Upload
goni56509
View
223
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
1/50
Edith Cowan University
Copyright Warning
You may print or download ONE copy of this document for the purpose
of your own research or study.
The University does not authorize you to copy, communicate orotherwise make available electronically to any other person any
copyright material contained on this site.
You are reminded of the following:
Copyright owners are entitled to take legal action against personswho infringe their copyright.
A reproduction of material that is protected by copyright may be acopyright infringement.
A court may impose penalties and award damages in relation tooffences and infringements relating to copyright material. Higher
penalties may apply, and higher damages may be awarded, for
offences and infringements involving the conversion of material
into digital or electronic form.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
2/50
TheImprovisationofStructuredKeyboard
Accompaniments
for
the
Ballet
Class
SimonFrosi
WesternAustralianAcademyofPerformingArts
EdithCowanUniversity
ThisdissertationissubmittedforthedegreeofBachelorofMusicHonours
2011
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
3/50
ii
DECLARATION
Icertify
that
this
thesis
does
not,
to
the
best
of
my
knowledge
and
belief:
(i) incorporatewithoutacknowledgmentanymaterialpreviouslysubmittedforadegreeordiplomainanyinstitutionofhigherdegreeordiplomainanyinstitutionof
highereducation;
(ii) containanymaterialpreviouslypublishedorwrittenbyanotherpersonexceptwhereduereferenceismadeinthetextofthisthesis;
(iii)containanydefamatorymaterial;(iv)containanydatathathasnotbeencollectedinamannerconsistentwithethics
approval.
ThiscopyisthepropertyofEdithCowanUniversity. However,theliteraryrightsofthe
authormustalsoberespected. Ifanypassagefromthisthesisisquotedorclosely
paraphrasedinapaperorwrittenworkpreparedbytheuser,thesourceofthepassage
mustbeacknowledgedinthework. Iftheuserdesirestopublishapaperorwrittenwork
containingpassagescopiedorcloselyparaphrasedfromthisthesis,whichpassageswouldin
totalconstituteaninfringingcopyforthepurposeoftheCopyrightAct,heorshemustfirst
obtainthewrittenpermissionoftheauthortodoso.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
4/50
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Iwishtothankmysupervisor,DrJonathanPaget,forallofhishardworkandtimeasmy
supervisorthis
year.
His
huge
wealth
of
knowledge
is
just
amazing.
Iwould
also
like
to
thankMichaelBrettforhisassistanceandforallowingmetoanalysesomeofhis
transcriptions,andobservinghisclasses.IwouldliketothankStewartSmithforsupervising
methroughoutthefirstsemesterandhelpingmecomeupwithideasformythesis.Iam
privilegedtohavebeensupportedandsupervisedsuchagreatartistashimself.Also,thanks
tomymumaswellasteachersAnnaSleptsovaandPeterTanfieldfortheircontinued
supportandcarethroughmyfinalyearofstudiesatWAAPA.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
5/50
iv
ABSTRACT
Thisdissertationexploresthequestionofhowapianistcanlearntoimprovise
accompanimentsfor
aballet
class.
It
aims
to
examine
the
background
knowledge
required
inordertoembarkuponsuchataskandtoprovideatheoreticaltoolkitforpianiststouse
inimprovising. Additionally,thisdissertationmakesadetailedcasestudyofnotated
improvisationsbyMichaelBrett,anexpertexponentofthisgenre.Athematiccatalogueis
providedofBrettsimprovisationsforaforthcomingpublication,examiningaccompaniment
figurationsandrhythmicstructures.Amoredetailedharmonicandphraseanalysisisthen
madeofthreecompletepieces,examiningthecadentialandmelodicstructuresthat
underpintheseworks. SimilartotheBaroquepartimentotradition,thesephraselevel
analysescanbeusedastemplates,providingthemiddlegroundscaffoldingforthe
improvisingpianisttoembellish. Theycanalsobetreatedasexemplarsastohowapianist
maystructuretheirownimprovisationstosuitanyparticularballetexercise.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
6/50
v
CONTENTS
DECLARATION.........................................................................................................
II
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.......................................................................................... III
ABSTRACT.............................................................................................................. IV
CONTENTS............................................................................................................... V
I. INTRODUCTION................................................................................................. 1
II. ABACKGROUNDTODANCEACCOMPANIMENT.............................................2
III. REQUIREDGENERALKNOWLEDGE.................................................................61. TheRhythmicBasisofDance........................................................................6
2.
Cadences:Their
Relative
Strength
................................................................
6
3. ConstructingPhrasesandPeriods................................................................7
IV. THEPARTIMENTOTRADITIONANDITSAPPLICABILITYTOSTRUCTURINGIMROVISATIONSFORTHEBALLETCLASS.......................................................................... 10
V. THEANALYSISOFFREEIMPROVISATIONFORTHEBALLETUSINGMICHAELBRETTASANEXEMPLAR................................................................................................... 12
A. MYOBSERVATIONS..............................................................................................12
B. CATALOGUEANDANALYSISOFMICHAELBRETTSSCOREDIMPROVISATIONS
13
1.
BARRE.........................................................................................................
14
PLIES......................................................................................................................14
2. DEMIPOINT................................................................................................18
3. CENTRE.......................................................................................................19
4. ADAGE.........................................................................................................20
1STADAGE............................................................................................................21
5. PIROUETTES................................................................................................23
6. ALLEGRO.....................................................................................................25
7. POINTE........................................................................................................29
C. ANALYTICALDISCUSSION...............................................................................32
1.
AccompanimentPatterns
...........................................................................
32
2. DevelopmentofMotivicIdeas....................................................................33
3. HarmonicTemplatesDerivedfromMichaelBrettsBalletImprovisations33
4. ImprovisingfromaTemplate.....................................................................40
5. StepstoCreatingyourOwnImprovisation.................................................41
VI. CONCLUSION............................................................................................... 41
VII. BIBLIOGRAPHY............................................................................................. 42
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
7/50
1
I. INTRODUCTIONWhenIarrivedatPerththisyear,Iwaspreparingmyselftoplayforsomeballetclassesat
theWestern
Australian
Academy
of
Performing
Arts
and
didn't
realise
what
adaunting
task
itistoplayforclasswithoutselectedmusic.Havingworkedasasessionalpianistplayingfor
examsandworkshopswiththeRoyalAcademyofDanceoverthelastthreeyearsIassumed
itwouldbefairlyeasyasIwasusedtoplayingwithsetmusicthatgavedetaileddirections
onexactlyhowtoplay.Theballetclassrequiresthepianisttounderstanddanceanddance
music,andtoapplythosedetaileddirectionsintothemusicwhentheyplay.Thisiswhere
theideaformythesiscame.HavingdecidedIwouldfocusonimprovisationinrelationto
theballetclass,IdecidedIwoulduseoneofAustralia'sleadingplayersandimprovisersin
thatstyle,MichaelBrett.FromthisIcameupwithsomequestions:
Firstly,whatweretherequirementsofaballetpianist? Howistheaccompanimentforaballetexerciseconstructedinrelationtophrase,
harmonyandcadence?
Howcouldoncereplicatethisinastheirownimprovisation? HowcouldIlearntoimproviseballetexercisesfromobservinganexpertimproviserin
thisstyle?
