Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page … · Ltr. motion of Victor Parker to join in complaint as pltf., Ltr. motion of Abdallah Khaliq to join in complaint

Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page 1 of 14 PageID: 1

1,(

' ,,.,, .. _

0312 03 85 4401 PLAIIIITIFFS

EMMITT VALENTINE, CLIFFORD ROBERTS, DARRYL V. CONQUEST, CHARLES HOLMAN, JAMES DRAYTON, ALLEN RODZIEWICz, DAVID FLETCHER, NAJEE SHABAZZ, JAMES WILLIAMS, DAVID GODWIN$ DARNELL RlCHARDSON, OTIS TERRELL, KENNETH WATSON1 ALI-MUSLIM MUHAMMAD KERWIN COLON, MASIA MUGMUK, ARNOLD TUCKER, ROBERT DAVIS, ASKIN MUHAMMAD, LAWRENCE WHITE, JOHNNY BANKSTON. BARRRY ROBINSON, JOHNATHAN COOK, MICHAEL BARRON, OMAR SHABAZZ, AARON STAMPS, MELVIN STAMPS, KENT COOPER, LEWIS WEBB, JAMES WEBB, RUBEN MEDAL~ MICHAEL GRAVES, JEFF JACOBITTI, ROBERT L. WEST, GREGORY MURCH INS ON, L. ROYAf, FISHER, EARL BAYARD,,DAWIJl;l.,.S .• ~.M;l:~T ., 1l1'-.II,Ji:F,M, J).l<l;l/1\,l'!.·, ~ RQT(T, T.l'\'l'JF,

ABDUS-SAML A. AKBA~ ADBUL QADIR, ALl NASIR, BARRY DUNN, LEROY JOHNSON, JOE KUKLINSKY, GERALD GARY, HENRY OLIVERIA, FRAN¥ HUBBARD, CHRIS ANDERSON, ANTHONY LATTIMORE~

j MI'&'t'ON J;·::CON!:Ll'!Q, iflh , FRANK 1 MILLER, RICHARD WILLIAMS, HENRY

MCCREE, EDWARD L. BROWN, GARY REEVES, CLIFFORD ROBERTSON, ANTHONY FREDERICK, LAWRENCE PETERSON, STANLEY FARMS~)) CHARLIE FARMS, DARREN HAWKINS, MICHAEL ROSE, C''\RLTON FRAN!<I,IN, DARVIN ELDER, JAMES CARTER, ·J;H;COJ;."o G!IAhJli'P., ROSCOE MILLER, THOMAS A. PATTERSON, LOUIS ZELTNER, WALTER SIMON. DEREK BETHEA, WILLIAM MARSHALL, MICHAEL L, MADISON, i!llll RR:II: Ill IIX U.lli'ill!l, SAMUEL G. BIBBY, EUGENE POOLE, RAYMOND TORRES, ISIAH COLLINS, CLAUDE TIGNEY, DAVID MITCHELL, WALTER SAXTON\ TERRANCE HAYES,

DEFENDANTS ,. v .HOWARD L. BEYER, Individually

!and ae Superintendent of Trenton •] State Prison; ELAINE W. BALLA!, !·Individually and as Special Assis-

tant for Legal Affairs for the Department of Corrections; A~THONY c. TURNER, Individually and as Assistant Superintendent of Trenton State Prison; WILLIS MORTON, Individually and as Assistant Superintendent of Trenton State Prison; JAMES BARBO, Individually and as Assistant Superintendent of Trenton State Prison; ED O'DOHERTY, Individually and as Legal Services Coordinator for the Department of Corrections; VERNON JOHNSON, Individually and as Policy Develop

~USE ment at Trenton Sta.te Prison; nrrRO'T'HV Wl!l.t.:;HJ't-.TI':;'f'ON" Tnf"'Ji ;r-1 ~ ......... , ~ ·.'"

.HE UN <>nil as 01rector ot ProtessHmal 'liEF ST. Services at Trenton State Prison 1 Ising BRTGT'l'F': MT'lY~Hr~l.T._. Tn0ivit1nrl1 1v

a11U aa Execu~iY$ As&ietant at 1'renton State Prison; TOM JOHNSON,

---- lndividually and as Director of IRNEV! Social Workers at Trenton State

Prison; CHARLES TRAUTMAN, Indivi-dually and as Chief Deputy Keeper of Trenton State Prison; DOUGLAS K. HElL, Individually and as Director of Education at Trenton State Prison; RON V. PAICE, Individual.J.y a.nd as Assistant Supervi>Oor of Education at Trenton St.,.te Prison; PATRICIA SINGLETON, Individually and as Librarian at Trenton State Prison; GARY SHEPPARD, Individually and as Disciplinary Hearing Officer for Department of Corrections, ROBERT MAKARSKI, Individually

-

ARNOLD FARMER KEITH HEARD ABDALLAH KHALIQ & VICTCR PARI<ER ( AMENn. )

and as Disciplinary Hearing Officer for Department of Corrections; WOODARD (First name unknown),

HERBERT I,EE SMI'l'!:I, LOUIS P. WRIGHT: .I JAMES F, PORNlNO ."

LLOYD JOHNSON I DAVID RUSSO

BRIAN COYLE NICHOLAS conREl\

Al~e1 JAMES RICHARDSON

l

Individually and as Disciplanary Hearing Officer for Department <Jf Co~·rections; FRED ZIMMER, l:ndivi-dually and as a Guard Captain ····· at Trenton State Prison; R. REA,

ert Twli.vJdnal.ly and as a Guard C<I.ptain at Trent.on State Prison; ANTHONY KUBALA, Individually and as a

Sta Guard at Trenton State Prison; Trenton, NJ PARHAM (First name unknown), Indivi

dually and as a Guard at Trenton State Prison; BARNEY DYRNES, Indivi dually and as a Guard at Trenton State Pri~tJP; HOJ..N:CY (Fi..cst: nama unknown), Incli-vidually and as <> Guax·d at •rrenton State Prison; HARRIS (First name unknown), Individually a.nd as ~ l'::l1arci ''l·~'1'n>nt.on Stat-.e Prison; AVERHART (.f:i'J.J:~st;. n.-.ur1e Llnl.,nvwn),. ..Luu.ivid.u an0 A~ ~ ~u~r11 ~t Trentort Stat Prlson; WILLIAMS (F.iJ;et name t

known), Indi viduall:"Y and as a · Guard a't-_ Tr,z:o't"lt- ...... ,... Q..j... .... ..._- ..... •

l/I.Jl)

Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page 2 of 14 PageID: 2.......... _ ....

l

I'

--·. '

Al)e

ti "" 1

... v

CAUSE

(CITE THE U.S. CIVIL STATUTE UN-.~·~··· '"v~IS FIL~D AND WRITE A BRIEF STATEMENT OF CAUSE)

PRISONER CIVIL RIGHTS - Improper housing, etc.

