Capital Budgeting RK 1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    1/54

    11

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    2/54

    22

    INTRODUCTION:

    For effective running of a business, management must

    know:

    where it intends to go , i.e. organizational objectives

    how it intends to accomplish its objective, i.e. plans

    whether individual plans fit in the overall

    organizational objective. i.e. coordination

    whether operations conform to the plan ofoperations relating to that period i.e. control

    Budgetary control is the device that a company

    uses for all these purposes.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    3/54

    IntroductionIntroduction

    A beer company is considering building a newA beer company is considering building a new

    brewery.brewery.

    An airline is deciding whether to add flights toAn airline is deciding whether to add flights to

    its schedule.its schedule. An engineer at a high-tech company hasAn engineer at a high-tech company has

    designed a new microchip and hopes todesigned a new microchip and hopes to

    encourage the company to manufacture and sellencourage the company to manufacture and sell

    it.it.

    A small college contemplates buying a newA small college contemplates buying a new

    photocopy machine.photocopy machine.

    A nonprofit museum is toying with the idea ofA nonprofit museum is toying with the idea of

    installing an education center for children.installing an education center for children.

    Newl weds dream of bu in a house.Newlyweds dream of buying a house.33

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    4/54

    IntroductionIntroduction

    What do these projects have in common? AllWhat do these projects have in common? All

    of them entail aof them entail a commitment of capitalcommitment of capital andand

    managerial effortmanagerial effort that may or may not bethat may or may not be

    justified by later performance.justified by later performance. A common set of tools can be applied toA common set of tools can be applied to

    assess these seemingly very differentassess these seemingly very different

    propositions.propositions.

    The financial analysis used to assess suchThe financial analysis used to assess suchprojects is known asprojects is known as capital budgeting.capital budgeting.

    How should a limited supply of capital andHow should a limited supply of capital and

    managerial talent be allocated among anmanagerial talent be allocated among an

    unlimited number of possible projects andunlimited number of possible projects and

    corporate initiatives?corporate initiatives?44

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    5/54

    Capital BudgetingCapital Budgeting

    Capital budgeting is the processCapital budgeting is the process

    of identifying, evaluating,of identifying, evaluating,

    planning, and financing anplanning, and financing anorganizations major investmentorganizations major investment

    projects.projects.

    Decisions to expand productionDecisions to expand production

    facilities, acquire new productionfacilities, acquire new productionmachinery, buy a new computer,machinery, buy a new computer,

    or remodel the office building areor remodel the office building are

    all examples of capital-all examples of capital-

    expenditure decisions.expenditure decisions.55

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    6/54

    Capital BudgetingCapital Budgeting

    Capital-budgeting decisions made nowCapital-budgeting decisions made now

    determine to a large degree howdetermine to a large degree how

    successful an organization will be insuccessful an organization will be in

    achieving its goals and objectives inachieving its goals and objectives in

    the years ahead.the years ahead.

    Capital budgeting plays an importantCapital budgeting plays an important

    role in the long-range success of manyrole in the long-range success of many

    organizations because of severalorganizations because of several

    characteristics that differentiate itcharacteristics that differentiate it

    from most other elements of thefrom most other elements of the66

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    7/54

    77

    BASIC FEATURES OF CAPITAL

    BUDGETING

    Capital budgeting decisions have long-term

    implications.

    These decisions involve substantial commitment of

    funds.

    These decisions are irreversible and require analysis

    of minute details.

    These decisions determine and affect the future

    growth of the firm.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    8/54

    Capital BudgetingCapital Budgeting

    Capital budgeting projects require relativelyCapital budgeting projects require relatively

    large commitments of resources. Majorlarge commitments of resources. Major

    projects, such as plant expansion orprojects, such as plant expansion or

    equipment replacement, may involveequipment replacement, may involveresource outlays in excess of annual netresource outlays in excess of annual net

    income.income.

    Relatively insignificant purchases are notRelatively insignificant purchases are not

    treated as capital budgeting projects even iftreated as capital budgeting projects even if

    the items purchased have long lives. Forthe items purchased have long lives. For

    example, the purchase of 100 calculators atexample, the purchase of 100 calculators at

    $15 each for use in the office would be$15 each for use in the office would be

    treated as a period expensetreated as a period expense

    by most firms, even though the calculatorsby most firms, even though the calculators88

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    9/54

    Capital BudgetingCapital Budgeting

    Most capital expenditure decisions are long-Most capital expenditure decisions are long-

    term commitments.term commitments.

