@c_JTLdcI�@UeS�"D x @j��RfI�BEe]R]QCR]Dh� �=���z�c���¡���\� HcbEN^@Ue]d�D{RSHJTR]TLy{D{dcTLQV@UyC_Ly{KLQ x dcy.D x d�D.D x @��9HJd�D®R]y �©�J� HJT�e]dcTL|±F

water

hsbt

landuser

on

on

live-in

ride

hsbt

house water

onmoves

¶ÌRS[JK\N^@ � × v }*H ��@Uy{y.¶EdcI­R]e]R]d�N.»�eS@UTE|Ly

v.x @Pd��9Hrac@�R]y�d«[cH�H4|�R]e]e]KEyMDMN^d�D{RSHJT�Hcb�D x @Pac@CN{�(R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzD²b�dcQVD�D x d�D*�EeS@UTE|Ly²d�N^@PT\HcD�KLTER]Ë�KL@cF¹£PI"�©RS[JKLRSD¨�dcTL|�RSD{y®N^@UyMHJe]K\D{RSHJT�d�N{@"B9@CN{a�dcy{RSac@«R]T�TLd�D{KLN^dce e]dcTL[JKLd�[c@iKETL|\@CN^yMD{dcTE|LR]T\[\F�£ }²HcNh|±_©B x N^dcyM@'HcNjyM@UT�DM@UTLQV@i}®RSD xdcT �°Hc�/a4RSHJKLy��I�@UdcTLR]T\[�R]T�HJT\@�QVHJT�DM@V�4DC_¬HcNiR]TÃR]yMHJe]d�D{RSHJT�_ QCdcT x dUac@�dºac@CN{��|LR��9@CN{@UT�D"I�@UdcTLRfT\[�R]T�dcTLHcD x @CNQVHJT�DM@V�/DCFd� x d�D�R]y*dcI­d��UR]TL[iR]y²D x d�D�}*@AN{@Uy{HJeSac@�dcI"�ER][JKLRSD{RS@Uy²yMH,@��=HcN{D{e]@Uy{y{eS��D x d�D�}*@Pd�N^@UT � D�@Cac@UTºdU}�d�N{@jD x d�DD x @C��@V�4RfyMDM@U|±_�yMHºD x d�D'R]DPD{d�Øc@Uy«yMHJI�@�@��9HcN{D�DMH�|LR]y^QVHrac@CN'D x @�HcD x @CN'B9HJy{y{RS�ERfe]RSD{RS@Uy�D x d�D�}²@CN{@�B©dcy{yM@U|�Hrac@CNiyMH@Udcy{R]e]� ��¶\HcNjdcT\HcD x @CN®@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_E£ABLB9@UTL|LR �(£ QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVD{y®d­QVHJT�DM@V�4DAR]Tº} x R]Q x D x @�HJe]|�d�B x HcNhR]y{I � v R]I­@ �ERS@Uye]RSØc@�dcT d�N{N{H }_��KLTL|L@CN{[cH�@Uy,d�|\N^dcy{D{R]Q�Q x dcT\[c@ºHcbPI�@UdcTLR]TL[\_ZdcTL|�dce]yMH�[JRSac@Uy�d�b�HcN^I­dce�yMB9@UQCRSÄEQCd�D{R]HJT¦HcbAD x @QVHJTLQV@CBLD{KEdce�[email protected]@U|�_4KEy{R]T\[iD x @«´j»��­y{�/yMDM@UI # z�� (�DMH­QVHJI�BEK\DM@�D x @��©eS@UTL|±_/BEd�N^yM@�D x @jy{@UTzDM@UTLQV@c_=dcTL|D x @UTÃ@Ca�dce]KEd�DM@�RSD'DMH�N{@Cac@Udce�D x @ �MI�@UdcTLR]T\[^�4F�£w|LR��9@CN{@UT�D'}*dr��DMH�R]efe]KLyMDMN^d�DM@,D x @(dcI"�ER][JKLRSD���Hcb��EeS@UTE|Ly�QCdcT�9@'yM@C@UT�RfTºD x @'�9@UdcK\D{RSb�KLe9dcTLdceS�4yM@UyA|\HJT\@'�/� *PRSN^d�[Jd # 3#� _ 3�� (oHcb x dcRSØ/K��/��D x @'[cN{@Ud�D �Jd�BEdcTL@UyM@'B9H�@CDA»*dcy x H\·y x @my x H }®yiD x d�Diy{@Cac@CN^dce�|LR��9@CN{@UTzDi�EeS@UTE|Ly'QVH/@V�4R]y{D«b�HcN,D x @UyM@ x dcRSØ4K±_¹dcTE|¦d�N{[JKL@Uy«D x d�DiD x R]y"R]yid�|\@Ue]RS�9@CN^d�DM@@V�4BEeSHJRSD{d�D{RSHJT�Hcb¹dcI«�ERS[JKLR]D���dcy.d�B9H�@CD{RfQ�|\@Ca/RfQV@cFm �?F7H K56ADb>�Oq6b>�<W:=GCI�:�N�>YRQ:�O76+>�D�PQO7<ZHW83F)D9H3:�PYOqU783P��Z6�DMH PYOq>YOx:=<WG=>�O�@�K 4769836AU78369g�>Y\083:=D�>�H36b@q47PQF)<W69<c>836`HW8V>YO7<WUkPY8WH36b@x\�I_\kP�>Hbl

z4â

Page 22: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

£PI"�©RS[JKLRSD¨�Ãdce]yMH�BEe]dr�/y,dcT R]T�DM@CN{@UyMD{R]TL[�N{HJeS@ºR]TÈyMH�QCdce]eS@U| �°HU�4�4I�HcN{HJTLy�É��efRSØc@$�MI�R]e]RSD{d�N{��RfTzDM@Ue]efRS[c@UTLQV@v�z�h×D x @UyM@,R]T�acHJeSac@"D¨}²H�|LR��9@CN{@UT�D®�Ee]@UTL|Ly�Hcb¬D¨}²Hm[JRSac@UT�}²HcN^|EyC_©HJTL@"Hcb¬} x RfQ x�x dcyAd(yMD{dcTL|Ld�N^|�I�@UdcTLR]TL[\_©dcTL|�D x @HcD x @CN(HcbA} x R]Q x x dcy�yMHJI�@�Ø4R]TL|�HcbjQVHJT �ER]QVD(R]T RSDCF v.x @�y{@UQVHJTL|ÉI�@UdcTLRfT\[�HJTLeS��d�N^R]yM@Uy,�9@UQCdcKLy{@�D x @º}*HcN^|�°HU�4�4I�HcN{HJT�� x dcy��9@C@UT­R]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@U|±_JdcTE|­D x R]y¬|L@Ue]RS�9@CN^d�[email protected]{@Ud�D{RSHJT�Hcb±d'y{K\N{BEN^R]y{R]TL[AdcI«�ERS[JKLRSD¨�iRfy¬} x d�DZI�d�Øc@UyD x @UyM@(d�b�HcN^I Hcb x KLI�HcNUFm¶\HcN �MI­Rfe]RSD{d�N{��R]T�DM@Ue]e]RS[c@UTLQV@v��D x @�yMD{dcTL|Ld�Nh|�I�@UdcTLR]TL[�R]y'dcT¦d�[c@UTLQV��D x d�D'[Jd�D x @CNhyR]T�DM@Ue]e]RS[c@UTEQV@º��RªF�@cFS_oR]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{R]HJT±_±@UyMB9@UQCR]dce]eS��yM@UQVN{@CD«RfT\bgHcNhI­d�D{RSHJT©�.bgHcN«I­R]e]RSD{d�N^��BEK\N{B9HJyM@UyU_±} x R]eS@iD x @�y{@UQVHJTL|±_QVHJT �ERfQVD{KLdceAI­@UdcTLR]T\[ÈR]y(y{HJI�@CD x R]T\[�e]RSØc@ �MyMD{K\BERf|�y{I�d�N{D{T\@Uy{y�4_®BEe]dU�4R]T\[¦H�� D x @�QVHJI­I�HJT~���EKLDmR]TEQVHcN{N{@UQVDh�BLN{@ Þ{KL|LRfQV@iD x d�D'D x @­I­R]efRSD{d�N{��d�N{@(yMD{K\BER]|�_±BEe]KLyPD x @�I­HcN{@­KLy{KLdce¬I­@UdcTLR]T\[ºHcb�R]T�DM@Ue]e]RS[c@UTLQV@cF�£weSHcD�Hcb x KLI�HcNyM@C@UI­yPDMH x drac@,dmy{R]I�R]e]d�N®Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CNU×jdcT�R]T\b�HcN^I­dce�y{KLN{ac@C��HcbZQCd�N{DMH/HJTLy�R]T�D x @,eSH/QCdce¹T\@C}®y{BEd�B9@CNAb�HJKLTL|�D x d�DI�HcN{@�D x dcT x dceSb«Hcb«D x @ÃR]T�DM@UTL|\@U|LeS� x KLI­HcN{HJKLy�QCd�N{DMH/HJTLy�dcQ x RS@Cac@U| D x @URSN�@��9@UQVD��/��N^@UQVHJTzDM@V�4D{KLdce]RS�Ud�D{R]HJT±_D x N{HJKL[ x �Ee]@UTL|LR]T\[«d"[JRSac@UT�QVHJTLQV@CBED{KLdce±yMBEdcQV@P}®RSD x yMHJI�@�T\@C} QVHJTLQV@CBLD{KLdce9yMB©dcQV@c_\DMHi[JR]ac@PyMHJI­@PB©d�N{D{yZHcboD x @HJe]|ºHJTL@'y{K\N{BLNhR]y{R]T\[iT\@C} I�@UdcTER]T\[JyCF

O/@UI�RSHcD{R]Q,I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yPQCdcT�dce]yMHºd�N^RfyM@,} x @UT�y{RS[JTLy�y x HJKLe]| x dUac@(yMHJI�@­dc|L|LR]D{RSHJTLdce¹yMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@,RfT�HcNh|\@CN�DMH�9@'QVHJTLy{R]|L@CN{@U| �°[cH�H4|��4F*¶\HcNA@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_\D��/BER]QCdce±N{@UQV@UT�D�*AHJe]eS�/}*H�H4|ºI�Hra4RS@Uy x dUac@id�D x N{@C@'dcQVDPyMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@�}®RSD xD�}*H�yMB9@UQCRSÄEQ �°B©eSHcD"B9HJR]T�D{y��D x d�DiI�H ac@(D x @mdcQVD{RSHJTÈb�N{HJI¥HJT\@(dcQVD�R]T�DMH�D x @�T\@V�4DC·ZeS@CD � yiQCdce]e²D x R]y'D x @$�^O/�4|¶ÌRS@Ue]|��PyMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@�d�bgDM@CN�dcT�dcKLD x HcN¬} x Hjdc|\acH4QCd�DM@UyZRSDE# â�3 (ªF¬»�eS@UTL|LR]TL[®D x R]y¹}®R]D x D x @ �°Ä©e]I I�@U|LR]KLI �®yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@��QVHJTLy{RfyMD{R]T\[iHcboy x HcD{yC_\y{QV@UT\@UyC_LdcT\[Je]@UyC_4@CD{Q�Fß�*[JRSac@Uy�diBLN{@UQCR]y{@Py{R][JTmy{�/yMDM@UIwD x d�D.QCdcT x @UeSBm}®RSD x KLTL|\@CNhyMD{dcTL|LR]TL[QV@CN{D{dcR]T(dcyMB9@UQVD{yZHcb±Ä©e]I­yCF�� v.x R]y�RfyZd'Nhd�D x @CN²|LR �=@CN{@UT�DZd�BLBEN{HJdcQ x DMHid�BLB©eS�/RfT\[�yM@UI­RSHcD{R]QCyZDMH«QCR]TL@UI­d�D x dcT�D x d�DHcbÌD x @'e]d�N{[c@«e]RSDM@CN^d�D{K\N^@Pb�HJKLTL|ºRfT�D x @"yM@UI­R]HcD{R]QCy�Hcb¹ÄEe]Iº_4@cF�[\FS_ #C&�(ª_L�EK\D�R]y.y{D{R]e]e9QVHJI�BEd�D{RS�©eS@�}®RSD x RSDCFß�

áAHr}ÝeS@CD � y,QVHJTLy^R]|\@CN,BLN{H4|LKLQVD{y"Hcb®N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLyCF�¶\HcN�@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_¬}*@ºI­RS[ x D x drac@�N{@CBLN{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLy � dcTL| / bgHcN'D{RfI�@­dcTL|�Hcb�DM@UI�B9@CN^d�D{K\N^@�D x d�D'}*@­}*dcT�D"DMH�KLyM@�DMH�N{@UdcefRS�C@­D x @­y{R][JT�yM�4yMDM@UI ��"S � ���QE_} x @CN^@­y{dU� � × ��-S�� � � dcTL| / × � ��Q�� � / F v.x @UT�} x d�D'}*@­}*dcT�D"R]y�d�yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q�I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y � � / × ��-S � � ��Q � � � � � / _o|\@CÄETL@U|�DMH��9@ � HJT � -S�dcTE| / HJT � ��Q©_±@V�\QV@CBLD«D x d�D'D x @�BLN^H/|LKEQVD'yMHcN{DHcb*@UdcQ x y{HJK\N^QV@­I­d�BEy'DMHºD x d�D'Hcb�RSD{yjD{d�N{[c@CDCF ��@�QCdcTÃT\Hr}YBEN{Hrac@­D x @�bgHJe]e]Hr}®R]TL[�efdU}®yC_odcTLdceSHc[cHJKLy�DMHºD x HJyM@b�HcN�BLN{H4|LKLQVD{yPHcb*y^RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI­yC_�} x @CN{@ G% � G% / G% � G% � d�N{@�yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q�I­HcN{B x R]y^I­yC_9dcTL| ��T\Hr} |L@UT\HcDM@UyD x @,R]|\@UT�D{RSD���yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q«I�HcN{B x R]y{IÝHJT�D x @iDMN^RSa4R]dceoy{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI �=_±dcTL|�} x @CN{@� D T\H } N^@Cbg@CN^yADMHºd�QVHJTLy{R]yMDM@UT�Db�dcI­R]eS�(Hcb¹R]y{HJI�HcN{B x Rfy{I­yC_/HJT\@'b�HcN.@UdcQ x Q x HJRfQV@"Hcb¹D x @"I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�R]T�acHJeSac@U| / ��×

��� �D ���� �D � � / �D / �� � � �Ã� / � � � �D � � �� / ��� �� � � / �h·r� � � � � �D � � ·% � ���Ã� / ·% � �PF

¯ DiR]y«QCeS@Ud�N,D x d�D,d�[cN{@Ud�D�|\@Udce*I�HcN{@�QVHJKLe]|Ã�9@(|\HJT\@�dceSHJT\[�D x @UyM@�e]R]T\@UyU_ob�HcN«@V�\dcI�BEe]@c_¬[JRSa/RfT\[�e]dr}®y"b�HcN,D x @I�HcN{@m[c@UT\@CN^dce�b�HcN^I­y«Hcb®�©eS@UTL|LR]TL[\F v.x R]yiR]T�DMN{H4|LKLQVDMHcN{��BEd�B9@CN,|\H/@UyiTLHcD,y{@C@UI¥D x @mNhRS[ x D«BEe]dcQV@�b�HcN,y^KLQ x d|\@Cac@UeSHcB©I�@UTzDC_E�EK\D.d,b�@C} I�HcN{@'efdU}®y.d�N^@'bgHJKETL|ºR]Tº£ABLB9@UTL|LR �(»PF

£ DMN^dc|LRSD{R]HJTLdce=a/RS@C} R]y�D x d�D.d�I�@CD{d�B x HcN.R]y�d�I�d�BLBER]T\[ib�N{HJIwHJT\@�QVHc[JTLRSD{RSac@'y{BEdcQV@�DMH�dcT\HcD x @CNr_Ldcy.R]TmD x @b�HcN^I­dce]RS�Ud�D{R]HJT�Hcb��P@UT�D{T\@CN # â %k(ªFw*AHr}*@Cac@CNU_ D x @i}*HcN{Ø�Hcb²¶LdcKLQVHJTETLRS@CN�dcTL| v KLN^T\@CN # âvz (�y{K\[c[c@UyMD{y�d�|LR �=@CN{@UT�Da4RS@C}'_ R]T�} x R]Q x D x @�@V�4R]y{DM@UTLQV@­Hcb�y{KLQ x d��MQVN{HJy{y'y{BEdcQV@�I­d�BLB©R]T\[^�m�9@CD�}*@C@UT�D�}*H�RfT\BEK\DjyMBEdcQV@Uy'Rfy'dºyMB9@UQCR]dcedcyM�4I­I�@CDMN^RfQAQVHJTL|ERSD{RSHJT­D x d�D�I�dU�­H4QCQCK\N�RSb±HJT\@jR]T\BEKLDZyMBEdcQV@j|\HJI­R]TEd�DM@Uy²D x @AHcD x @CN�R]T�D x @j�EeS@UTL|�Fo¯°T�[c@UTL@CN^dce¡_D x @CN{@­I�dU���=@�I�HcN^@iD x dcT�D�}*H�R]T\B©K\DAyMB©dcQV@UyC_ dcTL|�D x @­RfT\bgHcNhI­d�D{RSHJT�d��9HJK\D�e]R]T\Ø4yP�=@CD¨}²@C@UT�D x @­QVHJTzDM@UT�D{y'HcbD x @UyM@«yMBEdcQV@Uy®Rfy�|LR]yMDMN^R]�EK\DM@U|�dcI�HJT\[­D x @'R]T�ÞM@UQVD{RSHJTLy�R]Tºd­QVHJI­BEeS@V��}*dr�ºD x d�D®QCdcTLT\HcD®�=@'y^KLI­I­d�N^R]�C@U|mRfT�dcTz�y{R]TL[JeS@�I­d�B�F

� �wÖ��=Õ�Ô1��=Ö^ÒAÏv.x Rfy�BEd�B9@CN x dcymR]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@U| �c� �/�r�V�M���¡���C�C�,���c���¡�V� _®dÈT\@C}¼d�BEBLN{HJdcQ x DMH�KLyM@CN(RfTzDM@CN{b�dcQV@�|\@Uy{RS[JT±_�QVHc[JTLR]D{RSac@e]R]TL[JKLR]yMD{R]QCyU_�dcTL|�HcD x @CNid�N{@UdcyC_Ì�EdcyM@U|�HJT¦d�T\HcD{R]HJT�Hcb�y{RS[JT�dce]e]Hr}®R]TL[�QVHJI�BEeS@V� x RS@CNhd�N^Q x RfQCdce¬yMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@c_ D x KLymYH ,�O�H3476 H36�DV4)O):�Db>�GjG=>YO7RQF)>YRQ6+P�g Db>�H369RQPY8WI�H34)6�P�8WI�]vH34)69I�>�836AO)>�H3F08V>YG':=<WPYNEPY83U74):�<WNE<�l

zkz

Page 23: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

@Ue]d��9HcN^d�D{R]TL[�O4dcKEy{y{K\N{@ � y�RfTLy{RS[ x D«D x d�D,y^RS[JTLy�QVHJI�@�R]T�yM�4yMDM@UI­yUFÈÙ®@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLy�d�N{@�I�d�BLBER]T\[JyU_¬HcN ���c� �§E³z�g�h�i� _¬�=@CD¨}²@C@UTÈy{RS[JT¦yM�4yMDM@UI­yC_ÌdcTL|Ãd�KLyM@CNiR]TzDM@CN^b�dcQV@mR]y"QVHJTLy^R]|\@CN{@U|¦d�N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJT�Hcb�D x @mKLTL|\@CN^e]�/R]TL[b�KLTLQVD{RSHJTLdcefRSD���DMH�} x R]Q x RSD*BLN{Hra4R]|\@Uy�dcQCQV@Uy{yUF v.x R]y*I�HcD{RSa�d�[email protected],QCdce]QCKLefKLyZb�HcN.QVHJI«�ER]TLR]TL[«y{RS[JTEyC_/y^RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI­yC_dcTL|�N{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyCF�´�T\@«R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzDPI�H/|L@"HcbZQVHJI�B9HJy{R]D{RSHJT�Rfy �V�]�V�=µ��g�/� _±R]T�DMN{H/|EKLQV@U|��/��¶LdcKLQVHJTETLRS@CN�dcTL|v K\N^T\@CNU_c} x R]Q x RfyoN^@Ue]d�DM@U|�DMH"QV@CN{D{dcRfT­QVHJTLQV@CBLD{y¬b�N{HJIYQCd�DM@C[cHcN^��D x @CHcN{�cF v.x @.I­dcRfT�QVHJTzDMN^R]�EK\D{RSHJTiHcb=D x R]yÌBEd�B9@CNR]y"D x @(BEN{@UQCR]y{RSHJT�D x d�DiR]D{y"d�BLBLN^HJdcQ x QCdcTÃ�EN^R]T\[�DMH�d�BLBEefR]QCd�D{RSHJTLyCFº»�KLR]ef|LR]T\[�HJTÈdcTÈRfTLy{RS[ x D�bgN^HJI¥QVHJI�B©K\DM@CNy{QCRS@UTEQV@c_©D x d�DP|LR]y{QVN^@CDM@"yMDMN^KLQVD{KLN{@UyAQCdcT��9@"|\@Uy{QVNhRS�9@U|�����dceS[c@C�EN^dcR]Q'D x @CHcN^RS@UyC_ nr½�¾©¿ nCÀ�nCp Á/¦n d�N{@i|\@CÄET\@U|�dcydceS[c@C�LNhdcR]Q"D x @CHcN^RS@UyP}®RSD x yMHJI�@,@V�4DMN^d�yMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@c_9dcTE| nUÁ4ÂȽgÅEp ½�t�ÂÃÅ©q ÆÌÇo½�nr¦n d�N{@�|\@CÄET\@U|�dcyjI­d�BLBERfT\[Jy®HcbdceS[c@C�LNhdcR]QPD x @CHcN^RS@Uy�D x d�D�BLN^@UyM@CN{ac@jD x @j@V�/DMNhd�yMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@PDMH­y{HJI�@j@V�/DM@UT�DC·LD x @�Ë/KLdce]RSD¨�­HcboN^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLy�}�dcyb�HJKLTL|�DMH�QVHcN{N^@Ue]d�DM@'}®RSD x D x @"|\@C[cN{@C@'DMH�} x R]Q x yMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@'R]y�BLN{@Uy{@CN{ac@U|±F� x @UT­HJTL@AyM@C@Uy*QVHJTLQVN{@CDM@P@V�4dcI­BEeS@Uy�Hcb�y^RS[JT­yM�4yMDM@UI­y²e]RSØc@.[cN^d�B x R]QCdceLKLy{@CN²R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@UyC_/R]DZR]y�@Udcy{��DMH"�9@Ue]RS@Cac@

D x d�DjD x @UyM@­y^RS[JT�y{�/yMDM@UI�y �°N{@Udce]eS��@V�\R]yMD�4F"¯¨D�R]yjdcI­d��UR]TL[ x Hr}YË/KLR]Q{Ø4eS��dcTL|�@Udcy{RfeS��}*@,y{@C@­y{RS[JTLyPdcy�dcQVD{KLdce]eS�@V�\R]yMD{R]T\[�}®RSD x dce]eZD x @URSNiyMDMN^KLQVD{K\N^@ �°HJK\D"D x @CN{@v��RfT�D x @ �°N^@UdceZ}*HcN^e]|��4FºáA@Cac@CN{D x @UeS@Uy^yC_Ì} x d�D �°N^@Udce]eS��@V�4RfyMD{y���R]T�D x @,yM@UTLyM@iHcb�B x �/y^R]QCyh��d�N^@«D x @iB x HcDMHJTEyPQVHJI�R]T\[mH��ÃD x @,y{QVN{@C@UT±·±D x @,yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@"D x d�DP}*@,yM@C@�R]y.HJK\NjH }®TQVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVD{RSHJT±F v.x R]y�BEd�B9@CN®BEN{Hra4R]|\@UyAd­}�dU��DMHm|\@Uy{QVN^RS�9@"dcTE|�yMD{KL|L�mB9@CN^QV@UR]ac@U|�N{@C[JKLefd�N^RSD{RS@UyC_©dcyAI�H4|\@UeS@U|����y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yU_±}®RSD x HJK\DPQCe]dcR]I­RfT\[(D x d�DPD x @UyM@,N{@C[JKLe]d�N^R]D{RS@UyAQVHcN^N{@UyMB9HJTL|�DMH�N{@UdceÌHc�4ÞM@UQVD{yC_�eS@CD�dceSHJT\@,D x d�Dj�9@UyMDB9HJy{y{RS�©eS@­|\@Uy{QVN^R]BLD{RSHJTLy"@V�4R]y{D"b�HcN,dcT���[JRSac@UTÈB x @UT\HJI�@UT\HJT±F v.x R]y«R]y«QVHJTEy{R]yMDM@UT�D«}ARSD x HcN^|ER]TLd�N{��@UT\[JR]TL@C@CN^R]T\[BLN^dcQVD{RfQV@c_.} x R]Q x QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVD{ymI�H4|\@Ue]y(bgHcNm�LN^R]|L[c@UyC_.dcRSN^QVN^d�b�D�}AR]T\[JyC_.dcKL|ERSHÃdcI�BEefRSÄL@CN^yC_�@CD{Q�F�D x d�D�d�N{@�[cH�H4|@UT\HJK\[ x b�HcN¬D x @*BLN^dcQVD{R]QCdce4BEKLN{B9HJyM@²d�D x dcTL|�_�}ARSD x HJK\DÌQCe]dcR]I­RfT\[.D x d�D¬D x @�I�H4|\@Ue]y ���{� D x @*N^@Udce]RSD��c_JdcTE|iRfTL|\@C@U|±_}®RSD x d�|\@C@CB�dU}�d�N{@UT\@Uy{yU_©�Edcy{@U|�HJT�BLN^dcQVD{R]QCdce @V�/B9@CN^RS@UTEQV@c_ED x d�DAD x @«I�H4|\@Ue]y®d�N{@«|\@CÄ©TLRSDM@UeS� �©�c� dc|L@UË�KLd�DM@iR]TQV@CN{D{dcR]TÈN{@Uy{B=@UQVD{yU_ZyMHJI�@�Ø4T\Hr}®T�dcTL|�yMHJI­@�KET\Ø/TLHr}®T / ��F�£PT\HcD x @CN�dc|\a�dcTzD{d�[c@�Hcb®HJK\N�d�BLBLN^HJdcQ x R]y«D x d�D�RSD@UTLd��Ee]@Uy�KLy�DMH­dUacHJR]|�d�eSHcD�Hcbo|LRfyMDMN^dcQVD{R]T\[,B x R]eSHJyMHcB x R]QCdceLBLN^Hc�EeS@UI­yC_/@cF�[\FS_ x dra/RfT\[�DMH­|\H,}®RSD x D x @�|\H4QVDMN^R]TL@PHcbN{@Udce]Rfy{IºF

v.x @([email protected]�HcN{B x R]y{I­y'Hcb.D x @CHcN^RS@Uyib�HcN«N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTLyiR]TLyMDM@Udc|¦Hcb®I�HcN^B x R]y{I�y�Hcb®I�H4|\@Ue]y"N{@Ue]d�DM@UyiDMHD x @�d��9Hrac@'B9HJR]T�DC_4R]TmD x d�D�}²@jDM@UTL|�DMH�D x R]T\Ø�HcbÌI�H/|L@Ue]y�dcy�ÄETLdce]eS��[cN^HJKLTL|LR]TL["D x @jN{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTºBLN{H4QV@Uy{y�R]TyMHJI�@CD x R]T\[ �°N^@Udcef�4_4} x @CN{@Udcy*I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�TL@Cac@CN*QCe]dcRfI¤I�HcN^@®D x dcT(DMH«�9@AN{@��ªN{@CBLN{@Uy{@UTzD{d�D{RSHJTEyC_4} x R]Q x I­dr��dc|L|I�HcN{@«|\@CD{dcR]e¡_4�EK\D.|LH­T\HcD.@V� x dcKLyMD.dce]e9HcbÌD x @"B=HJy^y{RS�ER]efRSD{RS@Uy¬b�HcNA|\@Uy^QVN^RSBLD{RSHJT�F� R]e]e]RfdcIY»�K\N{N{HJK\[ x y�y{dcR]| � ���/�#)L�U�����f�����r��� )�� # � (ª_/I­@UdcTLR]T\[(��b�HcN*@V�4dcI�B©eS@ �ÌD x d�D*B9@UQCKLe]R]d�NhRSD{RS@UyÌHcb�dcQCQV@UT�DC_

