Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
GUNNISON COUNCIL AGENDA
MEETING IS HEAD AT CITY HALL, 201 W. VIRGINIA AVENUE
GUNNISON, CO, IN THE 2ND FLOOR COUNCIL CHAMBERS
Approximate meeting time: 3.5 hours
August 14, 2018 REGULAR SESSION 5:30 P.M.
I. Presiding Officer Call Regular Session to Order: (silent roll call by City Clerk):
II. Citizen Input: (estimated time 3 minutes)
At this agenda time, non-agenda scheduled citizens may present issues of City concern to
Council on topics on are not to be considered later in the meeting. Per Colorado, Open
Meetings Law, no Council discussion or action will take place until a later date; unless
an emergency situation is deemed to exist by the City Attorney. Each speaker has a time
limit of 3 minutes to facilitate efficiency in the conduct of the meeting and to allow an
equal opportunity for everyone wishing to speak.
III. Council Action Items:
A. Presentation on Low Income Housing Tax Credit.
Background: Representative, Natasha Weaver, with the Colorado Housing and
Finance Authority will discuss the Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC)
Program with Council.
Estimated Time: 15 minutes
B. Approval of the July 24, 2018 Regular Session meeting minutes
Background: per City Charter, the City Clerk produces minutes of the Council
actions for all regular and special session meetings. Minutes are approved or
amended at the follow regular session meetings and become permanent city
record. If a city councilor was not present no the meeting, they must abstain in the
vote and action on approval of the minutes.
Staff contact: Deputy City Clerk Tara Kindall
Action Requested of Council: To approve the July 24, 2018 Regular Session
meeting minutes.
Estimated time: 1 minute
C. Use of Right of Way for Rady Engineering Building at Western
Background: The City was approached by the Western Opportunity Fund for the
proposed construction of a University building on the property generally known
as the WSCU soccer field. An application was submitted for site development
plan review by staff and on July 25, 2018 the Planning and Zoning Commission
reviewed the request. The Commission authorized the submittal of a building
permit application with the condition that the City Council review and give final
approval of the rights-of-way use and configuration of Loveland, Georgia and
Adams Street, prior to issuance of a building permit.
Staff contact: Interim Community Development Director Andie Ruggera
Action Requested of Council: The City Council is being requested as the land
owner to approve of changes to parking and the City rights-of-way on Loveland,
Georgia and Adams Street which will enable the applicant to move forward with
obtaining a building permit.
Estimated time: 30 minutes
D. Termination of a 20-foot wide Utility Electrical Easement
Background: The City was approached by Marcus Lock, from the Law of
the Rockies, in regard to an electrical/utility easement located within the
West Gunnison Neighborhood (between 5th and 7th Street in vacated
Gunnison Avenue). The easement does not have any City utilities. On June
12, 2018, staff presented the request to terminate the 20-foot-wide utility
easement to City Council and was directed to draft a document to terminate
the easement.
Staff Contact: Interim Community Development Director Andie Ruggera
Action Requested of Council: Review and authorization of the City Mayor to
sign the Termination of Easement document for a 20-foot-wide utility easement
located in Vacated Gunnison Avenue between 5th Street and 7th Street.
Estimated time: 5 minutes
E. Temporary Tax Credit
Background: After July 3, 2018, four governing jurisdictions of the Gunnison
Valley Regional Housing Authority (GVRHA) passed resolutions granting
approval for the GVRHA to place a referred measure on the November 6, 2018
ballot. The GVRHA is asking for a tax increase on residential and commercial
properties in Gunnison County in an effort to provide more support for affordable
housing.
Contact: Mayor Jim Gelwicks
Action Requested of Council: To discuss whether or not Council will direct
Staff to draft a resolution to absorb 2/3 of the increased property tax amount for
the first year of tax increase, if the referred measure is passed by the voters.
Estimated time: 15 minutes
F. Discussion on Policy for Disposal of City-Owned Land/Ordinance No. 10,
Series of 2018
Background: As part of the deliberation related to Lazy K, the City Attorney
provided her opinion that disposal of Lazy K since it does not have a dedicated
use could be conveyed without a vote of the people. Furthermore, after reviewing
recent case law the City Attorney recommend the City create a policy on the
conveyance of City owned property. The Council on July 24th directed staff to
prepare a draft policy for their consideration which would also inform the
decision to call for a special election on Lazy K.
Staff contact: City Attorney Kathy Fogo
Action Requested of Council: To discuss and provide feedback on draft
Ordinance No. 10, Series 2018; Re: An Ordinance of the City Council of the City
of Gunnison, Colorado Adopting a Policy for Disposition of City-Owned
Property. Staff would suggest that Council first discuss this issue and then
provide direction to staff on next steps (versus taking action on Ordinance 10 on
August 14th.)
Estimated time: 10 minutes
G. Resolution No. 7, Series of 2018 to call a special election to put Lazy K on the
ballot and Lazy K ballot language.
Background: Council identified the need for livable and affordable housing
as one of its strategic priorities. Approximately 4.3 acres of the West Gunnison
property (Lazy K) has been identified as an option for affordable housing.
Staff Contact: City Attorney Kathy Fogo
Action Requested of Council: To determine if Council desires to put a question
regarding the disposal of the West Gunnison property (commonly known as Lazy
K) on the November 6, 2018, coordinated election ballot; and if so, then a vote to
pass Resolution No. 7, Series 2018, Re: A Resolution of the City Council of the
City of Gunnison, Colorado, referring a ballot question to the Qualified Electors
of the City of Gunnison to sell or otherwise convey a portion of real property
owned by the City at a Special Election to be held on November 6, 2018.
Estimated time: 10 minutes
H. Resolution No. 6, Series 2018 to approve ballot language for Charter
Background: Following Council’s direction to proceed with participation in the
November 6, 2018, Coordinated Election, a resolution containing the ballot
language needs to be passed by Council and final ballot language must be
submitted to the County Clerk and Recorder’s office by September 7, 2018.
Staff Contact: City Attorney Kathy Fogo
Action Requested of Council: Approve Resolution No. 6, Series 2018, Re: A
Resolution of the City Council of the City of Gunnison, Colorado, referring
ballot questions to the Qualified Electors of the City of Gunnison to amend the
Gunnison Municipal Home Rule Charter and to extend the current
Councilmember’s terms by six months at a Special Election to be held on
November 6, 2018.
Estimated time: 5 minutes
I. Review of Community Survey Questions
Background: Council directed staff to work RRC Associates to develop a
community survey to gather feedback on Council's strategic priorities and
City services.
Staff contact: City Manager Russ Forrest
Action Requested of Council: To review the draft survey and to provide
feedback to staff in order for the staff to develop final survey(s) with RRC
Associates.
Estimated time: 20 minutes
IV. Council Work/Discussion Items:
V. Reports:
City Attorney Report
City Manager Strategic Projects Update and Report
City Councilors with City-related meeting reports; discussion items for future Council
meetings
VI. Meeting Adjournment
The City Council Meetings agenda is subject to change. The City Manager and City
Attorney reports may include administrative items not listed. Regular Meetings and
Special Meetings are recorded and action can be taken. Minutes are posted at City Hall
and on the City website at www.gunnisonco.gov.Discussion Sessions are recorded;
however, minutes are not produced. For further information, contact the City Clerk’s
office at 970.641.8140. TO COMPLY WITH ADA REGULATIONS, PEOPLE
WITH SPECIAL NEEDS ARE REQUESTED TO CONTACT THE CITY CLERK
24 HOURS BEFORE ALL MEETINGS AT 970.641.8140.
low income housing tax credit (lihtc) basics
Gunnison City Council MeetingAugust 14, 2018
what is chfa?
chfa’s mission we strengthen colorado by investing in housing and
community development three lines of business
homeownership business financeaffordable rental housing
how chfa serves colorado’s housing continuum
what is affordable housing?
you should spend no more than 30% of your gross income on housing costs homeownership
principal, interest, taxes, and insurance rent
rent and utilities
how is market rate housing financed?
70% debt30% equity
how is affordable housing financed?
