Upload
vukhuong
View
214
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Close Reading WoRkshop 3Close Reading of poetryLearning Targets•Determineathemeorcentralideaofatextandanalyzeindetailitsdevelopment
overthecourseofthetext,includinghowitemergesandisshapedandrefinedbyspecificdetails;provideanobjectivesummaryofthetext.
•Determinethemeaningofwordsandphrasesastheyareusedinthetext,includingfigurativeandconnotativemeanings;analyzethecumulativeimpactofspecificwordchoicesonmeaningandtone(e.g.,howthelanguageevokesasenseoftimeandplace;howitsetsaformalorinformaltone.
•Determineorclarifythemeaningofunknownandmultiple-meaningwordsandphrasesbasedongrades 9–10 reading and content,choosingflexiblyfromarangeofstrategies.
•Demonstrateunderstandingoffigurativelanguage,wordrelationships,andnuancesinwordmeanings.
•Initiateandparticipateeffectivelyinarangeofcollaborativediscussions(one-on-one,ingroups,andteacher-led)withdiversepartnersongrades9–10topics,texts,andissues,buildingonothers’ideasandexpressingtheirownclearlyandpersuasively.
Close Reading for MeaningToread poetry closely meansthatasreaders,weshouldnotjustconsiderwhatinformationisconveyedbyatext,wemustalsoconsidertheauthor’suseofrhyme,meter,andothersoundtechniquestoconveyrhythmandothereffects.
Inthisworkshop,youwillreadthreedifferenttextsandwillpracticeclose-readingusingstrategiesthatwillhelpyoumakemeaningofthetext.Yourteacherwillguideyouthroughthefirstactivity.InActivity2,youwillworkinacollaborativegrouptoreadandrespondtothetext.Forthethirdactivity,youwillworkindependentlytoapplyclosereadingstrategiestodeterminemeaninginanewtext.
ACTiviTy 1
Guided PracticeYouwillreadthetextinthisactivityatleastthreetimes,focusingonadifferentpurposeforeachreading.
First Reading: First impressionsReadthefollowingpoemsilently.Yourfocusforthisfirstreadingisonunderstandingthemeaningofthepoem.Asyouread,practicediffusingthewordsyoumaynotknowbyreplacingunfamiliarwordswithsynonymsordefinitionsfortheunderlinedwords.Usethedefinitionsandsynonymstotherightorleftofthepoemtohelpyourunderstanding.
leaRning sTRaTegies:Diffusing,CloseReading,GraphicOrganizer,MarkingtheText,GuidedReading,QuestioningtheText,Rereading,SharedReading,Summarizing,Paraphrasing,Think-Pair-Share,ChoralReading,TP-CASTT,OPTIC,MetacognitiveMarkers
aCademiC VoCabulaRyRhymereferstotherepetitionofsoundsattheendsofwords.Meterisdeterminedbythenumberofstressedandunstressedsyllablesinaline.Rhythm referstothepatternorflowofsoundcreatedbyapoem’sarrangementofstressedandunstressedsyllables.
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
Close Reading Workshop 3 • Close Reading of Poetry 39
Close Reading of poetry (continued)
Spring and Fallby Gerard Manley Hopkins
To a Young Child
1 Margaret, are you grieving
Over Goldengrove unleaving?Leaves, like the things of man, youWith your fresh thoughts care for, can you?
5 Ah! as the heart grows olderIt will come to such sights colder
By and by, nor spare a sighThough worlds of wanwood leafmeal lie;
And yet you will weep and know why.
10 Now no matter, child, the name:Sorrow’s springs are the same.Nor mouth had, no nor mind, expressed
What héart héard of, ghóst guéssed:It is the blight man was born for,
15 It is Margaret you mourn for.
Second Reading: vocabulary in ContextNowthatyouhavereadthepoemsilently,listenandfollowalongasyourteacherreadsthepoemaloud.Asyoureadalongwithyourteacher,markthetextwithmetacognitive markers.Usethefollowingsymbolstorepresentyourthoughts:
?=partsofthepoemaboutwhichyouhaveaquestion
!=partsofthepoemyoufindsurprisingorinteresting
*=partsofthepoemaboutwhichyouhaveacommentorconnection
underlinekeyideas
Check your Understanding 1.Pairwithanotherstudent,andshareyourmetacognitivemarkers.Thenchoosetwo
orthreewordsfromthevocabularythathavebeenunderlinedorbolded,anddiscusshowthedefinitionshelpyouunderstandthemeaningofthepoem.