acH4QCd��EKLe]d�N{�c_�d�DMD{R]D{KL|\@c_�|LR]y{B=HJy^RSD{RSHJT±_EQVHJTLb�KLy^RSHJT±_±T\@UK\N{HJy^R]yC_=@CD{Q�F�d�N{@�QVHJTzD{d�[JRSHJKEyC_ dcTL|�DM@UTL|�DMHºyMBLN^@Udc|�}ARSD x R]TQVHJI­IiKLTLRSD{R]@UyCF���RSØ x d�@Ue¬»�d�Ø x D{R]T�# 3 (¬@UI�B x dcy{RS�C@U|�D x d�D'e]dcTL[JKLd�[c@­R]yjT\@Cac@CN"dºy{RfT\[JeS@ x HJI�Hc[c@UT\@CHJKLy«yM�4yMDM@UIº_KLy{RfT\[(D x @�}²HcN^| � x @CDM@CN{Hc[JeSHJy{y^R]dk�4F !Ìd�N^d�B x N^dcy^R]T\[º»�K\N{N{HJK\[ x yPRfT�D x @­e]RS[ x DjHcb*»�d�Ø x D{R]T�_�}²@­I�RS[ x D'y^dU��D x d�D�S�����#)L�U�/���f�­���É�{�^�c� �{�J���������E���C�°�J�r���g�/��� �g� )/�C�V� F­O/Hº|\@UyMBERSDM@,HJK\N'KEyM@,HcbZb�HcN^I­dce¬I­d�D x @UI�d�D{R]QCdce�|\@Uy{QVNhRSBLD{RSHJTDM@UQ x TLR]Ë/K\@UyC_¬}*@my x HJKLe]|ÃTLHcD«@V�4B9@UQVD,y^KLQ x d�N{@Udce]I¥DMH��9@mQ x d�N^dcQVDM@CNhRS�C@U|����ÃbgHcN^I�dce²I�H4|\@CN^TER]yMD'HcN^|L@CNU_¬�EK\DN^d�D x @CNiDMH�@V� x RS�©RSD'I«KEeSD{RSBEeS@�yMB9@UQCRS@Uy"Hcb.R]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{R]T\[�Q x d�HcD{R]Q(@CacHJe]K\D{R]HJT±×iy^RS[JTLy"dcTE|ÃR]T�DM@CN{BLN{@CD{d�D{R]HJTLy"d�N{@mQVH��@CacHJeSa4R]T\[ÃQVH��ª@UI­@CN{[c@UTzDºyMH4QCR]dce�B x @UT\HJI�@UTLd�D x d�D(d�N{@�DMH�HÈQVHJI�BEeS@V� DMH¦�=@�b�KLefeS�¦|\@Uy^QVN^RS�9@U|±·�HcN^|\@CNmd�BLB9@Ud�N^yR]T HJKLN(IiKLeSD{RSBEe]@c_�BEd�N{D{R]dce®|\@Uy{QVN^RSBED{RSHJTLyC_*dcTL|�y{KEQ x |L@Uy{QVN^RSBLD{R]HJTLy�d�N{@�} x d�D�}*@�QCdcT�b�HcN^I­dcefRS�C@cF�»�K\D­D x @UyM@|\@Uy{QVNhRSBLD{RSHJTLy�y x HJKLe]|�T\@Cac@CN.�9@'QVHJT\b�KLyM@U|�}®R]D x �°N{@Udce]RSD¨�j�4F�¯°TºQVHJT�DMN^dcyMD®}ARSD x y{RSD{KLd�D{R]HJT�D x @CHcN{�.#��)(ª_\}²@«|\H­T\HcDQVHJTLy{Rf|\@CN�D x d�D*y{RS[JTLy²dcTL|�N{@CBLN^@UyM@UTzD{d�D{R]HJTLy²d�N^@.BLN{@��ª@V�\R]yMD{R]TL['N{@Uy{R]|L@UTzD{y¬Hcb�y{HJI�@�!²e]d�DMHJTLR]Q x @Udrac@UT±_4�EK\DZRfTLyMDM@Udc|QCe]dcR]I D x d�D¬D x @C�id�N^RfyM@�R]T,dPQVHJT�DM@V�4D�Hcb=y{H/QCR]dce4R]T�DM@CN^dcQVD{RSHJT�F���¶EK\N{D x @CN¬B x R]eSHJyMHcB x R]QCdcez|LRfy{QCKLy{y{R]HJT"N{@Uefd�DM@U|,DMH�D x R]yd�BLB9@Ud�N^yAR]T�£ABLB9@UTL|LR ��GP_E} x @CN{@"R]Tº�EN^RS@Cb _L}²@«ÄETL|ºD x d�D®N{@Udce]Rfy{I R]y®|LRSà�QCKLe]D�DMH�N{@UQVHJTLQCRfeS@'}®RSD x D x @"BEN^dcQVD{R]QV@HcbÌ@UT\[JR]T\@C@CNhR]T\[�|\@Uy{RS[JT�_4dcTE|ºD x d�D.B x @UT\HJI�@UT\HJeSHc[c��R]y�I�HcN^@"QVHJT\[c@UTLR]dceªFß�

v.x @Z|\�4TLdcI­R]Q¬dcyMB9@UQVD�Hcb\y{R][JT'yM�4yMDM@UI­y�D x d�D @UI�@CN{[c@Uyob�N{HJI D x @*d��=H ac@²|LRfy{QCKLy{y{R]HJTA�EN^R]T\[Jy±HJKLD dcT"R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzDe]R]I�RSD{d�D{RSHJTºHcb¬D x @«bgHcNhI­dce d�BLB©d�N^d�D{KLy®RfTzDMN{H4|LKLQV@U|�R]TºD x Rfy.BEd�B9@CNU×*RSDA|\H/@Uy®TLHcDAdc|L|\N^@Uy{y.D x @ x R]yMDMHcN^�'��yM@UTEy{RSD{RSac@dcyMB9@UQVD{y²D x d�D²d�N{@PT\@C@U|\@U|(bgHcN*I­dcT��­d�BLBEe]R]QCd�D{R]HJTLy¬DMH«KEyM@CN²R]T�DM@CN{b�dcQV@P|L@Uy{RS[JT±F̶\HcN*@V�4dcI�B©eS@c_/I­HJyMDZDM@V�4D²@U|ERSDMHcN^yx drac@idcT3$��4���mQVHJI­I­dcTL|�D x d�D®D{d�Øc@UyjHJTL@«�EdcQ^Ø�DMHmD x @«yMD{d�DM@,�9@Cb�HcN{@'D x @,e]dcyMDPQVHJI­I­dcTL|�}*dcyA@V�4@UQCK\DM@U|±Fj»²�d�b�HcN{D{KLTLd�DM@�QVHJR]TLQCR]|L@UTLQV@c_*d�N{@UQV@UTzDmdc|\a�dcTLQV@�R]T�dceS[c@C�LN^dcR]Qºy{@UI­dcTzD{RfQCy(QCdce]e]@U| ³z�¡µJµz�V�¢������� �V�M� # z &\_ 3 �L_ â�� (BLN{H a/Rf|\@UyP@V�4dcQVD{eS��D x @�DM@UQ x TLR]QCdce¬d�BLB©d�N^d�D{KLyjD x d�D'R]yjT\@C@U|L@U|�bgHcN�D x Rfyj@V�/DM@UTLy^RSHJT±_±�/��KLy{RfT\[ x R]|L|\@UT�yMHcN{D{yjb�HcNm K �7PY8;6��7>YNEU7G=6Y] �cP�PQyko < Gr>�K g�P�8;H3476AG�6�O)R�H34xPYgi>d<WU783:�O)RE>�<;>dg�F7O)D9H3:�PQOxPYgTH3476 K56�:�RY4vHc:CH :�<;47PQG=@7:�O7R7])g�>Y:�G�<c:Cg H3476 K56�:�RY4vH;:�< H3P�P4)6�>���I�]0\k6�Db>�F)<W6`H3476`<WU783:�O)RdK :=G�G-\k6+@)>YN�>�RQ6b@^l

z 3

Page 24: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

R]T�DM@CN^TLdce�yMD{d�DM@UyCF v.x @m@V�4DM@UTLy{R]HJTÉR]y,dcQVD{KLdce]eS�¦ac@CN{��yMDMN^dcRS[ x DMbgHcN^}*d�N^| I�d�D x @UI­d�D{R]QCdce]e]�c_Z�EK\D,DMH�|\@Cac@Ue]HcBÉD x @I�@CD x H4|\HJeSHc[c�mb�HcNARSD{y�d�BLB©e]R]QCd�D{RSHJT�}®Rfe]e=N{@UË�KERSN{@�yMHJI�@'b�K\N{D x @CN�}²HcN{Ø=F

v.x @CN{@�d�N{@ZI­dcT��jHcD x @CN |\�4TLdcI­RfQ¹dcy{B=@UQVD{y Hcb\y{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yCFÌÙ.@UdceJ}²HcN^ef|�y{RS[JT'yM�4yMDM@UI­y�@CacHJeSac@c·Jb�HcN�@V�4dcI­BEeS@c_R]T­TEd�D{K\N^dceEefdcT\[JKLd�[c@UyC_/}²HcNh|LyZQ x dcT\[c@®D x @URSN²I�@UdcTER]T\[JyC_zTL@C}�}*HcN^|LyZd�N^@Adc|L|\@U|�_zHJe]|�}²HcN^|EyZ|LR]y^d�BLB9@Ud�NU_JyM�4TzD{d��Q x dcT\[c@UyC_9dcTL|�Hcb�QVHJK\NhyM@'D x @ x K\[c@iQVHJTzDM@V�4D{KLdceo�EdcQ{Ø/[cN{HJKLTE|�Q x dcT\[c@UyC_9dcy®yMH4QCR]dce @V�/B9@CN^RS@UTEQV@"Q x dcTL[c@UyCF�¯ T��c@CDdcT\HcD x @CN�R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�D�Ø4R]TL|�Hcb�|\�/TEdcI­R]QCyC_zdie]R]y{DM@UT\@CN�HcN*N{@Udc|\@CN���HcN��MKLy{@CN��z��QVHJTEyMDMN^KLQVD{y*I�@UdcTLR]TL[JyZ|\�4TLdcI­R]QCdcefeS�dcTL|�R]TLQVN{@UI­@UTzD{dce]e]�c_�RfTÉN{@UdceAD{R]I�@cF *AHr}¼D x R]y x d�BLB9@UTLy�R]y�d¦ac@CN{�É|LRSà(QCKLeSD�BLN{Hc�©eS@UIº_�d��9HJK\D�} x R]Q x e]RSDMD{eS@R]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{R]HJT�R]yº|ERSN{@UQVD{eS�Édra�dcR]efd��EeS@cF ¯ DºR]y x Hr}*@Cac@CN�QCeS@Ud�N�D x d�DºT\H y{R]I�BEe]@�dceS[cHcN^R]D x I+�EdcyM@U| HJT¦Þ{KLyMD�D x @yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@�Hcb�D x @my{R][JTÃyM�4yMDM@UI­yiR]T�acHJeSac@U|¦QCdcTÈ�9@(KEyM@U|ÃQVHJI�B©K\DM@mI­@UdcTLR]T\[JyC_¹�9@UQCdcKLyM@(@Cac@UT¦b�HcNiD x @my^R]I�BEeS@�EeS@UTE|�HcbAD¨}²HÈQVHJTLQV@CBLD{KLdceAyMBEdcQV@UyC_�yM@UeS@UQVD{R]HJTÉdcI�HJT\[�D x @�I­dcTLRSb�HJe]|ÈB9HJy{y{RS�©R]e]RSD{RS@Uy«R]y�[cH ac@CN^T\@U|����È@V�/DM@CNhTLdceQVHJT�DM@V�/D{KLdce=b�dcQVDMHcN^y�R]T�d"ac@CN{��QVHJI�B©eS@V�­}*dr�c_\QVN^KLQCR]dce]e]�iR]TEQCe]KL|LR]TL[PD x @

���c� )E�6� Hcb±D x @®B9@CN^y{HJT�|\HJR]TL['D x @P�EeS@UTL|±F��HcN{@CHrac@CNU_©D x @jB9@CN^QV@CBLD{RSHJT(D x d�D�D x @j�EeS@UTE|(R]y�R]TmyMHJI�@�}�dU� �^��³4�V�{�V�E� yM@C@UI�y�DMHi�9@�d�D�eS@UdcyMD�dcy.R]I­B=HcN^D{dcTzD�dcydcT��'HcbLD x @�I�HcN{@�I�@UQ x dcTLR]QCdce4I�@Udcy{K\N^@UyoHcbEHcBLD{R]I­dce]R]D��cF v®x R]y�B©d�B=@CNÌ|\H/@UyÌT\HcD¹d�DMDM@UI­BLDÌDMHPyMHJe]ac@*D x @UyM@*|ERSà�QCKLeSDBLN{Hc�©eS@UI­yC_ �EK\D±HJTLeS�PD x @*y{R]I�BEe]@CN=BEN{Hc�EeS@UI Hcb4BLN^Hra4R]|LR]T\[�d®BLN{@UQCR]yM@�efdcT\[JKLd�[c@Zb�HcNo|L@Uy{QVN^RS�ERfT\[�yMDMN^KLQVD{K\NhdceJdcyMB9@UQVD{yHcbjBEd�N{D{R]QCKEe]d�N­KLTL|\@CNhyMD{dcTL|LR]TL[JyCF�¯ TÉdÃ|\�/TEdcI­R]QºQVHJT�DM@V�/DC_�D x @Uy{@�yMD{d�D{R]Q�|\@Uy{QVN^RSBED{RSHJTLyi}®R]e]e��9@�y{TEd�BEy x HcD{y�Hcb@CacHJeSa4R]T\[­yMDMNhKLQVD{K\N{@UyCF

£PT\HcD x @CN�d�N{@Ud«D x d�D�T\@C@U|Ly²b�K\N^D x @CNZ}*HcN{Ø�R]ys� x RS[ x @CN*HcN^|\@CNY�"y{RS[JTERSÄEQCd�D{RSHJT±_z} x R]Q x QVHJTLQV@CNhTLyZ@V�4BEe]RfQCRSD�N{@Cb�@CNb�@UTLQV@Uy²DMHiI­@UdcTLR]T\[\·�HJT\@Ad�BLBEN{HJdcQ x DMH"D x Rfy�BLN{Hc�©eS@UIYR]yZDMH"BLN{H a/Rf|\@®yMHJI�@AbgHcNhIYHcb��MI�@CD{d)��yMB©dcQV@UyCF�� ��@UdcTLR]T\[iR]yHJT\@.Hcb=D x @.|\@C@CB9@UyMD�dcTE|­I�HJyMDZ|ERSà�QCKLeSD¹Hcb9dce]e\y{K\�4ÞM@UQVD{yC_zdcTE|­RSD�y x HJKEe]|,T\HcD¬�9@�D x HJK\[ x D�D x d�D�D x @�@V�4BEeSHcNhd�D{RSHJTLyR]T�D x @"BLN{@UyM@UT�D�BEd�[email protected]�N{@"I�HcN^@'D x dcTº@Ud�N^e]�myMDM@CB©y.|\Hr}ATºHJT\@'BEd�N^D{R]QCKLe]d�N�BEd�D x RfTzDMH�d­[cN{@Ud�DÌÞ{KLT\[JeS@cF

� �ZÑ ZÏ,Õ E���������������� ������������������� ��!��"���$#%��& (')��*�,+-�"�.�0/$213#546�078#9�;:�<;#5������7;:.=?>)@BA�@BC�DFE$G�H8IKJLG"D�M(N2O JPC�DRQBDFE$O ARSUTVD0CXW5Y�HUZB:

[ ��!�<;�?\^]^_;` \�\V����ab��c� ����d�0��:$e97F<B<f�27F<;�F�;:)�hg�i _ �j+-�lknm����/9 �<;�;o57�< [ /9'9�����p9<h#b�hg^_0q(���r\�')� ��s5�B�� qR�t��<��F<B7vuw�$�x�V#5<B78��<;���.y�& �$�� ���cz���!���c��.{�DhIKJ�|�GRQ}:��hk$~L\^�}��qK\^gR`9q�_0�9:9�;g�g��9�� ]K�ta���s p$�0���u6�0s p^�������(�)O$Hz��JLG0C�D���JL@f�}YtGB��JP>)G0��JLD0>)�v��DKW5��=�Q8QBGKARQ}�3���9��m�<B78������&t�0�.��<��9���v�0�v��/$��������:��;g�k9���� \0�t�v������$#�u6��7��Fp9<;�;�3���$�j����>r=�Q8QBGKA�GK>�In���*�*JP��W$I�H}Q}���x�������$#r�����9!$:��hg^_K\$����78�0�$�;�9�v�dc8p$�078#�aU����<;7;�� �R�t ����lu?��7�4v�d��<w���$#� ���p$�r��<;7�7F&����VJP�*W$GK�*JLDK>$Q�G0>)In�����*JP��W$I�H}Q}�.a�+��¡~Lu?7F��# �¢��78#$��:��;g�k�]9�� iK�t ���p9�Uu?�K4?<B78�B�6�6p9< [ ����£�F��c;�������¢��7F �����d�� r�6+-�bab�07������U¤�<;�$:$<h#5�£�F��7h:�¥2D0>$�-H�¦���Q§D�M,¥2D0YxE�W5�¨HB�}©¨ªbHFI0JLGK�-H8I�¥.D0Y§YnW5©

>$JL@8G0��JLD0>$�$���07Fm�<;����<;76�p9<;�0�F��p9<;�0��:��;g�g^q5���_h����������� «���9u?/97F7F��/9!�p$�B����O9Hf��I�IKJP> �tªbG�@FO5JP>)Hh�w��HBC�H8@��-H8I§=�Q8QBGKARQ}�2��7Fc;��#5<�:��;g�k�i9�� kK�t ���p9�n¬?��7�7F���*��¤�<h�07F�9���$!$:h/$�����9!V:0�0�$#�#9<;����!��9���$!x­$�<B�$�� �<;�j�0�$#�cB�� � t�0�$# [ �078��#5��!� t�;� ®�HFO$GK¯hJLDK��G0>)Ix��>;M�DK�}YtGK�*JLDK>

�VHF@8O >�DKC�DF��AK:���~L\^��� ]^q�_;`9qK\^i9:$�hg�k^q5�� gK�t�xd�0���%¬���p9<B���n®vC�G�I�Hn°�W5>$>�H��}�w�x<;����p$<����dcB�z�����0!����9�d�����dcB�w�0�$#b��p9<�d�R4±�0�?7�<h� [ ���$��<��(��Cv¥2GK>$>�D;@8@8O JLG0C�H�:�]9� \�]K`5��k9:

�;g�g�i$����;²K�,³w����<;�§e$�0/Vc����$�9��<;7(�0�V#"aU�07Fs���/97F�9<B7h�b¬����$cB< [ �F/$�0 [ 7���´�<;c��������µ�0�V#% n�d#9#5�<�� [ ��c�<;�;�l��<hc8p9�9�dcB�0?�v< [ ��7��§g�\�²9��:

�x�$��m�<B78������&t�0�3¬?�0��£�¢��7��$���n�K���5���ry���<B!��V:��;g�g0\$��y�< [ �h�$�0�2¬���!��9�£�F��m�<��5c���<B�$cB<���������,³w����<;�§e$�0/Vc����$�9��<;7§���$#"aU�07Fs¶��/97F�9<B7h�Uu?�<;�$#5���9!b�����Uc�<;�^��78�0 [ 7��5c�<h�����0�v!�78�0 � t�07h��+-�·��#5<;�<r1x�j³w���#9'V<;7�!V:

<;#9�£�F��7h:.¥.D0>)@8H-E)�*W$GKC��)���}W$@B��W5�FH}S��(JdQ�@8D0W5�8Q�H§GK>�In¸�GK> �0W$G;��HB: [ ��!�<;�w���;]R`��hq�g9�9¬6�5¤�+}:��hg�g�i$����hqR�,³w����<;�we$��/$c����9�9��<B7z�0�$#¶aU�07Fs���/97F�9<;7;�(¬����Vc�< [ ��/$������^��<B!�7F�0���������9<B��4���7�s5�;��¥2DF�0>VJP��JP¯KH���@�JLHB>)@8HB:�q�q$~�q������h]�]K`)�;k _ :

�;g�g�k$����;]K�,� &5#re���<Bd#��v��@��FHFHB>KE�C�GKA��t��O9Hf��DKW5>�I�GK�*JLDK>$Q(D�Mz��@���H8HB>$¹.�}JP�*JP>^���.y�<;�*:��hg�k�q9���6p9��78#�<h#5��������������B\0�ty�<B�d#57�<x³w<;���F�9<B7h�V�^�F7�/Vc}��/$7�<Bº* t� [$[ ���$!$���»�Fp9<B��7�<B���dcB�0^�¢78�0 �<B4?��7Fsz�¢��7.���$�0���!�&��.¥2D���>$JP�*JP¯KHx��@�JLHB>)@8HB: _9~�q������R���R`)�R_0²9:

�;g�k�]$�

z %

Page 25: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

���h�R�t �����< [ p³w��!�/9<B��� � <B t�����F��c;�t�0�fc��� [ /5�F�0��������� +-�127F�9<;����aU�0�$<;�;:?<h#5������7h:xN?��Dh@FH8H8IKJP> �KQ8S§�3JP�8Q}�z��>$�-H��}>�GK�*JLDK>)G0C�VAKY�E$DRQ}JPW5Y DK>%¥2GK�-H¨��D0�}A���O9H8D0�}A��?E�E�CXJLH8In�¨D�¥2DKY�E)W5�-GK�*JLDK>bG0>)I�¥2DK>$�*��D0CX: [ �0!�<;�x�R�5��`)�;i�]9�0� [ 7F���9!�<;7;:V�;g^_��5��~��5���e978�0�V���d��cB�$:5e9<;'97F/$�07F&��;g _R\$����¤�<;c���/97F< � ����<;�x���b¬��� [ /9��<B7��9c���<B�$cB<�:��.���/9 �<�q��9�

���;iK�t �����< [ pt³w��!�/9<B���V�p$�K�����./$�9�£­)cB�K�F�������l� c;�K��<;!���7��dcB��^m ��<B4»�0����/$'$���F�£�F/5��������:�<���/V�K�������t���$#������/5�F�������$+-�,ab�0/97F��cB<� ��mK�K�x�0�V#r�����F��������£��º��f��c��*: <;#5������7F�;:$°�H�QBDKCXW5�*JLDK>¶D�M�=� BW$GK�*JLDK>$QzJP>���C �^H��B��GKJL@��V�*�}W$@B��W5��H�Q8SfTVDKCXW5YtH����v��C ��H��B��GKJL@�VHF@8O >VJ� �W$H�Q}: [ ��!�<;�vq9�R_;`9q0i$��� ��cB��#5<B ��dc0:��hg�k�g$�

���R_h�t �����< [ p�³w��!�/$<B���$�c;�K�F<B!���7��dcB��� t���9�£�¢<h���F�$��ªbG0�PO$H�YtGK�*JL@8GKC)�V�*�}W$@��*W5��H�Q�JP>¶¥.D0YxE�W5�¨HB�6��@BJLHB>)@8H�:V��~��h�}� \�gK` i _ :KaU�078c8p�;g�g9���

���;kK�t �����< [ p³w��!�/9<B��� �3& [ <;�,������p$<B��7F��<;�;� +-� ³w<B��7�!�<laU��c8p$��<B��x<B<;#�:6���$#57F<B4 ��������� �x���Fc�� <�:6�0�$# �x�� [ p e���%��c8p^��<;7;: <;#9�£�F��78�B:��VDFE$DKC�DF��ArGK>�I�¥2GK�-H¨��D0�}A¶��O9H8DK�}A�JP>µ¥2DKY�E)W5�-H��z��@�JLHB>)@8HB: [ �0!�<;�v]^��_;`5]�g�²9����� �¢��7F#�:��hg�g9���j�37���ºc�<;<;#5���9!^�6�0�j�,¬����5�¢<B7F<B�$cB<zp9<Bd#l�K����� �¢��78#�:9 �/$�9<t�;g�k�g9�

���;gK�t �����< [ p�³w��!�/9<;��� ��� �9�0�8�K�F����� ~L� ��s�<B�Fc8p ���µ��p$< [ � [ <B7}�}� +-� u?��7F��� aU��!�� /$�F������:µu?<B7���78�0�$#�a�<B&�<B7h:�0�V#  �<;�0�9º¨e$7F���$c������·��<B7F7����;:l<;#5������7F�;: �����2¸�������� �$H8@8O >�DKC�DF�0A D�M���� �BH8@B��©!�6�}JLHB>$�-H8I ¸�GK> �0W$G;��H�Q G0>)I �VARQ}©�-H�Y§Q}: [ �0!�<;�µ�h`��;²$�z�37�<;�^���dc�<�º-�����*:l�;g�g�]9� �6p9<<B�^�F<B�$#9<;# m�<;7F������� �����Fp9��� [ � [ <B7µ t�R& ')<��'9�F�0���9<h# �¢7F�� "$#�#�%'&)(�(+*,*�*'-/.�01-�23.�054�-7684�29(+230+6�:90�(8;$<8;�2968=�(+%308(5=9<�#8='->%30?-�;$@ �

� q0²K�t �����< [ p¶³w��!�/9<;���z�v<��^/9��7�<; �<B�^�F��<B�9!����$<B<B7F���9!����x�Fp9<§7F<;cB���$cB����d�K�������b�0�3��� cB����j���$#��F<;c8p9�$��c;�0j���F��/$<;�;�w+-��aU�07F���$� ���7F�0�FsR���0�$#� �����< [ p(³w��!�/$<B��:R<;#9�£�F��78�B:0°�H/ BW5JP��HBY�HB>$��Q�=?> �0JP>�HFHB�}JP>^�^�?��D;@BJLGKC$G0>)I��VH8@FO5>$JL@8GKC��}QFQ}W$H�Q}: [ �0!�<h�2�hi��h`9q0²�²9���c;��#5<; ���c�:��;g�g�\$�

� q5���t �����< [ p�³w��!�/9<B���.���K4?��7F#$�?�����5c��d�0*:5<���p$��c;�0��Fp9<B��7�&,���j���5�¢��7� t�K�F��������+-�U³w<B�+A�7F<B&�u?�K4vs�<;7;:5¤�<B��!�p��^�F��7;:9������d�0 ��/97��$<B7h:2�0�$#·¤�<;�t³z������<B7h:�<;#5������7F�;:v��Dh@BJLGKC6��@BJLHB>)@8H}Sr�VH8@FO5>$JL@8GKC6�)ARQ}�¨HBY(QlGK>)I»¥2DhDFE$H��FGK�*JP¯RHCBlD0��|��U®�H�A�D0>)I%�¢O9HD ��H8GK����JP¯hJLI�HB: [ ��!�<h�xq�_;`9�0i$�^137��'$�0/$ r:��hg�g _ �

� q�qR�t �����< [ p ³w��!�/9<;��� � �5cB����w���$# ��<B ��������dcb���$�0�&5��<h�t�¢��7���p9<;��7F<B [ 7F�Km�<;7,/$��<B7r���^��<;7��L��c�<b#9<;����!���:���/9'9 ��£����<h# �¢��7[ /9'$��dcB�0���������;g�g�k9�

� q0]K�t �����< [ pl³w��!�/$<B���§��O9H8D0��H�Y N?��D0¯;JP> �lGK>)In��C �^H��B��GK��a�+��z: ���,� [9[ <h�07h�� qK\0�t �����< [ p�³w��!�/9<;���0�V#,�v�5#�u?/978���8�0����+-�$���F�£�F/5�������V�B�.�x'V���F7F��c}�� ��5#5<;V�Fp9<B��7�&n�¢��7?� [ <hc���­VcB�0�������r�0�$# [ 7���!�78�0 � ����9!V�

E DKW5�}>�GKC�D�M��PO$Hw�zQFQBDh@�JLG0��JLD0>§M�D0�,¥2DKY�E)W5�*JP>^�,ªUG�@FO5JP>)HB�}AK:)]�g$~��h�}� g��R`)�;\�i9:^ ���� /$�07F&��;g�g�q5�� q��R�t �����< [ p"³w��!�/9<B��:F�f�0�2¤�����:��xs ��7F�la���7��*:�³w7F��!���7F<n�v�HG��/�:��0�V#���s ��&�����p9�3�5�K�F�$�,y�������7F��'9/5��<h#"c�� � [ <B78�K�F��m�<(�¢��7� t��

�<��Fp9�5#9���F� ��d�B�^+-�(a��dc8p$�0<;^¤��K4v7�&�:;<h#5������7h:�N?��Dh@8H8HFI0JP>^�0Q8S)��W5�¨D0Y�G0�¨H8I���D�M8��¹3G0��H3=?> �0JP>�H8H��}JP> �0: [ �0!�<h�����h` i^q5��+�1�131�:�;g�g^_5�

� q0iK�t �����< [ p�³w��!�/9<B��:��f�0��¤�����:)�xs ��7F��a���7��*:V³w7F��!���7F<z�x�HG��/�:$�0�V#r��s ��&�����p9���5�0���$����� ��d�6�¢��7�#5�d���F7���'9/5�F<;#�c�� � [ <;7F�0����m�<#5<h����!��µ���$#"mK�0���#$�K����������+-�»N?��Dh@8HFH8I0JP>^�0QFS,¥2G�M�H+�3® E �VAKY�E9DKQ}JPW5Y§�. ^� [ ���%��#5mK�0�$cB<;#"+-�V���F�£�F/5��<��¢��7��5c���<B�$cB<����$#��<;c8p9�9�����!�&�:)�hg�g�k9� � �� §/�IB/�:9 �� [ �0��:9� [ 7F��.�hg�g�k$�

� q�_h�t �����< [ p"³w��!�/9<B�µ���$#µ¬�p$�07F������F<,¤����$#5<��J� [ �F�� t�0?���F7�/Vc}��/$7�<h�z�¢��7� §/9�����º* �<;#9�������$����7F/$c}�F�������l��<hc8p9�9�dcB�037�< [ ��7��h:�5�v+�+-�^��<B7F�$�0�������$���:��hg�k0\V�j���K�ML,c�<z�0� � �RmK�0��x<;��<;�078c8p�:5�3��&5c8p9�����!���c;�0��5c���<B�$cB<;�xy���m^�d���������

� q0kK�t �����< [ pl³w��!�/$<B�l�0�$#�³w78�0�^�xaU�0dc���� l�3��C �^H��B��GKJL@(��H�YtGK>V��JL@�Q(D�Mx�}Y�E$H���G0��JP¯KHfN?��DF�0�FGKY§Q8�2aU+��z:��;g�g�i9�� q0gK�t �����< [ p�³w��!�/9<B�����$#�³w78�0�^��aU���cB��� r�0� p9�d#9#5<B�§�0!�<;�$#9�$�0��<hc8p9�9�dcB�0^�v< [ ��7���¬6�5g _;`9�0]�k$:B�w¬6�9y(:Ry�< [ �;�0¬��� [ /9��<B7

�5cB��<;�$c�<ON 13�9!$��:xaU�R& �;g�g _ �±��� � [9[ <;��7���� � [ <hc��d�0��d�F��/9<b�0����O9H8DK�FH��*JL@8GKC�¥2DKY�E)W5�-H�����@�JLHB>)@8H���� ���!�<B'978�0�dc12�$!����9<B<;7����9!$:�<h#5�£�F<;#�' &�¬�p97F&5���F� [ p9<;7 � <BpV�0�9��mb�0�V#¶aU������ ���+¨�F�$��13��7��&U�0'V���F7F��c}�z��� N?��Dh@�P�S(¥2DK>;MQP3�}>$�-HBCPCXJ£��HB>$��VARQ}�-H�Y§QB�w� ��H�YnJLDK�*JL@(NvHB�8Q*E9H8@B��JP¯KH�S,TVDKCRPj�}:�<h#��) V���x�'9/$�;:�����a�<;& ����<;j���$#b���TS�/$���^��<;7��V: � �K�h�)+-�V���h���9c���<B�$cB<UN��<;c8p9�9�����!�&�~�³z���£�Fp9<B78��'V<;7�!taUy§:Vq0²K`5q�]V�wc�����')<B7z�hg�g�i^�}: [ ��!�<;�z�R�0gK`)�;i _ �

� ]�²K�t �����< [ p�³w��!�/9<;���0�$#r³w7F���^��aU�0dc���� l������#$#5<B�rc������$#5/Vc}����������u?<;p$�Rm ����7F��$c���7�7F<;c����9<h��� [ 7�� ���L�.�¢��7?��'9´�<;c}�8�B�2ªUG0�PO5©HBY�G0��JL@8GKC��V�*�}W$@��*W5��H�Q�JP> ¥2D0YxE�W5�¨HB�z��@BJLH�>�@8H�:5�F�,� [9[ <;��7z�;g�g�g9�

� ]9���t �����< [ p ³w��!�/9<;��:.�xs ��78�Ua���7��*:.�0�$#W�f�0��¤������¶�x�!�<;'978�0�dc,��<; ��������dcB�;:2�27F�^���¢�<B'$�(�0�$#µ#9������7F��'$/5��<h# c�� � [ <;7F�0����m�<[ 7F�Km ���9!V��+-�OX�m�<h��u6��7��F�0�;:�<h#5�£�F��7h:�N?��Dh@FH8H8IKJP> �KQ8SVY�QBHB�z��>$�-H��¢M�G�@8H}Q6M�DK�U�)O$H8DK��HBY N?�FDK¯KH��8Q}: [ ��!�<;�zq��R` ]�\$�9+ � �v+���:�;g�g^_5�?~*� � [ p$�����x�^�F� [ ������;:���`5qn� < [ �F<B §'V<;7��;g�g^_0���

� ]�qR�t �����< [ p"³w��!�/9<B��:� ��� n<h�z�¶<;���$<B7h:j���$#%¬�pV�07F�������<,¤����V#5<��,�v<h�������9���9!��0�V#¶�V�K��/$7F��.<�� [ d�0�$�0������������>$�-H��}>�GK�*JLDK>)G0CE DKW5�}>�GKC�D�MfªUG0>$©¨ªbG�@8O JP>�H§�V�*W$IKJLH�Q}:��;g9����q9�}`9���0g$:$�hg�k�]$�

� ]�]K�t�v��'V<;7���³w��d#5'9d�K���;�§�VDFE$DKJdS?�PO$H,¥2GK�-H¨��D0�}JLGKC���>)GKC£ARQ8JdQ§D�M�¸�DF��JL@�� � ��7���p5º-�x���d�0�V#�:��;g _Kg9�

z �

Page 26: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

� ]0\0�taU��7��F���(��<B�d#5<B!�!�<;7;�9®�HBJP>^�§GK>�I���JPY�HB�9u?���c8s^4?<B�*:^�hg�i^q5����7F���$����0��<;#�'^&� ���p$�(aU��c��^/$�07F7���<3���$#�13#94?��7F#��x��'9���$������¢7F�� ��H�JP>¶W5>)In�jHBJP�*: � ��<B �<B&�<B7h:��;g^q�_ �

� ]��R�taU������s��U���5����78�0!^�9��y��d�0!�7F�� ��6���$#, �<��8� [ p$��78�B��+�c����9�dcw��� [ <;c��F�?���rd�0�$!�/$��!�<�� E DKW5�}>)G0C�D�M�N?�FGB��Y�G0��JL@�Q}:)q�q9� �R`5q9��:�;g�g0\V�

� ]�iK�taU������s�� ��� �x��7F��!��9���x��/9!�p���<h���?�0�$#t��p9<w ����s &t4?�R&�� � u?�<;�$#5���9!�� ������O9GKJ�|0W���<�� �h��+-�rN?C�H�>�GK�}A BlD0��|KJP> �§NvG8E9HB�8QJP>±¥2DKY�E)W5�-GK�*JLDK>bM�D0�rªUHB�-GFE9O$DK�8Q8S(��>)GKC�D���AµGK>)I¶�3�^H�>V�LQ}: [ �0!�<;���R_;`9q0]$�j���9��m�<B78������&"�0�z�x� IB/�:w�;g�g�k$� ��<hc8p9�9�dcB���v< [ ��7��xg�k0ºF�Bº¨²�²��9:^³w78��#5/$�0��<��5c8p9� ����0�.¬��� [ /5��<;7��5cB��<;�$c�<f�0�V#r13�9!����9<;<B7F���9!V�

� ]^_h�taU������s�� �����x��7F��!��$� � u?�<B�$#9���9!����0�V#����"���^�F<B7 [ 7�<B�F�0���������0��O9GKJ�|0W���� c���!��9������m�<,� [9[ 7F����c8p���NvDhH��*JL@}Q��VDhI�GKAK:j�F�� [$[ <h�07z�;g�g�k9�

� ]�kK�taU��7����$�r ���7�����sK�r�0�$#% �����< [ p%³w��!�/$<B���,°�H/ BW5JP��HBY�HB>$��Qf=?> �0JP>�H8H��}JP> ���,��Dh@�JLG0C?G0>)I·�VH8@FO5>$JL@8GKCj�8Q8Q}W$H}Q}�t��c;��#5<; n�dc0:�;g�g0\V�

� ]�gK����������� ¤���'V�Km��¶�6p$<��F7F���$���¢��7� t�0�������"�0�x<B� [ <;7���<B�$cB<���� �$��7�78�K�F��m�<���&^�^�8�K���¶+-� ¸�G0>^��W$GB�^HlJP> �PO$H,�}>V>)HB�U¥�JP��AK:[ ��!�<;�6]^�K\K`5]�g�i9�����9��m�<B78���£��&,������<;�9�$��& �mK�0�$���$:)�hg^_�q5�

� \�²K�,³w<B��7�!�<w¤��0s��+AU�0�$#laU��7�s, ���p$�$�������?ªbH��-GFE$O9DK�8Q BlHw¸�JP¯KHz®xAK�?¬�p9�dcB��!��V:)�hg�k�²9�� \$���,�5��/9�$#5<;7F�6aU��cf¤��0�$<��z¥2GK�-H*�^DK�}JLH�Q3M�DK�(�PO$HJB�DK��|0JP>^�,ªbGK�¢O9HBY�G0��JL@BJLGK>V�?� [ 7F���9!�<;7;:��hg^_ ���� \^qR�tu?7�/$�9�n¤��K�F��/97h�?��@BJLH�>�@FH(JP>l��@B��JLD0>$� � [ <B��:��hg�k^_5�� \�]K�tu?7�/$�9�n¤��K�F��/97h�3����GKYnJdQ8S�DK�f�¢O9Hz¸�D0¯RH�D�M��VH8@FO5>)D0C�D���AK�����07FmK�078#�:��;g�g�i9�� \�\0�t ���p9�l¤�<hc8p��F<��3�3J M8��An{nHBA�¥2DK>V�¨HBYxE$DK�FGK�}A���O JP>5|�HB�8Q}�3�v��/5���<;#5!�<�:��hg�g0\V�� \^�R�t127F�dc�¤���m ���9!����������(�)O$Hf=?�PO5>)D0Y�HB�PO$D;I�DKC�DF��ArD�MfªUG0�PO$H�YtGK�*JL@�Q8���v��/5�F�<h#5!�< N �z<B!^�0���.��/9*:��;g�k _ �� \�iK�,³w78�0�^�§aU���cB��� ���$#µ �����< [ p ³w��!�/9<;���¶� ��!��$�n�0�V#"7�< [ 7F<;��<B�^�F�0�������$�;���5<B ��������dcB���¢��7n/$��<;7(���^��<B7��L��cB<�#5<h����!����U+-�

�x�R&��.�0�����l���$#r+-7�<;�9< � ��<Bd������:V<;#5������7F�;:xT�JdQ}W$G0C)°�H-E)�FH}QBHB>$�-GK�*JLDK>9Q§G0>)In�}>V�¨HB�*E)��HB�-GK�*JLDK>9Q}��� [ 7F���9!�<B7x����7Fs5��p$� [ �6���¬��� [ /9�����9!$:��hg�g�k$�j�37��5cB<B<;#9���9!^�?�0�j���l���^��<;7��V�K�������V�0�4���7�s5��p9� [ p9<Bd#r����¤���m�<B7 [ � ��*�

� \ _h�t ������<§a�<h��<;!�/9<;7��0�$#% �����< [ p"³w��!�/9<B���n+-�$�£�F���������&�:j���V#5/$c}�F�����"�0�$#�c��� [ /5�F��'9�������&��,+-�"aU��/97��dc�< � ��mK�K�(���$#% ���p9��v<;&^�$��d#9�B:5<h#5������78�;:V��C ��H��B��GKJL@(ªbH��¢O9DhIRQfJP>b��HBY�G0>$�*JL@}Q}: [ ��!�<h�6\^�0gK`5�0\$���5¬?�0 §'97��d#5!�<�:��;g�k��5�

� \�kK�ty����$���#r��� � ��7F t�0���(��O9Hz�nH}Q}J£��>�D�M�=6¯RHB�}A�I�G0A%��O JP> �KQ}�3y���/9'$�<h#9�R&�:��hg�k�k$�� \�gK��¬�p$��7��<;�.�5��/9�$#5<;7F����<B��78c�<��.¥2D0CPC�H8@��-H8IzNxGFE$H��8Q}�V���07FmK�078#�:5�;g�i��5�5+-��iwm����/9 �<h�Bo���<B<6<h� [ <;cB������& �.���/9 �<�q5�j12�<B �<B�^�8�

�0��¤���!��dc0�� �0²K�t12�<;���9��7w�v���Fc8p������U�Fp9<����^�F<B7F�$�0����F7�/Vc}��/$7�<n�0� [ <B78c�< [ ��/V�0.�0�$#¶��<; t�0�^���dc§c;�K�F<B!���7���<;�;�w+-�¶�z� a"��a�� ��7F<�:�<;#9�£�F��7h:

¥2D���>$JP�*JP¯KHw�nHB¯RHBC�DFE�Y�HB>$�vGK>�It�¢O9Hz��@/ BW5JdQ}JP��JLD0>�D�Mw¸�G0>^��W$GB�^H��$��cB��#5<B ��dc0:��;g _K]$�� �5���t12�<;���9��76�v�^��c8p��3¬���!��9������m�<z7F<��¢<B7F<B�Vc�< [ �����^�8�B�z¥2D���>$JP�*JP¯KHzN?Q8A�@8O9D0C�DF�0AK:�_ :��hg^_��5�� ��qR�t����7�m�<B&%�5��c8s5�;�J���%�Fp9<����$�0�&�I;��'9�������&b�0�x������7���<;�f' &%c8p9���#57F<B����+-�  ���p9� ³w/9 [ <B7��)I����$#"y�<B6�x& �<;�;:j<h#5������78�;:

�(JP��H8@��*JLDK>$QwJP>b��Dh@�JLD0CXJP>^��W5JdQ}��JL@�Q}: [ ��!�<h�?]^q��R` ]0\ �5�^�x����;:V�v���$<Bp$��7������$#�����$��������:��;g _0q9�� �0]K�t����7�m�<B&��5��c8s5�B�2¸�H8@B��W5�FH}Q�DK>·¥.D0>$¯KH��8QBG0��JLD0>$�3u?d��c8s 4�<;�*:��;g�g�q5��13#9�£�F<;#r' &�³z�0��� �<QA�<B78�������� �K\0�te9<;7F#9���$���$#r#5<(�5�0/V����/97F<��w¥.D0W5�8QBH(JP> D HB>)HB��G0C�¸�JP> �0W5JdQ}�*JL@}Q}�2y�/$c8s 4���7��Fp�:��;g _Ki$�j��7F���$����0��<;#�' &��v�K&����07F7��d�;�� ���R�tu?<B��� p9�9<;��#9<B7F ������3�nH}Q}J£��>$JP>^���¢O9HJY�QBH��x��>$�-H��¢M�G�@FHB�3��#9#5�d��������<;���<;&�:��hg�g _ �� �0iK�,� /$�F�0��¤�<B��!�pr�^�F��7;�j�6p9<�����7F/$c}�F/97F<��������£º-����7F/$c}�F/97�<h#������/5�������V�B��u?��/9�$#$�07F&§��'5´�<;c��F�?�0�$#�p9<��F<B7F��!�<;�9<B��/$� [ 7���'9�<; nº

�����m^���9!V�"+-�»¤�<;�t³z���F��<;7t�0�$#·a���c8pV�0<Bv��/9p9�$�;:�<h#5������78�;:���JdQ}�*�}J���W5�-H8IU���}��J �?@�JLG0C3�}>V�¨HBCPCXJ£�^H�>�@FHB:?m����/9 �<�q5: [ ��!�<h�]^_h`5�0\$� �2���� t�0��:��hg�k�g9�

� ��_h�t¤�/Vc�&(� /$c8p$ ������VN?C�G0>9Q�GK>�Iz�)JP��W$G0�¨H8I���@��*JLDK>$QB�(��O9HvN?��D���C�HBY D�M�fW5YtGK>V©-Y�G�@FO5JP>)H(¥2DKYnY§W5>VJL@FG0��JLD0>$�)¬?�� ('97F�d#5!�<�:�;g�k^_5�

� �0kK�taU��7�s,��/97F�9<B7h�(�)O$Hf¸�JP�-H���G0�}Atª�JP>)I0� ���^�¢��7F#�:��;g�g _ �

z��

Page 27: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

� ��� Ò�����7� � ��E�~Ö^Ï��5�� �

G*HJTLy^R]|\@CN�D x @²bgHJefeSHr}®RfT\[ �My{QCRS@UTEQV@²ÄEQVD{R]HJT��.b�N^d�[JI�@UT�DC_�} x R]Q x QVHJTLyMDMNhKLQVD{yodPQVHJT�DM@V�/D¬R]T�} x R]Q x D x @ZHJef|«d�B x HcN^R]y{I� v R]I­@ �ERS@Uy�e]RSØc@'dcT�d�N{N{Hr}��­KLTL|\@CN^[cH�@Uy.d�|LN^dcyMD{R]Q�Q x dcT\[c@"HcbÌI�@UdcTLRfT\[\×

£Ê[cN^dra/RSD¨�¦Ø4R]T\ئbgHcNhQV@U|�D x @�y x RSB�@UT\HJKL[ x H�� QVHJK\NhyM@ºD x d�D�N{@UdceSD{RfI�@�}*dcy­TL@C@U|\@U|�DMH�QCdce]QCKLe]d�DM@QVHcN^N{@UQVD{RSHJTLyCF v d�Ø4R]T\[�N{@UdceSD{RfI�@.R]T�d�}*HcN^I x HJe]@.QVN{@Ud�DM@Uy²d�e]H/QCdceLy{BEdcQV@��ªD{R]I�@.ac@UQVDMHcNr_4dcTE|�D{R]I�@E�ER]@Uy}*@CN{@�dceSN{@Udc|\���©K\�C�UR]T\[�d��9HJK\DC_¬I­d�Ø4R]T\[�D x @(QVHcN^N{@UQVD{RSHJTLyi@Cac@UT x d�N^|\@CNrF�� v.x @C� x dcTL[�HJT�DMH�dcT��ac@UQVDMHcN"D x @C��QCdcT�ÄETL|�HJK\D x @CN{@c_���Ù®dcTL|ER y{dcR]|�F � v RfI�@w�ER]@UyAe]R]Øc@«dcT�d�N{N{H }'Fq��@,I�dU��T\@Cac@CN�[c@CDHJKLDCF��

*A@CN{@­D x @�HcN^R][JR]TLdceÌac@CN{� ���©RS@Uy���9@UQVHJI�@Uy'D x @­y{K\�4ÞM@UQVDC·oD x @­HcN^RS[JR]TEdce¹y^K\�4ÞM@UQVD �°D{R]I�@v��T\H } I�H4|LRSÄL@Uy ���©RS@Uy�4·D x @­BEN{@CB9HJy{RSD{RSHJT �Me]RSØc@v���=@UQVHJI­@Uy'D x @­ac@CN^��·¹dcTE| �Md�N{N{H }_���9@UQVHJI�@Uy"D x @­Hc�4ÞM@UQVD"Hcb �Me]RSØc@v�4F v.x @�HJTLeS��}*HcN^|D x d�Di|\H�@Uy^T � D"Q x dcT\[c@mR]D{y"yM�4TzD{dcQVD{RfQ­N{HJeS@mR]y�D x @meSHr}AeS��d�N^D{R]QCeS@ �MdcT�� � *AHr}¸|\H/@Uy'D x R]y x d�BLB9@UT � v®x @ �MeSH4QCdceyMBEdcQV@��ªD{RfI�@­ac@UQVDMHcN�����} x d�DM@Cac@CNiD x d�D"R]y6�ABLN{@CBEd�N{@Uy'D x @­N{@Udc|\@CN«bgHcN �MdcTÃd�N{N{H }_�4_ÌdcTL|�D x @UT �°D{R]I�@ �ERS@Uy���d�N{@R]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@U|�@V�4BEe]RfQCRSD{eS�cF v®x @UyM@�D¨}²H�QVHJTLQV@CBED{KLdce�yMBEdcQV@Uy,�EeS@UTE|ÃR]T�DMH�dcTLHcD x @CNU_¬} x @CN^@�HJK\N�yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@�[c@CD{y�RSD{yT\@C} RfTzDM@CN{BEN{@CD{d�D{RSHJT±·\D x @C��y x d�N^@"d�y{K\�Ey{BEdcQV@�} x @CN{@'d�y x RSB�D{d�Øc@UyAN{@UdceSD{R]I�@'RfTºd�}²HcNhI x HJeS@cF��@P|\@Uy{QVN^RS�9@�D x @Uy{@.D x N{@C@®QVHJTEQV@CBLD{KLdceEy{BEdcQV@UyC_/bgHcN^I d��EeS@UTL|�_zdcTL|�D x @UT�BEd�N^[email protected]|­@Ca�dce]KLd�[email protected]\N*yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@

KLy{RfT\[�D x @�´j»���e]dcT\[JKLd�[c@���b�HcN�I�HcN{@mHJT ´�» ��dcTL|�RSD{yiKLTL|L@CN^eS�4R]T\[ºD x @CHcN{�c_²yM@C@u# z�� (��h_�} x R]Q x Rfy"@UyMB9@UQCR]dcefeS�y{KLR]D{d��EeS@,�9@UQCdcKLyM@�Hcb�RSD{yjN^R]Q x b�dcQCR]e]RSD{RS@UyPb�HcN"QVHJI«�ER]TLR]TL[mD x @CHcN^RS@UyCF v.x @�Øc@C��}*HcN^|�B©dcRSN 8�� ����� �"��� 8���|\@UefR]I­RSD{y´j»��iI�H4|LKLeS@Uy¬D x d�D*R]T�DMN{H4|LKLQV@ �°D x @CHcN^RS@Uy�«} x R]Q x dce]e]Hr}�dcT���I�H4|\@UeED x d�D*y^d�D{R]yMÄL@UyZD x @Pd��\RSHJI­yUF v®x @®D¨}²Hu� !��M� � Qj�ºefR]T\@Uy�R]TL|ER]QCd�DM@­R]I�B9HcN{D{d�D{RSHJT�Hcb�D x @�D x @CHcN{� M��� Q�R]T�y^KLQ x d�}*dr��D x d�D"RSD"Rfy'y x d�N{@U|�· � DM@Ue]e]y«´�» ��DMHb�HcN^I¸di�EeS@UTL|���} x R]Q x R]y�dcQVD{KLdce]eS�(D x @URSN�QVHJe]R]I�RSD*RfT(D x @jy{@UTLyM@jHcbo£ABLB9@UTL|LR ��»��9@UeSHr}j�h_/} x R]Q x R]y�D x @UTmTEdcI�@U|Q��� �idcy²BEd�N{DZHcb=D x @?%>� ��� ����� �-�4�"%�QVHJTLy{DMN^KLQVDC_/} x R]Q x ÞMKEyMD��EKLRfe]|LyÌdcTL|�TEdcI�@UyZd'I­H/|LKEeS@cF !ZN{@U|LR]QCd�DM@Uy*d�BLB9@Ud�Ndcy��4� ���E��@UdcT=�.a�dce]K\@U|�b�KLTLQVD{RSHJTEyCF"¶ÌR]TLdce]e]�c_#�4�&��DM@Ue]e]y'´j»��mDMHºBEd�N^y{@i} x d�DjbgHJe]e]Hr}®yC_±d�BLB©eS��@UË/KLd�D{RSHJTLy�dcy�eS@Cb�DDMH­N^R][ x D�N{@C}®N^RSDM@�N^KLe]@UyC_\dcTL|ºD x @UTºBEN^R]T�D*D x @�ÄETLdce9N{@Uy{KEeSD"��RSb D x @CN{@"R]y�HJT\@ �h×

#,"�����������0 08<8:�#��," ��=$; -<8%H0"!)#,"96 0 "���% # *9<�:%$9"9<�&,6('$69.5#�<�: &*)�+,�," ��=�; -<8%�-.��=/- &0�," ��=$;��,"���=$;1)�+(29<�<�& -<8%�-�$�3�4�6�0�- &5��" ��=$;��," ��=$;1)�+(29<�<�& -6�6 #,"96 0 " ��%���=C*9<�:%$9"9<�&,6,7C#�:,2�6 -'83�:�9 &0�," ��=$;�-.:6;9,$�3<4�690='�69.5#$<�:�7 #,:,296��%>�9���= *9<�:%$9"9<�&,6 -

68=$4,#,"

#,"1?�@A��B8���,0 %$:��<���C��-<8% #��D$H6;>8&.�5690 &E)�+,�," ��=$; -<8%H0"!F-�&.��4�6�-.#G!H-:I�2�@�@J3�:�<+2�=�48-.# &��" ��=$;;�,"���=$;K)�+(29<�<�& -6�6 #��D$H6;>8&.�5690LI�2�@�@�3�:�<+2�=�4 #,"96 0 "���%17 #�:�296 -'83�:�9 &0�," ��=$;�-.:6 #��D$H6;>8&.�5690,&.�C4�6,917 #�:�296��%>�917�7�'�69.5#$<�: -

68=$4,#,"

#,"1M�N�N8O:P��,0 %$:��<���C��-<8%K38=Q38:�:�<8* &*)�+(�," ��=$;�-6�6�38=Q38:�:�<8*17�'�69.5#�<8: -

68=$4,#,"

$�3<4�6,�.O%R8�S�,0J?�@A�CB��,T1M�N�N8O:P�- 6+=�4%$

:�6�4 #,"�6 0�" ��%($�3�4�6�0J38=Q38:�:�<8* -:�6�4 #��F$H6;>8&.�+690(&8�C4�6�38=�3�:�:�<8*�-

z#�

Page 28: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

´Pb¹QVHJK\N^yM@c_Edcy®dcT�KLTL|\@CNhyMD{dcTL|LR]TL[«Hcb¹D x @�DM@V�4DC_ED x R]y*b�HcN^I­dce�y{�/yMDM@UI R]y�[cN{HJy{y{e]�(H ac@CN^y{R]I�B©e]RSÄL@U|±· x H }²@Cac@CNU_©RSD.R]y§©�{�{�U�f�U� F v.x @UyM@iy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­y x dUac@,HJTLe]�ºD�}*H�e]@Cac@Ue]yi��b�HcN �°}²HcNh|Ly�mdcTL| �My{@UTzDM@UTLQV@Uy��z�h_ T\HmBLN^RSHcN^R]D��c_©dcTE|�b�@C}y{RS[JTEyC·ED x @iI�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�d�N{@.ÞMKEyMD®R]TLQCefKLy{RSHJTLyUFd!�N^Hc�Ed��EeS��D x @ x d�N^|\@UyMD®BEd�N{DC_ED x d�D �"� �-���4� � R]y®d � ��"8��&�©_ x dcy�9@C@UT�Þ{KLyMDAB9HJy{RSDM@U|±_=�9@UQCdcKLyM@­´j»��(QCdcTET\HcD�|\H�D x Rfy®Ø4R]TL|�Hcbw�MyM@UeS@UQVD{RSHJTi�(BEN{H/QV@Uy^yC_=dce]D x HJK\[ x RSDAR]yA}*@Ue]eoy^KLRSDM@U|b�HcN,|L@CÄETLR]T\[�dcTL|È�EeS@UTL|ER]T\[�y{R][JTÈy{�/yMDM@UI�yC_ZdcTL|Èb�HcNiB©d�N^y{R]T\[�dcTL|È@Ca�dce]KLd�D{R]T\[�@V�4BLN{@Uy{y{R]HJTLyCF.*®@CN^@�Rfy�´�» � � yHJK\DMBEKLD�bgN{HJIÝD x @'d��9Hrac@c×

