Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    1/23

    Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and beyond

    David Smith and Stephanie Hawke

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    2/23

    i

    Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and beyond

    Summary

    The impact of last years Comprehensive Spending Review has meant the dissolution of the

    extended services infrastructure within local authority. As a result it is the responsibility of individual

    schools to choose whether to continue to find funding to engage Extended Services Coordinators,

    whether to work together in clusters and which particular schools to partner with in this way. This

    report collates the findings of five interviews, four of which were conducted with Extended Services

    Coordinators and the remaining with a head teacher leading a cluster. What this report

    demonstrates is that there are more differences than similarities in the way that schools are working

    together. The waning emphasis on the achievement of an extended services core offer means that

    these initiatives are no longer the driving force for cluster working that they have been during the

    last six years.

    A headteacher of a Lancashire primary school flags up a number of ways in which schools are

    working together and their reasons for doing so, such as Local Childrens Trust Partnerships,

    Learning Trusts, and Sports Partnerships (all of which are summarized in Appendix 6.1 Glossary of

    terms). The interview is summarised in section 2.1.

    For Extended Services Coordinators, situations vary. One coordinator of a primary schools cluster

    (2.2), explains funding for her role is only secure until February 2012 meaning she is only able to plan

    for the next six months. For another interviewee, an extended services coordinator in the east ofEngland (2.3), funding was cut in April 2011 but her cluster of schools valued her work enough to

    commit their devolved extended services budget to employing her on a freelance basis. She has

    already developed a range of exciting partnerships and projects to help meet the schools needs.

    Two interviews were conducted with extended services coordinators in secondary schools, in

    Pennine Lancashire (interviews are summarised in 3.1 and 3.2). In the last year, neither had

    developed significant work with their clusters, and they described a situation of isolation, with their

    energy focused on the attraction of exciting after school activities to appeal to their own pupils and

    their families. Funding for one of these posts is secure until August, whereas the others school has

    attached great value to his work and are committed to keeping him.

    Each of these interviews worked to foreground the importance of funding and of personal

    relationships. Clusters are formed around a funding purpose along with trust and individual

    personalities. If head teachers get along, they will work collaboratively. If they have developed a

    long and trusting relationship with their extended services coordinator, they will strive to maintain

    the relationship. Recommendations in section 4 suggest there is potential to galvanise schools into

    cluster working if it is possible to signpost available funding and inspiring projects from which a

    collaborative approach will benefit.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    3/23

    ii

    Contents

    1. Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 1

    2 Primary Schools ............................................................................................................................... 1

    2.1 Headteacher ............................................................................................................................ 1

    2.2 Extended services coordinator for primary schools. .............................................................. 2

    2.3 Primary school clusters beyond Pennine Lancashire .............................................................. 4

    3 Secondary Schools .......................................................................................................................... 7

    3.1 Extended services coordinator with a high school ................................................................. 7

    3.2 Extended services and attendance officer at a local high school ........................................... 9

    4. Recommendations ........................................................................................................................... 11

    5. Conclusions ....................................................................................................................................... 11

    6. Appendices ........................................................................................................................................ 12

    6.1 Glossary of terms ........................................................................................................................ 12

    6.1.1 Extended Services ......................................................................................................... 12

    6.1.2 Local Childrens Trust Partnerships............................................................................... 12

    6.1.3 Future Learning Trust .................................................................................................... 12

    6.1.4 Sports Partnerships ....................................................................................................... 12

    6.1.5 Disadvantaged subsidy .................................................................................................. 12

    6.1.6 Local Area Partnerships ................................................................................................ 13

    6.2 Interview Questions .............................................................................................................. 14

    6.3 Local Area Needs ................................................................................................................... 15

    6.4 Letter from Mr Gove ............................................................................................................. 17

    7. Other references .............................................................................................................................. 20

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    4/23

    1

    1. IntroductionThis report explores the motivations and limitations of schools working in clusters as funding for

    Extended Schools Cluster Coordinators ends or has ended. It draws on conversations with fourExtended Schools Coordinators and one head teacher alongside desk-based research. The report

    sets out to:

    identify objectives of those working with Extended Schools Services and / or clusters identify why and how schools are coming together as clusters explore the relationship between extended schools and clusters and their Local

    Education Authority

    Questions asked of those interviewed can be found in section 6.2.