30% debt 70% gap
lihtc allocation process
lihtc allocation process
example: impact of tax credits @ $.95
GrantsDeferred Developer Fee
66%
28%
3%
3%
Total Project Costs $15,000,000
Tax Credit Equity $9,932,692
$400,000
Project Debt $4,167,308$500,000
Sheet1
Determination of
Tax Credit Amount
Three Calculations Performed:
Qualified Basis
Cost Reasonableness
Equity Gap
Sheet2
Qualified Basis Calculation
Total Project Costs$6,000,000
-Land Costs($150,000)
-Off Site Costs($50,000)
-Perm. Financing($20,000)
-Tax Credit Fees($20,000)
-Syndication Costs($10,000)
-Project Reserves($150,000)
Total Eligible Basis$5,600,000
Sheet6
Qualified Basis Calculation
$232,375
Cost Reasonableness Test
$228,995
Equity Gap Determination
$216,216
Annual Credit Amount $216,216
Sheet5
Total Project Costs$15,000,000
Tax Credit Equity$9,932,69266%
Project Debt$4,167,30828%
Grants$500,0003%
Deferred Developer Fee$400,0003%
Sheet4
Cost Reasonableness Test
Calculates Eligible Basis using
HUD 221(d)(3) Mortgage Limits
Eligible Basis$5,420,000
x Applicable Fraction50%
Qualified Basis$2,710,000
x Applicable %8.45%
Annual Credit Amount$228,995
Sheet3
Eligible Basis$5,600,000
x Applicable Fraction50%
Qualified Basis$2,800,000
Developer Fee Limit($30,000)
Contractor Fee Limit($20,000)
Adjusted Qualified
Basis$2,750,000
x Applicable %8.45%
Annual Credit Amount$232,375
why do lihtcs work? the developer agrees to long-term affordability
private sector assumes risk for project success
competitiveness generates strong projects
each state customizes its program through a qualified allocation plan
chfa’s qualified allocation plan (qap)
describes the process for allocation of lihtcs application process selection process for awards of lihtcs
developed and revised annually after considering public input public hearings across the state feedback from the Governor’s staff
qap guiding principles
help meet the diverse affordable housing needs throughout colorado geographic locations project types different populations three priorities
qap priorities
projects serving homeless projects serving persons with special needs projects in counties with
qap criteria for approval
market conditions
readiness to proceed
financial feasibility & viability
experience/track record of project team
proximity to other lihtc projects
site suitability
project costs
lihtc review and approval process
staff reviews applications
applicants present projects to tcac
staff presents projects to tcac
tcac deliberation and voting
executive director final approval
tcac = tax credit allocation committee
questions
Tasha [email protected]
Page | 1
ACTION: To Be Approved 08.14.18
July 24, 2018 CITY OF GUNNISON COUNCIL 5:30 P.M.
REGULAR SESSION MEETING MINUTES
The City Council Regular Session was called to order at 5:30 P.M., by Mayor James Gelwicks
with Councilors Mallory Logan, Jim Miles, Robert Drexel, and Leia Morrison present. City
Attorney Kathy Fogo, City Manager Russ Forrest, Finance Director Ben Cowan, City Clerk
Erica Boucher, Parks and Recreation Director Dan Ampierto, Interim Community Development
Director Andie Ruggera, and Police Chief Keith Robinson were present. Planning and Zoning
Commissioners Erich Ferchau, Andy Tocke, Ryan Taylor, Greg Larson, Erik Iverson, and John
Perusek were there. Anna Laybourn of Design Workshop and Margaret Loperfido of Sprout
Studio were there to present at the joint meeting. A handful of interested citizens and the press
were present.
Citizen Input:
Mayor Gelwicks called for any citizens to give input on any items not being considered on the
agenda. No citizens came forward.
Council Action Items:
Approval of the July 10, 2018 Regular Session Minutes as submitted. Councilor Morrison
moved and Councilor Logan seconded the approval of the July 10, 2018 Regular Session
minutes as submitted.
Roll call, yes: Logan, Miles, Gelwicks, Drexel, and Morrison. So carried
Roll call, no: None.
Joint Meeting with Planning and Zoning Commission. This was Council’s second joint
meeting with the Planning and Zoning Commission. They met to review, discuss, and provide
direction to City staff on how to proceed on the following items: West Gunnison (Lazy K)
property, IOOF Park, Land Development Code updates, parking assessment, the comprehensive
plan, and the hiring of a new Community Development director.
West Gunnison (commonly known as Lazy K) property: City Manager Russ Forrest
introduced Anna Laybourn of Design Workshop whose firm was hired to gather feedback and
create a design for possible future use of the West Gunnison property. Ms. Laybourn
summarized the feedback process that Design Workshop used in June 2018. It included three
days of community engagement, walking the site with multiple stakeholder groups, and receiving
in-person feedback during open meetings to develop three potential designs. Over the course of
the days in June, the community feedback emphasized the inclusion of maintaining the natural
resources already in the area (trees, pathways, natural habitat, ponds, etc.), a playground, and
room to explore natural spaces. Based on the feedback received, the consensus was that Option
#3 was the preference of the community. This design could be developed in two phases. The first
phase would include a park, a restroom, safe access to the river and ponds, and a nature trail for
walking. Ms. Laybourn mentioned more signage directing people to the area would be needed
and the creation of more parking. Phase 1 would include 26 parking spaces along 3rd Street. Ms.
Laybourn also discussed the areas on the property that could be used for housing development.
The cost to complete Phase 1 would be $622,179 and could help be funded by grants and City
resources. Design Workshop did not include a cost for Phase 2 since that phase is far out in the
future.
Council and the City Manager shared the feedback they previously received from the Parks and
Rec Advisory Board. The Advisory Board expressed a desire for shelters, quiet play, a trail
crossing on the eastern boundary, and a good 3rd Street crossing. Overall, the Advisory Board felt
comfortable with Option #3. Community members favored smaller cottage-like housing
structures that could fit within the landscape rather than larger multi-family complexes for the
property. A member of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board asked if the City had followed
up with the school about building a playing field at the Community School. It was confirmed that
Staff had engaged with the school district and there is a possibility that a new playing field could
possibly be developed at the school rather than on the West Gunnison property. A next step for
the City to move forward with Phase 1 would be to apply for and receive a GOCO grant. Citizen,
Page | 2
Kelsey Bennett, asked for clarification about the immediate focus for the space. Is it to build a
park or for affordable housing? The mayor responded that the park is the focus, but there is
always a consideration for housing and that it is important that a park and housing complement
each other in that area. Neither Council nor the Planning and Zoning Commission had
discomfort with the City moving forward with exploring funding options and the Option #3
design presented by Design Workshop.
IOOF Park: Parks and Recreation Director Dan Ampietro provided Council and the Planning
and Zoning Commission with background as to the purpose of remodeling IOOF Park. He
introduced Margaret Loperfido of Sprout Studio who gathered input and feedback from
community members and visitors regarding IOOF Park. In the end, the ideas which rose to the
top were a fire pit, a water feature, festival lighting, art, updated furnishings, and a stage. Many
of these ideas were also mentioned in the Gunnison Vibrancy Initiative. Based on feedback
received, Sprout Studio developed two options for IOOF. One concept was inspired by the
ditches (water) and the other concept was inspired by the landscape of rocks and mountains.
People favored the water inspired design. Ms. Loperfido said that the full redesign of IOOF Park
would done in two phases. Phase one would focus on a water feature that could be turned off and
on, a climbing feature, updated furnishings, a fire pit, and festival lighting. A portable stage
works better for the space rather that a permanent stage. IOOF Park is a small footprint;
therefore, it is important that the features have multiple uses. There is also the intention of
maintaining and creating memorial spaces and maintaining the Oddfellows distinction. One
Phase would take place within the existing space. Phase Two would include the change of the
curbs, bulb outs, additional seating, and more landscaping. The group discussed parking
surrounding the downtown area. The importance of having shade in the park was also mentioned.
The full-build out cost of Phase One, as presented, would be $166,233.50, which includes a 5%
contingency. The full-build out cost (Phase One and Phase Two) came in just under $480,000.
This amount does not include the cost of a mural because that piece requires more discussion.
Staff is still researching grant and funding options for IOOF Park. Discussion about the safety of
the water feature and climbing feature occurred. The need for year-round bathrooms at IOOF
continues to be expressed by downtown business owners to Council. Staff will research the cost
of maintaining or extending year-round bathrooms. Members of Council and the Planning and
Zoning Commission did not express any opposition to moving forward with IOOF Park
conceptual designs.
