115
DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND

ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN

THE OLDER ADULT

Page 2: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 2

OBJECTIVES

Know and understand:

• The factors that may lead to dizziness and syncope in older adults

• The elements of evaluation (history, physical examination, testing) of older adults with dizziness and syncope

• The treatment options for dizziness and syncope

Page 3: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 3

TOPICS COVERED

• Dizziness Classification and Causes Prognosis for Older Adults with Dizziness Evaluation and Management

• Syncope Pathophysiology Causative Factors Evaluation and Management

Page 4: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 4

IMPORTANCE AND COMPLEXITY OF DIZZINESS

Dizziness is a common symptom in older adults• Accounts for 7 million clinic visits/year in US• Prevalence = 13%–38%

Challenges for clinicians• Precise classification is difficult• Worry about serious causes• Specific therapy not available for many 50% of cases have multiple causes

Page 5: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 5

DRUG TOXICITY DIZZINESS

• In older adults, prescription drug toxicity is an important contributor to dizziness

• Use of 3 medications = dizziness risk factor

• Certain drugs are more frequently implicated

– Cause orthostasis or CNS effects

– Cardiovascular or antihypertensive drugs

– Psychotropic medications

Page 6: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 6

Oscillopsia• seen in ototoxicity and in patients on

chemotherapy• patients complain of blurred vision• patients on ototoxic medications (eg, 24-hr

gentamicin) should be assessed• testing—ototoxicity possibly developing if

moving head while looking at large printed word produces movement or blurring of word

Page 7: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 7

Ototoxicity

• associated with use of aminoglycosides

• Reassess need for ototoxic medication every week

• inform patients about possible dizziness and imbalance, and document

Page 8: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 8

DIZZINESS: CLASSIFICATION BY SYMPTOMS

• Vertigo — Rotational sensation

• Presyncope — Sensation of impending faint

• Disequilibrium — Loss of balance without head sensation

• Lightheadedness — Ill-defined, not otherwise classifiable

Page 9: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 9

Vestibular system• most patients with peripheral vestibular

dysfunction recover because • 1) central nervous system (CNS) resets incorrect

information received from ears by weighing it against information received from eyes

• 2) proprioceptive areas in feet and ankles maintain balance

• assess eyes• in elderly, check vibration sense, reflexes, and

position sense in toes

Page 10: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 10

Vertigo

• illusion of movement where none exists

• Implies asymmetry between right and left

• does not always imply peripheral vestibular dysfunction

• 60% of patients destined for stroke may complain of dizziness (not necessarily vertigo)

• vertigo often prominent in cardiac dysfunction

Page 11: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 11

CAUSES OF VERTIGO

• Peripheral vestibular disorders Benign positional vertigo Labyrinthitis Ménière’s disease

• Central vestibular disorders (minority of cases) Transient ischemic attack (TIA) Vertebrobasilar ischemia Brain tumors Multiple sclerosis

Page 12: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 12

BENIGN POSITIONAL VERTIGO (BPV)

• Episodic

• Aggravated or brought on by changes in position (eg, turning, rolling over, bending over)

• Spells are often brief (5–15 sec)

• Spells are often milder than in other peripheral vestibular disorders

Page 13: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 13

Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV)

• movement in the plane of semicircular canal (eg, lying back, sitting up, or roll-ing over) results in burst of rotary nystagmus

• check for latency (ie, 1-30 sec after patient lies down); when patient lies down, brief burst of nystagmus slows down and stops, but occurs

• (then reverses) when patient sits up again; when patient• in patients who do not have classic rotary nystagmus, alcohol use most

common cause of positional dizziness• lies down again, nystagmus improves or resolves• Epley maneuver— patient sits on side of bed, lies down quickly to one side,

looks over shoulder, then sits up and lies down on other side and looks over shoulder (should be initially performed 5 times per side

• dimenhydrinate [eg, Gravol] 30 min before exercise helpful)• most patients with uncomplicated BPPV improve within days to weeks• difficult for patients with cervicospinal problems (not recommended for

elderly• associated with high recurrence of dizziness)

Page 14: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 14

LABYRINTHITIS

• Also called vestibular neuronitis

• Occurs acutely

• Lasts several days

• Resolves spontaneously

Page 15: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 15

Vestibular neuritis• common; often occurs after upper respiratory

infection (URI), herpes infection, or gastrointestinal viral infection

• patients severely ill, and always have nystagmus• treatment—in emergency department (ED), give

dexamethasone (eg, Decadron)• in office, give prednisone (1 mg/kg per day)• starting steroids early may help patients recover

sooner• (eg, within 2 mo; most patients recover within 1 yr)

Page 16: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 16

Exercise and physiotherapy

• initiate after vomiting resolves

• Cawthorne-Cooksey exercises involve eye and head movements and tilting

• balance exercises with tossing balls

• challenge brain for faster recovery

Page 17: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 17

MÉNIÈRE’S DISEASE

• Repeated episodes of tinnitus

• Fluctuating hearing loss

• Severe vertigo

• Eventual progressive sensorineural hearing loss

• Frequency and severity of vertigo may improve as hearing impairment worsens

Page 18: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 18

Endolymphatic hydrops, Meniere’s disease

• classic episode— plugged ears; roaring tinnitus; severe vertigo• lasts 6 to 8 hr• vomiting; ataxia; hearing decreases with each successive episode• Rare• ask about headache and visual sensitivity• Vertigo and hearing loss in elderly patient more likely ischemic problem than true hydrops• counsel patients about decreasing caffeine, salt, and sugar intake• treatment—sublingual lorazepam (eg, Ativan) for severe episodes (effective in 15-30 min• Transdermal scopolamine patch slower)• rectal dimenhydrinate• Diuretic (eg, acetazolamide [eg, Diamox]) for pressure symptoms (discuss contraindications)• meclizine (eg, Bonine)• flunarizine (Sibelium) helpful when uncertain whether dizziness related to migraine or

peripheral vestibular problem• Meniett device decreases endolymphatic pressure (if ineffective, ablative procedure required)• differential diagnosis—atypical migraine; ischemic disease; autoimmune disease (consider

steroid trial in patients with eg, Crohn’s disease or lupus and fluctuating hearing loss)

Page 19: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 19

BRAIN TUMORS

• Found in <1% of dizzy patients

• Slightly more prevalent (2%–3%) in older patients referred to neurologists

• Acoustic neuroma Most common tumor associated with dizziness

Unilateral cochlear symptoms (tinnitus and hearing loss) predominate, not dizziness

Bilateral cochlear symptoms in older persons usually represent presbycusis, not tumor

Page 20: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 20

PRESYNCOPE

• Sensation of near-fainting

• Sign of decreased cerebral perfusion

• Cardiac causes Electrical: tachy- or bradyarrhythmias Structural, esp. aortic outflow obstruction

• Vascular causes (eg, orthostatic hypotension, vagal stimulation)

• Postural change (with or without orthostatic hypotension)

Page 21: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 21

DISEQUILIBRIUM

• Sensation of being unsteady when standing or, in particular, walking

• Many factors can contribute to imbalance:

Chronic vestibulopathies

Visual problems

Musculoskeletal disorders

Somatosensory or gait deficits

Page 22: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 22

LIGHTHEADEDNESS

• Best reserved as a description for patients who do not experience vertigo, presyncope, or disequilibrium

• Any cause of dizziness may occasionally produce “lightheadedness”

• The 2 most prominent considerations:– Psychiatric causes (depression, anxiety, somatoform

disorders)

– Idiopathic causes

Page 23: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 23

Ophthalmic migraine• may present as visual symptoms and dizziness

without headache• few patients have classic basilar migraine (ie,

migraine associated with dysarthria, visual symptoms, and bilateral hearing loss)

• migraine vestibulopathy diagnosis of exclusion• if dizziness clearly associated with migraine, try

empiric medication (eg, flunarizine or topiramate [Topamax]

• if patient not sleeping well, consider nortriptyline)

Page 24: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 24

PURPORTED CAUSES OF DIZZINESS, ESPECIALLY IN OLDER ADULTS

• Cervical arthritis

• Visual disorders

• Carotid sinus hypersensitivity

Page 25: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 25

Other causes of dizziness

• obstructive sleep apnea (OSA)

• Depression

• rule out nystagmus before attributing hyperventilation dizziness to anxiety

• vestibular physiotherapy may be helpful in anxious patients

Page 26: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 26

Elderly

• rarely present with primary ear problem

• Sudden dizziness may be due to ischemic cause

• perform computed tomography (CT) for patients in ED with risk factors or >60 yr of age

Page 27: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 27

Trauma• short-term memory loss, headache, and loss of sense of smell likely due

to central concussion• slight hearing loss and dizziness with movement of head can be due to

whiplash, or central or vestibular concussion• distinguishing central from peripheral concussion—dizziness with

head movement can be sign of either, but dizziness without head movement more likely vestibular

• BPPV—may present later if head trauma significant• (ask, “is this the same kind of dizziness that you had after your• accident?”)• perilymph fistula—classic history includes dizziness with straining• patient may develop plugged ears and hearing loss, especially after

exertion (eg, weight-lifting) or head trauma• improves in most patients if heavy lifting and straining avoided (fistula

may be repaired if hearing continues to drop)

Page 28: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 28

PROGNOSIS FOR OLDER PERSONS WITH DIZZINESS

• Usually resolves within days to several months

• Chronic or recurrent symptoms Experienced by ~25% of dizzy adults Commonly due to psychiatric disorders,

disequilibrium, or vestibulopathy other than BPV or labyrinthitis

• Not associated with increased mortality, hospitalization, or severe disability

• Associated with ↑ risk of syncope, falls, and depression, and with worse self-rated health

Page 29: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 29

EVALUATION OF DIZZINESS: HISTORY

• Elicit the patient’s own description of the event without prompting

• Learn:

– Whether the dizziness is characterized by any of 3 sensations: spinning, fainting, or falling

– Whether there is a positional effect on symptoms– What other symptoms are associated with dizziness

(specifically ask about focal neurological symptoms)– What medications the patient is taking

Page 30: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 30

EVALUATION OF DIZZINESS: HISTORY

• elderly have difficulty describing symptoms• patients may not mention other symptoms when overwhelmed by

dizziness and vomiting• ask about headache• tingling around mouth• Dysarthria• Imbalance• Severe problems usually present with nausea, vomiting, and

imbalance• assess reduced hearing• clinical signs more recognizable in patients with true disability• ask about bothersome movements• if symptoms worsen only when patient gets up, consider postural

problem

Page 31: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 31

EVALUATION OF DIZZINESS: HISTORY

• true positional—occurs when patients lie down, roll to one side, and rise (or with hyperextension of head)

• movement-induced—occurs with all types of movement• sometimes confused with positional dizziness• Ask whether dizziness occurs only while walking consider cerebellar

problem• peripheral vestibular system stimulated with all movements, even while

driving• exercise-induced— consider cardiac problem, lack of physical

conditioning, or spinocerebellar ataxia type 6 abnormality (associated with familial hemiplegia syndromes)

• if dizziness induced by arm movement (eg, weight-lifting), listen at base of neck for bruit (suggests subclavian steal syndrome)

• visually-induced— common in migraineurs• may present as new symptom in patients developing multiple sclerosis

Page 32: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 32

EVALUATION OF DIZZINESS:PHYSICAL EXAMINATION

• Take blood pressure and pulse while patient is supine and after standing for 1 to 2 min

• Perform a vestibular/nystagmus exam:– Primary position– Gaze-evoked– Head-hanging (Dix-Hallpike) test– Head shaking

• Perform cardiac examination

• Observe for balance and gait difficulties

Page 33: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 33

Physical examination

• ask about initial episode and current symptoms• test rapid alternating movements and corneal reflex• identifying nystagmus• Enlarging patient’s eyes with high-powered reading glasses may be

helpful• dim lights and look at retina for 1 min, then look for• movement in blood vessel in other eye• peripheral vestibular nystagmus may be seen in center gaze (accentuated

by looking in direction of past component• no accentuation in central vestibular nystagmus)• Fukuda stepping test for balance—positive if patient moves to side while

stepping in place with eyes closed• hearing test—distract one ear by rubbing, and speak into other ear, “Suzy

eats tomatoes” (start at low pitch and gradually increase)• test both ears

Page 34: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 34

EVALUATION OF DIZZINESS:DIAGNOSTIC TESTING (1 of 2)

• Audiometry

May help if cochlear symptoms are present (tinnitus, asymmetric hearing loss)

Abnormal results may indicate Ménière’s disease or, rarely, a tumor

• Vestibular testing

Electronystagmography Brain-stem auditory evoked responses Rotatory chair Dynamic posturography

Page 35: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 35

EVALUATION OF DIZZINESS:DIAGNOSTIC TESTING (2 of 2)

• Neuroimaging (CT, MRI) occasionally warranted

• Electroencephalography (EEG) and lumbar puncture typically not useful

• Study the vertebrobasilar system if other neurologic symptoms suggest TIA

• ECG: low yield in patients with normal cardiac exam and no syncope

• Not useful for isolated dizziness: Holter and event monitors, echocardiography, stress testing, tilt-table, electrophysiologic studies

Page 36: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 36

MANAGEMENT OF DIZZINESS (1 of 2)Treatable Cause Treatment

Acute vertigo of peripheral vestibular disorders

Reassurance and behavioral modification; meclizine (overused), plus a benzodiazepine only if absolutely needed, with caution for toxicity

BPV, mild Reassurance

BPV, severe or refractory Home habituation exercises, Epley’s maneuver

Ménière’s disease with frequent attacks

Salt restriction, diuretic, or both; occasionally refer for consideration of surgery

Page 37: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 37

EPLEY’S MANEUVER

Page 38: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 38

MANAGEMENT OF DIZZINESS (2 of 2)

