Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
National Highways Authority of India
(MinistryofRoadTransport&Highways)
GovernmentofIndia
Consultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of
Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode
REQUESTFOR PROPOSAL
(RFP)
October 2016
G-5&6, Sector-10, Dwarka-New Delhi-110075
2
INDEX
Sl. No. Content
s
PageNo.
1 NoticeInvitingTender (NIT) 3
2 Letter ofInvitation 4-18
3 Annex -I:Listof Projects alongwith PackageNos. 19
4 Annex-II:ProcedureofAssessmentofLeastCostto NHAI under special
circumstances 20-25
5 Data Sheet 26-36
6 Appendix-I: Terms ofReference 37-86
7 Supplement-I: Additional Requirements forHillRoads 87-91
8 Supplement-II:Additional Requirements forBridges 92-94
9 Supplement–III:Additionalrequirement forsafetyaudit 95-99
10 Enclosure-I: Manning Schedule 100
11 Enclosure-II: Qualification Requirements of KeyPersonnel 101-109
12 Enclosure-III:ScheduleforSubmission ofReports and Documents 109-110
13 Appendix–II: Formatsfor Eligibility 111-116
14 Appendix-III:Formats forTechnical Proposals 117-130
15 Appendix-IV:Formats for Financial Proposals 131-140
16 Appendix-V: Detailed Evaluation Criteria 141-159
17 Appendix-VI: Draft Contract Agreement 160-204
18 Appendix – VII: DPR Checklist for 6 stages [Stage 1: Inception Report,
Stage 2: Feasibility Report, Stage 3: LA & Clearances I, Stage 4:
Detailed Project Report, Stage 5: Technical Schedules, Stage 6: LA &
Clearances II]
205-266
3
National Highways Authority of India (NHAI)
(Ministry of Road Transport and Highways)
Government of India
NOTICE INVITING TENDER(NIT) 1. NHAIhas been assigned thework ofConsultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid
Annuity/EPC mode (asper AnnexureI).
2. Proposals arehereby invited from eligible Consultants for
preparationofDetailedProjectReportof Consultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh
through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode.TheLetterofInvitation (LOI)andTermsof Reference(ToR) including RequestforProposal(RFP)isavailableonlineon e-tenderportalof https:/nhai.eproc.in.The documentcanalsobe downloadedfrom NHAI website (www.nhai.org).The Consultant who download the RFP document from the website will be required to pay the non- refundable fee of Rs. 5,000/- at the time of the submission of the Bid proposal, through e-payment gateway. The RFP will be invited through e-tendering portal. Refer Procedure under e-tendering for submission of RFP through e-tendering.
3. The RFP has also been uploaded on “INFRACON” (www.infracon.nic.in). As such
before submitting the proposal the Consultant shall mandatorily register and enlist themselves (the
firm and all key personnel), on the MoRTH portal “INFRACON” and furnish registration details
along with its RFP. A copy of Infracon Operation Procedure is also enclosed for bidder’s
reference.
4. All the bidders registered on Infracon shall form a Team on Infracon and which
would be assigned unique Infracon Team ID. Bidders while submitting the proposal shall
quote the Infracon Team ID.
5. Bid must be submitted online at e-tender portal of NHAIhttps://nhai.eproc.in on or before
30.11.2016 upto 11.00 AM.
6. Thefollowingscheduleis to befollowed forthis assignment: i) Deadlinefor downloadingof bid:29.11.2016 (upto 5.00 PM) ii)Last dateforsubmission of queries:11.11.2016
iii) Prebid meeting:15.11.2016 at 3.00 PM iv) Deadlinefor Submission of bids :30.11.2016 (upto 11.00 AM)
Yours sincerely,
4
(Nishoo Gupta)
GM (T) HP
Tel: 91-011-25074100/1321
National Highways Authority of India
G-5&6, Sector 10,
Dwarka, New Delhi-110075 E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.nhai.org
5
LetterofInvitation(LOI)
NHAI/HP Border-Mandi/NH-20/DPR/HP/2016 Dated: 31.10.2016 Dear Sir,
Sub: Consultancy Services forConsultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode.
1. Introduction
1.1 TheNational Highways Authority of India (NHAI)has been entrusted with theassignment
o fConsultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00)
of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode. NHAI now invites proposalfromTechnicalconsultantsforcarryingoutdetailedprojectreportas per detailsgiven inAnnexure-1.
1.2 AbriefdescriptionoftheassignmentanditsobjectivesaregivenintheAppendix-I,
“Terms of Reference”.
1.3 The NHAI invitesProposals(the “Proposals”)throughe-tender(on-linebidsubmission)
forselectionof TechnicalConsultant(the“Consultant”)whoshallprepareDPR.A Consultant with“a ParticularTeam”maysubmitproposals for morethanonepackage.However,aConsultantisnotallowedto bidforapackagewithmore thanone team.For the sake ofclarity,it ismentionedthat one consultant can notsubmittwoproposals/bidsforthesamepackage. Aconsultant(eitheras soleorasinJV/Association)can be awarded only upto 2 packages. Consultants are hereby invited to submit proposals in the manner as prescribed in the RFP.A Consultant with “a Particular Team”may submitonly one“proofof eligibility (Part1)”and“TechnicalProposal(PartII)”foranynumberofpackages applied for by them. However,thepackagesforwhichaConsultant with“aParticularTeam” appliesshouldbeclearlymentioned. Financialproposalforeachpackagearetobesubmittedseparately. Financialproposalareonlytobesubmittedonlineandno hardcopy ofthe financial proposal should besubmitted. Themostpreferred bidder (H-1)foreachpackagewouldbedeterminedonthebasisofQuality andCostas mentionedintheRFP.AwardofworktoaConsultantwith“aParticularTeam”either assoleor asinJV/Associationshallbe limitedto onepackage only.Incase,aConsultantwith“aParticularTeam”turnsouttobethemostpreferredbidder(H-1)inmorethanonepackage,thepackagewhichistobeawardedtothisConsultantwith“aParticularTeam”shallbedeterminedonthebasisofleastcostto NHAIconsidering the financial quote of H-1 bidder and H-2 bidder limited to those packages, which shall be worked out as per the procedure given in the RFP. The consultants are hereby invited to submit proposals in the manner prescribed in the RFP.
6
1.4 Theconsultants shall submit proposals either insole capacity or in JV or in Association.
Joint Venture/Association shall not have more than two firms. Any entity which has been barred by the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MORTH) or its implementing agencies for the works of Expressways, National Highways, ISC and EI Works and the bar subsists as on the date of application,would not be eligible to submit the bid, either individually or as a member of a Joint Venture.
1.5 Toobtainfirsthandinformationontheassignmentandonthelocalconditions,the
consultantsareencouragedtopay avisittotheclient,localStatePWDsandtheproject sitebeforesubmittingaproposalandattendapre-proposalconference.They mustfully informthemselvesoflocalandsiteconditionsandtakethemintoaccountinpreparing the proposal.
1.6 FinancialProposalswillbeopenedonlyforthefirmsfoundtobeeligibleandscoring
qualifyingmarksinaccordancewithPara5hereof.Theconsultancy serviceswillbe awarded to thehighest rankingconsultant on the basisof Qualityand Cost.
1.7 Pleasenotethat (i)costs ofpreparingtheproposal and of negotiatingthecontract, including
visitstotheClient,etc.,arenotreimbursableasadirectcostoftheassignment; and(ii)Clientisnotboundtoacceptany oftheproposalssubmittedandreservetheright to reject anyor allproposals without assigning anyreasons.
1.8 Theproposals must be properlysigned as detailedbelow:
1.8.1 i. bythe proprietor in caseof a proprietary firm
ii. bythepartnerholdingthePowerofAttorneyincaseofafirminpartnership(A
certifiedcopyofthePowerofAttorneyonastamppaperofRs.100 andduly notarized
shallaccompanythe Proposal). iii. byadulyauthorizedpersonholdingthePowerofAttorneyincaseofaLimited Company
oracorporation(Acertifiedcopy ofthe PowerofAttorneyonastamp paper of Rs. 100
and duly notarized shall accompanythe proposal). iv. bythe authorized representativein caseof JointVenture.
1.8.2 IncaseaJointVenture/Associationoffirms,theproposalshallbe accompanied bya
certifiedcopyoflegallybindingMemorandumofUnderstanding (MOU)onastamp paper ofRs.100, signed byallfirms to the jointventure confirmingthe followingtherein: i.
Dateand placeof signing ii. PurposeofJointVenture/Association(mustincludethedetailsofcontractworks for
which thejoint venture has been invited to bid) iii. Aclearanddefinitedescriptionoftheproposedadministrativearrangementsfor
themanagementandexecutionoftheassignment.Name ofLeadFirmandother partner
of JV should be clearlydefined in the MOU
7
iv. Delineationofduties/responsibilitiesandscopeof worktobeundertaken byeach
firmalong with resourcescommittedbyeachpartneroftheJV/Association for the
proposed services v. Anundertakingthatthe JVfirmsarejointlyandseverallyliabletotheEmployer for
theperformanceof theservices vi. Theauthorized representativeof thejoint venture/Association
TheAssociation firm shall givea Letter of Association, MOUas in i)tovi aboveexcept v,
letterofAuthorization,copiesofGPA/SPAforthe personsigningthe documentsanda
certificate of incorporation.
1.8.3 In case of Joint venture, one of the firms which preferably have relatively higher
experience,willactastheleadfirmrepresenting theJointVenture.Theduties, responsibilitiesandpowersofsuchleadfirmshallbespecificallyincludedintheMOU /agreement.Itisexpectedthattheleadpartner wouldbe authorizedtoincur liabilitiesand toreceiveinstructionsandpaymentsforandonbehalfoftheJointVenture.Paymentto bemadeto theJVcanalsobemadetotheaccountoftheJV.ForaJVto beeligiblefor bidding,theexperienceof leadpartnerandother partner shouldbeasindicated indata sheet.
1.8.4 A firm can bidforaproject eitheras asoleconsultant orin theform of joint venturewith otherconsultantorinassociationwithany otherconsultant.However,alternative proposalsi.e. one assoleor inJV withotherconsultantandanother inassociation/JV withany otherconsultantforthesame packagewillbesummarily rejected.Insuchcases, allthe involved proposals shall be rejected.
1.9 Pre-proposal conferenceshallbeheld on thedate,time and venuegiven inData Sheet.
1.10 Bid Security
1.10.1 The applicant shall furnish as part ofits Proposal,aBid Securityof Rs 2,00,000 ( Rupeestwo
lakhs only) in the form of a Bank Guarantee issued by one of the Nationalized/ScheduledBanksinIndia infavour of theChairman, National Highway Authority of Indiapayableat New Delhi(the“BidSecurity”)valid for aminimumperiodof150days(i.e.30daysbeyondthevalidityofthebid) fromthelastdateofsubmissionofproposals. ThisBidSecurityisreturnablenotlaterthan30(thirty)days fromthedateofOpeningoftheFinancialproposalsexceptincaseofthetwohighest rankedApplicants. BidSecurity oftheSelectedApplicantandtheSecondrankedTeam shallbereturned, upon theSelected Applicant signingthe Agreement.
1.10.2 AnyBidnot accompaniedbytheBidSecurityoftherequiredvalueandminimum required
validityshallberejected bytheAuthority as non-responsive.
1.10.3 TheNHAI shallnot beliable to payanyinterest on theBid Securityand thesameshallbe
interest free.
8
1.10.4 TheApplicant,bysubmittingitsApplicationpursuanttothisRFP,shallbedeemedto
haveacknowledgedthatwithoutprejudicetotheNHAI's anyotherrightorremedy hereunder
orin law or otherwise, theBid Securityshallbeforfeited and appropriated by
theAuthorityasthemutuallyagreedpre-estimatedcompensationanddamagepayableto
theAuthorityfor,interaliathetime,costandeffortoftheNHAIinregardtoRFP including the
consideration and evaluation of the Proposal under the following conditions:
(a) If an Applicant withdraws its Proposal during the period of its validity as specified
in this RFPandas extended bytheApplicant from timeto time
(b) In thecaseoftheSelectedApplicant,iftheApplicantfailsto reconfirmits commitments
duringnegotiations as required videPara6
(c) In thecaseof aSelectedApplicant, if theApplicant fails to sign theAgreement
2 Documents 2.1 Toenableyoutoprepareaproposal,pleasefindandusetheattacheddocumentslistedin the Data
Sheet.
2.2 ConsultantsrequiringaclarificationofthedocumentsmustnotifytheClient,inwriting,
by11.11.2016 upto 5.00 PM.Any requestforclarificationinwritingorby tele-fax/e-mail mustbesent totheClient’saddressindicatedintheDataSheet.TheClientwillupload replies to pre-bid querieson its website.
2.3 Atanytimebeforethesubmissionofproposals,theClientmay,foranyreason,whether
atitsowninitiativeorinresponsetoaclarificationrequestedbyaConsultingfirm, modify theDocumentsbyamendmentorcorrigendum.Theamendmentwillbeuploaded onNHAI website. TheClientmayatitsdiscretionextendthedeadline for thesubmissionof proposalsandthe sameshallalsobeuploadedonNHAIwebsite.
3. Preparation ofProposal
Theproposal must be prepared in threeparts viz., Part 1: Proofof eligibility Part 2: Technical Proposal Part 3: Financial Proposal
3.1 Document in support ofproofof eligibility
3.1.1 Theminimumessentialrequirementinrespectofeligibilityhasbeenindicatedinthe
DataSheet.Theproposalfounddeficientinany respectoftheserequirementswillnotbe consideredforfurtherevaluation.Thefollowing documentsmustbefurnishedinsupportof proof ofeligibilityas per Formatsgiven in Appendix-II:
(i) Forwarding letterforProofofEligibility inthe Form-E1.
9
(ii) Firm’srelevantexperienceandperformanceforthelast7years:Project sheetsinsupportof relevantexperience asperForm-E2/T3 supportedby the experiencecertificatesfrom clientsinsupportof experienceasspecifiedindata sheetfortheprojectsizepreferably interrainofsimilarnatureasthatofproposed projectshallbesubmitted.Certificateshouldindicateclearly thefirms Design/DPRexperience,in2/4-/6-laning ofhighway,structureslike bridges, Viaducts,tunnels,hillslope stabilization,rockbolting,groundimprovement,etc. Scope of services rendered by the firm should be clearly indicated in the certificateobtainedfromtheclient.TheinformationgiveninFormE2/T3shall alsobe consideredaspart of Technical Proposalandshallbe evaluated accordingly.TheConsultantsarethereforeadvisedtoseecarefully theevaluation criteriafor Technical Proposal and submitthe Project Sheets accordingly.
(iii) Firm’s turnoverforthelast 5 years: Atabular statement as in Form E3 showing
theturnoverofthe applicantfirm(s)for thelastfiveyearsbeginningwiththelast financialyearcertifiedbytheCharteredAccountalongwithcertifiedcopiesof theaudit reportsshallbesubmitted in support ofthe turnover.
(iv) Documentfee:The Consultant who download the RFP document from the website
will be required to pay the non- refundable fee of Rs. 5,000/- at the time of the submission of the Bid proposal, through e-payment gateway. The RFP will be invited through e-tendering portal. Refer Procedure under e-tendering for submission of RFP through e-tendering.
(v) BidSecurity:BankGuaranteeinsupportofbidsecurityforanamountspecified
inDataSheetandhavingvalidity foraminimumperiodof150days(i.e.30days beyond the validityofthe bid),fromthe lastdate of submissionof proposals in the Form E4.
(vi) PowerofAttorneyonastamppaperofRs.100anddulynotarizedauthorizingto submitthe
proposal
(vii) IncaseaJointVenture/Associationoffirms,theproposalshallbeaccompanied
byacertifiedcopyoflegallybindingMemorandumofUnderstanding(MOU)on astamppaperofRs.100,signedbyallfirmstothejointventure/Association as detailed at para1.8.2 above
3.1.2 Theminimumessentialrequirementinrespectofeligibilityhasbeenindicatedinthedata
sheet,theproposalfounddeficientinany respectoftheserequirementswillnotbe considered for further evaluation.
3.2 Technical Proposal
3.2.1 YouareexpectedtoexaminealltermsandinstructionsincludedintheDocuments. Failuretoprovideallrequestedinformationwillbeatyourownriskandmayresultin rejection ofyour proposal.
10
3.2.2 Duringpreparationofthetechnicalproposal,youmustgiveparticularattentiontothe following:
Totalassignmentperiodisasindicatedintheenclosed TOR.Amanningschedule in
respectofrequirement ofkeypersonnelisalsofurnishedintheTORwhichshallbe thebasisofthefinancialproposal.Youshallmakeyourownassessmentofsupport
personnelbothtechnicalandadministrative toundertake theassignment.Additional
supportandadministrative staffneedtobe providedfortimelycompletionoftheproject
withinthetotalestimatedcost.Itisstressedthatthetimeperiodfortheassignment indicated
intheTOR should be strictlyadhered to. 3.2.3 ThetechnicalproposalshallbesubmittedstrictlyintheFormatsgiveninAppendix-III
And shallcomprise offollowingdocuments:
i) ForwardingletterforTechnicalproposaldulysignedbytheauthorizedpersonon behalf
ofthe bidder, as inForm-T-1 ii) DetailsofprojectsforwhichTechnicalandFinancialProposalshavebeensubmitted
byaConsultant with a particularTeam as in Form-T-2 iii) Firm’sreferences-RelevantServicescarriedoutinthelastsevenyearsasperForm- E2/T-
3.ThisinformationsubmittedaspartofProofofEligibility shallbeevaluated and need not be submitted again as apart ofthe Technical proposal
iv) SiteAppreciation:limitedtofourA4sizepagesin1.5spaceand12fontincluding
photographs, if any(Form-T-4). v) CommentsonTermsofReference:limitedtotwoA4sizepagesin1.5spaceand12 font
(Form-T-5). vi) ThecompositionoftheproposedTeamand TaskAssignmenttoindividualpersonnel:
Maximumthreepages(Form-T-6). vii) Proposed methodology for the execution of the services illustrated with bar charts of
activities, including any change proposed in the methodology of services indicated in the TOR, and procedure for quality assurance: Maximum 4 pages (Form-T-7)
viii) The proposal should clearly identify and mention the details of Material Testing lab
facilities to be used by the Consultants for the project (Form-T-8). In this connection, the proposals of the Consultants to use in-house lab facilities up to a distance of maximum 400 kmfromthe project sitebeing feasiblewould be accepted. For all other cases suitable nearby material Testing Laboratory shall be proposed before Contract Agreement is executed.
ix) The proposal shall indicate as to whether the firm is having the facilities for carrying
out the following field activities or these are proposed to be outsourced to specialized agencies in the Form- T-9.
a) Pavement Investigation
11
b) Geo-technical Investigation In case the consultant envisages outsourcing any or all of the above services to the
expert agencies, the details of the same indicating the arrangement made with the agencies need to be furnished. These agencies would however, be subject to approval of the client to ensure quality input by such agencies during technical negotiation before award of the work. For out-sourced services, proposed firms/consultants should have such experience on similar projects
x) Details of office equipment and softwareowned bythe firm in Form-T10 xi) CVs ofKeyPersonnel inForm-T11.
3.2.4 CVs ofKeyPersons:
i) TheCVsofthekeypersonnelintheformatasperFormT-11istobefurnished.It may please beensuredthattheformatisstrictlyfollowedandtheinformation
furnishedthereinistrueandcorrect.TheCVmustindicatetheworkinhandand theduration
till whichthepersonwill berequiredtobe engagedin thatassignment. Experience
certificatesshallalsobesubmitted. If anyinformationisfound incorrect,atany
stage,actionincludingterminationanddebarmentfrom future NHAI/
Ministryprojectsupto2 yearsmaybetakenbyNHAI onthepersonneland the Firm.
ii. No alternative to key personnel may be proposed and only one CV may be submitted
foreachposition. The minimum requirementsofQualificationand
ExperienceofallkeypersonnelarelistedinEnclosure-II ofTOR. CVofaperson
whodoesnotmeetthe minimum experience requirementasgivenatenclosure-II of TOR
shallbe evaluatedandthe marksobtainedshallbe takenintoconsideration
duringevaluationof TechnicalProposal(exceptTeam leader).Howeverifafirm
withsuchkeypersonnelisdeclaredthe “mostpreferredbidder”foraparticular package
,suchkey personnelshouldbe replacedatthe timeofContract
NegotiationswithapersonmeetingrequirementsofQualificationandExperience
asgivenatenclosure-IIof TOR andwhose CVsecures75% marksandabove.Ifa
proposedkeypersonneldoesnotpossessthe minimum(essential) educational
qualificationas givenat enclosure-IIofTOR,Zeromarksshallbeassignedtosuch
CVandsuchCVshallnotbeevaluatedfurther.The CV oftheproposedTeam
Leadershouldscoreatleast75% marksotherwisetheentireproposalshallbe consideredtohavefailedintheevaluationofTechnicalProposalsandshallnot be
considered for opening of FinancialProposals.
iii. TeamLeader,HighwaycumPavementEngineer,BridgeEngineer,Geo-technical cum
materialengineerandSeniorSurvey Engineershouldbeavailable from
beginningoftheproject.3Key PersonnelnamelyEnvironmentalSpecialist,
QuantitySurveyor/DocumentationexpertandTrafficand safetyexpertare
allowedtobedeployed/proposed in2teamsata time.IfsameCV issubmittedby two ormore
firms,zeromarksshallbe givenforsuchCVfor allthefirms.
12
iv. Theavailabilityofkeypersonnelmustbeensuredforthedurationoftheproject
asperproposedwork programme.Ifafirmclaimsthata key personnelproposed
bythemisapermanentemployeeofthefirm(thepersonnelshouldhaveworked
inthefirmcontinuouslyforaperiodofatleast1year) ,acertificatetotheeffect along
withpayslips arerequired to besubmitted.
v. The age limitforkey personnelis70yearsasonthe date ofbidsubmissionexcept
forSeniorsurveyengineerinwhichcasetheagelimitis65years.Theproofof
ageandqualificationof thekeypersonnelmustbefurnishedinthetechnical proposal.
vi. Anundertakingfromthekeypersonnelmustbefurnishedthathe/shewillbe
availableforentiredurationoftheprojectassignmentandwillnot engage
himself/herselfinany otherassignmentduringthe currency ofhis/herassignment on the
project. After the award of work, in case of non-availability of key personnelinspite
ofhis/herdeclaration,he/sheshallbe debarredforaperiodof two years for all projects
ofNHAI and MoRTH
vii. Agelimitforsupportingstafftobedeployedonprojectis65yearsasonthedate of bid
submission.
viii. AgoodworkingknowledgeofEnglishLanguageisessentialforkeyprofessional staff on
this assignment. Studyreports must be in EnglishLanguage.
ix. Photo,contactaddressandphone/mobilenumberofkeypersonnelshouldbe furnished in
theCV.
x. AvailabilityoffewkeypersonnelengagedforpreparationofDetailedProject
Reportfortheenvisagedprojectmay beensuredduringfirst 3to4monthsafter startof
thecivil workatsiteduring theperiodofsurveyandreviewofDPRbythe
Supervisionconsultant/Authority Engineer.Forthispurpose, paymentshallbe made
asperactualsitedeploymentofthe key personnelatthe man monthrates quoted bythe
firm in their financial proposal.
xi. Itmay pleasebenotedthatincasetherequirementofthe‘Experience’ofthe
firm/consortiumasmentionedinthe “ProofofEligibility’is metbyanyforeign
company,theirrealinvolvementforthe intendedprojectshallbe mandatory. This canbe
achievedeitherby includingcertainman-monthsinputofkey experts belongingtothe
parentforeigncompany,orby submittingatleastthe draft feasibility report and draft
DPR dulyreviewed bythe parent firm and theirpaying visittothe site
andinteractingwithNHAI.In case ofkey personnelproposedby
theforeigncompany,theyshouldbeonitspayrollforatleastlastsixmonths (from
thedateof submission).
xii. Incaseafirmisproposingkeypersonnelfromeducational/researchinstitutions,
a‘NoObjectionCertificate’fromtheconcernedinstitutionshouldbe enclosed
withtheCVoftheproposedkey personnelcommittinghisservicesfortheinstant project.
13
xiii) Original Curriculum Vitae (CV) and photocopies of certificates shall be recently
signed in blue ink by the proposed key professional staff on each page and also
initialed by an authorized official of the Firm and each page of the CV must be
signed. The key information shall be as per the format. Photocopy of the CVs will
not be accepted. Unsigned copies of CVs shall be rejected.
3.2.5 Thetechnical proposal must not include anyfinancial information.
3.3 FinancialProposal
3.3.1 TheFinancialproposalshouldincludethecostsassociatedwiththeassignment.These shallnormally cover:remunerationforstaff(foreignandlocal,inthefield,officeetc), accommodation,transportation,equipment,printingof documents,surveys,geotechnical investigationsetc. Thiscostshouldbe brokendown intoforeignandlocalcosts.Your financialproposalshouldbepreparedstrictly using,theformatsattachedinAppendix–
IV.Yourfinancialproposalshouldclearly indicatetheamountaskedforbyyouwithout any assumptions ofconditionsattachedtosuchamounts. Conditional offerorthe proposalnotfurnishedintheformatattachedinAppendix-IVshallbe considerednon- responsive and is liable to berejected.
3.3.2 Thefinancialproposalshalltakeintoaccountalltypesofthetaxliabilitiesandcostof
insurancespecified in theData Sheet.
3.3.3 CostsshallbeexpressedinIndianRupeesincaseofdomesticaswellasforforeign
Consultant.ThepaymentsshallbemadeinIndianRupeesbytheNational Highways Authority of
IndiaandtheConsultantthemselveswouldberequiredtoobtainforeign currency totheextentquotedandacceptedbyNHAI.Rateforforeignexchangefor paymentshallbeattherateestablishedbyRBIapplicableatthetimeofmakingeach paymentinstallmentonitemsinvolving actualtransactioninforeigncurrency.No compensation doneto fluctuation of currencyexchangerateshallbemade.
3.3.4 Consultantsarerequiredtochargeonlyrentalofequipments/software(s)usesoasto economizein
their financial bid.
4 SubmissionofProposals
4.1 The Applicants shall submit the proposal (Proof of Eligibility and Technical Proposal) in
hard bound form with all pages numbered serially and by giving and index of submissions. Applications submitted in other forms like spiral bound form; loose form etc shall be rejected. Copies of Applications shall not be submitted and considered. A Consultant with “a Particular Team” may submit only one hard copy (in original) of “proof ofeligibility (Part 1)” and“TechnicalProposal (Part II)” toNHAI for all thepackagesappliedbythemwithaparticularteamonorbeforethedeadlineofsubmissionofbids.Aconsultantcanapply for aparticularpackage withoneteamonly. The packages forwhich a Consultantwith “a ParticularTeam”applies shouldbeclearlymentionedintheirproposal.However,Consultantsarerequired
14
tosubmitacopyofProofofEligibilityandTechnicalProposalonlineseparatelyforeachpackage. Financialproposal for eachpackagearetobesubmitted separately. Financialproposalareonlyto besubmittedonlineandno hardcopy ofthefinancialproposal shouldbesubmitted.
4.2 You must submit original proposal as indicated in the Data Sheet.“Proof of Eligibility”inoriginal and hardboundshouldbeenclosedinanenvelopewhich shouldbemarkedas “Part-I –ProofofEligibility”.Similarly, “Technical Proposal” inoriginalandhard boundshouldbeenclosedinanenvelopewhichshouldbe markedas“Part-II–TechnicalProposal” TheproposalwillbesealedinanouterenvelopewhichwillbeartheaddressandinformationindicatedintheDataSheetand shall be submittedto NHAIon or before the deadline for submission of bids. The envelope must be clearlymarked:
Consultancy PackageNos. :NHAI/HP Border-Mandi/NH-20/DPR/HP/2016
Project Name:Consultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode
Do not open, except in presenceofthe evaluationcommittee
4.2.1 This outerenvelope will contain three separate envelopes. The first envelope containing
“Proof of Eligibility” (which should be clearly marked), the second envelope containing “Technical Proposal” (which should be clearly marked) and the third envelope containing Bid Security of required amount and validity as mentioned in the RFP and the Proof of Payment of Cost of RFP Document i.e. Rs 5,000/- and Proof of Payment of application processing fees amounting to Rs. 1295/- to M/s. C-1 India Pvt. Ltd.
4.2.2 Theproposalmustbepreparedinindelibleinkandmustbesignedbytheauthorized
representativeoftheconsultants.Theletterofauthorizationmustbeconfirmedby a writtenpowerofattorney accompanying theproposals.AllpagesoftheProofof EligibilityandTechnicalProposalmustbeinitialed by thepersonorpersonssigningthe proposal.
4.3 Theproposal mustcontain no interlineations or overwritingexcept as necessaryto correct
errorsmadeby theConsultantsthemselves,inwhichcasessuchcorrectionsmustbe initialed bythe person orpersons signingthe proposal.
4.4 YourcompletedProofofeligibilityandTechnical proposal(inhardcopy)mustbe
deliveredonorbeforethetimeanddate attheaddressstatedinDataSheet.Proof of Eligibility,TechnicalProposalandFinancialProposalfor each packageshallhavetobe submitted online also on or beforethe time and date at the address stated inData Sheet
4.5 YourproposalmustbevalidforthenumberofdaysstatedintheDataSheetfromthe closingdate of
submission of proposal.
15
5 Proposal Evaluation
5.1 TheproposalswouldbeevaluatedbyaCommitteeconstitutedbyChairman, NHAI.A three-
stageprocedurewillbeadoptedinevaluating theproposal.Inthefirststage-Proof of
Eligibility,itwillbeexamined as to whether:
i) Theproposal is accompanied byDocument fee
ii)The Proposalis accompanied by Bid Securityofrequired value andofvalidity equal or
morethan theminimum required validity
iii) Thefirms(s) haverequired experience
iv) Thefirms(s) have required turnover
v)Thedocuments areproperly signed by the authorizedsignatories andwhetherthe proposal
contains proper POA as mentioned at para1.8.1 above
vi) Theproposals have been received on or before the dead lineof submission.
vii) In casea JointVenture/Associationoffirms,theproposalshallbe accompanied by a
certified copyoflegally bindingMemorandumofUnderstanding(MOU)onastamp
paperofRs.100,signed by allfirmstothejointventure/Association asdetailed atpara
1.8.2 above
Incaseanswerstoany oftheaboveitemsis‘No’thebidshallbedeclaredasnon- responsive and
shallnotbe evaluated further.
AConsultantsatisfyingtheminimumEligibility CriteriaasmentionedintheDatasheet andwho
hadsubmitted the above mentioned documentsshallbe declared“pass” in Proof ofEligibility
andtheTechnicalProposalsofonlythoseconsultantsshallbeopenedand evaluated further.
5.2 In the second stage the Technical proposal shall be evaluated as per the detailed
evaluation criteriagivenin Data Sheet.
Aproposalsecuring 75pointsshallbedeclaredpassintheevaluationofTechnical Proposal.The
technical proposalshouldscore at least 75 points out of100to be
consideredforfinancialevaluation.TheCVoftheproposedTeamLeadershould
scoreatleast75%marksotherwisetheentireproposalshall beconsideredto have
failedinthe evaluationofTechnicalProposalsandshallnotbe consideredforopening of
Financial Proposals.
5.3 Evaluation ofFinancialProposal
5.3.1 In caseforaparticularpackage, onlyonefirmiseligiblefor openingofFinancial
Proposals,theFinancialProposalshallnotbeopened,thebidsfor that packageshallbe
16
cancelledandNHAIshallinvitefreshbidsforthis package.Forfinancialevaluation,total
costoffinancialproposalexcluding ServiceTaxshallbeconsidered.ServiceTaxshallbe payable
extra.
5.3.2 The evaluation committee will determine whether the financial proposals are
complete (i.e.whetherthey haveincludedcostofallitemsofthecorrespondingproposals
;ifnot,thentheircostwillbeconsideredasNIL buttheconsultantshallhoweverbe
requiredtocarry outsuchobligationswithoutanycompensation.Incase,ifclientfeels thatthe
work cannotbe carried outwithinoverallcostof financialproposal,the proposal
canberejected.Theclientshallcorrectanycomputationalerrorsandcorrectpricesin
variouscurrenciestothesinglecurrencyspecifiedinDataSheet.Theevaluationshall exclude
those taxes,duties,fees,leviesandotherchargesimposed underthe applicable law&applied to
foreigncomponents/ resident consultants.
5.3.3 For a package, the procedure as mentioned at Clauses 5.3.4, 5.4 and, 5.5 as mentioned
below shall be followed for determining the “most preferred bidder (H-1 bidder)” for this
package.
5.3.4The lowestfinancialproposal(FM)willbegivenafinancialscore(SF) of 100points.The financial scores of otherproposals will be computed as follows:
SF=100xFM/F (SF=FinancialScore,FM=Amountoflowestbid,F=Amountoffinancialproposal converted in thecommon currency)
5.4 CombinedevaluationofTechnicalandFinancialProposals.Proposalswillfinallybe
rankedaccordingtotheircombinedtechnical(ST)andFinancial(SF)scoresusingthe weights
indicated in theData Sheet:
S=STxT +SFxf Where, S=CombinedScore, ST=Technical Scoreoutof 100 SF=FinancialScore out of 100
Tandfarevaluesofweightagefortechnicalandfinancialproposalsrespectivelyas given in the
Data Sheet.
5.5 Foraparticularpackage,aConsultantwitha“particularTeam”havingthemaximum
Combined score (S) shallbedeclared as themostpreferred bidder(H-1).
5.6 In case work has to be awarded for multiple packages,
awardofworktoaConsultantwith“aParticularTeam”eitherassoleorasin
17
JV/Associationshallbelimitedtoonepackageonly.At first,Consultants whobecome H-1inone package eachshall be assignedthe respectivepackage.Then packagesin whichaConsultant with“aParticularTeam”turnsoutto be themost preferred bidder (H-1)inmorethanone package shall be considered.Incase,a Consultantwith“aParticularTeam” turnsouttobethemostpreferredbidder(H-1)inmorethanonepackage,thepackagewhichistobeawardedtothisteam ofa consultantshall be determinedonthe basisofleast costtoNHAIconsideringthe FinancialQuoteofH-1 bidderandH-2Bidder limitedtothosepackages.Procedure to be followed forawarding workbasedonQCBSincludingassessmentofleastcost toNHAIunderspecialcircumstancesi.e.WhenaConsultant with“aParticular Team” turnsout to be the most preferred bidder (H-1) inmore thanone package is given at givenat Annex-II.
6 Negotiations
6.1 Prior to the expiration period of proposal validity, the Client will notify the most
preferredConsultant/Bidderi.e.thehighestrankingconsultantinwritingbyregistered letter, e-mail, or facsimile and invite him to negotiatethe Contract.
6.2 Beforethestartofnegotiations,themost preferredConsultant/Bidder(H-1)shallbe
askedtogivejustificationforthecostquotedbythemtothefullsatisfactionof NHAI.
Eachkey personnelofthepreferredconsultantshallbecalledforinterviewatthetimeof negotiation at thecost ofconsultant beforethe award ofwork.
6.3 Negotiationsnormallytaketwotothreedays.Theaimistoreachagreementonallpoints and initial a draft contract bythe conclusion ofNegotiations.
6.4 Negotiations willcommencewithdiscussionontechnicalproposal, theproposed
methodology(workplan),staffingandanysuggestionsmadetoimprovetheTOR,the staffing andbar charts,whichwillindicateactivities, periodsinthe field andinthe home office,staffmonths, logistics andreporting.Thefinancialproposal issubject to rationalization.Specialattentionwillbepaidtooptimizetherequiredoutputsfromthe Consultantswithintheavailablebudgetandtodefineclearly theinputsrequiredfromthe Client to ensuresatisfactoryimplementation of theAssignment.
6.5 Changesagreeduponwillthenbereflectedinthefinancialproposalusingproposedunit rates. 6.6 Having selected Consultants, among other things, on the basis of an evaluation of
proposedkey professionalstaff,theClientexpectstonegotiate,withintheproposal validity period,acontractonthebasisofthestaffnamedintheproposaland,priorto contractnegotiations,willrequireassurancesthatthestaffwillbeactually available.The Clientmayasktogiveareplacement forthekeyprofessional who hasscoredless than75%marksbya personofatleast 75%score.Noreductioninremuneration would bemadeonaccount ofabove change.
TheClientwillnotconsidersubstitutionsduring contractnegotiationsexceptincasesof
18
incapacity ofkey personnelforreasonsofhealth.Similarly,afterawardofcontractthe Clientexpectsalloftheproposedkeypersonneltobeavailableduringimplementationof thecontract.Theclientwillnotconsidersubstitutionsduring contractnegotiations/ contractimplementationexceptunderexceptionalcircumstances.Forthereasonother thandeath/extrememedicalground,wherereplacementisproposedbytheConsultant duetononavailabilityoftheoriginallyproposedkey personnelorincaseswhere replacementhasbecomenecessaryas akeypersonnelproposedbytheConsultanthas beenfoundtobeunsuitablefortheprojectbyNHAIduringcontract negotiations/ contractimplementation,thefollowing shallapply (i)fortotalreplacementupto33%of keypersonnel,remunerationshallbereducedby5%(ii)fortotalreplacementbetween 33%to50%,remunerationshallbereducedby10%(iii)fortotalreplacementbeyond 50%and66%remunerationshallbereducedby15%(iv)fortotalreplacementbeyond 66%ofthetotalkey personnel,theClientmayinitiateactionfordebarmentofsuch consultantforfutureprojectsofMoRTH/ NHAIforaperiodof6months to24 months. Iffor anyreasonbeyondthe reasonable controlofthe consultants, it becomes necessarytoreplaceanyofthepersonnel,theconsultantsshallforthwithprovideas a replacement a personofequivalent orbetter qualificationandexperience.
6.7 The negotiations will be concluded with a review of the draft Contract Agreement
attachedatAppendix-V.The ClientandtheConsultantswillfinalize the contractto conclude negotiations.
6.8 IfaConsultantfailstoconcludethenegotiationswithNHAIorincaseaconsultant withdrawswithoutstarting /completingthe negotiationswith NHAI, itshallattract penalty–encashment ofBid Securitysubmitted bythe Consultant
7 PerformanceSecurity
Theconsultantwillfurnishwithin15daysoftheissueofLetterofAcceptance (LOA),an unconditionalBankGuaranteefromaNationalisedBank,IDBI orICICI/ICICI Bank/ForeignBank/EXIMBank/AnyScheduledCommercialBankapprovedbyRBI having anetworthofnotlessthan500croreasperlatestAnnualReportoftheBank. In thecaseofaForeignBank(issuedbyaBranchinIndia)thenetworthinrespectof Indianoperationsshallonlybetakenintoaccount. IncaseofForeignBank,theBG issuedby ForeignBankshouldbecounterguaranteedby any NationalisedBankinIndia. IncaseofJV,theBGshallbefurnishedonbehalfofthe JVorbytheleadmemberofthe JVsforanamountequivalentto10%ofthetotalcontractvaluetobereceivedby him towardsPerformanceSecurity validforaperiodofthreeyearsbeyondthedateof completion ofservices, or end of civil works contract, whichever earlier.TheBankGuaranteewillbereleased by NHAIuponexpiry of3years beyondthe date ofcompletionofservices, or end of civil works contract, whichever earlier, providedrectificationof errorsif any, foundduringimplementationofthe contractfor civil workandsatisfactory report byNHAIinthis regardisissued.IfaConsultantfailstosubmitthe Performance Security (asspecifiedabove),itshallattractpenalty–encashment ofBidSecurity submitted bytheConsultant
8. Penalty
19
Theconsultantwillindemnifyforanydirectlossordamagethataccrueduetodeficiency inservicesincarryingoutDetailedProjectReport.Penalty shallbeimposedonthe consultantsforpoorperformance/deficiencyinserviceasexpectedfromtheconsultant and as stated in GeneralConditions of Contract.
9. AwardofContract
AftersuccessfulNegotiationswiththeselectedConsultanttheClientshallissueletterof awardandasktheConsultanttoprovide Performance Security asinPara 7above.If negotiations(asperpara 6above)failortheselectedConsultantfailtoprovide performance security within the prescribed time or the Consultant fail to sign the ContractAgreementwithinprescribedtimetheClientmay invitethe 2ndhighestranking bidderConsultant for Contract negotiations and follow theprocedureoutlined in Para6,9 and 10 ofthisLetter ofInvitation.
10. Signing ofContract Agreement
Afterhavingreceivedtheperformancesecurity andverifiedit,theClientshallinvitethe selectedbidderforsigning ofContractAgreementonadateandtimeconvenienttoboth parties within 15 days ofreceiptof valid PerformanceSecurity.
11. TheClientshallkeepthebiddersinformedduringtheentirebiddingprocessandshall host the followinginformation on its website:
i) NoticeInvitingTender (NIT) ii) Request For Proposal (RFP) iii) Replies to pre-bid queries, if any
iv) Amendments/corrigendum to RFP v) Listof bidderswho submitted the bids up to the deadlineof submission vi) List of bidders who did not pass the eligibility requirements, stating the broad deficiencies vii) Listof bidderswho did not pass the Technical Evaluation statingthe reasons. viii) Listof biddersalong with thetechnical score, who qualified foropeningthefinancial bid ix) Final Scoreof qualified bidders x) Name ofthe bidders whois awarded theContract
12. Confirmation
Wewouldappreciateyouinformingusbyfacsimile/e-mailwhetherornotyouwill submit a
proposal.
Thankingyou.
Encl. as above
20
Y
o
u
r
s
s
i
n
c
e
r
e
l
y
,
National
H
i
g
h
w
a
ys Authority of
India
G5&6, Sector-10, Dwarka-New Delhi
21
Annex-1
Details ofthe stretch proposed forDPR preparation
S. No.
NHNo.
Section
State
Tentative Length (inkm)
PackageNo.
1 2 3 4 5 6
1 20 HP/Punjab Border to Mandi HP 197 km NHAI/HP Border-Mandi/NH-20/DPR/HP/2016
22
Annex-II
ProcedureofAwardingWork basedonQCBSincluding Assessment ofLeast Cost to NHAIunderSpecialCircumstances i.e. Whena Consultant with a particular teambecomes H-1 bidderinmorethanonepackage
A Consultant witha particular Team canapply forany numberofpackageswithone team.However,Awardof worktoaConsultantwith“aParticularTeam”eitherassoleoras in JV/Association shallbelimitedto one package only. Following procedure shallbe followed forthe selection of themostpreferredbidder for theconsultancyassignment:
1. Atfirst,ConsultantswhobecomeH-1inonepackageeachshallbeassignedthe respectivepackage.ThenpackagesinwhichaConsultantwith“aParticularTeam”turns outtobethe mostpreferredbidder(H-1)inmorethanonepackageshallbeconsidered.In case,aConsultantwith“a ParticularTeam”turnsouttobethe mostpreferredbidder(H-1)in more thanonepackage,thepackagewhichisto beawardedtothisteamofaconsultantshall bedeterminedonthebasisofleastcostto NHAI considering theFinancialQuoteofH-1 bidder andH-2Bidder limited tothosepackageswhichshallbe workedoutasper procedure illustrated with an example as mentioned below.
