Economic Impacts of Vermont Yankee Closure Economic... · model, w the study Impacts of Ver ... progressive ty as it end roughout, i ... 4 employment nerating Ope o occur during.2

EC Pr Pr UMEc De

EconomClosure

repared fo

repared by

Mass Donahconomic and

ecember 201

mic Impa

r the Frank

hue Instituted Public Polic

14

acts of

klin Region

cy Research

f Vermo

nal Counci

h

ont Yan

il of Gover

nkee

rnments

Economic

UMaEcon

Introd

Entergy’stheConnTheTri‐CCounty,Nprovidedregionaljskilled,w

Figure 1

MaintenaStates, prthroughoproductiolossof itsRegion.ToftheecoWhilethemodel,wthe study

Impacts of Ver

ass Donahue Insnomic and Public

duction

sVermontYaecticutRiverCountyRegioNewHampshafoundationjobsandamwell‐compens

. The Vermo

ancecostsinrincipally naout the countonandstartshigh‐payaThisstudy,uonomicandj

eeconomicimwillbeimporty also assess

rmont Yankee C

stitute c Policy Researc

ankeeNucler,hasbeenaonincludesFhire (seeFignfortheTrimuchhighersatedjobs.

nt Yankee N

combinationatural gas, htry, includinofdecommindbenefits tusingavailablobimpactso

mpactresulttantastheyses the ramif

Closure

ch

arPowerStacrucialcompFranklinCoungure1). Asa‐Countyeconshareofthe

uclear Powe

nwithcompeave resultedngVermontYssioning),antoworkerswledataonVeontheTri‐Co

ts,includingtillustratethficationsof t

ation(“Vermponentofthnty,Massacha fullyoperanomy,directregion’swa

er Plant and t

etitionfromd in the planYankee. ThenticipatedtowillhaveasermontYankountyRegion

theirmultipleimmediatethe closurea

montYankeeeTri‐Countyhusetts;Windationalelectrtlyaccountinageandsalar

the Tri-Coun

other,lessexnned closuree closure oftakeplaceisignificant imkee’semploynresultingfro

liereffectsasemagnitudeas they relat

e”), located inyRegion’secdhamCountyricpowerplangforslightlyryincomedu

nty Region

xpensivepowe of numerothis facilitynthefourthmpactontheymentandpaomthedecom

sgeneratedfoftheclosurte to the eco

nVernon,Veconomyforoy,Vermont;ant,Vermonylessthanonuetohundre

wersourcesus nuclear p(i.e., cessatiquarterof2e largelyruraayroll,providmmissioning

fromaregioreimpactsoonomic and

2

ermontalongover40yearsandCheshirentYankeehanepercentoedsofhighly

intheUnitedpower planton of energy2014,andthealTri‐Countydesestimategoftheplant

naleconomiontheregiondemographi

gs.esofy‐

dsyeyst.

cn,c

Economic

UMaEcon

fundamenhighlypaplant’sskoperationdepth inwage,andThefollowYankee adecline inpowergebasedoncontainednationallThefindifoundatioandthepdiscussiointheTri

Impacts of Ver


ntalsof theaid and skillekilledtechnicnsatVermonjob prospecdsalarylosse

winganalysias a fully opn economicenerationanndemonstratdTri‐Countylevelsasthey

ingsarelaidonoftheanaprogressiveronoftheclosi‐CountyReg

rmont Yankee C


Tri‐CountyRedworkersciansarealrentYankeehacts to retainesfromthep

isincludesanerational poimpacts as fndgoes throutingtheeconyRegion.Totywouldcapt

outasfollowalysis;b)thereductionofureofVermogion.

Closure

ch

Region. Thisare expectedeadyleavingavestopped.a large porplantclosure

nestimateofower generatfewer and feughsuccessinomicimpactaleconomictureagreate

ws:a)Vermeconomicimf economicimontYankeei

s last compod tomove togforotherpa. Thethree‐tion of Verewilllikelyta

fthedirectating, nuclearewer peopleivephasesotsoftheVercimpactsworrangeofsu

ontYankeeempactsofthempactsbrounthecontex

onent is impoother locatartsoftheco‐countyregiormont Yankeakeyearsto

andtotaleconr facility. Ite are neededofdecommissrmontYankeouldactuallyupplierstoth

employmentefullyoperaghtaboutbyxtofprevailin

ortantasmations. Recenountryevenondoesnotee’s employerecover.

nomicimpact then demod to work atsioning. TheeeclosureonbegreaterifheVermontY

tandpayrollationalVermydecommissngeconomic

anyofVermnt evidencebeforepowepresentlyofees,meaning

ctsgeneratedonstrates thet the propereanalysis, thntherelativefmeasuredaYankeepowe

lvaluesthatontYankeensioning;andcanddemogr

3

montYankee’indicates theergenerationffersufficieng the income

dbyVermone progressiverty as it endhroughout, ielysmallandatthestateoerplant.

tserveasthenuclearplanc)abroaderaphictrend

sente,

tessdr

etrs

Economic

UMaEcon

Direct

Overvi

TheVermmajorsupseeVermto six yecomparisthepropeVermont

Direct

In2014,higher thnuclear presponsibpayrollofAfterthethe plantexpects omanagemYankeeinand2016years,20phasewhofdryfueinitialweexisting,levels,wimillioninthattimebylowerin such jstorage.

