DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    1/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RD S A N D I E G O , C AA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    GORDONR. CARRIERFAIA, NCARB

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    2/36

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    3/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    I N T R O D U C T I O N

    The Opportunity : 90 Urban Apartments

    This prospectus describes an unique opportunity to become part of the investor

    development team responsible for the creation of 90 urban sophisticated market rate

    apartments located in the heart of downtown San Diego, one of the nations strongest

    growing urban settings.

    The Setting : Location

    The projects immediate access to San Diegos beautiful waterfront, the citys primary

    entertainment, theater, shopping, and restaurant districts, combined with its proximity

    to the city government center, light rail, the freeway system, and international airport, all

    serve to make it unique among investment properties and development opportunities. Asthey say, location, location, location!

    Agency Requirements : Approvals

    This site and project is governed by an already approved Planned District Ordinance

    (PDO), complete with environmental approvals for immediate development. As a result

    the project does not require discretionary approvals (ie: no noticed public hearings)

    but rather a straight forward administrative review by the Center City Development

    Corporation assuring the project is within the already approved parameters of the PDO.

    Market Research : This Study

    This market study is focused on describing relevant influencing characteristics affecting

    the successful development of this site as market rate apartments located within the

    El Cortez District of Downtown San Diego, California redevelopment area. Efforts were

    made to understand the marketplace as to population trends, relevant population growth

    projections, current apartment rental vacancy rates, market rent trends, as well as

    existing and upcoming competitive project composition.

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    4/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    S U M M A R Y T H I N K I N G + C O N C L U S I O N

    The Development Opportunity:An Urban Market Rate Apartment Project

    Data strongly suggests this property has great capacity for development as a market rate apartment

    site, with limited, but PDO defined ground floor retail space supplementing as amenity offering to its

    tenants (fitness, club room, caf etc.) and the pedestrian public.

    Approved rights for development are as follows:

    THE SITUATION

    Site

    + Far 8 @ 25,000 sf of land = 200,000 gsf of building area allowed above grade.

    Height limit varies from 85 at the north end of the site to 300at its south end.

    Construction Strategy

    + Type 3 Construction under 85 solution (5 stories over 1 story of concrete parking/retail podium)

    + While this proposal does not fully utilize the sites approved FAR of 8, it gains the advantage of a

    lesser construction cost on a per square foot basis.

    + Current apartment unit rents of $2.60-2.80/rsf and retail rents of $3.10/rsf support the

    potential of a project yield of the following (see following page):

    PROJECT INTENT ION

    A STREET

    ASH STREET

    THIRDA

    VE

    FOURTHA

    V

    E

    SITE

    SITE

    THIRDA

    VE

    A STREET

    ASH STREET

    BEECH STREET

    FO

    URTHAVE

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    5/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    ( C O N T . ) S U M M A R Y T H I N K I N G + C O N C L U S I O N

    PROGRAMMED USES PHYSICAL COMPOSITION OF PROGRAMUSES

    Apartment Units

    90 units @ Market Size of 856 rsf/unit

    Apartment Units

    Retail/Commercial Space

    Total Rentable Square Footage

    90 Living Unitswithin this 100,000 available

    gsf: However, given site dimensions and setback

    requirements this actually translates to a maximum

    floor plate size of 18,192 gsf (90,960 gsf over 5

    floors).

    Assuming 80% unit efficiency, this translates to

    72,770 sf of rentable apartment space and with the

    addition of 6th floor mezzanine space at 4,366 rsf, theresultant total rentable apartment space area equals

    72,770 rsf.

    6 suites at 1,333 rsf

    Apartment Units = 72,770 rsf

    Retail/Commercial = 8,000 rsf

    The Mix

    Studio (30) at 618 rsf = 18,550 rsf

    1 Bedroom (35) at 750 rsf = 26,250 rsf

    2 Bedroom (25) at 1,119 rsf = 27,975 rsf

    6th level mezzanine space in the topfloor units = 4,366 rsf

    Retail/Commercial Space

    8,000 rsf retail ground floor (revenue generating) at

    ground floor

    Parking

    Mezzanine : 14,209 sf

    B-1 : 26,836 sf

    B-2 : 26,836 sf

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    6/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    ( C O N T . ) S U M M A R Y T H I N K I N G + C O N C L U S I O N

