55
A review of the needs of students with ADHD in Trinity College Dublin Declan Reilly & Kieran Lewis Disability Service University of Dublin Trinity College June 2010 1

Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

  • Upload
    vudien

  • View
    214

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

A review of the needs of students with ADHD in Trinity College Dublin

Declan Reilly & Kieran LewisDisability ServiceUniversity of Dublin Trinity College

June 2010

1

Disability Service,Room 2054, Arts Building,Trinity College,Dublin 2, Ireland

Seirbhís do dhaoine faoí mhíchumas,Seomra 2054, Foígneamh na nEalaíon Coláiste na Tríonóide, Baile Átha Cliath 2, Éire

Page 2: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Contents

1. Abstract

2. Introduction and Background

3. The profile of students with ADHD at Trinity College 2000 to 2009

4. Comparison of grades between ADHD & Non-ADHD Students

5. Retention rates for students with ADHD

6. The medical perspective

7. The specific educational impacts

8. Personal statements from the CAO

9. Educational impacts reported in the Trinity Student Profile

10.The social model & neurodiversity

11.Rationale for existing supports and accommodations

12.Development of ADHD specific supportsRationale for ADHD specific supports

13.Conclusions & recommendations for future work

References and Bibliography

Appendices

1. Abstract

2

Page 3: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Research indicates a dramatic increase in students with disabilities attending 3rd level

education, from 1,350 in 1998 to almost 5,000 in 2009, Ahead (2010). In line with this,

the numbers of students with ADHD attending 3rd level education in Ireland have

dramatically increased in the past 5 years. In Trinity College the numbers of students

registering with the Disability Service have increased from less than 5 in 2005 to 18 in

2009. Making the transition from secondary school to college can be especially difficult

for this student group. There is a lack of sufficient knowledge and targeted resources to

adequately respond to the growing numbers and complex needs of this group of

students. Support services have struggled with the range of difficulties and the

increasing number of students presenting with ADHD symptoms. This paper will outline

the current approach used to support students with ADHD within Trinity College and

explore future interventions. We have categorised the supports we offer under the

following headings:

Inclusive curriculum and management of workload

Self Management

Environmental adaptations

ADHD Education and appropriate referral

Orientation to college environments and systems.

We propose that through the appropriate provision of supports within these areas,

students with ADHD can successfully engage with college and prepare for their future.

2. Introduction & Background:

The primary purpose of this paper is to focus on the support needs of students in Trinity

College who present with ADHD. Despite the Disability Service being 10 years old, it is

fair to say that as a service we have only recently recognised students with ADHD as an

emerging group with their own distinct set of difficulties. A secondary purpose of this

paper, therefore, is to set out how the Disability Service has responded to this emerging

group and what work can be done in the future to accommodate the needs of students

with ADHD. Essentially, this paper is part report and part work plan. What follows

reflects the experience of the Disability Service over the past 5 years in supporting

3

Page 4: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

students with ADHD and what areas have been identified where more work is needed.

In general, following medical and diagnostic symptoms, initially ADHD was seen and

treated as a mental health difficulty. However, from an educational point of view, ADHD

is often seen as a specific learning difficulty (SPLD). This conceptual ambiguity in

framing ADHD is important to emphasise because until recently supports for students in

this group were based on what worked for other students; with either a mental health

difficulty such as depression, or a SPLD such as dyslexia. But as the numbers of

students with ADHD have increased, especially over the last two years, it has become

increasingly apparent that more specialised forms of supports are required.

3. The profile of students with ADHD at Trinity College 2000 to 2009

Globally, the prevalence of ADHD in the childhood population is considered to be

between 1% and 5%. In Ireland, this means that the number of children in Ireland

under 14 with ADHD could be up to 40,000 and in the older group aged 15 to 24 it could

be up to 31,000. About 30%-50% of children referred to child psychiatry clinics have

ADHD. It is diagnosed in boys 3-4 times more often than in girls. ADHD symptoms

persist for up to 60% of individuals into adolescence and adulthood (although the

symptom profile may change). The prevalence in adults is estimated at about 2%.

According to the 2006 census there were 143,000 students in 3rd level in the academic

year 04/05. Just 1% of this is 1,430 and 5% is 7,177. But nothing close to these figures

are presenting with ADHD at present, although the figure are set to rise significantly.

Between 2000 and 2005 less than 5 students with ADHD had registered with the

Disability Service in Trinity College. In the next two years another 5 registered. In

2008 there were 9 more students registered with ADHD and in 2009 there were an

additional 11 students. In total, 25 students have registered since 2005 but

significantly the rate has increased from less than 1 a year from 2000 to 2005 to a

rate of 10 a year for 08/09. If this rates stabilises then by 2012 there will be between

40 to 50 students with ADHD.

3.1 Increase in students with ADHD registering with the Disability Service

4

Page 5: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

3.2 Increase in students with ADHD attending 3rd level education in Ireland

3.3 Disclosure of ADHD through CAO and DARE

Applicants to 3rd level education from students with ADHD have significantly increased

over the last 4 years. In 2006, 18 students disclosed ADHD on their CAO application.

In 2007 this figure increased to 27 students, to 40 in 2008, and 92 in 2009. The figures

for 2010 indicate that 82 students have disclosed ADHD through their DARE

application. The latter figure indicates that perhaps a levelling off has been reached.

However, as the criteria for ADHD may change in the DSM V in 2011, this may bring

5

Page 6: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

about significant changes to the current rates of diagnosis in Ireland. The proposed

changes are outline in Section 6 below.

3.4 Status of students

Of the 25 students with ADHD who have registered with the Disability Service since

2005;

6 have graduated

4 are in their final year

5 are in third year

3 are in second year

6 are in first year (this includes 2 Post Graduates)

1 student has withdrawn

6

Page 7: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Typically there are no surprises in the age and gender of students with ADHD.

They are predominantly male aged 18 to 24. Of the 25 students with ADHD who

have registered with the Disability Service since 2005, 17 are male (68%) and 8

are Female (32%). This is a ratio of 2:1, Male: Female. Internationally the

prevalence of males to females with ADHD is around the 4:1 ratio. However, it is

widely accepted that ADHD is under diagnosed in females. Also, in TCD the

student population is 44% male and 56% female so this may account for some of

the apparent gender discrepancy.