Treatable Cause Treatment

Orthostatic hypotension Correct reversible causes

Disequilibrium Prevent falls with cane or other assistive device

Depression Trial of an SSRI

Chronic vestibulopathy Vestibular rehabilitation, a type of physical therapy

Page 39: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 39

SYNCOPE: INTRODUCTIONSudden, transient loss of postural tone and consciousness

(not due to trauma) with spontaneous full recovery

• Accounts for:– ~3% of emergency department visits– 2% to 6% of hospital admissions

• 80% of those hospitalized for syncope are aged 65+

• Causes– May be benign or life-threatening– In older adults, may be multifactorial– Possible causes are numerous

Page 40: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 40

NORMAL REFLEXES THAT PREVENT SYNCOPE

• 1/3 of blood volume pools in legs while standing

• Reflex pathways facilitate venous return and increase cardiac output– Baroreceptor reflex: ↑ autonomic sympathetic tone

peripheral vasoconstriction and ↑ heart rate

– Renal nerve: ↑ renin release from juxtaglomerular apparatus angiotensin II (causes vasoconstriction) and aldosterone (causes sodium retention)

– Atrial natriuretic factor: reduced upon standing, further facilitating vasoconstriction

Page 41: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 41

PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF SYNCOPE: EFFECTS OF AGING

• Reflex mechanisms are less responsive – ↓ ability to increase heart rate in response to

sympathetic stimulation– ↑ sensitivity to effects of dehydration and vasodilator

drugs

• Comorbidities that affect postural responses are common (eg, diabetes mellitus)

• Drugs may further impair postural reflexes (eg, -blockers, -blockers, tricyclic antidepressants)

Page 42: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 42

SYNCOPE: NATURAL HISTORY

Altered systemic blood pressure orIncreased cerebral vascular resistance

Reduced cerebral perfusion

Syncope

Causes may be benign or life-threateningCauses may be multiple

Page 43: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 43

COMMON CAUSES OF SYNCOPEIN ELDERLY PERSONS

• Arrhythmia• Aortic stenosis• Carotid sinus hypersensitivity• Hypoglycemia• Myocardial infarction• Orthostatic hypotension• Postprandial hypotension• Psychogenic causes• Pulmonary embolism (large)• Vasovagal faint

Page 44: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 44

SYNCOPE: PROGNOSIS

Type of syncope 1-yr mortality

Cardiac 18%–33%

Noncardiac 6%

Unknown cause (1/3 to 1/2 of patients)

Intermediate, generally favorable

Page 45: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 45

SYNCOPE EVALUATION:HISTORY (1 of 2)

Precipitants? • Eating• Urinating• Coughing• Medication• Emotional stress• Physical exertion• Turning head

Prodromal symptoms?• Chest pain• Palpitations• Dyspnea• Diaphoresis• Presyncope• Nausea• Vomiting

Page 46: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 46

SYNCOPE EVALUATION:HISTORY (2 of 2)

• Medications?– How, when taken, what doses– Relationship to meals and activities– Recent changes

• Any witnesses?– Duration of event– Appearance of patient during event (flaccid tone

and motionless or increased tone and motion?)

• Comorbid conditions?Eg, coronary artery disease, diabetes mellitus

Page 47: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 47

SYNCOPE CAUSED BY ARRHYTHMIA

• Prior to event Occurs in any position, <5 sec warning No precipitant; palpitations rare

• During event Flaccid tone; pulse faint or absent Blue, ashen skin Incontinence (rare)

• Recovery Rapid and complete

Page 48: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 48

VASOVAGAL SYNCOPE

• Prior to event Aborted if person lies flat Seconds to minutes of warning Precipitant present; nausea/diaphoresis common Visual changes

• During event Motionless; relaxed tone; slow, faint pulse Pale color; dilated, reactive pupils

• Recovery Fatigue, nausea and diaphoresis common No retrograde amnesia

Page 49: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 49

SYNCOPE CAUSED BY SEIZURE

• Prior to event Occurs in any position No warning or prodrome

• During event Rigid tone; rapid pulse; elevated BP Tonic eye deviation common Frothing at mouth

• Recovery Slow, incomplete Disorientation; focal neurologic findings

Page 50: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 50

SYNCOPE EVALUATION:PHYSICAL EXAMINATION (1 of 2)

• Pulse in supine and standing positions

• Orthostatic vital signs: Measure BP in both arms, 1 min after standing and again after standing for 3 min

• Carotid pulse examination Delayed upstroke and low volume may identify aortic

stenosis Perform carotid massage only with continuous ECG and

resuscitation equipment availableContraindicated with carotid bruit, CVD, recent MI

Page 51: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 51

SYNCOPE EVALUATION:PHYSICAL EXAMINATION (2 of 2)

• Cardiac examination for murmurs, extra heart sounds

• Stool for occult blood

• Neurologic examination for focal deficits

Page 52: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 52

SYNCOPE EVALUATION: TESTING(1 of 2)

• ECG for all syncopal older adults; assess for: Acute or remote MI Conduction abnormalities and pre-excitation Sinus bradycardia Prolonged QT interval

• Ambulatory ECG

Among patients able and willing to operate loop recorders, diagnostic yield is ~25%

Implantable recorders are cost-effective for patients with ejection fraction >35% and symptoms not consistent with a neural cause of syncope

Page 53: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 53

SYNCOPE EVALUATION: TESTING(2 of 2)

• Echocardiography

• Tilt-table testing

• Electrophysiologic (EP) studies

• Neurologic testing (MRI and CT, plus EEG) if focal neurologic signs or symptoms are present, or if the history suggests seizure

Page 54: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 54

TREATMENT OF SYNCOPE (1 of 3)

• Focus on treating the underlying disorder

• In older patients, treatment of multiple possible causes is often necessary

• Discontinuation of medications that increase the risk of syncope is always an early step

Page 55: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 55

TREATMENT OF SYNCOPE (2 of 3)

Cause Treatment

Myocardial ischemia Revascularization or aggressive medical therapy

Valvular heart disease (esp. aortic stenosis)

Usually surgery, avoid preload reduction

Symptomatic SVT Medical therapy or electrophysiology ablation

Significant ventricular tachyarrhythmia

Implanted defibrillator or medical therapy

Bradyarrhythmia Usually pacemaker

Page 56: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 56

TREATMENT OF SYNCOPE (3 of 3)

Cause Treatment

Orthostatic hypotension

Adjust medications, ensure adequate volume, other conservative measures

Vasovagal syncope Avoidance of triggers; medical therapy is somewhat controversial (-blockers, clonidine, paroxetine, midodrine)

Carotid sinus hypersensitivity

Avoid stimulating factors (tight collars or rapid neck movements); pacemaker

Postprandial hypotension

Avoid alcohol and high-carbohydrate meals; remain recumbent after meals

Page 57: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 57

RECURRENT SYNCOPE WITHOUT IDENTIFIABLE CAUSE

• Help patients avoid harm to themselves or others

• Consider recommending against driving for several months and resuming if patient remains recurrence-free (American Heart Association guidelines)

• Many states have laws against driving with a history of syncope

Page 58: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 58

Complications of A Fib

• Complications associated with permanent atrial fibrillation (AF)

