Grant Agreement no : 614002

SCHeMA

INTEGRATED IN SITU CHeMICAL MAPPING PROBE

Collaborative project

OCEAN.2013-2: Innovative multifunctional sensors for in situ monitoring of marine environment and related maritime activities

D10.9 – Report on the applicability of the SCHeMA chemical probes

Due M48 (30.09.2017)

Actual submission date: 10.11.2017 Start date of project: October 1

st, 2013 Duration: 48 months

Organisation name of lead contractor for this deliverable: UNIGE Revision 1.0

Project co-funded by the European Commission within the Seventh Framework Programme (2007-2013)

Dissemination Level

PU Public X

PP Restricted to other programme participants (including the Commission Services)

RE Restricted to a group specified by the consortium (including the Commission Services)

CO Confidential, only for members of the consortium (including the Commission Services)

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 2

Deliverable D10.9

Report on the applicability of the

SCHeMA chemical probes

PU: Public the EU Commission Services

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 3

Project Number : 614002 Project Title : SCHeMA Deliverable Type : PU

Deliverable Number : D10.9 Title of Deliverable : Report on the applicability of the SCHeMA chemical probes Nature of Deliverable : Report Contractual Delivery Date : 30/09/2017 Actual Delivery Date : 10/11/2017 Contributing WPs : WP2, WP3, WP4, WP6, WP7, WP8, WP9, WP10 Author(s) : Mary-Lou Tercier-Waeber (UNIGE) Michela Castelano, Francesco Massa (UNIGe-IT) Antonio Novellino (ETT) Fabio Confalonieri (IDRO)

Abstract This Deliverable presents the submersible and portable chemical mapping probes and the integrated autonomous marine water quality observatory system that were developed, characterized and field-validated as part of SCHeMA. Their analytical performances are reported and their potential contribution to European environmental initiatives and programs evaluated. Finally their present status in view of a commercialization is discussed.

Keyword list

SCHeMA sensing probes, Analytical performances, Potentialities for monitoring initiative and programs, Commercialization.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 4

Table of Content List of symbols and acronyms ............................................................................................................... 5

1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 7

2 SCHeMA state of the art developments ......................................................................................... 9

2.1 Trace Metal Sensing Module: TMSM ...................................................................................... 9

2.2 Species relevant to the Carbon Cycle Sensing Module: CSM .............................................. 11

2.3 Nutrients Sensors Module: NSM ............................................................................................ 12

2.4 Miniaturized, multi-channel Algae Sensing Module: ASM ................................................... 12

2.5 Dissolved organic constituent sensing module: VOCs-SM ................................................... 14

2.6 SCHeMA integrated autonomous marine water quality observatory system ......................... 15

3 Performance of the field-evaluated SCHeMA chemical probes .................................................. 17

4 Application for environmental monitoring directives and programs ........................................... 20

4.1 Marine Strategy Framework Directive and Regional Sea Conventions ................................. 20

4.2 Environmental monitoring programs...................................................................................... 22

5 Evaluation for post industrialization/commercialization ............................................................. 24

5.1 NC - Network Controller ........................................................................................................ 25

5.2 TMSM - Three-channel trace metal sensing probe ................................................................ 26

5.3 FACM - Submersible peristaltic pump ................................................................................... 26

5.4 CSM and NSM - Nutrient and Carbon species submersible probes ....................................... 26

5.5 ASM – Miniaturized multi-channel algae sensing module .................................................... 27

5.6 Web based system interface ................................................................................................... 27

6 References .................................................................................................................................... 29

7 Annex 1: Regional Sea Conventions ........................................................................................... 31

8 Annex 2: Environmental monitoring programs and projects ....................................................... 32

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 5

List of symbols and acronyms

ASM Algae Sensing Module

AuNP Gold nanoparticles

ASV ASV anodic stripping voltammetry

BTEX BTEX benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylene

CDOM CDOM Colored dissolved organic matter

CMEMS Copernicus Marine Service

CSM Carbon Cycle Sensing Module

EMODnet European Marine Observation and Data Network

EMSO European Multidisciplinary Seafloor and water column

Observatory

E-P-co Ethylene-propylene copolymer

EQS Environmental quality standards

FACM Fluidic activation module

GCI GEOSS Common Infrastructure

GEOSS Global Earth Observation System of Systems

GIME Gel Integrated MicroElectrode arrays

GOOS Global Ocean Observing System

GPRS General Packet Radio Service

GRA GOOS Regional Alliances

HABs Harmful algal blooms

HTTP HyperText Transfer Protocol

HW/SW HardWare/SoftWare

ICT information and communication technologies

INSPIRE INfrastructure of SPatial InfoRmation in Europe

IOC Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission

ISE Ion selective electrode

IR-FEWS Infrared fiber-optic evanescent wave spectroscopy

JRA Joint Research Activities

JRAPs Joint Research Activity projects

LED Light emitting diode

LOD Limit of detection

MCT Mercury cadmium telluride

MSFD Marine Strategy Framework Directive

NA Networking Activities

NC Network Controller

NODCs National Oceanographic Data Centres

NSM Nutrients Sensors Module:

OEM Original Equipment Manufacturer

OGC OGC Open Geospatial Consortium

SensorML Sensor Model Language

SOS Sensor Observation Service

SOCAT Surface Ocean CO2 Atlas

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 6

STX Saxitoxin

SWE Sensor Web Enablement

TMSM Trace Metal Sensing Module:

UM Unit of measure

UMTS Universal Mobile Telecommunications System

VIP Voltammetric In Situ Profiler

VOCs-SM Volatile organic constituent sensing module

WAN Wide area network

WQS Water quality standards

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 7

1 Introduction

The world’s oceans and seas, and especially the coastal areas have a huge impact on our daily lives.

They play an integral role in the Earth's climate and weather. They are also vital to the livelihoods

and food security of billions of people around the world, and to the economic prosperity of most

countries. Globally, the market value of marine and coastal resources and industries is estimated at

$3 trillion per year. However, no economy can sustain its prosperity if the natural resource base upon

which this prosperity depends is systematically being degraded. The sustainable use of the oceans is

therefore vital for mankind.

Marine ecosystems are vulnerable and complicated regulated systems, including a large number of

physical, chemical and biological actions and reactions, which altogether ensure the functioning of

the system and its homeostasis. Correct functioning requires that all these processes are well tuned

and balanced. Pressures on the oceans related to climate change and pollution may shift natural

equilibria and block or modify the bio-chemical pathways. Therefore to understand, predict, protect

and manage ocean processes and resources requires detailed and continuous monitoring of the ocean

health.

Most monitoring approaches are still based on costly field campaign sampling followed by analysis

of the collected samples after return to the laboratory. This approach can only harvest data for a

limited time-space window, resulting in the serious issue of insufficient data resolution. Existing

recent developments involve the use of submersible in situ chemical sensor probes. They are

deployed from various facilities as part of a number of international, European and national ocean

monitoring programs. Such autonomous sensing systems allow long-term and frequent analysis.

However the commercial availability of field deployable sensors and sensing devices is still limited,

and most of these tools tend to be too large, expensive, and power-hungry, thus preventing their

widespread use.

The aim of the SCHeMA project was to contribute to enhance the capability of the Ocean

observation system networks. Toward this aim, SCHeMA developed an array of miniaturized sensors

combining various innovative analytical and technical solutions, namely: on-chip sensor arrays;

antifouling membranes; solid state ion-selective membrane electrodes; in-line desalination device;

multispectral optical sensing devices. These sensors were assembled into miniature low power

consumption probes based on advanced green and enOcean technology. The interfacing of the

individual probes, via a dedicated Network Controller, provides an open and modular sensing

solution for gathering spatial and temporal information on a range of chemicals and organisms that

may have an adverse effect on marine ecosystem functioning and health. An ad-hoc ICT wireless

networking solution, developed according to international standards, and a web-based information

system provide the necessary facilities for remote localization and configuration of the integrated

mapping systems, data transfer as well as data access and interoperability with other European and

international projects and initiatives.

This Deliverable briefly summarizes the SCHeMA state of the art developments. Analytical

performances of the chemical sensors and sensing probes and the integrated system developed are

presented, followed by the evaluation of their capabilities for environmental monitoring and water

pollution control. SCHeMA, by developing novel sensor systems for the determination of important

aspects of the oceans’ health, addresses key aspects of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 8

(MSFD) and provides potentiality to extend capability of current or future monitoring systems and

programs. This is illustrated by several examples. Finally, the forecast on how the SCHeMA devices

could be industrialized and commercialized is discussed.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 9

2 SCHeMA state of the art developments

SCHeMA developed, applied and field-validated an open and modular sensing solution for in situ

high resolution mapping of a range of anthropogenic and natural chemical compounds coupled to

master bio-physicochemical parameters. SCHeMA particularly focused on the detection of toxic

and/or essential trace metal species; species relevant to the carbon cycle; nutrients; toxic algae

species; volatile organic compounds (VOCs). All of them may represent a severe threat to the normal

functioning of the marine ecosystems and may have feedback (synergic) interaction.

The sections below summarize the major SCHeMA analytical and technical developments achieved

providing individual as well as open and modular sensing solutions for the detection of the targeted

parameters.

2.1 Trace Metal Sensing Module: TMSM

The growing necessity to continuously monitor the level of trace metals reflects the critical roles they

play in ecosystem functions. Some metals (e.g. Hg, Cd, Pb) and metalloids (e.g. As) exhibit high

toxicity even at extremely low concentrations, while others are either essential or toxic (e.g. Fe, Cu,

Zn), depending on their concentrations and the nature of the organisms. Assessing the risk of metal

contaminations on ecosystem and, ultimately, human health is difficult. Trace metals are persistent

and distributed under various chemical species (speciation) (Fig.1).1 Only some specific metal

species are potentially available for biouptake (Fig.1).