����������������������������������� ()�)�)JP96�&$.8<C$H6 #�<1O:2����1)�)�)

( ����������������������������������O:2���,'�6�:30��5<8=���-� ��;I�2��<&8#���������?$6<I������$<8=�����&� ���&���

� <8%� �:�� ;,"�#!�������#"��������#"������$� ��N�����=�#�6�:,=.38#��+<8=.3�&����������38=%���1��3�#�����&���� &&���

O:2��+7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7<<I�'1���A�C�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7<<I�'�?�@/�CB8�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7<<I�'�M�N�N.O:P7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7$�3<4�6,�.O%R8�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7:�6�4�2H.86K��=1�.O%R�� & #,"96 0 " ��%,$A3�4�690J38=�3�:�:$<8*:�6+*$:�� #�6�0?&(�:�6�0 2/&8#,29<,<�& &K#�:,2967�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7�7:�6�4�2H.86K��=1�.O%R�� & #��D$36�>�&.�+690,&.�C4$6�3+=�38:�:�<8*:�6+*$:�� #�6�0?&(�:�6�0 2/&8#,29<,<�& &K#�:,296O:2��+J2) �6�-

v.x Rfy�y x Hr}Ay«´j»���B©d�N^y{R]T\[��9HcD x yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@UyidcTL|�D x @UT �MKLTL|\@CN^y{D{dcTL|LR]T\[^�mD x d�D«D x @C��d�N{@ � 8���$��-�4·¹T\HcDM@�D x d�DT\@URSD x @CN�y{@UTzDM@UTLQV@�B©d�N^yM@Uy�HJK\D{y{Rf|\@AD x @��EeS@UTL|±F¹¯ x HcB=@PD x @jN{@Udc|\@CN.Rfy�dcy�BEeS@UdcyM@U|�dcy�D x @�dcK\D x HcN.d�D x Hr}¢@UdcyM� / �dce]e�D x R]y�R]yCF�´jbjQVHJKLN^yM@c_*}²@�QVHJKLe]|�[c@CD�D x @�KLy{KLdce®KLTL|\@CN^y{D{dcTL|LR]T\[�HcbjD x @�yM@UT�DM@UTLQV@����È@Ca�dcefKLd�D{R]T\[ÃR]D­R]TÉd|LR��9@CN{@UT�D.QVHJTzDM@V�4DCF��@mT\Hr} QVHJTLy{R]|\@CN«d�yMHJI�@C} x d�D"I�HcN{@�QVHJI­BEeS@V��@V�4dcI­BEeS@c_od�BLN{H/Hcb²D x d�D"HJT\@(I�@CD{d�B x HcN"R]y��9@CDMDM@CN«D x dcT

dcT\HcD x @CNr_¹KLTE|\@CN"QV@CN{D{dcR]T¦dcy{y{KLI­BLD{RSHJTLyCF v.x @�dcy{y^KLI�BLD{RSHJTEy'd�N{@­[JRSac@UT¦R]T�D x @(ÄLac@­D x @CHcNhRS@UyC_¹D x @�I�@CD{d�B x HcN^yR]T�D x @�D�}*HÈa4RS@C}®yU_®dcTL|�D x @�BEN{H�Hcb«R]TÉD x @�b�HJK\N�N{@U|LKLQVD{RSHJTEyCF v.x @�ÄLNhyMD(I�@CD{d�B x HcNU_ � v.x @�R]T�DM@CN^T\@CD�R]ymdcTR]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{R]HJT�DMHcN^TEdc|\H\_���QVHJI�@Uy�b�N{HJI d¦BLN{@Uy{ymN{@UeS@Udcy{@�b�N{HJI+D x @�¶\@U|\@CN^dce'G*HJI�I«KLTER]QCd�D{RSHJTLyºG*HJI­I­Rfy{y{RSHJT±_} x RfeS@«D x @,y{@UQVHJTL|±__� v.x @­R]TzDM@CNhT\@CD�R]y�dcT�R]T\b�HcN^I­d�D{RSHJT�acHJe]QCdcTLH\_���QVHJI�@Uy'bgN{HJI d�B9HJyMDM@CN�D x d�D'D x @�dcK\D x HcN'HcbD x R]y�BEd�B9@CN�BLN{@CBEd�N^@U|,bgHcN*d'QVHJK\N^yM@®HJT�I­d�DM@CN^RfdceER]T,D x Rfy¬BEd�B9@CNZd�D²`�G.O4?iF v.x @.Øc@C��}*HcN^| � $>'�����b�N{HJI �MKLy^R]T\[^�z�R]TL|ER]QCd�DM@Uy�R]I�B9HcN{D{d�D{RSHJTm�/�(QVHcB/�/R]TL[iNhd�D x @CN�D x dcTºy x d�NhR]T\[\_4dcTL|+* � �-!-, 8��"� � R]TE|LR]QCd�DM@Uy�diN{@UTLdcI­R]TL[«Hcb¹D x @HcB9@CN^d�D{RSHJT.,(DMH­�9@UQVHJI�@ �=F

#," � O����.O�/Q�,008<�:�#30LM,;�68=$#�B�>�>�69.5# -<8% 6�>�>$6�.5# &5M,;�68=$#�M�;�6+=$# )�+,B�>�>$6�.5# -<8%H0 "�2$:�# = �:& "�6�&+%96,4 & )�+,B�>�>$6�.5# -

68=$4,#,"

#,"1��N.O � B8���K�,0W2H0 � O����.O�/ -m U , H H3P�PQy�>Y\kPYF7HTY10�NE:�OvF7H369<�H3PdK 83:CH36AH34)6`D9Pv@76Q])>YO)@�G�6�<W< H34�>YO�>�<W6�D9PQO�@_g�PY8 # �#2�H3P�U783P�D�6�<W< :CHb]7NEPQ<ZH PYgjK 4):�DM4x:=< <WUk6�O�H PYO:�O)U7F7H - PQF0H3U)F7Hb]�8V>H34)698 H34)>YOxPYOxU083P�D�6�<W<W:�O)REH34)6 �Q>83:=PYF)<;@769D�G=>�8V>�H3:�PYO)<c>YO�@�@7PY:=O7R�H34)6 ��>YU)U7G�:=D�>�H3:�PQO7<cP�gT8369K 83:CH36A83F)G�6�<�l

z��

Page 29: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

08<�:�#���<�&+2<$H6 -<8%H0C0 2�I',69.5# %$:�<�.8690�0 & )�+;M�;$68=$#�-<8% >8&,<8* &0M�;�68=�#;M�;�68=$# )�+���<�&+2<$H6 -<8%H0,&,<8*($H6,4/��2<$ " � ;�" ",2$;�6 &E)�+���<�&+2<$H6 -

68=$4,#,"

#,"���/���B�N�/�B��K�,0 230! ��N.O � B8����� !/<8%�0 2�I'�69.5# #$< 2H0+6�:�#�� ! <8% %$:$<9.8690�0 #$<S��=�#�6�:,=968#�#�#1-6�6�>8&,<8* ! ��=$#�6�:�=96�# " 230868:�# 7C",2$;�6 -6�6�>8&,<8* ! 2H086�: "D��=$#�6�:�=968#�# 7�&�<8* -6�6 6�>�>$69. # ! ��=$#$6�:,=96�# " 23086+:�# 7C",2$:�#�-

68=$4,#,"

#,"��.O�@ � M�/.O1�,0W2H0"! ��N8O � B8�����G!/<8%�0 2�I',69.5# #�<;'��,. #��D$ #��G!/<8% %�:�<9.8690,0 #�<,'�<�&�.<3+=9</#�#1-6�6�>8&,<8* ! '�<�&�.<3+=9< " '���.5#A�D$G# 7 "�2$;�6 -6�6�>8&,<8* ! '��,.5#��F$ " '�<�&$.<3+=9<8# 7K&,<8* -6�6 6�>�>$69. # ! '�<�&$.<38=9< " '���.5#/�D$ # 7 "�2$:�#�-

68=$4,#,"

#,"1�.O<N�/�M��.O1�,0W2H0"! ��N8O � B8�����G!/<8%�0 2�I',69.5# #�<;'��,. #��D$ #��G!/<8% %�:�<9.8690,0 #�< #�<�:,=.3�4$</#�#1-6�6�>8&,<8* !7#�<�:,=.3�4$< " '���.5#A�D$G# 7K&,<8* -6�6�>8&,<8* ! '��,.5#��F$ "7#�<�:�=.3�4$<8# 7 "�2$;�6 -6�6 6�>�>$69. # !)#�<�:�=.3,4$< " '���.5#/�D$ # 7 "�2$:�#�-

68=$4,#,"

�����(�,"�6Q��=$#�6�:,=�6�#��,0,38=���=8>$<�:%$�3�#��+<+= #�<�:�=.3,4$<�-'��568*��.O<N�/�M��.O(>,:�<C$��.O:N�/�M��.O #$<Q��/���B�N�/�B��Q�,0

<8%�'��,.5#��F$ #�< 23086�:�-<8% #�<�:,=.3�4$< #�<Q��=$#�6�:�=96�# -

68=$4�'

#,"1��B8�<���S�,0 2H0! �.O<N�/�M��.OJT���/���B�N�/�B���#1- 68=�4,#,":�6�41>8&�<8* ! '���.5#��D$ " #�<�:�=83,4�</# 7�7�>8&,<+* !72H0868: " ��=$#$6�:,=�68#A#1-:�6�41>8&�<8* !)#�<8:,=.3,4$<#" '���. #��F$ # 7�7�>8&,<+* ! ��=$#$6�:,=96�# " 2H0+68:A#1-

�����(�,"�6Q��=$#�6�:,=�6�#��,0,38=���=8>$<�:%$�3�#��+<+=,'�<�&$.<38=9<�-'��568*��.O�@ � M�/.O(>,:�<C$��.O<@ � M�/.O #$<Q��/���B�N�/�B��Q�,0

<8%�'��,.5#��F$ #�< 23086�:�-<8%�'�<�&�.<3+=9< #�<Q��=$#�6�:�=96�# -

68=$4�'

#,"1��B8�<���S�,0 2H0!�.O�@ � M�/.OJT���/���B�N�/�B���#1- 68=�4,#,":�6�41>8&�<8* ! '���.5#��D$ " '�<�&$.:38=�</# 7�7�>8&,<+* !72H0868: " ��=$#$6�:,=�68#A#1-:�6�41>8&�<8* ! '�<�&�.<38=9<#" '���. #��F$ # 7�7�>8&,<+* ! ��=$#$6�:,=96�# " 2H0+68:A#1-

v.x @­´j»�� 3 HJKLDMBEK\DPbgN{HJIÜD x R]yAy x Hr}®yjD x d�D�D x @,ÄLN^yMDPD�}*HºN{@U|LKLQVD{R]HJTLyP[JRSac@ � ���4'-�ºdcTL|�D x @�yM@UQVHJTE|�D�}*Hº[JRSac@8���$��LF v.x Rfy�I�@UdcTLyAD x d�D®D x @"ÄLN^yMD®y{@UI­RSHcD{R]Q'I­HcN{B x R]y^I¸|\H�@UyAT\HcD®BEN{@UyM@CN{ac@«D x @"d��\RSHJI­y,��} x R]Q x QVHJTLQV@CN^T�D x @�LH }ÃHcb\I­d�DM@CN^R]dcez�9@CD�}*@C@UT"D x @²KLyM@CN dcTL|"D x @�Hc�4ÞM@UQVDC_�@URSD x @CNoDMHcN^TLdc|\H.HcNoacHJe]QCdcT\H��h_c} x R]eS@ÌD x @ZyM@UQVHJTE|"I�HcN{B x R]y{I|\H/@UyC_4} x R]Q x R]I�BEe]R]@Uy�D x d�D�D x @�yM@UQVHJTL|ºI­@CD{d�B x HcN.R]y*�9@CDMDM@CN�D x dcT�D x @jÄLN^y{D²}®R]D x N^@UyMB9@UQVD²DMH�BLN^@UyM@CN{a4R]T\["D x @UyM@d��\RSHJI­yCF��ª´jTÃD x @(HcD x @CN x dcTL|�_¹D x @(DMHcN^TEdc|\H�I�@CD{d�B x HcN,N{@UyMHJTLd�DM@Uyi}®RSD x I­dcT��ÃQVHJI­I�HJTÈB x NhdcyM@Uy"y{KEQ x dcy�°}®R]TE|Ly­Hcb"Q x dcT\[c@c_���} x R]Q x d�N{@�BEd�N^D�Hcb'HJK\NºQCKLe]D{K\N{@c_�} x @CN^@Udcy�}*@ x dUac@�eS@Uy{ymQVHJe]eS@UQVD{R]ac@�@V�4B9@CN^RS@UTLQV@�dcTL|dcy{yMH4QCR]d�DM@U|�e]dcT\[JKLd�[c@'b�HcN.acHJe]QCdcTLHJyCFß�

z &

Page 30: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

� � *Ð E�®ÒAÑ�Ö�E� ��� ��ZÏ,Ó&� ����Ô1���,ÒAÔ«Ð � �������� *Ð E�®ÒAÑ�Ö�E� .Ï,Ó � ���D��Ô1���,ÒAÔ«Ð �£PeSD x HJK\[ x D x R]y d�BEB=@UTE|LR �PRfy�}.N^R]DMDM@UT"KLTL|L@CN�D x @�dcy{y{KLI�BED{RSHJT�D x d�DoN{@Udc|\@CN^y¹dceSN{@Udc|\�jØ4T\Hr}�yMHJI�@*�Edcy{RfQ�QCd�DM@C[cHcN{�D x @CHcN{� / 2�_LRSD�R]y�T\HJTL@CD x @UeS@Uy{y�@Uy{y{@UTzD{R]dcefeS��yM@UeSb���QVHJT�D{dcR]T\@U|±_\D x HJKL[ x DM@CN^yM@c_ER]TmHcN^|L@CN�DMH­Ä\�(T\HcD{d�D{R]HJTºbgHcN®D x @�T\@C}I­d�DM@CN^Rfdce¡F v.x @"@Uy{yM@UT�D{R]dceÌR]T�D{KLRSD{RSHJT��=@ x R]TL|�QCd�DM@C[cHcN^R]@Uy�R]y®D x d�DAD x @C��QCd�BLD{K\N{@,I­d�D x @UI­d�D{RfQCdce¹y{DMN^KLQVD{K\N{@UyU·©b�HcN@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_\yM@CD{yC_4[cN{HJKLBEyC_/ac@UQVDMHcN®yMBEdcQV@UyC_LdcTE|mdcKLDMHJI­d�D{d4_LdceSHJT\[,}®RSD x D x @URSN�yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@PBLN{@UyM@CN{a4R]T\[iI�HcN{B x R]y{I­yC_@UdcQ x b�HcN^I¸d­QCd�DM@C[cHcN{�c_9dcTL|ºD x @UR]N.I�HcN{B x Rfy{I­y�d�N{@"dcTº@Uy^yM@UTzD{Rfdce±BEd�N{D.Hcb¹D x @'B©R]QVD{K\N{@cF� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿��u £ tJs\p Á�¾©ÅEq À� QVHJTEy{R]yMD{yZHcb¨×¬d"QVHJefeS@UQVD{RSHJT±_/|\@UT\HcDM@U| � �ß_�Hcb Å©l �rÁ�tJprn ·4bgHcN²@UdcQ x BEdcRSN�:�G �~HcbHc�4ÞM@UQVD{yC_Ed�yM@CD � :�G �­�²Hcb ÂÃÅ©q ÆÌÇo½�nr¦n ��dce]yMH­QCdcefeS@U| sLq q�Å � n HcN ¦sLƹn �ZbgN^HJI : DMH �m·\b�HcN�@UdcQ x Hc�\Þ°@UQVD!:«_d'I�HcN^B x R]y{I â�� b�N{HJI :�DMH�: QCdce]eS@U|�D x @ ½J,oÁ4¿=p ½gphÀ d�D :"·4dcTL|�b�HcNZ@UdcQ x D x N{@C@�Hc�4ÞM@UQVD{y�: G � GX�,_�dcT­HcB=@CNhd�D{RSHJTQCdce]eS@U| tJũ¦Æ�ÅEn ½fp�½gÅ=¿ _ � : G �­� � � � GX�«� � � :�GX�«�j|\@UT\HcDM@U| �V·���y^KLQ x D x d�D �¹·r���E·��©��DÜ� �¹·*�4�h·���dcTL|�¹· â�� D � dcTL| â�� ·*� D �É} x @UT\@Cac@CNºD x @UyM@�QVHJI�B9HJy{R]D{RSHJTLy�d�N{@�|\@CÄET\@U|�F ��@�}.N^RSDM@ �«× : � � } x @UT��� � : G �­�h_EdcTL|�QCdce]e : D x @ nUÅ��oq tzÁ dcTE|"� D x @ prsLq�¾EÁ�p Hcb��¹F =

Ù®@Uy{KLeSD{y¬R]T,D x @.�9H/|\�"Hcb©D x Rfy¬BEd�B9@CN�y x H }ÉD x d�D�y{RS[JT�yM�/y{DM@UI­y¬}®RSD x y{@UI­RSHcD{R]Q�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y¹b�HcN^IYd�QCd�DM@C[cHcN{�cF��@.}®Rfe]ezN^@Ca/RS@C} D x @�TLHcD{RSHJTLyÌHcb=BEKLy x HJKLDC_JQVHJT\@.dcTL|�QVHJe]R]I�RSDob�HcN�HcN^|ER]TLd�N{�"QCd�DM@C[cHcNhRS@UyC_zN^@Ue]d�DM@�D x R]yÌDMH��Ee]@UTL|LR]T\[\_dcTL|,D x @UT�QVHJTLy{R]|\@CN¬D x @.I�HcN{@�[c@UT\@CN^dceEyM@CDMD{R]T\[�Hcb �/ ��QCd�DM@C[cHcN^RS@UyU_�} x R]Q x QCd�BLD{KLN{@Uy�I�HcN{@�Hcb=D x @�B x @UT\HJI�@UT\HJeSHc[c�HcbÌ�EeS@UTL|ER]T\[\F

v.x @�R]TzD{KERSD{RSHJT�bgHcN�QVHJefR]I­RSD{yºR]y�D x d�DºD x @C� BEK\DºyMHJI�@�QVHJI�B9HJT\@UT�D{y�DMHc[c@CD x @CNU_'R]|\@UT�D{RSb��/R]TL[Èdcy�efRSDMD{eS@�dcyB9HJy{y{RS�©eS@c_²}ARSD x T\HcD x RfT\[ÃeS@Cb�D�H ac@CNU_®dcTL|�}®RSD x TLHcD x R]T\[�@Uy^yM@UTzD{Rfdce]eS� T\@C}Êdc|E|\@U| # â�� (ªF v.x R]y­y^K\[c[c@UyMD{y(D x d�DQVHJe]R]I�RSD{y¬y x HJKLef|,[JRSac@®yMHJI�@®Ø/R]TE|,Hcb=HcBED{R]I­dce\�Ee]@UTL|±F;��@A}®R]e]e4yM@C@®D x d�D�D x @CN{@Ad�N{@.BLN{Hc�©eS@UI­yÌ}®RSD x D x R]yC_JyMH"D x d�DD x @«DMN^dc|LRSD{RSHJTEdce�QCd�DM@C[cHcN^R]QCdceÌT\HcD{RSHJTEy.d�N{@«TLHcDAË/KLRSDM@"d�BLBEN{HcBLN^R]d�DM@"bgHcNA�EeS@UTL|LRfT\[\FZáA@Cac@CN{D x @UeS@Uy{yU_©D x @C�ºBEN{Hra4R]|\@d�[cH/H/|�BEe]dcQV@�DMH­�9@C[JR]T�HJK\N¬Þ°HJK\NhT\@C�(Hcb¹b�HcN^I­dce]RS�Ud�D{R]HJT±F� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿��9u �jRSac@UT d�QCd�DM@C[cHcN{� _Ìd �+RfT R]y,d�BEdcRSN � 3 ×���� 3 �B0 D â G z �«HcbAI­HcN{B x R]y^I­yC_¬dcTL|d tJÅ=¿ Á }ARSD x�sLÆ�Á/; �ÜHrac@CN,d � � � G � / Rfy�d�BEdcRSN � 34×& e3 � � �B0@D â G z �jHcb�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yU· D x @UT � � G � / dcTL|� � G � / DMHc[c@CD x @CNPd�N^@"y{dcR]|ºDMH�bgHcN^I d ,̽gs©ÂÃÅ=¿;, ��HcNAd n � � sLq�Á �hF v.x @'QVHJTL@m��HcNAR]D{y.|LR]dcI�HJTE|©� tJÅ©ÂÈÂ&��p Á�n R �� � · � � D � / · � / _±dcTL|�R]yPd Æ �onrÇ Å ��p R ��[JRSac@UT�dcTz��HcD x @CNjQVHJI�I«K\D{d�D{R]ac@,QVHJTL@18k34× e3 � � H ac@CN � � G � / _9D x @CN{@R]y�d­KETLR]Ë/K\@�d�N{N{Hr}��"×�� � �Yy{KLQ x D x d�D � 3¨·���D 8k3¹bgHcN 0 D â G z F

£ ,̽�sL¾Eq�sEÂ�� R]T�d(QCd�DM@C[cHcN{� RfyAdm|LRSN{@UQVDM@U|�[cN^d�B x }®RSD x RSD{yATLH/|\@UyPe]d��9@UeS@U|º�/��Hc�4ÞM@UQVD{yPbgN^HJI dcTL|RSD{y®@U|\[c@UyAefd��=@Ue]@U|�����d�N{N^Hr}®y®bgN{HJI _Ey{KEQ x D x d�DARSbÌdcT�d�N^N{Hr} �"× � 3�� � 6"e]d��9@Ue]y®dcT�@U|\[c@ �¬× 0 � 4\_©D x @UTD x @,yMHJK\N^QV@iT\H4|\@�0*Hcb��iR]yPe]d��9@UeS@U|º�/� �13 dcTL|�D x @"D{d�N{[c@CD�T\H4|\@@4mHcb��,R]y®e]d��9@UeS@U|���� ��6 F®£ tJÅ=¿ Á�Å �=Á�q��R]yPdcT�Hc�\Þ°@UQVD �m_=QCdcefeS@U|�R]D{y sLÆZÁ ; _=DMHc[c@CD x @CN'}®R]D x dcT�d�N{N{H } � 34× � 3 ���m_9QCdce]eS@U|�dcT ½�¿ �UÁ/tcp ½�Å©¿ _9bgN^HJI @UdcQ xHc�4ÞM@UQVD²Hcb � DMH��(_/dcTL|�Rfy tJÅ=¦Â&� prs\p ½��=Á R��ºb�HcNZ@UdcQ x �«× � 3 � � 6AR]T � _�}²@ x dUac@ / * � 3 D �¹· � 6�F�£ tJÅ=Ú�½�ÂȽgpHcb � R]yjdºQVHJI­IiK\D{d�D{RSac@�QVHJT\@ � 34× � 3 �'� H ac@CN � y{KEQ x D x d�D'RSb�8X3/× � 3 � � R]yjdcT���HcD x @CN'QVHJI�I«K\D{d�D{R]ac@QVHJT\@'H ac@CN � _\D x @UTºD x @CN{@"R]y�d­KETLR]Ë/K\@��«×�� � �~y^KLQ x D x d�D�� C � 3¨·���D 8k3ob�HcN®dce]e T\H/|L@Uy 0ZHcb � F =!²KLy x HJK\D{y*d�N{@PD x @jyMB9@UQCR]dce©QCdcy{@PHcboQVHJe]R]I­RSD{yZ} x @CN{@PD x @j|LR]d�[cN^dcI R]y*d � F/¯¨D�I­RS[ x D�d�BLB9@Ud�N²D x d�D*D x @CN{@�R]y*d

|LR]y^QVN{@CBEdcTLQV�­R]T�D x @�|\@CÄETLR]D{RSHJTLyC_J�9@UQCdcKLy{@ABEKEy x HJK\D{y²d�N{@PTLHcD*N^@UË�KLR]N{@U|­DMH x dUac@'dcTmd�N{N{H }5� �!�mF�»�K\D*} x @UTD x @"|ER]d�[cN^dcI¸R]y.d � _\D x Rfy.I­R]y{y^R]T\[,d�N{N{Hr} R]y.dcK\DMHJI­d�D{RfQCdce]eS�mBLN{Hra4R]|\@U|��/�mD x @"I�HcN{B x R]y{I � � · � � D � / · � / Fv.x @CN{@mRfy«d�y x HcN{DiBLN{H/Hcb�D x d�D�dcT��ÃD�}*H�QVHJe]R]I­R]D{y"Hcb®d�|LR]d�[cNhdcI � d�N{@mRfyMHJI�HcN{B x R]Q�F � @CDiD x @mQVHJT\@Uy,�9@� 3�× � 3 � �ÝdcTE| � �3 × � 3 �(� � F v.x @UT�D x @CN{@,d�N{@iKETLR]Ë/K\@"d�N{N{H }®y��"×2����� � dcTL|��A×2� � � �Ýy{d�D{R]y{bg�4R]T\[D x @�d�BLBEN{HcBLN^R]d�DM@ºDMNhR]dcT\[JeS@UyC_²dcTL| D x @CN{@�d�N^@�dce]yMH�KLTER]Ë�KL@md�N{N^Hr}®y,� � � dcTL| � � � � � y{d�D{R]yMb��/RfT\[�D x @URSNd�BLBLN^HcBLN^R]d�DM@,DMN^R]dcTL[JeS@UyC_ TLdcI­@UeS��D x @�N{@UyMB9@UQVD{RSac@­R]|\@UT�D{RSD{RS@Uy â�� dcTL| â �! · �EK\D"�o·���dcTE|��E·���dce]yMH�y{d�D{R]y{bg��D x @y{dcI�@"DMN^R]dcT\[JeS@UyU·4y{H­����KLTLRfË�K\@UTL@Uy{yC_#� ·��2D â�� dcTL|$�E·���D â �! F

¶\HJefeSHr}®RfT\[(D x @iy{KL[c[c@UyMD{RSHJT�Hcb*O/@UQVD{RSHJT �(D x d�DP�EeS@UTL|Ey®d�N{@�QVHJI­IiK\D{d�D{RSac@�QVHJT\@UyC_�R]DAb�HJe]eSH }®y®D x d�DPQVHJe]RfI­RSD{yy x HJKEe]|m�=@'y{HJI�@'Ø4R]TL|mHcboHcBED{R]I­dce±�Ee]@UTL|±F̶\HcN®@V�\dcI�BEeS@c_ED x @ � x HJKLyM@C�9HJd�D���©eS@UTL|�Hcbq� x HJKLyM@v�­dcTE| �°�=HJd�D�(R]ym@X )v6�6�! iki7]&Y �0] Y9;%&-gtPY8;836�G=>�H3:2��6�GCI�RQ6�O�H3G�6A:�O�HW83Pv@7F)DMH3:=PYO)< H3Pa<WPQNE6 \�>Y<W:�D+:=@76b>�<cP�g Db>H36�RQP�8WIxH34)69PY8WI^p7H34769836+>�836+>�G�<WPEN�>YO�I_N�>YO�IPYH347698;U�>�Uk6983<;>YO�@_N�>YO�I�PYH347698;\kP�PQyv<�lm . 25476�<W6+6WV�F�>H3:=PYO)< >836LD�>YG�G�6b@�;&% @C=%3('*),+.-d\k69G=PbKA]�>�gtH36M8;H3476`D�P�8W836�<WUkPQO)@7:�O)RaH340836�6`O)Pv@06AD�PQNENdF7HV>H3: �Q6`@7:=>�RY8V>YNE<�l� 2 25476�<W6+6WV�F�>H3:=PYO)< N�>�I�>YG�<WPE\k6`Db>�G�G=6�@ X�HW83:=>YO7RQG�6�<W[�\k6�G�PbKAl