3.5 Age range, faculty, entry route & level of students with ADHD registered with the Disability Service

Breakdown by age 19 - 21: 8 26 – 30: 1

22 – 24: 8 30 - 35: 0

25 – 26: 4 36 – 45: 4

7

Page 8: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Breakdown by Faculty

Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences: 18 (including 6 TSM)

Engineering, Maths and Science: 4

Health Sciences: 3

Breakdown by Entry Route

Merit: 18

Supplemental: 5

Mature: 2

Ratio of Undergraduate to Postgraduate

Undergraduate: 22

Postgraduate: 3

8

Page 9: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

4. Comparison of grades between ADHD & Non-ADHD Students

Figures from the TCD website indicate that 52.2% of CAO entrants to TCD had 500

points and above in 2008. Out of 23 students with ADHD 18 got into TCD by meeting

the points requirement for their course. However, the following grade record indicates

that perhaps students with ADHD are lagging behind their peers when it comes to

achieving grades when they get here. We can only say ‘perhaps’ because the sample of

25 is not large enough to be statistically significant. However, it is evident that when

only 16% of a student group are achieving a grade of 2.1 or above compared to 67%, it

is an area worth looking more closely at in future.

  ADHD Students Non-ADHD Students  no. % no. %

1st 1 4 330 15

2.1 3 12 1144 52

2.2 6 24 506 23

Pass 6 24 198 9

Pass PG 2 8 0 0

Fail 1 4 0 0

Yet to do exams 5 20 0 0

Withdrawn 1 4 22 1

Total: 25 100% 2200 100%

5. Retention rates of students with ADHD

In contrast to grades where there is some indication that students with ADHD are

performing significantly lower than their peers, it is noteworthy that as a group they are

more likely to remain in College. The retention rate for the 25 students with ADHD is

92% compared to the overall College rate of 84.5%. As with grade comparison it is

important to remember that a group of 25 is not large enough to be statistically

significant. In addition, the percentage rates are far closer in comparison to the rates of

9

Page 10: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

grades achieved. Despite these clarifications there is a strong sense that students who

are supported are less likely to withdraw from College, even if they are not achieving

grades as high as their peers, Seidman (2005). As this tendency appears throughout

the student with a disability population it should be relatively simple to objectively

compare grade and retention rates. At present, our own data indicates

 

ADHD Students Non-ADHD Studentsno. % no. %

Did not complete: 2 8 341 15.5

Did or are yet to complete: 23 92.0 1859 84.5

Total: 25 2200

6. The medical perspective of ADHD

Although we are a student service operating in a university and our primary aim is in

supporting students to reach their academic goals, we our dependent on the medical

model of disability for the legal and financial backing which that brings. In supporting

students with ADHD this is no different. To recognise a student as having ADHD we

must insist that a consultant psychiatrist or clinical psychologist has provided the

diagnosis and followed the criteria in the DSM IV or ICD – 10. Adhering to this criteria

allows applicants to 3rd level education eligibility for DARE and successful entrants,

funding through the ESF. The full criteria of the DSM IV are listed below in appendix 1.

The DSM V is due to be published in 2011 and there are 3 proposed changes for the

criteria to ADHD:

1) A change of the 3 subtypes as were developed in the DSM IV to 4 subtypes.

2) A change of age of onset from age 7 to age 12.

3) Fewer symptoms required for diagnosis in adult ADHD, down from 6 criteria to 4 for

those aged 17 and older. See appendix 2 below. The 2010 criteria for DARE are in

appendix 3. If these proposed changes for the DSM V are brought in and applied it will

most likely lead to an increase in the rate of diagnosis. This will be particularly the case

in Ireland where it is already considered that ADHD is underdiagnosed.

10

Page 11: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

7. The specific educational impacts of ADHD

Inattention, impulsivity and hyperactivity are widely regarded as the core symptoms of

ADHD. In adulthood, these symptoms are strongly associated with disorganisation,

poor-time-management and inadequate problem-solving skills. (Bramham & Young,

2009). Over the past decade, increasing research has being carried out to establish the

functional implications of ADHD within the college cohort. Reaser et al (2007) using the

Learning and Study Strategies Inventory (LASSI; Weinstein & Palmer, 2002), compared

the scores of students with ADHD, students with other specific learning difficulties and

students without a learning difficulty. They found that students with ADHD scored lower

than the students from the other two groups in the areas of time management,

concentration, selection of main ideas, and test taking strategies.

Lewandowski, Lovett, Codding, and Gordon (2008) compared self-report ratings

regarding ADHD symptoms, academic functioning and text-taking concerns from

students with an ADHD diagnosis and students without ADHD. Students with a

diagnosis of ADHD not only reported more frequent symptoms of the disorder but also

greater problems with academic functioning. Problems included struggles with timed

tests, lack of test completion on time, longer duration to complete assignments, and the

perception of working harder to achieve good grades.

Norwalk et al. (2008) suggest that ADHD symptoms are negatively correlated with

levels of study habits, study skills, and academic adjustment.

Parker & Benedict (2002) claim that executive function impairments associated with

ADHD can give rise to a variety of functional limitations for postsecondary students,

including difficulty developing realistic plans, activating and sustaining effort across

time, remembering goals, and regulating intense emotional reactions to daily

frustrations.

8. Personal statements from the CAO supplementary form

My disability (ADHD) has made concentrating in class and at home very difficult.

My grades have been affected because of my failure to reach deadlines or

complete work due to lack of concentration. Though this situation has improved

11

Page 12: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

since I began receiving learning support I still find school to be a stressful

environment. I think my disability prevents me from using my full potential and I

believe my work is of a lower standard than I am capable of. I also think my

confidence in m schoolwork has been lowered significantly and therefore has

reduced my willingness to participate in class.

This statement is typical of the 75 personal statements from applicants who disclosed

ADHD on their CAO forms in 2009. We identified general areas of academic and non-

academic difficulty from 75 statements. The issues and numbers of students who

reported these difficulties associated with their ADHD are outlined below:

Reported Difficulty Number (n=75) Inattention / Memory 57 (76%)

Poor Organisation /Planning / Time Management 22(29.33%)

Impulsivity 4 (5.33%)

Reading difficulties 9 (12%)

Writing difficulties 13(17.33%)

Dyspraxia 4 (5.33%)

Other Mental Health 1 (1.33%)

Dyslexia 6 (8%)

Due to ADD I have poor organizational skills. Although I spend a lot of time trying

to get organized, I tend to procrastinate and never seem to catch up which is very

frustrating. I have great trouble concentrating for even a short period. I have to

keep trying to bring my mind back to the task in hand. In an exam situation I find it

very hard to work in a room full of people without being distracted. I feel that I

have to work harder than everyone else and then when it comes to exams I don't

do as we as I should. I have a problem with time. It takes me much longer than

other people to read. I often have to reread things. I run out of time in exams,

although I know the answers to the questions. In test situations I get stressed.