1 Payroll anstudy among

Impacts of Ver


tImpacts

iew

montYankeepplierofelemontYankee’ars to be fosonwithanerty. ThisseYankeeplan

Econom

VermontYanhan 600. Thpower plantbilities.Withftheoperatio

cessationoft begins theon‐site jobsment. Thedrn2014tothe6,jobsareex16‐2020,thehichwillreqelmanagemet fuelmanaghighly compillcontinuetn2020ifthee). After202relativewagobs as grou

d wage data werg regional and la

rmont Yankee C


sofVermo

nuclearpowctricitytoNeseconomiccllowed by aoperatingnuectionwillbntcompared

ic Activit

nkeeemployhese employt, receive rehanestimatonalVermon

f powergenedecommissito fall fromrop in jobs oedryfuelmapectedtodeeformerVeruirefewerwentcouldbrgementphaspensatedwotobesignificwageandsa21,thesignifgelevelsasounds security

re not available fabor experts fam

Closure

ch

ontYanke

werplantiseewEngland.contributionlong‐perioduclearpowerrieflydescritothenumb

ty

yed550peopyees, most relatively higedaverageantYankeewo

rationatVeroningproce

m 550 in 20over only sixanagementpclineto316montYankeeworkers(appringemploymsesofthederkers. For tcantthroughalarylevelsoficantlyloweccupationssy while the

for 2014, but an miliar with Verm

eeDecom

expectedtoclTheclosurestotheTri‐Cd of continuerplant)assobeandcomperofjobsexp

pleaccordingequiring vergh wage andannualwageouldbeabou

rmontYankess. Presently14 to as fewxor sevenyphasebeginnduringaperenuclearpowproximately1mentlevelsoecommissionthis reason,hatleast202ofVermontYerjoblevelsshiftfromtecsite goes thr

estimate of overont Yankee and

mmissioni

loseinlate2eandensuinCountyRegioed but veryociatedwithparethe jobpecteddurin

gtoEntergyry specialized salary levperworkert$58million

eeinlate201y, the plannew as 24 duryearsbetweeningin2021riodofwetfuwerplantwi127).Finallyon‐sitedownning,Vermontotal payrol20(i.e.,payrYankee’sopeattheVermochnicalworkrough what

r $105,000 per wdeemed consist

ingandCl

2014andthungdecommisonfallsharplow economthedecontasandpayrolngthedecom

y.Asrecentlyed skills to mvels reflectivofapproximnin2014.1

14,joblevelsed timeline fring an exteen theoperawillbesharpuel(hot)manillbeinawey,beginningntoasfewantYankeewill, though onrollin2020cerationphaseontYankeeskerstoahighmay be mo

worker developetent with likely 2

losure

usendits42ssioningprocplyoverthecmic activity (aminationanllatthefullymmissioningp

yat2011,thmanage andve of theirmately$105,0

satthesitewfor the decoended periodational phasep(seeFigurenagement.Fetfuel(cool)gin2021,alas24. Durinillcontinuetnly a fractioncouldbeashearemaintasitemaybeaherproportioore than a d

ed for 2011 was v2014 compensati

4

yearrunasacesswillalsocourseoffive(especially inndsecurityoyoperationaprocess.

hisfigurewad operate thetraining and000,thetota

willdeclineaommissioningd of dry fueeof Vermone2).In2015oraboutfoumanagemenongerperiodgatleastthetoemployitn of previouhighas$13.5ainedthroughaccompaniedonofworkerdecade of dry

vetted for this ion levels.

aoenofal

sedal

sgelt5rtdess5hdsy

Economic

UMaEcon

Figure 2and the

Source: ENote: Thedepicted i VermontVermonttheplantemployeeforthereentertaineconomypercent oemployeeCounty.3areheldplantwas

2 Entergy prhttp://public3Countyes

Impacts of Ver


. Worker NuDecommissi

Entergy, Septee transition froin a slide desc

Yankee’s emYankeewort’slocationclesisanimpoegion(seeFinment reverby.TheTri‐Coof the totales lived iInthiseconconstant insoperational

resentation to thecservice.vermontstimatesfor201

rmont Yankee C


umbers at theioning Phase

ember 2014. om wet fuel (cribing Vermo

mployees livrkersliveovelosetothecortantpieceoigure6onpberates throountyregionin 2014 priin Windhaomicimpactfutureyearsl,itwillhave

e Nuclear Decomt.gov/sites/psd/fi14arebasedon

Closure

ch

e Vermont Yaes Begin

(hot) to wet fuont Yankee’s

ve and spenderwhelminglenteroftheofthisanalysage11)andough the Triwashometoior to the pm County,analysis,thes (e.g., if thee89percent

mmissioning Citfiles/NDCAP%2nanactual2011

ankee Site W

uel (cool) man staffing trans

d a large parlywithinthe2,250squarsisastheirbtheirspendi‐County Rego481ofVerplant closure 176 inesharesofVregionhadof127emplo

tizens Advisory P0September%201allocationapp

Will Decline a

nagement is asition to deco

rt of their eeTri‐Countyremileregiobuyingpowedingwhethergion, providrmontYankee. In 2014,Cheshire

