DALE W. BROADWATER EXECUTIVE DIRECrOA

George Ellis, President

PA Coal Association

212 North Third Street

Harrisburg, PA 17111

COAL MINE COMPENSATION RATING BUREAU OF PENNSYLVANIA

COMMERCE BUILOING - SUITE 1403 300 NORTH SECOND STREET

HARRISBURG, PENNSYLVANIA 17101

February 16, 2011

Re: PA Bituminous Underground, Surface, and Prep Plant Classes

Federal Black Lung Cla ims Activity

Data Source: Exhibit VIII-B-2, pages 1-3 from CM-1-2010

Dear George:

TELEPHONE/FAX 717-238-5020

Per our telephone conversation of February 9, 2011, 1 am providing the following requested

data for Federal Black Lung claims awarded against PA Bituminous operators In the 2000 through 2009

time frame. The attached three pages are taken from our current pending loss cost filing published In

the PA Bulletin on December 18, 2010. A complete copy of our filing can be located on our web site:

www.cmcrbpa.com

The three pages are Exhibit Vlli-B-2, pages 1·3. These pages provide Federal Black Lung claim filing activity for each of our ten classifications. More than likely, you are only Interested in three (3) of

the classes, Bituminous Underground, Bituminous Surface, and Bituminous Prep Plant. I have

highlighted tne Bituminous sections oftne exnlblts. In summary, these exhibits display a total of only

four (4) currently awarded Federal OD claims to date in ten years for the three bituminous classes

combined; however, we have anticipated that the ultimate number of awarded claims will exceed 15 .

when the data is fully mature.

However, I must warn you that interpretation of this data Is different than what appears at face

value. For this reason, the following conditions/restrictions must be considered when explaining the

data:

1) Our data is captured and coded by tne miner's social security number. This prevents multiple

counting of claims from one miner where the miner and/his survivors file more than one Federal

Claim. If a Federal claim Is denied and the miner re-files a new claim, the total filing activity of

this social security number Is considered one claim In our database 2) The "Year'' designated on the exhibits is the year of the miner's last exposure date; lt is not the

year when the claim Is flied or adjudicated

3) The award status (awarded, pending or denied) is the current status of each claim as of

4/30/2010. The award status of each claim does change over time. Ever if a claim Is currently

coded as awarded or denied, the decision can be appealed and the current decision can be

overturned.

4) All claims included in these exhibits must be Initially flied with DOL on or before 12/31/2009

5) The number of "reported" claims is the sum of the Awarded, Pending and Denied in each line

6) Only "Primary'' Federal claims are included in the exhibits

a) Only one federal claim filing per social security number is categorized as primary. This

eliminates the counting of multiple claims filed by the same miner and/or his survivors

b) If the miner also has filed a State Black Lung claim (verified by the social security number),

the Primary designation is assigned to only one claim so that potential values of both claims

are not prospectively recognized; if the Primary design a~ ion is assigned to the State OD

claim, no Federal OD claim would be Included In the exhibits. '

7) Claims included are only where a standard Workers Compensation policy with coal classes was

issued by a licensed Insurance carrier and purchased by the employer; the exhibits do not

Include claims against employers th~t are self-insured for Federal coverage

8) The time line for Federal OD claims from the miner's last exposure date, to the claim filing date,

to the f inal adjudication of the claim is measured in years, not months.

9} Just because the last several years have little or no claims currently filed or awarded does not

mean that ultimately there will be no awards. The more recent the year, the less mature the

data. look at the "IBNR" column on the tables (IBNR stands for "incurred, but not reported").

This column total Is higher than the reported column, indicating that less than 30% of the

estimated ultimate Bituminous claims for these 10 years have been filed to date.

10) A better number for comparison purposes Is the "Expected Ultimate Awarded" claim column.

This value contemplates the anticipated aggregate number of awards when the data ls mature

The counting of claims by insurance carriers as to reported and awarded is a complex and often

misunderstood topic. I have attempted to alert you to concepts subject to misinterpretation by non­

Insurance personnel. Should you wish to discuss the enclosed exhibits or the dialogue contained in this

letter, please contact me and a meeting can be arranged.