2.Usethesevocabularywordsinasummaryofthecentralideasinthepoem.Explainhowthesewordscontributetoyourunderstandingofthepoem.
3.Withasmallgroupofyourpeers,planandrehearseachoral readingofthepoemwithguidancefromyourteacher.
unleaving:losingitsleaves(“unleaving”isoneofmany
wordsHopkinsinventedhimself;thesewordsare
knownasneologisms)
wanwood:palewood(anotherneologism)
leafmeal:pilesofdead,decayingleaves(neologism)
blight:somethingthatcausesharmordamage;
also,adiseasethatmakesplantsdryupanddie;also,
somethingthatfrustratesplansorhopes
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
40 SpringBoard® English Language Arts Grade 10
Third Reading: Text-Dependent QuestioningNowreadthepoemagain,thistimewiththefocusofreadingtorespondtotheKeyIdeasandDetailsinterpretivequestions.Writeyourresponsestoeachquestion,andhighlightorunderlinethetextualevidencethatsupportsyouranswer.Duringclassdiscussion,youmayalsowanttoannotatethetexttorecordanewordifferentmeaningofthepoem.
Background information:GerardManleyHopkinswasanEnglishpoetandJesuitpriestwidelyregardedasoneoftheVictorianera’sgreatestpoets.AfterhisconversiontoCatholicism,Hopkinsburnedallofhisexistingpoemsandgaveupwritingpoetryforsevenyears.Evenafterhisreturntowritingin1875,mostofHopkins’spoemsremainedunpublisheduntilafterhisdeathin1889.Hopkins’spoetrywascharacterizedbyhisunconventionaluseofmeterthatheinventedandcalled“sprungrhythm,”aswellasbyhisexperimentationwithlanguageandsound.
Spring and Fallby Gerard Manley Hopkins
Margaret, are you grieving
Over Goldengrove unleaving?
Leaves, like the things of man, you
With your fresh thoughts care for, can you?
5 Ah! as the heart grows older
It will come to such sights colder By and by, nor spare a sigh
Though worlds of wanwood leafmeal lie;
And yet you will weep and know why.
10 Now no matter, child, the name:
Sorrow’s springs are the same.
Nor mouth had, no nor mind, expressed
What héart héard of, ghóst guéssed:
It is the blight man was born for,
15 It is Margaret you mourn for.
key ideas and deTailsWhattwoquestionsdoesthespeakerposeto“Margaret”atthestartofthepoem?Whatinferencescanyoumakeabout“Margaret”basedontextualevidence?
key ideas and deTailsExaminetherhymescheme(pattern)ofthispoeminordertoexplainwhenandwhythepatternchanges.
key ideas and deTailsLookforevidenceofplacesinthepoemwhereHopkinsputtwostressedsyllablesnexttoeachother.Whateffectdoesthishaveonthepoem’srhythm?Whatmightbetheauthor’spurpose?
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
Close Reading Workshop 3 • Close Reading of Poetry 41
Close Reading of poetry (continued)
Check your UnderstandingNowthatyouhavereadcloselyandworkedtounderstandchallengingportionsofthispoem,chooseonelinethatyouthinkisimportanttounderstandingwhatthepoemisaboutandwhytheauthorwroteit.Explaininyourownwordswhatthesentencemeansandwhyitisimportanttounderstandingthepoem.
Synthesizing your UnderstandingNowthatyouhavereadthepoemthreetimesandstudieditsvocabularyandsentences,synthesizeyourunderstandingbyapplyingtheTP-CASTTstrategy.
introducing the Strategy: TP-CASTTTP-CASTTisastrategyforclosereadingofpoetry.Thisreadingstrategyisusedtoguideanalysisofatextthroughexplorationofeachtopicintheacronym: Title (preview), Paraphrase, Connotation, Attitude, Shift, Title (revisited) and Theme.
T–Title:Beforereadingapoem,stoptoconsideritstitle.Revisitthepredictionsyoumadeaboutthepoembeforereading“SpringandFall.”
