Doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01 SubmissionSlide 1 99th Session of meetings of the IEEE 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks November 8-13,

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 1

99th Session of meetings of the IEEE 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks

November 8-13, 2015

Hyatt Regency Reunion

Dallas, Texas, USA

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 2

802.15 Organization Chart802.15WG Chair

Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance802.15 Vice Chairs

Rick Alfvin, VeriLANPat Kinney, Kinney Consulting

Task Groups

SecretaryPat Kinney, Kinney Consulting

Assistant SecretaryMike McInnis, Boeing

Working Group Technical EditorJames Gilb

SCs for New Projects (WNG), Maintenance, Rules

Chair: Pat Kinney, Kinney Consulting

TG8 Peer Aware Communcations Chair: Miung Lee, CUNY

TG9 Key Management ProtocolChair: Robert Moskowitz, Verizon

TG3e High Rate Close ProximtyChair: Andrew Estrada, Sony

TG4n 15.4 China MBAN PHYChair: Liang Li, Vinno

TG15.4q Ultra Low Power (ULP) 15.4 Chair: Chiu Ngo, Samsung

STUDY GROUPS:

SG12 Consolidated LLC (CLLC)Chair: Pat Kinney, Kinney Consulting

SG4t High(er) Rate PHY (HRP)Chair, Clint Powell

SG4u India 865-867 Band PHY (IBP)Chair, Phil Beecher, Wi- SUN

INTEREST GROUPS

IG TeraHertz (THZ) Chair: Thomas Kürner, Technische Universität Braunschweig

IG Dependability (of Radio Links)Ryuji Kohno,

IG High Rate Rail CommunicationsChair: Junhyeong Kim, ETRI

IG 6TischChair: Pat Kinney, Kinney Consulting

IG 15.4 GuideChair: TBD

To add your name to the WG/TG/SG/IG reflectors

please go to www.ieee802.org/15

TG10 Layer 2 RoutingChair: Clint Powell

x

TG3d 100Gbps PHYThomas Kuerner, Chair

Technische Universität Braunschweig

TG4mc 15.4 Revision 3Chair: Pat Kinney, Kinney Consulting

TG7R Optical Wireless CommunicationsYeong Min Jang, Kookmin University

Chair

TG4s Spectrum Resource Use (SRU)Chair: Shoichi Kitazawa,

ATR Wave Engineering Laboratories

TG3m 15.3 Revison 1Chair: Pat Kinney, Kinney Consulting

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 3

Dallas Session ObjectivesNovember 8-13, 2015

TASK GROUP 3d –100Gbps THz PHY1. Review and Discuss Contributions2. Resolve comments on 15.3d change PAR/CSD3. Secure EC approval to forward PAR to NesCom4. Update Project Plan/Timeline

TASK GROUP 3e –High Rate Close Proximity (HRCP)1. Review and Discuss Contributions2. Continue work on merged proposal3. Update Project Plan/Timeline

TASK GROUP 3m –15.3 REVISION 1• Secure EC approval to start Sponsor Ballot

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 4


TASK GROUP 4n –China MBAN1. Secure EC approval to forward to RevCom2. Update Project Plan/Timeline

Task Group 4q: 15.4 Ultra Low Power Amendment1. Secure EC approval to forward to RevCom2. Update Project Timeline accordingly

TASK GROUP 4s Spectrum Resoucre Utilization(SRU)– Work on Technical Guidance Doc (TGD)– Prepare the CFP– Update Project Timeline

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 5


Study Group 4t 15.4 High(er) Rate PHY1. Resolves comments on PAR/CSD if any 2. Secure EC approval to forward to NesCom

Study Group 4u 15.4 PHY for 865-867 band in India1. Resolves comments on PAR/CSD if any 2. Secure EC approval to forward to NesCom

Task Group 15.4mc -15.4 Revision 31. Secure EC approval to forward to RevCom2. Update Revision timeline as needed.

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 6


Task Group 7R Optical Wireless Communications1. Review and discuss contributions 2. Continue developing TGD3. Generate/Update Project Timeline

TASK GROUP-8 Peer Aware Communications1. Continue work on draft2. Update Project Plan/Timeline

TASK GROUP 9 –Key Management Protocol:1. Sponsor Ballot Comment Resolution2. Update Project Plan/Timeline

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 7


TASK GROUP 10--Layer 2 Routing (L2R):1.Letter Ballot comment resolution2.Update Project Plan/Timeline

STUDY GROUP 12 -15.4 Consolidated LLC (CLLC)1.Get updated on IETF94 outcomes2.Joint Meeting with 802.13.Continue work on draft PAR and CSD

THz Interest Group:–Hear contributions relating to THz comms.–Review ongoing mission/goals/new project potential

Dependability Interest Group:1.Discuss Contributions2.Evaluate if Study Group is warranted

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 8

High Rate Railroad Communications IG1. Discuss opportunities for standards work2. Review ongoing mission of the group

6 TiSCH Interest Group1. Hear contributions2. Get updated on IETF94 outcomes

15.4 Use Guide Interest Group1. Define goals2. Determine whether to move forward with an SG

NEW PROJECTS SUBCOMMITTEE (WNG)1. Review/discuss contributions


November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 9

99th IEEE 802.15 WSN MEETINGHyatt Regency ReunionDallas, Texas, USA

The graphic below describes the weekly session of the IEEE P802.15 WG in graphic format.

Rm 180 CR

Rn 230 CR

Rm 320 BR or CR

Rm 416 BR

Rm 512BR

Rm 180 CR

Rn 230 CR

Rm 320 BR or CR

Rm 416 BR

Rm 512BR

Rm 180 CR

Rn 230 CR

Rm 320 BR or CR

Rm 416 BR

Rm 512BR

Rm 180 CR

Rn 230 CR

Rm 320 BR or CR

Rm 416 BR

Rm 512BR

07:00-07:30

07:30-08:00

08:00-08:30

08:30-09:00

09:00-09:30

09:30-10:00

10:00-10:30

10:30-11:00

11:00-11:30

11:30-12:00

12:00-12:30

12:30-13:00

13:00-13:30

13:30-14:00

14:00-14:30

14:30-15:00

15:00-15:30

15:30-16:00

16:00-16:30

16:30-17:00

17:00-17:30

17:30-18:00

18:00-18:30

18:30-19:00

19:00-19:30

19:30-20:00

20:00-20:30

20:30-21:00

21:00-21:30

21:30-22:00

22:00-22:30

LEGEND

TG3d 100G Task Group-100G 15.3 PHY layer EC 802 EXECUTIVE COMMITTEETG3e Task Group-High Rate Close Proximity App Amendment to 15.3 AC 802.15 ADVISORY COMMITTEE

TG4n CMB Task Group 15.4n for China Medical Band SC-M Standing Committee on MaintenanceTG4q ULP Task Group Ultra Low Power 15.4 WNG 802.15 Wireless Next Generation Standing CommitteeTG4r DMT Task Group-15.4 Distance Measurement TechniquesTG4s SRU Task Group-15.4s Spectrum Resource Utilization IG GUIDE Interest Group-Guide for 15.4 Use

TG7R1 OWC Task Group-15.7Revison1-Optical Wireless Communications IG HRRC(Jt w/802.16) Interest Group- HIGH RATE RAIL COMMUICATIONSTG8 PAC Task Group 15.8 on Peer Aware Communication IG THZ Interest Group-TerahertzTG9 KMP Task Group 15.9 -KEY MANAGEMENT PROTOCOL Interest Group IG DEP Interest Group ON ENHANCED DEPENDABILITYTG10 L2R Task Group 15.10 -LAYER 2 ROUTING IG 6Tisch Interest Group-IETF Liaison

SG3R1 Study Group-15.3 Revision 1 (roll-up and 64-48 bit address conversion) SG LLC Interest Group-15.4 Consolidated Link Layer

802 EC MTG

TG4s SRU

CLOSING 802 EC MEETING

TG10L2R

TG8 PAC

TG9 KMP

802.15 WG Opening PlenaryROOM 1

TG4q ULP

TG8 PAC

TG9 KMP

TG10L2R

Tutorial 1 Dinner on your own

Tutorial 2

Tutorial 3

802.15 WG CLOSINGROOM 1

Dinner on your own

Break

Op

en

J oint802.15 /802.1

in802.1 Rm.

