Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
APR1400 HFE
Resolution Summary of Acceptance Review Results Introduction
Tier 1 Schedule for Submittals
HFE Program Status Document Review Summary
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
2 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
Resolution Summary of Acceptance Review TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
3 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
Resolution Summary of Acceptance Review
TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
4 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
Resolution Summary of Acceptance Review
TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
5 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
TS
Resolution Summary (15th PARM - HFE)
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
6 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
Resolution Summary (14th PARM - HFE) TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
7 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
Resolution Summary (14th PARM - HFE) TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
8 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
Resolution Summary (14th PARM - HFE) TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
9 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
Resolution Summary (14th PARM - HFE) TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
10 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
ITAAC for six elements of the HFE program
OER FRA & FA TA S&Q TIHA HSI Design
Introduction: Tier 1
Design Commitment
Inspection, Test and Analysis
Acceptance Criteria
Operating experience review identifies past human factors issues
An inspection will verify the operating experience review was conducted in accordance with the Operating Experience Review Implementation Plan.
A report exists and concludes that the operating experience review was conducted in accordance with the Operating Experience Review Implementation Plan.
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
11 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
ITAAC for two elements of the HFE program V&V Design Implementation
Introduction: Tier 1- continued
Design Commitment Inspections, Tests and Analyses Acceptance Criteria
V&V
The Control Room design incorporates human factors engineering principles that minimize the potential for operator error.
An integrated System Validation Test (ISV) will be performed in accordance with the Verification and Validation Implementation Plan.
All pass/fail criteria associated with each test scenario are passed either on initial performance of the scenarios or following remediation of failures.
Design Implementation
The as-built Control Room Human-System Interface is consistent with the final validated design specifications.
An inspection of the as-built Control Room Human-System Interfaces will be performed.
The as-built Control Room Human-System Interface conforms to the validated design with no configuration deviations.
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
12 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IPs and TeRs All documents will be submitted with the DCD, December 2014
Result Summary Reports KHNP goal is to complete the following ReSRs, December 2017
OER FRA/FA TA TIHA
ITAACs for these program elements are included in Tier 1 Considerations
Timely NRC approval of IPs and TeRs Timely NRC approval of Chapters 7, 15 and 19
Schedule of Submittals
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
13 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
All documents revised at least once
Implementation Plans Technical Reports
Basic HSI Platform V&V Scenarios Style Guide
DCD Chapter 18, Tier 1 and Tier 2 Revision process ~80% completed
One more review/revision cycle Revision 0 documents by the end of September for final internal review Final documents will be submitted with DCD (December 2014)
HFE Program Status
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
14 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
Program integration
Document internal and external referencing Interface reconciliation Unify definitions and abbreviations
Increase level of detail Editing
Technical clarity and consistency Definitive language (e.g., shall vs. may) English language and grammar Format standardization
Continuation and completion of independent reviews Responses to 17th PARM comments
General Work To Be Done by September 2014
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
15 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
PP Basic HSI TeR Others
Document Review
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
16 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
17 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
18 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
19 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
20 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
21 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
22 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
23 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
24 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
25 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: PP TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
26 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: Basic HSI TeR TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
27 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: Basic HSI TeR TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
28 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
NRC Comment: Basic HSI TeR TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
29 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
FRA/FA TA S&Q TIHA HD V&V Scenarios
Supplemental Material
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
30 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: FRA / FA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
31 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: FRA / FA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
32 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: FRA / FA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
33 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: FRA / FA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
34 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: FRA / FA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
35 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: TA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
36 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: TA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
37 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: TA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
38 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: S&Q TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
39 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: S&Q TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
40 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: S&Q TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
41 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: S&Q TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
42 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: TIHA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
43 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: TIHA TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
44 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: HD TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
45 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: HD TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
46 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: HD TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
47 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: V&V TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
48 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: V&V-continued TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
49 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
IP revisions: V&V TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
50 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
TeR Revisions TS
15th
Pre
-ap
pli
cati
on M
eeti
ng
115555
ththtPP
ree--aaaaaa
ppppppp
liccccaaaa
ttiionn
MMMeeee
ttinn
gg 1
7th P
re-a
pp
lica
tion
Rev
iew
Mee
tin
g
51 APR1400-K-J-EC-14007-NP
NON-PROPRIETARY
All IPs and TeRs will be revised to incorporate the 17th PARM results Tier 1 and Tier 2 of Ch. 18 will be revised to incorporate Acceptance Review results and 17th PARM results. All DCD, IPs, TeRs will be submitted to NRC before Readiness Assessment
Summary