• increased risk for stroke• systemic thromboembolism,• Death• mortality is a function of underlying structural

heart disease or other comorbidities (survival in patients with lone AF same as that in otherwise healthy age-matched controls)

Page 59: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 59

Evaluation

• history—control of hypertension important

• OSA

• look for reversible causes (eg, hyperthyroidism, pneumonia)

• medical history

• 12-lead electrocardiography (ECG) required

• echocardiography recommended

Page 60: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 60

Patterns of AF

• second episode of AF may occur years after first

• important when considering long-term or temporary antiarrhythmic drug therapy

• management of persistent AF

• may differ from that of paroxysmal AF

Page 61: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 61

Rhythm control vs rate control• AFFIRM trial found rhythm control not• superior to rate control for reducing mortality (survival curves similar• in Atrial Fibrillation Follow-up Investigation of• Rhythm Management (AFFIRM) trial, lower survival rates seen in patients

randomized to rhythm control• no difference in incidence of stroke over time between patients randomized

to rate control vs rhythm control• Canadian Cardiovascular Society guidelines—rate or rhythm control

acceptable• Management must be based on symptoms, patient’s preference, and risk

factors• (rhythm control might be favorable in high-risk groups)• factors that may favor rate control include persistent AF, frequent recurrent

AF, less symptomatology, older age, and hypertension• according to Atrial Fibrillation and Congestive Heart Failure (AF-CHF)

study, rhythm control appears more beneficial than rate control in HF

Page 62: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 62

Treatment of newly diagnosed AF

• paroxysmal AF— consider anticoagulation• treat if symptomatic, or if ventricular rate uncontrolled• persistent AF—restore sinus rhythm with electrical or

pharmacologic cardioversion• temporary use of antiarrhythmic drugs (consider

maintenance and long-term use)• permanent AF—anticoagulation and rate control drugs as

required• rhythm control—may need to consider cardioversion• reevaluate therapy over time (as AF evolves,

antiarrhythmic drugs may no longer maintain sinus rhythm)

Page 63: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 63

Infrequent episodes of paroxysmal AF

• “pill in the pocket” approach—give loading dose of propafenone (450 or 600 mg)

• then wait 30 min for conversion

• usually prescribed with rate control drugs

• shown highly effective

Page 64: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 64

Medications• Beta-blockers• calcium channel blockers; dose• based on symptoms• digoxin alone usually not effective in controlling heart

rate during AF, but may be synergistic with other drugs• flecainide, propafenone, sotalol, and amiodarone used in

patients with no underlying structural heart disease• dronedarone—amiodarone analogue with fewer

associated side effects (eg, no corneal deposits, lower frequency

• of hyper- or hypothyroidism, no pulmonary toxicity)• shown superior to placebo

Page 65: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 65

Stroke and systemic thromboembolism

• moderate-risk group—>75 yr of age with hypertension, some left ventricular dysfunction, HF, or diabetes

• high-risk group— history of stroke, transient ischemic attack (TIA), or valvular heart disease

• aspirin shown to slightly reduce risk for stroke in high-risk group, and warfarin significantly reduced risk for stroke (warfarin appears superior to aspirin in all risk groups

• but less beneficial because relative risk for stroke in low-risk group “very low”)

Page 66: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 66

CHADS2 score• 1 point assigned for history of CHF• hypertension• older age• Diabetes• 2 points assigned for history of stroke or TIA• paroxysmal AF, persistent AF, and atrial flutter assigned same number

of points• recommendations—• treat with aspirin (or no medication) with score of 0• Treat with aspirin or warfarin (based on patient’s preference) with

score of 1• treat with warfarin and maintain international normalized ratio (INR)

at 2 to 3 with score 2 or more• CHADS2 score and risk for stroke may vary

Page 67: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 67

Other risk factors for stroke

• Other risk factors• risk for stroke associated with paroxysmal

AF appears lower in recent clinical trials than in earlier studies

• patients who have episodes of AF lasting >24 hr have higher risk for thromboembolism than those with episodes lasting <24 hr

Page 68: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 68

Warfarin use in AFFIRM trial

• Warfarin use in AFFIRM trial• warfarin stopped in patients prescribed

antiarrhythmic drug therapy in mistaken belief patients would remain in sinus rhythm

• risk for ischemic stroke slightly higher in patients treated with rhythm control who discontinued warfarin

• maintain INR of 2 to 3• (>3 increases risk for significant hemorrhage)

Page 69: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 69

Risk for intracranial bleeding in elderly• predictors—

• inadequate education about use of oral anticoagulants• Polypharmacy• INR outside of therapeutic range• study did not see association between cognitive, visual, or

hearing impairment and increased risk of bleeding• careful use of anticoagulation can be successful• warfarin more effective than aspirin at preventing

thromboembolism in elderly patients with AF, but associated with increased risk of bleeding

• substantial risk in first year after initiation of anticoagulation (intense monitoring required)

• risk higher in patients with higher CHADS2 scores

Page 70: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 70

Cardioversion

• associated with increased risk for stroke• Anticoagulation recommended for 3 to 4

wk before initiating and for 1 mo after cardioversion

• if AF has persisted for >48 hr, perform transesophageal echocardiography to rule out clotting in atrium, then proceed with cardioversion

Page 71: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 71

ACTIVE studies• Atrial fibrillation Clopidogrel Trial with Irbesartan for

prevention of Vascular Events (ACTIVE) studies• ACTIVE W—warfarin superior to clopidogrel and aspirin in

preventing stroke (risk of bleeding similar)• patients naïve to warfarin at time of randomization and

treated with either clopidogrel and aspirin had increased risk of bleeding, compared to patients who were not naive to warfarin before randomization (suggests that patients with history of bleeding on warfarin had been weeded out of group)

• ACTIVE result a minor benefit in stroke reduction with aspirin and clopidogrel (compared to aspirin alone)

• but risk of bleeding same as with warfarin

Page 72: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 72

Principles

• Principles of antithrombotic therapy

• individualize therapy

• reassess risk factors over time

• risk stratify when deciding to use aspirin or warfarin

Page 73: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 73

RE-LY trial

• Randomized Evaluation of Long-term anticoagulation therapY (RE-LY) trial

• prevention of stroke or thromboembolism— low-dose dabigatran equivalent to warfarin

• high-dose dabigatran superior to warfarin• risk of bleeding—lower with low-dose

dabigatran than with warfarin• equivalent in high-dose dabigatran and warfarin

Page 74: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 74

Who to refer• most patients with AF• patients <35 yr of age with symptomatic AF

or atrial flutter should be evaluated for supraventricular or atrial tachycardia (can be cured with catheter ablation)

• patients who remain highly symptomatic despite trials of antiarrhythmic drug therapy

• patients intolerant of therapies

Page 75: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 75

Volume 360:668-678 February 12, 2009 Number 7 Effect of Dronedarone on Cardiovascular Events in Atrial

Fibrillation

Stefan H. Hohnloser, M.D., Harry J.G.M. Crijns, M.D., Martin van Eickels, M.D., Christophe Gaudin, M.D., Richard L. Page, M.D., Christian Torp-Pedersen, M.D., Stuart J. Connolly, M.D., for the

ATHENA Investigators• ABSTRACT• Background Dronedarone is a new antiarrhythmic drug that is being developed for the treatment of

patients with atrial fibrillation.• Methods We conducted a multicenter trial to evaluate the use of dronedarone in 4628 patients with atrial

fibrillation who had additional risk factors for death. Patients were randomly assigned to receive dronedarone, 400 mg twice a day, or placebo. The primary outcome was the first hospitalization due to cardiovascular events or death. Secondary outcomes were death from any cause, death from cardiovascular causes, and hospitalization due to cardiovascular events.

