Upload
bdhanwanthari-tej
View
244
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
1/19
FUNDAMENTALS OF MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS
TERM PAPER
ON
e Choupal- ANALYSIS USING SAP LAP FRAMEWORK
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
2/19
2 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
2 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
Contents
Objectives of the study ............................................................................................................... 3
Introduction SAP LAP Framework ............................................................................................. 3
SAP Framework ........................................................................................................................... 3
SITUATION: ............................................................................................................................. 4
ACTOR: .................................................................................................................................... 4
PROCESS: ................................................................................................................................. 5
LAP Framework ....................................................................................................................... 5
Agriculture in India-Overview...................................................................................................... 6
THE PARADOX OF INDIAN AGRICULTURE ............................................................................. 6
Introduction to e Choupal ........................................................................................................ 7
Operation of Mandi ............................................................................................................. 8
Figure 3. MandiOperation Process ...................................................................................... 9
SAP LAP Analysis of e-Choupal initiative of ITC .......................................................................... 11
SAP (Situation-Actor-Process) ................................................................................................ 11
e-Choupals Presence Across States in India .......................................................................... 12
LAP (Learning-Action-Performance)....................................................................................... 14
Efficiencies in e- Choupal Model ............................................................................................... 16
KEY LEARNINGS OF ANALYSIS .................................................................................................... 16
References ................................................................................................................................ 19
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
3/19
3 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
3 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
Objectivesofthestudy
y Understanding and analysing e-Choupal concept that is implemented in practicalmarkets by ITC Ltd.
y Understand all activities as well as challenges, problems and possible solutions in ITCsbusiness.
Introduction SAP LAP Framework
SAP-LAP is a holistic framework that aids the process of analysis to generate models for
managerial enquiry and problem solving. (Sushil, 2001). The Situation, Actor, and Process
comprise of the SAP framework where the freedom of choice lies with the Actor. The situation
to be dealt with, the actor or actors who deal with the situation, and a process or processes
that recreate the situation are all analyzed in the SAP framework.
A synthesis of SAP leads to LAP which deals with Learning, Action, and Performance. The
analysis carried out in SAP framework highlight the key learning issues for the context based on
which actions are suggested to address the concerns or problems. Finally, the impact of
suggested actions on performance is assessed so as to justify the actions.
SAP and LAP frameworks are explained below.
SAP Framework
Any managerial context basically consists of a "situation" to be managed, an "actor" or a group
of actors to deal with the situation and a "process" or a set of processes that respond to the
situation and recreate it.
Situation, Actor, Process and their interplay comprise of SAP framework
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
4/19
4 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
4 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
If the actors have more freedom, the processes will become flexible and adaptive to cope with
the changing situation. Lack of freedom of choice to the actors will restrict their options, limit
their movement ultimately making the process rigid and static and thereby failing to cope with
the problems in the situation.
SITUATION:
"Situation" is external and internal environment of the organization and its performance. It can
be of either.
1. External Situationwhere key components are competitive potential, economic policy,new technologies, type of supplies, infrastructure, industry performance etc.
2. Internal Situation where components comprises of financial performance, marketshare, corporate image, resources, capabilities and competencies, plant and machinery,
core values etc.
ACTOR:
"Actor" can be individual managers, groups, departments or class of actors.
Actors constitutes of suppliers, competitors, government, consultants, management,
employees, etc.
Important variables in the "actor" domain are motivation, morale, attitude, actor performance,
roles, capabilities, world-views, freedom of choice, communication, knowledge, skills etc.
The interface of "actor" and "situation" defines the organizational climate and culture that is
important for the evolution of the business processes.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
5/19
5 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
5 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
PROCESS:
The "process" is the overall transformation process that converts a set of inputs into outputs to
recreate the situation. The processes could be of various types, such as, supply chain process,
customer interface process, performance management process, technology transfer process,
innovation process, investment process, distribution process and so on. Depending upon the
situation, one or more processes are to be studied and improved for higher flexibility.
The interface of "actor" and "process" defines the strategy, structure and systems that need to
be transformed for organizational change.
The interface of "process" and "situation" defines the contingency to be taken care of (e.g.
contingency planning) and adaptation and response of the process to the changing situation.
LAP Framework
The interplay and synthesis of SAP leads to Learning-Action-Performance (LAP).
We need to learn about the situation, actor and process and bring out key learning issues of
interest. Based on the learnings, the action is to be taken on the fronts of situation, actor or
process or the relevant interfaces.