Attachments

Very truly yours,

Dale W. Broadwater

Executive Director

COAL IIINECOMPI!HIUITION RAT1N41!UR!AU ..,._ Vlll-11-2

P•t• 1 FEDERAL II.UIC OCCUPATIONAL DISEASE

AHTHRACI're UNDERGROUND [OliO) 10.YIII O.o400 ~- Slol<M4do Edlllllod Froq~>~ncy Payroll

IIINR+ - U11oolla Averaot Adj1111mtnl Mlllor ClliiNpw\00 WolahiOd Yl!l!: l!W£IIll ~ ~ .l!tD!d li!Wi flllllf!lA Blll2 fflll!ll lii!!U!II ~ Ella Yllll .bi!DI:.YB!l f!!m!!w

2000 I 0 ·a I 0.1430 11.1430 OJ1&7184 1,:110.168 II.Of7184 i11 1.031 ~1.6 0.1378 2001 4 2 D 2 11.2~ 11.2401 0.- 1,1311,522 Z.OMOIO 1144 1.11,11 47.1 ··-2002 0 0 0 D 0.:1888 D.2elll 0.107ol52 1,381,541 0.111746:1 ee2 1.031 311.! 0.2169 2003 0 0 0 0 O.UII7 0.3287 0.1,1iio0 1 ,~ 0.131114 875 1.031 37.2 0.3646 .2004 0 0 0 0 0.4118 0.4118 0.104738 1,345,321 0.1S47lll m 1.038 38.1 0.4K3 2005 D 0 0 0.54117 ue1 0.216678 1,417,&all 0.21118'1e 710 1.038 36.7 0.!858 2006 1 0 .o 0.8811 1.81118 0.0001 1,<442,524 0.818168 745 1.03!1 au. 1.8861 2007 0 0 0 0.11612 0.1812 D.31144Q2 1,ee:!.5S7 Ull44112 m 1.038 38.5 O.iT.I4 211011 0 0 0 ·o 1.4183 1.<4083 0.517718 Z.131,711 0.687716 807 1.038 48.1 1.lt70 .i.Q!l!! ___ o ___ o __ o ___ o

~ 1.1~ ~ 1,337,3&1 ~ 13& 1.{1;)8 _...1M ~ '!OTAL B 2 ' 1 3 1.1190 7.1190 2.1758BO 16,0111.115 U711UD 301.6 11.84115

AveRAGE 1.1850

~ BITUMINOUS UNDEIIC!llCUND [0151) O.IMI e.,.- St-· Elholl<l Frequency Payroll

IIINR+ AwaAI Ulllnua A••u• MjUitmo;,l toirJol Clalml pos1DO Yillgtud ~ RIU:I!ll ~ ~ ~ l!l!:IR f!nl!m Bl!l!! fl\!llll A'6!!!a!! ~ Em Y!l! .!i!I.!..Y!I!1 ft.twla

2000 7 0 0 7 2.81125 2.11825 0.128752 47,S20,e!l2 0.121'1t2 111 1.311Z 1.11746 0.01W 2001 3 0 1 2 11871 4.1&71 0.2000111 41,52%.130 0.2000111 1144 1.392 1,040.1 0.0182 2002 10 0 2 8 3.0763 5.0783 0.24*4 40,!37,11111i O.l43184 862 1.3112 152.2 D.ll28ll 2003 0 0 0 0 3.1127 3.1321 0.1&0388 36,4SI,«lll 0.150SBI 876 1.3112 747.0 0.0201 2004 z 0 1 1 4.47tli 6.41'15 0.212031 48,073.100 0.2112D1 eto U112 1122.6 0.0216 2005 0 0 0 0 7.11M 7.11168 0.348'3e7 1111,275,756 0.3453&7 710 1.3112 1,271.1 O.Q%70 2006 1 1 0 0 1.60U 1.5024 0.4tl8118 70,415,837 1.4tl811e 741 1.382 1,1108.7 0.1078 2007 2 0 G z 10.7361 10.7351 0.515287 79,1104,21!6 0.5162!7 m !.382 1.~17.1 GOJe~ 2001 1 0 1 0 15.088S 10.0813 o.mm 101,SU,I77 0,71121'8 807 1.382 1,735.1 0.11415 2!1!!1! ___ 0 ___ o __ o ___ o

~ -!!:!ll! ~ BR.IIIIZ.II04 ~ ~ 1.3112 ~ ~ TOTAL 211 w 7411443 11.0443 3.1137328 637,1C8.032 4.113'/m 12,022.3 o.mz