Plaintiffs, pro se ., c/o Emmitt Valentine Y74807 Trenton State Prison . CN 861 (•. Trenton, N.J 08625

Victor Parker #72690 CN 861 Trenton

Abdallah Khaliq #70743

James F, Fornino #78928 CN 861 Trenton, NJ

ATTORNEYS

) . )

&o '1-,.

Aud~e

P~:isone 2 Washing

I

mts

t: , .. ~ -·~ ~

Legal Clinic

Louis p, Wright #50254 Herbert Lee Smith #56625 CN 861

Newark, .• NJ 7102 (a tty ,Cor pla1 iff class) (~1"<.• ~-•')

, I,

Trenton, NJ

Rod~iswicz #64141 pro se CN 861 Trenton, NJ 08625

'V . ,1'-\ \ \<...::: r-. t./ C•C~ .:"'.

( 1, .\~ 6• cl ''· ::1:·.:· • ·1.. Mr. Robert #61531:

G. Davis i>Avid 1! 1 ,.··. ·•.

CN 861 Trenton State Prison Trenton, NJ 08625

, -. -·-------. JS-e; JSfi_,. ___ _

I~ A

I __,

UNITED STAfES OISTRICT COUIH DOCKET DC·111 (Rev.9/81)

Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page 3 of 14 PageID: 3DATE NR.

,,-~ ... -~ b

9-9-85 1

9-9-85 2

9-9-85 3 9-9-85

. 9-20-85 4 9-20-85 5

CIVIL 85-440l(MTB) PFIOCEI!!DlNGS

·--~~---=-~~=~====-~·.... ·=~---=-==='··~=~

Complaint with declaration in support of pltf's proceeding in forma

pauperis annexed, filed 9-5-85. Order granting pltfs leave to proceed in forma pauperis, filed 9-5-85,

(Barry) (NM) Notice of Allocation and Assignment,filed.(Trenton-Barry)

Summons issued(20 days)(forwarded to USM) filed. filed.

9-20-85 6

Ltr. motion of Victor Parker to join in complaint as pltf.,

Ltr. motion of Abdallah Khaliq to join in complaint as pltf,

Order granting motion of Abdallah Khaliq & Victor Parker to be includ d

10-1-85 7

10-9-85 8

as pltfs., filed (Barry) ill

Appl. & Clerk's order extending time of deft a to file an answer to and

including 10-17-85 filed, Summons ret'd served upon defts. Tom Johnson on 9-26-85; Patricia Sing

on 9-17-85; Averhart on 9-19-85; Paice, Washington, Vernon Johnson,

Kubala, & Rea on 9-16-85; lleil on 9-18-85; Dyrnes, Turner, !lardo, Mor

Mitchell, Ballai, Parham, Zimme~, Sheppard, O'Doherty, Beyer, Woodard

Inman, Williams & Holvey on 9-l2-85r Trautman & Makarski on 9-13-85

<1ton arri~

0~\ t. /

I filed 10-8-85

'~0-17-85 9 Notice of cross-motion of defts. for summary judg. w/ aff. of Doug He 1

1 annexed thereon filed (P.O. & brief sub. J

0-17-85J 10 I Aff. of Anthony Turner, filed.

10-24-8$ 11l Cert. of service, filed. I I

0-25-85: IAt call for hearing on appl. of pltfs. for preliminary injunction; the court

!reported the motion to be decided on briefs submitted pursuant to R. 7

I I(Barry)(l0-21-85) ,

11-21-SS 12i Notice of motion of Jarne$ F. Fornino to be added as pltf., filed 11- 0-85

11-21-851131 Notice of motion of Louis l?. Wright to be added as pltf., filed ll-20 85

ll.ll-21-SSf 14 i Notioe of motion of Herbert Lee Smith to be added as pltf., filed 11-' Q,-85

l-21-85i lSL Order ,amend'ing the,complaint to include Herbert lee Smith, Louie P. ,

' Wright. ·and James F. Fornino as pltfs·., filed 11-20-85. (Barry)NM' .

1- -86 16 Ceri:Hic·au of' service, filed 1-3-86 , 1.7 1 Aff. of Clifford D. Roberts, filed 1-3-86 1 18! Aff. Darryl v. Conquest, filed l-3-S6 :19 1 Aff. of Allen Radziewicz, filed 1-10-86' 201 Legal Access oomplaint of pltf, to Director of Educ. at prison, file

4-28-86:21 i Notice of motion by defts. for summary judg., ret' ble 5-19-86 filed

' 'i· 4-25-86 (P.o. sub.) (per JJF) 5-12-84 22 Aff. of Clifford D. Roberts, filed •.

5-23-86 2~ Order denying defts. motion for summary judgment filed.NM

5-28-8~

1

. AT CALL for Hearing on motion by detts. for summary judgment; the Cour

reported the motion to be d~cide~ on briefs submitted pursuant to Rule

1 78. (REC) (S-19-96)

6-12-86 2~ A.nswer filed 6-ll-86

8-7-86 I Notice of crossrnotion by pltf. Allen Radziewicz to consolidate Civil

85-4401 w/ 84-4928,. filed on 8-4-86, (SEE CIVIL 84-4928GEB) ,..._..t•; ... _, ''"···' .•

1-U-87 25 I Ex-Parte mot_;_,,.. o!: pltfs. Rc•berts & Radziewicz for temporary restrai'nt~

.w/aff'a in support annexed, filed. (P.o. sub.)

1-12-67 26 I Notice of Motion by pl.t.i'~; ~oberts & Radziewicz for preliminary I

lin~,,_.,,,~.ion, ret'ble 2-17-87 w/proof of mailing annexed, filed. (P.O. & \....-

lllrief sub.)

