BP0/VARDCOUNTY
Finance and Administrative Services Department
PURCHASING DIVISION115 8. Andrews Avenue, Room 212 Fort
Lauderdale, Florida 33301 954-357-6066 FAX 954-357-8535
Certified Mail No. 7006 3450 0003 8479 0868
March 20. 2018
Joseph M. Goldstein, Esq.Shutts & Bowen, LLP200 East Broward
Boulevard, Suite 2100Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301
Re: Protest - Solicitation No. D2114263B1, Elevator and
Escalator Maintenance and Repair,Group 1
Dear Mr. Goldstein:
The Broward County Purchasing Division (the "Purchasing
Division") is in receipt of your protestletter dated November 21,
2017 (the "Protest"), on behalf of your client Thyssenkrupp
ElevatorCorp., contesting the Recommendation for Award ("RFA") for
Solicitation No. D2114263B1,Elevator and Escalator Maintenance and
Repair (the "Solicitation"). The RFA was posted fromNovember 15,
2017 through November 21, 2017. Pursuant to Section 21.118 of the
BrowardCounty Procurement Code, the Protest accompanied by your
filing fee was received in a timelyand proper manner. For purposes
of our response to your protest, the Purchasing Division is
onlyaddressing the timely Protest and not the untimely supplemental
response from ThyssenkruppElevator Corp. submitted on February 21,
2018 at 1:00 p.m.
After carefully reviewing the Protest, Broward County's (the
"County") responses are as follows:
Assertion #1: The County's decision that Eastern Elevator can
perform the contract at itsunrealistically low prices lacks a
rational basis....of counter-evidence.
Response #1: The Solicitation contained all general terms and
conditions, special instructions,specifications, and requirements
to meet the County's needs for elevator and escalatormaintenance
and repair services. The Solicitation identified the required
services for Group 1and Group 2, and the Solicitation's General
Conditions states, "[A]s the best interest of the Countymay
require, the right is reserved to make award(s) by individual
commodities/services, group ofcommodities/services, all or none or
any combination thereof (see Solicitation, page 84, #10).On August
9, 2017, the Solicitation opened and all bids were reviewed
thereafter based upon allrequirements within the Solicitation. The
County found Eastern Elevator Service, Inc. ("Eastern")to be the
lowest responsive, responsible bidder for Group 1. Upon initial
review of the RFA,County's Facilities Management Division's ("FMD")
expressed concern about Eastern's ability toperform its services at
the offered bid prices and subsequently provided a
non-concurrencememorandum as to the RFA. As a follow-up, the
Purchasing Division conducted further duediligence by performing a
price analysis on several of Eastern's references to determine
whethertheir labor rates for governmental entities were comparable
to Eastern's bid for the Solicitation(Exhibit 1). Our price
analysis reveals that Eastern's bid submission is within their
price rangestructure offered to Lee County Schools, Hillsborough
County, and more recently Miami-DadeCounty. Eastern's bid prices
for the Solicitation fall between Lee County, which has lower
prices,and Hillsborough and Miami-Dade counties, which have higher
prices. Furthermore, Eastern'slabor rates for Broward County are
higher than the established local union rates (see Exhibit 1).
BrowarcySojMark D. Bogen Beam Furr Steve Geller DaJ^|
af County CommissionersRich Tim Ryan Barbara Sharief Michael
Udine
iro'rg
Exhibit 6 Page 1 of 16
Exhibit 6 Page 2 of 16
Exhibit 6 Page 3 of 16
Exhibit 6 Page 4 of 16
Bid
No.
D21
1426
3B1
(Gro
up 1
)Ea
ster
n El
evat
or S
ervi
ce, I
nc. (
EESI
)A
genc
y: F
acilit
ies
Man
agem
ent D
ivis
ion
(FM
D)
Pur
chas
ing
Age
nt:
Ran
dy P
lunk
ett
Item
#D
escr
iptio
nU
nit
Uni
t Pric
e* A
gree
men
t U
nit P
rice
Diff
eren
ce
from
EES
IC
ontr
act U
nit
Pric
eD
iffer
ence
fr
om E
ESI
Con
trac
t Uni
t Pr
ice
Adj
uste
d U
nit
Pric
e fo
r CPI
7.
34%
in
crea
se)
Diff
eren
ce
from
EES
IC
ontr
act U
nit
Pric
e
Adj
uste
d U
nit
Pric
e fo
r CPI
2.
