Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    1/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 1

    THE CRITICALITY OF HIGH-SPEED SEPARABLE ALIGNMENTby:

    Randy R. Raymer (El Paso Corporation)

    Robert Goodenough (El Paso Corporation)

    Ralph E. Harris, Ph.D. (Southwest Research Institute

    )Anthony J. Smalley, Ph.D. (Southwest Research Institute)

    This paper will cover four distinct areas:

    1. The evaluation of alignment on crankshaft-induced stress.

    2. A discussion on why the high speeds are very different from the slow-speed

    units.

    3. The equations and evaluation processes required to properly achieving

    satisfactory alignment.

    4. A recommended procedure that can be used as an installation specification.

    This discussion will show a case history of an actual installation and the reduced

    crankshaft stress levels achieved through proper alignment techniques. The paper will

    discuss the Finite Element Crankshaft model and show how distortion, stress, and bearing

    reaction loads were evaluated. In addition, the paper will provide readers with a

    specification adaptable to individual company usage, which will assure proper alignment

    at the time of installation.

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    2/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 2

    1.0 Introduction

    El Paso Corporations recent horsepower replacement project compressors

    have now been running for approximately 2 years. This effort involved

    installation of ten 8000 HP high speed Ariel units with both electric drive and

    engine drive configurations. The fixed speed electric drive units incorporate

    Hydrocom capacity control, the engine drive units utilize Wartsila engines with a

    speed range of 575 to 750 rpm (figure 1). On the engine drive units, cylinder end

    de-activation and conventional pockets are used in combination with speed

    reduction to achieve turn down ratios of more than 50%. Installation of these

    units involved several industry firsts with respect to throughput, drivers, speed

    and capacity control. As described in (1), several vibration issues arose, and

    have been managed to varying degrees. Many of these issues were associated

    with fundamental design decisions, both acoustic and mechanical. Following

    8000 hours of operation, alignment checks on all units were made. These

    alignment reviews were made in a continuing effort to resolve elevated vibration

    levels as well as unusual main bearing wear patterns. Significant misalignment

    was found on several of the units, however, interpretation of the data with respect

    to the role of alignment on vibration and unit integrity has been difficult to make.

    This paper presents an overview of ongoing efforts to interpret the alignment

    measurements, pre and post re-alignment vibration data, as well as a procedure

    developed to ensure proper initial or re-alignment of machines of this class. In

    addition, preliminary results of testing to acquire crankshaft dynamic strain will

    be presented. The dynamic strain values are to be used in combination with finite

    element models of the crankshaft and alignment data to establish meaningful

    alignment criteria for the family of compressors.

    2.0 Alignment Results and Analysis

    Frame based measurements of relative height along both sides of the units

    were obtained. Measurements on both the compressor, and driver (engine/motor)

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    3/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 3

    were acquired on all 10 installations. Of key interest is the bearing centerline

    distortion. In order to establish bearing displacement data from frame

    measurements, El Paso utilizes an Excel based alignment analysis package

    (Alignment Master). This software incorporates the geometry of the machine,

    and the location of the measurement points to establish absolute estimates of the

    bearing centerline position, as well as the position of the bearing centerline

    relative to a mean plane passing through 1 of the bearing locations. This mean

    plane has the same average slope (parallel to crankshaft) and list (perpendicular to

    crankshaft) as the compressor/driver. Figures 2 and 3 present the data from two

    of the units tested. The compressor frames are relatively square in cross section,

    and the distances from the frame edge to the bearing centerline is short in

    comparison to much of the installed fleet of integral slow speed units. For this

    reason, minor variations in frame misalignment translate into significant bearing

    centerline distortion.

    In order to help interpret the data, simplified finite element models of the

    crankshaft were developed (see figure 4). These models use the geometry of the

    crankshaft, and simplified spring representations for the bearing. Linear bearing

    stiffness values of 10^7 lbs/inch are used at the main centerlines. Clearly more

    complicated solid models of the crankshaft can be generated, however, for the

    relative ranking of stress severity across the fleet of units it was felt that this

    model would be sufficient. Bearing horizontal and vertical distortions (relative to

    mean slope and list) were applied to the base of the bearing springs. Modeled in

    this fashion, the static stresses throughout the crankshaft are estimated from

    applied bearing misalignment. Since the orientation the crankshaft producing the

    worst case stress cannot be pre-determined, the crankshafts are modeled and re-

    run at 45-degree increments. Von Misses stress levels are used to compare the

    relative severity of the misalignment for the ten units. The calculation of static

    stresses represents an estimate for the running speed stress levels as the crank

    rotates neglecting dynamic amplification effects. This is a reasonable assumption

    if the bending modes of the crankshaft are sufficiently far removed from the

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    4/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 4

    operating speeds. Figure 5 presents the first bending mode of the crankshaft

    calculated for the model. The resonant frequency is estimated to be 330 Hz.