Ialsobecameinterestedinhistoricalmodelsforimprovisationandcompositionandbegan
toevaluatetheBaroquepartimentotradition,examiningwhatitcouldteachusabouthow
tomouldandscaffoldimprovisationsinatonalstyle.Thetraditionofpartimentowas
developedprominentlyinNaplesthroughoutthe16thand17thcentury.Theideawasthat
thestudentwouldplayoffinstructionalbasslines(calledpartimenti),whichwere
representationsofaharmonicstructure.Studentspracticedrealisingthesebasslinesin
keyboardharmony,andabsorbedmanycompositionallessonsfromclichdmusical
patternsembeddedwithinthem. Ineffect,compositioncomprisedthestringingtogetherof
anumberofstockstandardpatternslearntthroughpracticingthepartimenti.1 Ibecame
intriguedwithwhethersuchawayofpracticingcouldaidmeasadanceaccompanist.
Couldtemplatesbederivedonwhichtoformimprovisationsforadanceclass?
1Aaron
Berkowitz,
The
Improvising
Mind:
Cognition
and
Creativity
in
the
Musical
Moment
(publication
place:OxfordUniversityPress,USA,2010),pagenr
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
8/50
2
II. ABACKGROUNDTODANCEACCOMPANIMENTThissectiondescribeswhattheexpectationsareforadanceaccompanistinaclassroom
setting.The
basic
structure
of
aballet
class
can
be
divided
into
three
sections:
barre,
centre
andallegro.TheteacherinstructstheclassusingFrenchterminologyanddemonstrates
whennecessary.First,thepianistmusthaveanunderstandingofballetterminologyand,by
observingthedanceteachersinstructions,mustplaysomethingfittingtothatparticular
exercise.2
Akeyconceptthatthedanceaccompanimentpianistmustcomprehendisthatof
howdancerscountmusic,andhowthisfitsinwithanideaofmusicalperiodicity,and
particularlytheprevalenceoftheeightbarphrase.ThisiscoveredextensivelyinCavallis
DanceandMusic,3andIexpounditfurtherinthenextchapter.
AnotherkeypublicationoutliningtherequirementsofdanceaccompanistisADance
ClassAnthology,producedbytheworldsleadingballetexaminationcompany,theRoyal
AcademyofDance.Thispublicationoutlinesinanutshellwhatisrequiredoftheclassical
danceaccompanistaswellasprovidingscorestosuitoneortwoclassesworthofmusic.
Someofthemusicincludesadaptedmovementsfromballets,opera,orchestralworks,and
solopianorepertoire. Therefore,itisnotmyintentiontofocusonselectingandadapting
repertoirefor
the
ballet
classas
this
has
already
been
donebut
instead
to
focus
on
techniquesthatcouldbeusedtoimproveapianistsimprovisatoryskills.
Thereisalsoavastamountofliteraturethatgivesclassoutlinesthatinclude
directionsfortherequiredaccompanimentforcertainexercisesbutnotnecessarilyasa
guideforthepianist.OneofthesethatincludemusicalscoredmusicalexamplesisBasic
PrinciplesofClassicalBalletbyAgrippinaVaganova,whichteachesRussianballettechnique.
Asamplelessonwithmusicalaccompanimentcanbefoundinthefinalchapterofthis
book.4Iamnotdiscouragingtheuseofadaptedrepertoire,butmerelysuggestingthatthe
2RoyalAcademyofDancing,ADanceClassAnthology:TheRoyalAcademyofDanceGuidetoBallet
ClassAccompaniment(R.A.D.)(London:RoyalAcademyofDance,2005),218.
3HarrietCavalli,DanceandMusic:AGuidetoDanceAccompanimentforMusiciansandDance
Teachers(Miami:UniversityPressofFlorida,2001).
4AgrippinaVaganova.TranslatedfromtheRussianbyAnatoleChujoy.Incorporatingallthematerial
fromthe4thRussianed.IncludingVaganova'sSamplelessonwithmusicalaccompanimentandtranslatedby
JohnBarker,
Basic
Principles
of
Classical
Ballet:
Russian
Ballet
Technique,
(New
York:
Dover
Publications,
1969),
pagenr.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
9/50
3
danceaccompanistwhoisabletoimprovisewillbeabletoplayaclasswithmuchgreater
ease.
Thejoboftheballetaccompanistisverydemanding,notonlyrequiringtheabilityto
sight
read
difficult
orchestral
reductions,
learn
large
amounts
of
repertoire
(whether
from
balletrepertoryorexaminationsyllabi),butalsotoobservetheinstructionsofthedance
teacher,watchthedancers,andplayintime.Notalldanceaccompanistshavetheabilityto
improvise,butIarguethattheseskillsarehugelybeneficial,ultimatelymakingthejobofthe
danceaccompanistlesstimeconsuming,andabletorespondmoreadequatelytothe
immediatedemandsofthejob.
Someofthebenefitsofbeingabletoimproviseintheballetclassincludethe
following:
First,astheballetclasscangoforupto30exercisesormore,usuallyinthespaceof
oneandahalfhours(dependingontheagegroupand/orlevel).Thepianistmaynotalways
havetimetofindsomethinginthepianistsbooksormemoryintimefortheclasstostart
theirexercise.
Second,whenplayingmemorisedmusic,mentalblankscanbecommon.Beingable
toimproviseandhavingasoundharmonicsenseofapiecewillenablethepianisttoadapt
themusictothedancewithaslittlestressortroubleaspossible
Third,another
advantage
of
being
able
to
improvise
is
the
obvious
fact
that
the
pianistneedstoknowwhatisgoingonandwatchthedancerasmuchaspossible.Playing
fromscoresdivertsyourvisualfocusonthemusicstandandmerelyusingperipheralvision
tofollowthedancer.
Fourth,whilsttheinstructorisdivulginginformationonhowthedancerisgoingto
approachaparticularexercise,thepianistmaygivethemtheirundividedattentionfocusing
theirenergyonhowtheirmusiccansupportwhattheteacheranddanceristryingto
achieveinsteadofspendingtheirpreparationtimesiftingthroughtheirmusic.
TogetanideaofhowaballetclassisrunIhavepresentedIhaveincludedtwo
examplesofaballetclass.Figure1isfromtheADanceClassAnthologyissuedbytheRoyal
AcademyofDancingandFigure2isanexampleofaRussian'SixthYearclassfrom100
LessonsinClassicalBalletwrittenbyVeraS.Kostrovitskaya.Aclassmayberuninmany
differentwaysdependingonthestudentslevel,theteacher,andwhethertheyare
preparingforanexamorperformance.Butmostballetclasseshaveafairlysimilar
structure.Most
exercises
at
the
bar
and
other
diagonal
exercises
are
played
at
least
two
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
10/50
4
timessothedancerhastheopportunitytopresentboththeleftsideandtherightside.On
occasions,theteachermayasksomethingontheleftsidetobeplayedslightlyslowerasitis
generallytheweakersidewhichneedstobeaccommodated.