P–Paraphrase:Dividethepoemintothreeorfourchunksbasedontherhymescheme,andthenworkwithapartnertoparaphrasethemainideaofeachchunkin yourownwords.
Chunk1:
Chunk2:
Chunk3:
Chunk4:
C–Connotation:Whatwordsorphrasessuggestsomethingbeyondtheirliteralmeanings?Whatdoyouthinkthepoetissayinginthispoem?Gobeyondtheliteralmeaningsortheplotofthepoem.
A–Attitude:Describethespeaker’sattitudeortone.Usespecificadjectivesandexplainyourchoices.
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
42 SpringBoard® English Language Arts Grade 10
S–Shifts:Describewherethepoemappearstoshift,eitherinsubject,speaker,ortone.Recordeachlinenumberwhereashiftoccurs,andthenexplainwhatkindofshiftisoccurring.
T–Title (revisited):Re-examinethetitle.Whatdoesitmeannowinthecontextofthepoem?Whatnewmeaningorsignificancecanyoufindinthechoiceoftitle?
T–Theme:Whatdoyouthinkistheunderlyingmessageaboutlifeexpressedinthispoem?
Writing Prompt:Basedonyourcurrentunderstandingofthepoem,explainhowGerardManleyHopkinsusessound(rhyme,meter)orlanguage(diction,imagery)toconveyconflictingtonesinthepoem.Besureto:•Identifyconflictingtonesinthepoem•Providetextualevidenceofthepoet’suseofsoundorlanguage•Includecommentaryexplaininghowthedetailsinthepoemconveytone
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
Close Reading Workshop 3 • Close Reading of Poetry 43
Close Reading of poetry (continued)
ACTiviTy 2
Collaborative PracticeThefollowingartworkisanengravingtitled“TheFirstSorrow,”createdin1833byEdouardSchuler.
introducing the Strategy: OPTiCOPTICisastrategyforsystematicallyanalyzingvisualtexts—includingpaintings,photographs,advertisements,maps,charts,orgraphs—anddevelopinganinterpretationregardingthemeaningortheme(s)ofthetext.TheacronymstandsforOverview,Parts,Title,Interrelationships,andConclusion.
Applying OPTiCTheOPTICstrategyallowsyoutoanalyzeavisualimageinasystematicwayinordertounderstandhowallaspectsoftheartworkcombinetocreateanoverallimpression.
WorkcollaborativelytorespondtothefollowingpromptsthatarepartoftheOPTICstrategy.Todoaclosereadingofavisualimage,youshouldviewandreviewtheartworkeachtimeyourespondtothequestions.
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
44 SpringBoard® English Language Arts Grade 10
O-Conductabriefoverviewofthevisualbyexaminingitcarefully.Notethedetails:images,shapes,positionorangleintheframe,etc.
P-Keyinonallofthepartsbynotinganyspecificdetailsthatseemimportant.Thiscanbeanything:captions,text,figures,scenery,oranyotherdetailthatmaybesymbolic.
T-Usethetitleandverbaltexttoclarifythesubject(s)oftheartwork.Howdoesthetextenhanceorsuggestmeaning?
i-Specifytheinterrelationshipswithintheartwork.Inotherwords,howdothepartsrelatetooneanother?Ifrelevant,consideranyconnectionsestablishedtotextsbeyondthispage.
C-Drawaconclusionaboutthethemeoftheartwork.Whatdoesitsuggestabouttheauthor’spurpose?
Writing Prompt:Nowthatyouhavecarefullyexaminedthisdrawingandidentifiedmanyofitsfeatures,makeaconnectionbetweenthispaintingandGerardManleyHopkins’spoem.Besureto:•Writeatopicsentencethatconnectsthetwotexts.•Includetextualdetailsandexplainhowtheysupportyourconnection.•Writeaconclusionthatfollowsfromyourexplanations.
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
Close Reading Workshop 3 • Close Reading of Poetry 45
Close Reading of poetry (continued)
ACTiviTy 3
independent PracticePreview the TitleThetitleofthenextpoemis“TheLoveliestofTrees.”Basedonthistitle,makeapredictionaboutwhatthepoemisabout.