    Figure 6 presents the predicted crankshaft displacement for the bearing

    distortion condition of figure 2. The corresponding stress levels associated with

    misalignment throughout the crankshaft are seen in figure 7. Note the significant

    slope change through the main bearing regions in the highly distorted regions.

    This would suggest that distributing the bearing springs along the length of the

    main bearings would be an improvement to the model. Figure 8 and 9 present

    the corresponding results for the bearing centerline distortions of figure 3.

    Clearly the relative displacement of adjacent main bearing is more important to

    raising stress levels in the crankshaft than peak to peak differences along the

    entire set of bearing.

    Table 1 presents a summary of results for the ten units. Note that bearing

    reaction loads computed from the resulting bearing centerline distortions are low

    in comparison to applied gas forces based on rod load limits of 80,000 lbf.

    Unusual bearing wear patterns have been observed in the main bearing of some of

    the units, and this appears to correlate with the predicted change in displacement

    across the main bearings using the FE model.

    Based on the bearing centerline distortion data and the FE analysis, unit 2

    at station 96 and unit 2 at station 47 were selected for re-alignment. A detailed

    procedure developed by El Paso for the alignment of separable high-speed units is

    provided as an attachment to this paper. Just prior to the re-alignment effort

    vibration data was acquired on both units at full load operating conditions. Test

    points included cylinder vibration in the stretch, vertical and horizontal directions,

    frame vibration, and relative displacement between then frame and skid measured

    using proximity probes. Figure 10 presents representative cylinder vibration

    spectrum in the stretch and vertical directions. Note the relatively small

    contribution at 1st

    order to the overall frequency content out to 200 Hz. Figure 11

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    5/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 5

    presents the cylinder stretch and frame stretch response. Again note the low 1st

    and 2nd order components. Figures 12 through 15 present the final alignment

    conditions and stress predictions following re-alignment. Significant reductions

    in both bearing centerline distortion, and predicted peak stress levels were

    achieved. Vibration data was re-acquired on both units in the newly aligned

    conditions. Every attempt was made to ensure similar test conditions with respect

    to speed, torque and load step. Table 3 presents a summary of results. Vibration

    and displacements before and after alignment were analyzed in the frequency

    bands 0-65 Hz and 0-200 Hz. No consistent trend in the results can be found in

    the results at station 96. Similar results were obtained at station 47.

    3.0 Discussion

    The results of the above described efforts raises serious questions

    regarding; the need for alignment, the impact of alignment on vibration levels, as

    well as alignment criteria on units of this type. The test data clearly establishes

    that misalignment can not easily be detected from external vibration

    measurements. Historically on low speed integral compressors, vibration levels

    measured on the frame or foundation would reflect large changes in alignment.

    For the unit discussed in this paper, the small contribution of the low orders (1st

    and 2nd

    ) to the overall vibration levels are likely contributing to this result.

    These units have shown themselves to be difficult to align, and appear to

    shift alignment quickly despite best efforts to improve frame and skid bolt down

    conditions. Establishment of reliable alignment criteria, (and perhaps less

    stringent criteria) for these particular units would be desirable under these

    conditions. The approach utilized here, specifically the use of FE models in

    conjunction with alignment data is a possible path forward. However, as noted

    earlier, more refined models of the crankshaft would be required. In an effort to

    move in this direction, testing has been completed on an electric drive unit at

    station 54 to acquire data to assist in the calibration of the stress models. Using

    SwRIs Strain Data Capture (SDCM) technology, strain levels in the fillets of the

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    6/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 6

    main bearings have been acquired. The SDCMs are microprocessor-based

    instruments, which power, condition and sample the strain data. The instruments

    are programmed to acquire data at selectable intervals and store the data in non-

    volatile memory. At the completion of the test, the units are removed and the data

    is downloaded to a PC for analysis. Typically, data is acquired at intervals on the

    order of 1 to 5 minutes. These devices have been used on a variety of compressor

    types including a very large hyper unit used in LDPE production.

    For the tests completed at station 54, data was acquired at 5-minute

    intervals for 24 hours. The compressor had previously been shut down for a 3-

    week period. Six SDCMs were installed along the crankshaft of the machine.