I I

·-..l .. _ .. ____ ··---~-----·--·-·- -----------

Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page 4 of 14 PageID: 4~C: lilA RIV. l/7S)

~LAINTIFF

CIVIL. DOCKET CONTINUATION SHEET

DEFEND ANi

Emmitt Valentine, et.al. Howard L. Beyer, et.al, DOCKET NO. 85-4401

PAGELOF __ PAGE:S

DATE NR.

t-27-87 27

2-6-87 28

2-6-87 29

2-6-87 30

2-6-B 7 31 2-6-8 7 32

3-2-87

3-10-8'

4-2-87 ,-5-87

5-13-8

33

34

(-14-87 35

(-22-87 36

I -2-a1 37 rp 6-2-87 38

6-4-87 39 ~-18-87 40

6-19-8' 41

'::/- -10-87

<6 -7-87 q -7-87

42

43 44

g -26-87 45

PROCI!:EDINOS

Notice of Motion by pltf. Clifford Roberts &'Allen Radziewicz for preliminary injunction, ret'ble 2-17-87 w/statement no brief ness., supp. aff's., cert. of serv., annexed, filed. (P.O. sub. l Notice of Ex Parte Motion by pltf, Clifford Roberta for a temporary restraining order, w/supp. aff., annexed, filed.(P.O. o Brief sub,) Notice of Motion by pltf. Clifford Roberts. for preliminary injunction, ret'ble 3-2-87 w/cert. of serv., annexed, filed.(P.O. & Brief sub.)

Certification of Serv, of brief in opposition to pltfs. motion for preliminary injunction, filed. (Brief sub,) Affidavit of Howard Beyer, filed. Affidavit of James Barbo, filed.

AT CALL for Hearing on motion by pltf. Roberts & Rodziewica for preliminary injunction; the Court reported the motion to be decided on briefs submitted pursuant to Rule 78(REC)(2-l7-87) HEARING on motion by pltf., Clifford Roberts for preliminary injunction; the Court reported the motion to be decided on briefs submitted pursuant to Rule 78.(REC)(3-2-87) STATUS CONFERENCE: (REC)(3-18-87) Notice of Mot'ion by pltf. Clifford Roberts. to compel discovery, ret'ble 6-1-87 w/cert. of serv., aff. of good-faith, supp. aff., statement no brief neas., annexed, filed.(P.O. sub.) (R.78, FLWl Ex-Parte Motion by pltfs. Allen Radziewicz & Clifford Roberts for a temporary restraining order w/supp. aff's., annexed, filed. (P.O. & Letter brief sub.) Order denying pltfs. application for a temporary restraining order, etc., filed. (REC)NM /' Notice of Motion by pltf. for pr~minary injunction, ret'ble 6-15-8 w/cert. of serv,, annexed, filed.(P.O. & brief sub.)

Minutes of 6-l-87 filed (FLW) Order granting in part & denying in part pltf. Clifford Robert's motion, filed (FLW) NM Aff. of Service of Letter Memo by defts., filed. (Memo sub. l

Minutes of 6-16-87, filed 6-16-87(REC) Hearing on Preliminary Injunction Minut~s of 6-17-87, filed 6-l7-87(RECl Cont. Hearing on motion by pltfs. for a Prelimi~-rnjunction. Notice of Motion by pltfs. Biegenwald & Rod~ icz to consolidate Civ.85-4401 w/ Civ.84-2562 ret'ble 9-9-87 cert. of serv., annexed, filed(P.O. • Brief sub.) Rule 78(REC)(9- 87) Opinion, filed.(REC)NM Order granting in part & denying in par.t pltfs. motions for

!Preliminary injunction, filed. (REC)NM 1

Notice of Appeal by defts. from order of 8-7-87, filed. (Cpys. to USCA: pltfs. pro se Valentine t74807, Parker i72690, Khaliq t70743, Fornino t 78928, Wright tS0254, and Rod2iewicz t64141 Trenton State Prison en 861 Trenton, NJ 08625 and Michael E. Kahn, nAG for all defts. RJ Hughes Justice Complex CN 112 Trenton, NJ 08625)


=:::::----------_;C,_,I_,_VI:::~rD:;;OCKET CONTINUATION SHE!:T !TIFf.' DEFENDANT

E NR.

87 46

87 47

DOCK~TNO. ----

PAGE: _,,...OF __ FAGE5

PROCEEDINGS

Notice of Motion by pltfs. Roberts & Radziewicz to hold defts. in contempt of order of 8-7-87, ret'ble 9-22-87 w/cert. of serv., anne ed, filed. (P.O. & Brief sub.) Rule 78(REC)(9-22-87) Application by deft. for a stay of Judgment on Short Notice, ret'bl 9-3-87.

'f-~-'E' q-'6~-t:t 49 q_,,.- 87

f-'' 87

48

50 51

Transcript Purchase Order, filed. (Trans,of 6-16-87 & 6-17-87 req.)

Order not staying Court's or<l'lr of R-7-87 penning appeal, .filed 9-3-87. (REC)nm

Minutes of 9-9-87, filed 9-9-87(REC) Order denying pltfs. motion to consolidate this action w/Civ.84-256 ,

w/o prejudice, filed 9-10-87(REC)NM

f.- ,.s~ 87

frl)- 87

(CJ, ?>o ,g

11-11-- ·8 1:: '8

/r~ ' -a /1 r 1"f -8 /r- "!--"

lr-1.Jve Vi -a 1'1.--(Z. -?4 ·8 (1" 7--f 8

~~-~ :~ 12-~ ·R r~.-- -a

/v rt--Vr -8

52

53

Notice of Motion by pltf. Allen Radziewicz to provide transcript of proceedings w/supp. aff., cert. of serv., annexed, filed. Order deeming pltfs. motion for transcription of proceedings as moot, filed(REC)NM

54 Transcript of motions taken on 6-16-87, filed 9-21-87. 55 Transcript of motions taken on 6-17-87, filed 9-21-87.

RECORD COMPLETE FOR PURPOSES OF APPEAL, (Parties notified) 56 Minutes of 9-22-87, filed 9-22-87(REC) 57 Notice of Motion by pltf. Allen Radziewicz to compel discovery,

ret'ble 11-16-87 w/supp. aff,, cert, of serv., annexed, filed. (P.O. & Brief sub,) Rule 78(FLW)(ll-16-87)

SS Notice of Motion by pltf, Clifford Roberts to compel discovery,

59

60 61 62 63

64 65

66

67

68

ret'ble ll-16-87 w/supp. aff., cert. of serv., ann~xed, filed. (P.O. & Brief sub.) Rule 78(FLW) (11-16-87) . Notice of Motion by pltfs. Clifford Roberts & Allen Rodziew1cz for preliminary injunction enjoining deft. Beyer from housing Roberts, Bibby & Tu'lam in admin. seqregation, ret'ble 12-7-87 w/cer of serv., annexed, filed. (P.O. & Brief sub.) Minutes of ll-16-87, filed ll-l6-87.(FLW) Aff. of James Barbo, filed. Aff. of Dolores Hewitt, filed. Order granting in part & denying in part pltf. Roberts motion to compel discovery; etc., filed ll-19-87(FLW)NM

Supplemental Aff, of Dolores Hewitt, filed. Petition & Order for Writ of Habeas Corpus as to Clifford Roberts, ret'ble 1~5-88, filed. Writ issued(to USM-Trenton) Petition & order for Writ of Habeas corpus as to Emmitt Valentine ret'ble 1-5-88, filed. Writ issued (to USM-Trenton) ~etition & Order for Writ of Habeas Corpus as to Allen Radziewicz, ret'ble 1-5-88, filed. W~it i~~n<>n. (t:o USM-~r<'!nton) Petition & Order for Writ of Habeas Corpus as to Lloyd Johnson, ret'ble 1-5-88, filed. Writ issued (to USM-Trenton)

Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page 6 of 14 PageID: 6!C 111A RIIW, 1/7$)

~LAINTIFP

CIVIL. POCK~T CON'fiNUA.TION BHEET

DEFEND ANi

Emmitt Valentine et.al. Howard Beyer et.al.