Op

en

TG7R1 OCC

TG4q ULP

Op

en

TG

4mc4REV

802.15 WG Midweek-ROOM 1

WNG ROOM 1

Break

SG4u India

TG

4mc4REV

IG 6TTG3m3REV

Lunch

Break

TG8 PAC

TG9 KMP

TG3e HRCP

TG10L2R

Break Break

TG4nCMB

TG

4mc4REV

TG4q ULP

8-Nov-2015 9-Nov-2015

TG4nCMB

Break

Break

Break

TG3d 100G

SUNDAY

WIRELESS CHAIRS MEETING

802.15 AC MEETING

Dinner on your own

Break

TG8 PAC

Social

IG DEP

TG3e HRCP

SG4u India

FRIDAY

TG3e HRCP

SG4t HR

IG DEP

Break

THURSDAY

TG

4mc4REV

12-Nov-2015 13-Nov-2015

SGLLC

LunchLunch

TG3e HRCP

802.15 AC MEETING-RM4

Dinner on your own

TG

4mc4REV

TG3e HRCP

Break

TG7R1 OCC

Joint 15/16

IG HRRC

TG

4mc4REV

TG3m3REV

TG8 PAC

Op

en

10-Nov-2015 11-Nov-2015

TG9 KMP

TG10L2R

TG10L2R

TG8 PAC

TG8 PAC

TG3e HRCP

SGLLC

TG8 PAC

SG4t HR

TG

4mc4REV

R5MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY

TG7R1 OCC

TG8 PAC

Lunch

Break

TG

4mc4REV

IG THzTG10L2R

TG7R1 OCC

SGLLC

TG3d 100G

TG7R1 OCC

TG4s SRU

TG4s SRU

TG4q ULP

Joint 15/16

IG HRRC

TG4q ULP

TG3d 100G

TG3d 100G

November 2015

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015

James Gilb (Pulse~LINK)Slide 10Slide 10

Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)Networks (WPANs)

Submission Title: TG3m November 2015 ReportDate Submitted: November 2015Source: James GilbContact: James GilbE-Mail: last name at ieee dot orgRe: TG3m reportAbstract: Report for the TG3m meeting in Dallas, TXPurpose: 802.15.3 revision.Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered

as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.

Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.

Slide 10

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015

James Gilb (Pulse~LINK)

Accomplishments• Approve conditional submission to

Sponsor ballot

• Approve liaising draft to ISO/IEC JTC1 under PSDO agreement

Slide 11

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015

James Gilb (Pulse~LINK)Slide 12

Conditional approval• Date ballot closed: 22 October 2015

• Ballot tally: 74 yes, 2 no, 4 abstain (97% approve)– One no voter has changed to yes in

current recirculation.– Remaining no voter has identified only one

comment as remaining unsatisfied (see next page)

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


Comment supporting no vote• Comment: As association request and response are not protected at all, what happens if

the rogue PNC will assing joining member wrong DEVID, which is duplicate with someone already in the network. When the valid DEV then tries send authetnicated frames to the real PNC using wrong DEVID, there will be nonce collisions. Is there something in the system that will prevent this? As the security message frames are not authenticated either, that means that attacker can do address translation for them too, i.e., change the address of the frame from the one that DEV thinks he has to the one that real PNC thinks he has, and other way around. Unless the security protocol run over those messages specifically authenticate the DEVID of the device, and not the full 48-bit address of the device, this phase will not detect this attack. After the security protocol, I think the device moves to use the encrypted frames, thus it might cause collision.

• Suggested resolution: blank

• Response Rejected: The Security Message command was introduced to allow 4-way handshake key agreement protocols (or 3-way for key agreements like ECMQV). The frames are authenticated by the handshake process and at this point, the DEV does not have a symmetric key and therefore, authentication is meaningless. The key agreement protocol will ensure the identities of the DEVs.

• As for a rogue PNC assigning an invalid DEVID, the attempt to authenticate with the true PNC would fail (it checks the DEVID).

• No change required.

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


Recirculation schedule• Current recirculation ends 15 November 2015

• BRC conference – 18 November 2015

• Recirculation #2:– 20 November 2015 to 5 December 2015

• BRC conference call– 7 December 2015

• Recirculation #3– 9 December 2015 to 24 December 2015

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


WG motion• 802.15 requests EC approval to forward

P802.15.3RevA-DF2 to ISO/IEC JTC1 SC6, for information under the PSDO agreement, once Sponsor balloting begins.

• WG vote– Moved Gilb, seconded Alfvin

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


TG motion• Motion: 802.15.3m requests that 802.15

request conditional approval from the EC to submit 802.15.3RevA draft amendment to Sponsor Ballot pending recirculation.

• TG vote– Moved: Second:

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


BRC formation• TG affirms the formation BRC

members: James Gilb (Chair), Thomas Kuerner, Andrew Estrada, Ko Togashi, Pat Kinney.

• TG vote

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


BRC conference call• 18 November, 2015, 22:00-23:00 PDT

– 29 October, 2015 6:00-7:00 CET, 14:00-15:00 JST

– Agenda• Resolve comments from WG letter ballot

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


Meeting Accomplishments• Resolved comments from comment

collection

• Voted to go to WG Letter Ballot

• Voted to form BRC

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


WG motions

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


Motion for conditional approval• Move that 802.15 WG start a WG Letter

Ballot requesting approval to forward document 802.15.3RevA-D00.pdf, edited in accordance with the instructions in document 15-15-0715-02-003m, to Sponsor Ballot pending the completion and inclusion of the edits in the draft.– Moved: Gilb– Second: Alfvin

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


WG motion• Motion: 802.15 requests conditional

approval from the EC to submit 802.15.3RevA draft amendment to Sponsor Ballot pending recirculation.

• WG vote– Moved: , Second:– Yes: , No:, Abstain:

IEEE 15-15-0912-00-003m

TG3m

November 2015


Motion to form BRC• Move that 802.15 WG approve the formation of a Ballot

Resolution Committee (BRC) for the WG balloting of the 802.15.3RevA draft standard with the following membership: James Gilb (Chair), Thomas Kuerner, Andrew Estrada, Ko Togashi, Pat Kinney. The 802.15.3m BRC is authorized to approve comment resolutions and to approve the start of recirculation ballots of the 802.15.3RevA draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution on recirculation ballots between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences announced to the reflector at least 7 days in advance.

– Moved: Gilb

– Second: Alfvin

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0905-001-003d_November_2015_Closing_Plenary_Slides

Submission

TG 3d Dallas November 2015Closing Report

Slide 24

November 2015


Submission

Meetings/Contributions

• 4 meetings• 4 Contributions:

– Contribution #1: Thomas Kürner, “CMD Simulation Scenarios” (15-15-0861r1)

– Contribution #2 Makoto Yaita, “Measured wave propagation characteristics under KIOSK use case”(15-15-0869r0)

– Contribution #3 Makoto Yaita, “KIOSK measurement_TG3d Channel Modelling Document”(15-15-0923r0)

– Contribution #4 “FCC NPRM” (15-15-0872)

Slide 25

November 2015


Submission

Tasks Completed (1/2)

• [Answers to PAR-Comments (completed at WG); 15-15-0682r2]• Revision of Supporting Documents (ToDo-List in 15-15-757r1):

– CMD (15-14-0310r14)– TRD (15-14-310r15)– ECD (15-15-412r8)

• Drafting of a Call for Proposals (15-15-0936r1)• Review on Time Planning (15-14-0155r8)

Slide 26

November 2015


Submission


• Drafting of Response to FCC_NPRM (15-15-0909r1)• Working on draft Response to Liaison Statement from ITU-R

(15-15-0699r4)• Review Status of Liasion Statement to ETSI ISG mWT (15-15-

0722r3)

Slide 27

November 2015


Submission


• 4 meetings• 4 Contributions:

– Contribution #1: Thomas Kürner, “CMD Simulation Scenarios” (15-15-0861r1)

– Contribution #2 Makoto Yaita, “Measured wave propagation characteristics under KIOSK use case”(15-15-0869r0)

– Contribution #3 Makoto Yaita, “KIOSK measurement_TG3d Channel Modelling Document”(15-15-0923r0)

– Contribution #4 “FCC NPRM” (15-15-0872)

Slide 28

November 2015


Submission


• [Answers to PAR-Comments (completed at WG); 15-15-0682r2]• Revision of Supporting Documents (ToDo-List in 15-15-757r1):

– CMD (15-14-0310r14)– TRD (15-14-310r15)– ECD (15-15-412r8)

• Drafting of a Call for Proposals (15-15-0936r1)• Review on Time Planning (15-14-0155r8)

Slide 29

November 2015


Submission


• Drafting of Response to FCC_NPRM (15-15-0909r1)• Working on draft Response to Liaison Statement from ITU-R

(15-15-0699r4)• Review Status of Liaison Statement to ETSI ISG mWT (15-15-

0722r3)

Slide 30

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

IEEE 802.15.3e

High Rate Close Proximity (HRCP)