    Five strain gages were located in the fillet of the crankshaft adjacent to the main

    bearing. Three were installed on the compressor pin side of the main bearings

    (Figure 16), two were installed opposite the compressor pin side. Due to the thrust

    bearing at the drive end of the shaft, the final gage was installed on the inside of

    the web (Figure 17). The state of alignment on this unit was recently determined

    and both crankshaft distortion and predicted stress levels were similar to worst

    case conditions presented earlier in this paper for the other units. Figure 18

    presents station-recorded unit HP and Hydrocom setting for test effort. Figure 19

    presents the overall cylinder and frame stretch vibration levels (5-200 Hz). Note

    that the unit shut down 3 times during the test due to suction gas temperature

    sensor problems. The strain levels recorded on the compressor pin side units are

    presented in figure 20. There are several key points to note. The low HP strain

    levels represent the majority of the full load levels. The low load levels consist of

    inertia driven and alignment driven crankshaft loads. The gages were located at

    the same depth in the fillet on the crankshaft, thereby minimizing location

    differences between the strain data. The low load (immediately following startup)

    levels are within 43 micro strain of each other. This is approximately a 1300-psi

    difference in stress between the locations. The FE calculations for the crankshaft

    predict peak stresses at the E gage location to be 4400 psi. At the A gage

    location, peak stresses are predicted to be 400 psi. This is a difference of 4000 psi

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    7/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 7

    or approximately 130 ustrain, just over 3 times less than measured. However,

    since gas and inertia loads are not include in the model, we cannot conclude that

    the crankshaft is less sensitive to misalignment than the geometry of machine

    would indicate. Clearly a reduction in effective bearing stiffness in the model

    would reduce both the predicted stress levels in the crankshaft and the relative

    differences across main bearings. Much more analysis of the SDCM data is

    required, including spectral analysis of the strain data as Hydrocom values are

    changed.

    4.0 Summary

    This paper outlines the effort to address the serious and challenging goal

    of developing alignment criteria for the HP replacement compressors. The

    measured crankshaft strain data indicates that the majority of the crankshaft stress

    is due to inertia terms, with only minor increases associated with unit loading.

    Peak stress levels do not appear to be sensitive to the state of misalignment. Use

    of FE models in combination with crankshaft distortion data appears to provide a

    systematic manner to access the significance of the alignment data. Continued

    refinement of the analysis models should produce a reliable screening tool for the

    compressors in question.

    [1] Acoustic and mechanical dynamics issues for high horsepower, high-speed

    compressors in gas transmission service. Presented 2002 GMRC Gas Machinery

    Conference.

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    8/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 8

    Figure 1: HP replacement units

    v 8,000 HP Siemens Motor DrivenUnit (720 RPM Fixed Speed

    capacity controlHydroComs,unloaders >50%turndown)

    v 8,000 HP Wartsila Engine DrivenUnit (575 to 750 RPM capacitycontrol pockets, variablespeed,>50% turndown)

    Figure 2: Station 96 U2 Alignment Summary

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    9/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 9

    Figure 3: Station 63-U1 Alignment Summary

    Figure 4: Basic Crankshaft FE Model

    Vertical Bearing Stiffness (1e7 lbf/inch)

    Horizontal Bearing Stiffness (1e7 lbf/inch)

    Crankshaft Distortion data

    Applied to base of bearing springs

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    10/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 10

    Figure 5: Frequency Analysis(1stbending mode)

    Figure 6: Station 96-U2 Crankshaft Displacement

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    11/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 11

    Figure 7: Station 96-U2 Crankshaft Stress

    Figure 8: Station 63-U1 Crankshaft Displacement

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    12/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 12

    Figure 9: Station 63-U1 Crankshaft Stress

    Table 1: Summary of Response Predictions

    96 U1 96 U2 87 U2 87 U1 47 U2 47 U1 54 U1 54 U2 63 U1 63 U2

    maximum crankshaft distortion (mils) 9.6 11.9 4 6 5.3 6.9 1.8 7.4 9.2 14

    maximum crankshaft stress (0-pk) 2709 6461 1110 3275 5329 2495 1018 3655 2181 3107

    maximum reaction lo ad (lbs) 6178 15006 3626 6422 17859 4581 3141 7234 4044 3230

    Maximum Mils across bearin g 1 1.4 0.9 1.3 1 1 1.5

  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    13/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 13

    Figure 10: Typical Cylinder Response Spectra

    Cylinder

    Stretch

    Cylinder

    Vertical

    Figure 11: Typical Cylinder/Frame Response Spectra

    Cylinder

    Stretch

    Frame

    stretch

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    14/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 14