Land Development Code updates: Interim Community Development Director Andie Ruggera
reviewed the amendments to the Land Development Code. Overall, the amendments included
reductions in off-street parking, allowance increases to allow for more housing, combining the
percentages for lot structures and parking spaces into one percentage to allow for more
flexibility, a look at possibly reducing set-back requirements especially on corner lots in
commercial and multi-family districts, a look at code buildings to allow for more flexibility with
existing structures or with retro-fitting older buildings, activating street frontage, and possibly a
reduction in fire suppression requirements. Interim Community Development Director Ruggera
highlighted and reviewed recommended changes to the R1, R2M, R3, B1 and industrial districts,
commercial zones, and the new Marker-Zone District. It was stated that many of these
recommendations will be vetted through the comprehensive plan process and require community
input. Additional points were made about the continued need for parking and the City needs to
maintain an awareness of the variety of housing needs required. No opposition was expressed to
the Land Development Code updates.
Mayor Gelwicks recessed the meeting for a short break at 7:03 P.M. The Regular Session begun
again at 7:08 P.M.
Mayor Gelwicks stated that Council needs a recommendation from the Planning and Zoning
Commission as to whether or not they support performance zones for Gunnison.
Parking Assessment: The dates for the parking study were moved from July 26-28 to August 2-
4. The Community Development department is looking for volunteers to assist with counting
cars during the two shifts throughout the days. Four zones surrounding the downtown district
will be surveyed. This study will provide the City with additional information about supply and
demand for parking in the downtown area that will allow the City to make data-based decisions
Page | 3
through planning processes.
Comprehensive Plan: The RFQ for a Comprehensive Plan did not generate the range of
responses the City was hoping for so the City Manager reached out to the firms who submitted a
RFQ for feedback. At this time, the City recommends proceeding with issuing a full RFP, open
to all qualified firms, if an effort to receive as many quality submissions as possible for the staff
to review. The City Manager spoke about the importance of the comprehensive plan being a
timely plan that produces measurable results. Discussion ensued about the how a comprehensive
plan can help the City address a variety issues as they arise and be a guiding document for
decision-making. Members of Council and the Commission encouraged staff to seek out a firm
that is innovation and timely with their work. This is a living document that should be flexible,
but provide a solid direction and foundation for the future. All supported issuing the RFP by the
end of the week.
Hiring a Community Development Director: Council and the Commission reviewed the list of
desirable qualities in a City Community Development Director and added a few suggestions. The
City Manager intends to include their suggestions in the list of desirable qualities in a candidate
and begin to draft the full job description.
Mayor Gelwicks and Council thanked the Planning and Zoning Commission for their time and
participation in the joint meeting. Both groups hope to continue the semi-annual meetings.
Mayor Gelwicks recessed the meeting. Council returned from recess at 7:44 P.M.
Procedure for the Sale of City-Owned Land.
City Attorney spoke about options for Council to consider for disposing of City-owned land. The
attorney reviewed what the City of Gunnison Municipal Home Rule Charter (Charter) states
about property and water rights in Section 11.2 and introduced Colorado Revised Statutes and
new laws to Council that lay-out legal options for how municipalities may dispose of City-owned
land. Both the Charter and State Statues requires that the disposal of any City-owned land
designated as a park or for governmental purposes must go to the voters. In the case of Lazy K,
this land has not been clearly designated as a park or for governmental purposes; therefore, it
wouldn’t be required to ask voters for permission to dispose of part of the West Gunnison
property, but Council could, if desired. If Council decides to put Lazy K on the ballot, it was
recommended that the ballot question remains broad enough to allow for maximum flexibility in
disposing of the City-owned land. To add clarity around disposing of City-owned land for
Gunnison, the attorney suggested the development of a policy. Discussion ensued that the policy
needs to be a helpful framework for all Councils when considering disposing of City-owned
land.
Council gave direction to City staff to draft a City-owned land disposal policy for Council’s
review and to a draft a resolution to put the sale of the West Gunnison property on the ballot in
November.
IGA with Gunnison County for a Coordinated Special Election in November.
The City Attorney explained to Council that the IGA with Gunnison County to hold a
coordinated election required one change. The Indemnification section 6.8 of the original IGA
had a contradiction. Therefore, the City and County attorneys worked together to revise the
opposing language Sections 6.8A and 6.8C so that the revised IGA stated that both government
agencies are protected under the Colorado Governmental Immunity Act. A revised copy was
given to the City Clerk prior to the start of the meeting for the Mayor to sign.
Councilor Drexel moved and Councilor Logan seconded the motion for the Mayor to sign the
IGA with County as modified for the amount of $10,599.
Roll call, yes: Gelwicks, Drexel, Morrison, Logan, Miles. So carried.
Roll call, no: None.
Authorization for Application for Energy Impact Assistance Funds.
In reviewing a DOLA grant application for funding for the Wastewater Treatment Plant
(WWTP) it was discovered that the application requires official action from Council to
authorizing Staff to apply for an Energy Impact Assistance Tier 2 grant for up to 1 million
dollars for the WWTP. Staff is requesting authorization from Council to apply for this grant.
Councilor Morrison moved and Councilor Logan seconded a motion to authorize staff to
Page | 4
complete and submit an Energy and Mineral Impact Assistance program application for the
purpose of obtaining funding assistance for the necessary updates at the City of Gunnison
Wastewater Treatment Plant.
Roll call, yes: Drexel, Morrison, Logan, Miles, Gelwicks. So carried.
Roll call, no: None.
Community Foundation of the Gunnison Valley account for Sister Cities International
projects and programs.
Mayor Gelwicks spoke about the importance of having a funding source established for
Gunnison supporting all Sister Cities International partnerships. He met with Pam Montgomery
of the Community Foundation of the Gunnison Valley to discuss the establishment of an account
to support Sister Cities International projects and programs. Once the account is established
contributions would be deposited in the Community Foundation account and distributed through
the Foundation. Recipients would apply for funding through Council, but all parties involved
would be required to follow the guidelines and policies of the Community Foundation.
Mayor Gelwicks reviewed the itinerary for the up-coming visit by the representatives from
Majhkali, India to sign the Sister Cities International agreement on August 7, 2018. Councilor
Logan moved and Councilor Morrison seconded a motion to direct staff to work with the
Community Foundation of the Gunnison Valley to establish a Sister Cities account to accept
donations to support projects and programming.
Roll call, yes: Morrison, Logan, Miles, Gelwicks, Drexel. So carried.
Roll call, no: None.
Adjourn Regular Session Meeting and move into Discussion Session.
With no further business for the Regular Session Mayor Gelwicks adjourned the Regular Session
Meeting and Council went into the discussion/work session at 8:11 P.M.
_______________________________________
Mayor
______________________________________
City Clerk
TO: City Council
FROM: Andie Ruggera, Interim Community Development Director
DATE: August 10, 2018
RE: Site Development Plan – Rady College of Computer Science and Engineering
INTRODUCTION
The City was approached by the Western Opportunity Fund, a private nonprofit organization,
regarding the proposed construction of a University building on the property generally known as
the Western State Colorado University soccer field. The property, bounded by Georgia on the
north, Adams on the east, Tomichi on the south and Loveland on the west (Blocks 2 and 9
Boutchers Addition), is owned by the Western State Colorado University Board of Trustees. The
private nonprofit expressed interest in going through the City’s land use process to obtain a
Building Permit and for construction of the facility.
The property is zoned as a Western State
Colorado University district on the City of
Gunnison’s Official Zoning Map. The
City’s Land Development Code does not
currently have regulations attached to this
zone district. Western State Colorado
University, along with the Board of
Trustees, have entered into a Ground Lease
with the Western Opportunity Fund (the
private nonprofit) to build the proposed
facility. Because WSCU and the Western
Opportunity Fund desire to go through the
City’s process, and even though the project
is located on State land, the City of
Gunnison has agreed to process the request
with the emphasis of the review on life and
safety issues, road configurations, drainage
and any other impact to the City’s streets or
infrastructure. A letter has been received
by the Colorado Attorney General to
provide permission for the Western Opportunity Fund to pursue applicable City permits for the
project.
REVIEW PROCESS
The process that has been outlined by the City Attorney includes review and comment by City
staff on a Development Site Plan to address any issues. The Development Site Plan request will
then go before the Planning and Zoning Commission for review and public comment. The
Commission has the option of authorizing the Western Opportunity Fund move forward with
applying for a Building Permit from the City’s Community Development Department with any
relevant conditions.
SITE ASSESSMENT
The proposed facility is approximately 60 feet high and a total of 80,000 square feet. The
structure is set back 80 feet from the north property line, 15 feet from the west boundary and less
than one foot on the east. The existing soccer field is being moved to the south of the parcel to
accommodate the new facility.