Depending upon the effectiveness of actions, performance is generated in terms of improved
processes/actors and better situational parameters. In a business situation, the performance
parameters could be market share, profitability, quality, productivity, competitive advantage,
core competence and so on. SAP-LAP framework can be used effectively for case analysis,
managerial inquiry and problem solving. The steps for case analysis using SAP-LAP framework
are: understanding situation, actors and roles, evolving process, learning issues, suggested
actions, and expected performance.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
6/19
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
7/19
7 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
7 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
Introductiontoe Choupal
Today in 21 century, e-business & e-commerce initiatives have become popular but it may be
rather difficult to think of poor illiterate farmers of India to use e-business as a part of their
daily lives.
Most of the Indian villages do not have basic facilities such as electricity, telephone, &
transportation. However large number of illiterate farmer groups started conducting e-
commerce transactions easily in the year of 2002 with the help of innovative & revolutionary
concept of e-Choupal which was introduced by ITC Ltd. The purpose of implementing e-Choupal
is to connect the villages in a network via internet and then procure agriculture products from
farmers. ITC started the program with just six e-Choupals in June 2000 and has managed to
expand them to 6500 e-Choupal centres in approximately 6500 village across 14 states. ITC
Limited plans to scale up to 20,000 eChoupals by 2012 covering 100,000 villages in 15 states,
servicing 15 million farmers. The company started e-Choupal with modest & focused valueproportion which is that the farmer should get better price for crops.ITC gained immense
credibility through the early success of e-Choupal.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
8/19
8 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
8 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
The ValueChain- Farmto Factory Gate
OperationofMandi
The operation of the Mandiconsists of a number of different stages, from the logistics of
transporting grain to the market to quality inspection, auction, bagging and weighing, and
payment. Based upon local information within the village, farmers decide in which of the
nearby mandis to sell. They transport their crops to the mandis in carts drawn by animals or
tractors. Very often, to avoid peak-time crowds, farmers will arrive at the mandithe night
before they intend to sell. When the mandiopens in the morning, farmers bring their carts todisplay areas within the mandi.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
9/19
9 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
9 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
The inspection by buyers is by sight. There is no formal method of grading the produce and the
only instrument used is the moisture meter; the crop is not tested for oil content.
Figure3.MandiOperation Process
Once potential buyers have inspected the produce, a mandiemployee conducts the auction,
where commission agents place bids. The auctions are typically open oral auctions with
incremental bidding. The auction represents a stark contrast from the buyers and sellers
perspectives. For the farmer, the moment is pivotal: a scant 30 seconds assesses the results of
six months of investment and hard work and establishes the value of one of only two or three
paydays he will have in the year. For the commission agent, on the other hand, the moment is
routine; he has many more carts of produce to buy and his margin is assured irrespective of the
price. Once the price has been established by the auction, the farmer moves the cart to the
weighing area run by the buying commission agent. In most cases, the weighing area is in the
mandicomplex. In some cases, especially if the mandiis small, the weighing area may be at the
commission agents home near the mandi. Here, the produce is transferred from the cart into
individual sacks. The sacks are then weighed, one at a time, on a manual scale. After weighing,
the full value of the grain is calculated. The farmer goes to the agents office to collect a cash
payment. The agent pays a mandifee (1% of purchase value in Madhya Pradesh) to the mandi.
The bagged produce is then loaded on to the buyers trucks and transported to the processing
plant.
E-Choupal Supply chain
The re-engineered supply chain looks very different from the existing system and has the
following stages:
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
10/19
10 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
10 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
Transaction Costs
In the mandisystem, there was a mark up of 7-8% on the price of soybean from the farm gate
to the factory gate. Of this mark up, 2.5% was borne by the farmer while 5% was borne by ITC.
With e- Choupal, ITCs costs are now down to 2.5%. Figure 4 shows transaction costs incurred
by the farmer and ITC per metric ton of soy procured in the mandiand e-Choupal. In absolute
numbers, both the farmers and ITC save about US$6 (Rs 270) per metric ton.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
11/19
11 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
11 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
SAP LAP Analysisofe-ChoupalinitiativeofITC
SAP (Situation-Actor-Process)
Whatisthepresentandpast Situation?
The situation is understood by framing some questions and providing explanation for these.