    2 Primary SchoolsConversations were held with a head teacher and two extended services coordinators. Each will be

    recounted below, with recommendations and conclusions to follow in sections 4 and 5 below.

    2.1HeadteacherThis conversation was held with a primary school headteacher, who said, In my experience the

    smaller clusters work best because they are more manageable in organisation terms. Faith school

    clusters in particular seem to be successful because of a shared belief and understanding but the

    success for all cluster work is heavily dependent on the personalities involved. A strong support

    structure is necessary whatever the cluster where support means commitment of staff time or the

    investment in a coordinator for whatever programme of work has been agreed

    For this interviewee, clusters tend to given purpose, meaning and life by the existence of external

    funding.

    Local clusters

    Local clusters were described. Those with an extended services focus were no longer functioning. An

    excellence in schools cluster existed but funding was limited to the current year. One cluster was

    led by the local high school as a family with head meeting one each half term for lunch paid for by

    the high school with a shared agenda. This cluster was described as having a team approach and no

    one school dominated its agenda. High value was attached to community profile of the cluster, with

    community based activity such as National Poop School Week becoming a driver for shared

    working.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    5/23

    2

    The cluster worked to make the most of shared opportunities such as high school staff working with

    primary schools to support modern foreign language teaching. The high school also shared its mini-

    bus with the cluster.

    Frustration can arise when schools are dealing with multiple agendas such as the Futures Learning

    Trust, Burnley Schools Sports Partnership and so on. A future Learning Trust (see Appendix 7.1,

    paragraph 7.1.3)) has been set up locally. The Trust partners include the Life Channel and the local

    Football Club and a regional University joined the newly established Trust this September. Each

    school is unique with significant strengths and qualities that the Trust will build on with a desire to

    improve aspirations to ensure each school reaches its true potential. Trust schools is the opportunity

    to sustain existing and develop new relations as well as bring a new perspective and dimension to

    what the schools are trying to achieve and the chance to do things differently.

    Projects underway include:

    Developing an innovative educational approach to outdoor learning. The Life Channel issupporting all schools in developing their outdoor environment in a number of ways.

    One of these is for the children to invest their pocket money to purchase and plant a

    tree in order to offset their carbon footprint. This is a project introduced to the schools

    by Life Channel involving one of its partners, Toshiba.

    Futures Learning Trust Youth Parliament. Four members from each school council havebeen voted onto the new Trust Parliament to ensure the pupil voice, shape the

    activities, address issues and recommend solutions.

    Partners benefit too and the football clubs physiotherapist is lecturing Universitystudents with exciting plans to develop work on nutrition in support of pupils andpartners.

    A local Schools Sports Partnership operates as a set of six clusters with a coordinator in the base

    school responsible for its own family. In addition further education colleges have joined the

    cluster.

    2.2Extended services coordinator for primary schools.This extended services coordinatorsbrief comes directly from the Clusters head teachers. She is

    tasked with:

    Encouraging parental involvement in schools Developing activities supporting literacy and numeracy for children (a high priority) Developing a range of activities related to family learning, contributing to improvements

    in literacy and numeracy thereby allowing children to enjoy and achieve

    Developing activities to meet the same outcomes in school holiday times. Developing activities that relate to the childrens interests and uncovering those

    interests through surveys.

    Encouraging long-term parental involvement in childrens learning.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    6/23

    3

    Engaging parents in school and in courses that invest in their long term ability to helptheir children with literacy and numeracy. Many parents struggle with language.

    Consultation and planning

    In the short term, she has planned activities up to October Half term with a focus on after schoolclubs. The head teachers met to discuss the clubs they would like. A decision was taken to conduct

    surveys amongst children and parents to find out what they want. This consultation was initially

    begun eighteen months ago but over time the perception of what is needed can shift. The surveys

    ask children and parents about the kinds of learning and other activities they would like to have

    access to or see developed. As part of this consultation, respondents will also be asked where such

    activities should take place, whether in schools or community centres.

    Many families do have language difficulties. The basic questionnaire goes out in English but can be

    translated into Urdu and parents are asked to respond with straightforward box-ticking.