3 �

Page 31: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

d�QVHJefR]I­RSDCF�»�K\D.D x @«b�dcQVDPD x d�DAQVHJefR]I­RSD{y.d�N^@"HJTLeS��|\@CDM@CN^I�R]T\@U|�K\B�DMH(R]y{HJI�HcN{B x Rfy{I¸yM@C@UI­yPR]TLQVHJTLy^R]yMDM@UT�D�}®RSD xD x R]yU_��9@UQCdcKLy{@²D x @�TLdcI­@Uy¹d�DMD{dcQ x @U|­DMHjD x @*@UeS@UI�@UT�D{y¬R]TidP�EeS@UTL|id�N{@�R]I�B9HcN{D{dcT�DC·JD x d�D¬R]yC_cR]yMHJI­HcN{B x R]QZQVHJT\@Uy¬|\H�©�c� N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D�D x @'y{dcI�@"�EeS@UTL|±F v.x R]y�|LR��9@CN^y�bgN^HJIwD x @"y{RSD{KEd�D{RSHJTºR]T�[cN{HJK\B�D x @CHcN{�mHcN.DMHcB9HJeSHc[c�c_L} x @CN^@'RSD.R]y@UT\HJK\[ x DMH,Q x d�N^dcQVDM@CNhRS�C@PdcT(Hc�4ÞM@UQVD*KLB�DMH,R]yMHJI�HcN{B x R]y{IºF *®H }²@Cac@CN�D x @AN{@UË/KLRSN^@UI�@UTzDP��dce]yMH«I­HcD{RSa�d�DM@U|m�/��D x @@V�\dcI�BEeS@Uy�RfT�O/@UQVD{RSHJT �J�ÌD x d�D�D x @®RfT�Þ°@UQVD{R]HJTLy¬y x HJKLef|«�[email protected]]TEQCe]KLy{RSHJTEy DMHidcy¬[cN{@Ud�D²dcT�@V�/DM@UT�DZdcyZB=HJy^y{RS�EeS@c_JQCdcKEyM@UyD x @�dcQVD{KLdce\TLdcI­@UyÌHcbE@UeS@UI�@UT�D{yÌDMHj�9@*QCd�BLD{KLN{@U|,���«�EeS@UTL|EyC_�dcTE|«D x KLy¹@Ue]R]I�R]TLd�DM@Uy¹D x @�d�BLBEd�N{@UT�D¬R]TLQVHJTLy^R]yMDM@UTLQV�cF

£PT\HcD x @CN�BLN{Hc�©eS@UIY}®R]D x |\@CÄETER]T\['�Ee]@UTL|Ly¬DMH,�9@®QVHJI­IiK\D{d�D{RSac@'QVHJT\@Uy�R]yZD x d�DC_\dcy�y x Hr}AT(R]T�O/@UQVD{RSHJT �/_\T\HcDdce]eE�EeS@UTL|LyZdcQVD{KLdce]eS� x drac@Pb�KLe]e]�«QVHJI­IiK\D{d�D{RSac@�QVHJT\@UyC·4b�HcN�� x HJKLyM@v�"dcTE| �°�9HJd�D�4_4HJTLeS�,D x @ � x HJKLyM@C�9HJd�D�«�EeS@UTL|x dcy²dce]eERSD{y�DMN^R]dcT\[JeS@Uy²QVHJI­IiK\D{d�D{RSac@cFZ»�K\DZdcy*y{K\[c[c@Uy{DM@U|�D x @CN^@c_�D x @PT\HcD{RSHJT�Hcb9dcK\�4R]efR]d�N{�«I­HcN{B x R]y^I~yMHJeSac@Uy²D x R]yBLN{Hc�©eS@UIºF v.x @ s � ; ½�Ú�½�sLq À ÂÃÅ©q ÆÌǹ½gn ÂÃn R]T � d�N{@­D x HJy{@�} x HJyM@�DMN^RfdcT\[JeS@Uy�d�N{@­T\HcD�N^@UË�KLR]N{@U|�DMH�QVHJI­IiK\DM@c·D x @UyM@,I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�QCdcT��9@"N{@UI­Hrac@U|�bgN^HJI � _EDMHm�/R]@Ue]|�dcT\HcD x @CNj|LR]d�[cNhdcI � ��x dUa4R]T\[(D x @«y^dcI�@«T\H4|\@UyPdcy � FG*HJI­IiK\D{d�D{RSac@­QVHJTL@UyjHrac@CN � � d�N^@iD x @UT�QVHJT\@Uy�Hrac@CN � D x d�D�QVHJI­IiK\DM@�@V�\QV@CBLD�B9HJy{y{RS�Ee]�ºHrac@CN'D x @�dcK4�\R]e]Rfd�N{�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yUF�áAHr}Ý}*@ºQCdcT dce]yMH�b�HcN^I d�QVHJefR]I­RSDiHcb � �g_ZDMH�[c@CD­d �°�9@UyMDiB9HJy{y{RS�©eS@v��y{KEQ x QVHJT\@�Hrac@CN � F�¯ DD x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@,I­d�Øc@UyjyM@UTLyM@iDMH�|\@CÄET\@id��Ee]@UTL|�DMHm�9@«dmQVHJI­I«KLD{d�D{RSac@�QVHJT\@«H ac@CN'd(|ER]d�[cN^dcIÊ}®RSD x D x @idcK4�\R]e]Rfd�N{�I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y*N{@UI­Hrac@U|±F

´jTL@Adc|\a�dcTzD{d�[c@jHcb�b�HcN^I­dcefRS�Ud�D{RSHJT�Rfy�D x d�D�RSD²I�d�Øc@Uy�RSD�B9HJy{y{RS�©eS@�DMH«BEN{Hrac@j[c@UT\@CN^dce=e]dr}®yC_4R]T­D x RfyZQCdcyM@c_\e]dr}®yd��9HJK\D¹�EeS@UTL|Lyo�EdcyM@U|iHJT,[c@UT\@CNhdce�N^@Uy{KLeSD{y¹b�N{HJI QCd�DM@C[cHcN{�,D x @CHcN{�c_zy{KEQ x dcyÌD x d�D �°D x @�BEKLy x HJK\DoHcb=dPBEKLy x HJKLDoR]yÌdBEKLy x HJK\DCF�� v.x R]yÌN{@Uy^KLeSD¬y{K\[c[c@UyMD{yZBLN{H a/R]TL[PD x d�Dw�°D x @.�Ee]@UTL|,Hcb=d'�EeS@UTL|�R]y¬d'�EeS@UTL|±_���y{H�D x d�DZQVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{R]HJTLdce]RSD¨�Hcb�D x @jØ4R]TL|�Hcb HcBLD{R]I�dceE�Ee]@UTL|Ly�[JR]ac@UT(�/�­BEKEy x HJK\D{y²bgHJefeSHr}®y²b�N{HJI D x @Pd��9H ac@'Ë�K\HcDM@U|mN{@Uy^KLeSD²d��9HJK\D*BEKLy x HJK\D{yCFv.x @'I­@UdcTLR]T\[�Hcb¹D x @UyM@"dcy^yM@CN{D{RSHJTLy.}®R]e]e©�9@'QCeS@Ud�N{@CNAR]b }*@'N{@Cb�@CN.DMH­D x @'b�HJe]eSH }®R]T\[,|LR]d�[cNhdcIº×

�� m ??~~~~~~~ �

� �__@@@@@@@

�( 1__@@@@@@@

� m??~~~~~~~ �

� �__@@@@@@@

�( m__@@@@@@@

( �??~~~~~~~

*A@CN{@«}*@�dcy{y{KLI­@"D x d�D � / G � � R]yAd(�©eS@UTL|ºHcb�� / G � � _=dcTL| 8 / G�8 � R]yPd(�EeS@UTL|�Hcb�� � G � / _±R¡F�@cFS_9D x d�D0� / · � / D � � · � �dcTL| � � ·�8 / D � / ·�8 � ·²D x @UT�D x @ºQCe]dcR]I R]y«D x d�D28 / G � � ·�8 � R]y,d��©eS@UTL|¦Hcb � / · � � G � � _Z} x R]Q x b�HJe]eSH }®yi�9@UQCdcKLyM@� / · � � ·�8 / D � � · � � ·�8 � F(`Ay{RfT\[�D x @�T\HcD{d�D{RSHJT � / � � � b�HcN"dcT�d�N{�©RSDMN^d�N{���EeS@UTL|�Hcb � / G � � _�}*@�QCdcT�}.NhRSDM@,D x R]yN{@Uy{KEeSD�N^d�D x @CNATER]QV@UeS�(RfT�D x @�bgHcNhI

� ��� � � / � � � �ED~� � / · � � � � � � _D{d�Ø4R]T\[�dc|\a�dcT�D{d�[c@iHcb¬d(QVHJTzac@UT�D{RSHJT�D x d�D � � � � � / � � � ��R]TL|ER]QCd�DM@Uy��EeS@UTE|LR]T\[ � � }®RSD x D x @"eS@Cb�DAR]T�ÞM@UQVD{RSHJTºHcb� � / � � � ����D x @�DMHcB�e]@CbgD�@U|\[c@"HcbÌR]D{y.|LR]dcI�HJTE|©�hF

v.x @�BEKLy x HJKLD�QVHJI­B=HJy^RSD{RSHJT�N{@Uy{KEeSD'��BLN{Hrac@U|�@cF�[\FER]T # 3 3 _i% â (��*yMD{d�DM@UyAD x d�D®RSb � / G � � R]y.d,B©KLy x HJK\D�Hcb4� / G � � _dcTL| 8 / G�8 � R]y.d(BEKLy x HJKLD�Hcb�� � G � / _ED x @UT 8 / G � � ·�8 � R]yAd­BEKLy x HJK\D�Hcb�� / · � � G � � F�¯ b¹}*@"}®N^RSDM@ � /���� � � bgHcNPD x @BEKLy x HJK\D�Hcb�� / G � � _\D x @UT�D x Rfy�N{@Uy{KLeSD�QCdcT�dce]yMH��9@�}.N^RSDMDM@UTºTL@Ud�D{eS�c_Edcy

� � ��� � � /���� � � � D~� � / · � � � ��� � � F��@mQCdcT¦dce]y{H�BEe]dcQV@�d�yM@UQVHJTL|��©eS@UTL|É��HcNiBEKLy x HJKLDh�AHJT�DMHcB¦Hcb � � R]TLy{DM@Udc|�Hcb � / ·¬QVHcN{N^@UyMB9HJTL|LR]T\[�N{@Uy^KLeSD{y

D x @UTºb�HJe]eSH }¢�/�myM�4I­I�@CDMN^�c_EdcTL|ºd�b�DM@CNAyMHJI�@"N{@UTLdcI­R]TL[iHcb¬d�N{N^Hr}®y.QCdcT��9@�}.N^RSDMDM@UTºdcy®bgHJe]e]Hr}®yC×� � ��� � / � � � � D � � � � � / · � � �jF� � � ��� � / � ��� � � D � � ��� � � / · � � �PF

��@,QCdcT�b�K\N{D x @CN®[c@UT\@CN^dce]RS�C@«DMH(dcT��ºBEd�DMDM@CN^T�Hcb�|LR]dcI�HJTL|EyCײRSb¹D x @C��dce]e QVHJI­I«KLDM@c_=D x @UT�yMHm|\H�@Uy®D x @"HJKLD{y{R]|\@ÄL[JK\N^@c·ÌdcTE|�RSb*D x @C��d�N{@�dce]e�BEKLy x HJKLD{yC_�D x @UT¦yMH�R]y"D x @­HJK\D{y{Rf|\@�ÄL[JK\N{@cF�£PT\HcD x @CN"ac@CN^��[c@UTL@CN^dce�N{@Uy^KLeSD�b�N{HJI

34â

Page 32: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

QCd�DM@C[cHcN{��D x @CHcN^�«y{dr�/y¬D x d�D¬D x @.QVHJe]R]I­R]DoHcb9dcTz�iQVHJTLT\@UQVDM@U|(|LR]d�[cN^dcI~QCdcT,�9@��EKLR]e]Dob�N{HJI BEKLy x HJK\D{yoHcb=RSD{yÌB©d�N{D{yCFv d�Øc@UT�dce]e9DMHc[c@CD x @CNr_©D x @Uy{@�N{@Uy{KLeSD{y.[JRSac@'d�[cH/H/|�|L@Udce±Hcb¬QCdce]QCKLe]d�D{RSHJTEdce9B=H }²@CNAbgHcN®�EeS@UTL|LRfT\[\F

áAHr}~RSD � yPD{R]I�@«DMH(�EN{HJdc|\@UT�HJK\NAb�N^dcI�@C}*HcN{Ø=F v.x @iQCd�DM@C[cHcN{��HcbZy{RS[JT�yM�4yMDM@UI­yP}®RSD x yM@UI­RSHcD{R]Q«I�HcN{B x R]y{I­yx dcy¹yMHJI�@�dc|L|LRSD{R]HJTLdcezyMDMNhKLQVD{K\N{@²Hrac@CN¬D x d�D¹HcbLdAQCd�DM@C[cHcN^�©×¬RSD¹R]yodcT ���Mµz�V�{�{µ,�h�c���ª�����h� _J�9@UQCdcKLy{@²HcbLD x @ZHcN^|\@CNhR]T\[Jy�/�ÃË�KEdce]RSD���Hcb.N^@CBLN{@UyM@UT�D{d�D{RSHJTÈD x d�D,QCdcT¦�9@(BEK\D"HJTÈRSD{yiI�HcN{B x R]y{I­yCF v®x R]y'@V�4DMN^d�yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@�[JR]ac@Uyid�N^R]Q x @CNb�N^dcI�@C}*HcN{Ø�bgHcN®QVHJTEy{R]|\@CN^RfT\[,�EeS@UTL|LyU·�¯��9@Ue]RS@Cac@jD x R]y®d�BLBLN{HJdcQ x QCd�BLD{K\N{@Uy®} x d�D.¶LdcKEQVHJTLTLRS@CNPdcTL| v K\N^T\@CN x drac@QCdce]eS@U| �°@UI�@CN{[c@UT�D�"yMDMN^KEQVD{K\N{@c_z}ARSD x HJK\D¬T\@C@U|LRfT\[�dcTz�,HcD x @CN*I­dcQ x RfT\@CN{�cF+��HcN^@CHrac@CNU_\dce]e4D x @AKLy{KLdce4QCd�DM@C[cHcN^R]QCdceQVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{R]HJTLdce]RSD¨��N{@Uy{KEeSD{y�d��9HJK\D�BEKLy x HJK\D{y�dcTL|�QVHJe]RfI­RSD{y�@V�4DM@UTL|ºDMH �/ ��QCd�DM@C[cHcN^R]@UyCF� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿��±u £�� � � tzs\prÁ/¾EÅEq À � � R]y(d�QCd�DM@C[cHcN{� y{KLQ x D x d�Dm@UdcQ x yM@CD � :�G �­��R]y�B©d�N{D{R]dce]eS��HcN^|L@CN{@U|±_QVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{R]HJT�BLN{@UyM@CN{[email protected] x @'HcN^|\@CNhR]T\[JyC_\dcTL|�Rf|\@UTzD{R]D{RS@Uy�d�N{@"I­d��\R]I­dceªF =»*@UQCdcKLyM@�}*@�d�N{@ºQVHJTLQV@CN^TL@U| x @CN{@�}®RSD x HcN^|L@CN{@U| QCd�DM@C[cHcN^RS@UyC_�d�yMHJI�@C} x d�D­|LR��9@CN{@UT�D,TLHcD{RSHJTÈHcbABEKEy x HJK\D,R]yd�BLBLN^HcBLN^R]d�DM@c_LdcTL|�b�HcN®D x R]y�T\HcD{RSHJT±_\D x @'KLTLR]Ë/K\@UT\@Uy{y�BEN{HcB9@CN{D��mR]y"��b�HcN{D{KLTLd�DM@UeS� �ß��eSHJy{DC×� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿��©u �jRSac@UT d � _��/3�× � � e3(�B0�D â G z �mR]T�d �/ ��QCd�DM@C[cHcN^� _�dÈQVHJT\@ � � G � / Hrac@CN�� � G � / R]ytJÅ=¿ nr½�nCp Á/¿=p R���D x @CN^@"@V�\R]yMD{yPyMHJI�@1,.× � ���Ýy{KLQ x D x d�D � � · � � � ,ºdcTL| � / · � / � ,L_9dcTL|�Rfy®d � � �^Æ��onrÇoÅ�� pR���[JRSac@UT�dcT��ºQVHJTLy{R]yMDM@UT�D.QVHJT\@�8k34×� e3�� � H ac@CN � � G � / _ED x @'yM@CD

� �'× � � � � � � ·�� � 8 � dcTL| � / ·�� � 8 /��x dcy.d�I­d��4RfI«KLIw@Ue]@UI�@UTzDCF =� q�ÅEÆ�Å©nr½gp ½�Å©¿±uYv®x @'QVHJI�B9HJy{RSD{RSHJT�HcbÌD¨}²H �/ �ªBEKLy x HJKLD{y�R]y�dce]yMH�d � / �ªBEKLy x HJKLDCF� q�űÅ&,^u ��@CD � � G � / �=@id � / �ªB©KLy x HJK\D®Hcb�� � G � / _=dcTL|�eS@CD�8 � G�8 / �=@«d � / �ªBEKEy x HJK\D.Hcb�� � G � � ·©}*@i}®R]e]e±y x Hr} D x d�D8 � � / ·�8 / Rfy�d � / �ªBEKLy x HJK\D�Hcb � � · � � G7� / F

��� �

���� �

� � � �������� �

������ � � � � � �

��

� �!��� � � � � � � " � � �

������� �" ���� � � � � � �

� �

#$

� ���� � � � � � � �� �

�������

O4K\BEB=HJy{@�, � G�, / DMHc[c@CD x @CNA}®RSD x � � · � � dcTL| � / bgHcN^I d�QVHJTLy{R]yMDM@UT�D.|LR]dcI­HJTL|±F v.x @UT � � ·�, � dcTL|�, / }®RSD x � � G � �dce]yMH¦bgHcNhI dÈQVHJTLy{R]y{DM@UTzD�|LR]dcI�HJTE|±_*dcTE|��9@UQCdcKLyM@ � � G � / R]y�d � / �ªBEKLy x HJK\D�b�HcN � � G � / _.D x @�y{@CD � � � � � ·*� �� � ·�, � G � / ·*�$� , /%� x dcy«d�I­d��\R]IiKLI @UeS@UI�@UT�DC_¹} x R]Q x }²@m|\@UT\HcDM@ �±Fºá®HcDM@mD x d�D�, � G��¦}®RSD x � � G � � bgHcNhI dQVHJTLy{RfyMDM@UTzD�|LR]dcI­HJTL|±F v.x @UT(�=@UQCdcKEyM@ 8 � G�8 / RfyZd � / �ªBEKLy x HJK\D�Hcb-� � G � � _4D x @PyM@CD � � �-8 � ·*� � , � G 8 / ·*� � � � x dcyd­I­d��\R]IiKLIw@UeS@UI�@UT�DC_L} x R]Q x }*@"|\@UT\HcDM@ �±F+��@iT\Hr} QCefdcR]IwD x d�D.D x @"bgHJe]e]Hr}®R]TL[iD¨}²H(yM@CD{y®d�N{@"@UË�KLdceª×

& � D � �$��8 � ·*� � , � dcTL|28 / ·*� � � � ·LdcTL|& / D � �$��8 � ·*� � , � dcTL| � / ·�8 / ·*� � , /�� '¶ÌRSN^yMD«eS@CD � � & � F v®x @UT � / ·r� 8 / ·*�4�&� � / ·��F� , / F v.x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@ � � & / F�G*HJTzac@CNhyM@UeS�c_¬y{K\BLB9HJyM@� � & / ·D x @UT�dce]e©}²@ x drac@PDMH,BLN^Hrac@�R]y²D x d�D 8 / ·*�>� �±F�»*@UQCdcKLy{@ � / ·r� 8 / ·*�4�7� , / dcTL| � � ·r� 8 / ·*�4��D � � � ·�8 � �h·*� � � � ·�, � _dcTL|��=@UQCdcKEyM@���R]y.D x @"I­d��\R]I«KEIÝ@UeS@UI�@UT�DAy^d�D{R]yMb��/R]TL[�D x @"R]T\@UË/KLdce]R]D{RS@Uy�d��9Hrac@c_9}²@«[c@CD 8 / ·*��� ��F v.x @CN{@Cb�HcN{@

& � D & / _L} x R]Q x R]I�BEefRS@Uy*D x @C� x dUac@"D x @'y{dcI�@"I­d��\R]IiKLIº_LTLdcI­@UeS� � F =�91 ,�O_H3476 G�:CH3698V>�H3F0836Q]7<W:=NE:�G=>�8 <ZHW83F7D9H3F78369<54�> ��6c\k6�6�OxD�>YG�G�6b@"X�PQO)6`>YO�@_>d4)>YGCgW[dDb>�H36�RYPY83:�6�<�]k\k69Db>YF7<W6 H34)69IE>�836`4)>YGCgjK5>bI_\k69H�K56�69OPY8V@0:�O�>�8WIsebXJPYO)6+@0:=NE69O)<W:�PQO)>YG�[�h5Db>H36�RQP�83:=69<`>YO)@_H3476`NEPY836`RY6�O)6M8V>YG X HJK�P ef@7:�NE6�O)<W:�PYO�>YGrhJ[aD�>�H36�RYPY83:�6�<�l

3kz

Page 33: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

*AHr}*@Cac@CNU_LKLTLe]R]Ø[email protected] x @jy{RSD{KLd�D{RSHJT(b�HcN²HcN^|ER]TLd�N{�,BEKLy x HJK\D{yC_�D x @PQVHJI­B=HJy^RSD{RSHJT­HcboQVHJTLy{R]yMDM@UT�D�|LR]dcI�HJTL|Ey�T\@C@U|�T\HcD�9@�QVHJTLy{R]y{DM@UTzDC_�dcTL| D¨}²HÈ|LR��9@CN{@UTzD �/ �ªB©KLy x HJK\D{y�TL@C@U|ÉT\HcD��9@�R]yMHJI�HcN^B x R]Q�·�D x R]y�I­@UdcTLy�D x d�D�dcI«�ERS[JKERSD���R]yTLd�D{K\Nhdce±R]T�D x R]y.y{@CDMD{R]T\[\F v.x @Pb�HJe]eSH }®R]T\[�R]y®dcT\HcD x @CN®QVHJI�B9HJy{R]D{RSHJTLdce]RSD¨��N{@Uy^KLeSD�bgHcN �/ �ªBEKLy x HJK\D{yC×� q�ÅEÆ�Å©nr½gp ½�Å©¿��±u ¯°TºD x @'|ER]d�[cN^dcIw�9@UeSHr}"_LRSb D x @�b�HJK\N.y{I�dce]e±y{Ë/KLd�N{@Uy.d�N{@ �/ �ªB©KLy x HJK\D{yU_/D x @UT�yMH­R]y�D x @'e]d�N{[c@HJK\D{y{Rf|\@'y{Ë/KLd�N{@cF

����� � �

��� � � � � � � �

� � � � �

� � � � � � � � ���� � � �

���� � � � � � � �

�� �� � � � � � � � �

� � �� �� � � � � � � � � �

� �

�� �� � � � � � � � �

� �

� q�űÅ&,^u £ABLBEeS�4R]T\[ !�N^HcB=HJy^RSD{RSHJT � D�}AR]QV@'[JRSac@Uy�D¨}²H � / �ªBEKLy x HJK\D{y�y x H }®Tº�9@UeSHr}"_�

����� �������� �

����� ��� !" " " " " " "

� � � �������� �

#�$ � � � !" " " " " " " # �� ��������

�% � � # � !" " " " " " " % �

� ��������

dcTL|�d�BEBEeS�4R]T\[ !�N{HcB9HJy{RSD{R]HJT � HJTLQV@"I�HcN{@"[[email protected]�D x d�D.D x @'�ER][,y^Ë�KLd�N^@'R]y.d �/ �ªBEKEy x HJK\DCF =!Ìdcy{y{RfT\[�b�N{HJI � � yiDMH�d�N{�ERSDMN^d�N^��|ER]d�[cN^dcI­y«Hcb.I�HcN{B x R]y{I­y�[c@UTL@CN^dce]RS�C@Uy �/ �ªBEKLy x HJK\D{y"DMH � � ��QVHJe]R]I�RSD{yC_¬dcTL|

BLN{H a/Rf|\@Uy"} x d�Diy{@C@UI­y�d�TEd�D{K\N^dce*}*dr�ÃDMH��EeS@UTE|ÃQVHJI�BEe]@V�¦R]T�DM@CN^QVHJTLT\@UQVD{RSHJTEy«HcbAI�@UdcTLR]T\[JyUF v.x @mT\HcD{R]HJT¦HcbQVHJTLy{RfyMDM@UTzDA|LR]dcI�HJTL|m@V�4DM@UTL|LyATLd�D{K\N^dce]e]�­DMH(d�N{�©RSDMN^d�N{�m|LR]d�[cN^dcI­yU_Ldcy�bgHJefeSHr}®yU×� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿��'&±u ��@CD � �9@�dÃ|LRfd�[cN^dcIºF v®x @UTÉd�b�dcI­R]eS� �)( 3 � 3�*,+ � + Hcb'I­HcN{B x R]y^I­y,R]y �"�^tJÅ©¿onr½�nCprÁ4¿=p R ��©· ( 6 � ( 3Ì} x @UTL@Cac@CNAD x @CN^@"R]y®d�I�HcN{B x Rfy{I ��×/0 � 4(RfT � F.O4R]I�R]e]d�N^eS�c_4[[email protected] � � � �ß_©}²@iy{dU��d�b�dcI­RfeS�(HcbI�HcN{B x R]y{I­y �)( 3 � 3/*10(R]y � ��QVHJTLy{R]yMDM@UT�D®R�� �)( 3 � 3�*20(@V�4DM@UTL|Ly.DMH�d � ��QVHJTLy{R]yMDM@UT�D.b�dcI­R]eS� �)( 3 � 3�*3+ � + F =4 sEtcp � �Eu £ |LR]dcI�HJTL| � � G � / G � � G � / R]y�QVHJTLy^R]yMDM@UT�D®RSbodcTE|ºHJTLeS��RSb � � � G � /�� R]y � � � G � /�� ��QVHJTLy{R]yMDM@UT�DCF� q�űÅ&,^u ¯¨b«D x @�|LR]dcI�HJTE|�R]y�QVHJTLy^R]yMDM@UT�DºD x @UT D x @CN{@�R]y�yMHJI�@�,�y{KLQ x D x d�D � � · � � � ,�dcTL| � / · � / � ,EF»�K\DPD x @UT � � � G � / G�, � R]y � � � G � /�� ��QVHJTLy{RfyMDM@UTzDC_�RªF�@cFS_ � � � G � /�� Rfy � � � G � /�� ��QVHJTLy^R]yMDM@UT�DCF'G�HJTzac@CN^y{@UeS�c_±RSb � � � G � /�� R]y� � � G � /�� ��QVHJTLy^R]yMDM@UT�DC_ D x @UT�yMHJI­@2,�@V�\R]yMD{y�y{KLQ x D x d�D � � � G � / G�, � R]y � � � G � /�� ��QVHJTEy{R]yMDM@UT�DC_ } x R]Q x y{dr�/y�@V�\dcQVD{eS�D x d�D � � · � � � ,�dcTE| � / · � / � ,E_ER¡F�@cFS_LD x d�D®D x @"|LR]dcI­HJTL|�R]y.QVHJTLy{RfyMDM@UTzDCF =� Á�ÛÌ¿¹½gp ½�Å©¿�� �9u ��@CD � �9@md�|LRfd�[cN^dcIºF v.x @UTÃd�b�dcI­RfeS� �)( 3 � 3�*3+ � + R]y«d �/ � tzÅ©Ú�½�¦½gp Hcb � R��ÉRSD«Rfy«d�QVHJT\@dcTL|�b�HcN"dcT�� � ��QVHJTLy{RfyMDM@UTzD�b�dcI­R]e]� �65 3 � 3�*3+ � + _ D x @­y{@CD � � � ( 3 ·�� � 5 3 G�bgHcNZ@UdcQ x 0�� � � � � x dcy'd �­�)�J�g� )4�@UeS@UI�@UT�DCF =

v.x @�bgHJe]e]Hr}®R]TL[,Rfy�dcT\HcD x @CN®D¨��B©R]QCdce±N{@Uy{KEeSD�D x d�D.@V�4DM@UTL|Ly�b�N{HJI¸HcN^|ER]TLd�N{�mQVHJe]R]I­RSD{y�DMH �/ ��QVHJe]R]I­RSD{yU×

