Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Dr. Dawn HennessySHAPE America Regional Conference
Boise, Idaho
BS - K-12 Physical Education, MEd – Instructional
Leadership, PhD – Educational Leadership and Organizational Performance and Change, K-12 Principal Licensure
Sarah Milner Elementary – Title I, 320 students
Truscott Elementary Bilingual Immersion – Title I, 250 students
Van Buren Elementary – Title I, 150 students
Dr. Dawn Hennessy
It is imperative that physical educators support each
child in developing a love of movement and a healthy lifestyle because the students’ lives depend on it. Creating an emotionally and physically safe learning environment where each student is empowered to reach their highest potential, support each other in doing so, and celebrate success can shape a child’s future. This is our profession; it is who we are.
Commitment
Federal and State Laws
National and State Teaching Standards
Social Emotional Intelligences Defined
Preventive Teaching Strategies
Building Positive Relationships
Moral Development
The Brain and Social Emotional Learning Principles
The Brain and Social Emotional Inhibitors
Classroom Culture to Support Positive Behavior
Quality Teaching Practices
Grading
Final Thoughts
Teaching Positive Behavior in Physical Education Outline
Federal and State Laws
School bullying has been identified as a risk factor
associated with antisocial and criminal behavior. Bullies are more likely to drop out of school …victims are more likely to have higher levels of stress, anxiety, depression, illness, and an increased tendency to suicide.
Morrison (2007)
Prevention is more cost effective than correction or remediation. An established relationship exists between dropping out of school and the probability of committing a crime and dropout prevention is cheaper in the long run than the cost of incarceration.
Hodgkinson (2003)
Recognized need for Federal and Colorado Laws
Links: www.cde.state.co.us/mtss/pbis -
implementation resources - current legislation
Dear Colleague Letter on Nondiscrimination School discipline – Explains and cross-references Federal Laws concerning positive supports in schools 2014
USDOE Resource Guide for Improving School Climate 2014
USDOE Directory of Federal School Climate and Discipline Resources
USDOE School Climate and Discipline Guidance
Federal Laws and Resources
Title IV of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title IV), 42
U.S.C. §§ 2000c et seq., which prohibits discrimination in public elementary and secondary schools based on race, color, or national origin, among other bases.
Civil Rights Act of 1964
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (Title II)
prohibits disability discrimination by public entities, including public school districts, in their services, programs, and activities.
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990
Holds schools responsible for ensuring that students
with disabilities receive the range of appropriate educational and related services they need to achieve their fullest potential.
Thompson School District requires two areas of great need: speech-language, occupational therapy, resource for literacy or math, adapted physical education, before services are scheduled. Not just adapted physical education service can be provided to a student.
IDEIA Individuals with Disabilities Improvement Education Act 2004
SB15-213 Concerning the Limited Waiver of Governmental
Immunity for Claims involving Public Schools for Injuries Resulting from Incidents of School Violence known as the Claire Davis School Safety Act.
An employee of a public school, school district or a charter school is not subject to suit under this section in his or her individual capacity unless the employee’s actions or omissions are willful and wanton.
Districts/schools should ensure they have met all required elements of the Safe Schools Act (C.R.S. 22.32.109.1).
Colorado Revised Statutes
Clair Davis Act
House Bill 12-1345 School Finance Bill Sec 21 The use of inflexible “zero-tolerance” policies has
resulted in unnecessary expulsions, out of school suspension and referrals to law enforcement agencies.
School district shall adopt a mission statement that includes “making safety for all students and staff a priority in each public school of the district” and create a “Safe School Plan”, including a Conduct and Discipline Code and Safe School Reporting Requirements
Colorado State Laws Assuring Positive Behavior Supports
House Bill 11-1254 Concerning Measures to Reduce the Frequency of Bullying in Schools.
“Bullying” means any written or verbal expression, or physical or electronic or gesture, or pattern thereof, that is intended to coerce, intimidate, or cause any physical, mental, or emotional harm to any student.
Bullying is prohibited against any student for any reason
Colorado State Laws Assuring Positive Behavior Supports
Iowa Code Section 280.28
Massachusetts General Law, Part I, Title XII, Chapter 69, Section 1P – Safe and Supportive Schools
California Violence Prevention Act of 2000, Assembly Bill 537
Minnesota’s Safe and Supportive Schools Act –addressing bullying, harassment, and discrimination
State Laws Addressing Safe and Supported Schools Defining
Bullying
An Imbalance of Power: Kids who bully use their
power—such as physical strength, access to embarrassing information, popularity, or exclusion through social or personal distance —to control or harm others. Power imbalances can change over time and in different situations, even if they involve the same people.
Repetition: Bullying behaviors happen more than once or have the potential to happen more than once.
Amstutz & Mullet (2015)
Bullying Defined
National and State Teaching Standards
National Board for Professional Teaching Standards in Physical Education - Standard 5
Rubric for Evaluating Colorado Teachers – Standard 2
Learning Environment
Creating a positive learning environment – Purposeful to inspire, challenge and motivate
Managing a well-organized environment – employ resources wisely, structure learning to engage all students, and help them achieve highest potential
Creating an environment of respect and rapport – Promote responsible behavior and helping to maintain welcoming learning environments
Establishing high expectations for learners – Understanding expectations creates comfort and a sense of ease that enhances productivity and better learning
Establishing a culture for learning – Students view themselves as important contributors to the culture of learning
National Board for Professional Teaching Standards www.boardcertifiedteachers.org
NBPTS Physical Education Standard 5
Standard 2 Teachers establish a safe, inclusive and respectful learning
environment for a diverse population of students
Basic- The teacher creates a classroom environment the facilitates Mutual respect, Positive relationships between and among students, Empathy for each student. And...
Partially Proficient – The teacher Creates a classroom environment that is conducive to learning. And…
Proficient (meets State Requirements) – the teacher Creates a classroom environment which values diverse perspectives, Establishes a nurturing and caring relationship with each student. And…
Accomplished – Students Respect their classmates and teacher. And…
Exemplary – Students’ interactions with their teacher(s) and each other are Respectful, Demonstrate mutual support.
www.cde.state.co.us
Rubric for Evaluating Colorado Teachers
Social Emotional Intelligence Defined
Emotions help focus reason and logic. The logical side helps set
goals and the emotional side provides the passion to persevere (Damasio, 1994 in Jensen 2008 p. 82)
Students learn best when their minds, hearts, and bodies are engaged. The more aspects of self that we can tap into for learners, the more effective we’ll be as educators. Jensen (2008)
Social emotional skills shape the process through which people learn to recognize and manage emotions, care about others, make good decisions, behave ethically and responsibly, develop positive relationships, and avoid negative behavior. Fredrick (2003)
Social and emotional skills are the foundation for a healthy
learning environment. Hensley et al. (2016)
Paradigm of Emotional Logic
Emotions are deeply engaged in the development of a sense of
self and are bound up in a person’s beliefs.
Teachers may not realize they are teaching when they affect the emotions of students. Teaching of this nature may be even more powerful in determining some students’ futures than mastering aspects of the curriculum.
Students’ emotional states profoundly influence their learning, and educators need to come to terms with this fact and learn how to work with emotions – theirs and their students’
Teach the 3 Positive Emotions of Joy (connected to Play), Enthusiasm (Creativity in connecting), and Awe (to see or experience inspiring mastery) Caine & Caine et al. (2016)
Paradigm of Emotional Logic
Awareness of Self and Others – Physical (how one looks including
clothes and home), Academic (how one does in school) , and Social (how one relates to other people) Awareness
Approval of Self and Others – Understanding of one’s physical, academic, and social strengths and weaknesses while valuing the differences in others (empathy)
Mastering Self-responsibility – In control of their actions, behaviors, consequences, and future destiny. Understands consequences before action is taken and can appropriately defend their position when wronged.
Finding Personal Meaning –Integral in the learning process, 4 M’s can foster personal meaning. Meaningful material, Motivation, Movement, Multiple Intelligences.
Valuing Honesty and Ethics – As a system of morals one lives by including responsibility, respect, cooperation, honesty, and integrity.
Doty (2001)
Emotional Intelligence
Identifying and labeling feelings
Reading others’ moods and feelings
Managing your own moods and feelings
Controlling impulses, delaying gratification
Expressing feelings appropriately and productively
Feeling compassion and empathy for others Jensen (2008)
Awareness of and ability to monitor one’s own and others’ feelings and emotions, to discriminate among them and to use this information to guide one’s thinking and action.
Has a positive influence in reducing stress, building positive social relationships, and assisting with learning strategies that
regulate emotions. Kochhar-Bryant (2010 )p.37
Emotional Intelligence
Self-Awareness – The ability to recognize and label
own emotions, identify what triggers those emotions, analyze emotions and how they affect others, accurately recognize own strengths and limitations, identify own needs and values, possess self-efficacy and self-esteem.
Self-Management – the ability to set plans and work toward goals, overcome obstacles, manage stress, seek help, regulate impulses and emotions, maintain attention, exhibit motivation and hope, persevere. Hensley et al. (2016)
5 Competencies for Social and Emotional Learning
Social Awareness – The ability to identify social cues,
predict others’ feelings and reactions, evaluate others’ reactions, show respect for others, understand other points of view or perspectives, appreciate diversity, identify and. Use resources in one’s family, school, and community.
Relationship skills – The ability to make friends, learn cooperatively and work toward group goals, communicate with others, provide help to those who need it, manage and express emotions in relationships while respecting diverse viewpoints, resist inappropriate social pressures. Hensley et al. (2016)
5 Competencies for Social and Emotional Learning
Responsible Decision-Making – The ability to reflect
on how current choices affect the future, make decisions based on moral, personal, and ethical standards, identify problems when making decisions and generate alternative options, negotiate fairly, become self-reflective and self-evaluative.
Social and Emotional Skills are the foundation for a healthy learning environment. Hensley et al. (2016)
5 Competencies for Social and Emotional Learning
Empathy – Understanding the perspectives of others
can be developed through service learning, charitable causes, learning about discrimination of innocents, diversity of humanity
Self-Control – Inner control is developed through awareness, complying, goal setting, transferring and monitoring
Integrity – Incorruptibility with firm adherence to a code of moral or artistic values taught through honesty, fairness, and doing what is right for others
Hoerr (2017)
Five Formative Skills for Relationships
Embracing Diversity – Recognizing and appreciating
the differences among us is taught by appreciating ourselves, recognizing others’ diversities, appreciating others, planning and implementing
Grit – Good Grit is persistence toward goals for the right purpose. Smart Grit is the ability to recognize when to stop pursuit of a goal because the gain is not worth the cost.