74%
in
crea
se)
Diff
eren
ce fr
om
EESI
D21
1426
3B1-
01-1
01La
bor:
Mec
hani
c R
eg. H
rs.
Hou
r$9
8.00
$76.
00-$
22.0
0$1
86.0
0$8
8.00
$78.
00$8
3.73
-$14
.27
$168
.00
$172
.60
$74.
60
D21
1426
3B1-
01-1
02La
bor:
Mec
hani
c O
verti
me.
Hrs
.H
our
$168
.00
$286
.00
$118
.00
$98.
00$1
05.1
9-$
62.8
1$1
98.0
0$2
03.4
3$3
5.43
D21
1426
3B1-
01-1
03La
bor:
Hel
per R
eg. H
rs.
Hou
r$6
8.00
$67.
46-$
0.54
$148
.00
$80.
00$7
8.00
$83.
73$1
5.73
$168
.00
$172
.60
$104
.60
D21
1426
3B1-
01-1
04La
bor:
Hel
per O
verti
me.
Hrs
.H
our
$98.
00$1
68.0
0$7
0.00
$98.
00$1
05.1
9$7
.19
$198
.00
$203
.43
$105
.43
D21
1426
3B1-
01-1
05La
bor:
Hur
rican
e S
tand
by
Mec
hani
cH
our
$168
.00
$286
.00
$118
.00
Uni
on R
ates
for L
ocal
71
NEB
A 2
018
Agr
eem
ent w
ith
IUEC
*Uni
on ra
tes
do n
ot
incl
ude
any
vend
or
over
head
and
pro
fit
N
EB
A -
Nat
iona
l Ele
vato
r Bar
gain
ing
Ass
ocia
tion
IU
EC
- In
tern
atio
nal U
nion
of E
leva
tor C
onst
ruct
ors
East
ern
Elev
ator
Ser
vice
, Inc
. (EE
SI),
Lee
Cou
nty
Scho
ols
Con
trac
t N14
7160
JCB
id O
pene
d 11
/'14
East
ern
Elev
ator
Ser
vice
, Inc
. (EE
SI),
Hill
sbor
ough
Cou
nty
Con
trac
t 694
1B
id O
pene
d 6/
'16
PRIC
E AN
ALYS
IS -
LAB
OR
ON
LY
East
ern
Elev
ator
Ser
vice
, In
c. (E
ESI),
Mia
mi-D
ade
Cou
nty
Con
trac
t E99
46-0
/18
Bid
Ope
ned
12/'1
7
Eas
tern
Ele
vato
r Ser
vice
, Inc
. (EE
SI),
Solic
itatio
n N
o. D
2114
263B
1 (G
roup
1)
Bid
Ope
ned
8/'1
7
B
id L
ine
Item
s 01
-01
thro
ugh
01-1
00 n
ot c
ompa
rabl
e to
oth
er c
onta
cts
due
to
equi
pmen
t typ
es a
nd s
ervi
ce c
ondi
tion.
C
PI A
dj.:
Pric
e A
djus
tmen
t to
Aug
. 201
7 pr
ices
for C
PI-W
incr
ease
s in
the
Mia
mi-F
t. La
uder
dale
are
a fo
r Ser
vice
s le
ss M
edic
al C
are
Ser
vice
s
G
rey
shad
ing
indi
cate
s fie
ld d
oes
not a
pply
.