Another
requirement
of
the
ballet
accompanist
is
to
motivate
and
inspire
the
dancers.BalletmasterandchoreographeroftheBolshoiballet,AsafMesserer,believed
thatmusicalaccompanimentforadvanceddanceclassesshouldalwaysbe'artistically
varied,richinmelody,andinteresting.'5
Figure1.SampleclassoutlinefromADanceClassAnthology6
5AsafMesserer,ClassesinClassicalBallet(NewYork:LimelightEditions,2007),pg.485.
6Royal
Academy
of
Dancing,
A
Dance
Class
Anthology:
The
Royal
Academy
of
Dance
Guide
to
Ballet
ClassAccompaniment(R.A.D.)(London:RoyalAcademyofDance,2005),20.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
11/50
5
Figure2.SampleOutlinefrom100LessonsinClassicalBallet7
EXCERSISESATTHEBARRE
DemiPlis
Exercise
16
Measures
in
4/4
BattementsTendus 32Measuresin2/4
RondsDeJambeATerreandGrandsRondsDe
JambeJetes
12Measuresin4/4
BattementsFondu 16Measuresin2/4
RondsDeJambeEnLair 8Measuresin4/4
PetitsBattementsSurLeCoudepied 16Measuresin2/4
BattementsDevelops 8Measuresin4/4
GrandsBattementsJets 16Measuresin2/4
EXCERSISESINTHECENTER
SmallAdagioandBattementsTendus 4Measuresin4/4
BattementsFondu
8Measures
in
4/4
PetitsBattementsSurLeCoudepied 8Measuresin2/4
GrandBattementsJetsBalancs 8Measuresin4/4
GrandAdagio 12Measuresin4/4
ALLEGRO
SissonnesFermesandEtrechatsquatre 16Measuresin2/4
BallonnsinPosEfface 8Measuresin4/4
BallottesandAssembles (Waltz)16Measuresin3/4
GrandEchappes 8Measuresin2/4
GrandJeteinattitudecroisee (Waltz)16Measuresin3/4
Glissades 4Measuresin4/4
PointeTendu (Waltz)16Measuresin3/4
Coupes 8Measuresin2/4
Emboites 8Measuresin2/4
BrisesDessusDessous 8Measuresin2/4
Petitschangementsdepieds 8Measuresin2/4
EXCERSISESONPOINTE
Echappes 8Measuresin2/4
SissonnesSimples 16Measuresin2/4
GargouilladesenDehors,andPasDeChat (Polka)16Measuresin2/4
Jetes 8Measuresin4/4
ToursSur
Le
Cou
de
pied
(Waltz)
16
Measures
in
3/4
ToursGlissadeenTournant 16Measuresin2/4
ToursenDehorswithDegage 8Measuresin2/4
7Vera
S.
Kostrovitskaya,
100
Lessons
in
Classical
Ballet,
1st
Limelight
ed.
(New
York:
Limelight
Editions,2004),pagenr.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
12/50
6
III. RequiredGeneralKnowledge1. TheRhythmicBasisofDance
Whentalkingdancestepsandrhythm,thedancertendstousedifferentlanguagethanthe
musician.Thedancergenerallyworksincountswhereasthemusicianthinksofbeats,
measures(orbars).Whenconvertingcountsonemustconsiderthetimesignatureandthe
pulse.Forexample;ifapianistwasplayinginathreefourtimesignatureforaGrand
Battementexercise,eachbarwouldbeconsideredacountandthetempocouldbemuch
faster,perhapsadottedminimequals70beatsperminute.IfonewastoplayaBattement
Fonduexerciseinathreefourtempo,eachcrotchetwouldbeconsideredacountandwould
berelatively
equal
in
tempo
to
awhole
bar
of
the
grand
battement
exercise.
Therefore
in
theFonduexerciseyouareplayingonethirdoftheamountofnotesiftheexerciseshares
thesamemusicandcounts.
Asmostdanceteachersarenotfamiliarwithdetailedmusicalanalysisanduse
differentterminology,theytendtoaskforaparticulartypeofdanceasanexamplelikea
slowwaltz,apolka,orarag.Thisfacilitatestheaccompanistwhenplayingfromscored
music,butwhenimprovisingthemusicianmusthaveanawarenessofotherfactors,which
inanycaseshouldalsobeconsideredwhenplayingoffnotatedmusic.Acomprehensive
understandingofhowrhythm,phraseandstructuresworkwillallowthepianisttomake
theirimprovisationseasilyunderstoodandbettersynchronisedwiththedancer(s).
2. Cadences:TheirRelativeStrengthCadenceisthebestwayofdefiningtheendsofphrases,aswellastonality.
8Cadencein
balletcanhelpguidethedancerthroughanexercise.Forthemusicaldancer,itprovides
themwithsubdivisionsofthephrase,whichifplayedcorrectlycanhelpthemwiththeir
ownsenseofphrasinganddirection.
Theimperfectauthenticcadence(IAC)andperfectauthenticcadence(PAC)are
characterizedbyadominantharmonyresolvinginthetonic.IntheUSterminologyIam
adoptinghere9,aperfectauthenticcadencereferstoclosedvoiceleading,withthesoprano
8WilliamS.Rockstro,etal."Cadence."InGroveMusicOnline.OxfordMusicOnline,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/04523(accessedNovember
16,2011).
9RobertGauldin,HarmonicPracticeinTonalMusicWorkbook,SecondEdition,Workbooked.(New
York,London:W.W.Norton&Company,2004),133.SeealsoStevenG.Laitz,TheCompleteMusician:an
IntegratedApproach
to
Tonal
Theory,
Analysis,
and
Listening,
3rd
ed.
(New
York:
Oxford
University
Press,
USA,
2012),121125.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
13/50
7
endingonthetonic,andthechordsbeinginrootposition. Thissoundsmorefinal,and
conclusiveanddesignatesthecloseofamusicalperiod.Theimperfectauthenticcadence
referstoaVIcadencethatdoesnotsatisfytheconditionsofbeingtonallyclosed(as
described
above).
As
such,
the
IAC
designates
the
end
of
a
phrase,
but
not
a
complete
musicalperiod. Thethirdsignificantcadencetypeisthehalfcadence(HC),whichdesignates
anycadenceclosingonchordV(whetherItoV,iitoV,IVtoV,vitoV,andsoon). The
fourthsignificantcadencetypeisthedeceptivecadence(DC),beingwhereadominant
chordsnormalresolutiontotonicisevadedbysubstitutionofthesubmediant.Finally,there
istheplagalcadence,whichappearsasasubstituteforthePACinsomelateRomantic
repertoire.Figure3)summarisesthesecadencetypes,theirabbreviations,andthe
harmoniesandvoiceleadingtheydesignate.
Figure3.Cadencestypes
CadenceType
(USterminology
English
terminology
Progression Voiceleading
Perfectauthentic
cadence(PAC)
Perfectcadence
withclosedvoice
leading
DominanttoTonic Sopranomoveseither7
8or2 1whilethebass
moves5 1
Imperfectauthentic
cadence
(AC)
Perfectcadence
with
open
voice
leading
DominanttoTonic Sopranocloseson5or3
Halfcadence(HC) Imperfectcadence Anythinggoingtothe
Dominant
Deceptivecadence(DC) Interrupted
cadence
Dominantto
Submediant
Plagalcadence Plagalcadence Subdominanttotonic
3. ConstructingPhrasesandPeriodsWhen
assessing
how
many
measures
one
would
play
to
fit
adance
exercise,
it
is
necessary
tofeelthemusicinphrasesandperiods.Itisalsovitaltothedancerthatthemusicisfeltin
phrasesratherthanindividualcounts,asthedancerneedstofeelthedirectionofthemusic
andhaveanaturalflowinordertogiveanorganicperformance.Whendiscussinghow
phrasesaretobedividedandthemusicalimpressiontheygive,itisusefultolabelthemby
theirtechnicalnames.
