27
Elderlaw & Ethics Confidentiality The Center for Elder Rights Advocacy presents Kimberly E. O’Leary Professor, Thomas M. Cooley Law School Director, Sixty Plus, Inc. Elderlaw Clinic

Elderlaw & Ethics

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

The Center for Elder Rights Advocacy presents. Elderlaw & Ethics. Confidentiality. Kimberly E. O ’ Leary Professor, Thomas M. Cooley Law School Director, Sixty Plus, Inc. Elderlaw Clinic Lansing, MI. About This Webinar. Handouts are available on www.legalhotlines.org - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Elderlaw & EthicsConfidentiality

The Center for Elder Rights Advocacy presents

Kimberly E. O’LearyProfessor, Thomas M. Cooley Law School

Director, Sixty Plus, Inc. Elderlaw ClinicLansing, MI

Page 2: Elderlaw  & Ethics

About This Webinar

• Handouts are available on www.legalhotlines.org

• A recording of the webinar will be available www.legalhotlines.org

• Today’s presentation is part of a three-part series exploring three of the unique ethical issues that attorneys are presented with when working with older clients.

• Dates for upcoming webinars:• Multi-representation: January 16th, 2014 from 2PM-3PM EDT• Register at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 3: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Today’s Presenter: Kimberly E. O’Leary

A Professor of Law and Director of the Sixty Plus, Inc. Elderlaw Clinic at the Thomas M. Cooley

Law School.

Page 4: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Audience participation!

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Q: Have you ever used a checklist to analyze confidentiality issues?

Page 5: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Learning outcomes

• During this presentation you will learn:• How to consistently clarify who your client is in an elderlaw

practice• How to engage the assistance of third parties to help an elderly

client without running afoul of confidentiality rules or best practices

• How to apply checklists to analyze those issues• How ethics rules affect your analysis• Practical tips for dealing with these issues

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 6: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Confidentiality typically arises in 2 different ways

• You need to involve third parties to help a client

• An elderly person is accompanied by family members, caregivers or other interested parties

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 7: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Ethics rules

• Rule 1.2 Scope of Representation and Allocation of Authority Between Client and Lawyer (client authorizes activity by lawyer)

• Rule 1.4 Communication (lawyer must inform client, client makes informed decisions)

• Rule 1.6 Confidentiality Of Information (lawyer must not disclose information without client consent or implied consent)

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 8: Elderlaw  & Ethics

First issue: An elderly person is accompanied by family members, caregivers or other interested parties• A person may not feel comfortable telling you what is on his or

her mind if other people are in the room

• This can be especially difficult if the person relies on the other person in important ways

• Although abuse or exploitation may be an issue (and one you should be watchful about), even well-intentioned third parties can keep an elderly person from telling you everything he or she wants to convey

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 9: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Use checklist: How to Maintain Confidentiality in an Elderlaw Practice

• Step 1: Identify the client• Who is the person with the primary legal issue?• Does this person want you to be his or her lawyer?

• Step 2: Are there other people involved? Who are they and what are their interests?

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 10: Elderlaw  & Ethics

How to Ensure Confidentiality in an Elderlaw Practice (continued)

• Step 3: Evaluate potential conflicts of interest• Step 4: If two people want representation and have

conflicting interests, choose who to represent (use multi-representation analysis if considering representing a group of people)

• Step 5: Are others involved who do NOT have legal interests? How do they want to be involved?

• Step 6: Are there red flags or indicators of abuse?

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 11: Elderlaw  & Ethics

How to Ensure Confidentiality in an Elderlaw Practice (continued)

• Step 7:Are there other people the client wants involved in the case?

• Step 8: Does the client want anyone involved in attorney-client discussions? • Explore why? • Counsel the client about reasons this might not be a

good idea.• Complete the Client Authorized Disclosure During

Representation form.

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 12: Elderlaw  & Ethics

• A woman calls your office and tells you her father needs a Will.