    Figure 12:Station 96 2D Re-Alignment

    Summary

    Figure 13: Station 96-2D Crankshaft Stress

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    15/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 15

    Figure 14: Station 47 U2 Re-Alignment

    Summary

    Figure 15: Station 47-U2 Crankshaft Stress

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    16/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 16

    Table 2: Comparison of distortion and stress

    levels following alignment

    96 - D2 47 - U2 96 - D2 47 - U2

    maximum crankshaft distortion (mils) 11.9 5.3 1.5 1.08

    maximum crankshaft stress (0-pk) 6461 5329 726 1037

    maximum reaction load (lbs) 15006 17859 2180 3187

    Maximum Mils across bearing 1.4 1 0.9 0.7

    Alignment AlignmentBefore After

    Table 3: Comparison of vibration results following

    Re-alignment (station 96)

    location Ratio (before/after (5-65 Hz)) Ratio (before/after (5-200 Hz))c1 stretch 1.03 0.87

    c2 stretch 1.08 0.87

    c3 stretch 1.11 1.19

    c4 stretch 1.14 1.03

    c5 stretch 0.80 0.68

    c6 stretch 0.95 0.76

    locationc1 horizontal 0.92 1.08

    c2 horizontal 0.86 1.15

    c3 horizontal 0.88 1.07

    c4 horizontal 0.80 0.81

    c5 horizontal 0.90 1.54

    c6 horizontal 0.83 1.39

    locationc1 vertical 0.57 0.96

    c2 vertical 1.43 1.22

    c3 vertical 0.80 0.51

    c4 vertical 0.60 1.02

    c5 vertical 0.58 1.00

    c6 vertical 0.61 0.77

    location

    c1 SB stretch 0.75 0.73c3 SB stretch 1.00 1.08

    c5 SB stretch 0.79 0.76

    c2 SB stretch 1.08 0.88

    c4 SB stretch 1.00 0.81

    c6 SB stretch 1.12 1.22

    locationc1 frame stretch 0.92 0.95

    c3 frame stretch 1.42 1.52

    c5 frame stretch 0.84 0.66

    c2 frame stretch 1.00 1.00

    c4 frame stretch 1.31 1.07

    c6 frame stretch 0.80 0.97

    location Ratio (before/after (5-65 Hz)) Ratio (before/after (5-200 Hz))c1 DB stretch 1.68 1.31

    c3 DB stretch 0.84 1.03

    c5 DB stretch 0.53 0.60

    c2 DB stretch 0.47 0.96

    c4 DB stretch 0.42 1.17

    c6 DB stretch 0.50 0.78

    locationskid C1 stretch 1.00 0.58

    skid C1/C3 stretch 1.20 0.83

    skid C3/C5 stretch 0.60 0.59

    skid C5 stretch 1.00 1.33

    skid C2 stretch 1.00 0.94

    skid C2/C4 stretch 1.40 0.92

    skid C4 stretch 0.86 1.00

    skid C4/C6 stretch 0.80 0.74

    locationframe C1 vertical 1.64 0.85

    frame C2 vertical 1.21 0.93

    frame C3 vertical 1.20 1.15

    frame C4 vertical 1.50 1.13frame C5 vertical 1.55 0.95

    frame C6 vertical 1.23 0.85

    locationodd chock 1 0.58 0.10

    odd chock 2 0.58 0.16

    odd chock 3 0.25 0.04

    odd chock 4 0.18 0.19

    even chock 1 1.00 0.55

    even chock 2 1.60 1.25

    even chock 3 0.17 0.10

    even chock 4 0.43 0.70

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    17/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 17

    Figure 16: SDCM unit installed on crankshaft

    (main bearing fillet)

    Strain gage on main fillet

    SDCM mounted

    on web flatCompressor Rod

    Figure 17: SDCM unit installed on WEB

    Strain gage on

    web

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    18/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 18

    Figure 18: Unit HP and Hydrocom Setting

    Unit HP and Hydrocom Setting

    0

    1000

    2000

    3000

    4000

    5000

    6000

    7000

    8000

    9000

    10000

    9:00:0

    0

    10:15:0

    0

    11:30:0

    0

    12:45:0

    0

    14:00:0

    0

    15:15:0

    0

    16:30:0

    0

    17:45:0

    0

    19:00:0

    0

    20:15:0

    0

    21:30:0

    0

    22:45:0

    0

    0:00:0

    0

    1:15:0

    0

    2:30:0

    0

    3:45:0

    0

    5:00:0

    0

    6:15:0

    0

    7:30:0

    0

    8:45:0

    0

    10:00:0

    0

    11:15:0

    0

    12:30:0

    0

    time

    HP

    -20

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    %H

    ydrocomS

    etting

    D01M-REAL-PWR

    D01M-HYDROCOM-HE

    Figure 19 Cylinder and Frame Stretch Vibration

    Frame and Cylinder Stretch (overall ips 5-200 Hz)