Ifadanceexerciseisplayedontwosides,thiswouldnormallycomprisetwoperiods,
eachconstructedinturnoftwodistinctphrases,oneanantecedentandoneaconsequent.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
14/50
8
Theantecedentandtheconsequentphrasebothcombinedprovidetonalfulfilment.10
The
antecedentphraseprecedestheconsequentphrase,whichisusuallylefttonallyopen
definedbyacadenceonthedominant(oranimperfectauthenticcadence).Theconsequent
is
tonally
closed,
that
is
having
a
PAC,
therefore
providing
tonal
fulfilment.
11
It
is
also
useful
torecallthattheplagalcadencemaybeemployedtoendaphrase,althoughthisisless
common.12
Therefore,inconstructingadanceimprovisation,anaccompanistmustnormally
choosethefourcadencestobeplayedandtheirrelativestrengths. Possibleoutlinesare
givenbelowinFigure4:
Figure4.Twopossibletonalplans(withcadences)foradanceimprovisation
PeriodOne PeriodTwo
Antecedent Consequent Antecedent Consequent
PlanA EndswithHCintonic,orIACin
tonic
EndswithPACin
tonic
EndswithHCin
tonic,orIACin
tonic
EndswithPACin
tonic
PeriodOne
(Modulatestodominantkey)
PeriodTwo
(modulatesbacktotonic)
Antecedent Consequent Antecedent Consequent
PlanB
Ends
with
HC
in
tonic,orIACin
tonic
Endswith
PAC
on
dominant(or
otherclosely
relatedkey)
Multiple
options...
Endswith
PAC
in
tonic
Understandinghowaperiodisconstructed,andbeingabletoreplicatethisasthe
danceorexercisewarrants,willensuretheharmonicstructureandtosomedegreemelodic
designwillsupportthedancersinasatisfyingway.
Another
consideration
in
constructing
periods
is
motivic
repetition.
It
is
very
commonfortheconsequentphrasetoimitateorrepeatmelodicideasfromtheantecedent
10RobertGauldin,HarmonicPracticeinTonalMusicWorkbook,SecondEdition,Workbooked.(New
York,London:W.W.Norton&Company,2004),page181.
11
11RobertGauldin,HarmonicPracticeinTonalMusicWorkbook,SecondEdition,Workbooked.(New
York,London:W.W.Norton&Company,2004),page181.
12Robert
Gauldin,
Harmonic
Practice
in
Tonal
Music
Workbook,
Second
Edition,
Workbook
ed.
(New
York,London:W.W.Norton&Company,2004),page134.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
15/50
9
phrase. Aperiodconstructedinsuchawayiscalledaparallelperiod.Ifnosuchrepetition
isemployed,itiscalledacontrastingperiod.13
Inconstructingapairofperiodsinthisway,adanceimprovisationmaysometimes
also
become
a
recognizable
musical
form
such
as
rounded
binary,
one
of
classical
musics
mostcommonformaltypes. DevelopedintheBaroque,roundedbinaryeventuallygrew
intosonataforminthelattereighteenthcenturybutpersistedastheformalmodelfor
minuets,trios,aswellasembeddedinminiaturewithinrondothemesandotherpiano
formssuchasmazurka.
Alsoknownastworepriseform,roundedbinaryisillustratedinFigure5below.
Figure5.RoundedBinaryFormasIllustratedinGauldin,HarmonicPracticeinTonalMusic14
Thefirstsection(A)isconstructedofaprogressiveperiod,theconsequentphrases
modulatingtothedominant. Thesecondsection(B)isdoublethelengthofthefirstsection
whichconsists
of
asmall
development
(often
consisting
of
sequential
material),
and
closing
witharepriseoftheAsectionthatisalteredsuchthattheconsequentphrasenowstayson
thetonic. Itiseasytoseethatroundedbinaryformislikeanincipientsonataform,contain
somequalitiesofaternaryform. Inadaptingroundedbinaryforadanceclass,therepeatof
theBsectionisomittedsuchthatthetwohalvesarepreciselyequalinlength.
13RobertGauldin,HarmonicPracticeinTonalMusicWorkbook,SecondEdition,Workbooked.(New
York,London:W.W.Norton&Company,2004),page183.
14Robert
Gauldin,
Harmonic
Practice
in
Tonal
Music
Workbook,
Second
Edition,
Workbook
ed.
(New
York,London:W.W.Norton&Company,2004),page427.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
16/50
10
IV. THEPARTIMENTOTRADITIONANDITSAPPLICABILITYTOSTRUCTURINGIMROVISATIONSFORTHEBALLETCLASS
AnewtypeofimprovisatorypiececalledapartimentoaroseintheBaroqueperiodwith
theinceptionofthethoroughbass.15
ThismethodwasdevelopedandpracticedinNaples
fromthe17thcentury.Theprincipalofthepartimentotraditionisthatthekeyboardplayer
wouldpracticesmallrealizations/patternsuntiltheyarewellingrainedandthenpractice
applyingtheseoverafiguredbassscoreinavarietyofwaysinmanydifferentkeys.Theidea
wasthatthenovicewouldhavetobuildupalargememoryofstoredmaterialthenlearnto
harbouritinsuchawaythattheycanperformstructuredimprovisations.16
Proficient
partimentiplayerscouldhavemorethan1,000differentpatternsmemorized,whichthey
couldapplywhenneeded.17Theresultwasastyleoffreeimprovisedperformancethat
couldbeusedforcompositionalpurposesorfortheperformerthemselves.Figure6isan
exampleisapartimentobasspattern'partimentinumeratibyFrancescoDurante.Theseare
cataloguedonlinebyNorthWesternUniversity.
Howisthisapplicabletodanceaccompaniment?Ofcourseitwouldntbeexpected
thatsomeonewouldhavetoknuckledownandlearnoverathousandrealizationsinallthe
keysand
be
able
to
apply
it
in
many
different
ways.
Good
improvisation
is
borne
of
logic
andformalorderandthesethingshavetobelearnt.Itisacraftasmuchasanart.
Developingastrategyandmethodofhowyouwouldpracticedanceaccompaniment
improvisationsandhavingasolidstructuralfoundationwillprovidethepianistwitha
repertoireofstockstandardphrasesundertheirfingers,addingfluencyandconfidenceto
theirimprovisations.
15BrunoNettl,etal."Improvisation." InGroveMusicOnline,OxfordMusicOnline,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/13738pg2 (accessed
September29,2011).