Exhibit 6 Page 5 of 16
A to Z Index | FAQs | About BLS | Contact Us Subscribe to E-mail
Updates
Follow Us | What's New | Release Calendar | Blog
Search BLS.gov
Databases, Tables & Calculators by Subject FONT SIZE:SHARE
ON: Change Output Options: From: 2008 To: 2017
include graphs include annual averages
Data extracted on: January 23, 2018 (5:40:03 PM)
CPI-Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (Current Series)
Series Id: CWURA320SASL5,CWUSA320SASL5Not Seasonally
AdjustedSeries Title: Services less medical care services in
Miami-Fort Lauderdale, FL, urban wage earners and clerical workers,
not seasonally adjustedArea: Miami-Fort Lauderdale, FLItem:
Services less medical care servicesBase Period: 1982-84=100
Download:
Year Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Annual
HALF1 HALF22008 232.138 233.362 235.374 236.801 238.086 238.604
235.376 233.191 237.5612009 240.117 239.370 237.651 237.675 239.100
239.449 238.858 239.125 238.5912010 236.780 237.024 237.517 237.667
237.526 239.335 237.646 237.267 238.0242011 240.651 241.494 240.192
241.888 242.589 243.926 241.598 240.707 242.4902012 244.391 245.817
246.117 248.355 249.533 249.533 247.057 245.259 248.8552013 250.676
251.476 251.496 250.080 252.278 254.070 251.490 251.052 251.9272014
257.041 257.910 258.394 258.860 261.188 263.339 259.068 257.421
260.7162015 265.211 266.891 266.565 267.731 269.955 272.035 267.570
265.840 269.3002016 273.107 274.343 275.132 275.964 277.954 279.786
275.653 273.744 277.5622017 284.694 280.068 281.118 282.662 284.430
285.156 282.923 282.094 283.752
RECOMMEND THIS PAGE USING: Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
Freedom of Information Act | Privacy & Security Statement |
Disclaimers | Customer Survey | Important Web Site Notices
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics | Postal Square Building, 2
Massachusetts Avenue, NE Washington, DC 20212-0001www.bls.gov |
Telephone: 1-202-691-5200 | TDD: 1-800-877-8339 | Contact Us
TOOLSAreas at a Glance Industries at a Glance Economic
ReleasesDatabases & TablesMaps
CALCULATORSInflationInjury And Illness
HELPHelp & TutorialsFAQsGlossaryAbout BLSContact Us
INFOWhat's NewCareers @ BLSFind It! DOLJoin our Mailing
ListsLinking & Copyright Info
RESOURCESInspector General (OIG)Budget and PerformanceNo Fear
ActUSA.govBenefits.gov Disability.gov
Home Subjects Data Tools Publications Economic Releases Students
Beta
Bureau of Labor Statistics Data
1/23/2018https://data.bls.gov/pdq/SurveyOutputServlet
Exhibit 6 Page 6 of 16
dykennedyTypewritten TextJune 2016 CPI-W % = ([282.662 -
275.132] / 275.132) x 100 = 2.74% IncreaseNov 2014 CPI-W % =
([282.662 - 263.339] / 263.339) x 100 = 7.34% Increase
rplunkettHighlight
rplunkettHighlight
rplunkettHighlight
rplunkettHighlight
1
Subject: FW: Request for Elevator Price Review - due COB
2/6/18
From:Leder,BruceSent:Tuesday,February06,201812:25PMTo:Swanson,RobinSubject:RE:RE:RequestforElevatorPriceReviewdueCOB2/6/18
Robin,AfterreviewingtheattachmentsthatyousentandwithoutknowingtheconditionofthevarioustypesofequipmentintheotherMunicipalities,IfindthatthepricingthatEasternElevatorsprovidedtoustobeFair,ReasonableandconsistentwiththepricingtheyprovidedtootherMunicipalities.Ialsofindthelaborratestobefairandreasonableaswell.
Ihopethishelpsbut,itishardtodoadetailedanalyseswithoutseeingtheconditionoftheotherequipmenttheyhavebidonbutoveralltheyseemtobewithintheindustrystandard.
Regards,
Bruce Leder Elevator Systems Specialist Public Works Dept.
Facilities Management Division 201 S.E 6 Street, Fort Lauderdale,
FL 33301 Office - (954) - 831- 6583, Cell - (954) - 309 - 6138, Fax
- (954) - 831-8555 [email protected]
From:Swanson,RobinSent:Tuesday,February06,201811:01AMTo:Leder,BruceSubject:RE:RequestforElevatorPriceReviewdueCOB2/6/18
HiBruce,
Asafollowuptoourmeetingyesterday,pleasefindattachedthematerialstoassistwiththeEasternPricereview.PleaselookatthepricingthatEasterngavetoothermunicipalitiesandcomparetheirpricingtowhatwasprovidedtoBrowardCountyanddetermineifthepricingwasfairandreasonablebasedonwhatthecontractsneeded.PleasegetbacktouswithyourfeedbackbyCOBtodayorsoonergiventheurgencyofthisproject.