Figure 1: Schematic representation of the bio-geochemical processes regulating metal cycling in the aquatic

systems1.Once they enter the ecosystem, they are involved in bio-geochemical processes and distributed under

various physical-chemical forms, including: particulate (> 0.45 m), colloidal (1 nm – 0.45 m) and

dissolved metal species ( 1 nm). The latter includes the so-called dynamic metal species, defined as the sum

of the free (hydrated)-metal ions (Mn+

) and small labile and mobile inorganic and organic complexes (ML),

that are potentially available for biouptake. Inorganic and organic colloidal/particulate materials play a key

role in coagulation, sedimentation, and adsorption processes that influence trace metal residence time and

transport from the water column to the sediments.

Bioavailability is therefore of primary concern when considering if a trace metal serves as

micronutrient or toxicant. While the global regulatory environmental quality standards (EQS) for

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 10

metals in water bodies are still mainly based on total (dissolved) concentrations, the revised Priority

Substances Directive (2013/39/EU) suggests measurement of the bioavailability of some trace metals

(Cd, Pb, Hg, Ni) either indirectly by modelling of their speciation or directly by applying specific

measurement methodology.

The TMSM is a new generation submersible multichannel voltammetric probe2 allowing direct,

simultaneous measurements of the bioavailable fraction a range of trace metals (cadmium, lead,

copper, zinc, arsenic, mercury) with sensitivity at the sub-nanomolar (ng/L) level. This is achieved

using antifouling Gel Integrated MicroElectrode arrays (GIME) interrogated by anodic stripping

voltammetry (ASV) consisting in a reduction and pre-concentration step followed by the stripping

and recording of the pre-concentrated metals.

Figure 2: a) Details of the key components of the TMSM. b) The TMSM individual probe ready for

deployment.

GIME are based on newly designed on-chip 190 interconnected iridium microdisk arrays

electrochemically plated with appropriate transducing elements and covered by an antifouling

membrane3. When a GIME sensor is interrogated using ASV, the metal flux (or current) at the GIME

during the electrochemical pre-concentration step selectively represents the dynamic metal species,

defined as the sum of free metal ions and small labile complexes; i.e. Mn+

+ ML (Fig. 1) and

corresponding to the maximum concentration of metals potentially available for bio-uptake 1,4,5

.

The entire system comprises an electronic housing, a three-channel flow-through cell and an external

multi-channel pump. Each individual channel of the flow-through cell incorporates an on-chip GIME

and counter electrode and a mini-reference electrode. The electronic housing incorporates three

potentiostats and pre-amplifiers, a 3.4V power supply as well as all required hardware and firmware

for trace metal, pressure and temperature measurements; background subtraction; automatic peak

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 11

current measurements and their conversion into concentrations; data storing; and data transmission

via wired or wireless interface. The TMSM can be used individually or interfaced with the other

SCHeMA sensing modules (see section 2.6)

2.2 Species relevant to the Carbon Cycle Sensing Module: CSM

The accurate measurement of the carbonate system in seawater is of critical importance to study

ocean acidification caused by the absorption of anthropogenically emitted CO2. As the

concentrations of the associated chemical species (CO2, pH, carbonate and bicarbonate) are

interconnected by thermodynamic constants, the carbonate system can be described from the

measurement of just any two species among the four (i.e. pH and carbonate). Additionally, the

quantification of dissolved calcium is related to the carbon cycle as it is involved in carbonate

precipitation/dissolution processes and its monitoring may contribute to a more complete description

of the marine system. Thus, CSM is based on the simultaneous potentiometric detection of pH,

carbonate and calcium in seawater using membrane electrodes.

In potentiometric sensors the analytical information is obtained through an ion recognition event

translated into a voltage signal. Thus, a local equilibrium is established at an ion-selective membrane

and the activity change of the ion analyte in the aqueous solution results in a change in membrane

potential. The potentiometric readout is the difference between this potential and that provided by a

reference electrode. CSM incorporates a flow cell (25 × 25 × 25 mm) containing three miniaturized

electrodes of all-solid-state type (2 mm of diameter and 20 mm long) based on nanomaterials and

selective membranes6 for pH, carbonate and calcium together with a reference electrode (Fig. 3a-c)

7.

The flow configuration of the detection cell allows for its implementation into a fluidics system

driven by a submersible pump and mainly based on a two-position valve to select the pass of either a

calibration solution or the seawater from the aquatic system (Fig. 3d).

Figure 3. (a) Flow cell. (b) Electrode set-up. (c)

Detection cell. (d) Fluidics design. (e) View from

outside of the CSM probe. (f) View from inside of

the CSM probe. (g) Cap to close the submersible

housing allowing the coupling between internal

and external connections. (h) SCHeMA probe. 1:

miniaturized electrode, 2: modified electrode, 3:

electrical connection, 4: fittings, 5: electronics

housing, 6: housing for the fluidics system, 7:

cap, 8: valve, 9: potentiometric flow cell, 10:

algae module, 11: pump, 12: CTD

multiparametric probe.

The flow configuration of the detection cell allows for its implementation into a fluidics system

driven by a submersible pump and mainly based on a two-position valve to select the pass of either a

calibration solution or the seawater from the aquatic system (Fig. 3d). The detection cell is placed

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 12

together with the algae module into a water- and pressure-proof cylindrical housing (Fig. 3e-g),

which is connected to the electronics part (hardware for pump and valve control, potentiometric

measurements, the adjustment of the experimental protocol, data acquisition, storage and

management). After fixing the fluidic system containing the potentiometric sensors, closing the

submersible housing and calibrating the CSM, this is incorporated into the titanium cage together

with the rest of the SCHeMA probes (Fig. 3h).

2.3 Nutrients Sensors Module: NSM

The importance of the reliable long-term monitoring of nutrients in seawater lies in their crucial role

in primary production and in their use as indicators of anthropogenic activities that disturb aquatic

ecosystems. Currently established approaches for nutrient detection involve sample extraction using

power intensive pumps, followed by analysis using expensive centralized laboratory instrumentation.

Such sampling procedures are likely to result in undesired alterations of the samples implying the

loss of useful information and therefore the concept of decentralized sensors for the in situ

monitoring of nutrients has reinforced its interest for environmentalists in the last years.

Potentiometric sensors are especially suitable for this purpose8 but it is necessary to reduce the

amount of certain major ions in seawater, i.e. chloride and hydroxide, prior to potentiometric

detection.

The developed NSM is based on the same potentiometric flow cell as in CSM but containing pH,

nitrate and nitrite membrane potentiometric sensors. NSM and CSM are interchangeable modules

sharing the same electronics. In the case of NSM, electrochemical desalination9 and passive

acidification modules10

are coupled to the detection cell (Fig. 4). Thus, the desalination module

reduces the amount of chloride in seawater down to millimolar levels and the acidification module

subsequently lowers the pH down to 5.5. In these conditions, potentiometric detection of nitrate and

nitrite in seawater is affordable with limits of detection of 0.9 µM and 0.6 µM respectively. The

incorporation of a calibration solution allows one compensating any electrode drift.

Figure 4: NSM image and fluidics design. 1: desalination unit, 2: valve, 3: acidification unit, 4:

potentiometric flow cell, 5: submersible housing.

2.4 Miniaturized, multi-channel Algae Sensing Module: ASM

Harmful algal groups, which can produce several biotoxins, are of particular interest since they can

kill fish, marine mammals and birds when they bloom. Further, algal blooms can cause green, brown

or even red colorations of the surface water wherefore these harmful algal blooms are also known

under the synonym red tides.11

After accumulation among the food web, biotoxins can also lead to

human disorders such as gastrointestinal, neurological and cardiovascular disturbances. Furthermore,

cyanobacteria, formerly known as blue-green algae, constitute another phytoplankton group of

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 13

interest. Cyanotoxins produced by this group of phytoplankton, can also lead to gastrointestinal

disorders, liver disease, heart failure or even death after accumulation over the food chain.12

In

addition to health effects, harmful algal blooms constitute also a threat to the fish industry as well as

to the tourism sector by having tremendous economic impacts.13

Due to algal contamination, food

products in the shell fish industry or even the shell fish itself gets poisoned and have to be disposed.

The tourism sector suffers heavy losses since they have to close their beaches until the nature of the

algae is determined. Moreover, the occurrence and intensity of (harmful) algal bloom has been

increased over the last few years.14

Therefore, in-situ detection and reliable identification of harmful

algae species at an early stage are of steadily growing importance.

Phytoplankton absorbs light at very specific wavelengths and re-emits part of the absorbed energy as

fluorescent light at longer wavelengths. Fluorescence can therefore be used as a selective technique

to identify relevant algal groups in an algal assemblage of mixed composition. In addition, distinct

emission windows reduce interferences from other marine compounds.

Conventional algae fluorometers compare the fluorescence emitted upon excitation at two different

wavelengths aiming at separating cyanobacteria and algae according to their major spectral

differences. However, there can be significant overlap in the spectral characteristics of different algae

making it difficult to discriminate further groups. In addition, various biological and chemical

interference, e.g. from colored dissolved organic matter (CDOM), yellow substances such as humic

matter or suspended particles in the sample can lead to alterations in the fluorescence signal and have

to be taken into account for data evaluation procedures.

To address these problems, TU Graz, as part of the SCHeMA project, has developed a miniaturized,

multi-channel detection module. This in-situ device enables the early stage detection of

phytoplankton species in algal blooms and the real-time identification of their taxonomic affiliation.

The appliance has a modular design to allow easy replacement of optical components. Although the

ASM is able to identify various algal groups, the system was optimized for reliable identification of

toxin producing cyanobacteria and dinoflagellates from among other algae in an algal assemblage of

mixed composition. In addition, the ASM is able to track the biomass concentration in order to

determine the onset and deterioration of algal blooms.

In the detection module (Fig. 5), up to eight different wavelengths are used to excite specific

pigments in the photosystems of the phytoplankton sample. Upon excitation, the energy absorbed is

rapidly transmitted throughout the light-harvesting complex of the photosystems to chlorophyll-a in

Figure 5: Rendered picture of the algae detection module (left and right) and the modular LED modules

used as excitation sources (middle). The picture on the right illustrates the arrangement of optical and

electronical components. Photodetectors are aligned with 90° angle to the excitation source and covered

with emission filters to minimize cross-talk between excitation and emission channels.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 14

the reaction centre. Part of the energy is used to maintain the photosynthesis of the algae and surplus

energy is emitted as fluorescent light. The resulting fluorescence and the contribution of certain

excitation wavelengths to the fluorescence signal are detected by the miniaturized ASM. Algorithms

are then applied to standardize and correct the fluorescence signal aiming at greater inter-

comparability within the detection system and between experiments. Subsequently, the recorded

fluorescence pattern is compared to a set of reference data and a multivariate pattern recognition

algorithm allows the identification of the taxonomic affiliation of the sample (Fig. 6).

For semi-quantification of the phytoplankton biomass, the detection unit count cell events passing

through the system and correlates the number of events with the average fluorescence intensity at

certain wavelengths. Up to a certain cell density limit, signal spikes can be resolved and the detected

spikes can be counted as cell events. This approach allows the measurement of changes in the

biomass concentration that indicate the onset and deterioration of an algal bloom.

2.5 Dissolved organic constituent sensing module: VOCs-SM

Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are of great interest for environmental monitoring due to their

toxicity, carcinogenicity, and mutagenicity.15-16

Even at low concentrations they are harmful for the

environment, and pose a significant risk to aquatic ecosystems and human health.17

Due to the

increasing industrialization and population of coastal regions, the ocean is still – intentionally or

unintentionally - serving as dumping site for organic matter. VOCs originate from the production,

handling, and use of fuels (e.g., gasoline and diesel fuel), solvents, paints, adhesives, deodorants, and

refrigerants. Hence, VOCs are the most commonly detected organic pollutants in ground and surface

waters,16,18

especially benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylenes (o-, m-, p-) (BTEX) originating

from petroleum-based products.19

Due to their volatility, VOCs occur only in low concentrations

(i.e., ng/L range) dissolved in surface waters (e.g., lakes, reservoirs or streams). In groundwater, their

concentrations may be hundreds or thousands of times higher.20

Within the project, an optochemical mid-infrared (mid-IR) evanescent field sensor system for

detecting volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in an aqueous environment has been successfully

achieved (Fig. 7). The IR-FEWS sensor includes a compact FT-IR spectrometer, from which IR

radiation is guided via coupling optics onto the entry facet of an AgX fiber sensing element (i.e.,

transducer) acting as an internal total reflection waveguide. The AgX waveguide has a flattened

section actually transducing the absorption signatures of VOCs enriched from aqueous solution into

Figure 6: (A) Relative fluorescence intensity upon excitation at different excitation wavelengths for

amphora sp, a diatom sample. (B) Resulting score plot after applying the multivariate pattern

recognition algorithm aiming at the comparison of the unknown sample to a set of reference data.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 15

a hydrophobic polymer membrane (i.e.,

E/P-co) coated onto this sensing segment.

The analyte molecules are enriched into the

membrane, while water is effectively

excluded due to the hydrophobic nature of

the polymer.

Thereby, VOCs are enriched into the

evanescent field emanating from the

transducer surface a couple of micrometers

into the adjacent media. At the same time,

the coating acts as a protective layer for the

AgX fiber against the high ionic strength of

seawater, which cause degradation

processes. For radiation detection, the liquid

nitrogen cooled MCT detector was replaced

by a thermoelectrically cooled MCT

detector providing similar performance

characteristics. For system control and data

evaluation, an industrial computer was used.

The entire IR-FEWS sensor was miniaturized to a size of 650 x 205 x 12.7 mm3 mounted on top of

an optical breadboard.

2.6 SCHeMA integrated autonomous marine water quality observatory system

The SCHeMA submersible chemical sensor probes can

be promptly prepared and deployed from multiple

platforms. They can be deployed individually or joined

all together to create a network of interconnected

measuring unit (Fig. 8).

Interfacing of the SCHeMA network of submersible

probes is achieved via a Network Controller built on an

open HW/SW platform based on LINUX operating

system and a custom hardware, specifically developed in

the frame of the project. The Network Controller custom

electronics is developed using up-to-date technologies,

which guarantee the maximum performance allowing the

interfacing of the SCHeMA submersible chemical probes

as well as other commercially available probes (e.g. CTD

and multiparameter probes). The network control unit is

completed with a wireless WAN data transceiver (GPRS,

UMTS) and an interface compliant with EU standards

(OGC SWE, SensorML, INSPIRE) and compatible with

EU infrastructures (e.g., EMODnet, SEIS).

Figure 7: (Top) IR-FEWS sensor system, (center)

system housing, (bottom) rendered image of the

developed optical sensor concept.

Peristaltic pump

Computer

FT-IR spectrometer

Thermoelectrically

cooled MCT detector

µ-flow cell with

AgX fiber

Figure 8: (Left) TMSM and (right)

Integrated system incorporating one

TMSM, CSM, ASM and CTD.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 16

An ad-hoc ICT wireless networking solution allows remote control of data transfer and system

reconfiguration (Sensor Panning Service – SPS) according to the OGC standard (Fig. 9). The land

station provides a web-based system interface for accessing sensor information and measured sensor

observation. This system is implemented as a SOS (Sensor Observation Service) system thus

providing standard interoperability and access to measured sensor observations – through

Observation and Measurements (O&M) standard – as well as sensor descriptions – encoded in

Sensor Model Language (SensorML).

A web-based system interface for accessing, interacting and configuring the SCHeMA network,

controller and probes, was developed according to the international OGC-SWE standards

(http://dataportal.schema-ocean.eu). The Schema Web Interface interoperability is based on the

exchange of standard messages between the service and the consumer by using the HTTP protocol.

The requests are sent to the service through an HTTP POST (XML file) or an HTTP GET method

(key-value-pairs) specifying the request type and the relative permitted parameters. The service

responses are always XML file compliant with the OGC specifications.

Figure 10: SCHeMA Web User Interface

User-friendly data discovery, access and download as well as interoperability with other projects are

achieved via dedicated interface compatible with INSPIRE and GEO/GEOSS standards and

principles.

Network Controller

SENSORS

SHDP SensorML, O&MCustom XML

Land Station(SOS Interface +

Custom interface)

Predefined XML template

SCHeMA Probe

XMLBinary

CTD

TMSM

NSM

CSM

ASM

Figure 9: SCHeMA SWE diagram. The submersible mapping system is managed by the Network Controller that

handles all the communication with the CTD (Multi-parameter submersible probe), TMSM (Trace Metals

Submersible Module), CSM or NSM (Carbonate or Nutrient Sensing Module) and ASM (Algae Sensing Module).

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 17

3 Performance of the field-evaluated SCHeMA chemical probes

The SCHeMA submersible trace metal, carbon cycle species, nutrient and algae sensing probes,

deployed individually or as part of the SCHeMA autonomous marine water quality observatory

system, have been evaluated in various Atlantic and Mediterranean coastal area characterized by

contrasting conditions (see D8.4 for details). The year 2017 SCHeMA field campaigns provided also

opportunity to evaluate on-board or in an on-shore laboratory the performances of yet non-

submersible devices, namely: Au-GIME sensor and methodology for direct detection of total

inorganic arsenic (As(III) + As(V)) and determination of arsenate (As(V) by substraction of As(III);

the VOCs portable sensing module.

The performance of the SCHeMA chemical probes revealed by the field data gathered in contrasting

conditions (i.e.: highly dynamic tidal areas, complete salinity gradient, low to high turbidity) were in-

line with the analytical specifications determined from their characterization in laboratory (Table 1)

validating their capability for direct measurements in complex media.

Table 1: Current analytical performances of the SCHeMA sensors and sensing probes.

(UM: Unit of measure. LOD: Limit of detection).

The potentialities of the SCHeMA individual sensing probes as efficient tools for environmental

studies and water quality control (Table 1, last column) were assessed by intercomparison of the

Cadmium dynamic 190 GIME / ng/L (nM) 2 (0.02)

Preconc.: 10 min

0.6 (0.005)

Preconc.: 30min

a) 2-11000 (0.02-100)

b) 0.6-5000 (0.005-50)

Preconc.: a) 10 and b) 30min

300

Env. monitoring (heavily to unpolluted area) /

Sentinel/Alarm system for:

Water quality control (EQS,WQS) /

Accidental emissions and discharges

Lead dynamic 190 GIME / ng/L (nM)4 (0.02)

Preconc.: 10min

1 (0.005)

Preconc.: 30min

a) 4-21000 (0.02-100)

b) 1-11000 (0.005-50)

Preconc.: a) 10 and b) 30min

300

Env. monitoring (heavily to unpolluted area) /

Sentinel/Alarm system for:

Water quality control (EQS,WQS) /

Accidental emissions and discharges

Copper dynamic 190 GIME / ng/L (nM)15 (0.25)

Preconc. 10min

6.3 (0.1)

Preconc.: 30min

a) 15-6500 (0.25-100)

b) 6.3-3000 (0.1-50)

Preconc.: a) 10 and b) 30min

300

Env. monitoring (heavily to unpolluted area) /

Sentinel/Alarm system for:

Water quality control (EQS,WQS) /

Accidental emissions and discharges

Zinc dynamic 190 GIME / ng/L (nM) 25 (0.40)

Preconc.: 10min

1.5 (0.015)

Preconc.: 30min

a) 25-6500 (0.40-50)

b ) 1.5-3000 (0.015-50)

Preconc.: a) 10 and b) 30min

300

Env. monitoring (heavily to unpolluted area) /

Sentinel/Alarm system for:

Water quality control (EQS,WQS) /

Accidental emissions and discharges

Inorganic arsenic (III) dynamic 190 AuNP-GIME / ng/L /nM)35 (0.50)

Preconc.: 10min

15 (0.2)

Preconc. 30min

a) 35-4000 (0.5-50)

b) 15-500 (0.2-15)

Preconc.: a) 10 and b) 30min

300

Env. monitoring (heavily to unpolluted area) /

Sentinel/Alarm system for:

Water quality control /

Accidental emissions and discharges

Inorganic As(V) + As(III) dynamic single Au-GIME / ng/L (nM) 100 (1.5)

Preconc.: 10min

35 (0.5)

Preconc. 30min

a) 100-4000 (1.5-50)

b) 35-500 (0.5-15)

Preconc.: a) 10 and b) 30min

surface

Env. monitoring (heavily to unpolluted area) /

Sentinel/Alarm system for:

Water quality control (EQS,WQS) /

Accidental emissions and discharges

Inorganic mercury (II) dynamic 190 AuNP-GIME / ng/L /nM) 8 (0.04)

Preconc.: 10min

2 (0.015)

Preconc.: 30min

a) 8-10000 (0.04-100)

b) 2-4000 (0.015-20)

Preconc.: a) 10 and b) 30min

300

Env. monitoring (heavily to slightly polluted area) /

Sentinel/Alarm system for:

Water quality control (EQS,WQS) /

Accidental emissions and discharges

Sea water pH Solid state ISE / - 3 3-9 30

Carbonate Solid-state ISE / mg/L (mM) 0.6 (0.01) 0.6-6000 (0.01-100) 30

Calcium Solid-state ISE / mg/L (mM) 0.4 (0.01) 0.4- 4000 (0.01-100) 30

Nitrate Solid state ISE / µg/L (µM) 56 (0.9) 56-62000 (0.9-10000) 30

Env. monitoring (heavily to slightly polluted area) /

Sentinel/Alarm system for:

Water quality control (EQS,WQS) /

Accidental emissions and discharges

Nitrite Solid state ISE / µg/L (µM) 28 (0.6) 28-46000 (0.6-10000) 30 Env. monitoring (heavily polluted area) /

Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

Benzene Optical / µg/L 18140 surface Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

Xylene isomers Optical / µg/L 420 surface Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

Toluene Optical / µg/L 7500 surface Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

trichloroethylene Optical / µg/L 2800 surface Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

1,3-dichlorobenzene Optical / µg/L 925 surface Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

Tetrachloroethylene Optical / µg/L 472 surface Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene Optical / µg/L 808 surface Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

p-cymene Optical / µg/L 1079 surface Alarm system: Accidental emissions/discharges

ASM

CSM

NSM

10 cells/LAlgae / Cyanobacteria

VOCs-SM

Optical / -

Applications

TMSM

Instrumental (Linear)

Response Range SCHeMA unit Parameter Sensor type/ UM Sensor LOD

Max. depth

/ m

30 Sentinel for harmful algal groups/bloom10 cells/L - 5.24E+9 cells/L

Sentinel for ocean acidification

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 18

performances achieved (Table 1) with the target chemical concentration ranges in open sea and

coastal area and, when available, the EU (or EU members) standards for environmental and water

quality (Table 2).

Table 2: Concentration ranges of the targeted chemicals in open sea and coastal/surface waters and EU or

European countries environmental quality standards (EQS) and water quality standards (WQS) for priority

substances.

a Depends on the ECO-REGION. b EQS refers to bioavailable concentrations of substances. Irish law in 2003. DLgs 172/15 Italy.

This evaluation revealed that:

The TMSM fulfils the performance requirements for direct detection of the target trace metals in

a concentration range covering the open sea (environmental background level concentration) to

highly polluted coastal areas by adjusting the preconcentration time. The only exception is Hg(II)

that presently is expected to be detected only in slightly to heavily polluted areas. The TMSM

has therefore great potentiality for environmental studies and water quality and pollution control.

It can be expected to be a valuable tool to allow more efficient and reliable environmental studies

on the influence of the bio-physicochemical conditions on trace metal speciation and especially

on the proportion of the metal-fraction available for bio-uptake. This is of primary concern for

trace metals that act either as toxicants (Hg(II), Cd(II), Pb(II), As(III), As(V)) or essential

micronutrients or toxicants (Cu(II), Zn(II)), depending on their concentrations, species and/or the

nature of the organisms. The TMSM has also the potentiality to serve as a real-time i) sentinel for

the tracing of diffuse or well-localized trace metal sources at extremely low levels; ii) alarm

system when the target analyte concentrations are close or above the EQS or WQS.

dissolved Cadmium 0.001-1.2 (nM) 0.005 - 25 (nM) 0.7 nM (0.08 µg/L) 1.8 nM (0.2 µg/L) 4.00 nM (0.45 µg/L) 4.00 nM (0.45 µg/L) 22nM (2.5 µg/L)

dissolved Lead 0.005-0.09 (nM) 0.03 - 200 (nM) 5.79 nM (1.2 µg/L)b 6.27 nM(1.3 µg/L) 67.57 nM(14 µg/L) 67.57 nM(14 µg/L) 120nM (25µg/L)

dissolved Copper 0.5-5 (nM) 1 - 235 (nM) 7.87 nM (0.5 µg/L) 80nM (5 µg/L)

dissolved Zinc 0.1 - 8 (nM) 0.3 - 680 (nM) 35.17 nM (2.3 µg/L) 610 nM (40µg/L)

dissolved Inorganic arsenic (III) 1 - 500 (nM) 130.00 nM

dissolved Inorganic arsenic (V) 10 nM 10 - 5000 nM

dissolved Inorganic arsenic (total) 10 nM 10 - 5000 nM 13 nM (1 µg/L) 0.07 nM (5 µg/L) 0.13 nM (10 µg/L) (25 µg/L)

dissolved Inorganic mercury (II) 0.0002-0.0015 (nM) 0.001 - 15 (nM) 0.25 nM (0.05 µg/L) 0.35 nM (0.07 µg/L) 0.35 nM (0.07 µg/L) 1.50 nM (0.3µg/L)

Sea water pH 7.8 - 8.3 7.6 - 8.4

Carbonate (surface) 0.2-0.28 (mM) 0.25 - 0.3 (mM)

Calcium 10.1-10.3 (mM) 9.8 - 12.2 (mM)

Nitrate concentration 0.01-5 (µM) 0.3 - 45 (µM) < 50 mg/L

Nitrite concentration 0.03 - 0.5 (µM)

VOCs < 0.5 ng/L

Benzene 10 (µg/L) 8 (µg/L) 50 (µg/L) 50 (µg/L) 30 (µg/L) 300 (µg/L)

Xylene isomers 5 (µg/L) 1 (µg/L) 30 (µg/L) 300 (µg/L)

Toluene 5 (µg/L) 1 (µg/L) 40 (µg/L) 400 (µg/L)

trichloroethylene 10 (µg/L) 10 (µg/L) not applicable not applicable 10 (µg/L)

1,3-dichlorobenzene 2 (µg/L) 0.5 (µg/L)

Tetrachloroethylene 10 (µg/L) 10 (µg/L) not applicable not applicable 10 (µg/L)

1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene 0.4 (µg/L) 0.4 (µg/L) not applicable not applicable 0.4 (µg/L)

Coastal /surface

water aAA-EQS (Inland

surface waters)

AA-EQS (Other

surface waters)

MAC-EQS (Inland

surface waters)Parameter Open Sea a MAC-EQS (Other

surface waters)AA-WQS MAC-WQS

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 19

The CSM fulfils the performance requirements for accurate measurement of the carbonate system

in both open seawater and coastal/surface waters and therefore has promising capability to serve

as a sentinel for ocean acidification and for studing carbonate precipitation/dissolution processes

that may be triggered by changes in the physical conditions of the media.

The NSM has demonstrated potential to serve as a sentinel for the tracking of anthropogenic

diffuse and punctual sources of nitrate and nitrite at relatively low concentrations in coastal area

and to act as an alarm system when the nitrate concentration is close or above the EU-WQS.

The ASM fulfils the performance requirements to identify and quantify, down to 10cells/L, toxin

producing cyanobacteria and dinoflagellates from among other algae in an algal assemblage of

mixed composition; and therefore has promising capability to serve as an efficient real-time

sentinel and alarm system for harmful algae groups at the very beginning of their bloom.

Moreover the ASM allows monitoring the spatial and temporal relative algal composition.

Identification of the algae are achieved due to a data base established fromcomprehensive study

of various algae species (76 algae species, 9 algae phyla) performed during the project and an in-

house software.

The portable VOC-SM developed is attractive due to its capability of simultaneous detection of a

range of VOCs. However, the remaining challenges are further improvement of the achievable

limit of detections towards the environmental limits recommended by the European Union.

Currently, the VOC-SM installed in industrial areas may serve as a real-time alarm system in

case of accidental emissions or release.

The evaluated promising capabilities of the SCHeMA individual sensing probes discussed above

were validated during the SCHeMA field campaigns (see Deliverable D8.4 for details).

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 20

4 Application for environmental monitoring directives and programs

The SCHeMA individual probes and integrated system are promising tools to address key aspects of

the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD) and to contribute to extend the capability of

ocean monitoring systems and programs.