AVERAGE D.D373

ANTIIAACITE IURFACE (01Q) o.zoo ~ Stnwido EIIIMIOd Froquonc:y ~I

IBNR+ - Ullinll!o ""'"'""' Adjuolmn1 Min.- Clorn pos100 ~hlod

Yua: . .IWDII A9als!l f!n!lilg_ ~ Ji!IR fiD!IJDa !!lllil fllllliL &!sDIQ ~ ~ lD!l l6l:lLr!n ~ 2000 e 0 I s 1.5271 ~.li211 0.101&88 11.8C7,t10 0.- 111 1.038 501.8 o.1m Z001 e 0 1 5 '1.3QI7 2.31187 0.471141 12,1123,7~1 0.~7'117411 844 1.038 :Jl'U 0.1280 20112 I 1 0 6 1.o4007 1.<4007 OJ801CZ 11,0<11,&70 1.211014.2 11112 1.031 3QII.1 0.41<12. ~ 1 0 1 0 1.1~13 2.7413 0.541258 11,128,2!10 0.1141255 m 1.0!1 :121.4 0.187& 2llll4 3 1 0 2 :1.0771 2.0778 0,415558 12.361,731 1.41558 8110 1.03l! uu OA285 2008 2 1 0 1 2.112SY 2.3267 OAM1o!Z 12,140,111 1.4801~2 711 1.038 314.2 O.o411113 :2ooe 1 0 1 0 Z.t!:ll 3,61J& 0.122B84 1Z.OU,W 0.7221184 741 1.038 300.0 IU«<II 2007 1 1 0 0 3.83211 3.~ 07211W 14,111111,558 1.7ZWI 771 1.038 353.0 0.4863 2008 0 0 0 0 U417 4.74t7 0.- 1II,JIIII.ol03 ll84IS40 - 1111 1.038 37U 0.2542 ~---0 ---!

__ o ___ o ~ ..._!!!!ll 1.113808 1!,~1112 .....l:1l!!!! ne 1.038 ~ ~ .

'TOTAL 211 4 8 11 27.0332 :IS.nu:l ~ 138,a!O,I>Q 10.11C11841 1,542.4 :1.0815 AVERAGE 0.3Qt1

9 BITUIIINOUI SURFACI! (11&11 0.17& EJopeciOd s- ElliNted froq._ p:oyron

III!IR. - .u,_ "-· .ActUICmonl MNr CIUII1 pw1oo WlfuiUod lH ~ ABlAU bnlllaa ~ 1IIHI! fiDIIm I!IIIR fJmll ~ ~ fllii!JI: ua l&lllLYW. ·~

11000 7 2 1 ~ 1.1840 2. 114G 0.8111137 48,113S,m 2.311!137 111 1.~ 1,114.1 0.11111 2001 3 0 0 3 1.7588 1.7111 O.SOIIII H,151,:SU 0.3081111 844 1.031 1,87:1.1 0.01811 2002 2 0 0 z I.IHO 1.116611 0.34401ll 13.102.1116 11.3441171 e82 1.031 1,4117.3 0.0230 2003 1 D 0 1 2.0705 2.0708 O.M4C15 ~?~740 O.:IIC411 m 1.038 l,a14.0 0.11277 2004 1 0 0 1 2.1483 2.84113 O.aJOOC5 lill,217,218 0.50014!1 880 1.038 1,601.5 0.0332 200ii 0. 0 1 UQ87 1.8087 O.IIIUUT.! 84,17\,112 11.168172 718 1.0311 1,871.1 O.IZIWI 2008 0 0 1 .ueoe 4.21105 0.74111U1 113,7i!!.l502 0.7.at41 7«1 1.0311 1.5U.5 o.ocn ~ 1 0 I 4.11110 4.1118 o.rem 84,101,083 1.11111505 711 1.Q311 1,541.3 0.1210 20011 1 0 1 0 1.3411 7.3411 1.21l21134 74,10\211 1.2Z(\34 8l17 1.038 1,712.7 0,07$4 Zlllfl ___ o ___ o __ o ___ o

~ ~ ~ e40C4.14C ~ 136 1.038 ~ ~ TOTAL ,. 3 I 14 36.:1111 :J7.38&1 U7t771 517,104,401 u111m lUlU 0.11210