Hoerr (2017)
Five Formative Skills for Relationships
Social and Emotional Skills
Following Instructions
Accepting Criticism or consequence
Accepting No for an Answer
Greeting Others
Getting the Teacher’s Attention
Disagreeing Appropriately
Hensley et al. (2016)
Making and Apology
Accepting compliments
Having a Conversation
Asking for Help
Asking Permission
Staying on Task
Sharing with Others
Working with Others
Listening to Others
Using an Appropriate Voice Tone
Comparison of Approaches to Social Emotional Programs
Traditional
Consequence based
Rewards and incentives create motivation
External controls (point chart, detention, removal)
Time-outs
Expectations based on chronological age
Behavior Management
New View
Regulatory based
Relational influence creates motivation
Internal controls (sense of self – accomplishment, love acceptance)
Time-ins
Expectations based on emotional/social age
Stress Management Forbes (2012)
Comparison of Approaches to Social Emotional Programs
Traditional
Individual focus
Performance/outcome based
Intervention
Major transitions identified
Student fits into environment
Behavior is a matter of choice
New View
Community/Family focus
Process based
Prevention
All transitions identified
Environment to fit the child
Stress drives behaviorForbes (2012)
Emotions are essential to the trait that makes us most
human, the ability to reason. Ratey (2001)
Empathy, Self-awareness, and Emotional Control create Emotional Intelligence. Peter Salovey, Yale & John Mayer,
University of New Hampshire
We cannot separate emotion from cognition or cognition from the body Ratey (2001)
Emotions help us focus our reason and logic Jensen
(2008)
Why Focus on Emotions in Physical Education?
Emotional events receive preferential processing
Bind the learning
Help us determine what’s real, what we believe, and feel
Activate long-term memory on an intense and widespread chemical basis in the brain and body
Help make better-quality decisions by engaging our values
Help make faster decisions by using nonconscious and gut-level judgment
Help us remember more easily
The more intense the emotion, the stronger the imprintPowell & Kusuma-Powell (2010)
Role of Emotions in Learning
Preventive Teaching Strategies
Your ability to give love and stay mindful is the new
outcome.
At the end of each day, each year, each decade, or entire lifetime, look back and ask yourself if you did all you could to make a loving and positive difference. p. 198
Forbes (2012)
The New Outcome
The Institute of HeartMath has studied the heart’s
impact on the brain for thirty years. The scientists have shown the heart generates forty to sixty times more electrical amplitude than the brain. This electromagnetic field of the heart, cardiac field, extends ten feet outside the body. The cardiac field has the power to influence another person’s mood, attitude, and feelings. A person’s heartbeat can actually be measured in the other person’s brainwave, creating a connection between these two people far beyond a surface interaction.
Forbes (2012) p. 129
Relationship Entrainment
When an emotionally regulated and calm teacher is
next to or gently touches the shoulder of a dysregulated and disruptive student, an energy exchange happens. Through the power of connection (physical and psychological) the teacher becomes the external regulator for the student. It is imperative the teacher’s emotional state is positive to drive the “coherence” of heart rhythm. Heart coherence is generated from a state of love, gratitude, and happiness. Forbes (2012) p. 130
Relationship Entrainment
Touch – Loving touch on the hand or shoulder can be a calming
and reassuring gesture to foster regulation for a student.
Breathing – Out of the three ways to calm the body’s nervous system (exercise, food) oxygen is most effective. Breathing can directly influence stress (increased heart rate, tense muscles, shallow and rapid breathing) to move someone from an anxious and chaotic state to a calm and regulated state
Nonverbal Communication – Nonverbal communication (Tone of Voice, Posture, Facial Expressions, Gestures, Intensity of response, Timing and Rhythm, Proximity, Touch) must match what is being said for the student to experience calm. If it is incongruent, it can invoke a fear reaction. Forbes (2012)
Relationship Entrainment
Resilience, or the capacity to surmount life
adversities “against all odds”, has been seen as a multidimensional trait that should protect individuals from risks known to eventuate in negative psychological outcomes
Attachment Theory as an integrated system of interaction to promote children’s confidence in 1. reliability of the world to respond in a timely and responsive fashion to their needs and 2. the perception that they are deserving of such responsiveness. Cameron, Tapanya, & Gillen (2006)
Research on Rocking a Child – Theoretical Perspective
Study Methodology: In Thailand, Canada, Italy,
Peru, and the United Kingdom researchers video taped 2-year olds in their home and during activities for one day, took notes, and the families reflected
Thailand – Child and parent achieved synchrony while swinging together. Often, these respites which achieved a common space of mutual alliance, succeeded a stormy passage of events that were usually succeeded by renewed vigorous activity
Cameron, Tapanya, & Gillen (2006)
Research on Rocking a Child
Canada – After the two got harmony swinging side-
by-side, both at last seemed to find a synchrony that allowed them idle chat and a mutuality not readily achieved earlier in the day
Italy – Child sat on mother’s lap rocking, playing little games, and pretending telephone talk. Interactional synchrony was clearly achieved during this almost half hour of mutual comfort giving.
Peru – Numerous opportunities for attachment security observed in their interactions. Almost every family member fed her lunch. Cameron, Tapanya, & Gillen (2006)
Research on Rocking a Child
United Kingdom – Mutual causal observations out the window,
singing nursery songs, the hum of the passage of time, and the lack of complaints on any side made this ride seem particularly grounding for all concerned and turned the vehicle into a virtual family hammock.
Findings – It seems possible that without rockers, swings, and hammocks, carers as well as children would have been the poorer. Their families’ foci upon autonomy and independence were one side of the resilience coin, the other side of which was provision of mutually satisfying soothing and dependency
Cameron, Tapanya, & Gillen (2006)
Research on Rocking a Child - Findings
Parental permission form
Rocking chair is available for individual student use at any designated time
Student can request during scheduled teacher time –teacher has hands on chair or at request, knees only.
Student turns one minute timer and watches the sand go out.
Collaborative decision-making by class to resolve fair turns, needed turn, limited time issues (on deck)
Reflective calm and greater capacity for learning
Rocking in a School Setting
Strategies to help strengthen relationships so students willingly accept instruction, corrections, and criticism:
Planned Teaching – Frequent prompting of the behavioral skill before giving feedback can help them internalize the accepting criticism skill
Praise – Can be the most powerful tool in changing negative behavior.
Behavior Correction – Intervene early when behaviors are small. Look at entire context of behaviors to analyze how to be proactive.
Hensley et al. (2016)
Preventing Intense Emotional Behaviors
When escalated behaviors occur, the first objective is
to help students gain self-control.
Cool-down time
Explicit description of behavior that needs to stop and the behavior that needs to be use
Reality statements and reasons – When you…, it shows…, and that is a sign of …(respect)
Empathy and caring by seeing the student’s point of view
Specific praise – Thank you for…, you’re doing great because… Hensley et al. (2016)
Help Students Gain Self-Control
Teacher self-care
Ask the right question
Seek support
Validate yourself
Take care of yourself at school
Apply self-care outside of school
Understand trauma
Love yourself
Hensley et al. (2016)
Personal Professional Manner
Use a soft voice tone
Be aware of body language
Maintain safe proximity
Use a slow rate of speech /pacing
Continue to use corrective teaching strategies
Allow cool-down time
Stay away from content – focus on behavior, not motives or blame
Hensley et al. (2016)
Personal Professional Manner
Due to the mirror neuron system (the basis for imitation),
students may, to some degree, pick up on the teacher’s mood, facial expressions, and actions far more than previously thought.
Our beliefs and attitudes as teachers are inextricably intertwined with how we teach. Our smiles, or lack thereof, communicates more to students than the words we verbalize. The tone of our conversations, appearance, organization, and effort all contribute to the collective whole.
Jensen (2008)
Personal Professional Manner
Some students have a talent for moving a teacher to her deepest, darkest, and most raw emotional states. To deal with this intensity, the teacher must operate at a higher level of consciousness and at a greater level of awareness to own and process any anger that surfaces within her.
Hensley et al. (2016)
Personal Professional Manner
Give the “evil eye” (a smile and wink from across the room)
Walk toward the student while teaching
Stand close to the student and continue to teach
Establish eye contact and slightly shake your head, indicating “No”
Wile teaching, gently place your hand on the student’s shoulder
Stop briefly and whisper something like, “Can you save that for later?” Fay & Fay (2002)
Preventative Interventions
Change the student’s location within the classroom
Whisper something like, “That behavior is fine for after school”
Use an I-message (“I find it hard to teach when you do that. Thanks for stopping”)
Use an enforceable statement (“I allow students to stay with the group when they are not causing a problem”)
Ask the student to leave for a brief “recovery” periodFay & Fay (2002)
Preventative Interventions
Require the student to complete a problem-solving
form during recovery, before he/she can return to the group.
Excuse the student to the office for a short “cooling off” period. No counseling or discussion takes place with the student during this period.
Give the student an appointment to talk with you about the problem
Fay & Fay (2002)
Preventative Interventions
Restrict the student from the area of his/her
infraction until a new plan of action is identified and written by the student
Restrict the student from the area of the infraction until you feel that another try is in order. The student is allowed to be in this area only when they are not causing a problem
Fay & Fay (2002)
Preventative Interventions
Are my students at an advantage because I am their
teacher?
Why do I teach, anyway?
How badly do I want to see my students succeed?
Where will my students be 10 years from now as a result of having me as their teacher?
Do my students see me as an example of who and what they can become?
Kafele (2016)
Reflection onTeacher Attitude
Building Positive Relationships
Trauma Theory suggests that many of the behavioral
symptoms that we see in individuals are a direct result of coping with adverse experiences. What we identify as maladaptive behaviors are really misapplied survival skills.
An example might be a child who has been physically abused who responds to teasing by a classmate with physical aggression - a "fight or flight" response to stress. In order to intervene effectively, we must move from a position of blame to one of questioning. http://www.sanctuaryinstitute.org
Trauma Theory
Sanctuary recommends changing the central
question we ask about clients from "What's wrong with you?" to "What's happened to you?" as the first step in recognizing the influence of the past on current behaviors and functioning.
http://www.sanctuaryinstitute.org
Sanctuary Response to Trauma
Healthy Relationships
Self It is when the family and
broader community guide, by way of example, restraint, caring, practice, and standards to be met that children become connected adults who relate to others with confidence and caring. This is how children learn that they belong
Caine & Caine et al. (2009)
Environment When students become
socially capable, they are able to reflect on their own behavior and actions, have empathy for others, believe in their ability to change, be positive, and have a sense of humor. All of these are characteristics that protect children and adolescents from adopting destructive patterns.
Authenticity
Clear Communication
Empowerment
Caine & Caine et al. (2009) pp. 62-63
Healthy Relationships
Genuine and truthful with everyone’s ideas and
work being acknowledged respectfully. All are a value to the community.
Discuss real issues as they occur or become relevant
Everyone is recognized and has their thinking and work acknowledged or critiqued in a respectful manner
Caine & Caine et al. (2009) pp. 62-63
Authenticity
Non-threatening sending, giving, and exchanging
ideas including the feeling tone of voice and body language.