WhatisEChoupalproject?
eChoupal is an initiative of ITC Limited (a large multi business conglomerate in India) to link
directly with rural farmers for procurement of agricultural / aquaculture produce like soybeans,
wheat, coffee, and prawns. E Choupal was conceived to tackle the challenges posed by the
unique features of Indian agriculture, characterized by fragmented farms, weak infrastructure
and the involvement of numerous intermediaries
WhywasEChoupalrequired?
India has 600,000+ villages with 1000+ million people. In this large population Agriculture is the
primary occupation for about 80 % of rural population.
Traditionally, the commodities were procured in "mandis" (major agricultural marketing centres
in rural areas of India), where the middleman used to make most of the profit. These
middlemen used unscientific and sometimes outright unfair means to judge the quality of the
product to set the price. Difference in price for good quality and inferior quality was less, and
hence there was no incentive for the farmers to invest and produce good quality output. With E
Choupal, the farmers have a choice and the exploitative power of the middleman is neutralised.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
12/19
12 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
12 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
Primary Stakeholders Interest
Farmer Community
y Access to information Empowered decisions Improved agriculture
y Economic benefits through lower transaction costs and procesefficiencies
y Served with dignityy Knowledge bundled sale of goods and servicesy Co-opted in product designy Hope for a brighter future
ITC
y Lower procurement costsy Direct interaction with farmers - Control on quality & supply
security
y Low cost distribution channely Access to market intelligence
Commission Agents
(Kachha & Pakka Adatiyas)
y Gain access to global markets through ITC and commission tocompensate some of the loss revenue
e-Choupals Presence Across StatesinIndia
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
13/19
13 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
13 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
WhatistheachievementofEChoupal?
E Choupalhas extracted value in four steps to make the model sustainable and scalable:
1. elimination of non-value added activities2. differentiated product through identity preserved supply chains3. value added products traceable to farm practices4. e-market place for spot transactions and support services to futures exchange5. Farmers can get real-time information despite their physical distance from the
"mandis"
6. Rise in yields, improvement in quality of output and a fall in transaction costs.
Whychanges were needed?
y Creation of employment opportunities to village enterprisingy Large base of Indian villages needs the initiatives like e Choupal to encourage
agricultural production in India by seeing that the farmer gets the fair share of profit.
y Introduction of Technology at the grassroots level of Agriculture viz., Farmers.y Role model for other states.y Public private partnership
ACTORS
Who are the Actors?
Government can be an actor which can implement the successful project throughout the
country.
Purchasers of commodities
Kiosk Operators
Farmers and Villagers
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
14/19
14 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
14 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
What are the Processes in evolution?What is being done?
ITC has established computers and Internet access in rural areas across several
agricultural regions of the country, where the farmers can directly negotiate the sale of
their produce with ITC Limited. The PCs and Internet access at these centres enable the
farmers to obtain information on mandi prices, good farming practices and place orders for
agricultural inputs like seeds and fertilizers. This helps farmers in improving the quality of
produce, and also helps in realizing a better price. Each ITC Limited kiosk having an access to
Internet is run by a sanchalak a trained farmer. The computer housed in the sanchalaks
house is linked to the Internet via phone lines or by a VSAT connection and serves an average of
600 farmers in the surrounding ten villages within about a 5 km radius. The sanchalak bears
some operating cost but in return earns service fee for the e-transactions done through his e
Choupal. The warehouse hub is managed by the same traditional middle-men, now called
samyojaks, but with no exploitative power due to the reorganised role. Indeed these
middlemen make up for the lack of infrastructure and fulfil critical jobs like cash disbursement,
quantity aggregation and transportation.
Whyit is being done?
It is being done to cover
o 40000 villageso 4 million farmerso To pass the benefits of profit earned on the commodities to the farmer.
LAP (Learning-Action-Performance)
Whatisthe Learning?
ITC chose to operate the platform on the "three business principles" of "free information and
knowledge,freedom of choice in transactions, and transaction-based income-stream" for
the sanchalak or person manning the internet-enabled e-Choupal booths.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
15/19
15 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
15 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
How ITC used the extensive network to procure farm produce for its own business needs while
pushing products down the chain for third parties.
What are the keyissues related to the situation, actors and performance?
The key factors in the situation are the:
y Limitations of e Choupal project-Poor telecom and transport infrastructure in villagesy Rate of change of technology and its updating in the processy
Scope of errors and maintenance issues with the Technology products especiallySoftware issues
y Rigidity of the farmers to accept the new things predominantly due to illiteracy levels inrural population
What are the Actions?
What is being done to improve the situation?