Attachment#1PriceComparisonSpreadsheetTab1includescomparisonoflaborrates,followingtabssummarizemonthlypreventivemaintenancecosts
ContractDetailincludedetailsonunitstocomparepreventivemaintenancepricestoseeequipmentdetail:
CityofFortLauderdale37311883Attachment#2seepage13forequipmentdetail
CityofFortLauderdale56311717Attachment#3seepage11forequipmentdetail
Exhibit 6 Page 7 of 16
2
SchoolDistrictofLeeCountyN147160JCAttachment#4seepage22forequipmentdetail
HillsboroughCounty6941Attachment#5seepage4forequipmentdetail
Regards,RobinSwanson,Contracts/GrantsAdministratorFacilitiesManagementDivisionContractsSectionBrowardCountyPublicWorksDepartment115SouthAndrewsAvenue,Room501,FortLauderdale,FL33301Office:9543576486,Fax:9543575544Email:[email protected]
Exhibit 6 Page 8 of 16
COUNTY CONTACT INFORMATION
Contract Administrator
Overseeing Division
Scott Campbell
FACILITIES MANAGEMENT
Email: [email protected]
EVALUATION SUMMARY
Numerical Score
Overall Rating
Unsatisfactory (1.0 - 1.8) | Poor (1.81 - 2.59) | Fair (2.60 -
3.19) | Good (3.20 - 4.49) | Excellent (4.50 - 5.00)
EASTERN ELEVATOR SERVICE INC Is RECOMMENDED For Future Contracts
Remarks: Evaluation is for Group 2 - Non-Critical Units only
EXCELLENT
4.50
APPROVED EVALUATION
Reviewed By
Scott Campbell, Facilities Management Division Director
Date: 2/6/2018
Rated By
Bruce Leder, Elevator Systems Specialist
Date: 2/5/2018
OPEN END CONTRACT - SERVICES
Agreement Nbr / TitleD2114263B1 / Elevator & Escalator
Maintenance & Repair (Critical/Non-Critical)
Not To Exceed Amount
$111,920.00
Used Amount
$49,618.00
2/6/2018D2114263B1 - Status: Approved Rated By: Bruce Leder,
Elevator Systems Specialist On: 2/5/2018 Reviewed By: Scott
Campbell, Facilities Management Division Director On: 2/6/2018
ID: 7298
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA
PERIODIC SERVICE EVALUATION
OF PRIME VENDOR - EASTERN ELEVATOR SERVICE INCRATING PERIOD FROM
11/7/2017 TO 2/5/2018
Exhibit 6 Page 9 of 16
4 - Good1. How well did the vendor's services meet the contract
specifications?
5 - Excellent2. How accurate and timely were any necessary
repairs or reconfigurations?
5 - Excellent3. How appropriate were vendor recommended repairs
or upgrades?
4 - Good4. How accurate were vendor reports of services
provided?
4 - Good5. How proactive was vendor in self-monitoring to ensure
required service quality was met?
5 - Excellent6. How well did vendor pass inspections of services
on the first inspection?
N/A7. How complete and timely did the vendor submit warranties,
manuals, etc.?
5 - Excellent8. How qualified and knowledgeable were the
vendor's staff in the performance of the specified work?
4 - Good9. How would you rate the overall quality of work?
RatingEvaluation Question
A) Quality Section Score: 4.50
Comments:
4 - Good1. How accurate were the estimated service hours to the
actual hours of service provided?
4 - Good2. How accurate were estimated services to those
actually needed to complete the project?
RatingEvaluation Question
B) Quantity Section Score: 4.00
Comments:
4 - Good1. How well did the vendor comply with the contract
requirements for delivery and/or scheduling for completion of
services?
5 - Excellent2. How timely was the vendor's response to
replacing damaged goods?
N/A3. How timely was the vendor in requesting inspections or
submittal of completion reports?
N/A4. How responsive was the vendor to correcting inspection
failures?
5 - Excellent5. How clear and understandable were vendor
invoices and reports?
5 - Excellent6. How accurate were vendor invoices?
5 - Excellent7. How prompt and responsive was the vendor when
sending invoices and resolving any invoice discrepancies?
4 - Good8. How complete and accurate was documentation of pass
thrus for invoices?
4 - Good9. How accurate were close out procedures followed (e.g.
documents provided at closeout - packing slips, invoices, technical
manuals, etc.) ?