Empathy and respect for one another are taught through modeling
Listening and times of silence give opportunity for students to reflect and think.
Belief that “I can make this work because I understand those around me and they in turn listen to me.”
Caine & Caine et al. (2009) pp. 62-63
Clear Communication
All students respect each other as individuals who
can and will reach new levels of mastery both personally, academically (and physically).
See themselves as continuous learners in all settings.
Belief that, “I choose to do this even if it turns out to be difficult. I support others in exploring their way of becoming fully competent.”
Caine & Caine et al. (2009) pp. 62-63
Empowerment
Teachers who help their students feel good about
themselves through learning success, quality friendships, and celebrations are doing the very things the learning brain craves Jensen (2008) p. 89
Nothing can substitute for face-to-face, eye-to-eye, and meaningful skin-to-skin moments in teaching empathy to a child. Izard (2016) p. 17
Teacher’s Actions
Be kind
Express empathy
Show concern
Give dignity
Communicate respect
Hensley et al. (2016)
Positive Relationships
Become aware of the child’s or student’s emotions
Recognize the emotional moment as an opportunity for relationship building and teaching
Listen empathetically in order to validate the student’s feelings
Support the child or student in finding the words to label the emotion that he or she is having
Set behavioral limits while exploring strategies to solve the problem at hand
Powell & Kusuma-Powell (2010), adapted from Gottman’s (1997) work
Emotion Coaching
Emotion Coach
Do’s
Dignifying – naming the emotion to create value and recover more quickly
Developing – intense emotional situations are opportunities for relationship building
Don’ts
Dismissing – does not take emotion seriously
Disapproving – emotion is unacceptable rather than related behavior
Denigrating – laughing at or teasing to change emotion
Powell & Kusuma-Powell (2010)
Give acceptance without solving the issue
Ask exploratory questions to create a deeper understanding
Allow student to be upset without insisting she stop
Accept that their reality may be skewed, do not try to convince otherwise
Tolerate the negative and exaggerated feelings being expressing for the moment so calm can return
Give understanding to the issue but not necessarily agree Forbes (2012)
Creating Emotional Space
Be kind, loving, safe, and patient
Listen with no agenda of teaching a life lesson. Simply listen, the lesson will come afterward.
Validate without identifying what he needs to do differently. That will come later when student is calm, regulated, and ready for change.
Engage in conversation, but do not force answers. Let it unfold naturally
Focus on the relationship. Strive for emotional safety and stay regulated. Trust in the process Forbes (2012)
Creating Emotional Space
General praise, “Awesome Job” is meaningful and
enough motivation for many students to continue acting appropriately.
Effective praise, allows student to understand she is in control.
Show approval
Describe the appropriate behavior
Give a reason
Use a positive consequenceHensley et al. (2016)
Effective Praise
Great teachers:
Never forget it is the people, not the programs that make a school great
Establish clear expectations at the start of the year and follow them consistently
When a student misbehaves, have one goal: to keep that behavior from happening again
Have high expectations for students and higher expectations for themselves
Know they are the variable in the classroom that makes a difference
Create a positive atmosphere in their schools and classroom
Consistently filter out negatives and share a positive attitude
Work hard to keep relationships in good repair , avoid personal hurt and repair damage
Whitaker (2004)
14 Things that Matter Most
Great Teachers:
Have the ability to ignore trivial disturbances and respond to inappropriate behavior without escalating the situation
Have a plan and purpose for everything – including reflecting and adjusting
Ask themselves: What will the best people think?
Notice who is most comfortable and least comfortable with decisions
Center on the real issue of student learning
Care about their students and understand that behaviors and beliefs are tied to emotion
Whitaker (2004)
14 Things that Matter Most
Treat everyone as if they were good p.97
Touch the heart, then teach the child p. 120
Respect your students, their parents and yourself p. 27
We never have too much nice p. 51
Our impact is significant; our focus becomes the student’s focus p. 56
Positive perceptions become reality p. 59-60
Say, “I am sorry for things that have happened” p. 67
Give students word-for-word language when they don’t have it themselves p. 69
Students care about great teachers because they know great teachers care about them p. 122
This book is about who we are, more directly, it is about what we do p. 6
Whitaker (2004)
Things that Matter Most
Building Trust
Teacher to Underachiever Interactions Attends to my interests in some way Cares about me individually Easy to talk to Helps me feel OK about myself Knows how I learn Knows me personally Knows what I’m feeling Listens to me; is understanding Listens when I have a problem Respects me Talks to me about what interests me outside of schoolCleveland (2011)
Building Trust
Responses to Misbehavior
Doesn’t hold a grudge
Fair
Gives me a second chance
Has no negative expectations
Likes me even if I mess up
Shows no favoritism
Cleveland (2011)
Building Trust
Support During Learning
Encourages me to try again
Explains work carefully
Helps me learn and makes sure that I get it
Helps me learn from my mistakes
Makes work interesting
Passionate about and committed to what is being taught
Cleveland (2011)
Building Trust
Fear Reduction
Doesn’t humiliate me in front of the class
Explains policies and why they are being enforced
Relaxed and can laugh at own mistakes
Cleveland (2011)
Do I know my students beyond the dismissal bell?
Am I intimidated by any of my students, their parents, or the community in which they reside?
How do my students perceive me and my treatment of them?
To what extent am I involved in my students’ lives?
How often do my students and I “break bread” together?
Kafele (2016)
Reflection on Building Relationships
Do I consider my students’ cultural backgrounds
when I plan instruction?
How do I infuse my lessons with the history and culture of y students?
Do I ensure that my students identify culturally with the lessons I teach?
How do I demonstrate my sensitivity to the racial and ethnic diversity of my students?
Am I willing to learn all that I can about my students’ culture?
Kafele (2016)
Reflection on Cultural Responsiveness
What is my signature classroom move?
Do I “Bring the fire” into my classroom every day?
Do I believe that my students can fly?
Have I helped my students to put a definition next to their names?
How do I prevent my students from wearing blindfolds in my classroom?
Kafele (2016)
Reflection onStudent Motivation
Moral Development
We want students to recognize goodness, pursue it in rightful ways, and feel a sense of “oughtness” about the pursuit
Stillwell, Galvin, & Kopta (2000)
Conscience is the inner voice of ethics, of right and wrong, of
good and evil. We can think of it as our built-in-guidance system in the search for the good life. It is the uncomfortable feeling we get, or should get, when we tell a lie, speak cruelly, cheat on somebody, use our fists, double-park, break a promise, or do any of the many things we know are wrong. It is also the warm and noble feeling that comes when we do the right thing – stand up for a friend, being true to a team-mate, or to a partner at home, or in business, giving time, effort and money to those in need, or insisting on the truth, especially when it costs us something to do these things.
Prozesky (2007)
Conscience
Nurturing the Moral Connection
Nurturing Moral-Emotional Responsiveness
Nurturing the Authority of Conscious
Nurturing the Golden Rule
Developing Moral Willpower
Developing the Meaning of Conscience
Stilwell, Galvin, & Kopta (2000)
Moral Development
Build the feeling of security through high-quality,
high-quantity involvement
Support the ability to enter into the feeling state of another person to respond to their joy, distress, or sorrow
Avoid relationship trouble of becoming emotionally disconnected through persistently negative or indifferent attitude
Nurturing the Moral Connection
Ages 0 to 6
Provide student with protection, care, and gentle teaching . Remember need for high-quality, high-quantity involvement.
Mirror and teach emotions, especially the positive ones. Empathize with the negative ones. Soothe distress.
Rescue student from danger without blaming them.
Look for cues of readiness for “oughtness” learning
Nurturing the Moral Connection
Ages 7 to 11
Cheer skill development
Security and emotional understanding are enhanced by structure and rules
Emphasize the goodness and burdens of effort
Intervene when the student’s efforts are too little or too much
Beware of commercial competition to the moral connection
Protect the talented student from being exploited
Nurturing the Moral Connection
Ages 12 to 13
Cheer virtuous aspirations
Provide opportunities for goodness and “oughtness to be extended
Enhance understanding of good intentions
Appreciate the power of a good relationship
Note that material rewards are less and less beneficial
Nurturing the Moral Connection
Ages 14 to 15
Be prepared for psychological emancipation
Recognize desire to commit to a virtue-seeking goal that will have an impact on the world
Be aware of avoidance of moral challenges that delay adolescent emancipation
Be ready for meaningful talks – connect to standards and Federal Law
Become part of the moral connection in the community
Nurturing the Moral Connection
Ages 16 to 17+
Anticipate increasing openness in communication
Anticipate processing of mistakes and wrongdoing
Cheer independent, courageous decision-making
Cheer moral leadership with younger students
Be grateful for gratitude
Nurture the Moral Connection
Linking our feelings of doing right to our body’s
physiology
Understanding emotions of Enthusiasm (Joy, interest, excitement), Anxiety (surprise, shyness, embarrassment, fear), Moodiness (sadness, anguish, shame, humiliation, guilt), Outrage (disgust, anger, hatred), Reparation (Making things right after wrongdoing), Healing (Making ones self feel better after wrong doing)
Developing Moral-Emotional Responsiveness
Ages 0 to 6
Affirm the “I am good, I feel good” connection
Teach the “I am good, I feel good, I do good” connection
Become aware of student’s moral anxiety and moodiness
Consequences are brief
Teach students how to “fix things”
Be forgiving, give positive attention
Developing Moral-Emotional Responsiveness
Ages 7 to 11 Appreciate students development of empathy with others
Appreciate feelings of sadness, shame, guilt and self-disappointment after wrong doing
After wrong doing, allow cooling off time for self-teaching to help resolve
Listen attentively, ask questions wisely, act benevolently, and be ready to forgive
Encourage self-initiated reparation
Enjoy the restoration of moral-emotional equilibrium after reparation
Enjoy renewed relaxation and energy
Developing Moral-Emotional Responsiveness
Ages 12-13 Appreciate how students’ conscience initiates co-parenting /
teaching
Be aware of amoral excitement
Appreciate the usefulness of guilt in ourselves and teenagers
Appreciate that time alone is moral processing time in a teenager’s life
Expect longer meaningful conversations
Enjoy moral-emotional exuberance. It flows from moral-emotional healing
Developing Moral-Emotional Responsiveness
Ages 14 to 15 Expect a variety of loyalty conflicts
Expect moral anxiety to occasionally escalate to confusion
Help process moral dilemmas. Look for an association between moodiness and moral issues.
Appreciate value of students processing with peers and trusted adults
Intervene with opinions and limit-setting when harm is imminent
Set limits on over-involvement in other people’s problems
Enjoy teenagers’ euphoric moral moments
Developing Moral-Emotional Responsiveness
Ages 16 to 17+ Appreciate the emergence of personal moral convictions
Appreciate the emergence of moral calm and courage
Never say “I told you so”
Admire the development of moral alertness
Talk and listen. Listen and talk
Empathize with episodes of moral despair
Affirm patience, tolerance, and forgiveness
Affirm moral enthusiasm
Developing Moral-Emotional Responsiveness
Model strong but flexible authority through the ways
we protect, instruct, admonish, exemplify, and encourage.