• Results The mean follow-up period was 21±5 months, with the study drug discontinued prematurely in 696 of the 2301 patients (30.2%) receiving dronedarone and in 716 of the 2327 patients (30.8%) receiving placebo, mostly because of adverse events. The primary outcome occurred in 734 patients (31.9%) in the dronedarone group and in 917 patients (39.4%) in the placebo group, with a hazard ratio for dronedarone of 0.76 (95% confidenceinterval [CI], 0.69 to 0.84; P<0.001). There were 116 deaths (5.0%) in the dronedarone group and 139 (6.0%) in the placebo group (hazard ratio, 0.84; 95% CI, 0.66 to 1.08; P=0.18). There were 63 deaths from cardiovascular causes (2.7%) in the dronedarone group and 90 (3.9%) in the placebo group (hazard ratio, 0.71; 95% CI, 0.51 to 0.98; P=0.03), largely due to a reduction in the rate of death from arrhythmia with dronedarone. The dronedaronegroup had higher rates of bradycardia, QT-interval prolongation, nausea, diarrhea, rash, and an increased serum creatinine level than the placebo group. Rates of thyroid- and pulmonary-related adverse events were not significantly different between thetwo groups.

• Conclusions Dronedarone reduced the incidence of hospitalization due to cardiovascular events or death in patients with atrial fibrillation. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00174785 [ClinicalTrials.gov] .)

Page 76: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 76

Safely switch from amiodarone to dronedarone in two days, suggests

analysisMARCH 15, 2010 | Steve Stiles• Atlanta, GA - Patients on amiodarone for maintenance of sinus rhythm after cardioversion of atrial fibrillation (AF)

who are looking to switch to dronedarone (Multaq, Sanofi-Aventis) in most cases can safely begin taking the newer antiarrhythmic agent within two days of stopping the older one, according to a post hoc analysis of two randomized trials [1].

• The rate of serious adverse events associated with initiating dronedarone in the combined population of >1200 patients was low and varied little by whether patients had stopped taking amiodarone <48 or >48 hours previously or hadn't been on amiodarone at all.

• The patients were part of the European Trial in Atrial Fibrillation or Flutter Patients Receiving Dronedarone for the Maintenance of Sinus Rhythm (EURIDIS) and American-Australian-African Trial with Dronedarone in Atrial Fibrillation or Flutter Patients for the Maintenance of Sinus Rhythm (ADONIS), which together saw dronedarone reduce the risk of AF recurrence by 25% (p=0.022) over one year compared with placebo [2].

•The most effective and most toxic drug for AF

• The finding that a switch can be made fairly safely and rapidly may help allay concerns over possibly severe increased risk if a patient starts dronedarone too soon after withdrawing from a drug with an unusually long half life and a notorious adverse-effect profile.

• "Amiodarone is the most effective drug we have for atrial fibrillation, and it's also the most toxic drug we have for atrial fibrillation," observed Dr Peter R Kowey (Main Line Health System, Wynnewood, PA) for heartwire. Its multiorgan toxicities are cumulative, he noted, so a transition to the demonstrably safer dronedarone might be wise for younger patients. "With amiodarone, the fear is that if you continue to use it over the long term, then eventually the toxicity will emerge."

• Others on amiodarone who might switch to the newer drug, he said, are those who aren't tolerating it and those who still have AF recurrences despite it.

• Kowey, who cautioned that the post hoc analysis is based on a fairly small population and can be only hypothesis-generating, was to present it here today at the American College of Cardiology 2010 Scientific Sessions/i2 Summit.

Page 77: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 77

Rapid transition preserves efficacy

•Of the 1237 patients with AF or atrial flutter in EURIDIS and ADONIS combined, who were randomized to dronedarone (400 mg twice daily) or placebo after cardioversion to sinus rhythm, 98 had started dronedarone within 48 hours of stopping amiodarone. Their rate of recurrence fell by 36% (p=0.022) compared with 56 placebo recipients with the same amiodarone history. But the two groups' rates of serious adverse events, including bradyarrhythmia, were similar, at 15.3% and 14.3%, respectively.

• For the 35 patients who started dronedarone longer than 48 hours after stopping amiodarone, the rate of serious adverse events was 17.1%, compared with 11.8% for their 17 corresponding placebo recipients.

• In the much-larger group with no history of receiving amiodarone, the rates were 13.7% for the 680 dronedarone patients and 16.2% for the 334 that had been assigned to placebo, Kowey reported.

• The rate of adverse events leading to drug discontinuation—especially bradyarrhythmia—was generally higher for dronedarone compared with placebo regardless of time since amiodarone withdrawal. It was 8.2% vs 3.6% for the group starting the new treatment within 48 hours and 20% vs 11.8% when the wait was longer than 48 hours.

• There were no instances of torsades de pointes, but QT-interval prolongation was more likely with dronedarone regardless of amiodarone status.

• Kowey says there may be some concern about adding dronedarone soon after amiodarone withdrawal in patients with a slow heart rate. In such cases, he said, "it's probably a good idea to wait a bit longer [than 48 hours]."

• And for patients with a long QT interval when taking amiodarone, "it's probably better to wait until the QT comes down."

• Otherwise, he said, "there doesn't seem to be any major liability" involved in starting dronedarone within 48 hours of stopping the older drug.

Page 78: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 78

Brits Not NICE to Dronedarone• Monday January 11, 2010• The British National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) has made a

preliminary determination NOT to cover the new antiarrhythmic drug dronedarone (Multaq, Sanofi-Aventis) for British patients with atrial fibrillation (AF). Instead, NICE implies, patients should continue receiving amiodarone (Cordarone, Pacerone), which is more effective and cheaper.

• Amiodarone is the most effective antiarrhythmic drug (drug that is supposed to stabilize the heart rhythm) available, but it unfortunately produces a bizarre array of side effects that are common, often dangerous or disabling, and difficult to treat. A suitable "replacement" for amiodarone has long been sought.

• Amiodarone: A Uniquely Toxic Drug• Amiodarone's Strange History• For a long time, it was hoped that dronedarone (a compound related to

amiodarone) would be that perfect replacement. It is not. While it appears to have much less toxicity than amiodarone, it is not as effective in treating AF.

Page 79: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 79

Dronedarone Drug Information• And indeed, this was the very logic used by NICE to deny approval for dronedarone -- it is not as

effective as amiodarone, and it is much more expensive. So it will not be made available for British patients.