Sometimes I misinterpret questions and underperform. This is very disappointing

as I know I have worked hard and should have done well.

12

Page 13: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

9. Educational impacts reported in the Trinity Student Profile (TSP)The Trinity Student Profile is an assessment of a student’s function in their various

college contexts. On the TSP, students identified areas of difficulty on a scale from 0-5,

with 0 being no difficulty in that area and 5 being great difficulty in that area. For the

purposes of identifying the areas of difficulty experienced by students with ADHD, we

show the areas where students most frequently chose either 4 (moderate difficulty) or 5

(great difficulty). These areas were as follows;

Area of Difficulty No. of Students who identified moderate or great difficulty (n=19)

Concentrating during lectures 11 (57.9%)

Maintaining concentration during study 13 (68.4%)

Maintaining good mental stamina /

endurance

11 (57.9%)

Handing up work on time 14 (73.7%)

Dealing with time pressures and

deadlines

15 (78.9%)

Dealing with work overload 13 (68.4%)

Knowing how best to study 12 (63.1%)

Getting started with Study 13 (68.4%)

Goal Setting 10 (52.6%)

Achieving Goals 14 (73.7%)

Organising Information 11 (57.9%)

Structuring and planning the essay 11 (57.9%)

Finishing the work 12 (63.1%)

Writing study notes 10 (52.6%)

Balancing college and work life 10 (52.6%)

The difficulties most frequently identified by the students who completed the TSP

appear consistent with the findings of the research outlined above. Both day to day

time management and planning of workload across terms and academic years appear

to be a challenge for the students within this group. Maintaining concentration in both

13

Page 14: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

study and in the lectures also appears to be difficult for these students.

10.The social model and neurodiversity:

While the DSM IV sets out the diagnostic criteria for what is classified as ADHD and the

medical perspectives of genetics, neuroscience, psychiatry and pharmacology continue

to both research and treat the respective causes and symptoms of ADHD; this ‘medical

model’ of disability is not the only valid perspective to consider.

The social model of disability has its roots in the civil rights movement of 1960’s

America. Adapted in the United Kingdom in the 1970’s most notably by the Union of the

Physically Impaired Against Segregation (UPIAS) and subsequently by other disability

groups and by writers such as Oliver (1990) and Shakespeare (2002), the social model

of disability asserts that it is society that is largely responsible for creating disability by

constructing barriers in the environment. While acknowledging to varying degrees that

physical, sensory and cognitive functioning can be impaired by the physical limitations

of the body; the social model of disability states that it is often only an environmental or

societal barrier that ultimately disables people.

If the medical and social models of disability represent a thesis and antithesis in dealing

with the phenomenon of ‘learning difficulties,’ then the concept of neurodiversity could

be the synthesis that finally leads to a breakthrough in our understanding of learning

difference. Armstrong (2010) in a recently published book on neurodiversity argues that

the human brain is far more complex and diverse than previously thought and that all

behaviours and learning styles occur on a continuum. In a world where ‘brain’ diversity

is vital so that new adaptations can be made at speed; people who think, talk, act and

learn differently should be valued and facilitated. The term was first published by Judy

Singer; ‘‘For me, the key significance of the ‘Autistic Spectrum’ lies in its call for and

anticipation of a politics of Neurological Diversity, or what I want to call ‘Neurodiversity.’”

(Singer, 1999).

Looking at ADHD from the paradigm of neurodiversity it should come as no surprise

that some people will have different thresholds of tolerance for the low level stimulus of

boredom, inaction, solitude and silence; and for the high level stimulus of frantic activity,

14

Page 15: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

rapid visual change, crowds and excessive background noise. In many learning

environments these thresholds are often ignored or poorly controlled with the result that

some people will be unable to function effectively.

The legitimacy of both the social model of disability and the perspective of

neurodiversity is that the right environment can effectively return an individual to the

point where they can function effectively once more. Regardless of the genetic,

biochemical or neurological causes of ADHD and regardless also of whether or not

medication is used; the perspectives of the social model of disability and neurodiversity

are pivotal in identifying and removing environmental barriers in the educational setting.

11.Rationale for existing supports & accommodations

Until recently the rationale for specific methods of intervention carried out in TCD and all

other HEIs by the Disability Service for students with ADHD tended to be based on what

supports and accommodations were commonly provided to students with mental health

difficulties and students with dyslexia. In most cases and to some considerable extent

these supports worked well enough. Typically these supports included:

With the student’s consent, dissemination of a LENS report outlining specific

learning needs and suggested accommodations to relevant tutor and

department.

The provision of extensions on coursework.

Provision of notes before lectures

Use of scribes within lectures and tutorials.

Material in alternate format

The use of Assistive Technology

Subject specific tuition

Extra time in exams

Photocopying /Printer cards

Referral to Unilink Occupational Therapy Support Service

12.Development of ADHD specific supportsHowever, as the numbers of students with ADHD increased over the past 2 years, and

15

Page 16: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

we gained a better understanding of the specific areas that students with ADHD were

experiencing difficulty in, it became ever more apparent that more specialised forms of

support and intervention were required in addition to the baseline supports on offer to

other students. Adopting both the social model of disability and the concept of

neurodiversity it was clear that greater emphasis was needed in looking at the

interaction of the individual student, their environment and the activity they were

involved in. To this end the PEO Model (Person-Environment-Occupation) was

introduced by the Occupational Therapy led support service (Unilink), to identify and

develop specialised supports and to implement them.

Unilink is a confidential, Occupational Therapy based support service for students who

may be experiencing mental health difficulties, including those with ADHD and AS. It is

a student-centred, college based service which offers support directly through face to

face meetings or indirectly through phone, text or email. During the one-on-one

meetings, the student and Occupational Therapist collaboratively work to develop

practical strategies within the PEO framework to help them fulfill their role as a student.

The PEO Model allows therapists within the Unilink Service to address complex

interactions between the person and their environment and to address their participation

and engagement in activities, tasks and roles that are meaningful to them. The focus of

this service is upon the occupational competence of the individual, in other words, the

therapist focuses upon engagement in activities that promote health and well being and

that have value for the individual. An important belief of this model is that people are

naturally motivated to explore their world and demonstrate mastery within it. An

individual’s ability and skill to do what he or she must do in order to meet personal

needs is measure of his or her competence. To do this a person must effectively use

the resources (personal, social and material) available within the living environment. A

second belief of this model is that situations in which people experience success help

them feel good about themselves. This motivates them to face new challenges with

greater confidence. The model proposes that through their daily occupations people

develop a self identity and derive a sense of fulfilment. Fulfilment comes both from

feelings of mastery as well as the accomplishment of goals that have personal meaning.