    This interviewee has not been in a position to plan beyond the short term, as her post is only secure

    until February 2012. Head teachers have not reached the point of long term plans and the extended

    schools work is only planned for six months ahead. Her relationship with the local education

    authority has changed over time. Initially there was a central team who sent funding ideas,

    evaluated and gave practical advice, such as health and safety. This team dissolved at the end of

    March 2011, and Extended Services Coordinators now work with their head teachers. Co-

    coordinators are appointed by the schools. This coordinator attends other local cluster meetings

    once a month with two other Extended Services Cluster Coordinators to keep in touch with what

    they are doing. At present there are nine coordinators for the LEA and at one point there had been

    fourteen. Some Coordinators have been given new roles that amalgamate different objectives forcombining responsibility for Extended Services with Attendance Officer duties.

    Organisation

    Head teachers meet once each term to discuss ideas and decide which should go ahead. The Co-

    coordinator then develops planning which is passed to heads by e-mail for checking. This is the

    system that has been used since the cluster was established. There are six schools and a childrens

    centre the head teachers from each meet with Karen once each term. The Co-coordinator

    communicates with schools by e-mail and visits each school once a fortnight. There is a contact

    within each individual school in addition to the head. This contact can be the homes-school liaison

    officer who speaks the language of the home. The officer works with families on attendance

    engaging with both children and parents and this is an effective link. This is the case in all of the

    schools in the cluster apart from two.

    The lead school holds the budget and the head there is line manager for the Extended Schools Co-

    coordinator. No one school drives the process. An idea is brought up and discussed on equal terms.

    The Cluster is still active, but after April it is impossible to predict and entirely dependent upon

    funding. At present funding for the cluster comes from the Disadvantaged Subsidy (see paragraph

    2.5) which gels members of the cluster together but when it stops or is shared in a different way,

    then the Cluster may dissolve. The funding holds the cluster together. This interviewee felt that in

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    7/23

    4

    the end, schools work for themselves and are interested in engaging their own parents with their

    own school. Heads who do not manage to attend meetings tend to be happy with the decisions

    reached. They receive a copy of the minutes.

    School improvement plans

    There is no formal requirement to base the work on individual school development plans. The last

    meeting focused on school priorities but only three heads attended. Those attending wanted the

    consultation survey to be carried out before planning priorities at the next meeting.

    The substance for the work has not changed. It has always been a core requirement to run a parent

    network group to persuade parents to come to regular meetings to get involved, to have a voice, to

    say what they want for their children. Parents will come along for a coffee and chat but they attend

    less when they realise they are being asked for a greater commitment or involvement. A parent

    group has been established for the whole Cluster to have one shared meeting in one school orcommunity centre. After one or two coffee and cake afternoons attracted parents, the meetings

    were inundated but the most recent meetings have had poor attendance, again because parents

    are sensing that some commitment will be required of them.

    A member of the Neighbourhood Team attends these meetings to signpost learning opportunities,

    training such as first aid, literacy, ITC,job seekers information and help with CV writing. Parents are

    happy with this and take away information. As a result, courses have been set up including healthy

    eating and lunch box sessions. Parents often put their names down then fail to turn up which makes

    planning difficult particularly when eight people are needed to make sessions cost effective. The

    interviewee felt that the parents are interested, but that they are being asked to attend increasingnumbers of events and sessions.

    Budget

    Budget for 2011-12: 68K excluding coordinators salary all spent for current year.

    2.3Primary school clusters beyond Pennine LancashireThis conversation took place with a Freelance Extended Services Coordinator working with a cluster

    of schools in the east of the country. This interviewee feels there is diversity of approach amongstextended schools services and clusters. So for example, her LEA has a different organisational set up

    to its neighbouring authority.

    Extended schools

    The interviewee had been Extended Services Cluster Coordinator for six years looking after eleven

    schools within a geographical area. Initially, the authority decided to split up into five Local Area

    Partnerships (LAPs). Schools were invited to sign up to be extended schools but it was suggested

    that many did not understand what that meant. Some were very proactive and wanted their Cluster

    Coordinator to sit within their school. This interviewee found herself based within one primary

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    8/23

    5

    school and line managed by that head teacher. Extended schools within the cluster were managed

    by that head. This evolved, after four years the Extended Services Cluster Coordinator was taken

    away from the schools, and a new management tier was introduced within the local authority.