RatingEvaluation Question
C) Delivery Section Score: 4.57
Comments:
2/6/2018D2114263B1 - Status: Approved Rated By: Bruce Leder,
Elevator Systems Specialist On: 2/5/2018 Reviewed By: Scott
Campbell, Facilities Management Division Director On: 2/6/2018
ID: 7298
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA
PERIODIC SERVICE EVALUATION
OF PRIME VENDOR - EASTERN ELEVATOR SERVICE INCRATING PERIOD FROM
11/7/2017 TO 2/5/2018
Exhibit 6 Page 10 of 16
5 - Excellent1. How promptly were County staff's communications
responded to, including requests for information, proposals, and
quotes?
5 - Excellent2. How proactive was the vendor in addressing
County staff's problems or concerns regarding the service?
5 - Excellent3. How courteous/professional was the vendor in
working with the County, sub-vendors, County tenants/customers?
4 - Good4. How sensitive/responsive was the vendor to working
around County operationaal needs?
4 - Good5. How consistent and clear were the vendor
communications with County staff?
5 - Excellent6. How responsive and timely was the vendor in
providing emergency services and/or support?
RatingEvaluation Question
D) Customer Service Section Score: 4.67
Comments:
4 - Good1. How close was the level of vendor technical expertise
to what was needed to support the service?
5 - Excellent2. How timely was the vendor response compared to
the contract requirements?
N/A3. How clear was the vendor information regarding the
warranty or replacement policy?
N/A4. How well did the vendor respond to warranty service
requests?
N/A5. How timely were repairs completed?
N/A6. How well did the vendor coordinate any sub vendors?
RatingEvaluation Question
E) Support Section Score: 4.50
Comments:
4 - Good1. How prominent was the Living Wage rate provision
poster displayed in workplace?
N/A2. How timely was the vendor in providing the three language
statement with each covered employee in the first paycheck or
direct deposit slip and every six months thereafter in accordance
with the Living Wage Ordiance?
N/A3. How timely and complete were the required compliance
payroll reports submitted?
N/A4. How proactive was the vendor in ensuring Living Wage
compliance, including inserting into subcontracts, by any
subcontractor with the Living Wage Ordiance as it applies to the
subcontract?
N/A5. If applicable, how cooperative was the vendor in
responding to and resolving any employee complaints regarding
alleged violations of Living Wage contract requirements?
RatingEvaluation Question
G) Living Wage Compliance Section Score: 4.00
Comments:
2/6/2018D2114263B1 - Status: Approved Rated By: Bruce Leder,
Elevator Systems Specialist On: 2/5/2018 Reviewed By: Scott
Campbell, Facilities Management Division Director On: 2/6/2018
ID: 7298
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA
PERIODIC SERVICE EVALUATION
OF PRIME VENDOR - EASTERN ELEVATOR SERVICE INCRATING PERIOD FROM
11/7/2017 TO 2/5/2018
Exhibit 6 Page 11 of 16
From: Robert RauchTo: Plunkett, RandallSubject: RE: Broward
County Request for Price Offer Confirmation; re: Solicitation
No.D2114263B1, Elevator and Escalator Maintenance and RepairDate:
Monday, October 09, 2017 1:24:38 PMAttachments: image002.png
image003.png
Yes, all pricing remains firm
Thank You,
Robert Rauch
On October 9, 2017 1:19:49 PM "Plunkett, Randall" wrote:
Mr. Rauch,Thank you and based upon your response, as a point of
clarity, all pricing remains firm as submitted in your bid. Please
confirm via emailand I look forward to your response. Regards,
Randy Plunkett, Purchasing AgentPurchasing Division-Unit M115 S.
Andrews Avenue, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301Office: (954) 357-6630;
Cell (954) 790-3239Fax: (954) 357-8290www.broward.org Customer Care
is my priority. How am I doing? Please contact my Manager, Carla
Byrd, at [email protected] with feedback. Broward County provides
electronic bidding services for our vendors through BidSync. Please
register your company with BidSync in order toparticipate in future
bidding opportunities, the free registration process will take less
than five minutes. If you are already registered with BidSync, log
into BidSync to update your vendor profile to include Broward
County as one of your agencies for solicitation notification.
From: Robert Rauch [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday,
October 09, 2017 12:57 PMTo: Plunkett, Randall Subject: RE: Broward
County Request for Price Offer Confirmation; re: Solicitation
No.D2114263B1, Elevator and Escalator Maintenance andRepair
Hello Randy. Yes we have reviewed the specifications of the bid
and have reviewed the equipment.
