Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    1/22

    Oregons Early Childhood

    Health and Mental Health Consultation

    System Planning

    A report to Health Matters

    From the Child Care Health and MentalHealth Consultation

    Priority Action Work Group

    December 2010

    Print

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    2/22

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    3/22I

    We wish to acknowledge the following individuals and organizations

    for their vision, expertise and guidance in creating this report and the

    underlying documents, which can be viewed at

    http://healthoregon.org/hcco.

    Name Agency

    Beth Green .............................................. NPC Research

    Betty Shuler ............................................. Neighbor Impact

    Bruce Spilde ............................................ Multnomah County Mental Health and

    Addictions Services

    Candace Artemenko ................................ Oregon Center for Children and Youth with

    Special Health Needs

    Charlotte Schley ...................................... Oregon Center for Children and Youth with

    Special Health Needs

    Cynthia Hurkes........................................ Oregon Child Care Resource and Referral Network

    David Anderson ....................................... Oregon Public Health Division Offi ce of

    Family Health

    David Willis ............................................. The Artz Center

    Dawn Sly ................................................. Mental health consultant

    Deanna Humphry ................................... Oregon Public Health Division Offi ce of

    Family Health

    Deborah Murray ..................................... Peninsula Childrens Center

    Dell Ford .................................................. Oregon Head Start Collaboration Project

    Diana Stotz .............................................. Washington County Commission on Children

    and Families

    Diane Ponder ........................................... Zero To Three

    Diane Smith............................................. Child Care Resource and Referral of

    Clackamas County

    Dianna Pickett ......................................... Oregon Public Health Division Offi ce of

    Family Health

    Donalda Dodson ..................................... Oregon Child Development Coalition

    Farzana Siddiqui ...................................... Community Action Head StartWashington County

    Gerry Morgan ......................................... Early Childhood Cares

    Gil Nicholson-Nelson .............................. Valley Mental Health

    Ginna Oliver ............................................ Oregon Department of Education

    Gracie Lee ............................................... Multnomah County Health Department

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    4/22II

    Janelle McCleod ...................................... Clackamas County Health Department

    Jean Johnson ............................................ Oregon Public Health Division Offi ce of

    Family Health

    Jeanette Ewald ......................................... Oregon Child Care Resource and

    Referral Network

    Jennifer Haake ......................................... Early Intervention, Klamath Falls, CitySchool District

    Jennifer Olsen .......................................... Oregon Child Development Coalition

    Jill Archer ................................................. Washington County Mental Health Organization

    Jill Dale .................................................... Oregon Addictions and Mental Health Division

    Jin Song ................................................... Oregon Public Health Division

    Offi ce of Family Health

    Joanne Trzcinski ...................................... Oregon Addictions and Mental Health Division

    Joy Rowley ............................................... Oregon Child Development Coalition

    Judy Cleave .............................................. Marion County Health Department

    Julie Dotson ............................................. Mental health consultant, Central Oregon

    Karen Hamilton .................................... Head Start of Lane County

    Karen VanTassel ...................................... Oregon Commission on Children and Families

    Kathryn Falkenstern ................................ Morrison Child & Family Services

    Kathy Seubert ......................................... Oregon Addictions and Mental Health Division

    Katrina Miller ......................................... Morrison Child & Family Services

    Kevin Burns ............................................. Family Relief Nursery

    Katrina Miller ......................................... Morrison Child & Family Services

    Kevin Burns ............................................ Family Relief Nursery

    Kim Ashley .............................................. Oregon Child Care Resource and

    Referral Network

    Kim Cardona .......................................... Oregon Commission on Children and Families

    Kristen Becker ........................................ Oregon Public Health Division Offi ce of

    Family Health

    Laurie Danahy ......................................... Oregon Department of Education Head Start

    Lucia Aleman .......................................... Oregon Child Development CoalitionLynne Reinoso ......................................... Oregon Department of Education Child Nutrition

    Program

    Maria Everhart ........................................ The Childrens Institute

    Marilyn Berardinelli ................................ Oregon Center for Children and Youth with

    Special Health Needs

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    5/22III

    Marilyn Hartzell ...................................... Oregon Center for Children and Youth with

