Upload
karen-stewart
View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
are illustrated with excellent drawings. I was initially impressed also bythe neat summary of information inthe first chapter. However, this chapter concerned cervical problems, withwhich I have limited clinical experience. When I came to the three chapters on upper extremity disorders, Idiscovered errors of omission that gaveme serious misgivings about the con tent of the other chapters.
I feel that if Dr . Swezey had beenmore familiar with the available literature on hand and upper extremityrehabilitation, he would have simplified his approach, recognizing that itis impossible to adequately cover allthe ground he attempted to cover inso little space. His readers would bebetter served with fewer specific treatment recommendations and referral tomore comprehensive sources for further information. As it is, he makesmisinformed suggestions, such as athumb-positioning splint that immobilizes the thumb CMC and MP jointsin a nonfunctional position, with a volar base that would further limit opposition by blocking ulnar metacarpalmobility. He recommends some exercises , such as passive PIP flexion, without giving guidelines as to the dangersof stressing lax joints. He neglects anumber of treatment options, includ-
DO YOU LIKE TO WRITE?
We are looking for ASHT members who can write thoughtful, concisebook reviews. Years of experience arenot a prerequisite, but strong writingand analytical skills are essential. Ifyouhave been looking for a way to becomemore active in your Society, here is anopportunity to do so, and at the sametime to become better acquainted withthe growing body of hand rehabilitation literature.
If you are interested, write to Karen Stewart, MS, OTR, at:
218 JOURNAL OF HAND THERAPY
ing many possible splints. This appears to reflect both difficulty prioritizing material to be covered, andinadequate research into state of theart upper extremity rehabilitation. Anexamination of the references cited inthe wrist and hand chapter reveals thatthe author's main sources are the Arthritis Foundation, an orthopedic text,and his own work. He has not cited asingle well-recognized expert withinthe field of hand rehabilitation.
Indeed, the author, a physicianwith extensive experience in rheumatology, internal medicine, andphysical medicine and rehabilitation,mentions physical and occupationaltherapists only one or two times, andnever specifically discusses their rolesor the fact that they are the individualsmaking those splints and treating thosepatients. There is no discussion of physician communication with therapists,patients, and allied health professionals, and no recognition of their essential contribution to treatment planning and implementation. The bookwould have benefited greatly from ashort description of each allied healthprofessional's role in the rehabilitationteam, and examples where appropriate. Such references might avoid potential communication problems byencouraging inexperienced rheuma-
Stewart Hand Therapy Group50 Maple Street, Suite 203Springfield, MA 01103(413) 732-4195
You may submit a review, following the ASHT guidelines (availablefrom Hanley & Belfus, 210 South 13thSt., Philadelphia, PA 19107), or suggestthe name of a book you would like toreview. This should be a book to whichyou have access, whether from yourown library or on loan. In the future,if you become a staff book reviewer,
tology residents, for example, to acknowledge and utilize the expertise oftherapists.
When I received this book for review, I hoped I had found a usefulhandbook to which I could turn, if notfor detailed information on the upperextremity at least for help in understanding and treating related joint andsoft-tissue disorders. I hoped also to beable to recommend the book to physicians seeking information on rehabilitation. Although I feel competentto judge the content of only the upperextremity chapters, I expect that thelimitations in these chapters are present in the others. The author has triedto address a broad field in too muchdetail, and thereby has made seriouserrors of omission. He gives insufficient importance to the growing fieldof hand and upper extremity rehabilitation, and has thus neglected a significant body of literature. Therefore,in spite of the author's evident expertise in the medical aspects of this field,and in spite of my agreement with hispragmatic and patient-oriented approach to rehabilitation, I am unableto recommend this book to either physicians or therapists.
Karen M. Stewart, MS, OTR
you will be sent free copies of booksto review.
If you can write a perceptive andthought-provoking book review, youcan help others in our professionchoose which of the many new publications to purchase, and in so doing,you will influence the direction of further writing in the field .
Karen Stewart, MS, OTR