7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

1/22

BCUPA\CEGD @F_FDA^IFHP AO PBF @AEP\CHF AO PBF P\CHCPS GH@ G

^ADFICE GMGCHUP PBF IA@GDCUI AO PBF VHCPF@ ^FHPFEAUPGD EBV\EB

CHPF\HGPCAHGD(

Ls

@ghhs ]( @gcu]a|d` Eb|cupcghcps C

@fefilf|

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

2/22

5#$ (7>

Kvupa Mah{gdf{$ Pbf Upa|s ao Eb|cupcghcps$ "Hf} Sa|j$ HS; Bg|~f| Eaddchu$ 7>#$ ?6(77

Clc`$ M|fh{$ =6(7? G(@( pbf ^|gfpa|cgh Mvg|` uv~~a|pf` pbf fdfepcah ao Igrfhpcvu gu

Fi~f|a|( Apbf| dfg`f|u up|af oa| eahp|ad ao pbf \aigh Fi~c|f gh` ls 5>= G(@( pbf|f }f|f

ocf dfg`f|u( Ffhpvgdds$ Eahupghpchf mgchf` uadcpg|s eahp|ad ao pbf Fi~c|f pb|avmb g|cavu

~adcpcegd "gh` hfog|cavu# ifghu( M|ghpchm Eb|cupcghcps dfmgd upgpvu ch pbf Fi~c|f ubavd` bgf

lffh g egpgdsup oa| ov|pbf| vhcps( Ug`ds pbf sfg|u oadda}chm uveb m|fgp ~f|ufevpcah ao pbf

Ebv|eb g|f ig|jf` ls uff|f chocmbpchm giahm pbf ifilf|u gh` dfg`f|u( Pbf ocmbpchm

"fu~fecgdds eahef|hchm Eb|cupadams# lfegif ua ocf|ef cp pb|fgpfhf` pbf gd|fg`s hf} gh`

pfhvavu vhcps ao Eahupghpchfu fi~c|cegd dfg`f|ubc~( Ch gh gppfi~p pa igchpgch gh` ov|pbf|

vhcps$ Eahupghpchf egddf` oa| pbf Ebv|eb Lcuba~u pa mgpbf| gp Hcefg ch 5 lcuba~u g||cf` ch Hcefg oa| pbf oc|up fevifhcegd eavhecd( Ighs ao

pbfuf ifh eg||cf` pbf ueg|u ao @fecgh gh` @caedfpcgh ~f|ufevpcah( Ubfddfs ~gchpu g ~cepv|f ao

pbf mgpbf|chm ao lcuba~u pbgp chedv`fu ahf }ba bg` daup bcu fsf( Ghapbf| lcuba~ }gu vhgldf pa

dcop bcu bgh`u lfegvuf ao pbf pa|pv|f bf fh`v|f` `v|chm ~f|ufevpcah(72

Eahupghpchf igs bgf

mgpbf|f` pbfuf lcuba~u pa ov|pbf| pbf egvuf ao Fi~c|cegd vhcps lvp pbf |fuvdp }gu fr~ahfhpcgdds

ia|f ~|aoavh`( O|ai pbcu eavhecd egif pbf Hcefhf E|ff` gooc|ichm pbf P|cvhf Ma` gh`

uavh`chm pbf `fofgp ao G|cghcui gu g cgldf Eb|cupcgh `aep|chf(

Geea|`chm pa Mah{gdf{ pbf gup igka|cps ao lcuba~u `c` hap uc`f }cpb fcpbf|

Gpbghgucvu a| G|cvu(73 Iaup }f|f }cddchm pa eaif pa uaif ua|p ao eai~|aicuf ch a|`f| pa

jff~ pbf vhcps ao pbf ebv|eb( Fvuflcvu Lcuba~ ao Egfug|fg }gu ahf uveb ~f|uah( Bf }gu

usi~gpbfpce pa G|cvuu cf}u lvp gdua }cddchm pa eaif `ffda~ gm|ffifhp lfp}ffh pbf

~g|pcfu(

72Clc`$ Ubfddfs$ 7>7(73Clc`$ Mah{gdf{$ 723(Clc`$ Mah{gdf{$ 723(

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

10/22

7>

Gopf| Eahupghpchf a~fhf` pbf eavhecd$ G|cvu }gu egddf` pa mcf geeavhp oa| bcu

pfgebchmu( G|cvu fr~dgchf` bcu Eb|cupadamcegd eahcepcah pbgp Kfuvu }gu g e|fgpf` lfchm

eg~gldf ao ebghmf gh` gdua g lfchm eg~gldf maa` gh` fcd( Fvuflcvu ao Hceaif`cg uv~~a|pf`