    Special Health Needs

    Marilyn Kennelly .................................... Yamhill County Commission on Children

    and Families

    Mark Anderson ........................................ Oregon Child Care Resource and

    Referral NetworkMarti Franc ............................................. Clackamas County Health Department

    Mary Rumbaugh ..................................... Clackamas County Mental

    Health Organization

    Maureen Short, RN................................. UCAN Head Start assistant director

    Michele Limpens ..................................... Morrison Child & Family Services

    Patricia Blasco ......................................... Oregon Health & Science University, Portland

    State University, Western Oregon University,

    Early Childhood Inclusion Project

    Patricia Trow ........................................... Oregon Child Development CoalitionPatti Blasco .............................................. Portland State University,

    Western Oregon University

    Paula Zaninovich ..................................... Multnomah County Mental Health and Addiction

    Services Division

    Shawna M. Rodrigues ............................. Clackamas County Childrens Commission

    Head Start

    Stacy Liskey ............................................. Oregon Child Care Resource and

    Referral Network

    Ted Keys .................................................. Department of Human Services Children Adultsand Families Division

    Teresa Cooper ......................................... Washington State Department of Health

    Terry Butler ............................................ Inclusive Child Care Program

    Tom Olsen ............................................... Employment Department Child Care Division

    Tom Udell ................................................ Western Oregon University

    Wendy Nakatsukasa-Ono ........................ Child Care Health Consultation

    Network Support

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    6/22IV

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    7/221

    Executive summary

    Quality child care is essential to the health and safety of our children, our

    families and our society. Daily experiences, both positive and negative, are the

    raw materials that build childrens brain structure and functioning, includingintelligence and personality. Because the majority of young children are in child

    care, early care and education providers play an essential role in

    their development.

    Children face some important challenges in early care and education settings while

    their parents are working or away. Care environments and practices powerfully

    affect their safety, health and well-being. For example:

    Children attending early childhood care and education (ECCE) programsare at much higher risk of exposure to infectious diseases, gastrointestinal

    illness, upper respiratory disease and ear infections than those cared for at

    home

    They are exposed to challenging behavior or engage in challenging

    behavior with both adults and other children.

    Children are cared for by a work force that receives low wages, has a

    historically low level of education with frequent turnover, and works inrelative isolation with limited infrastructure for support.

    To address these needs, the Child Care Health and Mental Health Consultation

    Priority Action Work Group (PAWG) proposes a statewide early childhood health

    and mental health consultation system to provide services in early childhood care

    and education settings. This system must be developed based on a clear vision for

    system infrastructure, a consultation delivery model and consultation services. This

    report outlines the essential system elements, as well as a logic model summarizing

    resources and actions to reach the desired outcomes of an effective child care

    consultation system. The PAWG report also describes the infrastructure that

    supports the consultation work force with training and technical assistance and

    proposes an evaluation strategy to measure effects. Finding sustainable funding is

    essential and likely to be challenging in the current fiscal environment. Finally, this

    report explores the costs of services and potential funding sources. It is intended as

    a condensed description and summary with recommended next steps. In addition,

    the PAWG developed a variety of products available online at

    http://healthoregon.org/hcco.

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    8/222

    The PAWG recommends the following steps in the development of a

    consultation system:

    Build consensus on priority and direction with the Health Matters, Early

    Learning Matters and Family Matters committees and the Early Childhood

    Matters Advisory Council.

    Ensure that early childhood health and mental health are included as

    priorities in current health reform activities.

    Conduct a comprehensive statewide assessment of the health and mental

    health consultation services now available in the state to use in program

    development and as a baseline to measure the effect of future efforts. The

    assessment should include a focus on gaps in services, as well as information

    on target population, model designs, funding resources, evidence-based

    practices used, and evaluation processes and tools.

    Explore sustainable funding strategies to address the need for consultation in

    multiple types of early care and education programs.

    Explore short- and long-term strategies for staging services as funding

    is available.

    Introduction

    Quality child care is essential to the health and safety of our children, our families

    and our society. Early childhood care and education (ECCE) enables parents to

    work, attend school, contribute to the well-being of their families and participate in

    their communities. Skilled child care providers play a key role in young childrenslives creating opportunities for them to learn new skills, develop friendships and

    prepare for a lifetime of success in education, relationships and careers.