2. Supposethereare8packagesnamelyPackage-1,Package-2,Package-3,Package-4,Package-5,package-6,package-7andPackage-8respectively.Itisalsoassumedthat10 consultantsnamely P,Q,R,S,T,U,V,W,XandYhasappliedforthesepackages.Itisalso assumedthatthreeConsultantsnamely P,RandUhasappliedwithtwoTeamsandthe remainingConsultantshaveappliedwithonly oneteam.Itisalsoassumedthatthefollowing isthepositionofvarious firmsafteropening oftheFinancialproposals(andafter arithmetic corrections if anyof theFinancial bids) ofthepackages and afterapplying QCBS
H-1 H-2 H-3 H-4 H-5 H-6
Package no. Name ofConsultants and Financial Quotes (Rsin lakhs)
Package-1 P(team-1) Q W X T Y
230 lakhs 200 lakhs 240 lakhs 220 lakhs 200 lakhs 230 lakhs
Package-2 V U(team-1) X P(team-2) T Y
240 lakhs 210 lakhs 240 lakhs 220 lakhs 200 lakhs 230 lakhs
Package-3 V P(team-1) U(team-1) R (team-2) X Y
200 lakhs 230 lakhs 250 lakhs 230 lakhs 220 lakhs 200 lakhs
Package-4 R (team-1) T U (team-2) P(team-2) Y X
250 lakhs 220 lakhs 250 lakhs 260 lakhs 220 lakhs 245 lakhs
Package-5 R (team-1) V S U(team-2) W T
220 lakhs 240 lakhs 260 lakhs 250 lakhs 220 lakhs 240 lakhs
Package-6 Q T S P(team-2) W U (team-2)
210 lakhs 240 lakhs 250 lakhs 220 lakhs 200 lakhs 230 lakhs
Package-7 R (team-1) U (team-1) Q S W Y
200 lakhs 220 lakhs 240 lakhs 255 lakhs 230 lakhs 240 lakhs
Package-8 V R(team-1) W S P(team-1) Y
190 lakhs 250 lakhs 220 lakhs 240 lakhs 255 lakhs 240 lakhs
23
Thedifferent packages shallbe awarded to consultants as mentioned below
2.1 Step-1 : Inthiscase,ConsultantsP(team-1)andQaretheH-1inonlyonepackageeachnamely package-1andpackage-6respectively.ConsultantVisH-1in3packagesnamely Package-2, Package-3and Package-8 respectively. ConsultantR(team-1) isH-1 in3 packagesnamely Package-4, Package-5 and Package-7respectively. SinceConsultantP(team-1)isH-1inPackage-1only andConsultantQisH-1in Package-6only,ConsultantP(team-1)shallbeawardedPackage-1andConsultantQ shall beawardedPackage-6.
2.2 Step-2: AfterConsultantP (team-1)isawardedPackage-1andConsultantQisawarded Package-6,the scenario for theremaining6 packagesisasgiven below.P (team-1) andQ occurring anywhereelsestands deleted as theyhave alreadybeenawardedonework each
H-1 H-2 H-3 H-4 H-5 H-6
PackageNo. Name ofConsultants and Financial Quotes (Rsin lakhs)
Package-2 V U(team-1) X P(team-2) T Y
240 lakhs 210 lakhs 240 lakhs 220 lakhs 200 lakhs 230 lakhs
Package-3 V U(team-1) R (team-2) X Y
200 lakhs 250 lakhs 230 lakhs 220 lakhs 200 lakhs
Package-4 R (team-1) T U (team-2) P(team-2) Y X
250 lakhs 220 lakhs 250 lakhs 260 lakhs 220 lakhs 245 lakhs
Package-5 R (team-1) V S U (team-2) W T
220 lakhs 240 lakhs 260 lakhs 250 lakhs 220 lakhs 240 lakhs
Package-7 R (team-1) U (team-1) S W Y
200 lakhs 220 lakhs 255 lakhs 230 lakhs 240 lakhs
Package-8 V R(team-1) W S Y
190 lakhs 250 lakhs 220 lakhs 240 lakhs 240 lakhs
ConsultantV s h a l l beawardedonlyonepackageoutofthe3packagesforwhichitisH-1 namelyPackage-2,Package-3andPackage-8respectively.SimilarlyConsultantR(team-1) Shallbeawardedonly onepackageoutofthe3packagesforwhichitisH-1 namelyPackage-4,Package-5andPackage-7respectively.Thedeterminationofpackageto be awardedtoConsultantV andConsultantR(team-1) shallbe workedoutina single step (i.e.oneatatime).NewH-1fortheremaining packages(4packages)shallbeworkedout only afterdeterminationofpackagestobeawardedtothe H-1biddersatthisstage[i.e. ConsultantVandR(Team-1)intheinstantcase]inonestep.DeterminationofPackageto be awardedtoeachofConsultantVandConsultantR(team-1)shallbeworkedoutas follows
(i)After the award of Package-1 to Consultant –P (team-1) and Package -6 to Consultant–Qandalsoconsidering thataConsultantwitha particularteamcanbeawarded onlyonework,thedetailsofH-1andH-2/NewH-2 intheremaining6packagesareasmentionedbelow.SinceVisH-1inmorethanonepackageandshallbeawarded oneofthesepackages,Vhasbeendeletedfrom
24
allotherpackages.Similarly,since R(Team-1) inmorethanonepackageandshallbeawardedoneofthesepackages,R (Team-1) has been deleted fromallotherpackages
<
H-1 H-2/New H-2
Remarks
Package-2 V U(team-1)
240 lakhs 210 lakhs
Package-3 V U(team-1) Since Consultant P( Team-1) is awarded Package-1, Consultant U(team-1) becomes thenewH-2
200 lakhs 250 lakhs
Package-4 R (team-1) T
250 lakhs 220 lakhs
Package-5 R (team-1) S
220 lakhs 260 lakhs
Package-7 R (team-1) U (team-1)
200 lakhs 220 lakhs
Package-8 V W Consultant-R(team-1)hasnotbeenconsidered asH-2since Consultant–C(team-1) istobe awardedone package outofthepackages4,5 and 7 inwhich itisH-1. HenceConsultant– W is thenew H-2
190 lakhs 220 lakhs
(ii) Packagetobeawarded toConsultant–VwhoisH-1inthreepackagesnamelyPackage- 2,3and8respectively shallbedeterminedonthebasisofleastcosttoNHAIconsideringthe FinancialQuote ofH-1bidder andH-2BidderlimitedtothosepackagesThe situationfor leastcosttoNHAIshallbe whenthefirmwith Consultant–Gisawardedthepackagefor which Financial Bidof secondrankedteam(H-2) minusFinancialBidofthefirstrankedteam (H-1) ismaximum.Thesame is illustrated as given below
H-1 H-2 / New H-2
FinancialBidofH-2/ New H-2 minus FinancialBid of H-1
Remarks
Package-2 V U(team-1) 210-240 = (-) 30 lakhs
240 lakhs 210 lakhs
Package-3 V U(team-1) 250 – 200 =(+) 50 lakhs
H-2 minus H-1 is Maximum. Hence Consultant V shallbe awardedPackage-3
200 lakhs 250 lakhs
Package-8 V W 220 – 190 = (+) 30 lakhs
25
Ina similar way,Package to be awarded toConsultant–R(team-1) whoisH-1in three packages namelyPackage-4,5and7respectivelyshall be determinedasillustrated below:
H-1 H-2 / New H-2
FinancialBidofH-2/ New H-2 minus FinancialBid of H-1
Remarks
Package-4 R (team-1) T 220-250 = (-) 30 lakhs
250 lakhs 220 lakhs
Package-5 R (team-1) S 260 – 220 =(+) 40 lakhs
H-2 minus H-1 is Maximum.Hence Consultant – R (team- 1) shall beawarded
Package-5
220 lakhs 260 lakhs
Package-7 R (team-1) U (team-1) 220 – 200 = (+) 20 lakhs
200 lakhs 220 lakhs
2.3Step-3
(i) Aftertheawardoftheabovementioned4packagesnamely,Package-1toConsultant–P(team-1),Package-6toConsultant–Q,Package-3toConsultant–V,Package-5to Consultant–R(team-1)andalsoconsidering thataConsultantwitha particularteamcanbe awardedonly onework,thedetailsof newH-1andNewH-2 intheremaining4 packages areasmentioned below
H-1 (New H-1)
H-2 (New H-2)
Remarks
Package-2 U(team-1) X Since Consultant V is awarded Package-3 , ConsultantU(team-1)becomesthenewH-1 andConsultant Xbecomes the newH-2
210 lakhs 240 lakhs
Package-4 T U (team-2) Since Consultant -R(team-1) is awarded Package-5 , Consultant Tbecomes the new H-1andConsultant U (team-2) becomesthe newH-2
220 lakhs 240 lakhs
Package-7 U (team-1) S Since Consultant R(team-1) is awarded Package-5,Consultant U (team-1) becomes the newH-1andConsultant Sbecomesthe newH-2
220 lakhs 255 lakhs
Package-8 W S Since Consultant V is awarded Package-3 , Consultant W becomes the new H-1 and Consultant S becomes thenewH-2
220 lakhs 240 lakhs
(ii)Consultant T is the new H-1 for only one package namely Package-4. Similarly
ConsultantWisthenewH-1foronlyonepackagenamelyPackage-8.AccordinglyPackage
- 8 shall beawardedtoConsultant–W and Package -4 shall beawardedto Consultant–T.
2.4Step-4:
26
ConsultantU (team-1)isthenewH-1forpackage-2andPackage-7respectivelyand
ConsultantU(team-1)shallbeawardedonlyonepackageoutofthis2packages.Package to be
awardedto Consultant –U (team-1) shall bedeterminedas illustrated below
H-1 H-2 / New H-2
FinancialBidofH-2/ New H-2 minus FinancialBid of H-1
Remarks
Package-2 U(team-1) X 240-210 = (+) 30 lakhs
210 lakhs 240 lakhs
Package-7 U (team-1) S 255 – 220 =(+) 35 lakhs
H-2 minus H-1 is Maximum. Hence
Consultant – U (team- 1) shall beawarded Package-7
220 lakhs 255 lakhs
2.5 Step-5 :
(i) Aftertheawardoftheabovementioned7packagesnamely,Package-1toConsultant
–P(team-1),Package-6toConsultant–Q,Package-3toConsultant–V ,Package-5to
Consultant–R(team-1),Package-4toConsultant-T,Package-8toConsultant-W,package
-7toConsultant–U(team-1)team andalsoconsideringthataConsultantwithaparticular
teamcanbeawardedonly onework,thedetailsofnewH-1and/NewH-2 inthe remaining
packagei.e. package-2 is as mentioned below
H-1 (New H-1)
H-2 (New H-2)
Remarks
Package-2 X A (team-2) Since Consultant V is awarded Package-3 and ConsultantU(team-1)isawardedpackage-7 , Consultant X becomesthe newH-1and Consultant P(team-2) becomes the newH-2
240 lakhs 220 lakhs
(ii)ConsultantXisthenewH-1foronlyonepackagenamelyPackage-2.Accordingly,Package-2 shall
beawardedto Consultant–X.
3. Thus as per the above mentioned procedure the 8 packages are awarded to the following
27
Consultant attheFinancialQuoted (afterarithmeticCorrections) by themfor the
respectivepackages
PackageNo. Name ofConsultants awarded packages
Package-1 Consultant-P(team-1)
Package-2 Consultant-X
Package-3 Consultant- V
Package-4 Consultant-T
Package-5 Consultant-R (team-1)
Package-6 Consultant-Q
Package-7 Consultant- U (team-1)
Package-8 Consultant- W
DATA SHEET
28
I(References to correspondingparagraphs ofLOI arementionedalongside) 1. TheNameoftheAssignment a n d descriptionofprojectasmentionedinAnnex-I(Ref.
Para1.1)
(TheNameofprojectandPackageNo.shouldbeindicatedintheformatgiveninthe technical proposal)
2. Thenameofthe Clientis: Chairman
National Highways Authority of India G5&6, Sector-10, Dwarka New Delhi-110075
3. Duration ofthe Project: 8 months
4. Date, TimeandVenueofPre-Proposal Conference
Date: 15.11.2016 Time: 3.00 PM Venue: National Highways Authority of India G5&6, Sector-10 Dwarka-New Delhi-110075, India (Ref. Para 1.9)
5. TheDocuments are: i. Appendix-I: Terms ofReference(TOR) ii) Appendix-II Formats forProof ofEligibility iii. Appendix-III: Formats forTechnical Proposal iv. Appendix-IV: Formats forFinancial Proposal v. Appendix-VI Draft Contract Agreement
(Ref. Para2.1)
6. Bid Security:Rs 2.0 Lakhs (RefPara 1.10) 7. Tax andInsurance (Ref. Para3.3.2)
(i). TheConsultantsandtheirpersonnelshallpayalltaxes(includingservicetax),custom
duties,fees,leviesandother impositionsleviedunderthelawsprevailing seven days beforethelastdateofsubmissionofthebids.Theeffectsofanyincrease/decreaseof any typeoftaxesleviedby theGovernmentshallbeborneby theClient/Consultant,as appropriate.
29
(ii). LimitationsoftheConsultant’sLiabilitytowardstheClientshallbeasperClause3.4of Draft Contract Agreement
(iii). Therisk and coverageshallbe as per Clause3.5 of Draft Contract Agreement.
8. Thenumberofcopies ofthe proposalrequiredto be submitted:1 no. (ref. para4.1)
9. The address is---(Ref.para4.2)
Nishoo Gupta,
GeneralManager (T) - HP
NationalHighwaysAuthorityofIndia
G-5&G-6,Sector10,Dwarka NewDelhi110075.
(Tel:-011-25074100/4200Ext.-1321)
(E-mail: [email protected]) The envelopes mustbeclearlymarked:
i. Original Proposal;
ii. Documents in proof of eligibility and technical proposal as appropriate; and,
iii. Do not open,except in presence of the evaluat ion committeeon the outer envelope.
iv. ConsultancyPackageNo.:NHAI/HP Border-Mandi/NH-20/DPR/HP/2016
v. Project Name: Consultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed
Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km
11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid
Annuity/EPC mode
vi. Name and Address of Consultant
10. Thedate, time and Address of proposal submission are
Date 30.11.2016 Time upto 11.00 AM Address National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) G-5&6, Sector-10 Dwarka-New Delhi-10075
(Ref. Para4.4)
11. Proposal Validityperiod(Numberof days): 120 days (Ref. Para4.5)
12. Evaluation criteria: (Ref. Para3&5)
12.1 First stage evaluation– eligibilityrequirement. (Ref. Para3.1&5.1)
30
Table-1: MinimumEligibility Requirements
S.No. Minimum experience and performance of
PreparationofDPRofHighways/Bridgesin the
last7years(NH/SH/Equivalent) (for past
performance attachundertaking for any
litigation history/ andarbitration).
Annual averageturnover
1 A Firm applying for a package should have Experience of preparationof Detailed Project Reportoffour/sixlane/Feasibility of four/sixlane projectsofaggregate lengthequalto the indicative lengthof the package(i.e.197 km).Firmshouldhave alsopreparedDPRfor atleast oneprojectof4/6laning ofminimum79 kmor Feasibility Study offour/six laning of minimum118 km.
Note:The experience ofa firminpreparationof
DPRfor a privateconcessionaire/contractorshall not
be considered
Annual average turnover for
last3yearsof thefirmshould be
equaltoor morethan Rs.5.00
Crores.
i) Thesole applicant shall fulfillalltherequirementsgiven in Table-1. (ii) IncaseofJV,theLeadPartnershouldfulfill atleast75%ofalleligibility requirements andthe other
partner shall fulfill at least 50% of all eligibility requirements.
(iii)Iftheapplicantfirmhas/havepreparedtheDPR/FSprojectssolelyonitsown, 100%weightageshallbegiven.IftheapplicantfirmhaspreparedtheDPR/FSprojects asa leadpartner ina
JV, 75% weightage shallbegiven.If theapplicantfirmhave preparedtheDPRprojectsastheotherpartner(notleadpartner) inaJV50%weightage shallbegiven.IftheapplicantfirmhavepreparedtheDPR/FSprojectsasanassociate,
25%weightageshallbegiven.
31
12.2 Secondstagetechnicalevaluation(Refer 5.2)
S.No. Description Points
1 Firm's relevant experience in last 7 years 20
2 Adequacy of approach and methodology 5
3 Material testing, survey & investigation, equipment and software proposed to be used
15
4 Qualification and relevant experience of the proposed key personnel
60
Total 100
Further break-up of each criteria has been detailed out below: A. Firm's relevant experience in last 7 years
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
1 Specific experience of the DPR consultancy related
to the assignment for eligibility
10
1.1 Aggregate Length of DPR / Feasibility study of 4/ 6
lane projects
5
1.1.1 More than the indicative Length of the package
applied for
3
1.1.2 More than 2 times the indicative length of the
package applied for
4
1.1.3 More than 3 times the indicative length of the
package applied for
5
1.2 DPR for 4/6 laning projects each equal to or more
than 40 % of indicative length of a package
applied for (or Feasibility Study for 4/6 laning
projects each equal to or more than 60 % of
indicative length of a package applied for)
5
1.2.1 1 project 3
1.2.2 2 projects 4
1.2.3 3 or more projects 5
32
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
2 DPR of Bridge having length more than 200 m 3
2.1 1 bridge 0
2.2 2 bridges 1
2.3 3 bridges 2
2.4 4 or more bridges 3
3 Specific experience of firms in terms of turnover 3
3.1 Firm’s Average Turnover of last 5 years >= 10 crore 3
3.2 Firm Average Turnover of last 5 years > = 5 crore
but < 10 crore
2
3.3 Firm Average Turnover of last 5 years < 5 crore 0
4 DPR for special category projects (Tunnels) 4
4.1 DPR of number of Tunnels (Minimum 200 mtr
Length)
4
4.1.1 1 project 0
4.1.2 2 projects 1
4.1.3 3 projects 2
4.1.4 4 projects 3
4.1.5 5 or more projects 4
Note: In case feasibility study is a part of DPR services the experience shall be counted in
DPRonly. In case bridge is included as part of DPR of highway the experience will be (1) and (2)
B. Adequacy of approach and methodology
S.No Description Points
1 Site appreciation 1
33
2 Comments on TOR 1
3 Team composition and task assignment 1
4 Methodology* 2
Total 5 *Higher marks for adoption of superior technology in data collection, processing and report may be given. Documents for association with vendors supplying LiDAR or better technology and GPR/ Induction Locator or better technology shall be furnished. C. Material testing, survey and investigation, equipment and software proposed to be used
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
1 Availability of in-house material testing facility 2
1.1 Available 2
1.2 Outsourced/ Not Available 0
2 Field Investigation Facilities 1
2.1 Available (Created in-house at site) 1
2.2 Outsourced/ Not Available 0
3 Office Equipment and Software 2
3.1 High Level (More than 75% as per ToR requirement) 2
3.2 Medium Level (Between 75%-50% as per ToR
requirement)
1
3.3 Low Level (Less than 50% as per ToR requirement) 0
4 Experience in LiDAR or better technology for
topographic survey (Infrastructure sector)
4
4.1 1-2 projects 1
4.2 3-5 projects 2
4.3 6-10 projects 3
4.4 >10 projects 4
5 Experience in using GPR and Induction Locator 3
34
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
or better technologies for detection of sub-surface
utilities (Infrastructure sector)
5.1 1-2 projects 1
5.2 3-5 projects 2
5.3 >5 projects 3
6 Experience in digitization of cadastral maps for
land surveys
3
6.1 Project of area upto 100 ha 1
6.2 Project of area between 100 - 500 ha 2
6.3 Project of area more than 500 ha 3
D. Qualification and relevant experience of the proposed key personnel The weightage for various key staff is as under:
S.No Key personnel Points
1 Team Leader- Senior Highway Engineer 13
2 Senior Bridge Engineer 9
3 Highway cum Pavement Engineer 9
4 Material-cum-Geo-technical Engineer- Geologist 9
5 Traffic and Safety Expert 7
6 Senior Survey Engineer 5
7 Environment Specialist 5
8 Quantity Surveyor/Documentation Expert 3
Total 60
The number of points assigned during the evaluation of qualification and competence of key staff are as given below:
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
1 General Qualification 25
35
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
1.1 Essential education qualification 20
1.2 Desirable education qualification 5
2 Relevant experience and adequacy for the project 65
2.1 Total professional experience 15
(max)
2.1 Experience in Highway Projects
(Bridge Projects for Senior Bridge
Engineer )
25
(max)
2.2 Experience in Similar Capacity 25
(max)
3 Employment with the Firm 10
3.1 Less than 1 year 0
3.2 1 year to 2 years 5
3.3 > 2 years 10
12.3 Detailedevaluationcriteriawhichistobeusedforevaluationoftechnicalbidsisas indicatedat Appendix-V.
The Consultant should carryout self-evaluationbased on the evaluationcriteriaat Appendix-V.Whilesubmittingtheself-evaluationalongwithbid,Consultantshallmake referencestothedocumentssubmittedintheirproposalwhichhavebeenrelieduponin self-evaluation Result of technical evaluation shall be made available on the website giving opportunity to the bidders to respondwithin7daysincasetheyhaveany objection
12.4 Third stage – EvaluationofFinancial proposal FinancialProposalsofallQualifiedConsultantsinaccordancewithclause5.2and5.3ofLetter ofInvitation shallbeopened. Theconsultancyserviceswillbeawardedtotheconsultantscoringhighestmarksincombined evaluation of Technical and Financial proposals in accordancewith clause1.3 and 5.4 hereof.
36
The Factors are: Theweightgiven to Technical Proposal (T) =0.80 Theweightgiven to Financial Proposal(f) =0.20 13. The common currencyis“IndianRupee”. (Ref. Para3.3.3)
Consultanthavetoquotein Rupeesboth fordomesticConsultantas well as Foreign Consultants
14. CommencementofAssignment(Date,Location): TheConsultantsshallcommencethe
Serviceswithinfifteendaysofthedateofeffectivenessofthecontractatlocationsas required for
theproject stretch stated in TOR.(Ref. Para1.2 ofLOIand 2.3of GCC/SC)
37
APPENDIXI
TERMSOFREFERENCE (TOR)
Consultancy ServicesforPreparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode
38
Terms ofReferenceforConsultancy Services (TOR) 1. General
1.1 TheNational Highways Authority of India(NHAI) hasbeenentrustedwith theassignmentofConsultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode.NHAInowinvitesproposalfrom Technicalconsultantsforcarrying outdetailedprojectreport as per details given inAnnexure-1.
1.2 NHAIwillbetheemployerandexecutingagencyfortheconsultancyservicesandthe
standardsofoutputrequiredfromtheappointedconsultantsare ofinternationallevelboth in terms ofqualityandadherenceto theagreed time schedule.
1.3 MinistryhasrecentlyawardedworksofconsultancyservicesforconstructionofROBs for
replacing levelcrossingsinvariousstates.Incasealevelcrossingexistsinaproject reach,consultantisrequiredtoco-ordinatewiththoseconsultantsandfinalise the alignment&configurationofroadaccordingly.However,ifthesameisnotcoveredin theaboveassignmentofDPR/feasibility studyawarded by Ministry,theconsultantunder this assignment shallberesponsible for preparing DPRforsuch level crossings.
2. Objective
2.1 Themainobjectiveoftheconsultancyserviceistoestablishthetechnical,economical, andfinancialviabilityoftheprojectandpreparedetailedprojectreportsforrehabilitation and upgradingof theexistingroad to 4 laneconfiguration.
2.2 Theviabilityoftheprojectshallbeestablishedtakingintoaccounttherequirementswith regardtorehabilitation,upgradingandimprovementbasedonhighway design,pavement design,provisionof serviceroadswherevernecessary,typeof intersections, rehabilitationandwidening ofexistingand/orconstructionofnew bridgesandstructures, road safety features, quantities of various items of works and cost estimates and economic analysis.
2.3 TheDetailedProjectReportwouldinter-aliaincludedetailedhighwaydesign,designof pavementandoverlay withoptionsforflexibleorrigidpavements,designofbridgesand cross drainage structures and grade separated structures, design of service roads, quantitiesofvariousitems,detailedworking drawings,detailedcostestimates,economic andfinancialviability analyses,environmentalandsocialfeasibility,socialand environmentalactionplansasappropriateanddocumentsrequiredfortendering the project on commercial basisforinternational /local competitivebidding.
2.4 TheDPRconsultantshouldensuredetailedprojectpreparationincorporatingaspectsof valueengineering,quality auditandsafetyauditrequirementindesignand implementation.
39
2.5 Theconsultantshould,alongwithFeasibilityReport,clearlybringoutthrough financialanalysisthe preferredmode ofimplementationon whichthe CivilWorks forthestretchesaretobetaken up.Theconsultantshouldalsogive costestimates along with feasibility report/ detailedProjectReport.
2.6 Ifatfeasibilitystage,employerdesiretoterminatethecontract,thecontractwillbe terminatedafterpayment up tothat stage.
3. Scopeof Services
3.1 Asfaraspossible,thewidening/improvementworkto4 laneshallbewithinthe existingrightofwayavoidinglandacquisition,exceptforlocationshavinginadequate widthandwhere provisionsofshort bypasses,serviceroads,alignmentcorrections, improvementofintersectionsareconsiderednecessary andpracticableandcosteffective. However bypassesproposalsshouldalsobe considered,whereverinurbanareas, improvementto4 laneoftheexisting roadisnotpossible.TheConsultantshallfurnish landacquisitiondetailsasperrevenue records/mapsforfurtherprocessing ofland acquisition.Consultantshallalsosubmit3a,3Aand3Ddraftnotificationforacquisition of land.
3.2 TheConsultantshallstudythepossiblelocationsanddesignoftollplaza, if applicable to the project.Wayside amenitiesrequiredontolledhighwayshallalsobeplanned.Thelocalandslowtraffic may needsegregationfromthemaintrafficandprovisionofserviceroadsandfencing maybe considered, wherever necessaryto improve efficiencyand safety.
3.3 Thegeneralscopeofservicesisgiveninthesectionsthatfollow.However,theentire scope of serviceswould,inter-alia,includetheitemsmentionedintheLetter ofInvitation and the TOR. The Consultant willalsomake suitable proposals for widening/improvementoftheexisting roadand strengtheningofthecarriageways,asrequiredattheappropriatetimetomaintainthe levelofserviceoverthe designperiod.TheConsultantsshallpreparedocumentsfor EPC/PPPcontracts for each DPRassignment
3.4 All readyto implement ‘good for construction’ drawings shallbeprepared.
3.5 EnvironmentalImpactAssessment,EnvironmentalManagementPlanandRehabilitation andResettlementStudiesshallbecarriedoutby theConsultantmeetingtherequirements of thelending agencies like ADB/ World Bank/JICA, etc.
3.6 Whereverrequired,consultantwillliaisewithconcernedauthoritiesandarrangeall
clarifications.ApprovalofalldrawingsincludingGAD anddetailengineeringdrawings willbe
gotdone by the consultantfromthe Railways.However,ifRailwaysrequire proof
checkingofthe drawingspreparedby theconsultants,the same willbe gotdone by
NHAIandpaymenttotheproofconsultantshallbe made by NHAI directly. Consultant will
also obtain final approval from Ministry of Environment and Forest for all applicable
40
clearances. Consultant will also obtain approval for estimates for shifting of utilities of
all types from the concerned authorities and NHAI.
ConsultantisalsorequiredtoprepareallLandAcquisition papers(i.e.allnecessaryschedule
anddraft3a,3A,and3D, 3G notificationasper L.A. act)for acquisition of land either under
NH Act orStateAct.
3.7 TheDPRconsultantmayberequiredto preparetheBidDocuments,basedonthe feasibilityreport, duetoexigencyof theproject for execution if desired by NHAI.
3.8 Consultantshallobtainalltypesofnecessaryclearancesrequiredforimplementationof theprojectonthegroundfromthe concernedagencies.Theclientshallprovide the necessary supportinglettersandany officialfeesasperthedemandnoteissuedby such concerned agencies from whom the clearances are being sought to enable implementation.
3.9 TheconsultantshallprepareseparatedocumentsforBoTaswellasEPCcontractsat Feasibility stage/DPRstage.ThestudiesforfinancingoptionslikeBoT,Annuity,EPC willbeundertaken in feasibilitystudystage.
3.10 The consultant shall be guided in its assignment by the Model Concession/ Contract Agreements for PPP/ EPC projects, as applicable and the Manual of Specifications and Standards for two/ four/ six laning of highways published by IRC (IRC:SP:73 or IRC:SP:84 or IRC:SP:87, as applicable) (the "Manual") along with relevant IRC codes for design of long bridges.
3.11 Theconsultantshallpreparethebiddocumentsincluding requiredschedules(as mentionedabove)asperEPC/PPPdocuments.Forthatitissuggestedthatconsultantshould alsogothroughtheEPC/PPPdocumentsofministry beforebiddingtheproject. TheConsultantshall assisttheNHAIandit'sFinancialConsultantandtheLegal Adviserby furnishingclarifications as required for the financial appraisal and legal scrutiny of the Project Highwayand Bid Documents.
3.12 Consultant shall be responsible for sharing the findings from the preparation stages
during the bid process. During the bid process for a project, the consultant shallsupport the authority in responding to all technical queries, andshall ensure participation of senior team members of the consultant during all interaction with potential bidders including pre-bid conference, meetings, site visits etc. In addition, the consultant shall also support preparation of detailed responses to the written queries raised by the bidders.
4. General
4.1 Primary Tasks
GeneralScopeof Servicesshallcoverbutbenotlimitedtothefollowing major tasks (additionalrequirementsforPreparationofDetailedProjectReportforHillRoads and MajorBridges are given inSupplement IandII respectively):
i. reviewofallavailablereportsandpublishedinformationabouttheprojectroad and the
41
projectinfluencearea;
ii. Environmental andsocial impact assessment, including such as related to cultural
properties, natural habitants, involuntaryresettlement etc.
ii(a). Public consultation,includingconsultationwith Communitieslocatedalongthe
road,NGOsworkinginthearea,otherstake-
holdersandrelevantGovernmentdepartments
atallthedifferentstagesofassignment(suchasinceptionstage,feasibility stage,
preliminarydesignstage and oncefinal designs areconcretized).
iii. Detailed reconnaissance;
iv. identificationofpossibleimprovementsintheexistingalignmentandbypassing
congested locationswith alternatives,evaluation ofdifferentalternatives
comparisonontechno-economic andotherconsiderationsandrecommendations
regarding most appropriate option;
v. traffic studies including traffic surveys and Axle load survey and demand
forecasting for next thirty years;
vi. Inventory and condition surveys forroad;
vii. Inventoryandconditionsurveysforbridges,cross-drainagestructures,other
Structures, river Banktraining/Protection worksand drainageprovisions;
viii. Detailed topographic surveys using LiDAR equipped with minimum engineering
grade system or any other better technology having output accuracy not less than
(a) specified in IRC SP 19 (b) Total Station (c) GPS/ DGPS. The use of
conventional high precision instruments i.e Total Station or equivalent can be
used at locations such as major bypasses, water bodies etc. where it may not be
possible to survey using LiDAR
ix. Pavement investigations;
x. Sub-gradecharacteristicsandstrength:investigationofrequiredsub-gradeand sub-
soilcharacteristicsandstrengthforroadandembankmentdesignandsub
soilinvestigation;
xi. Identification ofsources of construction materials;
xii. Detaileddesignofroad,itsx-sections,horizontalandverticalalignmentand
42
designofembankmentofheight morethan6mandalsoinpoorsoilconditions
andwheredensityconsideration require,evenlesserheightembankment.Detailed
designofstructurespreparationofGADandconstructiondrawingsand cross-
drainagestructures and underpasses etc.
xiii. Identification ofthe typeand the design of intersections;
xiv. Design of completedrainagesystemand disposal pointfor storm water
xv. Value analysis/ value engineering and project costing;
xvi. Economicand financialanalyses;
xvii. Contract packaging and implementation schedule.
xviii Strip plan indicating the scheme for carriageway widening, location of all
existingutility services(both over-and underground)and theschemefortheir
relocation,treestobefelled, transplantedandplantedandlandacquisition
requirementsincludingschedulefor LA: reportsdocumentsanddrawings
arrangement of estimates for cutting/ transplanting of trees and shifting of
utilities from the concerned department;
xix To find out financial viability of project for implementation and suggest the
preferred mode on which the project is to be taken up.
xx. Preparationofdetailedprojectreport,costestimate,approvedforconstruction
Drawings,rateanalysis,detailedbillofquantities,biddocumentsforexecutionof civil
works through budgeting resources.
xxi. Designoftollplazaandidentificationoftheir numbersandlocationandoffice cum
residential complexincluding working drawings
xxii. Design of weighing stations, parking areas and rest areas.
xxiii. Anyother user orientedfacility en-routetoll facility.
xxiv.Tie-in ofon-going/sanctioned works of MORT&H/ NHAI/ other agencies.
43
xxv. Preparationofsocialplansfortheprojectaffectedpeopleasperpolicyofthe lending
agencies/ Govt. of India R&R Policy.
4.2 Whilecarryingoutthefieldstudies,investigationsanddesign,thedevelopmentplans beingimplementedorproposedforfutureimplementationby thelocalbodies,shouldbe taken into account. Suchaspect should be clearlybrought outin thereportsand drawings.
4.3 The consultant shall study the possible locations and design of toll plaza, wayside amenities requiredand arboriculturealongthe highwayshallalso be planned.
4.4 Thelocalandslowtrafficmayneedsegregationfromthemaintrafficandprovisionof serviceroadsandphysicalbarrierincludingfencingmay beconsidered,wherever necessaryto improve efficiencyand safety.
4.5 Standards andCodes ofPractices
1. Allactivitiesrelatedtofieldstudies,designanddocumentationshallbedoneas per thelatestguidelines/circularsof MoRT&Handrelevantpublicationsof the Indian RoadsCongress (IRC) andBureauofIndian Standards (BIS).For aspects notcoveredbyIRCandBIS,internationalstandardspractices,may beadopted. TheConsultants,uponawardoftheContract,mayfinalizethisinconsultation withNHAI and reflect thesame in the inception report.
2. Allnotations, abbreviations and symbols used inthereports, documentsand drawings shall be as perIRC:71.
4.6 Quality AssurancePlan(QAP)
1. TheConsultantsshouldhavedetailedQualityAssurancePlan(QAP)forallfield studiesincluding topographicsurveys,trafficsurveys,engineeringsurveysand investigations,designanddocumentationactivities.Thequality assurance plans/proceduresfordifferentfieldstudies,engineering surveysandinvestigation, designanddocumentationactivitiesshouldbe presentedasseparatesectionslike engineering surveysandinvestigations,trafficsurveys,materialgeo-technicaland sub-soil investigations, road and pavement investigations, investigation and designofbridges&structures,environmentandR&Rassessment,economic& financialanalysis,drawingsanddocumentation,preparation,checking,approval andfilingofcalculations,identificationandtractability ofprojectdocumentsetc. Further,additionalinformationasperformat shallbefurnishedregarding the detailsofpersonalwhoshallberesponsiblefor carrying out/preparingand checking/verifyingvariousactivitiesformingpartoffeasibility studyandproject preparation,since inceptiontothecompletionofwork.The detailedDraftQAP Documentmustbe discussedandfinalisedwiththe concerned NHAI officers immediatelyupon theaward ofthe Contract and submitted as part of theinception report.
2. It is imperativethat theQAPis approved by NHAI beforetheConsultants start the field work.
4.7 ReviewofData andDocuments
44
1. TheConsultantsshallcollecttheavailabledataandinformationrelevantforthe Study.The dataanddocumentsof major interestshallinclude,butnotbe limited to, thefollowing:
i. Climate; ii. Road inventory iii Roadcondition,year of originalconstruction, yearand typeofmajor
maintenance/rehabilitation works; iv. Condition ofbridges and cross-drainagestructures; v. sub-surfaceand geo-technical data for existing bridges; vi. Hydrological data, drawings and details ofexisting bridges; vii Existing geological maps, catchment area maps, contour plansetc. for
theproject area
viii Condition of existing river bank / protection works, if any.
ix. Details of sanctioned / on-going works on the stretch sanctioned
byMoRT&H/other agenciesfor Tie-in purposes
x. Surveyand evaluation oflocally available construction materials; xi. Historical data on classified traffic volume (preferably for 5 years or
more); xii. Origin-destination and commoditymovement characteristics;if available xiii. Speed and delaycharacteristics; if available;
xiv. Commodity-wise trafficvolume; if available;
xv. Accident statistics; and, xvi. Vehicleloading behavior(axle load spectrum), if available. xvii) Typeandlocationofexistingutilityservices(e.g.FibreOpticalCable, O/H and
U/G Electric, Telephoneline,Watermains, Sewer, Trees etc.) xviii) Environmental setting and socialbaselineof theproject.
4.8. SocialAnalysis
Thesocialanalysisstudy shallbe carriedoutinaccordancewiththe MORT&H/World Bank/ADB Guidelines.The socialanalysisreportwill,amongother things,providea socio-economicprofileoftheprojectareaandaddressinparticular,indigenouspeople, communicablediseaseparticularly HIV/AIDSpoverty alleviation,gender,local population,industry,agriculture, employment,health, education, health, child labor, landacquisition and resettlement .
4.9 TrafficSurveys
All traffic surveys andstudies will be completed in feasibilitystudies.
4.9.1 NumberandLocation of Survey Stations
1. Thetypeoftrafficsurveysandtheminimumnumberofsurveystationsshall normallybeas under, unless otherwise specificallymentioned.
Sl.NR.
Description Numberof Survey
Stations 1. Classified TrafficVolume Count 3
45
2. Origin-Destination and Commodity Movement Characteristics
Minimum2
3. Axle LoadingCharacteristics 2
4. Intersection Volume Count All MajorIntersections
5. Speed-DelayCharacteristics Project Road Section
6. Pedestrian/animal cross trafficcount All major inhabitations alongthe highway
2. Thenumberofsurveylocationsindicatedinthetableaboveareindicativeonly. TheConsultantsshall,immediately uponawardofthework,submittoNHAI, proposalsregarding
thetotalnumberaswellasthelocationsofthetrafficsurvey stationsasputofinceptionreport.Suitablemapsandchartsshouldaccompany theproposalsclearlyindicatingtherationaleforselectingthelocationofsurveyStation
3. Themethodologyofcollectionandanalysisofdata,numberand locationof traffic surveystationsshallbefinalized in consultation withNHAI.
4.9.2. ClassifiedTraffic VolumeCount Survey
1. Consultant shall make use of traffic survey done by Indian Highways Management Company Limited (IHMCL) using ATCC systems. If required, especially in cases where a particular stretch is not covered by IHMCL, DPR consultant should carry out classified traffic volume count survey using ATCC systems or better technologies.
2. Consultant shall use ATCC systems that can meet the following accuracy levels
after validation/ correction: (a) Classification of vehicles: better than 95% (b) Counting of vehicles: better than 98% Before validation and correction, the ATCC system shall meet the following
accuracy levels: (a) Classification of vehicles: better than 90% (b) Counting of vehicles: better than 95% For verification of above accuracy levels, audit of raw ATCC shall be done on a
sampling basis. 3. ATCC systems such as Pneumatic Tube Detector, Inductive Detector Loop,
Video Image Detection, and Infrared Sensor or better technologies shall be adopted.
4. The classified traffic volume count surveys shall be carried out for 7 days
(continuous,direction-wise)attheselectedsurvey stations.Thevehicle classificationsystemasgiveninrelevantIRCcodemaybefollowed.However, the followinggeneralisedclassification systemissuggested inviewof the
46
requirementsof trafficdemand estimates and economic analysis:
Motorised Traffic Non-Motorised Traffic
2-Wheeler Bi-Cycle
3-Wheeler Cycle-Rickshaw
Passenger Car Animal Drawn Vehicle(ADV)
UtilityVehicle (Jeep, Van etc.) Hand Cart
Other Non-MotorisedVehicle
Bus MiniBus
Standard Bus
LCV LCV-Passenger
LCV-Freight
Truck MCV : 2-Axle Rigid Chassis
HCV : 3-Axle Rigid Chassis
MAV SemiArticulated
Articulated
5. All results shall be presented in tabular and graphical form. The survey data shall be analysed to bring out the hourly and daily variations. The traffic volume count per day shall be averaged to show a weekly average daily traffic (ADT) by vehicle type. The annual average daily traffic (AADT) shall be worked out by applying seasonal factors.
6. The consultant shall compile the relevant traffic volume data from secondary
sources also. The salient features of traffic volume characteristics shall be brought out and variations if any, from the traffic census carried out by the State PWD shall be suitably explained.
4.9.3. Origin-Destination andCommodity Movements Surveys
1. The consultants shall carry out 1-day (24 hour, both directions) O-D and
commodity movement surveys at locations finalized in consultation with NHAI. These will be essentially required around congested towns to delineate through traffic. The road side interviews shall be on random sample basis and cover all four-wheeled vehicles. The location of the O-D survey and commodity movement surveys shall normally be same as for the classified traffic count.
2. Thelocationoforigin anddestination zonesshallbedeterminedin relationto eachindividualstation andthepossibility oftrafficdiversiontothe ProjectRoad from/to other road routesincluding bypasses.
3. Thetrip matrices shallbeworked outforeach vehicletypeinformation onweight
47
fortrucksshouldbesummedupby commoditytypeandtheresultstabulated, giving totalweightandaverageweightpertruckforthevariouscommoditytypes. Thesamplesizeforeachvehicletypeshallbeindicatedonthetableandalsoin the graphicalrepresentations.
4. Thedataderivedfromsurveysshallalsobeanalysedtobringouttheleadand loadcharacteristicsanddesirelinediagrams.The dataanalysisshouldalsobring out therequirement for the construction ofbypasses.
5. Thedistributionofleadandloadobtainedfromthesurveysshouldbecompared Theaxleloadsurveysshallnormallybedoneusingaxleloadpadsorother sophisticated instruments. The location(s) ofcount station(s) and the survey
withthosederived from the axle load studies.
6. Thecommoditymovementdatashouldbedulytakenintoconsiderationwhile makingthe traffic demand estimates.
4.9.4..Turning Movement Surveys
1. TheturningmovementsurveysforestimationofpeakhourtrafficforthedesignofmajorandminorintersectionsshallbecarriedoutfortheStudy.Thedetailsregardingcompositionanddirectionalmovementoftrafficshallbefurnishedby the Consultant.
2. Themethodology forthesurveysshallbeasperIRC:SP:41-1994.Thedetails including locationand durationofsurveysshallbefinalizedinconsultationwith NHAIofficials.TheproposalinresponsetothisTORshallclearlyindicatethe numberoflocationsthattheConsultantswishtoconductturning movement surveys and the rationaleforthe same.
3. Thedataderivedfrom thesurvey shouldbeanalyzedtoidentify requirementsof suitable remedialmeasures,suchasconstructionof underpasses,fly-overs, interchanges,grade-separatedintersectionsalong theprojectroadalignment. Intersectionswithhightrafficvolumerequiring specialtreatmentseitherpresently or in futureshallbeidentified.
4.9.5. AxleLoad Surveys
1. Axleloadsurveysinbothdirectionsshallbe carriedoutatsuitablelocation(s) in theprojectroadstretchonarandomsamplebasisnormally fortrucksonly(both emptyandloadedtrucks)for2normaldays-(24hours)atspecialcountstations tobefinalizedinconsultationwith NHAI.However,afewbusesmay beweighed inordertogetanideaabouttheirloadingbehavior.Whileselecting the location(s)ofaxleloadsurveystation(s),thelocationsofexistingbridgeswith load restrictions,ifany,shouldbe takenintoaccountandsuchsitesshouldbe avoided.
2. Axleloadsurveysshall normally be done using axle load pads or other sophisticated instruments. The location(s) of count station(s) and the survey methodology including
48
the data formats and the instrument type to be used shall be finalized before taking up the axle load surveys
3. The axleloaddatashouldbe collectedaxleconfiguration-wise.The number of equivalentstandardaxlesper truckshallbe calculatedonthebasisofresults obtained.Theresultsofthesurvey shouldbringouttheVDFforeachtrucktype (axleconfiguration,ifthecalculatedVDF isfoundtobe belowthenational average,then nationalaverage shallbe used.Furthermore,the data from axle load surveysshouldbe analysedtobringouttheGrossVehicleWeight(GVW)and Single AxleLoad(SAL)Distributions bytruck type(axle configuration).