Authorize values of conscience through routines, rules, customs, laws, and commandments we honor.
Each interaction contributes to the authority of a child’s conscience
Developing the Authority of Conscience
Ages 0 to 6
Develop consistent routines
Assess the values being taught
Assess the manner in which routines are executed. Memory tapes are being formed.
Begin pointing out rules in the routines
Don’t expect rules to be followed without active participation
Developing the Authority of Conscience
Ages 7 to 11
Applaud child’s ability to deduce moral rules from routines at home, school, and community
Applaud child for being a rule follower
Appreciate the stress of change in child’s life
Appreciate how change may involve new moral rule building experiences
Enjoy playfulness with rules at any age
Developing the Authority of Conscience
Ages 12 to 13 Appreciate the inner personalization of conscience in emerging
teenagers
Model moral dialog that emphasizes facts, intentions, repair, fallibility, forgivability, and moral learning. Tell personal moral stories from when you were the same age.
Appreciate the growing understanding of intentionality
Appreciate the meaning of moral self-esteem
Link trust and responsibility to increasing amounts of freedom in the community.
Developing the Authority of Conscience
Ages 14 to 15 Expect confusion over authority. Expect a search for real
authority.
Expect episodic resistance to moral dialogue
Honor privacy of thoughts, moods, and possessions
Intervene when behavior may be harmful to self or others
Expect the development of idols and ideals that honor individual freedom and peer responsibility
Be on the lookout for adults and peers of bad conscience
Affirm inspiring teachers, religious leaders, coaches and all who work with youth
Be an admired authority
Developing the Authority of Conscience
Ages 16 to 17+
Encourage as much complex moral thinking as the teenager can tolerate
Give the teenager room to make as many independent moral decisions as you believe he or she can handle
Congratulate courageous moral decision making
Developing the Authority of Conscience
What is the fairest or most caring thing to do in this
situation?
Incorporating the Golden Rule gives a conscience flexibility. We want students to develop a flexible conscience – one that will help them think through moral issues in uncharted waters according to a general principle of fairness and caring.
Developing the Golden Rule of Conscience
Ages 0 to 6 Students search for the Golden Rule
Peer empathy is a requirement for finding the G. R.
Path to peer empathy includes mutual enjoyment, turn-taking, reciprocal tolerance, and mutual misery.
Intervene in conflicts when harm is threatened
Look for moral teaching moments with mediation:
Physically and emotionally safe zone; Frame conflict as a joint problem; Teach each child to listen calmly to the other’s point of view; Offer solution choices
When moral teaching moments fail, authority solutions
Developing the Golden Rule of Conscience
Age 7 to 11 Help equate friendship with niceness
Realize student’s need for continuity in friendship
Teach how to maintain self-worth through ignoring meanness
Help student understand justifications for mean feelings
Help student think carefully about consequences if meanness is returned with meanness.
Help find Golden Rule morality in literature and movies
Rescue when someone’s meanness is overwhelming
Developing the Golden Rule of Conscience
Ages 12 to 13 Expect “hanging out” and provide protective environments
Expect self-consciousness to emerge
Look for thinking that involves inductive (specific to general) and deductive (general to specific) reasoning.
Growing understanding of virtue and vice
Engage discussions about “the person I want to be”
Affirm efforts in seeking understanding of others
Engage in conscience discussions and honor moral privacy
When moral behavior improves, recognize the golden moment
Developing the Golden Rule of Conscience
Ages 14 to 15
Expect growth of peer loyalty and confidentiality
Expect peer-group labeling and judging
Be alert to over-involvement in peer problems
Strike a balance between nosiness and aloofness from teen peer activities
Be alert to potential harm – intervene
Be loyal to the whole teen community by getting involved in teen groups
Provide opportunities for altruistic behavior in teen groups
Developing the Golden Rule of Conscience
Ages 16 to 17+
Affirm moral individuality within peer group
Affirm emancipation from peer dependence
Affirm acts of moral courage
Affirm belief in universal human rights
Empathize with frustration over the gap between idealism and reality
Respect calls to service
Developing the Golden Rule of Conscience
Moral Willpower is using personal choice to follow,
not follow, or temper the guidance of conscience. The effect of willpower The establishment of self-concept (knowing who I am)
precedes the development of self-consciousness ( knowing right or wrong)
We want each student to have a courageous moral “I”
Want-to-do and will-do precede ought-to-do
Control and sharing control
Mold self-doubt and shame toward the pursuit of goodness
Goodwill involves a gradual transfer of responsibility to student
Developing Moral Willpower
Ages 0 to 6
Affirm basic goodness
Create a safe environment for play, take note of moral themes in play, and follow the lead of student
Use rewards to teach you child restraint and cheer success
Model restraint
Developing Moral Willpower
Ages 7 to 11
Support skill development
Help find balance between effort and sufficiency
Explore the values of truth, rule-following, and boundaries
Don’t get bored with board games. There are moral lessons
Help your child construct his own rules
Developing Moral Willpower
Ages 12 to 13
Affirm awareness of a private and public self
Admire abstract moral meaning based on experience and memory
Affirm virtuous striving
Study rules in terms of duty, virtue, and autonomy
Be open to negotiating student-initiated contracts
Find satisfaction in your own virtuous striving
Developing Moral Willpower
Ages 14 to 15 Appreciate student’s desire to belong in peer community
Accept peer belonging as a steppingstone to psychological emancipation
Be aware of adolescent risk-taking temptations
Become a risk-manager and intervene in times of danger
Admire student’s moral inspirations and aspirations
Become a promoter of moral inspiration and aspiration in the community
Affirm the moral decision-making process more than the decisions themselves
Developing Moral Willpower
Ages 16 to 17+
Affirm psychological emancipation from peer dependency
Affirm satisfaction in individual responsibility
Affirm judgment that incorporates the complexities of good and evil
Affirm tolerance and forgiveness
Affirm humor about human condition
Affirm moral alertness
Find new moral commitments
Developing Moral Willpower
Each of the biological building blocks of human
survival – attachment, caretaking, emotion, thought, memory, value, language, action, and defense –influences how we construct moral meaning. These program us to function with continuity, rhythm, structure, and alertness for meaning. Moral meaning captures what we believe to be the most important aspects of life. Conscience holds that meaning in place.
Developing the Meaning of Conscience
Ages 0 to 6
May not be able to describe conscience, but can draw and tell personal stories of right and wrong
Young students believe in moral heritage.
Moral-emotional responsiveness begin to function
Developing the Meaning of Conscience
Ages 7 to 11
Understanding that rules for right and wrong are inside
Adult attitudes shape the student’s attitudes about rules of conscience
Developing the Meaning of Conscience
Ages 12 to 13
Rules of conscience nag or whisper as a real authority. Temptation is conceptualized as a real force. Being well-intended or striving to do the right thing counts as moral behavior. Rules of conscience tend to be restated as virtues. Failure is more forgivable when wrongdoing was not intended. Reparation and healing are now undertaken to restore internal as well as external harmony
Developing the Meaning of Conscience
Ages 14 to 15
Moral authority is spoken about with less certainty. Tone will suggest hesitation, unrest, or confusion. Peer-centered values, well-fed by popular culture will capture moral interest. When facing a moral decision involving conflicting values, great distress could be experienced. Distress in tolerable amounts prompts moral development and growth of conscience.
Developing the Meaning of Conscience
Ages 16 to 17+
Leading a moral life is no longer a simple matter of compliance with stored rules. Each moral situation requires careful consideration. Ambiguity and dilemmas are often present. Philosophical questions regarding means-ends justifications are present. When to act may become just as important as how to act. Individual moral identity is more important than peer dependency.
Stilwell, Galvin, & Kopta (2000)
Developing the Meaning of Conscience
The Brain and Social Emotional Learning
Principles
Neuroscientists such as Damasio (1999, 2003) & Pert (1997) confirm that every thought and action is accompanied by emotion. Although the amygdala in the center of the brain often is referred to as the center of emotions because it is so deeply involved with threat and fear, emotions of any kind engage many areas of the brain and a cacophony of chemical and other physical interactions. For instance, many muscles are involved in emotional reactions, and the immune system, which guards against many diseases is affected (Detweiler et al. 2000).p. 91 In Caine & Caine et al. (2016)
Emotions and Brain Physiology
All communications and activities occur on
conscious and nonconscious levels at the same time. It is critical, therefore, to train teachers to make the most of nonverbal messages and replace negative implications with affirming impressions
Jensen (2008)
Conscious and Nonconscious Learning
Creating the optimal emotional climate for meaningful learning
Healthy Relationships within a stable, supportive social context
Developmentally appropriate challenging environment with influence over resources and activities - Learning comfort with high challenge
Confident, competent and intrinsically motivated through personal goals and interests
Feedback is immediate, reliable and relevant
Innate belief in oneself and one’s ability to achieve – Self-efficacy
Ongoing deep capacity to bounce back from failure or set-backs –Resilience
Belief that one can influence events and sustain motivation, set appropriate goals that are attainable and challenging, use appropriate strategies and manage their time and resources – Self-Regulated Learners
Caine & Caine et al (2009)
Optimal Emotional Climate
Flow is a pattern of activity in which individual or group goals
emerge (as opposed to being mandated) as a result of a pleasurable activity and interaction with the environment. When skills, attention, environment, and will are aligned, flow is more likely to occur. Creativity and learning emerge in an accelerated fashion when learners are encouraged to enjoy themselves while defining and refining their own learning challenges. Learners take responsibility for learning in a relaxed state when the balance of challenge and mastery is equal.
Csikszentmihalyi (1990)
Flow
Optimum learning resulting from a feeling of
confidence and competence.
Can think in abstract ways and has the ability to plan for the future.
Engagement of interests with purpose and meaning.
Reflection and higher-order thinking.
Subcortex and Neocortex areas of the Brain
Perry (2003) in Caine & Caine et al. (2009)
Calm Mind State
Chemicals of emotion are released simultaneously
with cognition
Critical links between emotions and cognitive patterning. High interest – Want more ; Low interest – Seek less
Feeling good allows one to sort experiences and recall with more clarity.