DOCKET NO. ~ .. 5-4401

FAG C. _!_oF-.... -· PAGES

OATE

1 2-29-8

L-13-88 l-15-SE

:2. -3-88 .,'2-19-88 -~-19-88

3 -7-88 .? -7-88

4-19-88

_9-11-88

5-17-8

5-25-88

5-25-8[

~~::~:: 6-24-88

1-ll-88 '-ll-8 8 -11-88 -ll-88

-15-88 '-15-88

7-18-88

NR. PROCE.E:C!NG$

69 Notice of Motion by defts. t~~,File response nunc pro tunc & grant a protective order ret'ble '2..-4'-88 w/cert. of serv, supp. aff., annexed, filed. (P.O. & Brief sub,) Rule 78(FLW)(2-l-88)

70 Cert. of Service, filed. (brief sub.) 71 Minutes of 1-7-88, filed 1-l4-88(JFG)

Hearing on Order to Show Cause why defts. should not be held in contmept; Order to Show Cause dismissed.

72 Minutes of 2-l-88, filed 2-3-88(FLW) 73 Letter Opinion filed. (Wolfson) 74 Order re: compelling defts. to make certain discovery & denying

defts' motion for protective order filed. (Wolfson)(NM) 75 Amended Order re: discovery due dates, filed 3~4-88(FLW)NM . 76 Order dismissing pltfs. motion to hold defts. ~n contempt, f1led

2-29-88(JFG)NM 77 Memo. & Order re: discovery due l'l.ates 1 granting defts. motion for a

protective order re: certain documents; etc., filed(FLW)NM 7$ Notice of Motion by pltf~ ~g~~iiWkfifd:h~~l'l~"t.o extend hours of InmatE

Legal Assoc. at TSP; compel discovery, ret'ble 7-6-88 w/cert. of serv., annexe·d, filed. (P.O. & Brief sub,)

79 Notice of Motion by deft. Lloyd Johnson for a protective order for discovery, ret'ble 6-20-88 (FLW) w/cert. of serv., annexed, filed. (P.O. & Letter brief sub.)

80 Notice of Motion by pltf. Allen Rodziewicz to hold defts in contempt of Discovery order ret'ble 7-6-88 w/cert. of serv., annexed, filed

(P.O. & B~ief sub.) 81 Notice of Motion by pltf. Allen Radziewicz to compel discovery

ret'ble 6-20-88 w/supp. aff's., cert. of se~v., annexed, filed.

82

83

84

85 86 87 88

89 90

91

1 (P.O. & Brief sub.) Stipulation & Order of Voluntary Dismissal as to pltf. Raheem A. Muslim a/k/a Barry Williamson, filed 5-26-88(JFG)NM Memo. ~ Order granting pltfs. motion for consolidation w/ Civ. 87-1301· granting pltfs. motion to amend' the complaint, filed 6-7-88 (AET)NM

Notice of Motion by pltf. Allen Radziewicz & Ronald Long for discovery; preliminary injunctions ret'ble 9-7-88 W/cert. of serv., annexed, filed. (P.O. & Brief sub.) Minutes of 7-5-88, filed 7-5-88. SEE i81 -RULE 78 - WOLFSON) Minutes of 7-5-88, filed 7-5-88. (SEE 179 -RULE 78 -WOLFSON) Minutes of 7-5-88, filed 7-5-88. (SEEt 78 -RULE 78 - WOLFSON) Minutes of 7-5-86, filed 7-5-88, (SEE i80-RULE 78-WOLFSON)

OPINION of USCA dated 7-20-88, filed 7-14-88. Cert. copy of order of USCA affirming judgment of u,s.o.c. entered

6-7-Bf w/costs taxed against appellants, filed 7-14-88. Order & Stipulation by pltf, Nicole Chalet, of voluntary dismissal a/tall defts., filed 7-ll-88.

B-18-88 92 1-30-88 93

'order re-assigning action from Judge LifLand to Judge Thompson, filed Copies of Order of Re-Assignment re:turned unknown as to certain pltfs., filed 8-26-88.

~ -30-88 94 Copy of Order of Re-Assignment returned on Interstate as to Pltf.

1 Milton J. Conklin, Jr., ProSe, filed 8-26-88.


JTJFF

·~ NR.

'25- ?o- ·88 95

l)~ '1vr as 96

'6~ ~0 r

88 97

~- ~(y sa 98

'f-'ti~ a a 99

'j' r 'ZU,.. 88 100

q~7J,- es 101

q~ Z.<6- Sf 102

CIVIl.. DOCKI!!:T CONTINUATION SHEET

DEFENDANT DOCKET NO,-------

PAGE_ OF" ... _FAGE5

Fi'AOCE:EOING:!ii

Copies of Order of Re-Assignment returned Released as to pltfs. Darvin Elder and Louis Zeltner, filed 8-26-88. Opinion, filed 8-24-88. (!'LW) (N/M). Order denying pltfs. motion for protective order, granting in part and denying in part defts. motion compelling discovery and denying pltfs. motion to hold defts. in contempt of court, filed B-24-88. (FLW) (N/M). ~otice of Call for Dismissaf pursuant to Rule 30 as to Pltfs. listed pn attached sheet ret'ble 9-15-88 before AET, filed. (N/M). ~etter by pltf. Clifford D. Roberts-re: General Rule 30, filed 9-13-88 Notice of Motion by pltf. Ronald E. Long, Sr. to compel discovery, etc. ret'ble l.0-3-88 before JWD with Rule lSC Certification in support and cert. of service annexed, filed 8-29-88. (Brief & P.O. Subm.)

Notice of motion of pltf., Radziewicz to compel discovery ret'ble 10-17-88 filed. (Brief & PO Subm.)