E Choupal is further now trying to be used by ITC to provide healthcare and other services like
weather forecast etc for rural population through its established network. Also studies were
put forward before government to implement the e Choupal model across rural India so that
the benefits are passed over till the producer.
What are the keyPerformance Parameters?
y Benefits passed on to the Farmersy Improvement in Rural GDP and increase in the Gross agricultural productivityy Accurate pricing which eliminates the menace of middleman in the transaction
of commodities.
y Role model for other states
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
16/19
16 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
16 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
y Public private partnershipy CSR initiatives by corporate world
Efficienciesine-Choupal Model
y Last mile low cost solutiony Full Service approachy Demand aggregationy Third party sellery Extensive use of technologyy Access to information about customersy Pull based strategy
KEY LEARNINGS OF ANALYSIS
The e-Choupal model demonstrates that a large corporation can play a major role in
recognizing markets and increasing the efficiency of an agricultural system, while doing so in
ways that benefit farmers and rural communities as well as shareholders.
This analysis also shows the key role of information technology, in this case provided and
maintained by a corporation, but used by local farmers, in helping bring about transparency,
increased access to information, and rural transformation.
Critical factors in the apparent success of the venture are ITCs extensive knowledge of
agriculture, the effort ITC has made to retain many aspects of the existing production system,
including respect and fairness with which both farmers and local partners are treated.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
17/19
17 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
17 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
Challenges
The e-Choupal system faces multiple continuing challenges. The first is the possibility that
radical shifts in computing access could fundamentally alter community-based business models.
That is one of the reasons ITC seeks to build and control its own ICT infrastructure. Second, as
the number and power of the sanchalaks increase, there is a threat that they will unionize and
extract rents unwarranted additional payments based on their increasing influence on the
system. Third, ITCs relationship with the samyojaks seems to be uneasy, and competitors with
the financial muscle to invest for scale could conceivably use discontented samyojaks as the
base to obtain market share. Fourth, the scope of the e- Choupal operation, the diversity of
activities required of every operative, and the speed of expansion create real threats to
execution management.
ITC has awakened the aspirations of farmers. If ITC fails to fulfil these aspirations, the farmers
will look elsewhere for satisfaction. As an example, in our conversation with a sanchalakabout
the potential for Indian onions to succeed in the global market, he also understood what the
key to success was better seeds. He half-complained that he had told ITC several times to
begin selling better onion seeds, but he had not heard back from them. In a competitive
environment, ITC would have to provide faster and more responsive customer service to
maintain its distribution system.The computer in the village is no doubt revolutionary, but there is also no doubt that the
villages we saw were stratified to the point where not everybody can walk up to the sanchalak
and ask to be shown the computer. There are clearly some segments of village society,
including the entire adult female population, that does not have access to the computer
although this may not be true in all regions. The presence of the computer by itself will not
transcend this barrier unaided. This is not a reflection on ITC, but rather the nature of society in
rural Madhya Pradesh. The solution might lie in observing where the system has driven socialchange. Village farmers belong to many social and economic strata. Yet the sanchalaks are
servicing all of them equally. In this case, the potential for commerce has broken a barrier
that society has built. Similarly, engagement with poorer segments of society and women may
be possible through the active distribution of products tailored specifically to them.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
18/19
18 | P a g e
F U N D A M E N T A L S O F M A N A G E M E N T S Y S T E M T E R M P A P E R
18 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
Conclusion
The e-Choupal model shows that a large corporation can combine a social mission and an
ambitious commercial venture; that it can play a major role in rationalizing markets and
increasing the efficiency of an agricultural system, and do so in ways that benefit farmers and
rural communities as well as company shareholders. ITCs example also shows the key role of
information technologyin this case provided and maintained by a corporation, but used by
local farmersin helping to bring about transparency, to increase access to information, and to
catalyze rural transformation, while enabling efficiencies and low-cost distribution that make
the system profitable and sustainable. Critical factors in the apparent success of the venture are
ITCs extensive knowledge of agriculture, the effort ITC has made to retain many aspects of the
existing production system, including retaining the integral importance of local partners, the
companys commitment to transparency, and the respect and fairness with which both farmers
and local partners are treated.
8/7/2019 FMS PROJECT
19/19
19 | P a g e
19 e Choupal - Analysis using SAP LAP Framework
References
1. Sushil (1994) Flexible System Methodology, System Practice, 7(6), 633-651.2. What Works: ITCs E-CHOUPAL & Profitable Rural Transformation- A Michigan School
Report.
3. http://www.echoupal.com/4. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echoupal