16RobertO.Gjerdingen,Gebrauchsformulas,MusicTheorySpectrum33,no.2(Fall2011):191
17FrancescoDurante,PartimentiSiminuiti(embellishedBasses),MonumentsofPartimenti,
http://faculty
web.at.northwestern.edu/music/gjerdingen/partimenti/collections/Durante/diminuiti/index.htm(accessed
June16,2011).FrancescoDurante,PartimentiSiminuiti(embellishedBasses),MonumentsofPartimenti,
http://faculty
web.at.northwestern.edu/music/gjerdingen/partimenti/collections/Durante/diminuiti/index.htm(accessed
June16,2011).
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
17/50
11
Figure6.ApartimentoexercisebyFrancescoDurante18
Moreover,thewayinwhichpartimentiwereconstructedisofgreatinterest.Firstly
thereisafiguredbasstemplate,whichprovidesthestructure,boththeharmonicstructure
andphrasestructure.Thepianistplayingofftheserealizationscouldplaytheprogression
inanydifferentkey.Thepartimentopracticecanbeadaptedtonotonlytomemorise
certainharmonicprogressionssuitedtotheeightbarphrase,butalsoforthepracticeof
differentpatterns
to
suit
the
exercise.
Example;
for
an
exercise
you
could
play
in
a2/4
meterwitharepeatedlefthandvampstyleaccompaniment,orusingthesameharmonic
outlineusea6/8meterarpeggiatedaccompaniment,orevena3/4vampstylelikeawaltz.
Thesearedifferentstylesofplayingtheyareutilizingthesameharmonicstructureand
outlineanditisuptothepianisttobecreativewiththetexturesandmotivicmaterial.
Howdoesonedothisexactly?Obviously,memorisingmanyharmonicpatternscan
takealifetime.Buttheideaofapartimentoasaharmonictemplateisalsoausefulconcept.
A
harmonic
template
can
be
used
to
create
a
scaffolding
for
embellishment
through
improvisation. Firstly,thestructuremustbesetineveneightbarphrases. Dependingon
thelengthoftheexercise,thepianistmayeasilyadaptthemusicbysimplyselectingwhich
phrasestouse,orrepeatingphrases.
18FrancescoDurante,PartimentiNumerati(figuredBasses),MonumentsofPartimenti,
http://faculty
web.at.northwestern.edu/music/gjerdingen/partimenti/collections/Durante/numerati/index.htm(accessed
November17,2011).
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
18/50
12
V. THEANALYSISOFFREEIMPROVISATIONFORTHEBALLETUSINGMICHAELBRETTASANEXEMPLAR
Mr.
Brett
has
almost
30
years
experience
playing
for
professional
ballet
classes
having
workedinGermanyfortheStuttgartBalletandHamburgBallet;inAustraliafortheWest
AustralianBallet;andinNewZealandfortheNewZealandSchoolofDance.Hewasthe
musicdirectorfortheRoyalAcademyofDanceinAustraliaandisnowthechief
accompanistforthedancedepartmentattheWesternAustralianAcademyofPerforming
Arts.Heisalsoindemandasanaccompanistforvisitingballetcompanies,balletmaster
classes,examinationsandcontinuestoassistdanceteachersinthemusicalaspectsoftheir
training.MostoftheworkMr.Brettdoes(syllabusandrepertoireworkaside)isimprovised.
However,he
also
extemporizes
from
memory
or
scores.
This
is
askill
he
has
developed
by
playingingroupsandensembleswhenhewasyounger,wherehehashadtoimproviseover
simplechordprogressionsandplayalargeamountofcommercialmusic,whichoverthe
yearshasbeeningrainedintohismemorysimilartoPartimentipatterns.Nowhehasthe
abilitytoaccessthisinformationanytimeheneeds.
A. MyObservationsWhenobservingMrBrettthefirstthingInoticedwashischoiceofrepertoire.Hetendedto
avoidusingmaterialfrompianorepertoireandusethemesfromeitherwellknowpiecesor
balletsandimprovisedaroundthem.Itseemstomakesenseastheyareavoidingrhythmic
repetitionormetricpredictability,whichisvitalfortheballetdancertofollow,whichdoes
againstwhatthegreatmastersweretryingtoachieve.19
MrBrettsstyleofmusicwasalsovarieddependingontheclass.Theclassitself
followsaspecific
structure
in
which
the
dancer
is
working
their
way
from
some
basic
stretchesandexercisesgraduallybuildinguptilltheyareperforminggreatleapsandjumps.
ThemusicthereforehasasenseofdoingthisandMichaelimprovisesindifferentstylesand
dynamic/intensitytosupportthedancers.
MrBrettsopeninggambitscreateanintroductiontothedance,providingaclear
rhythmiccharactertothedancers,givingthemtheopportunitytohearwhatstyleandpulse
19Wallis,Lynnetal.,ADanceClassAnthology:TheRoyalAcademyofDanceGuidetoBalletClass
Accompaniment,ed.
Jonathan
Still,
Melanie
Adams
and
Sabrina
Avellini
(London:
Royal
Academy
of
Dance
EnterprisesLtd,n.d.),12.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
19/50
13
theymustfollow.Generallyhewouldplayafouroreightcountintroductionallowing
enoughtimeforthedancertocatchon.Theamountofbarsthatwouldbewoulddepend
onthemeterandthepulseofthemusic.
B. CATALOGUEANDANALYSISOFMICHAELBRETTSSCOREDIMPROVISATIONS
ImprovisationisdefinedbyBrunoNettlasfollows:
Thecreationofamusicalwork,orthefinalformofamusicalwork,asitis
beingperformed.Itmayinvolvethework'simmediatecompositionbyits
performers,ortheelaborationoradjustmentofanexistingframework,or
anythinginbetween.20
InthissectionIhavecataloguedtheimprovisationsofMichaelBrett,whicharegoingtobe
publishedinanexaminationsyllabussometimein2012.Thesewereconstructedusinga
DiskClavierpianolinkedtoacomputer,whichtranscribedwhathewasplayingintoscored
music.Aswellascataloguingthesetranscriptions,Ihavealsoanalysedandconstructed
templatesofaselectfew,whichdemonstrateclearharmonicandphrasestructures. These
structurescanbeembellishedtocreatenewworksinasimilarfashiontothepartimento
tradition.
20BrunoNettl,etal."Improvisation." InGroveMusicOnline.OxfordMusicOnline,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/13738(accessed
November
2,
2011).
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
20/50
14
1. BARREPLIES
EFlatMajor
Time
Signature
32BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
Brokenchordaccompanimentwithsimplemelodymostlyconsistingofcrotchets.Givesa
flowingfeelwithlongmusicalline.
BATTMENTSTENDUANDGLISSSGMinor
2/4TimeSignature
32BarSetting
4Bar/8CountIntroduction
Nonlegatoalbertibasspatternwithastaccatomelodyconstructedwithsmallmotifs
accentuatingthebeat.Theresultisalight/snappyfeeling,whichcanhelpthedancer,
articulatetheirmovements.
RONDSDEJAMBEATERREANDASSEMBLSSOUTENUSCmajor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
21/50
15
RONDSDEJAMBEATERREANDASSEMBLSSOUTENUSCmajor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
Thisexercisehasaflowingquaver,brokenchordlefthandpattern.MrBrettpurposely
phrasedthelefthandquaversingroupsoffourtogiveasenseoftwocountsinabar,which
thedancerwillbefollowing.
