Upload
ben-robinson
View
220
Download
7
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Developmental Psychopathologyand Wellness: Genetic andEnvironmental InfluencesJ.J. Hudziak (Ed.)Arlington VA: American Psychiatric
Publishing, 2008. pp. 300. £31.00 (pb).
ISBN: 978-1-58862-279-5.
In 1974 Achenbach coined �develop-mental psychopathology� to emphasise
the developmental dimension in the
study of childhood psychopathology.
Over 30 years later, this book aims to
re-assess the paradigm with contribu-
tions from various experts including
Achenbach.
Part 1 sees Rutter mapping out the
key questions. How do genes and the
environment interact to result in psy-
chopathology? How does developmental
stage bear influence on this? Why are
there age differences in susceptibility to
disorders and treatment? What are the
continuities and discontinuities of psy-
chopathology over time and between
normality and disorder? Such ques-
tions were the scaffolding that originally
defined development psychopathology.
Has 30 years of research advanced the
paradigm?
Part 2 explores genetic and environ-
mental influences on development and
psychopathology. March and Susser
differentiate environmental factors into
individual, neighbourhood, and immi-
grant group levels. Angold describes sex
as a developmental process, dissecting
its composite levels (genes, chromo-
somes, hormones, genitalia, societal
perspectives) and their relation to psy-
chopathology at different developmen-
tal stages. Other chapters relate the
findings of longitudinal studies on per-
sonality and temperament.
Part 3 explores genetic and environ-
ment interplay for specific psychiatric
disorders (e.g. pervasive developmental
disorders) or symptoms (e.g. anxious/
depression). Other chapters illustrate
the role of 5-HTLLPR and BDNF poly-
morphisms in depressed maltreated
children (Kaufman), and the interaction
between DAT and DRD4 polymor-
phisms and prenatal smoking in ADHD
(Reierson et al.).
In Part 4, Faraone formulates gene-
environment interplay using an �ecoge-netic framework� of four patterns,
differentiated by the necessity or suffi-
ciency of genetic and/or environmental
factors in influencing pathology. In the
only chapter specifically applying to
clinical practice, Hudziak and Bartels
advocate a developmentally-aware fam-
ily-based approach. They urge us to go
beyond DSM-diagnostic criteria by
using developmental psychiatry re-
search findings to tailor prevention
and treatment strategies to specific
aetiological subtypes.
Overall, we learn the utility of tech-
niques such as longitudinal modelling
(which can track the stability of psy-
chopathology and help identify causal
factors), twin studies (which can tease
apart genetic and environmental influ-
ences) and molecular genetic and neu-
roimaging research. Such studies serve
to illuminate pieces of the jigsaw puzzle.
However, the interaction of genetic and
environmental processes is vast in
scope and complexity; the jigsaw puzzle
is greater than the sum of its parts. The
question is whether knowing small
pieces of albeit cutting-edge research
is good enough to make valid and useful
interpretations; this question is never
quite addressed by the book and more
could have been done to compare and
contrast the different contributions.
With detailed descriptions of re-
search, but without a strong narrative
or a clinical emphasis, the book
is aimed at the academic. However,
the content itself is sufficient to mark
this book as an important pillar in the
academic study of both developmental
psychopathology and psychiatry as a
whole.
Aaron K. Vallance
Imperial College, London
Children and Bullying: HowParents and Educators can ReduceBullying at SchoolK. RigbyOxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2008. pp.
232. £14.99 (pb). ISBN: 978-1-4051-
6254-8.
Children and bullying is a thoroughly
detailed exposition on how parents and
teachers can help to reduce bullying.
Rigby is realistic in his approach,
believing that it is more about reduction
than eradication. The book is very
readable, well structured and informa-
tive, with the author looking at the issue
holistically. Interestingly, the author
notes that bullying is a reflection of
the human condition and generally
defines it as �the systematic abuse of
power in interpersonal relationships�,citing examples in recent history such
as slavery.
Parents are increasingly being pro-
vided with the opportunity to take part
in anti-bullying initiatives and this book
is a timely recognition of that. It under-
stands their contribution to the issue
and values their inclusion in the dis-
cussion. Schools have the greatest
power differences amongst social
groupings and so there is often space
for conflict. Rigby identifies these power
differences and gives us the opportunity
to get inside the mind of a bully as well
as offering a focus on bystander sup-
port. The author states what some good
schools are doing about bullying, and
educators are provided with guidance
on how to write an anti-bullying policy.
Mental health issues are covered both
for the victim and the perpetrator, and
the author suggests that these charac-
teristics can be inherited. Parenting
styles are discussed and parents are
encouraged not to feel guilty about what
their child experiences. Excellent advice
is given on how to help children with
their bullying problems. The section
about the influence parents have on
their children at different ages will be
enjoyed by anyone who has heard
themselves talking to a child and
sounding like their own mother!
Ben Robinson
Anti-Bullying Development Officer
Leicestershire County Council
Mental Health Interventions andServices for Vulnerable Childrenand Young PeoplePanos Vostanis (Ed.)London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers,
2008. pp. 295. £19.99 (pb). ISBN: 978-
1-84310-489-6.
This book is an interesting read dealing
as it does with matters of policy as well
as intervention for vulnerable children
and young people. The definition of
vulnerability is broad, encompassing
children vulnerable because of their
social context, fostered due to a break-
down of care and/or abuse, homeless,
refugee and asylum seeking, children of
alcoholic or substance abusing parents,
as well as children with physical illness
or disability, and young offenders.
Although children and young people
vulnerable as a result of serious mental
illness are interestingly not included,
much of the content is very relevant for
this group.
The content is divided into three
parts: Part I, Evidence, policy and leg-
islation, Part II, Applied interventions,
and Part III, Applying the evidence and
therapeutic principles to different
welfare and health systems, cultural
110 Book News