• DrRich Comments:• The dronedarone/NICE story illustrates how panels of "clinical excellence" (like NICE, or like the

panels apparently being established in the United States under pending healthcare reforms), even when they strictly follow the results of randomized clinical trials, can make decisions that seem reasonable on the surface but ultimately are harmful to patients.

• Consider that while the effectiveness of dronedarone in treating AF (effective in approximately 30% to 40% of patients) is substantially less than for amiodarone (which is effective in approximately 50% to 60%), this still means that a substantial minority of patients could potentially be treated effectively with dronedarone. So, for instance, if patients with AF were given a trial of dronedarone, potentially up to 40% of them could be spared exposure to the extravagant toxicity of amiodarone.

• But because randomized trials tell us that, in a large population of patients, the averageresponse to dronedarone is significantly lower than the average response to amiodarone, no patients (in Britain, at least) will have the opportunity to try dronedarone.

• To my mind, this example succinctly illustrates a key problem with how our bureaucrats propose to use panels of experts. Such panels can be of immense help in providing guidance to clinicians. But when bureaucrats insist on converting such recommendations into strict, "up or down" coverage decisions, individual patients will lose their opportunity to receive the kind of individualized care most of us value -- care given by our chosen doctors, who judiciously apply expert-generated clinical guidelines, while still taking our individual circumstances into account.

Page 80: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 80

Dronedarone• Dronedarone is the latest antiarrhythmic drug to be developed for atrial fibrillation. In their search for a

safe and effective drug for atrial fibrillation, pharmaceutical companies have long imagined their "Holy Grail:" A drug that is as effective as amiodarone, but without its unique toxicity profile. Dronedarone (Multaq) was developed by Sanofi (the makers of amiodarone) specifically in the hopes of creating that holy grail.

• Dronedarone is indeed a derivative of amiodarone -- the most effective, but the most toxic, antiarrhythmic drug yet developed. Unlike amiodarone, dronedarone does not contain idodine atoms, and the iodine within amiodarone has been postulated to produce some of the drug's striking toxic effects, especially the thyroid toxicity seen with the drug, and perhaps the lung toxicity. Encouragingly, during the clinical trials with dronedarone, amiodarone-like toxicity so far has not been seen.

• Several clinical trials with dronedarone have been reported. Two of these trials (the EURIDIS and ADONIS trials) assessed the effectiveness of dronedarone for treating atrial fibrillation. In these trials, 64% of patients treated with dronedarone had recurrent atrial fibrillation during the first year after beginning treatment, as compared with 75% of patients treated with placebo. This improvement is statistically significant, but is by no means striking -- and indeed is little better than the reduction in atrial fibrillation seen with many other antiarrhythmic drugs.

• More recently, however, the ATHENA trial reported that patients treated with dronedarone for atrial fibrillation for 21 months had a signficantly reduced risk of death or cardiac hospitalization, compared to patients treated with placebo. This study is the first clinical study to suggest that treating patients who have atrial fibrillation with any antiarrhythmic drug can improve survival or reduce hospitalizations.

• While the results of the ATHENA trial have caused quite a stir, the mechanism for reduced mortality with dronedarone is unclear. Since dronedarone may not be remarkably effective in reducing recurrences of atrial fibrillation, perhaps the drug may have some other, undefined, benefit aside from actually preventing atrial fibrillation.

Page 81: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 81

Dronedarone• Keep in mind that in 2003, Sanofi had to prematurely halt a clinical trial using dronedarone in patients

with significant heart failure and atrial fibrillation, at the urging of the independent Data Safety and Monitorning Board, because those treated with dronedarone appeared to have an increased risk of death. Notably, patients enrolled in the ATHENA trial were significantly healthier than in that earlier, more alarming, study.

• Side effects with dronedarone so far appear to be relatively benign. The most common reported side effects are diarrhea or nausea, slow heart rate, and rash. The unique side effects seen with amiodarone (such as lung toxicity, thyroid disorders, visual disturbances, or neurological disorders) have not been seen with dronedarone. However, it should be noted that none of the clinical trials with dronedarone have lasted for more than two years -- and some of the unusual toxicities seen with amiodarone may not appear until the drug has been taken for for several years. So, while dronedarone at this point looks reasonably safe, its true safety profile will not be known until it has been in use for a substantial period of time.

• The FDA approved the use of dronedarone for the treatment of atrial fibrillation in the summer of 2009. The FDA specified that dronedarone should be limited to patients who (like those enrolled in the ATHENA trial) do not have significant heart failure.

• Sources:• Hohnloser SH, Crijns HJGM, van Eickels M, et al. Effect of dronedarone on cardiovascular events in

atrial fibrillation. N Engl J Med 2009; 360:668-678.• Singh BN, Connolly SJ, Crijns HJGM, et al. Dronedarone for maintenance of sinus rhythm in atrial

fibrillation or flutter. N Engl J Med 2007; 357:987-99.• Ezekowitz MD. Maintaining sinus rhythm—making treatment better than the disease. N Engl J Med

2007; 357:1039.

Page 82: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 82

Dabigatran• Atrial fibrillation increases the risks of stroke and death. Vitamin K antagonists,

such as warfarin, reduce the risks of stroke and death but increase the risk of hemorrhage as compared with control therapy.1 Therefore, warfarin is recommended for patients who have atrial fibrillation and are at risk for stroke.2Vitamin K antagonists are cumbersome to use, because of their multiple interactions with food and drugs, and they require frequent laboratory monitoring. Therefore, they are often not used, and when they are, rates of discontinuation are high.3,4 Many patients receiving warfarin still have inadequate anticoagulation.5Thus, there is a need for new anticoagulant agents that are effective, safe, and convenient to use.

• Dabigatran etexilate is an oral prodrug that is rapidly converted by a serum esterase to dabigatran, a potent, direct, competitive inhibitor of thrombin. It has an absolute bioavailability of 6.5%, 80% of the given dose is excreted by the kidneys, its serum half-life is 12 to 17 hours, and it does not require regular monitoring.6Dabigatran has been evaluated in a pilot trial involving patients with atrial fibrillation and in a study for the prevention of venous thromboembolism, in which doses of 150 mg twice daily and 220 mg once daily, respectively, were promising.7,8 We performed a large, randomized trial comparing the use of dabigatran, at doses of 110 mg twice daily and 150 mg twice daily, with warfarin.