    0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1

    1.2

    1.4

    1.6

    1.8

    2

    085736

    .DAQ

    101946

    .DAQ

    1031

    46.DAQ

    104354

    .DAQ

    105554

    .DAQ

    110754

    .DAQ

    111955

    .DAQ

    1131

    55.DAQ

    114355

    .DAQ

    115556

    .DAQ

    123533

    .DAQ

    133533

    .DAQ

    1433

    11.DAQ

    1533

    11.DAQ

    1633

    11.DAQ

    1733

    12.DAQ

    1833

    12.DAQ

    1933

    12.DAQ

    2033

    12.DAQ

    2133

    13.DAQ

    2233

    13.DAQ

    233336

    .DAQ

    0033

    14.DAQ

    0133

    14.DAQ

    0233

    14.DAQ

    0333

    14.DAQ

    0433

    15.DAQ

    0533

    15.DAQ

    0633

    15.DAQ

    0733

    15.DAQ

    083209

    .DAQ

    0924

    17.DAQ

    1024

    17.DAQ

    1124

    17.DAQ

    time

    ipspk

    cylinder stretch (overall ips 5-200 Hz)

    cylinder stretch (overall ips 5-200 Hz)

    20% torque(100% Hydrocom)

    97.4% torque (100% Hydrocom)104% torque(100% Hydrocom)

    Vary Hydrocom

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    19/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 19

    Figure 20 Main Bearing Strain Response

    Pin Side Main Bearing Strain Response

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    300

    350

    400

    450

    0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800

    minutes from SDCM starts

    ustrainpk-pk

    A ustrain pk-pk

    C ustrain pk-pk

    E ustrain pk-pk

    43 ustrain difference

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    20/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 20

    IntroductionThis procedural write-up is to provide guidance for field compressor / driver alignment /

    re-alignment. The purpose is to document job specific activities into an organized check-list that will result in a properly supported and well-aligned drive train.

    Objective:

    To obtain Driver (Gas or Electric) and Compressor alignment tolerances to the following spec. (Verify all

    readings with AlignmentMaster2)

    Driver and Compressor Frames Max allowable misalignment from anchor bolt to anchor

    bolt, (or bearing saddle to bearing saddle) is .002 w/ .004 overall.

    Driver and Compressor Twist Max allowable is of the bearing clearance at any bearing

    saddle location. Example - .006 bearing top clearance, equals a .003 side cl., which equals

    a max. allowable twist of .0015.

    Install and maintain Crosshead and Compressor alignment to + .004 / ft. and -.000 of the

    frame overall list, with both crosshead and compressor in-plane, w/ all bottles and piping

    attached.

    The following procedural steps are intended to address initial installation procedures as well as any re-

    alignment issues that may present themselves.

    1. Pre-job Checkl ist Coordinate compressor and driver manufacturers technical assistance involvement.

    Develop EPE written lock out/tag out work procedure for these realignment activities.

    The following information is required prior to physically starting the re-alignment.

    Determine (Measure) the shim thickness required to replace the individual

    (Loose) shims now in place. (Ideally, one shim plate and one shim pack per bolt)

    Order replacement shims. (Shims must be on site prior to disassembly)

    Note:Replacement shims (302ss min.) are to be a 1 piece solid, plus a laminated pack of no more

    than .003, with .002 laminations preferred, and .125 max. The thickness of the one-piece

    solid shim is determined by the measurements above, and may be location specific.

    Note:Compressor and Driver Frame measurements to be precision

    measurements using instruments within + / - .001 resolution. I.e. Optical

    or Laser Scope, Lectromaster level, etc

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    21/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 21

    o Gather the following unit information:

    1) Compressor Frame Length ---------------------(inches): ________

    2) Compressor Frame Width ----------------------(inches): ________

    3) Drive-train Coupling Length ----------------------(inches): ________

    4) Coupling alignment tolerance --------------------(inches): ________

    5) Comp. Published thermal growth (.xxx /100deg. F) : ________

    6) Driver Published thermal growth (.xxx/100deg. F) : ________

    7) Distance from Compressor Frame to Driver Frame

    (total distance between frame and driver) -------(inches): ________

    8) Driver Frame Length -------------------------------(inches): ________

    9) Driver Frame Width --------------------------------(inches): ________

    10) Compressor Main Bearing Clearance ------------(inches): ________

    11) Driver Main Bearing Clearance -------------------(inches): ________

    12) Drive-train Coupling flange bolt torques

    Compressor Flange --------------------------------------(ft-lb):