VermontYank89percentoyeesin202

Panel, Septembe025th%202014%pliedtothe2014

as Power Ge

anticipated toommissioning

earningswheRegion(seen.Theresidrissignificanronhomes,rding criticalee’s550empan estimateCounty, a

keeemployeof550empl20duringdec

er 25, 2014. We%20Presentation4employment

nerating Ope

o occur duringg.2

ere they reseFigure3),adencyofVermntlygreaterrestaurants,support to

ployees,accoued 204 Vermand 101esbycountyloyees in20commissioni

eb: %20-%20Final.ptotalforVermo

5

erations End

g 2016, as

ide. CurrenareflectionomontYankeethanaveragegroceries,othe regionauntingfor89mont Yankeein Franklinyofresidence014while theng).

pdf ontYankee.

d

tofeeral9enee

Economic

UMaEcon

Figure 3

Source:Vcountynuemployee

Impacts of Ver


. Place of R

VermontYanumbersapples

rmont Yankee C


esidence for

nkee(2014);ythe2011g

Closure

ch

r Vermont Ya

481ofVermgeographicpl

ankee Emplo

montYankee’laceofreside

oyees

s550emploenceallocatio

oyeesresideiontothe201

inTri‐County14totalof55

6

yRegion;50

Economic

UMaEcon

Econo

TheclosuVermont,placeatVreductionimpactspdirectlyaTheeconlevel. Toestimatelabor increported

Jo

Lhp

V

potoingr

O

fisa

The totainducedi

DYpwth

In

mbel

4 For more i

Impacts of Ver


omicImpa

ureanddeco, NewHampVermontYann in jobs asspresented inandindirectly

nomic impactconduct ththedirect, income, busineintermsoft

obimpactsr

aborincomealthandliferoprietaryin

ValueaddedroductsandrGDP).Valuocustomers.ntorefinedgareatervalue

Outputisabrnalusers(e.galeofcrudep

al economicimpacts.

Direct impacankee,whethases of decworkatthesihesite.

ndirect impmade to supusinessessulectronicequ

information on I

rmont Yankee C


actsofVe

ommissioninpshire, andMnkee.Thissesociatedwithn thissectionyintermsof

tsand jobefis analysis,ndirect,andess sales (outhefollowing

representac

econsistsofeinsurancebncome(paym

representstisroughlyequeaddedisthForexamplasoline.Simofrefinedga

roadermeasg.,thesaleofpetroleumth

impacts as

cts are onlyther during tcommissioniite,theirpay

pacts are genpport the diupplyinggoouipment,buil

MPLAN, see htt

Closure

ch

ermontYa

ngofVermonMassachusettectionoftheh the decomn,asestimatfthemultipli

ffectswereewe used ainducedeffeutput), valueg:

changeinave

ftotalemploybenefits,retirmentsreceive

totalbusinesquivalenttogheenhanceme,anoilrefinplistically,thasolineandth

urethatconsfgasolineathatisrequire

s estimated

y those assothe current ong. The diryroll,andthe

neratedwherect activitydsthatthepldingmateria

tp://www.implan

ankeeClo

ntYankeewts and generstudyprovidmmissioningedandrepoereffectsto

estimatedspcustomizedectsoftheVe added, and

erageannual

yeecompensrementpaymedbyself‐em

ssales(outpgrossstate/dmentacompanerytakescrhe“valueaddhelowerval

sistsoftotalaservicestaedtoproduce

by the IMPL

ociated specoperationalrect impactsrevenues(s

enmaterial,y. For Vermplant(ordecals,specializ

n.com/

osureand

will reverberarate impactsdesestimatesand closureorted, reflectthebroader

pecifically forIMPLAN inp

VermontYankd state reve

ljobsforthe

sation(wagementsandanmployedindiv

put)minusthdomesticproanygivesitsrudepetroleuded”inthisinueofcrudep

businessoration)aswellethegasolin

LAN model

cifically withphase or theof Vermontales)associa

equipment omont Yankecommissioninzedservices,

dDecomm

ate through ts beyond thesoftheovere of Vermonttchanges ineconomy.

r theTri‐Couput‐output mkeeclosure,nue. The re

yearindicat

eandsalarypnyothernon‐vidualsasin

hecostofpuroduct(commproductsbefumasaninpnstanceisthpetroleum.

industrysalelasintermedne).

are the sum

h activities te progressivt Yankee incatedwiththe

or other inteee, indirectngprocess)etc.

missioning

theTri‐Coune on‐site actalleconomict Yankee. Teconomicac

untyareaatmodel4 for tintermsofesults are ge

ted.

payments,as‐cashcompecome).

rchasingintemonlyreferreforeofferingputandthenthedifference

es.Itincludediategoodsa

m of direct,

taking placevedownsizinlude the emeactivitiesta

ermediate pimpacts comneedstoope

7

g

ntyRegion inivities takingcimpactsandThe economictivity–both

t theregionathe region toemploymentenerated and

swellasnsation)and

ermediateedtoasGSPgtheproducttransformsibetweenthe

essalestoales(e.g.,the

indirect, and

e at Vermonngduring themployeeswhoakingplacea

purchases areme from theeratesucha

ngdch

alot,d

d

te

d

nteoat

ees

Economic

UMaEcon

In

wlore

ThelowegeneratioanalysisiofVermofor foursYankeesi

Figure 4

Vermontoperationoperationbeyond pemployedjobs)andmany loc

Impacts of Ver


nducedimpworkers (wheocaleconomyestaurants,h

erlevelsofeon will transincludesestiontYankeebyspecifiedphaite).Theecon

. Economic

Yankeehasnalpowerplnal, employsprevailing red550peopled induced (3cal businesse

rmont Yankee C


pactsaregenether in they.Forexamhairsalons,et

conomicactslate to fewimatesoftheyphase(e.g.,asesofdeconomicimpac

Impact Anal

beenakeyant.Duetots a large numegional averaewithapayr87 jobs) impes such resta

Closure

ch

neratedbythoperationalple,spendintc.