AVERAGE 0.0821

FOUR ITANDAIUl ClAISEB 0.1&1 e.ocud St..-. Eo'lrnllod froqullnt)'

IBIIR+ - ~.~-...... _

/4uolmM11 lollrw a.\'U por100 Wolghtod

~ Bwi:IR!I ~ ~ ~ u fJJ!!!klll .8112 flmlll AwiW!l ~ fSl :(1m Mkl!LYIID. fllllllwx 2000 21 2 4 1li um a.ecn 1.511011 1111,634,153 :1.4171411 111 1,1;)11.7 0.1101 2001 1ft z 2 12 1.6127 I.M27 1.3114118 121,234,232 S.oi6D11 e.« 3,1U7 0.018& 2!102 11 1 2 16 8.7008 8.70QI 1.313402 108,77S.181i U7113J 11112 2PJ,4 O.IJT:I:I. 2003 2 0 1 1 7.2742 8..27o!Z 1.3155G& 117,1164,11:10 1.11141123 175 2,426.1 o.ocP 2004 8 1 1 ~ 1.1074 10.1074 1.718373 11a.aee.zso Z.S43170 1110 2.100.0 0.0837 2005 ! 1 0 2 11.117411 13.8748 2.208085 144,11)5,~ 2.111t171 711 ~.aou 0.0111 2006 • 1 2. 1 11.0813 18.011113 2.1721M 147,'712,2116 1.H7~18 746 3,228.1 0.1102 2007 5 i 0 3 20.2-470 20.2470 32.18285 111,l41,452 4.4111111 771 3.351.6 0.1340 2001 t 0 2 0 27.12e4 211.121M C.710442 1114.~7,324 1.1100174 11m 5,171).3 0.01190 m _ __ o ___ o __ o ___ o

~ ~ ~ 11011S1,481 ~ 1131 ~ --11!!!! TOTAL n 10 14 13 143.5118 117.1518 1UQD321 1,3C11,300,78t u.am:u 31,402.4 0.11310

AVEIWlE o.ma 0.0&7111

so=o: Clokn eaunli • CI.ICRB 00 DRbuo u o/41300010 IBNR: EoN>~! WI-C-8, p4 Payrul~ eMil\ X.A MBAinc.·PAJ '!lie Mtltd Rlfio II IC!\flllo AWl- + (AvM<Iul piUI Dorilll). Otler CIMtM u1011lo Tolal AWIId Rollo: 0.156>10 I [10 + 541 Fill~ Oat. ·Ooce~r 03.2010 ThoWI;oMJullm.,t Foctot- dii!Yodlromtii:RB IIIlA. See ElH>IIX-G Etllmalodllinii'Y,..•PIIV!'II/[~WWx!4.F.-•~ !: .... MI'!U-P'4Mur.-Y--n:.,,._... ... l"+ ... .._.. ... llret &M..,..,y..,-\.,4M

COAL MINE COMPEH8,6.l10N RA llNO !lf.lftE.o\U

FEDERAL BASIC OCC\JPATIONAI. CIIIE',6.81!

COKE(01141

IBNR~

Yw ~ ~ f!D!Iklll .l1!!1!lsl Jll!i!l fllllb. 2000 0 0 0 0 0.10111 0.1011 2001 0 0 0 D 0.1087 0.1067 2002 0 0 0 0 0.1233 0.1233 200S 0 0 0 0 0.1631 0.1531 2004 0 0 0 0 0.1111 ·0.1616 2005 0 .0. 0 0 0.2172 U172 2008 0 0 0 0.23115 02385 2007 0 0 0 11.2111 0.2&18 2001 0 0 0 0 0.2211 0.22158

Z2Qi --· _o ____ _ o __ o ___ o

~ ~ TOT,6.L 0 a 0 1.1728 1.77211

AV!!RIIOE

AUOER(OU7) IBNR Fodor 14ju>llld l>y0.400D-

IBNR+ ~ ~ ~ fJ!IIbl l!lnll!l Wlfl f.lo.lh

2000 0 0 0 0 . a.a213 0.0213 2001 0 0 0 0 0Jl2t4 0.0284 2002 0 0 a 0 0.0271 0.0271 2003 0 0 0 0 0.()2gJ O.C293 2004 0 0 0 a a.Q311 0.03111 2005 0 0 0 0 0.0347 a.0347 2008 0 0 0 0 OJioiiOO 0.0400 2007 0 0 0 0 O.G482 0.04112 2008 0 0 0 0 0.1te.! 0.11116 alm ___ o ___ a __ o ___ o ---2:!'§.2! ~