    The projects last more than 1 year, with manyThe projects last more than 1 year, with many

    extending over 5, 10, or even 20 years.extending over 5, 10, or even 20 years.

    The longer the life of the project, the moreThe longer the life of the project, the more

    difficult it is to predict revenues, expenses,difficult it is to predict revenues, expenses,

    and cost savings.and cost savings.

    Capital-budgeting decisions are long-termCapital-budgeting decisions are long-term

    policy decisions and should reflect clearly anpolicy decisions and should reflect clearly an

    organizations policies on growth, marketing,organizations policies on growth, marketing,

    industry share, social responsibility, and otherindustry share, social responsibility, and other

    goalsgoals 99

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    10/54

    1010

    CAPITAL BUDGETING DECISION INVOLVES

    THREE STEPS:

    1. Estimation of costs and benefits of a proposal or of

    each alternative.

    2. Estimation of the required rate of return, i.e., the cost

    of capital

    3. Selection and applying the decision criterion.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    11/54

    Project Cash FlowsProject Cash Flows

    A project creates wealth if it generates cash flowsA project creates wealth if it generates cash flows

    over time that are worth more in present-valueover time that are worth more in present-value

    terms than the initial setup cost. For example,terms than the initial setup cost. For example,

    suppose a brewery costs $10 million to build, butsuppose a brewery costs $10 million to build, butonce built it generates a stream of cash flows thatonce built it generates a stream of cash flows that

    is worth $11 million.is worth $11 million.

    Building the brewery would create $1 million ofBuilding the brewery would create $1 million of

    new wealth.new wealth. If there were no other proposed projects thatIf there were no other proposed projects that

    would create more wealth than this, then the beerwould create more wealth than this, then the beer

    company would be well advised to build the newcompany would be well advised to build the new

    brewery.brewery. 1111

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    12/54

    1212

    DECISION CRITERIA

    TECHNIQUES OF EVALUATION

    Traditional or Time-adjusted or

    Non-discounting Discounted cash flows

    1. Payback period 1. Net Present Value

    2. Accounting Rate of 2. Profitability Index

    Return 3. Internal Rate of Return

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    13/54

    Proposed ProjectProposed Project

    Bibba is evaluating a new projectBibba is evaluating a new project

    for her firm, Bibbafor her firm, Bibba Bakery (BB)Bakery (BB)..

    She has determined that theShe has determined that the

    after-tax cash flows for the projectafter-tax cash flows for the project

    will bewill be $10,000; $12,000;$10,000; $12,000;

    $15,000; $10,000; and $7,000,$15,000; $10,000; and $7,000,

    respectively, for each of therespectively, for each of theYearsYears

    1 through 51 through 5. The initial cash. The initial cash

    outlay will beoutlay will be $40,000$40,000..1313

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    14/54

    1414

    TRADITIONAL OR NON-DISCOUNTING

    TECHNIQUES

    I .PAYBACK PERIOD:

    # The payback period is defined as the number of

    years required for the proposals cumulative cash inflows to beequal to its cash outflows.

    # The payback period is the length of time required

    to recover the initial cost of the project.# The payback period may be suitable if the firm

    has limited funds available and has no ability or willingness to

    raise additional funds.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    15/54

    Payback Period (PBP)Payback Period (PBP)

    PBPPBP is the period of timeis the period of time

    required for the cumulativerequired for the cumulative

    expected cash flows from anexpected cash flows from aninvestment project to equal theinvestment project to equal the

    initial cash outflow.initial cash outflow.

    PBPPBP is the period of timeis the period of time

    required for the cumulativerequired for the cumulative

    expected cash flows from anexpected cash flows from aninvestment project to equal theinvestment project to equal the

    initial cash outflow.initial cash outflow.

    0 1 2 3 4 5

    -40 K 10 K 12 K 15 K 10 K 7

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    16/54

    (c)10 K 22 K 37 K 47 K 54 K

    Payback Solution (#1)Payback Solution (#1)

    PBPPBP == aa + (+ ( bb -- cc ) /) / dd

    == 33 + (+ (4040 -- 3737) /) / 1010

    == 33 + (+ (33) /) / 1010

    == 3.3 Years3.3 Years

    0 1 2 3 4 5

    -40 K 10 K 12 K 15 K 10 K 7

    CumulativeInflows

    (a)

    (b) (d)