Background:A.E.HousmanwasanEnglishscholarandwriterbornin1859,bestknownforhispoetrycollectionentitledA Shropshire Lad,whichcontained63poems.Hisstyleismarkedbyspare,simpledictionandpastoralimagery.
First Reading: First impressionsReadthepoemsilentlytoyourself.Asyouread,thinkaboutthemeaningsoftheunderlinedwords.Lookatthedefinitionsintherightmargin,andalsouseyourknowledgeofthewordsandcontextcluestohelpyoumakemeaningofthetext.
TreesLoveliest
of
by A.E. Housman
Loveliest of Trees, the cherry now
Is hung with bloom along the bough,
And stands about the woodland ride
Wearing white for Eastertide.
5 Now, of my threescore years and ten,
Twenty will not come again,
And take from seventy springs a score,
It only leaves me fifty more.
And since to look at things in bloom
10 Fifty springs are little room,
About the woodlands I will go
To see the cherry hung with snow.
Eastertide:theEasterseason
threescore:sixtyyears
ascore:twentyyears
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
46 SpringBoard® English Language Arts Grade 10
Second Reading: vocabulary in ContextAfterreadingthepoemtoyourself,listenandfollowalongasthepoemisreadagainaloud.Asyoureadalong,markthetextwithmetacognitive markers.Usethefollowingsymbolstorepresentyourthoughts:
?=partsofthepoemaboutwhichyouhaveaquestion
!=partsofthepoemyoufindsurprisingorinteresting
*=partsofthepoemaboutwhichyouhaveacommentorconnection
underlinekeyideas
Check your Understanding 1.Pairwithanotherstudenttoshareyourmetacognitivemarkers.Usingthe
underlinedandboldedvocabularyfromthepoem,discusshowlearningthevocabularyaffectsyourunderstandingoftheentirepoem.Choosetwoorthreeofthewordsyouhaveexaminedthatyouthinkaresignificanttounderstandingthepoem.Usethewordsinasentenceortwothatexplainshowthesewordscontributetoyourunderstanding.
2.Withasmallgroupofyourpeers,planandrehearseachoral readingofthepoembyfollowingthesesteps:•Separatethepoemintosense unitsbydrawingaslashmarkafteranyend
punctuation(periods,questionmarks,exclamationpoints.)•Divideupthesenseunitssothatatleastonepersonisspeakingeachone,
andhaveeachpersonhighlightthelinestobespokenoutloud.•Decidehowyouwillperformthelinestoemphasizetoneandmeaning.
Forexample,youmaychoosetoemphasizelinesbyhavingmorethanonespeakerreadatthesametime,oryoumaywanttovaryyourloudness,rateofspeech,and/ortoneofvoice.
Third Reading: Text-Dependent QuestioningNowreadthepoemagain,thistimewiththefocusofreadingtorespondtotheKeyIdeasandDetailsinterpretivequestions.Writeyourresponsestoeachquestionandhighlightorunderlinethetextualevidencethatsupportsyouranswer.
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
Close Reading Workshop 3 • Close Reading of Poetry 47
Close Reading of poetry (continued)
Loveliest of Treesby A.E. Housman
Loveliest of Trees, the cherry now
Is hung with bloom along the bough,
And stands about the woodland ride
Wearing white for Eastertide.
5 Now, of my threescore years and ten,
Twenty will not come again,
And take from seventy springs a score,
It only leaves me fifty more.
And since to look at things in bloom
10 Fifty springs are little room,
About the woodlands I will go
To see the cherry hung with snow.
Check your UnderstandingQuestioning the Text: Usingthetext-basedquestionsasamodel,askquestionsaboutthepoem.Beginyourquestionswith“why”or“how.”Rememberthatyoumaynotknowtheanswertothequestion,butyouthinktheanswermightbeimportanttounderstandingthemeaningofthepassage.
Synthesizing your UnderstandingNowthatyouhavereadthepoemthreetimesandstudieditsvocabularyandsentences,synthesizeyourunderstandingbyapplyingtheTP-CASTTstrategy.
T–Title:Beforereadingapoem,stoptoconsideritstitle.Revisitthepredictionsyoumadeaboutthepoembeforereading“LoveliestofTrees.”
P–Paraphrase: Numberthethreestanzasofthepoem,andthenworkwithapartnertoparaphrasethemainideaofeachstanzainyourownwords.