Positive memories aid the ability to remember
Jensen (2008)
Positive Emotions
Better working memory
Better memory of events
See more options for solving problems
More flexible in thinking
More competent in creating social relationships (helpfulness and sociability)
Greater verbal fluency (innovative)
Better decision-making ability
Perry (2003) in Caine & Caine et al. (2009)
Emotions in an arousal state are important in all mental functions and contribute significantly to attention, perception, memory, emotion, and problem solving LeDoux (1996) in Jensen (2008) p. 85
Positive Emotions Enhance Executive Function
Mind – calming visualization or relaxation exercise
Physical activity
Dialogue time with partners or small group
Internal reflection and goal setting
Allow negative feelings to be put behind us
Simulations of working together
Music
Two teams – games, challenges
Dance
Novel and challenging activities Jensen (2008)
Positive Emotions = Meaningful Learning
Felt Meaning – Engages thoughts, emotions, senses, and body.
Positive experiences increases long term memory and learning.
Purpose and Passion – Developing a sense of personal calling combined with rigor, persistence and perseverance.
Dissonance – A sense of discomfort in new situations until the familiar is found and meaning is established
Valuing – How we relate to ideas, situations, and other people. The valuing system is connected to emotions and will determine what we pay attention to or avoid.
Making Connections – How new ideas, skills, and experiences are related to what we currently know or believe.
Real Understanding – Synthesis and mastery to gain a shift in perception (actions)
Caine & Caine et al. (2009)
Meaningful Learning is Intrinsically Rewarding
Include the Brain
Provide variety of instruction
Use error correction daily
Use short instructional segments
Enrich the environment every chance you can
Keep adjusting what you do
Manage the emotional states
Manage the positives, and limit the intense negatives
Shape and influence meaning proactively
Jensen (2008)
Include the Brain
Influence perception more than reality
Engage multiple learning and memory systems
Use novel repetition
Teach estimation and prediction skills daily
Ask for student input; then incorporate it
Social structures
Arts and Physical Education
Collaboration
Jensen (2008)
A person’s level of motivation on any given task is a
product of both how much the person wants the rewards that accompany success and how much he or she expects to be successful
Motivation for most behaviors is usually a mix of intrinsic and extrinsic factors. The frequent skier may find that in addition to the exhilaration of skiing itself, she also enjoys having others comment on her skill
Sprick (2009)
Motivation
Meet learners’ needs and goals. Thank student for and
compliment specific observed actions.
Provide a sense of control and choice
Encourage and provide for positive social bonding
Support a sense of curiosity
Engage strong emotions
Encourage adequate nutrition
Incorporate multiple intelligences
Share success stories
Provide acknowledgements Jensen (2008)
Internal Motivation
Increase frequency of feedback
Manage physiological states
Provide the hope of success
Model the joy of learning
Mark successes and achievements with celebrations
Maintain a physically and emotionally safe learning environment
Incorporate learners’ individual learning styles
Instill positive beliefs about capability and contextJensen (2008)
Internal Motivation
Challenge – provides intermediate level of difficulty
for the learner
Goals – clear fixed goals or student-generated with varying difficulty, multiple levels of goals, hidden information (new information presented), randomness
Performance feedback – frequent, clear, constructive, and encouraging
Self-esteem – feedback promotes feelings of competence
Malone & Lepper (1987)
Individual Motivations
Curiosity – Provide moderate level of informational
complexity or discrepancy from the learner’s current state of knowledge and information
Sensory Curiosity – Activity promotes interactive exchange with the learner
Cognitive Curiosity – Curiosity may be promoted by instructional techniques that cause learners to be surprised and intrigued by paradoxes, incompleteness, or potential simplifications. Enhanced with topics in which learner is already interested.
Malone & Lepper (1987)
Individual Motivations
Control – Activity should promote feelings of self-
determination and control on the part of the learner.
Contingency – Provide a responsive learning environment
Choice – Provide and emphasize moderately high levels of choice over various aspects of the learning environment.
Power – Permits the learner to produce powerful effects
Malone & Lepper (1987)
Individual Motivations
Fantasy – Activity may promote intrinsic motivation
through the use of fantasy involvement
Emotional Aspects – Designed to appeal to the emotional needs of learners
Cognitive Aspects – Appropriate metaphors or analogies for the material presented for learning
Endogeneity – Have an integral, endogenous relationship to the material to be learned
Malone & Lepper (1987)
Individual Motivations
Cooperation – The appeal of the activity may be
enhanced by enlisting the motivation to cooperate with others. Internal cooperative motivation may be produced by segmenting the activity into inherently inter(de)pendent parts.
Malone & Lepper (1987)
Interpersonal Motivations
Competition – The appeal of the activity may be
enhanced by enlisting the motivation to compete with others. Internal competitive motivation may be produced by creating an activity in which competitors’ actions affect each other.
Malone & Lepper (1987)
Interpersonal Motivations
Recognition – The appeal of the activity may be
increased if the learner’s efforts receive social recognition. Internal recognition motivation may be produced by activities that provide natural channels for students’ efforts to be appreciated by others.
Malone & Lepper (1987)
Interpersonal Motivations
Setting short-term and long-term goals and believing
they will succeed
Persisting under pressure
Visualizing a positive future (optimism)
Searching out successful strategies or resources
Having a more positive attitude
Caine & Caine et al. (2016)
Self-Efficacy, Resilience, and Self-Regulation
Possessing good social skills (getting along with and
being liked by others)
Being independent (autonomy)
Using time management, which includes being able to pursue goals when situations change
Knowing how to learn and how they learn
Evaluating themselves
Caine & Caine et al. (2016)
Self-Efficacy, Resilience, and Self-Regulation
Think before reacting, “How can I (teacher or
student) bring this down and get back to learning?
Mindful moment to practice breathing, stretching and focusing
Lots of visual cues in classroom to increase memory retention and language development
Teaching strategies using repeating verbal instructions, using more written instructions, and visual prompts for multi-step directions
Flannery (2017)
Trauma Sensitive Education
A brief break for a student on the verge of losing
control, and needing to refocus, can be helpful
Give students the support (emotional) they need to access your regular curriculum
We need to provide the materials or create the conditions that enable children to be successful
Practice the lifelong skills of self-regulation or how to calm down and re-focus their minds
Flannery (2017)
Trauma Sensitive Education
Deep Breathing
Counting
Saying the ABC’s
Thought Stopping
Muscle Relaxation
Visual Imagery
Positive Self-Talk
Isometrics
Anger Diary/Journaling Hensley et al.(2016)
Self-Control Strategies
The ability to achieve the preferred state of alertness
for the given situation. This includes regulating one’s body’s needs as well as one’s emotions.
The ideal state of alertness is calm, happy, focused, or content and the student feels a strong sense of internal control.
Kuypers (2011)
Self - Regulation
Unproductive patterns of behavior resulting from
early neglect or trauma can be altered with awareness and practice. Pause, breathe deeply to relax and choose to act more appropriately. Jensen (2008)
Learned Positive Behavior
ABCDE of learned positive thought when faced with adversity Adversity – the introduction of a negative occurrence
Belief – negative feelings/beliefs that lower esteem and opportunity
Consequences – result of staying with the negative belief
Disputation – “Argument” to dispel negative belief including evidence, alternatives, implications, usefulness related to the negative belief
Energization – See the big picture of reflective perspective through disputation Seligman (1990)
Learned Optimism
Learned Optimism is a tool to help the individual
achieve the goals he has set for himself. It is in the choice of the goals themselves that meaning – or emptiness – resides. When learned optimism is coupled with a renewed commitment to the commons, our epidemic of depression and meaninglessness may end.
Seligman (1990) p. 291
Learned Optimism
The Brain and Social Emotional Inhibitors
Not knowing what to do or how to react - Sense of
Helplessness
Fear leads to the threat response of chemicals in the brain which limit complex thinking and activate the survival mode of thinking
These Mind States are progressive including Arousal, Alarm, Fear, and Terror
Perry (2003) in Caine & Caine et al. (2009)
The Brain and Social Emotional Inhibitors
Inhibitor Mind States in Physical Education
Arousal – Limbic and Cortex – Needs concrete information
Alarm – Midbrain and Limbic – Sensing danger and emotional with anger or withdrawal
Perry (2003) in Caine & Caine et al. (2009)
New motor skill learning – focusing every effort on making body parts perform the skill
Reteach, analysis, personalized positive and helpful hint. Problem solving with another person.
Inhibitor Mind States in Physical Education
Fear – Brain Stem and Midbrain – Reactive, stimulus-response automatic mode.
Terror – Brain Stem –Autonomic Nervous system – out of control or in shut down mode.
Perry (2003) in Caine & Caine et al. (2009)
Emotional response needing a calming time until able to join in –Complex physical learning such as Double Dutch needing total focus
Argue (cry) with teacher -Climbing rope/Cargo Net –Weak at net, Rest Station to internalize climbing method
Stress Responses
Positive Stress Response – is normal and an essential part of healthy development characterized by increases in heart rate and mild elevations in hormone levels
Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University (2017)
Tolerable Stress Response – activates the body’s alert systems to a greater degree as a result of more severe, longer-lasting difficulties such as loss of a loved one
Toxic Stress Response – can occur when a child
experiences strong, frequent, and/or prolonged adversity – such as physical or emotional abuse, chronic neglect, caregiver substance abuse or mental illness, exposure to violence, and/or the accumulated burdens of family economic hardship –without adequate adult support. This prolonged activation of the stress response systems can disrupt the development of brain architecture and other organ systems, and increase the risk for stress-related disease and cognitive impairment, well into the adult years. Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University (2017)
Stress Response
Distressed Emotions Lead to Fight or Flight Behaviors
Hyper-arousal (Fight)
Unable to focus or be still
Will not adhere to rules
Aggressive
Resistant to directives
Argumentative
Anxious before tests
Impulsive
Risk-taking
Forbes (2012)
Hypo-arousal (Flight)
Defiant
Withdraws from peers
Tardy
Absent
Disassociates – shuts down
Avoids tasks
Numbs out “I don’t care” attitude
Forgetful
Suppressing – Not feeling or pretending not to feel
Rebelling – Acting out
Bullying – Minimizing another
Undermining – Using sarcasm to reduce another
Ignoring – Failing to recognize the problem
Ostracizing – Out casting others to minimize them
Retaliating – Getting back at another
Intimidating – Threatening words
Marking – Destroying propertyCaine & Caine et al. (2009)
Negative Emotions Lead to Negative Behaviors
Positive Punishment occurs when an adverse stimulus is given to decrease the probability the undesired behavior will occur in the future. Negative side effects include:
The punisher is negatively reinforced
The student becomes emotional or aggressive
Avoidance and escape
Negative modeling
Unpredictability Hensley et al. (2016)
Positive Punishment has Negative Side Effects
Seek Professional Help when faced with these
challenges:
Depression
Anxiety
Eating Disorders
Psychosis
Substance Use
Disruptive Behavior Disorders
Suicidal Thoughts and BehaviorsNational Council for Behavioral Health (2016)
Mental Health First Aid
Possession or threat with a weapon
Physical Assault – striking with intent to harm
Verbal Abuse – Swearing, Obscene Gestures or Threats, Written
Intimidation – Frighten or coerce into obedience
Extortion – Coercion to reap financial or material gain
Bullying
Gang Activity – Groups advocating drug use, violence, or disruptive behavior School Board Policy JICDD
http://www.Thompsonschools.org
Acts of Violence or Aggression
Sexual Harassment -
Stalking – Persistent following, contacting, or watching that compromise peace of mind
Defiance – Opposing legitimate authority
Discriminatory Slurs – Derogatory comments made directly or by innuendo regarding race, color, ancestry, creed, sex, sexual orientation, religion, national origin, disability, or need of special education
School Board Policy JICDD http://www.Thompsonschools.org
Acts of Violence or Aggression
Vandalism – Damaging or defacing property
Terrorism – A treat to commit violence communicated with intent or reckless disregard for creating terror or causing public inconvenience such as evacuation of a building
School Board Policy JICDD http://www.Thompsonschools.org
Acts of Violence or Aggression
Classroom Culture to Support Positive
Behavior
Structures in the Classroom that Facilitate Valuing Diversity
7 Commitments leading individuals and
organizations away from trauma-reactive behaviors
Commitment to:
Nonviolence – building and modeling safety skills
Emotional Intelligence - teaching and modeling affect management skills
Inquiry & Social Learning - building and modeling cognitive skills
Democracy - creating and modeling civic skills of self-control, self-discipline, and administration of healthy authority http://www.sanctuaryinstitute.org
Sanctuary Model
Open Communication - overcoming barriers to
healthy communication, reduce acting-out, enhance self-protective and self-correcting skills, teach healthy boundaries
Social Responsibility - rebuilding social connection skills, establish healthy attachment relationships
Growth and Change - restoring hope, meaning, purpose
http://www.sanctuaryinstitute.org
Sanctuary Model
The Circle of Courage is based on Native American
child rearing philosophies that emphasize the education and empowerment of children. The Circle of Courage philosophy recognizes there are four basic values that are universal to human needs: Belonging, Mastery, Independence, and Generosity.
