28
1 Samuel S. Lyness, MD, FACS Director, Tele-Neurosurgery Program Wendy Baynard, MSW Program Manager, Tele-Neurosurgery Program The Walter Reed Tele-Neurosurgery Program American Telemedicine Association 2007 Annual Meeting Nashville, Tennessee

Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

1

Samuel S. Lyness, MD, FACSDirector, Tele-Neurosurgery Program

Wendy Baynard, MSWProgram Manager, Tele-Neurosurgery Program

The Walter Reed Tele-Neurosurgery

Program

American Telemedicine Association2007 Annual MeetingNashville, Tennessee

Page 2: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

2

James M. Ecklund, MD, FACS, COL, MC, USAProfessor/Chairman, National Capital Consortium Neurosurgery

ProgramWalter Reed Army Medical Center, National Naval Medical Center

andUniformed Services University of the Health Sciences

Leon E. Moores, MD, FACS, COL, MC, USAChief, Department of SurgeryWalter Reed Army Medical Center

John Posey, MDAssociate Professor of NeurosurgeryTulane UniversityNew Orleans, Louisiana

Alan AndersonClinical Business Analyst, Resource ManagementNorth Atlantic Regional Medical Command

Tele-Neurosurgery Program

Contributors

Page 3: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

3

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Agenda

Objectives

Scope of Care

Clinical Process

Case Management

Consult and Referral Sites

Consult Site Team/Functions

Referral Site Team/Functions

Resource analysis (earnings)

Page 4: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

4

Tele-Neurosurgery ProgramWalter Reed --- Ft Bragg

Page 5: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

5

Tele-Neurosurgery Program

Afghanistan ---- Walter Reed

Page 6: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

6

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Objectives

Optimize Specialty Care Delivery Neurosurgeon focuses on surgical candidates PA and PT evaluate patients for treatment options Nurse case manager and LPN support providers

Increase Access-to-Care with Neurosurgeon VTC

Improve Clinical Outcomes with Treatment Options Physical therapy Anesthesiologist pain management Surgical care

Ensure Continuity-of-Care from PC Referral to PC F/U PA and LPN manage evaluation and conservative care Nurse case manager coordinates all surgery-related care Patient documentation stored in single electronic record

 

Page 7: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

7

Tele-NeurosurgeryScope of Care

Not Robotic Surgery

Page 8: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

8

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Scope of Care

All Ages

Routine and Urgent Care

Intracranial and Spinal ConditionsVascular LesionsTumorsCongenital Malformations and DeformitiesDegenerative Diseases

Acute Brain and Spinal Injuries?

Page 9: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

9

Tele-NeurosurgeryScope of Care

Works well in sub-acute conditions in which a large proportion of patients recover without surgery

Page 10: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

10

Tele-Neurosurgery ProgramClinical Process

Referral guidance for primary care providers

Patient evaluation and diagnostic imaging/lab tests

Non-operative treatment as first tier intervention

Neurosurgeon VTC consult and surgery assessment

Patients come to Walter Reed if surgery is needed

Pre-operative assessment and surgery

Post-op care and primary care F/U

Return to duty

Page 11: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

11

Tele-Neurosurgery Program

Case Management

PA Conducts Referral ScreeningGuide primary care provider on referral guidelinesEvaluate referrals for neurosurgical conditions

Page 12: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

12

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Case Management

PA Performs Patient EvaluationObtain comprehensive problem-focused historyPerform neurological examinationOrder imaging studies and labs testsMake diagnosis

Non-Operative Conservative Care as First Tier InterventionDevelop treatment plan with neurosurgeon input as neededPrescribe PT and/or pain management interventionsAssess treatment results periodicallyRequest neurosurgeon VTC consult if conservative care fails

Page 13: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

13

Tele-Neurosurgery Program

Case Management

PA/LPN Manages Neurosurgeon VTC Consult Process

Schedule VTC consult and obtain patient consentForward digitized radiology images to neurosurgeonManage VTC session between patient and neurosurgeonNeurosurgeon discusses surgical options vs continued non-operative management

Page 14: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

14

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Case Management

PA/LPN and Nurse Case Manager Coordinate SurgerySchedule and manage pre-op evaluation and careSchedule surgery at WRAMCNeurosurgeon-led surgical team performs surgery

PA Manages Post-Surgery Follow-up CareDirect follow-up treatment and VTC specialist F/URefer patient to other health care providers as neededReturn patient to primary care with follow-up guidance

Page 15: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

15

Tele-Neurosurgery ProgramConsult and Referral Sites

Consult Site: Walter Reed Army Medical CenterAll neurosurgical subspecialties represented on faculty Center of Excellence for: Comprehensive clinical care and resident training Academic research on head and spinal cord/column injuries

Referral Sites: FT Bragg, FT Knox, Andrews AFB, QuanticoMRI and PT services available or in vicinityReasonable travel to Walter Reed if surgery is requiredCurrent/projected enrollment to sustain service demand

