Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
CRATER PLANNING DISTRICT COMMISSION
WIP III WORKING GROUP
Outfall & Gully Stabilization Projects (OGSP)April15, 2016
Joseph Battiata, P.E.
City of Hopewell
Stormwater Program Manager
AGENDA
1. Brief overview of pollutant load reduction strategies
2. BMP cost effectiveness3. Stream Restoration4. Outfall & Gully Stabilization Projects
LOCAL AREA PLANNING GOAL BMPS
Structural BMPs• Bioretention
Basins/Raingardens
• Dry Ponds/Wet Ponds
• Infiltration Practices
• Filtering Practices
• Permeable Pavement
• Vegetated Channels
• Shoreline
Non-Structural BMPs• IC Reduction
• Land Conversion
• Urban Tree Canopy
• Forest Buffers
• Street sweeping
• Storm Drain Cleaning
• Nutrient management
• Growth Management
STRUCTURAL BMP CROWD PLEASERS
Permeable PavementBioretentionRain Gardens
Performance (%)
DA
Cost ($$$$)
= Cost/lb
HIGH COST – HIGH PERFORMANCE BMPS
Stream RestorationShoreline ManagementLand Use Conversion
Performance
DA (length, other)
Cost ($$$$)
= Cost/lb
RIVERSIDE PARK STORMWATER GREENWAY
Design & construction:Preliminary Cost/lb = $ 14,615/lb TPFinal Cost/lb = $ 6,096/lb TP
RIVERSIDE PARK STORMWATER GREENWAY
Design & construction:Final Cost/lb ~ $ 50,000/lb TP
Bioretention (L1)- 1.84 acPermeable Pavmnt (L2) – 0.15 ac
STREAM RESTORATION LOAD REDUCTION CALCULATIONS
CBP Expert Panel Report Default Values
OR
CBP Expert Panel Report Protocols 1, 2, & 3
TN TP Sediment
Default Rate (lb/ft/yr) 0.075 0.068 44.88 non-coastal plain
15.13 coastal plain
STREAM RESTORATION LOAD REDUCTION CALCULATIONS
CBP Expert Panel Report Protocols 1, 2, & 3: Protocol 1: Credit for Prevented Sediment during Storm Flow (monitoring, BANCS, or Alt.)Protocol 2: Credit for Instream and Riparian Nutrient Processing during Base Flow (TN only)Protocol 3: Credit for Floodplain Reconnection VolumeProtocol 4: Credit for Dry Channel RSC as an Upland Stormwater Retrofit
Active Headcut
REGENERATIVE STORMWATER CONVEYANCE (RSC)
Sand/Wood chip mix
RIVERSIDE PARK STORMWATER GREENWAY RSC
TN TP Sediment
Pollutant Reductions (lb/yr) 54 11 3,144
Performance (%)
DA
Cost ($$$$)
= Cost/lb
CBP EXPERT PANEL REPORT:
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR CREDITING OUTFALL & GULLY STABILIZATION PROJECTS
Approved October 15, 2019
CBP EXPERT PANEL REPORT:
Protocol 5: Alternative Prevented Sediment for Outfalls
OUTFALL GULLY & STABILIZATION PROJECTS
Headwater Transition Zone = Stormwater Hotspot Erosive force of flows discharged from storm drain
outfalls High channel slopes and energy conditions Exposed and non-cohesive soils Poor vegetative cover Floodplains that are narrow or absent
OUTFALL GULLY & STABILIZATION PROJECTS
Courtesy: MDOT SHA Courtesy: VDOT
OUTFALL & GULLY STABILIZATION PROJECTS
1. Define Existing Channel Conditions;2. Define Equilibrium Channel Conditions;3. Calculate Total Prevented Sediment4. Convert Total Sediment Volume to Annual
Prevented Sediment Load5. Determine Annual Prevented Nutrients
OUTFALL GULLY & STABILIZATION
Very common in coastal zone: • development drainage systems discharge at the edge
of escarpment;• Channels typically hidden in dense overgrowth;• Headcuts migrate upstream and eventually impact
drainage and transportation infrastructure;• Require repair to protect infrastructure – get credit and
possibly funding
Performance
DA (length, other)
Cost ($$$$)
= Cost/lb
QUESTIONS???