Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Slide 1 Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.
March 2000Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
Submission Title: [LB2 Results]
Date Submitted: [6Mar00]
Source: [Ian Gifford] Company [M/A-COM, Inc.]Address [1011 Pawtucket Boulevard Lowell, MA USA 01853-3295]Voice:[+1 978 442 4650], FAX: [+1 978 442 5442], E-Mail:[[email protected]]
Re: []
Abstract: [The results of the Letter Ballot #2 held from 23Feb00 to 3Mar00.]
Purpose: [Provide TG1 with a detailed analysis of the LB2.]]
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 2
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks
TG1 LB2 ReportMarch 2000, Albuquerque, NM
USA
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 3
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Contents
• LB2 Summary
• TG1 Ballot Roadmap
• LB2 Background/Flowchart
• LB2 Results– Balloting– Commenting
• Next Steps
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 4
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
LB2 Summary
• Opened 23Feb00 closed 3Mar00, noon to noon EST• LB2 MOTION: “Submit the contents of -99/173r5
[99173r5P802-15_TG1-LB1-Comments-Resolution-Worksheet.xls] to the P802.15 WG for approval to apply the TG1 Comment Resolutions to the current P802.15.1 Draft Standard.”
• LB2 RESULT: Motion passed with 34/1/2 or 92% (-99/173r5a)
• LB2 yielded 20 Reply Comments to be resolved against –99/173r5a
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 5
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
TG1 Ballot Roadmap
1999 20009/99
Today
11/998/99 12/99
WG Balloting
2/00 3/00 4/00 5/00 6/00 7/00 8/00 9/00 10/00 11/00 12/00...10/99
SponsorBalloting
HICA IL NM WA CA TN FLMeetings/Events
WG LetterBallot
#1
WG LetterBallot
#2Sponsor Plan IEEE ETSI?
SponsorBallot
#1
SponsorBallot
#2
WGLB#1
TG 1 PlanWGLB#2
WGLB #3Option
TG 1 ActualWGLB#1
WGLB#2
SponsorLB#1
WGLB#(3)
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 6
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart
S oftw are W ork in g G rou p A ir In te rface W ork in g G rou p
n W ork in g G rou p s
W G C h a irm an
IE E E E d ito ria l W ork in g G rou p
P rog ram M an ag em en t(P M )
B lu e too thS p ec ia l In te res t G rou p
A d viso ry C ore
C oexis ten ce S tu d y G rou p (S G )
H ig h R ate S tu d y G rou p (H R S G )
S tu d y G rou p s
M an ag m en t E n tityL L C S u b layerM A C S u b layerP H Y L ayer
S u b Task G rou p s
Task G rou p 1 (TG 1 )
Task G rou p s
M arke tin g C om m ittee (M C )
C om m ittees
P 8 0 2 .1 5 W G
W G C h a ir
S p on sorIE E E 8 0 2
This graphic is provided to indicate the chain of custody for the Specification toStandard. The v1.0A was submitted 4Nov99, v1.0B was submitted on 1Dec99
And the v1.1 is expected in May00. V1.2 is just a place holder.
Bluetooth v1.0 A
Bluetooth v1.0 B
Bluetooth v1.1
Bluetooth v1.2?
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 7
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Letter Ballot #1Comment DB
TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart - 1
Draft StandardSubmission
V0.6 (v1.0A)4Nov99
Draft StandardSubmission
V0.64Nov99
23Dec99
Letter Ballot #1
Letter Ballot #1Comment DB 27Dec99
11Nov99
*Letter Ballot 1Ballot Results & Comment Prep.
{
27Dec99
*All comments are loaded into the database. Any Bluetooth comments are also loaded.
Draft StandardSubmission
(v1.0B)1Dec99
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 8
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart - 2 (cont.)
Letter Ballot #1Comment DB 27Dec9927Dec99
BluetoothResponse20Jan00
P802.15 Interim Meeting 10-13Jan00
27Jan00-99/173r5a
Letter Ballot #1Comment DB
3Mar00Letter Ballot #2
23Feb00
{P802.15 Interim Meeting 6-10Mar00
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 9
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Letter Ballot #2Comment DB
TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart - 3 (cont.)
Draft StandardSubmission
updated to V1.0
Letter Ballot #2Comment DB
6Mar00
Letter Ballot #2Ballot Results & Comment Prep.
3Mar00Letter Ballot #2
23Feb00
{
BluetoothResponse
Letter Ballot #1Comment DB
May00
{
Blu
etoo
th E
rrat
a P
roce
ss
P802.15 Interim Meeting 8-12May00Draft StandardSubmission
(v1.1)May00
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 10
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
23Feb00 the P802.15 Working Group was comprised of 43 voting members:
1 Mr. Houman Alborzi voter2 Mr. Dimitri Alexandrou voter3 Mr. Simon Baatz (Simon) voter4 Mr. Edul Batliwala (Edul) voter5 Mr. Alan Bien (Alan) voter6 Dr. Chatschik Bisdikian voter7 Mr. Dave Carlson (Dave) voter8 Mr. Harshal Chhaya (Harshal) voter9 Mr. Wm. Caldwell Crosswy voter10 Mr. William Cruz (Bill) voter11 Mr. Richard Ditch (Rich) voter12 Mr. Richard Eckard (Dick) voter13 Mr. Kurt Fischer (Kurt) voter14 Mr. Matthias Frank (Matthias) voter15 Mr. Ian Gifford (Ian) voter16 Ms. Nada Golmie (Nada) voter17 Mr. Allen Heberling (Allen) voter18 Mr. Robert Heile (Bob) voter19 Mr. John Paul Jones (John) voter20 Dr. Srinivas Kandala voter21 Dr. Parviz Kermani (Parviz) voter22 Mr. Stuart Kerry (Stuart) voter
23 Mr. Patrick Kinney (Pat) voter24 Mr. Bruce P. Kraemer (Bruce) voter25 Dr. Yunxin Li (Yunxin) voter26 Mr. Daniel R. McGlynn voter27 Mr. Michael D. McInnis (Mike) voter28 Dr. Akira Miura (Akira) voter29 Dr.Thomas Müller (Thomas) voter30 Mr. Peter Murray (Peter) voter31 Mr. Erwin R. Noble (Erwin) voter32 Mr. Mike Paczonay (Mike) voter33 Mr. Arto Palin (Arto) voter34 Dr. Davis Pan (Davis) voter35 Mr. Ivan Reede (Ivan) voter36 Mr. Carlos A. Rios (Carlos) voter37 Mr. Brian E. Roan (Brian) voter38 Mr. Karlheinz Schwarz voter39 Dr. Stephen J. Shellhammer voter40 Mr. Thomas Siep (Tom) voter41 Mr. Nick Stapleton (Nick) voter42 Mr. Steve Torp (Steve) voter43 Dr. Fujio Watanabe (Fujio) voter44 Mr. Todor Cooklev (Todor) Voter
= Resignation prior to the LB #1 Start
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 11
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
23Feb00 the P802.15 Working Group was comprised of 15 non members:
Nearly Voter
43 Mr. David Cypher (Dave) Voter
44 Mr. Rajesh Jarang (Rajesh) Voter
45 Mr. Kevin Marquess (Kevin) Voter
46 Mr. Richard Wilson (Dick) Voter
Aspirant
47 Mr. Richard Alfvin (Rick) Voter
48 Mr. James Allen (Jim) Voter
49 Mr. Thomas Baker (Tom) Voter
50 Dr. Victor Bahl (Vic) Voter
51 Mr. William Bailey (Bill) Voter
52 Mr. Timothy J. Blaney (Tim) Voter
53 Mr. Masaki Hoshina (Masaki) Voter
54 Mr. Gary McCoy (Gary) Voter
55 Mr. Anand R. Prasad (Anand) Voter
56 Mr. Matthew Sherman (Mat) Voter
57 Mr. Hirohisa Wakai (Hirohisa) Voter
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 12
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
LB2 Results - Overview
• 43 Total Voting Members
• 37 Total Votes (34/1/2)