Page 83: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 83

Volume 361:1139-1151 September 17, 2009 Number 12Dabigatran versus Warfarin in Patients with Atrial Fibrillation

Stuart J. Connolly, M.D., Michael D. Ezekowitz, M.B., Ch.B., D.Phil., Salim Yusuf, F.R.C.P.C., D.Phil., John Eikelboom, M.D., Jonas Oldgren, M.D., Ph.D., Amit Parekh, M.D.,

Janice Pogue, M.Sc., Paul A. Reilly, Ph.D., Ellison Themeles, B.A., Jeanne Varrone, M.D., Susan Wang, Ph.D., Marco Alings, M.D., Ph.D., Denis Xavier, M.D., Jun Zhu, M.D., Rafael

Diaz, M.D., Basil S. Lewis, M.D., Harald Darius, M.D., Hans-Christoph Diener, M.D., Ph.D., Campbell D. Joyner, M.D., Lars Wallentin, M.D., Ph.D., and the RE-LY Steering

Committee and Investigators

• ABSTRACT• Background Warfarin reduces the risk of stroke in patients with atrial fibrillation but increases the

risk of hemorrhage and is difficult to use. Dabigatran is a new oral direct thrombin inhibitor.• Methods In this noninferiority trial, we randomly assigned 18,113 patients who had atrial fibrillation

and a risk of stroke to receive, in a blinded fashion, fixed doses of dabigatran — 110 mg or 150 mg twice daily — or, in an unblinded fashion, adjusted-dose warfarin. The median duration of the follow-up period was 2.0 years. The primary outcome was stroke or systemic embolism.

• Results Rates of the primary outcome were 1.69% per year in the warfarin group, as compared with 1.53% per year in the group that received 110 mg of dabigatran (relative risk with dabigatran, 0.91; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.74 to 1.11; P<0.001 for noninferiority) and 1.11% per year in the group that received 150 mg of dabigatran (relative risk, 0.66; 95% CI, 0.53 to 0.82; P<0.001 for superiority). The rate of major bleeding was 3.36% per year in the warfarin group, as compared with 2.71% per year in the group receiving 110 mg of dabigatran (P=0.003)and 3.11% per year in the group receiving 150 mg of dabigatran (P=0.31). The rate of hemorrhagic stroke was 0.38% per year in the warfarin group, as compared with 0.12% per year with 110 mg of dabigatran (P<0.001) and 0.10% per year with 150 mg of dabigatran (P<0.001). The mortality rate was 4.13% per year in the warfarin group, as compared with 3.75% per year with 110 mg of dabigatran (P=0.13) and 3.64% per year with 150 mg of dabigatran (P=0.051).

• Conclusions In patients with atrial fibrillation, dabigatran given at a dose of 110 mg was associated with rates of stroke and systemic embolism that were similar to those associated with warfarin, as well as lower rates of major hemorrhage. Dabigatran administered at a dose of 150 mg, as compared with warfarin, was associated with lower rates of stroke and systemic embolism but similar rates of major hemorrhage. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00262600 [ClinicalTrials.gov] .)

Page 84: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 84

Dabigatran• We compared two fixed-dose regimens of dabigatran (110 mg twice daily and 150 mg twice daily), administered in a blinded fashion, with adjusted-dose warfarin,

administered in an unblinded fashion, in patients who had atrial fibrillation and were at risk for stroke. Both dabigatran doses were noninferior to warfarin withrespect to the primary efficacy outcome of stroke or systemic embolism. In addition, the 150-mg dose of dabigatran was superior to warfarin with respect to stroke or systemic embolism, and the 110-mg dose was superior to warfarin with respect to major bleeding.

• Previous studies seeking to identify a safe and effective alternative to warfarin for patients with atrial fibrillation have all had specific limitations. The combination of clopidogrel and aspirin was more effective than aspirin alone13 but less effective than warfarin.14 Subcutaneous idraparinux was more effective than warfarin but was associated with a substantially higher risk of bleeding.15 Ximelagatran, an earlier direct thrombin inhibitor, appeared to be similar to warfarin with respect to efficacy and safety but was found to be hepatotoxic.16 In our serial measurement of liver function, we did not find evidence of hepatotoxicity with dabigatran.

• The rate of myocardial infarction was higher with both doses of dabigatran than with warfarin. An explanation might be that warfarin provides better protection against coronary ischemic events than dabigatran, and warfarin is known to reduce the risk of myocardial infarction.17 However, rates of myocardial infarction were similar between patients with atrial fibrillation who were receiving warfarin and those who were receiving ximelagatran, another direct thrombin inhibitor.16The explanation for this finding is therefore uncertain.

• The most devastating complication of warfarin therapy is intracranial hemorrhage, especially hemorrhagic stroke. As compared with aspirin, warfarin doubles the risk of intracranial hemorrhage.1 Thus, our finding that the rate of this complication with both doses of dabigatran was less than one third the rate with warfarin,without a reduction in the efficacy against ischemic stroke, suggests an important advantage of dabigatran. The rate of major bleeding with warfarin was higher in our study than in some previous trials.11,13,14 This is partly explained by the more inclusive definition of major bleeding in our study. There was an increase in the rate of gastrointestinal bleeding with the higher dabigatran dose, despite the overall lower rates of bleeding at other sites. To enhance absorption of dabigatran, a low pH is required. Therefore, dabigatran capsules contain dabigatran-coated pellets with a tartaric acid core. This acidity may partly explain the increased incidence of dyspeptic symptoms with both dabigatran doses and the increased risk of gastrointestinal bleeding with the 150-mg dose.

• The benefit of dabigatran may be explained in part by the twice-daily dosing regimen. Since dabigatran has an elimination half-life of 12 to 17 hours, twice-daily dosing reduces variability in the anticoagulation effect, especially as compared with the anticoagulation effect of warfarin, which is difficult to control. Warfarin broadly inhibits coagulation (inhibiting factors II, VII, IX, and X and proteins C and S). By selectively inhibiting only thrombin, dabigatran may have antithrombotic efficacy while preserving some other hemostatic mechanisms in the coagulation system and thus potentially mitigating the risk of bleeding.

• The use of open-label warfarin could have introduced a bias in the reporting or adjudication of events. This risk was reduced by the implementation of several validated procedures, including blinded evaluation of outcome events. The unexpectedly different rates of myocardial infarction and gastrointestinal bleeding among the three treatment groups support an absence of bias. Control of anticoagulation with warfarin in our study was similar to that in previous international clinical trials, even though half our patients had not previously had extensive treatment with warfarin.10,17

• The net clinical benefit outcome, which is a measure of the overall benefit and risk, was similar between the two doses of dabigatran, owing to the lower risk of ischemia with the 150-mg dose and the lower risk of hemorrhage with the 110-mg dose. These findings suggest that the dose of dabigatran could potentially be tailored to take into consideration the risk characteristics of a specific patient, although this concept was not specifically tested in our trial.

• In conclusion, we compared two doses of dabigatran with warfarin in patients who had atrial fibrillation and who were at risk for stroke. As compared with warfarin, the 110-mg dose of dabigatran was associated with similar rates of stroke and systemic embolism and lower rates of major hemorrhage; the 150-mg dose of dabigatran was associated with lower rates of stroke and systemic embolism but with a similar rate of major hemorrhage.