Closing Report

Dallas, Texas

November 9-12, 2015

Slide 31

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

802.15.3e Officers

Chair: Andrew Estrada, Sony

Vice Chair: Thomas Kürner, Institut für Nachrichtentechnik Technische Universität Braunschweig

Secretary: Ken Hiraga, NTT

Technical Editor: Ko Togashi, Toshiba

Slide 32

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Goals for this meeting

• November Plenary: • Complete 1st draft of spec• Unify the different sections into a single

document.• Resolve remaining TG comments

Slide 33

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

TG3e Accomplishments

1. Presented 8 contributions:

1. Proposed terminology (Sony)

2. Frame aggregation and buffer empty flag (JRC)

3. MIMO (NTT)

4. Spectral Mask (Sony)

5. MAC (Toshiba)

6. RSSI Touch Model (ETRI)

7. OOK PHY (ETRI)

8. Optimal subframe length (Sony)

2. Reviewed draft spec

3. Drafted FCC NPRM text jointly with TG3d

Slide 34

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Timeline

35

JulyWaikoloa

12-17

SepBangkok

13-18

InitialPresentations

Deadline10 Sept

Mandatory Editorial

Coordination(at least 2 wks

before LB)

Jan ‘16Atlanta17-22

NovDallas8-13

Start Letter Ballot

Merge, Refine, Draft

Consensus

Merging

We are Here!

Technical Expert Group

Recommendations (couple of weeks before Jan mtg)

Mar ‘16Macau

.3 RevisionMid-Jan

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Draft status

• Members only folder• http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/15/private/Draft/TG3e/

• 6 sections of the draft uploaded• Awesome job so far!

Slide 36

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

TG Motion on Text for Response to FCC NPRM

• Motion: request that the text proposal contained in 15-15-0909-01-003d-3d-Text_Proposal_for_Response_to-FCC_NPRM be approved for submission to the WG for its approval and further submission to 802.11 and 802.18.

• Moved by: Ken Hiraga• Seconded by: Iwao Hosako• 15 yes / 0 abstain / 0 No

Slide 37

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Telecon Schedule

• 3 calls between now and Nov 2015• Time:

• EST 20:00 – 21:00• Dates:

• EST 2, 9, and 16 Dec, 6 Jan• Resolve all TG comments by 6 Jan

• Atlanta session = 18-21 Jan 2016

Slide 38

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Telecon Agenda

• Progress on draft spec

• Resolve TG comments• Return all comments to Ko Togashi by 1

Dec 2015, 11:59 EST in the provided Excel template.

• Share supporting materials and draft updates.

Slide 39

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Goals for next meeting

• January Interim: • Resolve remaining TG comments• MEC and TEG• Technically complete draft• Kick off Letter Ballot

Slide 40

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

A new spec is born…

41

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Thank You!

Slide 42

November 2015

doc.: <15-15-0854-02-0mag>

Submission

Slide 43

Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)

Submission Title: [SC Report for Nov 2015 Session]Date Submitted: [12 Nov 2015]Source: [Patrick Kinney] Company [Kinney Consulting LLC]Address [Chicago area, IL, USA]Voice:[+1.847.960.3715], E-Mail:[[email protected]]

Re: [SC Report for Nov 2015 Session.]

Abstract: [Report for the Nov Session]

Purpose: []

Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

SCmaintenance/SCwng Officer

Chair: Patrick Kinney

Vice Chair Ben Rolfe

Secretary

Slide 44Slide 44

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Chair’s Role• http://ieee802.org/

Mike_Spring_Article_on_Stds_Process.pdf…the chairperson of the working group is key to what and

how fast a standard is produced.

The chair of the committee acts as a facilitator with little power to legislate. The chair must be knowledgeable about the subject but also know how a standard may be used by various segments of the industry. A chairperson should be a leader-diplomat-observer, in equal proportions. Also, the chairperson should not be a doer, perfectionist or obstructionist. This is consistent with the view of the chairperson as a skilled leader with strong negotiation skills who delegates.

Slide 45Slide 45

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Meeting Goals (Agenda 15-15-0803-00)

Slide 46Slide 46

802.15 Standing Committee for maintenance of 802.15.4 has completed its task

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Meeting Goals (Agenda 15-15-0803-00)

Slide 47Slide 47

SC WNG (Wed, 11 Nov, AM2) Decoupling Band and Channel Plan from PHY specifications in

15.4 by B Rolfe

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Revision Schedule

• PAR Approval• EC 19 July 2013 (Geneva)• NesCom 21 Oct 2013

• Comment collection • Start 23 May 2014• End 6 June 2014

• Letter Ballot • Start 14 June 2014• End 13 July 2014

• Recirculations• Start 20 Oct 2014• End 6 Apr 2015

• Sponsor Ballot• Start 8 Apr, 2015• Ends 8 May, 2015

• Recirculation• Start 15 October, 2015• End 29 October, 2015

• EC approval 13 November, 2015 (Dallas)• RevCom

• Submission 23 October, 2015• Approval 4 December, 2015 (New Jersey)

Slide 48

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Voting Results

Slide 49

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Proposed Changes for Next Revision

1. Change 863 - 870 MHz Band to align with regulatory

2. Fix typo on Annex C.2.3.3.2 a) AuthData copied incorrectly

3. Change ANA assigned values from reserved to ANA assigned

4. Security clause – incoming frame security procedure to explicitly handle old encrypt only frames

5. Incorporate concept of doc 15-15-0859-01

Slide 50

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

SCm motionsBRC:SCm requests that 802.15 WG approve the formation of a Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the WG balloting of the 802.15.4 Revision draft standard with the following membership: Pat Kinney, James Gilb, Jussi Haapola, Jeritt Kent, Benjamin Rolfe, Clint Powell, Billy Verso, Kunal Shah, Fumihide Kojima, Tero Kivinen, and Tim Harrington. The 802.15.4 Revision BRC is authorized to approve comment resolutions and to approve the start of balloting the 802.15.4 Revision draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution on recirculation ballots between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences as announced to the reflector.

Kunal Shah moved, J Haapola seconded. Upon no opposition the motion carries with unanimous consent.

Slide 51Slide 51

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

SCm motions to WG15BRC:

Move that 802.15 WG approve the formation of a Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the WG balloting of the 802.15.4 Revision draft standard with the following membership: Pat Kinney, James Gilb, Jussi Haapola, Jeritt Kent, Benjamin Rolfe, Clint Powell, Billy Verso, Kunal Shah, Fumihide Kojima, Tero Kivinen, and Tim Harrington. The 802.15.4 Revision BRC is authorized to approve comment resolutions and to approve the start of balloting the 802.15.4 Revision draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution on recirculation ballots between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences as announced to the reflector.

Moved by Pat Kinney

Seconded by Ben Rolfe

Slide 52Slide 52

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

BRC Conference CallsStanding Weekly Conference Call:

BRC calls will start 7 December:

Mondays and Wednesdays at 8:00 PDT, 10:00 CDT, 18:00 EEST, Tuesdays and Thursdays at 00:00 JST•The call-in details are:

– Join the meeting: https://join.me/ieeesawg_802.15

– On a computer, use any browser with Flash. Nothing to download.

– On a phone or tablet, launch the join.me app and enter meeting code: ieeesawg_802.15

– Join the audio conference:

•Dial a phone number and enter access code, or connect via internet. •By phone:

– United States - Hartford, CT +1.860.970.0010

– United States - Los Angeles, CA +1.213.226.1066

– United States - Thousand Oaks, CA +1.805.309.5900

– Japan - Tokyo +81.3.4579.5983

– New Zealand - Auckland +64.9.951.8390

– United Kingdom - London +44.33.0088.2634

– Access Code 184-971-970#

Slide 53Slide 53

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Next BRC Call:Monday 7 December at 08:00 PDT, 10:00 CDT, 18:00 EEST Thursday 8 December at 00:00 JST

Slide 54

Agenda:Review RevCom’s reason for rejectionDiscuss recirculation of draft

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Accomplishments

Reviewed Status of Recirculation Reviewed plan to go forward Motion to create BRC along with Conference call

schedule as a contingency for the event that RevCom fails to approve the draft

Slide 55

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

SC WNG

One presentation: 15-15-0859-01-wng Decoupling Band and Channel Plan

from PHY specifications in 15.4 by B Rolfe Next Steps: Queue up for next revision

Start work now in SCM

Develop process OM addition?