GRANDBATTEMENTSENCROIXANDRETIRSBFlatMajor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
BATTMENTSFRAPPSEFlatMajor
2/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4
Count
Introduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
22/50
16
PETITSBATTMENTSDMinor
2/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
4Bar/8CountIntroduction
BATTMENTSFONDUSENCROIXANDRONDSDEJAMBEENLAIRC
minor
4/4TimeSignature
8BarSetting
2Bar/FourCountIntroduction
DVELOPPSANDDEMIGRANDSRONDSDEJAMBEAFlatMajor
6/8TimeSignature
9BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
23/50
17
EXERCISEFORATTITUDEANDARABESQUEAMinor
TimeSignature
16BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
GRANDBATTMENTSENCLOCHEQuickWaltz
TimeSignature
20BarSetting(4BarCoda)
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
24/50
18
2. DEMI-POINTRISESAFlatMajor
4/4Time
Signature
32BarSetting
2Bar/8CountIntroduction
RELEVSEFlatMajor
2/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
ECHAPPSRELEVSANDRELEVSAMinor
6/8TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4
Count
Introduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
25/50
19
3. CENTRE1STPORTDEBRASCMajor
6/8Time
Signature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
2ndPORTDEBRASGminor
TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
SETEXCERCISEFMajor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4
Count
Introduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
26/50
20
4. ADAGEEXCERSISEFORARABESQUEDFlatMajor
4/4Time
Signature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
EXCERSISEFORATTITUDESEFlatMajor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
TEMPSLISENAVANTANDENARRIRE
FMajor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
27/50
21
1STADAGE
GMinor(TierceDePicadiEnding)
TimeSignature
32BarSetting
4
Bar/4
Count
Introduction
2NDADAGE
AFlat
Major
4/4TimeSignature
32BarSetting
2Bar/FourCountIntroduction
UNSEENADAGEENCHANEMENT:6/8
CMajor
6/8TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
28/50
22
UNSEENADAGEENCHANEMENT3/4BFlatMajor
TimeSignature
16BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
UNSEENADAGEENCHANEMENT4/4
I. Fminor4/4TimeSignature16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
29/50
23
5. PIROUETTESPIROUETTESENDEHORS
D
Minor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
PIROUETTESENDEDANS
EFlatMajor,ModulatingtoAFlatMajoratmidpoint
TimeSignature
32BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
EMBOTSRELEVSANDPOSPIROUETTESBYHALFTURN
A
Minor
4/4TimeSignature
32or64BarSetting,dependingonrepeats
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
30/50
24
UNSEENPIROUETTESENCHAMENTMALE
BFlatMajor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2
Bar/4
Count
Introduction
TOURSENLAIRMALE
I.
C
Major
3/8TimeSignature
32BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
31/50
25
6. ALLEGROWARMUPENCHANEMENT
G
Major
6/8TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
1STALLEGRO
EFlatMajor
TimeSignature
32BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
2NDALLEGRO
FMajor
2/4TimeSignature
16
Bar
Setting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
32/50
26
3RDALLEGRO
Tempodipolkamazurka
EFlatMajor
TimeSignature
16
Bar
Setting
2Bar/6CountIntroduction
BATTERIEENCHANEMENTFEMALESamemusicasimmediatelysubsequent...
BATTERIEENCHANEMENTMALE
(Malemenomossoconbravura)
DMajor
Time
Signature
16BarSetting
2Bar/6CountIntroduction
UNSEENALLEGRONO.1POLKA
CMajor
2/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
33/50
27
UNSEENALLEGRONO.2GIGUE
AMinor
6/8TimeSignature
16BarIntroduction
2
Bar/4
Count
Introduction
UNSEENALLEGRONO.3MAZURKA
BFlatMajor
Time
Signature
16BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
UNSEENALLEGRONO.4SCHOTTISCHE
DMajor
4/4TimeSignature
8BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
34/50
28
UNSEENALLEGRONO.52/4
GMinor
2/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2
Bar/4
Count
Introduction
UNSEENALLEGRONO.6VIENNESEWALTZ
GMajor
TimeSignature
32BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
UNSEENALLEGRONO.7LYRICALWALTZ
FMajor
TimeSignature
32BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
35/50
29
7. POINTERISES
C
Minor
4/4TimeSignature
32BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
RELEVS
CMajor
4/4TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2Bar/4CountIntroduction
ECHAPPSRELEVSANDRELEVS
BFlatMajor
6/8TimeSignature
16BarSetting
2
Bar/4
Count
Introduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
36/50
30
UNSEENPOINTENO.14/4
FMajor
4/4TimeSignature
8BarSetting
2
Bar/4
Count
Introduction
UNSEENPOINTE
NO.2
CMinor
3/4TimeSignature
30BARSETTING
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
POINTEENCHANEMENT
EFlatMajor
TimeSignature
32BarSetting
4Bar/4CountIntroduction
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
37/50
31
RVRANCE
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
38/50
32
C. ANALYTICALDISCUSSION1. AccompanimentPatterns
Thisnexttable(seeFigure7)isatallyofdifferentlefthandpatterns/styles,whichMrBrett
employedinhistranscribedimprovisations.Whenlearningtoimprovise,itwouldprove
usefultopracticethepatternsMrBrettusesintheratioofthissetofpieces.Asisanoverall
representativeofhowheaccompaniesaballetclass.
Figure7.AnAnalysisoftheDifferentLeftHandAccompanimentPatterns
AccompanimentPattern
No
of
UsesComment
AlbertiBassPattern 1
Brokenchordpatternin4/4or2/4 6
Brokenchordfigurationin6/8 1
Arpeggiopatternin6/8 2
Arpeggiopatternin3/4 1
Simplechordalaccompanimentin3/4 2
Simplechordalaccompanimentin4/4 5
Simplechordalaccompanimentin6/8 1
Bassand
repeated
chord
pattern
in
3/4
2
Bassandrepeatedchordpatternin4/4 1
Vampstylebassandchordin4/4and2/4 11 Addsemphasisonthe'twoinabar'
feelasthebassfallsonevery
secondbeat.
Vampstylebassandchordin3/4 10
Vampstylebassandchordin6/8 3
'Barcarolle'arpeggiofollowedbychord
patternin6/8
1 Givesthemusicaliltedfeeling.
"Depictingthemovementofa
boat",isadescriptionintheNew
GroveDictionary.21
21MauriceJ.E.BrownandKennethL.Hamilton."Barcarolle."InGroveMusicOnline.OxfordMusic
Online,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/02021
(accessedNovember14,2011).
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
39/50
33
2. DevelopmentofMotivicIdeasFrommyobservationsofMichaelBrett'splayingandhistranscriptions,heusuallyhasa
themeormotivewhichheplaysaroundwiththroughouttheexercise.Forexample,exercise
3(Figure
7)
employs
arhythmic
motive
of
adotted
quaver
followed
by
asemi
quaver
that
givesthemelodyaliltedfeel.Thismotiveisrepeatedfifteentimes. Amotiveissimplya
shortmusicalidea,whetherharmonic,melodic,rhythmicoranycombinationofthem.22
Whenimprovisingitwouldproveusefultohavesomesortofthemeorideainmindand
developitinasmanydifferentwaysaspossible. Repetitioncreatesasenseofmusical
cohesionandisnecessarytoanysuccessfulimprovisation. However,repetitionshouldnot
beoverdone:repetitionandcontrastmustalwaysbekeptinadelicatebalance.