4. The Consultant shallascertain from local enquiries about the exceptional live loadsthat have used the highway in the past in order to assess the suitability of existing bridges to carry such loads.
4.9.6. Speed-Delay Surveys
TheConsultantsshallcarryoutappropriatefieldstudiessuchasmovingcar survey to determinerunningspeedandjourneyspeed. The datashouldbeanalyzedtoidentifysectionswithtypicaltrafficflowproblemsandcongestion. Theobjectiveofthesurvey wouldbetorecommendsuitablemeasuresfor segregationoflocaltraffic,smoothflowofthroughtrafficandtrafficsafety. These measureswouldinclude the provisionofbypasses,under-passes,fly-overs, interchanges,grade-separated intersections and serviceroads.
4.9.7 Pedestrian/ animal cross traffic surveys:
These may be conducted to determine if provision of viaduct for pedestrians/animals is necessary to improve the traffic safety.
4.9.8 TruckTerminal Surveys
The data derived from the O-D, speed-delay, other surveys and also supplementary surveysshouldbeanalysedtoassessrequirementsforpresentand futuredevelopment of truck terminals at suitablelocations enroute.
4.10. TrafficDemandEstimates
1. The consultantsshallmake trafficdemandestimatesandestablishpossibletraffic growthratesinrespectofallcategoriesof vehicles,taking intoaccount thepast trends,annualpopulationandrealpercapitagrowthrate,elasticityoftransport demandinrelationtoincomeandestimatedannualproductionincrease.The other aspectsincluding socio-economicdevelopmentplansandthelandusepatternsof theregionhaving impactonthetrafficgrowth,theprojectionsofvehicle manufacturingindustry inthecountry,developmentplansfortheothermodesof transport,O-Dandcommodity
49
movementbehaviourshouldalsobetakeninto account whileworkingout thetraffic demand estimates.
2. Thevaluesofelasticity oftransportdemand shallbebasedontheprevailing practices i n the country. The Consultantsshallgive completebackground includingreferences forselectingthe value of transport demand elasticity.
3. Itisenvisagedthattheprojectroadsectionscoveredunderthis TORwouldbecompletedandopenedtotrafficafter3years.Thetrafficdemand estimatesshallbe donefor afurtherperiodof30yearsfromcompletionof two/fourlane.The demandestimatesshallbedoneassuming threescenarios, namely,optimistic,pessimisticandmostlikely trafficgrowth.Thegrowthfactors shallbeworked out for five-yearlyintervals.
4. Trafficprojectionsshouldbebasedonsound andprovenforecastingtechniques.Incasetrafficdemand estimatedistobemadeonthebasisofa model,the applicationofthemodelinthesimilarsituation withthevalidationoftheresults shouldbeestablished. Thetrafficprojectionsshould alsobringoutthepossible impact of implementation of any competing facility in the near future. The demand estimatesshould alsotake intoaccountthefreight and passengertraffic alongthemajorcorridorsthatmayinterconnectwiththeproject. Impactoftoll charges on thetraffic estimates should be estimated.
5. The methodologyfortrafficdemandestimatesdescribedintheprecedingparagraphsisfornormaltrafficonly. In additiontothe estimatesfornormal traffic,theConsultants shall alsoworkoutthe estimatesforgenerated, induced and diverted traffic.
6. Thetrafficforecastsshall also be madeforboth diverted andgenerated traffic.
7. Overalltrafficforecastthusmadeshallformthebasisforthe design of each pavement type and otherfacilities/ancillaryworks.
4.11. Engineering Surveys andInvestigations
4.11.1. ReconnaissanceandAlignment
1. The Consultants should make an in-depth study of the available landwidth(ROW)
topographic maps, satellite imageriesandair photographsof the projectarea,geological
maps,catchmentarea maps,contourplans,floodflowdata andseismologicaldata and
otheravailablerelevantinformationcollectedby themconcerningtheexistingalignment.
Consultanthimselfhastoarrangetherequiredmapsandtheinformationneeded by him
fromthepotentialsources.Consultantshould make efforts forminimizingland
acquisition.
2. Thedetailedgroundreconnaissancemaybetakenupimmediatelyafterthestudy ofmapsandotherdata.Theprimary taskstobeaccomplishedduringthe reconnaissancesurveys
50
include;
i. topographical features of the area; ii. typical physical featuresalong the existing alignment within and outside
ROWi.e. land use Pattern; iii. possiblealignmentalternatives,vis-a-vis,schemefortheconstructionof
additionallanes parallelto the existing road; iv. realignmentrequirementsincludingtheprovisionofbypasses,ROBs/
Flyoversandvia-ductforpedestriancrossingswith possible alignment
alternatives; v. preliminary identification of improvement requirements including treatments
and measuresneeded for the cross-roads; vi. trafficpattern and preliminary identification of traffic homogenous links; vii. sections through congested areas; viii. inventoryofmajoraspectsincludinglandwidth,terrain,pavementtype,
carriageway type,bridgesandstructures(type,size andlocation),
intersections(type,cross-roadcategory,location) urbanareas(location, extent),
geologicallysensitiveareas, environmental features: ix. critical areas requiring detailed investigations; and, x. Requirementsfor carrying out supplementary investigations. xi. soil(texturalclassifications)and drainageconditions xii. Typeandextentofexistingutilityservicesalongthealignment(withinROW).
xiii. Typical physical features along the approach roads
xiv. Possible bridge locations, land acquisition problems, nature of crossings,
likely length of approaches and bridge, firmness of banks, suitability of
alignment of approach roads.
3. The data derived from the reconnaissance surveys are normally utilizedfor planningand programming thedetailedsurveysandinvestigations.Allfield studies including the traffic surveys should be taken up on the basis of information derived from the reconnaissancesurveys.
4. Thedataandinformationobtainedfromthereconnaissancesurveysshouldbe documented.The dataanalysisandtherecommendationsconcerning alignment and the field studies should be included in theInception Report. Thedata obtained fromthereconnaissancesurveysshouldformthecoreofthedatabasewhich wouldbesupplementedandaugmentedusingthedataobtainedfromdetailed field studies and investigations.
5. Thedataobtainedfromthereconnaissancesurveysshouldbecompiledinthe tabular as wellasgraphical (chart)form indicating the major physical features and theproposedwidening schemefor NHAI'scomments.Thedataandthecharts should also accompanytherationaleforthe selection of traffic surveystations.
4.11.2. Topographic Surveys
1. Thebasicobjectiveofthetopographicsurveywouldbetocapturetheessential groundfeaturesalongthealignmentinordertoconsiderimprovementsandfor working outimprovements,rehabilitationandupgrading costs.Thedetailed
51
topographicsurveysshouldnormally betakenupafterthecompletionof reconnaissancesurveys.
2. The carrying out of topographic surveys will be one of the most important and crucial
field tasks under the project. Technologies which can meet the following accuracy levels shall be adopted. For land based surveys (a) Fundamental horizontal accuracy of 2 cm or better (b) Fundamental vertical accuracy of 2 cm or better (c) More than 50 points shall be measured per sq. m and for aerial based surveys (a) Fundamental horizontal accuracy of 5 cm or better (b) Fundamental vertical accuracy of 5 cm or better (c) More than 10 points shall be measured per sq. m. To establish accuracy, a check point survey using DGPS (for horizontal accuracy) and Auto Level (for vertical accuracy) shall be carried out to establish the fundamental horizontal and vertical accuracy. A minimum of 25 check points, or check points once every 4 km should be established, and these should be strictly different from any geo-referencing or control network points.
3. The following are the set of deliverables which should be submitted after completion of survey: (a) Raw DGPS data for the entire highway length and adjoining areas of interest (b) Point cloud data or equivalent for the entire highway length and adjoining areas of interest in a format/ platform as per industry good practice which shall be amenable to operations by NHAI/ Consultant. NHAI may decide about format/ platform of point cloud data(c) Topographic map of scale 1:1000 of the entire highway length and adjoining areas of interest (d) Contour map of 50 cm of entire highway length and adjoining areas of interest (e) Cross section of the highway at every 1 m in *.dwg format.
4. For land based surveys, Mobile LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) or better technology that can meet above requirements shall be adopted. For aerial based surveys, Aerial Mobile LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) or better technology that can meet above requirements shall be adopted. In shadow areas such as invert levels below culverts, where LiDAR or better technologies cannot survey accurately, traditional methods of Total Station/ Auto Level shall be used to complete the study.
5. In case of mobile LiDAR or better technology, 360 degree panoramic images of the entire highway length and adjoining areas of interest shall be submitted. In case of aerial LiDAR or better technology, ortho-images of the entire highway length and adjoining areas of interest shall be submitted.
6. Thedetailed field surveys would essentiallyincludethe following activities:
i. TopographicSurveysalongtheExistingRightofWay(ROW):Carrying out
topographic survey using LiDAR or better technology along the existing road
and realignments, wherever required and properly referencing the same with
reference pillars fixed on either side of the centre-line at safe places within the
ROW
ii. The detailed field surveys would essentially include the topographic surveys
along the proposed location of bridge and alignment of approach road.
iii. The detailed topographic surveys should be carried out along the approach
52
roads alignment and location of bridge approved by NHAI.
vi.. Collection/ Extractionofdetailsforallfeaturessuchasstructures(bridges,culverts
etc.)utilities,existingroads,electricandtelephoneinstallations(both O/H as well
as underground), huts, buildings, fencingand trees(with girth greater
than0.3metre) oiland gaslinesetc. fallingwithinthe extent of survey.
4. Thewidth of surveycorridor will generallybeasgiven under:
i. Thewidth of thesurvey corridor should takeinto account thelayout of the
existingalignmentincludingthe extentofembankmentandcutslopesand
thegeneralgroundprofile.While carryingoutthefieldsurveys,the
wideningscheme(i.e.right,leftorsymmetricaltothe centreline ofthe
existingcarriageway) shouldbetakenintoconsiderationsothatthe
topographicsurveyscoversufficientwidthbeyondthecentreline ofthe proposed
dividedcarriageway.Normally the surveysshould extend a minimum of30m
beyondeithersideofthecentre line ofthe proposed divided carriageway or land
boundarywhicheveris more
ii. Incasethereconnaissancesurveyrevealstheneedforbypassingthe congested
locations, thetraverselines wouldberun alongthepossible
alignmentsinordertoidentify andselectthe mostsuitable alignmentfor
thebypass.The detailedtopographicsurveysshouldbe carriedoutalong
thebypassalignmentapprovedby NHAI..Atlocationswhere grade separated
intersectionscouldbetheobviouschoice,thesurveyareawillbesuitablyincreased.F
ieldnotesofthesurveyshouldbemaintained which would also provideinformation
about traffic, soil, drainage etc.
iii. Thewidthofthesurveyedcorridorwillbewidenedappropriatelywhere
developmentsand/orencroachmentshave resultedinarequirementfor
adjustmentinthe alignment,orwhereitisfeltthatthe existingalignment can
beimproved upon through minor adjustments.
iv Where existing roads cross the alignments, the survey will extend a
minimumof100meithersideoftheroadcentrelineandwill beof sufficientwidth
toallowimprovements,includingatgradeintersectionto bedesigned.
5. Thesurveyedalignment shall betransferred on tothe ground as under:
i. ReferencePillar and Bench Mark/ Referencepillar ofsize15 cmX 15cm
X45cmshallbecastinRCCofgrade M15withanailfixedinthecentre
ofthetopsurface. The reference pillarshallbe embeddedinconcrete upto
adepthof30cmwithCC M10(5cmwideallaround).Thebalance15cm above
groundshallbe paintedyellow. The spacingshallbe 250m apart, incase
BenchMarkPillarcoincideswithReference Pillar,onlyone ofthe two need
beprovided.
53
ii. EstablishingBenchmarksatsiteconnectedtoGTSBenchmarksata
intervalof250metresonBenchmarkpillarmade ofRCCasmentioned
abovewith RL and BMNo. marked on itwithred paint.
iii. BoundaryPillars-Whereverthereisaproposalofrealignmentofthe
existingHighway and/or constructionofNewBypasses,Consultantshall fix
boundary pillars along the proposed alignment on the extreme boundaryon
either sideof theproject Highwayat 50 m interval.
4.11.2.1 Longitudinal andCross-Sections
The topographic surveys for longitudinal and cross-sections shallcoverthe following:
i. Longitudinalsectionlevelsalongfinalcentrelineat every1minterval,
atthelocationsof curve points,smallstreams,and intersectionsandatthe
locations of changein elevation.
ii. Crosssectionsat every1mintervalinfull extentofsurvey covering
sufficientnumberofspotlevelson existing carriageway andadjacent
groundforprofile correction courseand earthwork calculations.Cross
sections shall be taken at closer interval at curves.
iii. Longitudinalsectionfor crossroadsforlengthadequatefordesignand quantity
estimation purposes.
iv. Longitudinaland crosssectionsformajorand minorstreamsshall cover Cross
section of the channel at the site of proposed crossing and few cross
sections at suitable distance both upstream and downstream, bed level
upto top of banks and ground levels to a sufficient distance beyond the
edges of channel, nature of existing surface soil in bed, banks &
approaches, longitudinal section of channel showing site of bridge etc.
These shall be as per recommendations contained in IRC
SpecialPublication No. 13
(GuidelinesfortheDesignofSmallBridgesandCulverts) andprovisions of
IRC:5 (“StandardSpecifications&CodeofPracticeforRoadBridges, Section
1– General Features of Design”).
At feasibility studystage cross sections at 50m interval maybetaken.
4.11.2.2 Details ofutility Services andOtherPhysical Features
1. TheConsultantsshallcollectdetailsofallimportantphysicalfeaturesalongthe alignment. These features affect the project proposals and should normally include buildingsandstructures,monuments,burialgrounds,cremationgrounds, placesofworship,railwaylines,stream/river/canal,watermains,severs,gas/oil pipes,crossings,trees,plantations,utility servicessuchaselectric,andtelephone
54
lines(O/H&U/G)andpoles,opticalfibrecables(OFC)etc.Thesurvey would covertheentireright-of-way oftheroadontheadequateallowanceforpossible shiftingof thecentral lines at someof theintersections locations.
2. Consultant shall also map out sub-surface utilities. The following criteria shall be
met by the process of sub-surface utility mapping: (a) Scope to be provided by RO/ PD using which bids shall be placed by consultant. For any additional length coverage identified later (including any necessary new alignments), the per km-pass rate quoted during bidding shall be used for compensation (as per actual). However, survey of sub-surface utilities should be limited to embankment/ carriageway portion only (b) Accurate mapping and resolution of all sub-surface utilities up to a depth of 4 m (c) Differentiation between sub-surface utilities such as live electric cables, metallic utilities and other utilities (d) Sub-surface utilities radargrams further processed into utility maps in formats such as PDF, JPEGand AutoCAD. To meet the accuracy levels, consultant shall use Ground Penetrating Radar, Induction Locator or better technologies.
3. Theinformationcollectedduringreconnaissanceandfieldsurveysshallbeshown ona stripplan sothatthe proposedimprovementscanbe appreciated andthe extentoflandacquisitionwithL.Aschedule,utilityremovalsofeachtypeetc. assessedandsuitableactionscanbe initiated. Separatestripplanfor eachofthe services involved shallbeprepared for submission to the concerned agency.
4.11.3. Road andPavement Investigations
TheConsultantsshallcarry outdetailedfieldstudiesinrespectofroadand pavement.Thedatacollectedthroughroadinventory andpavementinvestigations should besufficient to meet theinput requirements of HDM-IV.
4.11.3.1 Road Inventory Surveys
1. Detailed road inventory surveys shall be carried out to collect details of allexisting roadand pavementfeaturesalong theexisting road sections. The inventorydata shallincludebut notlimited tothe following:
i. Terrain (flat, rolling, mountainous);
ii. Land-use (agricultural, commercial, forest,residential etc) @ every
kilometer;
iii. Carriagewaywidth,surfacingtype@every500mandeverychangeof
featurewhichever isearlier;
iv. Shouldersurfacingtypeandwidth@every500mandeverychangeof
featurewhichever isearlier;
v. Sub-grade/localsoiltype(texturalclassification)@every500mand
everychangeof featurewhichever isearlier;
vi. Horizontal curve; verticalcurve
55
vii. Road intersection typeand details, ateveryoccurrence;
viii. Retaining structures and details, ateveryoccurrence;
ix. Location ofwater bodies(lakes and reservoirs), at everyoccurrence;
x. Heightofembankmentordepthofcut@every200mandeverychangeof
featurewhichever isearlier.
xi. Landwidth i.e. ROW
xii. Culverts, bridges and other structures(type, size, span arrangement and
location)
xiii. Roadside arboriculture
xiv. Existing utility services on either sidewithin ROW.
xv. General drainage conditions
xvi. Design speed of existing road
2. Thedatashouldbecollectedinsufficientdetail.Thedatashouldbecompiledand presentedintabularas wellasgraphicalform.Theinventorydatawould bestored in computerfiles usingsimpleutilitypackages, such as EXCEL.
4.11.3.2 Pavement Investigation
1. Pavement Composition
i. Thedataconcerningthepavementcompositionmaybealreadyavailable
withthe PWD. However,the consultantsshallmake trialpitstoascertain
thepavementcomposition.ThetestpitintervalwillbeasperPara4 below.
ii. For each test pit, thefollowing information shallberecorded:
• test pit reference(Identification number, location):
• pavementcomposition (material typeand thickness); and
• subgrade type(textural classification)and condition (dry, wet)
2. Road andPavement ConditionSurveys
i. Detailedfieldstudiesshallbecarriedouttocollectroadandpavement surface
conditions. Thedata should generally cover:
• pavementcondition (surfacedistress typeand extent);
• shoulder condition;
• embankment condition; and
• drainage condition Pavement Condition
• cracking (narrow and wide cracking), % of pavement area
affected;
• raveling, % of pavement area affected;
• potholing, % of pavement area affected;
• edge break, length (m); and,
56
• rut depth, mm
Shoulder Condition • Paved: Sameas for pavement
• Unpaved:materialloss, rut depth and corrugation,
• Edgedrop, mm.
Embankment Condition • general condition; and • extent of slope erosion
ii. Theobjectiveoftheroadandpavement conditionsurveysshallbeto identify
defectsandsectionswithsimilar characteristics. Alldefectsshall
besystematicallyreferenced,recordedandquantifiedforthepurposeof
determining the modeofrehabilitation.
iii. Thepavement conditionsurveysshallbe carriedoutusing visualmeans.
Supplemented by actualmeasurementsandinaccordance withthewidely
accepted methodology(AASHTO,IRC,OECD, TRL and WorldBank
Publications)adapted tomeet thestudy requirements. Themeasurement of
rut depth would be madeusing standard straight edges.
iv. Theshoulderand embankment conditionsshallbe evaluated by visual
meansandthe existenceofdistress modes (cuts, erosionmarks,failure,
drops)and extent(none,moderate,frequentand veryfrequent) ofsuch distress
manifestations would be recorded.
v. For sections with severe distresses, additional investigations as
appropriate shall be carried out to determine the causeof such distresses.
vi. Middle200m couldbe consideredasrepresentativesamplefor eachone km. of
road and incaseall other things are considered similar.
DrainageCondition
• General condition
• Connectivity of drainage turnouts into the natural topography
• Condition in cut sections
• Condition at high embankments
The data obtained fromthe conditionsurveysshouldbe analysedandthe road segmentsofmoreorlessequalperformancemaybeidentifiedusingthecriteria given inIRC: 81-1997.
3. Pavement Roughness
i. Theroughnesssurveysshallbe carriedoutusingBumpIntegratoror
similarinstrument. The methodologyforthesurveysshallbeasperthe
widelyusedstandardpractices. The calibration oftheinstrumentshall be
57
done aspertheprocedure giveninthe WorldBank’s Technical
Publicationsand duly gotauthenticated by established
laboratory/institution acceptableto the client
ii. Thesurveysshallbe carriedoutalongtheouterwheelpaths. The surveys shall
coveraminimumoftwo runsalongthe wheelpathsfor each directions.
iii. Theresultsofthesurveyshallbe expressedintermsofBIandIRIand
shallbepresentedintabularandgraphicalforms. Theprocesseddata
shallbeanalysedusingthe cumulativedifferenceapproachtoidentify road
segments homogenous with respect to surfaceroughness.
4. Pavement Structural Strength
i. TheConsultantsshallcarryoutstructuralstrengthsurveysforexisting
pavementsusingBenkelmanBeamDeflectiontechniqueinaccordance withthe
CGRAproceduregiveninIRC:81-1997(“Guidelinesfor
StrengtheningofFlexible RoadPavementsUsingBenkelmanBeam Deflection
Technique”).
ii. Itissuggestedthatthedeflectionsurveysmaybecarriedoutasperthe schemegiven
below:
• mainlinetesting; and,
• control section testing.
iii. Thedeflectiontestsforthemainlineshallbecarriedoutatevery500m along
theroad sectionscovered under the study. The control section
testingshallinvolvecarryingoutdeflectiontestingforeach100mlong
homogenousroadsegmentalongtheroadsections.The selectionof
homogenoussegmentshallbebasedonthedataderivedfrompavement
conditionsurveys. The totallengthofsuchhomogenoussegmentsshallnot be
lessthan100mperkilometre. The deflectionmeasurementsforthe control
section testing should beat an interval ofnot morethan 10 m.
iv. Testpitsshallbedugatevery500mandalsoalongeachhomogeneous road segment
to obtain pavement composition details(pavement course,
materialtypeandthickness) so as tobeableto studyifacorrelation exists
betweendeflectionandcomposition.Ifso,therelationshipmay be used
whileworking outthe overlay thickness for theexisting pavement.
v. Benkelman Beam Deflection surveys may not be carried out for severely
distressed sections ofthe roadwarranting reconstruction. The
Consultants,immediately uponthe awardofthe contract,shallsubmitto NHAI
the scheme describing the testing schedule including the interval. The
testing scheme shall be supportedby data fromdetailed reconnaissance
surveys.
vi. In case, the Consultants wish to use any acceptable method(s)other than
BenkelmanBeam deflectiontechnique for the evaluationofpavement strength,
58
viz.Fallingweightdeflectometer methodetc. detailsofsuch methods or
innovative features for deflection testing using Benkelman Beam technique
along with the methodology for data analysis,interpretation and the
use of such data for pavement overlay design purposes using IRC or any
other widely used practices, such as AASHTO guidelines, should be got
approved by NHAI. The sources of such methods should be properly
referenced.
4.11.3.3 SubgradeCharacteristics and Strength
1. Basedonthedataderivedfromcondition(surfacecondition,roughness)and structuralstrengthsurveys,theprojectroadsectionshouldbe dividedinto segments homogenouswith respect to pavement condition and strength. The delineation of segments homogenouswithrespecttoroughnessandstrength should bedoneusingthecumulativedifference approach (AASHTO, 1993).
2. Thedataonsoilclassificationandmechanicalcharacteristicsforsoilsalongthe existingalignmentsmay already beavailablewiththePWD.Thetestingscheme is, therefore, proposedasgiven under:
i. For the widening (2/- Laning) of existing road within the ROW, the
Consultantsshalltestatleastthree sub-gradesoilsamplesforeach homogenous
road segment or three samples for each soil type encountered,
whichever is more.
ii. Fortheroadsalongnewalignments,thetestpitsforsubgradesoilshall be @5km
orforeachsoiltype,whicheverismore.Aminimum ofthree samples should
betestedcorresponding to each homogenous segment.
3. Thetestingfor subgradesoilshallinclude:
i. in-situ densityand moisture content at each test pit
ii. FieldCBR using DCP ateach test pit iii. Characterization(grain size and Atterberg limits)at each test pit and, iv. Laboratory moisture-density characteristics (modified AASHTO
compaction); v. LaboratoryCBR(unsoakedand4-daysoakcompactedatthree energy levels)
and swell.
4. Forproblematicsoils,thetestingshallbemorerigorous.Thecharacteristicswith regardtopermeability andconsolidationshallalsobedeterminedforthesesoils. Thefrequency ofsamplingandtestingofthesesoilsshallbefinalisedin consultationwiththe NHAIofficersaftertheproblematic soiltypesareidentified alongtheroad sections.
5. Thelaboratoryfortestingofmaterialshouldbegotapprovedfrom NHAIbefore start of work.
59
4.11.4 Investigations forBridges and Structure
4.11.4.1 Inventory ofBridges, Culverts and Structures
TheConsultantsshallmakeaninventory ofallthestructures(bridges,viaducts, ROBs,/RUBandothergradeseparatedstructures, culverts,etc.)alongtheroad undertheproject.Theinventory forthebridges,viaductsandROBsshallinclude theparametersrequiredaspertheguidelinesofIRC-SP:35.Theinventory of culvertsshallbe presented ina tabularform covering relevantphysicaland hydraulicparameters.
4.11.4.2 HydraulicandHydrological Investigations
1. Thehydrologicalandhydraulicstudiesshallbecarriedoutinaccordancewith IRCSpecialPublication No.13(“GuidelinesfortheDesignof SmallBridgesand Culverts”)andIRC:5(“Standard Specifications& Codeof PracticeforRoad Bridges,SectionI GeneralFeatureofDesign”).Theseinvestigationsshallbe carriedoutforallexisting drainagestructuresalong theroadsectionsunderthe study.
2. Theconsultantshallalsocollectinformationonobservedmaximumdepthof scour.
3. Inrespectofmajorbridges,historyofhydraulicfunctioningofexistingbridge,if any,underfloodsituation,generaldirectionofrivercourse throughstructure, afflux,extentandmagnitude of flood,effectof backwater, ifany, aggradation/degradationofbed,evidenceofscouretc.shallbeusedtoaugment the available hydrological data. The presence of flood control/irrigation structures,ifaffectingthehydrauliccharacteristicslikecausing obliquity, concentrationofflow,scour,silting ofbed,changeinflowlevels,bedlevelsetc. shallbestudiedandconsideredindesignofbridges.Thedetailsofany future planned work that mayaffect theriver hydraulics shall be studied and considered.
4. The Consultants shall make a desk study of available data on topography(topographicmaps, stereoscopic aerialphotography), stormduration, rainfallstatistics, topsoilcharacteristics, vegetation coveretc.so astoassessthe catchmentareasandhydraulicparametersforallexisting andproposeddrainage provisions.Thefindingsofthe deskstudy wouldbefurthersupplementedand augmented by a reconnaissancealongthe area. All-importanthydrological features shall be noted duringthis field reconnaissance.
5. The Consultants shall collect information on high flood level (HFL),low water levels (LWL), hightide level(HTL),lowtide level(LTL)whereapplicable, dischargevelocity etc.fromavailablepastrecords,localinquiriesandvisible signs,ifany,onthestructuralcomponentsandembankments.Localinquiries shallalsobemadewithregardtotheroadsectionsgetting overtoppedduring heavyrains.
6. ConductingModelstudiesforbridgesisnotcoveredinthescopeofconsultancy
services.IfModelstudyisenvisagedforanybridge,requirementofthesame
shallbespeltoutintheRPFdocumentsseparatelyindicatingscopeandtime frame of
suchstudy. Salientfeaturesof the scope of servicestobe includedfor model
studyaregiven inthe supplement-IITermsof Reference.
4.11.4.3 ConditionSurveys forBridges, Culverts andStructures
60
1. TheConsultantsshallthoroughlyinspecttheexistingstructuresandshallprepare areportabouttheirconditionincluding alltheparametersgivenintheInspection pro-formaofIRC-SP; 35.Theconditionandstructuralassessmentsurveyofthe bridges/culverts/structuresshallbecarriedoutby seniorexpertsofthe Consultants.
2. Forthebridgesidentifiedtobeinadistressedconditionbaseduponthevisual conditionsurvey,supplementarytestingshallbecarriedoutasperIRC-SP:35and IRC-SP:40.Selectionoftestsmay bemadebasedonthespecificrequirementof the structure.
3. Theassessmentoftheloadcarryingcapacity orratingofexistingbridgesshallbe carried out underoneormoreof thefollowingscenarios:
i. whenthedesignliveloadislessthanthatofthestatutorycommercial vehicle
plying or likelyto plyon bridge;
ii. ifduringtheconditionassessmentsurveyandsupplementarytestingthe bridge
isfoundtoindicatedistressofseriousnatureleadingtodoubt about
structuraland / orfunctionaladequacy, and
iii. Designliveload is not known nor are therecordsand drawings available
.
4. Theevaluationoftheloadcarryingcapacityofthebridgeshallbecarriedoutas perIRC-SP:37(“Guidelinesfor EvaluationofLoadCarryingCapacity ofBridges”). The analyticalandcorrelationmethodshallbeusedforthe evaluationoftheload carryingcapacity asfaraspossible.Whenitisnotpossible todeterminetheloadcarryingcapacity ofthebridgeusinganalyticaland correlation method, the same shall be carried out using load testing. The consultanthastoexhaustallothermethodsofevaluationofstrengthofbridges beforerecommendingtotakeuploadtestingofbridges.Roadclosurefortesting if unavoidableshallbearranged by NHAI for limited duration say12 hours orso.
5. Consultantshallcarryoutnecessarysurveysandinvestigationstoestablishthe remaining servicelife ofeachretainablebridge orstructure withandwithoutthe proposedstrengthening andrehabilitationaccordingtoacceptableinternational practicein this regard.
4.11.4.4 Geo-technical Investigations andSub-SoilExploration
1. The Consultantsshall carryout geo-technical investigations and sub-surface explorationsfortheproposed Bridges/Roadover bridges/tunnels/ viaducts/ interchanges etc., alonghigh embankments and anyotherlocation as necessary forproperdesignoftheworks and conduct allrelevantlaboratory andfieldtests onsoil androcksamples.The minimumscope ofgeo-technicalinvestigationsfor bridge and structures shallbe as under:
61
2.
Thedeviation(s),ifany,bytheConsultantsfromtheschemepresentedabove should beapproved by NHAI.
3. However,whereastudyofgeo-technicalreportsandinformationavailablefrom adjacent crossings over the same waterway (existing highway and railway bridges)indicatesthatsubsurfacevariability issuchthatboringatthesuggested spacing will be insufficient to adequately define the conditions for design purposes,theConsultantsshallreviewandfinalisethebore holelocationsin consultation with the NHAI officers.
4. Geotechnical Investigations and Sub soil Explorations hall be carried out to determine the nature and properties of existing strata in bed, banks and approacheswithtrialpitsandbore holesectionsshowingthelevels,natureand propertiesof variousstrata toa sufficientdepthbelowthe levelsuitable for foundations,safeintensityofpressureonthefoundationstrata,pronenessofsite toartesianconditions,seismicdisturbanceandotherengineering propertiesofsoil etc.GeotechnicalinvestigationandSub-soilExplorationwillbedoneasperIRC 78.
5. Theschemefortheboringslocationsandthedepthofboringshallbeprepared by theConsultantsandsubmittedto NHAI forapproval.Thesemay befinalisedin consultation with NHAI.
6. The sub-soil exploration and testing should be carried out through the GeotechnicalConsultantsempanelledby MORT&H.Thesoiltestingreportsshall bein theformat prescribed in relevantIRC Codes.
7. Fortheapproachroadpavement,boreholesateachmajorchangeinpavement conditionorindeflectionreadingsorat2kmintervalswhicheverisless shallbe carriedouttoadepthof atleast2mbelowembankmentbaseortorockleveland aretobefullylogged.Appropriateteststobecarriedoutonsamplescollected fromtheseboreholestodeterminethesuitability ofvariousmaterialsforusein wideningof embankments or in parts ofnew pavement structure.
S.No. Description Location ofBoring
1 Overalllength = 6 – 30m One abutment location and One abutment
locationandatleastoneintermediatelocation
between abutments for structures having more
than one span
2 Overalllength = 30– 60 m One abutment location and at least one intermediate location betweenabutments for structures havingmorethan onespan.
3 Overalllength >60 m Each abutment andeachpierlocations.
62
4.11.5. MaterialInvestigations
1. TheConsultantsshallidentifysources(includinguseoffly-ash/slag),quarrysites andborrowareas,undertakefieldandlaboratory testingofthematerialsto determine their suitability for various components of the work and establish qualityandquantityofvarious construction materials and recommend theiruseon thebasisoftechno-economicprinciples.TheConsultantsshallpreparemasshaul
diagramforhaulagepurposesgivingquarry chartsindicatingthelocationof selected borrowareas, quarries and therespectiveestimated quantities.
“Environment friendlymaterials”
“AsperMORTHcircular No.RW/NH-33044/53/2013-
S&R(R)dated20thNovember,2013,alternative pavementmaterialsandtechnologies
for road constructionshallbeassessedandcomparedinthe designstage.Thealternative
resulting insubstantialreductioninGHGemissionandwithleastlife cyclecost
shallberecommended for implementation.
Technicalandeconomicfeasibility ofusingindustrialbyproducts,recyclableand
wastematerialsshallbeassesseddependingontheiravailability intheconcerned region.
2. Itistobeensuredthatnomaterialshallbeusedfromtheright-of-wayexceptby way oflevelingthegroundasrequiredfromtheconstructionpointofview,orfor landscaping andplantingoftreesetc.orfromthecuttingofexistinggroundfor obtainingthe required formation levels.
3. Environmentalrestrictions,ifany,andfeasibilityofavailabilityofthesesitesto prospectivecivilworkscontractors,shouldbeduly takenintoaccountwhile selectingnew quarrylocations.
4. TheConsultantsshallmakesuitablerecommendationsregardingmakingthe borrowandquarry areasaftertheexploitation ofmaterialsforconstructionof works.
5. The Material Investigation aspect shall include preparation and testing of bituminousmixesfor variouslayersandconcrete mixesof differentdesignmix gradesusing suitablematerials(binders,aggregates,sandfilleretc.)asidentified duringMaterialInvestigation to conform to latest MoRT&H specification.
4.12 DetailedDesignofRoad andPavements, Bridges, Structures
4.12.1. General
1. TheConsultantsaretocarryoutdetaileddesignsandprepareworkingdrawings forthe following:
i. Highspeedhighwaywithdividedcarriagewayconfigurationcompletein
allrespects with serviceroads atappropriate locations;
63
ii. Designofpavementfortheadditionallanesandoverlayfortheexisting road,
paved shoulders, medians, verges; iii. Bridges,viaduct/subwaysandothergradeseparatedstructuresincluding
ROBs/RUBs etc. iv. At-gradeand grade-separated intersections, interchanges(ifrequired);
v. ROBforrailwaycrossingsaspertherequirementandthestandardsof the Indian
Railways; and, vi. Prepare alignmentplans, longitudinal sections and cross-sections @
50mintervals; vii. Designsfor road furnitureand road safety/traffic control features; viii. Designs anddrawings for service road/under passes/overpass / cattle
passes treeplanting/fencing atlocations wherenecessary / required ix.. Tollplazasandoffice-cum-residentialcomplexforPIU(oneforeachcivil
contract package) xShortbypasses at congested locations xi. Drainage designshowing locationof turnouts, out falling structures,
separatedrawings sheet for each 5 km. stretch. xii. Bridges and structures rehabilitation planwith design and drawings xiii. Traffic amenities (Parking Areas, Weighing Station and Rest Areas,
etc.).
xiv Design of pavement for approach road
xv Design of river bank protection / training works. Innovative typeof
structures with minimum joints, aesthetically, pleasing and appropriate to
the topography of the region shall be designed wherever feasible.
4.12.2. Design Standards
1. TheConsultantsshallevolveDesignStandardsandmaterialspecificationsforthe Study primarilybasedonIRCpublications,MoRT&HCircularsandrelevant recommendations of theinternational standards forapproval by NHAI.
2. TheDesignStandardsevolvedfortheprojectshallcoverallaspectsofdetailed designincluding the designofgeometricelements,pavementdesign,bridgesand structures, traffic safetyand materials.
4.12.3. Geometric Design
1. Thedesignofgeometricelementsshall,therefore,takeintoaccounttheessential requirements of such facilities.
2. Basedonthedatacollectedfromreconnaissanceandtopographicsurveys,the sectionswithgeometricdeficiencies, if any,shouldbe identifiedandsuitable measures for improvement should be suggestedfor implementation.
3. Thedataonaccidentstatisticsshouldbecompiledandreportedshowingaccident type and frequency so that black spots are identified along the project road section.The possiblecauses(suchaspoor geometricfeatures,pavementcondition etc.) ofaccidentsshouldbeinvestigatedintoandsuitablecost-effectiveremedial measures suggested for implementation.
64
4. Thedetaileddesignforgeometricelementsshallcover,butnotbelimitedtothe followingmajoraspects:
i. horizontal alignment; ii. longitudinal profile;
iii. cross-sectional elements, including refuge lane(50m)at every2kms.
iv. junctions, intersections and interchanges; v. bypasses;and, vi. serviceroads as and when require i.ebuilt up area..
5. Thealignmentdesignshallbeverifiedforavailablesightdistancesasperthe standard norms.The provisionof appropriatemarkingsandsignsshall be made wherevertheexisting siteconditionsdonotpermittheadherencetothesight distancerequirements asper thestandard norms.
6. Theconsultantsshallmakedetailedanalysisoftrafficflowandlevelofservice fortheexistingroadandworkoutthetrafficflowcapacityfortheimproved projectroad.Theanalysisshouldclearly establishthewidening requirementswithrespecttothedifferenthorizonperiodstaking intoaccount special problems suchas road segments with isolated steepgradients.
7. InthecaseofcloselyspacedcrossroadstheConsultantshallexaminedifferent optionssuchas,providinggradeseparatedstructure for someofthemwithaview toreducenumberofat-grade crossings,servicesroadsconnecting thecross-roads andclosing accessfromsomeoftheintersectionsandprepareandfurnish appropriate proposals for this purpose keeping in view the cost of improvement, impact on traffic movementand accessibility to cross roads. The detailed drawings and cost estimate should include the provisions for realignments of the existing cross roads to allow such arrangements.
8. The Consultant shall also prepare design of grade separated pedestrian crossings (viaducts) for largecross traffic of pedestrians and / or animals.
9. TheConsultantshallalsopreparedetailsforat-gradejunctions,whichmaybe adopted asalternative tothegrade separatedstructures.Thegeometric designof interchangesshalltakeintoaccountthe siteconditions,turningmovement characteristics, level of service, overall economyand operational safety.
10. TheConsultantsshallpreparedesignandotherdetailsinrespectoftheparallel serviceroadsinurbanizedlocationsandotherlocationstocatertothelocal traffic,theireffectoftheviabilityoftheprojectoncommercialbasisifservice roadsare constructed aspart of the projectandthe implicationsof notproviding the serviceroads.
11. The consultantshallprepare complete road and pavement design including drainagefornew bypassoption identified aroundcongested town en-route.
4.12.4. Pavement Design
1. Thedetailed design of pavement shallinvolve:
i. strengthening of existingroadpavement and design of thenew pavement if
any,ifthe findingsofthe traffic studiesandlife-cyclecostinganalysis
65
confirmthe requirementforwideningofthe roadbeyond2lane undivided
carriagewaystandard;; ii. pavementdesign for bypasses;and,
iii. design of shoulders.
2. Thedesign of pavementshallprimarilybebasedonIRC publications.
3. ThedesignofpavementshallberigorousandshallmakeuseofthelatestIndian andInternational practices.Thedesignalternatives shallincludebothrigidand flexible designoptions.Themostappropriatedesign,optionshallbe establishedonlife-cycle costing andtechno-economic consideration.
4. Forthedesign ofpavement,eachsetofdesigninputshallbedecidedonthebasis ofrigoroustestingandevaluationofitssuitability andrelevanceinrespectof in-serviceperformanceofthe pavement. Thedesign methodologyshall accompany thedesignproposalsandshallclearlybringoutthebasicassumptions,valuesof the variousdesigninputs,rationale behindthe selectionof the designinputsand thecriteriaforcheckingandcontrolduring theimplementationofworks.Inother words,thedesignofpavementstructureshouldtake dueaccountofthetype, characteristicsofmaterialsusedintherespectivecourses,variability oftheir propertiesandalsothereliability oftrafficpredictions.Furthermore,the methodology adopted for the design of pavement shall be complete with flowchartsindicating thevariousstepsinthedesignprocess,theirinteractionwith one anotherand the input parameter required at each step.
5. Forthedesignofoverlaysfortheexisting2-lanepavement,thestrengthening requirementshallduly takeintoaccountthestrengthoftheexistingpavementvis- à-vistheremaininglife.Theoverlay thicknessrequirementsshallbeworkedout for eachroadsegmenthomogenouswithrespecttocondition,strengthandsub- gradecharacteristics.The rehabilitationprovisionsshouldalsoinclude the provisionofregulatinglayer.Forexisting pavementwithacceptablelevelsof cracking, provision of acrack inhibitinglayer should also beincluded.
6. Latesttechniquesofpavementstrengtheninglikeprovisionofgeo-syntheticsand cold/hotpavementrecyclingshouldbeduly consideredby theconsultantfor achievingeconomy.
7. Thepavedshouldersshallbedesignedasintegralpartofthepavementforthe maincarriageway.Thedesignrequirementsforthecarriageway pavementshall, therefore,beapplicablefor the designof shoulder pavements.The designof granular shoulder shouldtake intoaccountthedrainage considerationsbesidesthe structural requirements.
8. Thepavementdesigntaskshallalsocoverworkingoutthemaintenanceand strengthening requirements and periodicityand timingof such treatments.
4.12.5. DesignofEmbankments
1. The embankmentsdesignshouldprovideformaximum utilization of locally availablematerialsconsistentwitheconomy.Useofflyashwhereveravailable withineconomicalleadsmustbe considered.In accordance withGovernment instructions,useofflyashwithin100km from ThermalPowerStationsis
66
mandatory.
2. TheConsultantsshallcarryoutdetailedanalysisanddesignforallembankments of heightgreater that 6 mbased on relevantIRC publications.
3. The design of embankments should include the requirements for protection worksand traffic safety features.
4.12.6. DesignofBridges andStructures
1. Thedatacollectedandinvestigationresultsshallbeanalysedtodeterminethe following:
i. HFL
ii. LWL
iii. LBL
iv. Erodibilityof bed/scourlevel
v. Design discharge
vi. Linear waterwayand effectivelinearwaterway
vii. Likelyfoundation depth
viii. Safebearingcapacity
ix. Engineeringproperties ofsub soil
x. Artesianconditions
xi. Settlement characteristics
xii. Vertical clearance
xiii. Horizontal clearance
xiv. Freeboardfor approach road
xv. Severityof environmentwith referenceto corrosion
xvi. Data pertainingto seismic and wind load
xvii. Requirement ofmodel studyetc.
2. The Consultant shall prepare General Arrangement Drawing (GAD) and Alignment Plan showing the salient features of the bridges and structures proposedto be constructed/reconstructedalongtheroadsectionscoveredunder the Study.These salientfeaturessuchasalignment,overalllength,span arrangement,crosssection,decklevel,founding level,typeofbridge components(superstructure, substructure, foundations, bearings, expansionjoint, return walls etc.) shallbe finalized based upon hydraulic and geo-technical studies,costeffectivenessandease ofconstruction.The GADshallbe supplementedbyPreliminary designs.Inrespectofspanarrangementandtypeof bridgeafewalternativeswithcost-benefitimplicationsshouldbe submittedto
67
enableNHAIto approvethebest alternative. After approvalof alignment and GADtheConsultantshallpreparedetaileddesignasperIRCcodes/guidelines and workingdrawingsfor allcomponents of bridges and structures.
3. Thelocationofallat-gradelevelcrossingsshallbeidentifiedfallingacrossthe existing levelcrossingsforproviding ROBat theselocations.TheConsultants shallpreparepreliminaryGADfornecessaryconstruction separatelyto theClient. TheConsultantshallpursuetheIndianRailwaysAuthoritiesor/andany statutory authority ofState/CentralGovernmentforapprovaloftheGADfromconcerned Authorities.