TOTAL 0 0 0 0_~170 0.4270 AVERAGE

ANTHRACilt: C04EN (0111) IBI'IR footor ldjuotod ~O.fiOOO

t8NR+ WB llW!!I!I 6UIUI f.lmJIIQ. .lll.aiH Wl8 . b!Q

2000 0 0 0 0 0.01181 0.0111111 2001 0 0 0 0 0.11fi 0.11811 2111Z 1 0 t 0 D.1811J 1.1883 Zlll3 a 0 0 a 0.2321 0.3128 2004 0 0 0 0 0.2788 0.2788 2005 1. 0 0 1 0.3317 0.3317 20011 0 0 0 0 o.u:ll ~-2007 0 0 0 0 0.~734 0.4734 2008 0 0 0 0 04311 0.<1381 m ___ o ___ o __ o ___ o

~~ TOTAL 2 1 3.0338

AVERAGE

BITUMINOUS C0-4EN (Gilt) IBNR Factor O<Quatod by 0.5000

xw ~ ~ EIDlliDII .l!tD!!ll IW:B 2000 0 0 0 0 0.0411 2001 0 0 0 0 0.0&40 2002 0 0 0 0 0.0701 2003 0 0 0 0. 0.1011 2004 0 0 0 0 0.2400 .2005 0 0 a 0 0.3&00 2001 0 0 0 0 0.4411 2007 0 0 0 0 0.11580 2001 0 0 0 0 0.48211 m! ___ o ___ o __ ·o ___ o

~ TOTAL 0 0

AVERAGe

Sou~ta: CiU1I COU"III• CNCRB 00 Oollbau • of >113D13)1D IBNR; Eldllbtt VII~. p4 Paytoi~ E>chiii!X-A·1

2.1843

~-03311

IBNR+ fDIDg,

0.041:1 O.G.548 0 . .0701 0.1013 0.2AOO 0.31100 0.4412 o.55ao 0.4928

~ 2.8843

0.158 AwMi l!l!lR

0.01\1881 O.D1e&IS 0.01112.31 a.azl!8&4 O.QZD14 O.OJIIII3 11.0312011 IUI4!011 D.005Sf1 ~

D.271621

0.168 AWIId BJig

0.0033D 0«14518 0.0042Za. 0004571 0.004178 0.005413 0.0011240 0.007207 0.011174

~ o.oeee12

0.1M

-~~~ Bd! 0.018418 O.D1170o6 0.181US O.OJI288 0.043111 0.06174! 0.081443 0.073160 0.01111~1

~ OJI28273

0.1&e Awanf .!!Ill!!

O.OIJII443 0.001618 0.010838 0.018103 0.037~40 O.OMteO. O.o&aa27 0.1187048 0.071111411

~ 0.4481151

~ Statewldo Ultlmoio AY~n~~l

Emllll Wllllll ~ 12.082,574 O.D111et\ 111 10,378,821! 0,0101145 644 1o.-416,00S 0.0111235 182 11,SS4,DIO O,IQ38H m 12.041,128 0.021114 1110 12.U0,178 O.tl33813 711 12,1'Sl',,. 0.0137208 745 1~ ..... Hli a.oovu1 778 8,781,141 0.035381 807 !173,112 ~ 331

110,738,807 0.%111528

EllpoclocS -U111mole "Y!'flllll f!mll ~ ~

1.205,817 0.0013323 811 1,429,131 0.004SI8 1544 1,1i0,143 0.004221 ~ 582 1,102.223 0.004571 . 175 1.a.a.1ee 0.004V78 1110 1,D2a,537 0-006413 718 1,0118,831 0008240 745 1,121.1&8 0.00'1207 719 2,15011,7S8 0.01117~ 1107 1157~1 ~ 8~

12.125,178 0.0He12

Elpo;lod &i.11w!do ~. Avwoqo

frllg! ~ ~ 4.473,4!8 O.DIS41~ 811 4,881,113 D.Di8104 844 6,851,774 0.11114:1 eez 7,009,1111 O.DM2fll 675 7,311,514 0.041111 880 7,155,21111 0.051741 718 M12.627 0.0111441 745 8,1111,7011 0.073850 m 7,5;!1,400 0.011141 807 7,!15,1186 ~ 838