    Local Area Partnerships

    There are six LAPs within the LEA. These schools were pushed together for the purposes of Extended

    School Clusters, and initially were unhappy because the groupings had clearly been made by

    someone without any experience of the communities and based on their geographical closeness on

    the map. An individual who knew the area would realise where some areas simply did not link. Now

    the LEA is beginning to describe LAPs as neighbourhoods and have changed the boundaries.

    Funding

    Now, the funding for Extended Services is going directly to schools. Funding is largely for extended

    services but schools will also be able to add to this with their Disadvantaged Subsidy (see 2.5).

    Different LEAs might manage this differently, the subsidy is calculated per head of those in school

    eligible for free schools meals (even if those children dont actually claim those free school meals).

    LEA will have a database of this information. Schools might choose to label this subsidy, so in this

    interviewees cluster it is described as the Can Do Subsidy.

    Schools have already received this subsidy for the year from April. But it is not ring-fenced, it can be

    spent on anything that the school wants there is no accountability. So for example, the interviewee

    had worked with one school that is redeveloping their playground with all this money. Bigger schools

    in more deprived areas are finding themselves cash rich this year. But next year, no one knows.

    Given this interviewee is now working independently she is hoping schools will continue to pay for

    her services out of their budget.

    The government wants schools to have more autonomy and their accountability will come through

    attainment, results and Ofsted (with questions relating to community engagement, and the

    expansion of horizons and raising of aspirations). But clearly some schools will be able to make a

    satisfactory account of their work towards these goals without spending all of the money allocated.

    Extended Services Cluster Coordinators

    The LEA had eight Cluster Coordinators, but on April 30th

    all but one were made redundant. The

    trouble with this situation was that whilst schools had their budgets to start on April 1st

    , they are

    often not told what their budget will be until later in April or even May, then they have to meet with

    the finance department, and since there will be several schools and only a few finance staff, the

    process of holding these conversations takes longer. Some head teachers are more independent, but

    others take direction from the LEA into the way that the budget should be spent. These

    conversations might for example, involve a head teacher asking for advice on how to get extra

    money to develop the playground.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    9/23

    6

    The Extended Schools Cluster Coordinators hoped their roles would be left alone until the summer,

    giving schools time to digest their budgets and time for the Authority to develop an offer that

    schools would take up in the summer to start in August. However, the money ran out in April and

    the schools had not got to grips with their budgets. This also meant the LEA had no capacity to

    consult with schools and therefore the Traded Services Offer that schools might buy into was not

    quite what schools wanted.

    Freelance Coordination

    When this interviewee was offered redundancy, the ten primary schools and one nursery in her

    cluster were firm that they didnt want her or her colleague to go. The 11 schools decided they

    would buy in the two coordinators on a freelance basis. From there, the coordinators arranged

    meetings with individual schools. This contrasts with the authoritys offer which presents a

    somewhat unwieldy and confusing package with sections that schools can dip into. The authority has

    not considered how schools will be charged for the services, for example a school might want help

    with a funding bid, but if the bid was not successful, they would not get back the money they had

    spent on the application. The full offer from the local authority is in the region of 8000 per school

    and only four schools have as yet accessed any of this Traded Offer. The interviewee felt schools are

    keen to work with individuals with whom they have built a relationship and rapport. By buying into

    the Traded Offer, schools could just get anyone when what they actually need is a personal,

    bespoke service with a known person. The Local Authoritys Extended Schools Services do not offer

    the full range of possibilities to schools.

    Clusters have changed, the secondary schools have become preoccupied with academy status, lots

    of the LAPs have dissolved, and those which have survived are based on friendship and trust

    groupings between the head teachers (for example one group of male head teachers have

    naturally gravitated together into a cluster simply because they have bonded over shared interests).

    Secondary schools are completely different and take a different view. There is a sense that

    secondary schools are only interested in the primary schools when the children are in year six. There

    is huge potential to develop transition but is not sure the secondary schools are interested. The

    bottom line is that clusters depend entirely on schools and their priorities.