    INCOME ASSUMPTIONS

    $2.70/rsf/month

    Sub-Total @ 100% Occupancy = $208,148/month

    5% Vacancy Assumption less $10,407/month

    $3.25/rsf/month

    Sub-Total @ 100% Occupancy = $26,000/month

    5% Vacancy Assumption less $1,300/month

    SUB-TOTALAPARTMENTUNITRENT= $197,741 / MONTH

    SUB-TOTALUNITRENT= $24,700 / MONTH

    Gross Effective Rent

    $222,441/month or $2,669,292 annually

    Operating Expenses

    35% of Gross Effective Rent =

    $77,854/month or $934,252 annually

    Valuation @ 4% UPS at Stabilization

    5.5% CAP and stabilization

    ($2,029,757) /.055 (5.5 % CAP) = $36,904,572

    Cost Assumptions : Estimated Project Cost of Building

    The estimated hard and soft costs of construction for thisproject are $25,750,000

    Return on Investment (ROI)

    Income over cost of $5,800,000 or 22% against build costs

    Apartment Units

    Retail/Commercial

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    7/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    GRADELEVELPLAN FLOORS2 - 6

    ( C O N T . ) S U M M A R Y T H I N K I N G + C O N C L U S I O N

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    8/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    FLOORB1 FLOORB2

    ( C O N T . ) S U M M A R Y T H I N K I N G + C O N C L U S I O N

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    9/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Residential Net Rentable Area

    Units SF

    Level 1 0 0

    Level 2 18 14,544

    Level 3 18 14,544

    Level 4 18 14,544

    Level 5 18 14,544Level 6 18 18,876

    Subtotal 90 77,092

    Unit Average 856

    Retail Gross Area

    Units SF

    Retail 8,000

    Subtotal 8,000

    Circ. and Accessory Gross Area

    Units SF

    Lobby 4,440

    Other 12,560

    Subtotal 25,000

    Building Total Gross 110,658

    GROSSAREASUMMARY

    ( C O N T . ) S U M M A R Y T H I N K I N G + C O N C L U S I O N

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    10/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Studio A Studio B 1 BD A 1 BD B 2 BD A 2 BD B Total

    Level 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

    Level 2 5 1 6 1 4 1 18

    Level 3 5 1 6 1 4 1 18

    Level 4 5 1 6 1 4 1 18

    Level 5 5 1 6 1 4 1 18

    Level 6 w/ mezzanine 5 1 6 1 4 1 18

    Totals 25 5 30 5 20 5 90

    % of Totals 27.78% 5.56% 33.33% 5.56% 22.22% 5.56% 100%

    Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5 Level 6 Total Avg SFStudio 0 3,710 3,710 3,710 3,710 4,934 18,550 659

    1 BD 0 5,250 5,250 5,250 5,250 6,983 26,250 799

    2 BD 0 5,594 5,594 5,594 5,594 7,440 27,970 1,192

    Total SF 0 14,554 14,554 14,554 14,554 19,357 77,092

    UNITMIX

    UNITTYPEAREA

    ( C O N T . ) S U M M A R Y T H I N K I N G + C O N C L U S I O N

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    11/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Parking Total Gross

    SF

    Level Mez 14,209

    Level B1 26,836

    Level B2 26,836

    Total 67,881

    Parking Count

    Level Mez 19

    Level B1 49

    Level B2 53

    Total 121

    PARKING

    ( C O N T . ) S U M M A R Y T H I N K I N G + C O N C L U S I O N

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    12/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    B A C K G R O U N D + S E T T I N G

    This 25,000 sf property address (physical dimensions 100

    x 250) is located at1301 Third Avenue in the downtown

    PDOs El Cortez District of San Diego. It fronts on A street

    to its immediate South (a one way street heading east), and

    Third Avenue to its immediate West (a one way street heading

    north). Each of these streets are two lane, one way streets,

    with parallel metered parking along both sides and Right

    Of Way (ROW) dimensions at 80ft. This property is within

    the regulatory requirements as described in the El Cortez

    Redevelopment Neighborhood of the PDO.

    The property has an existing 30,000 gsf three story office

    building with additional basement space (8,500 gsf).