4. GAD forbridges/structures acrossirrigation/water waychannels shallbegotapprovedfromtheconcernedIrrigation/Waterway Authorities.Subsequentto approvalofGADandalignmentplan by NHAI,theConsultants shallprepare detailed designasperIRCcodes/guidelinesfor allcomponentsof the bridgesand structures.
5. Subsequent to the approval of the GAD and Alignment Plan by NHAIand Railways,theConsultantshallprepare detaileddesignasperIRCandRailways guidelinesandworking drawingsforallcomponentsofthebridgesandstructures. The Consultantshallfurnishthe designandworkingdrawingsforsuitable protection works and/orrivertrainingworks wherever required.
6. Dismantling/ reconstruction of existing structures shall be avoided as far as possibleexceptwhereconsideredessentialinview oftheirpoorstructural conditions/inadequacyof theprovisions etc.
7. Theexistingstructureshavinginadequatecarriageway widthshallbe widened/reconstructedinpatorfully asperthelatestMoRT&Hguidelines.The Consultantshallfurnishthedetaileddesignandworkingdrawingsforcarrying out the aboveimprovements.
8. Suitable repair / rehabilitation measures shall be suggested in respect of the existing structuresasperIRC-SP:40along withtheirspecifications,drawingsand costestimate intheformof a report.The rehabilitationor reconstructionof the structuresshallbe suggested basedonbroadguidelines forrehabilitationand strengtheningof existingbridgescontained inIRC-SP:35 andIRC-SP:40.
9. SubsequenttotheapprovaloftheGADandthealignmentplanby NHAI,detailed designshallalsobecarriedoutforthe proposedunderpasses,overpassesand interchanges.
10. The Consultants shall also carry out the design and make suitable recommendations for protection works forbridgesand drainagestructures.
11. Incaselandavailableisnotadequateforembankmentslope,suitabledesignfor RCC retainingwallshallbe furnished. However, RESwallmay also be considered dependingupon techno-economicsuitabilityto be approved by NHAI.
68
4.12.7. DrainageSystem
1. Therequirementofroadsidedrainagesystemandtheintegrationofthesamewith proposedcross-drainagesystemshallbeworkedoutfortheentirelengthofthe project road section.
2. Inadditiontotheroadsidedrainagesystem,theConsultantsshalldesignthe specialdrainageprovisionsforsectionswithsuper-elevatedcarriageways,high
embankmentsandfor road segments passing through cuts. The drainage provisionsshallalsobeworkedoutforroadsegmentspassingthroughurban areas.
3. Thedesigneddrainagesystemshouldshowlocationsofturnouts/outfallpoints withdetailsof outfallstructuresfittingintonaturalcontours.A separate drawing sheet covering every5 km. stretchof road shallbeprepared.
4.12.8. TrafficSafety Features,Road FurnitureandRoadMarkings
TheConsultantsshalldesignsuitabletrafficsafety featuresandroadfurniture including trafficsignals,signs,markings,overheadsignboards,crashbarriers, delineatorsetc.Thelocationsofthesefeaturesshallbegiveninthereportsand also shown in the drawings.
4.12.9. ArboricultureandLandscaping
TheConsultantsshallworkoutappropriateplanforplanting oftrees(specifying typeofplantation),horticulture,floricultureonthesurpluslandoftheright-of way withaviewtobeautify thehighwayandmakingtheenvironmentalongthe highway pleasing.Theexistingtrees/plantsshallberetainedtotheextent possible. TheTransplantation oftreesshallalso beproposed wherever feasible.
4.12.10. TollPlaza
1. TheConsultantsshallidentifythepossibletollplazalocation(s)basedonthedata andinformationderivedfromthetrafficstudiesandastudy oftheexisting physicalfeaturesincludingtheavailability ofland.Thelocationoftheplaza shouldkeepinviewthattheprojectroadistobedevelopedasa partially access controlledhighway facility anditisrequiredtocollecttollonrationalbasisfrom asmuchofthevehiculartrafficaspossibleconsistentwitheconomy ofcollection andoperations.The locationof the tollplaza shouldbe finalisedinconsultation with NHAI.
2. Toll Plazashall bedesignedas perIRC84.
4.12.11. Weighing Station, Parking Areas andRest Areas
Theconsultantshallselectsuitablesitesfor weighing stations,parkingareasand restareasandprepare suitableseparatedesignsinthisregard. The common facilitieslike petrolpump,first-aidmedicalfacilities,police office, restaurant, vehicleparking etc.shouldbeincludedinthegenerallayoutforplanning.For petrolpump,theguidelinesissuedbyOISDofMinistry ofPetroleumshallbe
69
followed.Thefacilitiesshouldbeplannedtobeatapproximately 50kminterval. Atleasteachfacility (1no.)isforeseentobeprovidedforthisprojectstretch. Weighing stationscan belocated neartollplazassothatoverloadedvehiclescan beeasily identifiedandsuitably penalizedandunloadedbeforebeingallowedto proceedfurther.Thetypeofweighing systemsuitablefortheprojectshallbe broughtoutinthereportgivingmeritsofeachtypeofthestate-of-theartand basisof recommendations forthe chosen system.
4.12.12 Office-cum-ResidentialComplex forPIU-Deleted
4.12.13 Miscellaneous Works
1. TheConsultantsshallmakesuitabledesignsandlayoutformiscellaneousworks includingrestareas,busbays,vehicle parking areas,telecommunicationfacilities etc. wherever appropriate.
2. TheConsultantsshallpreparethedetailedschemeandlayoutplanfortheworks mentioned in Para1.
3. TheConsultantsshallpreparedetailedplanforthetrafficmanagementandsafety duringtheconstruction period.
4.13 Environment and SocialImpactAssessment
Theconsultantshallundertakethedetailedenvironmentalandsocialimpactassessment inaccordancewiththestandardsetbytheGovernmentofIndiaforprojectsproposedto befundedbyMORT&H/NHAI.InrespectofprojectsproposedtobefundedbyADB loan assistance,EnvironmentalAssessmentRequirements,EnvironmentalGuidelinesfor selectedinfrastructure projects,1993ofAsianDevelopmentBankshallbefollowed. Similarly,forprojectsproposedtobefundedbyWorldBankloanassistance,World Bank Guidelines shall befollowed.
4.13.1 EnvironmentalImpactAssessment
Environmentimpactassessmentorinitialenvironmentexaminationbecarriedoutin accordancewith ADB’s Environmental Assessment Requirements of ADB 1998guidelinesforselectedinfrastructureprojects1993asamendedfromtimetotime /World Bank Guidelines/ Government ofIndia Guidelines, as applicable
1. Theconsultantshouldcarryoutthepreliminaryenvironmentalscreening toassess the direct and induced impacts due to theproject.
2. The consultant shall ensure to document baseline conditions relevant to the project with the objectiveto establish thebenchmarks.
3. Theconsultantshall assessthepotentialsignificantimpactsand identifythe mitigation measures to address theseimpacts adequately.
4. Theconsultantshalldotheanalysisofalternativesincorporatingenvironmental concerns. Thisshouldinclude withandwithoutscenarioandmodification incorporated in the proposed project due toenvironment considerations.
5. Theconsultantshallgivespecialattentiontotheenvironmentalenhancement measures in theproject for thefollowing:
70
(a) Cultural propertyenhancement alongthe highways (b) Bus bays and bus shelters includingareviewof their location, (c) Highwayside landscapeand enhancement oftheroad junctions, (d) Enhancement of highwayside waterbodies,and (e) Redevelopment of the borrow areas located on publicland.
6. The consultant shall prepare the bill-of-quantities (BOQ) and technical specificationsforallitemsofworkinsuchaway thatthesemay bereadily integrated to the construction contracts.
7. Theconsultantshallestablishasuitablemonitoringnetworkwithregardtoair, waterand noisepollution. The consultantwillalso provide additional inputs in the areas ofperformanceindicatorsandmonitoringmechanismsfor environmental components during construction and operational phaseof theproject.
8. Theconsultantshallprovidethecostofmitigationmeasuresandensurethat environmental related staffing, training and institutional requirements are budgeted in project cost.
9. The consultant shall prepare the application forms and obtain forestry and environmentalclearancesfromtherespectiveauthoritiesincluding theSPCBsand the MOEF on behalf of NHAI. The consultants will make presentation,ifrequired,indefending theprojecttotheMOEFInfrastructure Committee.
10. TheconsultantshallidentifyandplanforplantationandTransplantationofthe suitable trees alongtheexistinghighwayin accordancewithIRCguidelines.
11. The consultant shall assist in providing appropriate input in preparation of relevant environment andsocial sections of BPIP.
4.13.2 SocialAssessment
1 Theconsultantwouldconductbaselinesocio-economicandcensussurveyto assessthe impactsonthe people, propertiesandlossof livelihood.The socioeconomicsurvey willestablishthebenchmarkformonitoringofR&R activities.A socialassessmentisconductedforthe entire projecttoidentify mechanisms to improve project designs to meet the needs of different stakeholders.Asummary ofstakeholderdiscussions,issueraisedand howthe project design was developed to meet stakeholders need would beprepared.
2 TheconsultantshallprepareLandAcquisitionPlanandassistNHAI in acquisition ofland under various Acts.
4.13.2.3 The consultant would prepare Resettlementand Rehabilitation Plan and assess feasibilityandeffectivenessofincomerestorationstrategiesandsuitability and availability torelocationsites.Theresettlementplanwhichaccountsforland acquisitionand resettlementimpactswouldbebasedona 25% socio-economic surveyand100%censussurveyofprojectaffectedpeoplewhichprovidesthe completeassessmentofthenumber ofaffectedhouseholdsandpersons,including commonpropertyresources.Alluntitledoccupantsarerecordedattheinitial stagesandidentify cardswillbeissuedtoensurethereisnofurtherinfluxof
71
peopleintotheprojectarea.Allconsultationswithaffectedpersons(toinclude listofparticipants)shouldbefully documentedandrecordsmadeavailableto NHAI.
• Assessmentontheimpactoftheprojecton thepoorandvulnerablegroups alongthe project road corridor.
• Basedontheidentifiedimpacts,developingentitlementmatrixforthe project affected people.
• Assessment on social issues such as indigenous people, gender, HIV/AIDS, labourers includingchild labour.
• Implementation budgets, sources and timingof fundingand schedule of tasks.
• Responsibility of tasks, institutional arrangements and personnel for delivering entitlement and plans to build institutional capacity.
• Internal andexternal monitoringplans, keymonitoringindicatorsand grievanceredress mechanism.
• IncorporatinganyothersuggestionsoftheADB/ World Bank/ NHAI,tilltheacceptanceofthereportsby theADB/ World Bank/ NHAI
4.13.3 Reporting Requirements ofEIA
• Theconsultant would prepare the stand-alone reports as per the requirement of the ADB/World Bank /NHAI, as applicable, with contents as per the following:
• Executive Summary
• Description of the Project
• Environmental setting of the project.
• Identification and categorization of the potential impacts (during pre-construction, construction and operation periods).
• Analysis of alternatives (this would include correlation amongst the finally selected alternative alignment/routing and designs with the avoidance and environmental management solutions).
• The public consultation process.
• Policy, legal and administrative framework. This would include mechanisms at the states and national level for operational policies. This would also include a description of the organizational and implementation mechanism recommended for this project.
• Typical plan or specific designs for all additional environmental items as described in the scope of work.
• Incorporating any other as per the suggestions of the ADB/ World Bank / NHAI, till the acceptance of the reports by the ADB/ World Bank /NHAI, as applicable.
• EMP Reports for Contract Package based on uniform methodology and processes.TheconsultantwillalsoensurethattheEMPhasalltheelementsforittobea legal document. TheEMPreports would includethe following:
o Briefdescriptionoftheproject,purposeoftheEMP,commitmentson incorporating environmentalconsiderationsinthedesign,constructionand operationsphasesof the projectandinstitutionalarrangementsfor
72
implementingthe EMP. o AdetailedEMPforconstructionandoperationalphaseswithrecourseto
the mitigation measuresfor alladverseimpacts. o Detailed plans for highway-side tree plantation (as part of the
compensatoryaforestationcomponent). o Environmental enhancement measurewould be incorporated. o Enhancementmeasureswouldincludeitemsdescribedinthescopeof
workandshallbe complete withplans,designs,BOQ andtechnical specifications.
o Environmentalmonitoringplansduringandafterconstructionincluding scaling andmeasurementtechniquesfortheperformanceindicators selected for monitoring.
o TheEMPshouldbeamendabletobeincludedinthecontractdocuments forthe works.
o IncorporatinganyotherasperthesuggestionsoftheADB/WorldBank/ NHAI,tilltheacceptanceofthereportsby theADB/World Bank /NHAIas applicable.
4.13.4 Reportingrequirements ofRAP
Analysisonthe resettlementplan be conducted basedonADBsHandBookon Resettlement,A Guide toGood practice 1998asamendedtime totime/ World Bank Guidelines / GovernmentofIndia Guidelines, asapplicable.
• Executive summary
• Description of project
• Objectives of the project.
• TheneedforResettlementintheProjectandevaluationofmeasurestominimize resettlement.
• Description and results of public consultation and plans for continued participation of PAPs.
• Definition ofPAPs and the eligibilitycriteria.
• Census and survey results-number affected, how are they affected and what impacts will theyexperience.
• Legal and entitlement policy framework-support principles for different categories of impact.
• Arrangements formonitoringandevaluation (internal and external)
• Implementation scheduleforresettlement which is linked to the civil works contract
• Amatrixofscheduledactivitieslinkedtolandacquisitionprocedurestoindicate clearlywhat steps and actions will be taken at different stagesand the timeframe
• Thepayment ofcompensation and resettlement duringtheacquisition process
• Anitemizedbudget(replacementvalueforallassets)andunitcostsfordifferent assets
73
5. Estimation ofQuantities andProject Costs
1. The Consultants shall prepare detailed estimates for quantities (considering designsandmasshauldiagram)andprojectcostfor theentire project(civil packageswise),including thecostofenvironmentalandsocialsafeguards proposed based on MoRT&H’sStandardData Book and market rate forthe inputs.Theestimationofquantitiesshallbebasedondetaileddesignofvariouscomponentsoftheprojects.Theestimationofquantitiesandcostswouldhaveto beworked out separatelyfor civil work Packageas defined in this TOR.
2. TheConsultantsshallmakedetailedanalysisforcomputingtheunitratesforthe differentitemsofworks.Theunitrateanalysisshalldulytakeintoaccountthe variousinputsandtheirbasicrates,suggestedlocationofplantsandrespective leaddistancesformechanizedconstruction.Theunitrate for eachitemof works shallbeworked out in terms of manpower, machineryand materials.
3. TheprojectcostestimatessopreparedforNHAI/ADB/WBprojects are tobecheckedagainstratesforsimilaron-going worksinIndiaunder NHAI/ WorldBank/ ADBfinancedroad sector projects.
6. Viability andFinancingOptions
1. TheProjectRoadshouldbedividedintothetraffichomogenouslinksbasedon thefindingsofthetrafficstudies.Thehomogenouslinksofthe ProjectRoad shouldbe further subdividedintosectionsbasedonphysicalfeaturesof roadand pavement,sub-gradeanddrainagecharacteristicsetc. Theeconomic and commercialanalysisshallbecarriedoutseparately foreachtraffichomogenous link as wellas forthe Project Road.
2. The values of input parameters and the rationale for their selection for the economicandcommercialanalysesshallbeclearly broughtoutandgotapproved byNHAI.
3. For models to be used for the economic and the commercial analyses, the calibrationmethodology andthebasicparametersadaptedtothelocalconditions shallbe clearlybrought outand got approved byNHAI.
4. The economic and commercial analyses should bring out the priority of the different homogenous links in terms of project implementation.
6.1. Economic Analysis
1. TheConsultantsshallcarryouteconomicanalysisfortheproject.Theanalysis shouldbe for eachof the sectionscoveredunderthisTOR.The benefitandcost streamsshouldbe workedoutfor theprojectusing HDM-IVorother internationallyrecognized life-cycle costingmodel.
2. The economicanalysisshallcover but benot limited to be following aspects:
i. assessthecapacityofexistingroadsandtheeffectsofcapacityconstraints on
74
vehicleoperating costs(VOC); ii. calculate VOCs forthe existing road situation and thosefor theproject; iii. quantifyalleconomicbenefits,includingthosefromreducedcongestion,
traveldistance,roadmaintenance costsavingsandreducedincidence of road
accidents; and, iv. estimatetheeconomicinternalrateofreturn(EIRR)fortheprojectovera
30-yearperiod.IncalculatingtheEIRRs,identifythetradableandnon- tradable
componentsofprojectscostsandthe borderprice value ofthe tradable
components.
v. Saving in time value.
3. Economic Internal Rate of Return (EIRR) and Net Present Value (NPV), “with “and“withouttimeandaccidentsavings” shouldbe workedoutbasedon thesecost-benefitstream.Furthermore,sensitivity ofEIRRandNPVworkedout forth different scenariosas givenunder:
Scenario – I BaseCostsand BaseBenefits Scenario - II BaseCosts plus 15% and BaseBenefits Scenario - III BaseCostsand BaseBenefits minus 15% Scenario - IV BaseCostsplus 15%and BaseBenefits minus 15%
Thesensitivityscenariosgivenaboveareonly indicative.TheConsultantsshall selectthesensitivityscenariostakingintoaccountpossibleconstructiondelays, constructioncostsoverrun,traffic volume,revenue shortfalls,operatingcosts, exchange rate variations, convertibility of foreign exchange, interest rate volatility,non-complianceordefaultby contractors,politicalrisksandforce majeure.
4. Theeconomicanalysisshalltakeintoaccountallon-goingandfutureroadand transport infrastructureprojects and futuredevelopment plans in the project area.
6.2. FinancialAnalysis
1. Itisenvisagedthatthe projectstretchshouldbeimplementedonEPC/BOTbasis, therefore,theConsultantshallstudy thefinancialviability oftheprojectundera commercialformatand under different userfeescenariosand funding options. The Consultantsshallsubmit andfinalizeinconsultationwiththe NHAI officersthe formatfortheanalysisandtheprimary parametersandscenariosthatshouldbe takenintoaccountwhilecarryingoutthecommercialanalysis.Thefinancial model so developed shallbethe propertyof NHAI.
2. The Financial analysis for the project should cover financial internal rate of return,projected incomestatements,balance sheetsandfund flow statementsand shouldbringoutallrelevantassumptions.Thesensitivity analysisshouldbe carried out foranumberof probabilistic scenarios.
3. Thefinancial analysis should coveridentification,assessment, and mitigating measuresforallrisksassociatedwiththeproject.The analysisshallcover,butbe notlimited to,risksrelated toconstruction delays,constructioncostsoverrun, trafficvolume,revenueshortfalls,operating costs,exchange ratevariations, convertibility offoreignexchange,interestratevolatility,non-complianceor defaultbycontractors, political risks and forcemajeure.
75
4. TheconsultantshallsuggestpositivewaysofenhancingtheprojectViabilityand furnish different financial models forimplementingonBOTformat.
7. Timeperiod forthe service
1. TimeperiodenvisagedforthestudyoftheprojectisindicatedinAnnex-Ito LOI.Thefinalreports,drawingsanddocumentationshallbecompletedwithin this time schedule.
2. NHAI shall arrange to give approval on all sketches, drawings, reports and recommendationsandothermattersandproposalssubmittedfordecisionby the Consultantinsuchreasonabletimesoasnottodelayordisrupttheperformance of theConsultant’s services.
8. Project TeamandProject Officeofthe Consultant
1. The Consultants shall be required to form a multi-disciplinaryteam for this assignment. The consultantsteamshall be manned by adequate number of expertswithrelevant experience inthe executionof similar detaileddesign assignments.
2. Listofsuggestedkeypersonneltobefieldedbytheconsultantwithappropriate man-monthofconsultancy servicesisgiveninEnclosureIasperclient'sassessment.
3. A Manning Schedule for key personnel mentioned above is enclosed as EnclosureIalong with broadjob-descriptionandqualificationasEnclosureII. TheinformationfurnishedinEnclosuresI&IIaretoassisttheConsultants to understandthe client’s perceptionabout these requirements andshall be taken bythe Consultants for the purpose ofFinancialProposaland deploymentscheduleetc.intechnical proposal tobe submittedbythem.Any deviationproposedmay be recordedinthecommentsonTOR.Allthekey personnelmentionedwillbe evaluatedatthetime ofevaluationoftechnical proposal.Consultantsare advisedintheir owninteresttoframethetechnical proposalinanobjectivemanneras faraspossiblesothat thesecouldbeproperly assessed in respect of points to begivenas part ofevaluation criteria as mentioned inDatasheet.Thebio-dataofthekey personnelshouldbesignedoneverysheet by thepersonnelconcernedandthelastsheetofeachbio-datashouldalsobe signed bytheauthorisedsignatoryof theConsultants.
4. TheConsultantsshallestablishanofficeattheprojectsitemannedbysenior personnelduring thecourseofthesurveysandinvestigations.Alltheproject relatedofficeworkshallbecarriedout by theconsultantintheirsiteofficeunless there arespecialreasonsforcarrying outpartoftheofficeworkelsewherefor whichprior approvalof NHAIshallbe obtained.The addressofthesiteoffice including thepersonnelmanning itincludingtheirTelephoneandFAXnumbers will be intimated by the Consultant to NHAI before commencement of the services.
5. The Consultant shall maintain an Attendance Register to be signed by each individualkey personnelatsiteaswellasatHeadOffice.TheConsultantshall furnish certificate that all the key personnel as envisaged in the Contract
76
AgreementhavebeenactuallydeployedintheProjectsatthetimeofsubmission of their bills to the NHAI from timeto time.
9. Reports to besubmitted by the Consultant to NHAI
9.1 Allreports,documentsanddrawingsaretobesubmittedseparatelyforeachofthetraffic homogenouslinkoftheProjectRoad.Theanalysisof dataandthe designproposalsshall bebasedonthedataderivedfromtheprimary surveysandinvestigationscarriedout during theperiod ofassignment.Thesourcesofdataandmodelrelationshipsusedinthe reports shallbeindicatedwith completedetails foreasyreference.
9.2 Project preparation activities will be split into six stages as brought out below. Preliminarydesignworkshouldcommencewithoutwaitingforfeasibilitystudytobe completed. Stage 3, 5 and 6 shall run in parallel with Stage 2 and 4
Stage 1: Inception Report Stage 2: Feasibility Report Stage 3: LA & Clearances I Report Stage 4: Detailed Project Report (DPR) Stage 5: Technical Schedules Stage 6: LA & Clearances II Report
9.3 Consultant shallbe requiredtocomplete,tothesatisfactionoftheclient,allthedifferentstagesof studywithinthetimeframeindicatedinthescheduleofsubmissioninpara10pertaining toReportsandDocumentsforbecomingeligibleforpaymentforanypartofthenext stage.
10 Reports andDocuments to be submitted by theConsultant to NHAI
1. TheConsultantshallsubmittotheclientthereportsanddocumentsinbound volumes(andnotspiral binding form)aftercompletionofeachstageofworkas perthescheduleandinthenumberofcopiesasgiveninEnclosureIII.Further, thereportsshallalsobesubmittedinfloppydiskettes/CD’sinadditiontothe hardcopies asmentioned in Enclosure-III. Consultant shall submit all other reports mentioned specificallyin theprecedingparas of theTOR.
2. The time schedule for various submissions prescribed at s.l.no.1 above shall be strictly adhered to. No time-over-run in respect of these submissions will normally be permitted. Consultant is advised to go through the entire terms of reference carefully and plan his work method in such a manner that various activities followed by respective submissions asbroughtout at Sl.No.1 above are completed asstipulated.Consultantis,therefore, advisedto deploy sufficient numberofsupporting personnel,bothtechnicalandadministrative,toundertake the project preparation activities in construction package(Section) simultaneously.Asfaraspossible,theproposalshouldinclude complete informationsuchasnumber of suchpersons,name, position,periodof
77
engagement,remunerationrateetc.TheConsultantisalsoadvised tostart necessarysurveyworks fromthebeginningso asto gaintimeinrespectof various otheractivities in that stage.
STAGE 1
10.1 Quality AssurancePlan(QAP)Document
1. Immediatelyupontheaward,theConsultantsshallsubmitfourcopiesofthe QAPdocumentcovering allaspectsoffieldstudies,investigationsdesignand economicfinancialanalysis.Thequality assuranceplans/proceduresfordifferent fieldstudies,engineering surveysandinvestigation,designanddocumentation activitiesshouldbepresentedasseparate sectionslikeengineering surveysand investigations,traffic surveys,materialgeo-technicalandsub-soilinvestigations, road and pavement investigations, investigation and design of bridges &structures,environmentandR&Rassessment,economic& financialanalysis, drawingsanddocumentation;preparation,checking,approvalandfiling of calculations,identificationandtraceability ofprojectdocumentsetc.Further, additionalinformationasperformatshallbefurnishedregarding thedetailsof personnelwhoshallberesponsibleforcarrying out/preparingand checking/verifyingvariousactivitiesformingpartoffeasibility studyandproject preparation,sinceinceptionto thecompletionofwork.Thefieldanddesign activities shallstart afterthe QAP is approved byNHAI.
2. The data formats proposed by the Consultants for use in field studies and investigationsshallbesubmittedwithin 14daysafterthecommencementof services andgot approved byNHAI.
10.2 Inception Report (IR)
1. Thereport shallcover thefollowingmajor aspects:
i. Project appreciation;
ii. Detailedmethodologytomeettherequirementsofthe TOR finalisedin
consultationwiththe NHAIofficers;includingschedulingof various sub
activitiestobe carriedoutfor completionof variousstagesofthe
work;statingout clearlytheirapproach& methodologyforproject
preparation after due inspection of the entire project stretch and
collection/ collation of necessary information;
iii. TaskAssignment and Manning Schedule;
iv. Workprogramme;
v. Proforma for data collection;
vi. Design standards and proposed cross-sections;
vii. Keyplan and Linear Plan;
viii. Development plans being implemented and / or proposed for
implementationinthe nearfuture by thelocalbodiesandthepossible impact
ofsuch development plans on theoverall schemefor field workand design
for thestudy;
78
ix. QualityAssurancePlan(QAP)finalised in consultation with NHAI;
x. Draft design standards; and
2. Therequirements,ifany,fortheconstructionofbypassesshouldbeidentifiedon the basisof data derivedfrom reconnaissanceandtraffic studies.Theavailable alignmentoptionsshouldbe workedoutonthebasisof available maps.The most appropriatealignmentoptionforbypassesshouldbeidentifiedonthebasisofsiteconditionsandtechno-economic considerations.InceptionReportshouldinclude thedetailsregarding theseaspectsconcerning theconstructionofbypassesfor approval byNHAI.
STAGE 2: 10.3 Feasibility Report
1. The consultant shall commence the Feasibility Study of the project in accordancewith the acceptedIRand the report shallcontain the following:
i. Executivesummary
ii. OverviewofNHAIorganizationandactivities,and project financing and cost
recoverymechanisms
iii. Project description including possible alternative alignments/bypasses and
technical/engineering alternatives
iv. Methodologyadopted forthe feasibility study
v. Socioeconomicprofileofthe project areas
vi. Indicativedesign standards, methodologies and specifications
vii. Traffic surveys and analysis
viii. Environmentalscreeningand preliminary environmentalassessment
ix. Initial social assessment and preliminaryland acquisition/resettlement
plan
x. Cost estimates based on preliminary rate analysis and bill of quantities
xi. Economicand financialanalysis
xii. Conclusions and recommendations
2. Inviewofpara1 abovethe consultanthasto submitthefollowingdocuments insixsets:
i. TechnicalSpecifications:TheMORT&H’sTechnicalSpecificationsfor RoadandBridgeworksshallbefollowedforthisstudy.However,Volume - IV: TechnicalSpecificationsshallcontainthe specialtechnical
specifications which are not covered by MORT&H Specifications for
RoadsandBridges(latestedition/revision)andalsospecific quality control
norms for the construction of works. ii. RateAnalysis:Thisvolumewillpresenttheanalysisofratesforallitems
ofworks.Thedetailsof unitrateofmaterialsat source,carriagecharges, any
other applicable charges, labourrates, and machine chargesas
considered in arriving at unitrates will be included in this volume. iii. CostEstimates:Thisvolumewillpresenttheeachitemofworkaswellas a
summaryof totalcost. iv. Bill ofQuantities:This volume shall contain the detailed Bill of
79
Quantities for all items of works
3. The basic data obtained from the field studies and investigations shall be submitted in aseparate volume as an Appendixto FeasibilityReport.
4. The Final Feasibility Study Report incorporating comments, revisions and modificationssuggestedbyNHAIshallbesubmittedwithin15daysofreceiptof comments from NHAI ondraft feasibilitystudyreport.
STAGE 3:
10.4
1.
StripPlanandClearances
TheConsultants shall submitthe followingdocuments:
i. DetailsofthecenterlineoftheproposedwidenedNHalongwiththe
existingandproposedright-of-waylimitstoappreciatetherequirements of
land acquisition;
ii. The information concerningthe areaincludingownershipoflandtobe
acquiredfortheimplementationoftheprojectshallbe collectedfromthe
revenueandother concernedauthoritiesand presentedalongwiththe strip
plans;
iii. Strip plans showing the position of existing utilities and services
indicating clearlythe position of their relocation;
iv. Details for various clearances such as environment and forest clearances;
v. Separate stripplanshowingshifting/relocationof eachutility servicesin
consultation with the concerned local authorities;
vi. Theutilityrelocationplansshould clearlyshow existingright-of-wayand
pertinenttopographicdetailsincludingbuildings, majortrees,fencesand other
installationssuch aswater-mains,telephone, telegraphand electricity
poles,andsuggestrelocationofthe servicesalongwiththeir crossingsthe
highway atdesignated locations asrequiredandprepare necessary details
for submission tothe ServiceDepartments;
vii. Detail schedulesfor acquisition of additional land and additional
properties in consultation with the revenueauthorities;and
viii. Land Acquisition Plan shall be prepared after digitization of cadastral /
land revenue maps. The digitized map shall exactly match the original
map, like a contact print, since the dimensions and area of plots, or the
whole village is to be extracted from the map itself. An accuracy of
1mm or higher in a 1:1000 scale map shall be ensured, as this translates
into an accuracy of 1 m or higher on ground.
2. Thestripplansandlandacquisitionplanshallbepreparedonthebasisofdata from reconnaissance anddetailed topographic surveys.
3. TheReportaccompanyingthestripplansshouldcovertheessentialaspectsas given under:
i. Kilometre-wiseLandAcquisitionPlan(LAP)andscheduleofownership
thereofandCostsasper RevenueAuthoritiesandalsobasedonrealistic rates. ii. Detailsofproperties,suchasbuildingsandstructuresfallingwithinthe right-
ofwayand costsof acquisition based on realisticrates. iii. Kilometre-wiseUtilityRelocationPlan(URP)andcostsforrelocationper civil
80
construction packageas per concerned authorities. iv. Kilometre-wiseaccountinregardtofellingoftreesofdifferenttypeand
girthandvalue estimate ofsuchtreesbasedonrealistic ratesobtainable from
concernedDistrict forest office.
4. Thestripplansshallclearlyindicatetheschemeforwidening.Theviewsand suggestionsoftheconcernedState PWDsshould bedulytakenintoaccountwhile workingoutthewidening scheme(left,rightor symmetrical).The widening scheme shallbefinalisedin consultation withNHAI
5. Kilometre-wiseStripPlansforsection(Package)shallbepreparedseparatelyfor eachconcerned agencyand suggested by NHAI
10.5
1.
LandAcquisitionReport
TheLandacquisitionreportshallbepreparedandsubmittedforsection(package).
Thereportshallincludedetailschedulesaboutacquisitionoflandholdingsasper revenuerecordsandtheirlocationsina stripplanandalsothe costsasperdistrict authorities.Detailsshallbe submittedinlandacquisitionproforma tobe supplied by NHAI.ThelandacquisitionreportshallbesubmittedinbothHindand English languages.
2. The landacquisitionreportshouldbepreparedinconsultationwith affected persons, non-governmental organisationsand concernedgovernment agencies and shouldcoverlandacquisitionandresettlementplan andcostsofresettlementand rehabilitation of such affected persons. It should also include plan of compensatingafforestation,itsland requirementwithspecific locations andcost involved forundertaking allactivities in this regard.
3In addition as the stretch is passing through hilly terrain, to avoid dispute in land acquisition and proper demarcation/identification of PROW in future, ROW pillers (PROW) all along the section are to be erected by the consultant.
10.6 Deleted
STAGE: 4
10.7 Draft DetailedProjectReport (DPR)
1. The draft DPR Submission shall consist of construction package-wise Main Report,DesignReport,MaterialsReport,Engineering Report, DrainageDesign Report, EconomicandFinancialAnalysisReport, EnvironmentalAssessment Report includingResettlementAction Plan(RAP), Package-wisebidDocuments and Drawings.
2. TheReport volumes shallbesubmitted as tabulated in para10above.
3. TheDocumentsandDrawingsshallbesubmittedforthePackageandshallbein the followingformat:
81
Reports
i. Volume-I, Main Report: Thisreportwillpresenttheprojectbackground,social analysisofthe project,
detailsofsurveys and investigations carried out, analysis
andinterpretationofsurveyandinvestigationdata,traffic studiesand demand
forecastsdesigns, cost estimation, environmentalaspects, economic and
commercial analyses andconclusions. The report shallinclude Executive
Summarygiving brief accounts of thefindings of thestudy and
recommendations.
TheReportshall alsoincludemaps, chartsand diagramsshowing
locationsand detailsof existingfeaturesandthe
essentialfeaturesofimprovementand
upgrading.TheEnvironmentalImpactAssessment (EIA)Reportfor
contractpackageshallbe submitted as a part ofthe main report.
Thebasicdataobtained fromthefieldstudies andinvestigationsandinputdata
usedforthe preliminary designshallbe submittedinaseparate volume asan
Appendix to Main Report.
ii. Volume - II, Design Report: This volume shall containdesign calculations,
supportedby computer printoutof calculations whereverapplicable.
TheReport shall clearly bringoutthe variousfeaturesof
designstandardsadopted forthe study. The designreportwillbe
intwoparts.Part-I shallprimarily dealwiththe
designofroadfeaturesandpavement compositionwhilePart-IIshall dealwith
the designofbridges,tunnelsand cross-drainage structures. Thesub-soil
explorationreportincludingthe complete detailsofboringdone,analysesand
interpretationofdata andtheselectionofdesignparametersshallbeincludedas
an Appendix to the Design Report.
The detailed designfor allfeaturesshouldbe carriedoutasperthe
requirements of theDesign Standards for theproject. However,theremay
besituations wherein ithasnotbeenpossible
tostrictlyadheretothedesignstandardsduetothe existingsiteconditions,
restrictionsandother considerations. The report should clearly bring
outthe details oftheseaspect and thestandards adopted.
iii. Volume - III, Materials Report: The MaterialsReportshall contain details
concerningtheproposedborrowareasandquarriesfor constructionmaterials
andpossible sourcesofwaterfor construction purposes. The
reportshallinclude detailson locations of borrowareas and quarries shown
on maps and chartsand alsothe
estimatedquantitieswithmasshauldiagramincludingpossible enduse
withleadsinvolved,the detailsofsamplingand testing carriedoutandresultsin
the form of important index values with possible end usethereof.
82
Thematerials Report shall also includedetails of sampling, testing and test
resultsobtained inrespectphysicalpropertiesofsubgrade soils.
Theinformation shall be presented in tabular as well as in graphical
representations and schematic diagrams. TheReport shall present soil
profiles along the alignment.
The materialReportshouldalso clearly indicate the locations ofareaswith
problematicsoils.Recommendations concerningtheimprovementofsuchsoils
foruseintheproposed constructionworks,suchasstabilization(cement,lime,
mechanical)should be included in the Report.
iv. Volume - IV, Environmental Assessment Report including
Environmental Management Plan (EMP) & Resettlement Action Plan (RAP): The Report shall be prepared conforming to the Guidelines of the
Government of India, State Government and World Bank / ADB as
appropriate for construction package.
v. Volume - V, Technical Specifications: The MORT&H’s
TechnicalSpecificationsfor Road and Bridge works shall be followed for
this study. However, Volume IV: Technical Specifications shall contain
the special technical specificationswhich are not covered by MOST
Specifications for Roads and Bridges (latest edition / revision) and also
specific quality control norms for the construction of works.
vi. Volume - VI, Rate Analysis: This volumewillpresenttheanalysisof ratesfor
all itemsofworks. The detailsofunitrateofmaterialsatsource, carriage
charges, any otherapplicable charges,labourrates,machinechargesas
consideredin arriving atunitrates willbeincluded in this volume.
vii. Volume - VII, Cost Estimates:This volumewillpresentthe contract package
wise cost of each item of workas wellas a summaryof total cost.
viii. Volume - VIII, Bill of Quantities:This volumeshall containthepackage-
wise detailed Bill ofQuantities forallitems of works.
ix. Volume - IX, Drawing Volume:Alldrawings forming part of this
volumeshall be ‘good for construction’ drawings. All plan
andprofiledrawings willbe prepared inscale1:250Vand 1:2500H scale to
cover one km in onesheet. In addition this volumewill contain ‘good for
construction’ drawings for the following:
• Horizontal Alignment and Longitudinal Profile.
• Cross-section @ 50m interval along the alignment within ROW
• Typical Cross-Sections with details of pavement structure.
• Detailed Working Drawings for individual Culverts and Cross
DrainageStructures.
• Detailed Working Drawings for individual Bridges, tunnels
83
and Structures.
• Detailed Drawings for Improvement of At-Grade and Grade-
Separated
• Intersections and Interchanges.
• Drawings for Road Sign, Markings, Toll Plazas, and other
Facilities.
• Schematic Diagrams (linear chart) indicating but be not limited to
be following:
o Widening scheme;
o Locations of median openings, intersections, interchanges,
underpasses, overpasses, bypasses;
o Locations of service roads;
o Location of traffic signals, traffic signs, road
markings,safety features; and,
o Locations of toll plaza, parking areas, weighing stations,
bus bays, rest areas, if any.
• Drawings for toll plaza, Bus Bays, Parking areas, Rest areas,
weighing stations etc.All drawings will be prepared in A2 size
sheets. The format for plan, crosssection and profile drawings shall
be finalised in consultation with the concerned NHAI officers. The
drawings shall also include details of all BM and reference pillars,
HIP and VIP. The co-ordinates of all points should be referenced
to a common datum, preferably GTS referencing system. The
drawings shall also include the locations of all traffic safety
features including traffic signals, signs, markings, crash barriers,
delineators and rest areas, busbays, parking areas etc.
• The typical cross-section drawings should indicate the scheme for
future widening of the carriageway. The proposed cross-sections of
road segment passing through urban areas should indicate the
provisions for pedestrian movements and suitable measures for
surface and sub-surface drainage and lighting, as required.
10.8. Final Detailed Project Report, Documents and Drawings (6 Sets)
1. The Final package-wise DPR consisting of Main Report, Design Report, Drainage Design Report and Materials Report, incorporating all revisions deemed relevant following receipt of the comments from NHAI on the draft DPR shall be submitted as per the schedule given in Enclosure-III.
STAGE: 5
10.9. Technical Schedules
1. Civil Work Contract Agreement: A civil works contract agreement shall be submitted
84
STAGE: 6
10.10. LA & Clearances II Report
1. Draft 3a, 3A, 3D notification shall be submitted by the consultant. 2. All the necessary project related clearances such as environment, forest and
wildlife clearance from MOEF, Railways in respect of ROB/ RUBs, Irrigation Deptt and any other concerned agencies shall be obtained by the consultant. The final approvals shall be obtained and submitted to NHAI so that project implementation can straight away proceed without any hold up. For utility clearances, consultant shall prepare draft utility shifting estimates using the latest Schedule of Rates and obtain final approval from utility agency and NHAI.
11. Interaction with NHAI
1. During entire period of services, the Consultant shall interact continuously with NHAI and provide any clarification as regards methods being followed and carryout modification as suggested by NHAI. A programme of various activities shall be provided to NHAI and prior intimation shall be given to NHAI regarding start of key activities such as boring, survey etc. so that inspections of NHAI officials could be arranged in time.
2. The NHAI officers and other Government officers may visit the site at any time,
individually or collectively to acquaint/ supervise the field investigation and survey works. NHAI may also appoint a Proof Consultant to supervise the work of the DPR consultant including inter-alia field investigation, survey work, Design work and preconstruction activities
3. The consultant shall be required to send 3 copies of concise monthly Progress
Report by the 5th day of the following month to the designated officer at his Head Quarter so that progress could be monitored by the NHAI. These reports will indicate the dates of induction and de-induction of various key personnel and the activities performed by them. Frequent meetings with the consultant at site office or in Delhi are foreseen during the currency of project preparation.
4. All equipment, software and books etc. required for satisfactory services for this
project shall be obtained by the Consultant at their own cost and shall be their property.
12. Payment Schedule
1. The Consultant will be paid consultancy fee as a percentage of the contract values as per the schedule given in the Draft Contract Agreement.
85
13. Data and Software
1. The floppy diskettes/CD’s containing all basic as well as the processed data from all field studies and investigations, report, appendices, annexure, documents and drawings shall be submitted to NHAI at the time of the submission of the Final Report. If required by NHAI the consultant shall arrange at their own cost necessary software for viewing and measurement of imagery/ point cloud data. The data can be classified as follows:
i. Engineering Investigations and Traffic Studies:Road Inventory,
Condition,Roughness, TestPit (Pavement composition),BenkelmanBeam
Deflection, MaterialInvestigationincluding test resultsforsubgradesoils,
Traffic Studies(traffic surveys),axleloadsurveys,Sub-soilExploration,
DrainageInventory,Inventorydataforbridge and culvertsindicating
rehabilitation,new constructionrequirement etc.in MSEXCELor any other
format which could be imported to widelyused utility packages.
ii. Topographic Surveys and Drawings:Alltopographicdatawould be
suppliedin (x, y, z) formatalongwith completereferencesothatthedata could
be imported into any standard highway design software. The drawing files
would be submitted in dxf or dwg format.
iii. Rate Analysis: TheConsultantshallsubmitthe rateanalysisfor various
worksitemsincludingthe datadeveloped on computerinthisrelation so thatit
couldbeusedby theAuthoritylaterforthe purposeofupdatingthe cost ofthe
project.
iv. Economic and Financial Analysis
2. Software: TheConsultant shall also hand-overto NHAIfloppies/CD’s containing any generalsoftwareincluding thefinancialmodelwhichhasbeenspecifically developed for theproject.
3. Thefloppydiskettes/CD’sshouldbeproperlyindexedandacataloguegiving contents of all floppies/CD’s and print-outs of the contents (data from field studiestopographicdataanddrawings)shouldbehandedoverto N H A I atthe time ofsubmission of the Final Report.
4. Consultant shall include editable soft copies of the final versions of all
documents, including but not limited to the strip plan, plan & profile drawings, cross sections of right of way and details of structures as well as any cost workings.
87
SUPPLEMENT I
ADDITIONAL POINTSTO BE CONSIDERED FOR HILL ROADSIN ADDITION
TO POINTSCOVERED IN MAINTOR
S.
No.
ClauseNo.
ofTOR
Additional points
1. 2.2 a) Provisions of tunnels if required.
2. 2.3 a) Design of tunnels, if required
b) Designof protectiveworks,slope stabilizationmeasures,erosioncontrol
measures, land slide control/protection measures snow drift
control/snowclearancemeasures,avalanche protectionmeasures,if
required
3. 3 Feasibilitystudyandpreparationofdetailedprojectreportforhillroads shallbe done inaccordance withbestinternationalpracticesandwherever practicable/feasiblesteepgradientsandhairpinbendsmay beavoidedby realignments byprovision ofstructuresand provision of tunnels if required
4. 4.1 a)Inventoryand condition surveyfortunnels, ifrequired.
b)Identificationoffaultsinrockstrataandimpactoffaultsindesignof tunnels, if
required
c)Detaileddesignofroadconsideringandincorporatingspecificaspects
relatedtohillregionlike terrain,topographicconditions,extreme
weatherconditions, altitude effects etc.
d) Designofprotectiveworks,slopestabilizationmeasures,erosioncontrol
measures,land slidecontrol/protectionmeasures,snowdrift
control/snowclearancemeasures,avalanche protectionmeasures,if
required
e) Design of scenic overlooks/wateringpoints etc.