1!9,744,1185 O.S28273

E>cptolad SlatwM<Io UIIIINII A-o

Emil ~ ~ U70,720 0.00844'.1 111 2,121,121 0.008511 644 2.UI,12>4 0.010831 M2 3,052,62:l O.OWIOI 575 1\374,413 0.057~ 880 1,624,7&2 O.D5ll180 711 8,421,575 0.081121' 745

10,128.140 0.017041 m 1,481,111a 0.0781141 1117 7,asa,87t ~ 1198

01,004,216 0.44tllli1

l'hoA...n!Rollola o'IJII IDAWIIniod• 11\!IIMIOdtau Dolllod). OlhorCluooo .. o il>e TOial AWifl! Rolo; 0.15e-101 [10 +54) ThoWa~ Ac(uofmon\F-=IorW11odorilllldf111mCIIW dllill.8u Eld"loll X.O Elt"'oltd Mhot YHrl • Pl)'ral! I(SI.V.Wx Ad!. FKID< x 52) . "

~onl

.ESI! 1.1131 1-031 1.031 1.0311 1.051 1.031 1.031 f.OJI 1.038 1.031

Acl)lllmont .EGl21

1.0311 1.0JI 1.038 1.031 1.038 1.!131 1.<Xll 1.038 1.1131 1.038

.o\41olrolf11 , !lli!lir:

1.0JI 1.031 1.0JI 1~ 1.D31 f.OJI I.OJI 1.038 f.OJI 1.038

""""""" ... f.Wl 1.031 1.0JI 1.031 1.031 1.D31 1.031 1.031 1.03& 1.038 f.OSI

Extilbl Vlll-8-3 Pogo%

111-YNr e.lli!lllld F.-q- Payroll Min~r Clllmopw100 ~~ Y!m Ml!lK..YUI ~

3118.7 0.11045 ;!11.5 0.0051 mA 0.0018 31&1 0.0071 1123.1 o.ooea 3UI 0.0102 S"le.8 0.0111 !Z5.1 0.013& 22<4.1 a. om

---11!! __!!!!!!! 2,912.2 0.102S

0.01013

Elllmetod f'lllqUoncy MNr CIIIOII por 100 WolgNod

Y!!r! l!!m:!!m fallli.lorlt :18.1 D.OCtf

-41.1 0.0112 32.2 OD131 30.3 0.0151 21t4 0.0175

·~ O.o»> 28.5 0.0235 28.7 D.DVO 57.6 o.oa•

____!g ~ 327.1 02067

01l2118

Ellillattd ~II"ICII NN< Ct~ll'lll porfOO Wtl!tltod :wa MlliUUI DIAIIIII&I:

136.8 0.0114 134.1 0.0131 158.4 0.1141 1112.4 0.0111 1117.4 0.0211 2013 0.11256 211112 0.0294 21U 0~

1727 0.01191 ~ ~

1,7to.3 0.3550 0.011511

Elllmolocl ,_ "'""' Cloiml ,., 100 Woi;htocl :um ~ f'lllllllllll:

18.7 0.0114 no 0.014/1 18.1 0.0184 83.8 0.01811

171.2 O.Dl11 :z:zo.e ~

234.1 0.0284 267.li Q.033I 184.7 0.03811

----1!!2 ~ 1,m.8 0.2571

0.0257

MBA 11c.· ~AI Aln; Oat• - O.c:.mb~~rO;, 2:110

__,.,

COII.L IIIIPE COMP!NSATION RAl;ING BUREAU

FEllERAL BASIC OCCUPATIONAI..lltSI!AIIE

ANTHRA9J1E PIU!P PLANT (11113j

Ym l!w!ll!! ~ ~ l!.U!! lliN!i 2000 1 0 1 0 0.0683 l1101 0 0 0 0.1140 2CII2 0 0 0 D.1358 ;!IIOS 0 0 0 0 ~ 2CD4 1 0 1 0 0.3311 2006 0 0 0 0 D. ..sill 20011 0 0 0 0 M6l'i 2007 0 0 0 0 O.&t86 2008 0 0 0 0 0.1111110 m ___ o ___ o __ o ___ o

