17
ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid III, Michael Bottlang Source :BED-Vol. 50, 2001 Bioengineering Conference ASME 2001 Speaker : Ren-LI Shen Advisor : Ku-Yaw Chang 1

ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Introduction Cartilage thickness and volume ◦ characterize normal joints ◦ delineate joint degenerative disease Compute cartilage thickness and volume from high-resolution joint geometry scans ◦ three distinct algorithms 3

Citation preview

Page 1: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS:SURFACE SCANS:COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODSCOMPUTATIONAL METHODS

Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid III, Michael BottlangSource :BED-Vol. 50, 2001 Bioengineering Conference

ASME 2001Speaker : Ren-LI ShenAdvisor : Ku-Yaw Chang

1

Page 2: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

OutlineOutlineIntroductionMaterials and methodsResultDiscussion

2

Page 3: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

IntroductionIntroductionCartilage thickness and volume

◦characterize normal joints◦delineate joint degenerative disease

Compute cartilage thickness and volume from high-resolution joint geometry scans◦three distinct algorithms

3

Page 4: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

OutlineOutlineIntroductionMaterials and methodsResultDiscussion

4

Page 5: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

Materials and methodsMaterials and methodsJoint of a human cadaveric talus

◦obtained a laser displacement sensor◦scanning of a 31-mm x 34-mm

region of interest◦over 40,000 digitized surface points

Talar joint surface ◦intact articular cartilage (Atc)◦subchondral bone surface (Atb)

5

Page 6: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

Materials and methodsMaterials and methods

6

Page 7: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

Materials and methodsMaterials and methodsUse PV-Wave to compute cartilage

thickness from Atc and Atb in three distinct approaches◦a) vertical distance◦b) proximity method◦c) normal distance

7

Page 8: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

Materials and methodsMaterials and methodsIn addition to quantifying variances

◦closest approximation of the true cartilage thickness utilized a cylindrical object with two specific

radii 25.52-mm on one side 27.46-mm on the other

8

Page 9: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

Materials and methodsMaterials and methods

9

Page 10: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

Materials and methodsMaterials and methodsDefined thickness T=1.94-mm

◦idealized constant cartilage thickness distribution

10

Page 11: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

OutlineOutlineIntroductionMaterials and methodsResultDiscussion

11

Page 12: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

ResultResult

12

Cartilage thickness variances◦depicted as a grey-scale image

Page 13: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

ResultResult

13

Page 14: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

ResultResult

14

Page 15: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

OutlineOutlineIntroductionMaterials and methodsResultDiscussion

15

Page 16: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

DiscussionDiscussionThe other two methods

◦based on magnetic resonance imaging

◦based on stereophotogrammetry

16

Page 17: ESTIMATION OF CARTILAGE THICKNESS FROM JOINT SURFACE SCANS: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS Author :Frank Heuer, Mark Sommers, John B. Reid

EndEnd

17