Editorial Evaluation

Answer each of the following questions by checking one of the appropriate descriptors.

Needs Revision Average ExcellentIntroduction clearly states opinion (thesis) and interests the readerOpinion is developed in a logical manner – ideas follow thesisOrganization is clear and easy to follow – proper format is usedParagraphing is correctly done – all paragraphs include only one main idea and work towards opinion developmentOpinion is supported by evidence and specific examplesPurpose of editorial is achieved – inform, promote, praise, entertainWriter makes appropriate word choicesMechanics and Sentence Structure are correct