~ TOTAL 2 0 2 0 Ull24

1\VIIfiiJI

BITUMINOUS PREP PLANT(0114b, --= IMR Fact& QusGd 'i OMOl

~ Blm!l!t ~ ~ llJill!!1 mtiB zoo 0 0 0 0 0.1illl8 2001 0 0 0 0 D.:z81Z 2002 1 0 1 0 0.21187 2003 0 0 0 0 0.:1313 ' 2004 0 0 D 0 D.606! 21115 0 0 D 0 II.OHa 2008 0 0 0 0 0.711113 2007 0 0 D 0 0.8717 2001 0 0 0 0 1.2341 m ___ o ___ D __ o ___ o

1.3171! TOTAl. 1 0 D 8.8148

Awraao

TOTAL CIT11ER CUSSES

~ Bsalll ~ ~ l:!tlllli1 B 2000 1 0 1 0 0.5168 2001 0 D 0 D 0.11151 2002 1 0 l 0 0.112!11 200:1 0 D 0 0 1.Clt011 ~ 1 0 1 0 1.5508 2005 , 0 0 , 2.01110 20011 0 0 0 0 UIIM 1!001 0 0 0 0 U3211 20011 0 0 0 0 1.1T211 Zll!ll ___ o ___ a __ o ___ o

~ TOTAL 6 1 18.68411

Avtrogo

GRANO TOTAL

:tEa ~ 6Yt1DIJ!l l.C!IIIIca lll!ll!!l 1111:18 2000 22 2 & 11 &.Otn1 2001 Ill 2 2 12 7.2415 2llC2 za 1 4 16 7.6207 200:1 z 0 1 1 U&SO 2CD4 7 1 2 4 11.171a 200!i 4 1 0 3 1S.IIB:!e. 2008 4 2 1 11.4317 2007 B I) s U.17M 2008 2 0 2 D 80.1&J!I2 221111 0

___ o __ o ___ o ....mm TOTAL 12 10 11 64 1121415 ... _.

!loon:e; Cloi'n COIJnll• ~B 00 Doteb- M of ~10 IBNR: E>hlbi \Ill~ p4 PO)I'OII- Eicnlot x.t.-1

o.1111 IBNR+ AMid ~ .BIIl!l

1.0S&3 O.I!I6CIINI 0.1140 0.017.7114 0.1388 0.1121310 0.22112 O.DM217 USII ll.2017II 0.4386 0.0111110 0.4115 0.071370 o,&gas 0.08Si22 0.6680 0.10181111 ~ 0.130400

5.1162. O.V14534

0.1611 ·JBNR+ -eBb BlfQ

0.11811 0.02111i31 CUII12 0.0401Q 1.211117 0.202285 O.utl 0.052775 0.501\11 O.Dl'a1 11.1815 0.1011013 0.7111S 0.1245311 0.87'57 0.151881 1.a41 , 0.1112510

__!!1!! ~ 7,8148 1.117i01l

0.11111 IBNR+ A-d J!llllb allli!

1.5151 0.2384CIIi CJIIII 0.106815 2.1201 0.4381138 1.01108 0.18111011 2Ji6111 D.40073S 2.11710 0.12>4124 z.- 0.:11!'11128 2.113215 0.4674111 :1.1'128 0.-~ 0.&251110

22.5841 3.&241104

0.1150 IBNR• AMra ~ &Ia 11.08.'1 1.728142 1.2AM 1.4CZl'llll

11.6207 1,'187235 Uillll t.45i3711

1:1.11162 2.-11,1138 2.481'781 20.4377 3.188217 23.17111 ·U111010 112.711112 6.1111!122

..rum ...!1!lli! 1B0.1485 211. 1028&2

Ellp- 6-111 ~

... _. flltDIIl liiiiOIIi ~

1,318,4ee 0.1150115 e11 2,218,2811 0.017114 844 2,322,1111 O.Oll110 t62 1,407,1191 0.035217 171 4,«lli,8B3 0.207781 1190 5,170,061 0.061'110 7111 •.w.w 0.071S70 745 6,817,2111 D.Oill622 778 6.7S3,543 0.10181111 407 ~s ... ,I2S ~ 1138