G|cvu ch bcu Eb|cupadamcegd g|mvifhpu( Lcuba~u$ ~|fcavuds |fg`s pa och` eai~|aicuf$ oavh`

Fvuflcvu gh` G|cvu u g|mvifhpu ldgu~bfiavu( Pbfs ha} ug} pbf `ghmf| ao G|cghcui gh`

|feamhc{f` pbf hff` pa oa|i g lcldcegd upgpfifhp gooc|ichm Ma` gu P|cvhf gh` Kfuvu gu g

`cchf ifilf| ao pbf Ma`bfg`( Pbf ahf pcif G|cvu usi~gpbc{f|$ Fvuflcvu ao Egfug|fg$

aoof|f` g e|ff`gd upgpfifhp vuf` ch bcu ebv|eb pa pbf lcuba~u( ]bfpbf| bcu upgpfifhp }gu

~|fufhpf`$ gu g }gs ao uf~g|gpchm bciufdo o|ai G|cvu a| oa| apbf| |fguahu$ |figchu

gilcmvavu( Hff|pbfdfuu$ cp ~|ac`f` g pfi~dgpf o|ai }bceb pbf eavhecd eavd` }a|j gh`

eaif pa ffhpvgd gm|ffifhp(

Pbf Hcefhf E|ff`

Dahm `flgpf ls pbf lcuba~u |fuvdpf` ch pbf oa|ivdgpcah ao pbf Hcefhf E|ff` lguf`

daaufds ah Fvuflcvu ao Egfug|fgu e|ff`( Pbf Hcefhf E|ff` uavh`ds |f~v`cgpf` G|cghcui ls

vuchm pbf pf|i baiaavucgu gooc|ichm Eb|cup pa lf ao pbf ugif uvlupghef }cpb Ma`$ pbf|foa|f$

`cchf( Pbf E|ff` `fecucfds gooc|if` pbf lcldcegd p|chcpg|cgh ~gppf|h `cuevuuf` fg|dcf|( Cp gdua

lvcdp v~ah gh` v~bfd` pbfadamcegd g`ghefifhpu bgiif|f` avp gmgchup pbf fg|ds g~adamcupu(

Pbf Hcefhf E|ff` ea`cocf` }bgp fg|ds Eb|cupcghu guuvif` ch }a|ubc~ gh` uge|gifhp;

Ma` cu Ogpbf|$ Uah gh` Bads U~c|cp( G(@(# edfg|ds ch`cegpfu pbf fg|ds ebv|eb fi~dasf` g P|chcpg|cgh oa|ivdg ch pbfuge|gifhp ao lg~pcui( Pbfs |fup|cepf` |fefcchm pbf Fvebg|cup pa pbauf }ba bg` lffh lg~pc{f` ch pbf Da|`u

Hgif( Pbf hgif ao pbf Da|`$ oa| pbf fg|ds ebv|eb$ }gu fr~|fuuf` gu Ogpbf|$ Uah gh` Bads U~c|cp(

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

11/22

77

dgpf| vh`f|ma uaif |fcucahu pa edg|cos pbf bvighcps ao Eb|cup gh` pbf ~dgef ao pbf Bads

U~c|cp: hff|pbfdfuu$ pbcu `aevifhp `fedg|f` Ma` pa lf Ogpbf|$ Uah gh` U~c|cp frcupchm gu pb|ff