    The building sits on the southern most portion of the site

    occupying 10,000 sf of the 25,500 sf site and is a Class C

    steel frame building built in the mid 50s. It has 52 surface

    parking spaces adjacent and directly north of the building

    on the remaining 15,000 sf of land. The building currently

    houses an architectural/interior design firm, structural

    engineering firm and accountancy practice. The building is

    leased on a master reside on the third floor. The building cash

    flows approximately $270,000 annually to its owners based

    upon this master lease. Assuming a 6.5% CAP rate, this value

    is $4,154,000.

    LOCATION W ITHINTHECITY OF SAN DIEGO:AREA CODE92101

    EXISTING FACILITIES

    SITE CORTEZ DISTRICT

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    13/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    The property is part of what was the Center City

    Development Corporations redevelopment district until

    its abolishment by Gov. Jerry Brown as a State deficit cost

    savings measure throughout California implemented March

    2012. However, its development rights are still determined by

    this prior approved Planned District Ordinance (PDO) setting

    forth the detail of the development capacity of the site.

    The site has a designation to build a Minimum of FAR 5.0

    (125,000 gsf) with a Maximum by right development capacity

    of FAR 8.0 (200,000 gsf) and the capacity to bonus the FAR

    to 10.0 (250,000 gsf) with the inclusion of bonus incentive

    elements in the project such as Urban Open Space,

    Affordable Housing, Family Units, Green Roofs etc.

    PLANNEDDISTRICTORDINANCEDEVELOPMENTRIGHTS

    This calculation is based upon above grade build out and

    does not include additional space which might be built below

    grade (parking etc.). The site is covered by the PDOs master

    EIR, provided the property is developed within its regulations.

    The site has a height limit slope contour that requires a

    project does not exceed 85 above mean sea level at its north

    edge and 300 at its southernmost edge. On site parking

    requirements for the site depend upon the ultimate use

    defined for the property but are generally calculated at 1car

    per unit of residential development

    ( C O N T . ) B A C K G R O U N D + S E T T I N G

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    14/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Adjacent site to the west is vacant (60,000 sf used for surface parking)

    This parking may be rented by the hour or the month.

    Adjacent buildings on the same 60,000 sf block this site is within:

    Our site is located at the Southwest corner of the block

    To Our Eastrecently renovated 10,000 sf building used as an office

    hoteling site

    To Our Northeast ..Church of Scientology Office building on

    15,000 sf of land with a three story building on it. First floor is used

    for parking under the building, resulting in a 30,000 gsf building.

    To Our North North5,000sf single story historic office building

    currently housing a small law practice

    Existing 1960s City Government Office Complex two blocks from

    the subject site with plans slated for redevelopment as a new City

    Government Office District Complex.

    SURROUNDINGPROPERTY INFLUENCES

    Set directly adjacent to the most densely planned downtown core district this site

    is in the immediate surround of many of the citys most desirable offerings.

    SITE : V IEW OF TH E WEST SIDE ENTRY

    ADJACENTBLDG, NORTH: LA WF IRM ADJACENT BLDG, NORTH: SCIENTOLOGY ADJACENTBLDG, EAST : HOTELINGOFF ICE FUTUREBLDG: CENTRALLIBRARY

    ( C O N T . ) B A C K G R O U N D + S E T T I N G

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    15/36

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    16/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    San Diego Trolley

    Metropolitan Transit District Trolley System is accessed two blocks away and

    provides easy transport via rail loop to all of the downtown (ie: restaurants,

    convention center, waterfront, PetCo Park, Library etc), QualComm Football

    Stadium home of the San Diego Chargers, Historic Old Town San Diego, Tijuana

    Mexico, and San Diego State University including all of East County. Additional

    lines are in the planning stage to extend this service to UCSD and the northern

    regions of the city.

    Freeway System

    Access to I-5 (coastal north/south connector) and Highway 163/I-15 (inland

    north/south connector) is five blocks from the site.

    San Diego Lindberg Field

    The San Diego Airport International Airport is a 7 minute drive by car from the

    site.

    Bus Access

    Bus stop are available within three blocks of the site.