Over time, these meaningful experiences permit people to develop an understanding of

who they are and what their place is in the world. (Baum, C. M. & Christiansen, C.H.

16

Page 17: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

(2005)

13.Rationale for ADHD specific supports

As mentioned above, the approach to date has been centred on environmental

accommodations which focused on helping students to manage some of their cognitive

deficits. However, although this makes intuitive sense based upon some of the

difficulties experienced by students with ADHD highlighted above, this approach has not

received extensive empirical scrutiny (DuPaul, Weyandt, 2009). However it must be

noted that depriving students of these accommodations as part of a control group, to

provide this empirical data, may not be feasible.

Under the 5 identified headings of inclusive curriculum / management of workload, self

management, environmental adaptations, education and appropriate referral and

orientation to college environments and systems, we will examine the rationale for the

ADHD specific supports we are proposing.

14.1 Inclusive Curriculum / Management of Workload (Occupation)

1. Continue the existing support of providing one-on-one course specific tuition as it is

an effective way to allow students to review course material, as they may have difficulty

learning within lectures and tutorials as a consequence of their concentration difficulties.

This type of support should be provided in conjunction with learning support to facilitate

the development of generic academic skills such as note taking and essay writing.

2. Continue, through the use of the LENS report, the tutor system and if necessary

direct liaison with the department, the provision of extensions to course work across the

academic year.

3. Provide, where possible, course material that is presented through a variety of

accessible methods, so that students with various learning styles can engage with it. It

is essential that multi-sensory teaching methods are used because these are more

likely to suit a variety of learning styles. Lectures should be presented in a way that

17

Page 18: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

uses the visual, auditory, and kinaesthetic modes. Access to lecture notes or podcasts

online, or the opportunity to record lectures using digital recorders provides the student

an opportunity to go through the content in an environment and at a pace that is suited

to their learning style.

4. Provide individual meetings by appropriately trained staff to facilitate the identification

of specific course demands, prioritisation of workload, application newly learned

academic skills, breaking down of workload, and development of a productive routine.

Students with ADHD have identified the accountability provided to students through a

process of goal setting and reviewing within this type of support as an important coping

strategy. (Meaux, Green and Broussard, 2009). We propose that using regular, short

individual meetings, at flexible times around the student’s timetable is an effective

method in helping the student to achieve these goals. The use of individual ‘coaching’

is offered by many colleges in the United States for students with ADHD, with initial

research showing positive outcomes. (Parker & Boutelle, 2009; Swartz, Prevatt, &

Proctor,2005; ) DuPaul et al. (2009) claim however that no empirical studies beyond

qualitative reports of individual case studies could be found to support the use of

coaching. Many courses change in structure over the final two years, involving less

direct lecture and tutorial hours but demanding a more self-directed learning style.

Longer essays and research projects demand higher levels of planning and structuring

of time. We propose that the provision of short and regular meetings to break down the

workload, incorporating a goal based approach as outlined above could prove useful in

meeting the academic demands of these final years.

5. Another method of providing focus and accountability is to utilise peer support

through the use of study groups or a study partner. This also provides a more

interactive and engaging method of learning which may prove useful to students with

ADHD. Meaux, Green and Broussard (2009) highlight that the students with ADHD

within their study group identified peer-relationships as a particularly helpful coping

factor.

Specific supports for inclusive curriculum and management of workload:

18

Page 19: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Podcasting of lectures where possible.

Education of teaching staff and tutors in the area of ADHD and ideas for teaching

methods;

- Consistent lecture plans

- Written outlines of lecture plans

- Accessible format of material

- Limited material on slides

- The provision of templates for assignments online

- Clear reading lists

- Written instructions of assignments at the end of lecture, emailed

or on Webct.

- The use of variety a teaching modes, suitable to various learning

styles

Further uses of AT;

- Use of phone alarms set at 10 minute intervals to remind the

student to re-focus

- Screen rulers

- Changing the background of screens to suit visual stimuli

thresholds.

Study Groups / Study Partner – if possible utilise peer support to provide

structure and accountability to maintain workload.

Individual Unilink support

a. Short meetings at flexible times

b. Prioritisation of workload

c. Breaking down workload into manageable steps

d. Goal-setting

e. Accountability in achieving these goals

f. Development and application of study skills

g. Opportunity to practice using study skills within meetings rather

than a purely didactic approach.

h. Individual problem solving

i. Support in accessing other college based supports

19

Page 20: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

j. Identifying individual course demands and support in applying

above strategies to meet them.

k. Face to face, email and text contact with the student as

appropriate.

l. Organisation of materials, notes etc.

14.2 Self Management (Person)

For many students, coming to college is the first time that they have to take full

responsibility for their self-management. Prior to this point, students have come from

heavily supported environments both at home and school. Reminders from parents,

siblings, teachers, regular daily schedules, relatively small group sizes and daily

checking of homework and attendance are all systems in place at this time. In

describing this phenomenon, Katz (1998) observed that the ADHD brain “uses the

external stimulus to focus or sustain attention as a substitute for its own disregulation of

the mechanisms which mediate the attentional process, whether selective, sustained or

inhibitive.” (p. 3)

As students transition to the postsecondary education, greater demands are placed on

their internal capacity to organize goal-directed behavior. Faced with this environment,

which provides much less external structure, many individuals with ADHD encounter an

intensified need for support services. (Parker & Boutelle, 2009)

Helping students to develop the ability to manage their daily lives in support of their

various roles, although important for all students, is particularly pertinent for students

with ADHD and who are new to the college environment. Many students may have

moved away from the established support structures of friends and family.

As outlined in the above sections, possibly due to the individual’s attentional and

executive functioning difficulties, poor time management and organisation skills become

particularly prominent within the unstructured college context. The lack of regular

deadlines and self-directed nature of many courses, especially in the later years of

college, prove particularly difficult for students with ADHD. The use of various forms of

assistive technology, such as electronic reminders can be very beneficial for individuals

20

Page 21: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

with ADHD.