tivityemanater dollars avedirectandt,thecurrentmmissioningctmethodolo

lysis Method

driverof ththeadvancedmber of higages. Durinroll(includinpacts, shownaurants, real

helocalconsordecommgbyVermon

tingfromVevailable to ctotal(sumooperationalgshowingaogydescribed

dology

eTri‐Countydnatureofnghly‐skilled eg its last yengbenefits)on indetail inl estate, reta

sumerspendmissioningphntYankeeem

ermontYankconsumers ffdirect,indiphaseasanprogressivedaboveisvis

yRegion’secnuclearpoweengineers thear of operatof$82millionnTable1, thail shops, he

ding,primarihases) spendmployeessup

keeafterthefor spendingirect,andindactivenuclereductionosuallypresen

conomy forergenerationhat receive ction, 2014, Vn.Byalsoinhat include thealthcare, an

ilyfromVermding their eapportsjobsin

endingofnug. The econduced)econoearpowerplaofactivityatntedinFigur

wellover40n,VermontYcompensationVermont Yanncludingthehepositive ind suppliers

8

montYankeernings in thenlocalstores

uclearpowenomic impacomicimpactantaswellatheVermonre4.

0yearsasanYankee,whilen levels welnkee directlyindirect(282influencesonto the plant

ees,

rctsst

nelly2nt,

Economic

UMaEcon

Vermontthese Veagriculturegionaleinitslast

Table 1.

Direct

Em

Lab

Va

Indirect

Em

Lab

Va

Induced

Em

Lab

Va

Total*

Em

Lab

Va

Source:RNotes:Alrepresenindicated*TotalimAs canbeexpectedtheinitiatouseexireplacek

5TheecontheTri‐CouaroundtheYankeewor

Impacts of Ver


Yankee is eermont Yankral related jeconomicpilyearofoper

The Econom

mployment

bor Income

alue Added

Output

mployment

bor Income

alue Added

Output

d

mployment

bor Income

alue Added

Output

mployment

bor Income

alue Added

Output

Resultsarefrlleconomicattheannualdperiod;theympactsrepres

e seen inTatodeclineplwetfuelmaistingVermokeyVermont

nomicimpactanuntyareatoworcountry.Enterrkerswhohave

rmont Yankee C


stimated tokee generatejobs in thellar.Theoverationin201

mic Activity

Operation

550

$82,099,12

$244,286,9

$402,707,4

282

$10,425,32

$31,131,26

$47,691,30

387

$14,377,22

$26,575,15

$43,008,07

1,220

$106,901,6

$301,993,4

$493,406,8

romsimulatioactivitylevelcontributionyarenotmulsentthesum

able1, the ecprogressivelyanagementsontYankeeeYankeewor

nalysis,throughrkorstarttheirrgyisneedingtealreadyleft.

Closure

ch

contribute aed jobs is tTri‐Countyeralltotaleco14isestimate

Levels of Ve

nal 201

27 $38,

92 $66,

28 $81,

25 $3,5

67 $5,5

02 $10,

20 $6,1

52 $11,

77 $21,

72 $48,

11 $82,

06 $113

onsruninIMsshownarenstotheeconlti‐yearcumuofdirect,ind

conomic conyas theplantepsofthedmployeesorrkerswhoha

hout,assumesthrownbusinesseobringinrepla

a total of1,2hat they arRegion, thuonomicactivedtobealmo

ermont Yanke

5-2016

318

564,486

121,377

769,337

93

547,281

541,555

528,954

165

106,431

297,051

464,397

577

218,198

959,983

,762,689

MPLAN.annual(e.g.,nomythatarulativecontrdirect,andin

ntributionsontmoves thrdecommissiorbring‐insubavealready

hatveryfewofes.Theyarealracementemploy

220 jobs in tre not seasous underscorvityintheregost$500mill

ee to the Tri-

2017-2020

126

$15,508,264

$26,547,585

$32,091,293

37

$1,426,498

$2,224,922

$4,227,352

66

$2,455,631

$4,535,741

$8,617,908

229

$19,390,393

$33,308,248

$44,936,552

,thelevelsshreexpectedfributions).nducedimpa

ofVermontYroughsuccesning(througbstitutesfromleft forposit

theskilledVermreadybeingsucyeesfromother

the region inonal or cycliring the plagionassociatlioninoutpu

-County Reg

2021 Plu

58

$2,675,75

$7,849,91

$10,573,1

16

$618,52

$968,23

$1,734,17

10

$361,32

$667,94

$1,081,54

84

$3,655,60

$9,486,09

$13,388,9

howninthe“foreachindiv

acts.