~1.1111,1311 o.v~

lillpoclod 81a!Ao<40o Ull..,to AYirlll!ll

I!IY!ml MI!Ull ~ 8,61'4,1110 O.D215S1 Ill

10,155,02i 0.040l'Q 1144 10,0114,548 0.20I2AIII 112 10,1111.206 0.0111776 lf75 11,410,201 0.0790111 m 111~1107 0.1011013 718 17,050.187 0.124136 7411 11,185,11l! 0.111197 7711 21,2!10.2111 0.1111.520 807 11,t1t,581 ~ 1130

148,144,061 1.1171011

f>pociU 81-llllmllo ... ._. f!m!ll AuiUJt ~ N,liiii.BiS 0.2154111! 811 IO,IBI,GII 0.10UH ~ 32,08!,110 D.43tt311 1!12 34,301,1141 0.18811015 176 44,700,ne a.400733 11811 51,116,1131 0.3243:14 71t M.61'7,1711 0.:1011026 745' 111,1118,410 11.411748e 771 55,2.54,1181 D.411481f7 807 47,A22!518 o.aiillee 83$

441,1511,883 3.824104

.,.,_ SlallrMdo Uli!malrl .......

J!IWl lillil!!lsl ~ 14&,171,0011 3.714114 811 152, 113,11&7 3.11111111! ~ 138,117'1,306 :2.41&2e8 162 1:13,11e0,ZII8 1.313$211 178 1110,1117,0211 2.74480S 1190 1i11,8t1,728 a.CU6D1 T11 201,1411,C UZ7048 745 220,'/110,11112 4.114~ m 2411,812.316 4.118B331 401 22!,154,048 ~ 1:111

1,1111,167,8112 ~!.424131

Tho AWIId Aallo II oquaJ to 1\wen!od • (/\wolrlod piUs Dtnlod). O!hor C111•11 \Ill tho Tolllli>~Nord Rallo: 0.161!-10 I (10 • 54) Tho woge Adjuolrn•t Foetor Wll der1vocl ln!m CIACRB - Sao E><hlblt lG.G ~aJ .... atM U:wuwVIU!t!l•PJiill'ltMilRA'NNvArli FIIW'Mr•,;"

""'""'"'" .Eill2£ 1.031 1.031 1.1131 1.018 1.a3a 1.D38 1.D:l8 1.038 1.D38 I.D38

Adju-.Elm!:

1.ll82 I.S82 1.182 1.ll92 1.392 1.:!112 1l!IIZ 1:192 1.382 1.302

AdjUI-.1 Eat

A<l!wlrr!llll fl!il!l£

E>hl~~ VlH.P.2 Pagt 3.1.

111-Vo.-Elllmllld ~-., PoyroN

l.inlr Cl*'•poriOO \Volglltld :t!!C! M!!li!.Ym !ml!!!!lsl

40.0 0.4121 1118 0.0211 115.0 D.o:121 w o.o:m

118.3 0.11511 13U O.O!iOI 121.6 O.DA7 118.. D.C878 1a1,1 0.0789

--.Ji9.& ~ 1,045.8 1,1)381

0.10S8

Est)nolod fr.q<~lllq'

t.flnor a.,..p..-1oo Weight Ill

:1:!111 .Yil!LYID EWIII!la 11118 0.01!12 211.8 0.0187 210.7 0.08110 201.7 O.all3 2eU o.am 319.3 0.01141 3111.2 0.1131M :ISS. I II.IW63 ISU 0.0629

__...B!1 ~ 2,711U 0.4188

o.om

E.l!mllld "-'"""' hlnor Clllml por 10.0 WIQI!tad

XIIII l&!tY!m. fiKILtDa au O.D215 IIU 0.0131 11211.5 ll..ll&2 112.6.3 D.D112

1,101.3 0.03112 t,2H.4 0'.02112 1,224.5 0.0302 1,301.3 0.0362 1,144.4 0,0433

~ ~ 10,312.3 0.31114

0.113311 0.0351S2

Eolinllld p;.quoocy ....... ()loftltptr10.0 Wllglllod

nu llniLYID ~ II,I!IU.2 0.1.18311 1,8411.0 0.11101 II,W.I 0.06115 s,seo.~ Q.0407 UOI.3 110702 4,544.7 0.0116.!1 4,413.8 0.0112 4,882.1 0.10114 &,014.7 0.0817

--21! __1!;!!! 41,7114.7 o.ms

0.0718 0.074741

MilA Inc.· ~All RHng Dale. O.Cell)ber 111 :2Cto