Glembocki & Dunn (2010)
Circle of Courage
Belonging – The universal desire for positive and caring
relationships. To be an important person in the eyes of significant others. To believe, “I belong here and I am cared for.”
Mastery – Our innate thirst for learning. Mastery is nurtured as we gain academic and social competence and learn to cope with the world. To believe, “I am good at something.”
Independence – Our desire to exercise free will. Independence is fostered by increased responsibility. To believe, “I have the power to make good decisions.”
Generosity – Our passion for life nurtured by developing concern for others and a commitment beyond ones’ self. To believe, “I have a purpose. I can make a difference.”
Glembocki & Dunn (2010)
Circle of Courage Values
Restorative Justice repairs the harm caused by crime It emphasizes accountability, making amends and if interested,
facilitated meetings between victims, offenders, and other persons.
Problem Solving – Listen with Respect while one person speaks. Explain what happened – Tell how you felt about it –Share what you would like to happen differently next time. The other person then explains what happened, how s/he felt, and what could happen differently next time.
http://www.restorativejustice.org
Restorative Justice
Acknowledges that relationships are central to building
community
Builds systems that address misbehavior and harm in a way that strengthens relationships
Focuses on the harm done rather than only on rule-breaking
Gives voice to the persons harmed
Engages in collaborative problem-solving
Empowers change and growth
Enhances responsibility
Plan for restoration
Amstutz & Mullet (2015)
Restorative Discipline
Building schoolwide Climate and Culture of Caring and
compassion by teaching social emotional intelligence and life skills
Research shows that when basic emotional needs are met, classrooms are more productive and the learning environment is enhanced.
Developing compassionate communication skills for success in life
Moving away from punitive discipline to Restorative Practice
Kiri Saftler, MSD author http://www.peacecircles.org
Peace Circles
Student driven Conflict Resolution
Classroom and school-wide Community Building
Awareness of respectful relationship interactions and interpersonal affect
Preventative Restorative Justice Practice
Classroom Management tool
http://www.peacecircles.org
Peacekeeper Circles
Fortify student autonomy – empower children to resolve
own conflicts Engender respect across race, gender, and ability –
Educate children to respect and communicate with everyone
Reduce bullying behaviors – Compassionate communication taught in schools builds a healthier school-wide climate and culture
Teachers and students listen to one another – Becoming more understanding to others’ situations and tend to care and be responsive to needs.
http://www.peacecircles.org
Peacekeeper Skills
Students learn to:
Engage in honest and respectful dialog
Respect classmates and teachers
Respect the uniqueness of fellow students
Listen to others’ perspectives
Actively engage in collaborative and group learning
http://www.peacecircles.org
Peacekeeper Skills
Classrooms are an ideal place to develop
relationship-building skills. Students learn:
The art of relationship and community building
The value of making amends
Compassionate and respectful communications
Understanding and respecting others’ perspectives
How actions affect others
http://www.peacecircles.org
Peace Circles
Relationship – Caring, Compassion and
Understanding
Respect – No interrupting or shaming; Involves inclusion and collaboration
Responsibility – Ownership of harm and future behavior
Repair – Appropriate amends and solutions
Reintegration – Build trust, safety and community Saftler (2003)
Restorative Practices 5 R’s
Core of democracy is that people
Have a fundamental right to human dignity
Have a responsibility to care about the common good, dignity, and welfare of others
Can see their own personal fate tied to the good of the group as a whole
Have the intellectual and social capacity to work together to resolve issues as they arise
Student differences are not problems to overcome
The United States is based on this aspiration of continual self-improvement.
Beane (2005) In Thomlinson & Imbeau (2010)
Democratic Classroom
Mission – What we will do
Values – Guidelines for behavior
Practices - How we will achieve what we do
People – Developing the human resource
Narrative – Stories that convey culture
Place – Functional and appealing
Hoerr (2017)
Developing Culture
Use Flexible Grouping – Teachers plan a consistent flow of
varied student groupings within a unit of study based on the nature of the work and the individual needs of students.
Teach Up - Design group tasks to ensure that each student works with a rich curriculum and has to think about and apply essential ideas and skills.
Use Multiple Ability Tasks – Such tasks have more than one right answer or way to solve a problem, are intrinsically interesting and rewarding to a variety of students, allow different students to make different contributions to the successful completion of a task, and require a variety of skills and strengths for successful completion.
Tomlinson & Imbeau (2010)
Student Groups and Classroom Community
Assign Individual Roles Within Groups – Individual
roles ensure that each student has a genuinely important academic or intellectual contribution to make to the task.
Make Content Accessible to Everyone – In mixed-readiness groups, assure that content is available to all.
Assign Competence – Observe students carefully, noting the particular strengths, skills and insights they bring to group work. Specifically compliment when genuinely warranted – it is important for all students, but particularly important for students who may be seen as having lower status among peers.
Tomlinson & Imbeau (2010)
Student Groups and Classroom Community
Is my classroom a “Bam” classroom?
What is my classroom’s way of life?
What is it about my classroom that my students can’t wait to come back in the morning?
Do I teach math or do I teach Mathew?
Is my classroom’s brand identity conducive to learning at the highest levels?
Kafele (2016)
Reflection on Classroom Climate and Culture
Quality Teaching Practices
Joy – is connected to play. Fun (a precursor to joy) is
experienced when games are used.
Enthusiasm – is generated when new and creative ways are used to explore or connect with learning.
Awe – is generated when students see or experience inspiring mastery. At its core, awe is associated with a sense of wonder and engages the search for meaning. Caine & Caine et al. (2016)
Teach the Three Positive Emotions
The cerebellum processes balance, posture, and
movement leading to predicting, goal setting, analyzing variables, predicting outcomes, and then, executing movements. It also utilizes the mental processes of predicting, sequencing, ordering, timing, and practicing a task before carrying it out. There is a strong relationship between motor and cognitive processes.
Jensen (2008)
Mind, Body Link
Enhances circulation so neurons get more oxygen
and nutrients
Spur production of nerve growth factor which enhances brain function
Gross motor movement stimulates production of dopamine, a mood-enhancing neurotransmitter
Exercise enhances new cell production, memory, and connections between neurons in the brain for learning
Jensen (2008)
Exercise and the Brain
Aerobic exercise improves thinking and learning due
to the adrenaline-noradrenaline response which is critical to facing and coping with challenges
Physical activity uses 100% of the brain and no known cognitive activity can claim this.
“Physical Education at school is a great idea for many reasons, just one of which is that it builds new brain cells (neurogenesis). There are no data that say that about any other class at school!”
Jensen (2008)
Exercise and the Brain
Neurogenesis is correlated with improved learning
and memory and is also inversely correlated with depression
Exercise triggers release of Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor (BDNF) a natural substance that enhances cognition by boosting the ability of neurons to communicate with each other. This is also related to increases in long-term memory
Exercise reduces stress
Jensen (2008)
Exercise and the Brain
Exercise and the Brain
Learning
Ratey (2008)
Neurons sprouting new dendrites requires Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor. “All you have to do is lace up your running shoes.” p. 48
Exercise and the Brain
Stress
Ratey (2008)
Cortisol – a little helps wire in memory, too much suppresses them and an overload can actually erode the connections between neurons and destroy memories. “Just keep in mind that the more stress you have, the more your body needs to move to keep your brain running smoothly.” p. 84
Exercise and the Brain
Anxiety
Ratey (2008)
Outrun the fear It provides distraction
It reduces muscle tension
It builds brain resources
It teaches a different outcome
It reroutes your circuits
It improves resilience
It sets you free pgs. 106-108
Exercise and the Brain
Depression
Ratey (2008)
At its core, depression is defined by an absence of moving toward anything, and exercise is the way to divert those negative signals and trick the brain into coming out of hibernation. p. 140
Exercise and the Brain
Attention Deficit
Ratey (2008)
Aerobic Exercise for 30 minutes each day.