5. 4.5 (1) Allactivitiesrelatedtofieldstudies,designanddocumentationshallbe
doneasper the latestguidelines/circulars ofMORT&H andrelevant
publicationsof theIndianRoadsCongress(IRC)/BureauofIndian Standards
(BIS) for hillroads.For aspectsnotcoveredbyIRCandBIS,
internationalstandard practices,such as,British and American Standards
maybe adopted.
6. 4.7 Reviewof dataand documents pertainingto
a) Terrain and soil condition
b) Condition of tunnels, if required.
c) Sub-surfaceandgeo-technical data forexistingtunnels, if required. d)
Drawing and details ofexistingtunnels, if required.
e) Existing protective works, erosion control and land slide control/
88
protection works, slope stabilization measures, snow drift control measures,avalancheprotection measures
f) Existing land slide and snow clearance facilities g)Geological details of rock strata in the area in case of tunnels
7. 4.11(1) TheConsultantshouldmakeanindepthstudyofavailablegeologicaland
meteorologicalmapsof the area.
8. 4.11 (2) The primary tasks to be accomplished during the reconnaissance survey shallalso include: a) details of terrain (steep or mountainous ), cliffs and gorges, general
elevation of the road including maximum heights negotiated by main ascents and descents, total number of ascents and descents, hair pin bends, vegetation etc.
b)Climaticconditions i.e. temperature, rain fall data,snow fall data,fog conditions, unusual weather conditions etc.
c) Realignment requirements including provision of tunnels, if required. d) Inventory of tunnels and geologically sensitive areas like slip prone
areas, areas subjecttolandslides, rock fall, snow drifts, erosion, avalanche activity etc.
9. 4.11.2.1 (ii) Cross sections shall be taken at every 25 m. in case of hill roads and at points of appreciablechanges in soil conditions. While takingcross sections, soil conditions shallalso be recorded.
10. 4.11.3.1 (1) Theinventorydata shallalso include:
a)Generalelevationofroadindicating maximum&minimumheights
negotiated by mainascents &descents and total no. of ascents
&descents.
b)Detailsofroadgradients,lengthsofgentle& steepslopes,lengths& locationof
stretchesinunstableareas,areaswithcliffs,areaswithloose
rocks,landslideproneareas,snow driftprone areas,no.& locationof hairpin
bends etc.
c) Details of tunnels
d)Details&types ofprotective structures,erosion&landslide
control/protectionmeasures,snow driftcontrolmeasures,avalanche
protection/control measures etc.
11. 4.11.3.2 (2) Pavement:
a)Location of crust failures alongwith their causes
b)Conditionsofcamber/crossfalls/superelevationsetc.,whetheraffected
bysubsidence
Embankment:
Extent ofslope erosion on hill and valleyside
89
12. -- Condition Surveys &Investigation for Slope Stabilization, Erosion
Control, Landslide Correction/Protection &Avalanche Protection
Measures:
a) Inventory &Condition Surveys of Existing Protective/Control
Measures:
TheconsultantshallmakeaninventoryofallthestructuresrelatedtoSlope
Stabilization, ErosionControl,Landslide Control/protection, Avalanche
Protection etc. This shallinclude details of effectiveness of control measures
alreadydoneandcondition of protective/control structures.
b)LandslideInvestigation
Thisshallbecarriedouttoidentify landslideproneareas,tosuggest
preventivemeasuresoralternateroutesthatare lesssusceptibletolandslide
hazard.Furtherinexisting slideareasthisshallhelptoidentify factors
responsibleforinstability andtodetermineappropriatecontrolmeasures needed
to prevent or minimizerecurringof instabilityproblems.
Initial preliminarystudiesshallbecarriedoutusingavailablecontourmaps
, topographical maps,geological/geo-morphological maps,aerial
photographsetc.forgeneralunderstanding ofexisting slideareaandto identify
potential slide areas. This shall be followed by further
investigationslike geological/geotechnical/hydrologicalinvestigationto
determine specific site conditions prevailing in the slide area as per
relevantIRCspecifications/publications,MORT&Hcirculars andrelevant
recommendationsof theinternationalstandards for hillroads.The resultof the
investigations shall providebasis for engineering analysis and the design of
protection/remedial measures.
13. 4.11.4.4 a) For tunnels if required, geotechnical and subsurface investigation shallbedoneasperIRC:SP:91.
b) Geotechnical andsubsurface investigationandtesting for tunnels shallbe carriedoutthroughthe geotechnicalConsultantswhohave theexperience ofgeotechnicalandsubsurface investigationinsimilar project.
14. 4.12.1 (1) TheConsultantshallalsocarryoutdetaileddesignsandprepareworking
designsfor thefollowing:
a) cross sections at every25 m intervals
b) Slopestabilization anderosion control measures
c) Designofprotection/control structures in areas subjecttosubsidence,
landslides,rockfall,rockslide,snowdrifts,icing,scour, avalanche
activityetc.
d) Design of protectivestructures in slip prone andunstable areas
e) Design of scenic overlooks,wateringpoints etc.
f)Safetyfeatures specificto hillroads
15. 4.12.2 (1) TheConsultantshallevolveDesignStandardsandmaterialspecifications
90
4.12.2 (2)
fortheStudyprimarilybasedonIRCpublications,MORT&HCirculars andrelevantrecommendationsof the internationalstandards for hillroads for approval by NHAI.
The Design Standards evolvedfor theprojectshallcoverallaspectsof detaileddesignincluding thedesignofgeometricelements,pavement design,bridgesandstructures,tunnelsifrequired,trafficsafety and materials.
16. 4.12.3 Whereverpracticable/feasiblehairpinbendsandsteepgradientsshallbe
avoided by realignments, provision of structures or any other suitable
provisions.
17. 4.12.4 Whiledesigningpavementforhillroadsspecificaspectsrelevanttohill
regionsliketerrain& topographicconditions,weatherconditions,altitude
effectsetc.shallbedulyconsideredandsuitably incorporatedindesignso
thatpavementisabletoperformwellfor thedesigntraffic andservice life.
Effectsoffactorslikeheavy rainfall,frostaction,intensivesnowand
avalancheactivity,thermalstressesduetotemperaturedifferenceinday
andnight,damagebytrackedvehiclesduringsnowclearanceoperations
etc.mustalsobeconsideredalongwithtrafficintensity,itsgrowth,axle loads and
design life.
18. 4.12.5(3) Thedesignofembankmentsshouldincludetherequirementsforprotection
worksand traffic safetyfeatures includingfeatures specificto hillroads.
19. -- Designand Drawingof Tunnels:
TheConsultantshallpreparedesignanddrawingsfortunnels,ifrequired
aspertheresultsoffeasibility study,aspertherelevantspecificationsof
IRC:SP:91/MORT&H and otherinternational specifications.
20. 4.12.7 a)Topographyofhillsgeneratesnumerouswatercoursesandthiscoupled
withcontinuousgradientsofroadsinhillsandhighintensity ofrainfall
callsfor effective drainage of roads.The drainage systemshallbe
designedtoensurethatthewaterflowing towardstheroadsurfacemay
bedivertedandguidedtofollowadefinite pathby suitableprovisionof
roadsidedrains,catchwater drains,interceptorsetc.andflow onvalley side
is controlled so that stabilityis not affected.
b)Further,adequateprovisionshallbemade forsub-surface/subgrade
drainagetotakecareofseepagethroughtheadjacenthillfaceofthe road
&underground water flows.
21. 4.12.8 The Consultant shall design suitable traffic safety features and road
furnitureincludingtrafficsignals,signs,markings,overheadsignboards,
crashbarriers,delineatorsetc.includingany featurespecifictohillroads. The
locationsof these featuresshallbe given inthe reportsandalsoshown in
thedrawings.
22. 4.12.3 (1) TheConsultantshallmakesuitabledesignsandlayoutformiscellaneous
91
works including rest areas, bus bays, vehicle parking areas,
telecommunicationfacilities, scenic overlooks, watering points etc.
wherever appropriate.
23. 10.6 (1) VolumeII: DesignReport :
a)Inventoryof protection measures and otherstructures
b)Inventoryof tunnels, if required.
c) Proposed preliminarydesigns for tunnels, if required.
VolumeIII: Drawings
a) Drawings forprotection/control measuresand otherstructures
b) Drawings for tunnels,if required.
24. 10.7 (3) VolumeII: Design Report (PartII)
PartIIofDesignReportshallalsodealwithdesignoftunnels,ifrequired and
design of other protection/control structures.
VolumeIX: Drawing Volume
This shallalso include:
a) Detailedworkingdrawings for tunnels, if required.
b) Detailed workingdrawings for protection/control structures
92
SUPPLEMENT II
S.No. ClauseNo.
ofTOR
Additional points
1 4.1 Forstandalonebridgeprojectsthescopeofworkshallinclude
detailed designofapproachroadextending at least upto 2kmon
eithersideofthe bridge
1. 4.11.4.2(6) Model Studies forBridges
1. Objective
Physical/MathematicalModelstudy fordetailedHydraulic/
Hydrologicinvestigationsregarding theproposed bridgefor
hydraulic designof thebridge andassessmentand hydraulic design
ofrequired river trainingworks.
2. Methodology
Physical/MathematicalModelstudy shallbecarriedoutata
reputed/recognized institution. The consultant will be
responsibleforidentifyingtheinstitution,supplyingInformation
/Documents/Datarequiredformodalstudiesasindicatedinpara
4belowandcoordinating themodelstudy withtheinstitution
concerned
3. ScopeofWork
3.1 Physical Model study
Physicalmodelingwithappropriatemodelscalefor Hydraulic and
HydrologicInvestigations to :
i) Finalizespanarrangementcausinguniformityinflow
distribution,andworkout thealignmentandorientation of
rivertrainingworks and bridgeaxis.
ii) Provide informationon estimated/observed maximum
depth of scour.
iii) Provideinformationonrequiredrivertrainingworksfor
proposed bridge
iv) Providehydraulicdesignforthebridgeandtherequired river
training works.
v) Quantifythegeneraldirectionofrivercoursethrough
bridge,afflux,extentandmagnitudeofflood,effectof
backwater, ifany, aggradation/degradationof bed,
evidenceofscouretc.shallbe usedtoaugmentthe available
hydrologicaldata. Thepresence offlood
control/irrigationstructures,ifaffecting thehydraulic
characteristicslikecausingobliquity,concentrationof
93
flow,scour,silting of bed,changeinflowlevels,bed
levelsetc. shallbe studiedandconsideredinHydraulic
designofproposedbridge.Thedetailsofany planned
workintheimmediatefuturethatmay affecttheriver
hydraulics shall be studied and considered
3.2 Mathematical Model study
Mathematical modelingfor detailed Hydraulic / Hydrologic
investigations regardingtheproposed new bridgeto:
i) Finalizethe site/location ofthe proposed newbridge
based on mathematical modeling.
ii) Provideinformationon estimated/observed maximum
depth of scour..
iii)Provideinformation on required river trainingworks for
proposed bridge
iv)Providehydraulicdesignforthe bridgeand the required
river trainingworks.
v) Quantifythegeneral direction ofriver coursethrough
bridge,afflux, extent and magnitudeofflood, effect of
backwater, if any,aggradation/degradation ofbed,
evidenceof scouretc. shallbeused to augment the
available hydrological data. Thepresenceof flood
control/irrigation structures, if affectingthehydraulic
characteristics like causingobliquity,concentration of
flow, scour, siltingof bed, changein flow levels,bed
levels etc. shallbestudied and considered in Hydraulic
design of proposed bridge. Thedetails ofanyplanned
work in theimmediate futurethat mayaffect theriver
hydraulics shall be studied and considered.
4. Information /Documents /Data required for Physical
/Mathematical Model study
i) Plan layoutsshowing the locations of the proposed bridgeaswellastheexisting bridges/barragesetc.,in thevicinity oftheproposedbridgewiththechainages with respect to astandardreferencemarked on it.
ii) Highflooddischargesandcorrespondingfloodlevelsat thelocationsoftheexisting bridgesinthevicinity ofthe proposed bridge.
iii) General arrangement drawing (GAD) of the existing bridgesshowing numberofspans,pierandwell dimensions,foundinglevels,maximumscourlevel,the
94
designdischargeandtheHFL,guidebunddetails. On this,theplanformof the rivercoursewiththebridge alignment mayalso be shown as far as possible.
iv) Generalarrangementdrawing(GAD)oftheproposed new
bridge showingnumber of spans,pier and foundationdimensions.Onthis,theplanformofthe river coursewith the bridge alignment may also be shown as for as possible.
v) River cross sections at 500m longitudinal spacing (maximum)uptoa distance of 2timesthebridgetotal lengthonthe upstreamside anduptoa distance equalto thebridgetotal length on thedownstream with right bankandleftbankclearly markedonit.Atleastone crosssectiontobe provided atthe locationof the proposedbridge.At eachcross section,the bedlevelsto betakenatamaximum lateraldistanceof8minflow sectionandat25minnonflow section respectively.The abrupt variations in thebed levelsto becaptured by taking measurements at closer locations both in longitudinal as wellas lateral directions.
vi) Thecrosssections,asforaspossible,fromhighbankto high bank.
vii) Thelongitudinalprofileoftheriveralong thelengthof the
proposed alignment.
viii) Sizedistributionoftheriverbedmaterialandthebore log
dataatdifferentlocationsatthesiteoftheproposed bridge.
ix) Theseriesofannualpeakfloodoftheriverforatleast
15years period.
95
SUSUPP
LEMENT-III
ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT FOR SAFETY AUDIT
Theuseofchecklistsishighlyrecommendedastheyprovideauseful“aidememoire”for theauditteamtocheckthatnoimportantsafety aspectsarebeingoverlooked.They alsogiveto theprojectmanagerandthedesignengineerasenseofunderstandingoftheplaceofsafety audit inthedesignprocess.Thefollowing listshavebeendrawnupbasedontheexperience ofundertakingsystematicsafety auditproceduresoverseas.Thisexperienceindicatesthat extensivelistsof technicaldetailshasencouragedtheir useas“tick” sheetswithoutsufficient thoughtbeinggiven tothe processes behindtheactions.Accordingly,the checklistsprovide guidelineson the principalissues that need to be examined duringthe courseof thesafetyaudits.
StageF-During Feasibility Study
1. Theauditteamshouldreviewtheproposeddesignfromaroadsafetyperspectiveand heck the followingaspects
CONTENTS
ITEMS
Aspects to be checked
A. Safetyandoperationalimplicationsofproposedalignment and
junctionstrategy withparticular referencestoexpected road
usersand vehicletypes likelyto usetheroad.
B. Width options considered forvarious sections.
C. Departures from standards and action taken.
D. Provision of pedestrians,cyclistsand intermediatetransport E.
Safety implications of the scheme beyond its physical limits
i.e.howtheschemefitsintoitsenvironsandroad
hierarchy
96
A1 : General
� Departures from standards
�Cross-sectional variation
�Drainage
�Climatic conditions
�Landscaping
�Services apparatus
�Lay-byes
�Footpath
�Pedestrian crossings
�Access(minimizenumber ofprivateaccesses)
97
�Emergencyvehicles
�PublicTransport
�Futurewidening
�Stagingof contracts
�Adjacent development
A2 :Local Alignment
�Visibility
�New/Existingroad interface
�SafetyAids onsteep hills
A3 : Junctions
�Minimisepotential conflicts
� Layout
�Visibility
A4 : Non-Motorised
road usersProvision
�Adjacent land
� Pedestrians
�Cyclists
�Non-motorised vehicles
A5 : Signs andLighting
�Lighting
�Signs/Markings
A6 : Construction and
Operation
�Buildability
�Operational
�NetworkManagement
Stage1 – CompletionofPreliminary Design
1.Theauditteamshouldreviewtheproposedcheckthefollowingaspectsdesignfromaroad
safetyperspectiveand check the followingaspects
CONTENTS
ITEMS
Aspects to be checked
A.Safety andoperationalimplicationsofproposedalignment
andjunctionstrategywithparticularreferencestoexpectedroad users
and vehicle types likelyto usetheroad.
B. Width options considered forvarious sections.
C. Departuresfrom standards and action taken.
D. Provision ofpedestrians, cyclistsand intermediate transport
98
E.Safetyimplicationsoftheschemebeyonditsphysicallimits
i.e. howthe schemefits into its environs and roadhierarchy
B1 : General
�Departures from standards
�Cross-sectional variation
�Drainage
�Climatic conditions
�Landscaping
�Services apparatus
�Lay-byes
�Footpaths
�Pedestrian crossings
�Access(minimizenumber ofprivateaccesses)
�Emergencyvehicles
�PublicTransport
�Futurewidening
�Stagingof contracts
�Adjacent development
B2 :Local Alignment
�Visibility
�New/Existingroad interface
�SafetyAids on steep hills
B3 : Junctions
�Minimisepotential conflicts
� Layout
�Visibility
B4 : Non-Motorised road
users Provision
�Adjacent land
� Pedestrians
�Cyclists
�Non-motorised vehicles
B5 : Signs andLighting
�Lighting
�Signs/Markings
B6 : Construction and
Operation
�Buildability
�Operational
�NetworkManagement
99
Stage2 – CompletionofDetailedDesign
1. TheauditteamshouldsatisfyitselfthatallissuesraisedatStage1havebeenresolved.Items mayrequirefurtherconsideration wheresignificant design changes haveoccurred.
2.Ifascheme hasnotbeensubjecttoastage1audit,theitemslistedinChecklistsB1toB6should be considered together with the items listed below.
CONTENTS
ITEMS
Aspects to be checked
A. Anydesign changessinceStage1.
B. Thedetaileddesignfromaroadsafety viewpoint,includingthe roadsafetyimplicationsoffuturemaintenance(speedlimits;road signsandmarkings;visibility;maintenanceofstreetlighting and central reserves).
C1 : General
�Departures from standards
�Drainage �Climatic conditions
�Landscaping
�Services apparatus
�Lay-byes
�Access
�Skid-resistance
�Agriculture
�SafetyFences
�Adjacent development
C2 :Local Alignment
�Visibility
�New/Existingroad interface
C3 :Junctions
�Layout
�Visibility
�Signing
� Lighting
�Road Marking
�T,X,Y-junctions
�All roundabouts
�Trafficsignals
C4 : Non-Motorisedroad users Provision
�Adjacent land
� Pedestrians
�Cyclists
100
�Non-motorised vehicles
C5 : Signs andLighting
�Advanced direction signs
�Local trafficsigns
�Variable messagesigns
�Other trafficsigns
�Lighting
C6 : Construction and Operation
�Buildability
�Operational
�NetworkManagement
101
Enclosure-I
MANNINGSCHEDULE
SI. No
KeyPersonnel TotalProjectAssignment (8 months)
At site
(mm)
At design office (mm)
Total Time Period (mm)
1
TeamLeaderCum SeniorHighway Engineer
3.5
3.5
7
2 SeniorBridge Engineer
1
2 3
3 Highwaycum Pavement Engineer
1.5
2
3.5
4 Material-cum- Geo-technical Engineer– Geologist
3
2
5
5 SeniorSurvey Engineer
3
2
5 6 Traffic and Safety
expert
1
2
3 7 Environmental
Specialist
1 1.5
2.5 8 QuantitySurveyor/
Documentation Expert
1
3.5
4.5
Total 15 18.5 33.5
1. Consultantshavetoprovideacertificatethatallthekeypersonnelasenvisagedinthe
ContractAgreementhavebeenactuallydeployedintheprojects.Theyhavetofurnishthecertificate
at thetime ofsubmissionoftheirbills to NHAI fromtime totime.
2. IncaseTunnelsaretobeconstructed,necessaryinputofTunnelExpertsshallbeprovidedin addition
toabove mentioned Manpowerrequirement.
102
Enclosure-II
QualificationandExperienceRequirement ofKeyPersonnel
TeamLeader cumSeniorHighway Engineer
i) Educational Qualification
Essential Graduate in Civil Engineeringor equivalent
Desirable Post graduateinCivilEngineering
(highways/structures/trafficand
transportation/soil mechanics and
foundation engineering/ Construction
Management /Transportation)
ii) Essential Experience
a)Total Professional Experience Min. 20years
b) Experiencein Highwayprojects Min. 15 years in Planning, project
preparationand design ofHighway projects,
including 2/4/6laningofNH/SH/
expressways.Forhillroads,respective hill roads
experienceis required
c)Experienceinsimilarcapacity
(Either as Team Leader or in
Similar capacity)
InFeasibility oftwo/Four/SixLaningworks
and DPR/IC/Construction Supervisionof
Two/Four/sixlaning ofmajorhighway
projects(NH/SH/Expressways)/ feasibility
cum detailed project report of two/ four
laningprojectsofminimumaggregatelength of
80km.For hillroads,respective hillroads
experienceisrequired.
iii) AgeLimit 70 years onthe dateofsubmissionof
proposal
103
Enclosure-II(contd.)
QUALIFICATION AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENT OF KEYPERSONNEL
Highway cumPavement Engineer
i) Educational Qualification
Essential DegreeinCivilEngineering
Desirable Masters in highway engineering/
TransportationEngineering
ii) Experience
a)Total Professional Experience Min. 15years
b) Experiencein Highwayprojects Minimum10years experiencein pavement
design and maintenanceof highways
c) Experiencein similarcapacity Pavementdesignformajorhighwayprojects
(2/4/6 lane NH/SH/ Expressways) of
minimum aggregatelength of 80 km.
iii) AgeLimit 70 years onthe dateofsubmissionof
Proposal
104
Enclosure-II(contd.)
QUALIFICATION AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENT OF KEYPERSONNEL
SrBridge Engineer
i) Educational Qualification
Essential Graduate in Civil Engineeringor equivalent
Desirable Masters inBridgeEngineering /
Structural Engineering
ii) Essential Experience
a)Total Professional Experience Min. 15years
b) ExperienceinBridgeprojects Min. 10 years in project preparation
anddesign of bridgeprojects.
c) Experienceinsimilarcapacity Bridge Engineer in highway design
consultancy projects(2/4/6laneNH/SH/
Expressways)involving designofminimum
twomajorbridges(lengthmorethan200m
)
iii) AgeLimit 70 years onthe dateofsubmissionof
Proposal
105
Enclosure-II(contd.)
QUALIFICATION AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENT OF KEYPERSONNEL
Traffic andSafety Expert
i) Educational Qualification
Essential Graduate in Civil Engineering
Desirable Masters inTraffic Engineering /
TransportationEngineering / Transport
Planning
ii) Essential Experience
a) Total Professional Experience Min. 10years
b) Experiencein Highwayprojects Min. 5years on similar projects.
c) Experienceinsimilarcapacity Traffic Engineer in highway Projects
(NH/SH/Expressways) involving 2/4/6
laningofminimumaggregatelengthof80 km.
iii) AgeLimit 70 years onthe dateofsubmissionof
Proposal
106
Enclosure-II(contd.)
QUALIFICATION AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENT OF KEYPERSONNEL
MaterialEngineer– cum– Geotechnical Engineer cumGeologist
i) Educational Qualification
Essential Graduate in Civil Engineering
or M.Sc. Geology
Desirable Masters inFoundationEngineering / Soil
Mechanics / PhdinGeology /Geo Tech
Engineering
ii) Essential Experience
a) Total Professional Experience Min. 15years
b) Experiencein HighwayProjects Min. 8years on similar projects in design
and/or construction
c) Experiencein similarcapacity Material cum Geo-technical Engineer on
highway projects(2/4/6lane
NH/SH/Expressways)ofminimum aggregate
length of 80 km.
iii) AgeLimit 70 years onthe dateofsubmissionof
Proposal
107
Enclosure-II(contd.)
QUALIFICATION AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENT OF KEYPERSONNEL
Senior SurveyEngineer
i) Educational Qualification
Essential Graduate or equivalent in Civil Engineering or Diploma in Civil Engg or Diploma in Surveying
Desirable Masters in Survey Engineering/
Surveying /RemoteSensing
ii) Essential Experience
a) Total Professional Experience Min. 15years
b) Experiencein Highwayprojects Min. 5years on similar projects in project
preparation and construction &thorough
understandingof moderncomputer based
methods of surveying
c) Experiencein similarcapacity SurveyEngineerforprojects preparation of
highwayproject (NH/SH/Expressways)
involving2/4/6-laningof minimum
aggregate length of 80 km.
iii) AgeLimit 65 years onthe dateofsubmissionof
Proposal
108
Enclosure-II(contd.)
QUALIFICATION AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENT OF KEYPERSONNEL
Environmental Specialist
i) Educational Qualification
Essential Graduate in Civil Engineering/ Environment
Engineering/ Masters inEnvironment
Science
Desirable PostGraduateinEnvironmental
Engineering
ii) Essential Experience
a) Total Professional Experience Min. 10 years
b) Experiencein HighwayProjects Min. 5years in environment impact
assessment ofhighwayprojects (2/4/6
laning)
c) Experiencein similarcapacity Environmental Specialistin at least two
highwayprojects (2/4/6 laning)
iii) AgeLimit 70 years onthe dateofsubmissionof
proposal
109
Enclosure-II(contd.)
QUALIFICATION AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENT OF KEYPERSONNEL
Quantity Surveyor/DocumentationExpert
i) Educational Qualification
Essential Graduate or equivalent in Civil Engineering/
Certificate coursefrom ‘Institution of
QuantitySurveying’
Desirable
ii) Essential Experience
a) Total Professional Experience Min. 15years
b) Experiencein HighwayProjects Min. 5 years in Preparation of Bill of
Quantities, Contractdocuments and
documentationformajorhighway projects
involvingtwo/ fourlaning
c) Experiencein similarcapacity
QuantitySurveyor / Documentation Expert
in highwayprojects (NH/SH/Expressways)
involvingtwo/four/sixlaningof minimum
aggregatelength of 80 km.
iii) AgeLimit 70 years onthe dateofsubmissionof
proposal
110
Schedule forsubmissionofReports andDocuments
Enclosure-III
Stage No.
Activity No. ofcopies TimePeriod in
daysfromdateof
commencement 1 Monthly Reports 3 by10thdayofevery
month
2 Inception Report (i) DraftInception ReportincludingQAP document (ii) Inception Report includingQAP document
3
3
21
30
3 F.S. REPORT i)DraftFeasibilityStudy Reportincludingoption studyreport ii)Comments ofclient
iii)FinalFeasibility Study Report incorporating complianceofcomments ofClient.
4
1
4
75
90
105
4 LA & Clearances I Report i) Draft LA & Clearances I Report ii) Comments of client iii) Final LA & Clearances I Report incorporating compliance of comments of Client
4
1
4
90
105
120
5 DetailedProjectReport i)DraftDPR
ii)Comments ofclient
iii)FinalDPR incorporatingcompliance ofcomments ofClient
4
1
6
165
195
210
111
6 Technical Schedules i) Draft Technical Schedules ii) Comments of client iii) Final technical schedule
4
1
6
135
150
165
7 LA & Clearances II Report Approval of Projectclearancesfrom concernedagencies e.g. fromMOEF; Rlyfor approvalofGADand detailengineering drawingofROB/RUB; Irrigation Dept.,
Land Acquisitions: 3(a), 3(A), 3(D) Notifications
6
Original letters
fromthe concerned
agenciesand 5 photocopies
ofeach.
3 copiesea
ch
240
Note: Consultant shall self-evaluate the above reports based on the relevant checklists included in Appendix – VII and submit the checklists to the authority
112
APPENDIX-II
(Date and Reference)
To, **********
*********
*********
ProofofEligibility
Form-E1
Letter ofProposal (On Applicant’s letterhead)
Sub: AppointmentofConsultantfor preparation
ofDetailed Project Reportfor……………...
Dear Sir,
WithreferencetoyourRFPDocumentdated………,I/wei.eM/s-------------------------------------
--------------------------------------(NameofBidder) h a v i n g examinedallrelevantdocumentsand
understoodtheircontents,hereby submitourProposalforselectionasConsultant. Theproposal is
unconditional and unqualified.
2. AllinformationprovidedintheProposalandintheAppendicesistrueandcorrectandall documents
accompanyingsuch Proposal aretrue copies oftheirrespectiveoriginals.
3. ThisstatementismadefortheexpresspurposeofappointmentastheConsultantforthe aforesaid
Project.
4. I/We shall make available to the Authority any additional information it may deem
necessaryor requirefor supplementingorauthenticatingtheProposal.
5. I/Weacknowledgetherightoftheauthoritytorejectourapplicationwithoutassigningany
reasonorotherwiseandherebywaiveourrighttochallengethesameonany account whatsoever.
6. I/Wecertifythatinthelastthreeyears,weoranyofourAssociateshaveneitherfailedto
performonanycontract,asevidenced by impositionofapenaltyby anarbitralorjudicial authority
orajudicialpronouncementorarbitrationawardagainsttheApplicant,norbeen
expelledfromanyprojectorcontractbyanypublicauthoritynorhavehadanycontract terminated
byanypublicauthorityfor breach on our part.
113
7. I/WeunderstandthatyoumaycanceltheSelectionProcessatanytimeandthatyouare
neitherboundtoacceptanyProposalthatyoumayreceivenortoselecttheConsultant,
withoutincurringany liability totheApplicantsinaccordancewithClause1.7oftheRFP
document.
8. I/Wedeclarethatwe/anymemberoftheconsortium,are/isnotaMemberofanyother
Consortiumapplying for Selection as aConsultant.
9. I/Wecertifythatinregardtomattersotherthatsecurityandintegrityofthecountry,weor
anyofourAssociateshavenotbeenconvictedbyaCourtofLaworindictedoradverse orders passed
by a regulatory authority which would cast a doubt on our ability to
undertaketheConsultancy fortheProjectorwhichrelatestoagraveoffencethatoutrages the moral
senseof the community.
10. I/Wefurthercertifythat in regardto matters relatingto securityand integrityofthe
country,wehavenotbeencharge-sheetedbyanyagencyoftheGovernmentorconvicted byaCourt
ofLawfor anyoffence committed byus or byanyof our Associates.
11. I/Wefurthercertifythatnoinvestigationbyaregulatoryauthorityispendingeitheragainst us
or against our Associates or against our CEO or any of our
Directors/Managers/employees.
12. I/Wehereby irrevocablywaiveanyrightorremedywhichwemay haveatany stageatlaw or
howsoever otherwise arising to challenge or question any decision taken by the Authority
[and/ortheGovernmentofIndia]inconnectionwiththeselectionofConsultant or in connection
with the Selection Process itself in respect of the abovementioned Project.
13. The BidSecurityofRs. ***** (Rupees *****)in the form ofa Bank Guarantee is
attached, in accordancewith theRFPdocument.
14. I/We agree and understand that the proposal is subject to the provisions of the RFP
document.Innocase,shallI/wehaveany claimorrightofwhatsoevernatureifthe Consultancy
fortheProjectisnotawardedtome/usorourproposalisnotopenedor rejected.
15. I/Weagreetokeepthisvalidfor120(Onehundredandtwenty)daysfromtheProposal
DueDate specified intheRFP.
16. APowerofAttorneyinfavouroftheauthorizedsignatorytosignandsubmitthisProposal and
documents is attached herewith.
114
17. In the event of my/our firm/consortiumbeingselected as the Consultant,I/weagreetoenter
intoany AgreementinaccordancewiththeformAppendixVoftheRFP.Weagreenotto seek
anychanges in the aforesaid form and agreeto abide bythe same.
18. I/WehavestudiedRFPandallotherdocumentscarefullyandalsosurveyedtheProject
site.Weunderstandthatexcepttotheextentasexpressly setforthintheAgreement,we
shallhavenoclaim,rightortitlearisingoutofanddocumentsorinformationprovidedto
usbytheAuthorityorinrespectofanymatterarisingoutoforconcerningorrelatingto the Selection
Process includingthe award ofConsultancy.
19. TheProofofEligibilityandTechnicalproposalarebeingsubmittedinseparatecoversin hardcopy
andthey arebeing submittedonlinealso.FinancialProposalisbeing submitted
onlineonly.ThisProofofEligibility readwithTechnicalProposalandFinancialProposal
shallconstitute theApplication which shallbebindingon us.
20. I/We agreeandundertaketoabide byallthetermsandconditionsoftheRFPDocument.In
witnessthereof,I/we submitthis Proposalunderandinaccordancewiththe termsof the
RFPDocument.
Yours faithfully, (Signature, nameand designation oftheauthorized signatory)
(Name and seal of theApplicant/Lead Member)
115
Form-E2/T3 Appendix-II
FIRM’S REFERENCES Relevant Services Carried out in theLast Seven Years(2008-09 onwards)
Which BestIllustrate Qualifications
Thefollowing informationshouldbeprovidedintheformatbelowfor eachreferenceassignment forwhichyourfirm,eitherindividually asacorporateentity orasoneofthemajorcompanies within a consortium, was legallycontracted bytheclient:
Assignment Name: Country:
Location within Country: Professional Staff Provided by yourfirm:
Name ofClient : No. ofStaff :
Address : No. ofStaff Months :
Start Date (Month / Year)
Completion Date (Month / Year)
Approx. Value of Services : (inINR/current USD):
Name ofJV/Association Firm(s)ifany: No. ofMonths of Professional Staff provided byAssociated Firm(s)
Status ofyour Companyin theAssignment i.e., Sole/Lead Member/OtherMember/Associate
NarrativeDescription of Project :
Description of Actual Services Provided by yourCompany:
SignatureofAuthorisedRepresentative
(CertificatefromEmployerregarding experienceshouldbefurnished)
116
APPENDIX-II
Form-E3
FinancialCapacity ofthe Applicant
Name ofApplicant:
S.No. Financial Year Annual Revenue (Rs/US $ in million)
1 2015-16
2 2014-15
3 2013-14
4 2012-13
5 2011-12
CertificatefromtheStatutory Auditor$
This is to certifythat--------------(name oftheApplicant) has received the payments shown aboveagainstthe respectiveyears on account of ConsultancyServices.
Name oftheauditfirm Seal of the
auditfirm Date
(Signature, nameand designation ofthe authorized signatory)
$In caseheApplicant does not haveastatutoryauditor, it shall providethe certificatefrom its chartered accountant that ordinarilyaudits the annual account of theApplicant.
Note:
Pleasedo notattach anyprinted Annual FinancialStatement.
117
APPENDIX-II
Form-E4
BANK GUARANTEE FORMATFOR BID SECURITY (To bestamped in accordancewith Stamp Act if any, of thecountryof issuingbank)
Ref.: TenderNo. , dated Bank Guarantee: Date: WHEREAS, ____________ (Name of Bidder) ____(hereinafter called "the bidder") has submitted his bid dated ____________ (date) for the Tender No. _________, dated _______ (hereinafter called "the Bid". KNOW ALL MEN by these presents that We, ______________ [Name of Bank] of ____________ [Name of Country] having our registered office at ________ (hereinafter called "the Bank") are bound unto ___________ [name of employer] (hereinafter called "the Employer") in the sum of Rs. ______ (Rupees ______Lakhs only) for which payment will and truly to be made to the said employer the bank binds himself, his successors and assigns by these presents. SEALED with the Common Seal of the said Bank this _____ day of ____ 201_. THE CONDITIONS of this obligation are: 1. If the Bidder withdraws his Bid during the period of bid validity specified in the Bid document; or 2. If the Bidder does not accept the correction of arithmetical errors of his Bid Price in accordance with the Instructions to Bidder; or 3. If the Bidder having been notified of the acceptance of his Bid by the Employer during the period ofbid validity, a. fails or refuses to execute the Form of Agreement in accordance with the Instructions to Bidders, if required; or b. fails or refuses to furnish the Performance Security, in accordance with the letter of invitation, we undertake to pay the Employer up to the above amount upon receipt of his first written demand, without the Employer having to substantiate his demand, provided that in his demand the Employer will note that the amount claimed by him is due to him owing to the occurrence of one or any of the conditions, specifying the occurred condition or conditions. This Guarantee will remain in force up to and including the date 150 (one hundred and fifty) days after the deadline for submission of bids as such deadline is stated in the Instructions to Bidders or as it may be extended by the Employer, notice of which extension(s) to the Bank is hereby waived. Any demand in respect of this Guarantee should reach the Bank not later than the above date. Notwithstanding anything contained herein before, our liability under this guarantee is restricted to ___________ Rs._______ (Rs. _____________) and the guarantee shall remain valid till ______. Unless a claim or a demand in writing is made upon us on or before _______ all our liability under this guarantee shall cease DATE _______________ SIGNATURE OF THE BANK _______________________ SEAL OF THE BANK _____________________________ SIGNATURE OF THE WITNESS ____________________ Name and Address of the Witness ___________________ The bank guarantee shall be issued by a bank (Nationalized/Scheduled) located in India
118
Appendix III
(Form-T1)
TECHNICAL PROPOSAL
FROM: TO:
Sir:
Subject ConsultancyServicefor
Regarding Technical Proposal
I/We (name of
Bidder) Consultant/ Consultancy firm herewith enclose Technical Proposal for selection of
my/our firm/organization as Consultant for .
Yours faithfully,
(AuthorizedRepresentative)
Signature
FullName Designation Address
119
(Form-T-2)
Details ofprojects forwhich Technical andFinancialProposalshavebeensubmitted
Sl.No. Nameof Project ConsultancyPackageNo. Names ofProposed KeyPersonnel
1
2
3
4
120
Form-E2/T3
FIRM’S REFERENCES Relevant Services Carried out in theLast SevenYears
Which BestIllustrate Qualifications
Thefollowing informationshouldbeprovidedintheformatbelowforeachreferenceassignment forwhichyourfirm,eitherindividuallyasacorporateentityorasoneofthemajorcompanies within a consortium, was legallycontracted bytheclient:
Assignment Name: Country:
Location within Country: Professional Staff Provided by yourfirm:
Name ofClient : No. ofStaff :
Address : No. ofStaff Months :
Start Date (Month / Year)
Completion Date (Month / Year)
Approx. Value of Services :(inINR/current USD):
Name ofJV/Association Firm(s)ifany: No. ofMonths of Professional Staff provided byAssociated Firm(s)
Status ofyour Companyin theAssignment i.e., Sole/Lead Member/OtherMember/Associate
NarrativeDescription of Project :
Description of Actual Services Provided by yourCompany:
SignatureofAuthorisedRepresentative
(CertificatefromEmployerregarding experienceshould befurnished)
121
Form-T4
SITE APPRECIATION
Shallgivedetails ofsiteas peractual sitevisitand data providedinRFP andcollected from site
supported by photographsto demonstratethat responsible personnelofthe Consultant
haveactually visitedthe siteand familiarizedwith the salient details/complexities andscope
ofservices.
123
Form-T6
Compositionofthe TeamPersonnel andthe task Which wouldbeassignedto eachTeam Member
I. Technical/Managerial Staff
S.No. Name Position Task Assignment 1.
2. 3.
4.
….
….
….
II. Support Staff
S.No. Name Position Task Assignment
1. 2.
3.
4.
….
….
….
124
Form-T7
APPROACHPAPERON METHODOLOGYPROPOSEDFORPERFORMINGTHEASSIGNMENT
The approach and methodologywillbedetailed preciselyunder thefollowingtopics.
1) Composition of theteam [not morethan 1 page]
2) Methodologyfor services, surveying, datacollection [not morethan 2 pages]
andanalysis
3) QualityAssurancesystem for consultancyassignment [not morethan 1page]
.
125
Form-T8
Details ofMaterialTesting Facility
1 . State whether the Applicant has in-house Material Testing FacilityAvailable /
Outsourced/Not Available
2. Incaseanswerto1is Available, attach a list ofLabequipmentandfacilityfortestingof materials
and location oflaboratory
3. Incaselaboratoryislocatedatadistanceofmorethan400kmfromtheprojectsite,state
arrangements made/proposed to be madefor testingof materials
4. Incaseanswerto1isOutsourced/ Not Available
statearrangementsmade/proposedtobemadefortestingof materials
126
Facility forFieldinvestigationandTesting
Form-T9
1. State whether the Applicant has in-house Facility for
a) Geo-technical investigation Available (created in-house at site)/ Outsourced/ Not Available
b) Pavement investigation Available (created in-house at site)/ Outsourced/ Not Available
2. Incaseanswerto1is Available (created in-house at site) a list of field investigation and testing
equipments available in-house
3. Incaseanswerto1 is Outsourced/ Not Available arrangements made/proposed to be made for
each of above Field investigationand testing
4. For experience in LiDAR or better technology for topographic survey, GPR and Induction
Locator or better technologies for detection of sub-surface utilities and digitization of
cadastral maps for land acquisition, references need to be provided in following format:
127
REFERENCES
Relevant Services Carried Which BestIllustrate Qualifications
Thefollowing informationshouldbeprovidedintheformatbelowforeach referenceassignment forwhichyourfirm,eitherindividuallyasacorporateentityor asoneofthemajorcompanies within a consortium, was legallycontracted bythe client:
Assignment Name: Country:
Location within Country: Professional Staff Provided by yourfirm:
Name ofClient : No. ofStaff :
Address : No. ofStaff Months :
Technology Used:
Start Date (Month / Year)
Completion Date (Month / Year)
Approx. Value of Services :(inINR/current USD):
Name ofJV/Association Firm(s)ifany: No. ofMonths of Professional Staff provided byAssociated Firm(s)
Status ofyour Companyin theAssignment i.e., Sole/Lead Member/OtherMember/Associate
NarrativeDescription of Project :
Description of Actual Services Provided by yourCompany:
SignatureofAuthorisedRepresentative
(CertificatefromEmployerregarding experienceshould befurnished)
128
OfficeEquipmentandsoftware
Form-T10
Attacha list ofoffice equipment andsoftwareownedby the Applicant
129
Form-T11
Photo
Format ofCurriculumVitae(CV)ForProposedKey Staff
1. Proposed Position:
2. Name of Staff:
3. Date ofBirth: (Please furnish proof of age)
4. Nationality:
5. Educational Qualification: (Summarize college/university andother specialized educationofstaff
member,giving namesofschools, dates attendedand degreesobtained).(Please
furnishproof ofqualification)
Contact Address with Phone and mobile numbers:
6.
Membership of Professional Societies: 7. Publication:
(Listofdetailsofmajortechnicalreports/paperspublishedinrecognizednational and international journals)
8. Employment Record:
(Starting withpresentposition,list inreversed order,everyemployment held.List allpositionsheldby staffmembersincegraduation,givingdates,namesof employingorganization,titleofpositionsheldandlocationofassignments.For experienceperiodofspecificassignmentmustbeclearlymentioned,alsogive client references, where appropriate).
130
9. Summaryof theCV (Furnishasummary oftheaboveCV.Theinformationin thesummary shallbe
preciseandaccurate.Theinformationinthesummarywillhavebearingonthe evaluation of theCV). A) Education: i) Field of graduation and year ii) Field of post-graduation and year iii) Any other specific qualification
B) Experience i) Total experience in highways: ___ Yrs. ii) Responsibilities held: a) ___Yrs. b) ___Yrs. c) ___ Yrs. iii) Relevant experience: ___ Yrs. C) Permanent Employment with the firm: ___Yrs. If yes, how many years: If no, what is the employment: Arrangement with the firm?
Certification:
1 IamwillingtoworkontheprojectandIwillbeavailableforentiredurationof
theprojectassignmentandIwillnotengagemyselfinanyotherassignment during the
currencyof this assignment on theproject 2 I, theundersigned, certifythattothebestofmyknowledgeandbelief,this biodata
correctlydescribes myselfmyqualification and myexperience.