Fort Bragg

Walter Reed

Fort Knox

Page 16: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

16

Tele-Neurosurgery ProgramConsult Site Team/Functions

Neurosurgeon Performs Consults and Surgery

Neurosurgery PA Conducts Screening ClinicsWalter Reed three days per weekAndrews AFB and Quantico on-site one day/week each

Nurse Case Manager Supports NeurosurgeonCoordinates VTC clinics and neurosurgeon clinical support Provides case management for surgical patients

Surgical Team Supports Surgery (late afternoon )Operating Room Nurse and techAnesthesiologist (runs pain management clinic 3 days/wk)

Page 17: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

17

Tele-Neurosurgery ProgramReferral Site Team/Functions

Physician Assistant Manages Neurosurgery Care

LPN Supports and Optimizes Physician Assistant

Physical Therapist Provides Non-Operative Care

Pain Management if Available

Page 18: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

18

Level of Surgeries DRG Earnings Monthly Annual DRG        

Effort per Month per Surgery Earnings Surgery Earnings        

Level 1 5 $10,330 $51,650 $619,800        

Level 2 10 $10,330 $103,300 $1,239,600        

Level 3 15 $10,330 $154,950 $1,859,400        

level 4 20 $10,330 $206,600 $2,479,200        

Level 5 25 $10,330 $258,250 $3,099,000        

Level 6 30 $10,330 $309,900 $3,718,800        

Effort Neurosurgeons PAs PTs Anesthesiologists LPNs NCM OR Nurse OR Tech

Level 1 0.4 1.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.4 0.0 0.0

Level 2 0.6 2.0 1.0 0.2 1.6 0.6 0.2 0.2

Level 3 0.8 3.0 1.6 0.4 2.0 0.8 0.2 0.2

level 4 1.0 3.0 2.0 0.4 2.4 1.0 0.4 0.4

Level 5 1.0 3.0 2.4 0.6 3.0 1.0 0.4 0.4

Level 6 1.0 4.0 3.0 0.6 3.0 1.2 0.6 0.6

Level of RVUs by Clinical Projected FTEs ( est. $85 per RVU)

Effort Neurosurgeons PAs PTs Anesthesiologists LPNs NCMs OR Nurse OR Techs

Level 1 800 1,500 0 0 0 0 0 0

Level 2 1,200 3,000 1,500 500 0 0 0 0

Level 3 1,600 4,500 2,400 1,000 0 0 0 0

level 4 2,000 4,500 3,000 1,000 0 0 0 0

Level 5 2,000 4,500 3,600 1,500 0 0 0 0

Level 6 2,000 6,000 4,200 1,500 0 0 0 0

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Resource Requirements

Page 19: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

19

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Resource Requirements

TEAM: 20 spinal operations per month 1.0 Full-Time neurosurgeon 3.0 Physicians Assistants 2.0 Physical Therapists 1.0 Anesthesiologist 0.4 OR/0.6 Pain Mgt 2.4 LPN 1.0 Nurse case manager 1.0 OR Nurse 0.4 OR/0.6 Pain MGT 1.0 OR Tech 0.4 OR/0.6 Admin. Assist.

Page 20: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

20

1 Neurosurgeon $170,000 3 Physician Assistants 382,500 2 Physical Therapists 255,000 0.6 Anesthesiologists 125,500

TOTAL $933,000 Generated for Hospital

Tele-Neurosurgery ProgramAnnual Projected Earnings

Outpatient Visits Only

Page 21: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

21

Tele-Neurosurgery ProgramAnnual Projected Earnings

Surgery

Neurosurgeon (240 cases/yr) $2,470,200

Generated for hospital

Page 22: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

22

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Annual Projected EarningsOutpatient visits +Surgery

Total: $3,472,220/yr

Generated for Hospital

Page 23: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

23

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Startup Costs Equipment

POLYCOMs x 6 COMPUTERS x8BLACKBERRYs x4

About $60,000

Page 24: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

24

Tele-Neurosurgery Program

Fixed Costs

Personnel per/yr $1,800,000Blackberrys per yr 10,000

TOTAL $1,810,000

Page 25: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

25

Tele-Neurosurgery ProgramNet Annual Revenue

Income $3,472,200Fixed costs 1,810,000

NET + $1,662,200

Page 26: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

26

The Walter Reed Tele-Neurosurgery Program

Summary

Patient care objectives are being metFinancial objectives are being metTravel burden to and from WRAMC has, thus far, not been a problem nor increased the complication rateEnhanced resident exposure to the “bread and butter” cases

Page 27: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

27

The Walter Reed Tele-Neurosurgery Program

Plan: Resume svc to AAFB and Quantico Market the program to other remote sites (Aberdeen, Carlisle) Tele-mentoring link to acute care sites

that lack a neurosurgeon Recruit personnel as needed

Page 28: Cost Analysis of Tele-Neurosurgery (T4A4)

28

POC: Dr. Samuel LynessPhone: 202-782-5123Email: [email protected]

POC: Wendy BaynardPhone: 202-782-6416Email:[email protected]

Tele-Neurosurgery Program Questions?