Any medication taken when effects of exercise wears off (1 hour)
Exercise at lunch
Exercise and the Brain
Addiction
Ratey (2008)
Exercise is by far the best form of self-regulation we have (p 188)
Exercise isn’t necessarily a cure…rewiring the brain to circumvent the addictive pattern and curbing the craving (p 190)
Strengthens the cardiovascular system
Regulates fuel
Reduces obesity
Elevates your stress threshold
Lifts your mood
Boosts the immune system
Fortifies your bones
Boosts motivation
Fosters neuroplasticity Ratey (2008)
Exercise and the Brain
Aerobic – 4 days each week, varying from 30 to 60
minutes at 60 to 65 percent of maximum heart rate
Strength – 2 days each week, 3 sets of exercises at weights allowing 10 to 15 repetitions in each set
Balance and Flexibility – 2 days each week for 30 minutes
Mental Exercise – Keep learning
Ratey (2008)
Exercise and the BrainSelf-Care and Aging
Portrait of the Year – Curriculum Map
Identify the Units to be Taught
Determine Sequence of Units
Allocate Time for Each Unit
Systematize Decisions such as subject goals, grade-level standard objectives, integrated subject areas
Glatthorn (1994)
Developing a Quality Curriculum
Pre-exposure – Overview of new learning before
beginning to provide better conceptual understanding
Preparation – Creating curiosity and excitement to engage positive emotions
Initiation and Acquisition – Immersion by teaching with every learning modality – visual, auditory, kinesthetic
Jensen (2008)
Brain-Based Planning
Elaboration – Processing and making intellectual
sense of the learning
Incubation and Memory Encoding – Downtime to review and learn over time
Verification and Confidence Check – Students confirm learning with and to each other
Celebration and Integration – Engage positive emotions and a love of learning
Jensen (2008)
Brain-Based Planning
Evaluation
Synthesis
Analysis
Application
Comprehension
Knowledge
Bloom (1956) cited in Sousa (2006) p. 249
Bloom’s Taxonomy
Create
Evaluate
Analyze
Apply
Understand
Remember
Anderson et al. (2001) cited in Sousa (2006) p. 250
Bloom’s Taxonomy Revised Version (2001)
Level 4 – Extended Thinking (Complex Reasoning, Design,
Create, Synthesize, Analyze, Apply Concepts –Relate ideas within and among content areas and select one solution from many alternatives)
Level 3 – Strategic Thinking (Complex and Abstract, Revise, Justify, Critique, Draw Conclusions, Compare, Investigate, Differentiate- More than one answer and justify the response, multiple dependent variables)
Webb, N. L. (2002)
Depth-of-KnowledgeScience as Inquiry
Level 2 – Skills and Concepts (2 steps – Organize,
Represent, Interpret Data, Observe, Graph, Classify, Estimate – “Formulate a routine problem given data and conditions)
Level 1 - Recall and Reproduction ( 1 step -Calculate, Identify, Use, Recognize, Measure – Knowledge automatically provides answer)
Webb, N. L. (2002)
Depth-of-KnowledgeScience as Inquiry
Pre-Exposure and Priming – Tell students what unit is in the
future; it establishes (time for) background, relevance, and expedites future learning
Sufficient Time for Learning – Plan for content, review and reflection
Low or No Threat – Focus on learning with frequent nonjudgmental feedback and redirect as needed
Prep for Final Performance – Do not give pop quizzes. Rather, provide ungraded pretests (formative guided practice) so learners can discover strengths and weaknesses before test scores are final (mastery)
Jensen (2008)
Integrating Brain-Based Learning in the Classroom
High Engagement – Engage learners physically and
socially so that they are continually interacting and taking action
Positive Emotional Engagement – Teach learners to manage their own learning states and reduce negative states by changing activities frequently
Learner Choice – Learners feel empowered and trust you have their best interest at heart to feel power in the relationship
Jensen (2008)
Integrating Brain-Based Learning in the Classroom
Moderate to High Challenge – Can adjust factors of
time, standards, resources, or circumstances
Strong Peer Support – Learners helping each other achieve the best learning results for the greatest number of people
Mastery Goals – Share and post teaching goals and learning goals with benchmarks
Sufficient Non-learning Time – Provide time to process and transfer learning from short-term to long-term
Jensen (2008)
Integrating Brain-Based Learning in the Classroom
Balancing Novelty and Predictability – the best
balance is to provide high amounts of novelty (surprise) and predictability (ritual)
Safe for Taking Risks – Adopt a zero-tolerance policy for teasing, humiliation, put-downs, or name calling
Moderate Stress – Monitor tension and manage if too high (intro humor, movement, game, quiet time) or too low (intro challenges or raise the stakes)
Jensen (2008)
Integrating Brain-Based Learning in the Classroom
Alternating Low to High Energy - Acknowledge
biorhythm cycles of natural ups and downs
Multimodal Input – Learning activities offer auditory, visual and kinesthetic components
Frequent Feedback – Ensure that every students gets some kind of feedback every 30 minutes or so
Celebrate the Learning – Optimal learning adds an element of fun celebration to the process and engages the learner’s emotions
Jensen (2008)
Integrating Brain-Based Learning in the Classroom
Acknowledgment of Value – Each person contributes
to the learning community and is vital
Everyone Feels Cared For – For their contribution and involvement
Freedom of Expression – Each can share their feelings without fear of humiliation
Encourage Affiliation – Healthy friendships through group/team work
Accountability – Consistency with rules, policies and norms Jensen (2008)
Environment with the Brain in Mind
Hope of Success – Hope is bettering the situation
Orchestrated Common Experiences – Develop common ground with shared experiences
Physically Safe Environment – Zero tolerance of physical bullying
Trust of Others – We are safe to express ourselves and understand we will be treated fairly and with respect.
Consistency of Structure – Predictable rituals and traditions in which everyone participates. Jensen (2008)
Environment with the Brain in Mind
Instructional Approaches
Instructional Model
Inductive Thinking
Attaining Concepts
Inquiry
Advanced Organizers
Memorization
Cognitive Psychology
Biological Science Inquiry
Joyce & Weil (1986)
Physical Education Skills practice and solving
movement questions
Thinking skills in analysis
Build on current understanding toward greater analysis
Reference and visual graphics
Routines
Explaining concepts developmentally appropriate for students to understand
Gathering data, analyze and problem solve in fitness testing
Instructional Approaches
Instructional Model
Non-directive Teaching
Synectics
Increasing Awareness
Classroom Meeting
Group Investigation
Role Playing
Joyce & Weil (1986)
Physical Education
Create-a-game Strategy building to increase group
cohesion and empathy
Understand human potential
During closure for greater understanding
Democracy in understanding rules and Shared refereeing
Negative examples given by teacher, Positive examples by students
Instructional Approaches
Instructional Model
Jurisprudential Inquiry
Leadership
Social Science Inquiry
Mastery Learning
Direct Instruction
Learning Self-Control
Learning from Simulations
Joyce & Weil (1986)
Physical Education Fairness for all, fair teams, modified
rules
Increase ability to work with all
Converse about team dynamics
Standards attainment
Most concise explanation and increased movement time
Utilize feedback to modify behavior
Multiple opportunities to practice game play in a unit
Instructional Approaches
Instructional Model
Assertiveness Training
Thinking Skills
Conditions of Learning
Conceptual Systems Theory
Joyce & Weil (1986)
Physical Education
Problem solving Analysis, perspective,
comprehensiveness
Prerequisite knowledge builds new knowledge
Predicting student preferences and accommodating them – fair teams, modified rules
Each approach plays a part in learning and are on a continuum of complexity
Direct Instruction – Information delivered, skills practiced, testing is essential
Project-Based-Problem-Based Learning and Teaching – Builds upon DI, active and engaged, context matters and is meaningful, students connect with discourse and perform
Guided Experience – Embraces DI and PB with students designing their own research questions and presentation of learning with multiplicity of experiences
Caine & Caine et al. (2016)
Instructional Approaches
A teacher nurtures a child’s social/emotional, physical,
and cognitive development by basing all practices and decisions on: Theories of child development
The individually identified strengths and weaknesses of each child
The child’s family and cultural background
Individualization becomes key in making sure the needs and interests of each child are focused on.
Kochhar-Bryant (2010)
Developmentally Appropriate Practices
Bodily-Kinesthetic
Musical
Spatial
Verbal-Linguistic
Logical-Mathematical
Interpersonal
Intrapersonal
Naturalist
Silver, Strong, Perini (2000)
Multiple Intelligences
Perception Axis from Sensing (step-by-step
procedure and concreteness) to Intuition (insight and abstraction)
Judgement Axis from Thinking (logic and objectivity) to Feeling (emotion and spontaneity)
Silver, Strong, & Perini (2000)
Learning Styles
Specific type of group work with these defining
elements
Positive Interdependence – Success of the whole depends on each individual
Face-to-face Interaction – Students interact directly with each other
Individual Accountability – Each can be evaluated for specific elements of the task
Social Skill Development – Social skills incorporated
Evaluation – Evaluating how the group functions
Voltz, Sims, & Nelson (2010)
Cooperative Learning
Behavioral and academic expectations defined –
(Including safety and independent work)
Activities focus on material that student already knows – (Review after skills have been taught)
Equipment and Materials available in the activity area
Activities novel and engaging – (Variety of challenges with skill mastery)
System of accountability – Productivity is expectedVoltz, Sims, & Nelson (2010)
StationsLearning Centers
Identify content to be taught with the graphic
organizer
Select the layout that best fits the content
Complete the graphic organizer prior to instruction
Can be used before, during, or after instruction
Voltz, Sims, & Nelson (2010)
Graphic Organizers
Making explicit provisions for adapting the
curriculum to students’ particular abilities and needs…goes far beyond the narrow view of providing for self-pacing including:
Content emphasis
Skills to be mastered
Level of achievement expected
Pace of learning
Method of learningGlatthorn (1994)
Individualizing the Curriculum
Learning environment provided
Degree of learning structure
Learning materials
Type and amount of feedback
Means of final assessment
Personal meaning
Glatthorn (1994)
Individualizing the Curriculum
Student controls pace and mastery of topic
Teacher drives instruction through teacher-created tasks and related lesson plans.