Signatureofthe Candidate
Place Date
Signatureofthe AuthorizedRepresentativeof thefirm Place Date
Note: EachpageoftheCVshallbesignedininkbyboththestaffmember and the Authorized
representative of the firm. Photocopies will not be considered for evaluation.
131
UNDERTAKING FROM THE PROFESSIONAL
I,………………….(NameandAddress)havenotleftany assignmentwiththe consultantsengagedby MORT&H/contracting firm(firmtobesupervisednow)forany continuingworksofMORT&H/NHAIwithoutcompleting my assignment.I willbeavailableforthe entiredurationofthecurrentproject(named…………..).IfI leavethisassignmentinthemiddle ofthecompletionofthework,Imaybedebarredforanappropriateperiodtobedecidedby NHAI.Ihave also no objection if myservicesare extended by NHAIforthis work in future.
UNDERTAKING FROM CONSULTING FIRM
Theundersignedonbehalfof……………….(nameofconsultingfirm)certify that Shri………………………(nameoftheproposedpersonnelandaddress)tothebestof our knowledgehasnotlefthisassignmentwithany otherconsultingfirmengagedby MORT&H/ contractingfirm(firmtobesupervisednow)fortheongoing projects.Weunderstandthatifthe informationaboutleavingthepastassignmentwith NHAIwithoutcompleting his assignmentisknowntoNHAI, NHAIwouldbeatlibertytoremovethepersonnelfromthe present assignment and debar him foranappropriate period to bedecided by NHAI.
132
(Form-I) Appendix IV
FINANCIALPROPOSALS
FROM: TO:
Sir:
Subject: Consultants’ Services for
RegardingPriceProposal
I/We Consultant/consultancyfirm herewith enclose
*PriceProposal forselection ofmy/our firm/organization as Consultant for
Yours faithfully, Signature
FullName
Designation
Address
(Authorized Representative)
*TheFinancial proposal is to be filled strictly as perthe format giveninRFP.
133
(Form-II)
Format ofFinancialProposal Summary ofCostinLocalCurrency
No. Description Amount (LC)* (INR)
I
Local Consultants Remuneration forLocalStaff (inclusiveof per diem allowance)
II Support Staff (inclusiveof per diem allowance)
III Per diem allowanceof expatriate personnel
IV Transportation
V DutyTravel to Site
VI OfficeRent
VII OfficeSupplies, Utilities and Communication
VIII OfficeFurniture and Equipment (Rental)
IX Reports and Document Printing
X
A B
Surveys&Investigations
Topographical Survey Investigations
Subtotal Local Consultants :
Foreign Consultants
F-I Remuneration for ExpatriateStaff
F-II Mobilization and Demobilization
Total Cost Net of Tax :
Taxes and Duties
I. Income Tax(Expatriate) II. Import duties III. Value added tax
Total cost net of servicetax**
ServiceTax
TOTAL COSTS(Including ServiceTax)
LC*Local Currency ** Total Cost Net of ServiceTaxshallbe considered forfinancialevaluation
Note: No escalation willbepayable duringtheservices
Insurances shall notbeallowedseparately .Thesewill beincidental to mainitems. Rates for all items shallbequoted infigures aswellas inwords.
134
(Form-III)
EstimateofLocal CurrencyCosts
I. Remuneration forLocal Staff(includingperdiemallowance)
S.No.
Position
Name Rate
(INR)
SM
Amt.(INR)
Professional Staff
1 TeamLeadercumSenior HighwayEngineer
7
2 Senior BridgeEngineer 3
3 HighwaycumPavement Engineer
3.5
4 Material-cum-Geotechnical Engineer-Geologist
5
5 Senior SurveyEngineer 5
6 Traffic and SafetyExpert 3
7 Environmental Specialist 2.5
8 QuantitySurveyor/ Documentation Expert
4.5
Sub-Total:
Sub-Professional Staff (To be assessed byConsultant as per requirement of assignment)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Sub-Total:
TOTAL
135
II.Support Staff
No. Position Name Staff Months
Billing Rate( INR)
Amount (INR)
1 2
3
4
OfficeManager Typist
OfficeBoy
Night Watchman
Total :
III. Transportation(Fixed costs)
S.No Description Qty. Nos. of months
Rate/ Month (INR)
Amount (INR)
1 Thevehicles provided bythe Consultants shall includethe cost for rental, drivers, operation, maintenance,repairs, insurance,etc.
A. For useof consultants
Total
IV. Duty Travel to Site(FixedCosts)
Trips NO Rate (INR) Amount (INR)
V. OfficeRent (Fixed Costs)
Therent cost includes maintenance, cleaning,repairs, etc. months x
Total__
136
VI. OfficeSupplies, Utilities andCommunication(Fixed Costs)
No. Item Months Monthly Rate (INR)
Amount inINR.
1
2
3
4
OfficeSupplies
DraftingSupplies
Computer RunningCosts
Domestic andInternational Communication
TOTAL: ---------------------------
VII. OfficeFurnitureandEquipment (Rental)
No .
Description Unit Quantity Rate ( INR)
Amount (INR )
1 OfficeFurniture and Equipment LS
Total
137
VIII. Reports andDocumentPrinting
No. Description No. of Copies
Rateper Copy ( INR. )
Amount (INR.)
1 MonthlyReport 3 Per Month
2 Inception Report&QAP 3
3 Environment and SocialImpact ScreeningReport
4
4 DraftFeasibilityReport 4
5 Final FeasibilityReport 6
6 Strip Plan with L.A. Reports 6
7 Draft LA and Clearances I Report 4
8 Final LA and Clearances I Report 4
9 Draft Environmental Assessment report&RAP
4
10 Final Environmental Assessment report&RAP
6
11 Draft Detailed Design Report & Drawings etc. Draft EMP
4 4
12 DraftBidding Documents 4
13 Final Detailed ProjectReport withBill of Quantities, Cost Estimates, Updated Drawings etc. Final EMP
6
6
14 Final BiddingDocuments 6
15 Draft 3(a) ,3(A) and 3(D) notification for land acquisition ( 3 copies each)
9
16 LA & Clearances II Report 6
Total
138
IX. Survey andInvestigation
A. Topographical Survey (Fixed Rate)
No. Item Kms Rateper Km (INR)
Amount (INR)
1 Topographic Survey including hire charges for equipment and supply of survey teams comprising of project survey filed staff etc. inclusive of cost of materials, labourer
2 Detailed topographic surveys using mobile/ aerial LiDAR or better technology
B. Investigation(Fixed cost)
No. Description Quantity Amount (INR)
1 Road and BridgeInventory
2 BBD Testand PavementEvaluation
3 Roughness Survey
4 Axle Load Survey
5 Material SurveyandInvestigation
6 Sub-gradeInvestigation
7 TrafficSurvey
8 Socio-economic&Census Survey/Studies
9 LandAcquisition Studies
10 Anyother investigations/surveys
11 *Sub-Soil Investigation (Boring)
Rate Qty. Amount (Rs)
a) Boring in all type of soils (other
than hard rock)
b)Boring in hard rock
1500m (for projects of length < 110 km)
or
2000m (for projects of length > 110 km)
200m (for projects of length < 110 km)
or
300m (for projects of length > 110 km)
Total
139
Note: *QuantitiesofboringsshallbetakenfromFinancialProposalFormNo.V. For financial evaluation, these quantities and rates quoted by the consultant will be considered.However,Paymentshallbemadeontheactualquantityofboringatrates quotedabovebytheConsultant.whichmay besubstantially moreorlessthanthe estimated quantities.
140
(Form-IV)
EstimateofCosts forExpatriateConsultants(in IndianRupees)
I. Remuneration ofExpatriate Staffincludingper diem allowances
No. Positions Name Rate() SM Amount ()
Total :
II. Mobilizationand Demobilization
1. International Airfares (Fixed costs)
Position RoundTrips Rate Amount
Total
2 InlandTravel in HomeCountry(Fixed Costs)
LumpSum ……
3. Other Miscellaneous expenses ( like DA, internal travel expenses other incidentals)(fixed cost)
Lump Sum …….
141
S. No
Stretch Proposedfor DPR
NH No.
Approxi mate Length (inKm.)
Package No.
State Cumulative Tentative Quantities(in m)
In Soils other than hardrock
In hard rock
2 HP/Punjab Border to Mandi 20 197 km NHAI/HP Border-Mandi/NH-20/DPR/HP/2016
HP 2000 300
TENTATIVE QUANTITIESFOR SUB-SOILINVESTIGATIONS (BORING)
(Form–V)
142
Appendix-V
DETAILED EVALUATION CRITERIA
1. FirstStage Evaluation-ProofofEligibility (Para 12.1 ofData Sheet)
1.1 Eligibility criteriafor soleapplicant firm.
Thesole applicantfirmshallsatisfythefollowing3 (Three)Nos. ofcriteria.
(a)&(b) FirmshouldhaveexperienceofpreparationofDPR/Feasibility of4/6lane of
aggregatelengthasgivenbelow.ThefirmshouldhavealsopreparedDPR/Feasibility
ofatleastoneprojectof4/6laning ofminimum lengthasindicatedbelowinthelast 7 years
(i.e.from 2009-10onwards)
S.
No.
PackageNo. Tentative
Length
Minimum
AggregateLength
required
Minimumlengthofa EligibleProject(4/6
lane)
DPR/Feasibility=
TentativeLength
DPR=0.4x
TentativeLength
Feasibility=0.6x
TentativeLength
1 2 3 4 5 6
(c) AnnualAverageTurnOverforthelast3years{Incaseswhere,Audited/Certifiedcopy
ofBalanceSheetfortheFY2014-15isavailable,lastthreeyearsshallbecountedfrom2013-14to2015-
16.However,whereaudited/certifiedcopyoftheBalanceSheetfortheFY2015-16is
notavailable(ascertifiedbytheStatutoryauditor)theninsuchcaseslastthreeyearsshallbe consideredfrom 2012-
13to2014-15}ofthefirm from Consultancyservicesshouldbeequalto more than Rs 5crore.
143
1.2 Eligibilitycriteriafor Lead Partner/OtherPartner in caseofJV.
Incaseof JV, theLeadPartnershould fulfillatleast 75%ofalleligibility requirementsandthe
otherpartnershallfulfillatleast50%ofalleligibility requirementsasgivenat1.1 above. Thusa
FirmapplyingasLead Partner/OtherPartnerin case ofJV/Associateshould satisfythe following
(a)& (b) FirmshouldhaveexperienceofpreparationofDPR/Feasibilityof4/6laneof
aggregatelengthasgivenbelow.The firm shouldhavealsopreparedDPR/Feasibilityofatleast
oneprojectof4/6laningofminimumlengthasindicatedbelowinthelast7years(i.e.from
2009-10 onwards
S.
No.
Package No. MinimumAggregate
Length required of
DPR/Feasibility km)
MinimumlengthofaEligibleProject (4/6lane)
DPR Feasibility
Lead in
JV
Other
Partner
in JV
Lead in
JV
Other
Partner in
JV
Lead in
JV
Other
Partner
in JV
144
c ) Minimum Annual Average Turn Over for the last 5 years {In cases where,
Audited/Certifiedcopy ofBalanceSheetfortheFY2015-16isavailable,lastfive yearsshallbe
countedfrom2011-12to2015-16.However,whereaudited/certifiedcopyoftheBalanceSheet for the
FY2015-16isnotavailable (ascertified by theStatutory auditor) then in such cases last five years shall
be considered from 2010-11 to 2014-15} of a firm applying as Lead
Partner/OtherPartnerincase ofJV fromConsultancyservicesshould be as givenbelow:
No. Mode ofSubmission by afirm Annual Average TurnOverfor the last5years
1 Lead Partnerin aJV Rs 3.75 crore
2 OtherLead partner inaJV Rs 2.50 crore
Note: (i)WeightagetobegivenwhenexperiencebyaFirmasSoleFirm/LeadPartnerina
JV/OtherPartnerin aJV/As Associate
No. Status of thefirmin carrying
out DPR/Feasibility Study
Weightageforexperience
1 Solefirm 100%
2 Lead partnerin aJV 75%
3 Otherpartnerin aJV 50 %
4 As Associate 25%
(ii)TheexperienceofafirminpreparationofDPRforaprivateConcessionaire/contractorshall
notbeconsidered
2. Second Stage Evaluation -TechnicalEvaluation(Para 12.2 ofData Sheet)
2.1. Firm’s Relevant Experience
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
1 Specific experience of the DPR consultancy related
to the assignment for eligibility
10
1.1 Aggregate Length of DPR / Feasibility study of4/ 6
lane projects
5
1.1.1 More than the indicative Length of the package
applied for
3
1.1.2 More than 2 times the indicative length of the
package applied for
4
145
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
1.1.3 More than 3 times the indicative length of the
package applied for
5
1.2 DPR for 4/6 laning projects each equal to or more
than 40 % of indicative length of a package
applied for (or Feasibility Study for 4/6 laning
projects each equal to or more than 60 % of
indicative length of a package applied for)
5
1.2.1 1 project 3
1.2.2 2 projects 4
1.2.3 3 or more projects 5
2 DPR of Bridge having length more than 200 m 3
2.1 1 bridge 0
2.2 2 bridges 1
2.3 3 bridges 2
2.4 4 or more bridges 3
3 Specific experience of firms in terms of turnover 3
3.1 Firm’s Average Turnover of last 5 years >= 10 crore 3
3.2 Firm Average Turnover of last 5 years > = 5 crore
but < 10 crore
2
3.3 Firm Average Turnover of last 5 years < 5 crore 0
4 DPR for special category projects (Tunnels) 4
4.1 DPR of number of Tunnels (Minimum 200 mtr
Length)
4
4.1.1 1 project 0
4.1.2 2 projects 1
146
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
4.1.3 3 projects 2
4.1.4 4 projects 3
4.1.5 5 or more projects 4
Note: In case feasibility study is a part of DPR services the experience shall be counted in DPR only. In case bridge is included as part of DPR of highway the experience will be (1) and (2)
Note: (i)WeightagetobegivenwhenexperiencebyaFirmasSoleFirm/LeadPartnerina
JV/OtherPartnerin aJV/As Associate
No. Status of thefirmin carrying
out DPR/Feasibility Study
Weightageforexperience
1 Solefirm 100 %
2 Lead partnerin aJV 75%
3 Otherpartnerin aJV 50 %
4 As Associate 25%
(ii) TheexperienceofafirminpreparationofDPRforaprivateConcessionaire/contractorshall
notbeconsidered.
2. 2. Adequacy of the proposedwork plan andmethodology inrespondingto theTOR
S. No. Description Maxpoints
(i) Site Appreciation 1
(ii) Comments on TOR 1
(iii) TeamComposition andTaskassignment 1
(iv) Methodology* 2
147
TotalPoints 5
Rating givenbelowshallbe applicable on allabove Below Average (50 %) Average (75%) Good (90%) Excellent (100%) * Higher marks for adoption of superior technology in data collection, processing and report may be given. Documents for association with vendors supplying LiDAR or better technology and GPR/ Induction Locator or better technology shall be furnished.
148
2.3 Materialtesting, Surveyand investigation equipmentand software proposed to beused
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
1 Availability of in-house material testing facility 2
1.1 Available 2
1.2 Outsourced/ Not Available 0
2 Field Investigation Facilities 1
2.1 Available (Created in-house at site) 1
2.2 Outsourced/ Not Available 0
3 Office Equipment and Software 2
3.1 High Level (More than 75% as per ToR requirement) 2
3.2 Medium Level (Between 75%-50% as per ToR
requirement)
1
3.3 Low Level (Less than 50% as per ToR requirement) 0
4 Experience in LiDAR or better technology for
topographic survey (Infrastructure sector)
4
4.1 1 -2 project 1
4.2 3 - 5 projects 2
4.3 6 - 10 projects 3
4.4 > 10 projects 4
5 Experience in using GPR and Induction Locator
or better technologies for detection of sub-surface
utilities (Infrastructure sector)
3
5.1 1 – 2project 1
5.2 3 - 5 projects 2
149
S.No Description Maximum
Points
Sub-
Points
5.3 > 5 projects 3
6 Experience in digitization of cadastral maps for
land surveys
3
6.1 Project of area upto 100 ha 1
6.2 Project of area between 100 - 500 ha 2
6.3 Project of area more than 500 ha 3
150
2.4. QualificationandCompetenceoftheKeyStaffforadequacyoftheAssignment.(Para12.2 of
DataSheetand EnclosureII ofTOR)
2.4.1 TEAM LEADERcumSENIOR HIGHWAYENGINEER
S. No. Description Max. Points
I GeneralQualification 25
i) Degree in CivilEngineeringorequivalent 20
ii) PostGraduationinHighway Engg./Structures/TrafficandTransportation/Soil
Mechanicsand FoundationEngineering/ConstructionManagement/Transportation
5
II RelevantExperience&AdequacyfortheProject 65
a) TotalProfessionalExperience 14
<20 years 0
20-25years 11
>25-28 years 13
>28 years 14
(b) Experience in Highway Projects - Experience in Planning, project
preparation and design of Highway Projects (2/4/6 laning of
NH/SH/Expressways)
23
<15 years 0
15-20years 17
>20 -25 years 21
>25 years 23
c) Experiencein Similar Capacity 28
(i) InFeasibilityof2/4/6 laningworksorDPR/IC/ConstructionSupervisionof major
highwayprojects i.e. 2/4/6 laningofNH/SH/Expressways inSimilar Capacity
(MinimumAggregate lengthof80km)
19
< 80km 0
80 km-150km 14
> 150km-250km 17
> 250km 19
(ii) InFeasibilityof2/4/6 laningworksorDPR/IC/ConstructionSupervisionof
majorhighwayprojectsi.e.2/4/6laningofNH/SH/ExpresswaysinSimilar
Capacity-Number ofProjects
9
2 projects 7
3-5 projects 8
Morethan 5 projects 9
III EmploymentwithFirm 10
Lessthan 1Year 0
1-2years 5
more than 2 years 10
Total 100
151
2.4.2 HIGHWAYcumPAVEMENT ENGINEER
S.
No.
Description Max. Points
I GeneralQualification 25
i) Degree in CivilEngineeringorequivalent 20
ii) Postgraduationin HighwayEngg/
Transportation Engineering
5
II RelevantExperience&Adequacyforthe Project 65
a) TotalProfessionalExperience 14
<15 years 0
15-20years 11
>20 -25years 13
>25 years 14
(b) ExperienceinHighwayProjects -ExperienceinDesign/PavementDesign of
HighwayProjects(2/4/6laningofNH/SH/Expressways)
23
<10 years 0
10-15years 17
>15-20 years 21
>20years 23
c) Experiencein Similar Capacity 28
(i) In Design/ Pavement Design of Highway Projects (2/4/6 laning of
NH/SH/Expressways)inSimilar Capacity(Minimum aggregatelength 80 km)
19
<80km 0
80km-150km 14
>150km-250km 17
>250km 19
(ii) In Design/ Pavement Design of Highway Projects (2/4/6 laningof NH/SH/
Expressways)in SimilarCapacity– NumberofProjects
9
2 projects 7
3-5 projects 8
Morethan 5 projects 9
III EmploymentwithFirm 10
Lessthan 1Year 0
1-2years 5
more than 2 years 10
Total 100
152
2.4.3 SENIOR BRIDGE ENGINEER
S.
No.
Description Max. Points
I GeneralQualification 25
i) Degree in CivilEngineeringorequivalent 20
ii) PostGraduationinStructuralEngineering/Bridge Engineering 5
II RelevantExperience&AdequacyfortheProject 65
a) TotalProfessionalExperience 14
<15 years 0
15-20years 11
>20 -25years 13
>25years 14
b) ExperienceinBridgeProjects 23
(i) Experiencein projectpreparation and design ofbridgeprojects 18
<10 years 0
10-15years 13
>15 -20years 16
>20years 18
(ii) Experienceof2/4 lane configuration bridges 5
<2 Projects 0
2-4 Projects 4
> 4 projects 5
c) ExperienceasSeniorBridgeEngineeror SimilarCapacity inHighway
DesignConsultancyProjects(2/4/6laningofNH/SH/Expressways)involving
designof MajorBridges(minimum2 nos. of length more than200m)
28
<2 numbers 0
2-4 numbers 22
5-6 numbers 25
> 6 numbers 28
III EmploymentwithFirm 10
Lessthan 1Year 0
1-2years 5
more than 2 years 10
Total 100
153
2.4.4 TRAFFIC ANDSAFETYEXPERT
S. No. Description Max. Points
I GeneralQualification 25
i) Degree in CivilEngineering 20
ii) PostgraduationinTraffic Engineering/TransportationEngineering/
Transportation Planning
5
II RelevantExperience&AdequacyfortheProject 65
a) TotalProfessionalExperience 14
<10 years 0
10-15years 11
>15-20 years 13
>20years 14
b) ExperienceinHighwayProjects–ExperienceonSimilarProjects(2/4/6 laning
ofNH/SH/ Expressways)
23
<5 years 0
5-7years 17
>7-10 years 21
>10years 23
c) ExperienceasTrafficandSafetyExpert/TrafficEngineerorinSimilar
CapacityinHighwayProjects (2/4/6laningofNH/SH/Expressways)
(Minimumaggregate length 80 km)
28
<80km 0
80km-150km 22
>150km-250km 25
>250km 28
III EmploymentwithFirm 10
Lessthan 1Year 0
1-2years 5
more than 2 years 10
Total 100
154
2.4.5 MATERIAL ENGINEERcumGEOTECHNICAL ENGINEERcumGEOLOGIST
S. No. Description Max. Points
I GeneralQualification 25
i) Degree in CivilEngineering/M. Sc. in Geology 20
ii) Postgraduationin Foundation Engineering/SoilMechanics /GeoTechEngineering
orPhdin Geology
5
II RelevantExperience&Adequacyfor theProject 65
a) TotalProfessionalExperience 14
<15 years 0
15-20years 11
>20-25 years 13
>25 years 14
b) Experience in Highway Projects – In Similar Projects (2/4/6 laningof
NH/SH/Expressways)indesignand or Construction/ Construction Supervision
23
<8 years 0
8-10years 17
>10 -12 years 21
>12years 23
c) Experience as Material cum Geo-technical Engineer or in Similar capacity
on HighwayProjects (2/4/6 laningofNH/SH/Expressways)(Minimum aggregate
length 80 km)
28
<80km 0
80km-150km 22
>150km– 250km 25
>250km 28
III EmploymentwithFirm 10
Lessthan 1Year 0
1-2years 5
more than 2 years 10
Total 100
155
2.4.6 SENIORSURVEY ENGINEER
S. No. Description Max. Points
I GeneralQualification 25
i) Degree orequivalentin CivilEngineering/Diploma in CivilEngineering/
Diploma in Surveying
20
ii) PostGraduationinSurveyEngineering/Surveying/ Remote Sensing 5
II RelevantExperience&AdequacyfortheProject 65
a) TotalProfessionalExperience 14
>15 years 0
15-20years 11
>20-25 years 13
>25 years 14
b) ExperienceinHighway Projects 23
i) Experience in Similar Projects (2/4/6 laningof NH/SH/Expressways) in
projectpreparation/ Construction/Construction Supervision
18
<5years 0
5 -7years 13
>7-10 years 16
>10 years 18
ii) Knowledge and understanding of Modern Computer based method of
Surveying
5
Yes 5
No 0
c) Experience as Survey Engineer or in Similar Capacity for project
preparationofhighway project(2/4/6laningofNH/SH/Expressways) (Minimum
Aggregate Length of to 80km)
28
>80km 0
80km-150km 22
>150km-250km 25
>250km 28
III EmploymentwithFirm 10
Lessthan 1Year 0
1-2years 5
more than 2 years 10
Total 100
156
2.4.7 ENVIRONMENTALSPECIALIST
S. No. Description Max. Points
I GeneralQualification 25
i) Degree in CivilEngineering/EnvironmentalEngineeringorPostGraduate in
EnvironmentalSciences
20
ii) PostGraduationinEnvironmentalEngineering 5
II RelevantExperience&AdequacyfortheProject 65
a) TotalProfessionalExperience 14
<10 years 0
10-15years 11
>15-20 years 13
>20 years 14
b) Experience in Highway Projects- Experience in Environment impact
assessmentofHighwayProjects(2/4/6laningofNH/SH/Expressways)
23
<5 years 0
5 -7years 17
>7-10 years 21
>10 years 23
c) Experienceas EnvironmentalSpecialistorin Similar CapacityinHighway
Projects(2/4/6laningofNH/SH/Expressways)
28
<2 projects 0
2-4 projects 22
5-7 projects 25
>7 projects 28
III EmploymentwithFirm 10
Lessthan 1Year 0
1-2years 5
more than 2 years 10
Total 100
157
2.4.8 QUANTITYSURVEYOR/DOCUMENTATIONEXPERT
S. No. Description Max. Points
I GeneralQualification 25
i) Graduation orequivalent inCivilEngineering/Certificatecoursefrom‘Institution of
QuantitySurveying’
20
ii) Graduation orequivalent inCivilEngineering 5
II RelevantExperience&AdequacyfortheProject 65
a) TotalProfessionalExperience 14
<15 years 0
15-20years 11
>20-25 years 13
>25 years 14
b) ExperienceinHighwayProjects-ExperienceinpreparationofBillofQuantities,
Contractdocumentsanddocumentationformajorhighwayprojects(2/4/6laningofNH/
SH/Expressways)
23
>5 years 0
5 -7years 17
>7-10 years 21
>10 years 23
c) ExperienceasQuantitySurveyor/DocumentationExpertorinSimilarCapacity
inHighwayProjects (2/4/6laningofNH/SH/Expressways)(Minimum Aggregate
length of 80km)
28
>80km 0
80km-150km 22
>150km– 250km 25
>250km 28
III EmploymentwithFirm 10
Lessthan 1Year 0
1-2years 5
more than 2 years 10
Total 100
158
Assumptions to be made regarding SimilarCapacityfor various positions
1. TeamLeadercumSeniorHighway Engineer
i) On behalfofConsultant/Contractor: TeamLeader/SeniorHighwayEngineer.
ii) In GovernmentOrganizations: SuperintendingEngineer(orequivalent)and
above
2. Senior Bridge Engineer
i) On behalfofConsultant: SeniorBridge Engineer/Bridge Engineer/Bridge
Design Engineer
ii) In GovernmentOrganizations: Executive Engineer (orequivalent)and above
3. Highway cumPavementEngineer
i) On behalfofConsultant: HighwayEngineer/HighwayDesign
Engineer/PavementEngineer.
ii) In GovernmentOrganizations: Executive Engineer (orequivalent)and above
4. MaterialEngineer cumGeo TechnicalEngineer-Geologist
i) On behalfofConsultant: MaterialEngineer/MaterialExpert/Geo
TechnicalEngineer
ii) In GovernmentOrganizations: Executive Engineer (orequivalent)and above
iii)
On behalfofContractor:
MaterialEngineer/MaterialExpert/Geo
TechnicalEngineer/Manager(Material)
159
5. Traffic and Safety Expert i) On behalfofConsultant: Traffic Engineer/Transportation Engineer/Road
Safety
Expert
ii) In GovernmentOrganizations: Executive Engineer (orequivalent)and aboveiii)
On behalfofContractor : Traffic Engineer/Transportation
Engineer/Road SafetyExpert 6. SeniorSurvey Engineer
i) On behalfofConsultant: SeniorSurveyEngineer/SurveyEngineer/
SeniorSurveyor
ii) In GovernmentOrganizations : Surveyor/Engineer (orequivalent)
iii) On behalfofContractor: SeniorSurveyEngineer/SurveyEngineer/
SeniorSurveyor
7. EnvironmentalSpecialist
i) On behalfofConsultant /Contractor: EnvironmentalEngineer/Environmental
Specialist/EnvironmentalExpert
ii) In GovernmentOrganisation: Officers who has dealtenvironment/forest
matter.
8. Quantity Surveyor/Documentation Expert
i) On behalfofConsultant /Contractor: QuantitySurveyor
(ii) In GovernmentOrganizations : AssistantEngineer(orequivalent)
160
Appendix VI
DRAFT CONTRACT
AGREEMENT
Between
National Highways Authority of India (Ministry of Road Transport and Highways)
Dwarka, New Delhi-75
and
M/s ………………………..in JV with M/s……………………………………. inAssociationwithM/s…………
and
For Consultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode
(Fromkm tokm of NH in the State of…)
161
CONTENTS
Sl. No. Description PageNo.
I CONTRACT FORCONSULTANT’S SERVICES
II GENERALCONDITIONSOFCONTRACT
1. General Provisions
1.1 Definitions 1.2 Relation between theParties 1.3 Law GoverningtheContract 1.4 Language 1.5 Headings 1.6 Notices 1.7 Location 1.8 AuthorityofMember in Charge 1.9 Authorized Representatives 1.10 Taxesand Duties
2. Commencement,Completion, ModificationandTerminationofContract
2.1 EffectivenessofContract 2.2 Termination ofContract for Failureto BecomeEffective 2.3 Commencement ofServices 2.4 ExpirationofContract 2.5 EntireAgreement 2.6 Modification 2.7 ForceMajeure 2.7.1 Definition
2.7.2 No Breach ofContract 2.7.3 Measuresto beTaken 2.7.4 Extension ofTime 2.7.5 Payments
2.8
2.7.6 Suspension
Consultation
2.9 Termination 2.9.1
BytheClient
2.9.2 BytheConsultants 2.9.3 Cessation ofRightsand Obligations
2.9.4 Cessation ofServices 2.9.5 Payment upon Termination 2.9.6 Disputesabout EventsofTermination
3. Obligationsofthe Consultants 3.1 General
3.1.1 Standard ofPerformance 3.1.2 Law GoverningServices3.2 Conflict of Interests
162
3.2.1 Consultantsnot toBenefit fromCommissions,discountsetc. 3.2.2 Consultantsand Affiliatesnotto beotherwise
interestedin Project 3.2.3 Prohibition ofConflictingActivities
3.3 Confidentiality 3.4 LiabilityoftheConsultants 3.5 Insuranceto betaken outbytheConsultants 3.6 Accounting, Inspection and Auditing 3.7 Consultants’ActionsrequiringClient’sprior Approval 3.8 ReportingObligations 3.9 Documentsprepared bytheConsultantsto betheProperty
oftheClient 3.10 Equipmentand Materialsfurnished bytheClient
4. Consultants’Personnel
4.1 General 4.2 Description ofPersonnel 4.3 Approval ofPersonnel 4.4 WorkingHours, Overtime, Leave etc. 4.5 Removal and/or Replacement ofPersonnel 4.6 Resident Project Manager
5. Obligationsofthe Client
5.1 Assistanceand Exemptions 5.2 Accessto Land 5.3 Changein theApplicableLaw 5.4 Services, Facilitiesand PropertyoftheClient 5.5 Payment
6. Payment to the Consultants
6.1 Cost Estimates; CeilingAmount 6.2 Currencyof Payment 6.3 ModeofBillingand Payment
7. Responsibilityforaccuracy oftheprojectdocument
7.1 General 7.2 Retentionmoney 7.3 Penalty 7.4 Action for deficiencyin services
8. FairnessandGoodFaith
8.1 Good Faith 8.2 Operation oftheContract
9. SETTLEMENT OFDISPUTES
9.1 AmicableSettlement 9.2 DisputeSettlement
163
III. SPECIAL CONDITIONSOFCONTRACT
IV. APPENDICES
Appendix A: Termsofreferencecontaining, inter-alia, the Description oftheServicesand Reporting Requirements
Appendix B: Consultants’ Sub consultants, KeyPersonnel and Sub Professional
Personnel,Task assignment, work programme, manningschedule, qualification requirementsofkeypersonnel, schedulefor submission of variousreport.
Appendix C: Hoursofworkfor Consultants’ Personnel Appendix D: DutiesoftheClient AppendixE: Cost Estimate Appendix F: MinutesofFinancial/ Contract Negotiations with theConsultant Appendix G: Copyofletter ofinvitation Appendix H: Copyofletter ofacceptance Appendix I(1):Format for Bank Guaranteefor PerformanceSecurity for individual work Appendix I(2):Format for Bank Guaranteefor PerformanceSecurity for anumber ofworks AppendixJ: MinutesofthePre-bid meeting
165
INDIA
CONTRACT FORCONSULTANTS’ SERVICES
ConsultancyServicesforPreparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode
(Fromkm. 11.00 to km 208.00OfNH 20 in theStateofHimachal Pradesh)
ThisCONTRACT (hereinafter called the“Contract”) ismadeon the----------dayofthe
monthof -----------------2016,between,ontheonehand, National Highways Authority of India (NHAI),
New Delhi(hereinafter calledthe“Client”)and, ontheotherhand,M/s------------------------------------------inJVwith---------------------------------- and in Association with……………………………………………. (hereinaftercalledthe“Consultants”).
WHEREAS (A) theClient hasrequested theConsultantsto providecertain consultingservicesasdefined in
theGeneral Conditionsattached tothisContract (hereinaftercalledthe“Services”); (B) theConsultants, havingrepresented totheClient that theyhavetherequired professional
skills,personnelandtechnicalresources,haveagreedtoprovidetheServicesontheterms andconditions set forth inthisContract;
NOWTHEREFORE thepartieshereto herebyagree asfollows:
1 Thefollowingdocumentsattached hereto shall bedeemedto form anintegral partof
thisContract:
(a) TheGeneral ConditionsofContract (hereinaftercalled “GC”);
(b) TheSpecial Conditionsofcontract(hereinafter called “SC”); (c)
ThefollowingAppendices:
Appendix A: Termsofreferencecontaining, inter-alia, the Description oftheServicesand Reporting Requirements
Appendix B: Consultants’ Sub consultants, KeyPersonnel and Sub ProfessionalPersonnel,Task assignment, work programme, manningschedule, qualification requirementsofkeypersonnel, and schedulefor submission ofvariousreport.
Appendix C: Hoursofworkfor Consultants’ Personnel Appendix D: DutiesoftheClient
AppendixE: Cost Estimate
166
Appendix F: MinutesofFinancial/ Contract Negotiations with theConsultant
Appendix G: Copyofletter ofinvitation
Appendix H: Copyofletter ofacceptance
Appendix I: CopyofBank Guaranteefor PerformanceSecurity
Appendix-J: Minutesofthepre-bidmeeting
2. Themutual rightsand obligationsoftheClientand theConsultants shall be asset forth in
theContract; in particular:
(a) TheConsultants shallcarryout theServicesinaccordancewiththeprovisionsof theContract;and
(b) Client shall makepaymentsto theConsultantsinaccordancewith the
provisionsoftheContract. INWITNESSWHEREOF, thePartiesheretohavecausedthisContract to besigned in their respectivenamesasofthedayandyear first abovewritten.
FOR AND ONBEHALF OF Witness (National Highways Authority of India)
1 Signature Name Address
By AuthorizedRepresentative 2. Signature
Name Address
FOR AND ONBEHALF OF Witness (Consultant) 1. Signature Name Address By AuthorisedRepresentative 2. Signature
Name Address
168
GENERAL CONDITIONSOFCONTRACT 1. GENERAL PROVISIONS
1.1 Definitions
Unlessthecontext otherwiserequires, thefollowingterms whenever used in this Contract havethefollowingmeanings: (a) “ApplicableLawmeansthelawsandany otherinstrumentshavingtheforceoflawin
theGovernment’scountryastheymaybeissued andin forcefromtimeto time; (b) “Contract” means the Contract signed by the Parties, to which these General
ConditionsofContractareattached,togetherwithallthedocumentslistedinClause 1 ofsuch signed Contract;
(c) “EffectiveDate”meansthedateon which thisContract comesinto forceandeffect
pursuant toClauseGC 2.1;
(d) “foreigncurrency”meansanycurrencyother than the currencyoftheGovernment; (d)
“GC”meanstheseGeneral ConditionsofContract;
(f) “Government”meanstheGovernment of India;
(g) “localcurrency”meansthe currencyoftheGovernment;
(h) “Member”,incasetheConsultantsconsistofajointventureorconsortiumofmore than one
entity, meansanyofthese entities, and “Members”meansall ofthese entities;
(i) “Personnel”meanspersonshired bytheConsultantsor byanySubconsultant
asemployeesand assigned to theperformanceoftheServicesoranypartthereof; “foreignPersonnel”means such persons who atthetimeofbeingso hired hadtheir domicileoutsideIndia;and “local Personnel”meanssuch persons who atthetimeof beingso hired had their domicileinsideIndia;
(j) “Party”meanstheClientor theConsultants, asthecasemaybe, and Partiesmeans
both ofthem;
(k) “Services”meansthework to beperformed bytheConsultantspursuantto this Contract for thepurposesoftheProject, asdescribed in Appendix Ahereto;
(l) “SC”meanstheSpecialConditionsofContract bywhich theseGeneral
ConditionsofContract maybe amended or supplemented;
(m) “Subconsultant”meansanyentityto which theConsultants subcontractanypartof
theServicesin accordance with theprovisionsofClauseGC 3.7; and
(n) “Third Party”meansanyperson or entityother thantheGovernment, theClient, the Consultantsor aSubconsultant.
169
1.2 Relation between the Parties
Nothingcontained hereinshall be construedasestablishingarelation ofmaster and servant or ofagent and principal asbetween theClient andtheConsultants. TheConsultants, subject tothisContract, have completechargeofPersonnel performingtheServicesand shall befullyresponsiblefor theServicesperformed bythem or on their behalfhereunder.
1.3 Governing LawandJurisdiction
ThisContract, itsmeaningand interpretation,andtherelation between theParties shallbegovernedbytheApplicableLawsofIndiaandtheCourtsat…………shallhaveexclusivejurisdictionover mattersarisingout ofor relatingtothis Agreement.
1.4 Language
ThisContract hasbeenexecuted inthelanguagespecified intheSC, which shall bethe bindingand controllinglanguagefor all mattersrelatingto themeaningor interpretation ofthisContract.
1.5 TableofContentsandHeadings Thetableof contents,headingsorsub-headingsinthisagreementareforconveniencefor referenceonly andshallnotbeusedin,andshallnotlimit,alteroraffecttheconstructionand interpretation ofthisContract.
1.6 Notices
1.6.1 Anynotice, request orconsent required orpermittedto begiven or madepursuant tothis Contract shall bein writing. Anysuchnotice, request orconsentshall bedeemed
tohavebeen given or madewhen deliveredin person to an authorized
representativeofthePartyto whomthe communication isaddressed,orwhen sent
byregistered mail, facsimileore-mail tosuchPartyat theaddress specifiedin theSC. 1.6.2 Noticewillbedeemedtobe effective as specified intheSC. 1.6.3 Apartymaychangeitsaddressfor noticehereunder bygivingtheother Partynoticeof
such changepursuant totheprovisionslisted in theSC with respectto ClauseGC 1.6.2.
1.7 Location
TheServices shallbeperformedat suchlocationsasarespecifiedinLetterof Acceptance(Appendix-I)hereto and, wherethelocation ofaparticular task isnot so specified,atsuchlocations, whetherin Indiaor elsewhere, astheClient mayapprove.
1.8 Authority ofMemberinCharge
IncasetheConsultantsconsistof ajointventureof morethanone entity,withorwithoutan AssociatetheMembers herebyauthorizetheentityspecifiedintheSCtoactontheirbehalf in exercising all the Consultants’ rights and obligations towards the Client under this Contract, includingwithoutlimitationthereceivingofinstructionsand paymentsfromtheClient.
170
1.9 Authorized Representatives Anyaction required or permittedto betaken, andanydocument required or permittedto be executed, under thisContract bytheClient or theConsultantsmaybetakenorexecutedbytheofficials specifiedin theSC.
1.10 Taxesand Duties
Unlessotherwisespecified in theSC, theConsultants shall payall such taxes,duties, feesand otherimpositionsasmaybelevied under theApplicableLaw.
2. COMMENCEMENT, COMPLETION, MODIFICATION ANDTERMINATION
OFCONTRACT 2.1 EffectivenessofContract
ThisContract shall come into force andeffect on thedateoftheClient’snoticeto the ConsultantsinstructingtheConsultantsto begin carryingout theServices. Thisnotice shall confirmthat the effectivenessconditions, ifany, listed intheSC havebeen met.
2.2 TerminationofContractfor Failureto BecomeEffective
IfthisContract hasnot becomeeffectivewithin such timeperiod afterthedateofthe Contract signed bythePartiesas shall bespecified in theSC, either Partymay,bynot lessthan four (4) weeks’written noticeto theotherParty, declarethisContract to benulland void, and intheeventofsuch adeclaration byeither Party, neither Partyshall have anyclaim againsttheother Partywith respect hereto.
2.3 Commencement ofServices TheConsultants shallbegin carryingout theServicesat the end ofsuch time periodafter the EffectiveDate as shallbespecified intheSC.
2.4 ExpirationofContract
Unlessterminatedearlierpursuant toClauseGC 2.9hereof, thisContract shallexpire when serviceshavebeencompletedandall paymentshavebeen madeattheend ofsuch timeperiod aftertheEffectiveDateas shall bespecified in theSC.
2.5 EntireAgreement
ThisContract containsallcovenants,stipulationsand provisionsagreed bytheParties. No agent or representativeofeither Partyhasauthorityto make,andtheParties shall not bebound byor beliablefor, anystatement, representation, promiseoragreement not set forth herein.
2.6 Modification
Modification ofthetermsand conditionsofthisContract, includinganymodification of thescopeoftheServices, mayonlybemadebywritten agreement between theParties.Pursuant to ClauseGC 7.2hereof, however, each partyshall givedue consideration to anyproposalsfor modificationmadebytheother Party.
2.7 ForceMajeure
2.7.1 Definition
(a) For thepurposesofthisContract, “ForceMajeure”meansan event which isbeyond
171
thereasonablecontrol ofaParty, and which makesaParty’sperformanceofits obligationshereunder impossibleor so impractical asreasonablyto be considered impossibleinthecircumstances,and includes, butisnot limitedto, war, riots,civildisorder, earthquake, fire,explosion, storm, flood orotheradverseweather conditions, strikes, lockoutsor otherindustrialaction (except wheresuch strikes, lockoutsor other industrial actionarewithinthepower ofthePartyinvokingForce Majeureto prevent), confiscation or anyother actionbygovernmentagencies.
(b) ForceMajeureshall notinclude(i)anyevent whichiscaused bythenegligenceor intentionalaction ofaPartyor such Party’s Subconsultantsor agentsoremployees, nor (ii)anyevent whichadiligent Partycould reasonablyhavebeen expectedto both (A) takeintoaccountatthetimeoftheconclusion ofthisContract and (B) avoid or overcomein thecarrying out ofitsobligationshereunder.
(c) ForceMajeureshall notincludeinsufficiencyof fundsor failuretomakeany payment required hereunder.
2.7.2 No BreachofContract
ThefailureofaPartyto fulfill anyofitsobligationshereunder shall notbeconsideredto beabreach of, or defaultunder, thisContractinsofar as such inabilityarisesfrom an event of ForceMajuere, provided that thePartyaffected bysuch an event hastakenall reasonableprecautions, due careand reasonablealternativemeasures, all with the objectiveofcarryingout thetermsandconditionsofthisContract.
2.7.3 Measuresto beTaken (a) Apartyaffected byan event ofForceMajeureshalltakeall reasonablemeasures to remove such Party’sinabilitytofulfill itsobligationshereunder withaminimum of delay. (b) Apartyaffected byan event of ForceMajuereshallnotifytheother Partyofsuchevent as soon as
possible,and inanyevent not later than fourteen (14) daysfollowingthe occurrenceofsuch event, providingevidenceofthenature andcauseofsuch event, and shall similarlygivenoticeofthe restoration ofnormal conditionsas soon aspossible.
(c) TheParties shalltakeall reasonablemeasurestominimizetheconsequencesofanyevent of Force
Majeure. 2.7.4 Extensionof Time
Anyperiod within whichaPartyshall, pursuantto thisContract,completeanyaction or task, shall beextended foraperiod equalto thetimeduringwhich such Partywasunableto performsuchactionasaresult ofForceMajeure.