    ________Driver Flywheel ------------------------------------------(ft-lb): ________

    13) Compressor Frame Anchor Bolt torque ------------(ft-lb): ________

    14) Compressor Crosshead Pedestal Bolt torque ------(ft-lb): ________

    15) Compressor Cylinder Peanut Flange bolt torque --(ft-lb): ________16) Driver Frame Anchor Bolts -------------Torque (ft-lb): ________ or --------

    ------------------Stretch requirements (inches): ________

    17) Verify all Manufacturers Special Tools are available and are in proper working

    condition ------------ Compressor: ___________

    ------------- Driver : ___________

    18) 16 Bottle & Spool Flange Gaskets

    Quantity ______ Part Number: ___________ Deliv date: ________

    19) 16 Bottle & Spool Flange PTFE Coated Bolts

    Quantity: ______ Part Number: _________Deliv. date: ________

    20) Compressor Peanut Flange Gaskets

    Quantity: _____ Part Number: __________ Deliv. date: ________

    21) Compressor to Crosshead Guide Gaskets

    Quantity: _____ Part Number: ___________ Deliv. date: ________22) Recommended Driver to Compressor cold alignment --------------------

    Driver = Top ______ Bot ______ L ______ R ______

    Compressor = Top ______ Bot ______ L ______ R ______

    23) Acceptable coupling alignment limits :

    COLD T_____ B _____ L_____ R _____

    HOT T_____ B _____ L _____ R _____

    Note:Use Compressor as reference for Left and Right.

    2. Pre-Job Meeting

    A pre-job meeting needs to be conducted to discuss and clar if y

    many items contained with in thi s document. Th is is a complex process, and as such, not all

    items of concern / pr e-experienced can be satisfactor il y addressed with a wri tten explanation

    and/or procedure.

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    22/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 22

    Pre-Job Meeting required attendance:

    o Plant Services and Engineering

    o Division / Area

    o If under Warranty:

    o OEM Compressor and Driver (Driver optional)

    o Contractor

    3. NEW Installation

    SKID Mountingo Mount 4 to 6 leveling pads ( Vibracon or equivalent)

    o Securing temporarily with mortar to foundation top.

    o Using a precision leveling device (accuracy + .0015 / 40) level all pads to earth,

    and lock in place.

    o Place skid on pads and let set / stand for min. 24 hrs.

    o Adjust jackscrews to support skid in non-stressed position, and remove leveling

    pads.

    o Pour grout

    4. Activi ties Prior to Disassembly

    Before Shutdown Determine deteriorated equipment support condition issues:

    Loose anchor bolts and shims by location.

    Broken or cracked anchor bolts on driver, compressor or secondary

    discharge bottles.

    Loose discharge bottle (primary & secondary) wedges

    After Shutdown Hot (48 hrs running time) Drive trains hot coupling alignment, measure & record within 15 minutes of shutdown.

    Compressor crosshead guide clearances, measure and record within 30 minutes of shutdown.

    Gas reciprocating drivers hot crankshaft web deflections, if attainable.

    After Shutdown Cold Record as-found compressor conditions on EPCs Gas Path Integrity Condition (GPIC) data sheets;

    Rod run-out & wear

    Cylinder bore wear

    Piston wear band & ring condition

    Crosshead guide & cylinder bore slope, measured with a precision

    Machinists level in thousandths of an inch/foot.

    Using a precision elevation measurement device, determine existing drive-train alignment condition of

    the following equipment, recording elevations Data Sheets: (Has scope been calibrated on site via

    AlignmentMaster2

    procedure) __________

    Compressor frame RE initial

    Cylinder suction flange planes, CE & HE

    Driver frame feet

    Note:Compressor and Driver Frame measurements to be precision

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    23/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 23

    measurements using instruments within + / - .001 resolution. I.e. Optical

    or Laser Scope, Lectromaster level, etc.

    2. Major Equipment Disassembly Sequence

    When removing the following items, record any unusual conditions for review when reassembly begins;i.e. piping misalignment, binding, flange misalignment (flange to flange or flange to Compressor), gasket

    failures or pinching, piping angular misalignment, etc.

    Disassemble the process gas piping and compressor as follows:

    1) Remove compressor suction spools.2) Remove compressor suction bottles.

    Note:Place bottles beside compressor on concrete slab with plywood under flanges to protect

    gasket-sealing surfaces.

    3) Remove flange bolts between discharge bottles.4) Remove compressor discharge peanut flange bolts, then remove restriction orifice/gasket

    holder.

    5) Remove compressor piston rod assembly, mark piston and balance nutswith cylinder number, then place assemblies on plywood with balance

    nuts installed to protect threads.

    6) Remove compressor to crosshead mounting bolts.7) Move compressor cylinders away from crossheads approximately 6, supporting cylinder

    securely on discharge bottle flange & wood timbers under outboard end.

    8) Remove, clean and replace shims under compressor frame, crossheadpedestal and driver anchor bolts.

    9) Re-torque compressor frame, pedestal and driver anchor bolts to 50% of

    Manufacturers specified value.

    10) Remove drive-train coupling.

    Note:Carefully place & store all removed critical compressor fasteners in plastic buckets,

    protecting threads from impact damage.

    3. Drive-train Re-alignment /Shimming Procedure

    Note: Verify that the compressor and Driver Jackscrews do not distort or otherwise damage the

    soleplates. In some cases a pancake jack must be used.

    With all compressor frame, pedestal and driver anchor bolts re-torqued to at least 50% full value:

    1) Re-measure all precision elevation readings (compressor frame top and driver mounting feet),

    recording information on the sheets provided.

    2) Using EPEs AlignmentMaster2, process readings

    3) Make shim adjustments as required utilizing EPCs AlignmentMaster2 LIST function.

    Note:Maintain compressor and driver coupling end 0 reference points to

    minimize affect on coupling alignment.

    4) After each shimming adjustment, re-torque anchor bolts to 50% of manufacturers specified

    value and verify elevation adjustments using

    precision measurement device, recording readings on the sheets

    provided.

    5) Repeat steps 2, 3, and 4 until alignment of both Driver and Compressor frames are acceptable

    per EPCs AlignmentMaster2 and Web. Limits.

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    24/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 24

    6) Preload crosshead guide pedestals to approximately the same side-to-side plane as the

    compressor frame, using up to 0.012 shim under crosshead pedestal. Vary the pre-load

    between .005 and .012 to obtain the upper recommended value clearance. Example

    recommended x-head running clearance is .010 to .015, adjust the preload to obtain a

    clearance between .013 and .015.

    Note:After shimming adjustments, assure that the recommended crosshead

    running clearance is not reduced more than .001 and is not less than the

    minimum allowable clearance.

    4. Drive-train Coupling Alignment Procedure

    With compressor and driver frames acceptably aligned and all anchor bolts torqued to100% value, proceed as follows:

    1) Using either a Laser coupling alignment tool or the Reverse Dial indicator method;

    Measure drive-train coupling alignment

    Note:DO NOT shim any individual feet or foot (i.e. soft foot method) that

    might be indicated by the alignment readings. (We want to leave the unit flat) TheAlignmentMaster2 program will align the comp and driver to the same slope.

    2) Using the compressor frame as a fixed point, improve alignment as required by moving the

    driver frame as a whole i.e. all feet get same shim adjustment.

    Note:Horizontal frame movements can be made independently at each end.

    5. Equipment Reassembly Procedure

    Reassemble the compressor as directed by the compressor manufacturer representative (if present) or

    OEM Technical Manual. Reinstall associated process gas piping and associated equipment as follows:

    1) Reinstall the compressor cylinders to the crosshead guides, hand tightening four corner bolts.

    Note:Inspect all critical fastener threads for damage prior to install. Lubricate fastener threads

    and under bolt heads before installation by hand. All fasteners should turn freely be hand.

    2) Using a precision machinists level, adjust cylinder roll about the mounting bolts to align thesuction flange plane with the compressor frames (end to end) slope plane, then torque all

    mounting bolts to specified value.

    Note:Lower discharge bottle as required to facilitate cylinder installation and rotation.

    3) Verify that cylinder and crosshead bores are in the same plane with a precision machinistslevel, record readings.

    4) Install cylinders HE heads, with bolt snugged to prevent cylinder bore distortion when bottleflange bolts are torqued.

    5) Mount discharge bottles to the compressors cylinders with new gaskets in the orifice holder,checking for proper alignment and fit-up.

    Note:All cylinder peanut flange bolts shall be installed by hand. Adjust bottles vertical and

    horizontal position as required for ease of bolt installation.

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    25/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 25

    6) Using discharge bottle wedges, support the compressor cylinders so their bores are in thesame plane as the crosshead.

    7) Torque cylinder to discharge bottle flange bolts to the value specified.8) Install new gaskets and bolts, then torque primary to secondary discharge bottle flange bolts

    to the value specified for bolt coating.

    Note:Secondary discharge bottle wedge adjustment may be required to facilitate 16 600#ANSI flange alignment.

    9) Hand tighten discharge bottle wedges and hold down straps as required.10) Re-measure cylinder elevations using precision measurement device, recording readings on

    the sheets provided. Verify that compressor frame alignment is still good.

    11) Reinstall the suction bottles to the compressors cylinders with new gaskets in the orificeholder, checking for proper alignment and fit-up.

    Note:All cylinder flange bolts shall be installed by hand. Adjust bottles vertical and horizontal

    position as required for ease of bolt installation.

    12) Reinstall suction spools using new gaskets and bolts, then torque flange bolts to the valuespecified for bolt coating.

    13) Install compressors piston rod assemblies and HE heads, then torque fasteners and balancenuts as specified.

    14) Re-torque all bolts per OEM recommended lubricant, sequence, and pre-stress (PSI) tables.15) Loosen the bottle supports and measure (dial indicator) the overall drop. Re-tighten the

    supports to gain back of the observed drop.

    16) Record the compressor cylinders as-left conditions on EPCs Gas Path Integrity Check(GPIC) forms.

    17) Re-measure compressor cylinder elevations using precision measurement device, recordingreadings on the sheets provided. Verify that compressor frame alignment is still good.

    18) Reinstall the drive-train coupling

    6. Final Assembly Checks & Verifications

    Re-measure compressor frame & driver foot elevations using precision measurement device, recording

    readings on the sheets provided.

    Confirm as-left condition is within EPCs AlignmentMaster2 specifications.

    Confirm all compressor as-left conditions on EPCs Gas Path Integrity Check

    (GPIC) forms, In addition to:

    o Compressor and Driver Thrust measurements

    Compressor and driver frame jack bolts (2 per corner) are loosened at least 1 away from the frame.

    Record the driver conditions on appropriate EPC forms:

    Gas Reciprocating Web deflections

    Electric Motors Air gap Coupling Alignment within OEM specs.

    7. TGP Startup procedures

    Verify all flange (suction and discharge) bolts are torqued

    Verify all piping flange bolt are torqued

    Verify all GPIC work completed per COPP Section 105.1

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    26/27

    2003 Gas Machinery Conference 26

    Verify engine and compressor-frame thrust clearances

    Remove locks on affected unit valves

    Purge unit per approved procedures

    Pressurize unit to 50 PSI; perform leak check

    Increase pressure in increments of 100 PSI to 400 PSI, performing leak checks at each step.

    Increase unit to line pressure; perform leak check

    Bar unit at least one complete revolution to ensure no mechanical block Perform final walk-around inspection prior to first crank

    Crank unit on starter while listening for knocks, etc.

    Start unit, run to the point of loading, then shut down; inspect crosshead clearances and

    compressor cylinder elevations; note compressor-frame vibration readings at unit panel

    Start unit, place on-line; operate loaded for 48 hours while noting frame vibration readings at unit

    panel; shut down and perform hot engine web deflection readings; check compressor elevations; check

    crosshead clearances; check coupling alignment; check wedges under discharge bottles.

    Obtain frame and piping vibration readings (EPC Reliability Specialist or

    contract specialist).

    8. (30) Day Follow-up Maintenance Checks

    Record locations of any loose shims.

    While running, verify anchor bolt torque is adequate by feeling for relative movement at each interface.

    Re-torque anchor bolts as required to tighten shim-stack.

    Discharge bottle wedges providing positive lift without crosshead guide clearance deterioration.

    Crosshead clearances hot are within manufacturers tolerances.

    Hot coupling alignment is within coupling tolerances.

    With unit hot measure Compressor and Frame planes. Using the bottle supports, adj. as necessary toobtain equal planes, and lock in place.

    NOTES ***

    ______________________________________________________________________________________

    ______________________________________________________________________________________

    ______________________________________________________________________________________

    ______________________________________________________________________________________

    ______________________________________________________________________________________

    ______________________________________________________________________________________

    ______________________________________________________________________________________

    ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    ______________________________________________________________________________________

    ____

    Procedure signed OFF by Date ________________

    PDF created with FinePrint pdfFactory Pro trial version http://www.fineprint.com

    http://www.fineprint.com/http://www.fineprint.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Criticality of High Speed Separable Alignment

    27/27

    _____________________________ _____________________________

    Area / Division Rep Plant Services Rep.

    Rev. 1.0