Slide 56

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 57

IEEE 802.15 TG4n

China Medical Band

Closing Report

Dallas, Texas

November 12th, 2015

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 58

TG4n Schedule For This Week

MON TUE WED THU FRI

AM1

AM2

PM1CMB

PM2 CMB

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 59

Agenda

1. Review of IEEE policy2. Announcement of TG4n current status3. Formation of BRC for SB4. Schedule of BRC conference calls5. Preparation of a package for the 2nd re-circulation6. Other business issue (if necessary)7. Adjourn

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 60

Meeting Accomplishments

• Formation of BRC for SB recirculation• Scheduled BRC teleconferences• Reviewed TG4n activity results of SB and the 1st SB re-

circulation• Preparation of a package for the 2nd SB recirculation

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 61

• Move that 802.15 TG approve the formation of a Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the Sponsor balloting of the 802.15.4n draft standard with the following membership: Arthur Astrin (chair), Liang Li, Shinsuke Hara, WeiXia Zou and Kenichi Mori. The 802.15.4n BRC is authorized to approve comment resolutions and to approve the start of recirculation ballots of the 802.15.4n draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG.

• Moved by: Shinsuke Hara Seconded by: Bob Heile

Motion for 802.15 TG4n

InformativeMembers affiliated with different companies compose this TG4n BRC.

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 62

BRC Teleconferences

The following schedule was approved by TG4n.

Every Thursday, at 9:00 PM PST

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 63

Initial Sponsor Ballot of 15.4nBallot Open Data: 08-Feb-2015Ballot Close Date: 10-Mar-2015Must be satisfied: 34 (technical and editorial)Total comments: 48

Pool of 64 voter

Responses 54 (84%)Approve 48 (92%)Disapprove 4 (8%)Abstain 2

Recap of SB

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 64

Recirculation Ballot #1 of 15.4nBallot Open Date: 12-Jun-2015Ballot Close Date: 22-June-2015Must be satisfied: 0Vote changes: 3 (2 no voters => Approve, 1 no voter => Abstain)

Total comments: 1 (editorial, “This draft meets all editorial requirements.”)

Pool of 64 voter

Responses 54 (84%)Approve 50 (98%)Disapprove 1 (2%)Abstain 3

Recap of SB (re-circulation)

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 65

Move that TG4n, having reviewed the 5C statement, 15-12-0007-05 associatedwith P802.15.4n, approved this 5C statement.

Moved by: Shinsuke Hara Seconded: Bob Heile

Approved by unanimous consent

802.15.4n 5C Motion for TG4n

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 66

TG4n requests the 802.15WG seek conditional approval from the EC to submitthe IEEE P802.15.4n-D5.0 draft or final version to RevCom.

Moved by: Shinsuke Hara Seconded: Bob Heile

Approved by unanimous consent

802.15.4n to RevCom for TG4n (conditional)

November 2015

doc. IEEE802.15-15-0914-02-004n:

Submission Slide 67

Thank you

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 68

IEEE 802.15.4q Task Group

Closing Report19th Meeting of the ULP Task Group

Dallas, TX, USA

Nov. 9~12, 2015

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Nov. 2015 Sessions

• Secretary: Chandrashekhar Thejaswi PS

• Total of 5 time slots

Slide 69

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 70

Achievement this week

• Reviewed and approved the comment resolution for the second recirculation sponsor ballot on 802.15.4q draft spec. (D7.0).

• Reviewed the 5C conditions for 802.15.4q draft spec. (D7.0) and affirmed that the 5C conditions were met.

• Prepared an EC conditional approval package for submission 802.15.4q draft spec. (D7.0) to RevCom.

• Approved a motion to request 802.15 WG to seek conditional approval from EC to submit the 802.15.4q draft D7.0 to RevCom

• Reaffirmed the sponsor BRC

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 71

TG Motion: 5C Conditions

The 802.15.4q TG has reviewed the 5C and moves to affirm that the conditions of 5C (DCN 15-12-0387-06) for IEEE 802.15.4q draft D7.0 have been met.

Moved by: Hendricus De Ruijter

Seconded by: Chandrashekhar Thejaswi PS

Y/N/A: 7/0/0 (PASSED)

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 72

TG Motion: Submission 802.15.4q draft spec. to RevCom

Move the 802.15.4q TG to request 802.15 WG to seek conditional approval by EC for forwarding the 802.15.4q draft D7.0 (with the condition of correct referencing to the latest 802.15.4REV draft ) to RevCom.

Moved by: Kiran Bynam

Seconded by: Hendricus De Ruijter

Y/N/A: 5/0/0 (PASSED)

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 73

TG Motion: Reaffirmation of Sponsor BRCMove that the 802.15.4q TG requests 802.15 WG to reaffirm the Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the sponsor balloting of the 802.15.4q draft standard with the following membership:

The 802.15.4q BRC is authorized to approve sponsor ballot comment resolutions and the start of recirculation ballots of the 802.15.4q draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences announced to the reflector at least 30 days in advance.

Moved by: Hendricus De Ruijter

Seconded by: Allan ZhuY/N/A = 7/0/0 (PASSED)

– Chiu Ngo (Chair)

– Allan Zhu (Huawei)

– Hendricus De Ruijter (Silicon Labs)

– Youngsoo Kim (Samsung)

– Guido Dolmans (IMEC)

– Kiran Bynam (Samsung)

– Chandrashekhar Thejaswi PS (Samsung)

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 74

Teleconferences

• From Aug 17, 2015 to Mar. 13, 2016– Every Monday and Wednesday 7:00PM PST

(before US Daylight Saving started, 8:00PM PDT)

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 75

TG4q Timeline• Preliminary work

– Call for applications Dec 2012

– Applications presentations Jan 2013

– TGD outline Mar 2013

– TGD, applications and channel modeling contribution call Mar 2013

– Review TGD contributions May 2013

– TGD Ongoing & review application contributions Jul 2013

• Proposal effort– Call for intent Jul 2013

– TGD completed Sep 2013

– Call for proposals Sep 2013

– Proposal presentations Nov 2013

• Drafting – First draft May 2014

– Ballotable draft Jul 2014

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 76

TG4q Timeline (cont’)• Balloting

– WG letter ballot (#95) Oct 2014

– First WG LB recirculation (#100) Dec 2014

– Second WG LB recirculation (#101) Feb 2015

– Third WG LB recirculation (#105) Apr 2015

– Fourth WG LB recirculation (#107) May 2015

– Approval of sponsor ballot Jun 2015

– Sponsor ballot Jun 2015

– First SB recirculation Sept 2015

– Second SB recirculation Oct 2015

– EC Conditional Approval to submit to RevCom Nov 2015

– Third SB recirculation Dec 2015

– RevCom Approval Mar 2016

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Plan for Jan’16 Meeting

• Comment resolution for sponsor ballot recirc.

• Finalize material for RevCom approval

Slide 77

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 78

WG Motion: Reaffirmation of Sponsor BRCMove that 802.15 WG to reaffirm the Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the sponsor balloting of the 802.15.4q draft standard with the following membership:

The 802.15.4q BRC is authorized to approve sponsor ballot comment resolutions and the start of recirculation ballots of the 802.15.4q draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences announced to the reflector at least 30 days in advance.

Moved by: Chiu Ngo

Seconded by:

– Chiu Ngo (Chair)

– Allan Zhu (Huawei)

– Hendricus De Ruijter (Silicon Labs)

– Youngsoo Kim (Samsung)

– Guido Dolmans (IMEC)

– Kiran Bynam (Samsung)

– Chandrashekhar Thejaswi PS (Samsung)

November 2015

IEEE 802.15-15-0940-00-004q

Submission

Slide 79

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15- 0952-00-004s

Submission

Slide 80

IEEE 802.15 TG4sClosing report

Dallas, TXNovember 12, 2015

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15- 0952-00-004s

Submission

Slide 81

Agenda for the week

• Agenda Setting• Approve Bangkok and October Teleconference meeting

minutes• Hearing presentations• Work on Technical Guidance Document and Draft

document• Plan for January meeting and Teleconference• Report on progress to WG

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15- 0952-00-004s

Submission

Accomplishment for the meeting• Three meetings were held on Tuesday AM1, Thursday AM1

and AM2.• Approved September meeting and October Teleconference

meeting minutes.• Heard presentation.

– Proposal for SRM IE and TPC PIB in Technical Guidance Document (15-15-850r1)

• Reviewed and discussed of Technical Guidance Document (15-14-555)

• Reviewed Draft document.• Confirm plans for Teleconference and January meeting.

Slide 82

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15- 0952-00-004s

Submission

• TG4s November 2015 Agenda (15-15-794r1)• TG4s Opening Information for November 2015 (15-15-

882r0)• TG4s September 2015 Meeting Minutes (15-15-771r1)• TG4s Teleconference Minutes for October 2015 (15-15-

857r0)• Proposal for SRM IE and TPC PIB in Technical Guidance

Document (15-15-850r1)• TG4s Technical Guidance Document(15-14-555r9)

Contributions

Slide 83

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15- 0952-00-004s

Submission

Timeline

Slide 84

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15- 0952-00-004s

Submission

Plan for Teleconference and October Meeting

Slide 85

Teleconference

January Meeting• 3 meeting slot

– Hearing presentations– Work on Technical Guidance Document– Editing draft document.