2.7.5 Payments
Duringtheperiod oftheirinabilityto performtheServicesasaresult ofan event ofForceMajeure, theConsultants shall be entitledto bereimbursed for additional costs reasonablyand necessarilyincurred bythem duringsuch period for thepurposesoftheServicesand inreactivatingtheServicesafter the end ofsuch period.
2.7.6 Consultation
Not later than thirty(30) daysafter theConsultants,astheresult ofanevent ofForceMajeure,
172
havebecomeunableto performamaterialportion oftheServices, theParties shall consult with each other withaviewto agreeingon appropriatemeasuresto betaken in thecircumstances.
2.8 Suspension
TheClient may, bywritten noticeofsuspension to theConsultants, suspendall paymentsto theConsultantshereunderiftheConsultantsfailto perform anyoftheir obligations under thisContract,includingthe carryingout oftheServices, provided that such notice ofsuspension (i) shall specifythenatureofthefailure, and (ii) shall request the Consultantsto remedysuch failurewithinaperiod not exceedingthirty(30) daysafter receipt bytheConsultantsofsuch noticeofsuspension.
2.9 Termination 2.9.1 By theClient
TheClientmay,bynotlessthanthirty (30)days’writtennoticeofterminationtothe Consultants(exceptintheeventlisted inparagraph(f)below,forwhichthereshallbea written notice of not less than sixty (60) days), such notice to be given after the occurrenceofanyoftheeventsspecifiedinparagraphs(a)through(f)ofthisClause2.9.1, terminatethisContract: (a) iftheConsultantsfailto remedyafailureintheperformanceoftheir obligations areunder, as
specifiedinanoticeofsuspension pursuant to Clause2.8 hereinabove, within thirty(30) daysofreceiptofsuch noticeofsuspension or within such further periodastheClient mayhavesubsequentlyapproved in writing;
(b) iftheConsultantsbecome(or, iftheConsultantsconsist ofmorethan oneentity,ifanyoftheir
Membersbecomes) insolvent or bankruptor enterintoanyagreements with theircreditorsfor reliefofdebt or takeadvantageofanylawfor thebenefit of debtorsor go intoliquidation or receivership whether compulsoryor voluntary;
(c) iftheConsultantsfailto complywith anyfinal decision reached asaresultof arbitration
proceedingspursuant to Clause8 hereof;
(d) iftheConsultants submitto theClientastatementwhich hasamaterial effect on therights, obligationsorinterestsoftheClientandwhich theConsultantsknow to befalse;
(e) if, as the result of Force Majeure, the Consultants are unable to perform a material portion oftheServicesfor aperiod ofnot lessthan sixty(60) days; or
(f) if the Client, in its sole discretion and for any reason whatsoever, decides to
terminatethisContract.
173
2.9.2 By theConsultants
TheConsultantsmay,bynotlessthanthirty(30)day’swrittennoticetotheClient,such noticeto begiven after theoccurrenceofanyoftheevents specifiedin paragraphs(a) through (d) ofthisClause2.9.2, terminatethisContract:
(a) iftheClientfailstopayanymoneyduetotheConsultantspursuanttothiscontractandnot subjecttodisputepursuanttoClause8hereofwithinforty-five(45)daysafterreceiving written noticefromtheConsultantsthat such payment isoverdue;
(b) iftheClientisinmaterialbreachofitsobligationspursuanttothisContractandhasnot remediedthesamewithinforty-five(45)days(orsuchlongerperiodastheConsultantsmay have subsequently approved in writing) following thereceipt by the Client of the Consultants’ noticespecifying such breach;
(c) if, astheresult ofForceMajeure, theConsultant areunableto performamaterial portion oftheServicesfor aperiod ofnot lessthan sixty(60) days; or
(d) iftheClientfailstocomplywithanyfinaldecisionreachedasaresultofarbitrationpursuant to Clause8 hereof.
2.9.3 CessationofRightsandObligations
Uponterminationof thisContractpursuanttoClauses2.2or2.9hereof,oruponexpirationof thisContractpursuantto Clause2.4hereof,allrightsandobligationsofthePartieshereunder shall cease, except (i) such rights and obligations as may have accruedon the date of
terminationorexpiration,(ii)theobligationofconfidentialitysetforthinClause3.3hereof, (iii)the Consultant’sobligationtopermitinspection,copyingandauditingoftheiraccounts andrecordsset forth in Clause3.6 (ii) hereof, and (iv) anyright which aPartymayhaveunder theApplicableLaw.
2.9.4 CessationofServices
UponterminationofthisContractbynoticeofeitherPartytotheotherpursuanttoClauses 2.9.1or2.9.2hereof,theConsultantsshall,immediately upondispatchorreceiptofsuch notice,takeallnecessarystepstobringtheServicestoacloseinapromptandorderly mannerandshallmakeevery reasonableefforttokeepexpendituresforthispurposetoa minimum.Withrespecttodocumentsprepared by theConsultantsandequipmentand materialsfurnishedby theClient,theConsultantsshallproceedasprovided,respectively,by Clauses3.9 or 3.10 hereof.
2.9.5 Payment uponTermination
Uponterminationofthis ContractpursuanttoClauses2.9.1or2.9.2hereof,theClientshall makethefollowingpaymentstotheConsultants(afteroffsettingagainstthesepaymentsany amount that maybeduefrom theConsultantto theClient):
(i) remuneration pursuant toClause6 hereof for Services satisfactorilyperformedprior to
the effectivedateoftermination. (ii) reimbursableexpenditures pursuant to Clause 6 hereof for expenditures
actuallyincurred priorto the effectivedateoftermination; and (iii) except inthecaseofterminationpursuantto paragraphs(a) through (d) ofClause
2.9.1 hereof, reimbursement ofanyreasonable cost incident totheprompt andorderly termination oftheContract includingthecost ofthereturntravel oftheConsultants’ personneland theireligibledependents.
174
2.9.6 Disputesabout Eventsof Termination
IfeitherPartydisputeswhetheraneventspecifiedinparagraphs(a)through(e)ofClause 2.9.1orinClause2.9.2hereofhasoccurred,suchParty may,withinforty-five(45)daysafter receiptofnoticeofterminationfromtheotherParty,referthemattertoarbitrationpursuant toClause8hereof,andthisContractshallnotbeterminatedonaccountofsucheventexcept in accordancewiththetermsofanyresultingarbitralaward.
3. OBLIGATIONSOFTHE CONSULTANTS
3.1 General
3.1.1 Standard ofPerformance
TheConsultantsshallperformtheServices andcarry outtheirobligationshereunderwithall duediligence,efficiencyandeconomy,inaccordancewithgenerallyacceptedprofessionaltechniques andpractices, andshallobservesoundmanagementpractices,and employ appropriateadvancedtechnology andsafeandeffectiveequipment,machinery,materialsand methods.TheConsultantsshallalwaysact,inrespectofanymatterrelatingtothisContract ortotheServices,asfaithfuladvisers totheClient,andshallatalltimessupportand safeguardtheClient's legitimateinterestsinany dealingswithSubconsultantsorThird Parties.
3.1.2 LawGoverning Services
TheConsultantsshallperformtheServicesin accordancewith theApplicableLawandshall takeallpracticablestepstoensurethatanySubconsultants,aswellasthePersonneland agentsoftheConsultantsandanySubconsultants,complywiththeApplicableLaw.The ClientshalladvisetheConsultantsinwriting of relevantlocalcustoms and theConsultants shall,after such notifications, respectsuch customs.
3.2 Conflict ofInterests
3.2.1 Consultants not to BenefitfromCommissions, Discounts, etc.
Theremuneration oftheConsultantspursuant to Clause6 hereofshallconstitutetheConsultants' sole remuneration in connection with thisContract or theServicesand theConsultants shall not accept for theirownbenefitanytradecommission,discountorsimilarpaymentinconnectionwithactivities pursuantto thisContractortotheServicesorintheDischargeof theirobligationshereunder,andthe Consultants shall usetheirbesteffortsto ensurethatanySubconsultants, as well asthePersonnel and agentsofeither ofthem, similarlyshall not receiveanysuch additional remuneration.
3.2.2 ConsultantsandAffiliates not to beotherwiseinterestedinProject
The Consultants agree that, duringtheterm ofthis Contract and after its termination,the Consultants andany entityaffiliated with the Consultants,as wellas any Subconsultant and any entity affiliated with such Subconsultant, shall be disqualified from providing goods, works or services (other thanthe Services and any continuation thereof) for any project resulting from or closely relatedto the Services.
175
3.2.3 ProhibitionofConflicting Activities Neither theConsultantsnor their Subconsultantsnor thePersonnel ofeither ofthem shall engage, either directlyor indirectly, in anyofthefollowingactivities:
(a) duringthetermofthisContract, anybusinessor professional activitiesin
theGovernment'scountrywhich wouldconflict withtheactivities assigned to them under thisContract; or
(b) afterthetermination ofthisContract, such other activitiesasmaybe specified in theSC.
3.3 Confidentiality
TheConsultants, their SubconsultantsandthePersonnel ofeither ofthem shallnot,either during the term or within two (2) years after the expiration of this Contract, discloseanyproprietaryor confidentialinformationrelationto theProject,theServices,thisContract or theClient'sbusinessor operationswithouttheprior written consent oftheClient.
3.4 Liability oftheConsultants
Subject toadditional provisions, ifany, set forth in theSC, theConsultants'liability under thisContract shall be asprovided bytheApplicableLaw.
3.5 Insuranceto betakenout by theConsultants
TheConsultants(i) shall takeout and maintain, andshall cause anySubconsultantstotakeout andmaintain,attheir(ortheSubconsultants',asthecasemay be)owncostbutontermsand conditionsapproved bytheClient,insuranceagainsttherisks, and for the coverage, as shallbespecifiedintheSpecialConditions (SC),and(ii)attheClient'srequest,shallprovide evidencetotheClientshowingthatsuchinsurancehasbeentakenoutandmaintainedand thatthecurrent premiumsthereforehavebeenpaid.
3.6 Accounting, Inspectionand Auditing
TheConsultants(i) shall keepaccurate and systematicaccountsand recordsinrespect of theServiceshereunder,inaccordancewith internationallyacceptedaccountingprinciples and in such form and detail as will clearlyidentifyall relevant timechargesand cost, and thebasesthereof(includingthebasesoftheConsultants' costsandcharges), and (ii) shall permit theClient or itsdesignated representativeperiodically, and up to oneyear fromthe expirationor termination ofthisContact, toinspectthesameandmake copiesthereof as wellasto havethemaudited byauditorsappointed bytheClient.
3.7 Consultants' Actionsrequiring Client's priorApproval
TheConsultants shallobtain theClient'spriorapproval in writingbeforetakinganyof thefollowingactions:
(a) appointingsuch membersofthePersonnelasarelistedin Appendix B;
176
(b) enteringintoasubcontractfortheperformanceofanypartoftheServices,itbeing understood(i)thattheselectionoftheSub-consultantandthetermsandconditionsofthe subcontractshallhavebeenapprovedinwritingbytheClientpriortotheexecutionof thesubcontract, and(ii)thattheConsultantsshallremainfullyliablefortheperformance oftheServicesbytheSub-consultantand itsPersonnel pursuant tothisContract;
(c) anyother action that maybespecified intheSC. 3.8 Reporting Obligations
TheConsultants shall submitto theClientthereportsand documents specifiedin AppendixA/Ehereto,in theform, in thenumbersand withinthetimeperiodsset forth in thesaid Appendix.
3.9 Documents prepared by theConsultantsto bethe Property oftheClient All plans, drawings, specifications, designs, reportsand other documentsprepared bythe Consultantsinperforming theServicesshallbecomeandremaintheproperty of theClient,andthe Consultantsshall, notlaterthanupontermination orexpirationof thisContract,deliverallsuch documentstotheClient,togetherwithadetailedinventorythereof.TheConsultantsmayretaina copyof such documents. Restrictionsabout thefutureuseofthesedocuments,shall be as specified in theSC.
3.10 Equipment andMaterialsfurnished by theClient
Equipment andmaterialsmade availabletotheConsultantsbytheClient, or purchased bytheConsultants with fundsprovided bytheClient, shall betheproperty oftheClient and shall bemarked accordingly. Upon terminationor expiration ofthisContract,the Consultants shallmake availabletothe Client an inventory of such equipment andmaterials and shalldisposeof such equipment andmaterials in accordance withtheClient'sI instructions. Whileinpossessionof such equipment andmaterials,theConsultants,unless otherwiseinstructedbytheClientin writing, shallinsurethemin anamount equaltotheir full replacement value.
4. CONSULTANTS' PERSONNEL
4.1 General
TheConsultants shallemployand providesuch qualified and experienced Personnelas arerequired tocarryout theServices.
4.2 Descriptionof Personnel
(a) The titles, agreed job descriptions, minimum qualification and estimated periods of
engagement inthe carrying outof theServicesof eachof the Consultants'KeyProfessional / Sub Professional Personnel aredescribedin Appendix B.
(b) IfrequiredtocomplywiththeprovisionsofClause3.1.1ofthisContract,adjustmentswith
respecttotheestimatedperiodsofengagement ofKeyProfessional/SubProfessional PersonnelsetforthinAppendixBmay bemadebytheConsultantsby writtennoticetothe Client, provided (i)thatsuchadjustmentsshallnotaltertheoriginally estimatedperiodof engagementof any
177
individual bymorethan 10% or oneweek, whichever islarger, and (ii)thattheaggregateofsuchadjustmentsshallnotcausepaymentsunderthisContractto exceed
theceilingssetforthinClause6.1(b)of thisContract.Any othersuch adjustments shall only bemadewith theClient'swritten approval.
(c)If additionalworkisrequiredbeyondthescopeoftheServicesspecifiedinAppendixA,the
estimatedperiodsofengagementofKey PersonnelsetforthinAppendixBmay beincreased byagreementin writingbetween theClientand theConsultants.
4.3 Approval of Personnel
TheKeyPersonnel and Subconsultantslisted bytitleas wellasbynamein Appendix Bare herebyapprovedbytheClient. In respect ofother KeyPersonnel whichtheConsultants proposeto usein thecarryingout oftheServices, theConsultants shall submitto theClient for reviewand approval a copyoftheir biographical data. IftheClient doesnot object in writing(statingthereasonsfor theobjection) withintwenty-one(21)calendar daysfromthedateofreceipt ofsuch biographicaldata, such KeyPersonnel shall bedeemed tohavebeen approved bytheClient.
4.4 Working Hours, Overtime, Leave, etc.
(a) Workinghoursand holidaysfor KeyProfessional /Sub Professional Personnel are set forth in
Appendix C hereto.To account for traveltime, foreign Personnel carryingout ServicesinsidetheGovernment'scountryshall bedeemedto have commenced (or finished)work in respect oftheServices such number ofdays beforetheir arrival in (orafter theirdeparturefrom) theGovernment'scountryas is specifiedin Appendix Chereto.
(b) TheKeyProfessional / Sub Professional Personnel shall notbeentitled to be paidfor
overtimenortotakepaid sickleaveorvacationleaveexceptasspecifiedinAppendixC hereto, andexceptas specified in such Appendix, theConsultants'remunerationshallbe deemedto covertheseitems.AllleavetobeallowedtothePersonnelis includedinthestaff- monthsofserviceset forinAppendixB.AnytakingofleavebyPersonnelshallbesubject to the priorapprovaloftheClientbytheConsultants,whoshallensurethatabsencefor leavepurposes will not delaytheprogressand adequatesupervision oftheServices.
4.5 Removal and/orReplacement ofPersonnel
Removal and/or replacement ofPersonnel shall beregulatedasunder: 4.5.1 IncasenoticetocommenceservicespursuanttoClause2.1ofthis Contractisnotordered by
Clientwithin120daysofnegotiationsthekey personnelcanexcusethemselvesonvalid
grounds,e.g., selectionon some otherassignment, health problemdeveloped aftercontract
negotiation,etc.In sucha caseno penaltyshallbeleviedon theFirm oronthe person
concerned. Thefirmshallhoweverbeaskedtogiveareplacementbyanequalorbetter
scoringperson, whenever mobilization isordered.
4.5.2 In casenotice to commence services is given within 120 days of negotiations the
replacement shallbe as below:
178
a. Replacementupto33%:Replacementshallbebyanequalorbetterscoringperson. Reduction in remunerations forthe balanceperiodshallbe@ 5%of themonthlyrate.
b. Replacementofmorethan33%andupto50%: Replacementshallbebyanequalor betterscoring person.Reductioninremunerationsforthebalanceperiod shallbe@10% of themonthlyrate.
c. Replacementbeyond50%andupto66%.Replacementshallbeby anequalorbetter scoring person.Reductioninremunerationsforthebalanceperiodshallbe@15%ofthe monthlyrate.
d. Replacementbeyond66%shallnormally notbeconsidered.Howeverinexceptional circumstances,whereitbecomesabsolutely essentialtheremunerationsofthesubstitute shallbereducedby50%oftheoriginalpersonreplaced.Replacementshallbebyan equalorbetterscoringperson,TheDepartmentmay initiateactionfor termination/debarmentofsuchconsultantforfuture projectsof NHAI/ MoRTHfora period of6 months to 24 months dependingupontheseverityofcase.
4.5.3 Replacement after original contract period is over:
Thereshallbenolimitonthereplacementsandnoreductioninremunerationsshallbe made.
Thereplacement shallhowever beof equalor better score.
4.5.4IftheEmployer(i)findsthatanyofthePersonnelhascommittedseriousmisconductorhas beencharged withhavingcommitteda criminalaction or (ii) hasreasonable ground to be dissatisfied with theperformanceofanyof thePersonnel, then the consultantshall, at the Employer’s writtenrequestspecifyingthegroundstherefore,forthwithprovidea replacement withqualifications and experienceacceptableto him.
4.5.5 Iftheteamleaderoranyotherkeypersonnel/specialistconsideredpivotaltotheprojectis replaced, thesubstitutemaybeinterviewed by NHAIto assesstheir meritand suitability.
4.5.6Ifanymemberoftheapprovedteamofaconsultantengagedby NHAIleavesthat consultant
before completion ofthe job, heshall bebarred for aperiod of6 months to 24 months from being engagedasateammemberof any otherconsultantworking (ortobe appointed)forany other NHAI/ MoRTHprojects.
4.5.7 Inexceptionalsituationswherethereplacementwithequivalentorbetterqualificationisnot available,replacementwithlowerqualificationsthantheoriginallyapprovedmaybeaccepted with reduction in remunerationasper theprocedureprescribed below. This kind of relaxation shall however, belimitedto replacement of2 key personnelonlyin one consultancycontract package.
i) The new proposed personnel as a replacement has to be evaluated as per the criteria fixed at the time of evaluation of original proposal and marks/rating and then: -If the original personnel (included in the original proposal based on which the contract was awarded) is to be replaced at the instruction of NHAI and the new proposed personnel is having less qualification/ experience i.e marks/rating (but fulfilling the minimum requirement as per TOR), his remuneration would be reduced by 15% over and above the stipulated conditions in the contract because of less qualified personnel
179
-If the original personnel (included in Contract Agreement) is to be replaced by the Consulting firm and the new proposed personnel is having less qualification/ experience (marks/rating), then his remuneration would be decreased proportionally in comparison to the marks of the original personnel. This will also take into account the contract condition and if the proposed reduction is less than that stipulated in contract condition, it would be as per the contract provision. It will be ensured that the new proposed personnel should score at least75% of the marks of the originally approved key personnel. Both the Consulting firm and the proposed personnel should give the undertaking in the format available in Form VII of Appendix II along with the replacement CV. ii) The CV should be signed by personnel and the consulting firm in every page. If the CV is found incorrect at later date, the personnel accepted would be removed from the assignment and debarred from further NHAI/ MoRTHworks for an appropriate period to be decided by NHAI and the new proposed personnel in place of removed personnel would be paid 15% less salary than the original personnel. 15% reduction in the salary will be imposed as penalty for submitting the incorrect information. This penalty will be imposed only once. If the same consulting firm submits incorrect information again second time, necessary action will be taken by NHAI to blacklist the firm.
4.6 Resident ProjectManager
Ifrequired bythe SC, theConsultants shall ensure that at all timesduringtheConsultants' performanceofthe Servicesin the Government's countryaresident project manager, acceptabletothe Client, shalltake chargeoftheperformanceof such Services.
5. OBLIGATIONOFTHE CLIENT
5.1 Assistanceand Exemptions
Unlessotherwisespecified in theSC, theClient shall useitsbesteffortsto ensurethat theGovernment shall:
(a) provide the Consultants, Sub consultants and Personnel with work permits and such other documents as shall be necessary to enable the Consultants, Subconsultants or Personnel to perform the Services;
180
(b)assistfor thePersonnel and, ifappropriate,their eligibledependentsto beprovided promptlywith allsupportingpapersfor necessaryentryand exit visas, residence permits, exchangepermitsand anyother documentsrequired for their stayin India;
(c) facilitate prompt clearance through customs of any property required for the Services; (d) issue to officials, agents and representatives of the Government all such instructions as may
be necessary or appropriate for the prompt and effective implementation ofthe Services;
5.2 Accessto Land
TheClient warrantsthat theConsultants shall have, freeofcharge, unimpeded accessto alllandin theGovernment’scountryin respect ofwhich accessisrequired for the performanceoftheServices. TheClient will beresponsiblefor anydamagetosuch land or anypropertythereon resulting fromsuch accessand willindemnifytheConsultants and each ofthePersonnelin respect ofliabilityfor anysuch damage, unless such damageiscausedbythedefault or negligenceoftheConsultantsor anySubconsultants or thePersonnel ofeitherofthem.
181
5.3 ChangeintheApplicableLaw
If, after thedateofthisContract, thereisanychangein theApplicableLaw with respect to taxesand duties which increasesor decreasesthecost or reimbursable expenses incurred bytheConsultantsin performingtheServices, thentheremunerationand reimbursable expensesotherwisepayabletotheConsultantsunder thisContract shall be increased or decreased accordinglybyagreement between thePartieshereto, and correspondingadjustments shall bemadetotheceilingamounts specified in Clause 6.1(b),
5.4 Services, FacilitiesandProperty of theClient
Theclient shallmake availabletotheConsultantsand thePersonnel, for thepurposesof theServicesand freeofanycharge, theservices, facilitiesand propertydescribed in Appendix Dat thetimesand in themanner specifiedin said Appendix D, provided that if such services,facilitiesand propertyshall not bemade availabletotheConsultantsasand when so specified, theParties shallagreeon (i) anytime extension that maybe appropriateto grantto theConsultantsfor theperformanceoftheServices, (ii)the manner in which theConsultants shallprocure anysuch services, facilitiesandproperty fromother sources, and (iii) theadditional payments, ifany, to bemadetothe Consultantsasaresultthereofpursuant to Clause6.1(c) hereinafter.
5.5 Payment
In consideration ofthe Servicesperformed bytheConsultantsunder thisContract,the Client shall maketo the Consultants such payments and in suchmanner asis provided by Clause6 ofthisContract.
6. PAYMENT TO THE CONSULTANTS
6.1 Cost Estimates;CeilingAmount
(a) An abstract ofthecost oftheServicespayableinlocal currency (Indian Rupees)is set forth
inAppendixE. (b) Except asmaybeotherwise agreed under Clause2.6 and subjectto Clause6.1(c), the payments
under thisContract shall not exceed theceilingspecifiedin theSC.The Consultants shallnotifytheClientas soon ascumulative chargesincurred for the Serviceshavereached 80% ofthe ceiling.
(c) NotwithstandingClause6.1(b) hereof, ifpursuant toClauses5.4 hereof, theParties shall
agreethat additionalpayments shall bemadetotheConsultantsin order to cover anynecessaryadditional expendituresnot envisaged in thecost estimates referred toin Clause6.1(a) above, theceilingset forthin Clause6.1(b) aboveshall beincreased bythe amount or amounts, asthecasemaybe, ofanysuch additional payments.
182
6.2 Currency of Payment (a) Thepayment shall bemadein Indian Rupees.
6.3 ModeofBilling andPayment
Billingand paymentsin respect oftheServices shallbemadeasfollows:-
(a) TheClient shall causeto bepaidto theConsultantsan advancepayment as specified in theSC,and
asotherwiseset forth below. The advancepayment willbedueafter provision bytheConsultantsto theClient ofabank guaranteebyabank acceptable to theClientin anamount(or amounts) andin acurrency(or currencies) specified in theSC, such bank guarantee(i) to remain effectiveuntiltheadvancepayment has been fullyset offasprovided intheSC, andii)in suchformastheClient shall haveapprovedinwriting.
(b) Payment Schedule TheConsultant will bepaid stage-wise asapercentageofthe contract value aspertheschedule given below:
S.No Item Payment as % of contract value
1 Submission of final Inception Report 15%
2 Submission of final Alignment Report 10%
3 Submission of final Feasibility Report 5%
4 Submission of final Land Acquisition Report
10%
5 Submission of clearance proposals 5%
6 Submission of Draft DPR 10%
7 Approval of Final DPR 10%
8 Approval of Technical Schedules 5%
9 3D publication 10%
10 Clearance – Stage I Approval 5%
11 Clearance – Stage II/Final Approval 5%
12 Retention to be released after 3 years 10%
Total: 100%
13 Bonus on submission of draft 3A within 1 month of alignment finalization
2.5% bonus
14 Bonus on submission of draft clearance proposals within 1 month of alignment finalization
2.5% bonus
183
Note:Consultantshavetoprovideacertificatethatallkey personnelasenvisagedintheContract Agreementhasbeenactuallydeployedintheproject.Theyhavetosubmitthiscertificateatthetime ofsubmission ofbillsto NHAIfromtimeto time.
(c) Nopaymentshallbecomeeligibleforthenextstagetillthe consultant completes tothe
satisfactionoftheclienttheworkpertainingtotheprecedingstage.Thepaymentforthe workofsub-soilinvestigation(Boring)willbeasperplanapprovedby theclientandwillbe paidasperactual attheratesquotedbytheconsultants.Thepaymentforthequantitygiven by theclientforboringwillbedeemedtobeincludedintheabovementionedpayment schedule. Anyadjustmentin thepayment to the consultants will bemadein thefinal payment only.
(d) TheClientshallcausethepaymentoftheConsultantsinPara6.4(b)aboveasgivenin
scheduleofpaymentwithinthirty (30)daysafterthereceiptby theClientofbills.Interestsat theratespecifiedintheSCshallbecomepayableasfromtheaboveduedate onany amount dueby, but notpaid on, such duedate.
(e) ThefinalpaymentunderthisClauseshallbemadeonly afterthefinalreportandafinal
statement,identifiedassuch,shallhavebeensubmittedby theConsultants andapprovedas satisfactorybytheClient.TheServicesshallbedeemedcompletedandfinallyacceptedby theClientandthefinalreportandfinalstatementshallbedeemedapproved by theClientas satisfactory onehundred andeighty (180)calendardaysafterreceiptofthefinalreportand final statement by the Client unless the Client, within ninety(90) day period, gives written noticeto the ConsultantsspecifyingindetaileddeficienciesintheServices,the final report or final statement. The Consultants shall thereuponpromptly make any necessarycorrections, and uponcompletionofsuchcorrections,theforegoingprocess shall berepeated. AnyamountwhichtheClienthaspaidorcausedtobepaidinaccordance withthisClauseinexcessoftheamountsactually payableinaccordancewiththeprovisions ofthisContractshallbereimbursedby theConsultantstotheClientwithinthirty (30)days after receipt bythe Consultants of notice thereof. Any such claimby the Client for reimbursementmustbemadewithintwelve(12)calendarmonthsafterreceiptbytheClient ofafinal reportand afinal statementapproved bytheClientin accordancewith theabove.
(f) AllpaymentsunderthisContractshallbemadetotheaccountoftheConsultantsspecifiedin theSC.
7. ResponsibilityforAccuracy ofProject Documents
7.1 General
7.1.1 TheConsultant shall beresponsiblefor accuracyofthedatacollected, byhim directlyor procured
from other agencies/authorities, the designs, drawings, estimates and all other detailspreparedbyhimaspartoftheseservices.HeshallindemnifytheAuthorityagainst anyinaccuracyintheworkwhichmightsurfaceduringimplementationoftheproject.The Consultantwillalsoberesponsibleforcorrecting,athisowncostandrisk,thedrawings includinganyre-survey/investigationsandcorrectinglayoutetc.ifrequiredduringthe executionoftheServices.
7.1.2 TheConsultant shall befullyresponsiblefor theaccuracyofdesign and drawingsofthe bridgesand
184
structures. Allthedesignsand drawingsforbridgesand structuresincluding alltheir components shallbefullychecked byaSenior Engineerafter completion ofthe designs. All drawingsforbridgesand structures shall bedulysigned bythe(a) Designer, (b) Senior CheckingEngineer,and (c) Senior Bridge/ Structure Expert.Thedesignsand drawingsnot signed bythethreepersonsmentionedaboveshall not beaccepted. The Consultant shall indemnifytheClient againstanyinaccuracy/ deficiencyin thedesigns and drawingsofthebridgesandstructuresnoticed duringthe construction andeven thereafter and theClient shall bearno responsibilityfor the accuracyofthedesignsanddrawings submitted bytheConsultants.
7.1.3 Thesurveycontrolpointsestablished bytheConsultant shall beprotected bythe
Consultantstill the completion oftheConsultancyServices. 7.2. RetentionMoney
An amountequivalentto 10% ofthe contract valueshall beretainedat theend ofthe contractfor accuracyofdesign and quantities submittedand thesamewill bereleasedafterthecompletionofcivilcontractworksorafter3yearsfromcompletionofconsultancy services, whicheveris earlier.Theretentionmoney willhoweverbereleasedby theClientonsubstitution by Bank Guaranteeofthesameamount valid up to theperiodasabove.
7.3. Penalty
7.3.1. PenaltyforError/Variation
i) If variation inanyofthemain quantitiesofwork likeearth workincludingsub grade, GSB,
WMM, Bituminousworks(BM/DBM/AC/BC),drains, total concretequantitiesand reinforcing steel in bridgeworksor overall project cost, found duringexecution ismorethan +/-15%, the penaltyequivalent to 5% ofthe contract valueshall beimposed. For thispurposeretention moneyequivalent to 5% ofthe contract valuewill beforfeited. This shall exclude any additional/deletion ofitems/worksordered duringtheexecution
ii) Forinaccuraciesinsurvey/investigation/designworkthepenaltiesshallbeimposedas per
detailsgiven in Tablebelow:
Sl. No.
Item Penalty(%ageof contract value)
185
1
Topographic Surveys 0.5 to 1.0
a)Thehorizontalalignmentdoesnotmatchwithground condition.
b)Thecross sections donot match with existing ground.
c) The co-ordinates are defective as instruments of desired accuracynot used.
2
Geotechnical Surveys 0.5 to 1.0
a)Incompletesurveys
b)Data not analysed properly
c)Thesubstratasubstantiallydifferentfromtheactual stratafound during construction.
3
Trafficdatafoundtobevaryingbymorethan25%on resurvey at a later date, unless there are justifiable reasons.
0.2 to 0.5
4
Axleloaddatafoundtobevaryingbymorethan25%on resurvey at a later date, unless there are justifiable reasons.
0.20 to 0.5
5 StructuralDesignsfoundtobeunsafeorgrosslyover safe.
1.0 to 2.0
7.3.2 Penaltyfordelay
In caseofdelayin completion ofservices, apenaltyequalto 0.05%ofthe contract price per daysubject toamaximum 5% ofthecontract valuewill beimposedand shall be recovered frompaymentsdue/performancesecurity.However in caseofdelaydueto reasonsbeyond the control ofthe consultant, suitable extension oftimewill begranted.
7.3.3 Total amount ofrecoveryfrom all penalties shall belimitedto 10% oftheConsultancy Fee.
7.4 ACTIONFOR DEFICIENCY IN SERVICES
7.4.1 Consultantsliability towardstheClient
Consultant shall beliable to indemnifythe client foranydirect lossor damageaccrued or likelyto accrueduetodeficiencyin servicerendered byhim.
7.4.2 Warning / Debarring
In additionto thepenaltyasmentioned in para7.3,warningmaybeissued tothe erring consultantsfor minor deficiencies. In thecaseofmajor deficienciesintheDetailed Project Report involvingtimeand cost overrun andadverse effect on reputation of NHAI, other penalactionincludingdebarring for certain period mayalso beinitiated as perpolicyof NHAI.
8. FAIRNESS ANDGOOD FAITH
186
8.1 GoodFaith
ThePartiesundertaketo act in good faith with respect toeach other’s rightsunder this Contract and toadoptall reasonablemeasurestoensuretherealization oftheobjectives ofthisContract.
8.2 OperationoftheContract
ThePartiesrecognizethatit isimpractical inthisContract to providefor every contingencywhich mayariseduringthelifeoftheContract, and thePartiesherebyagree thatit istheir intention that thisContract shall operatefairlyasbetween them,and without detriment totheinterestofeither ofthem,and that,ifduringthetermofthis Contract either Partybelievesthat thisContractisoperatingunfairly, theParties will use their besteffortsto agreeon such actionasmaybenecessaryto removethecauseor causesofsuch unfairness,but no failuretoagreeonanyaction pursuantto thisClause shall giverisetoadisputesubject toarbitration inaccordancewith Clause9 hereof.
9. SETTLEMENT OFDISPUTES 9.1 AmicableSettlement
TheParties shall usetheirbest effortsto settleamicablyall disputesarisingout ofor in connection withthisContract ortheinterpretationthereof.
9.2 DisputeSettlement
Any disputebetween the Parties as to matters arising pursuant to this Contract which cannot besettled amicably within thirty (30) days after receipt by oneParty of theother Party’s request for such amicablesettlement may besubmitted by either Party for settlement in accordance with theprovisions specified in theSC.
10. ChangeofScope
The change ofScope on account of variation of total length as well as 4 laned length of project Highway from the indicative length asgiven at Annex-1 of Letter of Invitation of the RFP shall bedealt as follows
i) During the course of consultancy services in case it is considered necessary to
increase/decrease the scope ofservices(oftotal length or 4lanedlength as comparedto indicative Length as given in theRFP) by the client thesameshall benotified by Change of scopenotice. Similarly, if theConsultant determines that changeof scopeis needed, he shall inform of the sameto theClient. TheClientwill examine and shall either reject the proposal or issue changeof scopenotice.
ii) TheConsultancyfeeshallberevised onaccount of changeofscope asbelow:
- Incasethetotallengthofproject increase/decreaseuptomore10% ofindicative
lengthgiven in theRFP : No changein Consultancy Fees - Incasetheincrease/decrease intotallengthofprojectismorethan10%oftheindicative length
asgiven in theRFP: Theconsultancy feeshall beincreased/decreased inthesame proportionin which thelength oftheproject roadisincreased/ decreased beyond 10% .
187
- Incasethelengthof4laneroadisincreasedupto10% ofthelengthasindicatedinthe RFP: No changein Consultancy Fees
- Incasethelengthof4laneroadisincreasedbymorethan10% ofthelengthasindicatedin theRFP: The consultancy feeshallbe increased by 0.25timesthe averagequoted rate(Rs per km) for theincreasedlength of4 lanebeyond10%
iii) LengthofBypass/realignmentshallnotbetreatedasadditionalitytotheexistinglength of
thehighway forthepurposeof change/variationinlength.Increase/decreasein length onaccountofbypassesshallnotbeconsideredas changeofscope.However,thetotal lengthoftheprojecthighway (includingbypassesandrealignment)alongthefinally approvedalignmentshall becomparedwiththeindicativelengthintheRFPforthe purposeof variation.
188
SPECIAL CONDITIONSOFCONTRACT
Numberof GC Clause
A. Amendmentsof, and Supplementsto, ClausesintheGeneral Conditions
1.1(a) Thewords “intheGovernment’s country”areamendedto read “in INDIA”
1.4 Thelanguageis:English
1.6.1 Theaddressesare:
FortheClient : Chairman, National Highway Authority of India, G5&6, Sector-10, Dwarka, New Delhi-75
Attention: Nishoo Gupta, GM (T), HP National Highways Authority of India, G5&6, Sector-10, Dwarka, New Delhi-75
011-25074100/ 4200 Ext.- 1321; E-mail: [email protected]
FortheConsultants:
Attention: Name
Designation
Address
Tel: Fax: E-mail address
1.6.2 Noticewillbedeemedtobe effective asfollows:
(a) in thecaseofpersonal deliveryor registered mail, on delivery; (b) In the caseof facsimiles, 24 hoursfollowingconfirmed transmission. (c) In caseofEmail, 24 hoursfollowingconfirmed transmission.
1.8EntitytoActasMemberincharge(IncaseofJointVentureofConsultants)withorwithoutan Associate: - ……………………….. 1.9 TheAuthorized Representativesare:
FortheClient : (-- ) Chairman, NHAI(-- )
For theConsultant: Name
Designation 1.10 TheConsultantsand thepersonnel shall paythetaxes, duties, fees, leviesand other
impositionslevied under the existing, amended orenacted laws(prevailing7 daysbeforethe last dateofsubmission ofbids) duringlifeofthiscontract andtheClient shallperformsuch
189
dutiesin regard tothedeductionofsuch tax asmaybelawfullyimposed.
2.1 Theeffectivenessconditionsarethefollowing: a) Thecontracthasbeen approved by NHAI.
b) The consultant will furnish within 15 days of the issue of letter of acceptance, an
unconditionalBankGuaranteefromaNationalisedBank,IDBIorICICI/ICICIBank/Foreign Bank/EXIMBank/AnyScheduledCommercialBank approvedbyRBIhavinganetworthofnot lessthan 500 crore as per latestAnnualReportof the Bank. Inthe case ofa Foreign Bank(issued byaBranchinIndia)thenetworthinrespectofIndianoperationsshallonlybetakeninto account. IncaseofForeignBank,theBGissuedbyForeignBankshouldbecounterguaranteed byanyNationalisedBankinIndia.IncaseofJV,the BGshallbefurnishedonbehalfoftheJVor
leadpartnerofJVforanamountequivalentto10%ofthetotalcontractvaluetobereceived byhim towards PerformanceSecurityvalid for aperiod of three yearsbeyond thedateofcompletion ofservices.
2.2 Thetimeperiodshallbe “fourmonths”orsuchothertimeperiodasthepartiesmayagreein writing.
2.3 Thetimeperiodshallbe “fifteendays”orsuchothertimeperiodasthePartiesmayagree in writing.
2.4 Thetimeperiodshallbe------monthsorsuchothertimeperiodasthepartiesmayagree in writing.
3.4 LimitationoftheConsultants’ LiabilitytowardstheClient
(a) ExceptincaseofnegligenceorwillfulmisconductonthepartoftheConsultantsoronthe
partofanyperson orfirmactingon behalfof theConsultantsin carrying outtheServices, the Consultants,withrespecttodamagecausedby theConsultantstotheClient’sproperty,shall not beliableto theClient:
(i) foranyindirect orconsequentiallossordamage; and (ii) foranydirect lossor damagethatexceeds(A) thetotal paymentsfor Professional
Fees andReimbursableExpendituremadeor expectedtobemadetotheConsultants hereunder,or(B)theproceedstheConsultantsmay beentitledtoreceivefromanyinsurance maintained bytheConsultantstocover such aliability, whichever of(A)or (B) ishigher.
(b) ThislimitationofliabilityshallnotaffecttheConsultants’liability,ifany,fordamageto
ThirdPartiescausedby theConsultantsorany personorfirmactingonbehalfofthe Consultantsin carryingout theServices.
3.5 Therisksand the coverageshallbeasfollows: (a) Third Partymotor vehicleliabilityinsurance asrequired under Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 in respect
ofmotor vehiclesoperated in IndiabytheConsultantsor their Personnelor anySubconsultantsor their Personnel for theperiodof consultancy.
190
(b) ThirdPartyliabilityinsurancewithaminimumcoverage,forRs.1.00millionfortheperiod ofconsultancy.
(c) (i) TheConsultantshallprovideto NHAI ProfessionalLiabilityInsurance(PLI)foraperiodof
FiveyearsbeyondcompletionofConsultancy servicesorasperApplicableLaw,whichever ishigher.
(ii) TheConsultant will maintain at itsexpensePLIincludingcoveragefor errorsand
omissions causedby Consultant’snegligenceintheperformanceofitsdutiesunderthisagreement,(A) Fortheamount not exceeding totalpaymentsforProfessionalFees andReimbursable Expenditures made or expected to be made to the Consultants hereunder OR (B) the proceeds,theConsultantsmay beentitledtoreceivefromany insurancemaintainedby the Consultantsto cover such aliability, whichever of (A) or (B) is higher.
iii) Thepolicyshould beissued onlyfroman InsuranceCompanyoperatinginIndia.
iv) Thepolicymustclearlyindicatethelimitofindemnityintermsof“AnyOneAccident”
(AOA)and“Aggregatelimitonthepolicy”(AOP)andinnocaseshouldbeforanamount lessthan stated inthecontract.
v) IftheConsultant entersinto an agreement with NHAI in ajoint ventureor ‘inassociation’,
thepolicymustbeprocuredandprovidedto NHAI bythejointventure/inassociationentity and not bytheindividualpartnersofthejointventure/ association.
vi) ThecontractmayincludeaprovisiontherebytheConsultantdoesnotcancel thepolicy
midtermwithouttheconsentofNHAI.Theinsurancecompanymayprovideanundertaking in thisregard.
(d) Employer’sliabilityandworkers’compensationinsuranceinrespectofthePersonnelofthe Consultantsandofany Subconsultant,inaccordancewiththerelevantprovisionsofthe Applicable Law,aswellas,withrespecttosuchPersonnel,any suchlife,health,accident,travel orother insuranceasmay beappropriate;andallinsurancesandpoliciesshouldstartfromthe dateof commencement ofservicesandremaineffective asper relevant requirementsofcontract agreement.
3.9 TheConsultants shallnotusethesedocumentsfor purposesunrelated
tothisContract withouttheprior writtenapproval oftheClient. 4.6 Theperson designated asTeam Leader cum SeniorHighwayEngineer inAppendix B
shallserveinthat capacity, as specifiedin Clause4.6. 6.1 (b) The ceilingamount in local currencyisRs……… Excluding
Servi
191
ceTax)
6.3 (a) No advancepayment willbemade. 6.3 (e) Theinterest rateis: @12% perannum 6.3 (f) Theaccount is:
9.2 Disputes shall besettledbyarbitration in accordancewith thefollowingprovisions:
9.2.1 SelectionofArbitrators Eachdisputesubmitted byaPartyto arbitration shallbeheard byasole arbitrator or an arbitration panelcomposed ofthree arbitrators, in accordancewith thefollowing provisions:
(a) WherethePartiesagreethatthedisputeconcernsatechnicalmatter,theymayagreeto
appointasolearbitratoror,failingagreementontheidentityofsuchsolearbitratorwithin thirty(30) daysafter receipt bytheother Partyoftheproposalof a name for such an appointmentby thePartywhoinitiatedtheproceedings,eitherParty mayapply tothe President,IndianRoadsCongress,NewDelhi,foralistofnotfewerthanfivenominees and, onreceiptofsuchlist,thePartiesshallalternately strikenamestherefrom,andthelast remainingnomineeon thelist shallbethesolearbitratorforthematterindispute.Ifthelast remainingnominee hasnotbeendeterminedinthismannerwithinsixty(60)daysofthe dateofthelist,thepresident,IndianRoadsCongress,NewDelhi,shall appoint, upon the requestofeitherParty andfromsuchlistorotherwise,asolearbitratorforthematterin dispute.
(b) WherethePartiesdonotagreethat thedisputeconcernsatechnical matter, theClient andthe
Consultants shalleach appoint one arbitrator,and thesetwoarbitrators shall jointly appoint athirdarbitrator,whoshallchairthearbitrationpanel.Ifthearbitratorsnamedby theParties donotsucceedin appointing athirdarbitrator within thirty(30)days afterthelater of thetwo arbitratorsnamed bythe Partieshasbeen appointed,thethird arbitrator shall, at therequest of eitherParty, be appointedbySecretary, theIndian CouncilofArbitration, NewDelhi.