Copies of Notice of Call For Dismissal, etc. returned not delivered as to pltfs. Abdul Latif, Abdul Qadir Ali Nasir, Askin Muhammad, William Marshall, Michael L. Madison, Abdus-Sami A. Akbar, Michael Barron, Lewis Webb, James Webb, Samuel Bibby, Raheem Akbar, L~roy

Johnson, Keith Heard, Darryl v. Conquest, Gerald Gary, Richard Williams, Arnold Farmer, Roscoe Miller, Louis Zeltner, Charles Holman, Darvin Elder, Milton J, Conklin, Jr., Edward Brown, filed 9-7-88,

~ ~ Z..1 ~ 88 103 Copy of order of Re-Assignment returned Unknown as to pltf. Lewis Webb, filed 8-30-88.

q,.. 2-1~ 88 104 Order Re-Assigning action from Judge Thompson to Judge Lifla11d, filed 9-26-88. (JFG)(N/M),

q-zJ1- 88 105 Amended Complaint by pltf. Ronald E. Long, Sr., filed 9-28-88.

torl4 ·8 106 Copies of order of re-Assignment, etc. returned refused, filed. f\ , 1 -8 107 opies of order of re-Assignm~nt, etc. returned because pltf's tu~l"'l were released, filed.

(u~~-·8 108 Copies of Order of re-Assignment, etc. returned because address unknown, fil~d. ~

(Or it( -88 109 order re: Dlscovery and pltf'sArnot"Js-on be granted in part and denied in part, filed 10-13-88. (Devine) (NM)

(0'/";f -8 110 /'onswer by defj! .. Bl!lyer, Hell gnd StribliiJ.\4-tO Amended complaint, w/jury demand, fil@d 10-7-88.

(uri~ ·-a 111 Minutes of 10-3-88, filed 10-3-88. (SEE flOO RULE 78- DEVINE) til ·8 •12 Notice of Cro~Motion by defts., for a protectivB order,w/certifica e

(o~ ,~ of mailing, affidavit, ret'ble ll-7-88, filed 10-21-88. (Ltr brief o

88 ll4

P.o. subm)

i:>Jotiee of ,i·lo·l:ion ~JY t. ·=lll;;!n 1~od:ziGrvti.l.:1~ io:L. C\on'~t;!ll\bJ'l.: citation w/affidavit of service, ret'ble 11-21-88, filed 10-31-68. (brief • P.O. subm) ~linutes of 11-7-88 filed. (See UOl & 112 -RULE 78 -Wolfson)

Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page 8 of 14 PageID: 8OC UlA :~ev. 1/75)


FLAINfiFF DEFENDANT

EMMITT VALENT!NE , ET AL HOWAfiD BEYER, ET At PAOE:_,OF_~·· PAGES

DATI!: NR.

ll-14-88 11: Order re: Discovery, a~ to pltf, Allen Rodziewicz, .. filed 11•10·8~ •. (Wmlfson) (NM to said pltf and defense counsel per FLW)

l.l-28-8 116 Minutes of ll-18-88, filed 11-18-88, SEE 1113 - RULE 78 -LIFLAND)

12-5-88 117 Notice of Motion by pltfs to Appeal Magistrates order, w/certificat on pf service, ret'ble 1-3-89, filed 11-29-88. (Brief & P.O. subm)

(2-22-88 118 rotice of Motion by defts,, to compel certain discovery, w/certifica e pf service & affidavit, of certain pltfs, ret'ble 1-17-89, filed 12-21-88. (statement no brief & p.o. subm)

12-23-S 119 Memorandum & Order affirming Magistrate's Order of 11-10-88, ~i1ed 12-22-88. (Lifland) (NM)to said p1tf & defense counsel per JC

L2-23-8 120 order denying pltf's motion to hold defts. in contempt of court, bled 12-22-88. (Lifland) (NM to said pltf & defense Counsel per

chambers) \2-29-88 121 Ltr by pltf, Earl Bayard in opposition to defts,, motion re: discove y,

filed. 1-9-89 122 Minutes of 1-3-89, filed 1-3-89, (SEE ill7 -RULE 78 - LIFLAND)

L-10-89 123 NOtice of Motion by pltf, Allen Radziewicz, for an Order to amend o alter its previously·entered judgment denying contempt citation, w/certificate of service and affidavit, ret'ble 2-6-89, filed 1-6-8 Ltr brief & P.O. subm)

-13-89

1-24-8

~6-'69 6-89 -23-8

l-10-8~

3-22 ... 89

,.3-22-89

t.f.-s-a9

s-31-89

124

125

126 127 128 129

130

131

132

Order denying pltf'a motion to hold defts. in contempt, filed 1-12-!9. (JCL) (NM to $aid pltf and defen5e counsel per JCL)

Notice of motion by pltf to allow inmate paralegals to be allowed to represent death row prisoners, rtn 02-21-89, w/statement re. brief, cert of svc, filed 01-19-89. (po o memo subm)

Minutes of 2-6-89, filed. (SEE #118 RULE 78 - LIFLAND) • Minutes of 2-6-89, filed. (SEE #123 - RULE 78 - LIFLAND) Minutes of 2-21-89, filed 2-21-81, (SEE #125 -RULE 78 - LIFLAND) Affidavit of Ron Paice, filed 3-3-89. Order aci!rninistratively terminating case of pltf Conklin, filed 3-?l-R~, (.'<::!,) (~1M) (pc:: chanbe~~ ~Cnt t" n)'n ~ .. nllcf) Orderdismissing action as to pltfs Amin & Muslim, filed 3-21-89. (JCL) (NM) (per chamb8rs sent to pro se plft) Order denying pro se pltf Ronald E. Long, Sr. motion to allow in··· mate paralegals to represent death row prisoners, filed 4-4-89.

(JWD) (NM) (per chambers NM to Pro Se pltf and defence counsel)

133 Not~ce of Motion by pltf., Ronald E. Long, sr, to appeal non-disposi rul~ng by U.~.Mag1strate Concerning INmate - Paralegal Assistance to dea~h row pr~soner~ in disciplinary hearings, w/proof of service, ret ble 6-19-89, f1led 4-17-89, (ok per chambers)

134 ~inutes of 6-22-89, filed 6-22-89. (SEE #133 - RULE 78 - LIFLAND) 135 Memorandum ~ Order affirming Magistrate's Ruling, fi,led. ( JCL) ( NM) 136 Notice of motion of pltf., Robert Davis to compel d1scovery

ret'ble 9-5-89 filed. (Brief & PO Subm) 137 Letter of Pltf. re• Change of address fld 7-26-89.