Date (ET) Date (JST)

1 January 5, 22:00 January 6, 10:00

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0927-00-0000

SG4t (Higher Rate)

Nov. 2015

Clint Powell (PWC, LLC)

SG4tCLOSING REPORT

Slide 86

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0927-00-0000

SG4t (Higher Rate)

Nov. 2015


802.15 SG4t (Higher Rate)

Project:Draft a PAR and CSD for formation of an 802.15 TG4t for development of a Higher Rate PHY Amendment.

Leadership:Chair – Clint PowellTechnical Editor – …Secretary – …

Slide 87

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0927-00-0000

SG4t (Higher Rate)

Nov. 2015


Review Comments on PAR and CSD and Implement Changes as Agreed by SG

WG Approved Changes to PAR and CSD

Discuss Agenda for Jan. Mtg.

Discuss Rough Timeline for Project

Discuss Issuing a Call for Intent Prior to Jan. Mtg.

Meeting Goals

Slide 88

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0927-00-0000

SG4t (Higher Rate)

Nov. 2015


Review Comments on PAR and CSD and Implement Changes as Agreed by SG

WG Approved Changes to PAR (posted as 15-15-0738-01) andCSD (posted as 15-15-0739-01)

Discussed Agenda for Jan. Mtg.

Discussed Rough Timeline for Project

Agreed to Issuing a Call for Intent Prior to Jan. Mtg.

Meeting Status

Slide 89

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0927-00-0000

SG4t (Higher Rate)

Nov. 2015


Minutes - doc. # 15-15-0953-00

Minutes

Slide 90

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0927-00-0000

SG4t (Higher Rate)

Nov. 2015


Issue Call for Intent

Develop TRD/TGD & Call for Proposals

Issue Call for Proposals

Hear Proposals

Work to Achieve Baseline Draft

Prepare Draft

Letter Ballot

1st Letter Ballot Recirc.

2nd Letter Ballot Recirc.

3rd Letter Ballot Recirc.*

WG & EC Sponsor Ballot Approval

Sponsor Ballot

1st Sponsor Ballot Recirc.

2nd Sponsor Ballot Recirc.

3rd Sponsor Ballot Recirc.*

EC Approval

RevCom Approval

* May not be needed

SG4t Timeline (Relative)

Slide 91

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0927-00-0000

SG4t (Higher Rate)

Nov. 2015


Between Now and Atlanta Mtg. in Jan. Issue Call for Intent

At Atlanta Mtg. in Jan. Develop TRD/TGD Develop Call for Proposals

After Atlanta Mtg. Issue call for Proposals

Looking Forward

Slide 92

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0927-00-0000

SG4t (Higher Rate)

Nov. 2015


SG4t Conference Calls

No Conference Calls Planned

Slide 93

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0950-00-0000

Submission

SG4u Closing Report

November 12, 2015

Phil BeecherSG4u Chair

Slide 94

November 2015

Phil Beecher, Wi-SUN Alliance

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0950-00-0000

Submission

Meeting Objectives

Resolve comments received for PAR and CSD Prepare Provisional Timeline

November 2015

Slide 95 Phil Beecher, Wi-SUN Alliance

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0950-00-0000

Submission

Achievements 2 time slots used at this meeting PAR & CSD Comments resolved - included in document 15-

15-0919-00-0000-802-15-responses-to-par-csd-comments Provisional Timeline agreed – see slide 6

Slide 96

November 2015


doc.: IEEE 15-15-0950-00-0000

Submission

Plan for January Interim

Hear Proposals

Slide 97

November 2015


doc.: IEEE 15-15-0950-00-0000

Submission

Timeline TG formation Nov 2015 Call for Proposals Nov 2015 Presentation of Proposals Jan 2016 Start Letter Ballot Mar 2016 LB comment resolution + 2 recirculations Apr – Jun

2016 Sponsor Ballot Jul 2016 SB comment resolution + 2 recirculations Aug – Nov

2016 RevCom submission Nov 2016

Slide 98

November 2015


doc.: IEEE 15-15-0950-00-0000

Submission

Slide 99

November 2015


doc.: IEEE 802. 15-15-0087-00-0007

Submission

November 2015

Yeong Min Jang, Kookmin UniversitySlide 100

IEEE 802.15.7r1 OWC

Closing report

Dallas, USA Nov. 12, 2015

Doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0933-00-007r1

doc.: IEEE 802. 15-15-0087-00-0007

Submission

•Hear Call for Intent•Summary of 16 received Intent-for-Proposals•Outdoor Channel model discussion for High rate PD Communications

Agenda items for the week


November 2015 Doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0933-00-007r1

doc.: IEEE 802. 15-15-0087-00-0007

Submission

• 5 sessions (Mon., Tue., and Wed.) (0767-r3)• Summary of 16 Intent for Proposals (0844-04)

* 16 Institutions of submitted Intent for Proposal: Intel, pureLiFi, Ozyegin University, Texas A&M University at Qatar, Fraunhofer HHI, SYCA, National Taiwan University, Kookmin University, Panasonic, Boston University, Fudan University, Istanbul Medipol University, SNUST, Northumbria University, China Telecom, Huawei

Accomplishment for the Nov. meeting



doc.: IEEE 802. 15-15-0087-00-0007

Submission

• Requesting 10 meeting sessions– Hear CFP responses– Continue proposal mergers

Plan for January Meeting



doc.: IEEE 802. 15-15-0087-00-0007

Submission

The Committee Rules(15-15-0935-00-007a.docx) for the Presentation in the January and March meeting Document is up for a regular vote whether to be accepted:

Moved: Zeng Yu

Seconded: Richard D. Roberts

YES: 7 NO: 0 ABSTAIN: 1

MOTION



doc.: IEEE 802. 15-15-0087-00-0007

Submission

Motion to accept any intent for proposal submitted before November 5th 2015 as an official 802.15.7r1 intent for proposal.

Moved: Rick Roberts

Seconded: Hideki Aoyama

Yes: 10 No: 0 Abstain: 0

MOTION



doc.: IEEE 15-15-949-02-0008

Submission

TG8 PAC Closing Report

November 12, 2015

Myung J. Lee TG8 Chair

Slide 106

04/22/23

Myung Lee, CUNY

doc.: IEEE 15-15-949-02-0008

Submission

Meeting Objectives

Technical Presentation/Discussion Drafting v1.0 Discussion on Project Plan

04/22/23

Slide 107 Myung Lee, CUNY

doc.: IEEE 15-15-949-02-0008

Submission

Achievements 9 time slots used at this meeting Text Presentations on MAC functions and services Discussions on many-to-many communications Done a completed version for internal circulation Presented Documents

– Doc. 862r0: Two teleconf reports (Marco Hernandez)– Doc. 866r0: Doc.v0.16 (BJ Kwak)– Doc. 695r3: Revised table of contents– Doc. 877r0: One-to-many peering (HB Li)– Doc. 897r1: Many-to-many Group Formation (M. Lee)– Doc. 892r2: Cyclic superframe structure (SS Joo)– Doc. 920r1: NAV setting (Nah-oak Song and BJ Kwak)– Doc. 903r0: Text Physical layer security(BJ Kwak)

Slide 108

04/22/23

Myung Lee, CUNY

doc.: IEEE 15-15-949-02-0008

Submission

Achievements (cont.)

Presented Documents (cont.)