Integrating socially into the college environment is often extremely challenging for

students with ADHD. Shaw-Zirt, Popali-Lehane, Chaplin and Bergman (2005) found that

college students exhibited lower levels of adjustment, social skills, and self-esteem as

compared to a matched control group. Grenwald-Mayes (2002) found that students

with ADHD experience a lower quality of life relative to their non-ADHD peers. It is

important to facilitate the student to integrate into the social fabric of college through

practical social skills work, problem solving and engagement in leisure activities within

college. Substance use has also been identified as a possible problem area for this

group. It has been found that students, who actively display symptoms of ADHD, are

more likely to engage in substance use than students without current active symptoms.

(Upadhyaya et al., 2005)

Specific self management supports:

Individual Unilink support;

Management of basic needs – diet, substance use / misuse,

finances etc.

Medication – Compliance with medication may need to be

addressed.

Social skills training and development of leisure interests.

Identifying everyday occupations that the student must engage in to

meet the demands of their various roles.

Developing occupational balance within routine.

Support in developing and applying self management strategies to

various contexts within and outside college.

Time Management – scheduling / term planning / developing a

productive routine / Use of AT (Electronic reminders, Google

Calendar etc.)

If necessary, support through course transfer / withdrawal process.

Education around individual sensory needs and application of

strategies to manage these. Strategies may include:

21

Page 22: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Sitting in the front of lectures to reduce distractions

Using earplugs / earphones to block out auditory stimuli

Identify activities that provide sensory input to help the

student to modulate their level of alertness.

Taking breaks from situations that are over-stimulating such

as lectures, busy canteens or coffee shops, or buses / trains.

Taking earlier buses / trains or walk /cycle to avoid crowded

areas.

Arrive early to lectures / tutorials to avoid crowded stairways.

14.3 Environmental adaptations (environment)

Recent research studies have provided evidence of the association between

dysfunction in sensory modulation and ADHD (Mangeot et al, 2001, Dunn and Bennett,

2002). Sensory modulation is the capacity to regulate and organise the degree,

intensity, and nature of responses to sensory input in a graded and adaptive manner, so

that an optimal range of performance and adaption to challenges can be maintained

(Lane et al. 2000). Sensory Modulation Disorder (SMD) presents with responses that

are inconsistent with the demands of the situation, and an inflexibility in adapting to

sensory challenges encountered in daily life, leading to difficulty achieving and

maintaining a developmentally appropriate range of emotional and attentional

responses. (Miller et al., 2007).

Mangeot et al.(2001) propose that a subgroup of individuals with ADHD also have a

sensory modulation disorder. Miller et al. (2007) highlight that the hyperactivity and

impulsivity associated with some types of SMD can easily be confused with, but also

often co-occur with ADHD. Because of their heightened sensitivity to sensory

stimulation, some adults with ADHD are particularly prone to both sensory over- and

under-load. They may be highly sensitive to sensory input such as light, noise,

temperature, tactile sensations, odours, and strong tastes. (Gutman, 2005). Some

individuals may require certain types of sensory input, for example some types of

strenuous exercise, to help modulate this sensory over- or under-load, to allow them to

engage in their desired occupations.

22

Page 23: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

For a student who is sensitive to certain sensory input, adjustment to the postsecondary

education setting may involve functioning in a much more stimulating environment than

they are used to, including larger classes; coping with an unfamiliar roommate; and

living in a residence hall. (Johnson & Irving, 2008) If avoidance and predictability were

coping strategies previously used, a student sensitive to sensory stimulation may find

them harder to use or ineffective in this novel setting (Kinnealey et al, 1995). Students

who were once able to cope and adjust to a changing sensory environment may now

find coping more difficult, which could lead to exacerbation of feelings of depression and

anxiety (Johnson & Irving, 2008). As they get older, students may become more aware

of a mismatch between their own sensory integration characteristics and societal

norms, leading to low self-esteem, limited social participation and dissatisfaction with

quality of life. (Kinnealey et al, 1995; Pfeiffer, 2002)

If identified during assessment, based upon the Adolescent / Adult Sensory Profile

(Brown & Dunn, 2002), we propose the use of activities which provide certain sensory

inputs, based upon Sensory Integration Theory in addition to the use of strategies to

help manage various sensory environments in college. We suggest a combination of

adaptations to sensory environments, where possible, as well as the use of individual

sensory management strategies Educating the individual about their sensory needs is

important in helping them to develop the ability to manage various sensory

environments such as libraries, common areas, lecture halls, crowded stairways, coffee

shops and exam halls.

The provision of a distraction-free study environment is an accommodation regularly

suggested for students with ADHD. We suggest that this may be appropriate for some

students but not all. Some students require complete silence while some will study

better with some background noise. Some students study best in a dimly lit

environment, while others require a high level of lighting. Having a study space in

which the student can control the amount of sensory stimulation (noise, light,

temperature etc.), allows students who are sensitive to sensory input to create a

suitable environment. Study spaces such as these would also prove effective for

students with ADHD who do not have a SMD, as it would allow them to create a study

23

Page 24: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

space suitable to their individual needs learning needs.

We also suggest the provision of smaller distraction free exam venues, which is

another accommodation commonly offered by colleges to students with ADHD, but we

propose that an increased awareness of what type of sensory environment these

smaller venues are, is required. Is the student who is sensitive to noise taking an exam

in a venue beside a busy road or is there a ticking clock or buzzing light in the venue? Is

the venue cluttered with academic materials? Is the lighting appropriate? An

understanding of the student’s sensory needs is important for both the student and

college to have.

Specific environmental adaptations:

The provision of study carrels or separate study rooms.

The provision of distraction free exam venues based upon students’ sensory

needs.

Advice on setting up study space at home:

Appropriate to sensory needs

Removing distractions (computer, radio, t.v.,clutter)

Organising materials

14.4 Education and appropriate referral

Many students entering college may already have a diagnosis of ADHD and have

become accustomed to their possible difficulties, and may have developed effective

coping strategies. Some students however may only receive a diagnosis when they

come to college. The process of providing information and discussing possible

academic and non-academic functional implications as a result of ADHD is important for

students with a recent diagnosis. If there are possible sensory processing issues as

discussed earlier, then helping the student to develop an understanding of their sensory

needs is also necessary in developing their ability to function within the college context.

In interviews carried out by Meaux, Green and Broussard (2009) students with ADHD

identified four factors that helped them gain insight about their difficulties. They were:

24

Page 25: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

(1) learning through experience; (2) seeking information; (3) acknowledging their ADHD;

and (4) opening up. Often students react with a sense of relief when they receive a

diagnosis of ADHD as it helps them gain an understanding of why they experience

difficulty in certain situations. As Bramham & Young (2009) claim it is important to help

the student to understand that although there is no ‘magic cure’ for ADHD, it is possible

to change how they cope with it and to maximise specific strengths that they have.