Stanza1:
Stanza2:
Stanza3:
key ideas and deTailsWhyisthecherrytree
describedinthefirststanzaasthe“loveliestoftrees”?
Whatmakesitlovelierthanothers?
key ideas and deTailsWhatdoesthepoemtellusabouthowoldthespeakeris,andhowhefeelsabout
hislifespan?
key ideas and deTailsHowdoestheimage“hung
withsnow”reflectthespeaker’sattitudeinthe
thirdstanza?
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
48 SpringBoard® English Language Arts Grade 10
C–Connotation:Whatwordsorphrasessuggestsomethingbeyondtheirliteralmeanings?Whatdoyouthinkthepoetissayinginthispoem?Gobeyondtheliteralmeaningsortheplotofthepoem.
A–Attitude:Describethespeaker’sattitudeortone.Usespecificadjectivesandexplainyourchoices.
S–Shift:Describewherethepoemappearstoshift,eitherinsubject,speaker,ortone.Recordeachlinenumberatwhichyoubelieveashiftoccurs,andexplainwhatkindofshiftisoccurring.
T–Title (revisited): Re-examinethetitle.Whatdoesitmeannowinthecontextofthepoem?Whatnewmeaningorsignificancecanyoufindinthechoiceoftitle?
T–Theme:Whatdoyouthinkistheunderlyingmessageaboutlifeexpressedinthispoem?
Writing Prompt:Usingtextualevidencetosupportyourthinking,summarizehowHousemanusessound(rhyme,meter,rhythm)orlanguage(diction,imagery)toconveyatheme.Besureto:
•Writeatopicsentencethatidentifiesthepoem’stheme.•Chooseseveralpiecesofappropriatetextualevidence.•Explainhowyourtextualevidenceconveysthepoem’stheme.
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
Close Reading Workshop 3 • Close Reading of Poetry 49
Close Reading of poetry (continued)
ACTiviTy 4
Synthesis QuestionsYourteachermaychooseoraskyoutochooseoneofthefollowingassessmentsasawayofshowingyourunderstandingofthetextsyouhaveread.
Writing Prompt:Reviewthedifferentwaysthatthenaturalworldandthepassageoftimewereusedtoexpresshumanemotionsandreflectionsaboutmortalityinthisworkshop.Revisittheworkyouhavedonewiththesethreetexts,andconsiderhowthetwopoetsandtheartistusedsignificantdetailsandotherliteraryandvisualtechniquestoconveydifferenttonesandthemes.Writeanessaycomparingandcontrastinghownaturewasusedtoexpressdifferentattitudesandideasconcerningmortalityinatleasttwoofthesetexts.
Debate/Discussion:ConductaSocraticSeminar.Workwithasmallgroupofstudentstorevisitthetextsinthisunitandcreatetwoorthreeopen-endedquestionsforeachwrittenandvisualtext.Withyourquestionsandyourannotatedtextinfrontofyou,engagewithyourpeersinaSocraticSeminarinwhichyoushareyourquestionsandrespondtothequestionsthatotherstudentshavegenerated.
Multimedia Presentation:Locateasong,poem,photo,artwork,orotherwrittentextthatusestheimageryofthelosstoreflectonthehumancondition,aging,orthepassageoftime.Preparetopresenttheoriginaltextalongwithyouranalysisoftheauthor’spurposeinusingspecificimagery.Explainhowtheimageryisusedtoconveytone(s)andtheme(s).Considerusingapresentationtoolinordertoshareyourresearchwiththeclass.
ReflectionThinkaboutwhatyouhavelearnedfromyourclosereadingandanalysisofthetextpassagesyouhavereadinthisworkshop.
1.Howcanwritersandotherkindsofartistsusenaturalimagerytoreflectideasandattitudesaboutthehumancondition?
2.Inthisworkshop,youhavelearnedhowtomakemeaningofthreedifferenttexts.Howcanyouusewhatyouhavelearnedtohelpyouasyouencounterchallengingtextsinthefuture?Whatstrategiesbesthelpedyouasalearnerduringthisworkshop?Whenandwhywouldyouusethesestrategiesinthe future?
©2
014
Colle
geB
oard
.All
righ
tsre
serv
ed.
50 SpringBoard® English Language Arts Grade 10