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    17/54

    PBP AcceptancePBP Acceptance

    CriterionCriterion

    Yes!Yes! The firm will receive back theThe firm will receive back theinitial cash outlay in less than 3.5initial cash outlay in less than 3.5

    years. [years. [3.3 Years3.3 Years

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    18/54

    PBP StrengthsPBP Strengths

    and Weaknessesand Weaknesses

    StrengthsStrengths::

    Easy to use andEasy to use and

    understandunderstand

    Easier toEasier to

    forecastforecast ST thanST than

    LT flowsLT flows

    WeaknessesWeaknesses::

    Does not considerDoes not consider

    cash flows beyondcash flows beyond

    the PBPthe PBP

    Cutoff period isCutoff period is

    subjectivesubjective

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    19/54

    Internal Rate of ReturnInternal Rate of Return

    (IRR)(IRR)IRRIRR is the discount rate that equatesis the discount rate that equates

    the present value of the future netthe present value of the future net

    cash flows from an investmentcash flows from an investmentproject with the projects initial cashproject with the projects initial cash

    outflow (ICO).outflow (ICO).

    CF1 CF2 CFn

    (1+IRR)1 (1+IRR)2 (1+IRR)n+ . . . ++ICO =

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    20/54

    IRR Solution (TryIRR Solution (Try

    10%)10%)$40,000$40,000 == $10,000(PVIF$10,000(PVIF10%10%,,11) +) +

    $12,000(PVIF$12,000(PVIF10%10%,,22) +) + $15,000(PVIF$15,000(PVIF10%10%,,33) +) +

    $10,000(PVIF$10,000(PVIF10%10%,,44) +) + $ 7,000(PVIF$ 7,000(PVIF10%10%,,55))$40,000$40,000 == $10,000(.909) + $12,000(.826)$10,000(.909) + $12,000(.826)

    ++ $15,000(.751) +$15,000(.751) +

    $10,000(.683) +$10,000(.683) + $$7,000(.621)7,000(.621)

    $40,000$40,000 == $9,090 + $9,912 + $11,265 +$9,090 + $9,912 + $11,265 +

    $6,830 + $4,347$6,830 + $4,347

    == $41,444$41,444 [[Rate is tooRate is too

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    21/54

    IRR Solution (TryIRR Solution (Try

    15%)15%)$40,000$40,000 == $10,000(PVIF$10,000(PVIF15%15%,,11) +) +

    $12,000(PVIF$12,000(PVIF15%15%,,22) +) + $15,000(PVIF$15,000(PVIF15%15%,,33))

    + $10,000(PVIF+ $10,000(PVIF15%15%,,44) +) + $ 7,000(PVIF$ 7,000(PVIF15%15%,,55))$40,000$40,000 == $10,000(.870) + $12,000(.756)$10,000(.870) + $12,000(.756)

    ++ $15,000(.658) +$15,000(.658) +

    $10,000(.572) +$10,000(.572) +

    $$

    7,000(.497)7,000(.497)

    $40,000$40,000 == $8,700 + $9,072 + $9,870 +$8,700 + $9,072 + $9,870 +

    $5,720 + $3,479$5,720 + $3,479

    == $36,841$36,841 [[Rate is tooRate is too

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    22/54

    .10.10 $41,444$41,444

    .05.05 ICOICO $40,000$40,000 $4,603$4,603

    .15.15 $36,841$36,841

    ($1,444)(0.05)($1,444)(0.05)

    $4,603$4,603

    IRR SolutionIRR Solution

    (Interpolate)(Interpolate)$1,444X

    X = X = .0157

    IRR = .10 + .0157 = .1157 or 11.57%

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    23/54

    2323

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    24/54

    Discount rateDiscount rate

    TheThe discount ratediscount rate can mean ancan mean an

    interest rate a centralinterest rate a central

    bank charges depository institutions thatbank charges depository institutions that

    borrow reserves from it, for example forborrow reserves from it, for example forthe use of the Federalthe use of the Federal

    Reserve's discount window.Reserve's discount window.

    the same as interest rate; the termthe same as interest rate; the term"discount" does not refer to the common"discount" does not refer to the common

    meaning of the word, but to themeaning of the word, but to the

    meaning in computations of presentmeaning in computations of present

    value, e.g. net presentvalue, e.g. net present2424

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    25/54

    IRR AcceptanceIRR Acceptance

    CriterionCriterion

    No! The firm will receive 11.57%No! The firm will receive 11.57%for each dollar invested in thisfor each dollar invested in this

    project at a cost of 13%. [ IRR

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    26/54

    $15,000 $10,000 $7,000

    IRR SolutionIRR Solution

    $10,000 $12,000

    (1+IRR)1

    (1+IRR)2

    Find the interest rate (Find the interest rate (IRRIRR) that causes) that causes

    the discounted cash flows to equalthe discounted cash flows to equal

    $40,000$40,000..