The link between ADHD and other mental health difficulties is now well established.

Studies have shown a range of co-morbid conditions associated with ADHD such as

bipolar disorders (Bernaldi et al., 2009; Halmoy et al., 2009), anxiety (Edel at al., Dineen

& Gallagher, 2009), oppositional and conduct disorders (Alvaani and Dalvand, 2009;

Franc et al., 2009), and autism spectrum disorder (Dineen and Fitzgerald, 2009; Roy et

al.,2009; Sinzig et al. 2009) (from Thorne and Reddy, 2009). Education around these

mental health difficulties and management of functional problems that the student may

be experiencing as a result of a these difficulties, is essential in facilitating the student to

engage in their chosen occupations. This can be done through the established mental

health support services within Unilink, the college health centre and the student

counselling service.

Specific education / appropriate referral supports:

Education in the area of ADHD and its possible functional implications.

Education in other possible mental health or specific learning difficulties and

development of self-management strategies related to functional difficulties

associated with them. This can be done through Unilink.

Appropriate referral to other Disability Service Staff, Counselling, and College

Health services.

14.5 Orientation to college environments and systems

As outlined above the transition from the supported and structured environments of

secondary school and home to college can prove difficult for students with ADHD.

Trinity is a very large establishment with many different physical environments,

25

Page 26: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

administrative departments, academic and non-academic support services and IT

systems. The college offers orientation programs during the weeks leading up to the

start of term, but we suggest that individual orientation, specific to the student’s course,

relevant supports and interests, would prove useful in helping students with ADHD to

integrate into college. For many students, this will be the first occasion that they will be

advocating for themselves to various departments and some may need to be supported

through this process.

Specific supports for orientation to college environments and systems:

Orientation to physical environments such as libraries, lecture theatres,

administration offices and social settings around college.

Connection to support services – academic / non-academic

Instruction on IT services and course specific websites

Support in accessing college support and administration systems through

development of advocacy and assertiveness within Unilink.

14.Conclusions and recommendations for future work

The TCD Disability Service have developed significantly in the past 10 years. A

consequence of the success of access initiatives such as DARE is that far more ‘non

26

Page 27: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

traditional’ students are entering 3rd level education. The Disability Service are aware

of the need to comply with Equality and Disability legislation; and to uphold academic

standards and College regulations. Utilising the medical perspective is essential for

these purposes. But a service based only on the medical model of disability would be

hopelessly inadequate. By focusing on the needs of the students who present

themselves for support we must take pragmatic steps to provide reasonable

accommodations. The social model of disability allows us to support students by

solving problems that exist in the interaction between neurodiverse students, complex

environments and highly specialised tasks. The Unilink service provides a vehicle for

this problem solving and we have identified 5 specific areas for further development in

the provision of supports for students with ADHD. As is illustrated in this paper,

research is ongoing to evaluate the efficacy of some of the approaches used to support

students with ADHD. The Disability Service are currently implementing the above

proposed supports and accommodations and will be evaluating their effectiveness over

the foreseeable future.

The empirical study of ADHD in the college student is in its infancy compared to the

vast body of literature concerning ADHD in children and adolescents (DuPaul et al.,

2009). In addition, studies are needed to determine whether educational

accommodations offered to students with ADHD are truly effective and whether some

interventions are more effective than others. This paper has outlined the profile of and

the significant academic data relating to students with ADHD in TCD. The types of

supports offered to students with ADHD within the Disability Service have been

discussed and the areas where more work is required have been identified.

References:

AHEAD http://www.ahead.ie/inclusiveeducation_accessingthirdlevel.php (accessed

May 11th 2010).

27

Page 28: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Armstrong,T.

http://www.newhorizons.org/spneeds/inclusion/information/armstrong.htm (accessed

May 11th 2010).

Baum, C.M.& Christiansen, C.H. (2005) Person-environment-occupation-

performance: An occupation-based framework for practice. In C. H. Christiansen.

C.M. Baum, and J. Bass-Haugen (Eds.), Occuational Therapy: Performance,

participation, and well being (3rd ed.). THorofare, NJ: Slack Incorporated.

Bramham, J., Young, S., (2007) ADHD in Adults; A Psychological Guide to Practice.

John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., West Sussex,England.

DuPaul, G., Weyandt,L., O’Dell, S.M., Varejao, M., (2009). College Students with

ADHD. Current status and future directions. Journal of Attention Disorders, 13(3),

234-250.

Dunn, W., Bennett, D, (2002) Patterns of sensory processing in children with

attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Occupational Therapy Journal of Research,

22(1), 4-16.

Gutman, S.A., Szczepanski, M., (2005) Adults with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity

Disorder: Implications for Occupational Therapy Intervention. Occupational Therapy

in Mental Health, 21(2), 13-38.

Himanshu P. Upadhyaya, Kelly Rose, Wei Wang, Kathleen O'Rourke, Brian Sullivan,

Deborah Deas, Kathleen T. Brady. (2005) Journal of Child and Adolescent

Psychopharmacology., 15(5): 799-809.

Johnson, M.E., Irving, R., (2008) Implications of Sensory Defensiveness in a College

Population. Sensory Integration Special Interest Quarterly / American Occupational

Therapy Association. 31(2), 1-3

Katz, L.J. (1998, March/April). Transitioning into college for the student with ADHD.

The ADHD Challenge, 12, 3-4.

28

Page 29: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Kinnealey, M. Oliver, B. Wilbarger, P. (1995) A phenomenological study of sensory

defensiveness in adults. American Journal of Occupational Therapy,49(5), 444-51.

Lane, S. J., Miller, L. J., & Hanft, B. E. (2000). Toward a consensus in terminology in

sensory integration theory and practice: Part 2: Sensory integration patterns of

function and dysfunction. Sensory Integration

Special Interest Section Quarterly, 23, 1–3.

Lewandowski, L.J., Lovett, B.J., Codding, R.S. & Gordon, M. (2008). Symptoms of

ADHD and academic concerns in college students with and without ADHD

diagnoses. Journal of Attention Disorders, 12, 156-161.