– Doc. 924r0: Realization of Many-to-many group formation

– Doc. 901r1: MAC commands (Marco Hernandez)

– Doc. 902r0: Text for secret key exchange (BJ Kwak)

– Doc. 938r0: Many-to-many group formation (HB Li)

– Doc. 934r0: MAC Functional Decscription (BJ Kwak)

– Doc. 941r1: MAC Frame format & IE (Marco Hernandez & Billy Verso)

– Doc.946r1: Text for CFP and scheduling of Resources (Maro Hernandez)

Slide 109

04/22/23

Myung Lee, CUNY

doc.: IEEE 15-15-949-02-0008

Submission

Plan for January Interim Internal Comments resolutions Co-existence document Teleconferences

– Agenda: • Internal draft circulation and comment resolutions

– Date: • December 2 (Wednesday) 7:00amUS EST, 9:00pm Japan/Korea, Ireland 12:00PM

• December 21 (Monday) 8:00pmUS EST, 10:00 am (Tuesday, December 22) Japan/Korea, Ireland 1:00AM

• January 7 (Thursday) 7:00am US EST, 9:00PM Japan/Korea, Ireland 12:00AM

Slide 110

04/22/23

Myung Lee, CUNY

doc.: IEEE 15-15-949-02-0008

Submission

Timeline TG formation Mar 12 Call for Application April 12 Application presentation May 12 TGD approval/Call for proposal Jan 13 Re-affirmation of TGD/Call for proposal March 13 Preliminary proposal presentation May, 13 Final proposal presentation July 13 PAC Framework Document/Call for contribution Jan. 14 Contribution Presentation March 15 Draft spec (P802.15.8 D1.0) complete/Letter Ballot May 15

LB Comment resolution/ LB recirculation Nov. 15 Sponsor Ballot Mar. 16 RevCom submission July 16

Slide 111

04/22/23

Myung Lee, CUNY

doc.: IEEE 15-15-949-02-0008

Submission

TG8 PAC Officers Chair: Myung Lee (CUNY)

Vice Chair: Huan-Bang Li (NICT)

Secretary Marco Hernandez (NICT)

Editors: Byung-Jae Kwak (ETRI) Seung-Hoon Park (Samsung)

Slide 112

04/22/23

Myung Lee, CUNY

doc.: IEEE 15-15-949-02-0008

Submission

Slide 113

04/22/23

Myung Lee, CUNY

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0893-01-0009-closing-report-november-2015

Submission

November 2015

Robert Moskowitz, HTT ConsultingSlide 114

KMP TG9 Closing Report

Dallas, Texas

November 12, 2015


Submission

November 2015


Accomplishments of the November Meeting

Sponsor Ballot comment resolution– Resolved all 75 comments

Prepare for Sponsor Ballot Recirculation Reformulated BRC

– For sponsor ballot recirculation comment resolution


Submission

November 2015


BRC Conference Calls

Continuing Tuesday, November 17, 2015 5pm – 6pm EST

– Weekly


Submission

November 2015


Planning for January Meeting

3 sessions Sponsor Ballot Recirculation Comment

Resolution


Submission

November 2015


Motion for approval of Resolutions to Sponsor Ballot

Move that 802.15.9 TG approve the resolutions to the sponsor ballot comments as described in document 15-15-0821-02-0009.

Moved by: Tero Kivinen

Seconded by: Don Sturek

Approved by Acclamation


Submission

November 2015


Motion for reaffirmation of BRC for 802.15.9

Move that 802.15.9 TG reaffirm the constitution of a Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the sponsor balloting of the 802.15.9 draft recommended practice with the following membership: Robert Moskowitz, Tero Kivinen, Don Sturek, Peter Yee, Subir Das, Brian Weis, Gary Stuebing. The 802.15.9 BRC is authorized to approve comment resolutions and to approve the start of recirculation ballots of the 802.15.9 draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences announced to the reflector.

Moved by: Tero Kivinen

Seconded by: Don Sturek



Submission

November 2015


Motion for reaffirmation of BRC for 802.15.9

Move that 802.15 WG reaffirm the constitution of a Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the sponsor balloting of the 802.15.9 draft recommended practice with the following membership: Robert Moskowitz, Tero Kivinen, Don Sturek, Peter Yee, Subir Das, Brian Weis, Gary Stuebing. The 802.15.9 BRC is authorized to approve comment resolutions and to approve the start of recirculation ballots of the 802.15.9 draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences announced to the reflector.

Moved by: Robert Moskowitz

Seconded by: Don Struck


doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


TG10CLOSING REPORT

Slide 121

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


802.15 TG10 (L2R)

Project:Draft a recommended practice for Layer 2 Routing of Dynamically Changing 802.15.4 Mesh Networks.

Leadership:Chair – Clint PowellTechnical Editor – Verotiana RabarijaonaSecretary – Charlie Perkins

Slide 122

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Recap Sept. 802.15 Interim and Current Status

Agenda and Mins. Approval

Resolve Comments from LB 110 Comment Database - doc. # 15-15-0318-xx (currently r30)

Approve Editorial Resolutions

Re-Establish TG10 BRC

Generate Update for 802.1

Review & Update Timeline

Meeting Goals

Slide 123

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


LB 110 Technical Comments - 223152 Resolved28 TBR (proposed resolutions - To Be Reviewed by commenter)43 Open

3 Approved RDN(resolution agreed to - Resolution Details Needed)

38 WiP (resolution needs work - Work in Progress)2 to go

Rogue Technical Comments - 4326 Resolved1 TBR 16 Open

4 Approved RDN 4 WiP 8 to go

LB 110 Comment Resolution Status

Slide 124

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Proposed Plan for the Week

Topic SessionMCO - Jaehwan Mon. AM1 or Wed. PM1

P2P - Jaehwan Mon. PM1/PM2 or Thurs. PM2 (Needs Tero for one comment if he wants to be there)

Topology construction / Service selection - Sato Mon. PM1/PM2 or Thurs. PM2 (Needs Tero)

Address assignment 1095 - Rabarijaona (doc 803) Mon. PM1/PM2 or Thurs. PM2 (Needs Tero)

NLM IE - Sato Wed. PM1

IEs (including the long IE issue) - Rabarijaona (doc 792 r4)

Mon. PM1/PM2 (Needs Tero and Pat for the long IE discussion)

Some comments with RDN Wed. PM1 or Thurs. PM1

Misc (doc 828, 827) Mon. AM1

Comments depending on 1095 Thurs. PM1

Comments depending on the service selection Thurs. PM1

Slide 125

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Recap Sept. 802.15 Interim and Current Status

Agenda and Mins. Approval

Resolve Comments from LB 110 Comment Database - doc. # 15-15-0318-xx

Approve Editorial Resolutions

Re-Establish TG10 BRC

Generate Update for 802.1

Review & Update Timeline

Meeting Status

Slide 126

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Actual Plan for the Week

Topic SessionMCO - Jaehwan Mon. AM1, Thurs. PM1

Address assignment 1095 - Rabarijaona (doc 803) Mon. PM2 (Needs Tero)

IEs (including the long IE issue) - Rabarijaona (doc 792 r4) Mon. PM2 (Needs Tero and Pat for the long IE discussion)

P2P - Jaehwan Mon. PM2, Thurs. PM1 (Needs Tero for one comment if he wants to be there)

Misc (doc 828, 827) Wed. PM1

Topology construction / Service selection - Sato Wed. PM1 (Needs Tero)

Comments depending on the service selection Thurs. PM2

Comments depending on 1095 Next Conf. Call

NLM IE - Sato Next Conf. Call

Some comments with RDN Next Conf. Call

Slide 127

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


TOTAL # OF COMMENTS 810

# LB COMMENTS 580# TECHNICAL 223

Resolved 204Work in Progress 19

# ROGUE 230# TECHNICAL 43

Resolved 42Work in Progress 1

LB 110 Comment Resolution Status

Slide 128

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Minutes - doc. # 15-15-0947-00

Comment Database - doc. # 15-15-0318-xx (currently r31)

Minutes & Comment Database

Slide 129

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Letter Ballot March/April 2015 1st Letter Ballot Recirc. Aug./Sept 2015 2nd Letter Ballot Recirc. Nov./Dec. 2015 3rd Letter Ballot Recirc. Jan./Feb. 2016 WG Sponsor Ballot Approval March 2016 EC Sponsor Ballot Approval March 2016 Sponsor Ballot March 2016 1st Sponsor Ballot Recirc. May/June 2016 2nd Sponsor Ballot Recirc. July/Aug. 2016 3rd Sponsor Ballot Recirc.* Sept./Aug. 2016 EC Approval Nov. 2016 RevCom Approval Dec. 2016

* May not be needed

TG10 Timeline

Slide 130

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Between Now and Atlanta Mtg. in Jan. Finalize Comment Resolution on 1st Letter Ballot

Recirculation Hold 2nd Letter Ballot Recirculation

At Atlanta Mtg. in Jan. 2nd Letter Ballot Recirculation Comment Resolution -

Begin Comment Resolutions to be Applied to Draft in Preparation for 3rd Letter Ballot Recirculation

Seek TG and WG Approvals of TG10 BRC

Looking Forward

Slide 131

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


After Atlanta Mtg. 2nd Letter Ballot Recirculation Comment Resolution 3rd Letter Ballot Recirculation 3rd Letter Ballot Recirculation Comment Resolution

Next Update to 802.1 March 2016

Looking Forward (cont’d.)