CIVIL. DOCKET CONTINUATION SHe:ET

lT!Ff" DEFENDANT

MITT VALEN!J'T"" BRADLEY BOYD, r.T AL. PAGE .. _Of'_. PAGE:S

F'ROCIJ!:!OING$ ;-r-NR,

~U'I~s=· ,f======e""'" ~-.. ~-~=====~-· ~. · ··-- -o~,·~=·oc·.~-===---~---

Minutes of 9-6-8-9 fld. 1-See ~q6 - Rule. 78 - Wolfson) . " , .,

89 139

(\~ ?-V-- 8\ 140

{.- $"' .... cpa 141

l~(f-·9 142

;;.,~ ~~~ 90 143

;;..~ 1?--- 90 144

3" 1o ~'f'o 145

'(1~6rql) 146

(u ,..;(, -9~ .:;J

(or/~ /r-4'-11· ;)p -9

I,_,. w -9

I "2-- z_& -9

150

1St 152

tG 91 153 /~1- ,.- 911>4 2-" 11 -)..-?-9'" 9

155

p,~ 'J.T-- n 156

Li·- rf~ 9

L-\ ~ z_2~ 9

:f-- ,, .. Jff t-'"'2-r 9

'f.-1..-J ""9-

157

158 159

160

161

order denyiDg as moot pltf Robert Davis' request to compel discovery

( FLW) ( NM) ()"""> Rol."" ... ~"" "'""'"'"" Notice of motion by pltfsilfor a preliminary injunction barring the defts' from continuing their present policies and practices of elim various legal access hours wherein the ILA paralegals may service close custody prisoners; and from reducing the number of badges one made available to ILA for access to close custody units ret'ble before JCL on 12-18-89 fld. (Brief Subm) (R.78-2/20/90 JCL) U.S. Marshal's return of service of summons as to deft w. cary Edwards unexecuted fld 10-25-S9.~e,,.;~,l(ubz,f~',t.z:: JL· bJ"Ju;s

Notice of motion by pltfs"'{o_r ___ an order restraining the defts from

nadng

limiting the hours in which general population inmates have access to meaningful legal assistance tld 1-16~90. tLtr. Brief· 1 P~O. Sub

Notice of ltfotion of pltfs., Cook, Radziewicz & Davis for a temporary restraining order ret'ble 3-5-90 filed 2-13-90. (Brief & PO Subm.)

CertificaTION OF Brigete Mitchell Wilson filed.

Minutes of 2/20/90 f~led 2/20/90 (See #140-Lifland) Memorandum and Order denying pldtfs' motions for a temporary restrai order and a preliminary injunction fld. (JCL)(NM) Notice of motion by Plaintiffs-movants, Allen Radziewicz, Clifford Roberts, Robert G. Davis and Kaseem J. Murchison for a permanent injunction w/ Cert. of service ret'ble for 11-S-90 filed.( statemen in lieu of brief and PO subm.) Certification of David M. Russo, filed.

~o:cc,;r urder directing parties to submit pretrial memorandum by 12-5-90, fld, 11-5-90. (FLW) n/m

Notice of Motior1 of pltf 's for an order compelling discovery ret'ble 12-17-90, fld. (Ltr Brief • P.o. Subm)

Minutes of 12-17-90, fld. 12-17-90. (See #150 - Rule 78 - FLW)

Memorandum and Order denying as moot pltf, pro s,e Alan Radziewicz moti.on ~." oo"'P"l C!iscovery flc'. 17-~o-Qn, (WJMl INMl

Order re: due date for pretrial memorandum fld 1-17-91. (FLW)(NM)

Notice of motion of pltf to add parties to the complaint ret'ble 3-4-91 before FLW fld 2-8-91. (P.O. Subm) Letter by pltf dtd 9-19-90 re: all correcspondence to be mailed to inmate Radziewicz fld Order adjourning pltf's motiorl to add pltf's until 4-l-91, fld.

2-26-9.1. ( FLW) n/m order grantin~ pltf's motion to amend the complaint within 30 days fld. (FLW) (NM)

MINUTES OF 4/15/91 filed 4/15/91" (See tl54)(RULE 78)(FLW).

Notice of motion of pltfs to interview witnesses ret'ble 8-5~91 before JCL fld 6-28-91. (Brief & P.o. subm) Letter by plt£., Radziewicz, re: reserving deft., Pantano with copy of motion ret'ble 8-5-91 fld 7-19-91. Letter of pltf., Shukri Fardan dtd 7-5-91 re: disignating lead plt as Allen Radziewicz fld 7-9-91.

ing

Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page 10 of 14 PageID: 10c 111A teY. J/,!1)

CIVIL DOCKET CONTINUATION SHEET

DEF~NDANT 85-4401 EMMITT VALENTINE BRADLEY BOYD, ET AL.

DOCKET NO. ·---

PAGE_OF_ ._PAGES

OAT£ NR" PROCE:E:DINGS

-""~=!===+~=~"~~==~ """ ---" -~ 6-8-91 162 Minutes of 8-5-91 fld 8-5-91. (See #159 - RULE 78 - JCL)

QL6-91 63 Letter Order referring matter to FLW for a discovery/staus conferan e I on 9-24-91 fld 9-5-91. (JCL) (NM) 4-6-91 164 Petition and Order for a Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Kaseem I Murchison ret'ble 9-24-91 f1d 9-5-91. (FLW)(NM)

0,-6-91 Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Murchison ret'ble 9-24-91 issued. -~ (USM)

q-6 91 165 Petition and Order for Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Allen Rod~iewicz ret'ble 9-24-91 fld 9-5-91. (FLW)(NM)

~6-91 Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf,, Radziewicz ret'ble 9-24-91 issue 1 (USM) ~'-6-91 166 Petition and Order for Writ of Habeas Corpus as to p1tf., Robert G.

Davis ret'ble 9-24-91 fld 9-5-91. (FLW)(NMl q,-6-91 Writ of Habeas Corpus as to p1tf., Davis ret'b1e 9-24-91 issued. I (USM)

q-6-91 167 Petition and Order for Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Clifford D, Roberts ret'b1e 9-24-91 fld 9-5-91. (FLW) (NH)

q -6-91 168 Writ of Habeas Corpus as to p1tf., Roberts ret'b1e 9-24-91 issued. (USM)

0-6-91 169 Memorandum and Order denying pltfs' motion for leave to jointly 7 interview witnesses fld. (JCL)(NM)