3. HarmonicTemplatesDerivedfromMichaelBrettsBalletImprovisations
Figure8throughFigure12areharmonicanalysesofMichaelBrett'stranscriptions.Ihave
writtentheminfiguredbasssoonecouldreadoffthemlikeyouwouldreadoffapartimenti
basspattern.Ratherthandividingeachharmonyfromeachbar,Ihavestructuredthemin
countstomakeiteasierforthepianisttohaveanunderstandingofthedancersphraseand
beatas
opposed
to
the
musical
one.
So
if
there
are
two
or
more
harmonic
progressions
in
theonecount,thentheywillbewrittenintheonesquare.Itisthentheprerogativeofthe
pianisthowtheywilldivideandgivevaluetoeachoftheseharmonies.Inmostcasesthere
iseitheroneortwocountsinabar.
Ofthethreetablesinthesetemplates,thefirstrowinthetopleftcorneristhe
openinggambit.Thesecondisthefirsthalfoftheexercise,andthethirdrowisthesecond
halfoftheexercise.Ihavemarkedinthepivotalcadentialpointsandphrasenames,asthey
providetheunderlyingstructureofthemusic.Forthemusicaldancer,structureiskeytoa
successfulimprovisation,providingharmonicandrhythmicdirectionandstability.An
awarenessofthesestructureswhenpracticingwillhelpthepianistcreatetheirown
structuredimprovisations. Allgoodimprovisationsforballetclassareborneoflogicand
formalorder.
22WilliamDrabkin."Motif."InGroveMusicOnline.OxfordMusicOnline,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/19221(accessed
November
18,2011).
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
40/50
Figure8. AanalysisofEXERCISE1:PLIS
OpeningGambit
Q^4 CTo & T& T&
ANTECEDENTPHRASE CONSEQUENTPHRASE
EFlatMajor
I I ^ V $3 T& Q uO 4m
T
T^5 T^5 and viiO/w ii ^4 CTo& Q^4
CMinor EFlatmajor
i q T$3 T& q^ CTo & I^ 4 TZ 9 m w w CTo& Q^ CTo &
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
41/50
35
Figure9. TheMusicofEXERCISE1:PLISbyMichaelBrett23
23MichaelBrett,forthcomingpublication.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
42/50
36
Figure10.AnanalysisofEXERCISE2:BATTEMENTTENDUSANDGLISSS
OpeningGambit
q q^4 i q^ 4
ANTECEDENTPHRASE CONSEQUENTPHRASE
HCiV7
HCIII V $3
i i^ r qqO^4 T& T^ 5 q T& q q^ iv iv 6
ANTECEDENTPHRASE CONSEQUENTPHRASE
ACV^5 - i
PACV& - i
i qt T^ 5m E III Y^ Tm T V^ 5 q qr T^5m E III Y^
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
43/50
37
Figure11.TheMusicofEXERCISE2:BATTEMENTTENDUSANDGLISSSbyMichaelBrett24
24MichaelBrett,forthcomingpublication.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
44/50
38
Figure12.AnanalysisofEXERCISE3:RONDSDEJAMBETERREANDASSEMBLSSOUTENUS
OpeningGambit
I ^4 Q^ & Q ^ZZ# ii V
ANTECEDENTPHRASE CONSEQUENTPHRASE
HC V& - eO& (OPEN)
PACT& - Q
I I RZ# RZ# I I viiO $ 3m V V& eO& i^Z# T&m T uO$2
ANTECEDENTPHRASE CONSEQUENTPHRASE
PLAGALCADENCE
RZ# - Q^- Q
I vi ii V I ^ C/TO & ii R Z # I ^ viiO $ 3 ii V& / y R
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
45/50
39
Figure13.TheMusicofEXERCISE3:RONDSDEJAMBETERREANDASSEMBLSSOUTENUSbyMichael
Brett25
25MichaelBrett,forthcomingpublication.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
46/50
40
4. ImprovisingfromaTemplateSimilartothatofthebaroquepartimentibasspatterns,thisharmonicanalysiscanbeused
asthebasisofimprovisationforballetexercises.Itwouldbeagoodideatoworkthrough
thetemplate
practicing
the
chords
in
some
different
keys.
Inoticed
from
my
observations
of
MichaelBrettthathewouldusemostlykeyswithuptofourflatsorsharps.Hewould
generallyusekeyswithflatsandnotmorethanfourflats,butitisuptothepianistonwhich
keystheywillbeutilizing,aslongasthereisvarietywithdifferentexercises. Perhaps,one
couldpracticebetweeneachchordtwoatatimetoensurecontinuity.Oncethepianistis
comfortablewithplayingthesechordsanddoesn'thavetomakemuchofaconsciouseffort
toperformthetemplatebeginningtoenditistimetostartapplyingdifferent
accompanimentpatterns
and
motivic
textures.
Ifonewantssomesuggestedbasicharmonicpatternstopracticetheycouldstartby
referringtothecatalogueofworksandpracticeapplyingthedifferentlefthandpatternsto
thetemplatethepianistisworkingon.Onecouldalsopracticestockstandardtonal
progressions,suchasthecycleoffifths,orsimilarkeyprogressions(Iviii6VIorthe
similar). Itisimportantthatthepianistpracticesthelefthandseparatelytostartofwithto
ensurethattherightharmoniesarebeingemployedintheaccompanimentpattern.
Asfarasthemelody,themeand/ormotivicmaterialisconcernedIcanoffersome
suggestionsofhowtostartpracticingthese,butitisreallytrialanderroraswellaslistening.
Agoodstartwouldbepracticingsmallsectionsofsimpleofsimplemelodiesormotives.An
example:thefirsttwobarsofJ.S.Bach'sMinuetinGmajorFromAnnaMagdalena
notebook.Playthesefirsttwobarsineveryharmonysuggestedbythetemplate(oneata
time).Makesuretousethenotesofeachchord,andnotesnotfoundintheharmonyinthe
chordshouldbethatofthescalefromthekeyofmusic.Makesuremodulationsaretaken
intoconsideration,andthatifoneisplayinginaminorkeytheyshouldalsoconsider
employingthe
melodic
minor
scale
to
avoid
the
dissonance
between
the
flat
sixth
and
raisedseventh,unlessitisdesiredbytheplayer.Thesearenotaguaranteeofagood
soundingmelodybutmerelysomesuggestionsofhowonecouldpracticeimprovisinga
melody.Themostkeyislisteningandmakingsurethecontourofthemelodyreflectsthatof
thephrasestructureandharmonicstructure.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
47/50
41
5. StepstoCreatingyourOwnImprovisationInordertocreateonesownimprovisation,apartfromacompletetemplate,thepianist
needstoconsidermanyfactors. ThelogicalorderofstepsisoutlinedbelowinFigure14.