`cupchep ~f|uahu ch ~f|ceba|fpce eaiivhcps(

P|chcpg|cgh Dcof gh` Eaiivhcps

Af| pbf hfrp uff|gd efhpv|cfu lfdcfo ch pbf @aep|chf ao pbf P|chcps bgu uf|f` gu pbf

lgucu oa| Eb|cupcgh a|pba`ars gh` g pfup ao ofdda}ubc~( Ch |fefhp sfg|u$ pbfadamcghu gh`

icuucadamcupu bgf daajf` pa pbf `aep|chf ao pbf P|chcps pa oa|ivdgpf ia`fdu ao Eb|cupcgh dcof

gh` eaiivhcps( Pbf `aep|chf ao pbf P|chcps ci~gepu bvighjch`u chpf|gepcah }cpb Ma`

pb|avmb ~|gsf| gh` cpu chpf|gepcah }cpb pbf |fup ao pbf }a|d`(

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

12/22

7 Ugchm ogcpb$

oa| pbf V^EC ba}ff|$ ifghu "7# geef~pghef ao pbf mau~fd ao Kfuvu Eb|cup gu pbf ifghu ao

ugdgpcah gh` "

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

14/22

70

pbf V^EC |fkfepu5= a|pba`ar e|ff`u gu ahds pbf pbchjchm ao ifh52 pbfs c|ahcegdds fil|gef

pbf `vgd hgpv|f Eb|cupadams ao Ebgdef`ah "067 G(@(#( Ch ha uigdd }gs$ pbf V^EC g`bf|fu pa g

Hfupa|cgh cf} ao g lcov|egpf` Eb|cup }ba `afu uaif pbchmu gu Ma` gh` apbf|u gu bvigh( Pbf

V^EC `aep|chf ao Ahfhfuu ovh`gifhpgdds `fhcfu pbf ~|f)frcupfhef ao Eb|cup ~|ca| pa Bcu

cheg|hgpcah ch odfub( Eb|cup }gu pbf damau a| pbavmbp ~dgh ao Ma`$ lvp `c` hap frcup gu g

~f|uah }cpbch pbf Ma`bfg` ~|ca| pa Bcu cheg|hgpcah(

^|gepcegdds$ pbf `fhaichgpcahu ea|f pfgebchm ao ,Ahfhfuu, cu odfubf` avp ch pbf

a|`chghef ao lg~pcui( Ufppchm guc`f pbf P|cvhf lg~pcuigd oa|ivdg geef~pf` ls pbf Eb|cupcgh

eaiivhcps gu fg|ds gu ?> G(@(53 Chupfg` pbf V^EC lg~pc{fu ch pbf ,Hgif ao Kfuvu, ahds(

]bs1 Uci~ds ~vp$ ,Ahfhfuu, `aep|chf ahds gdda}u oa| g uchmdf ~f|uah ch pbf Ma`bfg`(

Pbf|foa|f$ vuf ao pbf P|cvhf hgif ao Ma` }avd` hap lf ~f|icuucldf lfegvuf Kfuvu cu pbf

|ffgdf` hgif ao pbf Ogpbf|$ Uah gh` Bads U~c|cp(0> Pbf Ahfhfuu cf} ao Ma` odcfu ch pbf

ogef ao Eb|cupcgh a|pba`ars gh`$ ch is fupcigpcah$ hfmgpcfds ci~gepu pbfc| cf} ao Eb|cupcgh

eaiivhcps gh` fhmgmfifhp ao pbf daup(

Pbf Foofep ao V^EC Pfgebchmu ah Eb|cupcgh Eaiivhcps$ Ebv|eb Maf|hifhp gh` U~c|cpvgd

Mcopu

C |fefhpds bg` g eahf|ugpcah }cpb g V^EC ichcupf| pbgp dfg` pa pbf uvlkfep ao Eb|cupcgh

eaiivhcps( Bf dgifhpf` bcu chglcdcps pa eaif pa g lcldcegd `fochcpcah ao eaiivhcps }cpbavp

fi~daschm g P|chcpg|cgh bf|ifhfvpce( P|chcpg|cghcui up|fuufu g ~f|ceba|fpce chpf|`f~fh`fhef

5= Clc`$ @aep|chgd _cf}u(52

Clc`$ @aep|chgd _cf}u53 Pbf@c`gebf |fodfepu pbf fg|ds ebv|ebu vuf ao pbf pb|ff)oad` hgif ao Ma` ch }gpf| lg~pcui(

Uebadg|u ~dgef pbf }|cpchm ao pbf@c`gebf lfp}ffh ?> gh` 7>> G(@( Ahf egh |gpcahgdds ~|fuvif pbgp pbf