Yankeeon thssivephasesghabout202maroundthetionselsewh

montYankeeemccessfullyrecrurplantstodoth

n2014. Anical as arent’s long‐tertedwithVerut.

gion Over Tim

us 2021 P

2

50 $1,10

19 $3,24

88 $4,32

2 $246

3 $386

71 $692

7 $148

6 $275

49 $445

3

00 $1,49

99 $3,90

908 $5,46

“2017‐2020”vidualyeard

heTri‐Countsofdecomm20),Entergyecountry,ifhere.5 Thoug

mployeesareliitedandmovinheworkofthef

9

advantageotourism andrm role as amontYankee

me

Plus (2)

24

00,406

42,067

28,235

6

6,311

6,153

2,314

4

8,855

5,168

5,562

34

95,572

03,388

66,111

”columnduringthe

tyRegionaremissioning. Inwillcontinuenecessary,toghdrastically

kelytostayinngtonewjobsformerVermon

ofdae

eneoy

t

Economic

UMaEcon

reducedcVermontCountyRexpectedshorttiminducedjbythespAfter202completespent fueYankee scontributindicatedvarying dplaceattonlybemjobscontFigure5of jobs (tupcomingregionwtheclosuduringce

Figure 5in jobs co

Source:RTable2ditsoperatheplant

Impacts of Ver


comparedtoYankee dec

Regionthrougdeclineto2

meframe)whejobs–thejobendingofVe

21,whentheed, Vermontels) thatmaysite will shitions from td inTable1,degrees of ethesite.Atthmakingatottributionoft

showstheimthedifferencgdecommissillhave643rewillincreaertaindryfue

. Total Job Iompared to a

Resultsareba

demonstratestionalaswetsupported1

rmont Yankee C


otheoperaticommissioningh2020.By229compareenthepowerbsinsuchinermontYanke

wetfuel(deYankeewilly last a decaift to morethe closed nthe long‐terconomic conhelowestlevalcontributitheoperation

mpactsofthecebetween tsioningphasfewerjobscaseto991feelmanageme

Impacts of thn operational

asedonsimu

stheeconomellas its four1,220jobsin

Closure

ch

onalplantinng will conty2020,thenedto1,220irplantwassndustriesasreeworkersi

e‐fueling)mal enter a proade or longeconstructio

nuclear powermperiodofntributions tvel,“2021Pluionof34 jobnalpowerpla

eVermontYathe total jobses) intheTcomparedtoewerregionaentphases.

he Vermont Yl Vermont Yan

ulationsruni

miccontributrdecommissntheTri‐Cou

n2014,theseinue tomaknumberofjobin2014(a lostillgeneratirestaurants,ntheTri‐Cou

anagementpolonged phaser. During tn and secuer plant to tf interimcarto the Tri‐Cous(2)”(aterbstotheTriantin2014.

ankeeclosurnumbers inri‐CountyRehavinganoaljobsbetwe

Yankee Deconkee)

inIMPLANin

tionsofVermsioningphasuntyRegion,

ehighlycomke significantbssupportedossofaboutngelectricityretail,andpuntyRegion.

phasesofthese of dry futhis long‐territy personnthe Tri‐Couneandmaintounty RegionrmusedbyE‐Countyregi

reanddecomn2014compegionexpectoperationalpeen2017and

ommissionin

nSeptember

montYankeees. Asanopwithnearly

mpensatedemt economicdbyVermon1,000regioy.Thisincluersonalserv.

edecommisselmanagemm period, thnel. With tnty RegiontenanceatVn dependingEntergy),theion,or lesst

mmissioningpared to theted incominpowerplant.d2020andfi

ng in the Tri-C

r2014.

ebyindustryperational,phalfofthese

mployeeswocontributionntYankeeinnal jobsoveudesthelossvices–thata

ioningareexment (dry cashe needs atthis shift, thwill declineermontYankg on the actiVermontYathanthreep

intermsofttotal jobnungyears. InTheeconomfinallyto1,18

County Regi

y,intermsofpower‐genereinutilities,

10

orkingonthens to the Tritheregioni

erarelativelyofabout320

aresupported

xpectedtobesk storage othe Vermonhe economifurther. Akeewillhaveivities takingnkeesitewilercentof the

thereductionmbers in the2015‐16, themicimpacto85fewerjob

ion (net loss

fjobs,inbothrating facilitytheindustry

ei‐sy0d

eoftcseglle

neeofs

hy,y

Economic

UMaEcon

sector cloperationin Retail,Educationetc.) in2jobssuppfeweremmeantherepresenmovietheclosure otemporarthe2015sectorsautilitiesin

Table 2. Closure

Industry

Natur

P

Educa

Source:RNotes:AlrepresenindicatedThiseconlikely todecommi

Impacts of Ver


assificationnalVermont, 54 jobs innandHealth014. AsVerportedbythemployees andenumberofting a net loeaters,hotelof Vermont Yryupticksse‐2016initialstheeconomndustrybeca

Vermont Yaand Decomm

y Supersecto

ral Resources

Wholes

ReTranspor

Wa

Co

Man

In

FinanciaProfessional &

ation & Health

Leisure & H

Othe

Public Adm

Resultsarefrllemploymettheannualdperiod;they

nomicanalystake place iissioning.

rmont Yankee C


of VermontYankeesupp

n Financial AhServices,armontYankeeplantinead lower labojobsinLeisuoss of 136 jos,andperforYankee takeeninConstrulphaseofdemicactivitytausetheprop

ankee’s Jobsmissioning (

or

s & Mining

Utilities

sale Trade

etail Trade rtation and arehousing

onstruction

ufacturing

nformation

l Activities & Business

Services

h Services

Hospitality

r Services

ministration

Total

romsimulationtlevelsshocontributionyarenotmul

sisdoesnotin the late 2

Closure

ch

Yankee. Aported141jActivities (band46 jobs ieegoesthrouchoftheseinor incomeemureandHospobs for the inrmingarts,aes place in auctionandPcommissionitakingplacepertyisnolo

s Contributiototal employm

Operational16

550

15

81

25

44

3

15

54

111

116

141

46

4

1,220

onsruninIMownareannunstotheeconlti‐yearcumu

includeafin020s or 203

As plant worobsinLeisuanking, monnOtherServughthedecondustriesdemanating fropitalitywillfndustries claamongothersall of the indProfessional&ingissimplyatVermontongerproduc

ons to Tri-Rement associat

2015-2011

3

7

31

7

65

2

5

21

320

49

42

22

2

577

MPLAN.ual(e.g.,thelnomythatarulativecontr

alupsurge,l30swhichw

rkers spendreandHospney managemvices(e.g.,dommissionineclinessharpmVermontfallfrom141assifiedwiths).Thispattdustry secto&BusinessSyashiftinjoYankeecancingenergy.

egion Industrted with Verm

16 2017-0

0

3

15

1

27

1

2

8

12

20

16

9

1

22

levelsshownreexpectedfributions).

ledbythecowould be the

d their paychpitality(inclument, real erycleaning,ngprocess, thplyasshownYankeeas it1in2014tohin the sectoternofjobsdors of the TrServicesfrombsfromthenolongerb

ries Will Decmont Yankee b

-2020 200

0

3

5

1

7

1

2

8

27

0

6

9

1

29

ninthe“2017foreachindiv

onstructionoe final phase

hecks in theudesrestauraestate, etc.),petcare,rephenumberoinTable2.t isdecommfewerthanor (includingdeclineresulri‐County ecmtheoperatioutilitiesindubeclassifieda

line Over Timby industry)

021 Plus 20

0

2

1

1

12

0

1

2

55

3

5

2

0

84

7‐2020”columvidualyeard

ofashelterfoe of the Verm

11

e region, theants),81job116 jobs inpairservicesofTri‐CountyForexample

missionedwilfiveby2021g restaurantstingfromtheonomy. Theonalphasetoustrytootheaswithinthe

me with the

2021 Plus (2)0

0

0

2

0

5

0

0

1

23

1

1

1

0

35

mnduringthe

forspentfuelmont Yankee

esns,ye,ll1,s,eeore

l,e

Economic

UMaEcon

TheV

The econYankeetoplant andtheirhighsomeconincome,u(generallofVermo

Figure 6

Source:VThere is(wageanthanthenow direMeanwhiareassho

$‐

$20,000

$40,000

$60,000

$80,000

$100,000

$120,000

Impacts of Ver


VermontY

nomic contriotheTri‐Coud enters a sehcompensatntextforwhaunemploymey2003‐2013ontYankeean

. Average W

VermontYan

ahugewagendsalary)ofaveragepayectly accounile, theTri‐Cown)arefurt

0

0

0

0

0

0

rmont Yankee C


YankeeCl

ibutions, asuntyRegionweries of decotionlevelswiatthisclosurent,andpopu3)provideanditseconom

Wage Per Em

nkee(2011);

edifferentiaaVermontYintheregionnts for 0.7 pountyarea’stheratriska

Closure

ch

losureina

demonstratewilldeclinemommissioninillhavelong‐emaymeanulationarebrgreaterundmicactivities

ployee, Verm

BureauofLa

l betweenVYankeeworkn(about$40percent of rsrelatively loftertheloss

aRegiona

ed in the prmarkedlyasng phases. T‐termeffectstotheTri‐Corieflyillustraderstandingoswillhaveon

mont Yankee

aborStatistic

VermontYanker,approxim0,000in2013regional emowaveragewofhigh‐payin

alContex

revious sectittransitionThe loss of VsontheTri‐Countyeconomatedinthispofthepotentntheregion.

e Compared t

csQCEW(20

kee and themately$1053).Vermontmployment awages(belongVermont

xt

tion of the snsfrombeingVermontYanCountyeconmy,anumbepartofthestutialimplicati

to Region, S

013)

Tri‐County5,000, is twotYankee,asand 1.8 percwthestateYankeejobs

study, madeganactivenunkeeworkeromy.Inorderofrecenttrudy.Thedationsofthes

States, and U

Region. Thoandahalf tanoperatingcent of regiandnationa.

12

by Vermonuclearpowes, alongwithertoproviderendsinjobstaandtrendustainedlos

.S.

e annualpaytimesgreategpowerplanonal payrolllcomparison

trhes,ss

yrtl.n

Economic

UMaEcon

Figure 7.

Source:BTheTri‐Cparticipathenationearly as2003andpercent.England’s

0.92

0.94

0.96

0.98

1.00

1.02

1.04

1.06

1.08

20

Impacts of Ver


Jobs Growt

BureauofLa

CountyRegiotefullyinthententativelys robustly asd2013, then The closursandthenat

003 2004 200

rmont Yankee C


th Index (200

borStatistics

on’s recent jeeconomiceyentersanes theUnitednumberof jore of Vermotion’supward

05 2006 2007

Closure

ch

03=1.00), Tri-

s,QuarterlyC

obs performexpansionofwperiodofStates,Massobs intheTrnt Yankee adcycleofgro

2008 2009 2

-County Reg

CensusofEm

mance showsfthe2000saeconomicexsachusetts,Nri‐Countyareadds a signifowth.

2010 2011 20

gion Compare

mploymenta

s that it is unandgothithaxpansion,theNewHampsheadeclinedficant obstac

012 2013

ed to States

andWages(Q

nderperformarderbytheeTri‐Countyhire, andVefrom82,917cle for the r

United St

Massachu

New Ham

Vermont

Tri‐Count

and U.S.

QCEW)

ming. The re2008‐2009ryRegionisnormont, overa7to79,713,egion to par

ates

usetts

mpshire

y

13

egion did norecession.Aotrecoveringall. Betweenadropof3.9rtake in New

tsgn9w

Economic

UMaEcon

Figure 8.

(Per Capi

Source:BPercapittransferpeoplelivriseinitsthroughonation’s.progressneighborthroughoTheVermare elimiregion.

0.80

0.90

1.00

1.10

1.20

1.30

% Above/Below US PCI Level

Impacts of Ver


Per Capita

ita Income Gr

BureauofEc

taincomeispayments livingwithinaspercapitaoutNewEnglBy2012,itcomparedtoingandhostoutthe1990montYankeeinated and b

0

0

0

0

0

0

1990

1991

1992

1993

rmont Yankee C


Income Rela

rowth Index,

onomicAnal

anencompake Social Searegion. Inincomelevelland.In1990hadgrowntotheU.S.,thetNewEnglans,thestatehclosurewillby lowering

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

Closure

ch

ative to U.S. f

U.S=1.00)

lysis

assingmeasuecurity, andgeneral,asslscompared0,theTri‐Coto1.4perceneregion’sgrndstates.Whasrecentlyaffecttheinthe investm

1998

1999

2000

2001

for Tri-Count

ureofincomeinvestmentshowninFigtotheUniteunty’spercanthigherthanowthinincoWhileincomecaughtupancomeinthement income

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

ty Region an

ethatcoversincome) angure8,theTedStatesandapitaincomentheU.S.avomelevelsapelevelsinthandevensureTri‐Countyof former e

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

nd States, 19

sallincomend representTri‐CountyRdisfollowinelevelwasfivverage.HoweppearsnottoeregionwerrpassedtheTareabyreduemployeesw

2011

2012

990-2012

sources(wats the meanRegionisseeingalong‐termvepercentloever,despiteobekeepingrehigherthaTri‐Countyaucingpayrollwhomove aw

U.S. = 1.00

Massachuse

New Hamps

Vermont

Tri‐County

14

ages,salariesn average foingarelativemtrendseenowerthantheethisrelativepacewithitanVermont’areaby2012laspositionway from the

tts

hire

s,reneess2.se

Economic

UMaEcon

Figure 9.

Source:UTheTri‐CUnlike thacceleratCounty Reveryyeatakingpleffecton

0.95

1.00

1.05

1.10

1.15

1.20

1.25

1.301990

Impacts of Ver


Population

U.S.CensusB

CountyRegiohe rest of Ntion in its raRegion’s poparsincehittiaceevenpritheTri‐Coun

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

rmont Yankee C


Growth Inde

Bureau

onisfollowinNew Englandate of populaulation, accoingapeakiniortothestontyarea’spop

1995

1996

1997

1998

Closure

ch

ex (1990=1.0

ngthenorthd, Massachusation increasording to thn2007. Theoppageofpopulationgrow

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

0), Tri-Count

hernNewEnsetts (led byse and is nowe U.S. Censuout‐migrati

owergeneratwthincomin

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

ty Region Co

nglandtrendy its Greatew growing cus Bureau, honofVermotionlaterinngyears.

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

ompared to S

towardsslor Boston recloser to thehas actually sontYankeew2014,willh

2012

2013

States and U

owingpopulaegion) has see national raseen populaworkers,whihaveafurthe

United State

Massachuse

New Hamps

Vermont

Tri‐County

15

U.S.

ationgrowtheen a recenate. The Trition declineichisalreadyerdampening

es

tts

hire

h.ti‐syg

Economic

UMaEcon

Figure 10

(Unemplo

Source:B

Figure 11

(Labor Fo

Source:BTheTri‐CFigure10shrinkingpeoplemaway, oreconomicforcegro

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

2000

92

94

96

98

100

102

104

106

108

1990

Impacts of Ver


0. Unemploy

oyment Rate, i

BureauofLa

1. Tri-County

orce, in thous

BureauofLa

Countyunem0.Thepost‐rglaborforcemaybediscour made othecopportunitiwthinthere

02001200220

1991

1992

1993

1994

1995

rmont Yankee C


yment Rate, 2

in percent)

borStatistics

y Labor Forc

sands)

borStatistics

mploymentrarecessionde(seeFigureuragedwither long‐termiesitprovideegion.

00320042005

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

Closure

ch

2000-2013, T

s

ce Growth, 19

s

ategenerallyeclineinther11)thanjobtheirprospe decisions sedtothereg

20062007200

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

Tri-County Re

990-2013

ytrackswithregion’sunebsgrowth.TectsintheTsuch as retiionwhenful

08200920102

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

egion Compa

hNewHampemploymentThedeclineiTri‐Countyarrement. Thllyoperation

011201220132008

2009

2010

2011

2012

ared to State

pshireandVerate,howeveinthelaborreaandhavehe loss of Vnal,willfurth

3

U.S.