3 3

Page 34: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

� Ç Á/ÅEq�Á/ � ��u ��@CD(d D ,¹½�sL¾©q sE QVHJTLy{RfyMD­HcbjD�}*H � � y�QVHJTET\@UQVDM@U|�d�D�D x @�I­R]|E|LeS@�DMHcB�F�¯¨b � R]y­d �|LR]d�[cNhdcIº_.D x @UT d �/ ��QVHJe]R]I­R]D�Hcb � Rfy(Hc�ED{dcR]T\@U|����ÉD{d�Ø4R]T\[�d �/ �ªBEKLy x HJK\D�Hcb«@UdcQ x.� _�dcTE|�D x @UT�D{d�Ø4R]T\[ dBEKLy x HJK\D�D x HJyM@'D¨}²H(BEKLy x HJK\D{yC_\dcy.y x H }®Tº�9@UeSH }'F� q�űÅ&,^u ��@CD � QVHJTzD{dcR]T¦D x @mI�HcN{B x Rfy{I­y � � G � / G � � G � � _¬eS@CD � � G � / �9@�d � / �ªBEKLy x HJK\D'Hcb7� � G � / _¬eS@CD � � G � � �9@d �/ �ªBEKEy x HJK\D�Hcb � � G � � _odcTE|�eS@CD�8 � G�8 / �9@�d � / �ªBEKLy x HJK\DjHcb � / � � F v®x @UT�}²@(I«KLy{D"y x H } D x d�D'D x @­b�dcI�R]eS��HcbI�HcN{B x R]y{I­y � � � ·�8 � G�� / · � / ·�8 � G � / ·�8 � G�� � · � � ·�8 / G � � ·�8 /�� R]y�d � / ��QVHJe]RfI­RSD�Hcb � F

�� � �

���� ��

� �

� ����� ����

���� � � �

��� � �� ����

����

�� ����� ����

! "

�� � � � �

��� � � �$#���� ����

#

% &

��(' � � �

��� � �

*)

+,

�- ���� � � � � � � -.�

� ��������

/10

�- #��� � � � � � � - '

� ��������

2'

3 4

�65�7 � , � G�, / G�, � G�, � G�, ���98 5;: � �=<?>[email protected]@H7JI�:LKMDFNPOLQSRUTV5G@2, � :L@VW", �YX DP7ET � � G � / I(>LZ[K\:]<?>[email protected]@H7^WCDF:LK_>A@VW` 8 5G<�:LaVB.5 � � ·�, � � , / :L@VW � / ·�, � � , /cb[d :L@VW 8 5G<�:LaCB.5 � � G � / DeBf: � / �hgCaVBiTj>Aaj7 d X 5;Wj5GWVaV<?5Y7ETC:k7f7ETj5�ZE5U5?ljDFB.7EB � �` :LB97ETj5mKM:nljDFK]aVKo>LIf:MB.5�79>LISK_>LZEgCTVDeBEKMB b BEaV<[Tp7ETV:k7 � � ·�� � �F, � :L@VW � / ·�� � �F, � QUqrDFKMDFNe:kZiNPOM7ETj5�Zi5s5?lrDeB.7EB� / BEaV<[Tt7ETC:k7 � � ·�� / � , � :L@CW � � ·�� / � , � Q�á;> X @V>L7.5]7ETC:k7 � � G�� / X DP7ET � / G � �mu DPvL5_:w<?>[email protected]@H7xWCDF:LK_>A@VW` 8 5G<�:LaVB.5s7ETV5�ZE5sDFB7, � BEaV<iTp7ETV:k7 � / ·�� � � , � :L@VW � � ·�� / � , � b Q+�y5z@V5?l{7U<�NF:LDeK|7ETV:k7U7ETj5sI$>ANFNP> X DF@ u 7 X >}B.5�7EB:kZE5s5UË{aV:LN¡×

& � D � ����8 � ·�� � � � :L@VW28 / ·�� � � /�� ·C:L@CW& / D � ��� ` � � ·�8 � b ·�� � , � :L@VW ` � / ·�8 � b ·�� � , � :L@VW ` � � ·�8 /cb ·�� � , � � '` RUTj5z<?>LZEZE5GB.g~>A@VWVDe@ u DF@j5UË{aV:LNFDP7EDP5GB�I$>LZ , / :L@VW�, � :kZE5z>AKMDP7.7.5GWpI$ZE>AK & /�8 5G<�:LaVBE5s7ETj5�Op:kZE5mDeK_gCNFDF<�DF7 b QZ¶�DPZiB.7

X 5mBETj> X & � � & / Q¬¯�I � � & � 7ETj5G@� ` � � ·�8 � b ·��>D � � · ` 8 � ·�� b � � � ·�� � � , � Q� ` � / ·�8 � b ·��>D � / · ` 8 � ·�� b � � / ·�� � � , � Q� ` � � ·�8 / b ·��>D � � · ` 8 / ·�� b � � � ·�� / � , � QRUTVDeBJDFK_g�NFDP5GB ��� & / QJ��>A@�vL5�Z[B.5GNPO d DPI � � & / 7ETj5G@ � � · ` 8 � ·�� b � � � ·�� � � , � :L@VW � / · ` 8 � ·�� b � � / ·�� � � , � QRUTj5G@ 8 O�KM:nlrDeKM:LNFDP7�O�>LI � � d X 5 u 5�718 � ·�� � � � Q�¯*@�:�BEDFKMDeNF:kZ X :GO d X 5}<�:L@�BETV> X 8 / ·�� � � /kd :L@VW�7ET{aVB��� & � Q^RUTj5�ZE5�I$>LZE5 & � D & /nd X TVDF<[T�DFK_gCNeDP5GB�7ETV:k7U7ETj5GB.5sBE5�7EB;TV:cvL5m7ETj5sBE:LKM5mKM:nljDFKzaCK|5GNP5GK_5G@H7�Q =�fl{7.5G@VWCDF@ u >AajZ9gCaVBETV>Aaj7;@j>L7E:k7EDP>A@ ��� 7.> �/ �=<�:k7.5 u >LZiDF5GB d 7ETj5z: 8 >�vL5zZE5GBiaVNP7;<�:L@ 8 5sZi:k7ETj5�Zx@j5G:k7ENPO X ZiDP7.7.5G@DF@�7ETj5mI(>LZiK` � � ��� � / b ��� ` � � ��� � � b D��S�k���$� ` A b�d

X Tj5�Zi5IA DFBU7ETj5 8 >L7.7.>AK�gC:kZE7;>LI�7ETV5zWVDF: u Z[:LK d X DP7ETp5GW u 5GB9Ne: 8 5GNF5GW � � G � / G � � G � � Q�� u 5G@V5�Zi:LNFDP�G:k7EDP>A@t>LIS7ETj5: 8 >cvL5xZE5GBEaCNP7^DFKMgCNFDP5GBS7ETC:k7 � / �hg�aVBETj>Aaj7EB^<�:L@ 8 5�aVB.5GW}7.>�<?>AK_gCaj7.5�7ETj5 �/ �=<?>ANFDFKMDF7f>LI�:L@HOw<?>A@V@j5G<?7.5GW�WVDe: u Zi:LK�Q´ 8 BE5�ZEvL5s7ETV:k797ETj5m@j>L7EDP>A@t>LIS:LarlrDeNFDF:kZEO}K_>LZEgCTVDeBEKo<�:kZEZiDP5GBU>cvL5�Zx7.>�7ETj5mI(Zi:LKM5 X >LZ{Ø�>LI �/ �=<�:k7.5 u >LZiDF5GB X DP7ETj>Aaj7:L@HO�<[TV:L@ u 5LQ¯27JDFBf@C:k7EajZi:LNr7.>zaCB.5Y7ETj5;<?>A@VWCDP7EDP>A@VB�7ETV:k7^K_>LZEgCTVDeBEKMB�BETj>AaVNeW 8 5U:LB^Wj5CÄC@j5GW_:LBJg~>ABEBED 8 NF5 d BiTj>AaVNFW�gVZi5GB.5�ZEvL5:LB�KM:L@HO�:nljDP>AKMB�:LBxg~>ABEBED 8 NP5 d :L@CWyBETj>AaVNFW 8 5]:LB�De@V<�NFaVBEDFvL5z:LBxg~>ABEBED 8 NP5 d 7.>pWj5CÄ�@j5]:�Ë{aV:LNFDP7�Op>LZiWj5�Z[DF@ u ` B.5�5��5CÄC@VDP7EDF>A@ 3 b Qw�t>LZE5�gVZE5G<�DFBE5GNPO d u DPvL5G@ K_>LZEgCTVDeBEKMB �G*�A×!: �(� 8 5�7 X 5�5G@y<?>A@V<?5�gV7EaV:LN�B.g�:L<?5GB5:�G � d NP5�7�aVBWj5CÄC@V50� � �}D�� ��gVZi5GB.5�ZEvL5GBY:LBYK]aV<iT�<?>[email protected]@�79:LB � d gVZE5GB.5�ZEvL5GBY:LNeN¡:nljDP>AKMB�7ETC:k7 ��Wj>{5GB d :L@VW�DFB�:LBYDF@C<�NFaVBEDPvL5:LB ��Qs��NP7ETj>Aa u T�K_>LZE5 X >LZ{Ø�BETV>AaVNFW 8 5�Wj>A@j5]7.>�Wj5�7.5�ZiKMDe@j5 X Tj5�7ETj5�Zx7ETVDFB�gC:kZE7EDe<�aVNF:kZ �.Wj5GBED u @j5�Zx>LZiWV5�ZiDF@ u �ZE5G:LNFNFO X >LZ{Ø{BU7ETj5 8 5GB.7�I(>LZU7ETCDFB�gC:kZE7EDF<�aCNF:kZY:kgVgCNFDF<�:k7EDF>A@ d 7ETV5mBEDP7EaV:k7EDF>A@ X DP7ET�ZE5GB.g~5G<?7Y7.>_>AajZ;TV>AaVB.5�:L@VW 8 >A:k75?lj:LK_gCNP5�I(Zi>AK¢q{5G<?7EDF>A@ �9ZE5G:LNeNPO�DFBÌËHaVDF7.5^BE:k7EDFBEI(OrDF@ u d DF@z7ETV:k7�7ETj5�KM>AB.7�@C:k7EajZi:LN 8 NP5G@VWzDFB�:L@z>LZ[WVDF@V:kZEOxgCaCBETj>Aaj7 d3 %

Page 35: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

:LNFN 7ETj5]>L7ETj5�Z u >H>rW 8 NP5G@VWCB;:kZE5 �/ �hgCaVBiTj>Aaj7EB d :L@VW�vn:kZiDF>AaVB 8 NP5G@VWVB;7ETV:k7xI$:LDFN 7.>�gVZE5GB.5�ZivL5]:LBxK]aV<iT B.7.ZiaC<?7EajZE5:LBU7ETV5�O}<?>AaVNeWp:kZE5s@j>L7;:L@HO�Ø{De@VW}>LI�g�aVBETj>Aaj7�Q

� �"Ò�� � ��Ö��^Ò!�=Ò ����Ö{Õ ���Î<��=Ô1E�RUTj5mZE5GB.5G:kZi<[TtgVZi> u Zi:LK�>LI X TVDe<iT�7ETVDeBYgC:kg~5�Z;DFB;gC:kZE7 d DFBUgVZiDFKM:kZ[DFNPO�<?>A@V<?5�Z[@j5GW X DP7ET�gVZi:L<?7EDe<�:LN6:kgVgCNFDe<�:k7EDP>A@VB d:L@VW_7ETV5 u >A:LNC>LI~7ETVDeBSgC:kg~5�ZfDFBS7.>zgVZE>cvrDFWj5UBE>AK_5U>LI~7ETj5U7ETj5�>LZiO]7ETC:k7^DFBf@V5�5GWj5GW_7.>zBiajgVg~>LZE7SBEaV<[TM:kgVgCNFDe<�:k7EDP>A@VB�Q»�O�<?>[email protected]:LB.7 d K_>ABE7 X >LZ{Ø [email protected]�DP>L7EDF<�BsTV:LBmTV:LWy:pK]aV<iT�KM>LZE5MgCTVDeNP>AB.>LgCTVDe<�:LN6I$>{<�aVBGQM�9Bs:pZE5GBEaVNP7 d : u ZE5G:k7Wj5G:LNS>LI�gCTCDFNP>AB.>LgCTCDF<�:LN WCDFBE<�aVBEBiDP>A@ <?>AaVNFW 8 5 u 5G@j5�Zi:k7.5GW <?>A@V<?5�Zi@CDF@ u 7ETj5�TV5�ZE5�7EDF<�:LNf:kgVgCZE>A:L<iT >LI�7ETCDFB�gC:kg~5�ZGQRUTVDeBY:kgVg~5G@VWVD lw<?>A@LÄ[email protected] 7.>jÞEaVB.7U:�I$5 X g~>ADF@H7EBY7ETV:k7;BE5�5GKo7.>wTV:cvL5mB.>AK_5mgVZi:L<?7EDF<�:LN6BiD u @VDSÄC<�:L@C<?5LQR >{WC:GOwT{aVKM:[email protected]�>LI @j5G:kZ[NPOM:LNFN~BE<iTV>H>ANFB�Zi5 Þ*5G<?7�7ETj5�@j>L7EDP>A@�7ETC:k7�BE>AK_5jØ{DF@CW�>LIx�i��:kZE7.5GBEDF:L@�<?>{>LZiWVDe@V:k7.5GB�<�:L@ 8 5�DFK_g~>AB.5GW >A@ 5?lrg¡5�Z[DP5G@V<?5 d Wj5GB.g�DP7.5pgC:kZE7EDe:LNU5�vrDFWj5G@V<?5�7.>�7ETj5�<?>A@�7.Z[:kZEO I$ZE>AK ÄC5GNFWVB�NeDSØL5tNFDF@ u aVDFB.7EDF<�B:L@VW�KzaCBEDF<kQxRUTVDFB;ZE5 Þ*5G<?7EDF>A@�DeB9aV@CWj5�ZiB.7E:L@VWC: 8 NP5s:LBx:}ZE5G:L<?7EDP>A@�7.>w7ETV5]BE<�DF5G@�7EDFBE7EDF<mZi5GWVaV<?7EDP>A@VDeBEKo7ETV:k7�@j5G:kZiNFO:LN X :GOrBY:L<�<?>AK_gC:L@VDF5GB�gVZE>�Þ.5G<?7EB^7.>MDeK_g~>AB.59B.7.Z[aV<?7EajZE5�>A@}5?l{g~5�ZiDP5G@C<?5LQfqjaV<iT}7.5G@VWj5G@C<�DP5GB�:kZE5�Wj5�5�gCNPOMDF@ u Zi:LDF@j5GWDF@ �y5GB.7.5�Zi@t<�DPv{DeNFDP�G:k7EDP>A@ d u >ADF@ u 8 :L<^Ø}:k7UNP5G:LBE7�7.> !JOH7ETC: u >LZi:LBU:L@VW !^NF:k7.>jQ�»�aj7Y5�v{DeWj5G@V<?5xI(Zi>AK : X DFWj5�Zi:L@ u 5>LI�ÄV5GNFWVBx@j> X KM:�ØL5GBzDP7s<�NP5G:kZz7ETV:k7s7.Zi:LWVDF7EDP>A@V:LN�ZE5GWVaV<?7EDF>A@VDFBEK TV:LBmB.5�ZiDP>AaVB�NeDFKMDP7E:k7EDP>A@CB�Q_RUTj5_I$>ANFNP> X DF@ u :kZE58 ZiDF5�I Wj5GBE<?Z[DPgV7EDP>A@VB�>LISB.>AK_5 8 5�7.7.5�ZAØ{@j> X @�5?lj:LK_gCNP5GBU×

â Q��y>LZ^Øy>A@�K_5G<iTC:L@VDF<�:LNfB.g~5�5G<[T�ZE5G<?> u @VDF7EDP>A@�TV:LBsBiTj> X @�7ETV:k7m<?>[email protected]?l{7EaV:LN�DF@jI$>LZiKM:k7EDF>A@�DeB�5GBEB.5G@H7EDF:LNSI$>LZWV5�7.5�ZiKMDF@VDe@ u X TV:k7SgCTj>A@j5GKM5�BE>AK_5YZi: X :L<?>AaVB.7EDF< X :GvL5�I$>LZiK ZE5�gVZE5GB.5G@H7EB ` DPI¡:L@�O{7ETVDF@ u b ·H7ETVDFBS<?>[email protected]?l{7EaC:LNDe@jI(>LZ[KM:k7EDP>A@ KM:GO�DF@V<�NFaCWj5z@j>L7²ÞEaVB.7xgVZiDF>LZ 8 aV7�:LNFBE>�Bia 8 B.5UË{aj5G@H7�B.g~5�5G<[T d :}gVZE>cÄCNF5zI$>LZx7ETj5MDF@VWVDFv{DFWCaV:LNBEg¡5G:�ØL5�Z ` :L<�<?5G@H7 d 5G<�<?5G@�7.Z[DF<�DP7EDP5GB d 5�7E<kQ b[d 7ETj5p7.>LgCDF<p>LIsWVDFBE<?>AajZ[B.5 d :L@CW KzaC<iT K_>LZE5 d ajg 7.> :kZ 8 DP7.Zi:kZiOBiTV:kZE5GWp<�aVNF7EajZi:LN9Ør@j> X NF5GW u 5LQz Q.¯*@�K]aVBEDF< d 7ETj5�BE:LKM5�:L<?>AaVB.7EDF<M5�vL5G@�7]DF@y:tWVD �¡5�ZE5G@H7s<?>[email protected]?l{7]<�:L@ TV:cvL5w:�Zi:LWCDF<�:LNFNPO�WVD��~5�ZE5G@�7sDeK_gC:L<?7 dZ[:L@ u DF@ u I$ZE>AK a u NPO :L@VW DF@C<?>A@ u Ziaj>AaVB d 7.> u ZE5G:k7 8 5G:Laj7=Oy:L@VW 5GNP5 u :L@V<?5LQ �t>LZE5�>cvL5�Z d 7ETj5 8 :L<^Ø u ZE>AaC@VW>LI�7ETj5�NeDFB.7.5G@j5�ZpDFB�<?Z[aV<�DF:LN¡·zI(>LZp5?lj:LK_gCNF5 d @C:LDPvL5�NFDFB.7.5G@V5�ZiB�TV:GvL5 NFDP7.7ENP5y<iTC:L@V<?5�>LI�:kgVgVZE5G<�DF:k7EDe@ u 7ETj5Bia 8 7ENP5�7EDP5GBm:L@VW 8 5G:Laj7EDP5GBm>LI;��5G<�DFNfR�:GOrNP>LZ]>LZ,´�Zi@V5�7.7.5���>ANP5GK�:L@ d TV> X 5�vL5�ZzI�:LKMDFNFDe:kZ X DP7ETy7ETV5�>LZiDP5GBs>LIg�B.O{<[Tj>��=:L<?>AaVB.7EDe<�B9:L@VW�TC:kZiK_>A@HOw7ETj5�O�KMD u T�7 8 5LQ

3 Q�qjDFKMDFNF:kZ�7ETVDF@ u B�TC:kgVg~5G@}De@}<�De@j5GKM:�:L@VW�g~>H5�7.ZiO d :L@VW�DF@VWj5�5GW�:L@HO}:kZi7�>LZ9<?Zi:kI(7 d I$ZE>AKo:kZi<[TVDP7.5G<?7EajZi5m:L@VWDe@�7.5�ZiDF>LZ;Wj5GBED u @ d 7.> 8 :LBMØL5�7 X 5G:cv{De@ u d g~>L7.7.5�ZEO d :L@VW �V> X 5�Z�:kZEZi:L@ u DF@ u Q�´�I$7.5G@t: u Zi5G:k79Wj5G:LN�>LI�<�aCNP7EajZi:LN<?>[email protected]?lr7mDFBx@j5�5GWj5GW 7.>p:kgVgCZE5G<�DF:k7.5 ` DF@ :L@�O Wj5�5�g�[email protected] b :}BiDF@ u NP5�:kZE7EDPI�:L<?7C· 8 aCDFNFWVDF@ u B d ZE>{>AKMB d 8 :LB{ØL5�7EB:L@CWMg~>L7EBJ:kZE5�aVB.5GW 8 O�>LZiWVDe@V:kZEO]g¡5�>Lg�NP5UDF@M7ETV5GDPZf>LZiWVDe@V:kZEO�NFDPvL5GB d :LBfgC:kZE7^>LI~7ETj59<?>AK_g�NP5?lMB.>{<�De:LNVI�: 8 ZiDF<kQR;Tj5.� �xaV<�<�Df��NF: 8 5GN�>A@y:}gCajZiBE5�DeB�@V>L7xNF>cvL5GNPO DF@ DP7EB.5GNPI d~8 aj7�@j>A@j5�7ETV5GNP5GBEBxDP7�TV:LB�:�K_5G:L@VDe@ u 7.>�7ETV>AB.5X Tj> u >�>Aaj7x>LIf7ETV5GDPZ X :GO�7.>�:L<CËHaCDPZE5zDF7�Qx� 8 ZiD u TH7ENPO�<?>ANP>LZE5GW�g~>AB.7EK_>rWj5�Zi@ 8 :L@\Ø 8 aVDFNFWCDF@ u DF@ ��DFB 8 >A@TC:LBU:M<?>AK_gCNF5?l�<�aVNF7EajZi:LN K_5G:L@VDe@ u 7ETV:k7;Wj>{5GB;@j>L7Y7.Z[:[email protected]$5�ZU7.> !�:kZiDFB d ��>A@VWj>A@ d >LZAá;5 X �f>LZ{Ø�Q

%jQ;��5GB.g�DP7.5p7ETj5�B.7EaV@V@VDe@ u BiaV<�<?5GBEBw>LIx:kgCgCNPOrDF@ u BEDFK_g�NP5�:k7.>AKMDF<�7ETj5�>LZiO 7.> 8 :LBEDF<tK_>ANP5G<�aVNF:kZw<iTj5GKMDeB.7.ZEO dg�T�OrBEDF<�B�TV:LB�I$>AaV@VW�DP7Y@j5G<?5GBEBi:kZEOw7.>_g~>AB.7EaCNF:k7.5�@j>A@VNP>r<�:LNFDP��5GWmËHaC:L@�7EaVKwÄC5GNFWVB�7.>_5?l{g�NF:LDF@}KM:L@�O�DFK_g~>LZb�7E:L@H7SgCTj5G@V>AK_5G@V: d B.>AK_5Y>LI X TVDF<[Tz:kgCg¡5G:kZS5�vL5G@_De@]:kgCgCNFDP5GW]<iTj5GK�DFB.7.ZEO d 7.>sBE:cOz@j>L7ETCDF@ u >LI�K_>LZE5YZ[:kZE5CÄV5GW:kZi5G:LB�Q

�{Q��t5�7E:LKM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�BMTV:LB]TV:LW u ZE5G:k7_BEaV<�<?5GBEB�DF@ I(>LZiK�:LNFDP�GDF@ u KM:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�B d :L@VW�De@ B.7EaVWVO{DF@ u X TV:k7�DFBgCZE>cvk: 8 NP5LQ¬»�aj7^DF7EB u ZE5G:k7.5GB.7�BEaV<�<?5GBiB.5GB^TC:GvL5 8 5�5G@�ZE5GBEaVNF7EB d NFDSØL5 ���>AWj5GN � B�DF@V<?>AK_g�NP5�7.5G@j5GBEBS7ETV5�>LZE5GK d 7ETV:k7WV5GK_>[email protected]:k7.5^7ETj5;� �$�]��������� ����>LIjI(>LZ[KM:LNFDP�G:k7EDP>A@6Qc�p>LZi5�>cvL5�Z d I$>LZiKM:LN�gVZE>{>LI$B NF:L<{Ø�7ETV5^<?>AK_gVZi5GTj5G@VBED 8 DFNFDP7�O d:L@CWM7ETj5�THaVK�:L@�[email protected]�ZE5GB.7 d >LI X 5GNeNCWj>A@j5�DF@jI$>LZiKM:LNrgVZi>H>LI�B�QJq{5�59�9gVg~5G@VWVDPl]� I$>LZ�KM>LZE59WVDeBE<�aVBEBEDF>A@_:LNP>A@ u7ETV5GB.5mNFDF@V5GB d Wj5GK_>[email protected][:k7EDF@ u 7ETj5sDFKMg¡>LZi7E:L@V<?5�>LI�<?>[email protected]?lr79I$>LZ;KM:�ØrDF@ u gVZE>{>LI�B �.<?>AK_5z:LNeDPvL5LQ��ÙU5�7EaVZi@VDF@ u @V> X 7.>9>AajZ K�:LDF@�g~>ADF@H7 d 7ETj5�Zi5JDFB�:ÌÞ.aVBE7EDSÄC: 8 NP5�>LgVg~>ABEDF7EDP>A@�7.>;7.>L7E:LNeDP�GDF@ u Zi5GWVaV<?7EDP>[email protected]<?7EaVZi:LNFDFB.7B.OrB.7.5GKMB d X TCDFNP59:k7�7ETj5�BE:LKM5�7EDeK_5 d 7ETj5�ZE5xDFB�7ETj5�aj7.7.5�ZiNPOMg~5�ZEvk:LBEDPvL59gVZE5GB.5G@C<?5�>LI�B.7.ZiaV<?7EaVZE5GWwBiD u @VB�Q`� TV:k7U:kZE5X 5s7.>�Wj>M: 8 >Aaj7Y7ETVDeBUB.5�5GKMDF@ u NPOw<?>[email protected]:LWVDF<?7.>LZiO�BiDP7EaV:k7EDP>A@ �R X >M:LNP7.5�Zi@C:k7EDPvL5GBYTV:GvL5 8 5�5G@�K_>ABE7Y5?l{gCNF>LZE5GW d 5G:L<iT X DP7ET�B.>AK_5�vk:LNFaV: 8 NP5�ZE5GBEaCNP7EB�QSRUTj5jÄVZiBE7�DFB�7.>_g�ajZiBEaj57ETj5PËHaj5GBE7^I$>LZ�BE7.ZiaV<?7EajZE5 d WVD uLu De@ u Wj5�5�g~5�Z X Tj5�ZE5�vL5�ZYDP7JB.5�5GK�B^7.> X >LZ{Ø d :L@VW}:GvL>ADFWCDF@ u 7ETV5 ` vL5�ZEO�K�:L@�O b :kZi5G:LBX Tj5�Zi5p7ETVDF@ u BAÞEaVB.7wB.5�5GK 7.>{>�BENeDPgVg~5�ZEO�7.> :LWVKMDP7MK]aV<iT gVZE5G<�DFBiDP>A@ Q RUTCDFB_DF@j5�vrDP7E: 8 NPO�ZE5GBEaVNF7EBMDF@ :yg�:kZE7EDF:LN