    + +

    ++$40,000 =

    (1+IRR)3 (1+IRR)4 (1+IRR)5

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    27/54

    2727

    DISCOUNTED CASH FLOWS OR TIME

    ADJUSTED TECHNIQUES

    These are based upon the fact that the cash flows occurring at

    different point of time are not having same economic worth.

    I.NET PRESENT VALUE (NPV) METHOD:

    The NPV of an investment proposal may be defined as the sum

    of the present values of all the cash inflows less the sum of present

    values of all the cash outflows associated with the proposal.

    The decision rule is Accept the proposal if its NPV is positive

    and reject the proposal if the NPV is negative.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    28/54

    Net Present ValueNet Present Value

    (NPV)(NPV) (NPV) is the difference between the(NPV) is the difference between the

    setup cost of a project and the value ofsetup cost of a project and the value of

    the project once it is set up.the project once it is set up. If that difference is positive, then theIf that difference is positive, then the

    NPV is positive and the project createsNPV is positive and the project creates

    wealth.wealth.

    If a firm must choose from severalIf a firm must choose from severalproposed projects, the one with theproposed projects, the one with the

    highest NPV will create the most wealth,highest NPV will create the most wealth,

    and so it should be the one adopted.and so it should be the one adopted. 2828

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    29/54

    Net Present ValueNet Present Value For example, suppose the car company can eitherFor example, suppose the car company can either

    build the new plant or, alternatively, can introducebuild the new plant or, alternatively, can introduce

    a new product a mid segment car.a new product a mid segment car.

    There is not enough managerial talent to overseeThere is not enough managerial talent to oversee

    more than one new project, or maybe there are notmore than one new project, or maybe there are not

    enough funds to start both.enough funds to start both.

    Let us assume that both projects create wealth:Let us assume that both projects create wealth:

    The NPV of the new plant is $1 million, and theThe NPV of the new plant is $1 million, and the

    NPV of the new-product project is $500,000.NPV of the new-product project is $500,000.

    If it could, the car company should undertake bothIf it could, the car company should undertake both

    projects; but since it has to choose, building theprojects; but since it has to choose, building the

    new plant would be the right option because it hasnew plant would be the right option because it has

    the higher NPV.the higher NPV.

    CAPITAL BUDGETING PRACTICES IN INDIA

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    30/54

    3030

    CAPITAL BUDGETING PRACTICES IN INDIA

    Capital budgeting decisions are undertaken at the topmanagement level and are planned in advance. The Corporates

    follow mostly top-down approach in this regard.

    Discounted cash flow techniques are more popular now.

    High growth firms use IRR more frequently whereas Payback

    period is more widely used by small firms.

    PI technique is used more by public sector units than by

    private sector units.

    Capital budgeting decisions are of paramountimportance as they affect the profitability of a firm, and

    are the major determinants of its efficiency and

    competing power.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    31/54

    ADVANTAGES ANDADVANTAGES AND

    DISADVANTAGES OF IRR AND NPVDISADVANTAGES OF IRR AND NPV

    A number of surveys have shown that, inA number of surveys have shown that, in

    practice, the IRR method is more popularpractice, the IRR method is more popular

    than the NPV approach.than the NPV approach.

    The reason may be that the IRR isThe reason may be that the IRR isstraightforward, but it uses cash flows andstraightforward, but it uses cash flows and

    recognizes the time value of money, likerecognizes the time value of money, like

    the NPV.the NPV.

    In other words, while the IRR method isIn other words, while the IRR method is

    easy and understandable, it does not haveeasy and understandable, it does not have

    the drawbacks of the payback period,the drawbacks of the payback period,

    which ignores the time value of money.which ignores the time value of money.3131

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    32/54

    ADVANTAGES ANDADVANTAGES AND

    DISADVANTAGES OF IRR ANDDISADVANTAGES OF IRR AND

    NPVNPV The main problem with the IRR method isThe main problem with the IRR method isthat it often gives unrealistic rates ofthat it often gives unrealistic rates of

    return.return.

