• Home

  • Documents

  • Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of...
56
Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, [email protected] - @a_velios Nicholas Pickwoad, [email protected] Versioning Cultural Objects symposium – 1, 2 Dec 2016 Maynooth University

Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, [email protected] - @a_velios Nicholas

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Versioning materiality

Documenting evidence ofpast binding structures

Athanasios Velios, [email protected] - @a_veliosNicholas Pickwoad, [email protected]

Versioning Cultural Objects symposium – 1, 2 Dec 2016Maynooth University

https://twitter.com/a_velios
Page 2: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 3: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

First Sequence Second Sequence

Support 1

Support 2

Support 3

Support 1

Support 2

Support 3

Support 4

Support 5

Page 4: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

First Sequence Second Sequence

Support 1

Support 3

Support 1

Support 2

Support 3

Support 4

Support 5

Support 2

Page 5: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

First Sequence Second Sequence

Support 1

Support 3

Support 1

Support 2

Support 3

Support 4

Support 5

Support 2

Page 6: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

First Sequence Second Sequence

Support 1

Support 3

Support 1

Support 2

Support 3

Support 4

Support 5

Support 2

Page 7: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

First Sequence Second Sequence

Support 1

Support 3

Support 1

Support 2

Support 3

Support 4

Support 5

Support 2

Page 8: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

The Works of the Most High and Mighty Prince James, London, 1616

Page 9: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

The Works of the Most High and Mighty Prince James, London, 1616

original Oxford-style blind-tooling of the early 17th century

Page 10: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Rhetores Selecti … Græcè & Latine Oxford, 1676

Page 11: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Rhetores Selecti … Græcè & Latine Oxford, 1676

Page 12: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacques Coret, L’Ange Conducteur dans la Dévotion Chrétienne, Vienna, 1769

Gabr. Bartholomæus Grammondus, Historiarvm Galliæ ab excessv Henrici

IV. Libri XVIII, Amsterdam, 1653

Page 13: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacques Coret, L’Ange Conducteur dans la Dévotion Chrétienne, Vienna, 1769

Gabr. Bartholomæus Grammondus, Historiarvm Galliæ ab excessv Henrici

IV. Libri XVIII, Amsterdam, 1653

Page 14: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Pontificale Romanvm Clementis VIII, Antwerp: ex officina Plantiniana, 1627

Page 15: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Pontificale Romanvm Clementis VIII, Antwerp: ex officina Plantiniana, 1627

Page 16: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Pontificale Romanvm Clementis VIII, Antwerp: ex officina Plantiniana, 1627

Page 17: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Pontificale Romanvm Clementis VIII, Antwerp: ex officina Plantiniana, 1627

Page 18: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 19: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Bulletin des Lois de la Republique Française, 3me Série, Paris, 1802/3

Oldendorp, Ioannes, Enchiridion exceptionum Forensium, Lyon: Sebastianus Gryphius, 1556

Page 20: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Bulletin des Lois de la Republique Française, 3me Série, Paris, 1802/3

Oldendorp, Ioannes, Enchiridion exceptionum Forensium, Lyon: Sebastianus Gryphius, 1556

Page 21: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Bulletin des Lois de la Republique Française, 3me Série, Paris, 1802/3

Oldendorp, Ioannes, Enchiridion exceptionum Forensium, Lyon: Sebastianus Gryphius, 1556

Page 22: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Bulletin des Lois de la Republique Française, 3me Série, Paris, 1802/3

Oldendorp, Ioannes, Enchiridion exceptionum Forensium, Lyon: Sebastianus Gryphius, 1556

Page 23: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacobus Philippus, De claris mulieribus, Ferrara, 1497

Page 24: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacobus Philippus, De claris mulieribus, Ferrara, 1497

Page 25: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacobus Philippus, De claris mulieribus, Ferrara, 1497

Page 26: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacobus Philippus, De claris mulieribus, Ferrara, 1497

Page 27: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacobus Philippus, De claris mulieribus, Ferrara, 1497

Page 28: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacobus Philippus, De claris mulieribus, Ferrara, 1497

Ioannes a Sancto Geminiano, Summa de exemplis , Venice, 1499

Page 29: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacobus Philippus, De claris mulieribus, Ferrara, 1497

Page 30: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 31: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 32: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 33: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 34: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Implied relationships

Component Type→component is of type

Component Component→

component is part of component

Page 35: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Language of Bindings Thesaurus

http://www.ligatus.org.uk/lob

Page 36: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 37: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Types with implied period of time

● Added endleaves● Current – Previous – Earlier

Page 38: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Jacobus Philippus, De claris mulieribus, Ferrara, 1497

Ioannes a Sancto Geminiano, Summa de exemplis , Venice, 1499

Page 39: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

1497 1600

Page 40: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

1497 1600

Page 41: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

1497 1600

Page 42: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

1497 1600

v2v1

Page 43: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

http://www.cidoc-crm.org/get-last-official-release

Page 44: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Eventsaffect

Things(Physical andnon-physical)

People(or Groups)

participate

Placesat

Time-spanduring

Page 45: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 46: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 47: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 48: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 49: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 50: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 51: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas
Page 52: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Issues to discuss

● Subjectivityare there objective criteria to define versions?