Mangeot, S.D., Miller, L.J., McIntosh, D.N., McGrath-Clarke, J., Simon, J.,

Hagerman, R.J., Goldson, E. (2001) Sensory modulation dysfunction in children with

attention-deficit-hyperactivity disorder. Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology,

43:399-406

Meaux, J.B., Green, A., Broussard., (2009) ADHD in the college student: a block in

the road. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing. 16, 248-256

Miller,L.J., Anzalone,M.E., Lane,S.J., Cermak,S.A., Osten. E.T.(2007) Concept

Evolution in Sensory Integration: A Proposed Nosology for Diagnosis. American

Journal of Occupational Therapy, 61(2), 135-140.

Norwalk, K., Norvilitis, J.M., & McLean, M.G., (2008). ADHD symptomatology and its

relationship to factors associated with college adjustment. Journal of Attention

Disorders, 1-8

Oliver, M. The Politics of Disablement. Basingstoke, Macmillan (1990)

Parker, D., Benedict, K.B., (2002) Students with ADHD Assessment and

Intervention: Promoting Successful Transitions for College Assessment for Effective

Intervention, 27 (3)

29

Page 30: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Parker, D.,Boutelle, K. (2009) Executive Function Coaching for College Students

with Learning Disabilities and ADHD: A New Approach for Fostering Self-

Determination. Learning Disabilities and Research and Practice, 24(4), 204-215

Reaser, A., Prevatt, F., Petscher, Y. & Proctor, B. (2007). The learning and study

strategies of college students with ADHD. Psychology in the Schools, 44, 627-638.

Seidman, A. (ed.) College student retention: Formula for student success. Westport,

CT: ACE/Praeger (2005).

Shakespeare, T., Watson, N., The social model of disability: an outdated ideology? Research in Social Science and Disability Volume 2, pp. 9-28 (2002).

Singer, J. Why Can’t You Be Normal for Once in Your Life in Marian Corker and

Sally French (eds.), Disability Discourse, Buckingham, England:  Open University

Press, 1999, p. 64

Trinity College Dublin, http://www.tcd.ie/Communications/Facts/student-numbers.php

(Accessed May 11th 2010).

Thome, J., Reddy, D.P., (2009) The Current status of research into attention deficit

hyperactivity disorder: proceedings of the 2nd international congress on ADHD: from

childhood to adult disease. ADHD Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorders, 1(2),

165-174.

Weyandt, L.L., DuPaul, G. (2008) ADHD in College Students: Developmental

Findings. Developmental Disabilities Research Review, 14, 311-319

Upadhyaya HP, Rose K, Wang W, O'Rourke K, Sullivan B, Deas D, Brady KT.

Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, medication treatment, and substance use

patterns among adolescents and young adults. Journal of Child and Adolescent

Psychopharmacology. 2005;15:799-809.

30

Page 31: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Appendix 1:

Diagnostic criteria for Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder

According to the DSM-IV-R, the following five criteria (A-E) must be met in order for

a diagnosis of ADHD to be made:

A. Either (1) or (2):

(1) six (or more) of the following symptoms of inattention have persisted for at least

six months to a degree that is maladaptive and inconsistent with developmental

level.

31

Page 32: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Inattention

a. often fails to give close attention to details or makes

careless mistakes in school work, work, or other activities

b. often has difficulty sustaining attention in tasks or play

activities

c. often does not seem to listen when spoken to directly

d. often does not follow through on instructions and fails to

finish schoolwork, chores, or duties in the workplace (not

due to oppositional behavior or failure to understand

directions)

e. often has difficulty organizing tasks and activities

f. often avoids, dislikes, or is reluctant to engage in tasks

that require sustained mental effort (such as schoolwork

or homework)

g. often loses things necessary for tasks or activities (e.g.,

toys, school assignments, pencils, books or tools)

h. is often easily distracted by extraneous stimuli

i. is often forgetful in daily activities

(2) six (or more) of the following symptoms of hyperactivity-impulsivity have

persisted for at least six months to the degree that is maladaptive and inconsistent

with developmental level.

Hyperactivity

a. often fidgets with hands or feet or squirms in seat

b. often leaves seat in classroom or in other situations in

which remaining seated is expected

c. often runs about or climbs excessively in situations in

which it is inappropriate (in adolescents or adults, may be

limited to subjective feeling of restlessness)

d. often has difficulty playing or engaging in leisure activities

quietly

e. is often "on the go" or often acts as if "driven by a motor"

32

Page 33: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

f. often talks excessively

Impulsivity

b. often blurts out answers before questions have been

completed

c. often has trouble awaiting turn

d. often interrupts or intrudes on others (e.g., butts into

conversations or games)

B. Some hyperactive-impulsive, or inattentive symptoms that caused

impairment were present before age 7 years;

C. Some impairment from the symptoms is present in two or more settings

(e.g., at school [or work] and at home;

D. There must be clear evidence of clinically significant impairment in

social, academic, or occupational functioning;

E. The symptoms do not occur exclusively during the course of a

Pervasive Developmental Disorder, Schizophrenia, or other Psychotic

Disorder and are not better accounted for by another mental disorder

(e.g., Mood Disorder, Anxiety Disorder, Dissociative disorder, or a

Personality Disorder).

(DSM-IV APA 1994)

Appendix 2: DSM V 314.0x

Diagnostic Criteria for Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder

http://www.dsm5.org/ProposedRevisions/Pages/proposedrevision.aspx?rid=383#

(Accessed June 2nd 2010)

The disorder consists of a characteristic pattern of behavior and cognitive functioning

that is present in different settings where it gives rise to social and educational or

work performance difficulties. The manifestations of the disorder and the difficulties

that they cause are subject to gradual change being typically more marked during

times when the person is studying or working and lessening during vacation.

33

Page 34: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Superimposed on these short-term changes are trends that may signal some

deterioration or improvement with many symptoms becoming less common in

adolescence. Although irritable outbursts are common, abrupt changes in mood

lasting for days or longer are not characteristic of ADHD and will usually be a

manifestation of some other distinct disorder.

In children and young adolescents, the diagnosis should be based on information

obtained from parents and teachers. When direct teacher reports cannot be

obtained, weight should be given to information provided to parents by teachers that

describe the child’s behavior and performance at school. Examination of the patient

in the clinician’s office may or may not be informative. For older adolescents and

adults, confirmatory observations by third parties should be obtained whenever

possible.

A.   Either (1) and/or (2).

1.  Inattention: Six (or more) of the following symptoms have persisted for at least 6

months to a degree that is inconsistent with developmental level and that impact

directly on social and academic/occupational activities. Note: for older

adolescents and adults (ages 17 and older), only 4 symptoms are required. The

symptoms are not due to oppositional behavior, defiance, hostility, or a failure to

understand tasks or instructions.