A ten-foot-wide east/west trail connection is proposed that aligns with College Avenue to the
east and curves to the south to align with Virginia Avenue on the west. ADA ramps will be
provided to make the pedestrian facilities accessible for all users.
The majority of the proposed structure sheds to the north of the facility. Drainage facilities have
been placed to address stormwater and snow storage issues that could arise. Staff asked the
applicant to make a variety of changes to their civil and drainage plans for existing and modified
runoff; the applicant has effectively responded to the requested changes. Pending final
stormwater drainage and geotechnical report, staff has no further objections to what has been
submitted.
A new configuration for Georgia Avenue is proposed that includes bulb outs at the intersections
of Loveland and Adams Street that will provide some traffic calming. Parking configurations
along Georgia Avenue are diagonal parking to the south (with accessible spaces) and parallel
parking on the north side. Along the north side of Georgia, separating the existing Western
parking lot, a new east/west sidewalk is proposed along with a green space.
New diagonal parking is proposed along the soccer field property on Loveland and Adams
Street. The new configuration provides a total of 100 diagonal spaces within these two street
rights-of-way. The new parking lot layout (existing Western parking lot) along with the street
layout provides an additional 58 spaces from existing configurations.
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION ACTION
On July 25, 2018 the Planning and Zoning Commission, at a regular meeting, reviewed the
proposal of the new facility and the Site Development Plans. Public comments received were in
support of the proposed facility; however, a letter was received that inquired on the parking
configurations along Loveland and Adams Street.
The Commission made a motion to authorize the Western Opportunity Fund to proceed with
submittal of a building permit application with the condition that the City Council review and
give the final approval of the use and configuration of the Loveland, Georgia and Adams rights-
of-way.
COUNCIL REQUESTION ACTION: The City Council is being requested as the land owner to
approve of changes to parking and the City rights-of-way on Loveland, Georgia and Adams
Street which will enable the applicant to move forward with obtaining a building permit.
GROUP
www.f-w.comEngineers | Architects | Surveyors | Scientists
5613 DTC PARKWAY, SUITE 1100GREENWOOD VILLAGE, COLORADO 80111(303) 692-8838 / [email protected]
MEMORANDUM TO: City Council FROM: Andie Ruggera DATE: August 14, 2018 RE: Termination of 20-foot-wide Utility Easement On June 12, 2018, Council was made aware of an electrical/utility easement located within the West Gunnison Neighborhood and directed staff to prepare a document to terminate the easement. The easement is 20 feet wide and was originally conveyed to the West Gunnison Sanitation District. In 2007, the West Gunnison Sanitation District was dissolved through an Intergovernmental Agreement between the City and the District and ultimately, through a Quit Claim Deed, the easement (among other interests) was transferred to the City. The easement is located within vacated Gunnison Avenue between 5th and 7th Street adjacent and overlapping (by five feet) an existing 35-foot-wide utility easement to the north. The City has water and sewer within the 35-foot easement as well as private service lines (gas) with no utilities in the 20-foot-wide easement. A draft document to terminate the 20-foot-wide easement is attached.
Council Request: Approval of the Termination of Easement document and authorization for the Mayor to sign the document for recording at the Gunnison County Clerk and Recorder’s office.
TERMINATION OF EASEMENT THIS TERMINATION OF EASEMENT is given and entered into this ____ day of August, 2018, by the CITY OF GUNNISON, a Colorado home rule municipality, whose address is P. O. Box 239, Gunnison, Colorado 81230, hereinafter referred to as “RELEASOR.” WHEREAS, on the 28th day of February, 2007, any and all interests in real property that was held by the West Gunnison Sanitation District transferred to the RELEASOR including a Quit Claim Deed for a utility easement that is described as:
A non-exclusive easement twenty (20) feet in width, described as the southernmost twenty (20) feet of Vacated Gunnison Avenue between the centerlines of 5th Street and 7th Street, as set forth in the official Amended Plat of West Gunnison and Guerrieri Addition, City of Gunnison, County of Gunnison, State of Colorado” recorded June 18, 1980, Book 551, Page 221, and Book 602, Page 253 and Book 602, Page 260, hereinafter referred to as “Terminated Easement Area”.
For Ten Dollars and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the RELEASOR does, by this instrument, release to the property owners affected by the Terminated Easement Area, described above, it being the intention of the parties to terminate such easement.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the RELEASOR has hereunto set their hands the day and year first above
written. CITY OF GUNNISON By: Jim Gelwicks, Mayor STATE OF COLORADO ) ) ss. COUNTY OF GUNNISON )
The foregoing Termination of Easement was acknowledged before me this _____ day of August, 2018, by Jim Gelwicks, City of Gunnison Mayor. WITNESS my hand and official seal. My commission expires: SEAL Notary Public
August 10, 2018
1
Memorandum
To: City Council
From: Jim Gelwicks
Date: 8/10/2018
Re: 1 Mill Temporary Tax Credit in Support of Housing Tax
Purpose:
This is a request to direct the Finance Director to include a 1 mill temporary tax credit on the
mill levy ordinance for the 2018 tax year to offer support for the proposed 1.5 mill housing
tax.
Housing Tax Support:
During the June 26, 2018, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 4, Series 2018 consenting
to the calling of an election by the Gunnison Valley Regional Housing Authority on November
6, 2018.
The proposed ballot language includes a 1.5 mill property tax starting January 1, 2019 through
December 1, 2028, reducing to .5 mill January 1, 2029 for planning, financing, repairing
maintaining, managing, and operating housing projects or programs in Gunnison County, to
provide:
1) Dwelling accommodations at rental prices or purchase prices within the means of
families of low- or moderate-income;
2) Affordable housing projects or programs for employees of employers located within
the jurisdiction of the Authority;
3) Senior housing facilities;
4) Administration of housing voucher programs funded through the U.S. Department of
Housing and Urban Development or other similar programs; and
5) Mixed income or mixed use properties that facilitate either of the purposes set forth in
1 and 2 above.
To clearly communicate the importance of this ballot initiative and to soften the initial financial
impact to taxpayers within the City of Gunnison in the event the initiative passes, I propose
the City Council votes to reduce the property tax levy for the 2018 tax year, collected in 2019,
by 1 mill if the housing tax is approved by voters on November 6, 2018.
August 10, 2018
2
Financial Impact:
The City of Gunnison ad valorem mill levy is currently 3.868. This generates $285,281
annually in net property taxes after County Treasurer’s Fees and estimated uncollectable
taxes. These taxes are unrestricted and are used to support costs incurred in the City’s
General Fund.
A temporary tax credit of 1 mill will offset the impact of two-thirds of the proposed 1.5 mill
levy increase for the first year to soften the initial financial impact to the City’s taxpayers. A
temporary tax credit can be added to the mill levy ordinance to preserve the City’s permanent
mill levy of 3.868 (not to be confused with a mill levy reduction, which would require voter
approval to return to the current mill levy in a subsequent year). The temporary tax credit 1
mill will ease the burden for seniors on a fixed income and allow businesses to adjust over
time. The temporary tax credit will assist in meeting Council’s Strategic Initiatives to increase
housing and maintain a healthy economy.
The reduction in property tax revenue received in 2019 is estimated to be $73,754, subject
to changes in the 2018 assessed valuation. This will not result in current services being cut.
The reduction can be offset by the estimated $250,000 increase in sales tax revenue for 2018.
Action Requested:
A motion to direct the Finance Director to include a 1 mill temporary tax credit on the mill
levy ordinance for the 2018 tax year in support of the proposed 1.5 mill housing tax in the
event the housing property tax is approved by voters during the November 6, 2018 election.