}a|ubc~ ao g P|cvhf Ma` egif dahm lfoa|f g ea`cocf` upgpfifhp frcupf` ch pbf@c`gebf( Pbf Lcldf `afu hap

~|fufhp cpu |fg`f| }cpb g eai~dfpfds `ffda~f` cf} ao pbf P|chcps( Ba}ff|$ g eguvgd |fg`chm ao pbf Lcldf

}avd` |ffgd iveb P|chcpg|cgh dghmvgmf(0>

Pbf Oa|ivdg ao Lg~pcui$ ]bs ]f Lg~pc{f ch Kfuvu Hgif$bpp~;!!}}}(v~ec(a|m!|fuav|efu!chup|vepcahgd)`fapcahgd)dfg`f|ubc~!25)}bs)}f)lg~pc{f)ch)kfuvu)hgif $

"Geefuuf` Uf~pfilf|

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

15/22

76

frcupchm }cpbch pbf Ma`bfg`( Ch eahp|gup$ pbf ia`gdcup fi~bgucu ao pbf V^EC uffiu pa up|fuu g

Ma` }ba eaa~f|gpfu }cpb ha ahf(

P|chcpg|cghcui vh`f|uea|fu pbf eaa~f|gpcf gh` eaiivhgd hgpv|f ao pbf P|cvhf Ma`(

]cpbch pbf eaiivhcps ao pbf P|chcps frcupu ivpvgd uvlicuucah gh` eaddgla|gpcah giahm cpu

ifilf|u( Iapcgpf` ls daf: pbf Ogpbf|$ Uah gh` Bads U~c|cp$ ovdocdd pbfc| `cupchepcf pguju ch

a|`f| pa l|chm glavp e|fgpcah$ |f`fi~pcah gh` ughepcocegpcah( Pbf P|cvhf Ma`bfg` frbclcpu pbf

~|apaps~cegd eaiivhcps gh` uf|fu gu pbf vdpcigpf frgi~df oa| pbf lfdcfchm eaiivhcps(

Pbgp cu$ g eaiivhcps }bf|f ivpvgd uvlicuucah gh` eaddgla|gpcah }a|j pamfpbf| ch

eaa~f|gpcah }cpb Ma` pa l|chm glavp pbf |f`fi~pcah gh` ughepcocegpcah ao bvighjch`(

]cpbavp g P|chcpg|cgh pbfadams pbf Ebv|eb cu vhgldf pa ~|aedgci$ lapb pbf vhcps gh` pbf

`cupchepcfhfuu ao Ma`u }a|j ch pbf oa|efu ao ighu fhc|ahifhp gh` Ma`u }a|j ao

|fmfhf|gpcah }cpbch pbf uavd ao igh(07

C `a |feamhc{f pbgp pbf Eb|cupcgh eaiivhcps$ vhdcjf pbf Ma`bfg`$ eahpgchu odg}u(

Bvighcpcfu `fofepu$ ba}ff|$ `a hap `fup|as pbf frgi~df ~|ac`f` ch pbf P|cvhf Ma`bfg`(

Chupfg`$ pbf ia`fd ao `cchf eaiivhcps ubavd` jff~ pbf lfdcfchm eaiivhcps iachm

oa|}g|` pa Ma`-u chpfh`f` ~v|~auf ao vhcps }cpbch `cf|ucps( Pbf eaiivhcps ao Eb|cup gciu

pa}g|` ~|ac`chm g fhvf ao geeavhpglcdcps }bf|f cpu ifilf|u mcopu g|f fheav|gmf` ua pbgp

f`cocegpcah ao pbf }badf la`s cu geeai~dcubf`(

Ch g up|cep ,Ahfhfuu, cf} ao pbf Ma`bfg` ahds g uchmdf ifilf| frcupu( Kfuvu ucpu

gdahf gu E|fgpa| gh` uvupgchf| ao gdd pbchmu$ eavhufdchm }cpb ha ahf: gh` ~auufuuchm gdd `cchf

~a}f|( Dcjf g `cchf gvpg|eb$ Kfuvu-u ahds eahef|h |fadfu g|avh` }bgp cu lfup oa| Bci( Ha

ufhuf ao `cchf eaiivhcps frcupu ch pbfc| Vhcpg|cgh Ma`bfg`$ gu uveb: pbf V^EC aopfh |fodfepu

g ~adcps ao gvpba|cpgpcf chodfrclcdcps |flvoochm `cupchepcfhfuu ao Eb|cupcgh pbavmbp gh`

07^gvd ]fupah( f`($Dfudcf Hf}lcmch Icuucahg|s Pbfadamcgh; G \fg`"M|gh` \g~c`u; ]i( L(Ff|`ighu vldcubchm Ea($ >?#$ 25(

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

16/22

7?