    An enormous number of children in the United States 63 percent are in some

    type of formal or informal child care; 18.5 million of those children are under the

    age of 5. Nationally, preschoolers spent an average of 32 hours per week in child care.1

    In Oregon only 32.9 percent of children in care under the age of 4 were in paid (usually

    licensed) child care in 2008.2

    Childrens daily experiences have long-term effects on them, their families and

    society. The ECCE work force, composed of teachers working in child carecenters and caregivers working in homes, is foundational to young childrens daily

    experiences. Warm, nurturing and stimulating interactions between teachers/

    caregivers and children is the single most important predictor of positive child

    outcomes from child care and early education. Though only 10 percent of child

    care is estimated to be of poor quality, most of child care is considered of fair or

    minimal quality, which does not offer the ideal safe and nurturing environment for

    these children.3 Clearly, there is work to be done to improve child care quality.

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    9/223

    Children in safe and healthy environments are more likely to grow into healthy

    adults. Warm, nurturing and attuned responses from caring adults within

    the context of sound physical health provide the foundation for early brain

    development and are associated with a broad range of abilities and learning

    capacities. Infants and young childrens early relationships, family, community and

    culture support their healthy growth and development.Skilled ECCE providers can preserve, protect and promote childrens health

    through daily opportunities for healthy meals and regular physical activity;

    protection from communicable disease by sanitary practices and community

    connections to health insurance and to routine health, mental health and dental

    care services as needed.

    Research consistently suggests that higher levels of provider education and

    training predict program quality in child care settings.4 Professional development

    encompasses education, training and related activities such as consultation. Most

    of the related activities involve individualized instruction and are sometimes

    described as relationship-based professional development. Education and

    training that increase positive interactions between adults and children affect

    multiple areas of the childrens development.

    Problem

    Although the professionalism of child care is gaining momentum, this work

    force which fills such a critical function for families and our society needs

    substantially more support.There are major problems facing children in early care and education settings.

    Children attending ECCE programs are at much higher risk of exposure to

    infectious diseases, gastrointestinal illness, upper respiratory disease and ear

    infections than those cared for at home.4 Caregivers must provide healthy, safe,

    nurturing environments while simultaneously responding to the challenges

    posed by increasingly diffi cult behaviors from young children in their care. This

    demanding work is done by caregivers who are paid a marginal wage, generally

    work in isolation and are characterized by historically low levels of education and

    high job turnover.

    Parents, as well as early childhood care and education (ECCE) providers, have

    concerns regarding the experiences of children in ECCE settings and the quality

    of their care, health and safety. Of all Oregon parents with children in ECCE

    settings, 16 percent reported their children did not always feel safe in child

    care. Only 44 percent agreed with the statement, My child always got a lot of

    attention, and 53 percent agreed that My childs caregiver/teacher was always

    open to new learning.5

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    10/224

    Children arrive in child care with health risks and challenges. Poor health in

    children can lead to chronic disease as adults. Obesity, hypertension and diabetes

    are on the rise in children. In the United States, 11 percent of children age 2 to

    5 are considered obese. In Oregon in 2005 nearly 25 percent of Oregon eighth

    graders were overweight or at risk for being overweight.7 More than 20 percent of

    Oregons 2-year-olds are not fully immunized against serious childhood diseases.8

    There was a drop in the number of uninsured children (under the age of 18)

    between 2008 and 2009 from approximately 109,200 (12.5 percent) to 90,500 (10.4

    percent); however, the uninsured rate for Oregons children under the age of 18 was

    higher than that of 40 other states in 2009.9

    It is estimated that between 9 percent and 14 percent of children from birth to 5

    years of age experience social and emotional problems that negatively affect their

    functioning and development. These are expressed by behaviors such as aggression

    and tantrums or through withdrawal and lack of engagement. According to the

    Center on the Social and Emotional Foundations for Early Learning(CSEFEL), therate of expulsion for preschool children is three times that of school-age children.

    In very young children these behaviors can be severe enough to overwhelm their

    caregivers and warrant their removal from their preschool programs, setting into

    motion a cascade of negative experiences.6

    How can we best solve these problems and facilitate a system of early childhood

    care and education that contributes to childrens healthy development? Because

    childrens physical, cognitive and emotional capabilities are integrated, early

    care and education practices are most successful when they incorporate health

    and mental health approaches. The positive effects of this holistic approach aremagnified for children from disadvantaged situations or with special needs.

