Upload
savana-minson
View
220
Download
2
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
COR 401Lecture #11 Mechanisms of
InheritanceFebruary 17, 2009
German biologist/artist Ernst Haeckel (1834-1919),
Moore: If the
hypothesis of evolution
is true, only those
variations that are inherited
will be important
Even Aristotle knew about sex – But how is sex related to
Wallace and Darwin?:
Mechanism of Inheritance
Aristotle’s“Historia Animalium”
~350 BC
Aristotle’s Query:
What is it exactly that parents transmit to their offspring?
Aristotle’sMale Semen/Female Blood
CoagulumTheory
A Cheesy Analogy
Male Semen (bearing “movement”) Sets the Female Semen (bearing
“substance”)
Milk + Rennet = Cheese
Aristotle knew there was something up with the egg
Oviparous Viviparous
Aristotle’s Embryology
Chick EmbryologyTime Lapse
Video
http://www.exploratorium.edu/traits/more.html
48 vs 72 hr Chick Embryos
“Blood is formed out of something that is not blood”
Aristotle’s Theory of Epigenesis
Moore: Parents transmit not structures to their offspring but “information” (p 424)
Pangenesis: Every part of the adult body contributes some specific material to the semen
which then configures the offspring
If so:
How are they packaged to allow for multiple kids?
Why not produce 2 every time?
?
?
Aristotle:Modern
Man in a
Toga?
Fast Forward: 17th-18th C & Preformation
Hartsoeker’s Humunculus (1694)
Malphigi’s 2-Day Chick Embryo
1692
How could structures appear in the course of development from structureless material?
12th C Virgin and ChildTurkey
Epigenesis vs PreformationBut if Preformist Theory is true:
How can offspring be intermediate?
Why this?And
not this?
If both sperm and egg preformed, why not 2 every time?
?
Epigenesis vs PreformationBut if Preformist Theory is true:
How to explain regeneration?
How to conceptualize
Infinite regress?
If all from Eve, what about
Human Variability
What about Dawkins’ Recipe and Blueprint Analogy ?
Which of the Following Statements Best Describes the Analogy:
1. A blueprint is like a scaled down version of an adult, whereas a recipe if obeyed in the right order will
result in an adult.2. The blueprint corresponds one-to-one with the finished product
whereas there is no one-to-one correspondence between recipe and final product.
3. A blueprint implies set purpose and design, whereas a recipe can deviate from the end product depending on the materials and tools available in the kitchen.
4. Of the two, the comparison between epigenesis and recipe is more valid given the strong implication of the importance of
process – it’s all about information driving form/structure
Discovery of cells
Robert Hooke’s Compound Microscope
Discovery of cells
Van Leeuwenhoek’s Simple Microscope
1632-1723
Blending Inheritance:Offspring are an average of parents
Mom Dad
But then where do Darwin’s adaptations come from?
Gregor Mendel 1822-1884
Traits are controlled by heritable “factors” that we now call genes
Summary• Aristotle performed the groundwork in
suggesting that it is information, not structure that is inherited
• Aristotle’s epigenesis was challenged by Pangenesis and Preformist Thinkers
• Microscopes, put Preformist thought to rest • Darwin struggled with Blending Inheritance
as a mechanism by which adaptation would prevail in the struggle for existence.
• But it was Mendel who allowed us to understand the gene and its mode of inheritance.