    Motivation for collaborative initiativesFor this interviewee, ultimately all the cluster initiatives are about attendance, aspiration and

    behaviour and that these are the kind of soft outcomes that are difficult to measure. She is

    developing a project around mental health and emotional wellbeing as her schools want a package

    of workshops on this theme. She has drawn together youth workers, sports based team building

    experts and a local arts organisation.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    10/23

    7

    3 Secondary SchoolsThe situation for secondary schools seemed very different as Extended Services Coordinator for a

    local High School suggested: Were very much isolated really as a school we do our own thing and I

    dont know if thats common in other places.

    3.1Extended services coordinator with a high schoolThis interview was conducted with an Extended Services Coordinator based in a local high school.

    In the past the extended schools work had some government funding behind it and this meant there

    were strategic extended schools managers at local authority. These individuals had a low profile and

    were based at the LEA and the roles were dissolved with the end of funding for this work. The

    people on the ground doing grass roots work were those employed to work in the schools.

    This interviewee was employed by the school. Initially the school had direct links with the strategic

    managers at the Local Education Authority, who took responsibility for ensuring each school

    achieved the core offer (see Extended Services paragraph 2.1). These officers at Local Authority

    might work with a number of schools and would be tasked with ensuring they achieved the core

    offer by 2011. Funding was available for the schools to employ Extended School Coordinators.

    Funding came from central government to the LEA then it was allocated to schools. The Extended

    Services Coordinator then had to look for funders and partners.

    Cluster working

    Working with a cluster was not explicit in the core offer. The interviewee explained that with a

    changed agenda, the core offer no longer exists. When working as a cluster, the primary schools

    involved were all partner primary school for the high school so the work built on existing

    relationships. The cluster was less collaborative than others, and each school focused on what the

    Extended Services Coordinator could add value to their existing work. Their needs were all slightly

    different.

    On his work with the cluster the interviewee said, I didnt find it difficult, just a little bit different, it

    was like having four jobs to be honest with you. It ended up being three partner schools, one high

    school and three primary schools:

    Each school benefited but they asked for something different. For example

    when (one of the primary schools) had Ofsted, one of the issues was the

    community cohesion side was a bit weak. We got some funding through the

    council, applied for some funding and we did a 12 week community cohesion

    programme which involved Arabic Calligraphy, Polish dancing, a Masala project

    where they worked with herbs and spices to produce art. We brought artists in

    and we did Samba drumming.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    11/23

    8

    (another primary school) had issues regarding space, so we managed to get

    10,000 worth of funding and they had an annex building that we could

    renovate and create that space for extended schools, for their after school

    clubs.

    With good relationships between the head teachers in this cluster, the potential remains to work

    collaboratively, but the interviewee suggests caution, its about giving it enough time. If I popped in

    next week and said, right, were going to do something in October, it would be difficult. Because

    theyre quite heavy in terms of their timetable. If an idea is attractive however, the primary schools

    are keen to be involved. The interviewee however, felt he had to work hard to interest them,

    sellable sometimes youve got to be like a salesman, and its about believing in the project really.

    Youve got to believe in theproject and youve got to believe the project will benefit the kids.

    Current objectivesThe interviewee finds himself in a new position in which he is tasked with tailoring extended services

    to the schools specific needs. He spent around three months when he took up post in consultation

    with parents, children and the community and now he is in a position to build on these findings to

    better tailor extended schools to the schools needs. He is clearly well thought of by the school has

    rapport with the children and this success means he now has some autonomy in the direction in

    which he chooses to take his offer for children and their families. His more successful projects are

    now embedded into the curriculum and planning cycle, for example he has developed a school radio

    station and accompanying projects such as radio advertisement competitions and monthly topical

    live shows which now run regularly. This year has meant blending the extended services offer more

    closely with the curriculum, bringing a different dimension to the classroom with visitors from

    outside of school bringing new ideas and creativity. With the radio project this will involve bringing

    members of the community in for interviews, discussing hot topics and preparing shows based

    objectives within the curriculum for example from the literacy or RE syllabus.