    The authors of this report are convinced that an effective system of consultation

    that helps ECCE providers and families best meet childrens needs is fundamental

    to healthier children. The reports goal is to engage support to implement a

    statewide health and mental health consultation program that approaches

    childrens health and mental health needs in a well-coordinated, holistic way.

    Background

    Oregons early childhood system has one overarching goal: Children are healthy,

    growing and learning. Over the last decade, a group of cross-agency, public

    and private partners have collaborated to develop the vision for Oregons early

    childhood system, supported by legislation (ORS 417.727) that led to the early

    childhood system.. In March 2008 the Governors Summit on Early Childhood

    engaged Oregons most influential partners in meaningful dialogue and action

    around Early Childhood Matters, Oregons framework for a statewide birth-

    through-5 early childhood system.7 The committees charged with developing the

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    11/225

    system and integrating suggestions from the summit into strategies and actions

    included Early Learning Matters, Family Matters and Health Matters.

    Following the Governors Summit, Health Matters charged the Priority Action

    Work Group (PAWG) with developing approaches to expand and sustain

    statewide early childhood health and mental health consultation in child care.

    The Child Care Health and Mental Health Consultation Priority Action WorkGroup (PAWG) consisted of more than 50 people representing state and local

    early childhood, health, mental health and special needs communities across the

    state. The work group used technologies such as teleconferencing and interactive

    websites that allowed for participation from a distance. Smaller groups developed

    to address specific tasks and responsibilities.

    PAWG members were charged with developing the following products:

    Approaches to consultation, which incorporate the essential elements, a

    logic model and identification of outcomes at the system and servicedelivery levels;

    Survey to determine what is occurring across the state;

    Needed supports including consultant competencies, training, supports and

    supervision (in particular, consultants need reflective supervision);

    An evaluation approach that would monitor implementation and outcomes

    of a system of early childhood care and education health and mental health

    consultation services; and

    Funding and sustained resources necessary for an ongoing system ofhealth and mental health consultation in early childhood care and

    education settings.

    These products are available at http://healthoregon.org/hcco.

    Putting these components together, the group developed a statewide approach

    with a consultation delivery model that can be implemented in urban or rural

    settings, with incremental implementation as resources are available.

    DefinitionsCommon language that supports clarity and understanding among partners from

    multiple disciplines is essential.

    The following working definition used to describe consultation provides key

    context to the PAWGs work. It is derived from the Early Childhood Mental

    Health Consultation Evaluation Tool Kit.8

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    12/226

    Early childhood consultation includes developmentally appropriate, culturally

    sensitive and primarily indirect services for children in child care and early

    education settings. Services build capacity of staff and family members to

    support healthy child development. This may include observing children and the

    caregiving environment; identifying concerns and needs; and problem solving

    and recommending interventions that involve changes in the environments, skills,

    knowledge, attitudes and behavior of caregivers. Early childhood consultants

    collaborate with administrators, staff, family members and caregivers who

    intervene directly with children in child care, early education and/or home settings.

    Figure 1 Consultation dynamics

    The consultants primary goal is to strengthen the ECCE providers knowledge

    and skills to assure high-quality care of all children. The solid arrows in Figure

    1 show the direct relationship between the consultant and the ECCE provider,

    as well as between the provider and the child and family. However, children in

    child care with higher needs and those children who are at risk for poor health

    and mental health outcomes (refer to Definitions in appendix) can also benefit

    from consultation that includes early identification, screening and referral tomore intensive services. The goal of consultation focused on individual children

    is to meet their needs and keep them in child care. The consultant offers

    recommendations for the childs care based on a professional assessment for use in

    planning with both the ECCE provider and the family. The consultants indirect

    relationship with the child and family represents a general approach to making

    referrals out for treatment needs rather than providing direct health or mental

    health treatment. This indirect relationship is shown with an intermittent arrow.