Slide 132

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Motion to form a TG10 BRC.TG10 requests that 802.15 WG approve the formation of a Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the WG balloting of the 802.15.4 TG10 draft recommended practice with the following membership: Clint Powell, Verotiana Rabarijaona, Fumihide Kojima, Noriyuki Sato, Kiyoshi Fukui, Soo-Young Chang, Jaehwan Kim, SangSung Choi, Charlie Perkins. The TG10 BRC is authorized to approve comment resolutions and to approve the start of balloting the TG10 draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution on recirculation ballots between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences as announced to the reflector.

Moved by: Charlie Perkins Seconded by: Verotiana RabarijaonaDiscussion: NoneVote: 11/0/0

TG10 Motion 1

Slide 133

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


TG10 Conference Calls Reminder

TG10 Standing Conference Call Info

Day: Mon.

Time: 6PM-8PM Mon. (Arizona)10AM-Noon Tues. (Japan-JST,

Korea)

Conf. #: To Be Sent to TG10 Reflector

Next Call: 16th, Nov. 7PM-8PM (Arizona)11AM-Noon Tues. (Japan-JST,

Korea)

Slide 134

doc.: IEEE 15-15-0858-01-0010

TG10 (L2R)

Nov. 2015


Motion for WG approval to form TG10 BRC.Move that 802.15 WG approve the formation of a Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) for the WG balloting of the TG10 draft recommended practice with the following membership: Clint Powell, Verotiana Rabarijaona, Fumihide Kojima, Noriyuki Sato, Kiyoshi Fukui, Soo-Young Chang, Jaehwan Kim, SangSung Choi, Charlie Perkins. The TG10 BRC is authorized to approve comment resolutions and to approve the start of balloting the TG10 draft on behalf of the 802.15 WG. Comment resolution on recirculation ballots between sessions will be conducted via reflector email and via teleconferences as announced to the reflector.

Moved by: Clint PowellSeconded by:

TG10 Motion 1 to WG

Slide 135

doc.: <15-15-0855-02-0llc>

Submission

<Pat Kinney>, <Kinney Consulting LLC>Slide 136


Submission Title: [SG LLC Closing Report for Nov 2015 Session]

Date Submitted: [12 Nov 2015]Source: [Patrick Kinney] Company [Kinney Consulting LLC]Address [Chicago area, IL, USA]Voice:[+1.847.960.3715], E-Mail:[[email protected]]

Re: [SG LLC Report for Nov 2015 Session]

Abstract: [Report for the Nov Session]

Purpose: []

Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.


<Nov 2015>

doc.: <15-15-0855-02-0llc>

Submission

Administrative Items• Required notices

– IEEE Code of Ethics• http://www.ieee.org/about/corporate/governance/p7-8.html

– IEEE Standards Association (IEEE-SA) Affiliation FAQ• http://standards.ieee.org/faqs/affiliation.html

– Antitrust and Competition Policy• http://standards.ieee.org/resources/antitrust-guidelines.pdf

– IEEE-SA Patent Committee FAQ & Patent slides• http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/faq.pdf

• http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt

– Letter of Assurance Form• http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/loa.pdf

• Chair and Secretary request– Chair is Pat Kinney (Kinney Consulting)

<Pat Kinney>, <Kinney

Consulting LLC>

<Nov 2015>

Slide 137

doc.: <15-15-0855-02-0llc>

Submission

<Nov 2015>

<Pat Kinney>, <Kinney Consulting LLC>Slide 138Slide 138

SG LLC Meeting Goals

Tuesday, 10 Nov, PM2 Opening report (15-15-0855-01) LLC proposal presentation (15-15-0521-01) Report of announcement at IETF94 (15-15-838-00) Discussion on topics for tonight’s joint meeting with 802.1

Ethertype, bridging 64-bit to 64-bit, etc.Wednesday 11 Nov, AM1:

First cut at PAR (15-15-760-01) and CSD (15-15-768-01)Thursday 12 Nov, PM1

Second cut at PAR (15-15-760-02) and CSD (15-15-768-02)Agenda approval (15-15-0806-00)Minutes from Bangkok approval (15-15-0719-00)

doc.: <15-15-0855-02-0llc>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


Discussion of Topics at 802.1/802.15 Joint Meeting

doc.: <15-15-0855-02-0llc>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


Summary of joint meeting with 802.1Here's a list of the feedback topics collected from the joint meeting with 802.1:•Don’t use EtherType compression! Don’t use compression per field. Some people don’t want to route because the packets get too long. Want to look at taking a full size 802 header, and using a header compression technology.•If you are using work from another organization, you could do it by reference, but then you lose change control. [related to bullet 5 of Prioritized Functionality slide]•Should use same values for Ethertype that already exists•To obtain a new EtherType, it is required to show a subtype plan•How much of this work could be done in 802.1 is encouraging to use ISS•802.15.4 does not have managed objects. But if LLC does configuration, it is going to deal with managed objects. It is possible that this will not define any new managed objects.•Can use 6lowpan protocol discriminator from IETF; ask 6lo to request EtherType from IEEE RAC

doc.: <15-15-0855-02-0llc>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


Replacement names for LLC

The following names were proposed by the SG attendees which was followed by a straw poll to determine the group’s consensus:•DFUL (Dot Four’s Upper Layer) – 0 straw poll votes•ULI (Upper Layer Interface) - 5 straw poll votes•None of the above – 2 straw poll votes

The consensus from the group is to use ULI as the group’s name.

doc.: <15-15-0855-02-0llc>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


Review and edits to PAR and CSD

The PAR and CSD documents, 15-15-0760-01 and 15-15-0768-01 respectively, were reviewed and modified as per the group’s consensus. The resulting PAR and CSD documents, 15-15-0760-02 and 15-15-0768-02 respectively were uploaded to mentor.

The consensus from the group was to authorize the chair to send these documents to the following organizations for their review:•802.1•IEEE-IETF Coordination Committee•IETF 6tisch•IETF 6lo•WiSUN•ZigBeeComments from these groups will be considered at the January session.

doc.: <15-15-0855-02-0llc>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


Motion to extend the SG 802.15.12 till March Plenary

Motion: that the 802.15 Working Group seeks approval from the 802 EC to extend the study group in 802.15 to develop the PAR and CSD documents for “802.15.12” Moved by B RolfeSeconded by T KivinenUpon neither discussion nor objection the motion carries

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

IEEE 802.15 IG HRRC(High Rate Rail Communications Interest Group)

Closing Report

Dallas, TX USA

Wednesday AM2, November 11, 2015

Junhyeong Kim, ETRISlide 144

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

IG Group Leadership

• Chair : Junhyeong Kim (ETRI, South Korea)

• Secretary : Bing Hui (ETRI, South Korea)


November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

Sessions

• 6th meeting for IG HRRC– Joint 15/16 meeting

• 1 session– Tuesday PM1 (13:30 ~ 15:30), November

10, 2015

• 9 participants


November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

Meeting Accomplishments• Technical discussions

– Ray-tracing based Study on Mobile Channel in Typical Urban Environment with Various Beamforming Strategies at 32 GHz : 15-15-0837-00-hrrc

• Small RMS delay spread and RMS Doppler spread in urban environment

• In case the train moves along a straight track, fixed beamforming used on both Tx and Rx is enough for stable communication link with advanced handover strategies

– Handover Strategy for High-speed Rail Communications : 15-15-0839-00-hrrc

• Different handover procedures for head antenna and tail antenna of high-speed rail

• Difficulty in defining the Handover trigger condition


November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

Contributions

• 5 contributions– Contribution #1 (15-15-0847-00-hrrc) : IG HRRC November

2015 Agenda– Contribution #2 (15-15-0837-00-hrrc) : Ray-tracing based

Study on Mobile Channel in Typical Urban Environment with Various Beamforming Strategies at 32 GHz

– Contribution #3 (15-15-0839-00-hrrc) : Handover Strategy for High-speed Rail Communications

– Contribution #4 (15-15-0915-00-hrrc) : Meeting Minutes of November 2015

– Contribution #5 (15-15-0916-00-hrrc) : Closing Report for November 2015


November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission


Thank you

November 2015

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

November 2015

Slide 150

IEEE 802.15 IG DEP

Closing Report

Dallas, TX, U.S.A.November 11th, 2015

Jussi Haapola(CWC/UoO)

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

New presentation by Yeong Min Jang (Kookmin University), Doc #895.

Recap of Call for Interest document, Doc #15-14-0449-06 to highlight required information.

Meeting Objectives

Slide 151

November 2015


doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

One new interest presentation, Doc #895. Currently, 15 different proposed applications.

Discussion of scope and targeted task group, amendment or new TG.