• 6 Total Failed to vote
YEAS 34 92%NEAS 1 3%ABSTAINS 2 5%Total 37 100%FAILED TO VOTE 6
TOTAL 43
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 13
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
LB2 Results - DetailNO Last name First name status LB2 Yea Yea w/c Nea Abs Fail Total1 Alborzi Mr. Houman (Houman) voter y 12 Alexandrou Mr. Dimitri (Dimitri) voter y 13 Baatz Mr. Simon (Simon) voter y 14 Batliwala Mr. Edul (Edul) voter y 15 Bien Mr. Alan (Alan) voter a 16 Bisdikian Dr. Chatschik (Chatschik) voter y/c 17 Chhaya Mr. Harshal (Harshal) voter y 18 Cooklev Mr. Todor (Todor) voter y 19 Crosswy Mr. Wm. Caldwell (Caldwell) voter f 110 Ditch Mr. Richard (Rich) voter y 111 Eckard Mr. Richard (Dick) voter y 112 Fischer Mr. Kurt (Kurt) voter y 113 Frank Mr. Matthias (Matthias) voter y 114 Gifford Mr. Ian (Ian) voter y 115 Golmie Ms. Nada (Nada) voter n 116 Heberling Mr. Allen (Allen) voter y/c 117 Heile Mr. Robert (Bob) voter y 118 Jones Mr. John Paul (John) voter f 119 Kerry Mr. Stuart (Stuart) voter y 120 Kinney Mr. Patrick (Pat) voter y 121 Kraemer Mr. Bruce P. (Bruce) voter y 122 Li Dr. Yunxin (Yunxin) voter y 1
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 14
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
LB2 Results - Detail23 McGlynn Mr. Daniel R. (Dan) voter y 124 McInnis Mr. Michael D. (Mike) voter y 125 Miura Dr. Akira (Akira) voter y 126 Mueller Mr. Thomas (Tom) voter y 127 Murray Mr. Peter (Peter) voter a 128 Noble Mr. Erwin R. (Erwin) voter y 129 Paczonay Mr. Mike (Mike) voter y 130 Palin Mr. Arto (Arto) voter y/c 131 Pan Dr. Davis (Davis) voter y 132 Reede Mr. Ivan (Ivan) voter y 133 Rios Mr. Carlos A. (Carlos) voter y 134 Roan Mr. Brian E. (Brian) voter y 135 Schwarz Mr. Karlheinz (Karlheinz) voter f 136 Shellhammer Dr. Stephen J. (Steve) voter y 137 Siep Mr. Thomas (Tom) voter y 138 Stapleton Mr. Nick (Nick) voter y 139 Torp Mr. Steve (Steve) voter y 140 Watanabe Dr. Fujio (Fujio) voter y/c 1
41 Carlson Mr. Dave Carlson (Dave) voter f 142 Kandala Dr. Srinivas Kandala (Srinivas) voter f 143 Kermani Dr. Parviz Kermani (Parviz) voter f 1
30 4 1 2 6 43
a = Abstainn = Do Not Approve (Negative)y = Approve (Affirmative)/c = with Comments w/o = with out Comments y = failed to respond Red = dropped from Membership
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 15
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks
Sponsor Balloting Pool Status
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 16
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
P802.11
Sponsor Balloting Pool as of 16Feb00
WG Membership• 43 Voting• 7 Nearly Voting• 16 Aspirant
LAN/MAN802.15
54?
P802.1666
1579+9
?
?
?
?
DATE COUNT15-Dec-99 38
6-Jan-00 4816-Feb-00 54
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 17
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Sponsor Balloting Pool as of 16Feb00 (cont.)