    TRANSPORTATIONACCESS

    ( C O N T . ) B A C K G R O U N D + S E T T I N G

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    17/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    S A N D I E G O C O U N T Y - W I D E D E M O G R A P H I C SSource: County of San Diego HHSA, Community Statistics Unit: Year 2009

    Total Population

    Types of Households By Percentage (2009)

    Observation:

    1,923,939

    Married Couples/Families50% (961,969)

    Other Families16% (307,830)

    People Living Alone26% (500,224)

    Other Non-Family Households8% (153,915)

    34% of the population is notmarried or considered a family,equaling 654,139 people.additionally some percentageof the married couple category

    representing 961,969 persons arewithout children. Assume a 20%number conservatively this equals192,393 persons, or 96,196households.

    Types of Housing Units (2009)

    Single Unit Structures 61%

    Multi-Unit Structures 35%

    Mobile Homes 4%

    Occupants with a Housing Cost Burden (2009)

    (Percent paying 30% or more ofincome for housing)

    Owners with Mortgage 53% Average $2,409/month

    Owners without mortgage 15%...Average $442

    Renters 56%...Average $1,198

    Observation:

    Metric for rent assessment equals56% of the population andrepresents an ability to pay onaverage $1,198/month

    Educational Attainment by Percent for Persons

    25 Years or Older (2009)

    Graduate or Professional Degree13%

    Bachelors Degree21%

    Associates Degree8%

    Some College, No Degree23%

    High School Diploma or Equivalent20%

    Less than High School Diploma15%

    Observation:

    This age group represents 41% ofthe population indicating highereconomic capacity per individual

    Age Distribution (2009)

    65 and over 11%...(211,633)

    45-64 24%...(461,745)

    Observation:

    35% of population exceeds 45years of age (673,378)

    Observation:

    40% of the population is between18 and 24 years of age (769,575)

    25-44 29%...(557,942)

    18-2411%...(211,633)Under 1825%...(480,984)

    While the property is located in the 92101 Zip code, the greater pool for this opportunity comes from the larger county demographic offered by the following data:

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    18/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    S A N D I E G O A R E A Z I P C O D E 9 2 1 0 1

    D E M O G R A P H I C S Y E A R 2 0 1 0Source: San Diego Association of Governments

    Total Population Population by Age Group : Reference Year 2010

    Average # of Persons/Household

    Population By Age, And Predicted Growth To

    The Year 2020:

    Observation:

    Observation:

    50,117Predicted 2020:60,073 (+995 persons/year)

    Median Age41.10Predicted Age Year 202037.9

    1.67

    18-19 1,842

    Predicted Year 20201,938 (+.5%/year)

    20-24 5,068Predicted Year 20206,060 (+1.96%/year)

    25-29 4,244Predicted Year 20205,626 (+3.26%/year)

    30-34 3,943Predicted Year 20204,654 (+1.8%/year)

    + 995 persons /year growth for thenext ten years (+2%/year). At 1.67persons per unit this equates to 596units need per year. This personper household calculation wouldindicate the need for a total 30,010units to meet the 2010 populationwith an existing housing pool of24,004 or a predicted net need of6,006 or average 600 units /year.Considering a contingency of 15%applied to this number,predicted net

    need may be more conservativelylook like 511units /year.

    From 2010 thru 2020 age 20-34 ispredicted to increase in populationby 3,085 persons.if currentknown occupancy demographicshold at 1.67 persons per householdthis equates to an additional needof 184 units per year for the years2012 thru 2020.

    Total Existing Housing Units (as of 2010)

    Existing Single Family

    Existing Multi Family

    Observation:

    24,004

    Predicted 2020:30,044 (+2.5%/year)

    476 unitsPredicted 2020:375 (-30%)

    23,526 unitsPredicted 2020:29,667 (+2.6%/year)

    The population is leaning moretoward multi-family versus singlefamily home living, renderinggreater strength in the need for

    multi-family provision in themarketplace. The #s appear toindicate a 648 unit/year short fallbased upon a persons/unit metric of1.67.

    Mobile Homes

    Multi-Family Unit Vacancy Rate

    Observation:

    2

    4.32%(Source: Market Pointe RealtyAdvisors March 22,2012)

    5% vacancy rate is considered anideal market condition..this wouldindicate a more than favorabledemographic for rental multi-familyhousing

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    19/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    ( C O N T . ) S A N D I E G O A R E A Z I P C O D E 9 2 1 0 1

    D E M O G R A P H I C S Y E A R 2 0 1 0

    (continued) ...Population By Age, And Predicted

    Growth To The Year 2020:

    Observation:

    35-39 4,090Predicted Year 20204,435 (+.84%/year)

    40-44 4,473Predicted Year 20203,841 (-1.41%/year)

    45-49 4,400Predicted Year 20203,766 (-1.4%/year)

    50-54 3,758Predicted Year 20204,226 (+1.26%/year)

    This age group represents adeclining population of -.27%/year,thus a less likely target market forfuture building activity

    (continued) ...Population By Age, And Predicted

    Growth To The Year 2020:

    Observation:

    75 + ..3,372Predicted Year 20204,090 (+2.1%/year)

    Observation: This would seem adifferent category of clientele,requiring more extensive medicalservices given the advanced agedemographic represented. While agrowth sector, the advanced servicerequirement to serve this growth agegroup must also be considered. Thisage category represents a 2.1%/year growth market for the ten yearperiod in question (2010-2020)

    (continued) ...Population By Age, And Predicted

    Growth To The Year 2020:

    Observation:

    55-59 2,902Predicted Year 20204,182 (+4.4%/year)

    60-64 2,238Predicted Year 20203,440 (+5.4%/year)

    This group, including ages 55-74, is an increasing demographic,representing predicted growth of53% over 10 years or 5.3%/year.Using a most conservative caseof 1.67 persons per unit typical forthis advanced age group within the92101 demographic market, thisrepresents a potential need for 252units per year dedicated solely tothis age group. However, it is morelikely this age category would result

    in a lower persons per unit ratiogiven the greater propensity forspousal death, and health issues.This result would create a demandexceeding 252 units per year butdesigned and exclusively dedicated

    to seniors. However, to date seniorhousing solutions have beensubsidized events. Additionally, theevents of the State of Californiavia elimination of RedevelomentAgencies has taken several of thepotential subsidy funding sourcesaway. (20% Affordable Housingrequirement, Tax Credit Funding,Housing Commission Funding).If this property can find a wayto attract the elite income

    categories of the senior populationor the private equity and debtnecessary to allow them to bebuilt, these subsidies may be lessimportant.

    65-69 1,567Predicted Year 20202,563 (+6.3%/year)

    70-74 1,262Predicted Year 20202061 (+6.3%/year)

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    20/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Current 92101 Population by Gender and Marital Status

    (cont)...Current 92101 Population by Gender and Marital

    Status

    Observation:

    62.97% Male (20,939)

    37.03% Female (11,990)

    Never married45.31%

    Married27.36%

    This population factor by gender coulddefine certain design characteristics worthy ofoffering occupants for a development lookingforward, such as entertainment centers with

    TV (ie: sports events etc), soft seating, cardroom, health facility with weight room, bocceball court, etc.

    Household Income 92101 Year 2010

    Observation:

    Average Household Income

    $58,007

    Income between $35,000 and $200,000 +in zip code 92101 represents 35.62% of thepopulation

    Assuming 30% of income capable ofbeing dedicated to housing cost currentmedian income = rental income capacity of$15,270/year or an average of $1,450/monthdisposable rental income.

    Renter Occupied Units In The 92101 Zip Code

    81.39% of all occupied units

    Of The 4.32% Vacant Housing Units Available In

    The 92101 Zip Code

    59.38% are rental units

    Observation:

    This speaks to the strong rental demographicsof the subject project site environment.

    ( C O N T . ) S A N D I E G O A R E A Z I P C O D E 9 2 1 0 1

    D E M O G R A P H I C S Y E A R 2 0 1 0

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    21/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    U P C O M I N G M U L T I - F A M I L Y H O U S I N G S U P P L Y C H A I NSource: Urban Housing Partners

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    22/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Source Urban Housing Partners

    ( C O N T . ) U P C O M I N G M U L T I - F A M I L Y H O U S I N G S U P P L Y C H A I N

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    23/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Source Urban Housing Partners

    ( C O N T . ) U P C O M I N G M U L T I - F A M I L Y H O U S I N G S U P P L Y C H A I N

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    24/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    ( C O N T . ) U P C O M I N G M U L T I - F A M I L Y H O U S I N G S U P P L Y C H A I NSource Urban Housing Partners

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    25/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    ( C O N T . ) U P C O M I N G M U L T I - F A M I L Y H O U S I N G S U P P L Y C H A I NSource Urban Housing Partners

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    26/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Merrill Gardens2537 2nd Ave

    84 units

    619-752-1099

    contact: Jennifer

    Westminister Manor1730 3rd Ave

    155 units

    619-233-7001

    contact: Marasella

    Luther Tower1455 2nd Ave

    200 units

    619-234-1272

    contact: Jonathan

    Sanford Hotel1301 5th Ave

    130 units

    619-235-7900

    contact: David

    Coronado Village299 Prospect

    90 units

    619-437-1777

    contact: Liset

    Lions Manor310 Market Street

    125 units

    619-235-4433

    contact: Gloria

    Horton House333 G Street

    150 units

    619-239-5171

    contact: Bob (female)

    Potiker Center525 14th Street

    200 units

    619-237-8004

    contact: Leslie

    Cathedral Arms3911 Park Blvd

    unknown units

    619-291-3883

    possible bad number

    Grace Tower3955 Park Blvd

    unknown units

    619-298-4632

    possible bad number

    Balboa Nursing/Rehab3520 4th Ave

    170 units

    619-291-5270

    contact: Erika

    Green Manor4041 Ibis Street

    150 units

    619-297-1601

    contact: Gloria

    ( C O N T . ) U P C O M I N G M U L T I - F A M I L Y H O U S I N G S U P P L Y C H A I NSource Urban Housing Partners

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    27/36

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    28/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    S A N D I E G O 9 2 1 0 1 Z I P C O D E H O U S I N G R E N T A L R A T E S + T R E N D S

    Observation:

    While this 2010 data supports a lesser rental rate, thecurrent offering rates for rental on a per square foot basisindicate a strong leasing market and or a greater amount ofexpendable income being spent for housing needs (ie: greaterthan 30% of typical earnings). The extent to which a projectcan be designed to maintain a lower per month rental metric(something closer to a $1,141rental rate ) the stronger thecapacity to minimize vacancy in a competitive marketplace

    Median Rent

    $1,141/month

    Average Rent / Month

    $1,387/month average

    Range of Rents

    $750-$999/month

    2,841 units17.62%

    $1,000- $1,249/month3,385 units20.99%

    Median Household Income for 2011

    $62,31430 % of income predicted as spendable for housing thisequals a median buyer capacity of $1,558/month

    2010SANDIEGO92101 Z IPCODEHOUSING RENTALRATES

    2011FOURTHQUARTERSA NDIEGO92101ZI PCODEHOUSINGRENTALRATETRENDS

    $1,250-$1,499/month

    2,000 units12.4%

    $1,500-$1,999/month2,724 units16.69%

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    29/36

    DOMUS@3 RD S A N D I E G O , C A

    F E A S I B I L I T Y A N A L Y S I S

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    30/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3 RDA N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    DOMUS@ 3RD

    The following outlines the financial feasibility of the 90 Unit Domus @ 3rd project to be located in

    downtown San Diego, California

    Conclusion:

    This project is conservatively pro-formad exclusive of the idea that market forces are trending higher

    than projected in these assumptions, and if true, our assumptions will simply create an enhanced

    financial outlook. We have not relied on trending rentsthese numbers are based upon our market

    research and set at the reasonable range of expectation for this building type and marketplace.

    Please enjoy as you view the results for :

    Domus @ 3rd

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    31/36

    F O R R E N T - A P A R T M E N T S C E N A R I O

    DOMUS@3 RD S A N D I E G O , C A

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    32/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3RD

    A N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    FORRENT-APARTMENTASSUMPTIONS INCOME

    Total Land Area = 25,000 gsf

    Apartments - 90 units @ 808 rsf/unit average = 72,770 rsf6th Floor Mezzanine space at 4,366 rsf = 77,092 rsf

    Unit Mix

    Studio, 30 : 618 rsf

    One Bedroom, 35 : 750 rsf

    Two bedroom, 20 : 1,119 rsf

    6th Floor Mezzanine Space : 4,366 rsf

    Retail /Commercial

    Ground Floor : 8,000 rsf

    Apartment Rent@ $2.70/rsf @ 77,092 rsf (with mezzanine) =Potential Apartment Gross Income of $208,148 /month