3 �

Page 36: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

vrDP5 X d X TVDF<iTwDFB^>Lg¡5G@�7.>]<?Z[DP7EDF<�DFBEK DF@Mvk:kZiDP>AaCB X :GOrB ` :LB�g~>AB.7��=B.7.Z[aV<?7EajZi:LNFDeBEK TV:LB�<?ZiDP7EDF<�DF��5GWM7ETj5�B.7.ZiaV<?7EajZ[:LNFDFBEK>LI9qr:LaVBiBEajZE5 d �65�vrD��2q{7.Zi:LaVBiB d »�:kZE7ETj5GB d 5�7E<kQ b QtRUTj5�BE5G<?>A@VW�:LNF7.5�Zi@V:k7EDPvL5}DFBs7.>�: 8 :L@VWj>A@�B.7.ZiaV<?7EajZi5w:L@VW X >LZ{ØX DP7ET�DF@H7EaVDP7EDPvL5�5?lrg~5�ZiDP5G@V<?5GB9:L@VW�WV5GBE<?ZiDPgV7EDF>A@VB ` B.>AK_5]<�ajZEZE5G@H7ENPO�I�:LBETVDP>A@V: 8 NP5 X >LZiWVB;:kZi5 �*ZiDF<[T d �$�.@HaV:L@C<?5GW d ��*7.5?lr7EajZE5GW d ��:L@VW �*g~>AB.7EK_>rWj5�Zi@�� b Q�RUTVDFB�7.>{>pDF@j5�vrDP7E: 8 NPO�Zi5GBEaVNP7EB�DF@ :�gC:kZi7EDF:LN�v{DF5 X d X TVDF<[T DF@�7ETj5_5?l{7.Zi5GK_5:GvL>ADeWVBm<?ZiDF7EDF<�DFBEK 8 O�Zi5�I$aVBiDF@ u 7.> 8 5_gCDF@V@V5GW�WV> X @ d 5�vL5G@ 7.>p7ETV5_5?l{7.5G@H7m>LIYaVBEDe@ u DF@V<?>[email protected]@�7 d DF@V<?>ATj5�ZE5G@H7NF:L@ u aC: u 5LQJRUTjZE>Aa u T 8 >L7ET�:kZE5x5?lr7.ZE5GK_5�g~>ABEDP7EDP>A@CB d DP7YB.5�5GK�BYWVDSà�<�aVNF7J7.>�ÄC@VW}:_<�NP5G:kZ d <?>[email protected]@H7 d Wj5�I(5G@CBED 8 NP5KMDFWCWVNP5 u ZE>AaV@VW Q ` � u 5G@j5�Z[:LN ZE5�I$5�ZE5G@V<?5sI$>LZ;<?>A@H7EDF@j5G@H7E:LN6gCTVDeNP>AB.>LgCTHO�DFB # %k%k(hQ b¯27YB.5�5GKMB�7.>_K_5x7ETV:k7�5�7ETV@j>AK_5�7ETV>{Wj>ANF> u O�gVZE>�v{DeWj5GB�B.>AK_5xvn:LNeaV: 8 NP5�TVDF@H7EB^>A@�: X :GOw>Aaj7�>LI�7ETVDFB�DFKMgC:LBEB.5LQ´�I$7.5G@�[email protected] :LBM: gCZiDF@V<�DPg�NP5GW <?ZiDF7EDF<�DFBEK >LI97.Z[:LWVDP7EDP>A@V:LN�B.>r<�DP>ANP> u O d 5GB.g~5G<�DF:LNFNFO DP7EB_@j>LZiK�:k7EDPvL5p<�:k7.5 u >LZEOBE<[Tj5GK_5GB ` u 5G@VWj5�Z d Zi:L<?5 d BE7E:k7EaVB d 5�7E<kQ b[d 5�7ETV@j>AKM5�7ETj>{WV>ANP> u O <�:L@�g¡5�Z[TV:kgCB 8 5�7.7.5�Z 8 5wB.5�5G@�g~>ABEDP7EDPvL5GNPOy:LB]:L@:kgVgVZi>A:L<iT�7.>}aC@VWj5�ZiB.7E:L@CWVDF@ u B.>r<�DF:LN gCTj5G@j>AK_5G@C: ` BEaV<[T�:LB�BED u @CB � b�8 OpB.5�5GDF@ u Tj> X K_5GK 8 5�ZiBU>LI^B.>AK_5 u Zi>Aajg<?>AK_5s7.>MBE5�5�7ETj>AB.5mBED u @}:LBUgVZE5GB.5G@H7�QJRUT{aVB d 5�7ETV@j>AKM5�7ETj>{WV>ANP> u O X :L@H7EBY7.>�Ø{@V> X X TC:k7U<�:k7.5 u >LZiDP5GBU7ETV5sK_5GK �8 5�ZiB]>LI9: B.>r<�DF:LN u ZE>Aajg aVBE5 d :L@VW X TV:k7_K_5�7ETV>{WVB]7ETj5�O aVB.5�7.>�Wj5�7.5�ZiK�DF@j5�[email protected]:L@V<?5GB]>LI�7ETj>AB.5�<�:k7.5 u >LZiDP5GBGQRUTVDeBfZE5UË{aVDPZE5GBJ<�:kZE5�I$aCN�:k7.7.5G@H7EDP>A@�7.>]ZE5G:LN�BE>{<�DF:LN�[email protected]�Zi:L<?7EDP>A@ d :L@VW}:GvL>ADFWVB�7ETj5x!JNF:k7.>[email protected]^:LBiBEaVK_gV7EDF>A@M7ETV:k7�7ETj5<�:k7.5 u >LZiDP5GB�TV:cvL5}:tgVZE5�� u DPvL5G@ 5?lrDeB.7.5G@V<?5 �.De@ @V:k7EajZi5LQ�� Ù9:k7ETj5�Z d X 5wB.5�5}Tj> X K_5GK 8 5�ZiBm>LIU: u ZE>AaVg�:L<iTCDP5�vL5<�:k7.5 u >LZiDP�G:k7EDF>A@�DF@�:L<?7EaC:LN6gVZi:L<?7EDe<?5 d X DP7ETj>AaV7UTV:GvrDF@ u 7.> u DFvL5s7ETj5GB.5s5GDF7ETj5�ZU7ETj5s<�:k7.5 u >LZiDF5GB;>LZ97ETj5GDPZUDF@VBE7E:L@V<?5GB:L@HO�B.7E:k7EaVBs>L7ETj5�Z�7ETV:L@ X TV:k7�TV:LB 8 5�5G@ :L<iTVDF5�vL5GW�DF@�:�gC:kZE7EDF<�aVNe:kZ X :GO :k7�:�gC:kZE7EDF<�aVNe:kZ97EDFKM5LQmRUTj5 8 Zi:L@C<iT>LIY5�7ETV@j>AKM5�7ETj>{WV>ANP> u O�<�:LNFNP5GW��[��

����� ����� �� ��� �k��� � �TV:LBs7E:�ØL5G@�:tZi:k7ETj5�ZmZ[:LWVDF<�:LNJ:kgCgVZE>A:L<iT�7.>t7ETV5wB.>r<�DF:LN<?>[email protected]?l{7s>LI�NF:L@ u aC: u 5 d BETj> X DF@ u 7ETV:k7�5�vL5G@�BEDeK_gCNP5zI(5G:k7EajZi5GBsBEaV<[Ty:LB X Tj>AB.5�7EajZi@yDF7�DFBx7.>pBEg¡5G:�Ø�:kZE5_:LN X :GOrB@j5 u >L7EDF:k7.5GW�De@�ZE5G:LN¡7EDFKM5 8 O�:L<?7EaV:LN B.>r<�DF:LN u ZE>AajgCB #�� z d � 3 ( d :L@VW�BETj>AaCNFW�@j>L7 8 59<?>A@CBEDFWj5�ZE5GW}:LB u DPvL5G@ QA�y>LZ[WVBNFDSØL5 �*ZE5GDSÄ�<�:k7EDP>A@�� :L@VW �*7.Zi:L@VBE<?5G@CWj5G@�7E:LNeDP�GDF@ u � :kZE5�aVB.5GW 7.>�Wj5GBi<?ZiD 8 5w:kgVgCZE>A:L<iTj5GBM7ETV:k7�7E:�ØL5p7ETj5�>LgVg~>ABEDP7.5vrDP5 X Q ` ´�If<?>AajZiBE5 d :L@HOp>A@j5mg�:kZi: u Zi:kgCT�Wj5GBE<?ZiDPgC7EDP>A@�>LIS5�7ETV@j>AKM5�7ETj>{WV>ANP> u OpDFB;@V5G<?5GBEBE:kZiDFNFO}: u ZE>ABEB9>cvL5�ZiBEDeK �gCNFD]ÄC<�:k7EDP>A@±·VK_>LZi5mDF@jI$>LZiKM:k7EDP>A@tKM:GO 8 5sI$>AaV@VWpDe@ #�� � ( :L@VW$# z4â (�:LKM>A@ u KM:L@HO�>L7ETj5�Z;g�NF:L<?5GB d BE>AK_5m>LI X TVDe<iTKM:cO 8 5�vL5�ZEO�WVDSàw<�aVNP7�7.>MZE5G:LW Q b��NP7ETj>Aa u T�7ETCDFB�gC:kg~5�Z_DFB_@j>L7_7ETj5�gCNe:L<?5�7.>�WVDFBE<�aVBiB]DF7 d gCTj5G@V>AK_5G@j>ANP> u O TV:LB_:LNFB.> 8 5�5G@ :L@ DFKMg¡>LZi7E:L@�7DF@ ��aj5G@V<?5�>A@�>AajZ9I$>LZiK]aVNF:k7EDP>A@p>LIf:�gCTCDFNP>AB.>LgCTCDF<�:LN¡I(>AaV@CWV:k7EDP>A@pI$>LZxB.5GKMDP>L7EDF<�B d gC:kZE7EDe<�aVNF:kZiNPO}DF@tDF7EB;[email protected]@V<?57ETV:k7�7ETj5;>A@CNPO�g¡>ABiBED 8 NP5YB.7E:kZi7EDF@ u g~>ADF@H7JDFBJ7ETj5 u Zi>AaV@VWM>LI >AaVZJ> X @w:L<?7EaV:LN¡5?lrg~5�ZiDP5G@V<?5 d X DP7ET�:LNeNVK_5�7E:kgCTHO{BiDF<�:LNgVZiDe@V<�DPgCNP5GB²ÄVZiK�NPO 8 Zi:L<^ØL5�7.5GW QRUTV5�BED u @ d > 8 Þ*5G<?7 d [email protected]�ZEgVZi5�7E:L@�7s7.Z[DF:LWy>LIY<�NF:LBEBEDe<�:LNfB.5GKMDP>L7EDe<�B ` !�5GDPZi<?5 d �p>LZiZiDFB d �J<?> d 5�7E<kQ b gVZi5GBEajgVg~>AB.5GB:L@ > 8 Þ*5G<?7EDPvL5 X >LZ[NFW d X Tj5�ZE5G:LBM>AaVZ�K_>LZEgCTCDF<�B.5GKMDP>L7EDF<�BwDFBM<?>[email protected]@H7 X DP7ET�7ETj5�v{DF5 X 7ETV:k7�KMDe@VW ` aVBEaV:LNeNPOaV@V<?>A@CBE<�DP>AaVBENFO b <?>[email protected]<?7EBmK_>{WV5GNFB 8 O�B.5GNP5G<?7EDF@ u :L@VW 8 NP5G@VWVDF@ u ` : 8 B.7.Zi:L<?7EDF>A@VB�I$ZE>AK b DFKMK_5GWCDF:k7.5]:L@CW gC:LB.75?lrg¡5�Z[DP5G@V<?5 d aVBEDe@ u ` 5LQ u Q b 7.5GK_gCNF:k7.5GBSWj5�Z[DPvL5GW�I(Zi>AK 5GK 8 >{WCDP5GW�K_>L7EDP>A@ # %���( d BE>�7ETC:k7 X TV:k7 X 5UBE5�5U:LB �*> 8 Þ*5G<?7EB��:kZE5M:L<?7EaV:LNeNPOtgC:kZi7EBx>LI^7ETj5GBE5MK_>{WV5GNFB�QzR;TVDFB�Wj>H5GB�@V>L7sWj5G@�O�7ETV:k7s: � X >LZiNFW���5?ljDFB.7EB d 8 aj7�DP7�Wj>H5GB�WV5G@�O�7ETV:k7X 5s5?l{g~5�ZiDF5G@V<?5sDP7UWVDPZi5G<?7ENPOLQf�9B_*;5GDFWV5 uLu 5�Z;> 8 B.5�ZivL5GW d X 5m<?>AK_5m<�NP>ABE5GB.7U7.>M5?lrg~5�ZiDP5G@V<�DF@ u �*Zi5G:LNFDP7=OT� X TV5G@�>AajZK_>rWj5GNFB 8 Zi5G:�Ø Wj> X @ # 3 %k(hQ qrDFKMDFNe:kZiNPO d X 5tKM:GO�ZE5GDe@�7.5�ZEgCZE5�7�7ETj5tB.Or@�7E:nl d B.5GKM:L@H7EDF<�B d gVZi: u KM:k7EDe<�B_7.ZiDF:LW >LI<�NF:LBEBiDF<�:LN6B.5GKMDF>L7EDF<�B dV8 O}<�Ne:LDFKMDF@ u 7ETC:k7;[email protected]:L@V<?5GB;<�:L@tgVZE> 8 : 8 NPO 8 5 8 5�7.7.5�Z9aV@CWj5�ZiB.7.>{>{W�7ETVZE>Aa u T�7ETj5zaVB.5>LISB.5GKMDP>L7EDe<�K_>LZEgCTVDeBEKMB�Q

RUTV5]: 8 >cvL5MDeWj5G:LBxBEa uLu 5GB.7xvk:kZiDP>AaVB X :cO{Bx7.>p:cvL>ADFW 7ETj5]5?l{7.Zi5GK_5GBx>LI^KMDe@VWVNP5GBEB;ZE5GWVaV<?7EDF>A@VDFBEK�:L@VW KMDF@VWT�NP5GBEB]Tj>ANFDeBEK�QtRUTV5wK_>AB.7�B.7.Zi:LD u T�7.I$>LZ X :kZiW�:kgVgVZE>A:L<[T DeBm7.> :LWVKMDP7z7ETV:k7 X TVDFNF5M5G:L<iT DF@CWVDPvrDFWVaV:LN�:L@V:LNPOrBEDFBz@j>Wj>Aa 8 7�TV:LB 8 De:LB.5GB9:L@CW�NeDFKMDP7E:k7EDP>A@CB d DP7x@j>A@j5�7ETV5GNP5GBEB�5GK 8 >rWVDP5GB�<?5�ZE7E:LDF@ B.7.ZiaC<?7EajZE5GB d vk:LNFaj5GB d DF@VBiD u T�7EB d 5�7E<kQm�u DPvL5G@�:L@V:LNPOrBEDFB d DPISDP79DFB9<�NP5G:kZ d <?>ATj5�ZE5G@H7�:L@CW�<?>[email protected]@H7 d <�:L@ 8 5mI$>LZiKM:LNFDP��5GW d :L@VW�KM:GOpTV:cvL5_B.>AK_5mvk:LNFaj5]:LBBEaV<[T±·�I(>LZz5?lr:LKMgCNP5 d DP7EBsNFDFK�DP7E:k7EDP>A@VB X DeNFN 8 5M5G:LBEDP5�Zz7.>�B.g~>L7�QpqraV<iT :L@�:L@V:LNFO{BEDeB�BETj>AaVNFW @j>L7sgVZE5�7.5G@CW�7.> 8 5> 8 Þ.5G<?7EDPvL5 d I�:L<?7EaV:LN d <?>AK_g�NP5�7.5 d aV@VDPvL5�Z[BE:LN d >LZU5�[email protected]��=<?>A@H7E:LDF@j5GW±·VDP7YDFBY:�K_>AKM5G@�7E:kZEO�BE@C:kgCBETj>L7�>LI :�g�:kZE7EDF:LNaV@VWV5�ZiB.7E:L@VWVDe@ u >LIf>A@j5 ` >LZsK_>LZE5 b [email protected]�ZE5GB.7.5GW�gC:kZi7=O d :L@VW�>LI^<?>AajZ[B.5 d <�:L@�>A@CNPO 8 5zaV@CWj5�ZiB.7.>{>{W 8 O�>L7ETj5�Z�DF@T�7.5�ZE5GB.7.5GW�g�:kZE7EDP5GB X Tj>�TV:GvL5�:]K_>LZE5�>LZ�NF5GBEB�<?>AK_gC:kZi: 8 NF5 8 :L<^Ø u ZE>AaC@VW Q¬¯27�TV:LB�I$ZE>L��5G@}>Aaj7�7ETj5���aVDFWMgCZE>{<?5GBiB.5GB>[email protected]�ZEgVZE5�7E:k7EDP>A@�7ETC:k7;:L<?7EaV:LNFNPO}gVZE>rWVaV<?5GW�7ETV5maV@VWj5�Z[B.7E:L@VWVDF@ u QRUTV5sgVZE5�vrDP>AaVBYg�:kZi: u Zi:kgCT�KM:GOp<�NF:LDeKo7.>H>}NFDP7.7ENP5 dC8 5G<�:LaCB.5zB.>AKM5�7EDFK_5GB;:L@C:LNPO{BE5GB;<�:L@�TV:GvL5 u ZE5G:k7�DeK_gC:L<?7 dX DP7ET 8 Zi>A:LW�:L<�<?5�gC7E:L@V<?5 d DeK_g~>LZE7E:L@�7x:kgVgCNeDF<�:k7EDP>A@VB d 5�7E<kQ d 5LQ u Q d á;5 X 7.>A@CDF:L@yK_5G<iTC:L@VDF<�B�� / Q�*;> X 5�vL5�Zz7ETVDFB�gC:)��3mcI�6`<W4)PYF)G=@�O7PYH5gtPY83RY69HcH34)>�Hb]7>YD9D�PY8V@0:=O7R�H3PdH3Pv@7>�I'o < <WD�:�6�O7D�6Q]� 69K H3PYO):=>YOxNE6�DM4)>YO7:=D9<�])@06�<WU):CH36`:CH3<5HW836�NE69O�@7PYF)<5F0H3:�G=:CH�I�]7:�< O7PYH

3��

Page 37: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

g~5�ZzDFBz@j>L7m7ETV5�gCNF:L<?5�7.>�7.ZEOy7.>�aV@VWj5�Z[B.7E:L@VW X THO�B.>AK_5}:L@V:LNPOrB.5GBmK�:GO X >LZ{Ø 8 5�7.7.5�Zz7ETC:L@�>L7ETj5�ZiB]DF@�B.>AK_5u DPvL5G@ B.>r<�DF:LN�<?>[email protected]?lr7�QP¯27xDFBU5G@j>Aa u T�I$>LZ�>AajZ9g�ajZEg~>AB.5GBU7ETC:k7�:L@V:LNFO{B.5GB95?ljDFB.7 d 5?lrTVD 8 DP7;B.7.Z[aV<?7EajZE5 d :L@VW�<�:L@ 8 5I$>LZiKM:LNFDP��5GW d X DP7ETj>Aaj7YZE5UË{aVDPZ[DF@ u :�7.>L7E:LNFDP�GDF@ u d ZE5GWVaV<?7EDP>[email protected] d >LZUZE5G:LNFDeB.7UB.7E:L@V<?5LQ

� � �*Ð~Ö�� ��ѱÒ'Ò� ����:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�DF:L@CBm7E:LNSØy>LI �*gVZi>H>LI�B�t:LBzZE5G:LNJ7ETVDF@ u B�Qº»�aj7m:LNeN X 5w<�:L@�5�vL5�Z]:L<?7EaV:LNeNPO�ÄC@VW�De@y7ETj5�Zi5G:LN X >LZiNFW>LIS:L<?7EaV:LN 5?lrg~5�ZiDP5G@V<?5s:kZE5 § � �c� � � � � � � d >LZ �*gVZE>cvrDF@ u B�� d 5G:L<iT�>LI X TVDF<iT�DeBY:MB.>r<�DF:[email protected]�Zi:L<?7EDP>A@�>r<�<�ajZEZ[DF@ u :k7:Mg�:kZE7EDF<�aVNF:kZ;7EDFK_5z:L@CWpgCNF:L<?5 d DF@HvL>ANPv{De@ u gC:kZE7EDF<�aCNF:kZUg~5�>LgCNP5 d X Tj>�TV:cvL5zg�:kZE7EDF<�aVNF:kZ9BMØ{DeNFNFBY:LB�K_5GK 8 5�ZiB;>LIf:L@:kgVgVZi>LgVZiDF:k7.5�KM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�:LN�B.>r<�DF:LN6<?>AK�KzaV@CDP7=OLQ

� gCZE>H>LIj5�vL5G@H7fKMDF@CDFKM:LNFNPO�DF@HvL>ANPvL5GB�: �*gCZE>H>LIC> 8 B.5�ZEvL5�Z�� X DP7ETz7ETj5�ZE5GNP5�vk:L@�7 8 :L<^Ø u ZE>AaC@VW�:L@VW�DF@�7.5�Zi5GB.7 d :L@VWB.>AK_5]K_5GWVDF:k7EDe@ u gCTHO{BEDe<�:LN > 8 Þ.5G<?7EB d BEaC<iTt:LB�B.g~>cØL5G@ X >LZiWVB d u 5GB.7EajZE5GB d TV:L@VW X ZiDP7.7.5G@tI(>LZiK]aVNF:k5 d 3 � K_>rWj5GNFB d>LZ�gVZiDe@�7.5GW X >LZiWVB d WVDe: u Zi:LKMBx>LZ�I$>LZiKzaCNF:k5LQi»�aj7�@j>A@V5_>LIJ7ETj5GB.5M<�:L@ 8 5�: �*gVZE>{>LI� 8 O�DP7EB.5GNFI d~8 5G<�:LaVB.5_5G:L<[TK]aVB.7 8 [email protected]�ZEgVZE5�7.5GWpDe@�>LZiWj5�ZU7.>�<?>AKM5m:LNFDPvL5s:LB9:_gVZE>{>LI�5�vL5G@H7�QRUTV5Y5Cà�<�:L<?OM>LI B.>AK_5UgCZE>H>LI¡5�vL5G@H7EB^Wj5�g~5G@VWCB�>A@M7ETj5;K�:kZ{Ø{Bf7ETV:k7^<?>[email protected];:sWCDF: u Zi:LK 8 5GDF@ u BE5�5G@M7.> 8 5WjZi: X @�DF@t:}<?5�ZE7E:LDF@�>LZiWj5�Zr·�5LQ u Q d �^aV<�NFDFWj5G:L@ u 5�>AK_5�7.ZiDF<]gVZi>H>LI�B d :L@CW�<?>AKMK]aj7E:k7EDPvL5MWCDF: u Zi:LKMB�DF@t:LN u 5 8 Zi:4· DF@B.>AK_5�<�:LB.5GB d 7ETj5x>LZiWj5�ZYKM:GO�@j>L7 8 5�5G:LBiDFNPOMDF@jI$5�ZEZE5GWwI$ZE>AK Þ.aVBE7^7ETj5�WVDe: u Zi:LK�QfRUTj5�Zi5�I(>LZE5 X 5xK]aVB.7 u 5G@j5�Z[:LNFDP��5I$ZE>AK gCZE>H>LIS> 8 Þ*5G<?7EBx7.>}gVZE>{>LISgVZE>r<?5GBEB.5GB d BEaC<iT�:LB�WCDF: u Zi:LKMB 8 5GDF@ u WVZi: X @ d K_>�v{DF5GB 8 5GDF@ u BETj> X @ d :L@VW ��:Gvk::kgVgCNF5�7EB 8 5GDF@ u 5?l{5G<�aV7.5GW Q��:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�De:L@VB�TV: 8 DP7EaV:LNeNPO�:L@CW gVZi>LI(5GBEBiDP>A@V:LNFNPO ZE5GDFI(O d :L@VW DP7zBE5�5GKMB]7ETV:k7 X TV:k7z7ETV5�O <�:LNFN^gVZE>{>LI$B]:kZE5DFWj5G:LNeDP��5GWs!^NF:k7.>A@VDF<��.KM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�:LNj> 8 Þ.5G<?7EB d �sNFD]ØL5�@{aVK 8 5�Z[B d 7ETV:k7S<�:L@V@j>L7 8 5^I$>AaV@VW�:L@HO X TV5�ZE5^>A@�7ETCDFB�5G:kZi7ET Qq{>MNP5�7UaCBU: u ZE5�5m7.> u >�:LNP>A@ u X DF7ET�7ETVDFBY<?>A@jI�aVBEDP>A@ ` ¯�:LNFK_>ABE7 X ZE>L7.5 �gÞ.>cØL5v� b :L@CWp<�:LNFN :L@HO}> 8 Þ*5G<?7U>LZ;gVZE>r<?5GBEB: �*gCZE>H>LI�tDPI�DF7s5��¡5G<?7EDFvL5GNPO�K_5GWVDF:k7.5GBz:�gVZE>{>LI�5�vL5G@�7 d @j>L7mI(>LZ u 5�7.7EDe@ u 7ETV:k7]:L@ :kgVgCZE>LgVZiDF:k7.5M<?>[email protected]?lr7]DFBm:LNFB.>@j5�5GWj5GW6QzRUTj5G@�g~5�ZiTV:kg�B9BEaVZEgVZiDFBiDF@ u NPO d :LNFK_>AB.7�:L@HOH7ETVDe@ u <�:L@ 8 5�:�gVZE>{>LI �"¶j>LZm5?lr:LK_g�NP5 d 3 u 5�5GB.5PÞ.>ADF@VDF@ u :u ZE>Aajg�>LI � u 5�5GB.5 �VO{De@ u @j>LZE7ET�DFB;:wgVZE>{>LIS7ETV:k7 � � 3 D â � d 7.>}:L@�:kgVgVZi>LgVZiDF:k7.5s> 8 B.5�ZEvL5�ZGQx! 5GDFZi<?5 � B9@V>L7EDP>A@>LIJB.5GK�DP>ABEDFB;7E:�ØL5GB�:�<?> u @VDP7EDFvL5zvrDP5 X >LIS5?lr:LK_g�NP5GB9NeDSØL5m7ETVDeB d gCNe:L<�DF@ u 5GK_g�TV:LBEDFB;>A@�:wBED u @�TV:GvrDF@ u :�Zi5GNF:k7EDP>A@7.>�:L@pDe@�7.5�ZEgCZE5�7E:k7EDP>A@ Q