    Child and familyEarly care

    and education

    providers

    Health andmental health

    consultants

    Infrastructuresupports health and

    mental healthconsultation for childcare providers and the

    childs family.

    http://healthoregon.org/hccohttp://healthoregon.org/hcco
  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    13/227

    System infrastructure

    Delivery model supportshigh quality health and mental

    health consultation

    Services provided by consultant

    to assist child care providers and/orthe child and family

    Building toward a statewide health and mental health

    consultation system

    An effective system of health and mental health consultation has at its core a

    strong and coordinated state and local infrastructure supporting high-quality

    services that meet the needs of ECCE providers, children and their families. This

    system assumes close collaboration among early childhood partners to develop askilled consultant work force; makes use of relevant research and evidence-based

    tools; secures adequate and sustainable funding; and provides process and

    service evaluation.

    The Child Care Health and Mental Health Consultation Priority Action Work

    Group proposes the following vision and steps for building toward a statewide

    health and mental health consultation system.

    Essential elements

    The following essential elements of a statewide health and mental healthconsultation program are strongly interconnected: a consistent, statewide

    infrastructure at the system level; a regional or local consultation delivery model;

    and consultation services in the early childhood care and education setting.

    Figure 2 Essential elements

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    14/22

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    15/229

    The logic model

    The essential elements describe a vision for health and mental health

    consultation that promotes health and mental health and prevents problems

    during the early years. How can Oregon create a system and services based

    on this vision? The logic model presents strategies that support this visionand meet both system and service delivery outcomes. The logic model

    includes strategies to support:

    Cross-disciplinary partnerships, relationships and services;

    Evidence-based consultation practice and tools;

    Quality assurance;

    Adequate and sustainable funding.

    These strategies are relevant to the needs of ECCE providers, families and

    children and address state and community priorities.

    Collaboration among partners at both the state and community levels and

    across health, mental health and child care disciplines is critical. Champions

    and leaders who are committed to this vision must emerge at both the

    state and community levels to support the effort. Leaders must set to work

    exploring and securing needed funding to build the system. Processes

    must be put in place to provide a system of coordination and oversight andassure high-quality services through work force development and support.

    Evaluation of the effect of services is essential.

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    16/2210

    Logicmodels

    ummaryforastatewidehealthandmentalhealthconsultationsy

    stem

    Part1.Statew

    ideconsultationsystem

    Goal1:Oregonchildcarehealthandmentalhealthconsultationserviceswillbesupportedbyastrongpartnershipof

    bothstateandlocallevelstakeholders.

    Inputs

    Strategie

    s

    Outputs

    Outcomes

    Communication

    andplanning

    discussionsamong

    potentialpartnersa

    nd

    stakeholdersabout

    the

    developmentofah

    ealth

    andmentalhealth

    consultationsystem

    for

    childcare.

    a.Completeabaselineassessmentof

    currenthealthandm

    entalhealth

    consultationservices;

    b.Identifysharedvalue

    sanddevelopa

    sharedvisionandm

    ission;

    c.Developstateandloc

    alprocessesfor

    communication,sha

    reddecision

    makingandfunding

    ;

    d.Createstateandloca

    l

    interagencyagreements;

    e.Cultivatecross-system

    relationships

    thatsupportreferralandaccessto

    communityhealth,mentalhealth

    andsocialresources

    forcareproviders

    andfamilies;

    f.Conductlocalcommunityneeds

    assessmenttoidentifylocalpriorities;

    g.Providelocalprogram

    oversightto

    assuretheprogram

    meetstheessential

    elementsandaddresseslocaland

    partnerpriorities.

    a.Thecompletionofabaseline

    assessmentandreport;

    b-c.The

    completionofapartnership

    documentthatincludesavisionand

    missionstatementandprocessesfor

    comm

    unication,shareddecision

    makingandfunding;

    d.Signedmemorandaof

    understandingamongstateand

    local

    agencies;

    e.Thedevelopmentofcross-system

    relationshipsthatsupportreferral

    anda

    ccesstocommunityhealth,

    mentalhealthandsocialresources

    forca

    reprovidersandfamilies;

    f.Theco

    mpletionoflocalcommunity

    needsassessments;

    g.Thed

    evelopmentoflocal

    progr

    amoversight.

    1.Thereisanobjective

    descriptionof

    systemprocesses

    andtheoutcomesof

    consultationservices.