ORDINANCE NO. 10
SERIES 2018
DRAFT
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GUNNISON, COLORADO,
ADOPTING A POLICY FOR DISPOSITION OF CITY-OWNED PROPERTY
WHEREAS, the City of Gunnison, Colorado, is a Colorado home-rule municipality; and
WHEREAS, Section 31-1-102, C.R.S. provides that Title 31 of the Colorado Revised Statutes is
applicable to home rule municipalities except insofar as superseded by charter or ordinance passed
pursuant to such charter; and
WHEREAS, both the City’s Charter (Section 11.2) and Section 31-15-713(1)(a), C.R.S., state that
real property owned and used by the City for park purposes or for a governmental purpose, may
not be sold or conveyed without an affirmative vote at an election of the qualified electors of the
City; and
WHEREAS, Section 31-15-713(1)(b), C.R.S. provides that any other real estate owned by the City
may be disposed of by the City upon such terms and conditions as the governing body may
determine at a regular or special meeting; and
WHEREAS, in order to create flexibility and allow for creative solutions to land use and
development, the City Council desires to create an ordinance that will allow City Council to
determine the terms and conditions of the disposition of City-owned real estate without the need
for an election, except in the circumstances where real estate has been dedicated for and used as a
park or for a specific governmental purpose.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF GUNNISON, COLORADO, THAT:
Section 1. Definition of Dedicated. Dedicated, for purposes of this ordinance, shall mean any
property conveyed to the City by grant, deed, or trust, or other means, that contains a specific use
within the conveyance documents as a condition of ownership of the property…
Section 2. Purpose. The purpose of this ordinance is to establish a uniform procedure for the
disposition by the City Council of City-owned real property.
Section 3. Guiding Principles.
a. To encourage sale, conveyance, and development of real property in a manner beneficial to the residents of the City;
b. To encourage development that will maximize the public investment in existing and future capital improvements and infrastructure development;
c. To provide additional opportunities and options in the development of public-private partnerships;
2
d. To allow for flexibility and creativity in the development of real property within the City.
Section 4. Procedure for disposition of City-owned real property.
The City Council has authority to determine whether it is in the best interest of the City to sell or
otherwise convey or dispose of City-owned real property and to determine the appropriate terms
thereof according to the following considerations:
a. The significance of the positive economic impact on the City, including, but not limited to, housing, the number of jobs, average salary, benefits, etc.;
b. The potential of the development for providing quality housing, employment or community enrichment opportunities;
c. The monetary value of the land, as well as the monetary value of the proposed development upon completion;
d. The request and value of economic development incentives by a potential developer;
e. The elimination of blighted property or efforts to expand the tax base for the City;
f. Additional criteria the City Council may wish to consider in making its determination.
The City Manager may develop site-specific recommendations to the City Council for the sale or
disposition of such real property pursuant this section.
Prior to authorizing the sale or other disposition of a specific property, the Council shall hold at
least one public hearing to allow for citizen input.
Section 5. When an Election is Required. Notwithstanding the authority of City Council to
authorize the sale or disposition of City-owned real property, any property dedicated as set forth
above, shall be subject to prior approval through a regular or special election.
Section 6. Severability. Should any section, clause, phrase, or provision of this ordinance be ruled
invalid or unenforceable by any court of competent jurisdiction, it is hereby declared the intent of
the City Council of the City of Gunnison, Colorado, that the remaining provisions of this ordinance
shall be given full force and effect if it is possible to do so.
INTRODUCED, READ, PASSED, AND ORDERED PUBLISHED this ______ day
of ____________, 2018, on first reading, and introduced, read, and adopted on second and final
reading this ______ day of _____________, 2018.
Jim Gelwicks, Mayor
3
ATTEST:
Erica Boucher, City Clerk
To: City Council
From: City Clerk Erica Boucher
Date: August 14, 2018
Re: Resolution No. 7, Series 2018 to set Ballot Language to Bring the Sale of Real Property
before the Voters
______________________________________________________________________________
Purpose:
The purpose of Resolution No. 7, Series of 2018 would be to set ballot language to seek public
approval to sell that portion of the Lazy K property identified for a potential housing project(s) in
the future. Staff wanted to review the election schedule timing for a coordinated election and the
key considerations with this potential ballot issue. Given the previous discussion on creating a
policy for the disposal of City land and the legal opinion provided by the City Attorney, the City
Council could elect to:
1) Create a policy on the disposal/sale of land without referring the question of Lazy K to a
vote,
2) Refer the question of Lazy K land disposal/sale to the voters , or
3) Not take any action and retain all lands on Lazy K without the flexibility to convey those
portions of the property that are not planned for a park.
Timing and Next Steps
Election Schedule: Below is an election schedule for Council to review to understand
deadlines to participate in an election in November.
Tuesday, August 14, Council Meeting
Council reviews and, if acceptable, approves ballot language. After the ballot language is
approved, the City submits the ballot language to the County. While a public hearing is not
required by law, the City staff recommends gathering public input on the ballot language.
Tuesday, August 28, Council Meeting
Council has the opportunity to finalize and approve any ballot language, if the language
was not approved on August 14.
Friday, September 7
Last day for the City to certify ballot language and order to the County Clerk.
Tuesday, September 25
City must deliver to the County Clerk the full text of any required ballot issue notices.
Key Provision of Resolution No 7, Series of 2018
Attached Resolution No. 7, Series 2018, key provisions include:
Participation in a Special Election with Gunnison County on November 6, 2018;
Asking the qualified voters if the City of Gunnison shall be able to sell or otherwise convey
approximately 4.3 acres of the West Gunnison property (commonly known as Lazy K);
While City Council maintains flexibility in regarding to selling or conveying the land.
Stated in 31-10-102.7 C.R.S. Council may also pass resolution to confirm that the
municipality will utilize the requirements and procedures of the “Uniform Election Code of
1992”; therefore, Resolution No. 7, Series 2018 also includes this request.
Action Requested of Council:
To determine if Council desires to put a question regarding the disposal of the West Gunnison
property (commonly known as Lazy K) on the November 6, 2018, coordinated election ballot; and
if so, then a vote to pass Resolution No. 7, Series 2018, Re: A Resolution of the City Council of
the City of Gunnison, Colorado, referring a ballot question to the qualified electors of the
City of Gunnison to sell or otherwise convey a portion of real property owned by the City at a
Special Election to be held on November 6, 2018. Note: The City Council can consider has
additional time to consider this question, but would need to pass this Resolution no later than
August 28th without holding a special meeting.
Appendix A: Resolution No. 7, Series 2018
Appendix B: Conceptual drawing of approximately 4.3 acres of the West Gunnison property
designated for affordable and/or workforce housing
RESOLUTION NO. 7
SERIES 2018
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GUNNISON,
COLORADO, REFERRING A BALLOT QUESTION TO THE QUALIFIED ELECTORS
OF THE CITY OF GUNNISON TO SELL OR OTHERWISE CONVEY A PORTION OF
REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY THE CITY AT A SPECIAL ELECTION TO BE HELD
ON NOVEMBER 6, 2018
WHEREAS, On August 3, 2015 the City of Gunnison purchased, a 15.93 acre parcel of
real property described as:
15.93 acres in Blocks 115-118 and a Tract West of Block 118, WEST GUNNISON
(AKA Section 2, 49N1W) including streets and alleys as recorded at Reception No.
602864, located within the City of Gunnison, County of Gunnison, State of Colorado
Known by Street address as 1415 W. Tomichi Avenue, Gunnison, 81230, and known generally as
the “Lazy K” property; and
WHEREAS, since the property was purchased in 2015, the property has remained
undeveloped as the City completed several evaluations of the land with the assistance of
professional planning firms to understand the community’s desired use for the property and to
create conceptual plans of how the property could best be utilized to address the needs of the
community; and
WHEREAS, in July, 2018, Aspen-based planning firm, Design Workshop, after reviewing
surveys of the land, examining the property’s natural resources, gathering feedback from a variety
of stakeholder groups and public input, and identifying 4.3 acres suitable for affordable and/or
workforce housing, presented a conceptual design to Council and the Planning and Zoning
Commission with possible ways to develop the property; and
WHEREAS, the need for more affordable and/or workforce housing has been identified
in Gunnison County as a strategic priority which was supported the Gunnison Valley Regional
Housing Authority’s Needs Assessment completed in November 2016 indicating a “housing
shortfall of 900 of units.”
WHEREAS, the City Council recognizes the need for affordable and/or workforce
housing options within the City of Gunnison and are committed to exploring opportunities for
development of affordable and/or workforce housing in a variety of forms; and
WHEREAS, Council believes that the actual development and construction of such
housing is best left to professional developers, contractors, and real estate agents; and
WHEREAS, Council has determined that the registered electors of the City of Gunnison
should determine whether the approximately 4.3 acres should be sold or otherwise conveyed for
an affordable/workforce housing project, upon such terms and for such consideration as Council
may later determine; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF GUNNISON, COLORADO, THAT:
Section 1. The following ballot question shall be referred to a vote of the registered electors
of the City of Gunnison at the Special Election to be held on November 6, 2018:
BALLOT QUESTION 3
Shall the City of Gunnison, Colorado, be able to sell or otherwise convey approximately 4.3
acres of property, as shown on the West Gunnison Site Plan presented by Design Workshop,
for affordable and/or workforce housing, upon such terms and conditions as the City Council
may determine, to include, but not be limited to:
a. The significance of the positive economic impact on the City, including, but not
limited to, housing, the number of jobs, average salary, benefits, etc.;
b. The potential of the development for providing quality housing, employment or
community enrichment opportunities;
c. The monetary value of the land, as well as the monetary value of the proposed
development upon completion;
d. The request and value of economic development incentives by a potential
developer;
e. The elimination of blighted property or efforts to expand the tax base for the City;
f. Additional criteria the City Council may wish to consider in making its
determination.