Page 85: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 85

SUMMARY (1 of 2)

• Precise classification of dizziness into vertigo, presyncope, disequilibrium, and lightheadedness is often difficult, and multiple causes of the same symptoms are common

• Most dizziness resolves within days to several months

• Key physical exam steps include checking for orthostatic hypotension, performing the head-hanging (Dix-Hallpike) test, and observing gait

Page 86: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 86

SUMMARY (2 of 2)

• In older adults the cause of syncope is often multifactorial

• Most diagnostic procedures for syncope are expensive and have a low yield unless findings from the H & P suggest a particular cause

• The absence of cardiac disease strongly suggests that the cause of syncope is not cardiac

• Treatment of dizziness and syncope focuses on treating the underlying disorder

Page 87: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 87

CASE 1 (1 of 3)

• For the past several weeks, a 69-year-old man has had recurrent spells of room-spinning vertigo that last for about 4 minutes.

• The spells occur spontaneously and are unassociated with positional changes. They are accompanied occasionally by double vision and sometimes by weakness on the right side.

• Several times, the patient has had sudden drop attacks, followed by mild weakness of both legs lasting several minutes.

• The patient has a history of diabetes mellitus and CAD.

Page 88: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 88

CASE 1 (2 of 3)

Which of the following is the most likely cause of the vertigo?

(A) Vestibular neuronitis

(B) Vertebrobasilar insufficiency

(C) Labyrinthitis

(D) Migraine-associated vertigo

(E) Ménière’s disease

Page 89: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 89

CASE 1 (3 of 3)

Which of the following is the most likely cause of the vertigo?

(A) Vestibular neuronitis

(B) Vertebrobasilar insufficiency

(C) Labyrinthitis

(D) Migraine-associated vertigo

(E) Ménière’s disease

Page 90: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 90

CASE 2 (1 of 3)

• A 75-year-old woman reports repeated episodes of profound dizziness and near loss of consciousness, along with at least two episodes in which she found herself on the floor but was unaware of how she fell. She denies any confusion after the episode or any significant trauma.

• The patient takes amlodipine 5 mg/day for hypertension.

• BP is 152/84 and pulse is 76 when the patient is supine. In the upright posture, BP is 146/86 and pulse is 86. There is no jugular venous distension or carotid bruit. Lungs are clear. There is a slightly delayed carotid upstroke and a II/VI systolic murmur at the base with an intact S2 but no gallop.

Page 91: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 91

CASE 2 (2 of 3)

Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in the evaluation of this patient to stratify her risk of adverse outcomes?

(A) Blood tests

(B) Electrocardiography

(C) Holter monitoring

(D) Event monitor

(E) Tilt-table test

Page 92: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 92

CASE 2 (3 of 3)

Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in the evaluation of this patient to stratify her risk of adverse outcomes?

(A) Blood tests

(B) Electrocardiography

(C) Holter monitoring

(D) Event monitor

(E) Tilt-table test

Page 93: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 93

CASE 3 (1 of 2)

Of the following features that may be available from a patient history, which best distinguishes syncope from an unexplained fall?

(A) Tonic-clonic movements

(B) Urinary incontinence

(C) Postictal state

(D) Loss of consciousness

(E) Loss of postural tone

Page 94: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 94

CASE 3 (2 of 2)

Of the following features that may be available from a patient history, which best distinguishes syncope from an unexplained fall?

(A) Tonic-clonic movements

(B) Urinary incontinence

(C) Postictal state

(D) Loss of consciousness

(E) Loss of postural tone

Page 95: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 95

Vertigo

• (A) Illusion of movement where none exists• (B) Often occurs after upper respiratory infection;• patients present with nystagmus• (C) Characterized as dizziness without hearing

loss;• treated with topiramate• (D) Seen in ototoxicity and in patients on

chemotherapy;• patients complain of blurred vision

Page 96: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 96

Answer

• (A) Illusion of movement where none exists

Page 97: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 97

Oscillopsia

• (A) Illusion of movement where none exists• (B) Often occurs after upper respiratory infection;• patients present with nystagmus• (C) Characterized as dizziness without hearing

loss;• treated with topiramate• (D) Seen in ototoxicity and in patients on

chemotherapy;• patients complain of blurred vision

Page 98: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 98

Answer

• (D) Seen in ototoxicity and in patients on chemotherapy; patients complain of blurred vision

Page 99: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 99

Vestibular neuritis

• (A) Illusion of movement where none exists• (B) Often occurs after upper respiratory infection;• patients present with nystagmus• (C) Characterized as dizziness without hearing

loss;• treated with topiramate• (D) Seen in ototoxicity and in patients on

chemotherapy;• patients complain of blurred vision

Page 100: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 100

Answer

• (B) Often occurs after upper respiratory infection; patients present with nystagmus

Page 101: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 101

Choose the correct statement about benign paroxysmal positional vertigo

(BPPV).(A) Rotary nystagmus occurs

immediately after movement (eg, to lying down position)

(B) Uncomplicated BPPV improves within days to weeks

(C) Epley maneuver recommended for elderly patients

(D) Most commonly caused by alcohol and drug use

Page 102: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 102

Answer

• (B) Uncomplicated BPPV improves within days to weeks

Page 103: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 103

Which of the following medications is recommended for severe endolymphatic hydrops?

(A) Dimenhydrinate (B) Prednisone

(C) Sublingual lorazepam (D) Nortriptyline

Page 104: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 104

Answer

• (C) Sublingual lorazepam

Page 105: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 105

If a patient is found to have short-term memory loss, headaches, and loss of sense of smell after head

trauma, themost likely cause is:

(A) A central concussion (B) A cervical injury

(C) A perilymph fistula (D) Whiplash

Page 106: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 106

Answer

• (A) A central concussion

Page 107: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 107

In the Atrial Fibrillation Follow-up Investigation of Rhythm

Management (AFFIRM) trial, patients randomized to

rate control therapy had a significantly higher incidence of stroke than those who received

rhythm control therapy.(A) True (B)False

Page 108: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 108

Answer

• (B)False

Page 109: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 109

When considering therapy for patients with atrial fibrillation (AF), which of the following factors might

favor ratecontrol over rhythm control therapy?

(A) Persistent AF (B) Older age

(C) Hypertension (D) All the above

Page 110: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 110

Answer

• (D) All the above

Page 111: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 111

Which of the following therapies is recommended for a patient with AF

and CHADS2 score of 0?(A) Warfarin with maintenance of

international normalized ratio at 2 to 3

(B) Aspirin or warfarin(C) Aspirin or no medication(D) Aspirin and clopidogrel

Page 112: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 112

Answer

• (C) Aspirin or no medication

Page 113: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 113

In elderly patients, warfarin appears to be more effective than aspirin at

preventing thromboembolism, but isassociated with increased risk of

bleeding.(A) True (B) False

Page 114: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 114

Answer

• (A) True

Page 115: DIZZINESS, SYNCOPE AND ATRIAL FIBRILATION IN THE OLDER ADULT

Slide 115

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

Co-Editors: Karen Blackstone, MD

Elizabeth L. Cobbs, MD

GRS6 Chapter Authors: David Bush, MD

Kurt Kroenke, MD

GRS6 Question Writers: Gail Ishiyama, MD Mathew Maurer, MD

Medical Writer: Barbara B. Reitt, PhD, ELS(D)

Reviewer: Colleen Christmas, MD

Managing Editor: Andrea N. Sherman, MS

© American Geriatrics Society