No Last Name FirstName Phone EMailAlias COMPANY Voter1 Aihara Toru 81-46-273-4905 [email protected] ?2 Alborzi Houman 301-405-7027 [email protected] University of Maryland3 Alspaugh Matthew D 303-583-5255 [email protected] SpectraLink4 Andersson Daniel 46703242783 [email protected] Celsius Test Systems AB5 Bell Ernest 44-1442-438025 [email protected] 3Com Corporation6 Belvin Stephen E 727-302-2296 [email protected] Raytheon7 Bisdikian Chatschik 914-784-7439 [email protected] IBM Research 18 Boer Jan 31-30-6097483 [email protected] Lucent9 Carter James S 919-543-2436 [email protected] IBM Corp10 Crosswy William C 281-514-2774 [email protected] Compaq 111 Currivan Bruce J 949-585-5460 [email protected] Broadcom12 Ecclesine Peter 408-527-0815 [email protected] CISCO Systems13 Fischer Kurt B 925-280-7779 [email protected] Hyper Corp.14 Fischer Michael A 210-614-4096 [email protected] Intersil Corp.15 Freedman Avraham 972-3-6959552 [email protected] InnoWave-ECI Ltd.16 Gaucher Brian P 914-945-2596 [email protected] IBM TJ Watson Research17 Gifford Ian C 978-442-4650 [email protected] M/A-COM, Inc. 118 Gilb James P 480-413-8421 [email protected] Motorola19 Godfrey Tim 913-897-0908 [email protected] Choice Microsystems20 Harrison Simon 44-1753-661421 [email protected] Madge21 Heberling Allen 716-588-1939 [email protected] Eastman Kodak 122 Heile Robert 617-873-4835 [email protected] GTE 123 Hermann Reto J 41-1-724-8479 [email protected] IBM Research24 Izadpanah Hossein 310-317-5563 [email protected] HRL Laboratories25 Kardach Jim 408-765-4469 [email protected] Intel26 Kerry Stuart J 408-267-4680 [email protected] Consultant 127 Khanna Amarpal S 408-970-3108 [email protected] Agilent Technologies
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 18
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Sponsor Balloting Pool as of 16Feb00 (cont.)
28 Kiernam Brian G 610-878-5637 [email protected] InterDigital Comm Corp.29 Kinney Patrick W 319-369-3593 [email protected] Intermec Inc. 130 Langston J Leland 972-344-0795 [email protected] Raytheon31 Marks Roger B (303) 497-3037 [email protected] NIST32 McInnis Michael D 425-865-2840 [email protected] Boeing 133 Noble Erwin 281-719-1955 [email protected] Telxon Corp. 134 O'Hara Robert 408-986-9596 [email protected] Informed Technology, Inc.35 Orzol Roman 856-222 7467 [email protected] Oki Data36 Paine Richard H 425-865-4921 [email protected] Boeing37 Pandanda Roger 619-839-3942 [email protected] MCS Corp.38 Park Yunsang 301-548-1291 [email protected] Hughes Network Sytems39 Petry Brian D 858-674-8533 [email protected] 3Com Corporation40 Ralston Margarete A 408-988-1112x117 [email protected] Wytec Inc.41 Rautenberg Peter 49-2166-27-2778 [email protected] Alcatel Cabling Systems42 Rohner Christian 41-1724-8703 [email protected] IBM Research43 Roy Jaideep 973-793-5823 [email protected] Bear Sterns & Co.44 Sanders Ray W 310-476-5063 [email protected] CircuitPath45 Schott Wolfgang 41-1-724-8476 [email protected] IBM Research Div.46 Sherman Matthew J 973-236-6925 [email protected] AT&T47 Shimura Akihiro 81-44-798-7579 [email protected] Canon48 Solomon David 914-731-2259 [email protected] Fujitsu Network Communications49 Srinivas Kandala 360-817-7512 [email protected] Sharp 150 Thomas Nicholas A 801-320-7533 [email protected] 3Com Corporation51 Turner Edward 44-1442-438586 [email protected] 3Com Corporation52 Tzerefos Polychronis D 44-411-265-793 [email protected] University of Sheffield53 Valcourt Scott A 603-862-4489 [email protected] University of New Hampshire54 Zhang Wei 301-975-3443 [email protected] NIST
10
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 19
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Sponsor Balloting Pool Planning Schedule - Overview
The LAN/MAN 802.15 Balloting Pool needs to filled before theMay00 Interim Meeting. We need to send requests to join in Mar00.
2000 2001
LB143D
LB(3)40D
May00 Jul00
LB210D
Mar00
Working GroupSponsor Balloting Group
•Invitation•Balance
•Form Balloting Group
Preliminary Balloting Pool(3 Months)
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 20
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Sponsor Balloting Pool Planning Schedule - Detail
March 2000
Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 21
doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/052r0
Submission
Next Steps
• More Request to join via e-mails?• The MC will craft a generic letter to help
promote and explain the Balloting Pool -00/056r0
• Contact?– 802 Secretary to advertise – P802.11, .16 Chairs to advertise– Liaison Mailing List
• New Link on .15 Web Site?• Other?
