21

people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

���������������� ��� ������������������� ���������� �!�����#"$�������%�&��' ��)(

*�+-,/.1032�46587:9<;>=@?ACB-DFE/GIH�BJDLKNMIB-O�PRQ/SLDLKNDFT/DUGWVYX�Q/KNZWGI[\SLKND\]�^-_a`�b3_c^/[\d

`�b3_c^/[\d�Vfe�Q/g3OhB3Q/d

i�j�k:l$m�i n$lof^p[\G�MIBJSLD�G�Z-B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ�r:B-SLG�d�^pQsSLKqQ/gWONG%t:[\G�d:KNM�DLKN^pQ/SuV:GIB-M�E�d:G�DLGI[UH�KqQ/G�d�_R[\^pHvB3Q�KqH�twGI[x_cG�M�DUOy]�^/r3zSLGI[\ZWG�d&KhQ/KNDLKqB-O{SUDFB-DLGWV|KNS�KhQ/M�^/H�t/ONG�DLGW}�^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q:B-OaT:Q/M�GI[�DFB-KqQWD\]�KqH�t/ONKNG�S�DFE:B-D BWQ&GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�^-_KhQ/KNDLKqB-O�SLDFBJDLG�S'^-_�DFE/G�SL]/SLDLGIH�KNS�M�^pQ/SUKySUDLGIQWDs�$KNDFE6B�gWKNZWGIQ�^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q���PxQ6BCQ/^pQ/ONKqQ/GIBW[sSL]pS�zDLGIH�V�DFE/KNS�KqQ/KyDUKhBJO�d:KNSLD@[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQC��KyONO�d:G�ZWG�ON^pt�B�Q/^pQ3z��'B3T/SLSLKqBWQ�SLD@[LT/M�DFT:[\GWV�G�ZWGIQ�K�_ DFE/G�_�^p[\G�MIBJSLDH�^pd:G�O�KNS�t:GI[x_�G�M�DI� i t:GI[x_�G�M�D�t:[\G�d:KNM�DLKN^pQ��cDFE:B-D�KNSIV�_�^p[\G�MIB-SLDUKhQ/g6�>�p��_RT/DFT:[\G�SLDFBJDLG�^J_ DFE/G�SL]pS�zDLGIH���_�[�^pH�BWQ6T:Q/M�GI[\D@B-KqQ6KqQ/KNDLKqB-O ^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQ�V�KNS�Q/^WD�t:^WSLSUKhr/ONG�G�ZWGIQ��$KNDFE�BCt:GI[�_cG�M�D�H�^pd:G�O���{G�D%D@E/KySsKh[U[\G�dfT/M�Kqr/OyGCT:Q/M�GI[\D@B-KqQWD\]�KyS�B-M�M�^pT:Q3DFBWr/ONGWV�KqQ�DFE:BJD%KND�KNS�d:KNSLDLKqQ/M�Ds_�[\^/H�H�^pd:G�O�GI[L[\^/[��e�Q/SLGIH�r/ONG�t:[\G�d:KNM�DLKN^pQ�^-_�Q/^/Q/OyKqQ/GIBW[�SL]/SLDLGIH�S'[\G�ZWGIB-ONS�SFE/^p[�DLM�^pH�KqQ/gWS�KhQ)DFE/G�DF[LB-d:KNDLKN^pQ:B-O{G�Z-B-OqT3zB-DLKN^pQ�^J_{_c^p[�G�MIB-SLD\zRZWGI[�K��fMIBJDLKN^pQt:B-Kq[\S��$KNDFE&ONGIB-SLD\zRSU ¡T:BW[�G�dGI[L[\^/[$M�^WSUD�_�T:Q/M�DUKy^/Q/SI}¢BWQ&B-ONDLGI[LQ:B-DUKyZ3GG�Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ�^-_�KqH�t:GI[�_cG�M�D�H�^/d:G�OyS�D@E:[\^pT/gpE�DFE/G�Kq[�BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^�SFE:B-d:^-�£T:Q/M�GI[�DFB-KqQ�^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNSd:KySUMIT/SLSLG�d���¤�K�¥�MIT/ONDLKNG�S�SFT:[L[\^/T:Q/d:KhQ/g&DFE/G�M�^pQ/SUDF[LT/M�DLKN^pQ�^-_�B3Q�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�^-_$KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/SBW[\G�M�^pQ/SLKNd:GI[\G�d�V/DFE/G$KqH�t/ONKNMIB-DLKN^pQ/S�^-_YKqH�twGI[x_cG�M�D�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�S$BW[\G$Q/^WDLG�d�V/BWQ/d�DFE/G�T/SLG$^-_¢r:[\G�G�d:KqQ/gZWG�M�DL^p[\S$BWQ/d�SUKhQ/g/T/OhB3[�ZWG�M�DL^p[\S�KNS�M�^pQWD@[LB-SLDLG�d�KqQ�ON^-��zRd:KqH�GIQ/SLKN^pQ:B-O�SL]/SLDLGIH�Su�

� � PR¦ l$m `�¤'X n$l PR`�¦

§�E/KNOyG�t:[\G�d:KNM�DLKN^pQ/S�_�^pT:Q/d:G�d�T:t:^pQ�OyG�SUS DFE:B3Qt:GI[�_cG�M�D$^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQ/S ��KyONO{B-ON�$BI]/S rwG'KqQ�GI[L[�^p[�V:��G�MIBWQ�SLDF[\KNZWGDL^�B-M�M�^pT:Q3D¨_c^/[�D@E/G�^p[\KNgWKqQ�^-_�_c^p[�G�MIB-SLD�GI[U[\^p[\SI�{PxQt:BW[\DUKyMIT/OqBW[©V:��G MIBWQ�BJDLDLGIH�t/D¨DL^�d:G�DLGI[LH�KqQ/G'D@E/G�G�bpDLGIQ3D�DL^� E/KNM�E�SFE/^p[�DLM�^pH�KqQ/gWS{BW[\G{dfT/G�� � ��DL^�H�KNSLKqQWDLGI[Ut:[\G�DLKqQ/g�DFE/G�B-M�MIT:[LBJM�]�^-_¡D@E/G�^pr/SLGI[�Z~B-DLKN^pQ/SuV¡��ª3��DL^ H�^/d:G�O/GI[L[\^p[�V^p[���«3��DL^DFE/GsOyKqH�KNDLG�d�M�^pH�t:T/D@B-DLKN^pQ:B-O�[\G�SL^pT:[\M�G�S'BuZ-B-KNOhB3r/OyGW� l ^�r:G�SLG�O�_>zRM�^pQ/SLKNSLDLGIQ3DIV�Q/^/Q/OyKqQ/GIBW[�t:[\G�d:KNM�DLKN^pQSLM�E/GIH�G�S�H%T/SUD�BJM�M�^pT:QWD�_�^p[¨^pr/SLGI[\Z-B-DLKN^pQ:B-O¢T:Q/M�GI[�DFB-KqQWD\]rw^WDFE�� E/GIQ�DFT:Q/KqQ/g�DFE/G�_c^/[\G�MIB-SLD$H�^/d:G�O¢BWQ/d&� E/GIQKqQWDUGI[Lt:[\G�DLKqQ/g�GIB-M�E�^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q�_R[\^pH¬� E/KNM�E�B�_c^/[\G�MIB-SLD$KNS�KqQ/KNDLKqB-DLG�d�� l E/KNS'H�Bu]�rwG%d:^/Q/GWV:_�^p[�G�b:BWH�t/ONGWV�r3]M�^pQ/SLKNd:GI[\KqQ/g­B3QCGIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�^-_ KqQ/KNDLKqB-O$M�^/Q/d:KyDUKy^/Q/SIV{GIB-M�EC^J_ � E/KNM®E�KNS�M�^pQ/SLKNSLDUGIQWD��$KNDFE�B&gWKNZWGIQC^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQ�>SLG�GWVa_c^p[�G�b:BWH�t/ONGWV�¯�°f±®���u²´³|V �IµW¶Wµ V¨·��I²>�>�pV �uµW¸-¹ V»º½¼\¾�¿%À3³ÁÀW³|Â�Ã'ÀWÄN³fÀWÅuÆ �IµWÇ «wV�È�ÉpÊ�°f�pÅ-V �IµWÇWÇ V�Ë�ÀWÄN¿��IÊUÆ�IµWµ ª:V�Ì�Ê�À3ÍI��¼W³�ÀW³fÂ�Ã'À3Äy³|ÀWÅuÆ �IµWµ «wV�¯¨�pÊ\�I³|ÂW¼WÊÏή�uÊLÆ �Iµ3µ-¹ BWQ/dÁ[\G@_�GI[\GIQ/M�G�S�DFE/GI[\G�^J_®���­P�DLGIHÐ��«3�'KqQ�DFE/KNS�ONKySUDd:K�Ñ�GI[\S$_R[\^pHÒDFE/G�^3DFE/GI[\S$KqQ�D@E:B-D$KND KNS t:[�KhHsBW[\KNON]<B�DLG�M�E:Q/KNMIB-O$�>^p[�B-D$ONGIB-SLDuVfB�DLG�M�E:Q/^WON^WgWKNMIB-Oq��M�^pQ/SLDF[LBJKhQ3DI� l ^DFE/G�G�bpDLGIQ3D$DFE:BJD�D@E/G'SFE/^p[�DLM�^pH�KqQ/g�^-_�B�_�^p[\G�MIB-SUDLKqQ/g�SL]/SLDLGIH¬KNS�dfT/G'DL^<��«W��V/��G�SFE:B-ONO¢S@BI]�KND$KNS½BJM�M�^pT:QWD@BWr/ONGW}DFE/G&_R[\G� ¡T/GIQ/M�]Ó^-_�^pM�MIT:[U[\GIQ/M�GC^-_%T:Q:BWQ3DLKNM�Kqt:B-DLG�dÔG�ZWGIQ3DLS�MIBWQÓr:GCG�SUDLKqH�B-DLG�d�V�BWQ/d�[\G�dfT/M�G�d£D@E:[\^pT/gpEÕDFE/GM�^pH�H�KyD@H�GIQWD�^-_»BJd:d:KyDUKy^/Q:B-Oa[�G�SL^pT:[\M�G�SI� l ^�DFE/G'G�b/DLGIQ3D$DFE:B-D�DFE/KNS�KNS½Q/^WD�DFE/G'MIB-SUGWV:DFE/G�_�^p[\G�MIBJSLD�KyS�KqQ&GI[L[\^p[�VBWQ/dÓKqH�t:[\^-ZWGIH�GIQ3D�^-_%DFE/G�H�^/d:G�O'BWQ/dfÖ-^p[sDFE/G�KqQWDLGI[Ut:[\G�DFB-DLKN^pQ�^-_'D@E/G<^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQ/S�KNSQ/G�G�d:G�d��Ø×�GI[x_�G�M�DH�^/d:G�ONSIV/gWKNZWGIQ�twGI[x_�G�M�D�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�S'�>d:G@�YQ/G�dr:G�ON^-� ��V/BW[\G B-ON�$Bu]pS�BJM�M�^pT:QWD@BWr/ONGWV¡BJOyD@E/^pT/gpE�KqQ�[\G�gWKN^pQ/S�^-_Yg/[\GIB-DSLGIQ/SLKNDLKNZ/KND�]�DU^�KqQ/KyDUKhBJO¢M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ�V|DFE/G�Kq[�_c^p[�G�MIB-SLDLS$H�Bu]�r:G'^J_¢ONKhH�KyDUG�d­T/DLKNONKyD\]W�

l E/G&KhHst:^p[\D@BWQ/M�G^-_�DFE/G�[\^WONG<t/OqBu]WG�dÙr3]6T:Q/M�GI[\DFB-KqQ3D�]6KqQ�DFE/G�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQÓE:B-S�rwG�GIQÓ[\G�M�^WgpQ/KNSLG�dÓKqQQ/T:H�GI[\KNMIB-O:��GIB-DFE/GI[�_�^p[\G�MIB-SUDLKqQ/g$_�^p[�SL^pH�G�DLKqH�G%���~ÚÜÛ¡Ú�Ì��/¼W¿�°f±®¼3³:Æ �IµWÝW¸ ��� j G�Oy^-�'V3��G��$KNONOY[\G�SUDF[\KNM�D�B-DLDLGIQ3DLKN^pQDL^�ON^-��zR^p[\d:GI[¨SL]/SLDLGIH�S�� E/GI[�G�DFE/G½B3t:t/OyKNMIB-DUKy^/Q�^-_�Q/^pQ/ONKqQ/GIBW[�d:]:Q:BWH�KNMIB-O�SL]/SLDLGIH�S�D@E/G�^p[\]�MIBWQ�rwG't:T/D$DL^�DFE/GDLG�SLD$T/SLKqQ/g�GIQ/SUGIH%r/ONG�S�� E/KNM®E&BW[\G�^p[\d:GI[\S�^-_{H�B-gpQ/KNDFT/d:G�OqBW[\g3GI[�DFE:BWQsDFE/^WSLG�t:[LB-M�DUKyMIBJO�KqQ�QpT:H�GI[�KyMIBJO���GIB-DFE/GI[_�^p[\G�MIB-SLDUKhQ/gÁH�^pd:G�ONSI�Þ��GIQ/GI[LB-ONON]WV���GC�$KNONO%t/ON^WDB�SLKqQ/gWONG�^pr/SLGI[\Z-BWr/ONGWV'ßWV�BWQ/d�M�^/Q/SLKNd:GI[BWQ�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG­^J_KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/SIV�GIB-M�EM�^/Q/SLKNSLDLGIQ3D'�$KNDFE�D@E/G�T:Q/M�GI[\DFB-KqQ3D\]^-_$BWQ�^pr/SLGI[�Z~B-DLKN^pQ)KhQ)SLDFB-DLG@zRS@t:B-M�GW��¦$^3DLG�DFE:B-DB-S�ON^pQ/gCB-S�d:KNgWKNDFB-O�M�^pH�t:T/DLGI[�S�B3[\G�KqQ3ZW^WONZWG�d�V{D@E/G�G@Ñ�G�M�DLS�^-_ ^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQ:B-O�T:Q/M�GI[�DFB-KqQWD\]6BW[\G�T:Q:BuZW^3KydfB3r/OyGG�ZWGIQ�KqQ�t:[\KqQ/M�Kqt/ONGW}¢B-D¨DFE/G�ZWGI[\]�ONGIB-SUDIV:DFE/GI[\G���KyONO¢rwG�DF[LT:Q/MIB-DUKy^/Q�GI[L[\^p[\S�dfT/G�DL^�BWQ�BWQ:B-ON^WgJzRDL^-zRd:KNgWKNDFB-O�� i Ö-¤'�M�^pQ3ZWGI[\SLKN^pQ�� i S�DFE/G�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O'T:Q/M�GI[\DFB-KqQ3D\]­KqQ6D@E/GDF[LT/G�Z-B-OqT/G^-_'ß&G�ZW^WONZWG�S���KyD@E6DLKqH�GWV¨��GMIBWQ�DF[�GIB-D�DFE/GG�ZW^WOqT/DLKN^pQ�^J_½DFE/G�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG<B-S�B&_�^p[\G�MIBJSLD%r3]­KqQ3DLGI[Lt:[\G�DUKhQ/g�DFE/G�d:KNSLDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQÕ^-_ DFE/G�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG<tw^WKqQWDUS�B-SDFE/G�t:[�^pr:BWr/KNONKyD\]Cd:GIQ/SUKyD\]&_RT:Q/M�DLKN^pQÁ��×»¤�o���^-_�ß�Bu_�DLGI[$DUKhH�G�àFV�� E/KNM�E���G�d:GIQ/^WDLG�B-S�á�â���ßu��� l E/G�G�Z3^WOqT/DLKN^pQ^-_½á�âL��ßu�'��KyD@E�DLKqH�G�_c^/['SUG�ZWGI[LB-O¨M®E:B-^3DLKNM�SL]pSUDLGIH�S'KNS�S@E/^~��QCKqQ6D@E/G��Y[\SUD%D@E:[\G�G��fgpT:[\G�SI��§�E/GIQ6rw^WDFE�DFE/GH�^/d:G�O�d:]:Q:BWH�KNM�S½B3Q/d�DFE/G�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG%BW[\G'twGI[x_�G�M�DIV:��G'E:BuZWG½B3Q�^pt/DLKqH�B-O�_�^p[\G�MIBJSLD¨_c^p[�B�g3KyZ3GIQ�d:G�DLGI[LH�KhQ/KNSLDUKyM

Page 2: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

ã:ä�å�æ¢ç�èYé{ê:ë�ê�ì{ë�í$í$î�ï�ð�æ/ë½ñ�åxé�å�æ$ò6ë�ð�ó!ô�õ$õ�î$õ¬öIöuö ª

SL]/SLDLGIH�}-D@E/G�SLDFBJDLKNSLDLKNMIB-OpB-S@t:G�M�D�KyS{T:Q:BuZW^WKNdfBWr/ONGW��`�T:[�KqQ/M�^pH�t/ONG�DLG ÷/Q/^-�$ONG�d:gWG�^-_fD@E/G�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O:M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/S�_�^p[\M�G�SDFE/G�t:[�^pr:BWr/KNONKySUDLKNM�KhQ3DLGI[Lt:[�G�DFB-DLKN^pQ�G�ZWGIQ�� E/GIQ���G�÷pQ/^-�vD@E/G�G�b¡BJM�D'd:G�DLGI[LH�KhQ/KNSLDUKyM�d:]:Q:BWH�KNM�SI��o|^p[�M®E:BJ^WDLKNMSL]/SLDLGIH�SuV~á�âF��ßu�¢HsBI]WV-^/[¢H�Bu]'Q/^WDuVføL :T/KNM®÷3ON]pù�SFt:[\GIB-d�^-ZWGI[�D@E/G�_RT/ONOf[LBWQ/gWG¨^-_1ß3}-gWKNZWGIQ�B�t:GI[x_�G�M�D�H�^/d:G�O�VWKND{�$KNONOG�ZWGIQ3DFT:B-ONON]G�ZW^3OyZ3G'DL^-�$BW[\dBWQ�KqQWZ-BW[\KqBWQ3D'×{¤�o$Vfá{ú���ßu���$PRQ&DFE/G�BWr/SLGIQ/M�G�^-_�BWQ3]÷pQ/^-�$ONG�d:gWG�^-_{DFE/G�MIT:[L[\GIQ3DSLDFBJDLG ^J_¢DFE/G�SL]/SLDLGIH�V/^pT:[�rwG�SLD t:[\G�d:KNM�DLKN^pQ&KNS$SFT:H�HsBW[\KNû�G�drW]�á ú ��ßI���\²�ÚÏ�~Ú|DFE/G�M�ONKhHsB-DL^WON^WgWKNMIB-O�d:KNSLDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQ^p[�G� ¡T/KNZ~BJOyGIQ3DLON]WV�DFE/G�t:[�^Wü\G�M�DLKN^pQC^J_�D@E/G�KqQ3Z~BW[\KqBWQ3D�H�GIB-SFT:[�G<�@øLDFE/G�B-DLDF[LBJM�DL^p[\ùp��^pQ3DL^D@E/G�Z-BW[\KqBWr/ONG���G�BW[\G^pr/SLGI[�ZpKqQ/gp���

PRQ/KNDLKqB-ONON]WV�^pQ/GCH�Bu]6^pr/SLGI[\ZWG�BWQ�G�b¡tw^pQ/GIQ3DLKqB-O�gp[\^-�$DFEÕ^-_%T:Q/M�GI[\DFBJKhQ3D\]Y}�� E/KNOyG�DFE/KNS<H�T/SLD�SLDL^ptÕ� E/GIQ�DFE/GT:Q/M�GI[\DFBJKhQ3D\]­KNS�M�^pH�t:BW[UBWr/ONG��$KNDFE6DFE/G�d:KqBWH�G�DLGI[�^J_ DFE/G<BJDLDF[LB-M�DU^p[�V�SFB-DFT:[UB-DLKN^pQ�H�Bu]C^pM�MIT:[�B-DÀ3³fÅ��YQ/KNDLGONGIQ/gWDFE�SUMIB-ONG<�>KqQCt:BW[\DUKyMIT/OqBW[©V¢B-D�BW[Lr/KNDF[LB3[\KNOy]�SFHsB-ONO{OyGIQ/g3DFE�SLMIB-ONG�SF��BWQ/dCt:GI[\SUKySUD�_�^p[�BW[Lr/KNDF[LB3[\KNOy]�ON^pQ/g&DLKqH�G�SI�l E/G�øFBuZWGI[LBJgWG¢G�b:t:^/Q/GIQWDLKqB-O:g/[\^-�$DFE/ù$^-_fM�E:B-^WDUKyM¨SL]/SLDLGIH�S�KNS�B$gWON^pr:BJOyON]�BIZ3GI[LB-gWG�d'[LBJDLG�r:B-SUG�d%^/Q�KqQ3�YQ/KNDLG�SLKqH�B-OT:Q/M�GI[\DFBJKhQ3DLKNG�SI}3KyD�t/OqB-M�G�S�Q/^�À�°�ÊF²>¼WÊ@²pONKqH�KNDLS¨� E:B-DLSL^/G�ZWGI[�T:tw^pQ�^pt:GI[UB-DLKN^pQ:B-O:t:[\G�d:KNM�DFBWr/KNONKND�]WV/^p[�T:t:^/Q'D@E/G�ON^pMIBJOgp[\^-�$D@E [LBJDLG�S�� E/KNM�E'MIB3Q�V~BWQ/d�^-_�DLGIQ�d:^fV-M�^p[L[�G�SFt:^pQ/d�DL^$d:G�MI[\GIBJSLKqQ/g½T:Q/M�GI[\D@B-KqQWD\]��Ï_�^p[|�YQ/KNDLG¨DLKqH�G�SF��KhQ�M®E:BJ^WDLKNMSL]/SLDLGIH�Su�

ª:� `�× l P�A i�ý oa` m e n�i�k:l�k:n e�¦ i�m PR`

l ^CKNSL^WOqB-DLG�DFE/G�Z-BW[\KN^pT/S�ONKqH�KNDFB-DUKy^/Q/S�^pQ6t:[�G�d:KyM�D@BWr/KNOyKND\]WV��Y[�SLD�M�^pQ/SLKNd:GI[�D@E/G�^pt/DLKqH�B-O¨_�^p[\G�MIB-SLD�SLM�GIQ:B3[\KN^fþBt:GI[�_cG�M�D�H�^pd:G�O�^-_ D@E/G�d:]:Q:BWH�KNM�SIV�B3Q�G�b¡B-M�D�T:Q/d:GI[\SUDFBWQ/d:KqQ/gC^-_ D@E/G�^p[�Kyg3KhQ�^J_ ^pr/SLGI[\Z-B-DLKN^pQ:B-O$T:Q/M�GI[\D@B-KqQWD\]WVBWQ/dCB�t:GI[�_cG�M�D�GIQ/SLGIH�r/OyG�^-_�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/SI� l E/G�t:GI[x_�G�M�D'H�^/d:G�O{SLM�GIQ:BW[\KN^KNS�B�M�^pH�H�^pQ&^pQ/GWþ���G��$KNONOT/SLGWV�_�^p[�G�b:BWH�t/ONGWV�D@E/G ý ^p[\GIQ/û�G� :T:B-DLKN^pQ/S�x·�¼WÊ\�I³wÿFÆ �IµW¶ «W��DL^<t:[�G�d:KyM�D�dfB-DFB�gWGIQ/GI[LB-DUG�d�_�[\^/H DFE/G ý ^/[\GIQ/ûG� :T:B-DLKN^pQ/SI�&of^p[�SLKqH�t/ONKNM�KyD\]WV���G�DFB3÷-G�D@E/G�^pr/SLGI[\Z-B-DLKN^pQ:B-O$T:Q/M�GI[\D@B-KqQWD\]CDL^�r:G�dfT/G�^pQ/ON]CDL^&�YQ/KNDLG�B-M�MIT:[LB-M�]z%D@E:B-D�KNSIV���G^pr/SUGI[\ZWG�DFE/G&DF[LT/G�Z~BJOhT/G�^-_'GIBJM®EÕZ~BW[\KqBWr/ONGWV�r:T/D�^pQ/ON]ÁDL^�B&�fbpG�d�Q/T:H�r:GI[s^-_½d:KNgWKNDLSu� l E/GT:Q/M�GI[\DFBJKhQ3D\]CKNS�DFE/GIQCdfT/G�DU^DF[LT:Q/MIBJDLKN^pQCGI[U[\^p[�� l E/KySsG@Ñ1G�M�DUKyZ3G�Oy]�d:KyZ/KNd:G�S�D@E/G�SLD@B-DLG@zRSFt:B-M�G�^-_$DFE/G�SL]/SLDLGIHKqQWDU^B�H�G�SFE�^-_$EW]:t:GI[�zRMIT:r:G�SI}�^pT:[�^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q�DLG�ONONS%T/S'��E/KyM�E�MIT:rwG�DFE/G�SL]/SLDLGIH8KNS�KhQ�V�r:T/D�SFBu]pS'Q/^3DFE/KqQ/gB-S�DL^�� E/GI[\G���KyD@E/KhQ�D@E/G�MIT:r:G�KND$KNSI� i S$��G S@E:B-ONO�SLG�GWV3_c^/[�SU]pSLDUGIH�S�G�ZW^WONZpKqQ/g�^/Q�B-DLDF[LBJM�DL^p[\S{DFE/KNS$KNS B�SLGI[�Ky^/T/SONKqH�KNDFB-DLKN^pQ���§CG�ONK�_�D'D@E/KyS�M�^/Q/SLDF[LB-KqQ3D'rW]�M�^/Q/SLKNd:GI[\KqQ/g)B�t:GI[�_cG�M�D�GIQ/SLGIH�r/OyGW}�DFE:B-D�KNSIV�BWQ&GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�^-_�KqQ/KNDLKqB-OM�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/S�� E/KNM®E�B3[\G½Q/^3D�^/Q/Oy]s�$KNDFE/KqQ�DFE/G�M�^p[L[\G�M�D$E3]¡twGI[xzRMIT:r:GWV�r:T/D$B-ONSL^�^pQsDFE/G�B-DLDF[UB-M�DL^p[�� l ^�M�^pQ/SUDF[LT/M�DSFT/M�E6BWQ�GIQ/SLGIH�r/OyG�_c^/[%B&SFtwG�M�K��fMKqQ/KNDLKqB-O M�^/Q/d:KyDUKy^/Q�V���G�_�^WONOy^-�¬DFE/GB-d:Z/KNM�G�gWKNZWGIQ�KqQ�·�¼WÊ\�I³:ÿ�� �uµW¶ «W��þ���GøLSLKqH�t/ON]/ù6KqQWDLG�g/[LB-DLG&DFE/G�SL]pSUDLGIH�^J_'KhQ3DLGI[\G�SUDBWQ/dÁM�^WONONG�M�DG�b:B-M�D�BWQ:B-ON^WgWSuV$G�b:B-M�D�D@E:B-D�KNSIV�DL^��$KNDFE/KqQÓ^pT:[H�GIB-S@T:[\GIH�GIQ3D B-M�MIT:[LB-M�]C��tw^WKqQWDLS��$KNDFE/KqQD@E/G�SFBWH�G'E3]¡twGI[xzRMIT:r:GWV{À3³fÂ�ÀWÄ�±®¼�^/Q�DFE/G'B-DLDF[UB-M�DL^p[L�©�

i [LH�G�d��$KNDFECD@E/KySsGIQ/SLGIH�r/OyG�^J_�B3Q:B-ON^WgWS��BWQ/d�^pr/SLGI[\Z-B-DLKN^pQ/S�^-_ D@E/G�Kh[�_RT/DFT:[\G�DF[LBJü�G�M�DL^/[\KNG�SF��V���G�MIBWQ�H�BW÷-GBWQ&^pt/DLKqH�BJO�_�^p[\G�MIB-SUD$_�^p[�DFE/KNS�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q�� i Q&G�b¡BWHst/OyG�_c^p[�DFE/G ý ^p[�GIQ/û �uµW¶ «sSL]pSUDLGIH8KNS�gWKNZWGIQ�KqQo{KNgpT:[\G � � l KqH�G�KqQ/MI[\GIB-SUG�S�_R[\^pH r:^3DLDL^pH8DL^�DL^pt�V�KqQ�D@E/G�ON^~��GI[�ONG@_�D���GsSLG�G�DFE/G�d:KNSLDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQ�^-_�Z-B-OqT/G�S%^J_� B-D�DFE/G�KhQ/KNDLKqB-O{DUKhH�GW� i ONO{^-_�DFE/G�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O{M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/S'��E/KyM�ECBW[�G'M�^pQ/SLKNSLDUGIQWD��$KNDFE&DFE/G�MIT:[L[\GIQ3D ^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQONKNG��$KNDFE/KqQ�DFE/G�S@BWH�G�MIT:r:G�^-_$SLDFBJDLG@zRSFt:B-M�GWV{E/GIQ/M�G�DFE/G�KqQ/KyDUKhBJO$d:KNSLDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQÕKhQ � KNS�ZWGI[\]�SFE:B3[Lt��<PxQ/KNDLKqB-ONOy]�����Óà���� ö ªW��DFE/G�d:KySUDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQ�SFt:[�GIB-d:S ^/T/D'B-S½H�Kyg/EWD�r:G�G�b:t:G�M�DLG�d�_R[\^pH#ONKqQ/GIBW[�t:[\G�d:KNM�DLKN^pQ�DFE/G�^p[\]W� l E/G_�^p[\G�MIB-SLD�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�DFE/GIQ­[�G@zRSFE:BW[LtwGIQ/S��SFE/^-�$KqQ/g�DF[LT/G�øF[\G�DFT:[LQ)^-_ SF÷3KNOyO�©ù)T:Q3DLKNO�à ��� ö Ý }{DFE/G�d:KNSLDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQDFE/GIQ�^WSLM�KNONOqB-DLG�S�T:Q3DLKNO�à � � ö Ý V�� E/GIQ�KyD�r/K�_�T:[\MIBJDLG�S�BWQ/d­B�SFT:r/SLDFB3QWDLKqB-O»_�[UB-M�DLKN^pQ�^-_$DFE/G�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/SG�b:t/Oy^/[\G$GIB-M�E�ON^pr:G�^-_�DFE/G$B-DLDF[LBJM�DL^p[�� l E/G�SL]¡HsH�G�DF[\]�^-_YDFE/G�SL]/SLDLGIH![�G�SFT/ONDLS�KqQ�B�_�B-ONSLGsøF[\G�DFT:[LQ�^-_�SF÷3KyONONù�\²�Úq�-ÚB-D�à��Òª ö «��Uà��Ò« ö ���fB3Q/d<SU^�^pQ:��B-S�Q/^WDLG�dCr3]CË�À3Äy¿��uÊ'� �IµWµ «3��� ¦�B� �NZWG�ON]WV�KND'H�KNgpEWD'B3t:t:GIBW[�SFT:[Lt:[\KNSLKqQ/g&DFE:B-DBWQ3]�SLDF[UT/M�DFT:[\G$SFE/^/T/Oyd[�GIH�B-KqQ�KqQ�DFE/G d:KNSLD@[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQ�B-D�à�� � ª:VWg3KyZ3GIQ�DFE:BJD�D@E/G ONGIB-d:KqQ/g ý ]/BWt:T:Q/^-Z�G�b¡tw^pQ/GIQ3D� � � � ö «�r/KNDLS�t:GI[$T:Q/KND�DLKqH�GWVYB3Q/d�DFE/G�KqQ/KyDUKhBJO¢M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/S���GI[\G'÷/Q/^-� Q�DL^�^pQ/ON] Ç r/KNDLSI�

PRQ ^p[\d:GI[sDL^ÁBuZW^WKNdÁDFE/G�M�^pH�t/ONKNMIB-DLKN^pQ/S<B3[\KNSLKqQ/g6_R[\^pH DFE/G�SL]¡HsH�G�DF[\]ÁBWQ/d�Q/GIBW[�z��YB-DFQ/G�SLS­�>D@E/G)BJOhH�^WSLDªuzd:KqH�GIQ/SLKN^pQ:B-O�SLDF[LT/M�D@T:[\GI��^J_'DFE/G ý ^p[\GIQ/ûCB-DLD@[LB-M�DL^p[©V���G�SFE:B-ONO'B-ONSL^6M�^pQ/SUKyd:GI[�B3Q/^WDFE/GI[�DFE:[\G�G&d:KqH�GIQ/SLKN^pQ:B-OSL]/SLDLGIH�^-_$^p[\d:KqQ:BW[�]Cd:K�Ñ1GI[�GIQWDLKqB-O�G� ¡T:B-DUKy^/Q/S���È<¼I¼3Ê���À3³fÂ��3°Y²´�xÛp�uÄNV �IµW¶3¶ ��� l E/G�G� ¡T:B-DUKy^/Q/SIV{gWKNZWGIQ�KqQ�DFE/G

�������! #"%$'&($*)*+� �,�-/.��!+�$0"%$*12�!34.53267 �+�,8+�$'9: <;7,8)*$>=?�!+<���@.5=����!)A�CBEDFD��@./-�.��!+�$* <�!GH,EI7;J$%"%+<K/"�L(,E+<�!32.7 � <��"��@.�MH=��!+<�N+<�!GH$EO8,E �$P �+�,4L�I@�! <�7$*Q,4.(,4I!R+<�!)P,4I@ISRTL�RTUWVFX%Y7Z[B\7\5]�^*_8_E`a�6�34"�+<�7$5bJcd:X4\feg]�^*_8hEifaj �R �+�$*GkOl,4.(Qk6�32"%$* �$*$'. 6�34"m.(34.�I@�@.7$P,4"5 �R �+�$*G� n�@. 1E$'.($'"%,4I>L�Rpo�c\qB\7r[sCc2X'B\7BrrVS\[]�^*_8tEta'uwvjI! �3H �$P$HU�VFX%Y7ZNB\7\5X4x>BED!y#]�^*_8_z8a'O#{JZNVFx!Y|]�^*_8_E`8,/O LJa�,4.(Q}{JZNVFx!YkX2x0BED!y#]�^P_E_8ha'u~2�$*$EO�6�34"�$*�,8G[;�I!$EOl��\7rX2dA�Pc\5B\7rH�2B\�rX2\k��c2cED/]�^P_E_8`a'u

Page 3: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

ã:ä�å�æ¢ç�èYé{ê:ë�ê�ì{ë�í$í$î�ï�ð�æ/ë½ñ�åxé�å�æ$ò6ë�ð�ó!ô�õ$õ�î$õ¬öIöuö «

BWt:twGIQ/d:Kyb�VWd:G�SUMI[\Kqr:G$DFE/G�H�^WDLKN^pQ�^-_fB t:BW[�M�G�Op^-_:KN^pQ/KNû�G�d�gpB-S�KhQ�DFE/G�B-DFH�^3SFt:E/GI[\G�^J_wB�SLDFBW[©}�_�^p[�DFE/G�t:BW[LBWH�G�DLGI[\SM�E/^WSLGIQ�V|DFE/G�SL]/SLDLGIH¬KNS�M�E:B-^WDLKNM��$KNDFE � � ��� ö ªWªsr/KyDUS½twGI[ T:Q/KND�DLKqH�GW��o{KNgpT:[\G�S�ª�BWQ/d<«�SFE/^-��DFE/G'G�Z3^WOqT/DLKN^pQ^-_{SLG�ZWGI[LBJO1twGI[x_�G�M�D$GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�S'T:Q/d:GI[ B�t:GI[�_cG�M�D�H�^/d:G�Oc��PRQ�o{KNgpT:[�G%ª:V/GIB-M�E�KqQ/KyDUKhBJOa×»¤�o6KyS�_c^WONON^-��G�d�_�^p[¨^pQ/GT:Q/KND�^-_�DLKqH�GWVpBu_�DLGI[»� E/KNM®EsDFE/G$DF[UT/G$SLDFB-DUG$^-_�DFE/G$SL]/SLDLGIH KNS�^/r/SLGI[\ZWG�d�B3Q/d�DFE/G�×{¤�o�M�^WONOqBWt/SLG�S$^pQ3DL^�DFE/G�Q/G��^pr/SLGI[�Z~B-DLKN^pQ#�W� i Q/G��ØtwGI[x_cG�M�D�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�KNS'DFE/GIQ&_�^p[LH�G�d_�^p[�DFE/Gsà�� � ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q�V¢BWQ/dCD@E/G�t:[�^pM�G�SLS�KNS[\GItwGIB-DLG�d��$o{KNgpT:[�G%«sKyS�SUKhH�KyOqBW[©V�E/^~��G�ZWGI[�DFE/G%×»¤�o6KyS�G�Z3^WONZWG�d�_�^p[ Ý T:Q/KNDLS�^-_�DLKqH�G�r:G�D\��G�GIQ^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQ/SI�of^/[�M�OqBW[\KND\]WV:DFE/G�DLKqH�G�^-_aGIBJM®E�Q/G���^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQ�KNS H�B3[L÷-G�dr3]�B�Z3GI[\DLKNMIB-O�gpB3t��

l E/G�SLG&�fgpT:[�G�SSFE/^-�8DFE:B-D�DFE/GI[\GCBW[�GG�b/DF[\GIH�G�Z~B3[\KqB-DLKN^pQ/SKqQ�t:[�G�d:KyM�D@BWr/KNOyKND\]�G�ZWGIQ KhQ DFE/G�SLG�SLKqH�t/ONGCON^-��zd:KqH�GIQ/SLKN^pQ:B-O�H�^/d:G�ONSI�ÁPRQ�o{KNgpT:[�Gª:V�D@E/G�GIQ/SLGIH�r/OyG�S�SLDFB3[\DLKqQ/gCB-D�à������Fª&BWQ/d Ç BW[�Gr:[\^pB-d:ON]�d:KyS@t:GI[\SLG�d�$KNDFE/KqQ���à�� � V:DFE/^WSLG'BJD�àN� � �F«�� Ý BWQ/d ¶ [\GIH�B-KqQs_RB-Kq[\ON]�DLKNgpEWDu� l E/G�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�KhQ/KNDLKqB-DUG�d)BJD�à�� ¸  :T/KNM®÷3ON]r/K�_�T:[�MIB-DLG�S�KqQ3DL^�D���^�t:B-M®÷JG�DLS�� E/KNM®E6[\GIHsB-KqQ�d:KySUDLKqQ/M�D�BWQ/d�_RB-Kq[\ON]­��G�ONO�zRd:G@�YQ/G�d�� l E/G�KhQ/KNDLKqB-O�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONGB-Dà�� �3� KqQ6o{KNgpT:[\G�«�[\G�ZWGIB-ONS�KqQ3DLGI[LH�KNDLDUGIQWD�[\G�DFT:[UQC^-_�SF÷WKNONO�V�� E/KNONGDFE/G�^pQ/G�KhQ/KNDLKqB-DUG�dÙB-D�à�� �u¶ d:G�Z3G�Oy^/t/SH�B-MI[�^WSLM�^pt/KNM�SLDF[UT/M�DFT:[\G��\²�Úq�-Ú �I¸ ö Ý �6àH� �IÇ ö Ý �¨� E/KNOyG�[\GIHsB-KqQ/KhQ/gs_RB-Kq[\ON]�M�^pE/GI[\GIQ3D T:QWDUKyO�à���ª � ö

`�QsDFE/G½BJd:d:KyDUKy^/Q:B-O�B-SLSFT:H�t/DUKy^/Q�DFE:B-D¨DFE/G KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/S B3[\G$M�E/^WSLGIQ�T:Q/K�_�^p[LH�Oy]�_�[\^/H!DFE/^WSUG$KqQ�DFE/G$MIT:r:G� E/KNM�EBW[\G�^pQ�DFE/G�B-DLDF[LBJM�DL^p[�V3DFE/G�_c^/[\G�MIB-SLDLS�d:KySUMIT/SLSLG�dCBWr:^-ZWG'B3[\G�^pt/DLKqH�B-O���t:GI[x_�G�M�DF��KqQ�DFE/G�SLGIQ/SLG'D@E:B-D�DFE/G_RT/DFT:[\G�GIQ/SLGIH�r/OyG�d:KNSLDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQ�BWt:t:[\^-b/KhHsB-DLG�S'D@E/G�DF[LT/G�t:[\^pr:BWr/KNONKND\]Cd:KNSLDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQ�_�T:Q/M�DLKN^pQÓ��×»¤�o���^-_$DFE/GSL]/SLDLGIH�V�gWKNZWGIQ�DFE/KNS�KqQ/KyDUKhBJO$^pr/SLGI[\Z-B-DLKN^pQ���X Q/G�b:t:G�M�DUG�d6G�ZWGIQWDUS��>d:G�Z/KqB-DLKN^pQ/S�_R[\^pH DFE/G�_�^p[\G�MIBJSLD'×{¤�o���V�BW[\GB-M�M�^pT:Q3DFBWr/ONG�KhQ�DFE:B-D$D@E/G�Kh[�_R[\G� ¡T/GIQ/M�]�S@E:B-ONO�d:G�MI[\GIB-SLG�KqQ�DFE/G�G�b¡twG�M�DLG�d<H�B3Q:Q/GI[ B-S�DFE/G���t:GI[�_cG�M�DF��GIQ/SLGIH�r/OyGSLKNû�G�KhQ/MI[�GIB-SLG�SI�`�_$M�^pT:[�SLGWV�K�_$��G�÷/Q/G��¬DFE/G�G�b:B-M�D'KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ�V{DFE/GIQ�DFE/G�×»¤�oÓ��^/T/Oyd6[\GIH�BJKhQ�Bp�©z_RT:Q/M�DLKN^pQ�_�^p[�B-ONOWDUKhH�GW}Wr:T/DaB-S�DFE/G{KqQ/KyDUKhBJO�¼l�@±��IÊE�IÀW��²>¼W³�M�^p[L[\G�SFtw^pQ/d:S�DL^�BWQ�KqQ3�YQ/KyDUG QpT:H�rwGI[�^-_ft:^WDLGIQ3DLKqB-OWKqQ/KNDLKqB-OM�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/SIV���G�H�T/SLD½HsBW÷-G�t:[\^pr:BWr/KNONKNSLDLKNMt:[\G�d:KNM�DLKN^pQ/S�_c^p[�D@E/KyS�d:G�DLGI[LH�KqQ/KNSLDLKNM�SL]/SLDLGIH�� l E/G�t:[\^pr:BWr/KNONKNSLDLKNMB-SFtwG�M�D$M�^pH�G�S�^pQ/ON]�_R[\^pHÒDFE/G'T:Q/M�GI[\D@B-KqQWD\]�KhQ�^/r/SLGI[\Z~BJDLKN^pQC�>DFE/GI[\G�KNS Q/^sKhQ/G�b:B-M�D$M�^/H�t:T/DFB-DLKN^pQ���KyD@E�BWQ:B-ON^Wg_�^p[\G�MIB-SLDUSF���

`�t/DLKqH�B-O1_c^p[�G�MIB-SLD�SUM�GIQ:BW[\KN^WS BW[�G'[\G�SLDF[\KNM�DLG�d�G�KNDFE/GI[�DL^�SL]pSUDLGIH�S�� E/KNM®E���G M�^pQ/SUDF[LT/M�DIV/^p[¨DL^�DFE/^WSUG�_c^p[¨� E/KNM�E^pr/SLGI[�Z~B-DLKN^pQ/S�^-ZWGI[�H�BWQ3]C×�^WKqQ/MIBW[#�G�[\G�D@T:[LQ�DLKqH�G�S�BW[\G�BuZ~B-KNOqBWr/ONGW��of^/[�H�^WSLD't:E3]pSUKyMIBJO�SU]pSLDUGIH�S�DFE/KNS'KNS�Q/^WDt:^3SLSLKqr/ONGWVpBWQ/d�KyD�KNS{KqQWDLGI[�G�SLDLKqQ/g DU^$SLG�G�E/^-�6B�ONG�SLS\zRDFE:B3Q3z�t:GI[x_�G�M�D�H�^/d:G�O-_RB-KNONSI� l E/G�DFE/GI[LH�B-ONON]�df[\KNZWGIQ�VW[\^3DFB-DLKqQ/g�YT/KNdCBWQ:QpT/OqT/S�^-_N���FÀWÂ��I�¨ÀWÄqÚ{� �IµWµ ªW��t:[\^-Z/KNd:G�S½BWQ�G�b:BWH�t/ONG�^-_»t:B3[\DLKNMIT/OqBW[$KqQ3DLGI[\G�SLD�BWQ/d[\G�ONG�Z~BWQ/M�GW� i DF[LT/ON]KqQ3�YQ/KNDLG�d:KqH�GIQ/SUKy^/Q:B-O{SL]/SLDLGIH�V|KND�KyS�r:G�ONKNG�ZWG�d�DL^�G�b:E/Kqr/KND'ON^-�£d:KqH�GIQ/SLKN^pQ:BJOcV�M�E:B-^WDLKNM�d:]:Q:BWH�KNM�SI}�DUKhH�G%SUGI[\KNG�S^-_{DLGIH�twGI[LB-DFT:[\G'H�GIB-SFT:[\GIH�GIQ3DLS¨_R[\^pH¬B�M�^-z�[\^3DFB-DLKqQ/g�t:[\^prwG%BW[\G�^J_cDLGIQ�BWQ:B-ON]/SLG�d��cSLG�G'B-ONSL^p�½Új��¿�²´�>��� �IµWµ ªW�BWQ/d�·�Ú��Y¿�²>�>�%� �IµWµ ª3�L����o{KNgpT:[\G�S¨^-_YGIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�_c^p[�G�MIB-SLDLS�_c^/[{B�[LB-d:KqB-Ofr:B-SLKNS»_�T:Q/M�DLKN^pQ�H�^/d:G�O:^-_YD@E/G$DFE/GI[LH�BJOyON]df[\KNZWGIQ�[\^WDFBJDLKqQ/g-z�BWQ:Q/T/OhT/S�BW[\G�gWKNZWGIQ�KqQ��Y¿�²>�>�)� �Iµ3µWÝ ��� l E/G�SLG�_�^p[\G�MIB-SLDUS'BW[\G�Q/^WD'BJM�M�^pT:QWD@BWr/ONGWV¢KqQ/d:KNMIB-DLKqQ/gZ~B3[\KqB-DLKN^pQ/S�KqQÁH�^pd:G�O�GI[L[\^/['��KyD@E6KqQ/KNDLKqB-O$M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQÕKhQ�B-d:d:KNDLKN^pQ6DU^<Z-BW[\KqB-DLKN^pQ/SsKhQÕSL]/SLDLGIH�SLGIQ/SLKNDLKNZ/KyD\]W�ÁPxQB-d:d:KNDLKN^pQ�DL^�GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�_�^p[\G�MIB-SLDUS�� E/KNM®E�S@t:[\GIB-dC^pT/D� :T/KNM®÷3ON]Ù��[\GIH�KhQ/KNSLM�GIQ3D�^-_�D@E/G'_�^p[\G�MIBJSLD�_�[�^pH8à�����DL^à�� � B-D$D@E/G'r:^WDLDU^pH¬ONG@_cD�t:BWQ/G�O¢^J_¢o{KNgpT:[\G%ª3��V/DFE/GI[\G%B3[\G'B�±�²�Û/³f² ��Í@ÀW³f�fQ/T:H�r:GI[�^J_¢_�^p[\G�MIB-SUDLS�_�^p[¨� E/KNM®E�DFE/G×{¤�o�[\GIHsB-KqQ/S'M�^pE/GI[\GIQ3D���B-S�KqQ�D@E/G'_�^p[\G�MIBJSLD�_�[�^pH8à5� Ý DU^�à�� ¶ B-D D@E/G�r:^WDUDL^pH [\KNgpE3D't:BWQ/G�O{^-_�o{Kyg/T:[\GªW��V�r:T/D�� E/KNM®E�gWKNZWG�û�GI[\^Ct:[\^/r:BWr/KNOyKND\]CDL^&DFE/G�Q/G�b/D�^pr/SLGI[\ZWG�d�DLGIH�t:GI[UB-DFT:[\G�^J_�D@E/G�BWQ:Q/T/OqT/S��T:Q/ONKh÷JG�DFE/^WSLG^-_{o{KNgpT:[\G�ªW��� l E/G%÷JG�]���^/[\dE/GI[\G�KNSIVf^J_aM�^pT:[�SLGWV�øUSLKNgpQ/K��fMIBWQWDUù�� E/KNM�E&KhHst/OyKNG�S�OhB3[\gWG'g3KyZ3GIQD@E/G%Q/T:H%rwGI[$^J_G�ONGIH�GIQ3DLS KqQ�DFE/G'GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONGW��of^/[�D@E/G%BWQ:Q/T/OqT/S½H�^/d:G�O�VfD@E/G'GIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�KyS�Q/^WD twGI[x_�G�M�D%�>DFE/G�KhQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/Sd:^CQ/^WD�ONKyG&^pQ�DFE/G�BJDLDF[LB-M�DU^p[L��V�BWQ/d­D@EpT/S�KND�KNS�Q/^WD�M�OyGIB3[�E/^-�ØDU^<H�BW÷JG�DFE/KNS�[�G�OhBJDLKN^pQ�G�b¡BJM�DI�<PxQ/d:G�G�d�V$B-SKNONOhT/SUDF[LB-DLG�d�KqQ���¿%²>�>��� �IµWµWÝ �©V-DFE/GI[\G�G�bpKNSLD�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O�M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/S�M�^pQ/SLKNSLDUGIQWD��$KNDFEsDFE/G�^pr/SLGI[\Z-B-DLKN^pQ/S�� E/KNM®E�ONKNG�KqQB�d:K�Ñ�GI[\GIQ3D r:B-SLKqQ�^J_»B-DUDF[LB-M�DLKN^pQ��

X�SLKqQ/g%D@E/G½BWQ:Q/T/OqT/S$B-S$B�DLG�SLD¨MIB-SLG�E:B-S�SUKyg/Q/K��fMIB3QWD BJd:Z~BWQ3DFB-gWG�S¨^-ZWGI[{r:^WD@E�Q/T:H�GI[\KNMIB-O�H�^/d:G�ONS�B3Q/d�H�G�DUG�^p[\^-zON^WgWKNMIB-O�^pr/SLGI[\Z-B-DLKN^pQ/SI}�B-S Bst:EW]/SLKNMIB-O�SL]pSUDLGIH�V:DFE/G�SFBWH�G� :T:B-ONKNDFB-DLKNZWG�d:K�¥�MIT/ONDLKNG�S'BW[\KNSLG�B-S�KhQ&H�G�DLG�^p[�^WON^WgWKNMIB-O^pr/SLGI[�Z~B-DLKN^pQ/S$BWQ/dsMIBWQ:Q/^WD�rwG M�Kq[\MIT:H�ZWGIQ3DLG�d�B-S�D@E/G�]�^-_�DLGIQ�BW[\G�KhQ�Q/T:H�GI[\KNMIB-O�SLDFT/d:KNG�SIV/G�KNDFE/GI[¨^pQ�t:T:[Ltw^WSLG�^p[r3]�B-M�M�KNd:GIQ3DI}|KyD�KNS½B3Q�KqQ3�YQ/KNDLG�d:KhH�GIQ/SLKN^pQ:B-O$���YT/KNdf��SL]pSUDLGIH�V/KqH�t:GI[x_�G�M�DLON]^/r/SLGI[\ZWG�d��¨�{G�D D@E/G't:EW]/SLKNMIB-O�DLKqH�GSLMIB-ONG�S�^-ZWGI[�� E/KNM�E�B-M�MIT:[UB-DLG�^pr/SLGI[\Z-B-DLKN^pQ/S�MIB3Q�rwG H�B-d:G�KNS�H�T/M�E�gp[\GIBJDLGI[�DFE:BWQ�D@E/G��>G� :T/KNZ~B-ONGIQ3DF�¨DLKqH�G�SLMIB-ONG_�^p[$D@E/G�B-DFH�^3SFt:E/GI[\GW��e{b/DLGIQ/SLKNZWG�GIQ/SUGIH%r/ONG�_�^p[\G�MIBJSLDLKqQ/g�G�b¡twGI[\KqH�GIQ3DLS�_�^p[�DFE/KNS'SL]/SLDLGIH8BW[\G�Q/^-�vT:Q/d:GI[\�$Bu]

� �����! 5)*34I@I!,2;7 �$��! *O�326n)P34K�"% �$EO�32./I!R}�@.p32K/"�K/.()*$'"%+�,2�@.�+<R7��+<�7$�34L��E�!34K( k,2.7,2I!3E18R�=��!+<���EK7,2.�+<K7G GH$P)A�(,4.��!)* |�! NK7 �$'6SK/ImL�K7+ <K�;J$'"�-()'�!,4I�O� <�@.()*$��@.}32K/"�)*,8 �$[+<�($N34L( �$'"%�2,E+<�!34.�Q�3$* j.(3E+�$'¡J$*)*+�+<�7$� �+�,8+�$[326>+<�7$� �R �+�$PGkO7�!+nGH$%"%$'I!RT]�,8+�+�$*G[;(+� n+�3a0"%$'-�.($[32K/"M.(34=�I!$*Q�1E$�346#�!+*u

Page 4: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

ã:ä�å�æ¢ç�èYé{ê:ë�ê�ì{ë�í$í$î�ï�ð�æ/ë½ñ�åxé�å�æ$ò6ë�ð�ó!ô�õ$õ�î$õ¬öIöuö ¹

0.00

1.00

0.500.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

3.50

4.00

4.50

5.00

5.50

6.00

6.50

7.00

7.50

8.00

8.50

9.00

9.50

10.00

10.50

11.00

11.50

12.00

Page 5: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

ã:ä�å�æ¢ç�èYé{ê:ë�ê�ì{ë�í$í$î�ï�ð�æ/ë½ñ�åxé�å�æ$ò6ë�ð�ó!ô�õ$õ�î$õ¬öIöuö Ý

BWQ/d�SFE:BJOyO�rwG'[\GIt:^p[�DLG�d�G�ONSLG�� E/GI[\GW��PxQ�DFE/G'Q/G�b/D�SUG�M�DLKN^pQ�V:��G M�^/Q/SLKNd:GI[ B-DUDLGIH�t/DLS¨DL^� ¡T:BWQ3DLK�_�]�t:[\G�d:KNM�DFBWr/KNONKND�]DFE:[\^/T/gpE�D@E/G gp[�^~��DFE�[LB-DUG�S�^J_¢KqQ3�YQ/KyDUG�SLKqH�B-ONSIV�r:G@_�^p[\G�[\G�DFT:[UQ/KhQ/gsDL^�M�^pQ/SLKNd:GI[$t:[LB-M�DUKyMIBJO1H�G�DFE/^pd:S�^-_�_�^p[LH�KqQ/gGIQ/SLGIH�r/ONG�S KqQ k G�M�DLKN^pQ ¹ �

«:� ý P�ACP l�i�l Px`�¦ k `�oÁPR¦�o�PR¦�P l e k P�A i�ý�k

P�D�KNS�M�^pHsH�^pQ/ON]CB-SLSFT:H�G�d�DFE:BJD M�E:B-^WDLKNM�SL]/SLDLGIH�S�BW[\G�t:[LBJM�DLKNMIB-ONOy]CT:Q:t:[\G�d:KNM�DFB3r/OyG�G�b/M�GIt/D�KqQ�DFE/G�ZWGI[\]�Q/GIBW[_RT/DFT:[\GW}¨KhQ�_RB-M�DIV»DFE/G�]�HsBI]CrwG�ZWGI[\]­t:[\G�d:KNM�DFB3r/OyGWV�G�b/M�GIt/D�KqQ6D@E/G�G�b/M�G�G�d:KqQ/gWON]Ù[\GIH�^3DLG�_RT/DFT:[\GW� l E/GH�KNS\zt:GI[�M�GIt/DLKN^pQT/SFT:BJOyON]BW[�KySUG�S�_�[�^pH¬B%H�KySUKhQ3DLGI[Lt:[�G�DFB-DLKN^pQ�^-_¢DFE/G�M�^pQ/SUDF[LB-KqQ3DLS�KhHst/OyKNG�dCr3]�B�t:^3SLKNDLKNZWG ý ]pBWt:T:Q/^-ZG�b:t:^pQ/GIQ3DI� ý ]/BWt:T:Q/^-ZG�b:t:^pQ/GIQ3DLS�MIBWQ�r:G�T:Q/d:GI[\SLDL^/^pd�KqQ�DLGI[UH�S ^J_�DFE/G�DFBWQ/gWGIQ3D½t:[�^pt:B-gpB-DU^p[�d:KNSLMIT/SLSLG�d�KqQk G�M�DLKN^pQ ¹ � l E/G�OqBW[\gWG�SUD ý ]pBWt:T:Q/^-Z�G�b:t:^pQ/GIQ3DIV � � V/ :T:BWQWDUK��fG�S�DFE/G�gp[\^-�$D@E�[LB-DLG�^-_aB-OqH�^WSUD�BWQ3]�KqQ3�YQ/KNDLG�SLKqH�B-OT:Q/M�GI[\DFBJKhQ3D\]�BuZWGI[LB-g3G�d�^-ZWGI[»DFE/G'B-DLDF[UB-M�DL^p[�}-��E/KyONG�KND$KNS$M�^pHsH�^pQ/ON]�SFB-KNd�DFE:BJD�B3Q�T:Q/M�GI[\D@B-KqQWD\]�¢I�cà����$KNONO�gp[�^~�B-S�¢u�>à��[��¢I���W�wG�b¡t�� � � à��©V:DFE/KNS½Q/G�G�d�r:G�DF[LT/G�¼W³|ÄyÅ�B-S rw^WDFEp¢H£¤��BWQ/d&à�£¦¥Ó��PxQ�ZWGI[\]�SLKqH�t/ONG�SL]/SLDLGIH�S$��GH�Bu]��YQ/d�T:Q/K�_�^p[LHÔG�b:t:^pQ/GIQ3DLKqB-Ofg/[\^-�$DFE�VIr:T/D¨KhQ�gWGIQ/GI[UB-O�VpQ/^pQ3z�T:Q/K�_�^p[LH�KND\]�KyS{D@E/G�[UT/OyG�^pQ�SLDF[LBWQ/g3G�B-DLD@[LB-M�DL^p[�SIVB-S Q/^3DLG�drW]�§$�I³wÿ®²��u��ÀWÄqÚ{� �IµWÇWµ ���

l E/G ý ]/BWt:T:Q/^-Z�G�b:t:^pQ/GIQ3DLS$^J_»B�SL]/SLDLGIH¬d:G�SUMI[\Kqr:G'D@E/G�øLG@Ñ�G�M�DLKNZWG�ù�gp[\^-�$D@E�[LB-DLG�^-_�BWQ�KqQ3�YQ/KNDLG�SLKqH�B-O{t:GI[\D@T:[xzr:B-DLKN^pQ�V�DFE/G�Kq[�BWt:t/ONKNMIB-DLKN^pQ�DL^&d:G@�YQ/KqQ/g­B6øLONKqH�KND�^-_ t:[\G�d:KNM�DFBWr/KNONKND�]/ù�KyS�E:BWHst:GI[\G�d6rW]�D\��^�_�BJM�DLSIþ��Y[\SLDIV{Q/^H�B-DUDLGI[$E/^-��OqBW[\gWG�BWQ�KqQ3�YQ/KNDLG�SLKqH�BJO{gWG�DLSIVfBJS ON^pQ/g�B-S�KyD�[\GIH�BJKhQ/S�KqQ3�YQ/KNDLG�SLKqH�B-O{KND't/OqB-M�G�S�Q/^�ONKqH�KNDLS�^pQ&t:[\G@zd:KNM�DFBWr/KNONKND�]WV�B3Q/dB-S�SL^p^/Q�B-S�KyD�r:G�M�^pH�G�S��YQ/KyDUGWVfDFE/G ý ]pBWt:T:Q/^-Z�G�b:t:^pQ/GIQ3DLS�M�GIB-SLG�DL^�d:G�SLMI[\KqrwG'KNDLS$G�ZW^3OhT/DUKy^/Q��k G�M�^pQ/d�V ý ]pBWt:T:Q/^-ZCG�b:t:^pQ/GIQ3DLSIV{��E/G�DFE/GI[�gWON^pr:B-O�^p[��YQ/KNDLG@zRDUKhH�G¨pV�BW[�G<ÀJ�u�IÊ\À�Û/��Ê�À3����±�VaB3Q/d­G�SLDUKhHsB-DLKqQ/g­BWQBuZWGI[LB-g3G$DLKqH�G�rW]�D@E/G KqQ3ZWGI[\SLG�^-_aBWQ�BuZWGI[LB-g3G�[UB-DLG�KyS�SL^/H�G�� E:B-D�E:B-ûIBW[\d:^pT/S/�N©�Q/^-�$KqQ/g%D@E/G½BuZWGI[LBJgWG$ZWG�ON^/M�KyD\]^-_$B�ü\^pT:[LQ/G�]�_�[\^/H `�bW_�^p[\d�DL^�M�GIQWD@[LB-O ý ^pQ/d:^pQ�Z/KqB m GIB-d:KqQ/g<HsBI]�DUG�OyO�T/S�ONKyDUDLONG�BWr:^/T/D�DFE/G�DLKqH�G�[\G� ¡T/Kq[\G�dDL^�[�GIB-M®E m GIB-d:KqQ/gf�

«:� � ��ª�«>¬g­�®�¯�°²±l³�¬n¯j®w±0®>´�µ

PRQ6t:[UB-M�DLKNM�GWV{KND�KNS�GIB-SL]�DL^d:GIH�^/Q/SLDF[LB-DUG�DFE:BJD ý ]pB3t:T:Q/^~Z�G�b¡tw^pQ/GIQWDUS�d:^CQ/^WD�[\G�SLDF[\KNM�D�t:[\G�d:KNM�DFBWr/KNONKND\]Y}�DFE/Gj BW÷-GI[¶ÜS i t:t:[\GIQ3DLKNM�G�A)B3t/S%t:[\G�SLGIQ3DLG�dCKqQ��Y¿�²>�>�<� �IµWµ-¹ BW��V�B-ONO�E:BuZWG � ��· � r/KyD�twGI['T:Q/KND�DLKqH�GWV�� E/KNONG�DFE/GH�BJü�^p[�KyD\]�^-_YKqQ/KNDLKqB-O|M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/S�H�Bu]'rwG t:[\G�d:KNM�DLG�d��$KNDFE�H�T/M�E'g/[\GIB-DLGI[�B-M�MIT:[LB-M�]�DFE:BWQ�DFE/G�SLDFB3Q/dfBW[\d j BW÷JGI[¶ SACBWt�_c^/[$� E/KNM�E � � � � �'P�D�KyS�DFE/G�KqQ:E/^pH�^WgWGIQ/G�KND\]�^-_�DFE/G i t:t:[\GIQWDUKyM�G�ACBWt/S�� E/KNM®E�g3KyZ3G�S'[\KNSLG�DL^�DFE/G�GIQ3zE:BWQ/M�G�d�t:[\G�d:KNM�DFBWr/KNONKND�]W� k KqH�KNOqBW[\ON]WVfD@E/G$KqQWDFT/KNDLKN^pQsDFE:B-D�BWQ�B-DUDF[LB-M�DL^/[��$KNDFEsQ/^%t:^3SLKNDLKNZWG ý ]pBWt:T:Q/^-Z�G�b¡tw^pQ/GIQWDUSKqH�t/ONKNG�S't:[\G�d:KNM�DFBWr/KNONKyD\]&KyS�T:Q3_c^pT:Q/d:G�d�}�B-DLD@[LB-M�DL^p[�S{_�^p[¨� E/KNM®E�KqQ3�YQ/KNDLG�SLKqH�B-O�T:Q/M�GI[�DFB-KqQWDUKyG�S�SFE:[\KqQ:÷|VfH�Bu]�E:BuZWGM�^pH�t/ONKNMIB-DLG�d�H�B-MI[\^WSUM�^pt/KNM%SUDF[LT/M�DFT:[\G��$KNDFE/KqQ�� E/KNM�E<BJOhH�^WSLD�B-ONO��YQ/KyDUG�T:Q/M�GI[\DFB-KqQ3DLKNG�S�gp[\^-�'V|SL^pH�G�DUKhH�G�S G�b3zt:^/Q/GIQWDLKqB-ONON]WV�_�^p[�DFE/G%HsB-ü\^p[\KND\]�^-_�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O¨M�^pQ/d:KNDLKN^pQ/S�KqQSUDFB-DLG@zRSFt:BJM�GW� i S½BsgWON^pr:B-O{BuZWGI[LB-gWG�d�[LB-DLGWV � � Q/G�G�dSFBu]�Q/^WDFE/KqQ/g�BWrw^pT/D$DFE/G�G�ZW^WOqT/DLKN^pQ�^J_aBWQ3]��YQ/KNDLG�T:Q/M�GI[\DFB-KqQ3D�]�^/[�B3QW]s�fbpG�d&DLKqH�GW�

«:��ª ��®m¸7±W¹/´«>ºA®>´EªÁ��¯m­m»�¼<º�®�½Á ºA¾�±Wµ

i Q%BJOyDUGI[LQ:B-DLKNZWG�BWt:t:[\^pB-M�E�DU^$ ¡T:B3QWDLK�_�]pKqQ/g't:[\G�d:KNM�DFB3r/KyONKND\]�KNS{DL^$G�SLDUKhHsB-DLG�T:Q/M�GI[�DFB-KqQWD\]�d:^pT:r/ONKhQ/g�DUKhH�G�SIVJ¿ �<³¢��V^p[�H�^p[�G�gWGIQ/GI[LB-ONON]�¿À~�Á³¢��VW��E/GI[\G�¿À�KNS$DFE/G�DLKqH�G'[\G� :T/Kq[\G�d�_�^p[$B3Q�KhQ3�YQ/KNDLG�SUKhHsB-OaT:Q/M�GI[�DFB-KqQWD\]�DL^�KqQ/MI[\GIB-SUG%r3]B�_RB-M�DL^p[�^-_gÂ/�{§�G'SFE:B-ONO{B-SLSFT:H�G�DFE:B-D$DFE/G�KqQ/KNDLKqB-O{^p[�KyGIQ3DFB-DUKy^/Q�^-_{GIB-M�E�KhQ3�YQ/KNDLG�SUKhHsB-O�T:Q/M�GI[\DFB-KqQ3D\]E:B-S r:G�GIQd:G�DLGI[LH�KhQ/G�dÁr3]�DFE/GÃ�f^~��V�DFE:B-D�KNSIV�KyD�KNS�d:Kq[\G�M�DLG�d�KhQ�DFE/G�ON^pMIB-O¨^p[\KNGIQ3DFB-DLKN^pQ�^-_$DFE/G��Y[\SUD'gWON^pr:B-O ý ]pBWt:T:Q/^-ZZWG�M�DL^/[�V-d:G@�YQ/G�d�KqQ k G�M�DLKN^pQ ¹ � � r:G�ON^-�'� l E/G$d:KNSLD@[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQ�^J_j¿ _�^p[�DFE/G ý ^p[\GIQ/û B-DUDF[LB-M�DL^/[�KNS�S@E/^~��Q�KqQp��¿%²>�>�� �Iµ3µ-¹ BW��BWQ/dÅÄ¢²>���p¿�ÀW³|³�� �IµWµ-¹ �©V¢[\G�ZWGIBJOyKqQ/g­B�r:BWQ/d:G�d6SUDF[LT/M�DFT:[\G�[\GIH�KqQ/KNSLM�GIQWD�^-_$DFE/G�d:KNSLDF[\Kqr:T/DLKN^pQÕ^-_$DFE/Gj BW÷-GI[¶ÜS i t:t:[\GIQ3DLKNM�G�A)B3t/SI�

Æ*���($'"%$�,4"%$�,��4,2"��!$*+<R�346>)*32./&��!)*+<�@.(1�Q/$%-/.��!+<�!34.( n6�34"m-�./�!+�$%9<+<�!G�$H34"� �349:)*,2I@I!$*Q�Ç�I!3)*,2I!ÈkÉ#R8,4;�K/.(32�k$*�E;Ê34.($'.�+� *u�ËjK/"�GH$P,4.��@.71�! �GH,8Q/$�)'I!$*,2"��@.C�Ì$*)P+<�!34.�`�u�vjI!+�$%"�.7,8+<�!�E$n;J32�@.�+� j326l�E�!$*=�GH,2R[LÊ$j6�32K/.(QH�@.TÍwÎ%ÏZ[B\7\�X4x�BED!y�]�^P_Et8ha'O���Ð%Bd'Ð%B\7X*D�X2x#BED!y�]�^*_8_/^Ña'Os�ÎÒ�B�Ó�d<X2ÔkX2x�BED!y�]�^*_8_Õ8a'OHo�cx!Y�B\7rkÖ�BED!\(BÔ4O�]�^P_E_z8a[,4.(Q×+<�7$5"%$'6�$'"%$%.7)*$P H+<�7$%"%$'�@.#u�Øn38+�$k+<�(,E+*O>,E H �+<"%$P � �$*Q}L�R²Ù�cED Ú|X2x�BED!y]�^*_8tz8a?,2.7Q�Û0�PX*D!X'rX%Î�]�^*_Eh8ta'O(É#RE,2;/K�.(34�5$*�E;Ê34.($'.�+� n)*,2./.(3E+�LJ$�Q�$'-�.7$PQk�@.�+�$'"%GH w346#I!3)P,4I#;�"%34;Ê$'"%+<�!$* n326�,NQ/RE.(,EGN�!)*,4I> �R �+�$*G�u

Page 6: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

ã:ä�å�æ¢ç�èYé{ê:ë�ê�ì{ë�í$í$î�ï�ð�æ/ë½ñ�åxé�å�æ$ò6ë�ð�ó!ô�õ$õ�î$õ¬öIöuö ¶

0.00

1.00 0.50

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

3.50

4.00

4.50

5.00

5.50

6.00

6.50

7.00

7.50

8.00

8.50

9.00

9.50

10.00

Page 7: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

ã:ä�å�æ¢ç�èYé{ê:ë�ê�ì{ë�í$í$î�ï�ð�æ/ë½ñ�åxé�å�æ$ò6ë�ð�ó!ô�õ$õ�î$õ¬öIöuö ¸

0.00

1.00 0.50

11.50

12.00

12.50

13.00

13.50

14.00

14.50

15.00

15.50

16.00

16.50

17.00

17.50

18.00

18.50

19.00

19.50

20.00

20.50

21.00

Page 8: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

ã:ä�å�æ¢ç�èYé{ê:ë�ê�ì{ë�í$í$î�ï�ð�æ/ë½ñ�åxé�å�æ$ò6ë�ð�ó!ô�õ$õ�î$õ¬öIöuö Ç

ÜÝÞßà áâãäåæçèéêëìíîïðñòóôõö÷øùúûüýþÿ����������� � ����������������� !"#$%&'()*+ ,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNO PQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefgh ijklmnopqrstuvwxy z{|}~������������������������� �������� ¡¢£¤¥¦§¨©ª«¬­ ®¯°±²³´µ¶·¸¹ º»¼½¾¿ÀÁÂÃÄÅÆÇÈÉÊË ÌÍÎÏÐÑÒÓÔÕÖ×ØÙÚÛÜ ÝÞßàáâãäå æçèéêëìí îïðñòóôõö÷øùúûü ýþÿ������ ����� ��� ������������� �� !"#$%&'( )*+,-./012345678 9:;<=>?@ABCD EFGHIJKLM NOPQRSTUVWXY Z[\]^_`abcdefghi jklmnopqrstu

vwxyz {|

}

~������� ����� ������������� �������

 ¡¢

£

¤¥¦§

¨

©ª«¬

­®¯°±

²

³

´

µ¶·¸ ¹

º

»

¼½¾¿

À

ÁÂÃÄ

Å

ÆÇ

È

É

ÊËÌÍÎÏÐÑ

Ò

ÓÔÕÖ×ØÙÚ ÛÜÝ

Þ

ßàáâãäåæç

è

é

ê

ëì

í

îïð

ñ

ò óôõ

ö

÷ø ùúû

ü

ýþÿ���� ���� �

�� � ��

���

�������� �� !"#$%&' ()*

+

, -./0 12 3 456789:;<=>?@A B

CDEFG H I J

KLMNO

P

Q RS

T

UVWXYZ[

\]

^_`abc d

ef

ghijklmno

p

qr s

t

uvwxyz

{

|}~���

� ��� �

��������� �

���

��

����

���� ¡¢£

¤

¥

¦§

¨©

ª«¬­

®

¯

°

± ²³´µ¶·¸

¹

º

»¼½

¾

¿

À

Á

Â

Ã

ÄÅÆÇ È

É

ÊËÌ

ÍÎ

ÏÐÑ

Ò Ó ÔÕÖ×Ø

ÙÚ

Û

Ü

Ý

Þßàá

â

ãäå

æ

çèé

ê ë

ì

íîï

ð

ñò

óô

õ

ö÷ø

ùú

ûü

ý þ

ÿ

� ���

�����

��

��

���

���

��

!"

#$ %&

'(

)

*+

,

-

.

/

0

1234

5 6

789:

;

<=>

?

@

ABCDE

F

GH

I

J

K

L

M NO

PQRST

U

VWXYZ[\]

^

_`ab

c d

efghijklmnopq

r

stuv

w

xyz{|}~��������

������

� � �

��

� �

�����������

  ¡

¢£¤

¥

¦

§

¨©

ª«¬­®¯°±²³

´

µ

· ¸¹

º»¼

½ ¾ ¿

À

ÁÃÂ Ä Å

Æ

Ç ÈÉ Ê Ë ÌÍ Î Ï ÐÑÒ

Ó

Ô

Õ Ö ×

ØÙ ÚÜÛ

Ý

Þ ßàá âã äå æ çè éê ëì íîðïñò óôöõ ÷øù úûýü þÿ� ���� ��� � � ������� ������������ !#"$&%�'(*)+,-. / 01243 56 78 9 :;�<>=?@ ABCD E F GHJI K LMONPRQSUT VXWY[Z\^] _` abdcef ghi jkmln o pq rstu vxw4yz {|}~x�� ���������� � ��������� �� ���� � �� ��  ¡¢ £¤¥ ¦§¨© ª«­¬®¯°²±´³ µ¶ ·¸ ¹º»¼¾½ ¿ ÀÁ¾ÃÅÄÇÆ ÈÉÊÌËÎÍ ÏÐÑÓÒÔ Õ Ö ×ØÙÛÚÜÝßÞàá âã äåæ çè�é êëì íïîð´ñò óôõ4ö÷ø�ùú ûüý�þ ÿ���� ��� �� � � ���� �� �� � ����� ��� � ! "$# %&'( )+*,- . / 021354 678:9 ;<>= ?@ ABCDFE GH>I JKLNMOQPR STFU VWX YZ [\ ] ^_a`bc defgih jk lm n oqpr sut vwxy z {|} ~���� ��� �� �� ��$��� ��� ��� � ��� ������2�  ¡ ¢£¥¤§¦ ¨© ª«¬®­¯ °± ²³´ µ+¶· ¸¹º »¼½ ¾¿ À Á à ÄÅÆ ÇÈÉËÊ�ÌÍ ÎÏ ÐÑ+ÒÓ Ô ÕÖ× ØÚÙÛÜ ÝÞ ßàáãâäå æçèé ê ëì í îï ðñóòôöõ÷ø ùúüûýþ ÿ��� ������� � ��� �� � ��� �� � ��� � �� � !"#%$&(' )* +, -.0/1 23%4 56 789 : ; < => ?@ A BCEDFG HIKJ LMON PRQSUTV W XY Z [\] ^ _`bacedfg hi jlknmo p q rs tuv wOx yz{}| ~ � �� �� ����� �� �� � �� �� ��� �� ���� �� �� �¡ ¢£n¤ ¥¦ §¨© ª¬«­ ®¯ °±³² ´ µ¶· ¸¹º»¼ ½¾¿À ÁU ÃÄ ÅÆ ÇÈ É ÊË Ì ÍΠϳÐÑ Ò ÓÔKÕÖ ×ØÚÙ ÛÜÝ Þßáà âã ä åæçéè êìë íîï ð ñò óôöõ÷ø ùú ûü ýþ ÿ� � ���� � �� �� � ������� �� ������ �� ! " #$ %'&()* +, -./0 123 4 5 67 8:9;<=?>@ ABCDE F G HIJKML N�OPQ RTSU VWX YZ[ \] ^`_ acbde f ghij klmn opqrsut vw xy z {|} ~ �� ����� � �� � �c���� �� � � �� ������ ���� ��   ¡¢ £¤¥¦ §¨ © ª« ¬­®°¯ ±³²´µ·¶ ¸¹º » ¼½¿¾ ÀÁ ÃÄÅÆÈÇÊÉ ËÌÍ ÎÏÐ Ñ ÒÓÔ Õ×ÖØÚÙ ÛÜÝÞàßâá ãä åæ çèé êëì íîï ðñ òó ôõ ö ÷øùú ûüý þÿ �� � ��� ��� �� � ���� �� �� ���������� ! "# $%'& ()* +,.-/ 0213546 7�8:9 ;< =?>@BA

0 10 20 300

20

40

60

q-pling time

q 2-p

ling

time

CEDGFIHKJMLONQP.RTSULOVXWYJZD[W]\^DG_I`aD[`a\bSULcHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\MikjK_IHKlUmGD[`UFa\^DgncLoW]p.pbSU_fq.`alYisrUmG_Y\t\^Dg`UFvu�wOWfFIWfDg`Up^\xuzyoWfp|{~}c�g�WfmGp^_apbSU_fq.`aD~pcuz� w WfFIWfDg`Up^\�u���� wMyv� Wfpc{�������Pc���Tp^\bJML�\td�SUDg`UF�W]m~_U`UFk\bSUL�Wf\^\zJ^Wfd�\^_IJ�qTWfpxLz��L�d�\^DGVYL�mGi�HK`UD���_IJ^n�Wf\\bSUL�p^Lx\tD[n�L�p^deWfmGL�pe��\bSULor�_YDg`Y\^p�pbSU_IHUmGjk��WfmGm�WfmG_I`UF�\bSULxmGDg`UL��O� �Y¡£¢Kq.SUDGd�S¤DGp.pbSU_fq.`���_IJ¥d�_In¦rKWhJMDGp^_I`�P

��`KW]pbncHUd�S�W]p�\bSUL�u�§OjKDgJML�d�\^mGi¨JMLz©QL�d�\�\zSUL¦\^DgncL�D~\O\bWYªfL�p�Wh`«Dg`h¬­`UD~\tL�p^Dgn¦Wfm.HK`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`Y\Mi«\^_kFIJM_fq��£\bSUL�i�WYJMLnc_IJZLvHUp^Lz��HUm¥\bSKWY`¯®�iIWYrKHK`U_fV�L��KrK_U`ULe`Y\^p°q.SUDGd�S¯jKLz¬­`ULsW�VYLeJ^W]FYL�J^Wf\tL�p�_fVYLeJ±¬Q�UL�j²rKLeJZD~_UjKp�_f�T\^DgncLYP�³¥HU\\bSUL«u § deWY`´lKL�ncDGp^mGLeWfjKDg`UFµWfp�q¥L�mGm¶P¸·�d�_In¦nc_I`´nc_Y\^DGVfWf\^DG_I`5�¶_UJcd�_In¦rKHU\^Dg`UF¨\bSUL«jK_IHKlUmGDg`UF²\tD[n�LsDGpk\^__IlU\bW]D[`¯Wsl�Le`Ud�SKn°WYJ^ªa��_IJx_h\bSULeJ�¹UºTrUmGDg`UF�\^DgncL�pe»cD¼�.\bSUL°jK_IHKlUmGD[`UF¯\^DgncL�DGp�½¤jQW�iIpe�£_I`ULkncDGFISY\OL��¾r�L�d�\�WY`L�DGFISh\±�¶_YmGj«Dg`UdeJMLeWfp^L°D[`À¿�jQWeiUpePxÁKHUd�S�W¦FhLe`ULeJ^WfmGDGÂeWf\^DG_I`«Dgn¦rUmGDGd�DG\^mgiÃWfptpbHKncL�p�W�\^DgncLcp^deWfmGL¦L��UDGp^\^px_I`aq.SUDGd�Su §�Ä �¶Å �EÆ �Yu�§ �¶Å ��PÇCEDGFIHKJMLxN¦pbSU_fqTp�\bSKWf\e�h��_IJÈ\bSULxÉ«_I_IJZLzÊËÁKrUD~L�FhL�m�p^iUp^\^Len¤�I\zSUD~p�D~px`U_Y\T\zSULxdeWfp^LYPÌRTSUDGp¥¬QFUHKJMLrUmG_Y\^pcu w WfFIWfDg`Up^\cu y ��WY`Uj¨WfmGp^_«uz� w WfFIW]D[`Upt\ou���� wZy �£�¶_IJxWa`IHKncl�LeJ�_]�ÍDg`UDG\^DgWfm¥d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`UpeP«RTSUL¦_UlUp^LeJMVXW]\^DG_I`\bSKWf\È\bSUL�p^LxrK_YDg`h\^p¥jK_¦`U_Y\ÌmGDGLx_I`°\bSUL.mGDg`UL�WYl�_XVhLTDgn¦rUmGD~L�p±\bSKWf\Èq¥LTdeWY`K`U_Y\¥FYLe`ULeJ^W]m~DGÂ�L±��JM_InÎu § HK`UmGL�p^p.¹Oϲ½Y�� Wf\EmGLeWfpt\b���Yq±SUD~d�S°D[`°\bHKJ^`��UJML�ÐKHUD[JZL�pÌ\bSKWf\È_IHKJEHK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\Mi¦deWY`cpt\^DGm~m�lKL±d�_I`Up^DGjKLeJML�j�pbn¦WfmGm�W��¶\tLeJÇqÑL±SKWeVhLTmG_Yp^\WY`«WfjKjKDG\^DG_I`KWfmÌÒklUDG\^p�P���`«pzSU_IJM\e�Ó\bSULcd�_I`Up^L�deHU\^DGVYL°jK_IHKlUmGD[`UF«\^DgncL�p�W]m~_U`UFsWkrKWYJM\^DGdeHUmgWYJ±\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\t_IJMikWYJML¦`U_Y\Dg`UjKLerKLe`UjKLe`h\ePc���Ìq¥L�qTDGpbSa\^_kªU`U_XqÕW°Ð¾HKWfjQJtHKrUm~Dg`UFa\^DgncLY�Qq¥LcnoHUpt\ÖncLeW]pbHKJMLouzyOjKDgJML�d�\^mGiY��Wfp±DG\xDGp�`U_Y\Tq¥L�mGmL�p^\^Dgn¦W]\^L�j�lYis�Yu w P±CQ_IJÍpbHh×�d�DGLe`Y\tm~i«mG_I`UFs¹ØÊËrUmGDg`UFs\^DgncL�p±q¥LoL��KrKL�d�\�u §�Ä ��Å �¥ÆÕ�Yu�§ �¶Å ���ÓCED~FUHKJML�N�DGm~mgHUp^\zJ^Wf\^L�p\bSKWf\���_IJT\zSUD~pxptD[n°rUm~L°p^iIpt\^Lenk��uz� w DGp¦ÙQÚYÛÇpbHh×�d�DGLe`h\^mGi«m~_U`UFQPxRTSUDGp�rK_Yp^L�p�W���HK`UjQWYncLe`h\bWfmÇm~DgncDG\bW]\^DG_I`«_I`¤\bSULHUp^LO_f��Dg`h¬­`UDG\^L�p^Dgn¦WfmÌHK`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`Y\^DGL�pxWYJMDGp^Dg`UF°�ÜJM_UnÝ\bSUL�`U_I`hÊËHK`UD¼��_IJ^ncDG\Mik_f�E\bSUL�Wf\^\bJtWfd�\^_IJ�P

½KP�½ ÞÌßÜà�ßgáeâ°ãQäxå�æ�çKè�ß�éfá�êQëÇß2ì�ßgází

��`¯\zSUL�p^Lkp^Dgn¦rUmGLsmG_fqîjKDgncLe`Up^DG_I`KWfm±p^iUp^\^Lencp��Eq¥L�deWY`¯ÐKHKWY`h\^D¼�¶i¨Wa\bJ^HULkmGDgncDG\�_]�ÖrKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`²lhi¯_IlUp^LeJMVUDg`UF\bSUL±L�VY_YmgHU\^DG_I`�_f��r�LeJ��¶L�d�\¥Le`Up^LenclUmGL�p.HK`UjKLeJTr�LeJ���L�d�\Ín�_IjKL�mGpePÌïðVYLe`h\bHKWfmGmGiY�QWY`hi¦Le`Up^LenclUmGL�lKL�d�_IncL�p¥Dg`UjKDGp^\^Dg`hÊFIHUDGpbSKWYlUmGL|�ÜJM_UnÝ\bSULxd�mGDgn¦Wf\^_YmG_YFhi �Mñ�òôóXò \bSULxmGD[n�D~\tD[`UFkjKDGp^\zJMDglKHU\^DG_I`a_f�õWfmGm�_IlUptLeJMVYL�jkVXW]m[HUL�p±d�_IJ^JZL�pbrK_I`UjKDg`UF�\^_\bSUL±VXWYJZD[WhlUm~LxDg`�ÐKHUL�p^\^DG_I`Kö���PE÷x`Ud�Lx\bSUDGp¥_Ud�deHKJMpe�U\bSULxrKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`�DGpÖøhù óeúGó ùzù��YW]pÑDG\TJML�\bW]D[`UpT`U_OD[`h��_IJ^n°Wf\^DG_I`�JMLzÊFIWYJZjKD[`UFc\bSULxrKWYJM\tD~deHUmgWYJÈ_IlUptLeJMVXWf\tD~_U`c��JM_Inûq.SUDGd�S�DG\¥qTWfpÌDg`UDG\^DgWf\^L�j�»ÈDG\Ñ\tL�m~mGpTHUpT`U_Y\bSUDg`UF�nc_UJMLT\bSKWY`°jQJ^W�qTDg`UFWcVfWfmgHULoWf\TJ^WY`UjK_UnÕ��JM_InÎ\bSULxd�mGDgn¦Wf\t_YmG_YFYi � Dg`hVXWYJMDgWY`h\.ncLeW]pbHKJMLe��PERTSUDGpTmGDgncDG\^Dg`UFk\^DgncL�q�D~mGm�jKLer�Le`Uj��­Whnc_I`UF_Y\bSULeJÈ\bSUDg`UFYp��I_U`¦\bSUL±Dg`UDG\^DgWfm�d�_U`UjKD~\tD~_U`kWY`Uj�\zSUL.p^DGÂ�Lx_f�Ç\bSUL.Le`UptLenolUmGLYP¥RTSUL±\^DgncL�Wf\Ìq±SUD~d�S�\bSUDGp.rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`mG_Yp^L�pkWfmGmTVXW]m[HULY�¥q±SUD~mGL�WfmGqTW�iIp�rKJZD~_UJc\^_�\bSUDGp¦mGDgncDG\^Dg`UF²\tD[n�LY�ÌqTDGmGm��T_f�xd�_IHKJMptLY�ÌjKLer�Le`Ujµ_U`¯\bSUL�rKWYJZ\^DGdeHUm[WhJWYrKrUmGDGdeWf\^DG_I`���WfpTp^\zJML�p^p^L�jslhisü«øIýÜþQÿ�� ��� ¿Y¿Y½h��P��L¥ÐKHKWY`Y\tD���i�\zSULÑ_U`Up^L�\E_f�­HUp^L�mGL�p^pb`UL�ptpÍlhixjKL�\^LeJ^n�D[`UDg`UFc\bSUL¥\^DgncLTWf\Çq.SUDGd�S�qÑL¥deWY`c`U_xmG_I`UFYLeJEJZLMÔËL�d�\E\bSULT`UHUmGmShi¾r�_Y\bSUL�p^DGpx\bSKWf\�\bSULxL�VY_YmGVYL�jaLe`Up^LenclUm~LcjKD¼��LeJMp��ÜJM_UnÝ\bSUL�d�mGDgn¦Wf\t_YmG_YFYDGdeWfmEjKDGp^\bJMDglKHU\^DG_I`���lhiY�U��_IJ¥L��KWYn¦rUmGLY��W�±_Ymgnc_YFh_IJM_fVYÊËÁKn�D[Jt`U_XV°\^L�p^\ePECÓ_IJ¥nc_Yp^\¥Dg`UDG\^DgWfmÇd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`Upe�Ó\bSUDGp.\^DgncLxDGp.ncHUd�S�FIJMLeWf\tLeJ¥\bSKWY`°\bSULx\^DgncLOp^deWfmGL����� ���� ������������������ ���! #"$���% �'&����� #���'()���* #"+���,(%-�.'���.�(% /�0��.1�#2� �/2�($3%��/ #"%�����0��.��#2% ���0��(% 4��2�($�� #����(65

Page 9: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/D9EFD4G/EIHJHJKML�NM<6EPO0:�B4:=<JQ!ENSRUTWVJVSKJVYX%X�X ¿

Dg`h�¶LeJtJML�jslYi°jKD~VUDGjKDg`UFk\bSUL.Dg`UDG\^DgWfm�HK`Ud�LeJZ\bWfDg`Y\MiklYi°\bSULT¬­JZp^\T®�iIWYrKHK`U_fV¦L��KrK_I`ULe`h\ePECÓ_IJÈ\bSUL±p^iIpt\^Lencp¥q¥LÖSKW�VYLd�_I`Up^DGjKLeJML�j��Èq¥L�SKW�VYL°�¶_IHK`Uj¨`U_spt\bJM_I`UFad�_IJ^JML�mgWf\^DG_I`¯lKL�\Mq¥L�Le`¯WY`YiÀ\^DgncL�ptdeWfmGLvlKWfptL�j HKr�_I`¯Dg`h¬­`UD~\tL�p^Dgn¦WfmGpWY`Uj¦\zSUL.mGDgncDG\¥_f��rKJML�jKDGd�\bWYlUDGmGD~\Mi�jQHUL.\t_oHUp^L�mGL�p^pb`UL�ptpePÌ÷xlUp^LeJMVUDg`UF¦\bSUL.l�LeSKW�VIDG_IJÈ_f��\bSULTLe`UptLenolUmGL�p¥Dg`¦CEDGFIHKJZL�p� �Q���QWY`Uj�½�pbHUFYFYL�p^\tpT\bSKWf\T\zSUD~p±DGp.\t_�lKLOL��¾r�L�d�\^L�j�P¥É�WfdeJM_Yp^d�_UrUD~dOp^\bJ^HUd�\zHKJMLxDg`k\bSULFZ/[xC²HUpbHKWfmGmGisjKL�VhL�m~_UrUp��WfDgJMmGiÃp^_U_I`¯W���\^LeJx\bSULkDg`UDG\^DgWfmT\tD[n�L �MóXò]\¾ò�^ Æ ��_ X ÒkDg`¯CEDGFIHKJMLs½h��P�÷x`Ud�Lk\zSUD~p°_Id�deHKJMp��EDG\oDGp¦Dg`Ud�_I`Ud�L�DGVfWYlUmGL\bSKWf\¥\bSUL±��HU\bHKJMLxL�Vh_YmgHU\^DG_I` � ��_IJ¥lKL�\^\^LeJÍ_IJð�¶_IJÈq¥_IJMptLe�Ìd�_UHUm~j«lKLxFY_fVYLeJt`UL�jvlhivWOmG_UdeWfm�mGDg`ULeWYJMDGÂeWf\^DG_I`«WYl�_IHU\.WJMLz��LeJMLe`Ud�Lx\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\t_IJMicDg`kWY`YiklKHU\¥\bSULxp^Dgn¦rUmGL�p^\e��SU_Inc_hFYLe`UL�_IHUp¥p^iUp^\^LencpeP/ZÈJ^Wfd�\^DGdeWfm�mGDgncDG\^p._]�õrKJML�jKDGd�\bWYlUDGmGDG\ËincHUp^\Çd�_I`Up^DGjKLeJǬ­`UDG\^LTHK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\^DGL�pe�UWY`UjcD~\ÌWhrKrKLeWYJMpÇ\bSKWf\Ç\bSUL�p^L¥deWY`O_I`UmGiclKL¥jKL�\^LeJ^ncDg`UL�j¦\zSKJM_IHUFIS|Le`Up^LenclUm~L��_IJML�deWfp^\tpeP