4.1 Marine Strategy Framework Directive and Regional Sea Conventions

In 2008, the European Union has established the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD) with

a goal to protect the marine environment in Europe. The MSFD uses a set of 11 descriptors which,

together, summarize the way in which the whole system functions. Some of these descriptors can be

said to represent the most important ecosystem features of concern (D1 – Biological diversity, D2 –

Non-indigenous species (NIS), D3 – Commercial fish and shellfish, D4 – Food webs, D6 –Sea floor

integrity, D7 – Hydrological conditions) either in terms of favorable or threatened features, forming

different sectors of the ecosystem-based approach. Another part of the descriptors represents human

drivers, pressures on the ecosystems and their resulting alterations (D3 – Fishery, D5 –

Eutrophication, D8 –Contaminants, D10 – Litter, D11 – Energy and noise).

Table 3: Qualitative descriptors for determining good environmental status in the MSFD

(Directive 2008/56/EC).

The developed SCHeMA sensing probes address a number of variables relevant to several

descriptors (Table 4). Among these variables are a range of trace metals (D8) for which the

SCHeMA TMSM is presently the only available system allowing their real-time in situ detection.

Trace elements are ubiquitous and diverse components of the earth’s biogeochemistry, playing

critical roles in ecosystem functioning. Some metals (e.g. Hg, Cd, Pb) and metalloids (e.g. As) have

high toxicity even at very low concentrations, while others are either essential or toxic (e.g. Fe, Cu,

Zn), depending on their concentrations and the nature of the organisms exposed. Due to their

intrinsic properties of toxicity, persistence, and/or tendency to bio-accumulate, trace metals may

have a long-term impact on the biomass composition, activity and health, even a long time after a

significant decrease in their release. Therefore, as the nutrients (D5), they also contribute to the

achievement of D1 and D4.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 21

Table 4: Variables relevant to several descriptors of the MSFD and the monitoring programmes of the

HELCOM, OSPAR and Black Sea Regional Sea Conventions addressed by SCHeMA

The SCHeMA integrated autonomous marine water quality observatory system - interfacing the

TMSM, CSM, NSM and ASM together with a multiparameter probe - provides capabilities for

simultaneous, in situ, high-resolution monitoring of a significant number of parameters relevant to

the descriptors D1, D4, D5, D7 and D8. It appears therefore to be a very promising near future tool

to support studying, and ultimately better understanding, the synergic interaction between the

variables relevant to these descriptors.

The integration of the data of chemical monitoring programmes, and combination of data from

chemical and biological effects to define consistent sets of EQS taking account mixture effects, are

an active part of Science within the Regional Sea Conventions (i.e. OSPAR, HELCOM, Black Sea,

Barcelona Conventions). Therefore, the sensing probes suitable for in-situ and high-resolution

acquisition of a range of chemical and biological parameters (Table 4) in marine environments

(estuary, coastal and open ocean) as well as the ICT wireless networking solution and the Web data

information system developed as part of SCHeMA contribute to the availability of technological

solutions to address key aspects of these Conventions.

HELCOM OSPAR BlackSea

Cadmium dynamic fraction 8 x x x

Lead dynamic fraction 8 x x x

Copper dynamic fraction 4,8 x x x

Zinc dynamic fraction 4,8 x x x

Inorganic arsenic (III) dynamic fraction 8 x x x

Inorganic arsenic (V) dynamic fraction 8 x x x

Inorganic mercury (II) dynamic fraction 8 x x x

Sea water pH 7 x x x

Carbonate 4 x x x

Calcium 4 x x x

Nitrate concentration 4,5,7 x x x

Nitrite concentration 4,5,7 x x x

ASM Algae (Phytoplankton) / Cyanobacteria 1,4,5,7

VOCs-SM VOCs 2, 8 x

T 7

pH 7

Dissolved oxygen 4, 5, 7

Conductivity/Salinity 7

Turbidity 7

Chlorophyll a 4,5,7

Phycocyanin 4,5,7

Phycoerythrin 4,5,7

MSFD 2008/56/EC

Summarized

Descriptors

Sea Conventions

SCHeMA unit SCHeMA Parameter

Multiparameter probe

TMSM

CSM

NSM

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 22

4.2 Environmental monitoring programs

The SCHeMA submersible sensing modules (TMSM, CSM, NSM and ASM), thanks to their

technical specifications (low-power consumption, miniature multichannel sensing devices, wireless

interfaces) and analytical performances (selectivity, sensitivity, multielement analysis, high-

resolution data acquisition), together with the comprehensive ICT solution based on international

standards developed provide attractive new tools to address the objectives of a large number of on-

going environmental monitoring programs and projects as illustrated in Table 5. The aim of this table

is not to be exhaustive as there are many further initiatives (e.g. other H2020 projects) that are not

listed. The Table5 intends to show the relevance of the developed devices and tools to major

European monitoring programs and projects.

Some programs are mainly focusing on some specific parameters, therefore the individual modules

themselves are already valuable devices. Some other initiatives are looking at integrated datasets and

for those the integrated system is more pertinent.

Attractive advantages of the SCHeMA proposed solution are thereby:

the flexibility and modularity of the system that, in modules or as integrated system, can

contribute to studying ocean processes by providing high quality data for key parameters;

each of the developed SCHeMA submersible probes has the capability to monitor simultaneously

several parameters that are relevant to specific group of chemical and biological indicators while

being compact; most of the commercially available tools are restricted to the measurement of one

parameter per probe.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 23

Table 5: Variables relevant to several descriptors of the MSFD and monitoring programmes of the

HELCOM, OSPAR and Black Sea Regional Sea Conventions addressed by SCHeMA

EMODnet

Physics

EMODnet

Chemistry

EMODnet

DIngestion

Copernicus

Marine GOOS SOCAT SeaDataCloud

JERICO

Next AtlantOS Odyssea EMSO GEOSS

OGC

SWE

Cadmium dynamic fraction x x x x

Lead dynamic fraction x x x x

Copper dynamic fraction x x x x

Zinc dynamic fraction x x x x

Inorganic arsenic (III) dynamic fraction x x x x

Inorganic arsenic (V) dynamic fraction x x x x

Inorganic mercury (II) dynamic fraction x x x x

Sea water pH x x x x x x x x

Carbonate x x x x x x x x

Calcium x x x x x x

Nitrate concentration x x x x x x x

Nitrite concentration x x x x x x x

ASM Algae (Phytoplnakton) / Cyanobacteria x x x x x x x

T x x x x x x x x x x

pH x x x x x x x x x x x

Dissolved oxygen x x x x x x x x x

Conductivity/Salinity x x x x x x x x x x x

Turbidity x x x x x x x x x x

Chlorophyll a x x x x x x x x x

Phycocyanin x x x x x x x x x

Phycoerythrin x x x x x x x x x

Network controller x x x x

Data information system x x x x x x

Observation and monitoring programs Research Infrastructures and projects Interoperability

NSM

Multiparameter probe

SCHeMA unit SCHeMA Parameter

TMSM

CSM

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 24

5 Evaluation for post industrialization/commercialization

Prototypes of submersibles probes for trace metals, nutrients, species relevant to carbon cycle, and

algae have been successfully developed. A Network Controller and a Web-based system interface,

based on-up-to-date wireless data transceiver and standards, were also successfully developed. The

SCHeMA submersible individual probes and the autonomous integrated marine water quality

observatory system has been successfully field evaluated, validated and applied in Atlantic and

Mediterranean coastal areas (D8.4). There capabilities were demonstrated on-field to potential end-

users (see Deliverable D9.1). More than 20 thousand results were collected and loaded into the

SCHeMA project web data portal by means of the network controller.

The portable IR-FEWS sensor system allowing direct chemical sensing and continuous monitoring

of a range of dissolved volatile organic compounds was also evaluated on-site during the year 2017

SCHeMA field campaign.

The maturity level of the SCHeMA components and prototypes was first evaluated at month 36 to

choose the prototypes ready for the year 2017 field campaigns and on-field demonstration to end-

users. A re-evaluation was made at month 48 after the field evaluation and application in Atlantic

and Mediterranean coastal areas during the year 2017 (Table 6). The components that are the most

promising for short-term commercialization were identified (Table 6, last column).

Table 6: TRL ratings of the SCHeMA components and prototypes at month 36 and 48 and

SCHeMA units ready for short-term commercialization.

36M 48M

Cadmium dynamic fraction TRL8 TRL8

Lead dynamic fraction TRL8 TRL8

Copper dynamic fraction TRL8 TRL8

Zinc dynamic fraction TRL8 TRL8

Inorganic arsenic (III) dynamic fraction TRL3/TRL4 TRL6/7 Yes

Inorganic arsenic (V) dynamic fraction TRL1 TRL4 No

Inorganic mercury (II) dynamic fraction TRL3/TRL4 TRL6 Yes

Sea water pH TRL6 TRL6/7

Carbonate activity in water TRL6 TRL6/7

Calcium activity in water TRL6 TRL6/7

Nitrate concentration TRL5 TRL6/7

Nitrite concentration TRL5 TRL5

Phosphate concentration TRL1 TRL1

Algae / Cyanobacteria TRL6 TRL7

STX TRL3 TRL3

VOC IR-FEWS sensor system VOCs* TRL4 TRL4 No

TMSM HW/SW mechanic Trace metal submersible probe TRL8 TRL8 Yes

CSM HW/SW mechanic Carbon species submersible probe TRL7 TRL8 No

NSM HW/SW mechanic Nutrient species submersible probe TRL5 TRL7/8 No

ASM - HW/SW mechanic Algae sensing module TRL6 TRL7 No

FACM Single/double submersible peristaltic pump TRL8 TRL9 Yes

NC Network controller TRL8 TRL7/8 Yes

Web system interface Web-based system and user interfaces TRL8 TRL8 Yes

No

Yes

No

No

SC

HeM

A o

ther

com

ponents

SCHeMA unit Parameter

TM

SM

sensors

CS

M / N

SM

sensors

AS

M

dete

cto

r

LED

GIME

AuNP-GIME

Solid-state ISE

Solid-state ISE

Technology Readiness Level Commerciali

zation

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 25

The forecast on how the various devices could be industrialized and commercialized is discussed in

more detail below. These conservative forecasts and opinions have been formulated by Idronaut

(SCHeMA SME partner). IDRONAUT has been manufacturing state-of-the-art CTDs and advanced

sensors for 35 years, selling them all over the world to scientists in environmental sciences and

especially the marine research community (chemists, geochemists, biologists, oceanographers,

limnologists) studying aquatic environments. The present, extremely fluctuant market and average of

sales and declarations of interest in this kind of products that IDRONAUT has received in the last

few years from their sales network have been taken into account.