Thank You,
Robert RauchEastern Elevator Service.
On October 9, 2017 11:20:51 AM "Plunkett, Randall" wrote:
Mr. Rauch,In review of the prices bid, as the offered prices
appear considerably lower than the other bidders and lower than the
currentprices paid on the existing contract, please confirm that
your firm has understood the specifications and requirements of the
bidsolicitation and have reviewed the sites to be maintained. With
this understanding, you maintain that your firm can provided
therequired services at the prices bid. Your response is required
no later than 2:00 p.m. on Monday, 10/09. Your immediateattention
will be greatly appreciated.Respectfully,
Randy Plunkett, Purchasing AgentPurchasing Division-Unit M115 S.
Andrews Avenue, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301Office: (954) 357-6630;
Cell (954) 790-3239Fax: (954) 357-8290www.broward.org Customer Care
is my priority. How am I doing? Please contact my Manager, Carla
Byrd, at [email protected] with feedback. Broward County provides
electronic bidding services for our vendors through BidSync. Please
register your company with BidSync in order toparticipate in future
bidding opportunities, the free registration process will take less
than five minutes. If you are already registered withBidSync, log
in to BidSync to update your vendor profile to include Broward
County as one of your agencies for solicitation notification.
Exhibit 6 Page 12 of 16
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.broward.org/mailto:[email protected]://www.bidsync.com/bidsync-cas/login?service=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bidsync.com%2FDPXLoginmailto:[email protected]://www.broward.org/mailto:[email protected]://www.bidsync.com/bidsync-cas/login?service=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bidsync.com%2FDPXLogin
rplunkettHighlight
rplunkettHighlight
Bid
#D
2114
263B
1El
evat
or a
nd E
scal
ator
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air (
Re-
Bid
)O
pene
d:8/
9/17
Agen
cy: F
acilit
ies
Mai
nten
ance
Div
isio
nR
espo
nses
:4
Purc
hasi
ng A
gent
: R
andy
Plu
nket
tD
eclin
atio
ns:
0
Aw
arde
d by
the
Purc
hasi
ng M
anag
er b
y D
eleg
ated
Aut
horit
y of
the
Dire
ctor
of P
urch
asin
g on
Oct
ober
20,
2017
SUM
MA
RY
Eas
tern
Ele
vato
r Ser
vice
Inc.
X
pert
Ele
vato
r Ser
vice
s In
c.
Ora
cle
Elev
ator
T
hyss
enkr
upp
Elev
ator
T
hyss
enkr
upp
Elev
ator
(A
ltern
ate)
211
1 N
. Com
mer
ce P
kwy
644
7 M
iam
i Lak
es D
r.,
Ste.
103
-D
231
5 St
irlin
g R
d.
280
1 SW
15t
h St
.
Wes
ton,
FL
3332
6 M
iam
i Lak
es, F
L F
t. La
uder
dale
, FL
3331
2 P
ompa
no B
each
, FL
3306
9 Ite
m
No.
Com
mod
ity C
ode(
s) 9
1371
Des
crip
tion
Tota
l Pric
eTo
tal P
rice
Tota
l Pric
eTo
tal P
rice
Tota
l Pric
e
Gro
up 2
$
10
1,92
0.00
$
13
7,97
0.00
$
595
,315
.00
$
899
,254
.00
$
2
43,3
60.0
0
$
1
0,00
0.00
$
1
0,00
0.00
$
10
,000
.00
$
1
0,00
0.00
Tota
l Gro
up 2
:11
1,92
0.00
$
14
7,97
0.00
$
605,
315.
00$
90
9,25
4.00
$
24
3,36
0.00
$
A
WD
AW
D -
Rec
omm
enda
tion
for A
war
d
Mis
cella
neou
s Pa
rts a
nd M
ater
ials
on
"pas
s-th
ru"
BID
TA
BU
LATI
ON
Tabu
latio
n of
Bid
s
Exhibit 6 Page 13 of 16
BID
TABU
LATI
ON
Bid
#D21
1426
3B1
Elev
ator
and
Esc
alat
or M
aint
enan
ce a
nd R
epai
r (Re
-Bid
)Lo
t: Gr
oup
2
Item
#Ite
mQ
tyU
nit
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
D211
4263
B1--0
2-01
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
WRC
H El
evat
or N
o.