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    17/2211

    Logicmodelsumma

    ryforastatewidehealthandmentalhealthconsultationsystem

    Goal2:Therewillbead

    equatefundingtoinitiatea

    ndsustainastatewidesyste

    mofconsultationservices.

    Inputs

    Strategies

    Outputs

    Outcom

    es

    Costestimatesfor

    asystem,basedon

    identifiedneeds

    thatprovide

    essentialelements.

    a.Developstrategiesto

    fundconsultation

    servicesstatewide;

    b.Createandimplementa

    plan,includingstepsand

    atimeline,todevelopand

    sustainneededresources.

    a.Thedevelopmentofalist

    of

    strategiesandcostestima

    tesfor

    consultationservices;

    b.Thecompletionofaplan

    tofundand

    sustainservicesstatewide

    .

    2.Adequatefund

    ingisdedicatedto

    initiateandsu

    stainasystemof

    consultations

    ervicesatstatewide

    andcommunitylevels.

    Goal3:Skilledandcom

    petenthealthandmentalh

    ealthconsultantswillprovideservicestochildcarepro

    viders

    acrossOregon.

    Inputs

    Strategies

    Outputs

    Outcom

    es

    Essentialelements:

    Consultation

    servicemodel;

    Consultation

    servicestandards;

    Qualityassurance

    procedures

    andconsultant

    competencies;

    Consultationwork

    forcetraining

    andtechnical

    assistanceneeds.

    a.Developaplanforastatewide

    systemincludingatimeframe

    andmeasurablesteps;

    b.Createstrategiesto

    implementand

    evaluatestatewide;

    c.Createstate-levelteamto

    assurequalityhealthand

    mentalhealth

    consultationservices;

    d.Developstatewidetraining

    andtechnicalassistance

    strategiesforconsultants.

    a.Thedevelopmentofan

    implementationplan;

    b.Thedevelopmentofstrategies

    thatsupporthigh-qualityhealth

    andmentalhealthconsu

    ltation

    servicesinchildcareand

    supporta

    competenthealthandmental

    healthconsultationwork

    force;

    c.Thecreationofastate-lev

    el

    implementationteam;

    d.Thedevelopmentoftrainingand

    technicalassistancestrategies.

    3.High-qualitya

    ndevidence-

    basedconsultationservicesare

    providedstatewide;

    4.Consultantsar

    eskilled

    andcompeten

    t.

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    18/22

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    19/2213

    Funding and support

    The vision for statewide health and mental health consultation presented here is

    likely to require some new funding.

    Potential sources of public and other funding include the following:

    Medicaid;

    Early Head Start/Head Start;

    Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA Part B,

    Section 619, Part C);

    Mental Health and Substance Abuse Block Grants;

    Child Care and Development Fund, including funding for quality;

    Child welfare funds, such as Title IVE of the Social Security Act;

    Maternal and Child Health BlockGrant under Title Vof the Social

    Security Act;

    Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF);

    Supplemental Security Income (SSI, Title XVI of the Social Security Act);

    Private insurance coverage;

    Child care licensing fees; 9

    Service fees.

    Costs ofhealth and mental health consultation

    Oregon consultation program strategies differ from each other in depth and

    intensity. An informal scan of Oregons known health and/or mental health

    consultation service budgets was conducted. Oregon programs with more

    consultant staff tend to receive more prevention services. Those with fewerconsultants tend to focus on children with special needs and serious behavior

    issues. Cost levels are higher when programs employ more consultants or

    services include consultation covering the continuum from promotion and

    prevention to treatment.

    The scan compared information about costs from programs within Oregon and

    from other states to develop an estimateof costs for health and/or mental health

    consultation. While these programs have differences, they have the common

    element of consultation. The cost-per-child in Oregon programs ranged from $258

    to $348. One Oregon program has 342 children per consultant.In comparison, the

    Massachusetts-Worcester and South County Together For Kids (TFK) program

    has a cost-per-child of $295 with 200 children per consultant. Estimated return

    for Together For Kids is $1.67to $2.23 for every dollar invested.10Summaries

    of other mental health consultation programs, including program costs andstaff

    compositions, can be obtained from What Works? A Study of Effective Early

    Childhood Mental Health Consultation Programs.11

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    20/2214

    The current federal and state economic environment has severely limited available

    funding for most services. It is unlikely that the vision for statewide health and

    mental health consultation can be realized without new funds. A recommended

    strategy for building the necessary statewide infrastructure and services may be

    to stage them over time, beginning with limited services and the infrastructure to

    support them and expanding as funds become available. Effectively leveragingfunds where possible and including private funds such as grants or fees for services

    should be considered. Collaboration that results in braided funding streams and

    builds on existing services could reduce the amount of new funds needed.