    Impact

    In the past, the interviewee has been tasked with meeting community cohesion objectives through

    his extended services work, but largely the impact of the work relates to the raising of self-esteem,

    development of personal and transferable skills, broadening friendship groups. When we do theprojects we work with all the departments, SEN department, high achievers, the Aim Higher,

    pastoral staff so in terms of the kids were getting sent, its a variation. So therell be a project

    where youre working with pupils who are A star level and come from affluent backgrounds, to

    people who are from, not affluent backgrounds. Some people have you know, issues, social issues,

    self-esteem issues, all those people are blended in into one project. And how they come out of that

    journey is clearly visible.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    12/23

    9

    3.2 Extended services and attendance officer at a local high schoolThis interview was conducted with an Extended Services Coordinator and Attendance Officer at a

    local high school. She has not met with other extended services coordinators for around a year and

    says, I just kind of get on with what I have to get on with. Her post has been funded for three

    years, with some of her salary made up of attendance improvement funds and the rest from

    extended services. Her contract for the extended services work ends in August.

    Clusters

    The interviewees work with the cluster was limited to a simple invitation to primaries to access

    activity taking place at her school. To this extent, she continues to work in this way, but focusing

    more specifically on partner primary schools. This would mean individuals would have to make their

    own financial contribution to the activities taking place, but some would be offered help from the

    Disadvantaged Subsidy money (see paragraph 2.5).

    She explained that the Extended Services Cluster did not include many of her schools partner

    primary schools but she could not explain where the original cluster had come from.

    Funding

    There is no funding for Extended Services and any money that the school has received has

    contributed to the Coordinators salary. The disadvantaged subsidy is ring-fenced and audited, so

    she explained that it contributes to her programme of work but she has to use it with caution.

    Why not?

    The most useful networking activity in which the coordinator engages is to meet with the Why Not?

    board. This is a charity for young people with an agenda to prevent youth offending and antisocial

    behaviour. The regular monthly meetings provide the coordinator with an opportunity to meet with

    other Extended Services Coordinators. Other representatives at Why Not?meetings include those

    from the health sector, police and social services so projects can be planned that benefit from the

    signposting, connections and partnership presented by this network. Why Not?provide activities

    during the holidays and evenings ranging from drama to multisports. Working in partnership with

    Why Not?can mean in-kind contributions such as the loan of a school sports hall.

    Current objectives

    The interviewees objectives are to try and establish youth provision in the evening for young people

    in the local area. Her long term focus is to develop the library as an after school drop in that is more

    accessible, open to parents and suitable for less academic activities like computer gaming. This

    would help to better engage the community with the school as a local institution. Ultimately she

    would like establish a youth club open to all local young people. In the short term, she is about to

    distribute a leaflet promoting the extended services offer and signposting other young peoples

    services to students. The coordinator presents a development plan each year to her line manager,

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    13/23

    10

    the schools Business Manager, but she is not sure whether these objectives are included in the

    schools improvement plan.

    Day to day service:

    extra-curricular PE every evening as well as team sports animal club in science astronomy in science allotment club / gardening club animation every Thursday school reporters every week working on stories for a newsletter gathering information

    by visiting other clubsthey went and did something with the BBC, its like a journalist club

    library drop in on a Wednesday evening cooking maths puzzles club but this is on a lunchtime before school the dining room is open, like a breakfast club looking to make that more

    interactive, but just staffing at the moment

    sports hall is hired out every evening to different sports groups in the area and on a Fridaynight given free to the Why Nots, they do multisports for local children to get them off the

    streets

    Fundraising

    The coordinator plans to work with the community and local housing associations when she begins

    fundraising. The housing associations provide homes for many of the children attending the schooland are interested in helping to provide youth club facilities by supporting a bid to Awards for All.

    The Why Not? team will also support applications. Thisis the route Im going down, any bid I put

    in, I want to work with others.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    14/23

    11

    4. Recommendations

    4.1From conversations with the primary school headteacher, it is recommended that a pitch bemade to the active cluster through the identified lead.

    4.2From conversation with extended services coordinstor, it is recommended that a meeting be setup in her local area inviting extended services coordinators from each of the schools and

    representatives. Without a strong network, there is a clear need for leadership and focus, any

    ideas suggested would be openly received and interested subgroups could then choose to work

    together.

    4.3 It is recommended that a meeting be arranged with the local primary school extended servicescoordinator interviewed, who from there, can facilitate a meeting with the head teachers in her

    cluster.

    4.4Given the emphasis within these interview accounts on the importance of purpose in clusterworking, it is recommended that Curious Minds identify funding sources and invite schools to

    meet and consider collaborative working to achieve successful funding bids that will allow them

    to access Curious Minds Services to Schools.