)-24-9 170 'Petition and Order for writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Shukri

l-24-9

L0-7-9 171 f-0-ll-91 172

f.0-11-91 -

//)-11-91 173

[&-ll-911

lfj-ll-91 174

(O-ll-91

{l-13-9 175 1 z-4-91 176

(2-ll-9 177

Fardan ret' ble 9-24-91 fld 9-23-91. (FLS) (NM) Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Fardan ret'ble 9-24-91 issued. (USM) Amended Complaint fld 10-4-91. Petition and Order for Writ of Heabeas Corpus as to pltf., Clifford Roberts ret'b1e l0-16-91 fld 10-9-91. (FLW)(NM) Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Roberts ret'ble 10-16-91 issued. (USM) Petition and Order for Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Kaseern Murchison ret'ble 10-16-91 fld 10-9-91. (FLW)(NM) Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Murchison, ret'b1e 10-16-91 issu d, (USMl Petition and Order for Writ of Habeas Corpus as to pltf., Allen Radziewicz ret'ble 10-16-91 fld 10-9-91. (FLW)(NM) Writ of Habeas Corpus as to p1tf,, Radziewicz, ret'ble 10-16-91 issued. (USM)

Transcript of status conference taken on 11-6-91 fld, Letter Order re• production of certain documents fld 12-3-91. (FLW) (NMl Order denying defts' request for an adjournment of 30 days and to

I be relieved of its obligation to produce certain discovery fld . 12-10-91. (JCL) (NM)

~2-13-91 178 Notice of appearance for defts f1d 12-12-91.

/ -22-92 179 Affidavit of Gary Lee Drake f1d ll-19-91. 1 ·22-92 180 Affida~it of Carl Joseph Culley fld 11-19-91. / -22-92 181 Affidavit of Michael Bartels f1d ll-19-91,


I)

NTJFF

TE N~.

( r?.-'L~ 92 182

t ~ '2--'\..-<" 92 183 1.-'-l ..... 92 184

("' I~ 'Z'f -9 165

t- '2.-'{ -9 186

,_'2--q ·92 187

I ~?v -9, 188

I ~ .i?t.:) -9 2 189

'2---? 92 190 5'-~ .q 2 l91

5'-Zf -92 192

',_ (~CJ 2 193

& -~,1 2 194

!;, _t; 2 195

:t-ro~cr 2 196

(--21. ·92 197

7-·rp ·92 198

l)'r~,-9 2 199

"Qr ?~'f 2 200

'2,r '1 0 ·93 201

L.J ~ I ,., 93 202

~-~7 -93 203

r-- lv S3 204

CIVIL COCKET CONTINUATION SHEET DEFENDANT

P~OCE:EDINGS

Affidavit of Michael CorsT'"fid 11-19 91. Affidavit of Salvatore Gerardi fld ll-19-91,

OOCKE:T NO. ·-----

FAGE_OP_ PAGe:S

Order setting trial for l-27-92 at NJ State Prison fld l-23-92. (JCL)

Certification of Allen Rod~iewicz re: fld l-21-92.

response to discovery disput

Certification of Jesse Guzman fld 1-21-92. Minutes of l-27-92, fld, l-27-92. (Hearing on motion by pltfs for

permanent injunction - denied. Hearing on motion by defts to compel payment of witness fees - denied. Stipulation read into record re: inmate population- JCL)(Joseph Trotto)

Minutes of 1-28-92 fld 1-28-92, (Hrn. on motion by pltfs. for permanent injunction continued - Ordered hrn. continued to 1-29-92 JCL) (Pasquale Corvine) Minutes of 1-29-92 fld 1-29-92. (Hrn. continued on pltf's motion for permanent injunction. SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE. Action reported settled. Terms of settlement read into record - JCL) (J. Trotto)

Transcript taken on 1-29-92 fld, Notice of motion of pltf., Lloyd Johnson, for a contempt citation ret'ble 6-1-92 fld 5-4-92, (letter brief o P.O. Subrn) Affidavit of Howard L, Beyer fld 5-18-92, Minutes of 6~1-92 fld 6-1-92, (See #191 - RULE 78 - MLP) Affidavit of David M, Russo fld 6-1-92, Letter of pltf., Lloyd Johnson re: objection to Video tape submitte~ for in camera review fld. Memorandum and Order denying pltf's motion for contempt sanctions and direoting deft., Beyer, to comply with provisions of the prelirn'nary injunction entered on 1-11~88 f1d 7-2-92. (JCL)(NMl Notice of motion of defts to vacate the preliminary injunction ente ed by Judge Thompson on 1-11-SS fld 7-21-92.. (P.O, & Brief subml Copy of letter order of Judge Lifland sett~ug motion hearing date of 9-14-92 on motion to vacate fld 7-23-92. Affidavit of David M. Russo fld 7-30-92. Affidavit of Lloyd Johnson fld 7-30-92. Memorandum and Order denying deft's. motion to modify the injunctio entered on l/11/88. fld. 3/25/93.

Order re-allocating case from Trenton to Newark and re-assigned from Judge Pare11 to Judge Lifland. (NM)

Notice of Motion by pltfs to enter judgment based on proposal. flo. 5-21-93. Ret. S-9-93. With proof of service, att aff of Allen Radziewicz, (b~ief & appendix sub).

MEMORANDUM & ORDER denying pltf'e Motion to enter judgment based upon their proposed $ettlement agreement. Fld. 7-14-93. (JCL) n/m

·------- '" ··-·-··-··-·- --------· -·


( (

K:: UiA Rev. 1/75)

PLAINTIFF CIVIL. OOCKEi CONTINUATION I$HE:II!:T

Ot:F~NOANT

DOCKET NO. 65-4401

EMMITT VALENTINE HOWARD L. BEYER PAGE _OF __ PAGES

NA, PAOCEE:CJNG5

10-14-93 205 Order setting Settlement Conference for 10-21-93, at 2:00p.m., and writs having been issued for A. Rodziewicz, c. Roberts,

L0-14-9 ~ 206

L0-14-9 p 207

L0-14-9 3 206

D. Russo and L. Johnson· prose pltfa in this action to be produced for this conference· etc. Fld 10-13-93. (LIFLAND) n/m

nraer of issuance of Writ of Habeas Corpus issued as to Cleft, Lloyo Johnson #79940. Fld. 10-11-93.

Order of issuance of writ of Habli>-'s Carpus issued as to deft, David M. Russo #208920. Fld. 10-13-93.

Order of issuance of Writ of HabeJ!ile Corpus iaaueO as to deft, Allen Radziewicz #64141. Fld. 10-13-93.

L0-14-93 209 Order of issuance of Writ of Habe~ Corpus issued as to deft, Clifford D. Roberts #54601. Fla. 10-13-93.

0-21-9 210 Minutes of Proceedings of l0-21-93 fld. Settlement Conference. ordered action certified as a Class Action. OTBS (CR~LYNNE JOHNSON) ( L IFLAND) .

0-27-9 211

0-28-9 212

.2-21-9 ~ 213

Order certifying action as class action. Fld. 10/2$/93. (LIFLAND) n/m.