______YES _______NO
Section 2. For the purposes of the November 6, 2018, election and to carry out the
provisions of the IGA with Gunnison County, the City shall utilize the requirements and
procedures of the “Uniform Election Code of 1992”, Articles 1 to 13 of Title 1, C.R.S.
INTRODUCED, READ, PASSED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City Council
of the City of Gunnison held on this 14th date of August, 2018.
______________________
Jim Gelwicks, Mayor
(SEAL)
ATTEST:
______________________________
Erica Boucher, City Clerk
To: City Council
From: City Clerk Erica Boucher
Date: August 14, 2018
Re: Resolution No. 6, Series 2018 to set Ballot Language for Charter Amendment
Councilors:
Following Council’s direction to participate in the November 6, 2018, a Coordinated
Election, a resolution approving the ballot language needs to be passed by Council. The key
provisions of attached Resolution No. 6, Series 2018 include:
Amending the election date the City of Gunnison Municipal Home Rule Charter from the
second Tuesday in May of each odd number year to the first Tuesday in November; and
If voters approve to amend the election date, then the resolution asks the voters to extend
Councilmember’s terms from May to November to allow for an orderly transition of the election
date needs to be passed by Council. Councilors Drexel’s, Logan’s and Morrison’s terms would
be extended from May 2019 to November 2019. Mayor Gelwicks and Pro Mayor Miles’ terms
would be extended from May 2019 to November 2021.
Stated in 31-10-102.7 C.R.S. Council may also pass resolution to confirm that the
municipality will utilize the requirements and procedures of the “Uniform Election Code of
1992”; therefore, Resolution No. 6, Series 2018 also includes this request.
Final ballot language must be submitted to the County Clerk and Recorder’s office by September
7, 2018.
Action Requested of Council: Approve Resolution No. 6, Series 2018, Re: A Resolution of
the City Council of the City of Gunnison, Colorado, referring ballot questions to the
qualified electors of the City of Gunnison to Amend the Gunnison Municipal Home Rule
Charter and to extend the current Councilmember’s terms by six months at a Special
Election to be held on November 6, 2018.
Appendix A: Resolution No. 6, Series 2018
Appendix B: Redline copy of Article II Elections of the Charter with the amendments.
RESOLUTION NO. 6
SERIES 2018
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GUNNISON,
COLORADO, REFERRING BALLOT QUESTIONS TO THE QUALIFIED ELECTORS
OF THE CITY OF GUNNISON TO AMEND THE GUNNISON MUNICIPAL HOME
RULE CHARTER AND TO EXTEND CURRENT COUNCILMEMBERS’ TERMS BY
SIX MONTHS AT A SPECIAL ELECTION TO BE HELD ON NOVEMBER 6, 2018
WHEREAS, the Gunnison Municipal Home Rule Charter (Charter) was adopted by the
electors of the City of Gunnison on July 10, 1962, and amendments to the Charter must be
approved by the qualified electors of the City of Gunnison; and
WHEREAS, City Council and staff believe that participating in coordinated elections in
November will result in a more efficient and effective use of City resources and finances; and
WHEREAS, Council passed Resolution No. 5, Series 2018 to participate in a coordinated
Special Election with Gunnison County on November 6, 2018 to amend the City Charter election
date to the first Tuesday in November of each odd numbered year and to extend the current
councilmembers’ terms by six months to allow for an orderly transition to the new election date.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF GUNNISON, COLORADO, THAT:
Section 1. The following ballot questions shall be referred to a vote of the registered
electors of the City of Gunnison at the Special Election to be held on November 6, 2018:
BALLOT QUESTION 1
Shall Article II Elections, Section 2.4 of the Gunnison Home Rule Charter be amended to
make the City’s regular election date the first Tuesday in November of odd years, and state
as follows:
Section 2.1 Applicability of Colorado Municipal Election Code:
For any non-Gunnison County coordinated elections, the Colorado Municipal Election Code,
and any amendments thereto, heretofore or hereafter adopted shall prevail, except those
provisions which are inconsistent with the Charter. The Council shall provide by ordinance,
resolution or motion, for the manner of holding City elections and such additional
regulations in respect to elections as may be necessary to accomplish the intent of this article.
Section 2.2 Elective Officers and Terms of Office:
The elective officers of the City shall be five Council members, all of whom shall be
nominated and elected from the City at large. At each regular City election there shall be
elected three Council members and such additional number as may be required to fill
vacancies pursuant to the provision of Section 4.7 Filling Vacancies in Elective Offices. The
two receiving the highest number of votes shall be elected for a term of office of four years.
The one receiving the third highest number of votes shall be elected for a term of office of
two years. A number equal to the number of vacancies being filled (if any) who shall receive
the next highest numbers of votes in order shall be elected for a term of office of two years.
A. The terms of office for Council members shall commence on the first scheduled regular
meeting following the Regular Municipal or Special election at which they are elected.
B. Elections shall be non-partisan. There shall be no partisan designations affixed in any
way or manner to any candidate for the office of City Council member.
Section 2.3 City at Large; Voting Precinct:
The City of Gunnison shall consist of one ward. The voting precinct of the City shall consist
of one until changed by the Council as hereinafter provided. The Council shall by resolution
from time to time establish convenient voting precincts in accordance with this Charter and
statutes.
Section 2.4 Election Date:
http://www.codepublishing.com/CO/Gunnison/#!/GunnisonCH/GunnisonCH04.html#Section 4.7
A regular City election shall be held on the first Tuesday in November of each odd numbered
year. Special City elections shall be held in accordance with the provisions of this Charter.
Section 2.5 Election Commission:
An Election Commission is hereby created, consisting of the City Clerk and two qualified
electors of the City, who during their term of office shall not be elected officials or employees
or candidates or nominees for elected City office. These two members shall be appointed by
the Council from July 1 following a regular City election for a term of two years, and shall
serve without compensation.
The City Clerk shall be chair. The Election Commission shall appoint the Board of Election
judges and clerks for each voting precinct and have charge of all activities and duties
required of it by statute and this charter relating to the conduct of elections in the City. In
any case where election procedure is in doubt, the Election Commission shall prescribe the
procedure to be followed.
The Election Commission shall provide for ballots and sample ballots or voting machines for
determination of the winner in the event of a tie vote or canvassing of returns and issuance
of appropriate certificates.
The Election Commission shall only serve when the election is not a coordinated with
Gunnison County.
YES______ NO______
BALLOT QUESTION 2
Contingent upon approval of Ballot Question 1, shall the current councilmembers’ terms be
extended by six months to allow for an orderly transition to the new election date:
YES______ NO______
Section 2. For the purposes of the November 6, 2018, election and to carry out the
provisions of the IGA with Gunnison County, the City shall utilize the requirements and
procedures of the “Uniform Election Code of 1992”, Articles 1 to 13 of Title 1 C.R.S.
INTRODUCED, READ, PASSED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City
Council of the City of Gunnison held on this 14th date of August, 2018.
______________________
Jim Gelwicks, Mayor
(SEAL)
ATTEST:
______________________________
Erica Boucher, City Clerk
To: City Council
From: City Clerk Erica Boucher
Date: August 14, 2018
Re: Review and Provide Feedback on Community Survey Draft
Councilors:
Purpose: The purpose of this agenda item is to ask for feedback on the draft of the
community survey to achieve the community engagement goals as stated in the 2017 Strategic
Plan.
Strategy: To complete a community survey in summer 2018 that will provide Council
and the City with a feedback from a cross section of the community on the City of Gunnison’s
strategic priorities and direction, City Services, to gather data to benchmark City Services against
other communities, gain a higher level of understanding of the socio-economic characteristics of
the residents of Gunnison, and receive feedback on the best way to communicate with the public.
Result: Issuing and completing a community survey is a necessary and important
exercise for the City to complete to further develop effective two-way communication with 80%
of the residents and businesses in Gunnison by December 31, 2020.