At the moment of the release of this document, the most promising project devices for

commercialization within short-term are:

The NC - Network Controller unit.

The TMSM – Fully integrated three-channel trace metals submersible probe measuring

simultaneously the potentially bioavailable Cd(II), Zn(II), Pb(II), Cu(II), As(III) and Hg(II)

fractions.

The FACM - Double and/or single submersible peristaltic pump with integrated battery pack

Web information

The other project products that we presently judge to need more important R&D investment prior to

commercialization are:

CSM - Submersible probes for in-situ simultaneous detection of species relevant to the

carbon cycle (pH, carbonate, calcium).

NSM - Submersible probes for in-situ simultaneous selective detection of nitrate and nitrite.

ASM – Fully integrated miniaturized multi-channel optical detection module enabling in-situ

early stage detection of phytoplankton species in algal blooms and the real-time identification

of their taxonomic affiliation.

5.1 NC - Network Controller

IDRONAUT presently produces and sells the BUOY CONTROLLER unit, which is the core of the

IDRONAUT BUOY 601 PROFILER system. The BUOY CONTROLLER unit has become obsolete

and in the future the SCHeMA Network Controller will replace it.

Before introducing the NC into the market, it is necessary that IDRONAUT provides the R&D

investment to rebuild the NC electronics and add the HW/SW interface for the available

IDRONAUT BUOY WINCH PROFILER. The motorized winch interface is a unique feature that

makes the NC different from the many other “data loggers” presently available on the market and

makes it indispensable to guarantee the BUOY PROFILER product continuity.

When the NC is ready for the commercialization, IDRONAUT will collaborate with ETT, which

developed the NC OGC/SWE interface and the WEB DATA PORTAL, to offer a complete and up-

to-date solution. This collaboration will guarantee the interoperability of the NC with the most

important international networks of marine monitoring, such as: EMODnet, GOOS, EuroGOOS,

Copernicus Marine Environmental Monitoring Service, and SeaDataNet network of National

Oceanographic Data Centers (now running the SeaDataCloud project).

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 26

5.2 TMSM - Three-channel trace metal sensing probe

IDRONAUT presently produces and sells the GIME-VIP (Voltammetric In Situ Profiler), a single-

channel submersible trace metal probe, to detect: Zn, Cu, Pb, and Cd in marine and fresh waters21

.

The VIP was developed in collaboration with UNIGE and IMT as part of a previous EU project

(VAMP- MAST III program, contract no. MAS3-CT95-0033). The VIP is the only system

commercially available with capacity for in situ trace metal monitoring and profiling, down to 500

m, with sub-nanomolar sensitivity.

The TMSM, based on up-to-date electronic components and highly integrated sensors is of similar

size as the VIP albeit providing three independent measuring channels. The novel and highly

integrated sensors greatly simplify the preparation and field deployment and provide new trace

metals detection capability (As (III), Hg (II) using novel AuNP-GIME).

Reliable mass production of on-chip 190 interconnected Ir-based arrays using simplified

deposition/patterning protocols has been demonstrated. The sensitivity of GIME prepared using these

novel on-chip devices is twice as high that reached previously3. The GIME-TMSM can therefore

replace advantageously the GIME-VIP.

Concerning the AuNP-GIME for direct detection of As(III) and Hg(II), R&D investment is still

required as the preparation of these sensors is far from being reproducible enough to be performed by

non-specialist end-users. Further improvement in term of sensitivity for Hg(II) detection is also

required for environmental studies.

We believe that the TMSM, when completed and fully characterized, could induce new interest

mainly in the Far East countries like China and India where the demand for trace metal analysis,

especially As(III) and Hg(II), in water is increasing. In Europe, the interest is presently scarce,

mainly because of the lack of funds for environmental monitoring. However, we believe that the

interest for the TMSM could greatly increase if i) the revised WFD Priority Substance Directive

(2013/39/EU) suggesting to monitor the bioavailable concentration of trace metals instead of their

total concentration, and ii) the MSFD (2008/56/EC) extending the requirement to monitor and define

appropriate EQS not only for the WFD priority substances but for all substances entailing a

significant risk to the health of marine environment22

are properly supported, which is the case for

the targeted trace metals.

5.3 FACM - Submersible peristaltic pump

The developed submersible double and/or single submersible peristaltic pumps with integrated

battery pack are ready for the commercialization. This is rather a new market where IDRONAUT

was not present before. Therefore, it is difficult to estimate the potentiality of this rather unique and

peculiar product. After the end of the project, IDRONAUT will start a dissemination campaign

(newsletters via email, advertising on specialized magazines) to their dealers and sales network and

will then verify the interest in this kind of product.

5.4 CSM and NSM - Nutrient and Carbon species submersible probes

Even though these devices are based on innovative all solid-state ISE and in-line desalinator and

acidification modules, they need a more important R&D investment before commercialization.

Indeed, the sensors for nutrients (nitrate and nitrite) and species relevant to the carbon cycle

(calcium, carbonate, pH) as well as desalinator and acidification modules are still hand-made

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 27

laboratory prototypes and the associated required fluidic systems are still too complex. More rugged

devices that can be readily assembled and ideally deployed without the requirement of a fluidic

housing, limiting deployment at depth > 30 m, are needed.

We believe that when such developments will be completed and the new probes fully characterized,

the CSM and NSM could show significant interest as the measurement of nutrients and CO2 are

important topics for the scientific community and environmental protection agencies all around the

world.

5.5 ASM – Miniaturized multi-channel algae sensing module

The algae detection module is at prototype stage and while it has been successfully validated in field

and in laboratory it is still far from becoming an industrial product that can be commercialized as it

is.

The system is ready for inclusion into submersible housings and can be deployed in surface water

down to ~30 m depth.

Products characterizing the algae in water, such as: i) Chelsea V-Lux; ii) Turner designs PhytoFind;

iii) Bbe-Moldaenke GMBH Fluoroprobe; etc., currently present on the market, are integrated

submersible probes that are sold as standalone probes or OEM components ready for the integration

into CTD or/and multi-parameter submersible probes. However, we think that with further R&D

investment to produce a more rugged device that can be deployed without the requirement of a

fluidic housing the ASM may be competitive due to due to its extremely miniaturized size (Fig. 5),

very low-cost components, validated algorithms to correct biological and chemical interferences, and

integrated data base. Low-cost alarm systems for the early detection of harmful algal blooms (HABs)

having important socio-economic impacts represent a huge potential market as such blooms are

occurring with increased regularity worldwide.

5.6 Web based system interface

The developed web interface relies on a very innovative and unique information system. It includes

several modules each of them providing key features (e.g. OGC SWE interoperability, interactive

data quality check and quality flagging, sensing probes planning services, sensor alarm system etc.)

that can be activate or de-activate according to the specific needs of the user. The developed

information system is highly flexible and as it interacts with the hardware by means of SOS standard,

it can also be connected to interact with any device supporting such an interface. The system was

also designed to provide access at multiple users having various right levels on the control of the

mapping modules, thereby turning the information system in a high valuable tool and at high

exploitation potential.

Besides being the ICT interface for the SCHeMA system when it is going to be sold, ETT can

already propose the SCHeMA web package on the market. Clients can be institutes owning systems

that support SOS and interested in having a complete tool to interact with their device and data, as

well as owners of devices that are interested in one specific SCHeMA web features (e.g. the Quality

Check / Quality Flag, QC/QF).

Moreover, the expertise that ETT gained by developing the SCHeMA ICT wireless networking

solution facilitated ETT being invited to participate to meetings and to collaborate to projects

adopting OGC standards. These projects are targeting remote sensing and internet data information

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 28

system solutions for a broad range of monitoring programs (environment, land, buildings,

infrastructure for transport, etc).

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 29

6 References

1. M.-L. Tercier-Waeber, S. Stoll, V. Slaveykova. Trace metal behavior in surface waters: emphasis

on dynamic speciation, sorption processes and bioavailability. Review. Archive of Science, 65,

2012, 119-142.

2. M.-L. Tercier-Waeber, F. Confalonieri, M. Fighera. Lab-on-Cable for in situ real-time

monitoring of the bioavailable fraction of a range of trace metals. Front. Mar. Sci., in prep.

3. M. Fighera, P.D. van der Wal, M.-L. Tercier-Waeber, H. Shea. New designed interconnected

microelectrode arrays and their evaluation for trace metal detection. Sensors & Actuators,

Submitted

4. J. Buffle, M.-L. Tercier-Waeber. Voltammetric environmental trace-metal analysis and

speciation: from laboratory to in situ measurements. (Review). Trends in Analytical Chemistry,

24 (2005) 172-191.

5. H. P. Van Leeuwen, R.M. Town, J. Buffle, R.F.M.J. Cleven, L. Sigg. Dynamic speciation

analysis and bioavailability of metals in aquatic systems. Env. Sci. Tech. 39 (2005) 8545-8556.

