7
EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August 2011

EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August

EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments

Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August 2011

Page 2: EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August

Scope

Great response to call with comments that:

Reflect international nature of EAD: from France, Germany, Netherlands, Spain, Sweden, UK as well as the US

Come from both technical and archival point of view

127 comments on the spreadsheet – we’ll do further analysis and de-duplication in advance of working meeting in March and share this as well

Range from the very general to the very specific and local

Today then a whistle stop tour of main points!

Page 3: EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August

Revision Process

Calls for:

A XML schema alone, no DTD:

Consistent with current best practice for XML, e.g. camelCasing Use XML and XLINK libraries, e.g. @xml:lang

Updated tag library

Migration script(s) : EAD2002 → EADnew

Page 4: EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August

Fundamentals #1

EAD should:

Be aligned with EAC-CPF in terms of: underlying relationship model element names and semantics – especially <bioghist> but it must remain possible to use EAD alone!

Include data from other XML namespaces: EAC-CPF, MARC21, MARCXML, MODS, TEI, KML, HTML

Allow rich description of digital representations within <dao> or reference to them, including technical and structural metadata

Include or reference user generated data

Page 5: EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August

Fundamentals #2

EAD should be:

Simpler and have fewer tags!

Data rather than text centric: less concerned with the publication of finding aids: fewer

formatting tags, especially <head>, <emph> and <table> more database friendly: fewer opportunities for mixed content

Page 6: EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August

Specific Areas of Tagging #1

<eadheader> should be: simpler less about publishing a title page and more about description

<control>

Structure tags: lose numbered <c> and <dsc> tags make <archdesc> a wrapper tag containing <c> descriptions at

all levels

Page 7: EAD Revision: Response to Call for Comments Bill Stockting: Co-Chair TS-EAD: EAD Roundtable/EAD Revision Forum: SAA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 24 August

Specific Areas of Tagging #2

Wrapper tags: role and purpose of <did> and <physdesc>? Related to role of <descgrp> but one call at least to lose it!

<*name> tags: Allow optional tagging of parts of names including perhaps

subjects and places Allow geo-coding of places

Extend the elements that can be qualified by language /script

Ensure ability to encode span, uncertain and complex dates as well as normalise them