Mas

New

Verm

Tri‐C

2013

es and U.S.

ermontascaer,ismorethforcesuggesestoppedlooVermont Yanherstresslon

sachusetts

w Hampshire

mont

County

16

anbeseeninheresultofaststhatmanyoking,movednkee and theng‐termlabo

nayder

Economic

UMaEcon

Concl

Since begsignificanoperationonanannwho overestauranWiththeplantfortheeconofacility wprocess,tduringthwhichwareport,evThis EcoCouncil oParticipaCouncil oCommissthe econdecommi

Impacts of Ver


usion/Su

ginning consntlytotheTrnalelectricitynualbasistorwhelminglynts, retailouclosureofVoverfourdeomiccontribwas fully opetheeconomiheplant’s42asalreadycovenbeforeth

nomic Impaof Governmentsinthisefof Governmeion(VT).Thnomic impacissioning.

rmont Yankee C


ummary

struction inri‐CountyRey‐generatingtheTri‐Couny reside witutlets,andreermontYankecadeswillbebutionsofVeerational. Accontributioyearsofopeonfrontingeheannouncem

act study waents, as partffortincludeents (MA), Seseorganizacts of Verm

Closure

ch

1967 and itgion’seconognuclearpowntyRegion.Tthin the regealestateserkeeinlate20egintoerodeermontYanks soon as 20onsofVermoeration.TheconomicandmentofVerm

as preparedof a Tri‐CoutheBrattlebSouthwest Rationsarecolont Yankee’

ts commissioomy.AspoinwerplantcoThehighcomgion have hervices,amon014,theecone.Asshownkeewillbegi021, dependontYankeewplant’sdrawddemographmontYankee

by the UMaunty effort tboroDevelopRegion Plannllaboratingt’s discontinu

oning in 197ntedoutinthontributed1,mpensationlelped suppongmanyothenomicbenefiinTable1ofin todecreasding on the pwillonlybeawdownwillahicchallengee’sclosure.

ass Donahueto forward epmentCreditning Commioexplorewauation of en

72, Vermonthisreport,V220jobs,incevelsofVermort a rangeers, thatbenitsthathavefthisreportse sharply,aprogressionasmallfractiadverselyaffees,asshown

e Institute foeconomic devtCorporationssion (NH),aystobetternergy gener

t Yankee hasermontYankcludingmultmontYankeeof businessnefit fromthbeenassocia(page9),staascomparedof the decoonofwhatthecttheTri‐Coninthe latte

or the Frankvelopment in(VT),Franand Windhunderstandration activi

17

s contributedkee,asafullytipliereffectse’semployeees, includingeirspendingatedwiththeartingin2015 towhen theommissioningheyhadbeenountyRegionrpartof thi

klin Regionan the regionklinRegionaham Regionaandmitigateities and it’

dys,sgg.e5egnns

aln.alales

Economic

UMaEcon

About

TheUMaUniversitinitiativeneeds ofeconomicmanagemassociatiobridgebeTheEconclientsmin‐depthconstitueprovidingand has csciences,MassBencprospectseconomicFormore

Impacts of Ver


tUs

ssDonahuetyofMassachsthatlinkUMf governmenc and pubment educations,andcoretweentheor

nomicandPumakemoreineconomic iments, plan ecgunbiasedecompleted atelecommuchmarks,anesfortheMascbaseofthe

einformation

rmont Yankee C


Institute(UMhusettsPresMass,otherpnt agencies,lic policyion, researcporations. Ury,innovation

ublicPolicyRnformeddecimpact and inconomic deveconomicanaa number ofnications, heeconomicjoussachusettsestate.

n,visitwww.

Closure

ch

MDI)isthepsident’sOfficpublicandprcorporationanalysis, orh, and evalUMDIdrawsn,andreal‐w

Research(EPisionsaboutndustry studvelopment inalysisonstateconomic stealth care, aurnalthatpreconomy,inc

donahue.um

publicservicece. Establishrivatehighers, and nonprganizationauation to feonitsuniqu

worldapplica

PPR)groupistrategiceco

dies that helpnitiatives, ante‐levelecontudies onmaand transporesentstimelcludingecon

massp.eduand

eoutreachanhed in1971,reducation,aprofit organial developmederal anduepositionwations.

isaleadingponomicandp clients buind prioritizenomicpolicyanufacturingortation. Thlyinformationomicanalys

dwww.mass

ndeconomictheUMDIcandotherexizations. UMment, traininstate agencwithinhighe

providerofapublicpolicyild credibilitye investmenissuesinMag, technologyheir trademaonconcerninesofkeyind

sbenchmarks

cdevelopmeoordinatesmxternalresouMDI provideng, educatioies, nonprofreducation

appliedreseyissues. EPy, gain visibnts. EPPR iassachusettsy, defense inark publicatngtheperformdustriesthat

s.org.

18

ntunitofthemulti‐campuurceswiththees significanon, financiafits, industrytoserveasa

arch,helpingPPRproduceility, educates known fosandbeyondndustries, lifetion is calledmanceofandtmakeupthe

esetalya

gserd,edde

Documents

Economic Impacts of Vermont Yankee Closure Economic... · model, w the study Impacts of Ver ... progressive ty as it end roughout, i ... 4 employment nerating Ope o occur during.2