    Recommendations and next steps

    Build consensus on priority and direction with the Health Matters, Early

    Learning Matters and Family Matters committees and the Early Childhood

    Matters Advisory Council.

    Ensure that early childhood health and mental health are included as

    priorities in current health reform activities.

    Conduct a comprehensive statewide assessment of the health and mental

    health consultation services now available in the state to use in program

    development and as a baseline to measure the effect of future efforts. The

    assessment should include a focus on gaps in services, as well as information

    on target population, model designs, funding resources, evidence-based

    practices used, and evaluation processes and tools.

    Explore sustainable funding strategies to address the need for consultation in

    multiple types of early care and education programs.

    Explore short- and long-term strategies for staging services as funding

    is available.

    For additional information contact:

    Dianna Pickett, 971-673-0259, [email protected], or;

    Kathy Seubert, 503-947-5526, [email protected]

  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    21/2215

    References1.Census report on child care. (2005). Based on 2002 data.

    2. 2008 Oregon Child Care Research Partnership (June 2009). Child care and education in

    Oregon and its counties.

    3.

    Vandell, D.L. and Wolfe, B. (May 2000). Child care quality: Does it matter and does it needto be improved? Institute for Research on Poverty. University of WisconsinMadison.

    http://aspe.hhs.gov/hsp/ccquality00/ccqual.htm#quality.

    4.NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. (2001). Child care and common communicable

    illnesses: Results from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Study

    of Early Child Care. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 155, 481-488.

    5.Region population survey. (2008).

    6..Gilliam, W.S. (May 2005). Expulsion rates in state prekindergarten programs. FDC policy

    brief series no. 3.

    7. National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), 2005-2006. (Obese is

    defined as M 95th percentile BMI-for-age using the 2000 CDC growth chart for children

    aged 2 years or older.)

    8.ALERT Immunization Information System, Oregon Immunization Program, Department of

    Human Services. (2009). www.oregon.gov/DHS/ph/imm/docs/county/OREGON.pdf.9.

    Duran,

    F. B., Hepburn, K.S., Kaufmann, R. K., Le, L.T., Allen, M.D., Brennan, E.M. and Green, B.L.

    Research synthesis: Early childhood mental health consultation. The Center on the Social and

    Emotional Foundations for Early LearningVanderbilt University.http://csefel.vanderbilt.edu/resources/research.html.

    9.. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Surveys, 2009 and 2009.

    10..

    Warfield, M.E. (2006).Assessing the known and estimated costs and benefits of providing

    mental health consultation services to preschool-age children in early education and care

    centers in Massachusetts: An economic evaluation of the Together For Kids (TFK) Project.

    P. 6. Downloaded Aug. 31, 2010. www.hfcm.org/CMS/images/Final%20Full%20TFK%20

    Economic%20Report%20June%202006.doc.

    11.

    Duran, F., Hepburn, K., Irvine, M., Kaufmann, R., Anthony, B., Horen, N. and Perry, D.

    (August 2009). What works? A study of effective early childhood mental health

    consultation programs. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Center for Child

    and Human Development.

    Return to last page read

    http://www.hfcm.org/CMS/images/Final%20Full%20TFK%20Economic%20Report%20June%202006.dochttp://www.hfcm.org/CMS/images/Final%20Full%20TFK%20Economic%20Report%20June%202006.dochttp://www.hfcm.org/CMS/images/Final%20Full%20TFK%20Economic%20Report%20June%202006.doc
  • 8/8/2019 Draft 14 White Paper - Oregon's Health and Mental Health Consultation Systems Planning

    22/22

    This document can be provided upon request in alternative formats for

    individuals with disabilities. Other formats may include (but are not limited to)

    large print, Braille, audio recordings, Web-based communications and other

    electronic formats. E-mail [email protected], call 503-971-0259

    (voice) to arrange for the alternative format that will work best for you.