(a)  Often fails to give close attention to details or makes careless mistakes in

schoolwork, at work, or during other activities (for example, overlooks or

misses details, work is inaccurate).

(b)  Often has difficulty sustaining attention in tasks or play activities (for

example, has difficulty remaining focused during lectures, conversations, or

reading lengthy writings).

(c)  Often does not seem to listen when spoken to directly (mind seems

elsewhere, even in the absence of any obvious distraction).

(d)  Frequently does not follow through on instructions (starts tasks but quickly

loses focus and is easily sidetracked, fails to finish schoolwork, household

chores, or tasks in the workplace).

(e)  Often has difficulty organizing tasks and activities. (Has difficulty

managing sequential tasks and keeping materials and belongings in order.

34

Page 35: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Work is messy and disorganized. Has poor time management and tends to

fail to meet deadlines.)

(f)   Characteristically avoids, seems to dislike, and is reluctant to engage in tasks that require sustained mental effort (such as schoolwork or

homework or, for older adolescents and adults, preparing reports, completing

forms, or reviewing lengthy papers).

(g)  Frequently loses objects necessary for tasks or activities (e.g., school

assignments, pencils, books, tools, wallets, keys, paperwork, eyeglasses, or

mobile telephones).

(h)  Is often easily distracted by extraneous stimuli. (for older adolescents and

adults may include  unrelated thoughts.).

(i)   Is often forgetful in daily activities, chores, and running errands (for older

adolescents and adults, returning calls, paying bills, and keeping

appointments).

2.  Hyperactivity and Impulsivity: Six (or more) of the following symptoms have

persisted for at least 6 months to a degree that is inconsistent with developmental

level and that impact directly on social and academic/occupational activities.

Note: for older adolescents and adults (ages 17 and older), only 4 symptoms are

required. The symptoms are not due to oppositional behavior, defiance, hostility,

or a failure to understand tasks or instructions.

(a)  Often fidgets or taps hands or feet or squirms in seat.

(b)  Is often restless during activities when others are seated (may leave his or

her place in the classroom, office or other workplace, or in other situations

that require remaining seated).

(c)  Often runs about or climbs on furniture and moves excessively in

inappropriate situations. In adolescents or adults, may be limited to feeling

restless or confined.

(d)  Is often excessively loud or noisy during play, leisure, or social activities.

(e)  Is often “on the go,” acting as if “driven by a motor.” Is uncomfortable being

still for an extended time, as in restaurants, meetings, etc. Seen by others as

being restless and difficult to keep up with.

(f)   Often talks excessively.

35

Page 36: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

(g)  Often blurts out an answer before a question has been completed. Older

adolescents or adults may complete people’s sentences and “jump the gun”

in conversations.

(h)  Has difficulty waiting his or her turn or waiting in line.

(i)   Often interrupts or intrudes on others (frequently butts into conversations,

games, or activities; may start using other people’s things without asking or

receiving permission, adolescents or adults may intrude into or take over

what others are doing).

(j)   Tends to act without thinking, such as starting tasks without adequate

preparation or avoiding reading or listening to instructions. May speak out

without considering consequences or make important decisions on the spur

of the moment, such as impulsively buying items, suddenly quitting a job, or

breaking up with a friend.

(k)   Is often impatient, as shown by feeling restless when waiting for others and

wanting to move faster than others, wanting people to get to the point,

speeding while driving, and cutting into traffic to go faster than others.

(l)   Is uncomfortable doing things slowly and systematically and often

rushes through activities or tasks.

(m) Finds it difficult to resist temptations or opportunities, even if it means

taking risks (A child may grab toys off a store shelf or play with dangerous

objects; adults may commit to a relationship after only a brief acquaintance or

take a job or enter into a business arrangement without doing due diligence).

B.   Several noticeable inattentive or hyperactive-impulsive symptoms were present

by age 12.

C.   The symptoms are apparent in two or more settings (e.g., at home, school or

work, with friends or relatives, or in other activities).

D.   There must be clear evidence that the symptoms interfere with or reduce the

quality of social, academic, or occupational functioning.

E.   The symptoms do not occur exclusively during the course of schizophrenia or

another psychotic disorder and are not better accounted for by another mental

disorder (e.g., mood disorder, anxiety disorder, dissociative disorder, or a

personality disorder).

36

Page 37: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Specify Based on Current Presentation

Combined Presentation: If both Criterion A1 (Inattention) and Criterion A2

(Hyperactivity-Impulsivity) are met for the past 6 months.

Predominately Inattentive Presentation: If Criterion A1 (Inattention) is met but

Criterion A2 (Hyperactivity-Impulsivity) is not met and 3 or more symptoms from

Criterion A2 have been present for the past 6 months.

Predominately Hyperactive/Impulsive Presentation: If Criterion A2 (Hyperactivity-

Impulsivity) is met and Criterion A1 (Inattention) is not met for the past 6 months.

Inattentive Presentation (Restrictive): If Criterion A1 (Inattention) is met but no

more than 2 symptoms from Criterion A2 (Hyperactivity-Impulsivity) have been

present for the past 6 months.

Appendix 3:

DARE Screening Criteria – Attention Deficit (Hyperactivity) Disorder

www.accesscollege.ie (Accessed May 11th 2010).

Accepted Medical Consultant/Specialist

Students should ideally be diagnosed within a

multi disciplinary team setting. Students can be

diagnosed by an appropriately qualified

psychiatrist/psychologist who is a member of their

respective professional or regulatory body.

Evidence of Disabil i ty All applicants should complete the Evidence of

37

Page 38: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

Disability Form 2010.

Applicants who have an existing report

completed by the accepted Medical

Consultant/Specialist may submit this report.

The report must have been completed within

the appropriate timeframe and must contain the

same detail as the Evidence of Disability Form.

Age of ReportWhile there is no age limit on diagnostic evidence

submitted it is advisable to submit a recent report.

Other Disabil i t iesWhere there are two or more co-existing

disabilities, then evidence of each disability must

be submitted for consideration under DARE.

Personal Statement and Academic Reference

Student’s personal statement should outline

the impact of disability on their academic and

educational experience to date.

The Academic Reference provides background

information on the student’s educational

experience, stating the educational impact of

the disability and describing the need for any

supports and/or accommodations in third level.

DARE Eligibil i ty

The applicant is eligible for consideration once

the appropriate professional has provided a

diagnosis of Attention Deficit Disorder/Attention

Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.

38

Page 39: Dyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the … Docs/Conf... · Web viewDyscalculia in Higher Education: A Review of the Literature Author TCD Last modified by Declan Reilly

39