    5. Conclusions

    This report has presented the findings of five interviews, four of which were conducted with

    Extended Services Coordinators and the remaining with a Head Teacher leading a cluster. It

    demonstrates that there are more differences than similarities in the way that schools are working

    together. Extended services initiatives are no longer the key driving force for cluster working in the

    way that they have been during the last six years.

    Each of the interviewees stressed the centrality of funding and of personal relationships in driving

    schools to work together. Clusters are formed around a funding purpose along with individual

    personalities. If head teachers get along, they will work collaboratively. If they have developed a

    long and trusting relationship with their extended services coordinator, they will strive to maintain

    the relationship. The interviews suggest there is potential to galvanise schools into cluster working if

    it is possible to signpost available funding and suggest inspiring projects from which a collaborative

    approach will benefit.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    15/23

    12

    6. Appendices

    6.1 Glossary of terms

    6.1.1 Extended Services

    A programme of work formally launched in 2006 to deliver the policy set out in Extended Schools:

    schools, families, communities working together. In 2010 the school circular Extended Schools

    Building on Good Practice refreshed policy and disseminated good examples.

    Extended Schools -schools, families, communities - working together PDF 1,010 KB

    Extended_Schools_Circular_2010 English PDF 190KB

    School were encouraged to deliver a Core Offer which combined:

    a varied menu of activity (catch up and stretch activities, arts activities, sportsactivities, and other recreational activities such as special interest clubs)

    parenting support (information for parents, access to parenting groups and familylearning sessions)

    community access to school facilities swift and easy access to targeted and special services (children with additional needs or

    at risk of poor outcomes)

    6.1.2 Local Childrens Trust PartnershipsSetting out to address particular needs. These local area needs are set out in appendix 2.

    6.1.3 Future Learning TrustA trust school is a state funded foundation school supported by a charitable trust and made up of

    the school and partners working together for the benefit of the school

    http://trustschools.ssatrust.org.uk/schools/trust_schools.aspx

    6.1.4 Sports PartnershipsSport Partnerships were familiar to the Hyndburn and Burnley interviewees, and are partnerships

    with the aim of achieving high quality sport and physical education. See for example

    http://www.burnleyssp.co.uk/

    6.1.5 Disadvantaged subsidyThe Additional Standards Fund Grant or Disadvantaged Subsidy Grant is available to support

    children and young people to access extended services. In the past it had been proposed that

    schools manage these resources in partnership, but now the funds go directly to the individualschool. This finance is to provide support for economically disadvantaged children and young people

    http://www.deni.gov.uk/extended_schools_-_revised_02-05-07.pdfhttp://www.deni.gov.uk/extended_schools_circular_2010.pdfhttp://trustschools.ssatrust.org.uk/schools/trust_schools.aspxhttp://trustschools.ssatrust.org.uk/schools/trust_schools.aspxhttp://www.burnleyssp.co.uk/http://www.burnleyssp.co.uk/http://www.burnleyssp.co.uk/http://trustschools.ssatrust.org.uk/schools/trust_schools.aspxhttp://www.deni.gov.uk/extended_schools_circular_2010.pdfhttp://www.deni.gov.uk/extended_schools_-_revised_02-05-07.pdf
  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    16/23

    13

    to access extended services which would not be available to them without financial assistance.

    These children are identified according to their entitlement to free school meals. The sum is

    calculated per head, with the assumption that only 60% of those eligible for free school meals will

    actually access the provision. The overall aim of this subsidy under the last government was to

    narrow the gap in attainment and wellbeing.

    6.1.6 Local Area PartnershipsLocal Area Partnerships are geographical groupings of schools for the purposes of extended services

    provision. The often match the area organisation of other children and family services and

    sometimes a wide range of community services.

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    17/23

    14

    6.2 Interview Questions

    Extended schools clusters

    1. Whats your brief for extended schools this year?2. What do you expect to be doing in the short, medium and long term?3. How do you plan this work? (Who sees that plan?)4. How is it different from last year?5. What objectives are you tasked with achieving?

    6. Which schools are part of the cluster (or have been)?7. How do you communicate do you meet (did you meet)?8. Who represents (represented) each school (head, teacher...)9. Is one school a particular driver of extended schools cluster projects?10.If the cluster is no longer functioning why not?11.In what circumstances might you work together again?