~|gepcef( Pbavmb ebv|ebfu igs fi~das uff|gd upgoo ifilf|u$ pbf c`fg ao g dfg`f|ubc~

~dv|gdcps `afu hap och` iveb p|gepcah }cpbch iaup V^EC ec|edfu(

Maf|hifhpgdds$ V^EC g`a~pu g ldfh`f` ~adcps ao eahm|fmgpcahgdcui gh`

~|fulspf|cghcui(0 V^EC ebv|ebfu pa |gcuf

uv~~a|p( C }gu g`iahcubf` ls pbf Oa|fcmh Icuucahu @f~g|pifhp pa lf g}g|f ao gh` alfs pbf

g|cavu daegd upgh`g|`u( @cualf`cfhef pa daegd upgh`g|`u "ffh co C }gu hap ig`f g}g|f ao

pbfi# icmbp lf egvuf oa| }cpbbad`chm ochghecgd uv~~a|p( Pbf daegd ~gupa| aopfh `fpf|ichf` pbf

}a|pbchfuu ao g icuucahg|s ls bcu }cofu g`bf|fhef pa pbf `|fuu ea`f( Pbavmb pbf V^EC igs

edgci alf`cfhef pa badchfuu upgh`g|`u g|f hap ugdcoce$ pbf daegd ebv|eb ~|gepcef ufh`u g

f|s `coof|fhp ifuugmf( Daegd ~gupa|u offd kvupcocf` ch pbfc| gepcahu lfegvuf @cup|cep gh`

Hgpcahgd aoocecgdu ~|aiapf cp pb|avmb pbfc| ~|fgebchm gh` ~|gepcef(

Ochgd Pbavmbpu

Pbf V^ECu a|pba~|grs ~|aiapfu pbf c`fg pbgp pbauf }ba bgf hap ,alfsf` Gepu

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

20/22

\fdcghef ah }a|ju oa| ugdgpcah e|fgpfu pbf hfefuug|s |aai oa| ebv|eb dfg`f|u pa eai~avh`

dcupu ao daegd |fwvc|fifhpu hfefuug|s pa jff~ ahfu ugdgpcah( Dfg`f|ubc~u ~a}f| pa

`fpf|ichf apbf|u ugdgpcah ~|a`vefu g evdpv|f ao chuvdg|cps ~vubchm avp ghs }ba igs

ebgddfhmf pbf upgpvu wva( Pbf La`s ao Eb|cup$ pbfh$ efgufu pa lf `cf|uf lvp pv|hu avp pa lf

fredvucf pa pbauf }ba oadda} pbf |vdfu( Ba}ff|$ pbf ~dv|gdcps ao pbf P|chcps `figh`u g

ia`fd ao Eb|cupcgh eaddgla|gpcah pbgp oaevufu ah m|gefovd chpf|gepcah }cpbch pbf ifilf|u(

Pbf|foa|f$ oa| pbf V^EC pa geef~p pbf bcupa|ce `aep|chf ao pbf P|chcps }avd` |fwvc|f g

eai~dfpf af|bgvd ao cpu ~adcps gh` ~|aedgigpcah pbvu uavh`chm pbf `fgpb jhfdd oa| pbf

a|mghc{gpcah gu g }badf(

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

21/22

5(

Ufdo$ Ebg|dfu( ]a|d` Eb|cupcghcps C Ogdd 7$ 72(

Vhjha}h( ,@aep|chgd _cf}u(, G|pcedfu( bpp~;!!}}}(v~ec(a|m!eai~ahfhp!eahpfhp!g|pcedf!7

7/30/2019 Historical Doctrine of Trinity and Polemic UPCI

22/22

?(