0532
924
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$110
.00
$2,6
40.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-02
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
WRC
H El
evat
or N
o.
4569
724
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-03
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
NRC
H El
evat
or N
o.
4449
424
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-04
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
SW R
egio
nal L
ibra
ry
Elev
ator
No.
576
3124
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$110
.00
$2,6
40.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-05
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
SW R
egio
nal L
ibra
ry
Elev
ator
No.
576
3224
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-06
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Wes
ton
Libr
ary
Elev
ator
N
o. 0
5-00
033
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
40.0
0$3
,360
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-07
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Pom
pano
Bea
ch L
ibra
ry
Elev
ator
No.
250
1824
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-08
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Impe
rial P
oint
Lib
rary
El
evat
or N
o. 4
0555
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
10.0
0$2
,640
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-09
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
NW
Reg
iona
l Lib
rary
El
evat
or N
o. 5
8984
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
10.0
0$2
,640
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-10
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
NW
Reg
iona
l Lib
rary
El
evat
or N
o. 5
8985
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
40.0
0$3
,360
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-11
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
AAR
Libr
ary
Elev
ator
No.
10
8857
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$3
25.0
0$7
,800
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-12
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
AAR
Libr
ary
Elev
ator
No.
10
8858
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
10.0
0$2
,640
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-13
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Wes
t Reg
iona
l Lib
rary
El
evat
or N
o. 0
6-00
089
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
10.0
0$2
,640
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-14
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Wes
t Reg
iona
l Lib
rary
El
evat
or N
o. 0
6-00
090
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
40.0
0$3
,360
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-15
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Wes
t Reg
iona
l Lib
rary
Ga
rage
Ele
vato
r No.
06-
0009
124
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-16
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mar
gate
Lib
rary
W
heel
chai
r Lift
No.
409
362
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$6
0.00
$1,4
40.0
0$1
50.0
0$3
,600
.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
thys
senk
rupp
Ele
vato
r (a
ltern
ate)
Xper
t Ele
vato
r Se
rvic
es In
cEa
ster
n El
evat
or
Serv
ice
Inc.
thys
senk
rupp
Ele
vato
rO
racl
e El
evat
or
Exhibit 6 Page 14 of 16
BID
TABU
LATI
ON
Bid
#D21
1426
3B1
Elev
ator
and
Esc
alat
or M
aint
enan
ce a
nd R
epai
r (Re
-Bid
)Lo
t: Gr
oup
2
Item
#Ite
mQ
tyU
nit
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
thys
senk
rupp
Ele
vato
r (a
ltern
ate)
Xper
t Ele
vato
r Se
rvic
es In
cEa
ster
n El
evat
or
Serv
ice
Inc.
thys
senk
rupp
Ele
vato
rO
racl
e El
evat
or
D211
4263
B1--0
2-17
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mira
mar
Lib
rary
El
evat
or N
o. 0
7-00
412
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$3
25.0
0$7
,800
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-18
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mira
mar
Lib
rary
El
evat
or N
o. 0
7-00
413
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
10.0
0$2
,640
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-19
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Cent
ral H
omel
ess
Shel
ter E
leva
tor N
o. 5
4955
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
40.0
0$3
,360
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-20
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Fern
For
est P
ark
Elev
ator
No.
338
1824
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$110
.00
$2,6
40.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-21
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Anne
Kol
b N
atur
e Ct
r. El
evat
or N
o. 4
9866
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
40.0
0$3
,360
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-22
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Cent
ral B
row
ard
Regi
onal
Par
k El
evat
or N
o. 0
7-00
307
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
40.0
0$3
,360
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-23
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
WW
S O
pera
tions
Ctr
. El
evat
or N
o. 4
4216
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
10.0
0$2
,640
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-24
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
WW
S Ad
min
. Bld
g.
Elev
ator
No.
442
0724
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$110
.00
$2,6
40.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-25
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
WW
S Di
st. 2
Wat
er
Supp
ly E
leva
tor N
o. 2
0676
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$1
40.0
0$3
,360
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-26
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mas
s Tra
nsit
Adm
in.
Bldg
. Ele
vato
r No.
339
9024
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$110
.00
$2,6
40.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-27
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mas
s Tra
nsit
Mai
nt.
Bldg
. Ele
vato
r No.
339
9224
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-28
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mas
s Tra
nsit
Ops
. Bld
g.