Since Council directed City staff to sign a professional services contract with RRC Associates on
June 26, 2018, we have been working with them to develop a comprehensive, useful, and
accessible community survey for distribution early this fall. The primary purpose of the
community survey is to gather feedback from residents on Council’s strategic priorities and City
services. The City, in working with RRC Associates, aims to gather has many responses as
possible through a direct mailing to every household in Gunnison, as well as offer residents the
opportunity to respond online through an open link. The open link will be available to all
residents and Western State Colorado University students a week to 10 days after the direct
mailing is sent.
City staff is also interested in gather responses from our Limited English Proficiency (LEP)
residents. To do so, RRC Associates suggests that a modified survey be developed. This survey
would be shorter in length and focus on more objective questions. Developing a survey for LEP
residents and will require different methods of outreach and communication resources to assure
the residents that they are safe to answer the questions and to understand what the City is asking.
Even with additional resources directed towards LEP residents, we can’t guarantee a large
response rate. However, it is important to receive their feedback. Staff has also reached out to
Ellen Pederson of the Gunnison County Multicultural Resources and was informed that on
February 23, 2018, Gunnison County Multicultural Resource Office, completed a Community
Café exercise where they gathered quite a bit of feedback from the LEP population on the topics
of Health, Housing, Communication, Mental Health, and Adult and Youth Activities through
tabletop discussions. Through a collaboration between the Gunnison County Multicultural
Resource Office and City Staff, Ellen’s report may provide Council and the City with the
information they need to address concerns and issues of the LEP population as our type of survey
would yield far less participation than the tabletop discussions already conducted.
Tentative Timeline for Community Survey:
August 14, 2018, Council Meeting
Gather feedback from Council on the community survey draft
August 15-August 23
Work with RRC Associates on survey revisions. Work with RRC Associates to draft
communication for direct mailing. Begin promoting the survey.
August 28, 2018, Council Meeting
Receive final approval from Council on community survey(s) and finalize with RRC Associates.
Week of September 3, 2018
Begin mailing survey to households.
Week of September 10, 2018
Make open link available to residents and target Western students.
Week of September 24, 2018
Close survey.
Early October
RRC Associates prepares tabulation and final results report.
Mid-October
Share final survey results with Council and the public
Action Requested of Council: To review the draft of the community survey and to provide
feedback to staff in order for staff to develop final survey(s) with RRC Associates.
Appendix A: Draft of Community Survey (with or without comments)
Appendix B: Summary results of the Gunnison County Multicultural Resource Office’s
Community Café
1
COMMUNITY SURVEY 2018 – DRAFT 2 First, a few questions about you and the general state of Gunnison… 1. Where is your residence located?
[ ] Inside Gunnison city limits [ ] In the county, within three miles of city limits [ ] Almont [ ] Crested Butte or Mt. Crested Butte [ ] Crested Butte South [ ] Pitkin or Ohio City
[ ] Somewhere else in Gunnison County [ ] In another Colorado county [ ] Other [ ] In another state (specify where: _________________) [ ] In another country (specify where: _______________)
2. Which of the following best describes you?
[ ] Year-round resident (11+ months/year) [ ] Part-time resident [ ] Student at Western State Colorado University (“Western”)
(if ‘Yes’ to Student) Do you live in housing owned/managed by the University? [ ] Yes [ ] No Which category best describes you? [ ] Freshman [ ] Sophomore [ ] Junior [ ] Senior [ ] Graduate student [ ] Taking classes [ ] Other
[ ] Employed in the city but don’t live in the City of Gunnison [ ] Get mail in the city but don’t live or work in the City of Gunnison [ ] Non-resident owner of business/commercial property
3. What is the ZIP Code of your primary residence? _________________________________ 4. Would you say that things in the city are going in the right direction, or have they gotten off on the wrong track? [ ] Right direction [ ] Wrong track [ ] Don’t know
In a few words, why do you feel that way?____________________________________________________________________ (Please attach an additional sheet of paper with your comments if needed on any survey question.)
5. Using the 1 to 5 scale below, how satisfied are you with the City government in terms of providing information to citizens about what
local government is doing, including offering ample communications, public engagement opportunities, and approachability of staff and Council?
NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Providing information to citizens 1 2 3 4 5 x
Offering public engagement opportunities 1 2 3 4 5 x
Approachability of staff and City Council members 1 2 3 4 5 x Do you have any specific comments on your ratings?
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
2
CITY SERVICES – The following questions ask you about your use of various services provided by the City and your satisfaction with these services.
The Public Works Department provides the City with public services and roads.
6. Rate your satisfaction with Public Works services in the city.
NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Snow removal on roads 1 2 3 4 5 x
Condition of streets 1 2 3 4 5 x
Condition of sidewalks 1 2 3 4 5 x
Condition of ditches 1 2 3 4 5 x
Street improvement and sealing projects (notification, traffic control, etc.)
Utilities Electric 1 2 3 4 5 X Water/Sewer 1 2 3 4 5 X Refuse/Recycling 1 2 3 4 5 X 1 2 3 4 5 x
Friendliness and courteous attitude of Public Works employees 1 2 3 4 5 x
7. How would you rate the current level of safety on City of Gunnison roads? NOT AT ALL AN EXTREMELY IN NEED OF IMPORTANT AREA DON’T ATTENTION FOR ATTENTION KNOW 1 2 3 4 5 x Do you have any suggestions on how Public Works can improve its services? ___________________________________________________________________________________________________ Public Safety
8. Please rate your satisfaction with the following aspects of Fire Services in the city.
NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T
SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Response times to emergency incidents 1 2 3 4 5 x
Courtesy and helpfulness of fire department staff 1 2 3 4 5 x
Fire safety, awareness and education programs 1 2 3 4 5 x Do you have any suggestions on how the Fire Department can improve its services? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________ 9. Please rate your satisfaction with the following aspects of Police Services in the city.
NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T
SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Overall feeling of safety and security 1 2 3 4 5 x
Friendliness and approachability of Gunnison Police Department employees 1 2 3 4 5 x
Overall quality of service 1 2 3 4 5 x
Confidence in the Police Department 1 2 3 4 5 x Do you have any suggestions on how the Police Department can improve its services? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________
3
Parks and Recreation
10. Please rate your satisfaction with the following aspects of Parks and Recreation Department in the city.
NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T
SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Availability of information on programs and facilities 1 2 3 4 5 x
Quality of park and recreation facilities 1 2 3 4 5 x
Friendliness and approachability of Parks and Recreation employees 1 2 3 4 5 x
Quality of recreation programs 1 2 3 4 5 x
Quality of City trails 1 2 3 4 5 X 11. From the list below, please select which three parks or facilities should be the HIGHEST PRIORITIES to add or improve in Gunnison
in order to better meet the needs of your household. A. Bill’s Park B. Legion Park C. Meadows Park D. Jorgensen Park E. IOOF Park F. West Tomichi Riverway G. Whitewater Park H. Hartman Rocks I. CharMar Park
J. Van Tuyl Ranch K. Community Center/pool L. Taylor Mountain Park M. Cranor Ski Hill N. Trails O. Ice rink P. Baseball/softball fields Q. Basketball courts R. Skate park
S. Soccer/lacrosse/football/open play fields T. Tennis courts U. BMX area V. Community gardens W. Picnic shelters X. Playgrounds Y. Other
Please write the letter from above for: ___________Top Priority ____________Secondary Priority ____________Third Priority Do you have any suggestions on how the Parks and Recreation Department can improve its services? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________
12. Please rate your satisfaction with the following aspects of the Clerk Department in the city.
NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T
SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Overall quality of service 1 2 3 4 5 x
Friendliness and approachability of Gunnison Clerk Department employees 1 2 3 4 5 x
Do you have any suggestions on how the Clerk Department can improve its services? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________
13. Please rate your satisfaction with the following aspects of the Finance Department in the city.
NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T
SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Overall quality of service 1 2 3 4 5 x
Friendliness and approachability of Gunnison Finance Department employees 1 2 3 4 5 x
Providing clear, accurate and timely financial information 1 2 3 4 5 x Do you have any suggestions on how the Finance Department can improve its services? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Community Development Department
The Community Development Department provides planning, design review, environmental programs, and building inspection services.