6. D. Yuan, A.H.C. A.H.C. Anthis, A. M. Ghahraman, N. Pankratova, M. Cuartero, G.A. Crespo, E.

Bakker. All-Solid-State Potentiometric Sensors with a Multiwalled Carbon Nanotube Inner

Transducing Layer for Anion Detection in Environmental Samples. Anal. Chem. 87 (2015) 8640-

8645.

7. M. Cuartero, N. Pankratova. T. Cherubini, G. Crespo, F. Massa, F. Confalonieri, E. Bakker. In

Situ Detection of Species Relevant to the Carbon Cycle in Seawater with Submersible

Potentiometric Probes. Environ. Sci. Technol. Let. 4 (2017) 410-415.

8. M. Cuartero, E. Bakker. Environmental Water Analysis with Membrane Electrodes. Curr. Opin.

Electrochem. (2017) DOI : 10.1016/j.coelec.2017.06.010

9. M. Cuartero; G.A. Crespo, E. Bakker. Tandem Electrochemical Desalination-Potentiometric

Nitrate Sensing for Seawater Analysis. Anal. Chem. 87 (2015) 8084

10. N. Pankratova, M. Cuartero, T. Cherubini, G.A. Crespo, E. Bakker. In-Line Acidification for

Potentiometric Sensing of Nitrite in Natural Waters. Anal. Chem. 89 (2017) 571

11. Harmful Algal Blooms, National Oceanic And Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), United

States Department of Commerce, 2014.

12. L. Bláha, P. Babica, B. Maršálek, Interdiscip. Toxicol. 2009, 2, DOI 10.2478/v10102-009-0006-

2.

13. P. Hoagland, D. M. Anderson, Y. Kaoru, A. W. White, Estuaries 2002, 25, 819–837.

14. G. M. Hallegraeff, Phycologia 1993, 32, 79–99.

15. L. Wang, E. Liu, Y. Cheng, D. N. Bekele, D. Lamb, Z. Chen, M. Megharaj, R. Naidu, Talanta

2015, 144, 1104–1110.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 30

16. A. D. Nikolaou, S. K. Golfinopoulos, M. N. Kostopoulou, G. a. Kolokythas, T. D. Lekkas, Water

Res. 2002, 36, 2883–2890.

17. R. Lu, W.-W. Li, B. Mizaikoff, A. Katzir, Y. Raichlin, G.-P. Sheng, H.-Q. Yu, Nat. Protoc.

2016, 11, 377–386.

18. T. Schädle, B. Pejcic, M. Myers, B. Mizaikoff, Anal. Chem. 2014, 86, 9512–9517.

19. M. Karlowatz, M. Kraft, B. Mizaikoff, Anal. Chem. 2004, 76, 2643–2648.

20. M. N. Kostopoulou, S. K. Golfinopoulos, a D. Nikolaou, N. K. Xilourgidis, T. D. Lekkas,

Chemosphere 2000, 40, 527–532.

21. M-L. Tercier-Waeber, J. Buffle, F. Confalonieri, G. Riccardi, A. Sina, F. Graziottin, G.C.

Fiaccabrino, M. Koudelka-Hep. Submersible voltammetric probes for in situ trace element

measurements in surface water, groundwater and sediment-water interface, Meas. Sci. Technol.,

10 (1999) 1202-1213.

22. V. Tomero, G. Hanke. Chemical contaminants entering the marine environment from sea-based

sorces: A review with a focus on European seas. Mar. Poll. Bul. 112 (2016) 17-38.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 31

7 Annex 1: Regional Sea Conventions

HELCOM

www.helcom.fi

HELCOM (Baltic Marine Environment Protection Commission - Helsinki Commission) is the

governing body of the Convention on the Protection of the Marine Environment of the Baltic Sea

Area, known as the Helsinki Convention. The Contracting Parties are Denmark, Estonia, the

European Union, Finland, Germany, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Russia and Sweden.

HELCOM was established about four decades ago to protect the marine environment of the Baltic

Sea from all sources of pollution through intergovernmental cooperation.

OSPAR

https://www.ospar.org/

OSPAR is the mechanism by which 15 Governments & the EU cooperate to protect the marine

environment of the North-East Atlantic.

OSPAR started in 1972 with the Oslo Convention against dumping and was broadened to cover land-

based sources of marine pollution and the offshore industry by the Paris Convention of 1974. These

two conventions were unified, up-dated and extended by the 1992 OSPAR Convention. The new

annex on biodiversity and ecosystems was adopted in 1998 to cover non-polluting human activities

that can adversely affect the sea.

The fifteen Governments are Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Iceland, Ireland,

Luxembourg, The Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and United Kingdom.

OSPAR is so named because of the original Oslo and Paris Conventions ("OS" for Oslo and "PAR"

for Paris).

Black Sea Commission

http://www.blacksea-commission.org/

Acting on the mandate of the Black Sea countries (Bulgaria, Georgia, Romania, Russian Federation,

Turkey and Ukraine) which on the 21-04-1992, signed and shortly thereafter ratified the Convention

on the Protection of the Black Sea Against Pollution, the Commission on the Protection of the Black

Sea Against Pollution (the Black Sea Commission) implements the provisions of the Convention and

the Black Sea Strategic Action Plan.

The Main Challenges are:

Combating Pollution from land-based sources and maritime transport,

Achieving sustainable management of marine living resources,

Pursuing sustainable human development.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 32

8 Annex 2: Environmental monitoring programs and projects

European Marine Observation and Data network

www.emodnet.eu

The European Marine Observation and Data Network (EMODnet) is a network of organizations

supported by the EU’s integrated maritime policy. These organizations work together to observe the

sea, process the data according to international standards and make that information freely available

as interoperable data layers and data products.

This "collect once and use many times" philosophy benefits all marine data users, including policy

makers, scientists, private industry and the public. It has been estimated that such an integrated

marine data policy will save at least one billion Euros per year, as well as opening up new

opportunities for innovation and growth.

EMODnet provides access to European marine data across seven discipline-based themes:

Bathymetry, Geology, Seabed habitats, Chemistry, Biology, Physics, Human activities. For each of

these themes, EMODnet has created a gateway to a range of data archives managed by local,

national, regional and international organizations. Through these gateways, users have access to

standardized observations, data quality indicators and processed data products, such as basin-scale

maps. These data products are free to access and use.

Among the others, three EMODnet thematic assemblies are very pertinent to SCHeMA activities and

in particular: EMODnet Chemistry, and EMODnet Physics.

EMODnet Chemistry

www.emodnet-chemistry.eu

Water chemistry data acquisition is often in the centre of routine monitoring efforts of Member

States in response to national and European legislation or regional obligations.

EMODnet Chemistry (http://www.emodnet-chemistry.eu) provides access to individual

measurements as well as a range of products such as interpolated maps of chemical variables per

region over time and graphics of station time series. Data include measurements of fertilizers,

dissolved gases, chlorophyll, silicates, pH, Organic Matter, synthetic compounds, trace metals,

hydrocarbons, radionuclides, and plastics.

EMODnet Physics

www.emodnet-physics.eu

Europe’s oceans and atmosphere are constantly measured and monitored through an extensive

network of remote, fixed and mobile in situ observing stations. The volume of data collected this

way is substantially enormous, ranging from the most fundamental information such as sea level,

atmospheric pressure, sea temperature and salinity, to more complex measurements of turbidity and

fluorescence in the water column.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 33

EMODnet Physics (http://www.emodnet-physics.eu/) provides a single gateway to near real-time

data and historical time series and datasets covering a wide range of physical conditions of the

European sea-basins monitored both by fixed and mobile observation platforms such as moorings,

drifters, gliders and ferryboxes. With high level services, features and functionalities, but not

duplicating services or adding complexity, the EMODnet Physics data portal provides near real-time

data and metadata provided by national data owners originators organized at EuroGOOS Regional

level according the ROOS’s distributed infrastructure and conventions. Achieved validated data are

made available in collaboration with the network of National Oceanographic Data Centres (NODCs)

organized under the SeaDataNet (SDN) network.

EMODnet Physics provides free and open access to all available near real time data from the latest

60 days to any user without the need for registration. Operational platforms provide data time series

as soon as data is ready; for example a fixed platform delivers data daily, and an ARGO float

delivers almost weekly.

EMODnet Data Ingestion and safe keeping

www.emodnet-ingestion.eu

The EMODnet Data Ingestion portal seeks to identify and to reach out to other potential providers in

order to make their data sets also part of the total offer. It aims at streamlining the data ingestion

process so that data holders from public and private sectors that are not yet connected to the existing

marine data management infrastructures can easily release their data for safekeeping and subsequent

distribution through EMODnet. This will enrich the total offer for all types of users and conform to

the EMODnet motto 'collect data once and use it many times'.

Copernicus Marine Environment Monitoring Service

www.cmems-marine.eu

The Copernicus Marine Service, CMEMS, offers a wide range of oceanographic products:

observation products (in situ and satellite) and numerical modelling products. These various

products, gathered in a unique catalogue, cover the global ocean and the 6 European basins: Arctic,

Baltic, North West Shelves and South West Shelves, Mediterranean Sea and Black Sea. These

products inform on physical and biogeochemical states of the oceans. They cover long temporal

periods starting from the 1990’s or near real-time for observation products and few days forecast for

modelling products.

Within the Copernicus Marine Service, the In Situ thematic centre products are organised by region

for the global ocean and the six European seas. All in situ platforms of a given region are therefore

gathered together to one same product.

In situ data in a given region are collected, quality controlled and distributed into a product that can

be NRT (assessed using automated procedures) for real time activities or reprocessed (assessed by

scientific teams) for reanalysis and research activities. The products are distributed by the

Copernicus Marine Service via an online catalogue where formats, access and information are

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 34

similar for all products. A service desk is ensuring the interface with users and supports them during

office hours with any question and request.