Meeting Accomplishments

Slide 152

November 2015


doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0916-00-hrrc

Submission

15-15-0843-00-0dep-November-2015-agenda

15-15-0888-00-0dep-ig-dep-november-opening-report

15-15-0895-00-0dep-kookmin-university-response-to-call-for-interests-cfi-of-ieee-802-ig-dep

15-15-0894-00-0dep-November-2015-meeting-minutes

15-15-0907-00-0dep-ig-dep-november-closing-report

Attendees 4

Contributions

Slide 153

November 2015


doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0904-000-0thz_November_2015_Closing_Plenary_Slides

Submission

IG THz Dallas 2015 Closing Report

November 2015

Thomas Kürner, TU BraunschweigSlide 154


Submission


• 1 meeting • 15 participants• 1 contribution:

– Contribution #1: Thomas Kürner, “Angle of Arrival Estimation for Moving User Equipment,” (15-15-0852r0)

• Discussion on response to ITU-R liaison statement and to FCC NPRM– Reponses will be tightly coordinated with TG3d– Discussion on a joint meeting with TG3d at Atlanta

November 2015



Submission


Straw Poll on Joint Meeting wit TG3d at Atlanta

• Straw Poll: Should tze IG THz shoud have a joint meeting wit TG3d to coordinate the reponses to ITU-R WP1 and to FCC-NPRM?

5 Yes / 0 abstain / 0 No

November 2015

doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission



Submission Title: [IG 6tisch Closing Report for Sept 2015 Session]

Date Submitted: [10 Nov 2015]Source: [Patrick Kinney] Company [Kinney Consulting LLC]Address [Chicago area, IL, USA]Voice:[+1.847.960.3715], E-Mail:[[email protected]]

Re: [IG 6tisch Opening& Closing Report for Nov 2015 Session.]

Abstract: [Opening Report for the Nov Session]

Purpose: []

Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.


<Nov 2015>

doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission

Administrative Items• Required notices

– IEEE Code of Ethics• http://www.ieee.org/about/corporate/governance/p7-8.html

– IEEE Standards Association (IEEE-SA) Affiliation FAQ• http://standards.ieee.org/faqs/affiliation.html

– Antitrust and Competition Policy• http://standards.ieee.org/resources/antitrust-guidelines.pdf

– IEEE-SA Patent Committee FAQ & Patent slides• http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/faq.pdf

• http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt

– Letter of Assurance Form• http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/loa.pdf

• Chair and Secretary request– Chair is Pat Kinney (Kinney Consulting)

November 2015


doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


IG 6T Meeting GoalsTuesday 10 Nov, PM1:

AgendaReview of IETF94, Yokohama; Nov 20156tisch issues discussion

6top IEsSecurityReCharterLLC impact

Approval of agenda (15-15-807-00)Approval of minutes from Bangkok (15-15-0766-

00)

doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


Review of IETF94, Yokohama; Nov 2015

Summary: New Charter •Status Document•New Charter•Milestones•Action PlanDynamic Scheduling•draft-wang-6tisch-6top-sublayer-03•draft-dujovne-6tisch-6top-sf0-00Tracks in 6TiSCH•draft-thubert-6tisch-4detnet-01Any Other Business•Announcement second ETSI 6TiSCH Plugtests

doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


6TISCH Issues Discussion

6top IEsReCharterSecurityLLC impact

doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


6TISCH Issues Discussion - 6top IEs

The 6P messages are carried in a payload IE, i.e. IETF Information Element:•Group ID: IANA_IETF_IE_GROUP_ID -Length: variable•Content: defined as follows

IEEE Liaison Considerations•If the specification described in this document is supported by the 6TiSCH WG, the authors of this document ask the 6TiSCH WG chairs to liaise with the IEEE to request a Payload Information Element Group ID to be assigned to the IETF (Group ID IANA_IETF_IE_GROUP_ID described in Appendix A).•Members of 6tisch also asked if IG 6tisch could assist in the use of the requested ID by proposing a detailed format consisting of elements such as sub-ids and other fields

Current 6tisch proposal•draft-wang-6tisch-6top-coapie-01

doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


6TISCH Issues Discussion - ReCharterThree new work items: dynamic scheduling (6top, SF0), secure bootstrap, track definition and DetNet requirements

•Produce "6TiSCH architecture" to describe the design of 6TiSCH networks. This document will highlight the different architectural blocks and signaling flows, including the operation of the network in the presence of multiple LBRs. The existing document will be augmented to cover dynamic scheduling and application of the DetNet work. •Describe the mechanisms offered by the 6top sublayer. This includes a protocol for neighbor nodes to negotiate adding/removing cells. The work on the protocol and associate packet formats could be continued at the IEEE. •Produce a specification for a default 6top Scheduling Function including the policy to enable distributed dynamic scheduling of time slots for IP traffic. This may include the capability for IoT routers to appropriate chunks of the matrix without starving, or interfering with other 6TiSCH nodes. This particular work will focus on IP traffic since the work on tracks is not yet advanced enough to specify their requirements for dynamic scheduling operations. •Produce a specification for a secure 6TiSCH network bootstrap, adapted to the constraints of 6TiSCH nodes and leveraging existing art when possible.•Produce requirements to the DetNet WG, detailing 6TiSCH chunks and tracks, and the data models to manipulate them from an external controller such as a PCE.

doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


6TISCH Issues Discussion - SecurityJoin Process:•PANA

• More than just restricted forwarding rules and hooks for the upper layers, it also involves resource isolation at the lower layers to help ensure that unauthorized traffic cannot interfere with authorized traffic

•802.15.9 KMP• The main use of PANA in 802.15.9 is for provisioning the link-layer credentials (LLCs) to the

joining node, where the LLCs can be of any type including shared key and public key credentials• While PANA can be used for both bootstrapping and link-establishment, this document provides

the guidelines for the use of PANA as a bootstrapping KMP•Metrics to evaluate secure join mechanism

• So IMO the key metric is the duration of the overall process, network-wise. Percentage of battery consumed was not the best metric to consider as it clearly depends on the capacity of your battery. The duty cycle with minimal schedule during joining will probably be on the order of 10-15% (1/11, 1/7 cells). That means that 10-15% of time you will be wasting energy listening to the transmissions of others, collisions, retransmissions, the duration of which depends on the number of nodes contending for the minimal cell and obviously the traffic load per node

• It’s not that we do not care it, but as the joining process is done only once, it is so small amount of actual network lifetime. For example, if the joining process takes an hour for the 100 node network, and the network is then up and running for a year, before next maintenance cycle, that is 0.01% of the lifetime of the network.

•Use of well-known key for beacons

doc.: <15-15-0856-03-006T>

Submission

<Nov 2015>


6TISCH Issues Discussion - LLC impactCommentary•IETF AD seemed irritated that advance notice of the LLC group formation had not been given to him•Significant confusion as to the LLC’s impact on IETF efforts such as 6tisch and 6lo, i.e. will LLC define new and different versions of 6tisch and 6lo?Announcement of 802.15.12 (LLC) effort in the IEEE•LLC Interest Group has progressed to a Study Group that had first meeting recently.

• general goal is to make 15.4 easier to use. Right now, a lot left to implementers• on the todo list: dispatch code (a la Ethertype), 15.9 and 15.10 alignment with LLC, etc.• interface for Key Management Protocol (KMP) and L2 routing.

•802.15 has growing awareness of 6TiSCH thanks to 6TiSCH interest group at IEEE, that reports at every meeting about 6TiSCH progress•provides link to presentation on LLC on IEEE side•at January meeting: submit PAR and CSD •how is it organized? 802.15.12 will not be merged into 802.15.4 release?

• 802.15.12 and 802.15.4 would have reasonably distinct content so they can be kept separated. LLC work would be delivered separately from 802.15.4 and not wrapped into 802.15.4 revisions.

•at 6TiSCH, we plan on just continuing our work at the current fast pace. Discussion and coordination with IEEE will happen in parallel.

• agreement that both groups want the same thing. Other "customers" also out there. 6TiSCH is a primary customer that LLC wants to keep satisfied

doc.: IEEE 802.15-15-0964-01

Submission

Slide 171

Upcoming Sessions• January 17-22, 2016, Hyatt Regency Atlanta, Atlanta, GA, USA, 802

Hosted Interim.* (100th Session of 802.15)

• March 13-18, 2016, Sands Venetian Hotel Macau, PRC (TBC), 802 Plenary Session.

• May 15-20, 2016, Hilton Waikoloa Village, Kona, HI, USA, 802 Wireless Interim Session.*

• July 24-29, 2016, Grand Hyatt Manchester, San Diego, CA, USA, 802 BPlenary Session

• September 18-23, 2016, TBD (Europe), 802 Wireless Interim Session.*

• November 6-11, 2016, Grand Hyatt San Antonio, San Antonio, TX, USA, 802 Plenary Session.

November 2015

Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance