Corpo Case Digests 2016.pdf

8/17/2019 Corpo Case Digests 2016.pdf

1/19

"

!"#$" !&'( )*+(',' -./0

/1 $&2,#&2!" (3$4"5((' &''"!1 67 24#!

89:;7<

!"#$ &'( )&*+,- ./0&12 3/+/ 43'/( 52 16/ 74'8&0/- 9&:,02; 1/( 52

16/ !I"F.I"CJ #)!*1/( 14 @+4*//( &E&,'-1 16/ !"D= !"D )&(/*4+= &'( )/E& !+,:/; !"D ,-

-4>E61 14 5/ 6/0( 0,&50/ 5/*&>-/ ,1 &*?>,+/( !"#$ 16+4>E6 "$BC &1 16/ 1,:/ 36/' !"#$ 3&-->99/+,'E 9,'&'*,&0 +/A/+-/-; !"DM)&(/*4+ ,- 5/,'E :&(/ 14 &'-3/+ 94+ >',4'G- 0&54+ *0&,:- &-

16/ 43'/+ 49 16/ ->5N/*1 !&'1+&'*4 @+4@/+1,/- &'( &- & ->5-,(,&+2 49 !"D; )/E& !+,:/ ,- &0-4

,'*0>(/( 94+ 6&A,'E &*?>,+/( !"DG- -6&+/- 4A/+ !"DM)&(/*4+;

00,9,*&1,4' 49 16/

3+,1 4' 16/ E+4>'(- 16&1 16/2 3/+/ '41 @&+1,/- 14 16/ 0&54+ *&-/ 9,0/( &E&,'-1 !"#$ &'( 16&1 16/2

6&A/ -/@&+&1/ @/+-4'&0,1,/- (,-1,'*1 9+4: 16&1 49 !"#$;

*77=><

RJ" !"D= !"DM)&(/*4+= )/E& !+,:/ :&2 5/ 6/0( 0,&50/;

?>@A<

"J; F6/ ->5N/*1 @+4@/+12 ,- '41 43'/( 52 16/ N>(E:/'1 (/514+= 16&1 ,-= !"#$; "436/+/ ,' 16/

+/*4+(- 3&- ,1 -643' 16&1 !"#$ 43'/( 16/ !&'1+&'*4 @+4@/+1,/-; !/1,1,4'/+-= ,' 9&*1= '/A/+

&00/E/( ,' &'2 49 16/,+ @0/&(,'E- 16/ 9&*1 49 ->*6 43'/+-6,@;

F6/ E/'/+&0 +>0/ ,- 16&1 & *4+@4+&1,4' 6&- & @/+-4'&0,12 -/@&+&1/ &'( (,-1,'*1 9+4: 164-/ 49 ,1-

-14*Q640(/+- &'( 416/+ *4+@4+&1,4'- 14 36,*6 ,1 :&2 5/ *4''/*1/(; F6,- ,- & 9,*1,4' *+/&1/( 52

0&3 94+ *4'A/',/'*/ &'( 14 @+/A/'1 ,'N>-1,*/= 643/A/+ ,1 &(:,1- 49 */+1&,' /H*/@1,4'-= 14 3,1S(/9/&1 49 @>50,* *4'A/',/'*/ &- 36/' 16/ *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4' ,- >-/( &- & A/6,*0/ 94+ 16/ /A&-,4'

49 &' /H,-1,'E 450,E&1,4'T UP 9+&>( *&-/- 4+ 36/' 16/ *4+@4+&1/ /'1,12 ,- >-/( 14 N>-1,92 & 3+4'E=

@+41/*1 9+&>(= 4+ (/9/'( & *+,:/T 4+ VP !"#$% $'( *&-/- 36/+/ 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' ,- -4 4+E&',8/(

&'( *4'1+400/( &'( ,1- &99&,+- &+/ -4 *4'(>*1/( &- 14 :&Q/ ,1 :/+/02 &' ,'-1+>:/'1&0,12= &E/'*2=

*4'(>,1 4+ &(N>'*1 49 &'416/+ *4+@4+&1,4'; $' 16/ &5-/'*/ 49 :&0,*/= 5&( 9&,16= 4+ & -@/*,9,*

@+4A,-,4' 49 0&3 :&Q,'E & *4+@4+&1/ 499,*/+ 0,&50/= ->*6 *4+@4+&1/ 499,*/+ *&''41 5/ :&(/

@/+-4'&002 0,&50/ 94+ *4+@4+&1/ 0,&5,0,1,/-;


2/19

#

J5A,4>-02= !"D= !"DM)&(/*4+= )/E& !+,:/= &'( !"#$ &+/ *4+@4+&1,4'- 3,16 16/,+ 43'

@/+-4'&0,1,/-; F6/2 :>-1 -643 16&1 !"D 3&- >-,'E !"#$ &- & :/+/ &(N>'*1 4+ ,'-1+>:/'1&0,12 4+

6&- /H@04,1/( 4+ :,->-/( 16/ *4+@4+&1/ @+,A,0/E/ 49 !"#$ 5>1 >'94+1>'&1/02 16/2 9&,0/( 14

(,-*6&+E/ ->*6 5>+(/';

I0-4= '/,16/+ *&' 3/ :/+E/ 16/ @/+-4'&0,12 49 !"#$ 3,16 !"D -,:@02 5/*&>-/ 16/ 0&11/+ &*?>,+/(16/ 94+:/+ &'( 16&1 9&*1 &04'/ ,- '41 ->99,*,/'1 14 640( !"D 0,&50/ 94+ 16/ (/51- 49 !"#$;

-1 '(&"*4 67 &B,"!"#$

89:;7<

L/&4,0 @>+*6&-/( &' /H*&A&14+ I>14*4+@ 7+4>@; L/&4,0 ,-->/( WU *6/*Q- &- @&2:/'1 16/+/94+T

643/A/+ WX *6/*Q- 3/+/ '41 64'4+/( 52 16/ 5&'Q -,'*/ L/&4,0 +/?>/-1/( 16&1 @&2:/'1 5/

-14@@/(; I>14*4+@ 9,0/( & *4:@0&,'1 94+ +/*4A/+2 49 16/ /H*&A&14+ 3,16 16/ .FC;

L/&4,0 *0&,:- 16&1 L/&4,0 &'( I>14*4+@ 3/+/ 4'02 >1,0,8/( &- *4'(>,1- 14 -/110/ 16/ 450,E&1,4' 494'/ 94+/,E' /'1,12 '&:/( Y',0,'/ ,' 9&A4+ 49 &'416/+ 94+/,E' /'1,12= Z4*>-; F6/ +/&0 1+&'-&*1,4'

,- 16&1 Y',0,'/= 16+4>E6 .4(+,E>/8 364 ,- &0-4 & (,+/*14+ 49 IYFJCJ.!= 43/( :4'/2 14 Z4*>-;

$' 0,/> 49 @&2:/'1= Y',0,'/ ,'-1/&( &E+//( 14 *4'A/2 16/ /H*&A&14+ 14 Z4*>- &'( @&2:/'1 -6&00

5/ :&(/ 52 .4+,E>/8 16+4>E6 16/ ,-->&'*/ 49 16/ @4-1M(&1/( *6/*Q-= 643/A/+ 16,- 3&- +/N/*1/(

52 I1>14*4+@ 5/*&>-/ ,1 ,- ,' 16/,+ @40,*2 16&1 ,1 *&''41 &**/@1 *6/*Q (>02 ,-->/( 52 ,1- (,+/*14+-;

F4 +/:/(2 16/ -,1>&1,4'= ,1 3&- K>= 16/ (,+/*14+ 49 L/&4,0= 364 ,-->/( *6/*Q- ,' 9&A4+ 49

I>14*4+@ 5>1 ->5N/*1 14 +/,:5>+-/:/'1 52 .4(+,E>/8;

L/&4,0 &:/'(/( ,1- *4:@0&,'1 &'( ,:@0/&(/( .4(+,E>/8 ,' 16/ *&-/;

*77=><

RJ" & -14*Q640(/+ &'( (,+/*14+ :&2 5/ 6/0( @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ 94+ 16/ (/51- 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4';

?>@A<

2"1 .4(+,E>/8 ,- & @/+-4' -/@&+&1/ &'( ,'(/@/'(/'1 9+4: I>14*4+@; R6&1/A/+ 450,E&1,4'-

.4(+,E>/8 *4'1+&*1/( *&''41 5/ &11+,5>1/( 14 I>14*4+@

&'( A,*/ A/+-&; .4(+,E>/8= &-

-14*Q640(/+ &'( (,+/*14+ 49 Y',0,'/= *&''41 5/ 6/0( @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ 94+ 16/ (/51- 49 16/

*4+@4+&1,4'= 36,*6 6&- & -/@&+&1/ 0/E&0 @/+-4'&0,12 49 ,1- 43'; R6,0/ L/*1,4' VW 49 16/

C4+@4+&1,4' C4(/ 0&2- (43' 16/ /H*/@1,4'- 14 16/ +>0/= 16/ -&:/ (4/- '41 &@@02 ,' 16,- *&-/;L/*1,4' VW :&Q/- & (,+/*14+ @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ 94+ *4+@4+&1/ (/51- ,9 6/ 3,009>002 &'( Q'43,'E02

A41/- 94+ 4+ &--/'1- 14 @&1/'102 >'0&39>0 &*1- 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'; L/*1,4' VW &0-4 :&Q/- &

(,+/*14+ @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ ,9 6/ ,- E>,012 49 E+4-- '/E0,E/'*/ 4+ 5&( 9&,16 ,' (,+/*1,'E 16/ &99&,+- 49

16/ *4+@4+&1,4'; F6/ 5&( 9&,16 4+ 3+4'E(4,'E 49 16/ (,+/*14+ :>-1 5/ /-1&50,-6/( *0/&+02 &'(

*4'A,'*,'E02; D&( 9&,16 ,- '/A/+ @+/->:/(; F6/ 5>+(/' 49 @+4A,'E 5&( 9&,16 4+ 3+4'E(4,'E 4'

16/ @&+1 49 .4(+,E>/8 3&-= 4' @/1,1,4'/+= & 5>+(/' 36,*6 ,1 9&,0/( 14 (,-*6&+E/; F6>-= ,1 3&-

@+4@/+ 94+ 16/ 1+,&0 *4>+1 14 6&A/ (,-:,--/( 16/ 16,+(M@&+12 *4:@0&,'1 &E&,'-1 .4(+,E>/8 4' 16/

E+4>'( 16&1 6/ 3&- '41 & @&+12 14 16/ -&0/ 49 16/ /H*&A&14+;


3/19

$

$1 ,- -/110/( 16&1 & *4+@4+&1,4' 6&- & @/+-4'&0,12 -/@&+&1/ &'( (,-1,'*1 9+4: ,1- ,'(,A,(>&0

-14*Q640(/+- 4+ :/:5/+-= &'( ,- '41 &99/*1/( 52 16/ @/+-4'&0 +,E61-= 450,E&1,4'- &'(

1+&'-&*1,4'- 49 16/ 0&11/+; F6/ *4+@4+&1,4' :&2 '41 5/ 6/0( 0,&50/ 94+ 16/ 450,E&1,4'- 49 16/

@/+-4'- *4:@4-,'E ,1= &'( '/,16/+ *&' ,1- -14*Q640(/+- 5/ 6/0( 0,&50/ 94+ ,1- 450,E&1,4' >'0/-- ,1

,- 5/,'E >-/( 14 (/9/&1 @>50,* *4'A/',/'*/= N>-1,92 3+4'E= @+41/*1 9+&>(= 4+ (/9/'( *+,:/;

$' 9&*1= 16/ 450,E&1,4' 16&1 L/&4,0 @+499/+- &- ,1- (/9/'-/ [ >'(/+ 16/ +*6&-/ IE+//:/'1

[ 3&- '41 /A/' ,'*>++/( 52 .4(+,E>/8 4+ 52 I>14*4+@ 5>1 52 Y',0,'/; F6/ 1+&'-&*1,4' >'(/+

*4'-,(/+&1,4' ,- -/@&+&1/ &'( (,-1,'*1 9+4: 16&1 >'(/+ 16/ +*6&-/ IE+//:/'1; $' 16/

94+:/+= ,1 ,- L/&4,0 16&1 43/- I>14*4+@= 36,0/ ,' 16/ 0&11/+= Y',0,'/ ,'*>++/( 450,E&1,4'- 14

Z4*>-;

C1 !?*2& D&2E*2+ !"#$"#&,*"2 67 )52(F'(3 (4(!,#"2*!' !"#$"#&,*"2

89:;7<

F6/ @&+1,/- 14 16,- *&-/ &+/ @/1,1,4'/+- C6,'& D&'Q &'( +/-@4'(/'1- B2'/ML/:;

R6&1 6&@@/'/( ,' 16,- *&-/ 3&- 16/+/ 3&- 16,- *4+@4+&1,4' B2'/1,*-= &'( & */+1&,' )+; 1/( &' &*1,4' 94+ *400/*1,4' 49 ->: 49 :4'/2 &E&,'-1 )+;

-,'/-- &'( -4:/ 49 16/

/?>,@:/'1 49 B2'/ML/: 3&- &*1>&002 &*?>,+/( 9+4: B2'/1,*-;

*77=><

RJ" B2'/ML/: :&2 5/ 6/0( 0,&50/;

?>@A


4/19

%

• "4 :/+E/+ 5>1 4'02 -&0/ 49 &--/1-]16/ 450,E&1,4' 49 4'/ (4/- '41 &>14:&1,*&002

5/*4:/- 16/ 450,E&1,4' 49 16/ 416/+;

!,/+*,'E 49 16/ A/,0 49 *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4' 3&- '41 N>-1,9,/(;

G1 $&'#*!?& 67 )"2 4B*' )*'"2 #(&4,5H *2!1

89:;7<

F6/+/ 3/+/ U 0/&-/ *4'1+&*1 5/13//' @/1,1,4'/+ !&-+,*6& O0/--//P &'( +/-@4'(/'1 B4' ,-

B,-4' ./&012 $'*; O0/--4+P; Z4+ V 2/&+- +/'1- 3/+/ +/0,E,4>-02 @&,( 5>1 ,1 -14@@/( (>/ 14 16/

*4'9>-,4' O,'1/+'&0 -?>&550/P &- 14 364 ,- &>164+,8/( 14 +/*/,A/ 16/ @&2:/'1- O+/'1-P]16/

94+:/+ 7/'/+&0 )&'&E/+= !&*6/*4= 3&- +/@0&*/( 52 D&>1,-1&; L,'*/ !&-+,*6& +/9>-/ 14 @&2 ,1-

450,E&1,4' (/-@,1/ +/@/&1/( (/:&'(-= B4' ,- 9,0/( &' /N/*1:/'1 ->,1 &E&,'-1 16/ 94+:/+ 16+>

)-; D&>1,-1& 4' B/*/:5/+ W_= W``V; L#C ->-@/'(/( &'( /A/'1>&002 +/A4Q/( 16/ */+1,9,*&1/ 49

+/E,-1+&1,4' 49 +/-@4'(/'1- 4' Z/5+>&+2 Wa= W``_;

!/1,1,4'/+ :4A/ 14 (,-:,-- 16/ /N/*1:/'1 ->,1 5/*&>-/ )-; D&>1,-1& 0&*Q &>164+,12 14 +/@+/-/'1

16/ *4+@4+&1,4' &5-/'1 &'2 54&+( +/-40>1,4' 14 16/ /99/*1;

*77=><

W; RJ" +/-@4'(/'1 *4:@&'2 6&- -1&'(,'E 14 ->/;

U; RJ" )-; D&>1,-1& 6&- *&@&*,12 14 ->/ ,' 5/6&09 49 16/ *4:@&'2;

?>@A<

W; K#L; I0164>E6 16/ L#C ->-@/'(/( &'( /A/'1>&002 +/A4Q/( +/-@4'(/'1G- */+1,9,*&1/ 49

+/E,-1+&1,4' 4' Z/5+>&+2 Wa= W``_= +/*4+(- -643 16&1 ,1 ,'-1,1>1/( 16/ &*1,4' 94+ /N/*1:/'1 4'

B/*/:5/+ W_= W``V; I**4+(,'E02= 36/' 16/ *&-/ 3&-* 4::/'*/(= ,1- +/E,-1+&1,4' 3&- '41 2/1

+/A4Q/(; D/-,(/-= 16/ L#C 0&1/+ -/1 &-,(/ ,1- /&+0,/+ 4+(/+- 49 ->-@/'-,4'&'( +/A4*&1,4' 49

+/-@4'(/'1G- */+1,9,*&1/= +/'(/+,'E 16/ ,-->/ :441 &'( &*&(/:,*;

U; K#L; I *4+@4+&1,4' 6&- '4 @43/+- /H*/@1 164-/ /H@+/--02 *4'9/++/( 4' ,1 52 16/ C4+@4+&1,4'

C4(/ &'( 164-/ 16&1 &+/,:@0,/( 9+4: 4+ &+/ ,'*,(/'1&0 14 ,1- /H,-1/'*/; $' 1>+'= & *4+@4+&1,4'

/H/+*,-/- -&,( @43/+- 16+4>E6 ,1- 54&+( 49 (,+/*14+- &'(^4+ ,1- (>02 &>164+,8/( 499,*/+- &'(

&E/'1-; !62-,*&0 &*1-= 0,Q/ 16/ -,E','E 49 (4*>:/'1-= *&' 5/ @/+94+:/( 4'02 52 '&1>+&0 @/+-4'-(>02 &>164+,8/( 94+ 16/ @>+@4-/ 52 *4+@4+&1/ 52M0&3- 4+ 52 & -@/*,9,* &*1 49 16/54&+( 49

(,+/*14+-; F6>-= &'2 @/+-4' ->,'E 4' 5/6&09 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' -64>0( @+/-/'1 @+449 49 ->*6

&>164+,12;

I0164>E6 )-; D&>1,-1& ,',1,&002 9&,0/( 14 -643 16&1 -6/ 6&( 16/ *&@&*,12 14 -,E' 16/ A/+,9,*&1,4'

&'( ,'-1,1>1/ 16//N/*1:/'1 *&-/ 4' 5/6&09 49 16/ *4:@&'2= 36/' *4'9+4'1/( 3,16 ->*6

?>/-1,4'= -6/ ,::/(,&1/02 @+/-/'1/( 16/ L/*+/1&+2G- C/+1,9,*&1/ *4'9,+:,'E 6/+ &>164+,12 14


5/19

&

+/@+/-/'1 16/ *4:@&'2; F6/+/ ,- &:@0/ N>+,-@+>(/'*/ 640(,'E 16&1 ->5-/?>/'1 &'( ->5-1&'1,&0

*4:@0,&'*/ :&2 *&00 94+ 16/ +/0&H&1,4' 49 16/ +>0/- 49 @+4*/(>+/ ,' 16/ ,'1/+/-1 49 N>-1,*/;

$' "4A/012 !6,0-;= $'*; A; C4>+1 49 I@@/&0-= 16/ C4>+1 9&>01/( 16/ &@@/00&1/ *4>+1 94+ (,-:,--,'E &

@/1,1,4' -40/02 4' @/1,1,4'/+G- 9&,0>+/ 14 1,:/02 ->5:,1 @+449 49 &>164+,12 14 ->/ 4' 5/6&09 49 16/

*4+@4+&1,4'; $' !9,8/+= $'*; A; 7&0&'= 3/ >@6/0( 16/ ->99,*,/'*2 49 & @/1,1,4' A/+,9,/( 52 &'/:@042:/'1 -@/*,&0,-1 (/-@,1/ 16/ 141&0 &5-/'*/ 49 & 54&+( +/-40>1,4' &>164+,8,'E 6/+ 14 &*1 94+

&'( 4' 5/6&09 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'; 0/- 49 @+4*/(>+/ 5/*&>-/ 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'

+&1,9,/( 16/ :&'&E/+G- -1&1>- &- &' &>164+,8/( -,E'&14+2;

$' &00 49 16/ &54A/ *&-/-= 3/ 5+>-6/( &-,(/ 1/*6',*&0,1,/- ,' 16/ ,'1/+/-1 49 N>-1,*/; F6,-

+/0&H&1,4' 49 16/ +>0/- &@@0,/- 4'02 14 6,E602 :/+,14+,4>- *&-/-= &'( 36/' 16/+/ ,- ->5-1&'1,&0

*4:@0,&'*/;

)-; D&>1,-1&G- 0&*Q 49 &>164+,12 3&- *>+/( &91/+ ->5-/?>/'1 54&+( +/-40>1,4' ,-->/( 14 6/+

9&A4+;

_; &! #9I7JK 49LJM BINJI 61 24#! O/PQ0R

B4*1+,'/S L,'*/ & *4+@4+&1/ /:@042/+ ,- &' &+1,9,*,&0 @/+-4'= ,1 :>-1 6&A/ &' 499,*/+ 364 *&' 5/

@+/->:/( 14 5/ 16/ /:@042/+= 5/,'E 16/ b@/+-4' &*1,'E ,' 16/ ,'1/+/-1 49 16/ /:@042/+;c

89:;7<

J' d>'/ a= WàW= /:@042//- 49 IC .&'-4:= :4-1 5/,'E :/:5/+- 49 16/ IC .&'-4: -/( +/,'-1&1/:/'1;

B>+,'E Wà`= 16/ \/+'&'(/8 9&:,02 O43'/+- 49 IC .I"LJ)P 4+E&',8/( &'416/+ *4+@4+&1,4'

>'(/+ 16/ '&:/ 49 .4-&+,4 $'(>-1+,&0 C4+@4+&1,4'; F6/ -&,( *4:@&'2 (/&01 ,' 16/ -&:/ 12@/ 49

5>-,'/-- &- IC .&'-4:; F6/ ,-->/ 49 5&*Q 3&E/- 3&- 5+4>E61 5/94+/ 16/ C4>+1 49 $'(>-1+,&0

./0&1,4'- 36,*6 +/'(/+/( & (/*,-,4' 4' B/*/:5/+ W`= WèU 4+(/+,'E 16/ 13/'12 134 -1+,Q/+- 14

5/ +/,'-1&1/( 3,16 5&*Q 3&E/-;

J' I@+,0 U= WèV= .I"LJ) 9,0/( &' &@@0,*&1,4' 94+ *0/&+&'*/ 14 *04-/ 4+ */&-/ 4@/+&1,4'-; F6/

-&:/ 3&- E+&'1/( 52 16/ ),',-1+2 49 E6 ,1 6&- -14@@/(4@/+&1,4'-= .I"LJ) 6&- *4'1,'>/( ,1- @/+-4'&0,12 &- & *4+@4+&1,4'; Z4+ @+&*1,*&0 @>+@4-/-=

+/,'-1&1/:/'1 49 16/ UU -1+,Q/+- 6&- 5//' @+/*0>(/(; I- & :&11/+ 49 9&*1= +/,'-1&1/:/'1 ,- '41

&' ,-->/ ,' 16,- *&-/; I :41,4' 49 /H/*>1,4' 3&- 9,0/( 52 16/ Y',4' &E&,'-1 IC .&'-4: 5>1 16/

94+:/+ 3&- >'&50/ 14 *400/*1 (>/ 14 16/ ,'&5,0,12 14 9,'( 0/A,&50/ &--/1- 49 16/ *4:@&'2; F6/

Y',4' ->5-/?>/'102 &-Q/( 16/ 499,*/+- 49 .&'-4: 14 5/ @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ 94+ @&2:/'1 49 16/

5&*Q 3&E/-; F6/ :41,4' 3&- E+&'1/( 52 16/ 1 3&- ->5-/?>/'102 +/A/+-/( 5216/

"


6/19

'

*77=>7<

W; R^" .JLI.$J C4:@&'2 -64>0( 5/ 6/0( 0,&50/ 94+ 16/ *0&,:- 49 IC .&'-4: :/'1 14 &A4,( @&2:/'1 49 5&*Q3&E/- &'( 16/ +/,'-1&1/:/'1 49 16/ UU

34+Q/+-; F6,- ,- &'416/+ ,'-1&'*/ 36/+/ 16/ 9,*1,4' 49 -/@&+&1/ &'( (,-1,'*1 *4+@4+&1/ /'1,1,/-

-64>0( 5/ (,-+/E&+(/(;

$1 ,- A/+2 45A,4>- 16&1 16/ -/*4'( *4+@4+&1,4' -//Q- 16/ @+41/*1,A/ -6,/0( 49 & *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4'

364-/ A/,0 ,' 16/ @+/-/'1 *&-/ *4>0(= &'( -64>0(= 5/ @,/+*/( &- ,1 3&- (/0,5/+&1/02 &'(

:&0,*,4>-02 (/-,E'/( 14 /A&(/ ,1- 9,'&'*,&0 450,E&1,4' 14 ,1- /:@042//-; R6/' & '41,4' 49 0/E&0

/'1,12 ,- >-/( 14 (/9/&1 @>50,* *4'A/',/'*/= N>-1,92 3+4'E= @+41/*1 9+&>(= 4+ (/9/'( *+,:/= 16/0&3 3,00 +/E&+( 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' &- &' &--4*,&1,4' 4+ @/+-4'-= 4+= ,' 16/ *&-/ 49 134 *4+@4+&1,4'-=

3,00 :/+E/ 16/: ,'14 4'/;

U; K#L; Y'(/+ I+1,*0/ UWU O*P 49 16/ -1 6&A/

&' 499,*/+ 364 *&' 5/ @+/->:/( 14 5/ 16/ /:@042/+= 5/,'E 16/ b@/+-4' &*1,'E ,' 16/ ,'1/+/-1 49

16/ /:@042/+ O.&'-4:P;c$' !B _U_= 36/+/ & *4+@4+&1,4' 9&,0- 14 @&2 16/ /:/+E/'*2 &0043&'*/

16/+/,' @+4A,(/(= 16/ @+/-*+,5/( @/'&012 b-6&00 5/ ,:@4-/( >@4' 16/ E>,012 499,*/+ 4+ 499,*/+-c

49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'; $' 16/ ,'-1&'1 *&-/= .I"LJ)= ,' 94+/-//,'E 16/ @4--,5,0,12 4+ @+45&5,0,12 49

@&2:/'1 49 5&*Q 3&E/- 14 16/ UU -1+,Q/+-= 4+E&',8/( .JLI.$J 14 +/@0&*/ .I"LJ)= 3,16 16/0&11/+ 14 5/ /A/'1>&002 @6&-/( 4>1 ,9 16/ UU -1+,Q/+- 3,' 16/,+ *&-/;

F6/ +/*4+( (4/- '41 *0/&+02 ,(/'1,92 b16/ 499,*/+ 4+ 499,*/+-c 49 .I"LJ) (,+/*102 +/-@4'-,50/ 94+

9&,0>+/ 14 @&2 16/ 5&*Q 3&E/- 49 16/ UU -1+,Q/+-; $' 16/ &5-/'*/ 49 (/9,',1/ @+449 ,' 16&1 +/E&+(=

,1 -64>0( 5/ @+/->:/( 16&1 16/ +/-@4'-,50/ 499,*/+ ,- 16/ !+/-,(/'1 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' 364 *&'

5/ (//:/( 16/ *6,/9 4@/+&1,4' 499,*/+ 16/+/49;

01 !9M9S 61 24#! O-..TR


7/19

(

89:;7<

"&1,4'&0 Z/(/+&1,4' 49 (E:/'1 &3&+( 4' 16/ 5&-,- 49

I+1,*0/ UWUO*P 49 16/ !6,0,@@,'/ & !&-14+/-= &- *4>'-/0 94+ +/-@4'(/'1-=

->5:,11/( & @4-,1,4' @&@/+ (&1/( UW Z/5+>&+2 W``g &'( -1&1/( 16&1 *4:@0&,'&'1- -64>0( '41

6&A/ ,:@0/&(/( C&+&E &'( B&A,( 5/*&>-/ )IC ,- &*1>&002 43'/( 52 & *4'-4+1,>: 49 5&'Q-;

C&+&E &'( B&A,( 43' -6&+/- ,' )IC 4'02 14 ?>&0,92 16/: 14 -/+A/ &- )ICh- 499,*/+-; R,164>1

&'2 9>+16/+ @+4*//(,'E-= I+5,1/+ J+1,E>/++& +/'(/+/( 6/+ B/*,-,4' (&1/( We d>'/ W``g E+&'1,'E

16/ :41,4' 14 ,:@0/&( C&+&E &'( B&A,(; $' 16/ -&:/ B/*,-,4'= I+5,1/+ J+1,E>/++& (/*0&+/( C&+&E

&'( B&A,( -40,(&+,02 0,&50/ 3,16 )IC +>0,'E 16&1 *4+@4+&1/ 499,*/+- 364 (,-:,--/( /:@042//- ,'5&( 9&,16 4+ 3&'14'02 A,40&1/ 0&54+ -1&'(&+( 0&3- 4+ 36/' 16/ *4:@&'2 6&( &0+/&(2 */&-/(

4@/+&1,4'- &'( 16/+/ ,- '4 3&2 52 36,*6 & N>(E:/'1 ,' 9&A4+ 49 /:@042//- *4>0( 5/ -&1,-9,/(=

*4+@4+&1/ 499,*/+- *&' 5/ 6/0( N4,'102 &'( -/A/+&002 0,&50/ 3,16 16/ *4:@&'2; C&+&E= 16+4>E6 &

-/@&+&1/ *4>'-/0= 9,0/( &' &@@/&0 (&1/( VX I>E>-1 W``g 5/94+/ 16/ "0E&1/( 4' _ d&'>&+2 W``_= 16/ "'0&39>0 &*1- 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'; L/*1,4' VW &0-4:&Q/- & (,+/*14+ @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ ,9 6/ ,- E>,012 49 E+4-- '/E0,E/'*/ 4+ 5&( 9&,16 ,' (,+/*1,'E 16/

&99&,+- 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4';

F4 640( & (,+/*14+ @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ 94+ (/51- 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'= &'( 16>- @,/+*/ 16/ A/,0 49

*4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4'= 16/ 5&( 9&,16 4+ 3+4'E(4,'E 49 16/ (,+/*14+ :>-1 5/ /-1&50,-6/( *0/&+02 &'(

*4'A,'*,'E02; D&( 9&,16 ,- '/A/+ @+/->:/(; D&( 9&,16 (4/- '41 *4''41/ 5&( N>(E:/'1 4+

'/E0,E/'*/; D&( 9&,16 ,:@4+1- & (,-64'/-1 @>+@4-/; D&( 9&,16 :/&'- 5+/&*6 49 & Q'43' (>12

16+4>E6 -4:/ ,00 :41,A/ 4+ ,'1/+/-1; D&( 9&,16 @&+1&Q/- 49 16/ '&1>+/ 49 9+&>(; "/,16/+ (4/- 5&(


8/19

)

9&,16 &+,-/ &>14:&1,*&002 N>-1 5/*&>-/ & *4+@4+&1,4' 9&,0- 14 *4:@02 3,16 16/ '41,*/ +/?>,+/:/'1

49 0&54+ 0&3- 4' *4:@&'2 *04->+/ 4+ (,-:,--&0 49 /:@042//-; F6/ 9&,0>+/ 14 E,A/ '41,*/ ,- '41 &'

>'0&39>0 &*1 5/*&>-/ 16/ 0&3 (4/- '41 (/9,'/ ->*6 9&,0>+/ &- >'0&39>0; L>*6 9&,0>+/ 14 E,A/

'41,*/ ,- & A,40&1,4' 49 @+4*/(>+&0 (>/ @+4*/-- 5>1 (4/- '41 &:4>'1 14 &' >'0&39>0 4+ *+,:,'&0

&*1; L>*6 @+4*/(>+&0 (/9/*1 ,- *&00/( ,00/E&0 (,-:,--&0 5/*&>-/ ,1 9&,0- 14 *4:@02 3,16 :&'(&14+2

@+4*/(>+&0 +/?>,+/:/'1-= 5>1 ,1 ,- '41 ,00/E&0 ,' 16/ -/'-/ 16&1 ,1 *4'-1,1>1/- &' >'0&39>0 4+

*+,:,'&0 &*1;

Z4+ & 3+4'E(4,'E 14 :&Q/ & (,+/*14+ @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ 94+ (/51- 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'= 16/

3+4'E(4,'E &@@+4A/( 4+ &--/'1/( 14 52 16/ (,+/*14+ :>-1 5/ & @&1/'102 >'0&39>0 &*1; )/+/

9&,0>+/ 14 *4:@02 3,16 16/ '41,*/ +/?>,+/:/'1 49 0&54+ 0&3- 4' *4:@&'2 *04->+/ 4+ (,-:,--&0 49

/:@042//- (4/- '41 &:4>'1 14 & @&1/'102 >'0&39>0 &*1; !&1/'102 >'0&39>0 &*1- &+/ 164-/

(/*0&+/( >'0&39>0 52 0&3 36,*6 ,:@4-/- @/'&01,/- 94+ *4::,--,4' 49 ->*6 >'0&39>0 &*1-; F6/+/

:>-1 5/ & 0&3 (/*0&+,'E 16/ &*1 >'0&39>0 &'( @/'&0,8,'E 16/ &*1;

$' 16,- *&-/= I+1,*0/ UiV 49 16/ ,+,'E & 4'/M:4'16 @+,4+ '41,*/ 14 /:@042//- &'(16/ B/@&+1:/'1 49 '0&39>0 &*1 @>',-6&50/ >'(/+ 16/ C4(/;

F6/+/ ,- '4 @+4A,-,4' ,' &'2 416/+ I+1,*0/ 49 16/ 0 &*1 &'( @+4A,(,'E 94+ ,1- @/'&012; C4:@0&,'&'1- (,( '41 &00/E/ 4+ @+4A/= &'( I+5,1/+

J+1,E>/++& (,( '41 :&Q/ &'2 9,'(,'E= 16&1 C&+&E &@@+4A/( 4+ &--/'1/( 14 &'2 @&1/'102 >'0&39>0

&*1 14 36,*6 16/ 0&3 &11&*6/- & @/'&012 94+ ,1- *4::,--,4'; J' 16,- -*4+/ &04'/= C&+&E *&''41 5/

6/0( @/+-4'&002 0,&50/ 94+ 16/ -/@&+&1,4' @&2 49 *4:@0&,'&'1-;

T1 'N9I (I;>MUMN7>7 61 !=U>M;NIJ #>9@;V O-..PR

89:;7<

J' I@+,0 WX= W``_= @/1,1,4'/+ L,&,' 451&,'/( & 04&' 49 !Ve=XXX=XXX;XX 9+4: +/-@4'(/'1

C>@/+1,'4 *4A/+/( 3,16 & @+4:,--4+2 '41/ -,E'/( 52 5416 @/1,1,4'/+h- &'( +/-@4'(/'1h-

+/-@/*1,A/ @+/-,(/'1-= C>& 1/( & +/&0 /-1&1/ :4+1E&E/ 4A/+ 134 @&+*/0- 49 0&'( &'(

416/+ ,::4A&50/-= ->*6 &- /?>,@:/'1- &'( :&*6,'/+,/-; F34 (&2- 0&1/+= 16/ @+4:,--4+2 '41/

3&- &:/'(/( 14 ,'*0>(/ & Wej ,'1/+/-1 @/+ &''>: 4' 16/ '41/; F6,- 3&- &E&,' -,E'/( 52 /&*649 16/ @+/-,(/'1- 49 16/ @&+1,/-;

J' I>E>-1 WU= W``_= C>& @/+1,'4 94+ !WaX=XXX=XXX;

J' 16/ -&:/ (&1/= 16/ @&+1,/- /H/*>1/( &' &:/'(:/'1 4' 16/ +/&0 /-1&1/ :4+1E&E/; $1 '43

,'(,*&1/( 16&1 16/ 141&0 04&' 14 5/ -/*>+/( 52 16/ :4+1E&E/ ,- !W`e= XXX=XXX;XX;


9/19

*

C>+,4>-02= 4' )&+*6 WW= W`à= @/1,1,4'/+= 16+4>E6 *4>'-/0= -/'1 & 0/11/+ 14 +/-@4'(/'1

(/:&'(,'E 16/ +/0/&-/ 49 16/ !WaX=XXX=XXX 04&'; !/1,1,4'/+ &00/E/- 16&1 +/-@4'(/'1 6&( 2/1 14

+/0/&-/ 16/ @+4*//(- 49 16/ 04&'; C>@/+1,'4 +/9>1/( 16/ &**>-&1,4'- &'( :&,'1&,'/( 16&1 L,&,'

6&( 04'E 451&,'/( 16/ @+4*//(-;

C>@/+1,'4 (/*0&+/( @/1,1,4'/+h- (/:&'( &- :&(/ 14 b&5-*4'( 9+4: & N>-1 &'( A&0,( 450,E&1,4'=c

& :/+/ &91/+164>E61= 940043,'E C>@/+1,'4h- 0/11/+ (/:&'(,'E @&2:/'1 49 16/ !Ve=XXX=XXX 04&'

*4A/+/( 52 16/ 9,+-1 @+4:,--4+2 '41/ 36,*6 5/*&:/ 4A/+(>/ 4' )&+*6 _= W`à;

"41 ->+@+,-,'E02= C>@/+1,'4 ,'-1,1>1/( /H1+&N>(,*,&0 94+/*04->+/ @+4*//(,'E- 4A/+ 16/ @+4@/+1,/-

->5N/*1 49 16/ &:/'(/( +/&0 /-1&1/ :4+1E&E/; F6/ &>*1,4' -&0/ 3&- -*6/(>0/( 4' J*145/+ WW=

W`à 3,16 +/-@4'(/'1 "41&+2 !>50,* #(3,' .; C&1&*>1&' *4::,--,4'/( 14 *4'(>*1 16/ -&:/;

F6,- @+4:@1/( @/1,1,4'/+ 14 9,0/ & *4:@0&,'1 3,16 & @+&2/+ 94+ & +/-1+&,','E 4+(/+ 14 /'N4,'

"41&+2 !>50,* C&1&*>1&' 9+4: @+4*//(,'E 3,16 16/ @>50,* &>*1,4' 4' 16/ E+4>'(- 16&1 16/ +/&0

/-1&1/ :4+1E&E/ 3&- A4,( 94+ 0&*Q 49 *4'-,(/+&1,4';

B>+,'E 16/ @+/M1+,&0 *4'9/+/'*/= 16/ @&+1,/- 9&,0/( 14 &++,A/ &1 &' &:,*&50/ -/110/:/'1; \/'*/=

1+,&0 4' 16/ :/+,1- /'->/(; .FC >@6/0( 16/ A&0,(,12 49 16/ +/&0 /-1&1/ :4+1E&E/; CI &99,+:/(;

$' 16,- +/E&+(= 16/ 043/+ *4>+1- &@@0,/( 16/ (4*1+,'/ 49 b@,/+*,'E 16/ A/,0 49 *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4'c 14

@+/*0>(/ @/1,1,4'/+ 9+4: (,-&A43,'E +/*/,@1 49 16/ !WaX=XXX=XXX;XX &'( @&2,'E ,1- 450,E&1,4'

>'(/+ 16/ &:/'(/( +/&0 /-1&1/ :4+1E&E/;

*77=><

R^" 16/ (4*1+,'/ 49 f!,/+*,'E 16/ k/,0 49 C4+@4+&1/ Z,*1,4'f -64>0( 5/ &@@0,/( ,' 16/ *&-/ &15&+;

?>@A<

K#L; I- & E/'/+&0 +>0/= & *4+@4+&1,4' 3,00 5/ (//:/( & -/@&+&1/ 0/E&0 /'1,12 >'1,0 ->99,*,/'1

+/&-4' 14 16/ *4'1+&+2 &@@/&+-;

D>1 16/ +>0/ ,- '41 &5-40>1/; I *4+@4+&1,4'G- -/@&+&1/ &'( (,-1,'*1 0/E&0 @/+-4'&0,12 :&2 5/

(,-+/E&+(/( &'( 16/ A/,0 49 *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4' @,/+*/( 36/' 16/ '41,4' 49 0/E&0 /'1,12 ,- >-/( 14

(/9/&1 @>50,* *4'A/',/'*/= N>-1,92 3+4'E= @+41/*1 9+&>(= 4+ (/9/'( *+,:/; $' 16,- *&-/= C>@/+1,'4@+/-/'1/( 4A/+36/0:,'E /A,(/'*/ 16&1 @/1,1,4'/+ &'( ,1- &99,0,&1/ *4+@4+&1,4'- 6&( +/*/,A/( 16/

@+4*//(- 49 16/ !WaX=XXX=XXX;XX 04&' ,'*+/&-/ 36,*6 3&- 16/' :&(/ 16/ *4'-,(/+&1,4' 94+ 16/

I:/'(/( ./&0 #-1&1/ )4+1E&E/; F6/ 9&*1- /-1&50,-6/( ,' 16/ *&-/ &1 5&+ 6&- *4'A,'*/( 16/

C4>+1 49 16/ @+4@+,/12 14 &@@02 16/ @+,'*,@0/ 52 A,+1>/ 49 36,*6= 16/ N>+,(,*&0 @/+-4'&0,1,/- 49 16/

A&+,4>- *4+@4+&1,4'- ,'A40A/( &+/ (,-+/E&+(/( &'( 16/ /'->,'E 0,&5,0,12 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' 14

&11&*6 (,+/*102 14 ,1- +/-@4'-,50/ 499,*/+- &'( -14*Q640(/+-

F6/-/ &+/ &- 940043-S


10/19

"+

W; F6&1 16/ *6/*Q-= (/5,1 :/:4- &'( 16/ @0/(E/- 49 16/ N/3/0+,/-= *4'(4:,',>: >',1- &'(

1+>*Q- 3/+/ *4'-1,1>1/( '41 /H*0>-,A/02 ,' 16/ '&:/ 49 l@/1,1,4'/+m 5>1 &0-4 /,16/+ ,' 16/ '&:/

49 K>2/Q )&'>9&*1>+,'E C4+@4+&1,4'= L,&,' F+&'-@4+1= $'*;= C>& 2/Q 6&A/ l&m *4::4' -/1 49 l,'*4+@4+&14+-m= -14*Q640(/+- &'( 54&+( 49 (,+/*14+-T

V;F6/2 6&A/ 16/ -&:/ ,'1/+'&0 544QQ//@/+ &'( &**4>'1&'1 ,' 16/ @/+-4' 49 .4-/:&+,/

.&E4(4'T

g; F6/2 6&A/ 16/ -&:/ 499,*/ &((+/-- &1 VXa d4-/ .,8&0 L1;= )&'(&0>24'E C,12T

_; F6/2 6&A/ 16/ -&:/ :&N4+,12 -14*Q640(/+ &'( @+/-,(/'1 ,' 16/ @/+-4' 49 C>& 1 &>164+,12 9+4: 16/ D4&+( 49 B,+/*14+-= 14 >-/ 16/ 9>'(- 49 L,&,' F+>*Q,'E 14 @&2 16/

450,E&1,4' ,'*>++/( 52 16/ @/1,1,4'/+*4+@4+&1,4';

)* I- ->*6= @/1,1,4'/+ *4+@4+&1,4' ,- '43 /-14@@/( 9+4: (/'2,'E 16/ &54A/ &@@&+/'1

&>164+,1,/- 49 C>& I>M9@ !M>AN; !JMU 61 &@7JI7 )>61 9IA *I6>7;K>I; !JMU O-..TR

89:;7<

!/1,1,4'/+ 7/'/+&0 C+/(,1 C4+@4+&1,4' O7CCP= 16/' Q'43' &- C4::/+*,&0 C+/(,1 C4+@4+&1,4'

OCCCP= /-1&50,-6/( CCC 9+&'*6,-/ *4:@&',/- ,' (,99/+/'1 >+5&' */'1/+- 49 16/ *4>'1+2; $'

9>+16/+&'*/ 49 ,1- 5>-,'/--= 7CC 3&- &50/ 14 -/*>+/ 0,*/'-/ 9+4: C/'1+&0 D&'Q OCDP &'( L#C 14

/'E&E/ &0-4 ,' ?>&-,5&'Q,'E &*1,A,1,/-; J' 16/ 416/+ 6&'(= +/-@4'(/'1 CCC #?>,12 C4+@4+&1,4'O#nY$FKP 3&- 4+E&',8/( ,' 52 7CC 94+ 16/ @>+@4-/ 49= &:4'E 416/+ 16,'E-= 1&Q,'E 4A/+ 16/

4@/+&1,4'- &'( :&'&E/:/'1 49 16/ A&+,4>- 9+&'*6,-/ *4:@&',/-; I1 & 1,:/ :&1/+,&0 6/+/14=

+/-@4'(/'1 I0-4'- B/A/04@:/'1 &'( $'A/-1:/'1 C4+@4+&1,4' OI/(

I1 /A/' 5/94+/ 16/ /H/*>1,4' 49 16/ &--,E':/'1 (/&0 &94+/-1&1/(=

0/11/+- 49 (/:&'( 94+ ,'1/+/-1 @&2:/'1 3/+/ &0+/&(2 -/'1 14 #nY$FK; #nY$FK '4 04'E/+ 16/'6&A,'E &--/1- 4+ @+4@/+12 14 -/110/ ,1- 450,E&1,4' '4+ 5/,'E /H1/'(/( 9,'&'*,&0 ->@@4+1 52 7CC=

@0/&(/( ,'&5,0,12 14 @&2; I+/ &E&,'-1 #nY$FK &'(= >'(/+ 16/ (4*1+,'/ 49

@,/+*,'E 16/ A/,0 49 *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4'= &E&,'-1 7CC= #nY$FK 6&A,'E 5//' 4+E&',8/( &- & 1440 &'(

:/+/ *4'(>,1 49 7CC; I**4+(,'E 14 #nY$FK O*+4--M*0&,: &E&,'-1 7CCPS ,1 &*1/( :/+/02 &-

,'1/+:/(,&+2 4+ 5+,(E/ 94+ 04&' 1+&'-&*1,4'- &'( 416/+ (/&0,'E- 49 7CC 14 ,1- 9+&'*6,-/- &'( 16/

,'A/-1,'E @>50,*T &'( ,- -40/02 (/@/'(/'1 >@4' 7CC 94+ ,1- 9>'(,'E +/?>,+/:/'1-; \/'*/= 7CC ,-


11/19

""

-40/02 &'( (,+/*102 0,&50/ 14 I@A+1 3,00 491/' 044Q &1 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' &-

& :/+/ *400/*1,4' 49 ,'(,A,(>&0- 4+ &' &EE+/E&1,4' 49 @/+-4'- >'(/+1&Q,'E 5>-,'/-- &- & E+4>@=(,-+/E&+(,'E 16/ -/@&+&1/ N>+,(,*&0 @/+-4'&0,12 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' >',92,'E 16/ E+4>@; I'416/+

94+:>0&1,4' 49 16,- (4*1+,'/ ,- 16&1 36/' 134 OUP 5>-,'/-- /'1/+@+,-/- &+/ 43'/(= *4'(>*1/(

&'( *4'1+400/( 52 16/ -&:/ @&+1,/-= 5416 0&3 &'( /?>,12 3,00= 36/' '/*/--&+2 14 @+41/*1 16/

+,E61- 49 16,+( @&+1,/-= (,-+/E&+( 16/ 0/E&0 9,*1,4' 16&1 134 *4+@4+&1,4'- &+/ (,-1,'*1 /'1,1,/- &'(

1+/&1 16/: &- ,(/'1,*&0 4+ 4'/ &'( 16/ -&:/;

I>164+,1,/- &+/ &E+//( 4' &1 0/&-1 16+// OVP 5&-,* &+/&- 36/+/ @,/+*,'E 16/ A/,0= 3,16 36,*6 16/

0&3 *4A/+- &'( ,-40&1/- 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' 9+4: &'2 416/+ 0/E&0 /'1,12 14 36,*6 ,1 :&2 5/ +/0&1/(=

,- &0043/(; F6/-/ &+/S WP (/9/&1 49 @>50,* *4'A/',/'*/= &- 36/' 16/ *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4' ,- >-/( &-

A/6,*0/ 94+ 16/ /A&-,4' 49 &' /H,-1,'E 450,E&1,4'T UP 9+&>( *&-/- 4+ 36/' 16/ *4+@4+&1/ /'1,12 ,->-/( 14 N>-1,92 & 3+4'E= @+41/*1 9+&>(= 4+ (/9/'( & *+,:/T 4+ VP &01/+ /E4 *&-/-= 36/+/ &

*4+@4+&1,4' ,- :/+/02 & 9&+*/ -,'*/ ,1 ,- & :/+/ &01/+ /E4 4+ 5>-,'/-- *4'(>,1 49 & @/+-4'= 4+

36/+/ 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' ,- -4 4+E&',8/( &'( *4'1+400/( &'( ,1- &99&,+- &+/ -4 *4'(>*1/( &- 14

:&Q/ ,1 :/+/02 &' ,'-1+>:/'1&0,12= &E/'*2= *4'(>,1 4+ &(N>'*1 49 &'416/+ *4+@4+&1,4';

F6/ C4>+1 &E+//- 3,16 16/ (,-@4-,1,4' 49 16/ CI 4' 16/ &@@0,*&1,4' 49 16/ @,/+*,'E (4*1+,'/ 14

16/ 1+&'-&*1,4' ->5N/*1 49 16,- *&-/; !/+ 16/ C4>+1G- *4>'1= 16/ 1+,&0 *4>+1 /'>:/+&1/( '4 0/--

16&' UX (4*>:/'1/( *,+*>:-1&'*/- &'( 1+&'-&*1,4'-= 36,*6= 1&Q/' &- & @&*Q&E/= ,'(//(

-1+4'E02 ->@@4+1/( 16/ *4'*0>-,4' 16&1 +/-@4'(/'1 #nY$FK 3&- 5>1 &' &(N>'*1= &'

,'-1+>:/'1&0,12 4+ 5>-,'/-- *4'(>,1 49 @/1,1,4'/+ 7CC; F6,- +/0&1,4'= ,' 1>+'= @+4A,(/- & N>-1,92,'EE+4>'( 14 @,/+*/ @/1,1,4'/+G- *4+@4+&1/ /H,-1/'*/ &- 14 I


12/19

"#

f@&+/'1M->5-,(,&+2 *4+@4+&1,4'-f 16/ 94+/E4,'E @+,'*,@0/- &'( (4*1+,'/- 9,'( ->,1&50/

&@@0,*&5,0,12 ,' 16/ *&-/ &1 5&+T &'(= ,1 6&A,'E 5//' -&1,-9&*14+,02 &'( ,'(>5,1&502 -643' 16&1 16/

-&,( +/0&1,4'-6,@- 6&( 5//' >-/( 14 @/+94+: */+1&,' 9>'*1,4'- '41 *6&+&*1/+,8/( 3,16

0/E,1,:&*2= 16,- C4>+1 9//0- &:@02 N>-1,9,/( 14 f@,/+*/ 16/ A/,0 49 *4+@4+&1/ /'1,12f &'( (,-+/E&+(

16/ -/@&+&1/ /H,-1/'*/ 49 16/ @&+/'1 &'( ->5-,(,&+2 16/ 0&11/+ 6&A,'E 5//' -4 *4'1+400/( 52 16/

@&+/'1 16&1 ,1- -/@&+&1/ ,(/'1,12 ,- 6&+(02 (,-*/+',50/ 16>- 5/*4:,'E & :/+/ ,'-1+>:/'1&0,12 4+

&01/+ /E4 49 16/ 94+:/+;

`; 59K9KJ;J 61 2N7WNIJ O-..QR

)J:;MNI>'*1= & 5>-,'/-- *4'(>,1= 4+ &01/+ /E4 49 & @/+-4'= 16/ :/+/

43'/+-6,@ 52 & -,'E0/ -14*Q640(/+ 49 /A/' &00 4+ '/&+02 &00 49 16/ *&@,1&0 -14*Q- 49 & *4+@4+&1,4'

,- '41 52 ,1-/09 & ->99,*,/'1 E+4>'( 14 (,-+/E&+( 16/ -/@&+&1/ *4+@4+&1/ @/+-4'&0,12;

89:;7<

K&:&:414 4+E&',8/( RIoJ #'1/+@+,-/- 36,*6 /'E&E/( ,' 0/&16/+ 1&'','E 364 16/' *6&'E/(

16/,+ '&:/ 14 ",-6,'4 2M4>1 16/ -6&+/- 49 -14*Q 49

K&:&:414; B>+,'E 16/ '/E41,&1,4'= 16/ *4>'-/0 49 16/ 5+416/+- ",-6,'4 &(A,-/( K&:&:414 ,' &0/11/+ -1&1,'E 16&1 K&:&:414 :&2 1&Q/ _ :&*6,'/+,/- 36,*6 6/ *4'1+,5>1/( 14 16/ *4:@&'2 ,9

6/ 3&'1/(= @+4A,(/( 16&1 16/ A&0>/ 49 ->*6 ,- (/(>*1/( 9+4: 6,- &'( RIoJG- *&@,1&0

*4'1+,5>1,4'- &'( 16&1 K&:&:414 3&- &-Q/( 14 E,A/ 6,- *4::/'1- *4'*/+','E 16/ 0/11/+; J'

16/ 5&-,- 49 16/ 0/11/+= K&:&:414 1+,/( 14 +/*4A/+ ->*6 :&*6,'/+,/- 36,*6 3/+/ +/9>-/( 52

",-6,'4;

K&:&:414 16/' 9,0/( 3,16 16/ .FC 94+ & 3+,1 49 +/@0/A,' 36,*6 3&- 16/' ,-->/(; ",-6,'4 *0&,:/(

16&1 16/ /?>,@:/'1 94+: @&+1 49 K&:&:414G- *&@,1&0 *4'1+,5>1,4' &'( -64>0( 5/ 1+/&1/( &-

*4+@4+&1/ @+4@/+12 &'( 16&1 16/ 0/11/+ 52 16/,+ &114+'/2 3&- N>-1 & :/+/ @+4@4-&0 *4'(,1,4'/(

4' 16/ -/00M4>1 49 K&:&:414 36,*6 @+4@4-&0 3&- 14 5/ &>164+,8/( 52 -14*Q640(/+- &'( 54&+( 49(,+/*14+-;

J' &@@/&0= CI +/A/+-/( .FC &'( *0&,:/( 16&1 )&*6,'/+,/- &'( /?>,@:/'1 *0&,:/( 52

K&:&:414 &+/ *4+@4+&1/ @+4@/+12 49 "


13/19

"$

*77=>7<

W; RJ" 16/ &(A,*/ ,' 16/ 0/11/+ 36/+/ K&:&:414 :&2 +/1+,/A/ 16/ /?>,@:/'1 36,*6 3/+/ @&+1

49 6,- ,'A/-1:/'1= 5,'( 16/ *4+@4+&1,4';

U; RJ" 16/ *4>+1 :&2 @,/+*/ 16/ A/,0 49 *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4';

?>@A<

W; "J; R,164>1 & D4&+( ./-40>1,4' &>164+,8,'E ",-6,'4 14 &*1 94+ &'( ,' 5/6&09 49 16/

*4+@4+&1,4'= 6/ *&''41 5,'( 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'; Y'(/+ C4+@4+&1,4' '0/-- 416/+3,-/

@+4A,(/(= *4+@4+&1/ @43/+- &+/ /H/+*,-/( 52 16/ D4&+(;

U; "J; K&:&:414 &+E>/- -4 &- 14 @,/+*/ 16/ A/,0 49 *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4'; ",-6,'4 5+416/+- &'(

K&:&:414 3/+/ 16/ 43'/+- 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'= 16/ @+/-/'*/ 49 16/ 416/+ -14*Q640(/+- 5/,'E

4'02 94+ 16/ @>+@4-/ 49 *4:@02,'E 3,16 16/ :,',:>: +/?>,+/:/'1- 49 16/ 0&3; C4>+-/ 49 &*1,4'16/ *4+@4+&1,4' 3,00 (4 (/@/'(- 4' 36&1 16/ 5+416/+- (/*,(/ &'( 16&1 16/ *4:@&'2; F6&1 16/

9&*1 16&1 @&+1,/- -1&+1/( &1 eXMVX +&1,4' &'( WXj 0/91 14 K&:&:414= (4/-'G1 :/&' 16&1 16/ UXj

3/'1 14 416/+-; $1 3/'1 14 $Q>4; K4-6,'45> 6&- '4 -&2 ,' 16/ 5>-,'/--; F6/+/ 3/+/ '4 416/+

:/:5/+- 49 16/ D4&+( 364 6&A/ '41 E,A/' 16/,+ &@@+4A&0;

R6,0/ 16/ A/,0 49 -/@&+&1/ *4+@4+&1/ @/+-4'&0,12 :&2 5/ @,/+*/( 36/' 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' ,- :/+/02

&' &(N>'*1= & 5>-,'/-- *4'(>,1= 4+ &01/+ /E4 49 & @/+-4'= 16/ :/+/ 43'/+-6,@ 52 & -,'E0/

-14*Q640(/+ 49 /A/' &00 4+ '/&+02 &00 49 16/ *&@,1&0 -14*Q- 49 & *4+@4+&1,4' ,- '41 52 ,1-/09 &

->99,*,/'1 E+4>'( 14 (,-+/E&+( 16/ -/@&+&1/*4+@4+&1/ @/+-4'&0,12;

F6/ /0/:/'1- 49 16/ (4*1+,'/ 49 @,/+*,'E 16/ A/,0 49 *4+@4+&1/ 9,*1,4' 940043S

W; C4'1+40= '41 :/+/ :&N4+,12 4+ *4:@0/1/ -14*Q *4'1+40= 5>1 *4:@0/1/ (4:,'&1,4'= '41 4'02 49

9,'&'*/- 5>1 49 @40,*2 &'( 5>-,'/-- @+&*1,*/ ,' +/-@/*1 14 16/ 1+&'-&*1,4' &11&*Q/( -4 16&1 16/

*4+@4+&1/ /'1,12 &- 14 16,- 1+&'-&*1,4' 6&( &1 16/ 1,:/ '4 -/@&+&1/ :,'(= 3,00 4+ /H,-1/'*/ 49 ,1-

43'T

U; L>*6 *4'1+40 :>-1 6&A/ 5//' >-/( 52 16/ (/9/'(&'1 14 *4::,1 9+&>( 4+ 3+4'E= 14

@/+@/1>&1/ 16/ A,40&1,4' 49 & -1&1>14+2 4+ 416/+ @4-,1,A/ 0/E&0 (>12= 4+ (,-64'/-1 &'( >'N>-1 &*1

,' *4'1+&A/'1,4' 49 16/ @0&,'1,99h- 0/E&0 +,E61-T &'(

V; F6/ &94+/-&,( *4'1+40 &'( 5+/&*6 49 (>12 :>-1 @+4H,:&1/02 *&>-/ 16/ ,'N>+2 4+ >'N>-1 04--

*4:@0&,'/( 49;

F6/ &5-/'*/ 49 &'2 4'/ 49 16/-/ /0/:/'1- @+/A/'1- f@,/+*,'E 16/ *4+@4+&1/ A/,0;f $' &@@02,'E

16/ p,'-1+>:/'1&0,12h 4+ p&01/+ /E4h (4*1+,'/= 16/ *4>+1- &+/ *4'*/+'/( 3,16 +/&0,12 &'( '41 94+:=

3,16 643 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' 4@/+&1/( &'( 16/ ,'(,A,(>&0 (/9/'(&'1h- +/0&1,4'-6,@ 14 16&1

4@/+&1,4';f $' +/0&1,4' 14 16/ -/*4'( /0/:/'1= 14 (,-+/E&+( 16/ -/@&+&1/ N>+,(,*&0 @/+-4'&0,12 49


14/19

"%

& *4+@4+&1,4'= 16/ 3+4'E(4,'E 4+ >'N>-1 &*1 ,' *4'1+&A/'1,4' 49 & @0&,'1,99h- 0/E&0 +,E61- :>-1 5/

*0/&+02 &'( *4'A,'*,'E02 /-1&50,-6/(T ,1 *&''41 5/ @+/->:/(; R,164>1 & (/:4'-1+&1,4' 16&1 &'2

49 16/ /A,0- -4>E61 14 5/ @+/A/'1/( 52 16/ (4*1+,'/,- @+/-/'1= ,1 (4/- '41 &@@02;q $' 16/ *&-/ &1

5&+= 16/+/ ,- '4 -643,'E 16&1 ",-6,'4 >-/( 16/ -/@&+&1/ @/+-4'&0,12 49 "'N>-102 &*1 4+ (4

3+4'E 14 K&:&:414 ,' *4'1+&A/'1,4' 49 6,- 0/E&0 +,E61-; R6/+/94+/= @/1,1,4' ,- B#"$#B;

/.1 ?*F5*(4) #(&4,5 67 !&

89:;7,1 3&- 9,0/( &E&,'-1 /84' C,12= &'( @/1,1,4'/+ \,MK,/0( ./&012= $'*; O\,MK,/0(P;

!/1,1,4'/+ :4A/( 14 (,-:,-- 16/ @/1,1,4' 4' E+4>'(- 49 ,:@+4@/+ A/'>/ &'( @&2:/'1 49

,'->99,*,/'1 (4*Q/1 9//-; F6/ .FC (/',/( -&,( :41,4' ,' &' J+(/+ (&1/( d&'>&+2 UU= UXXg; F6/

1+,&0 *4>+1 6/0( 16&1 16/ *&-/ 3&-= ,' '&1>+/= & +/&0 &*1,4' ,' 16/ 94+: 49 & (/+,A&1,A/ ->,1

*4E',8&50/ 52 & -@/*,&0 *4::/+*,&0 *4>+1 @>+->&'1 14 I(:,',-1+&1,A/ )&11/+ "4; XXMWWMXVMLC;

!/1,1,4'/+ -4>E61 +/*4'-,(/+&1,4'= 5>1 ,1- :41,4' 3&- (/',/(;

*77=>


15/19

"&

5P 6/ 6&- 1+,/( 14 /H6&>-1 ,'1+&M*4+@4+&1/ +/:/(,/-= ,;/;= 6&- :&(/ & (/:&'( 4' 16/ 54&+( 49

(,+/*14+- 94+ 16/ &@@+4@+,&1/ +/0,/9 5>1 16/ 0&11/+ 6&- 9&,0/( 4+ +/9>-/( 14 6//( 6,- @0/&T &'(

*P 16/ *&>-/ 49 &*1,4' &*1>&002 (/A40A/- 4' 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'= 16/ 3+4'E(4,'E 4+ 6&+: 6&A,'E

5//'= 4+ 5/,'E *&>-/( 14 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' &'( '41 14 16/ @&+1,*>0&+ -14*Q640(/+ 5+,'E,'E 16/ ->,1;

Z4+ & (/+,A&1,A/ ->,1 14 @+4-@/+= 16/ :,'4+,12 -14*Q640(/+ ->,'E 94+ &'( 4' 5/6&09 49 16/

*4+@4+&1,4' :>-1 &00/E/ ,' 6,- *4:@0&,'1 16&1 6/ ,- ->,'E 4' & (/+,A&1,A/ *&>-/ 49 &*1,4' 4'

5/6&09 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' &'( &00 416/+ -14*Q640(/+- -,:,0&+02 -,1>&1/( 364 :&2 3,-6 14 N4,' 6,:

,' 16/ ->,1T 16&1 /&+'/-1 /994+1- 3/+/ :&(/ 14 +/&*6 & *4:@+4:,-/ &:4'E 9&:,02

:/:5/+-^-14*Q640(/+- 5/94+/ 6/ 9,0/( 16/ *&-/; F6/ C4>+1 9,'(- 16&1 .45/+14 6&( -&1,-9,/(

16/-/ +/?>,+/:/'1-;

R6,0/ ,1 ,- 1+>/ 16&1 16/ *4:@0&,','E -14*Q640(/+ :>-1 -&1,-9&*14+,02 -643 16&1 6/ 6&- /H6&>-1/(

&00 :/&'- 14 +/(+/-- 6,- E+,/A&'*/- 3,16,' 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'T ->*6 +/:/(2 ,- '4 04'E/+ '/*/--&+2

36/+/ 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' ,1-/09 ,- >'(/+ 16/ *4:@0/1/ *4'1+40 49 16/ @/+-4' &E&,'-1 364: 16/ ->,1,- 5/,'E 9,0/(; F6/ +/&-4' ,- 45A,4>-S & (/:&'( >@4' 16/ 54&+( 14 ,'-1,1>1/ &' &*1,4' &'(

@+4-/*>1/ 16/ -&:/ /99/*1,A/02 34>0( 6&A/ 5//' >-/0/-- &'( &' /H/+*,-/ ,' 9>1,0,12;

\/+/= .45/+14 &00/E/( ,' 6,- @/1,1,4' 16&1 /&+'/-1 /994+1- 3/+/ :&(/ 14 +/&*6 & *4:@+4:,-/

&:4'E 9&:,02 :/:5/+-^-14*Q640(/+- 5/94+/ 6/ 9,0/( 16/ *&-/; \/ &0-4 :&,'1&,'/( 16&1 '/ WX= W`Ù=

36/' 16/ 9,+-1 :4+1E&E/ (//( 3&- /H/*>1/( >'1,0 d>02 UV= UXXU= 36/' 16/ @+4@/+1,/- :4+1E&E/(

3/+/ 94+/*04-/(= 16/ D4&+( 49 B,+/*14+- 49 \FL$ (,( '416,'E 14 +/*1,92 16/ &00/E/( >'&>164+,8/(

1+&'-&*1,4'- 49 29;NJI9@ D9IX 671 &IAM9A9 (@>:;MN: Y (ISNI>>MNIS !J1 O-..-R

89:;7<

J' Ua I>E>-1 Wè_= 16/ !6,0,@@,'/ '&1,4'&0 D&'Q O!"DP &*?>,+/( 16/ &--/1- 49 16/ !&:@&'E&

L>E&+ ),00- O!ILY)$

01,:&1/02

14 '&1,4'&0,8/ &'( *4'-40,(&1/ ,1- ,'1/+/-1 ,' 416/+ !"D *4'1+400/( ->E&+ :,00-;

!+,4+ 14 U` J*145/+ WèW= !ILY)$< /'E&E/( 16/ -/+A,*/- 49 16/ I'(+&(& #0/*1+,* r #'E,'//+,'E

C4:@&'2 OI##CP 94+ /0/*1+,*&0 +/3,'(,'E &'( +/@&,+= :4-1 49 36,*6 3/+/ @&+1,&002 @&,( 52

!ILY)$'1- 3,16 I##C; J' U` J*145/+ WèW= I##C &'( !ILY)$<

/'1/+/( ,'14 & *4'1+&*1 94+ I##C 14 @/+94+: 16/ C4'-1+>*1,4' 49 & @43/+ 64>-/ 5>,0(,'ET

+/,'94+*/( *4'*+/1/ 94>'(&1,4' 94+ V >',1- V_X oR (,/-/0 /'E,'/ E/'/+&1,'E -/1-= +/,'94+*/(

*4'*+/1/ 94>'(&1,4' 94+ 16/ _=XXX oR &'( W=U_X oR 1>+54 E/'/+&14+ -/1-= &:4'E 416/+-; I-,(/


16/19

"'

9+4: 16/ 34+Q *4'1+&*1= !ILY)$< +/?>,+/( I##C 14 @/+94+: /H1+& 34+Q= &'( @+4A,(/ /0/*1+,*&0

/?>,@:/'1 &'( -@&+/ @&+1-; J>1 49 16/ 141&0 450,E&1,4' 49 !eee=UaV;iX= !ILY)$< 6&( @&,( 4'02

!U_X=XXX;XX= 0/&A,'E &' >'@&,( 5&0&'*/= &- 49 Ue d>'/ WèV= &:4>'1,'E 14 !_Ue=UaV;iX; J>1 49

-&,( >'@&,( 5&0&'*/ 49 !_Ue=UaV;iX= !ILY)$< :&(/ & @&+1,&0 @&2:/'1 14 I##C 49 !Wg=XXX;XX=

,' 5+4Q/' &:4>'1-= *4A/+,'E 16/ @/+,4( 9+4: _ d&'>&+2 Wèg >@ 14 UV )&2 Wèg= 0/&A,'E &'

>'@&,( 5&0&'*/ 49 !_WV=UaV;iX;

!ILY)$< &'( !"D= &'( '43 "ILYB#CJ= &00/E/(02 9&,0/( &'( +/9>-/( 14 @&2 I##C 16/,+ N>-1=

A&0,( &'( (/:&'(&50/ 450,E&1,4'; F6/ !+/-,(/'1 49 16/ "ILYB#CJ ,- &0-4 16/ k,*/M!+/-,(/'1 49

16/ !"D; I##C 5/-4>E61 -&,( 499,*,&0 14 @&2 16/ 4>1-1&'(,'E 450,E&1,4' 49 !ILY)$99/+/( &*1>&0 (&:&E/- ,' 16/ 141&0 &:4>'1 49 !_WV=UaV;iXT &'( 16&1 ,' 4+(/+14 +/*4A/+ 16/-/ ->:-= I##C 3&- *4:@/00/( 14 /'E&E/ 16/ @+49/--,4'&0 -/+A,*/- 49 *4>'-/0= 14

364: I##C &E+//( 14 @&2 & ->: /?>,A&0/'1 14 U_j 49 16/ &:4>'1 49 16/ 450,E&1,4' (>/ 52 3&2

49 &114+'/2h- 9//-;

!"D &'( "ILYB#CJ 9,0/( & N4,'1 :41,4' 14 (,-:,-- 4' 16/ E+4>'( 16&1 16/ *4:@0&,'1 9&,0/( 14

-1&1/ ->99,*,/'1 &00/E&1,4'- 14 /-1&50,-6 & *&>-/ 49 &*1,4' &E&,'-1 !"D &'( "ILYB#CJ= ,'&-:>*6

&- 16/+/ ,- 0&*Q 4+ 3&'1 49 @+,A,12 49 *4'1+&*1 5/13//' 16/ 16/: &'( I##C; L&,( :41,4' 3&-

(/',/( 52 16/ 1+,&0 *4>+1 ,' ,1- Ue "4A/:5/+ 4+(/+= &'( 4+(/+/( !"D '&( "ILYB#CJ 14 9,0/ 16/,+

&'-3/+- 3,16,' W_ (&2-; I91/+ (>/ @+4*//(,'E-= 16/ F+,&0 C4>+1 +/'(/+/( N>(E:/'1 ,' 9&A4+ 49

I##C &'( &E&,'-1 !"D= "ILYB#CJ &'( !ILY)$002 @&,(T OUP 16/ ->: 49 !WXU=eUg;ea &-

&114+'/2h- 9//-T &'(= OVP C4-1-; !"D &'( "ILYB#CJ &@@/&0/(; F6/ C4>+1 49 I@@/&0- &99,+:/(

16/ (/*,-,4' 49 16/ 1+,&0 *4>+1 ,' ,1- (/*,-,4' 49 We I@+,0 UXXX; !"D &'( "ILYB#CJ 9,0/( 16/

@/1,1,4' 94+ +/A,/3;

*77=><

RJ" !"D &'( "ILYB#CJ :&2 5/ 6/0( 0,&50/ 94+ !ILY)$@A


17/19

"(

49 16/ !6,0,@@,'/- OBD!P= 3,00 '41 :&Q/ !"D 0,&50/ 94+ 16/ !ILY)$+S

OWP *4'1+40 ] '41 :/+/ -14*Q *4'1+40= 5>1 *4:@0/1/ (4:,'&1,4' ] '41 4'02 49 9,'&'*/-= 5>1 49@40,*2 &'( 5>-,'/-- @+&*1,*/ ,' +/-@/*1 14 16/ 1+&'-&*1,4' &11&*Q/(= :>-1 6&A/ 5//' ->*6 16&1

16/ *4+@4+&1/ /'1,12 &- 14 16,- 1+&'-&*1,4' 6&( &1 16/ 1,:/ '4 -/@&+&1/ :,'(= 3,00 4+ /H,-1/'*/ 49

,1- 43'T OUP ->*6 *4'1+40 :>-1 6&A/ 5//' >-/( 52 16/ (/9/'(&'1 14 *4::,1 & 9+&>( 4+ & 3+4'E

14 @/+@/1>&1/ 16/ A,40&1,4' 49 & -1&1>14+2 4+ 416/+ @4-,1,A/ 0/E&0 (>12= 4+ & (,-64'/-1 &'( &'

>'N>-1 &*1 ,' *4'1+&A/'1,4' 49 @0&,'1,99h- 0/E&0 +,E61T &'( OVP 16/ -&,( *4'1+40 &'( 5+/&*6 49 (>12

:>-1 6&A/ @+4H,:&1/02 *&>-/( 16/ ,'N>+2 4+ >'N>-1 04-- *4:@0&,'/( 49;

F6/ &5-/'*/ 49 16/ 94+/E4,'E /0/:/'1- ,' 16/ @+/-/'1 *&-/ @+/*0>(/- 16/ @,/+*,'E 49 16/

*4+@4+&1/ A/,0; Z,+-1= 416/+ 16&' 16/ 9&*1 16&1 !"D &'( "ILYB#CJ &*?>,+/( 16/ &--/1- 49

!ILY)$+,(,*&0 @/+-4'&0,12 3&- >-/( 14 *4::,1 &

9+&>( 4+ 14 (4 & 3+4'ET 4+ 16&1 16/ -/@&+&1/ *4+@4+&1/ /'1,12 3&- 9&+*,*&002 >-/( &- & :/+/ &01/+

/E4= 5>-,'/-- *4'(>,1 4+ ,'-1+>:/'1&0,12 49 &'416/+ /'1,12 4+ @/+-4'; F6,+(= I##C 3&- '41

(/9+&>(/( 4+ ,'N>+/( 36/' !"D &'( "ILYB#CJ &*?>,+/( 16/ &--/1- 49 !ILY)$,-,1,4' 49 16/ 94+/*04-/( &--/1-= !ILY)$< 6&(

@+/A,4>-02 :&(/ @&+1,&0 @&2:/'1- 14 I##C 94+ 16/ 94+:/+h- 450,E&1,4' ,' 16/ &:4>'1 49

!eee=UaV;iX; I- 49 Ue d>'/ WèV= !ILY)$< 6&( @&,( !U_X=XXX 14 I##C &'(= 9+4: _ d&'>&+2

Wèg 14 UV )&2 Wèg= &'416/+ !Wg=XXX; "/,16/+ (,( !"D /H@+/--02 4+ ,:@0,/(02 &E+// 14 &-->:/

16/ (/51 49 !ILY)$< 14 I##C; V>7 61 #,! JZ 39X9;N O-..QR

89:;7<

!/1,1,4'/+ &'( @+,A&1/ +/-@4'(/'1 3/+/ -,50,'E- 14E/16/+ 3,16 134 416/+-= '&:/02 !/(+4 &'(

I'&-1&*,&= ,' & 9&:,02 5>-,'/-- /-1&50,-6/( &- t/',16 $'->+&'*/ C4+@4+&1,4' Ot/',16P= 9+4: 36,*6

16/2 43'/( -6&+/- 49 -14*Q-; !/(+4 &'( I'&-1&*,& ->5-/?>/'102 (,/(; F6/ 94+:/+ 6&( 6,- /-1&1/

N>(,*,&002 @&+1,1,4'/( &:4'E 6,- 6/,+-= 5>1 16/ 0&11/+ 6&( '41 :&(/ 16/ -&:/ ,' 6/+ -6&+/640(,'E

,' t/',16;


18/19

")

t/',16 &'( .4(+,E4 9,0/( & *4:@0&,'1 3,16 16/ L/*>+,1,/- &'( #H*6&'E/ C4::,--,4' OL#CP &E&,'-1

@/1,1,4'/+ OWP & (/+,A&1,A/ ->,1 14 451&,' &**4>'1,'E 49 9>'(- &'( &--/1- 49 t/',16= &'( OUP 14

(/1/+:,'/ 16/ -6&+/- 49 -14*Q 49 (/*/&-/( !/(+4 &'( I'&-1&*,& 16&1 3/+/ &+5,1+&+,02 &'(

9+&>(>0/'102 &@@+4@+,&1/( l52 J-*&+= &'( 3/+/ >'&**4>'1/( 94+m; $' 6,- &'-3/+ 3,16

*4>'1/+*0&,:= @/1,1,4'/+ (/',/( 16/ ,00/E&0,12 49 16/ &*?>,-,1,4' 49 -6&+/- 49 I'&-1&*,& &'(

?>/-1,4'/( 16/ N>+,-(,*1,4' 49 L#C 14 /'1/+1&,' 16/ *4:@0&,'1 5/*&>-/ ,1 @/+1&,'- 14 -/110/:/'1

49 lI'&-1&*,&G-m /-1&1/; F6/ *&-/ 3&- 1+&'-9/++/( 14; !/1,1,4'/+ 9,0/( )41,4' 14 B/*0&+/

C4:@0&,'1 &- ">,-&'*/ 4+ \&+&--:/'1 L>,1 &'( :>-1 5/ (,-:,--/(; .FC (/',/( 16/ :41,4'; F6/

:41,4' 3&- /0/A&1/( 14 16/ C4>+1 49 I@@/&0- 52 3&2 49 @/1,1,4' 94+ */+1,4+&+,= @+46,5,1,4' &'(

:&'(&:>-= 5>1 3&- &E&,' (/',/(;

*77=>7<

W; RJ" .4(+,E4 :&2 5/ *4'-,(/+/( & -14*Q640(/+ 49 t/',16 3,16 +/-@/*1 14 16/ -6&+/640(,'E-

4+,E,'&002 5/04'E,'E 14 I'&-1&*,&;

U; RJ" 16/+/ ,- &' ,'1+&M*4+@4+&1/ +/0&1,4'-6,@ 5/13//' 16/ @&+1,/- 16&1 34>0( *6&+&*1/+,8/16/ *&-/ &- &' ,'1+&M*4+@4+&1/ (,-@>1/;

V; RJ" 16/ *4:@0&,'1 ,- & (/+,A&1,A/ ->,1 3,16,' 16/ N>+,-(,*1,4' 49 16/ .FC &*1,'E &- & -@/*,&0

*4::/+*,&0 *4>+1;

?>@A<

W; "J; .4(+,E4 :>-1= 6>+(0/ 134 45-1&*0/- 5/94+/ 6/ *&' 5/ *4'-,(/+/( & -14*Q640(/+ 49 t/',16

3,16 +/-@/*1 14 16/ -6&+/640(,'E- 4+,E,'&002 5/04'E,'E 14 I'&-1&*,&; +,%-# = 6/ :>-1 @+4A/ 16&1

16/+/ &+/ -6&+/640(,'E- 16&1 3,00 5/ 0/91 14 6,: &'( 6,- *4M6/,+-= &'( 16,- *&' 5/ (/1/+:,'/(

4'02 ,' & -/110/:/'1 49 16/ (/*/(/'1G- /-1&1/; "4 ->*6 @+4*//(,'E 6&- 5//' *4::/'*/( 14(&1/; .$/(01 = 6/ :>-1 +/E,-1/+ 16/ 1+&'-9/+ 49 16/ -6&+/- &00411/( 14 6,: 14 :&Q/ ,1 5,'(,'E

&E&,'-1 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'; \/ *&''41 (/:&'( 16&1 16,- 5/ (4'/ >'0/-- &'( >'1,0 6/ 6&-

/-1&50,-6/( 6,- -@/*,9,* &0041:/'1 O&'( 2%,3! 4!/,$ 43'/+-6,@P 49 16/ -6&+/-; R,164>1 16/

-/110/:/'1 49 I'&-1&*,&G- /-1&1/= 16/+/ *&' 5/ '4 (/9,',1/ @&+1,1,4' &'( (,-1+,5>1,4' 49 16/

/-1&1/ 14 16/ 6/,+-; R,164>1 16/ @&+1,1,4' &'( (,-1+,5>1,4'= 16/+/ *&' 5/ '4 +/E,-1+&1,4' 49 16/

1+&'-9/+; I'( 3,164>1 16/ +/E,-1+&1,4'= 3/ *&''41 *4'-,(/+ 16/ 1+&'-9/+//M6/,+ & -14*Q640(/+

364 :&2 ,'A4Q/ 16/ /H,-1/'*/ 49 &' ,'1+&M*4+@4+&1/ +/0&1,4'-6,@ &- @+/:,-/ 94+ &' ,'1+&M

*4+@4+&1/ *4'1+4A/+-2 3,16,' 16/ N>+,-(,*1,4' 49 & -@/*,&0 *4::/+*,&0 *4>+1; F6/ ->5N/*1 -6&+/-

49 -14*Q O,;/;= I'&-1&*,&G- -6&+/-P &+/ *4'*/+'/( [ .4(+,E4 *&''41 5/ *4'-,(/+/( & -14*Q640(/+

49 t/',16;

U; "J; C4>+1 *&''41 (/*0&+/ 16&1 &' ,'1+&M*4+@4+&1/ +/0&1,4'-6,@ /H,-1- 16&1 34>0( -/+A/ &- 5&-,-

14 5+,'E 16,- *&-/ 3,16,' 16/ -@/*,&0 *4::/+*,&0 *4>+1G- N>+,-(,*1,4' >'(/+ L/*1,4' _O5P 49 !B

`XUMI= &- &:/'(/( 5/*&>-/ .4(+,E4G- *4:@0&,'1 9&,0/( 16/ +/0&1,4'-6,@ 1/-1 &54A/;

V; "J; F6/ &00/E&1,4'- 49 16/ @+/-/'1 *4:@0&,'1 (4 '41 &:4>'1 14 & (/+,A&1,A/ ->,1; +,%-# = &-

&0+/&(2 (,-*>--/( &54A/= .4(+,E4 ,- '41 & -6&+/640(/+ 3,16 +/-@/*1 14 16/ -6&+/640(,'E-

4+,E,'&002 5/04'E,'E 14 I'&-1&*,&T 6/ 4'02 -1&'(- &- & 1+&'-9/+//M6/,+ 364-/ +,E61- 14 16/ -6&+/


19/19

"*

&+/ ,'*64&1/ &'( >'+/*4+(/(; .$/(01 = ,' 4+(/+ 16&1 & -14*Q640(/+ :&2 -643 & +,E61 14 ->/ 4'

5/6&09 49 16/ *4+@4+&1,4'= 6/ :>-1 &00/E/ 3,16 -4:/ @&+1,*>0&+,12 ,' 6,- *4:@0&,'1 16&1 6/ 6&-

/H6&>-1/( 6,- +/:/(,/- 5,#6,0 #6$ /(%2(%!#,(0 52 :&Q,'E & ->99,*,/'1 (/:&'( >@4' 16/

(,+/*14+- 4+ 416/+ 499,*/+- 94+ &@@+4@+,&1/ +/0,/9 3,16 16/ /H@+/--/( ,'1/'1 14 ->/ ,9 +/0,/9 ,-

(/',/(; 7!-#"8 = C4>+1 94>'( '4 ,'N>+2= &*1>&0 4+ 16+/&1/'/(= &00/E/( 14 6&A/ 5//' (4'/ 14 16/

*4+@4+&1,4' (>/ 14 J-*&+G- &*1-; $9 ,'(//( 6/ ,00/E&002 &'( 9+&>(>0/'102 1+&'-9/++/( I'&-1&*,&G-

-6&+/- ,' 6,- 43' '&:/= 16/' 16/ (&:&E/ ,- '41 14 16/ *4+@4+&1,4' 5>1 14 6,- *4M6/,+-T 16/

3+4'E9>0 1+&'-9/+ (,( '41 &99/*1 16/ *&@,1&0 -14*Q 4+ 16/ &--/1- 49 t/',16;

$' ->::&+2= 36/16/+ &- &' ,'(,A,(>&0 4+ &- & (/+,A&1,A/ ->,1= 16/ .FC [ -,11,'E &- -@/*,&0

*4::/+*,&0 *4>+1 [ 6&- '4 N>+,-(,*1,4' 14 6/&+ .4(+,E4G- *4:@0&,'1 -,'*/ 36&1 ,- ,'A40A/( ,- 16/

(/1/+:,'&1,4' &'( (,-1+,5>1,4' 49 ->**/--,4'&0 +,E61- 14 16/ -6&+/640(,'E- 49 I'&-1&*,&

./2/-; .4(+,E4G- @+4@/+ +/:/(2= >'(/+ 16/ *,+*>:-1&'*/-= ,- 14 ,'-1,1>1/ & -@/*,&0 @+4*//(,'E

94+ 16/ -/110/:/'1 49 16/ /-1&1/ 49 16/ (/*/&-/( I'&-1&*,& ./2/-= & :4A/ 16&1 ,- '41 94+/*04-/(

52 16/ (,-:,--&0 49 6,- @+/-/'1 *4:@0&,'1;

Documents

Corpo Case Digests 2016.pdf