½KP�N `Fa�ç�ßcb�ê*d?dÇæ�ãCdÇæXßôêKá�çeb­çKâeâ�ãÓä.ìgçUêQâ�á�â%f�g�êQæ�ç¾âRTSULxd�_In°rUm~L��UDG\Mik_f��\bSUL)Zh[xCT��pTWfmGp^_�SU_YmGjKpTDgn¦rUmGDGdeWf\^DG_I`Up±��_IJ¥nc_UjKL�m�L�VXWfmgHKWf\tD~_U`�PÑRÈiKrUD~deW]m~mGi �MóXò]\¾òjikóeñk\Ió Ù*lm Ùelon ó ýtùzÿ ó Ùqp ó�ú lh� � ¿Y¿Y½Y�Ø��`U_I`UmGD[`ULeWhJx��_IJML�deW]p^\^Dg`UFsnc_UjKL�m~p¦SKW�VYL¦lKL�Le` L�VXWfmgHKWf\^L�j¨lhi�d�_U`Y\bJtWfp^\^Dg`UF�\bSUL�JM_U_Y\MÊncLeWY`hÊ�ptоHKWYJZL ��r É�ÁK�¥LeJtJM_IJ¥_f�E\bSUL�DgJ±rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`UpePT·±p.WY`¤L��I\zJMLencL�L��KWYn¦rUmGLY�Ód�_I`Up^DGjKLeJ�CED~FUHKJML � W]\ ^ Æ N X �q.SULeJMLO\bSULMZ/[xC¨DGp�JM_IHUFUSUm~ikpti¾n¦n�L�\bJMDGdeWfmGmGisjKDGp^\bJMDglKHU\^L�j¯WYlK_IHU\±Â�LeJM_Q��WfmG\bSU_IHUFUSk\bSULeJMLODGp�`U_�d�SKWY`Ud�Lc_f�E_IlhÊp^LeJMVUDg`UFo¡��ts�Wf\Ç\bSUDGpÌ\^DgncLY�U¡��js±D~pÈ\bSULTlKL�p^\¥rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`°D[`�\bSUL r É�ÁcLeJ^JZ_IJ�ptLe`Up^LYP/� SUDGm~LxrKLeJË�¶L�d�\^mGicVUD[WhlUm~Lq.SULe`«\zSULoFh_IWfmÇD~pOp^Dgn¦rUmGi«\^_sncDg`UDgncDGÂ�L�\bSUL r É�Á�rKJZL�jKD~d�\tD~_U`�LeJ^JZ_IJ���_I`UL¦ncDGFISh\�rKJMLz��LeJ�W�jKD¼��LeJMLe`Y\�n�L�\bJMDGd��_IJ�Ô^HUjKFYDg`UF¦lKL�\Mq¥L�Le`knc_IjKL�mGpe�KrKWYJZ\^DGdeHUm[WhJMmGi�Dg`�\bSULTjKL�VhL�m~_UrKncLe`Y\�_f��nc_IJML.JZLeWfmGD~pt\^DGd�nc_IjKL�m�p^DgncHUmgWf\^DG_I`UpePh��LJML�\bHKJt`�\^_¦\bSUDGp.r�_YDg`Y\±Dg`sÁUL�d�\^DG_I`aÒK�QW���\^LeJÈd�_I`Up^DGjKLeJMDg`UFsncL�\bSU_UjKpT_f�ELe`Up^LenclUmGLx��_IJ^n¦W]\^DG_I`�P

NQP ïWu±ÁKïEÉ�³¥®�ï¨CE÷ r É«·ÌRT��÷uRTSUL«VXW]m[HUL«_f��Le`UptLenolUmGL«��_IJML�deW]p^\^Dg`UFÃDg` ncL�\^L�_UJM_YmG_YFYiY��D~pkJMLz©QL�d�\^L�j D[`´DG\^psWfjK_UrU\^DG_I`²lhiµl�_Y\bS²ïÈHKJM_Ir�LeWY`WY`Uj«·xncLeJMDGdeWY`aq¥LeWf\bSULeJÈ��_IJML�deWfpt\^Dg`UFkd�Le`Y\^LeJZp � ptL�LY�K��_IJ�L��¾WYn°rUm~Lov�ÚYÛ�ÿ m Ù*lxw m ú Ù m �zy�{�|�|+}�~$�0� m ú��có ý ó Û m úgòy�{�|�|=��~ÑWh`Uj�JZLz�¶LeJMLe`Ud�L�pÇ\bSULeJML�_]����P4�EL�\Ç\bSULÈm~_U`UF�JML�deHKJ^JMLe`Ud�L¥\^DgncLÈ_f�­lK_Y\zSx\bSULTWf\bn�_YpbrKSULeJMLY�fWY`Uj�pt\bWf\^LzÊ�_f��Ê�\bSULzÊWYJM\u±HKncLeJMDGdeWfmW�ÀLeWf\bSULeJZÌJZL�jKD~d�\tD~_U` � u���ZÈ�.n�_IjKL�mGpon°WYªfL�px\bSUL¦WY`KWfmG_YFsWhrKrKJM_IWfd�Sa_f�Ír�LeJ��¶L�d�\xLe`UptLenolUmGL�pjKDGp^deHUp^p^L�jkDg`�ÁUL�d�\^DG_I`���HK`KJMLeWfmGDGp^\^DGdYP¥��`UjKL�L�j��KDg`°\bSUL±deWfp^LT_f��\bSUL±Wf\bnc_YpzrKSULeJMLY�Y\bSULxJML�deHKJ^JZLe`Ud�L.\^DgncL±WYrKrKLeWYJZpmG_I`UF�d�_In°rKWYJML�j¯\^_«\bSUL�mGD¼��L�\^DgncLs_f�±\bSULkp^iUp^\^Lenk�Ç_IJ|��_IJO\bSKWf\on°Wf\^\^LeJ��Ç\bSULkmGD¼��L�\^DgncLs_f�±\bSUL��±`UDGVYLeJMp^L � p^L�L��ÚYý ó Ù��1� � ¿��h¿K��� m Ù;l ó Ù��xÚeÚ ú � � ¿Y¿]NI���U\bSUDGpTdeWY`aSKWYJMjKmGivl�L�d�_I`UptD~jKLeJZL�j W�\^L�d�SK`UDGdeWfm£d�_I`Up^\bJ^W]D[`h\eP��`°\bSUL.WhlUp^Le`Ud�LT_f��rKLeJË�¶L�d�\ÈLe`Up^LenclUm~L�p��I\zSULeJML.JMLen¦W]D[`UpÈp^_IncL�jKD~pzWfFIJML�LencLe`h\ÑJZL�FIWYJMjKDg`UFoSU_fq lKL�p^\È\^_�rKJM_Ud�L�L�j�P� DGVYLe`�\zSUL�SUD~FUSkjKDgncLe`Up^DG_I`KWfmGDG\Mik_f�E\bSULxp^\bWf\tLzÊ�pbrKWfd�LxWY`Ujk\bSULxd�_In¦rKHU\zWf\^DG_I`KWfm�d�_In¦rUmGL��UDG\Ëi�_f�E\bSULxnc_IjKL�mGpe��WÉ«_I`h\^L��TWhJMmG_sWYrKrKJM_IWfd�SaqTDG\bS�HK`UD¼��_IJ^ncmGi«jKDGp^\bJMDglKHU\^L�j�Dg`UDG\^DgWfm¥d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`UpOD~pc`U_Y\±��LeWfp^DglUmGLY�õ`U_UJ±qÑ_UHUm~j«DG\ol�LjKL�p^DgJ^WYlUmGLY�hD���\bSUL � \bJ^HULe�ÇrK_h\^Le`Y\tD[W]mIDg`UDG\^DgWfmQd�_U`UjKD~\tD~_U`UpÌq¥LeJMLÌjKDGp^\zJMDglKHU\^L�j�HKrK_U`oWh`oW]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJÓ_f�­jKDgncLe`Up^DG_I`�m~L�ptp\bSKWY`O\bSKW]\E_f��\bSUL¥p^\bWf\^LzÊ�pzrKWfd�LYPE��`c\bSUDGpÈdeWfp^LY�Y_U`ULTd�_IHUmGj¦p^iUp^\^Len¦W]\^DGdeWfmGm~i°d�_In¦rKHU\^LT_fVYLeJËÊ�_IrU\^DgncDGp^\^DGdTL�p^\tD[n°Wf\^L�p_f�ÌrKJML�jKDGd�\bWYlUDGmGDG\ËiajQHUL�\^_°\bJ^WY`Up^DGLe`h\.lKLeSKW�VUDG_IJ¥_f�ELe`Up^LenclUmGL�r�_YDg`Y\tpTd�_YmGmgWYrUp^Dg`UFk_I`h\^_c\bSULoWf\t\bJ^Wfd�\^_UJ�P

RTSULTpt_YmgHU\^DG_I`¦d�SU_Yp^Le`�qTDGm~m�jKLer�Le`Ujk_I`O\bSULÖrKJZL�d�D~ptL.FY_UWfmI_]� \zSULTLe`Up^LenclUmGLT��_IJML�deWfpt\^LeJ�»�q±SUL�\bSULeJE\bSUL�_IlUÔML�d�\^DGVYLDGp¦\^_«_IlU\bW]D[`¨Wh`ÃHK`UlUDgWfp^L�j²L�pt\^Dgn¦Wf\^L�_f�.\bSUL�Zh[xCT��\^_«Dgn¦rKJM_fVYL�\bSUL���_IJML�deWfpt\e�Ç\^_�lK_IHK`Uj¨\bSUL���_IJML�deW]p^\e�Ç\^_rKJML�jKDGd�\±\bSUL±�¶_UJML�deWfp^\¥pbªhDGm~m��Ó\^_¦L�p^\tD[n°Wf\^Lx\bSUL�rKJM_UlKWYlUDGm~DG\Mik_f�õW°rKWYJM\^DGdeHUmgWYJ�L�VYLe`Y\��I_UJ¥_Y\bSULeJMq�D~ptLYPÌ��`krKJ^W]d�\^DGd�LY�\bSUL�rKJM_IlUmGLen DGpsd�_Un¦rUmGD~deW]\^L�j lhi²\bSULajKL�p^DgJML�\^_ Ú�� ó ý���pbWYn¦rUmGL�\zSUL n�_IJML�JtWYrUDGjKm~i FIJZ_Xq�D[`UF¨jKDgJML�d�\tD~_U`UpsDg`p^\bW]\^LzÊ�pbrKWfd�LxDg`a_IJMjKLeJ¥\t_�W�VY_YDGj�øIÙel ó ý�L�p^\^Dgn¦W]\^Dg`UFvnc_UjKL�mÇp^Le`Up^DG\^DGVIDG\MiYPT��\xSKWfpxlKL�Le`¤jKL�LencL�j«jKL�p^DgJ^WYlUmGLcq.SULe`p^L�mGL�d�\^Dg`UF¨Le`Up^LenclUmGLÃncLenclKLeJZpe�¥\^_ÃrKJMLz��LeJMLe`h\^DgWfmGmGi²pbWYn°rUm~L�JML�mGL�VfWY`Y\�jKDgJML�d�\^DG_I`UpaD[`5p^\bWf\tLzÊ�pbrKWfd�Lsq±SUD~d�S WYJMLmGDgªfL�mGi�\^_slKLc\bSUL��ÜWfpt\^L�p^\±FIJM_fqTDg`UFQP)u�_Y\^LcDg`�rKWfp^ptD[`UFa\bSKWf\e��q±SKWf\^L�VYLeJ±ncL�\bSU_Uj�DGp�WfjK_IrU\^L�j�� �ÜW]D~mGDg`UF«\^_�\bWYªfLDg`UDG\^DgWfm¥d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`Up¦Wf\ÖJtWY`UjK_In ÚhÙÃÛ�ÿ ó m Û�Û�ý m�� Û�ÚYý±qTDGmGmÌ_IlUptdeHKJML¦\bSUL¦Dg`h\^LeJ^rKJML�\zWf\^DG_I`«_f�¥\bSUL�rKJML�jKDGd�\^L�j!Z/[xCTP��jKLeW]m~mGiY��Le`Up^LenclUm~L�ncLencl�LeJMpvWhJMLkq¥L�D~FUSY\^L�j lYi¯\bSUL«rKLeJMd�Le`h\bWfFYLk_]��\bSULs`ULeWYJ^lhi²rK_YDg`h\^p¦_I`5\bSULsWf\^\zJ^Wfd�\^_IJq.SUDGd�S²\zSUL�i²JMLerKJML�p^Le`h\ � \bSKWf\¦DGpe��\bSUL�JML�mGL�VfWY`Y\°��J^Wfd�\^DG_I`5_f��\bSULsmG_UdeWfmxncLeWfpbHKJMLe�Ø�TDg` rKJ^Wfd�\^DGd�LY�T\zSUD~p�DGpe�T_]�d�_IHKJMptLY�QHK`KªI`U_fq.`�P

Page 10: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � s

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

���

���

��

� �� �

��

��

��

��

� ��

��

��

�� �

��� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

�� � �

��

��

��

��

���

�� �

��

��

��

�� �

���

� �

� �

� ����

��

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

� �

� �

���

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

��

� �

��

��

��

���

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

�� �

�� �

��

� �

� �

���

� �

��

�� ��

��

��

��

��

�� �

��

���

� �

� �

��

���

����

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

� �

� �

��

��

� �

��

� ����

� �

� ��

���

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

���

� �

��

��

��

�� �

��

��

��

� ��

��

��

��

���

��

��

��

� ���

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

� ��

� �

� ��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��� �

��

��

� �

��

��

� � ���

��

��

���

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

���

��

��

��

���

��

��

� ��

��

���

� �

� � �

� �

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

�� �

���

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

��

���

� �

��

��

���

���

� ��

��

��

� �

���

��

��

��

�� �� �

� �

���

��

� ��

�� �

��

��

� �

��

��

��

� �

��

� � �

��

��

�� �

��

��

��

��

� ��

� ����

��

��

��

� ��

��

� �

��

�� �

� �

��

��

��

� �

��

��

��

��

� �

� �

���

��

��

��

�� �

� �

��

��

���

��

��

��

�� �

� �

��

��

� �

��

� ��

��

��

���

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

��

� �

��

� �

��

��

����

��

��

��

��

�� �

��

� � �

��

� �

� ��

��

��

��

��

���

��

��

��

���

��

� �

��

�� �

� �

��

� �

�� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

�� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

� ��

��

� �

� �

���

��

��

� �

��

� �

��

��

� �

���

��

� �

��

��

� �

�� �

� �

��

����

��

��

��

��

��

��

� ��

� �

��

���

��

����

��

��

��

� �

��

� �

��

� �

��

��

��

��

� �

��

�� �

��

��

���

��

��

� �

��

��

�� �

��

��

��

���

��

��

� ��

��

��

���

� �

��

���

��

���

���

��

���

� �

��

��

��

��� �

��

� �

��

���

��

���

���

���

���

���

��

�� �

��

��

���

��

����

���

��

��

��

��

��

� �

���

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

���

��

� �� �

��

��

���

��

��

��

��

��� �

�� �

� �

��

�� �

�� ��

��

��

� �

���

��

��

��

��

��

� �

� �

��

� �

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

� ��

���

��

� �

��

��

� ��

��

��

��

� ���

�� �

�� �

� �

� �

���

��

��

��

��

��

� �

� �

��

��

���

��

��

��

��

��

�� �

��

� �

��

��

���

��

��

� �

� ��

� ���

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

� �

��

��

���

��

� �

�� ��

��

��� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

��

��

�� �

����

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

��

��

� �

����

��

�� �

���

��

��

��

� �

���

��

� �

�� �

�� �

��

���

��

���

��

��

��

��

� �

� �

�� � �

��

��

��

��

���

��

��

� �

� �

��

��

��

��

��

� �

� ��

��

��

��

�� �

��

� �

��

���

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

� ��

��

���

��

��

� � �

��

��

��

� �

� �

��

��

��

� �

��

��

��

� �

��

���

�� �

��

��� �

�� �

���

��

��

��

��

���

�� ��

� ��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

� �

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

� �

� �

��

� �

�����

��

���

�� ��

��

���

���

��

��

��

���

��

��

��

���

��

� �

��

��

��

���

��

��

��

��

���

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

� �

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

� �

� ���

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

��

��

� �

��

���

��

��

��

��

��

� ��

� �

� ��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

� � ��

��

��

� �

� �

��

��

��

� �

��

��

� ��

��

���

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

�� �

���

���

����

��

���

��

� �

��

��

� �

��

� ��

��

��

��

��

� �

�� �

��

� � �

��

��

� ���

��

��

��

� �

��

���

���

�� �

���

��

� �

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

� �

� �

� ��

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

�� �

� �� �

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

� ��

��

� �

� �

���

� � �

���

��

��

���

���

��

� �

��

� �

� �

� �

�� �

� �� �

� �

� �

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

� �

�� �

� �

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

��

��

��

��

��

��

� �

��

� �

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

-1 -0.9

0.9

1

CEDGFIHKJML�ÒKPÕÁUd�SULen¦Wf\^DGd«DGm~mgHUp^\zJ^Wf\^DG_I` _]�o\bSULaD[n°rK_Yp^ptD[lUDGmGDg\Mi _f��jKL�\tLeJ^ncDg`UDg`UF²\bSUL�rKJM_IlKWhlUD~mGDG\Mi _f�oWY`¨Dg`UDG\^DgWfmd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`��ÈFYDGVYLe`¯_I`UmGi¨WY`¯_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`¯WY`Uj²W«rKLeJ���L�d�\¦jKL�p^deJZD[rU\tD~_U`¨_f�.\zSULv`U_YDGp^L«rKJM_Ud�L�p^pePo�¥_I`UptD~jKLeJ�\bSUL`U_YDGp^Lc\^_�l�LoHK`UD¼��_IJ^ncmGisjKDGp^\zJMDglKHU\^L�j«qTDG\bS«W¦n¦Wf�UDgnoHKn?VXW]m[HUL¦JMLz©QL�d�\tL�j lhi�\bSUL�jKDgWYncL�\tLeJT_f�Ì\zSUL�d�DgJMd�mGL¦WY`Uj\bSULÈ_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`�W]\�DG\^pÇd�Le`Y\tLeJ�PERTSUDGp�q¥_IHUmGj�Dgn¦rUmGic\bSKWf\ÇWfmGm¾r�_YDg`Y\^pÇqTDG\bSUDg`c\bSULÈd�DgJMd�mGLÑq¥LeJMLÈL�оHKW]m~mGicmGDgªfL�mGi­�UlKHU\\bSUL�i�WhJMLÖ`U_h\ePE÷x`Um~ik\zSULÖr�_YDg`Y\^pOÚYÙsÛ�ÿ ó m Û�Û�ý m�� Û�ÚYý¥WYJML±d�_I`Ud�L�DGVXWYlUmGLoW]pÑ\zJ^HUL.Dg`UDG\^DgWfmÇd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`Upe�QWh`Uj�qTDG\bSU_UHU\WfjKjKDG\^DG_I`KWfm�Dg`h��_IJ^n¦Wf\tD~_U`¦\bSUL�ptL.deWY`K`U_h\Íl�L.DGjKLe`h\^D¼¬QL�j��Q\zSIHUpTW�r�LeJ���L�d�\TLe`Up^LenclUmGLxdeWY`K`U_Y\Ñl�Lx_IlU\bWfDg`UL�j�Dg`�\bSUDGpqTW�iYP

ZÇ_Y\^Le`h\^DgWfm�_IJMDGLe`h\bWf\^DG_I`Up�_f�õDg`UDG\^DgWfmEHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\MikD[`Ud�mgHUjKLY»

� É�_hp^\¥m~DgªfL�mGiap^\bWf\^DGd�HK`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`Y\Mi � mG_IdeWfm£jKD~pt\bJMDglKHU\^DG_I`a_f�ÌrK_YDg`h\^pT_I`�\bSULcWf\^\bJtWfd�\^_IJ^�ØP�5C­Wfp^\tL�p^\¥FIJM_fqTDg`UFcD[`h¬­`UDG\^L�ptD[n°WfmEjKDGpbrUmgWfd�LencLe`h\ � Dg`Up^\bWY`h\bWY`UL�_IHUpz��P½´®�_IdeW]m�_IJMDGLe`h\bWf\^DG_I`�_f�EFYmG_IlKWfmGmGi���Wfp^\^L�p^\¥FIJZ_Xq�D[`UF�HK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\Ëi � Dg`h¬­`UDG\^L¦rKWfp^\b�ØPN´C­Wfp^\tL�p^\¥FIJM_fqTDg`UFcD[`h¬­`UDG\^L�ptD[n°WfmEjKDGpbrUmgWfd�LencLe`h\ � ¬Q�IL�j�¬­`UDG\^Lc\^DgncLe�ØPÒ5CED[JZp^\¥D[`h¬­`UDG\^L�ptD[n°WfmEjKDGpbrUmgWfd�LencLe`h\�rKWfp^\.Wc\zSKJML�pbSU_YmGj � VXWYJMDgWYlUmGL|¬­`UD~\tL�\^DgncLe��P�5É�_hp^\¥m~DgªfL�mGia_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`KWfm�HK`Ud�LeJZ\bWfDg`Y\MiYP

� ÷x`UL�_f��\zSULoWYl�_XVhLY�¾lKHU\±WfmGp^_�d�_U`Up^DGp^\^Le`h\TqTDG\bS�\bSULOm~_U`UFfÊ�\^LeJ^nÝjKiK`KWYncDGd�p �S� _I`�\zSUL�Wf\^\bJ^W]d�\^_IJ��I�ØP

RTSULslKWfptD~dkjKD¼×�deHUmG\Mi¨DGp�\zSKWf\cq.SUDGm~Laq¥L�deWY`¯d�_Un¦rKHU\^Lk\bSULsrKJM_UlKWYlUDGm~DG\Mi¨_f�ÖWh`¯_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`¡ Å FYDGVYLe`¨lK_h\bS\bSULc\bJ^HUL°p^\bWf\^L Å WY`Uj«\bSUL¦p^\zWf\^DGp^\^DGd�px_f�¥\bSULc_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`KWfmÌHK`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`Y\Mi � _IJ � `U_YDGp^L=�srKJM_Ud�L�p^pb�Ø��q¥LcdeWY`K`U_Y\d�_In¦rKHU\tL�\bSULcrKJM_IlKWYlUDGmGDG\Ëi«_f�Ì\zSUL�\bJ^HULOp^\bWf\tL�lKL�Dg`UF Å FhD~VhLe`s_U`Um~ia\bSUL�_UlUp^LeJMVXW]\^DG_I`sWY`Uj«\bSULc`U_YDGp^L¦rKJM_Ud�L�p^pe�p^Dg`Ud�L¥q¥LÌjK_x`U_Y\õªU`U_fq�\bSULÈm~_UdeWfmUp^\bJ^HUd�\zHKJMLÌ_f�Q\zSULÑWf\^\zJ^Wfd�\^_IJØP­RTSUDGpEDGpÇD~mGmgHUp^\bJtWf\^L�j¦Dg`OCEDGFIHKJMLÑÒ��f\bSULÌd�_fVXWhJMDgWY`Ud�Ln¦Wf\zJMDG�¦\^L�mGmGp.HUp¥\bSULÖrKJZ_IlKWYlUDGmGD~\Mi�\bSKWf\È\bSUL.\zJ^HUL.pt\bWf\^LTmGDGL�pTqTDG\bSUDg`¤\bSUL.d�DgJMd�mGLY�KDG\¥deWY`K`U_Y\¥\^L�mGm�HUp¥q.SUDGd�Skr�_YDg`Y\tpqTDG\bSUDg`k\zSUL�d�DgJMd�mGL¦WYJML±d�_I`Up^DGp^\^Le`h\.q�D~\zS�\bSUL�mG_I`UF¦\tLeJ^nÝjKiK`KWYncDGd�p �Zñ¶òôóXò mGD~Lc_I`�\zSUL�Wf\^\bJ^W]d�\^_IJ^��P

÷xrU\^DG_I` � jKLerKLe`UjKp¦_I`À\bSUL¦mG_UdeWfm¥p^\bJ^HUd�\zHKJML�_]�Í\zSULvWf\t\bJ^Wfd�\^_UJ.`ULeWYJO\bSUL�\bJ^HUL°D[`UDG\^DgWfm�d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`��ÌWfpcpbSU_fq.`p^d�SULen¦Wf\^DGdeWfmGmGisDg`¤CED~FUHKJMLoÒK��\bJMLeWf\^Dg`UF¦\zSULorK_hD[`h\^p±_I`�\bSULcWf\^\bJ^W]d�\^_IJÌW]pTDGjKLe`Y\^DGdeWfmÌr�_YDg`Y\xn¦Wfptp^L�pe�U\bSUDGp._UrU\^DG_I`n¦W�i�lKLkDg`h\^LeJ^rKJML�\^L�j¨Wfp¦JMLz©QL�d�\^Dg`UF«\bSULknc_IncLe`h\^pO_f�.Dg`ULeJM\^DgWa_f�.\bSUL�mG_IdeW]mÑjKDGp^\zJMDglKHU\^DG_I`¯_f�Ön¦W]p^pePkCÓ_IJxL��hÊWYn¦rUmGLY�ÇDg`�CEDGFIHKJZL�Òk\bSUL�n¦WfdeJM_Yptd�_IrUDGd¦p^\bJ^HUd�\zHKJML¦_f�T\bSUL�W]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJ.n�LeWY`Up�\bSULeJZL�WYJML¦ptD[n°rUm~i¯nc_IJML�r�_YDg`Y\tp_I`¯\bSUL«Wf\^\bJtWfd�\^_IJ|qTDG\bS¨jKDGpbrUmgWfd�LencLe`h\^pk\^_À\bSULsHKrKrKLeJ°mGLz�¶\kWY`Uj²mG_fq¥LeJ¦JMDGFISh\¦_f�x\bSULkd�Le`h\^LeJ¦_]�Ö\bSULkd�DgJMd�mGLY»��_IJ��ÜJtWfd�\bWfm�W]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJMpe�Kq¥LcdeWY`K`U_Y\�W]p^pbHKncLc\bSUL�rKJZ_IlKWYlUDGmGD~\Mi«jKLe`Up^DG\Mi«_f�Ì\bSUL¦\bJtHULopt\bWf\^LOD~pcHK`UD¼�¶_IJtn Wf\�WY`hi

Page 11: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X ���

mGLe`UFY\bS«ptdeWfmGLYPv÷xrU\tD~_U`��sJMLz©QL�d�\tp�\bSUL¦Dg`Up^\zWY`Y\zWY`UL�_IHUpxFIJM_fqT\zS�JtWf\^L�pe��WfpxÐKHKWY`h\^D¼¬QL�j lhi«\bSUL¦mG_UdeWfmW¢IW]d�_IlUDgWY`_f�¥\bSULc��HUm~m¥`U_I`UmGDg`ULeWYJOjKi¾`KWYn�D~deW]mÌp^iUp^\^LenkPc÷xrU\^DG_I`Up¦½kWY`Uj�NkjKL�ptdeJMDglKLklKJML�L�jKDg`UF�VhL�d�\^_IJMp � ³�£x�xWY`Uj«¬Q�UL�j_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\tD~_U`«\^DgncL¦p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ|VYL�d�\^_IJZp � Á6£Ö�Ø�­JML�pzrKL�d�\^DGVYL�mGiY�Eq.SUDGd�S�WYJMLcjKLz¬­`UL�j¨lYia\bSUL¦\bWh`UFYLe`Y\xrKJM_IrKW]FIWf\^_IJ_f�T\bSUL�p^iUp^\^LenkPkRTSUL�p^LkWYJML�jKDGp^deHUp^p^L�j¨Dg`À\bSULk`UL��I\cp^L�d�\^DG_I`��EWfpODGp�÷xrU\tD~_U`¨ÒK�Çq.SUDGd�SÀDGpoL�ÐKHUDGVXWfmGLe`h\¦\^_a\bSUL¬Q�UL�j�\^DgncL¦p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJOVYL�d�\t_IJMpe��WfpxmG_I`UF«Wfpx\bSULcjKiK`KWYncDGd�pc_f�ÍW�\MiKrUD~deW]mÌHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\Ëi�JMLen°WfDg`«q¥L�m~mÈjKL�p^deJMDglKL�jlhi¦\bSUL±m~Dg`ULeWYJ±WYrKrKJM_f�UDgn¦Wf\^DG_I`��¶_UJE\bSULxLe`h\^DgJML±_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I`�\^DgncLYPÈ÷xrU\^DG_I`¤�O\bWYªfL�pÈVXWYJMDgWf\tD~_U`�D[`�\zSUL.mGL�VYL�m�_]�HK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\Mi�Dg`c\bSUL±ncLeWfpbHKJMLen�Le`Y\Ç_f�­jKD¼��LeJMLe`h\ÌVfWYJMDgWYlUmGL�pÌDg`h\^_�Wfd�d�_IHK`h\e�IJZL�\bHKJ^`UDg`UF�\^_±CEDGFIHKJML.Ò��fD[`h\^LeJ^rKJZL�\^Dg`UF\bSULcd�DgJMd�mGL�Wfp�W°d�_I`h\^_IHKJ�_f�ÑL�ÐKHKWfmEHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\ËiaDgn¦rUmGD~L�pc\bSKW]\.\bSULc\Mq¥_�VfWYJMDgWYlUmGL�poWhJML¦ncLeWfpbHKJML�j«qTDG\bSaL�ÐKHKWfmWfd�deHKJ^W]d�iYPÌ���^�U��_IJEL��KWYn¦rUmGLY�Ó\bSUL.VfWYJMDgWYlUmGLorUmG_Y\t\^L�jsWfmG_I`UF¦\bSUL±VYLeJM\tD~deW]m�Wf�UD~p¥q¥LeJML�nc_UJMLÖJZL�m~DgWYlUmGisªU`U_fq.`�\bSKWY`\bSULx_Y\zSULeJ��Kd�_I`h\^_IHKJMp¥_f�EL�ÐKHKWfm�HK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\Mi�q¥_IHUmGj«lKLoSU_UJMDGÂ�_I`Y\zWfmGm~ikL�mG_I`UFUWf\^L�jkL�mGmGD[rUptL�pe��`U_Y\Td�DgJMd�mGL�peP

RTSUL¦mgWfpt\xLe`Y\bJZisDg`�\zSULomGDGp^\¦WYl�_XVhL � jKLe`U_Y\^L�j�lYi�W � � �I�.JZLz©QL�d�\^p�\bSUL°p^LerKWYJ^Wf\tL�JZL�оHUDgJMLencLe`h\e� �¶_IJxWkr�LeJ���L�d�\Le`Up^LenclUmGLY�K\bSKWf\È\bSULxrK_YDg`h\^p¥d�SU_YptLe`¦mGDGLx_I`°\bSULÖW]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJ�P�RTSUL±d�_I`Up^\bJtHUd�\^DG_I`¦_]�£WcJMLeW]mQLe`Up^LenclUmGLxqTDGmGm JZLz©QL�d�\\bSULcHUp^L�pT_f�ÌWO��_IJML�deWfp^\��U�¶_UJÌL��KWYn¦rUmGLcq.SUL�\bSULeJÍ\bSULx��_IJML�deWfpt\^LeJÈqTDGpbSUL�p.\zSULolKL�pt\ÖWYrKrKJZ_X�UDgn¦Wf\^DG_I`�_]�õ\bSULO\bJ^HULZ/[xCT��_UJ±p^L�LeªYpc\^_kÐKHKWY`h\^D¼�¶i«\bSUL�lKLeSKW�VIDG_IHKJ � q¥_IJZp^\.deW]p^L=��r�LeJM\bHKJ^lKWf\tD~_U`Up�lhi«Dg`Y\^Le`h\^DG_I`KWfmGmGi�_fVYLeJMpzWYn¦rUmGDg`UF\bSULT\zWfDGm~pÈ_f�­\zSULÑ\zJ^HUL�Z/[xCTPfRTSUL¥��_IJML�deW]p^\^LeJ���pÇjKL�p^DgJMLTq�D~mGmÓjKL�\^LeJ^ncDg`UL±q.SUDGd�Sc_]�­\bSULTptD~�c_IrU\tD~_U`UpEp1¥YSULTd�SU_I_hp^L�pe�lKHU\�DG\^p|�ÜHUm¼¬QmgncLe`h\cqTDGm~mÈjKLerKLe`Uj¨HKrK_I`ÀWkd�_I`Up^DGp^\tLe`Ud�i l�L�\MqÑL�Le` \bSUL¦Dg`UDG\^DgWfmTrKLeJM\bHKJtlKWf\^DG_I`Up�d�SU_Yp^Le`ÀWY`Uj«\bSULmG_IdeW]m�p^\bJ^HUd�\zHKJMLx_f�E\bSUL�Wf\^\bJtWfd�\^_IJ�P

NQP � ¦ æ�çIçKè�ßcb�§o¨�çKéfá�ã­æfâcê�b�èt©Tß Å ç¾èª`�ßÜà�笫�ß�b�§4g�ìôêQ椨�çKéfá�ã�æXâRTSULÈ\Ëq¥_.n�L�\bSU_IjKpÇ_f�KLe`Up^LenclUmGLÌ��_IJ^n°Wf\^DG_I`xnc_Ypt\�jKDGp^deHUp^p^L�jcjQHKJMDg`UFx\bSUL¥ÁULencDg`KWYJEWYJMLÌlKWfptL�j�_I`OlKJML�L�jKDg`UFxVYL�dzÊ\^_IJ Le`Up^LenclUm~L�p � ³�£Ö�ÇWY`Uj|¬­`UD~\tLzÊ�\^DgncL � JMDGFISh\b��ptD[`UFUHUm[WhJÇVYL�d�\^_IJ£Le`Up^LenclUmGL�p � Á6£Ö�Ø��\bSUL�ioWhJMLÑrKJML�ptLe`Y\^L�jODg`�jKL�\zWfDGmL�mGp^L�q.SULeJMLxDg`�\bSUDGp¥VY_YmgHKncLYPh��LÖ`U_h\^L.\zSKWf\Ì\bSULxlKJML�L�jKDg`UF¦VYL�d�\t_IJMpÑHUptL�jslYi¦\zSULPu�Éo�²WYJML±d�_I`Up^\zJ^HUd�\^L�jkHUp^Dg`UF¬­`UDG\^Lon°WfFI`UDG\bHUjKL�rKLeJZ\bHKJ^lKWf\^DG_I`Up��Iq±SUD~mGLc\bSULxÁ6£ Len°rUm~_fiYL�jslhikïW�¥É;� C�d�_I`Up^DGjKLeJ�Dg`h¬­`UD~\tL�p^Dgn¦WfmErKLeJM\bHKJtlKW�Ê\^DG_I`UpePÇCÓ_IJ�\zSULÌp^Dgn¦rUmGLeJEptiIp^\tLencp�d�_I`Up^DGjKLeJML�j°D[`O\bSUDGpÌrKWYr�LeJ��Yq¥LÈpbSKWfmGmI\zJMLeWf\E³W£²W]põlKWfptL�j�HKr�_I`ODg`h¬­`UD~\tL�p^Dgn¦WfmGpWfpcq¥L�mGm¶P���`�\zSUD~p°deWfp^LY�E`U_Y\^L�\bSKWf\O\bSULvl�_Y\bS¯Á6£ WY`Uj²³�£ WYJZD~ptL¦��JM_In \bSUL�ptD[`UFUHUm[WhJcVXWfmgHULkjKL�d�_In°rK_Yp^DG\^DG_I`� Á6£S[��T_]��­ ��ÅÑ�®^ ��¢�¯ ^ ���U\bSULO��_IJMqTWYJMja\bWY`UFYLe`h\xrKJM_IrKWfFIW]\^_IJ � _UJTmGDg`ULeWYJ�rKJZ_IrKWfFIWf\t_IJ^�¥_f�Ì\zSUL�`U_U`Um~Dg`ULeWYJOp^iUpMÊ\^Len±° ��Å ¢ ^ ��PÇ��`cq.SKW]\���_YmGmG_Xq�pe�fq¥LÌd�_I`Up^DGjKLeJÈW.rKWYJZ\^DGdeHUm[WhJÌ`U_I`UmGDg`ULeWYJE\zJ^WfÔML�d�\^_IJMi ÅÑ�#^ ��¢eºJ²´³ ^ ³²}² �fFYDGVYLe`rK_hD[`h\ Å?µ � ÅÑ�#^�µ ���*° �¶Å ¢ ^ �¥jKLz¬­`UL�px\bSUL�\zJ^WfÔML�d�\^_IJMi°q.SUDGm~LF­ ��Å¥�#^ ��¢�¯ ^ �Èn¦WYrUp �Mñ�ògófò L�VY_YmGVYL�pb�±WY`hi�Dg`h¬­`UDG\^L�p^D¼Ên¦WfmKjKDGpbrUmgWfd�Len�Le`Y\¥ísWYl�_IHU\ ÅÑ�®^ �£\^_�WY` � Dg`h¬­`UDG\^L�p^Dgn¦W]m[�ÈjKDGpbrUmgWfd�LencLe`h\e�Uí�¶¾WYl�_IHU\ ÅÑ�#^ }¤¯ ^ �Ø�f\bSKWf\EDGpe�f��_IJMqTWYJZj��_IJTWc\^DgncLF¯ ^ WfmG_I`UF¦\bSUL|�ÜHUmGmGi�`U_U`hÊ�m~Dg`ULeWYJ±\zJ^WfÔML�d�\^_IJMi�rKWfp^p^Dg`UF�\bSKJM_IHUFIS Å¥�#^ �TW]\Ñ\tD[n�L ^ PT��`kL�ÐKHKWf\^DG_I`Upe��\bSULÁ6£S[Õ_f�·­

í ¶ �t­ ��ÅÑ�#^ ��¢1¯ ^ �Mík�±¸P¹�º»�í ��� �

pbSU_fqTpE\bSKW]\ÌD¼��qÑL±n¦WYrF¼W½U�Y\zSUL¥¬­JMp^\¥JMDGFISY\Èp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJÈVYL�d�\^_IJÇ_]�¾­ ����_IJMqTWYJZjo\zSULe`cDG\^p¥D[n°WfFYL.Wf\ ^ }¿¯ ^ qTDGmGm l�LDg`«\bSULcjKDgJML�d�\^DG_I`«_]�Ñ\bSULO¬­JMp^\±mGLz�¶\Op^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJxVhL�d�\^_IJ��Àg ½ n¦WfFI`UD¼¬QL�j � _IJTjKDgncDg`UDGpbSUL�jQ�¦lhik\bSULcd�_IJ^JZL�pbrK_I`UjKDg`UFp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ�VfWfmgHULY�PÁ � P RTSUL�Á6£ Wf\ Å¥�#^ ���TW]pvHUp^L�j lhi²ïW�¥É;� CT�Ed�_I`UptD~jKLeJ�\zSUL JZD~FUSY\�p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ�VYL�d�\^_UJMp�_]�­ ��ÅÑ�®^ ��¢zu=Â�Ã�Ä[�Ø�Qq.SULeJZL�u=ÂcÃ1ÄÈDGp.\bSULc_IrU\tD[n�D~ÂeW]\^DG_I`a\^DgncLY��q.SUDGmGLc�¶_UJTd�SKWf_Y\^DGd|©Q_Xq�pe�Q\zSUL � Dg`h¬­`UDG\^L�p^Dgn¦Wfmg�c³�£ Wf\ÅÑ�#^ �¥WYrKrKJM_f�IDgn¦W]\^L.\zSULxm~Lz��\Tp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ�VYL�d�\^_UJMp¥_f�?­ ��ÅÑ�®^ º;¯ ^ �Ø¢1¯ ^ ���Uq.SULeJML)¯ ^ D~p�\bSULxjQHKJ^Wf\^DG_I`�_fVYLeJÈq.SUDGd�S\bSUL�r�LeJM\bHKJ^lKWf\tD~_U`UpÖWYJZL�lKJML�j�PWu�_Y\^Lx\bSKWf\Tl�_Y\bSkjKLer�Le`Uj«_I`kWY`�_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\tD~_U`k\^DgncLYPÅ ù óeúGó l ó � �Æ� ¿���ÇY�ErKJZ_XVhL�jvWOJ^Wf\bSULeJ¥JMLen¦WhJ^ªeWYlUmGLxJML�pbHUmG\�ÈYPE·±p^pbHKn�L.\bSUL±p^iUp^\^Lenû_f��Dg`Y\tLeJML�p^\Ìd�_U`Y\bW]D[`UpTWcHK`UDGоHULLeJMFY_UjKDGd�Wf\t\bJ^Wfd�\^_UJ�»°�¶_IJ°Wfmgnc_Yp^\�Wh`Yi¨rK_YDg`h\ ÅÀÉ _I`¯\bSUL�W]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJx\bSULa\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\^_UJMi�qTDGmGm.L�VhLe`Y\bHKW]m~mGi JML�\bHKJ^`WYJ^lUDG\bJtWYJMDGmGiµd�mG_YptL�\^_¨\bSUL�rK_hD[`h\ ÅÀÉ PÊ[xLe`U_Y\^L«pbHUd�S¡ZÇ_YDg`UdeWYJ6ËL�JML�deHKJtJMLe`Ud�L�\^DgncL�p«lYi ^ Ì�Í Ä�Î Ï �cÐ � � ¢z�K¢ X�X%X ��P�¥_I`UptD~jKLeJÈ\bSUL���_IJMqTWYJMjc\bWY`UFhLe`Y\ÌrKJM_UrKWfFIWf\^_UJ�­ ��Å4É ¢�¯ ^ ���hL�VXWfmgHKWf\tL�jvWfmG_I`UFc\bSUL±`U_I`UmGD[`ULeWhJ¥\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\^_UJMi�q.SUDGd�SJML�\bHKJt`Up.WYJ^lUDG\bJ^WhJMDGm~iad�mG_Yp^L�\t_ Å4É W��¶\tLeJTW � r�_Y\^Le`h\^DgWfmGm~io� ó ý��xVYLeJMi�mG_I`UFI�±JML�\bHKJ^`�\tD[n�L�¯ ^ � ^�Ì�Í Ä�Î ÏMPÑR�SUD~p±jK_UL�p`U_Y\OD[n°rUm~i¯\bSKWf\ Å É«DGpo_U`�Wsr�LeJMDG_IjKDGds_UJ^lUDG\e�Eq¥L¦qTDGmGm¥jQJM_Ir«\bSUL�pbHKlUp^deJZD[rU\ Ð lKL�mG_fqÎ�¶_IJ|d�mgWYJMDG\MiY�õlKHU\cp^\zJML�p^p\bSKWf\x\zSUL ^�Ì�Í Ä�Î ÏTWYJML¦`U_Y\xL�ÐKHKWfmGmGi«pbrKWfd�L�j�Dg`«\^DgncLYP¦��`«\bSUL¦mGDgncDG\�¯ ^�Ñ ² �£\bSULeJML¦L��UDGp^\ � n°WY`YiK�±WYJ^lUDG\bJ^WYJZD~mGid�mG_Yp^Lx`ULeWYJÌJZL�\bHKJ^`Upe�U÷±p^L�mGL�jKL�dY��p.RTSUL�_IJZLenÕ\^L�mGmGpTHUpÑ\zSKWf\ÌWf\Ì\zSUL�p^LT\^DgncL�pe�U\bSUL±Á6£�[¸_f�4­ ��Å4É ¢ ^ Ì�Í ÄcÎ Ï2�ÌrKJM_fVUDGjKL�pW�HK`UDGÐKHUL�jKL�d�_In¦r�_Yp^DG\^DG_I`´_f�x\bSULsp^\zWf\^LzÊ�pbrKWfd�LsW]\¦\bSUL�r�_YDg`Y\ Šɯq.SUDGd�S JMLz©QL�d�\tp�\bSULkmG_UdeWfm±_IJMDGLe`Y\zWf\^DG_I`¨_]�

Ò�Ó*.��!Ô' .1 �����2%�9 ��0Õ�5�Ö�.�(+����(��×�'?����.���,�×���,($Ô #"����������,(% / ��0�0��5

Page 12: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � �

\bSULcFYmG_IlKWfmGmGi�jKLz¬­`UL�j¨®�iIWYrKHK`U_fVajKL�d�_In¦rK_hp^DG\^DG_I`9Ø�JZL�FIWYJMjKmGL�p^px_f�¥\bSUL¦rKWYJM\^DGdeHUmgWYJODg`Y\tLeJ^ncL�jKDgWf\^L�rKW]\bSa\bWYªfLe`lKL�\Mq¥L�Le`sJZL�\bHKJ^`UpePÇÉ�HUmG\^DgrUm~DGdeWf\tD~VhLzÊËïÌJMFY_UjKDGd�Dg\Mi«iIDGL�mGjKp.\zSUD~pxWYrKrKWYJZLe`Y\^mGi�\^L�mGL�_YmG_YFYDGdeWfmÇd�_I`K`UL�d�\^DG_I`�P

·T\J¯ ^ � ^ Ì�Í ÄÌ\bSUL�JMDGFISh\¥p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ�VYL�d�\^_IJMp¥_f�/­ d�_IJ^JML�pbr�_I`Ujs\t_o\zSUL�Á6£BWf\ Å4É �K\bSULxmGLz��\Tp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ�VYL�d�\^_IJZpÑ_]�­ � q.SUDGd�S«lhisd�_I`Up^\zJ^HUd�\^DG_I`���WfmGp^_�d�_IJ^JML�pzrK_I`Uj«\^_kW�\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\^_UJMi�WYJ^JZD~VUDg`UF�Wf\ ÅÑ�#^ Â�} ^�ÌÆÍ Ä�� Ñ Å4É �.JZLerKJML�p^Le`h\\bSULx³�£ W]\ Å É�PER�_O\bSUL.L��U\^Le`h\Ì\bSKW]\E\bSULT¬­JZp^\ÑlKJML�L�jKDg`UF¦VhL�d�\^_IJEJMLerKJML�ptLe`Y\^p¥\bSUL�_IJMDGLe`Y\zWf\^DG_I`°D~\ � \bSUL¥¬­JZp^\T³W£x�q¥_IHUmGj�\bWYª]L�_I`«Wf\ Å4É W]\x\bSULcm~DgncDG\ ^ Ì�Í Ä�Î Ï Ñ ² �£D~\�JZLz©QL�d�\^px\bSUL¦mG_UdeWfmE_IJMDGLe`h\bWf\^DG_I`a_f�¥\bSULO¬­JMp^\ � ®�iUWYrKHK`U_fV£EL�d�\^_IJÆ�._IJE®Ù£oP6Ú×p�\zSUL̬­JZp^\õ³�£´qÑLeJZLÑL�ÐKHKWfmU\^_±\bSULȬ­JMp^\Ì®�iIWhrKHK`U_XV£EL�d�\t_IJ��KÛ�ÿ ó ÙxDG\EqÑ_UHUm~j¦l�L.WY`xL�DGFYLe`hVYL�d�\^_UJ_f�/­ ��Å ÉQ¢ ^ Ì�Í Ä �Ø�IDg`aq.SUDGd�SkdeWfp^Lx\zSULx¬­JMp^\±³W£ÕWY`Uj¤¬­JMp^\.Á6£ � DG\^p.rKJMLzÊ�Dgn¦W]FYLe�Tq¥_IHUmGj«lK_Y\bS�d�_hD[`Ud�DGjKL¦q�D~\zS�\bSUL¬­JMp^\ÈL�DGFYLe`YVhL�d�\^_IJE_]�¾­ PEÁUDgncDGmgWYJMmGiY�K\bSUL�m[W]p^\ÑJMDGFISh\ÌptD[`UFUHUm[WhJÌVhL�d�\^_IJE_]�¾­ WYrKrKJZ_X�UDgn¦Wf\^L�pÈ\bSULTmgWfp^\¥®�iIWYrKHK`U_fVVYL�d�\^_UJ � L�ÐKHUDGVXWfmGLe`h\^mGiY�E\bSULO¬­JMp^\�®Ù£ Dg`�JML�VYLeJZp^L�j«\^DgncL Ø ��Px·±FIWfDg`���D¼�T\bSULcmgWfp^\�Á6£ÎL�оHKWfmGpO\bSULcm[W]p^\�®+£c��\bSULe`DG\xDGpoWY`aL�DGFYLe`hVYL�d�\^_IJ±_f�0­ WY`Uj«D~pOL�оHKW]mE\^_�DG\^pODgn¦WfFYLY»±\bSULcmgWfp^\�³�£cP�RTSULcL�D~FhLe`YVYL�d�\t_IJMp�_]�W­ rKJZ_XVUDGjKL�WlKWfp^DGp±q.SUDGd�S¤DGpÖrKJML�ptLeJMVYL�jsHK`UjKLeJ�\bSUL±©Q_fq��Kq.SUDGmGLc\bSUL�JMDGFISh\Tp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ�VYL�d�\^_IJMp±rKJM_fVIDGjKL�WY`¤_IJM\bSU_YFh_I`KWfm­lKW]p^DGpq.SUDGd�S¨n¦WYrUpcDg`Y\^_«Wap^L�d�_I`Uj¨_IJM\zSU_YFY_I`KWfmÌlKW]p^DGp � \bSUL�mGLz��\cp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJcVYL�d�\^_UJMpb���Çq.SULe`¬­ DGp¦pti¾n¦n�L�\bJMDGdY�Ç\bSUL\bSKJML�Lxd�_hD[`Ud�DGjKLYP

CQ_UJx\bSUL�n�L�\^L�_IJM_YmG_YFhD~deW]mÌp^iUp^\^LencpO_f�TDg`Y\^LeJZL�p^\e��\zSUL�p^L�ZÇ_hD[`UdeWhJ�ËL¦JML�deHKJ^JZLe`Ud�L�\^DgncL�p¦WYJZL � nc_IJZL¦\bSKWY`K�xWfpt\bJM_fÊ`U_IncDGdeWfm��QWh`Ujkm~DGLOqÑL�mGm�_UHU\Ñ_]�ðJMLeW]d�S�PÇ·±p.n¦Wf\bJZD~��noHUmG\^DgrUmGDGdeWf\^DG_I`ajK_UL�p.`U_Y\¥d�_In¦ncHU\^LY�U\bSULxLe`h\^DgJMLx\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\t_IJMiq¥_IHUmGjµl�L JZL�оHUDgJML�j Dg`¨_IJZjKLeJ¦\^_Àd�_In¦rKHU\^L¿­ ��Å ¢ ^ Ì�Í Ä ��P²·x`Uj D¼��pbHUd�S5\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\^_UJMDGL�p¦q¥LeJML�W�VXW]D~mgWYlUmGLY��\bSULe`��_IJ^ncDg`UF�r�LeJ���L�d�\�Le`Up^LenclUmGL�pcqÑ_UHUm~j¨lKL�d�_UncLvWh`s_UrU\^DG_I`�P¤ZÌShiIp^DGdeWfmGmGiY�E\bSUL�³W£ � _UJ�Á6£x�xJML�mGL�VXWY`h\O�¶_IJ�¬­`UDG\^LHK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\^DGL�pTdeWY`�_U`Um~i°jKLerKLe`Ujs_U`¦\bSUL�¬­`UDG\^LorKW]p^\ � _UJE��HU\bHKJMLe�Ø�IWY`Ujsn¦W�i¦lKL±��WYJõ�ÜJM_Un \zSUL.mG_I`UFfÊ�\tD[n�Lxm~DgncDG\_f�Ì®+£cP³¥HU\ÌDGpÌDG\È\bSUL�p^LTmG_I`UFO\^DgncLTp^deWfmGL�p¥q.SUDGd�S¦WYJMLT_]�­Dg`Y\tLeJML�p^\1ÛaRTSUL.nc_Y\tD~VfWf\^DG_I`O��_IJÇ\bSUL�ptLTjKL�d�_In¦r�_Yp^DG\^DG_I`Up¥qTWfpE\^_HK`UjKLeJMp^\zWY`Uj«\bSUL�jKiK`KWYncDGd�px_f�E¬­`UDG\^L¦HK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\^DGL�pe��Wfp±\bSULcmGDg`ULeWYJ±jKi¾`KWhncDGd�p�WYJMLoJZL�m~L�VfWY`h\±�¶_IJ�W¦\^DgncLcVYLeJZiVYLeJMi�pbSU_IJZ\Ñd�_Un¦rKWYJML�ja\^_ ^ Ì�Í Äz�K\bSUL�®+£ÕWYJML�`U_Y\±rKWYJM\^DGdeHUmgWYJMmGi�JZL�m~L�VfWY`h\eP/��L�JML�\zHKJ^`k\^_c\bSULOоHUL�pt\^DG_I`�_f�E\^DgncLp^deWfmGL�p±Dg`k\bSUL�`UL��U\TpbHKlUp^L�d�\tD~_U`��­lKHU\�¬­JMp^\¥d�_I`h\bJ^Wfpt\̬­`UDG\^LO\^DgncLo³�£ÕWY`Uj�Á6£cP� SKWf\�D~pkd�mGLeWYJ�DGpk\bSKW]\ � ¬­`UDG\^LzÊ�\^DgncL=� lKJML�L�jKDg`UF¨VYL�d�\^_IJMpkJMLerKJML�ptLe`Y\k\bSU_hp^LsjKDgJML�d�\^DG_I`Upkq±SUD~d�S¸ÿ m � ó FIJM_fq.`nc_Ypt\x_XVhLeJT\^DgncL°p^Dg`Ud�L¦Dg`UD~\tD[W]m~DGÂeWf\tD~_U` �Mñ�ògófò ­ ��Å¥�#^ ºÜ¯ ^ ��¢�¯ ^ �^�Ø��\bSULcp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJxVYL�d�\t_IJMp�JMLerKJML�ptLe`Y\x\bSU_hp^LcjKD�ÊJML�d�\^DG_I`UpcDg`Àq.SUDGd�S¨WY` D[`h¬­`UDG\^L�ptD[n°WfmÖr�LeJM\bHKJ^lKW]\^DG_I`�Ý ñ�ú�ú SKWeVhL¦FIJM_fq.`«\zSUL�nc_Yp^\ m ÛÈ\bSUL�_UrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I`À\^DgncL�Mñ�ògófò ­ �¶ÅÑ�#^ �Ø¢bu ÂcÃ1Ä �^��PERTSULxLen¦rKSKW]p^DGpTDGpÑDg`h\^Le`UjKL�js\t_opt\bJML�p^pÈ\bSKWf\TlK_Y\zSkJMLz©QL�d�\¥\bSUL.Lz��L�d�\^DGVYLxFUJM_fqT\bSc_fVYLeJ¥WY`Dg`Y\tLeJMVXWfm�_f�Ç\^DgncLY�K\bSULx³�£ Dg`k\bSULx`ULeWYJ¥rKWfp^\e�U\bSULxÁ6£¸D[`�\zSULÖ`ULeWYJð��HU\bHKJMLY»E\zSUL�i¦FYDGVYL�`U_cDg`h�¶_IJtn¦Wf\^DG_I`°_I`°\bSULn¦WY`K`ULeJ|Dg`¯q.SUDGd�SÀ\bSUDGpcFIJM_fqT\bSadeWYncL�WYlK_IHU\cWf\�Dg`h\^LeJ^ncL�jKDgWf\tL�\^DgncL�p�PsRTSUL�VYL�d�\^_IJ±q.SUDGd�S¨SKWfp�FUJM_fq.`a\bSULnc_Ypt\x_XVhLeJ±\bSUL¦Dg`Y\tLeJMVXWfm0¯ ^ `UL�L�jÃ`U_Y\oSKW�VYL¦l�L�Le`�\bSUL°VYL�d�\^_IJ±FIJZ_Xq�D[`UFk\zSUL � ��Wfp^\^L�p^\'�vWf\cWY`his\^DgncL¦q�D~\zSUD[`\bSUL�r�LeJMDG_Ijo¯ ^ �QWcp^DgncDGmgWYJ�p^\bWf\^Len�Le`Y\TSU_YmGjKp��¶_IJÍ\bSUL�®�iIWYrKHK`U_fV�VYL�d�\^_IJZpePR£_spbW�i«\bSKWf\�W«J^WY`UjK_Un D[`h¬­`UDG\^L�ptD[n°WfmTVYL�d�\^_UJ � JM_h\bWf\^L�px\^_fqTWYJMj9��\bSUL � Dgn¦WfFYL°_f���±\bSULklKJML�L�jKDg`UF«VYL�d�\^_IJMpODGpncDGp^mGLeWfjKDg`UFQ�ÌW]px\bSUL�nc_Ypt\�n¦WfFI`UD¼¬QL�j�d�_In°rK_I`ULe`h\�_f�.Wfmgnc_hp^\xL�VYLeJMiaD[`h¬­`UDG\^L�ptD[n°WfmTVYL�d�\^_UJ � m ÛÇ_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I`\^DgncLe�°qTDGmGmolKL«DG\^pkrKJM_YÔML�d�\^DG_I`´_I`h\^_�\bSULa¬­JMpt\�p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ�VhL�d�\^_IJ��Tlhi¨jKLz¬­`UDG\^DG_I`�P ��`´\bSUDGpkp^Le`Up^LY�T\zSULsmG_IdeW]mlKJML�L�jKDg`UF�VYL�d�\^_IJMp � JM_Y\zWf\^LT\^_fqTWYJMj9�O\bSUL�¬­JMp^\¥p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ¥VYL�d�\t_IJMpTWfp¥q¥L�m~m�PÌ��`�\bSUL�J^WYJZL.deWfptL.\bSKW]\Ñ\zSUL�i¦jK_¦`U_Y\e��Mñ�ògófò \bSULcdeWfp^Lc\bSKWf\x\bSULO¬­JMpt\�lKJML�L�jKDg`UFsVYL�d�\^_UJ±D~pO_IJM\bSU_hFY_I`KWfm�\t_k\bSULO¬­JMp^\xp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ|VYL�d�\^_IJ^�Ø�QDG\�DGpO\bSULO¬­JMp^\lKJML�L�jKDg`UF�VYL�d�\^_IJ¥q±SUD~d�Skd�LeW]p^L�pT\^_�l�L�_f�ÌJML�mGL�VXWh`Ud�L=ÞIPRTSUL.lKJZL�L�jKD[`UFcVYL�d�\t_IJMpÌSKW�VYL¥\MqÑ_xWYrKrKWYJZLe`Y\¥WfjKVXWY`h\bWfFhL�pe��¬­JMp^\È\bSUL�ioWYrKr�LeWYJÌn�_IJML¥q¥L�m~mÓjKLz¬­`UL�j�\zSKWY`c\bSUL.Á6£c�q.SUDGd�S��Y��_IJÈL��KWYn¦rUmGLY�KWYJML.nc_UJML._UlYVUDG_IHUp^mGi�W|�ÜHK`Ud�\tD~_U`¦_f� ^ Â�Ã�Ä^�IptL�d�_I`Uj�\zSULeJML.DGpTWY`°Dg`Y\bHUDG\^DGVYL±��L�L�mGDg`UF¦\bSKWf\È\bSULlKJML�L�jKDg`UF¦VYL�d�\t_IJMp¥qTDGmGm l�L�\^\^LeJÈjKL�p^deJMDgl�L�\bSUL±mG_IdeWfm�p^\zJ^HUd�\bHKJML±_f��\bSULxWf\^\zJ^Wfd�\^_IJ � \bSUL.mG_UdeWfm�jKDGp^\bJMDglKHU\^DG_I`¤_f��\bSULncLeWfpzHKJMLe���Yq±SUD~mGLO\bSULÖÁ6£¸n¦W�i�r�_YDg`Y\ � _]�s\bSULÖW]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJ�P,�S��L±qTDGm~mÇJML�\bHKJ^`c\t_o\zSUL.ÐKHUL�p^\^DG_I`°_f��_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I`ß�à �'W.J3q����� 2+���#����(¤�'�¾á���������3%����â �/ã�"+���' ���t.�(+3) #"%���h���=��.���3%�����1�����1�#�� #���'(��������Jä�å æ=çWè=é+éIè=é$ê�ë4ì%í�î�î�íhï�ð�ñ�ò�ó�ô�5Wã�"+�W ��� �

õ#ö ��.���2%(+��-F÷*���� ��� ��øï ö ÷/ô¾"$.��W�0.�(%����'(%ù����� #�,(+Ô)3�� ú�(%�� #���'($��5SÕ)�0û��,�,�C���'($�#��3�� J�'(%���I üû��Jû����,�C3�� ú�($��3I���=��.����������(% �.� #����(+��� #"$��ú� �� ö ÷;û�"%���c" ��ù$���� ��4Ô� �'û4 #"P.��?ý9þ±ÿx�+.�(+3� #"+�/��.��� ö ÷;û�"%���c"� ��ù$���� ���Ô� ��ûÀ #"P.��?ý9þ��?ÿx5���e����.�������,() #"$�À .1 #"+��?���= # ���0�/��.����/û�"$�� �/ #"$��ú� �� ���÷�.� � É ���4�' #"$��Ô1�'($.'�* ��W #"+�/�#2�+�#�$.������#�$.'(%(+��3�%�� #"$�/�#�,($Ô'2%��.'

-����� ��' �4û��� #"S���1�#�� #��-��0Ô� ��ûÀ #"� .� ������$ #"+� ( #"%��� �C÷;û��,�,�6($�� �"+.�-1�/Ô' ��û�(.� 4.��,�9.� 4 #"$�����+ #��������.� #���'( #���0��5CÓ (P #"+�/��-1��(���' ����= # �����0��.����Jû�"$�� �0 #"%���h"$�'��3%�0.���ý������4þ ÿ��� #"$��(M #"%�������� #����.� ���3Fú% �� �� ����3q�,($ÔI-1���� ���03=��3I($�� W���'� ���#�Ù�'($3 ��� #"+�Wú� �� ö �1.'�%2�($��--����� ��'?.� � É 5

Page 13: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � ½

\^DgncLklKL�mG_fq�P�CEDgJMp^\o`U_h\^L¦\bSKWf\cWfpol�_Y\bS«d�_U_IJMjKDg`KWf\tL�p^iUp^\^Len�poWYrKrUmGi�_I`UmGi�\t_kD[`h¬­`UDG\^L�ptD[n°WfmTjKDGpbrUmgWfd�LencLe`h\^pe�\bSUL�DgJ±JML�mgWf\^DG_I`UpbSUDgra\^_c\bSUL�jKDGp^\zJMDglKHU\^DG_I`k_f�E\bSULcncLeWfpbHKJML�W]\̬­`UDG\^LOjKDGp^\bWY`Ud�L�p±DGpÖHK`Ud�mGLeWYJ���WY`Uj��KDg`aWY`Yi�L�VYLe`h\e�q¥_IHUmGj�jKLer�Le`Ujvl�_Y\bS°_I` Å4É WY`Uj°\bSUL.`UL�DGFISUlK_IHKJ^SU_U_Ujkp^DGÂ�L � ptL�L��TýËÚ�Ú � ÿ ó m l ó Û m ú[ò � ¿�Ç _ � � ¿Y¿ � �Ø�YJML�pbHUmG\^p¥qTDGmGmVXWhJMi�q�D~\zSk\bSULxp^iUp^\^Len d�_I`Up^DGjKLeJML�j�P

R£_¦\^L�p^\T\zSUD~p±Dg`Y\zHUD~\tD~_U`sDg`aWcpbn¦WfmGmE`IHKncl�LeJ¥_f�EVYLeJMikpbr�L�d�D[W]m�deWfptL�pe�QlKJML�L�jKDg`UFkVYL�d�\^_UJMpe�Up^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ±VYL�d�\^_UJMpTWY`Uj\bSULcmG_IdeW]mEp^\bJ^HUd�\bHKJZLo_]�Ñ\bSUL¦Wf\^\zJ^Wfd�\^_IJÍqÑLeJZLod�_U`Up^DGjKLeJML�j���_IJ�p^L�VYLeJ^W]mÌrK_YDg`h\^pxDg`«\bSUL¦®�_IJMLe`UÂY�£É«_I_IJZLzÊËÁKrUD~L�FhL�mWY`Uj r��_hp^p^mGLeJTShi¾r�LeJ�Ê�d�SKW]_YpTp^iUp^\^Lencp � L�ÐKHKWf\^DG_I`UpÍ�¶_IJÈLeWfd�S�p^iUp^\^LenÝWYJMLxFhD~VhLe`�D[`¤\bSULx·xrKrKLe`UjKDG�¾�ØPÑRTSUL�r�_YDg`Y\tpq¥LeJMLcd�SU_hp^Le`«pbHUd�S«\bSKWf\xWY`«L�pt\^Dgn¦Wf\^Lc_f�¥\bSULO¬­JMp^\�lKJML�L�jKDg`UF«VYL�d�\^_IJ±qTWfpxªU`U_Xq±`���\bSULc¬­JZp^\xp^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJxVhL�d�\^_IJqTWfpE\bSULe`°deWfmGdeHUmgWf\^L�j���_IJEp^L�VhLeJ^WfmK_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\tD~_U`¦\^DgncL�p�PECEDg`KWfmGm~iY�ÓWxmG_I`UF�Dg`h\^L�FIJ^W]\^DG_I`¦_]�­\bSUL±p^iUp^\^Len rKJZ_XVUDGjKL�jWY`cLe`UptLenolUmGL±_f�­Dg`UDG\^DgWfm�d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`UpÈqTDG\bSUDg`¦L�DG\bSULeJ¥W��ÊËlUDG\Ì_UJ/Ç�ÊËlUDG\ÑlK_f�cd�Le`h\^LeJML�j�HKr�_I`¦\zSULÍr�_YDg`Y\¥_f��Dg`Y\^LeJZL�p^\ePRTSUDGpsrKJM_fVUD~jKL�j¸WY`¨L�p^\tD[n°Wf\^Ls_]�o\bSULam~_UdeWfmxp^\zJ^HUd�\bHKJMLa_f��\bSUL�Wf\^\bJtWfd�\^_IJ�P R�SIHUpsWf\°LeWfd�S r�_YDg`Y\kq¥Lsd�_UHUm~jd�_In¦rKWhJMLÖ³�£c�KÁ6£o�QWh`UjvWcrKLeJË�¶L�d�\TLe`UptLenolUmGL � ��_IJ¥WOFYDGVYLe`kHK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\MiYÊËJtWfjKDgHUpb��PE·T\È\bSULxDg`UDG\^DgWfm�\^DgncLY�KDG\¥qTWfp_f��\^Le`�\bSULxdeWfptL�\bSKWf\¥jKDGp^\bJZD[lKHU\tD~_U`s_]�ðr�_YDg`Y\^p±_I`�\bSUL�W]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJÈqÍW]pÍl�L�\^\^LeJ¥jKL�ptdeJMDglKL�jÃlhi�\zSUL±¬­JMp^\.lKJML�L�jKDg`UFVYL�d�\^_UJc\bSKWY`¨lhiÃ\zSUL�¬­JMp^\¦p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ°VYL�d�\^_UJ � Wfp¦ÐKHKWY`h\^D¼¬QL�jµlhiÃ\zSULsjK_Y\¦rKJM_UjQHUd�\�_]�Ö\bSUL�¬­JZp^\�nc_In�Le`Y\¦_]�\bSUL�n°Wfp^p±jKD~pt\bJMDglKHU\^DG_I`���qTDG\bS«\bSULO¬­JMp^\�³�£îWY`Uj�q�D~\zSs\zSULc¬­JMp^\�Á6£x��P�RTSUDGp�qTWfp�rKWhJM\^DGdeHUmgWYJMmGi«\bJ^HULc��_IJ�\bSULÉ«_I_UJMLzÊËÁKrUDGL�FYL�m�ptiIp^\tLenkP

·T\�_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I` \^DgncLY�.SU_fq¥L�VYLeJ��¥\bSUDGpaqÍW]pv`U_¯mG_I`UFYLeJ�\bSUL«deWfp^LY�±rKWYJM\^DGdeHUmgWYJMmGi q.SULe`´\bSULa¬­JMp^\kptD[`UFUHUm[WhJVXW]m[HUL�qTWfpxmgWYJMFYLYPcCÓ_IJ�\bSUL¦\^L�p^\xdeW]p^L�pe��\zSUL�³�£c��poJZLerKJML�p^Le`h\x\bSUL¦Dg`UDG\^DgWfm¥jKD~pt\bJMDglKHU\^DG_I`¯lKL�\^\^LeJ±\zSKWY`«\bSUL�Á6£c�`UL�VYLeJM\zSUL�m~L�ptp¦\bSULsrKLeJË�¶L�d�\¦Le`UptLenolUmGL�p�SKW�VYL�pbHh×�d�DGLe`h\�rKJM_hÔËL�d�\^DG_I`¯HKrK_U`¯\bSULsÁ6£ pt_�\zSKWf\�\bSULsÁ6£?\^Le`Uj¨\^_Dg`UjKDGdeWf\^Lc\bSULxjKDgJML�d�\^DG_I`a_f��Le`UptLenolUmGLcFIJM_fqT\zS�P

RTSUL�p^L¦rKJML�mGDgncDg`KWYJMi¯JML�pbHUmG\^p�WYJMLY�Ó��_IJ�\bSUL¦nc_Yp^\xrKWYJM\���D[`Ud�_U`Ud�m[HUptD~VhLvWY`Uj�W�mgWYJMFhLeJx`IHKncLeJZD~deW]mEL��¾r�LeJMDgncLe`Y\ODGpHK`UjKLeJMqTW�i­�hiYL�\Ì\zSUL.SUDGFIS¦jKL�FUJML�L.\t_xq.SUDGd�S°\bSULTjKL�\bW]D~mGp¥_f��\bSUL�p^L�D[`UDG\^DgWfmÇJML�pbHUmG\^pÑWhJMLTp^iUp^\^LenûjKLerKLe`UjKLe`h\ � L�VYLe`Dg`¦\zSUL�p^L.mG_fq¥Ê�jKDgncLe`Up^DG_I`KW]m n�_IjKL�mGpb���UpbHUFhFYL�p^\^pÈ\bSKWf\Ì\zSUD~p¥WYrKrKJM_IW]d�S¦n°Wei¦SKW�VYLT_U`Um~i°m~DgncDG\^L�jsHU\tD~mGDG\Mi�Dg`xuJ�¡ZÇPÉ«_IJMLEDgn¦r�_IJM\bWY`h\e�frKLeJ^SKWhrUpe�fDGp�\bSULÈjKLerKLe`UjKLe`Ud�L.HKr�_I`x\zSULÑn¦WfdeJZ_Yp^d�_IrUDGdÌpt\bJ^HUd�\bHKJMLE_]�Q\bSULÑWf\t\bJ^Wfd�\^_UJ���WY`Uj�\bSUHUp\bSULTn¦WfFU`UD~\zHUjKLÑ_]�­\bSULTHK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\MixÊ�FYmgWY`Ud�Dg`UFoWfFIW]D[`cWf\ÇCEDGFIHKJML.Ò�pbSU_fqTpESU_fq¨\bSULÑnc_hp^\�mGDgªfL�mGi¦_IJZD~Le`h\bWf\tD~_U`�_]�W�¬­`UDG\^LxHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\ËicjKLer�Le`UjKpÍncHUd�S¦nc_IJZLÑ_U`c\bSUL.n¦W]FI`UDG\bHUjKLT_f��\bSULT_IlUp^LeJZVXWf\^DG_I`KW]mQHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\Ëi � Dg`UjKDGdeWf\^L�jlhi�\bSULxjKDgWYn�L�\^LeJT_]�õ\bSULxd�DgJMd�mGLe��\bSKWY`¤_I`�\bSULx_IJMDGLe`h\bWf\^DG_I`Up�_f�õL�DG\bSULeJ�mG_IdeW]m�³�£Õ_IJ¥Á6£oP

NQP�� `Fa�ç�ÞÈß�à�ßôá�ãÓäÖÞÈß�b�çIêQæfßôábí��LÃ`U_fq JML�\zHKJ^` \^_¨\bSUL«ÐKHUL�p^\^DG_I` _f�o_UrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I` \^DgncL�_f�c\bSULÃÁ6£cP¥·.paD~pad�mGLeWYJ¤�ÜJM_Un CED~FUHKJML«NQ�±\bSULHK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\Mi«jK_IHKlUmGD[`UFÀ\^DgncL�VfWYJMDGL�pcp^DGFI`UD¼¬QdeWY`h\^mGiÃqTDG\bSÀDg`UDG\^DgWfm¥d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`�P�R�SUD~pcpbHUFhFYL�p^\^pO\bSKWf\e� �¶_IJ±Dg`UDG\^DgWfmHK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\^DGL�p�_]�ÑW¦FYDGVYLe`«n¦W]FI`UDG\bHUjKLY�Q\zSULo\tD[n�Lo_fVYLeJÍq.SUDGd�Sa\bSULcmGDg`ULeWYJMDGÂeWf\^DG_I`�SU_hm~jKpOqTDGmGmEVXWYJMisW]p.q¥L�mGm���Dg`\^LeJ^n�pÌ_f��Á6£ Le`Up^LenclUmGL�pe�KDG\ÈD~p¥deJ^HUd�DgWfm�\bSKW]\Ì\bSUL±mGD[`ULeWhJMDGÂeWf\^DG_I`kJMLen¦W]D[`UpTJML�mGL�VfWY`Y\TWf\ÈmGLeWfp^\THK`Y\tD~mÓ_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I`\^DgncLY�£_Y\bSULeJMqTDGp^L°\bSUL¦deWfmGdeHUmgWf\^L�j¯p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJxVhL�d�\^_IJMpxqTDGmGmT`U_Y\�JMLz©QL�d�\O\bSULcjKD[JZL�d�\^DG_I`UpcD[`Àq.SUDGd�S�SUDGFISULeJO_IJMjKLeJ\^LeJ^n�p�qTDGmGm��¥ý^ù�ÛIl�L�d�_IncL¥Dgn¦rK_UJM\bWY`h\eP�R�SUD~pÈjK_IL�pÌ`U_h\�Dgn¦rUmGic_I`UL¥pbSU_IHUmGj¦Dg`UdeJMLeWfptLÑ\zSULÑpt\bWY`UjQWYJMjO_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I`\^DgncLY�ÇlKHU\x\bSULeJML¦n¦W�islKL¦Dg`UDG\^DgWfmÈd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`Upx��_IJ�q.SUDGd�S�Waù � m ú�ú~ó ý�Úzþ�Û ñü�cñ � m Û ñ ÚYÙ¯Û ñü�có ncHUp^\�l�LcLen¦rUmG_XihL�j��\bSUDGp�d�_UHUm~j¯lKL¦jKL�\^L�d�\tL�j�_IrKLeJtWf\^DG_I`KWfmGmGiY����_IJ±L��KWYn¦rUmGLY��lhi«L�VXWfmgHKWf\^Dg`UFa\bSULcоHKWfmGDG\Mi«_f�Ñ\bSULO��_IJMqTWYJMja\bWY`UFYLe`h\rKJM_IrKW]FIWf\^_IJ�WfpÖW�rKJML�jKDGd�\^_IJ±_]�Ñ`U_I`UmGD[`ULeWhJx\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\t_IJMDGL�p¥��_IJ ^ ³ ^ ÂcÃ1Ä^P±���Ñ\zSUL�p^L¦rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`UpoWYJZLorK_U_IJ���W�`UL�qp^L�\¥_f��Á6£c�¾lKW]p^L�j�_U`�WOpbSU_IJZ\^LeJE_IrU\tD[n�D~ÂeW]\^DG_I`�\^DgncLY�UpbSU_IHUmGjslKLxLen°rUm~_fiYL�j�PÈ��jKLeWfmGmGiY�K_I`UL±q¥_IHUmGjsnc_I`UDG\^_IJð\bSULmG_IdeW]m�Dgn¦r�_IJM\bWY`Ud�LO_f�ÌSUD~FUSULeJ�Ê�_IJMjKLeJ�\^LeJ^ncp�L��¾rUmGDGd�DG\^mGiY��WY`Uj«WfjfÔZHUpt\T\bSUL�_UrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I`k\tD[n�LoWfd�d�_IJZjKD[`UFhm~iYP¥CÓ_IJu���Z¸nc_UjKL�mGpe�E\bSUDGp¦WYrKrKJM_IW]d�S�n°Wei�rKJM_fVYL°\^_I_ad�_In¦rKHU\bW]\^DG_I`KWfmGmGi�Dg`Y\^Le`UptD~VhLY�ÌWfmG\bSU_IHUFISÀp^Dgn¦rUmGLeJ¦`U_I`UmGDg`ULeWYJnc_UjKL�mGpÖn¦W�iklKL�WYlUmGLO\^_¦L��KrUm~_hD~\±DG\eP

��� ����� �,ú+��.��,���1�e #"$��ú% �� ��0�1�0��(% /���� #"$�03=���� #�� �2$ #���'(��'�*���'�,(% ��W�'() #"$�0.� � # .1�� ��'W.�(+3)û��� #"��,( #"+�/"%������"!ü��2���J3�� ú�($��3#%� #"$�/�$$���� -�.� #���'(�5 � ���&%�'�(�(=ç*)+í�è=ê�í$+*è�î�,�ï�ð�ñ�ò.-q�9ð�ñ1ñ�ðÆô¾.�(+30/21�é430í�+*è�î�,6ï�ð�ñ�ò.-�ô��×�'43=������2$���#���'($�����* #"����4���'�,(% �5

Page 14: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � N

ÒKP Á65T·S[�÷J� ��u � ·Pu�[ ��ÉoZÌï r CÌïW��R É�÷S[�ïÌ®�Á��L¥d�_I`Ud�mgHUjKL.lhixd�_I`Up^DGjKLeJMDg`UFoSU_fq¨_I`UL¥ncDGFISh\Ed�SU_U_Yp^L¥lKL�\Mq¥L�Le`�d�_Un¦rKL�\^Dg`UF�`U_I`UmGDg`ULeWYJÈnc_IjKL�mGpe�UWY`UjcоHUL�pt\^DG_I`_IHKJȪI`U_fqTmGL�jKFYL±_f��\bSUL�deHKJ^JMLe`h\ � m~DgncDG\T_]�£rKJZL�jKD~d�\zWYlUDGm~DG\Mi6�¦_f�õWf\znc_YpbrKSULeJMLYP���L�pbW�qµWYl�_XVhLT\bSKWf\È\bSUL._UrU\^Dgn¦WfmLe`Up^LenclUmGL«��_IJML�deWfp^\�Zh[xC ÐKHUDGd�ªhmGi lKL�d�_In�L�p�SUDGFISUmGi p^\bJ^HUd�\bHKJZL�j��.\zSIHUpk\bSUL«L�VfWfmgHKWf\^DG_I` _f��nc_UjKL�mxÐKHKWfmGD~\Mi\bSKJM_UHUFIS r É�Á LeJ^JM_IJ�n¦W�iµl�L«��WYJc��JM_In _UrU\^Dgn¦Wfm�PÝÉ«D[`UDgncHKn LeJtJM_IJ°deJMDG\^LeJMDgW¨qTDGmGm�ptL�m~L�d�\«nc_UjKL�m~p«q.SUDGd�SWfp^iKn¦rU\^_h\^LE\^_±\bSULTncLeWY`x_]�Q\bSULÌjKDGp^\bJZD[lKHU\tD~_U`c_f�Qq.SKWf\tL�VYLeJ�ÐKHKWY`h\^DG\MixD~pÌl�L�Dg`UF�rKJML�jKDGd�\^L�j��Uq.SUDGm~LTWfmGm � JZLeWfmGD~pt\^DGd=�nc_UjKL�mGpsd�_I`h\^Dg`IHUL«\^_¯_Yp^d�DGmGmgWf\^LYPî��`UjKL�L�j��ÖW]pkp^_I_U`µW]p�\bSUL�HK`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`Y\MiµJZLz©QL�d�\^L�j lhi²\bSULoZ/[xCÝlKL�d�_In�L�pd�_In¦rUmGDGdeWf\^L�j���WOmGLeWfp^\TLeJ^JZ_IJÈdeJMDG\^LeJMDG_I`�q¥_IHUmGjsJMLMÔML�d�\T\bSULx®�_IJMLe`UÂOL�оHKWf\tD~_U`UpÍW]p.WOFY_I_Ujsnc_UjKL�m�_f��\bSUL�®�_UJMLe`UÂL�ÐKHKWf\^DG_I`Up�7ER£_xp^L�LT\bSUDGpe�hd�_I`Up^DGjKLeJECEDGFIHKJML � Wf\ ^ Æ N X �K�YW.r�LeJ���L�d�\Ñnc_UjKL�mKqTDGmGmQ\^Le`Uj¦\t_�rKJML�jKDGd�\ÑW±VXW]m[HUL�D[`�_I`UL_IJ£\bSUL¥_Y\bSULeJÇ_f�Q\zSULÑ\Mq¥_±m~_UlKL�pE_f��\bSULJZ/[xCT��D~\Eq�D~mGmQl�LTDg`Ud�_IJ^JML�d�\ÌWYl�_IHU\ÌSKWfm¼�­\zSULÑ\tD[n�LYPõ® L�\E\bSUL¥p^LerKWYJ^Wf\tD~_U`�_]�\bSUL±mG_IlKL�p.l�L���8U�U\bSULe`¦\zSUL r É�Ákr�Le`KWfmG\Ëi°��_IJE\bSULxrKLeJË�¶L�d�\.n�_IjKL�m�qTDGmGm�W�VYLeJ^WfFhL �w � ��8f� w �I\zSUD~p�D~p¥FIJZLeWf\^LeJÈ\bSKWY`\bSKWf\O_f�T\bSUL�HK`KrKShiIptD~deW]mÍn�_IjKL�m¥q.SUDGd�SÃWfd�SUDGL�VYL�p98 w lYi�rKJML�jKDGd�\^Dg`UF�\zSULvncLeWh`«_f�T\bSUL�jKD~pt\bJMDglKHU\^DG_I` � q.SUDGd�SSKWfp¥Â�LeJM_¦d�SKWY`Ud�Lx_f�ElKL�Dg`UF�d�_UJ^JML�d�\e�UlKHU\.WOm~_fq¥LeJÈL��¾r�L�d�\^L�j r É Á�LeJtJM_IJ^��P£·.VhLeJ^WfFYL�jk_fVYLeJÈrKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`UpÖlKW]p^L�j_I`«n¦WY`hisjKD¼��LeJMLe`h\ � HK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`K�|_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`Upe��\zSUD~pOqTDGmGmEm~LeW]j�\^_ r É�Á«JMLMÔML�d�\^DG_I`«_f�¥\bSUL¦rKLeJ���L�d�\onc_UjKL�mEDg`��WeVh_IHKJÈ_f�õ\zSUL�HK`KrKSYiUp^DGdeWfmEnc_IjKL�m�P

��`arKJ^Wfd�\^DGd�LY�Kq¥L�SKW�VYL�WcptLeJMDGL�p._f�EHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`a_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`UpT_]�ðWcptiIp^\tLenk�KJMLerKJML�p^Le`h\^L�jsptd�SULen¦W]\^DGdeWfmGm~islhi�\bSULd�DgJMd�mGL�p�Dg`ÀCEDGFIHKJML��KP«RÈi¾rUDGdeWfmGmGiY�ÌmG_fqÝ_IJMjKLeJc`U_I`UmGDg`ULeWYJ¦nc_UjKL�mGp�WYJML�L�VXW]m[HKW]\^L�j²lYiÀp^\bWYJM\tD[`UFa_I`À\bSUL�Dg`UDG\^DgWfm_IlUp^LeJZVXWf\^DG_I`Up � \bSUL±p^_YmGDGjkm~Dg`ULOD[`�CEDGFIHKJZL)�Y���KWY`Uj�d�_I`Up^DGjKLeJMDg`UFvW�VYLeJtWfFYL r É�ÁkrKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`¤LeJ^JM_IJ¥WfpTW|��HK`Ud�\^DG_I`_f�¥��_IJML�deWfp^\x\tD[n�LY�õlKHU\¦SKW�VUD[`UFa\bWYªfLe` _IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`KWfm¥HK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\Ëi«Dg`h\^_�Wfd�d�_IHK`h\�Dg`�\zHK`UD[`UF«\bSUL�nc_IjKL�m��Eq¥LpbSU_IHUmGj�\zWYªfL�DG\xDg`h\^_vW]d�d�_IHK`Y\xDg`«\zSUL�Dg`UDG\^DgWfmÌd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`ÀWfpxq¥L�m~m�P�R�SUD~pxpzHUFYFYL�p^\^p±\bSULO��_YmGm~_fqTDg`UFaL��¾r�LeJMDgncLe`Y\�P� DGVYLe`kWOp^LeJZD~L�p±_f�õHK`Ud�LeJZ\bWfDg`k_IlUptLeJMVXWf\tD~_U`Up � \bSUL±d�DgJMd�mGL�pb���Ód�_I`Up^\bJ^HUd�\TWOFY_U_Ij r É ÁkrKJZL�jKD~d�\t_IJ � \bSULxjQW]pbShÊ�jK_Y\\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\t_IJMiK�xWY`Uj²W�JMLeWfmGDGp^\^DGd«nc_IjKL�m � \zSULkp^_YmGDGj¨m~Dg`ULe��lK_Y\zS¯_f�.q.SUDGd�S¨p^\bWhJM\x��JM_In�\bSULkDg`UDG\^DgWfmT_IlUptLeJMVXWf\tD~_U`�»deWY`�q¥L�¬­`Uj�WY`�Dg`UDG\^DgWfm�d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`aqTDG\bSUDg`¤\bSUL._UlUp^LeJMVXW]\^DG_I`KWfm�HK`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`Y\MiY�KpbHUd�S�\bSKWf\¥\bSUL�n�_IjKL�m�\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\t_IJMirKWfp^ptL�pE\^_.q�D~\zSUD[`�\bSUL¥_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`KWfmKHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\Mi�_f�Q\bSULTJMLen°WfDg`UjKLeJE_f�Q\bSUL¥p^LeJZD~L�p � \bSUL¥jQWfpbSUL�jcmGD[`UL±Dg`OCED~FUHKJML�Y��Û ÷xJ���nc_IJMLcÐKHKWY`h\^DG\bWf\^DGVYL�mGiY�Çq.SKWf\±DGp�\bSUL¦jKDGp^\zJMDglKHU\^DG_I`�_]�Ñ\^DgncL�p � _fVYLeJ±jKD¼��LeJMLe`h\xDg`UD~\tD[W]mÑd�_U`UjKD~\tD~_U`Upb�±��_IJq.SUDGd�SsW¦nc_UjKL�m�deWY`¤pbSKWfjK_fq \bSULx_UlUp^LeJMVXW]\^DG_I`Up.\t_oq�D~\zSUD[`a\bSULx_UlUp^LeJMVXW]\^DG_I`KWfmEHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\Ëi9Û;�¥mGLeWYJMmGiY��HK`UjKLeJ\bSUDGp±deJMDG\^LeJMDgW¦\zSUL�®�_IJMLe`UÂOL�оHKWf\tD~_U`Up.qTDGmGmErKJM_fVIDGjKLoWh`�_IrU\^Dgn¦Wfm�n�_IjKL�m���_IJ¥\zSUL�®�_IJMLe`UÂOL�оHKWf\tD~_U`Upe�Qq±SUD~mGLO\bSUL_IrU\^Dgn¦W]m r É�ÁkrKJML�jKDGd�\^_IJÍ�¶_UJÑW�FYDGVYLe`k_IlUptLeJMVXWf\tD~_U`KWfm�HK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\Mi�q¥_IHUmGj«lKLoJZLMÔËL�d�\^L�jkLeWhJMmGik_I`�P��`ÀWkn¦Wf\bSULen¦W]\^DGdeWfmEd�_I`h\^L��I\���\bSULc\^LeJ^n pbSKWfjK_fqTDg`UF«SKWfp�lKL�Le`¯HUp^L�j�\^_sJZLz©QL�d�\�\bSULcL��U\^Le`Y\x\t_kq.SUDGd�S«\zSULeJMLL��UD~pt\^pÌp^_UncLTL��KWfd�\Ìp^_hm[HU\tD~_U`¦_f��WxFYDGVYLe`�p^L�\Ì_f��L�ÐKHKWf\^DG_I`UpÈq.SUDGd�S�JML�p^LenclUmGL�pÑW|jKD~FhD~\zWfm¼Ê�p^_YmgHU\^DG_I`°��JM_In W±jKDGFYDG\bW]md�_In¦rKHU\tLeJ�PsRTSUL¦\tLeJ^n � Wh`UjÃRTSUL�_IJMLen°�xDGp¦WfmGp^_«D[`hVY_Iª]L�j�Dg`¯p^\bHUjKDGL�pc_f�.rKWYJ^WYncL�\tLeJ±L�p^\^Dgn¦Wf\^DG_I` ��_IJ±þ ó ý p ó � ÛrKWYJ^WhncL�\bJMDGd�nc_UjKL�mGp � p^L�LY�£�¶_UJ±L��¾WYn°rUm~LY�;: m Ù�ù ó Ù m Ùel�w�ý ñ�ó \Uóeú � � ¿�ÇYÒkWY`Uj�\bSULkJMLz��LeJMLe`Ud�L�pc\bSULeJML�Dg`K��Px� SKWf\q¥LoWYJZL�Dg`Y\tLeJML�p^\^L�j«Dg`�SULeJMLcDGpxоHKWh`Y\^D¼��iIDg`UFsSU_fq¸qÑL�mGmEDgn¦r�LeJ��¶L�d�\�n�_IjKL�mGp�JMLz©QL�d�\x\bSUL¦l�LeSKWeVUDG_IHKJ±_f�ÑrKShiIptD~deW]mp^iUp^\^Lencp�FYDGVYLe`5_IrKLeJ^W]\^DG_I`KWfm±_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`KWfm.HK`Ud�LeJZ\bWfDg`Y\tD~L�p�»�\bSULapbSKWfjK_fqTDg`UFÃ_]�orKSYiUp^DGdeWfm±_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`UpslhiDgn¦rKLeJË�¶L�d�\.n�_IjKL�mGpePE·x`UjkDG\^pTHUp^LxDg`�d�SU_U_Yp^Dg`UF¦lKL�\Mq¥L�Le`��KJMLz¬­`UDg`UFQ�QWY`Uj�d�_InclUDg`UDg`UF�\bSUL���_IJML�deWfp^\tpÌ_f��jKDGp^\tD[`Ud�\��_Ir�LeJ^Wf\^DG_I`KWfmÇ`U_I`UmGD[`ULeWhJ¥��_IJML�deWfpt\^Dg`UF¦p^iUp^\^Lencp �=<C�cñ Û�ÿ m Ùel�n ñ�ú�� ÚhøIýz� � ¿Y¿��Y��P·x`Uj¦��_IJÈ\bSUL±qÑLeW]\bSULeJ�Ûk��\¥q¥_IHUmGjklKLxDg`Y\tLeJML�p^\^Dg`UF¦\^_OjKL�\^LeJ^ncDg`ULx\bSUL±jKDGp^\bJMDglKHU\^DG_I`�_]�õn¦Wf�UDgnoHKnû\^DgncL�pTq.SUDGd�S_Ir�LeJ^Wf\^DG_I`KWfmKnc_UjKL�mGpÌd�_IHUmGj¦pbSKW]jK_Xq¯\bSUL � ¬Q�UL�jQ��Wh`KWfmGiIp^DGpeP ��� ��`KWfpbncHUd�SoW]pEjKL�\^LeJ^ncDg`UDg`UF�\bSUL � d�_UJ^JML�d�\��TDg`UDG\^DgWfmd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`¦JZL�оHUDgJML�pÌWxªU`U_fqTmGL�jKFYL¥_f�Q\bSULÈ�ÜHU\zHKJML¥qÑLeW]\bSULeJ���pbHUd�ScWY`cWYrKrKJZ_IWfd�Sxq¥_IHUmGj¦`U_Y\õ`UL�d�L�ptpbWYJMDGmGi¦Dgn¦rKJM_fVYLJMLeWfm¼Ê�\^DgncLO��_IJML�deWfpt\^pePT÷x`a\bSULc_Y\bSULeJ±SKWY`Uj��ÓD��¥\bSUL¦rKLeJM\zHKJ^lKWf\^DG_I`UpxJML�ÐKHUD[JZL�j�\^_¦pbSUD¼��\x\bSUL�_UrKLeJ^Wf\tD~_U`KWfm�Dg`UDG\^DgWfmd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`a\^_c\bSUL � nc_UjKL�m�Ê�d�_UJ^JML�d�\��¦VfWfmgHULcd�_I`Y\zWfDg`UL�jsp^_In�Lxp^iIpt\^Len¦Wf\^DGdxp^\zJ^HUd�\bHKJMLY�K\zSUD~p�p^\bJ^HUd�\bHKJZLxd�_IHUmGj l�LLen¦rUmG_fiYL�j¯\^_«D[n°rKJM_fVYLc��HU\bHKJML°�¶_IJZL�deWfp^\^pePa��`¨WfjKjKDG\^DG_I`��ÌrKJZ_YÔML�d�\^Dg`UF�\zSUL�p^L � pbSKWfjK_fqTDg`UF�rKLeJM\bHKJtlKWf\^DG_I`Up��«Dg`\^LeJ^n�p�_f�­Á6£ WY`Ujo³�£ ncDGFISY\ESUL�mgrc\^_xJML�p^_YmGVYLÈ\bSUL¥Ð¾HUL�pt\^DG_I`O_f�Q\bSULÑl�L�p^\E_Ir�LeJ^Wf\^DG_I`KWfmULe`Up^LenclUmGLYPÌ��`cWY`hixL�VYLe`h\e�\bSUL¦L��KrKLeJZD[n�Le`Y\OqÑ_UHUm~j¯rKJM_fVIDGjKL�WY` L�p^\^Dgn¦Wf\^Lc_f�¥\bSUL¦\bJtHULomGDgncDG\c_f�.rKJML�jKDGd�\bWYlUDGmGDG\ËiÀ_f�ÑdeHKJ^JZLe`Y\O_IrKLeJ^W]\^DG_I`KWfmnc_UjKL�mGpeP

>@?��C� úA�=��3 û��S�0��.'(¤.��× ���J.�(%�M-'.����.� #����(+.��03%.� �.F.1���#�����,��.� #����(;"$.��&�����(�.'�%���,����3¿ ��) #"+���+��� -'.1 #���'($�FïCB�è�î�è�34'#è=é$êIè=é+êD (=ì�'E+@1�í�'���ð�ñ�ò.-0.'($3S ���×�� ��($�����4 #"$�� ������ô�5 � "+.13���û��,(+ÔJ�,(F��2�?��.1���h���?���'($�����($��3û��� #") #"$�����"$.'-�����2���'�* #"$�/�0�=3%���*��-���4����(+Ô #���0�E!ü����.������/ï×û����EF%���%�0��(% #"+�C�'4�0�� ��ô4éG(4+� #"$���,(% ��� .��� #����(���� üû�����(� #"$���0�=3%����.'($3J #"+�4 .'û 3�.1 �.��%û�"�����"J����2+�#2$.'�,����3���($.��������-���?�#"$�' ���· #���0�/����.�������5

Page 15: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � Ò

0 0.1 0.2

-1

0

1

time

tem

pera

ture

CEDGFIHKJML�KPERTSUL±pbSKWfjK_fqTDg`UFcjKD~mGLen¦n°WKP � DGVYLe`kW|p^LeJMDGL�p¥_f�õHK`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`¦_IlUptLeJMVXWf\tD~_U`Upe�UD[`UjKDGdeWf\tL�j�lhio\zSUL.d�DgJMd�mGL�pe�\bSUL±jK_Y\MÊ�jQWfpzSUL�jkm~Dg`ULOD[`UjKDGdeWf\tL�p.\bSUL���_IJML�deWfp^\¥qTDG\bS�ncDg`UDgncDGÂ�L�px\bSUL r É�Á�LeJ^JM_IJ�PE�Ü\Ñd�mGLeWYJZm~i�_IHU\TrKLeJË�¶_IJtncp¥\bSULnc_IJZL.JMLeWfmGDGp^\^DGd�nc_UjKL�mQp^\zWYJM\^L�jc��JM_In¸\zSUL.Dg`UDG\^DgWfm�_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I` � \bSULTpt_YmGD~jkmGDg`ULe��P/� SKWf\Èq¥LTqTWY`Y\È\^_xjKL�\^LeJ^n�D[`ULDGp�q±SUL�\bSULeJc\bSULeJMLkL��UDGp^\^p�Wh`U_Y\bSULeJcDg`UDG\^DgWfm±d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I` �Mófò,\Kò \bSULkjQWfpbSUL�j¨mGDg`ULe����d�_I`Up^DGp^\^Le`h\¦qTDG\bS¯\bSULkDg`UDG\^DgWfm_IlUp^LeJZVXWf\^DG_I`��¾�¶_IJÍq.SUDGd�S¤\bSULx\bJ^W]ÔËL�d�\^_UJMic_f�õ\zSUL�JMLeWfmGDGp^\^DGd¦nc_IjKL�mÇrKWfp^p^L�pTq�D~\zSUD[`¤\bSUL�HK`Ud�LeJM\bW]D[`h\MivJtWfjKDgHUp._f�ÌWp^LeJMDGL�p±_f�E_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`UpeP

�KP �T÷u���®4�.ÁK��÷u.ÁïÌ`UptLenolUmGLc��_IJML�deW]p^\^Dg`UF�rKJM_fVUDGjKL�poWk`UL�q rKWhJ^WfjKDGFIn?��_IJ±jKL�\^LeJ^ncDg`UDGp^\^DGdkrKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`¯_f�T`U_I`UmGD[`ULeWhJ�ptiIp^\tLencpe��WrKWYJ^W]jKD~FUn q.SUDGd�S«deWhJ^JMDGL�pon¦Wh`Yi«rKJ^Wfd�\^DGdeWfmEDgn¦rUmGDGdeWf\^DG_I`UpeP�R�_kjKDGp^\tD[`UFUHUD~pzS�\bSUL°d�_In¦rUmGDGdeWf\^DG_I`UpoWhJMDGp^Dg`UFk��JM_InWY`¯Dgn¦r�LeJ��¶L�d�\�nc_IjKL�m±WY`UjÃ\zSU_Yp^L���JM_In WY`ÀD[`UL��KWfd�\�ªU`U_fqTmGL�jKFYLk_f�x\bSUL�D[`UDG\^DgWfm±p^\bW]\^LY�Eq¥LvSKW�VYL�d�_I`Up^DGjKLeJML�jLe`Up^LenclUmGL��¶_UJML�deWfp^\^pODg`ÃWY`À_IrU\^Dgn¦W]mE��_IJML�deWfp^\Op^d�Le`KWYJMDG_�WY`Uj¯jKDGp^deHUp^p^L�j¨\bSUL�Dgn¦rK_UJM\bWY`Ud�L�_f�ÖWarKLeJ���L�d�\ ��� _I`\bSUL�W]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJ��I�¥Le`UptLenolUmGL�_f�ÑDg`UDG\^DgWfm¥d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`UpeP � DGVYLe`«_UlUp^LeJMVXW]\^DG_I`Upx��JM_In W�p^\zJ^WY`UFYL¦Wf\^\zJ^Wfd�\^_IJ�pbHKlUÔML�d�\_I`UmGi�\^_�\bJtHK`UdeWf\^DG_I`°LeJ^JM_IJ��h_I`ULxn¦W�i¦d�_I`Up^\bJtHUd�\ÑWY`°Le`Up^LenclUmGL�HK`UD���_IJ^n�m~i�jKDGp^\bJMDglKHU\^L�ja_fVYLeJE\bSUL±ÐKHKWY`Y\tD~ÂeW]\^DG_I`Shi¾r�LeJ�Ê�deHKlKLY�ElKHU\�\zSUD~pxLe`UptLenolUmGL�DGp±©­Weq¥L�j«Dg`«\bSKWf\x\zSULo\zJ^HULcp^\bWf\^L�px_]�Ì\bSUL¦p^iUp^\^Len qTDGmGmTÙQÚhÛÌlKL¦HK`UD¼�¶_UJ^ncmGijKDGp^\bJMDglKHU\^L�j�PÈRTSULTp^L�mGL�d�\^DG_I`°_f�QDg`UDG\^DgWfm�d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`UpÌd�_I`UptD~pt\^Le`Y\ÈqTDG\bSO\bSUL.nc_UjKL�mKDGpÑWx`U_I`h\bJMDGVUDgWfmQrKJM_IlUmGLenk�hL�VYLe`q.SULe`¤\bSUL�`U_YDGp^LorKJZ_Id�L�p^p�D~pxªU`U_Xq±`�P

·±poL��KrKL�d�\tL�j¨��JM_In \zSULs`U_I`hÊËHK`UD¼�¶_IJtncDG\Ëi¯_f�.pt\bJ^WY`UFYL�Wf\^\bJ^W]d�\^_IJMp �Mófò,\Kò&Hxñ � Ú úGñ ù ó Û m úgòT��� ¿�ÇY½Y���I� ó Ù9� ñTó Û m úgò��� ¿�ÇY¿Y��� Hxó � ó��Æ� ¿�ÇY¿Y�Ø�0�ÖÚ ó ýzÙ ó ý ó Û m ú[òx�Æ� ¿Y¿ � �Ø� <C�cñ Û�ÿ ��� ¿Y¿fNIWY�cWY`Uj JMLz��LeJMLe`Ud�L�p�\zSULeJML�Dg`K���TlK_Y\zS¨\bSUL«rKJMLzÊjKDGd�\bWYlUDGmGDG\ËikWY`Uj¦\zSULÖnc_UjKL�mK��_IJML�deW]p^\EpbªhD~mGm�VXWhJMicqTDGjKL�m~iklKL�\Mq¥L�Le`cjKD¼��LeJMLe`h\ÑDg`UDG\^DgWfm�p^\bW]\^L�pEDg`¦d�SKWf_Y\^DGdTptiIp^\tLencpePCQ_UJEp^iUp^\^LencpE_]�£rKShiUp^DGdeWfmQDg`h\^LeJML�p^\e�U\bSUL±n¦WfdeJM_Yptd�_IrUDGdTp^\bJ^HUd�\zHKJMLT_f��\bSUL.W]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJ�mGDgncDG\^pT\zSUL.HU\^DGmGD~\Mi¦_]� pt\bWf\^DGpMÊ\^DGd�pÑlKW]p^L�j�HKrK_U`cDg`h¬­`UD~\tL�p^Dgn¦WfmGpe»È\bSULTHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\ËicjK_IHKlUmGDg`UFc\^DgncL.n¦W�ix\^L�mGm�HUpEm~DG\^\tm~LxWYl�_IHU\E\bSULT\^DgncL�D~\E\zWYªfL�pWY`ÀDg`h¬­`UD~\tL�p^Dgn¦WfmT\^_aDg`UdeJMLeWfp^LslhiÃW¤�ÜW]d�\^_IJ±_f�T��_IHKJ�P¤·Ö` � Lz��L�d�\^DGVYL=� � W�VYLeJ^WfFhLe�±FIJM_fqT\bS�JtWf\^L�WYrKrUmGDGL�j²\t_�Wpbr�L�d�D�¬QdY��pbSU_IJM\È\^DgncL � ®�iIWYrKHK`U_fVcL��¾r�_I`ULe`h\^pb�E\tL�m~mGp.HUpÈL�VYLe`°m~L�ptpePWu�L�D~\zSULeJÌÐKHKWY`h\^DG\Mi�`UL�L�jkJMLz©QL�d�\¥mGDgncDG\bWf\^DG_I`Up\^_¦rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`a_f�Ǭ­`UDG\^LoHK`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`Y\^DGL�pe»¥Wfp¥mG_I`UFkWfpTWY`kHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\MivJMLen°WfDg`Up.Dg`h¬­`UDG\^L�p^Dgn¦WfmÇDG\Ör�_Yp^L�p.`U_°m~DgncDG\\^_�rKJZL�jKD~d�\tD~_U`J7

RTSULOLe`Up^LenclUm~L�p±d�_I`Up^DGjKLeJML�j«\bSUHUp��ÜWYJ�SKWeVhLxd�_I`Up^DGp^\^L�ja_f�ðW�p^L�\._]�õp^DgncDGmgWYJ�Dg`UD~\tD[W]mEd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`UpxL�VY_YmGVYL�j«HK`UjKLeJ\bSULcpbWYn�Lonc_UjKL�m�PoRTSUL¦ncL�\zSU_IjaLen¦rUmG_XihL�j�\^_�d�_I`Up^\bJ^HUd�\±pbHUd�SaLe`Up^LenclUm~L�pOpbSU_IHUmGjÃJMLz©QL�d�\x\zSULoFh_IWfmGp._]�Ì\bSUL��_IJML�deWfp^\tLeJ��Ç\bSULvrKJZ_IrKLeJM\tD~L�p°_f� � JMDGFISh\b�OÁUD[`UFUHUm[WhJF£EL�d�\^_IJ|Le`Up^LenclUm~L�pkWY`Uj � Dg`h¬­`UDG\^L�p^Dgn¦Wfmg�¦³¥JML�L�jKDg`UF¬£EL�d�\^_IJLe`Up^LenclUmGL�p�SKW�VYL�lKL�Le`¤jKD~ptdeHUp^p^L�j�PJ�¥_I`Upt\bJ^WfDg`h\^pTjQHUL�\t_¦\bSULxDg`h¬­`UDG\^L�p^Dgn¦WfmGpoHKr�_I`kq±SUD~d�Sa\bSUL�p^L�ncL�\zSU_IjKpxWYJMLlKWfp^L�jÀqÑLeJZL�`U_h\^L�j���WfpOqTWfp.\zSUL¦Dgn¦rK_IJZ\bWY`Ud�L¦_f�TVfWYJMDgWf\^DG_I`UpOD[` \bSUL�JML�mGL�VXWh`Y\O_IrU\^DgncDGÂeWf\^DG_I`À\^DgncL�px��_IJ±LeWfd�S�PCEDg`UDG\^Lor�LeJM\bHKJ^lKWf\tD~_U`UpÌ��JM_InÎL�DG\bSULeJTn�L�\bSU_Ijsn°Wei�lKL�HK`KrKShiIp^DGdeWfm��ÓD¼�õ\bSULxptiIp^\tLen L�Vh_YmGVYL�pT_I`�WY`�Wf\^\bJ^W]d�\^_IJE_]�jKDgncLe`Up^DG_I`¤m~L�ptpÑ\zSKWY`¦\zSKWf\Ì_f�Ç\bSUL.pt\bWf\^LzÊ�pbrKW]d�LY�Y\bSULe`�Dg`UDG\^DgWfm�d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`Up�D[`kW]m~m � pbW�VYL.Wh`KWfmG_YFI�ÈLe`Up^LenclUmGL�pTqTDGmGmmGDGL � _f��\bSUL�W]\^\bJ^Wfd�\t_IJ��cqTDG\bSkrKJM_IlKWhlUD~mGDG\Mis_I`ULY�ÓlK_Y\bS�\zSUL�p^DGÂ�L�_]�õ\bSULcrKLeJM\zHKJ^lKWf\^DG_I`kWY`UjaDG\^pT_IJMDGLe`h\bWf\^DG_I`aWYJMLDgn¦rK_UJM\bWY`h\eP

Page 16: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � �

RTSUL¦jKDGp^\tD[`Ud�\tD~_U`¨lKL�\Mq¥L�Le` � lKW]j9���¶_IJZL�deWfp^\^pxjQHUL�\^_�SUDGFISÀp^Le`Up^DG\^DGVUDG\ËiÀ_f�T\bSUL¦p^iUp^\^Len WY`Uj � lKWfj9����_IJML�deW]p^\^pjQHULx\^_¦nc_UjKL�mGm~Dg`UF�LeJ^JM_IJ � LeW]d�S°jKLerKLe`UjKDg`UFsHKrK_U`�\bSUL.mG_UdeWf\^DG_I`�_f�Ç\bSUL.Dg`UDG\^DgWfmÇd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`K�TSKWfpTl�L�Le`kp^\bJZL�p^p^L�j�P��`¯\zSUL¦��_IJ^ncLeJOdeWfptL�\bSUL���_IJML�deW]p^\^poWhJMLvW]d�d�_IHK`Y\zWYlUmGLY�Ì\bSUL�mgWf\^\^LeJOdeWfptLkD[`UjKDGdeWf\tL�pvnc_UjKL�m¥LeJ^JM_IJØP�ïÈ`Up^LenclUm~L��_IJML�deWfp^\tp�WhJMLsWfd�d�_IHK`h\bWYlUmGLk\^_«\bSULkL��U\^Le`h\¦\bSKWf\c\bSUL�Zh[xC JMLz©QL�d�\^p¦\bSULkL�Vh_YmgHU\^DG_I`¨_f�xW�rKWYJM\^DGdeHUmgWYJcDg`UDG\^DgWfm_IlUp^LeJZVXWf\^DG_I`�»�D¼�Ñ\bSULMZ/[xC WYrKrKLeWhJMpx\^_klKL � Dg`aLeJ^JM_IJ��Ó� � ��_IJ�L��¾Whn¦rUmGLY��D��¥\bSULcVYLeJMD¼¬QdeWf\^DG_I`a\bJtWfÔML�d�\^_IJMiknc_fVYL�p\^_¦W¦JML�FhD~_U`k_f��Â�LeJZ_�rKJM_IlKWYlUDGmGDG\MisjKLe`Up^DG\Mi¾�Ø�Kq¥LxdeWY`kWfd�d�_IHK`h\¥��_IJÈ\bSUDGp.L�VYLe`h\.Wfp¥jQHULO\^_¦\bSUL±¬­`UDG\^LOp^DGÂ�L�_f�E_IHKJLe`Up^LenclUmGLYP¦��`UdeJMLeW]p^Dg`UFs\bSUL¦ptD~Â�L°_f�Ì\bSUL¦Le`Up^LenclUmGL¦pbSU_UHUm~j¯JML�jQHUd�L¦\bSULc��JML�ÐKHULe`Ud�is_f�¥pbHUd�S«L�VYLe`h\^peP�÷xHU\^ptD~jKL\bSULc_IrU\^Dgn¦W]m���_IJML�deWfpt\.p^d�Le`KWhJMDG_k\bSUDGp�`UL�L�jÃ`U_Y\±_Id�deHKJ��£Dg`«q.SUDGd�SadeWfptLoq¥L¦SKW�VYL�L�VUDGjKLe`Ud�L�\zSKWf\e�ÓD[`«WfjKjKDG\^DG_I`\^_�HK`Ud�LeJZ\bWfDg`Y\MiY��W¦pt_IHKJMd�L�_]�ÌLeJ^JM_IJ¥L��UDGp^\^pe�ÓL�DG\bSULeJ±qTDG\bSUDg`a\bSULon�_IjKL�mÇ_IJ¥qTDG\bSUDg`a\bSULOp^L�mGL�d�\^DG_I`«_f�E\bSUL�Dg`UDG\^DgWfmd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`UpeP«·±d�d�_IHK`h\^Dg`UF«��_IJxpbHUd�S¯LeJ^JM_UJMpe��Dg`¨rKWYJZ\^DGdeHUm[WhJcjKDGp^\^Dg`UFIHUDGpbSUDg`UF¨p^iUp^\^Len ptLe`Up^DG\^DGVIDG\Mi���JM_In nc_UjKL�mLeJ^JM_UJ��KJMLen¦WfDg`UpxW¦n¦WfÔM_IJðd�SKWfmGmGLe`UFYLc\^_¦Le`UptLenolUmGLcrKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`�P

���TWkrKLeJ���L�d�\on�_IjKL�mEDGp�`U_Y\�W�VXW]D~mgWYlUmGLY�Ç_I`UL¦n¦W�i�W]m~pt_sn¦WYªfLOLe`Up^LenclUm~L�pc_fVYLeJ�jKD¼� LeJZLe`Y\x\MiKrKL�px_f�Tnc_IjKL�mGpe�£_IJLe`Up^LenclUmGL�p�_]�|nc_UjKL�mGp�_fVYLeJ°HK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`²rKWhJ^WYncL�\^LeJ�VXWfmgHUL�pkHUp^Dg`UFÃ\bSULapbWYncLsn�_IjKL�mTpt\bJ^HUd�\bHKJML � p^L�LK� ó � ó Ùm ÙelL� ñ Ù úGó �f� � ¿Y¿Y�h��P���` \bSUDGp�deWfp^LY�ÇHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\Mi�Dg`«\zSUL¦Dg`UD~\tD[W]mÌd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`Àd�_InclUDg`UL�p�qTDG\bS«VfWYJMDgWf\^DG_I` D[` \bSULp^Le`Up^DG\^DGVUDG\Ëi�_f��jKD¼��LeJMLe`Y\Tnc_UjKL�mGp � WY`Uj¦\bSUL±p^iUp^\^Len¦�ðDg`�WOn¦WY`K`ULeJÈq.SUDGd�S°d�_In¦rUmGDGdeWf\^L�p¥\bSUL±d�SU_YDGd�L._f�EW � l�L�p^\��nc_UjKL�m�PÌ��`¦rKWhJM\^DGdeHUmgWYJ��KncDg`UDgnoHKn r É�ÁcLeJtJM_IJÇdeJMDG\^LeJMDgW|deWY`¦lKL±jKDGp^deJML�jKDG\^L�j � W]pE\bSUL�i�qTDGmGm�d�_I`Up^DGp^\^Le`h\^mGiO�ÜW]D~mÓ\^_d�SU_I_YptL.\bSULxrKLeJË�¶L�d�\.n�_IjKL�mg��PE·x`�WfmG\^LeJ^`KWf\^DGVYL�WhrKrKJM_IWfd�ScDGpT\^_Od�_I`Y\zJ^Wfp^\¥SU_Xq q¥L�mGm�VXWYJMDG_IHUp�D[n°rKLeJ���L�d�\.nc_UjKL�mGpdeWY`�pbSKW]jK_Xq \bSULx_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`UpeP

� SUL�\bSULeJ¥\bSULxLe`UptLenolUmGL�pxWYJML��¶_UJ^ncL�jk_fVYLeJÈDg`UD~\tD[W]m�d�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`Up��Q_IJ¥nc_UjKL�mGpe�K_IJ�lK_Y\bS��U\bSULx\tD[n�L�Wf\Tq.SUDGd�S�\bSULrKJM_IlKWhlUD~mGDG\MiÃjKLe`UptD~\Mi«��HK`Ud�\^DG_I`À_f�T\bSUL¦Le`Up^LenclUmGLY�NM Ä �"O �Ø�õl�L�d�_IncL�pcDg`UjKDGp^\^Dg`UFIHUDGpbSKWYlUmGLa�ÜJZ_In DG\^p¦Wfp^iKn¦rU\^_Y\^DGdjKDGp^\bJMDglKHU\^DG_I`���MQP �"O �¥jKLz¬­`UL�px\bSULO\bJ^HUL � mGDgncDG\x_f�ÌrKJML�jKDGd�\bWYlUDGmGD~\Mi6�sFYDGVYLe`¤\bSUDGp.\zJMDgrUm~L�\x_]�õ_IlUptLeJMVXWf\tD~_U`��­nc_UjKL�mWY`Uj�Le`Up^LenclUmGL�p^DGÂ�LYPÌRTSULxLe`UptLenolUmGL±��_IJML�deWfpt\ ��m ÙOd�_I`h\bWfDg`kHUpbWYlUmGLxDg`h�¶_UJ^n¦Wf\^DG_I`kW]pÌmG_I`UF�Wfp¥DG\¥DGpTjKDGp^\^Dg`UFIHUDGpbShÊWYlUmGL°�ÜJM_UnRMQP �"O �Ø�õlKHU\c\bSUL�ÐKHUL�p^\^DG_I`À_f�Tq.SUL�\bSULeJO_IJ�`U_h\�W¤FYDGVYLe` �¶_IJZL�deWfp^\�DGp � HUp^Lz��HUm���DGp¦Wkd�_In¦rUmGDGdeWf\^L�j_I`ULY�ÓjKLerKLe`UjKLe`h\oHKr�_I`a\bSUL�FY_UWfmGp._f�Ì\zSUL�HUptLeJT_f�Ì\zSULx��_IJML�deWfp^\�P0� SKW]\.q¥L�deWh`slKLcpbHKJZLo_]�õDGpx\bSKWf\±_I`Ud�LO\bSULDgn¦WfFYL°_f�T\bSUL¦Le`Up^LenclUmGLvJZLen¦WfDg`UpcD[`UjKDGp^\tD[`UFUHUD~pzSKWYlUmGLs��JM_InSMQP �"O ����\zSULe`«\bSULc��_IJML�deWfpt\�DGp�øhù ó�úGó ùzù�PF�EL�\O\bSUL\^DgncLxp^deW]m~L�p���_IJÈ\bSULx_I`Up^L�\T_]�õHUp^L�mGL�p^pb`UL�p^p�WhJML.ptD~FU`UD�¬QdeWh`Y\^mGiaFIJMLeWf\^LeJÈ\bSKWh`¦\bSU_hp^LxpbHUFYFYL�pt\^L�jslYi�p^Dgn¦rUmGL�LeJtJM_IJFIJM_fqT\zS�nc_UjKL�mGpeP.R�SUL�VYLeJMi�Dgn¦rK_UJM\bWY`h\TÐKHUL�p^\^DG_I`«WfpT\^_�SU_Xq m~_U`UF�DGp � \bSUL�VhLeJMiYÊ�mG_I`UF]ÊËJ^WY`UFYLY�,��JMLen¦WfDg`Up±qTDG\bSHUpeP

·ZWZÌï�uJ[��UT ®�÷�� [���É�ïWu±ÁK��÷u�·Ö®¨Á6�xÁKRTïðÉ ÁRTSUL�`UHKncLeJMDGdeWfm�JZL�pbHUmG\^pTjKDGp^deHUp^p^L�j«WYlK_fVYLxq¥LeJMLxlKWfp^L�jk_U`�deWfmGdeHUm[W]\^DG_I`���JM_InÎ\bSKJML�LxmG_fq jKDgncLe`Up^DG_I`KW]m�d�SKW]_Y\^DGdjKiK`KWYncDGdeWfm�p^iUp^\^Len�pe»

� WY�¥RTSULc®�_IJMLe`U �Æ� ¿��Y½Y�Èp^iUp^\^LenV ¡V ^ � ºJÁ�¡�}ªÁ�� � �Y�V �V ^ � ºT¡XW±}ZYX¡°º�� � ½Y�V WV ^ � ¡Q�Oº\[4W � NI�

qTDG\bS¤\bSUL�rKWYJ^WYn�L�\^LeJMpJÁk� � sK�]Y.� ��ǦWY`Uj^[¥� Þ� P� lK�xRTSUL°É�_U_IJMLzÊËÁKrUDGL�FYL�m ��� ¿����Y�¥p^iUp^\^Lenk�£q.SUDGd�S jKL�p^deJMDglKL�pc\bSUL�n�_Y\^DG_I`a_f�ÍWkrKWhJMd�L�mÌ_f�¥DG_I`UDGÂ�L�jÃFIW]pxD[` \bSULWf\bn�_YpbrKSULeJMLx_f�ÌWOp^\bWYJØ»

V ¡V ^ � � � ÒY�V �V ^ � W � �Y�

Page 17: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X �%_V WV ^ � º_Wxº �#^ º`Y¥}aYf¡ w �^�Oº ^ ¡ ��_ �

qTDG\bSarKWYJ^WYncL�\tLeJMp ^ � ���¦WY`Uj^Y±� � s�sKPÇ·x`Uj� de�TR�SUL r��_Yp^p^mGLeJ � Shi¾r�LeJ�Ê�d�SKW]_Yp��¦p^iUp^\^Len¤»

VcbV ^ � º � ¡O}¨�I� � ÇY�V ¡V ^ � b }edI¡O}aW � ¿Y�V �V ^ � [Ç} b � ��� sY�V WV ^ � f4Wxº V � ����� �

qTDG\bS¤\bSUL�rKWYJ^WYn�L�\^LeJMp_dc�¡s X �YÒ��c[T� ½ X s�sK��fÑ�js X sYÒcWY`Uj V �¡s X Ò�sKP

g°çIä�ç¾æ�çeb éfçKâ� P_5OP,[¦P��tPI·xlKWYJ^lKWh`UL�m¶� r PK³¥JM_fq.`��KWY`UjkɨPK³.Pe�±Le`K`UL�m¶P�£ÌWYJMDgWf\tD~_U`�_f�õ®�iIWhrKHK`U_XV�L��KrK_I`ULe`h\^pT_I`kWOp^\zJ^WY`UFYLWf\t\bJ^Wfd�\^_UJ�PQ: ò Ú�p H ÚYÙ ú~ñ Ù ó m ý < � ñ¶ò � � » �%_ ÒAh � ¿Y¿K� � ¿Y¿ � P

�KP0¢QP¼®EPÌ·x`UjKLeJMp^_U`²WY`Uja5OP�ɨPÇVXWY`5jKLe`![x_U_Ym�P²ÁKªYDGmGm�WY`Uj²JML�\zHKJ^`¯_f�xpbªYDGmGm±D[`5jKi¾`KWhncDGd�L��U\^Le`UjKL�jUÊËJ^Wh`UFYL��_IJML�deWfpt\^pePÈü�ÚYÙÓÛ�ÿ ú � ikó m Û�ÿ ó ýji ó � ñ�ó ÝE� � �Y�K»¼Ò�s _ h¾Ò � �K� � ¿Y¿]NQP

½KP r PY³ÈLe`UÂ�DQWY`Uj � P�CTP$��WYJ^`UL�VXW]m~LYP�·µrK_hp^p^DglUmGL.ncLeWfpbHKJZLÑ_]�Qm~_UdeWfmQrKJML�jKDGd�\bWhlUD~mGDG\MiYP�: ò�k Û � Úfù ò�< � ñ�ò �fN6�K»�½YÒY¿hÒlh½YÒh¿�ÇK� � ¿�ÇY¿�P