    12.What has been your relationship with the local authority and how has this changed? (e.g.were you appointed by the LEA, are you now appointed by the school?)

    13.Do you work with other extended schools coordinators locally who and how?

    14.Are there elements of the school improvement plan that you are tasked with achievingthrough extended schools work? How does / did this work when part of a cluster?

    15.Are you aware of Curious Minds? What do you know of their work?16.What are your perceptions of the services Curious Minds can offer to you?17. If CM wanted to tell you more / open a dialogue, what in your opinion would be the best

    way to do this?

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    18/23

    15

    6.3 Local Area NeedsEach area of Lancashire has its own characteristics and specific areas of need. This is a summary of

    agreed priorities to meet local needs. These priorities will help us to commission services togetherfor children, young people and their families.

    Burnley

    - Foundation learning and parental support at Early Years

    - School attendance

    - Drugs and alcohol abuse

    - Domestic abuse

    Emerging issues:

    - Child obesity

    - Teenage conceptions

    Chorley

    - Early Intervention

    - Reducing the number of NEET

    - Things to do / places to go

    - Reducing risk taking behaviours

    Fylde- Persistent absence

    - Emotional health and wellbeing

    - Child obesity

    Hyndburn

    - Child sexual exploitation

    - Drugs and alcohol misuse

    - Domestic abuse

    Lancaster

    - Improving the health and wellbeing

    - Reducing the number of NEET

    - Improving outcomes for vulnerable groups (16-17 year olds)

    - Things to do / places to go

    Pendle

    - Narrow the gap in educational attainment

    - Reducing the number of NEET (16-18)

    - Infant mortality

    - Health - reducing child obesity

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    19/23

    16

    - Safeguarding

    Preston

    - Supporting parents and families in priority areas to reduce neglect

    - Reducing teenage pregnancies

    - Reducing the number of NEET

    - Reducing child obesity

    RibbleValley

    - Family/parenting issues

    - Emotional health and wellbeing

    - Places to go / things to do

    - Personal safety / risk taking behaviour

    Rossendale- Provide support to family victims of domestic abuse

    - Reducing risk taking behaviours

    - Improve outcomes for 16 -17 year olds moving to independent living

    - Narrow the gap in educational attainment

    SouthRibble

    - Early Intervention

    - Things to do / places to go

    - Risk taking behaviour

    West Lancashire

    - School exclusions

    - Narrow the gap in educational attainment

    - Improving breastfeeding

    - Reducing child obesity

    - Things to do / places to go

    Wyre

    - Volunteering and community involvement experiences for those at risk of becoming NEET or

    involved in criminal activity

    - Develop the Fleetwood Integrated Services Model

    - Support for parents / carers to help them enhance the emotional / physical wellbeing of their

    children

    - Promoting emotional health and positive perceptions of young people across Trust activity

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    20/23

    17

    6.4 Letter from Mr Gove

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    21/23

    18

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    22/23

    19

  • 8/3/2019 Clusters in Pennine Lancashire and Beyond MPA 081111 Web

    23/23

    7. Other references

    Department for Education, 2011 Extended services evaluation: The role of local authorities. Thematic

    reviewavailable athttps://www.education.gov.uk/publications/eOrderingDownload/DFE-RR088.pdf

    Childrens Trusts in Lancashire, 2009 Lancashire children and young peoples plan 209-2012, LCC,Preston

    Department for Children, Schools and Families, 2009 Your child, your schools, our future: building a

    21st

    century schools system, The Stationary Office, Norwich.

    Lancashire County Councils Extended Services available at

    http://lancashire.gov.uk/corporate/web/?Extended_Services/26063

    https://www.education.gov.uk/publications/eOrderingDownload/DFE-RR088.pdfhttps://www.education.gov.uk/publications/eOrderingDownload/DFE-RR088.pdfhttp://lancashire.gov.uk/corporate/web/?Extended_Services/26063http://lancashire.gov.uk/corporate/web/?Extended_Services/26063http://lancashire.gov.uk/corporate/web/?Extended_Services/26063https://www.education.gov.uk/publications/eOrderingDownload/DFE-RR088.pdf