4
14. Have you used the services of the Community Development Department within the past 12 months? [ ] Yes [ ] No (GO TO Q. 16)
15. Please rate your satisfaction with the following aspects of the Community Development Department. NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T
SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Timeliness of response (to telephone calls, inspections,
questions/inquiries, plan review, etc.) 1 2 3 4 5 x
Building permit review and inspections 1 2 3 4 5 x
Courtesy and attitude/helpfulness 1 2 3 4 5 x
Knowledge/ability to answer questions 1 2 3 4 5 x Do you have any suggestions on how the Community Development Department can improve its services? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________
EVENTS
Gunnison has developed a wide variety of events and special programs in all seasons that have become part of our community culture. 16. In general, how would you describe the experience that events in Gunnison create for you and your guests? VERY VERY DON’T NEGATIVE POSITIVE KNOW 1 2 3 4 5 x Is there a specific type of event or special program you would like to see added to Gunnison’s city-wide calendar? _________________________________________________________________________________________________
Do you have any further comments on events or programs in Gunnison? _____________________________________________ The Downtown Area 17. When visiting the Downtown area, how do you most frequently travel there?
[ ] Bike [ ] Drive [ ] Walk
18. Please rate your satisfaction with the following aspects of the Downtown area. NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T
SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW
Location and availability of parking 1 2 3 4 5 x
Locations and adequacy of lighting at night 1 2 3 4 5 x
Do you have any comments on how the Downtown area could be improved to better serve your household’s needs? _________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Gunnison Valley Regional Housing Authority
19. To what extent are you satisfied with City of Gunnison housing? VERY VERY DON’T DISSATISFIED NEUTRAL SATISFIED KNOW 1 2 3 4 5 x 20. Currently, do you pay more than 33% of your total income on housing?
[ ] Yes [ ] No [ ] Don’t know
5
Do you have any comments on your response?________________________________________________________ Western State Colorado University 21. What can Western do to make campus more welcoming/inviting for Gunnison community members? ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ 22. How can Western as well as students, faculty, and staff better serve the Gunnison community? ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bus Service 23. Bus/transit services are currently provided by the RTA (Gunnison Valley Regional Transportation Authority). How satisfied are you with
regional bus service? NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T SATISFIED SATISFIED KNOW 1 2 3 4 5 x Do you have other suggestions on how bus/transit service can be improved in the Gunnison area? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________
COMMUNITY ISSUES AND OPPORTUNITIES
24. The Gunnison City Council and staff value community input to help understand your priorities. For each area listed below, indicate the
level of priority you believe is appropriate. (Use a 1 to 5 scale where 1=Not a Priority, 3=Neutral, 5=High Priority.) NOT A HIGH DON’T PRIORITY NEUTRAL PRIORITY KNOW
1. Continue to improve and build city infrastructure 1 2 3 4 5 x
2. Build more paths to parks, open spaces (i.e., VanTuyl Ranch) and schools 1 2 3 4 5 x
3. Build more sidewalks 1 2 3 4 5 x 4. Continue Cranor Hill ski operations 1 2 3 4 5 x
5. Improve safety at street intersections 1 2 3 4 5 x 6. Encourage affordable housing development 1 2 3 4 5 x
7. Expand and improve the bus system in the city limits 1 2 3 4 5 x
8. Expand the Community Center (indoor walking track, weight room, gym area) 1 2 3 4 5 x
9. Expand the variety of recreation programs 1 2 3 4 5 x
10. Improve appearances of city entrances 1 2 3 4 5 x 11. Increase the number of public events 1 2 3 4 5 x 12. Improve signage for information and finding your way 1 2 3 4 5 x 13. Improve street lighting 1 2 3 4 5 X
What two areas are your highest priorities? (Insert numbers from list above: #____________, #____________)
Any comments on your responses?______________________________________________________________
6
25. Through public input, four strategic priorities have been identified. From the list below, which single priority should receive most immediate attention? Or should they all be considered simultaneously?
[ ] Community Engagement
[ ] Economic Prosperity
[ ] Infrastructure and Safety
[ ] Livable and Affordable Housing
[ ] OR All should receive immediate and equal attention
Do you have any specific comments on your responses? ___________________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________________ Financial Prioritizing We are interested in the relative priority that you would place on improvements to serve the Gunnison community, including residents and visitors/guests. Recognizing that the categories of projects listed below would likely involve significant investment that may require expenditures greater than the City’s typical annual budget, please provide your input. 26. With $5 increments being the smallest amount you might use, if you had $100 to spend on major efforts, how would you allocate that
$100 across the following categories? Or, if you would not allocate funds to any of these categories, please indicate by checking the box provided below. Leave any items blank if you don’t want to allocate funds to a category and please make sure your allocation totals $100. $ _____ Attract new businesses to the City $ _____ Environmental sustainability efforts (including waste and recycling, wildlife habitat, climate change, and energy efficiency) $ _____ Expanded housing opportunities for a wide range of household incomes $ _____ Improve quality of roads and sidewalks $ _____ Recreation facilities and programs $ _____ Efforts to improve hotel occupancies $ _____ Expanded regional marketing efforts $ _____ Increased broadband redundancy $ _____ Transportation improvements to address needs through bus service - in Gunnison $ _____ Other: (please explain) ___________________________________________________________ $ 100 TOTAL OR [ ] I would not allocate any substantial funding to these types of efforts in the future
Do you have comments on any of your responses above? ______________________________________________________ 27. How much of a priority should the City place on investing more time and resources in creating affordable housing options? NOT AT ALL HIGH DON’T A PRIORITY NEUTRAL PRIORITY KNOW 1 2 3 4 5 x Do you have additional comments regarding your response on creating affordable housing options? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
7
The Environment Gunnison has successfully undergone an audit as part of its goal to be a sustainable community. Sustainable communities seek to leverage the positive benefits of tourism while ensuring the health and viability of the local community. 28. Do you have any comments or suggestions concerning Gunnison’s efforts toward being a sustainable community?
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
29. Please rank the importance of the following environmental sustainability program focus areas for the City. NOT AT ALL VERY DON’T IMPORTANT IMPORTANT KNOW 1 2 3 4 5 x 1 2 3 4 5 x 1 2 3 4 5 x
Household Preparedness for an Emergency During major emergencies, public safety is our first priority; in some situations the emergency may exceed the capacity of local first responders. It is imperative that you are prepared to provide for your own safety. 30. How prepared would you say you and your household are in the event of a catastrophic emergency event? [ ] Extremely prepared [ ] Somewhat prepared [ ] Slightly prepared [ ] Not at all prepared Do you have any comments or unanswered questions related to Emergency Preparedness in Gunnison? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Ownership and Property Rental Information
31. Do you own or rent your residence? [ ] Own [ ] Rent [ ] Other (specify)__________________________
32. How long have you lived within the city (or owned property if a non-resident)? [ ] Less than 1 year [ ] 1-5 years [ ] 6-15 years [ ] 16-25 years [ ] More than 26 years [ ] Not applicable
33. (If own home) How do you expect to be using your home five years from now? (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY) [ ] As a primary residence for my household, the owner [ ] I intend to sell my home within the next five years but stay in the area [ ] I intend to sell my home in the next five years and relocate outside the area [ ] A vacation home for owner or guests of owner [ ] I intend to use home as my retirement residence [ ] Vacation rental to visitor/tourists [ ] Rented long term to local resident [ ] Other [ ] Don’t know/uncertain
Do you have any further comments on your experience with the housing market or affordability of workforce opportunities in the Gunnison region?
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
8
Please provide the following demographic information. Remember that all responses remain strictly confidential and are reported only in group format. 34. Which of the following best describes your employment
status? [ ] Work 8 months or more a year in the City of Gunnison [ ] Work 7 or fewer months a year in the City of Gunnison [ ] Currently employed outside of the local area (work on Front
Range, out of state, etc.) [ ] Retired [ ] Unemployed and/or looking for work [ ] Homemaker [ ] Other:___________________________________ 35. (If employed) What is the location of your place of work?
(Check all that apply) [ ] Inside Gunnison city limits [ ] In the county, within three miles of city limits [ ] Almont [ ] Crested Butte or Mt. Crested Butte [ ] Crested Butte South [ ] Pitkin or Ohio City [ ] Somewhere else in Gunnison County [ ] In another Colorado county [ ] In another state (specify where: _________________) [ ] In another country (specify where: _______________)
36. (IF RESIDENT) Do you own or operate a business within
the city? [ ] Yes [ ] No
37. Are you a registered voter in the City of Gunnison? [ ] Yes [ ] No
38. Which of these cate