Figure14.LogicalStepstoCreatinganImprovisation
Step1:workoutthecounting,metre,andnumberofbarsrequiredfortheparticularexercise
Step2:chooseakeyandcreatephrasestructuresandcadential/tonalgoals Step3:findasuitableaccompanimentpattern Step4:haveamotivic/melodicgermtodevelop
VI. CONCLUSIONWhenIsetoutonmystudyforthisdissertation,mymaingoalwastoseehowIcould
becomeabetterimproviserfortheballetclass.ThekeyquestionIwasseekingtoanswer
waswhatexactlyisrequiredinordertolearntoimproviseforaballetclass.First,Ifound
thatIneededtohaveastrongunderstandingofhowaballetclassisstructured,andwhat
wasexpectedofthepianist. Second,IthenrealisedIneededtolearnmoreabouttonal
harmonyin
order
to
structure
an
effective
improvisation.
Ithus
read
extensively
from
theorytextsonthewaysthatphrasesandperiodsareconstructedintonalmusic. Third,I
wasalsointriguedbytheBaroquepartimentomethodanditsapparenthistoricalsuccessin
facilitatingstructureimprovisationsinaknownmusicalstyle. Mygoalwastodevelopmy
owntemplatestobeusedinsimilarfashiontothepartimentotradition. Fourth,Iwantedto
learnasmuchaspossiblefromtheimprovisationsofMichaelBrett. Forthelastyear,Ihave
effectivelybeenhisapprentice. Ihaveattemptedtousedmynewfoundtheoretical
knowledgetoanalysesomeofhiscompositionsandapplythemastemplatesinmyown
improvisatorypractice. Ihavefoundthatthisprojecthasgivenmeenoughtoolsto
commencerudimentaryimprovisations.Indeed,ithaslayedbarethepreviouslyhidden
structureunderlyingmuchtonalrepertoire. Inessence,theoryhastaughtmehowto
structureanimprovisation. ButobservationofMichaelBretthastaughtmethestylesand
typesofaccompanimentpatternsneeded,andthewaystodevelopmusicalmotives. This
hasbeenarichlyrewardingmusicaljourney,oneinwhichIhavecomefar,butone
presentingmanyfurthermusicalchallengesandpotentiallyalifetimetomaster.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
48/50
42
VII. BIBLIOGRAPHYAimer,
Peggy.
"Dance
and
Music."
Music
&
Letters
15,
no.
1
(1934):
21
25.
Berkowitz,Aaron.TheImprovisingMind:CognitionandCreativityintheMusicalMoment.
Publicationplace:OxfordUniversityPress,USA,2010.
Brown,MauriceJ.E.andKennethL.Hamilton."Barcarolle."InGroveMusicOnline.Oxford
MusicOnline,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/020
21(accessed
November
14,
2011).
Buch,DavidJ."TheSourcesofDanceMusicfortheBalletDeCourbeforeLully."Revuede
Musicologie82,no.2(1996):31431.
Cavalli,Harriet.DanceandMusic:AGuidetoDanceAccompanimentforMusiciansand
DanceTeachers(publicationplace:UniversityPressofFlorida,2001).
WilliamDrabkin.
"Motif."
In
Grove
Music
Online.
Oxford
Music
Online,
http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/192
21(accessedNovember18,2011).
Durante,Franceso.PartimentiSiminuiti(embellishedBasses),MonumentsofPartimenti,
http://faculty
web.at.northwestern.edu/music/gjerdingen/partimenti/collections/Durante/diminui
ti/index.htm
(accessed
June
16,
2011).
Durante,Francesco.PartimentiNumerati(figuredBasses).MonumentsofPartimenti.
http://faculty
web.at.northwestern.edu/music/gjerdingen/partimenti/collections/Durante/numera
ti/index.htm(accessedNovember17,2011).
Gauldin,Robert.HarmonicPracticeinTonalMusicWorkbook,SecondEdition.Workbook
Ed.New
York,
London:
W.
W.
Norton
&
Company,
2004.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
49/50
43
Gjerdingen,Roberto.Gebrauchsformulas.MusicTheorySpectrum33,no.2(Fall2011):
191.
Gombosi,Otto."AboutDanceandDanceMusicintheLateMiddleAges."TheMusical
Quarterly27,no.3(1941):289305.
Hammond,SandraNoll.Ballet:BeyondtheBasics.California:WavelandPrInc,2011.
Kassing,GayleandLynnMortensen,CritiquingStudentPerformanceinBallet,Dance
ReasearchJournal14,no.1(19811982):4346,
http://www.jstor.org/stable/1477949(accessedJune16,2011).
Laitz,Steven
G.
The
Complete
Musician
Student
Workbook,
Volume
I:An
Integrated
ApproachtoTonalTheory,Analysis,andListening.Workbooked.publicationplace:
OxfordUniversityPress,USA,2003.
Messerer,Asaf.ClassesinClassicalBallet.NewYork:LimelightEditions,2007.
Mara,Thalia,andIllustratedbyTinaMackler.TheLanguageofBallet:anInformal
Dictionary.NewJersey:PrincetonBookCompany,1987.
Nettl,Brunoetal."Improvisation."InGroveMusicOnline.OxfordMusicOnline,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/137
38pg2(accessedSeptember29,2011).
Paskevska,Anna.BothSidesoftheMirror:theScienceandArtofBallet.2nded.Pennington,
NJ.:PrincetonBookCompanyPublishers,1992.
Preston,Sophia.""GivingDanceRoomtoBreathe":DanceMusicRelationshipsinSiobhan
Davies'Choreography,19721979."DanceChronicle22,no.3(1999):32157.
Rockstro,WilliamS.etal."Cadence."InGroveMusicOnline.OxfordMusicOnline,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/045
23(accessedNovember16,2011).
Sanguinetti,
Giorgio.
"The
Realization
of
Partimenti:
An
Introduction."
Journal
of
Music
Theory51,no.1(2007):5183.
7/27/2019 Frosi, S. (2011). the Improvisation of Structured Keyboard Accompaniments for the Ballet Class.
50/50
Vaganova,Agrippina.TranslatedfromtheRussianbyAnatoleChujoy.Incorporatingallthe
materialfromthe4thRussianed.IncludingVaganova'sSamplelessonwithmusical,
andtranslatedbyJohnBarker.BasicPrinciplesofClassicalBallet:RussianBallet
Technique,.New
York:
Dover
Publications,
1969.
VeraS,Kostrovitskaya.100LessonsinClassicalBallet.1stLimelighted.NewYork:Limelight
Editions,2004.
Wallis,Lynn,JacquelineFergason,MartinCleave,CurtisProbel,andJonathanStill.ADance
ClassAnthology:TheRoyalAcademyofDanceGuidetoBalletClassAccompaniment.
EditedbyJonathanStillStill,MelanieAdamsandSabrinaAvellini.London:Royal
Academyof
Dance
Enterprises
Ltd,
n.d.
W.DeanSutcliffeandMichaelTilmouth."Ternaryform."InGroveMusicOnline.Oxford
MusicOnline,http://0
www.oxfordmusiconline.com.library.ecu.edu.au/subscriber/article/grove/music/277
00(accessedNovember18,2011).
Woolliams,Anne.BalletStudio:anInsideView.Sydney:UreSmith,1978.