Page 53: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Issues to discuss

● Subjectivityare there objective criteria to define versions?

● Observation and deductionwhat do I see and what do I know?

Page 54: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Issues to discuss

● Subjectivityare there objective criteria to define versions?

● Observation and deductionwhat do I see and what do I know?

● Thousands of identifiershow do we manage them?

Page 55: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Issues to discuss

● Subjectivityare there objective criteria to define versions?

● Observation and deductionwhat do I see and what do I know?

● Thousands of identifiershow do we manage them?

● Communicate structurehow do we make the schema/model accessible to professionals?

Page 56: Documenting evidence of past binding structures · Versioning materiality Documenting evidence of past binding structures Athanasios Velios, a.velios@arts.ac.uk - @a_velios Nicholas

Documenting Democracy:

Documenting Democracy:

Documents
Documenting Life

Documenting Life

Documents
Documenting Discipline

Documenting Discipline

Documents
Documenting UX

Documenting UX

Design
Providing and Documenting Medically Necessary Services · Providing and Documenting Medically Necessary ... Providing and Documenting Medically Necessary Services 3 ... Support those

Providing and Documenting Medically Necessary Services · Providing and Documenting Medically Necessary ... Providing and Documenting Medically Necessary Services 3 ... Support those

Documents
Documenting Systems

Documenting Systems

Documents
Options for Documenting Functional Improvement in ... · PDF fileOptions for Documenting Functional Improvement in Conservative Care. ... as carpal tunnel syndrome, ... Documenting

Options for Documenting Functional Improvement in ... · PDF fileOptions for Documenting Functional Improvement in Conservative Care. ... as carpal tunnel syndrome, ... Documenting

Documents
Documenting Nursing Activities

Documenting Nursing Activities

Documents
Documenting Clinical Interventions in Community Pharmacy ...6cpa.com.au/wp-content/uploads/Documenting-Clinical-Interventions... · Documenting Clinical Interventions in Community

Documenting Clinical Interventions in Community Pharmacy ...6cpa.com.au/wp-content/uploads/Documenting-Clinical-Interventions... · Documenting Clinical Interventions in Community

Documents
Documenting Python

Documenting Python

Documents
documenting source

documenting source

Documents
Documenting Patterns with Business Process Modelshillside.net/plop/2012/papers/Group 3 - Coyote/Documenting Patterns...Documenting Patterns with Business Process Models ... paradigm

Documenting Patterns with Business Process Modelshillside.net/plop/2012/papers/Group 3 - Coyote/Documenting Patterns...Documenting Patterns with Business Process Models ... paradigm

Documents
Documenting The Future

Documenting The Future

Education
Documenting ExpressionEngine

Documenting ExpressionEngine

Technology
Documenting Patient Non- Influenza Immunization - … Patient Non-Influenza... · Documenting Patient Non-Influenza Immunization – NB 1 Documenting Patient Non-Influenza Immunization

Documenting Patient Non- Influenza Immunization - … Patient Non-Influenza... · Documenting Patient Non-Influenza Immunization – NB 1 Documenting Patient Non-Influenza Immunization

Documents
Documenting Observations

Documenting Observations

Documents
Documenting digital dialogues

Documenting digital dialogues

Design
Documenting First

Documenting First

Technology
Documenting facts?

Documenting facts?

Documents
Documenting with JSDuck

Documenting with JSDuck

Technology
Documenting Process Architecture Identifying a process network and documenting the process hierarchy

Documenting Process Architecture Identifying a process network and documenting the process hierarchy

Documents
New Landscapes - arts.ac.uk

New Landscapes - arts.ac.uk

Documents
Documenting Process Calibrator - Flukeassets.fluke.com/manuals/741b743bumeng0100.pdf · Documenting Process Calibrator Introduction Fluke 741B and 743B Documenting Process Calibrators

Documenting Process Calibrator - Flukeassets.fluke.com/manuals/741b743bumeng0100.pdf · Documenting Process Calibrator Introduction Fluke 741B and 743B Documenting Process Calibrators

Documents
BA (Hons) Illustration - arts.ac.uk

BA (Hons) Illustration - arts.ac.uk

Documents
Documenting Charitable Contributions

Documenting Charitable Contributions

Economy & Finance
Deliverable 2.3: Report documenting vehicle specification, topology and … · 2015-11-06 · Report documenting vehicle specification, topology ... D 2.3 Report documenting vehicle

Deliverable 2.3: Report documenting vehicle specification, topology and … · 2015-11-06 · Report documenting vehicle specification, topology ... D 2.3 Report documenting vehicle

Documents
documenting work

documenting work

Documents
“The value of the Wow Factor in education” Professor Dr Anne Bamford Engine Room a.bamford@arts.ac.uk

“The value of the Wow Factor in education” Professor Dr Anne Bamford Engine Room [email protected]

Documents
Documenting Maidan

Documenting Maidan

Documents
DOCUMENTING CONSENT

DOCUMENTING CONSENT

Documents