    Less Vacancy of 5% = $10,407 Total Apartment Project Gross Effective Income = $197,755/

    monthRetail Rent

    @ $3.25/rsf @ 8,000 rsf = Potential Retail Gross Income of$26,000/month

    Less Vacancy of 5% = $1,300/month Total Retail Gross Effective Income of $24,700/monthTotal Project Total Apartment and Rental Gross Effective Income =

    $222,415/month Annualized = $2,668,980/year

    Less Operating Expenses @ 35% = $934,143/year

    F O R R E N T - A P A R T M E N T

    Net Operating Income (NOI) =$1,734,837/yearTotal Rentable Square Footage =85,092 rsf

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    33/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3RD

    A N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    PROJECTVALUE@STABILIZATION PROJECTPROFITANALYSIS

    @5.50% CAP = $36,882,000

    @ 5.25% CAP = $38,639,000

    @ 5% CAP = $40,578,000 (researched current assumption)

    @ 4.75% CAP= $42,706,000

    @ 5.50% CAP

    Build Profit = $5,800,000 or 22% on Total Build Costs

    @ 5.25% CAP

    Build Profit = $7,298,000 or 28% on Total Build Costs

    ( C O N T . ) F O R R E N T - A P A R T M E N T

    4%UPS

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    34/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3RD

    A N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Land

    Hard Costs

    Soft Costs @ 15% of Hard Cost of Construction/Contingency

    Cost @ $200/sf @ 25,000sf = $5,000,000

    Land Cost/Residential Unit = $56,000

    Above Grade Costs:

    Residential @ $106/gsf (Type 3 Construction) @ 88,679 gsf (87%) =$9,408,000

    First Floor Garage/ @ $100/gsf @ 25,000 gsf = $2,500,000

    Off Site Costs = $313,000

    Below Grade Costs:

    Garage @ $92.50/gsf @ 53,672 gsf = $4,964,660

    Hard Costs Sub-Total = $17,185,000

    5% contingency = $859,250

    Architectural and Engineering

    Permits and Impact fees

    Title Closing

    Professional Fees

    Inspecting Engineer

    FFE Set Up

    Operating Deficit

    Loan CostsDeveloper Fee

    TI and Retail Leasing Commissions

    Contingency

    Soft Costs Sub-Total @ 15% of hard costs/contingency = $2,706,750

    MARKETRATERESIDENTIALCONSTRUCTIONCOSTESTIMATEASSUMPTIONS

    TOTALLAND/HARD/SOFTCOSTS*: $23,044,000 + 2,706,000 = $25,750,000

    ( C O N T . ) F O R R E N T - A P A R T M E N T

    * Assume land sale @ $5,000,000

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    35/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3RD

    A N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    CASHFLOWANALYSIS(000S)

    carry/land

    soft ttl $2,728,000

    a/e 5%

    dev cost 3.5%

    other

    offsite

    totals

    construction

    income $2.70/sf4% ups

    sale 5.5% cap

    0

    (35) (35) (35) (35) (5,000)

    (636)

    (125)

    (25)

    (205)

    (125)

    (100)

    (69)

    (125)

    (100)

    0

    (125)

    (100)

    0

    (136)

    (825)

    0 (188) (188) 0 0

    0 (13,638) (4,547) 0 0

    0 0 1,255 1,948 2,025

    0

    (821)

    0

    (14,291)

    0

    (3,809)

    0

    1,688

    36,818

    32,882

    1 2 3 4

    Discounted Cash Flow and IRR

    24% @ 5.5% CAP

    ( C O N T . ) F O R R E N T - A P A R T M E N T

  • 8/12/2019 DomusFINAL Version 07-19-2012 Email

    36/36

    M A R K E T I N G +

    DOMUS@3RD

    A N A L Y S I S

    F E A S I B I L I T Y

    Conclusion:

    Domus @ 3rd provides potential investors an opportunity to be part of a spectacular real

    estate play in the strong San Diego market.

    Supported by growth demographics of the downtown area, as well as the competitive

    financing rates of our current time, this 90 unit project is packaged neatly for success.

    Its size, its simplicity, its location and its available right to build approvals make it

    attractive to an investor who desires to minimize risks while participating in a deal which

    creates good return. Domus @ 3rd is an attractive opportunity for any savvy investor, and we

    welcome your interest.

    Best Regards,

    Gordon R Carrier FAIA

    Managing MemberDomus@3rd LLC