á9>L7EDF<?5�7ETV:k7M: gVZi>H>LIU5�vL5G@H7�<�:L@ TV:cvL5tKM:L@HO�WVD �¡5�ZE5G@H7�>Aaj7E<?>AK_5GB�Q�¶j>LZ�:yK�:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�DF:L@�5G@ u : u 5GW DF@gVZE>�v{De@ u d 7ETj5MK_>ABE7sBE:k7EDFB.I�:L<?7.>LZEO >Aaj7E<?>AK_5�DeBx7ETV:k7m:LNFN�gC:kZi7EDF<�DPgC:L@H7EB�: u ZE5�5M7ETV:k7 �.:�gVZE>{>LI^TV:LB 8 5�5G@ u DFvL5G@ Q��´�7ETj5�Zx>Aaj7E<?>AKM5GB�KM:GO 8 5]7ETV:k7�K_>AB.7x:kZE5_K_>LZE5]>LZsNP5GBEB�<?>A@Hv{DF@C<?5GW d~8 aj7 X :L@H7x7.>�BE5�5�BE>AK_5�I$ajZi7ETj5�Z�WV5�7E:LDFNFBC·>LZM7ETj5�O�KM:cO�: u Zi5�5p7ETV:k7_7ETj5pZi5GBEaVNP7�DFB�gVZE> 8 : 8 NPO�7.ZiaV5 d^8 aV7 8 5GNFDF5�vL5}7ETV5�ZE5p:kZE5tBED u @VDSÄC<�:L@H7 u :kgCBC·Y>LZM7ETj5�OKM:cO�7ETCDF@\Øt7ETC:k7m7ETj5MgCZE>H>LI�DFB 8 :LW :L@VWy7ETj5MZi5GBEaVNP7sDFBsI$:LNFBE5LQ��9@CWy>LIY<?>AajZiB.5 d B.>AK_5M> 8 BE5�ZEvL5�ZiBmK�:GO 8 5MNP>AB.7>LZ_<?>A@jI�aVB.5GW Q�¯*@ ZE5G:LN�gVZi>cvrDF@ u B d >Aaj7E<?>AKM5GB_:kZE5�@j>L7]:LN X :cO{BAÞEaVB.7�� 7.Ziaj5 � >LZ�� I$:LNFBE5 � Q �p>LZE5�>�vL5�Z d : u ZE>AaVg >LIgVZE>{>LI~> 8 B.5�ZEvL5�Z[BJ@j5�5GW}@j>L7^: u Zi5�59:LK_>A@ u 7ETj5GKMBE5GNPvL5GB d De@ X TVDe<iTM<�:LB.5�7ETj5�ZE59KM:GOM@j>L7 8 5;:L@�OMWV5CÄ[email protected];BE>{<�DF:LNeNPO@j5 u >L7EDF:k7.5GW �*>Aaj7E<?>AK_5v�}:k7;:LNFN ���>ADe@ u :_NFDP7.7ENP5xI�ajZE7ETj5�Z d 7ETV5sWVDFB.7EDF@C<?7EDP>A@ 8 5�7 X 5�5G@t:_gVZE>{>LI u DPvL5�Z9:L@VW�:_gVZE>{>LI�> 8 B.5�ZEvL5�Z;DFB�>LI$7.5G@p:kZE7ED]ÄC<�DF:LN>LZ�gVZE> 8 NP5GK�:k7EDF<�·HI$>LZ�5?lr:LK_g�NP5 d : u ZE>Aajgw>LI�KM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�DF:L@VB X >LZ^Ø{DF@ u <?>ANFNF: 8 >LZi:k7EDFvL5GNPO�>A@w:zgVZE>{>LI6KM:GOw:kZ u aj5:LK_>A@ u 7ETj5GKMB.5GNFvL5GBw: 8 >Aaj7 X Tj5�7ETj5�Zw>LZ}@j>L7}B.>AK_5 u DPvL5G@ g~5�ZiBE>A@ TV:LB}<?>A@�7.Z[D 8 aj7.5GW BEa 8 B.7E:L@H7EDPvL5GNPO�7.> �*7ETj5gVZE>{>LI�rQ *95G@V<?5 X 5�BiTj>AaVNFW B.g~5G:�Ø >LI �*gVZE>{>LIUgC:kZE7EDF<�DFgC:L@�7EB�� d Tj> X 5�vL5�ZM7ETj5�O TV:kgVg~5G@�7.> 8 5�WVDFBE7.ZiD 8 aj7.5GW�[email protected]:L<?5M:L@CW 7EDFK_5 d :L@VW 8 5_: X :kZE5M7ETV:k7�7ETV5M@V:k7EajZE5�>LI�7ETj5GDPZ�gC:kZE7EDe<�DPgC:k7EDP>A@�DFB�BEa 8 Þ*5G<?7x7.>tB.>r<�DF:LN�@j5 u >L7EDF:k7EDF>A@ dNFDSØL5�5�vL5�ZiOH7ETVDe@ u 5GNFB.5LQRUTV5m: 8 >cvL5�Wj5G<?>[email protected]<?7EDP>A@�>LI �*gVZE>{>LI�B�M:LB9> 8 Þ*5G<?7EDFvL5GNPO�5?lrDFBE7EDF@ u ZE5G:LN�7ETVDF@ u B;DFBY>A@VNPO�7ETj5"ÄVZiB.7Ug�:kZE7U>LIf:K_>LZE5�<?>AK_g�NP5?lwB.7.>LZEOLQZ¯2@�:LWVWVDF7EDP>A@�7.>_:�gVZi>H>LI6> 8 Þ*5G<?7 ` >LZYgVZE>r<?5GBEB b[d <?5�ZE7E:LDe@ § � � � ��� � � ` :LNFB.>_<�:LNFNP5GW�� � � ³ � µ b:kZE5s@j5�5GWV5GWw7.>_5GBE7E: 8 NFDFBET�:L@�[email protected]�ZEgVZi5�7E:k7EDP>A@}>LI :�gVZE>{>LI6> 8 Þ.5G<?7U:LBU:]gVZE>{>LI�5�vL5G@H7�QZ¶j>LZ;5?lr:LK_g�NP5 d 7.>[email protected]�ZEgVZE5�77ETj5 �VOrDF@ u�u 5�5GB.5}:LBs:�gVZi>H>LI�: 8 >AaV7s:LWVWVDP7EDP>A@ Zi5UËHaVDFZE5GBx:�gVZi:L<?7EDF<?5�>LI�<?>AaV@H7EDF@ u QMR;TVDFB�ZiaV@VB�<?>AaC@�7.5�Zz7.>p7ETj57.5G@VWj5G@C<?O d DF@wKM:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDe<�B^:LB X 5GNeNC:LB�[email protected]�Z[:k7EajZE5;:L@VWwNFDF@ u aCDFB.7EDF<�B d 7.>][email protected]>A@�7ETV5 �*gVZiDFK�:L<?O_>LI 7ETj5U7.5?lr7�D u @j>LZ[DF@ u 7ETj5_gVZi:L<?7EDF<?5GBmZE5UË{aVDPZE5GW�7.> 8 ZiDe@ u 7.5?lr7EBs7.>�NFDPI$5 d :LB X 5GNeNS:LB�7ETj5M<?>AKMK]aV@VDP7EDF5GBx7ETV:k7�5GK 8 >rWjOt7ETV>AB.5gVZi:L<?7EDe<?5GB�Q>`D�P�8W836�D9H5U74�I7<W:�Db>�G7H3476�PY8WI�]Q\)F7HiPYO)GCIE>`U08V>YD9H3:�Db>�Gk>YU7U783P �0:=N�>H3:�PQO�H34)>�H?4)PQG=@0<iK :CH34):�OED�6M8WHV>Y:�O e O)P�H�6�O�H3:C836�GCI�K�6�G�G�<WUk6�D�: /)6b@�h G�:=NE:CH3<�l

3#�

Page 38: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

¯*@tI�:L<?7 d gVZi:L<?7EDF<?5GBx:L@VW�7ETj5GDPZx<?>AKMK]aV@VDP7EDF5GB;:kZE5_:k7xNP5G:LB.7x:LB�DeK_g~>LZE7E:L@�79:LB9gCZE>H>LIS> 8 Þ*5G<?7EBC·6De@pgC:kZE7EDe<�aVNF:kZ dDP7;DeB;<�NP5G:kZ97ETV:k7;7ETj5�Op:[email protected]~5G@VBE: 8 NF5;I$>LZ�[email protected]�ZEgVZi5�7EDF@ u B.>AK_5z5?l{g~5�ZiDF5G@V<?5m:LB�:MgVZE>{>LI ·CDPI�OL>Aa�<�:L@ � 79<?>AaV@H7 d7ETj5G@_OL>Aaw<�:L@ � 7^BE5�5 u >H>ABE5;gC:k7.7.5�Zi@CBJ:LBfgCZE>H>LI�B d :L@CWMDPICOL>Aa}TV:cvL5G@ � 7 8 5�5G@_7E:La u TH7J: 8 >Aaj7f7ETV5;@HaCK_5�Zi:LNFB � � � d � 3 � d� â � � d 7ETj5G@�OL>Aa�<�:L@ � 7J5?l{gCNe:LDF@]OL>AajZfgVZE>{>LIC7.>m7ETj5UWj5G<�DFKM:LNjWCD u DP7SB.g~5G:�Ø{De@ u <?>AK�KzaV@CDP7=OLQ²´�I¡<?>AajZiB.5 d 7ETVDFB�NFDF@V5�>LI7ETj>Aa u TH7�7E:�ØL5GBYaVB^I$ajZi7ETj5�Z^I$ZE>AK 7ETj5�> 8 Þ.5G<?7EDPvL5�<?5�ZE7E:LDF@H7EDP5GB�7ETV:k7YKM:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�BYNeDSØL5GBJ7.>_<�NF:LDeK d�8 aV7�DPI X 5xNP>H>cØ:k7U7ETj5sTCDFB.7.>LZEOM>LI�KM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�B d DP7YDFBY<�NF5G:kZU7ETV:k7U7ETj5�Zi5sTV:GvL5 8 5�5G@�KM:L@HO�WVD��~5�ZE5G@�7Y<?>AKMK]aV@VDF7EDP5GB�>LI gCZE>cvrDF@ ugVZi:L<?7EDe<?5c·jI(>LZ�5?lj:LK_gCNP5 d X TC:k7 X 5�<�:LNFNE�.KM:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDe<�:LN~ZiD u >LZ���DFB�:]ZE5GNF:k7EDPvL5GNFOMvL5�ZEOw@V5 X vrDP5 X g~>ADF@H7 d :L@VW}5�vL5G@X DP7ETCDF@pDP7 d 7ETj5�ZE5�:kZE5�vk:kZiDP>AaVB�<?>AK_g~5�7EDF@ u BE<iTj>{>ANFB d DF@C<�NFaVWVDF@ u I(>LZiK�:LNFDFB.7EB d DF@H7EaVDP7EDP>[email protected]:L@VW <?>[email protected][aV<?7EDPvrDFB.7EB d5G:L<iT}>LI X TCDF<iTwDP7EB.5GNPI TV:LB�KM:L@HO_vn:kZiDe:L@�7EB�Q+�t>LZE5�>cvL5�Z d 7ETj5�:cvn:LDeNF: 8 DFNFDF7=O]>LI6<�:LNF<�aVNF:k7.>LZiB�:L@VWw<?>AK_gCaj7.5�ZiB�DFBJ5�vL5G@@j> X >A@V<?5mK_>LZi5m<iTV:L@ u DF@ u KM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�:LN6gVZ[:L<?7EDF<?5LQ��:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�:LN�NP> u De<sZE5GB.7.Z[DF<?7EB;:k7.7.5G@H7EDP>A@�7.>}BiKM:LNFN6B.5�7EB�>LIfBEDeK_gCNP5sK_5G<[TV:L@VDF<�:LN K_5�7ETj>rWVB d <�:LNFNP5GW � ) � � �� �� � � � � � � � � d :L@VW�<�NF:LDFKMB 7ETV:k7S:LNFN{gVZE>{>LI�B <�:L@ 8 5�<?>[email protected]<?7.5GW_:LB¹Ä[email protected]�BE5UËHaj5G@C<?5GB >LI¡:kgVgCNFDe<�:k7EDP>A@VB6>LI¡BEaV<[TzZ[aVNP5GB�Q� TVDFNP5x7ETVDFBY:kgCgVZE>A:L<iT�DFBY:kgVgVZi>LgVZiDF:k7.5xI$>LZUI(>AaC@VWV:k7EDP>A@V:LN BE7EaVWVDP5GB d :L@VWtTV:LB 8 5�5G@�[email protected]�ZE5GB.7EDF@ u :L@CW�vn:LNFaC: 8 NP5�DF@KM:L@HO X :GOrB d DP7UDFB�I�:kZUI(Zi>AK�<�:kgV7EajZiDe@ u 7ETj5 u ZE5G:k7�WVDPvL5�ZiBEDF7=Ow:L@CW�v{DF7E:LN6NFDPvrDF@ u ËHaC:LNFDP7=Ow>LIS@V:k7EajZi:LN~gVZi>H>LI�B�Q

��@jI$>LZE7EaV@V:k7.5GNPO d X 5pNe:L<{Ø 7ETj5pWj5�7E:LDFNP5GW�B.7EaCWVDP5GB]7ETV:k7 X >AaVNFW�ZE5�vL5G:LNY7ETV5}I�aVNFN�ZiDe<iTV@j5GBiBz>LIxKM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�:LNgVZi:L<?7EDe<?5 dH8 aV7JDP7JDFB^:LNPZE5G:LWjO_<�NP5G:kZ�7ETV:k7^gVZE>{>LI¡g�:kZE7EDF<�DPgC:L@H7EB 8 ZiDF@ u :m7.ZE5GK_5G@VWj>AaCBfvk:kZiDP5�7=O_>LI~ZE5GBE>AajZi<?5GB^7.> 8 5G:kZ>A@�gCZE>H>LI�> 8 Þ.5G<?7EB ` B.5�5 # % �k(JI(>LZ]:L@�5?lj<?5GNFNP5G@H7zWVDeBE<�aVBEBEDF>A@ b Q(¶j>LZ]5?lj:LK_gCNP5 d :pWVDFBi<�aVBEBEDP>A@y:LKM>A@ u : u ZE>Aajg >LIKM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�DF:L@VB�:k7Y: 8 NF:L<{Ø 8 >A:kZiW X DFNFNV7=O{gCDF<�:LNFNPOwDF@�vL>ANFvL597ETj5�[email protected] u Zi:k7EDP>A@}>LI X ZiDP7EDF@ u d WjZi: X DF@ u d 7E:LNSØrDF@ u :L@VWu 5GB.7EajZ[DF@ u DF@�ZE5G:LN 7EDeK_5sKzaCNP7EDFK_5GWVDe:[email protected]�Zi:L<?7EDP>A@6Q¬¯2@�:k7;NF5G:LB.7;B.>AK_5s<�:LBE5GB d 7ETVDFBYDe@�7.5�Zi:L<?7EDF>A@pTV:LBU:MTCD u T�NP5�vL5GN�.@V:kZEZ[:k7EDPvL5v��B.7.ZiaV<?7EajZi5 d De@ X TCDF<iT�B.5UË{aj5G@H7EDF:LNFNPO_>LZ u :L@CDP��5GW}gVZE>{>LI6gC:kZE7EB�:kZE5�[email protected]�ZiNP5G:cvL5GW X DP7ETw5�vn:LNFaC:k7EDP>A@�:L@VWK_>L7EDPvk:k7EDP>A@pDe@�<?>AK_gCNP5?l X :cO{BGQ�9ZiDFB.7.>L7ENF5�BE:LDFW �.�9Z[:LKM:�DeBs<?>A@ �CDF<?7� d K_5G:L@CDF@ u 7ETV:k7z7ETj5wWVZi:LKM:k7EDF<MDe@�7.5�ZE5GBE7 d >LZ]5?lr<�DF7.5GK_5G@�7 d >LIY:tgCNF:GO<?>AK_5GB�I$ZE>AK\<?>A@ ��DF<?7 d 7ETC:k7^DFB d I(Zi>AK > 8 B.7E:L<�NF5GB�:L@CW�WVDSàw<�aVNP7EDP5GB�Q��9@HOL>A@j5 X Tj>mTC:LB^Wj>A@V59KM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�BZØr@j> X B7ETV:k7fKM:L@HOzWCDSà�<�aVNP7EDF5GB�:kZiDFBE5LQ¹»�aj7�7ETj5 X :GO]gVZE>{>LI$B�:kZE5Y7�OHgCDe<�:LNFNPO�gVZE5GBE5G@�7.5GW ³ � µ � �7ETV>AB.5UWVDSà�<�aCNP7EDP5GB d BETj> X DF@ u>A@VNPO 7ETV5�B.g~5G<�DF:LNeDP��5GW 8 aCNFNFWj>L��5�ZiB d u Zi5G@V:LWj5GB d 7.>LZig¡5GWV>AB d 5�7E<kQ�7ETV:k7 X 5�ZE5 8 aVDeNP7M7.>�5�Zi:LWVDF<�:k7.5�7ETj5GK�Q¢RUT{aVBZE5G:LWVDe@ u :z<?>A@�vL5G@H7EDP>A@V:LN~gVZi>H>LI <�:L@ 8 59:]TVD u TVNPO�:LNFDP5G@C:k7EDF@ u 5?lrg~5�ZiDP5G@V<?5 d BEDF@V<?5�DP7^DeBJWVDSàw<�aVNP7f>LZ�DFK_g~>ABEBED 8 NP5�7.>aV@VWV5�ZiB.7E:L@VW X THOs7ETj5GB.5�gC:kZE7EDF<�aCNF:kZ X 5G:kg~>A@VBSTV:cvL5 8 5�5G@�Wj5�gCNF>cOL5GW QÌá;> X >A@VWj5�Z�7ETj5�gCa 8 NFDF< � B67�OHg�DF<�:LN{ZE5GB.g~>[email protected].>wK�:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�B�DFBUB.>AKM5�7ETVDF@ u NFD]ØL5 �°¯YWj>A@ � 79aC@VWj5�ZiB.7E:L@CW�DP7�Q²¯�<�:L@ � 7xWj>�DP7�Q²¯YWj>A@ � 7;NFD]ØL5mDP7�rQ*¯ 8 5GNFDF5�vL5�7ETV:k7KM:k7ETj5GK�:k7EDF<�DF:L@VB � B.OrB.7.5GKM:k7EDF<95GNFDFBEDF>A@M>LI6<?>A@ �CDe<?7�K]aVB.7^7E:�ØL5x:]BED u @CDSÄC<�:L@H7fgC:kZE7^>LI67ETj5 8 NF:LK_5UI$>LZ�7ETVDFB�Q ` á9>L7.57ETj5xKMDFNFDF7E:kZEO]KM5�7E:kgCTj>LZ�aVB.5GW}: 8 >�vL5c·VDP7^DeBJBEa uLu 5GBE7EDPvL5 d :L@VWw:LNeB.>mvL5�ZEOw<?>AKMK_>A@�DF@�K�:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�:LN~WVDFBi<?>AajZiB.5LQ bq{>w<�:LNFNP5GW��.@V:k7EaVZi:LN�Wj5GWCaV<?7EDP>A@�� ` WVaV5s7.> ��5G@H7.��5G@ b DFBU:_gVZi>H>LI�B.7.ZiaV<?7EaVZE5 X DP7ETtB.>AK_5m:LWjvk:L@H7E: u 5GB d�8 aj7UDP7DFB^vL5�ZEOMI�:kZ�I(ZE>AK �.@V:k7EajZ[:LNf�zDe@�7ETj5xB.5G@VBE59>LI 8 5GDF@ u X TV:k7^gVZE>�vL5�ZiBYWj>�DF@�@V:k7EaVZi:LN�BE5�7.7EDF@ u BC·j@V:k7EajZ[:LN�Wj5GWCaV<?7EDP>A@gVZE5GBE5G@�7EB9gVZE>{>LI$B�DF@�:�gCaVZE5GNPO}7.>Lg WV> X @�KM:L@V@j5�Z d B.>w7ETV:k7 d I(>LZ�5?lr:LKMgCNP5 d NP5GKMKM:LB�<�:L@V@j>L7 8 5mgVZE>�vL5GW 8 5�I$>LZE57ETj5�Os:kZE5�aVB.5GW6Q;�y5Y@j5�5GWz7.>�K_>�vL5 8 5�OL>A@VWz7ETj5^5?l{7.ZE5GKM5�g~>�vL5�ZE7=Os>LIj7ETV5^gVZi>H>LIjB.7.ZiaC<?7EajZE5GB 7ETV:k7�:kZi5^7.Zi:LWCDP7EDP>A@V:LNDF@ KM:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDe<�:LN�NP> u DF< dU8 O Wj5�vL5GNP>Lg�DF@ u K_>LZE5 �V5?lrD 8 NP5�:L@CW De@V<�NFaVBEDFvL5tB.7.ZiaV<?7EaVZE5GB�Q � ÄVZiBE7}B.7.5�g 7.> X :kZiWCB:L<�<?>AKMK_>rWV:k7EDF@ u <?>A@ �CDe<?7zDF@ygCZE>H>LI�BmK�D u T�7 8 5�7.>�:LNFNP> X :LNP7.5�Z[@V:k7EDPvL5�gCZE>H>LI�Bs7ETC:k7z:kZE5}DF@V<?>AK_gCNF5�7.5 d >LZz5�vL5G@DF@V<?>LZiZE5G<?7�QZ¶j>LZU5?lj:LK_gCNF5 d 7.>�BETj> X X THO}:_NP5GK�KM:_DFBY@j5�5GWj5GW d DP7YDFBUTj5GNPgCI$aVN�7.>­ÄVZ[B.7YBETj> X Tj> X 7ETV5�gVZE>{>LI�I�:LDFNFBX DP7ETV>Aaj7SDP7C·�>LZf7.>zBETj> X X T�O]7.Zi:L@VB{Ä[email protected]@VWCaV<?7EDP>A@�DFBf@j5�5GWV5GW d DP7fKM:cO]TV5GNPg_7.>mBETj> X Tj> X >LZiWVDe@V:kZEOmDF@CWVaV<?7EDP>A@I�:LDFNFB�Qm� TVDFB.7.>LZiOt>LI^:k7.7.5GKMgV7EB�7.> 8 aVDeNFWt:�gVZi>H>LI^ZE5G<?>LZiWVB�<?>A@ ��DF<?7EB d :L@VWyTj5G@C<?5]Zi5GDF@�7.Zi>{WVaC<?5GB�WVZi:LKM: d X TVDe<iT<�:L@ KM:�ØL5_gVZE>{>LI�B9K_>LZi5][email protected]�ZE5GB.7EDe@ u :L@CW�NP5GBiB�:LNeDP5G@V:k7EDF@ u Q�´�IJ<?>AajZ[B.5 d X 5_BETj>AaCNFWt@j>L7 u >�7.>H>�I�:kZ X DP7ET�7ETVDFBC·@j>_gVZi>H>LI ZE5G:LWj5�Z X DeNFN X :L@H7U7.>�B.5�5s:LNeN~7ETj5mBEKM:LNeN�5�ZiZE>LZiBU:�gVZi>H>LI�:Laj7ETj>LZUKM:�ØL5GB d 5LQ u Q dV8 :LWtB.O{@H7E:nl d I$:LDeNFajZE5�7.><iTV5G<{Ø_T�O{g~>L7ETj5GB.5GBS>LI¡:x7ETj5�>LZE5GK 8 5�I$>LZE5Y:kgVgCNPOrDF@ u DP7 d 5�7E<kQf��BfDF@�: u >{>{WMKM>cvrDP5 d <?>A@ �CDe<?7�De@�7.ZE>rWVaV<?7EDF>A@]BiTj>AaVNFW8 5�<�:kZE5�I�aVNFNPO�B.7.ZiaV<?7EaVZE5GW :L@VW <�:kZE5�I$aCNFNPO�7EDFK_5GW d B.>t7ETV:k7m7ETj5w<�NF:kZ[DP7=O >LI�7ETj5�@V:kZiZi:k7EDPvL5wNeDF@j5_DFBs@j>L7]NP>AB.7 d�8 aj7:L<?7EaV:LNFNFO}5G@CTV:L@V<?5GW QURUTV5m7E:k7E:LKMD�B.OrB.7.5GK d X TVDF<[T�5GK 8 >rWVDP5GB9KM:L@�O�>LIS7ETV5GB.5zDFWV5G:LB d DFB9Wj5GBE<?ZiD 8 5GWtDF@ # z � d z�� ( d:L@VW�K_>LZE5zWV5�7E:LDFN6>A@t7ETj5z:kgVg�NFDF<�:k7EDP>A@�>LIfDeWj5G:LB;DF@t7ETVDFBYg�:kg¡5�Z97.>�7ETV:k7xB.OrB.7.5GK <�:L@ 8 5sI$>AaV@VWpDe@ # 34â d zkz (ª·�I$>LZ:MNP5GBiB�I(>LZiK�:[email protected]>{WCaV<?7EDP>A@}7.>wB.>AKM5�>LI�7ETV5sDFWj5G:LBY>LIS:LN u 5 8 Z[:LDF<�B.5GKMDP>L7EDe<�B d B.5�5m:LNFBE> # % � (hQRUTV5s@V:kZEZi:k7EDPvL5zB.7.ZiaV<?7EajZi5GBY>LIS@V:k7EajZi:LN gCZE>H>LI�BUB.5�5GK 7.>�TV:cvL5zK]aV<iT�DF@�<?>AKMK_>A@ X DP7ETp<�DF@V5GKM:4×f7ETj5�ZE5zDFBU:TVDP5�Z[:kZi<iTVDe<�:LNjB.7.ZiaV<?7EajZ[DF@ u ` >LI :L<?7EB d BE<?5G@V5GB d BETV>L7EBJDF@_<�DF@V5GKM: d :L@VW_>LI~gVZi>H>LI�gC:kZE7EBJDe@_KM:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�B b ·H7ETj5�Zi5;:kZE5�C:LBET 8 :L<^Ø{B9:L@VW �C:LBETVI(>LZ X :kZiWVBU·j7ETj5�ZE5mDFB;:_ZiDF<[TpaVB.5s>LISK]aVNP7EDFKM5GWVDF:4·r5�7E<kQ�R;Tj5�7.Zi:LWVDP7EDF>A@V:LN I$>LZiKM:LN6NF:L@ u aV: u 5GBI$>LZJgVZE>{>LI�Bf:kZE5;:LNFBE>svL5�ZEO_DFK_g~>cvL5�Z[DFBETj5GW_DF@�7ETV5;K_5G<iTC:L@VDFBEKMBf7ETj5�O�gVZE>cvrDFWj5YI$>LZ^BE7.ZiaV<?7EajZiDe@ u gVZE>{>LI$BfDe@�7.>sg�:kZE7EB d

3��

Page 39: home/goguen/soc/pa/as - Home | Computer Sciencegoguen/pps/as.pdf · 2005. 1. 14. · Title /home/goguen/soc/pa/as.dvi

:L@VW�I(>LZ]5?lrgCNF:LDF@VDe@ u 7ETj5GB.5�B.7.ZiaC<?7EajZE5GB]:L@VW g�:kZE7EB�Q !JZE> 8 : 8 NFO X 5�<?>AaVNFW NP5G:kZi@ KzaV<[T�: 8 >Aaj7�Tj> X 7.> 8 5�7.7.5�ZB.7.ZiaC<?7EajZE5�gCZE>H>LI�B 8 O�B.7EaVWVO{DF@ u K_>cvrDP5GB d�8 5G<�:LaVB.5}:tK_>�v{DP5}KzaCB.7mgVZi5GB.5G@�7]:�<?>AKMgCNP5?l X >LZ[NFW d DF@�vL>ANFv{DF@ u 7ETj5gC:kZi:LNeNP5GNjNFDPvL5GBS>LI6K�:L@�O�g~5�>LgCNP5 d :LB^:mNFDe@j5G:kZfB.5UË{aj5G@V<?5;>LI BE<?5G@V5GB d DF@�: X :cO_7ETV:k7^TV>ANFWVBf:LaVWCDP5G@V<[email protected]�ZE5GB.7 d 5LQ u Q dB.5�5"#C&�(hQZá;>wWj>Aa 8 7Y7ETj5�Zi5m:kZE5mKM:L@HO�>L7ETj5�ZU5?lj<�DP7EDF@ u :kZi5G:LB;I$>LZUI�ajZE7ETj5�ZY5?lrgCNP>LZi:k7EDF>A@pDF@�>AajZ®Ë{aj5GB.7;7.>�DFK_gVZi>cvL57ETj5�aV@VWV5�ZiB.7E:L@VWV: 8 DFNFDP7�O]>LI gVZE>{>LI$BGQfqjaV<�<?5GBEBYDF@w7ETVDFB�Ë{aj5GB.7Y<?>AaVNFW�TV:cvL5s:]BiD u @VDSÄC<�:L@H7�DFK_gC:L<?7�>A@�KM:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDe<�B5GWVaV<�:k7EDF>A@ d u DPvL5G@�7ETj5_DFK_g~5G@VWVDF@ u g~5�ZEvk:LBEDPvL5G@V5GBEB�>LIJ<?>AK_gCaj7.5�Z[B�De@�BE<[Tj>{>ANFB d :L@VW�7ETj5_K_>AaV@H7EDF@ u I$ZiaVBE7.Zi:k7EDP>A@X DP7ET�<�aVZEZE5G@H7UKM:k7ETj5GKM:k7EDF<�:LN�5GWVaV<�:k7EDP>A@pgVZi:L<?7EDF<?5GB�Q` RUTV5]5GBiBE:GO DF@�7ETVDFBx:kgVg~5G@VWVD l X :LBsDF@�gC:kZE7�DF@VBEgCDPZE5GW 8 OpZi5GKM:kZ{ØrBx>LI^�fZ[DF<s� DPvrDF@ u B.7.>A@ d X Tj>AK¼¯ X DFBET�7.>7ETV:L@\Ø d 7ETj>Aa u T�¯9KM:cO�B.7EDeNFN�TV:GvL5 u >L7mDF7 X ZE>A@ u Q�RUTj5�ZE5GKM:kZ{ØrBx>A@y@V:kZEZ[:k7EDPvL5MWjZi: X >A@yWj5�7E:LDFNP5GWyB.7EaCWVDP5GB 8 O7ETj5mBE>{<�DP>ANeDF@ u aVDFBE7L� DFNFNFDF:LK � : 8 >�v # 3 &)(hQ�q{5�5 # z4â (6I(>LZ;BE>AK_5sZE5GNF:k7.5GWtWVDFBE<�aVBiBEDP>A@�:L@VW 8 :L<^Ø u Zi>AaV@VW Q b

3 &