Elev
ator
No.
339
9124
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-29
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mas
s Tra
nsit
Mai
nt.
Bldg
. Ele
vato
r No.
340
3624
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$110
.00
$2,6
40.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-30
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mas
s Tra
nsit
Bldg
. 6
Elev
ator
No.
05-
0043
324
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-31
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Traf
fic E
ngin
eerin
g El
evat
or N
o. 4
0114
324
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-32
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Traf
fic E
ngin
eerin
g El
evat
or N
o. 4
0114
424
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
Exhibit 6 Page 15 of 16
BID
TABU
LATI
ON
Bid
#D21
1426
3B1
Elev
ator
and
Esc
alat
or M
aint
enan
ce a
nd R
epai
r (Re
-Bid
)Lo
t: Gr
oup
2
Item
#Ite
mQ
tyU
nit
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
Pric
eTo
tal
thys
senk
rupp
Ele
vato
r (a
ltern
ate)
Xper
t Ele
vato
r Se
rvic
es In
cEa
ster
n El
evat
or
Serv
ice
Inc.
thys
senk
rupp
Ele
vato
rO
racl
e El
evat
or
D211
4263
B1--0
2-33
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mill
s Cen
ter E
leva
tor
No.
09-
0021
824
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$110
.00
$2,6
40.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-34
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mill
s Cen
ter E
leva
tor
No.
09-
0021
924
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-35
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mill
s Cen
ter E
leva
tor
No.
09-
0022
024
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-36
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Mill
s Cen
ter E
leva
tor
No.
09-
0022
124
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$140
.00
$3,3
60.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-37
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Hist
oric
al C
omm
issio
n El
evat
or N
o. 0
8-00
250
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$3
25.0
0$7
,800
.00
$640
.00
$15,
360.
00$9
42.0
0$2
2,60
8.00
$260
.00
$6,2
40.0
0
D211
4263
B1--0
2-38
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Carp
ente
r Hou
se
Whe
elch
air L
ift N
o. 1
0-00
082
24m
onth
$100
.00
$2,4
00.0
0$6
0.00
$1,4
40.0
0$1
50.0
0$3
,600
.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-39
Mai
nten
ance
and
Rep
air-
Hous
ing
Fina
nce
Auth
ority
Ele
vato
r No.
425
0224
mon
th$1
00.0
0$2
,400
.00
$110
.00
$2,6
40.0
0$6
40.0
0$1
5,36
0.00
$942
.00
$22,
608.
00$2
60.0
0$6
,240
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-40
Labo
r Rat
e M
echa
nic
(Reg
ular
Hou
rs)
40ho
ur$9
8.00
$3,9
20.0
0$9
1.00
$3,6
40.0
0$2
26.0
0$9
,040
.00
$175
.50
$7,0
20.0
0D2
1142
63B1
--02-
41La
bor R
ate
Help
er (R
egul
ar H
ours
)30
hour
$68.
00$2
,040
.00
$50.
00$1
,500
.00
$189
.00
$5,6
70.0
0$1
40.4
0$4
,212
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-42
Labo
r Rat
e M
echa
nic
(Oth
er H
ours
)10
hour
$138
.00
$1,3
80.0
0$1
54.0
0$1
,540
.00
$339
.00
$3,3
90.0
0$3
51.0
0$3
,510
.00
D211
4263
B1--0
2-43
Labo
r Rat
e He
lper
(Oth
er H
ours
)10
hour
$98.
00$9
80.0
0$8
5.00
$850
.00
$169
.50
$1,6
95.0
0$2
80.0
0$2
,800
.00
SUBT
OTA
L (G
roup
2)
$101
,920
.00
$137
,970
.00
$595
,315
.00
$899
,254
.00
$243
,360
.00
Misc
ella
neou
s Par
ts a
nd M
ater
ials
on "p
ass-
thru
"AL
$10,
000.
00$1
0,00
0.00
$10,
000.
00$1
0,00
0.00
TOTA
L (G
roup
2)
$111
,920
.00
$147
,970
.00
$605
,315
.00
$909
,254
.00
AWD
Exhibit 6 Page 16 of 16
Exh1-Price Analysis, D2114263B1 - Labor Only (Grp 1).pdfPrice
Analysis - Labor Only
Exh5-Group 2 Tabulation, D2114263B1.pdfSummaryGroup 2