Transcript of Proceedings of 10-21-93. Fld. 10-27-93.

Notice of atty appearance by Audrey Somi~ Esq. for plaintiff class. Flo. 12-20-93.

I L2-29-l 3 214 order for proposed Settlement Agreement (LIFLAND) fld 12-29-93. (in English)

I 2-29-9

I -13-94

( -13-94

I -13-94

I -21-94

( -21-94

( -21-94

( -24-94

21S

216

217

218

219

220

221

222

• settl~rnent Anreernent (L!FLAND) f1d 12-29-93. order for propose~ - ~ (in Spanish)

Order of Issuance of Writ of Habeas Corpus issued as to deft. Clifford D. Roberts, #54601. Fld. l-12-94. (LIFLAND)

Order of Issuance of Writ of Habeas Corpus issued as to deft, Allen Radziewicz, *64141. Fld. 1-12-94. (LIFLAND)

Order of Jssuance of Writ of Habeus Corpus iss~ed as to deft, David Russo, #208920. Fld. 1-12-94 (LIFLAND)

Order Of Issuance of Writ of Habeus corpus issued as to deft, Allen Radziewicz #64141. Fld. (LIFLAND)

Ord~r of Issuance of Writ of Hab@us Corpus issued as to deft, David M. Russo #208920. Fld. (oiFLAND)

Order of Issuance of Habeue corpus issued as to d@ft 1

Clifford D. Roberts #54601. Fld. (LIFLAND)

Response in Opposition by Royce Davis to terms of propoeed settlement agreement, etc F1d.


;).,~ 1:) d-1)

;}-- 1)

rE NR.

223

224

22S

226

227

228

229

230

231

232

233

234

235

236

237

238

239

240

241

242

243

-94 225

-94 226

-94 22 7

:1~1 (p ~ ·94 228

~ ..... rt- 94 229

CIVIL, DOCKET GONTINUAIION SHEET

DEF"ENOANT DOCKCT NO.

PAGE _OF __ FAGESi

~ROCEEOING$

Objection by Al-Damany Kanau to P~oposed Settlement. Fld.

Objection by James D. Cecil to Proposed Settlement Fld.

Objection by Marco Vincent Di Giovanni to Proposed Settlement Fld.

Objection by Jame~ D. Cecil to Proposed Settlement Fld.

Objection by Alonzo Jenkins to Proposed Settlement Fla.

Objection by Daud Obika Tulam to P~oposed settlement Fld.

Objection by Ronald Long to Proposed settlement Fla.

Objection by Jesus Sanabria to Proposed Settlement ~la

Affidavit of mailing by Royc8 Davis Re: mailing of objection. Fld.

Letter by pltf, Ronald Long Re: Legal Access Complaint. flo.

Objection by Patrick Welke to Proposed Settlement. Fld.

Objection by James Storozynsky to Proposed Settlement. Flo

Objection by Jeffrey Dishon to Proposed Settlement. Fld.

Objection by Jim stoorzyneky to P~oposed Settlement. Fld.

Objection by Robe~to Marquez to Proposed Settlement. Fld

Objection by Richard Linsky to Proposed Settlement. Fla.

Objection by Peter Joe Rivera to Proposed Settlement. Fld.

Objection by Alfred Anderson to Proposed Settlement. Fld.

Objection by Jamaal w. Allah to Proposed Settlement .. Fld.

Objection by Emerson Tucker to Proposed Settlement. Fla.

Objection by David M. Russo. Executive Director to proposed Settleme t Agreement. Flo.

Minutes of Proceedings of 2-14-94 fld. Hrg to approve class action settlement. Settlement not approved. New Settlement agreement due 2-28-94 or tri~l date will be set. (CR-LYNNE JOHNSON (LIFLANP) 1 A ment · · Re: Propos@d Sett ement gree ·

Letter by Maalik Abdul-~lllm Fld. 2-8-94. , , R Proposed Settlement Ag~eement.

Letter by Maalik Abdul-Al1lm e: Fld 2-10-94. t , . Re: Propos~a Settlement Agreemen

Letter by Maalik Abdul-Al11m Fld. 2-10-94.

Objection by Martin Luther King to proposed Settlement Agreement.

Fld. deft Of Intent to file motion for Summary Notice by atty tor

Judgment Fld.



DO<;;KET N0_85-440l PLAINTIFF OE:FE:NDANT

EMMITT VALENTINE HOWARD L. BE¥ER

DATE NR.

J :-25 94 223

3 :-25-94 224

5i-l3-94 225

~-13-94 22(i 10-6-9 227

{

{

l

l0-6-9 228 10-6-9 229

ll-1-9• 230

l-7-94 231

1-29-9 232

2-28-9 233

l-20-9 2.34

~--:::::_

r-, __

PAGE_OF __ PAGg$

PAOCE:E:OINGS

Certification by James cecil Re: objections to Settlement Agreement. Fld.

Letter by pltf, James Cecil #230103 voluntarily withdrawing his objections to Settlement Agreement, etc. Fld

Certification of DavidM- Russo Re: settlement proceedings. Fld. Certification of Allen Radziewicz Re: settlement proceedings Fld. Settlement Agreement of Class Action Fld. 10-5-94 Memorandum Fld- 10-5-94 (LIFLAND) Order granting defts motion dismissing class action complaint

w/prejudice and further ordering that no fees or coste are to be awardPd to either party- Fld. 10-5-94. (LIFLAND)

Deficient Mot'ion by pltfs, 'Allen Radziewicz, Clifford Roberts & David Russo to vacate the judgment entered 10-5-94. (S!"a' OR ~rief not aub) Fld. 10-25-94.

Substitution of Attorney for pltf claee terminating Augrey Borne, Esq and adding David Russo, Allen Radziewicz and Clitford Roberts pro se. Fld. 10-26-94.

Notice of Motion by pltfs allen Radziewicz, clifford Rob~~S· & David Russo vacating the judgment entered 10-5-94~~ttached certf of A~ Rodziewicz & D- Rueso & cert of aervic@. Ret-12-27-94. Fld. 11-22-94. Minutes of Proceedlngs of 12-27-94 fld- Notice of motion by by pltfs to vacate judgment entered 10-15-94 taken under advisement. purs to to Rule 78. (CR-JOHNSON) ("IFLAND)

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER danying motion to vacate this Court's order of 10~5-94 Fld 11-19-98 (LIF"AND)

Documents

Case 3:85-cv-04401-MLC-TJB Document 235 Filed 10/03/06 Page … · Ltr. motion of Victor Parker to join in complaint as pltf., Ltr. motion of Abdallah Khaliq to join in complaint