Kallick & Zmuda (2017)
Individualization
Student selects from a range of content, process, or
product options
Teacher shapes instruction based on individual student needs and preferences Kallick & Zmuda (2017)
A main purpose of choice is to offer options so the student can self-differentiate
Demonstrate metacognition, teach honest self-assessment, promote a growth mindset
Finding an appropriate challenge within the “Zone of Proximal Development” will bring the learner closer to their potential Anderson (2016)
Differentiation
Every student is worthy of dignity and respect
Diversity is both inevitable and positive
The classroom should mirror the kind of society in which we want our students to live and lead
Most students can learn most things that are essential to a given area of study
Each student should have equity of access to excellent learning opportunities
A central goal of teaching is to maximize the capacity of each learner
Tomlinson & Imbeau (2010)
Differentiated Instruction
Examine standards and objectives to be taught
Establish conceptual understanding related to facts and skills
Design independent student activities
Self-reflect on knowledge, attitudes to resources, content, and students
Pre-assess students in knowledge facts, skills, conceptual understandings, experiences, attitudes, motivations, and ideas
Determine strategies for instruction at different levels of cognitive processing – concrete, representations, and abstract
Determine activities to include individual, small-group, and whole-group instruction
Determine benchmarks of student performance and ongoing measurement
Develop the performance that accurately reflect the intended outcomes of the unity O’Meara (2011)
Unit Planning Design for Differentiated Instruction
Student pursues authentic actions and co-creates
inquiry, analysis and final product
Voice – Student involvement
Co-creation – Student innovation and creation
Social Construction – Build ideas through relationships
Self-Discovery – Process of understanding learning self
Teacher facilitates learning through questions, conferences, and feedback Kallick & Zmuda (2017)
Personalized Learning
Goals – SMART - S strategic and specific, M
measurable, A attainable, R realistic & relevant, T time-bound
Inquiry/idea generation
Task and audience
Evaluation
Cumulative demonstration of learning
Instructional plan
FeedbackKallick & Zmuda (2017)
Elements of Personalized Learning
Teaching Critical Thinking
Gather information and utilize resources
Flexibility in form and style
Predicting
Ask high quality questions
Weigh evidence before drawing conclusions
Use metaphors and models
Analyze and predict
Conceptualize strategies
Deal productively with ambiguity, differences, and novelty
Jensen (2008) p.146
Generate possibilities and probabilities
Develop debate and discussion skills
Identify mistakes, discrepancy, and illogic
Examine alternative approaches
Develop hypothesis-testing strategies
Analyze risks
Develop objectivity
Detect generalizations and patterns
Sequence events
Increase Feedback
Encourage Group Work
Self – Assessment
Acknowledgment of intrinsic rewards of success
Keep student work such as fitness cards
Compare students only to themselves, not others
Emphasize Mastery for all students
Discuss Assessment Philosophy and Approach
Post Grading Policy / ApproachJensen (2008)
Brain-Friendly Assessment Strategies
Assesses the quality of learning by asking tougher
questions and broadening our definition of learning (understanding)
Content – What learners know, data, facts
Emotions – How learners feel and what is meaningful
Context – How learners relate it to the real world
Processing – How learners apply the learning through summary, synthesis, hypothesis
Embodiment – Applying new learning through personal actions
Jensen (2008)
Authentic Assessment
Habits of Mind
Persisting
Listening with Understanding and Empathy
Metacognition
Questioning and Problem Posing
Clarity and precision
Creating, Imagining and Innovating
Responsible Risk Taking
Interdependent Thinking
Managing Impulsivity
Thinking Flexibly
Accuracy and Precision
Apply Past Knowledge
Data Gathering through all Senses
Wonderment and Awe
Finding Humor
Remaining open to Continuous Learning
Kallick & Zmuda (2017)
Build positive, enriching relationships
Celebrate and affirm students’ strengths, efforts and dreams
Create a safe atmosphere for learningEmotional safety in making mistakes, greet students by name
Give students a sense of controlProvide choice
Use a calm voice to teachAn educator’s calm voice can soothe those painful sounds and words running through their minds and replace them with words and a tone that can free their bodies from tensing up and locking their brains from learning.
Izard (2016)
Teaching to Address Challenges of Poverty
Teach emotional skills
Teach gratitude; it strengthens the brain
Working with students who act outProvide a safe place for the student to save face, regain control, and cool down while processing what just happened
Working with withdrawn studentsInvite the student to join, describe the safe environment, keep student in class, discuss with other professionals
Build short-term working memoryAttentional skills can be built by practicing short-term working memory skills
Izard (2016)
Teaching to Address Challenges of Poverty
Expressive writing and Teach reading skills
The captive feelings from poverty and trauma can be released
Build students’ vocabularyIncreasing vocabulary builds new structure in the brain for learning
Teach self-regulationModel calm and teach the student awareness of their current emotional sensations
Teach empathy[Nonthreatening phrases to express how much you care about them and their success voice with a soothing, caring tone Hensley et al. (2016)]
Izard (2016)
Teaching to Address Challenges of Poverty
Meaningful touch
Connections with eye contact and touch increases the hormone level of oxytocin that elevates good moods and strengthens the immune system
Teaching hopeTeach optimism
Listening to the students’ storiesListen so the student feels heard and teach within their learning modality
Izard (2016)
Teaching to Address Challenges of Poverty
Teaching with Poverty in Mind
School-wide
Support of the Whole Child
Hard Data
Accountability
Relationship Building
Enrichment Mind-set
Jensen (2009)
Classroom
Standards-Based Curriculum and Instruction
Hope Building
Arts, Athletics, and AP
Retooling the Operating System
Engaging Instruction
SHARE for Physical Education
Support the Whole Child and Standards-Based Curriculum and Instruction. Kids raised in poverty are more likely to have disabilities than middle and upper income kids. As a result, educators should be extra vigilant in discovering ways to support their least advantaged learners. Standards-based curriculum and instruction, vertically aligned curricula and standards, meaningful units of study, and multiple measures of students’ performance make learning accessible to all students.
Hope Building. Hope changes brain chemistry which influences the decisions we make and the actions we take. Hopefulness must be pervasive, and every single student should be able to feel it, see it, and hear it daily.
Accountability. The best way to achieve accountability is to create a compelling, collaborative goal and then to administer formative assessments that provide useful, specific data demonstrating progress toward that goal.
Jensen (2009)
Relationship Building. Secure attachments and stable
environments are vitally important to social and emotional development. One-on-one attention and nurturing guidance enable children to succeed and improve self-esteem. Long-term teacher-student relationships increase student self-esteem, health, exposure to positive social norms, outcomes at school/work, and decrease involvement with gangs or violence.
Engaging Instruction and Enrichment Mindset. Engaging instruction is any strategy that gets students to participate emotionally, cognitively, or behaviorally (actions). The enrichment mindset fosters intellectual curiosity, emotional engagement, and social bonding while maximizing potential.
Jensen (2009)
SHARE for Physical Education
Cool-down Time – time to regain calm
Coupling Statement – Describe inappropriate behavior, then offer a more appropriate alternative behavior
Reality Statements – Rationale to explain “why” that is real and relevant to the immediate situation
Empathy – Understand the situation to de-escalate a problem behavior and convince student not to give up
Specific Praise – Reinforce students when they make good choices Hensley et al. (2016)
Corrective Strategies
Offer initial praise or empathy
Describe the inappropriate behavior
Describe the appropriate behavior
Give a rationale
Practice
Use a negative consequence (optional)
Hensley et al. (2016)
Corrective Teaching
To what extent do I prepare beyond my lesson
plans?
How does data drive my practice?
Have I developed expertise in my content area?
What role does child development theory play in my overall planning?
Am I highly organized as a teacher?
Kafele (2016)
Reflection on Planning and Organization
How do I know which instructional strategies work
best with each of my students?
Who are the true stars of the show in my classroom?
How do I connect learning across the content areas?
Do I take into account that no two of my students are alike?
Does my teaching address the 21st century student?
Kafele (2016)
Reflection onClassroom Instruction
Do my students have the option of failing in my
classroom?
Do I hold myself accountable for student failure?
Am I willing to accept responsibility and accountability for my students’ successes andfailures?
Do I reject poverty as a legitimate excuse for failure?
What does my mirror say abut my effectiveness as a teacher?
Kafele (2016)
Reflection on Teacher Accountability
Grading
*All students upon entering the gym have earned the highest grade possible – Exemplary, Outstanding, Above Grade Level, “4”
*Each moment students are observed and assessed
*The Professional Teacher does what it takes to help each student keep their Exemplary, “4” each lesson and references the descriptors of Highly
Effective on the Teacher Evaluation Rubric indicating student interactions.
*Units are designed incorporating real-world authentic experiences with contextual understanding to provide deeper meaning – Above Grade
Level
IDEIA – Teacher provides equal educational access
ADA – No discrimination due to disability
Take away fear of failure – research on brain learning
High expectations for success
Teach expectations (Students describe the “4” physical education student behaviors)
Design lessons that are authentic real-world experiences – above grade level for listed standard based on performance within contextual application
Research Supporting Highest Grade
Builds identity of athletic self – self esteem and
multiple intelligences research
Affirming conscious and nonconscious learning (Jensen 2008) about healthy bodies, lifelong active lifestyle, who they are as a healthy individual.
Research Supporting Highest Grade
Demonstrates Personal Leadership while Helping
Others Succeed
Team Collaboration and Strategy Building while using Creativity and Higher-Order Thinking Skills
Compliment and Encourage
Physical Education Vocabulary
Applying Feedback in Movement Principles
Fitness for Body and Brain Wellness
Excellence Transfers to hallway, recess, and the community
Grade of Exemplary, Above Grade Level, “4”
Listen To and Follow Directions
Best Effort and Self Improvement
Safe Movement and Use of Equipment
Positive Behavior
Grade of Meets, Masters Understanding, “3”
Nothing is listed – Statistically, one cannot average
an average for meaningful data. Therefore a student either Meets “3” or is Emerging “1” on a day to day basis. A student either demonstrates lesson objects or does not demonstrate lesson objectives each day –saving the averaging for the quarter grade.
Grade of Progressing, “2”
Low Level of Engagement
Off Task
Hurts Self or Others
Argue, Putdowns, Name Calling
Gum
Universal Gym Rules Not Followed
Grade of Emerging, Not Yet Showing Understanding,
“1”
Low level of Work Habits may influence lack of
demonstration of Motor Competence Standards. If a student has high skill ability and does not demonstrate the skills during the lesson due to any reason, s/he has earned an Emerging “1” grade for motor competence as well as Emotional – Social Wellness, and Personal Physical Wellness
Result of Not Yet Showing Understanding
9 weeks each quarter = 18 lessons
1 or 2 lessons with Emerging “1” behaviors (bad day) a student can still be “4” Outstanding
3 lessons of Emerging “1” behaviors = no longer eligible for Outstanding “4” = highest grade possible is Meets “3”
3 more lessons of Emerging = highest grade possible is Progressing “2”
3 more lessons of Emerging = highest grade possible is Emerging “1”
Quarter Grades Averaged or Cut Scores
Final Thoughts
Creating Fair Teams
Compliment success of others
Self referee to contribute to knowledge of the game
Inclusion and respect for all
Support Others in Reaching Highest Potential
Every child who enters the gym is eligible to earn a
grade of “Outstanding”
Grading Rubric is based on so many assessments, the high skill and strategy performances outweigh the low performances
Teach honoring others’ success builds our own success
Physical Fitness Awards include “Outstanding Efforts in Achievement” recognition.
Celebrating Success
When _______ happened, was it _______ (name the 5
things you grade on) ?
If you don’t know if you can do that, imagine every student doing that action. Would we have a safe learning environment?
Questions to Ask During Redirect
Gano-Overway (2013) Exploring the Connections
Between Caring and Social Behaviors in Physical Education.
Only published study – not generalizable to greater populations. Only two schools (528 students in Southeast USA)
Report on Survey Describing Caring in PE
2 local schools urban/rural, 528 students, 41% participated, 70 questions,
Research Purpose:
Explore the relationships between a perceived caring climate, empathy, and social behaviors in Middle School physical education classrooms.
Differences of empathy and prosocial behavior compared to antisocial and bullying behavior between girls and boys.
Research Findings:
When students perceived the climate to be caring, they were less likely to engage in antisocial behavior including bullying and more likely to engage in prosocial behaviors.
Relationships between caring, empathy, and social behaviors were the same for boys and girls.
Gano-Overway 2013