• She tells you he cannot hear well enough to talk on the phone, so you schedule an appointment.

• When they come in, she wants to sit in on the meeting, stating that her father is only comfortable with her in the room.

• She becomes agitated when you tell her you need to meet with her father alone; she says, “But I had some things I needed to ask you.”

Case Study #1

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 13: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Audience participation!

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

1. Would you allow the daughter to sit in on the client meeting initially?

Page 14: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Audience participation!

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

2. Would your answer be different if this did not involve a Will but rather involved a complaint against a contractor for an

inadequate driveway repair?

Page 15: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Audience participation!

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

3. If you would not allow her to sit in initially, might there be circumstances where you would ask her to sit in with

you and the Dad later?

Page 16: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Analysis

Is Dad the client? If so,

1. Potential undue influence

2. Potential creation of attorney-client expectation with daughter

3. Lack of privacy

4. Depending upon how agitated, potential exploitation issues

Might Daughter be the client?

Possible involvement later

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 17: Elderlaw  & Ethics

• While visiting a client in a nursing home, her aide tells you another woman needs help with a Medicaid application. The woman is physically frail but mentally sharp.

• When you get to her room, there are two family members visiting her and she has a roommate.

• The family members in tag team start telling you all about why Mom needs a lawyer, the status of assets, and how worried they are about the bill being paid. One of them says “I’m her power of attorney. You can talk to me about this.”

• The woman says, “Hi. Thanks for stopping by.”

Case Study #2

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 18: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Analysis

• Figure out a way to have a private conversation

• Discuss authorization to speak to different family members, aide, nursing home administrators whether to involve the attorney in fact in confidential meetings

• Discuss possible conflicts with the client

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 19: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Do you have any questions?

Page 20: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Audience participation!

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Q: If you need to reach out to a third party to help in some way to achieve a client’s goals, do you need permission

from your client before you speak to the third party?

Page 21: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Second Issue: You need to involve third parties to help a client

• Importance of consulting with your client:

• Rule 1.6 Confidentiality Of Information• (a) A lawyer shall not reveal information relating to the representation of a

client unless the client gives informed consent, the disclosure is impliedly authorized in order to carry out the representation or the disclosure is permitted by paragraph (b).

• MR Comment allows for implied authorization; NAELA standards encourage discussion and clarification with client

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 22: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Second Issue cont’d: You need to involve third parties to help a client

• Elderly people often experience people talking about them

• Conversations with people around them might affect them

• Some information-even if not all- might be considered private

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 23: Elderlaw  & Ethics

How to How to Maintain Confidentiality in an Elderlaw Practice (continued)

• Step 9: During representation, you and your client might agree that your client wants something that requires the assistance of a third party. Document what your client wants the third party to understand about the client’s decisions.

• Step 10: Communicate with your client any concerns you might have about discussing this matter with a third party.

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 24: Elderlaw  & Ethics

• You’ve been helping a woman draft a contract to govern the management of a small vacation cabin that has been in the family for several generations. • Although the woman has sole ownership of the cabin, she thinks of it

as a family property

• The cabin is used by some of her siblings, cousins, nieces and nephews. When it is not being used by family, it is rented and the income is used to maintain the cabin.

• Your client’s nephew drops into your office and tells your secretary he wants to discuss the family property.

Case Study #3

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 25: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Audience participation!

A. Ask your secretary to politely tell him you cannot speak with him

B. Speak to him in the waiting area just to tell him you can’t speak to him

C. Invite him into your office to find out what he wants to tell you, being careful not to tell him anything

D. Invite him into your office to discuss options on the table for managing the property

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Do you:

Page 26: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Analysis

• Any of the answers might be correct, depending upon the conversations you have had with your client.

• If you haven’t had any conversations with your client about this, you need to speak with her.

Materials covered in this webinar can be found at www.legalhotlines.org

Page 27: Elderlaw  & Ethics

Do you have any questions?