The Copernicus Marine Service provides an open and free service according to the service

commitments and licence. To be able to download products, a user needs first to register. He/she

then has access to any product of the catalogue.

Thanks to this registration, CMEMS has set up a user monitoring which enables statistics of the

service and a targeted communication and support to users depending of their download behaviour.

Global Ocean Observing System

http://www.goosocean.org/

GOOS is a program executed by the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC) of the

UNESCO, but its success relies on the coordinated contributions of several people and organizations

worldwide.

The GOOS governance model is divided in three tiers: a multinational Steering Committee to

provide oversight, scientific Expert Panels to guide system requirements, and Observation

Coordination Groups that implement global unified network execution. The GOOS Project Office

facilitates the collaboration between these different governance bodies.

GOOS Regional Alliances (GRAs) identify, enable, and develop sustained GOOS ocean monitoring

and services to meet regional and national priorities, aligning the global goals of GOOS with the

need for services and products satisfying local requirements.

The European GRA is EuroGOOS (www.eurogoos.eu)

Surface Ocean CO2 Atlas

https://www.socat.info/

The Surface Ocean CO2 Atlas (SOCAT) is a synthesis activity for quality-controlled, surface ocean

fCO2 (fugacity of carbon dioxide) observations by the international marine carbon research

community (>100 contributors).

SeaDataCloud

https://www.seadatanet.org/About-us/SeaDataCloud

SeaDataNet is a standardized infrastructure for managing the large and diverse data sets collected by

the oceanographic fleets and the automatic observation systems. The SeaDataNet infrastructure

network and enhance the currently existing infrastructures, which are the national oceanographic

data centers or data focal points of 34 countries, active in data collection. The networking of these

professional data centers, in a unique virtual data management system provide integrated data sets of

standardized quality on-line. As a research infrastructure, SeaDataNet contributes to build research

excellence in Europe.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 35

SeaDataNet connects together more than 100 data centers aiming at preserving and making re-

useable marine observations ranging from ocean physics to chemistry and biology.

SeaDataNet infrastructure was implemented during the SeaDataNet project (2006-2011), grant

agreement 026212, EU Sixth Framework Programme. The second phase, SeaDataNet 2

project (2011-2015), grant agreement 283607, EU Seventh Framework Program has upgraded the

SeaDataNet infrastructure into an operationally robust and state-of-the-art Pan-European

infrastructure for providing up-to-date and high quality access to ocean and marine metadata, data

and data products by: setting, adopting and promoting common data management standards,

realizing technical and semantic interoperability with other relevant data management systems and

initiatives on behalf of science, environmental management, policy making, and economy.

SeaDataCloud project (2016-2020), grant agreement 730960, EU H2020 program, aims at

considerably advancing SeaDataNet Services and increasing their usage, adopting cloud and High

Performance Computing technology for better performance.

JericoNEXT

http://www.jerico-ri.eu/

The coastal area is the most productive and dynamic environment of the world ocean with significant

resources and services for mankind.

JERICO-NEXT emphasizes that the complexity of the coastal ocean cannot be well understood if

interconnection between physics, biogeochemistry and biology is not guaranteed. Such integration

requires new technological developments allowing continuous monitoring of a larger set of

parameters.

In the continuity of JERICO (FP7), the objective of JERICO-NEXT consists in strengthening and

enlarging a solid and transparent European network in providing operational services for the timely,

continuous and sustainable delivery of high quality environmental data and information products

related to marine environment in European coastal seas.

In order to reach its ambitious objectives, JERICO-NEXT will concentrate the efforts on 3

coordinated activities (i.e. NA, TNA and JRA). The work flow is organized in 8 work packages plus

one dedicated to the coordination (WP9). WP1, 2, 5 and 8 are devoted to Networking Activities

(NA) with objective to federate the consortium around actions strategically important to sustain the

JERICO-RI on long term. Joint Research Activities (JRA) are including technical and

methodological developments in WP3. In addition, the Joint Research Activity projects (JRAPs) are

relevant to the 6 JERICO-NEXT thematic areas implemented in WP4. Support Actions to the

infrastructure are distributed in WP6 for Virtual Access and in WP7 for Trans National Access.

AtlantOS

https://www.atlantos-h2020.eu

AtlantOS is a BG 8 (Developing in-situ Atlantic Ocean Observations for a better management and

sustainable exploitation of the maritime resources) research and innovation project that proposes the

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 36

integration of ocean observing activities across all disciplines for the Atlantic, considering European

as well as non-European partners.

The vision of AtlantOS is to improve and innovate Atlantic observing by using the Framework of

Ocean Observing to obtain an international, more sustainable, more efficient, more integrated, and

fit-for-purpose system. Hence, the AtlantOS initiative will have a long-lasting and sustainable

contribution to the societal, economic and scientific benefit arising from this integrated approach.

This will be achieved by improving the value for money, extent, completeness, quality and ease of

access to Atlantic Ocean data required by industries, product supplying agencies, scientist and

citizens.

The overarching target of the AtlantOS initiative is to deliver an advanced framework for the

development of an integrated Atlantic Ocean Observing System that goes beyond the state-of –the-

art, and leaves a legacy of sustainability after the life of the project.

The legacy will derive from the AtlantOS aims at:

improving international collaboration in the design, implementation and benefit sharing of

ocean observing,

promoting engagement and innovation in all aspects of ocean observing,

facilitating free and open access to ocean data and information,

enabling and disseminate methods of achieving quality and authority of ocean information,

strengthening the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS) and to sustain observing systems

that are critical for the Copernicus Marine Environment Monitoring Service and its

applications and

contributing to the aims of the Galway Statement on Atlantic Ocean Cooperation

Odyssea

http://odysseaplatform.eu/

ODYSSEA will develop, operate and demonstrate an interoperable and cost-effective platform that

fully integrates networks of observing and forecasting systems across the Mediterranean basin,

addressing both the open sea and the coastal zone.

The platform will collect its data from the many databases maintained by agencies, public

authorities, and institutions of Mediterranean EU and non-EU countries, integrating existing earth

observation facilities and networks in the Mediterranean Sea building on key initiatives such as

Copernicus, GEOSS, GOOS, EMODNet, ESFRI, Lifewatch, Med-OBIS, GBIF, AquaMaps, Marine

IBA e-atlas, MAPAMED and others with marine and maritime links. Through ODYSSEA’s end-user

centered approach, in which the various groups of end-users and stakeholders, within and external to

the Consortium, will be involved from Day 1 of the project in the design, development and operation

of the platform, including identification of gaps in data collection and accessibility.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 37

EMSO

http://www.emso-eu.org

The European Multidisciplinary Seafloor and water column Observatory (EMSO) aims at

further exploring the oceans, to gain a better understanding of phenomena happening within and

below them, and to elucidate the critical role that these phenomena play in the broader Earth systems.

EMSO is a system of observatories distributed in the European seas that provide key data and

constant monitoring of marine environments. Eleven key areas have been selected across the Arctic

Ocean, the Atlantic Ocean, the Mediterranean Sea and the Black Sea where facilities are located to

screen and study environmental processes.

EMSO’s deep-seafloor and water column observatories constantly measure different biogeochemical

and physical parameters, such as water temperature and acidity, and ground/water interactions

such as during earthquakes and tsunamis. The facilities offer scientists new opportunities to study

multiple, interrelated natural phenomena over time scales ranging from seconds to decades, from

episodic to long term processes.

Global Earth Observation System of Systems

The Global Earth Observation System of Systems (GEOSS) is composed of contributed Earth

Observation systems, ranging from systems collecting primary data, to systems concerned with the

creation and distribution of information products. Although GEOSS systems continue to operate

within their own mandates, since 2007 (GEO 2007) GEOSS system community started a process of

interconnection and harmonization of data, applications, models, and products, i.e. the development

of the GEOSS Common Infrastructure (GCI).

Within the GCI, a fundamental and common approach is to link different information systems via a

federation architecture in which different systems interoperate by means of common standards,

models, and interfaces.

Currently, to classify a system and rank its GCI compliancy four metrics are applied:

Data accessibility – this metrics tests whether a matching resource is accessible with “one

click”, meaning the returned record contains a clickable link that downloads the data (or the

map). Data accessibility is usually verified considering three features:

o The presence of “access information” in the metadata describing the resource;

o The score provided by an online service run to test the actual resource accessibility;

o The existence of a preview service;

GEOSS Social Benefit Areas Essential Variables – this metrics verifies if the system is

providing one or more of the following SBAs1:

o Climate SBA - Global Climate Observing System2;

o Biodiversity SBA - GEO BON3;

1 more can/will be added in the future

2 http://www.wmo.int/pages/prog/gcos/index.php?name¼EssentialClimateVariables.

10/11/2017 PU: Public

SCHeMA – 614002_ D10.9 38

o Water/Ocean SBA - UNESCO4 and Southern Ocean Observing System

5.

GEOSS Data Core – this metrics checks if data is full and open access;

Metadata Completeness – to verify if a matching resource is sufficiently described, thus

allowing evaluation.

Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) standards

An Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) standard is: “a document, established by consensus and

approved by the OGC Membership, that provides rules and guidelines, aimed at the optimum degree

of interoperability in a given context”, more specifically the OGC standards6 are developed to make

geo-enable and geo-processing technologies ready to the web and to enable geo-web based services

in various contexts (e.g. Aviation, Defence, Geoscience, Spatial data infrastructure, Sensor Webs,

etc.) ranging from local to global level”.

3 http://www.earthobservations.org/documents/cop/bi_geobon/ebvs/201303_ebv_table.pdf.

4 http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0021/002112/211260e.pdf

5 http://www.soos.aq/index.php/science/eovs

6 The full list of OGC standards is available at http://www.opengeospatial.org/standards