(c) If,inadisputesubjecttoClauseSC9.2.1(b),onePartyfailstoappointitsarbitratorwithin
thirty(30)daysaftertheotherPartyhasappointeditsarbitrator,thePartywhichhasnamed an arbitrator mayapplytotheSecretary,Indian Council ofArbitration, New Delhi, toappoint asolearbitratorforthe matterindispute, andthearbitratorappointedpursuanttosuch application shall bethesole arbitrator for that dispute.
9.2.2 Rulesof Procedure
192
Arbitration proceedings shall be conducted in accordancewith procedureoftheArbitration & Conciliation Act1996, of IndiaunlesstheConsultant isaforeign national/firm, where arbitrationproceedings shallbeconductedinaccordancewiththerulesof procedurefor arbitrationoftheUnitedNationsCommissiononInternationalTradeLaw(UNCITRAL)as in forceon thedateofthisContract.
9.2.3 SubstituteArbitrators
If for any reason an arbitrator is unable to perform his function, a substitute shall be appointed in thesamemanner astheoriginal arbitrator.
9.2.4 QualificationsofArbitrators
Thesolearbitratororthe thirdarbitratorappointedpursuanttoparagraphs(a)through(c)of Clause8.2.1 hereofshallbeaninternationallyrecognizedlegalortechnical expertwith extensive experiencein relation tothematterin dispute.
9.2.5 Miscellaneous
In anyarbitration proceedinghereunder:
(a) Proceedings shall, unlessotherwiseagreed bytheParties,
beheldinDELHI (b) the Englishlanguageshallbetheofficial languagefor
allpurposes;and [Note:English languagemaybe changed to anyother Language, with the agreement ofboth theParties.]
(c) thedecision ofthesole arbitrator or ofamajorityof the arbitrators(or ofthethird
arbitrator if thereisnosuchmajority)shallbefinalandbindingandshallbeenforceableinany courtof competentjurisdiction,andthePartieshereby waiveany objectionstoorclaimsofimmunity in respect of such enforcement.
(d) Themaximumamount payableper Arbitrator in Arbitrationclauses shallbeasunder
S. No. Particulars of fee and
other charges
Schedule Amount payable per Arbitrator / per case
1. Arbitrator fee
Rs.25,000/- per day Or
Rs. 7 lacs (lump sum) subject to publishing the Award within 6 months. Or
Rs. 5 lakhs (Lump-sum) subject to publishing the Award after 6 months but before 12 months. Note:- The amount of fees already paid for the days of hearing @ Rs.
193
25,000/- would be adjusted in the lump-sum payment.
2. Reading Charges
Rs. 25,000/- per Arbitrator per case including counter claim.
3. Secretarial Assistance and Incidental Charges (telephone, fax, postage etc)
Rs. 20,000/-
4. Charges for Publishing / declaration of the Award
Rs.35,000/-
5. Other expenses (As per actual against bills subject to maximum of the prescribed ceiling given below)
Traveling Expenses Lodging and Boarding
Economy class (By Air), First Class AC (By Train) and AC Car (By Road) (a) Rs. 15,000/- per day (in metro cities) (b) Rs. 7,000/- per day (in other cities) (c) Rs. 3,000/- per day, if any Arbitrator makes their own arrangements.
6. Local Travel Rs. 1,500/- per day
7. Extra Charges for days other than hearing / meeting days (maximum for 2 days)
Rs. 5,000/- per day for outside Arbitrator
Note: 1. Lodging, boarding and traveling expenses shall be allowed only for those members who are residing 100 kms. away from place of meeting. 2. Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, Bangalore and Hyderabad shall be considered as Metro Cities.
Inexceptionalcases,suchascasesinvolvingmajorlegalimplications/widerramifications/higher financialstakesetc., aspecialfeestructure couldbefixedinconsultationwiththeContractor/ SupervisionConsultantsandwiththespecificapprovalof theChairman, NHAI beforeappointmentof theArbitrator,
194
Appendix A
Terms ofreference containing, inter-alia, the Description of theServices and Reporting
Requirements
196
Appendix C
Hours of workforConsultants’ Personnel
TheConsultant’spersonnelshallnormally workfor8hoursinaday andsixdaysaweek.
NormallySundaysshallbeclosedforworking.Inadditiontheyshallalsobeallowedtoavail
holidaysasobservedby theClient’sofficeintherelevantstatewithoutdeductionof
remunerations.Incaseany personisrequiredtoworkonSunday orHolidayduetoexigency of work,
he/she shallbegiven compensatoryleavewithin thenext 15 days.
202
Appendix-I
Format forBankGuaranteeforPerformance Security (Forindividual work) BANK GUARANTEE FORPERFORMANCE SECURITY
To, Chairman National Highways Authority of India, G-5&6, Sector-10, Dwarka, New Delhi-110075
Inconsiderationof "National Highways Authority of India” (hereinafter referredasthe “Client”,whichexpressionshall,unlessrepugnanttothecontextormeaning thereofincludeits successors,administratorsandassigns) havingawardedto M/s.………………………………………………having its office at ……………….. (Hereinafter referredtoasthe “Consultant” whichexpressionshallrepugnanttothe contextor meaningthereof,includeitssuccessors,administrators,executorsandassigns),acontractby issueofclient’sContractAgreementno./LetterofAcceptanceNo.………………..dated ………………andthesamehavingbeenunequivocallyacceptedbytheConsultant,resultingin aContractvaluedatRs…………../-(Rupees….………………….)excluding servicetaxfor “Consultancy Services for Preparation of Feasibility and Detailed Project Report for upgradation to 4 lane of HP/Punjab Border to Mandi Section (Km 11.00 to Km 208.00) of NH-
20 in the State of Himachal Pradesh through BOT/Hybrid Annuity/EPC mode” (Total Length - 197 km) on NH-20 in the stateof Himachal Pradesh ………….under –Contract PackageNo.NHAI/HP Border-Mandi/NH-20/DPR/HP/2016 (Hereinaftercalledthe“Contract”),andthe ConsultanthavingagreedtofurnishaBankGuaranteetotheClientas“PerformanceSecurity as stipulatedby theClientinthesaidcontractforperformanceoftheaboveContractamountingto Rs.……………./-(Rupees…………………………………….).
We,……………………………..having registeredofficeat……………..,abody registered/constituted under the ……………………….(hereinafter referred to as the Bank), which expression shall, unless repugnant to the context or meaning thereof, include its successors,administrators,executorsandassigns)doherebyguaranteeandundertaketopay the clientimmediatelyondemandanyor,allmoneypayablebytheConsultanttotheextentofRs. …………..(Rupees………..………………..)asaforesaidatany timeupto………..withoutany demur,reservation,contest,recourseorprotestand/orwithoutany referencetotheconsultant. Any such demand made by the client on the bank shall be conclusive and binding notwithstandinganydifferencebetweentheClientandtheConsultantoranydisputepending beforeany Court,Tribunal,Arbitratororany otherauthority.WeagreethattheGuaranteeherein containedshallbe irrevocable andshallcontinuetobe enforceable tillthe Clientdischargesthis guarantee.
TheClientshallhavethefullestlibertywithoutaffectinginanywaytheliabilityoftheBank underthisGuarantee,fromtimetotimetovaryortoextendthetimeforperformanceofthe contractby theConsultant.TheClientshallhavethefullestlibertywithoutaffectingthis guarantee,topostponefromtimetotimetheexerciseofanypowersvestedinthemorofany rightwhichtheymighthaveagainsttheconsultantandtoexercisethesameatanytimeinany
203
manner,andeithertoenforceortoforbeartoenforceany covenants,containedorimplied,inthe ContractbetweentheClientandtheConsultantany othercourseorremedyorsecurity available totheClient.Thebankshallnotberelievedofitsobligationsunderthesepresentsbyany exercise by theClientofitslibertywithreferencetothemattersaforesaidorany ofthemorby reasonofany otheractorforbearanceorotheractsofomissionorcommissiononthepartofthe Clientorany otherindulgenceshownby theClientorbyany othermatterorthingwhatsoever which under law would but forthis provision havethe effect of relievingtheBank.
TheBankalso agreesthat the Clientatits option shallbeentitled to enforcethis Guarantee againsttheBankas aprincipal debtor,in thefirstinstancewithoutproceeding againstthe Consultantandnotwithstandingany security orotherguaranteethattheClientmay havein relation to the Consultant’s liabilities.
Notwithstandinganythingcontained herein,
a) Our liability under this Bank Guarantee is limited to Rs.
……………….(Rupees……………………………)anditshall remaininforceupto andincluding …………andshallbeextendedfromtimetotimeforsuchperiodas may bedesired by M/s…………………….,onwhosebehalfthisguaranteehasbeen given.
b) This Bank Guaranteeshallbevalid up to …………..
c) WeareliabletopaytheguaranteedamountoranypartthereofunderthisBank
Guaranteeonlyandonlyifyouserveuponusawrittenclaimordemandonor before……………(dateof expiryof Guarantee).
(Signatureof theAuthorisedOfficial)
(Name&Designation with Bank Stamp)
NOTE: (i) Thebankguarantee(s)contains thename, designation and codenumber of the
officer(s) signing theguarantee(s). (ii) Theaddress, telephoneno. and other details oftheHead Officeof theBankas wellas of
issuing branch shouldbementioned on thecovering letter of issuing Branch. (iii) ThebankguaranteeforRs. 10,000 and aboveis signed byat least two officials (or as per
the norms prescribedbythe RBIin this regard).
205
APPENDIX-VII
DPR Checklist – Stage 1 – Inception Report (Pavements)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
1 Executive Summary Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Project Appreciation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.1 Location of site office Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.2 Review of scope of ToR and gap
identification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.3 Key departments identified for various
documents Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.4 Start and end location of project verified
with client (Mention details) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.5
Project description
• Start and End Chainage
• Village/District
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.6
Project location map
• On State Map
• On District Map
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.7 Site photos and data of project alignment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
206
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
2.8 Overview of land use plans Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.9
Overview of existing pavement
conditions
• Number of Lanes
• Type of Pavement (Flexible/Rigid/Surfaced/ Unsurfaced)
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.10 Existing right of way details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.11 Number/ Location of major and minor
bridges Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.12 Number/ Location of level crossings
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.13 Number/ Location of ROB and RUB Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.14 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Approach Methodology Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.1 Engineering survey and investigations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.2 Design of road, pavements and structures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.3 Environment and social impact
assessment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.4 Estimation of project cost, viability and
financing options Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.5 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Task Assignment and Manning
Schedule Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Number of key personnel provided Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
207
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
4.2 Specific tasks assigned to each key
personnel Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.3 Manning schedule for key personnel Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.4 Number of key personnel deployed at site Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5 Performa for data collection Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6 Indicative design standards and cross
sections Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7 Development plans Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Overview of development plans being
implemented/ proposed by local bodies Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.2 Overview of impact of such development
plans Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8 Quality Assurance Plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Engineering surveys and investigation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.2 Traffic surveys Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.3 Material geo-technical and sub-soil
investigations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.4 Road and pavement investigations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.5 Investigation and design of bridges and
structures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.6 Environment and R&R assessment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.7 Economic and financial analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.8 Drawing and documentation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.9 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
208
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
8.10 Discussion of draft QAP document with
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.11 Approval of final QAP document by
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9 Draft design Standards Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.1 Geometric design standards of highway
(Plain) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.2 Geometric design standards of highway
(Hilly) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.2 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.3 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.4 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
209
DPR Checklist – Stage 2 – Feasibility Report (Pavements)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/ NO/ NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
1 Executive Summary Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Overview of client organization /
activities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Methodology adopted for feasibility
study Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Socioeconomic profile of the project
areas Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Regional economic profile basis last 10
years data as per IRC Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.2 Economic profile of project influence
area basis last 10 years data as per IRC Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.3 Socio Economic status of project
influence area Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5 Indicative design standards,
methodologies, and specifications Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6 Traffic surveys and analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.1 Classified traffic volume counts using
IHMCL data (7 day data) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
210
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/ NO/ NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
6.2 Traffic projection methodology as per
IRC:108 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.3 Projected Traffic data for 20 years Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.4 Current and Projected PCU Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.5 Current and Projected TVU Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.6 Origin destination surveys as per IRC:
102 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.7 Speed and delay studies as per IRC:102 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.8 Traffic surveys for the design of road
junctions as per data in IRC: SP:41 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.9 Analysis for replacing railway level
crossings with over bridges/ subways Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.10 Axle load survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.11 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.12 Traffic surveys monitored and reviewed
by the client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7 Reconnaissance survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Road Inventory Survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.2 Review of Road Inventory survey by
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.3 Chainage wise details of pavement
composition survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.4
Geological Survey
• Geological Map of the Area
• Seismicity
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
211
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/ NO/ NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
7.5
Climatic Conditions
• Temperature
• Rainfall
• Wind
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.6 Pavement composition and condition
survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.7 Review of pavement composition and
condition survey by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.8 Pavement roughness survey as per
IRC:SP:16 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.9 Review of pavement roughness survey
by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.10 Pavement structural strength survey as
per IRC:81 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.11 Review of pavement structural strength
survey by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.12 Sub grade characteristics and strengths Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.13
Topographical survey as per IRC:SP:19
using LiDAR
• Gradient
• Terrain
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.14 Review of topographical survey by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.15 Inventory of bridges, culverts and
structures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.16 Condition survey for bridges, culverts
and structures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.17 Review of condition survey for bridges,
culverts and structures by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.18 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
212
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/ NO/ NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
8 Geotechnical Survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Geo-technical and sub-soil explorations
as per IRC:78 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.2 Bore holes dug for every pier and
abutment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.3 Review of geo-technical and sub-soil
explorations by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.4
Field testing, soil sampling, laboratory
testing in accordance with BIS/
AASHTO/ BS
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.5 Recommendation of Foundation Type
and Depth Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.6 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9 Hydraulic and Hydrological Survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.1
Hydraulic and hydrological
investigations as per IRC:SP:13 and
IRC:5
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.2 High Flood Level specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.3 Depth of Water Table specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.4 Ponded Water Level specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.5 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.6 Review of hydrological investigations by
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10 Materials Survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Materials Survey conducted as per
IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
213
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/ NO/ NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
10.2
Sources of Naturally Occurring
Aggregates specified
• Details of Borrow Pits with Distance from Project Site
• Cost of Material/ Transportation
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.3
Sources of Manufactured Items specified
• Details of suppliers with distance from project site
• Cost of material/ transportation
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.4 Sources of water for construction
specified as per IS: 456 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.5 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11 Environmental screening/ preliminary
environmental assessment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.1 Analysis basis Initial Environment
Examination in IRC: SP: 19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.2 Recommended feasible mitigation
measures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12 Initial social assessment/ preliminary
LA resettlement plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.1 Analysis basis Initial Environment
Examination in IRC: SP: 19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.2 Details of consultation with potentially
affected persons Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.3 Names/ Details of consultation with local
NGOs Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
12.4 Names/ Details of consultation with
municipal authorities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
12.5 Preliminary resettlement plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
214
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/ NO/ NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
12.6 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13 Cost estimates Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13.1 Item rates and rate analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13.2 Escalation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14 Economic and financial analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.1 Estimated cost details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.2 Projected revenues details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.3 Assumptions stated Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.4 Analysis and results (IRR, Sensitivity
Analysis, Financial Viability) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15 Strip plan and Alignment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.1 Details of center line of proposed
highway Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.2 Details of existing RoW Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.3 Details of proposed RoW Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.4 Details about ownership of land to be
acquired Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.5 Strip plan basis reconnaissance and
topographic surveys Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.6 Strip plan reviewed and approved by the
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16 Alignment Options Study Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16.1 At least two alignments proposed
• Details of Alignments on Map
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
215
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/ NO/ NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
16.2 Review of options with client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16.3 Length of the project along proposed
alignment options Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
16.4 Land Acquisition required along
alignment options Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
16.5 Cost Estimates of alternatives Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
16.6 Recommended Alignment with
Justification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16.7 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
17 Technical Specifications Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
17.1 MoRTH technical specifications for
Roads and Bridge works followed Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
17.2 Details of technical specifications Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
18 Rate Analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
18.1 Rate analysis for all relevant items as per
latest SoR Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
19 Cost Estimates Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
19.1 Cost estimates for all relevant items as
per latest SoR Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
20 Bill of quantities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
21 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
21.1 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
21.2 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
21.3 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
216
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/ NO/ NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
21.4 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
217
DPR Checklist – Stage 3 – LA and Clearances I Report (Pavements)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1 Executive Summary Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Environment Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.1 Requirement for environment clearance
identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.2 Date/ Details of Initial consultation with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.3 Date of submission of draft EIA report/
proposal for clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.4 Review of proposal/ EIA report by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Forest Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.1 Requirement for forest clearance
identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.2 Date/ Details of initial consultation with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.3 Details/cost of trees being felled basis
concerned District Forest Office Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
218
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
3.4 Date of submission of proposal for forest
clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.5 Review of proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Wildlife Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Requirement for wildlife clearance
identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.2 Date/ Details of initial consultation with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.3 Details/cost of trees being felled basis
concerned District Forest Office Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.4 Date of submission of proposal for
wildlife clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.5 Review of proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5 Utility Clearances (Electricity) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.1 Identification of overground utilities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.2
Identification of underground utilities
using GPR, Induction Locator or
equivalent technologies
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.3 Name/ Details of consultation with local
authority/ people Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.4
Utility relocation plan with existing /
proposed location showing existing RoW
and topographic details
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.5 Cost for relocation as per authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.6 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
219
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
5.7 Review of utility relocation plan/
proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6 Utility Clearances (Water) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.1 Identification of overground utilities in
RoW Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.2
Identification of underground utilities
using GPR, Induction Locator or
equivalent technologies
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.3 Name/ Details of consultation with local
authority/ people Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.4
Utility relocation plan with existing /
proposed location showing existing RoW
and topographic details
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.5 Cost for relocation as per authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.6 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.7 Review of utility relocation plan/
proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7 Utility Clearances (Others) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Identification of overground utilities in
RoW Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.2
Identification of underground utilities
using GPR, Induction Locator or
equivalent technologies
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.3 Name/ Details of consultation with local
authority/ people Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.4
Utility relocation plan with existing /
proposed location showing existing RoW
and topographic details
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
220
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
7.5 Cost for relocation as per authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.6 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.7 Review of utility relocation plan/
proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8 Railway Clearances Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Identification of ROB/ RUB on project
corridor Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.2 Initial consultation with competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.3 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
8.4 Review of GAD/ proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9 Other Clearances Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.1 Requirement for other clearances
identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.2 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
9.3 Review of proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10 Land Acquisition Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Detailed schedule about acquisition of
landholdings as per land records Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.2 Consultation with affected persons Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.3 Name/ Details of consultation with
NGOs Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
221
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
10.4 Name/ Details of consultation with
concerned government agencies Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.5 Total land required, land area already
available , land to be acquired identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.6 Review of land acquisition using digital
cadastral map by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.7 Draft 3a notification submitted Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.8 Review of 3a notification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.9 Date of 3a gazette notification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.10 Draft 3a notification submitted Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.11 Review of 3A notification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.12 Date of 3A gazette notification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
11 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.1 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.2 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.3 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.4 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
222
DPR Checklist – Stage 4 – Detailed Project Report (Pavements)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
1 Main Report Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Introduction and project background Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.1 Overview of project location, project
objectives etc. Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.2 Overview of report structure,
deliverables etc. Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Social analysis of the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.1 Project impact on stakeholders such as
local people Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.2 Project impact on residential, commercial
and public properties Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.3 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Reconnaissance survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
223
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
4.1
Geometric Features of the Existing Road
Design Speed
• Sight distance details
• Horizontal Alignment Details
• Vertical Alignment Details
• Height of Embankment
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.2
Topographical Survey using LiDAR (or
equivalent technology) as per IRC:SP:19
• Gradient
• Terrain
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.3 Pavement composition and condition
survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.4 Pavement roughness survey as per
IRC:SP:16 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ Na
4.5 Pavement structural strength survey as
per IRC:81 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.6
Geological Survey
• Geological Map of the Area
• Seismicity
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.7
Climatic Conditions
• Temperature
• Rainfall
• Wind
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.8
Land Use along the existing alignment
• Map of the Project Area depicting Agricultural/Habitation/Forest Area
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.9
Details of Existing Structures
• Map of the Project Area depicting Hutments/Buildings/Temples/Public Building/Any Other Significant Structure
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
224
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
4.10 Inventory and condition survey of
culverts Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.11 Geo-technical and sub-soil explorations
as per IRC:78 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.12 Number of Bore holes dug (holes for
every pier and abutment) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.13 Field testing, soil sampling, laboratory
testing as per IRC: 78 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.14 Recommendation of Foundation Type
and Depth Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.15 Hydrological investigations as per IRC:5 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.16 High Flood Level specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.17 Depth of Water Table specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.18 Ponded Water Level specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.19 Materials Survey conducted as per
IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.20
Sources of Naturally Occurring
Aggregates specified
• Details of Borrow Pits with Distance from Project Site
• Cost of Material/Transportation
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.21
Sources of Manufactured Items specified
• Details of Suppliers with Distance from Project Site
• Cost of Material/Transportation
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.22 Source of Water for construction
specified as per IS:456 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.23 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
225
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
5 Traffic studies and demand forecast
designs Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.1 Classified traffic volume counts using
IHMCL data (7 day data) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.2 Traffic projection methodology as per
IRC:108 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.3 Projected Traffic data for 20 years Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.4 Current and Projected PCU Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.5 Current and Projected TVU Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.6 Origin destination surveys as per IRC:
102 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.7 Speed and delay studies as per IRC:102 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.8 Traffic surveys for the design of road
junctions as per data in IRC: SP:41 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.9 Analysis for replacing railway level
crossings with over bridges/ subways Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.10 Axle load survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.11 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.12 Traffic surveys monitored and reviewed
by the client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6 Cost estimates Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.1 Project costing as per latest SoR Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7 Environmental aspects Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Environment profile of the project region Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
226
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
7.2
Details of Public consultation at
residential and commercial settlements
affected
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.3 Impact analysis and mitigation measures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8 Economic and commercial analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Estimated cost details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.2 Projected revenues details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.3 Assumptions stated Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.4 Analysis and results (IRR, Sensitivity
Analysis, Financial Viability) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.5 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.1 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.2 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.3 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10 Design Report Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Highway improvement proposals Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.2 Highway geometric designs Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.3 Roadside drainage Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.4 Intersections Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.5 Urban service roads Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
227
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
10.6 Bus-stops Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.7 Toll plazas Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.8 Pedestrian crossings Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.9 Utility relocation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.10 Pavement Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.11 Structures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.12 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.13 Pavement deflection survey as per IRC
81-1997 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.14 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11 Materials Report Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.1 Material investigations as per IRC:10 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.2 Review of material investigations by
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.3 Multiple borrow areas identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.4 Material survey as per IRC: SP: 19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.5 Review of material survey by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.6 Geo-technical and sub-soil explorations
as per IRC:78 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.7 Review of geo-technical and sub-soil
explorations by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.8
Field testing, soil sampling, laboratory
testing in accordance with BIS/
AASHTO/ BS
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
228
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
11.9 Pavement composition and condition
survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.10 Review of pavement composition and
condition survey by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.11 Pavement roughness survey as per
IRC:SP:16 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.12 Review of pavement roughness survey
by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.13 Pavement structural strength survey as
per IRC:81 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.14 Review of pavement structural strength
survey by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.15 Water sample tests as per MoRTH
specifications Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.16 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12 Environmental Assessment Report/
Resettlement and Rehabilitation Plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.1 Option for alignment alternatives
considered and conclusions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.2 Land environment data collection and
details/ impact/ mitigation measures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.3 Air environment data collection and
details/ impact/ mitigation measures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.4 Water resources details/ impact/
mitigation measures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.5 Noise environment details/ impact/
mitigation measures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
229
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
12.6 Biological environment details/ impact/
mitigation measures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.7 Details of public consultation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.8 Environment monitoring and
management plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.9 Details of social impact assessment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.10 Details of resettlement and rehabilitation
action plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.11 Measures to minimize resettlement Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.12 Details of public consultation with
stakeholders Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.13 Details of implementation arrangement /
budget Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.14 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13 Technical Specifications Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13.1 MoRTH technical specifications for
Roads and Bridge works followed Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13.2 Details of technical specifications Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14 Rate Analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.1 Rate analysis for all relevant items as per
latest SoR Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15 Cost Estimates Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.1 Cost estimates for all relevant items as
per latest SoR Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16 Bill of quantities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
230
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
17 Drawing Volume Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
231
DPR Checklist – Stage 5 – Technical Schedules (Pavements)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details /
Specifications Remarks
1 Schedule A - Site of the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Schedule B - Development of the
project highway Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Schedule C - Project facilities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Schedule D - Specifications and
standards Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5 Any other relevant details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
232
DPR Checklist – Stage 6 – LA and Clearances II Report (Pavements)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1 Executive Summary Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Environment Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.1 Details of public hearings completed Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.2 Date of final environment clearance by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3 Forest Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.1 Date/ Details of Joint site inspection with
DFO/ competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.2 Date of Stage I forest clearance approval
by competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.3 Date of final forest clearance approval by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4 Wildlife Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Date/ Details of joint site inspection with
DFO/ competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.2 Date of final wildlife clearance approval
by competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
233
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
5 Utility Clearances (Electricity) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.1 Date/ Details of Joint site inspection with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.2 Date of estimate submission by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.3 Date of estimate approval by competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6 Utility Clearances (Water) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.1 Date/ Details of Joint site inspection with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.2 Date of estimate submission by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.3 Date of estimate approval by competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7 Utility Clearances (Others) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Date/ Details of Joint site inspection with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.2 Date of estimate submission by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.3 Date of estimate approval by competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
8 Railway Clearances Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Date/ Details of joint site inspection with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
8.2 Date of final approval of GAD by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
9 Other Clearances Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
234
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
9.1 Date of final approval by competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10 Land Acquisition Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Draft 3a notification submitted Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.2 Review of 3a notification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.3 Date of 3a gazette notification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.4 Draft 3a notification submitted Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.5 Review of 3A notification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.6 Date of 3A gazette notification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.7 Date of Joint Measurement Survey with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.8 Draft 3D notification submitted Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.9 Review of 3D notification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.10 Date of 3D gazette notification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
11 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.1 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.2 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.3 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.4 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
235
Annexure III: Checklists for Structures such as ROB/ RUB
DPR Checklist – Stage 1 – Inception Report (Structures)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1 Executive Summary Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Project Appreciation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.1 Location of site office Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.2 Review of scope of ToR and gap
identification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.3 Details of key departments for
documents Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.4
Project description
• Existing LC number
• Start and End Chainage
• Village/District
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.5
Project location map
• On State Map
• On District Map
• Latitude & Longitude Coordinates of the LC
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
236
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
2.6
Details of Existing Level Crossing
• Number of Railway Tracks
• Type of Railway Tracks (Broad/Meter/Narrow)
• No. of trains per day
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.7 Justification for need of an ROB/RUB
(on basis of TVU count) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.8 Overview of land use plans Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.9
Overview of existing pavement
conditions
• Number of Lanes
• Type of Pavement (Flexible/Rigid/Surfaced/Unsurfaced)
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.10 Existing right of way details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.11 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Approach Methodology Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.1 Engineering survey and investigations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.2 Design of road, pavements and structures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.3 Environment and social impact
assessment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.4 Estimation of project cost, viability and
financing options Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.5 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Task Assignment and Manning
Schedule Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Number of key personnel provided Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
237
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
4.2 Specific tasks assigned to each key
personnel Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.3 Manning schedule for key personnel Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.4 Number of key personnel deployed at site Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5 Performa for data collection Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6 Indicative Design standards and cross
sections Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7 Development plans Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Overview of development plans being
implemented/ proposed by local bodies Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.2 Overview of impact of such development
plans Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8 Quality Assurance Plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Engineering surveys and investigation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.2 Traffic surveys Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.3 Material geo-technical and sub-soil
investigations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.4 Road and pavement investigations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.5 Investigation and design of bridges and
structures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.6 Environment and R&R assessment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.7 Economic and financial analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.8 Drawing and documentation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.9 Discussion of draft QAP document with
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
238
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
8.10 Approval of final QAP document by
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.11 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9 Draft design standards Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.1 Geometric design standards of bridges
(Plain) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.2 Geometric design standards of bridges
(Hilly) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.3 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.2 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.3 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.4 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
239
DPR Checklist – Stage 2 – Feasibility Report (Structures)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1 Executive Summary Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Overview of client organization /
activities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Methodology adopted for feasibility
study Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Socioeconomic profile of the project
areas Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Regional economic profile basis last 10
years data as per IRC Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.2 Economic profile of project influence
area basis last 10 years data as per IRC Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.3 Socio Economic status of project
influence area Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5 Indicative design standards,
methodologies, and specifications Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6 Traffic surveys and analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.1 Classified traffic volume counts using
IHMCL data (7 day) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
240
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
6.2 Traffic projection methodology as per
IRC:108 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.3 Projected Traffic data for 20 years Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.4 Current and Projected PCU Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.5 Current and Projected TVU Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.6 Axle load survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.7 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.8 Traffic surveys monitored and reviewed
by the client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7 Reconnaissance survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Road Inventory as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.2 Review of Road Inventory Survey by
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.3
Geometric Features of the Existing Road
• Design Speed
• Sight distance elements
• Horizontal Alignment Details
• Vertical Alignment Details
• Height of Embankment
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.4
Topographical Survey as per IRC:SP:19
using LiDAR or equivalent technology
• Gradient
• Terrain
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.5 Review of topographical survey by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.6 Pavement composition and condition
survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
241
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
7.7
Geological Survey
• Geological Map of the Area
• Seismicity
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.8
Climatic Conditions
• Temperature
• Rainfall
• Wind
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.9
Land Use along the existing alignment
• Map of the Project Area depicting Agricultural/Habitation/Forest Area
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.10
Details of Existing Structures
• Map of the Project Area depicting Hutments/Buildings/Temples/Public Building/Any Other Significant Structure
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.11 Inventory and condition survey of
culverts Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.12 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8 Geotechnical Survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Geo-technical and sub-soil explorations
as per IRC:78 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.2 Number of Bore holes dug (holds for
every pier and abutment) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
8.3 Review of geo-technical and sub-soil
explorations by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.4 Field testing, soil sampling, laboratory
testing as per IRC:78 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.5 Recommendation of Foundation Type
and Depth Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
242
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
8.6 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9 Hydraulic & Hydrological Survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.1 Hydrological investigations as per IRC:5
and IRC: 13 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.2 High Flood Level specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.3 Depth of Water Table specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.4 Ponded Water Level specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.5 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.6 Review of Hydrological Survey by the
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10 Materials Survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Materials Survey conducted as per
IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.2
Sources of Naturally Occurring
Aggregates specified
• Details of Borrow Pits with Distance from Project Site
• Cost of Material/Transportation
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.3
Sources of Manufactured Items specified
• Details of Suppliers with Distance from Project Site
• Cost of Material/Transportation
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.4 Source of Water for construction
specified as per IS:456 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.5 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11 Determination of whether ROB or
RUB is appropriate Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
243
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
11.1 Justification of whether ROB or RUB
should be built Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.2 Review of justification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12 Alignment Options Study Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.1 At least two alignments proposed
• Details of Alignments on Map
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.2 Review of options with client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.3 Length of the project along proposed
alignment options Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.4 Land Acquisition required along
alignment options Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.5 Cost Estimates of alternatives Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.6 Recommended Alignment with
Justification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
12.7 Skew Angle of Proposed Alignment
Specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
12.8 Review and approval of alignment by
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.9 Traffic Diversion Route Specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.10 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13 Environmental screening/ preliminary
environmental assessment Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13.1 Analysis basis Initial Environment
Examination in IRC: SP: 19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
13.2 Recommended feasible mitigation
measures Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
244
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
14 Initial social assessment/ preliminary
LA resettlement plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.1 Analysis basis Initial Environment
Examination in IRC: SP: 19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.2 Details of consultation with potentially
affected persons Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.3 Details of consultation with local NGOs Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.4 Details of consultation with municipal
authorities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.5 Preliminary resettlement plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
14.6 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15 Cost estimates Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.1 Item rates and rate analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
15.2 Escalation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16 Economic and financial analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16.1 Estimated cost details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16.2 Projected revenues details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16.3 Assumptions stated Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16.4
Analysis and results
• IRR
• Sensitivity Analysis
• Financial Viability
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
16.5 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
17 Strip Plan NA
245
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
17.1 Details of center line of proposed
structure Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
17.2 Details of existing RoW Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
17.3 Details of proposed RoW Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
17.4 Details about ownership of land to be
acquired Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
17.5 Strip plan basis reconnaissance and
topographic surveys Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
17.6 Strip plan reviewed and approved by the
client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
17.7 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
18 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
18.1 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
18.2 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
18.3 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
18.4 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
246
DPR Checklist – Stage 3 – LA and Clearances I Report (Structures)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1 Executive Summary Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Environment Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.1 Requirement for environment clearance
identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.2 Date/ Details of Initial consultation with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.3 Date of submission of draft EIA report/
proposal for clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.4 Review of proposal/ EIA report by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Forest Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.1 Requirement for forest clearance
identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.2 Date/ Details of initial consultation with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.3 Details/cost of trees being felled basis
concerned District Forest Office Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.4 Date of submission of proposal for forest
clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
247
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
3.5 Review of proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Wildlife Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Requirement for wildlife clearance
identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.2 Date/ Details of initial consultation with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.3 Details/cost of trees being felled basis
concerned District Forest Office Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.4 Date of submission of proposal for
wildlife clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.5 Review of proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5 Utility Clearances (Electricity) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.1 Identification of overground utilities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.2
Identification of underground utilities
using GPR, Induction Locator or
equivalent technologies
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.3 Name/ Details of consultation with local
authority/ people Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.4
Utility relocation plan with existing /
proposed location showing existing RoW
and topographic details
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.5 Cost for relocation as per authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.6 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.7 Review of utility relocation plan/
proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6 Utility Clearances (Water) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
248
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
6.1 Identification of overground utilities in
RoW Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.2
Identification of underground utilities
using GPR, Induction Locator or
equivalent technologies
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.3 Name/ Details of consultation with local
authority/ people Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.4
Utility relocation plan with existing /
proposed location showing existing RoW
and topographic details
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.5 Cost for relocation as per authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.6 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.7 Review of utility relocation plan/
proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7 Utility Clearances (Others) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Identification of overground utilities in
RoW Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.2
Identification of underground utilities
using GPR, Induction Locator or
equivalent technologies
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.3 Name/ Details of consultation with local
authority/ people Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.4
Utility relocation plan with existing /
proposed location showing existing RoW
and topographic details
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.5 Cost for relocation as per authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.6 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
249
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
7.7 Review of utility relocation plan/
proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8 Railway Clearances Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Identification of ROB/ RUB on project
corridor Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.2 Initial consultation with competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.3 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
8.4 Review of GAD/ proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9 Other Clearances Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.1 Requirement for other clearances
identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.2 Date of proposal submission to
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
9.3 Review of proposal by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10 Land Acquisition Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Detailed schedule about acquisition of
landholdings as per land records Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.2 Consultation with affected persons Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.3 Name/ Details of consultation with
NGOs Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.4 Name/ Details of consultation with
concerned government agencies Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.5 Total land required, land area already
available , land to be acquired identified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
250
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
10.6 Review of land acquisition using digital
cadastral map by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.1 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.2 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.3 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.4 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
251
DPR Checklist – Stage 4 – Detailed Project Report (Structures)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1 Project background Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
1.1
Project description
• Existing LC number
• Start and End Chainage
• Village/District
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
1.2
Project location map
• On State Map
• On District Map
• Latitude & Longitude Coordinates of the LC
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
1.3
Details of Existing Level Crossing
• Number of Railway Tracks
• Type of Railway Tracks (Broad/Meter/Narrow)
• No. of trains per day
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
1.4 Justification for need of an ROB/RUB
(on basis of TVU count) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
1.5 Overview of land use plans Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
252
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1.6
Overview of existing pavement
conditions
• Number of Lanes
• Type of Pavement (Flexible/Rigid/Surfaced/Unsurfaced)
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
1.7 Existing right of way details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
1.8 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Social analysis of the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.1 Project impact on stakeholders such as
local people Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.2 Project impact on residential, commercial
and public properties Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.3 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Reconnaissance survey Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.1
Geometric Features of the Existing Road
• Design Speed
• Sight distance details
• Horizontal Alignment Details
• Vertical Alignment Details
• Height of Embankment
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.2
Topographical Survey using LiDAR or
equivalent technology as per IRC:SP:19
• Gradient
• Terrain
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.3 Pavement composition and condition
survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.4
Geological Survey
• Geological Map of the Area
• Seismicity
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
253
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
3.5
Climatic Conditions
• Temperature
• Rainfall
• Wind
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.6
Land Use along the existing alignment
• Map of the Project Area depicting Agricultural/Habitation/Forest Area
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.7
Details of Existing Structures
• Map of the Project Area depicting Hutments/Buildings/Temples/Public Building/Any Other Significant Structure
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.8 Inventory and condition survey of
culverts Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.9 Geo-technical and sub-soil explorations
as per IRC:78 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.10 Number of Bore holes dug (holds for
every pier and abutment) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.11 Field testing, soil sampling, laboratory
testing as per IRC: 78 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.12 Recommendation of Foundation Type
and Depth Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.13 Hydraulic and Hydrological
investigations as per IRC:5 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.14 High Flood Level specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.15 Depth of Water Table specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.16 Ponded Water Level specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.17 Materials Survey conducted as per
IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
254
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
3.18
Sources of Naturally Occurring
Aggregates specified
• Details of Borrow Pits with Distance from Project Site
• Cost of Material/Transportation
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.19
Sources of Manufactured Items specified
• Details of Suppliers with Distance from Project Site
• Cost of Material/Transportation
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.20 Source of Water for construction
specified as per IS:456 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.21 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Traffic surveys and analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Classified traffic volume counts using
IHMCL data (7 day) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.2 Traffic projection as per IRC:108 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.3 Projected Traffic data for 20 years Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.4 Current and Projected PCU Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.5 Current and Projected TVU Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.6 Axle load survey as per IRC:SP:19 Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.7 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5 Determination of whether ROB or
RUB is appropriate Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5.1 Justification of whether ROB or RUB
should be built Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6 Alignment Options Study Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
255
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
6.1 At least two alignments proposed
• Details of Alignments on Map
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.2 Length of the project along proposed
alignment options Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.3 Land Acquisition required along
alignment options Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.4 Cost Estimates of alternatives Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.5 Recommended Alignment with
Justification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.6 Skew Angle of Proposed Alignment
Specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.7 Traffic Diversion Route Specified Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.8 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7 Design Specifications Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Number of Lanes Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.2
Width of ROB
• Width of Carriageway
• Width of Safety Kerbs
• Width of Footpath
• Any other
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.3
Proposed Number of Lanes on ROB in
line with PCU as per latest MoRTH
guidelines
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.4
Proposed Length of the Project
• Length of ROB
• Length of Viaduct
• Length of RE Wall
• Length of Approach Road
• Length of Service Road
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
256
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
7.5
Span Arrangement
• Span Length
• Number of Spans
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.6
Are all spans of standardised length as
per Railways standards
(https://ircep.gov.in/RCApproval/)
• If non-standardised, suitable justification provided
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.7
Details of Proposed Superstructure
Design
• Type
• Details of Material Use Proposed
• Drawings of Cross-Sections
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.8
Details of Proposed Substructure Design
Type
• Details of Material Use Proposed
• Drawings of Cross-Sections
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.9
Details of Proposed Pavement Design
Type
• Details of Material Use Proposed
• Thickness
• Design MSA
• Drawings of Cross-Sections
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.10 Details of Drainage Structures Proposed Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.11 Any other details relevant to the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8 Cost estimates Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Summary of Cost Estimates (Refer
following subsection) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
8.2 Detailed Abstract of Cost Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.3 Detailed Bills of Quantity Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
257
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
8.4 Detailed Rate Analysis Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9 Financial Viability Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.1 Estimated cost details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.2 Projected revenues details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.3 Assumptions stated Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
9.4
Analysis and results
• IRR
• Sensitivity Analysis
• Financial Viability
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10 Land Acquisition Study Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1
Land Acquisition Details
• Total Land Required
• Land Area already available
• Area of Land to be Acquired
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.2 Land Acquisition Plan on Cadastral Map Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.3 Details of LA Cost Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
11 Utility Shifting Study Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.1 Results of GPR investigation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.2
Utility relocation plan with existing /
proposed location showing existing RoW
and topographic details
Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.3 Cost for relocation as per authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
12 General Arrangement Drawing Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.1 Elevation of Railway Portion Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.2 Plan of Railway Portion Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
258
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
12.3 General Elevation Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.4 General Plan (showing complete
ROB/RUB along with diversion) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.5 Key Plan Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
12.6 Cross-Section of Railway Portion Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
Cost Summary Table
S.No. Particulars Cost Estimate(in '000)
1 Cost of ROB Portion
Foundation
Substructure
Superstructure
Total-ROB Portion
2 Cost of Viaduct
Foundation
Substructure
Superstructure
Total-Viaduct
3 Cost of Approach Road
4 Cost of RE Wall
259
S.No. Particulars Cost Estimate(in '000)
5 Cost of Service Road
6 Miscellaneous Costs
Cost of Subway
Cost of Toll Plaza
Cost of Culverts
Any Other Costs
Civil Cost of the Project
7 Contingencies @x%
Total Civil Cost
8 Supervision Charges @x%
9 Cost of Quality Control @x%
10 Maintenance Charges @x%
11 Escalation Costs @x%
12 Land Acquisition Costs
13 Utility Shifting Costs
14 Any Other Costs
Total Cost of the Project
260
DPR Checklist – Stage 5 – Tchnical Schedules (Structures)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1 Schedule A - Site of the project Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Schedule B - Development of the
project highway Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3 Schedule C - Project facilities Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4 Schedule D - Specifications and
standards Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
5 Any other relevant details Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
261
DPR Checklist – Stage 6 – LA and Clearances II Report (Structures)
General Details
Project Name
Consultant's Name
Date of Review
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
1 Executive Summary Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2 Environment Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
2.1 Details of public hearings completed Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
2.2 Date of final environment clearance by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3 Forest Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
3.1 Date/ Details of Joint site inspection with
DFO/ competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.2 Date of Stage I forest clearance approval
by competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
3.3 Date of final forest clearance approval by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4 Wildlife Clearance Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
4.1 Date/ Details of joint site inspection with
DFO/ competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
4.2 Date of final wildlife clearance approval
by competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5 Utility Clearances (Electricity) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
262
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
5.1 Date/ Details of Joint site inspection with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.2 Date of estimate submission by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
5.3 Date of estimate approval by competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6 Utility Clearances (Water) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
6.1 Date/ Details of Joint site inspection with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.2 Date of estimate submission by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
6.3 Date of estimate approval by competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7 Utility Clearances (Others) Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
7.1 Date/ Details of Joint site inspection with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.2 Date of estimate submission by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
7.3 Date of estimate approval by competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
8 Railway Clearances Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
8.1 Date/ Details of joint site inspection with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
8.2 Date of final approval of GAD by
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
9 Other Clearances Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
263
S.No SECTION OF THE REPORT YES/NO/NA Details/
Specifications Remarks
9.1 Date of final approval by competent
authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10 Land Acquisition Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.1 Draft 3a notification submitted Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.2 Review of 3a notification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.3 Date of 3a gazette notification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.4 Draft 3a notification submitted Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.5 Review of 3A notification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.6 Date of 3A gazette notification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.7 Date of Joint Measurement Survey with
competent authority Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
10.8 Draft 3D notification submitted Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.9 Review of 3D notification by client Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
10.10 Date of 3D gazette notification Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐
11 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.1 Conclusions and recommendations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.2 Report fulfils project objectives and
scope as per RFP Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.3 Report reviewed for errors and omissions Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA
11.4 Compliance report prepared on client
observations Yes ☐ No ☐ NA ☐ NA