NQPJ�cP�³ÈL�VYLe`«WY`Uj«·cP�³ÌDg`UmGL�iYPcRTSULO�ÜHU\bHKJZLo_]�ÌjKD~pt\bJMDglKHU\^L�jÃnc_UjKL�mGpe»±É«_IjKL�mEdeWfmGDglKJ^Wf\tD~_U`�Wh`Uj HK`Ud�LeJZ\bWfDg`Y\MirKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`�P�m�+lYýMÚ ú Ú \Uñ ��m ú �ÑýMÚ � ó ùzù ó ù����K� � ¿Y¿h�KPÒKP0[¦P�Á�PT³¥JM_U_In¦SULeW]j�� r P.��`UjKDgªÓ��·cP��xP0u�L�qÑL�mGm��cWY`Ujt[¦P¥·oP r WY`Uj�Pî®�_UdeWfmoW]jQWYrU\^DGVYL � WfmGLeJ^ªhDg` lKW]p^L�pePH ÚYÙ úGñ Ù ó m ý ñ Û��f�UN � �Y�Ø» � ÒY¿lh � ¿ _ � � ¿Y¿ � P

�KP0[¦P�Á�PȳÑJZ_I_In°SULeWfj�� r P/¢Y_I`UL�pe�¥WY`Uj � P/�±Dg`UFQPµR£_Ir�_YmG_YFYDGdeWfmTjKDgncLe`Up^DG_I` WY`Uj¨mG_UdeWfm±d�_I_IJZjKD[`KW]\^L�pc��JM_In\^DgncLzÊ�ptLeJMDGL�pxjQWf\bWKPn: ò �Ìÿ���ù òJk �Q��s � ¿Y��»¼®sÒ��Y½oh°®¯Ò��Y¿�� � ¿�Ç _ P

_ P r P+[x_ULeJ^`ULeJ��f³±PA5 �HKlUDg`UFYLeJ����BPØÉ WhJM\^DGLe`Up^Le`��YÁ�P � JM_Yptpbn¦WY`K`��eWh`UjoÁ�PfRTSU_In¦WfLYP6ZÌJML�jKDGd�\bWhlUD~mGDG\Mi¦rK_IJM\zJ^WfDG\^p��_IJ¥d�SKWf_Y\^DGd�nc_h\^DG_I`UpeP�pEÿ m Úfù�� < Ú úGñ Û�ÚYÙKù m Ù*lrq�ý m�� Û m ú ù�� � »�ÒYÒY½Ah¾Ò _9� � � ¿Y¿ � P

ÇKP0¢QP4ZÇP�ïEd�ªIn°WY`K`��­Á�P�÷cP4�xWYn¦rKSU_UJMp^\e�9[¦P r HUL�mGmGLY�EWY`Uj�Á�P��¥DGmGD[l�LeJM\^_QPO®�DgWYrKHK`U_fV�L��KrK_U`ULe`Y\^p���JM_In?\^DgncLzÊp^LeJZD~L�p�PJ�Èÿ���ù ò i ó � òJk �K½fN � �h��»�NI¿ _�� hINI¿ _ ¿K� � ¿�Ç��KP

¿KP0¢QP Ê�Z�PYïðd�ªUn¦WY`K`OWY`Uj)[¦P r HUL�mGmGLYP­ïÈJMFY_UjKDGdÑ\zSUL�_IJMix_f�Qd�SKWf_YpEWY`Uj�pt\bJ^WY`UFYL¥Wf\^\bJtWfd�\^_IJMp�P�i ó � ñ�ó ÝÇù¥Ú�p¥ü�Ú�l ó ýzÙ�Èÿ���ù ñ � ù��KÒ _ »�� ��_ h �YÒ���� � ¿�ÇYÒKP

� s�PÌɨPYïÌSKJZLe`UjK_IJ���LeJ�P­R�SUL.®�DG_IHUVUD~mGmGL�L�ÐKHKWf\^DG_I`°WY`Uj¦DG\^pÑr�_Y\^Le`h\^DgWfm­HUptLz�ÜHUmg`UL�p^pÈ��_IJÇ\bSUL.rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`°_f�Ó�¶_IJZL�deWfp^\pbªhDGmGm¶P±ü«ÚYÙQÛ�ÿ ú � ikó m Û�ÿ ó ý�i ó � ñ2ó ÝE� � �Y�K» _9� NGh _ ��Ç�� � ¿Y¿fNQP

��� PÑï�P�Á�PQïÌrUpt\^L�Dg`�PÑÁU\^_Ud�SKWfp^\^DGdxjKiK`KWYncDGdorKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`�PMv ó�ú2ú øhù��U� �I� �h��» _ ½Y¿Ah _ Òf¿K� � ¿��h¿KP� ��P r PG5�_f��n¦WY`xWY`Uj¦ïTPk�xWfmg`KWeiYPY®£WfFYFYL�jcWeVhLeJ^WfFYLÇ��_IJML�deWfpt\^Dg`UFQ�XWh`�WfmG\^LeJ^`KW]\^DGVYLÌ\^_�É�_U`Y\^L0�TWYJMmG_¥��_IJML�deW]p^\^Dg`UFQP

v ó�ú2ú øhù��K½YÒf·c» � s�slh ��� Ç�� � ¿�ÇY½KP� ½�PW�ÕP9¢IWh`Up^Le`kWY`Uj��OP*�xJMDGL�FYL�m�PÑÁU_UncL�rKJM_IlUmGLencp±_f��\bSUL�rKWhJ^WYncL�\^LeJÈL�p^\tD[n°Wf\^DG_I`�_f�Ep^\bJ^Wh`UFYLÖW]\bJ^Wfd�\^_UJMpeP���`

�ÕP�ïÌl�L�mGD[`UF�WY`Uj«É¨P4ZÇL�p^d�SUL�m���L�jKDG\^_IJMp��/��ÚYÛ�s m �AtQÚ ú Û ó ýbý m � k þhþ­ýMÚ m�� ÿ�Û�Ú`pÈÚeÚzþ ó ý m Û ñ ÚYÙ m Ù*l`pÈÚ � þ ó Û ñ Û ñ ÚYÙñ Ù¿�P�fÙ m �oñ � < �eù�Û ó%� ù��IrKWfFhL�p ��� NGh � �Y�K�U³ÌLeJZm~Dg`�� � ¿�ÇYÒKPY·xªeW]jKLencDGLzÊ £ELeJMmgWfFQP

� NÓP � P*�±Dg`UFQ� r P*¢Y_U`UL�pe�QWY`Uj¿[¦P�Á�PK³ÑJZ_I_In°SULeWfj�P�ZÈSKWfp^L�r�_IJM\bJ^W]D~\tp¥�ÜJZ_InîWc\^DgncLOp^LeJMDGL�pe»ÌW°p^Dg`UFIHUmgWYJ�p^iUp^\^LenWYrKrKJZ_IWfd�S�P H ø � úGó m ýS�Ìÿ6�eù ñ � ù�� yc�ÑýMÚ � òJ< ø�þhþ úgò ~Y�K�K»�½ _ ¿�� � ¿�Ç _ P

� Ò�P��xPfïTP�®�L�DG\bS�PQRTSUL�_IJZL�\^DGdeWfmYpbªhDGm~mK_]�QÉ�_U`Y\^LW��WYJMmG_T��_IJML�deW]p^\^pePUü«ÚYÙQÛ�ÿ ú � ikó m Û�ÿ ó ýni ó � ñ�ó ÝE� � sY� � �Y��»�N�sh¿lhIN � ÇK�[xL�d�LenclKLeJ � ¿ _ NQP

� ��PÑï�P$uOPX® _IJMLe`UÂYPU·T\bnc_hpbrKSULeJMDGdTrKJML�jKDGd�\bWYlUDGmGD~\Mi¦WfpEJML�VYLeWfmGL�j¦lhi�`KWf\bHKJ^WfmGmGi�_Ud�deHKJ^JMDg`UF�WY`KW]m~_hFIHUL�peP6: ò�k Û � Úfù ò< � ñ�ò �Q���K»��Y½��Ah �fN��K� � ¿��Y¿KP

�%_ PÑï�P�u�PÓ®�_IJMLe`UÂYP/[xL�\tLeJ^ncDg`UDGp^\^DGd¦`U_I`KrKLeJMDG_UjKDGd�©Q_fq�P;: òJk Û � Úfù ò < � ñ¶ò �K��sK» � ½�slh � N � � � ¿��Y½�P� Ç�PW[¦P�CTP£É«d%�TW���JML�iY�EÁ�P�ïðm~mg`ULeJ��È·cP r P � WfmGmgWY`h\e�ÌWY`Uj¬[¦P,�ÕP4u�iId�SKªeWKP�ïðp^\^Dgn¦Wf\tD[`UF«\bSULk®�iIWhrKHK`U_XVÀL��¾r�_fÊ

`ULe`h\¦_f�.Wad�SKW]_Y\^DGd�ptiIp^\tLen q�D~\zSÃ`U_I`KrKWhJ^WYncL�\bJZD~dkJML�FIJZL�p^p^DG_I`�Pu: òQk�có ý ñ ��m Ù < Û m Û ñ ù�Û ñ �1m ú�k ùzù�Ú � ñ m Û ñ ÚYÙQ�Ç _Ó� N � ¿Y�Ø»���ÇY�lh9�Y¿fÒK�YÁULerU\^LenclKLeJ � ¿Y¿Y��P� ¿�PW[¦PS�ÕPTÉ«_U_IJML¨WY`UjBï�PT· ÁKrUDGL�FYL�m�P · \bSULeJtn¦WfmGmGi L��Ud�DG\^L�j `U_I`UmGDg`ULeWYJ«_Yp^d�DGmGmgWf\^_IJØP k ù�Û�ýMÚzþQÿ���ù ò : ò �

� NU½ � ½Y��»kÇ _9� h Ç�Ç _ � � ¿����KP��s�PÌ·cPX5OPKÉ�HKJ^rKSYiYPh� SKW]\TDGp.W � FY_U_Uj9�c�¶_UJML�deWfp^\1Û ikó m Û�ÿ ó ý m Ù*lrq�ÚYý ó ��m ù�Û ñ Ù \ ��ÇK»���Ç � h¾�Y¿h½K� � ¿h¿Y½KP

Page 18: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � Ç

� � PW¢QPðÉ PÇÉ�HKJ^rKShiYP�RTSULkDgn¦rKWfd�\¦_]�.Le`Up^LenclUmGLk��_IJML�deWfp^\tp�_I`¨rKJML�jKDGd�\bWhlUD~mGDG\MiYPwv ò : ò i ò ü ó Û ó ÚYýMÚ úgò;< Ú � ò ���� NQ»�N��Y½AhINI¿Y½K� � ¿�Ç�ÇKP�Y��PW¢QP É PeuTL�p^LYPnxxHKWY`Y\tD���iUD[`UF�mG_IdeW]mõrKJML�jKDGd�\bWhlUD~mGDG\MisDg`srKSKW]p^L�pbrKW]d�LYP0�Ìÿ���ù ñ ��m �x�­½hÒK»��Y½ _ h¾�YÒ�sK� � ¿�ÇY¿KP�Y½�PW¢QP¼Á�PCu�DGd�_YmGD~p�� � PÓÉ«L�iYLeJ�Ê��xJML�ptpe�QWY`Uj � P]5.WYHKlUp�P�u�_I`hÊÍHK`UD¼��_IJ^n d�SKWf_Y\^DGd�jKiK`KWYncDGd�pxqTDG\bS¤Dgn¦rUmGD~deW]\^DG_I`Up

\^_°D[`h��_IJ^n°Wf\^DG_I`krKJM_Ud�L�p^p^Dg`UFQPzy óeñ Û�ù � ÿIý ñ p�Û9p*{øUý H m Û�øIý p�ÚYý^ù � ÿUøIÙ \ �Q½�Ç°WK» ��� Ò _ h ��� �h¿K� � ¿�ÇY½KP�fNÓPW£cP��^P�÷±p^L�mGL�jKL�dYPI·¯É�HUmG\^DgrUm~DGdeWf\tD~VhL.ïÌJMFh_IjKDGdÑR�SUL�_IJMLenkP�®UÔ^WYrKHK`U_fVxd�SKWhJ^Wfd�\^LeJMDGp^\tD~dÌ`UHKnclKLeJMp£��_IJÓjKi¾`KWYn�D~deW]m

p^iUp^\^Len�peP)v�ý m ÙKù ò ü«Úfù � Ú�Ý5ü m Û�ÿ ò2< Ú � ò � � ¿K» � ¿ _ h¾�Y½ � � � ¿���ÇKP�YÒ�PÑRxPeu�P*ZEW]m[n�LeJ�PÌïÌ`UptLenolUmGLcrKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`�PTü ó Û ó ÚYýMÚ ú Ú \Uñ ��m ú � � Ò�ÇY��»�Òlh � ÒK��¢UHK`UL � ¿Y¿h�KP����PÑRxP4uOP?ZEW]m[n�LeJ�� r P�³¥HUDGÂ�ÂeWK�ÇCTP�É«_YmG\^Le`UD��4�cP Ê��U�TSULe`��EWY`Uj�Á�P?�Í_IJM\^D�PcÁUD[`UFUHUm[WhJ�VhL�d�\^_IJMp�WY`Uj«\bSUL�rKJMLzÊ

jKDGd�\bWYlUDGmGDG\Mi�_]��q¥LeWf\bSULeJTWY`Ujkd�mGDgn¦Wf\tLYPJ�Èÿ ñ2úgò v�ý m Ù�ù ò i ò�< Ú � ò ��ÚYÙ*l ò �U·B½]N�Ç ��� ��Ç�ÇY��»�NUÒY¿lhYN _ ÒK� � ¿Y¿]NQP� _ PÑRxPku�P9ZEWfmgncLeJ�PÈïE�U\^Le`UjKL�jUÊËJ^WY`UFYL�W]\bnc_YpbrKSULeJZD~d�rKJZL�jKD~d�\tD~_U`�Wh`Ujk\bSULxmG_IJMLe`UÂon�_IjKL�m�P&�Tø ú2úGó Û ñ Ù kA�oó ý ñ ��m Ùü ó Û ó ÚYýMÚ ú Ú \Iñ ��m ú]< Ú � ñ2ó Û��f� _ NQ»�NI¿lh9�YÒK� � ¿Y¿Y½KP��Ç�P�ZÇP r LeW]j��QɨP9¢QPÓ³ÌL�mGm��e[¦P9�ÕP9¢Y_ISK`Up^_U`��QWY`Uj r PKɨPQÁKn¦WfmGm�P|xxHKW]p^D¼ÊËrKLeJMDG_UjKD~d�WY`Ujsd�SKWf_Y\^DGd±©Q_fq JML�FhD[n�L�p

Dg`sW�\bSULeJ^n¦WfmGmGikjQJMDGVYLe`���JM_Y\bW]\^Dg`UF�©­HUDGj�WY`K`UHUmgHUpeP_: ò q ú ø ñ l°ü ó � ÿ ò �K�Y½�ÇK»�Òh¿Y¿lh �Y½h�K� � ¿Y¿Y��P�Y¿�PÑ÷cP�ï�P r��_Yptp^mGLeJ�PÌ·x`�L�ÐKHKWf\^DG_I`���_IJ¥Shi¾r�LeJMd�SKW]_YpeP0�Èÿ���ù ñ � ù� ó Û�Û ó ý^ù k � _��I� �K��½h��» � ÒYÒAh � Ò _ �f·xrKJMDGm � ¿ _ ¿�P½�s�PÑ®EP�·cP�ÁKncDG\bS�Pc��jKLe`h\^D¼¬QdeWf\^DG_I`¯WY`Uj�rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`À_f�ÌmG_XqÍÊ�jKD[n�Le`Up^DG_I`KWfm¥jKi¾`KWhncDGd�pePM�Èÿ���ù ñ ��m �Ö��Ò�Ç�»�Ò�slh _ �K�

� ¿h¿Y�KP½ � PÑ®EPÓ·cP¾ÁKn�D~\zS�PÑ®�_UdeWfm�_UrU\^Dgn¦Wfm�rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`�P��Ìÿ ñ2úgò v�ý m ÙKù ò i ò2< Ú � ò � ÚhÙ*l ò �U· ½fN�ÇK»�½ _9� h¾½�Ç � � � ¿Y¿fNIWKP½Y��PÑ®EP�·cP�ÁKncDG\bS�PI£.DGpbHKW]m~DGp^Dg`UFÃrKJZL�jKD~d�\zWYlUDGm~DG\Mi�qTDG\bSad�SKWf_Y\^DGd¦Le`UptLenolUmGL�pePc��` CTP�RxP�®�HKªQ��L�jKDG\^_UJ�� k l�� m Ù � ó l

<�ñ�\ Ù m ú �¥ýËÚ � ó ùbù ñ Ù \~} kxú \ ÚYý ñ Û�ÿ � ù1� k ý � ÿ ñ Û ó � Û�øIý ó ù m ÙelIÚ � þ úGó%�có ÙÓÛ m Û ñ ÚhÙKù��fVY_YmgHKncL.�Y�h¿��K�frKWfFYL�pÑ�h¿Y½lh¾½�s]NQ�Á9ZÈ��ïTP�³ÈL�mGm~Dg`UFISKWhnk���«·o� � ¿Y¿]NIl�P

½Y½�PÑ®EP ·oPEÁKncDG\bS�P¯ïÌ`Up^LenclUmGLsrKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`Up�WY`Uj¨d�SKWf_Y\tD~d�p^iUp^\^Lencp�P���`¨�^P�÷cPÇÉ�HUDgJMd�SULeWhJM\bWfDGFIS��EL�jKDG\^_UJ��0�ÑýMÚ+�� óbó l ñ Ù \ ù�Ú�p¦Û�ÿ ó�� Ä�� ÚbÙQÛ ó ýbÙ m Û ñ ÚYÙ m ú ü ózó Û ñ Ù \ ÚYÙ < Û m Û ñ ù�Û ñ ��m ú p úGñü� m Û�Ú ú Ú \ �f��rKWfFYL�p�ÒY¿Y¿Ah ��sY�K�e�.`UDGVYLeJMptD~\Mi�¥_hm~mGL�FYLYP � W]m~qTW�iY�K��JML�mgWY`Uj�� � ¿Y¿hÒKP

½fNÓPÑ®EP ·oPUÁKncDG\bS�Wh`Ujv�tP � DGmgnc_IJZLYP�÷x`c©QL�L�\^Dg`UFcpbSKWfjK_fqTp��f_IrU\^Dgn¦WfmÓLe`Up^LenclUm~L�p±WY`Uj�nc_UjKL�m­JMLeW]m~DGpbn¤P k ÙQÙ m úGó ùn ó ÚzþQÿ���ù ñ ��m ó � � NQ� � ¿Y¿��KP½YÒ�PÑ®EP ·oPÇÁKncDG\bS��/�xP���DGLeSKn¦WY`K`hÊËÁUd�SUmgHKnol�_ISKnk�¥WY`Uj �cP�C�J^WfL�jQJMDGd�S�PvR�SUL¦mGD[n�D~\tpo_]�ÍrKJML�jKDGd�\^DGmGDG\Ëi�»�R�SUL¦jKLzÊdeJMLeW]p^L�_f�EHK`Ud�LeJM\bWfDg`h\ËisWh`UjsJML�\bHKJ^`�_f�EpbªhDGm~mÇDg`k\bSUL�® _IJMLe`UÂoÁUiUp^\^Len¤PÇþ­ý ó þ­ý ñ ÙQÛ�� � ¿Y¿���P

½���P r PK®EPUÁKncDG\bS�P�ïEpt\^Dgn¦Wf\^Dg`UFcjKDgncLe`Up^DG_I`�Dg`�`U_hD~ptiod�SKWf_Y\tD~d±\^DgncLTptLeJMDGL�pePQ: ò i ò�< Û m Û ñ ù�Û ò]< Ú � ò �T�YÒfN � �Y��»�½Y�h¿lh½YÒh�K� � ¿Y¿Y�KP

½ _ PÑ÷cP�R�W]m[W]FIJ^WY`Uj«WY`UjzZÇP*�¥_UHKJM\^DGLeJ�P0£ÌWYJMDgWf\tD~_U`KWfm�Wfp^ptD[n�D~mgWf\tD~_U`«_f�ÌncL�\^L�_IJM_hm~_hFYDGdeWfm�_IlUp^LeJZVXWf\^DG_I`Up±qTDG\bS¤\bSULWfjfÔM_YDg`h\TVY_IJM\tD~d�DG\Mi�L�оHKWf\tD~_U`�»�ZEWYJZ\Í�t»QRTSUL�_IJZiYP�v ò : ò i ò ü ó Û ò < Ú � ò � ��� ½�» � ½ ��� h � ½Y��Ç�� � ¿�Ç _ P½�Ç�P�ZÇP�[¦PÑRTSU_Un¦rUp^_I`�P±�.`Ud�LeJM\zWfDg`Y\Mi¨_f��Dg`UDG\^DgWfmxp^\bW]\^L�WfpkWa��Wfd�\^_IJ°Dg`´\bSUL�rKJML�jKDGd�\bWhlUD~mGDG\Mi _f��mgWYJMFhLzÊ�p^deWfmGLWf\znc_YpbrKSULeJMDGd|©Q_Xq¸rKWf\^\^LeJ^`Up�PPv ó�ú2ú øhù��U¿K»�� _ Òlh¾�Y¿YÒ�� � ¿YÒ _ P

½Y¿�P|5OPYR�_U`UFÖWY`Uj r PfÉ«_ULeWY`KWfjKjKDg`�PQ÷x`cncHUmG\^D¼Ê�p^\^Ler¦`U_I`hÊ�mGDg`ULeWYJðm~LeW]p^\Ep^ÐKHKWYJML�pErKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I`�P�võÿ ó_< Û m Û ñ ù�Û ñ � ñ m ÙQ�½ _ » � s � h ��� sK� � ¿�Ç�ÇKPN�s�P|�EPfR£_Y\bScWY`Ujoï�P$�xW]m[`KW�iYPQïÈ`Up^LenclUmGLÌ��_IJML�deW]p^\^Dg`UFÖW]\·u�Éo�xP]�Íø ú�ú~ó Û ñ Ù k�có ý ñ ��m Ùcü ó Û ó ÚYýMÚ ú Ú \Iñ ��m úG< Ú � ñ�ó Û��f�_ N ��� �Y��»¼�Y½ �%_ hK�Y½f½�sK� � ¿Y¿h½KPN � P|�EP�R£_Y\bSaWY`Uj�ïTP��xWfmg`KW�iYPoïÈ`Up^LenclUm~LO��_IJML�deWfpt\^Dg`UFsWf\Pu�Éo�ÕWY`Uj«\bSULolKJZL�L�jKD[`UF�ncL�\zSU_Ij�P � ¿Y¿hÒKPuTÉo�

÷�×�d�LFuT_h\^LxN�s _ �U·xrKJMDGm _ � � ¿Y¿YÒKPNI��PÌɨP�Á�PÌRÇJ^Wfd�\t_I`ÃWh`Uj²ïTP��xWfmg`KW�iYP²÷xr�LeJ^Wf\^DG_I`KWfm�Le`Up^LenclUm~L«rKJML�jKDGd�\^DG_I` Wf\c\bSULs`KWf\^DG_I`KW]m.ncL�\^L�_IJZ_YmG_YFYDGdeWfm

d�Le`h\^LeJ�»WZÈJ^Wfd�\^DGdeWfmÇWfpbrKL�d�\tpeP ikó m Û�ÿ ó ý m Ù*lrq�ÚYý ó ��m ù�Û ñ Ù \ �6ÇK»�½ _ ¿Ah¾½Y¿�ÇK� � ¿Y¿Y½KPNI½�P|5OPUÉ PhVXWY`�jKLe`x[x_U_Ym�P�ÁULeWhJMd�SUDg`UFO��_IJ¥WY`KWfmG_YFIHUL�pe�KSU_fq²mG_I`UF�noHUpt\Ìq¥L.qTWfDG\1ÛUv ó�ú2ú øhù��hN��x· � ½Y�Ø»�½ � NGhK½Y�fNQ�

� ¿h¿fNQPNYNÓPÌ·cP/��L�DGFYLe`Uj WY`Uj�u�P � LeJMpbSULe`h��L�m~j��¥L�jKDG\^_UJMpeP!�¥ý ó l ñ � Û ñ Ù \ Û�ÿ ó q�øUÛ�øIý ó m Ù*l���Ùel ó ýtù�Û m Ù*l ñ Ù \ Û�ÿ ó � m ù�Û }

k pÌÚ � þ m ý ñ ù�ÚYÙ«Ú�p k þhþ­ýMÚ m�� ÿ ó ù��QVh_YmgHKncL�TS£Õ_f� < q/Ú < Û�ø6l ñ2ó ù ñ ÙupÌÚ � þ úGó4�fñ Û��fPÈ·.jKjKDGp^_I`hÊ �ÀL�p^mGL�iY�?u�L�q�E_IJtªQ� � ¿Y¿Y½KP

NIÒ�PÌ·cP*�À_Ym¼�Z�e¢QP�ÁUqTD¼�¶\e�J5OP­®EP�ÁUqTDg`K`UL�iY��WY`Uj¿¢QPQ·cPe£ÌWfpbJ^WY`U_ÓPW[xL�\^LeJtncDg`UD[`UFs® iIWYrKHK`U_fVkL��¾r�_I`ULe`h\^p±�ÜJZ_InîW\^DgncLOp^LeJMDGL�peP0�Èÿ���ù ñ ��m � � �I[¦»���ÇhÒK� � ¿�ÇYÒKPN���P��xP���DGLeSKn¦WY`K`hÊËÁUd�SUmgHKnol�_ISKnkP0tQÚhý^ÿ ó ý^ù m \Uó ù�Û�ø�l ñ�ó Ù ñ Ù � ÿ m ÚYÛ ñ ù � ÿ ó Ù < �eù�Û ó%�có Ù�øUÙ*l ñ Ù¤l ó ýJ�¥ý m �Xñ ù�P�ZÌS6[\bSUL�ptD~p��¥C­JML�DGLo�.`UDGVYLeJZp^DG\ �Wf\�³ÈLeJMmGDg`�P¥É«L�\^L�_IJM_YmG_YFhD~ptd�SULk·xlKSKWY`UjKmgHK`UFYLe`�P�u�LeHULsCÓ_YmGFYLsÁULeJMDGL«·oPȳÑWh`Uj Ç5�Lz�¶\±½K� � ¿Y¿]NQP

N _ P��xP6��DGLeSKn¦Wh`K`hÊËÁUd�SUmgHKnclK_ISKn¤�4�cPIC�J^WfL�jQJMDGd�S��KWY`Ujs®EP�·cPKÁKncDG\bS�PEïEDg`�Dg`Y\^LeJt`UL�pTVY_IJ^SULeJZpbWfFIlKWYJtªfL�DG\^p^L��KrKLeJ�ÊDgncLe`h\.Dgn ®�_IJMLe`UÂzÊËn�_IjKL�mGm�P±ü ó Û ó ÚYýMÚ ú Ú \Iñ Úfù � ÿ ó iTøUÙ*lfù � ÿ m ø�� H|ò q ò �INÓ» � �lh¾� � � � ¿Y¿YÒ�P

Page 19: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � ¿

CEDGFIHKJML � P£·Ö`O_IrU\^Dgn¦W]mY��_IJML�deWfpt\�_f�Q\zSULÑL�Vh_YmgHU\^DG_I`O_f�­W.r�LeJ���L�d�\ELe`Up^LenclUm~L�_f�QDg`UD~\tD[W]mQd�_I`UjKDG\^DG_I`UpÈ_I`x\bSULT®�_UJMLe`UÂWf\^\zJ^Wfd�\^_IJ¥WY`UjaDg`UjKD~pt\^Dg`UFIHUDGpbSKWYlUmgLkHK`UjKLeJ.Wh`�Ç�ÊËlUDG\±_IlUp^LeJMVfWf\^DG_I`�PTïÌW]d�SaSU_IJMDGÂ�_I`h\bWfm�deHKJMVhLoJMLz©QL�d�\^p�M � ¡Q��Wf\.W\^DgncL ^ �K\bSULOmGLz�¶\±d�_YmgHKn¦`���_IJ¥\tD[n�L�pPs ³ ^ ³ ���K\bSUL�JMDGFISh\¥��_IJJ�M³ ^ ³ � ��PÌRTSUL�ptdeWfmGLx��_IJ_M´DGp.FYDGVYLe`�ÔZHUpt\T\^_\bSUL�JMDGFISh\T_f�E\bSULxmGLz��\.d�_YmgHKn¦`�P

Page 20: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X ��s

CEDGFIHKJML.��P�· p^LeJMDGL�pÌ_f��_IrU\tD[n°WfmQLe`Up^LenclUmGL��¶_IJZL�deWfp^\^pð�¶_IJÇ\zSULTÉ«_I_IJZLzÊËÁKrUD~L�FhL�m­ptiIp^\tLenkPEïÌWfd�S¦SU_IJMDGÂ�_I`h\bWfmKdeHKJZVYLJMLz©QL�d�\^p0M � ¡Q�±Wf\oW�\tD[n�L ^ �Ç\bSUL¦mGLz��\�d�_YmgHKn¦` ��_IJ±\^DgncL�p�s;³ ^ ³U�K��\bSUL�JMDGFISY\±��_IJI��³ ^ ³ � �KP¦RTSUL°FIWYrUpDg`UjKDGdeWf\^L�\bSKWf\�\zSUL¦\bJ^HUL¦\zJ^WfÔML�d�\^_IJMisSKW]polKL�Le`À_IlUp^LeJZVYL�j���WY`Uj¯W���JML�pbS�r�LeJ��¶L�d�\OLe`Up^LenclUmGLvSKWfpclKL�Le`Àd�SU_hp^Le`WYl�_IHU\x\bSUL¦`UL�qÕ_IlUp^LeJMVhL�j�p^\bWf\tLYPÖ÷xlUptLeJMVXWf\tD~_U`UpoWYJML¦n¦W]jKLoL�VhLeJMi���\^DgncLcp^\tLerUpePoR�SULoptdeWfmGLc�¶_UJ�M DGpOFYDGVYLe`Ô^HUp^\T\^_c\bSULcJMDGFISY\�_f��\bSULOm~Lz��\Td�_YmgHKn¦`�P

Page 21: people.maths.ox.ac.uk · G Z~B-OqT:B-DLKN^pQ^-_ KqHt:GI[ _cG M D H ^/d:G OyS D@E:[\^pT/gpE DFE/G Kq[ BWr/KNONKyD\]&DL^SFE:B-d:^- £T:Q/M GI[ DFB-KqQ^pr/SUGI[\Z~B-DUKy^/Q/S KNS

798;:=<?>A@CB/DeEFD4G�E)HJHJKML�NM<6EO�:�B4:=<�Q�EN�RUT�VJVSKJVYX%X%X � �

CEDGFIHKJML�½KPð·.p¥Dg`kCEDGFIHKJML����¾lKHU\�\bSUDGp.\^DgncLx\zSULxp^iIpt\^LenÎD~p±L�VY_YmGVYL�j���_IJ¥WY`�L��U\^Le`UjKL�js\tD[n�L�lKL�\Mq¥L�Le`�_IlUp^LeJMVfW�Ê\^DG_I`UpeP