    Suppose the cutoff rate is 11% and theSuppose the cutoff rate is 11% and theIRR is calculated as 40%. Does this meanIRR is calculated as 40%. Does this mean

    that the management shouldthat the management should

    immediately accept the project becauseimmediately accept the project because

    its IRR is 40%.its IRR is 40%. The answer isThe answer is nono! An IRR of 40%! An IRR of 40%

    assumes that a firm has the opportunityassumes that a firm has the opportunity

    to reinvest future cash flows at 40%. Ifto reinvest future cash flows at 40%. If

    past experience and the economypast experience and the economy3232

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    33/54

    ADVANTAGES ANDADVANTAGES AND

    DISADVANTAGES OF IRR ANDDISADVANTAGES OF IRR AND

    NPVNPV Another problem with the IRR method is thatAnother problem with the IRR method is thatit may give different rates of return.it may give different rates of return.

    Suppose there are two discount rates (twoSuppose there are two discount rates (two

    IRRs) that make the present value equal toIRRs) that make the present value equal tothe initial investment. In this case, whichthe initial investment. In this case, which

    rate should be used for comparison with therate should be used for comparison with the

    cutoff rate? The purpose of this question iscutoff rate? The purpose of this question is

    not to resolve the cases where there arenot to resolve the cases where there aredifferent IRRs.different IRRs.

    The purpose is to let you know that the IRRThe purpose is to let you know that the IRR

    method, despite its popularity in the businessmethod, despite its popularity in the business3333

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    34/54

    WHY THE NPV AND IRRWHY THE NPV AND IRR

    SOMETIMES SELECTSOMETIMES SELECT

    DIFFERENT PROJECTSDIFFERENT PROJECTS When comparing two projects, the use ofWhen comparing two projects, the use of

    the NPV and the IRR methods may givethe NPV and the IRR methods may give

    different results. A project selecteddifferent results. A project selectedaccording to the NPV may be rejected ifaccording to the NPV may be rejected if

    the IRR method is used.the IRR method is used.

    Suppose there are two alternativeSuppose there are two alternative

    projects, X and Y. The initial investmentprojects, X and Y. The initial investmentin each project is $2,500. Project X willin each project is $2,500. Project X will

    provide annual cash flows of $500 for theprovide annual cash flows of $500 for the

    next 10 years. Project Y has annual cashnext 10 years. Project Y has annual cash

    flows of $100, $200, $300, $400, $500,flows of $100, $200, $300, $400, $500,3434

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    35/54

    3535

    Using the trial and error method you findUsing the trial and error method you find

    that the IRR of Project X is 17% and thethat the IRR of Project X is 17% and the

    IRR of Project Y is around 13%.IRR of Project Y is around 13%. If you use the IRR, Project X should beIf you use the IRR, Project X should be

    preferred because its IRR is 4% morepreferred because its IRR is 4% more

    than the IRR of Project Y.than the IRR of Project Y.

    But what happens to your decision if theBut what happens to your decision if theNPV method is used?NPV method is used?

    The answer is that the decision willThe answer is that the decision will

    change depending on the discount ratechange depending on the discount rate

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    36/54

    3636

    For instance, at a 5% discount rate,For instance, at a 5% discount rate,

    Project Y has a higher NPV than XProject Y has a higher NPV than X

    does. But at a discount rate of 8%,does. But at a discount rate of 8%,Project X is preferred because of aProject X is preferred because of a

    higher NPV.higher NPV.

    The purpose of this numericalThe purpose of this numerical

    example is to illustrate an importantexample is to illustrate an importantdistinction: The use of the IRR alwaysdistinction: The use of the IRR always

    leads to the selection of the sameleads to the selection of the same

    project, whereas project selectionproject, whereas project selection

    using the NPV method depends on theusing the NPV method depends on the

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    37/54

    3737

    II .ACCOUNTING RATE OF RETURN (OR) AVERAGE

    RATE OF RETURN

    (ARR)

    # The ARR may be defined as the annualized net

    income earned on the average funds invested in a project.

    # The annual returns of a project are expressed as a

    percentage of the net investment in the project.

    COMPUTATION OF ARR:

    Average Annual profit (after tax)

    ARR = x 100

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    38/54

    Accounting Rate of Return (Or) AverageAccounting Rate of Return (Or) Average

    Rate Of Return (ARR)Rate Of Return (ARR)

    A comparison of the profitA comparison of the profit

    generated by the investment withgenerated by the investment with

    the cost of the investmentthe cost of the investment Denominator is Book Value ofDenominator is Book Value of

    Fixed InvestmentFixed Investment

    3838

    A ti R t f R tAcco nting Rate of Ret rn

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    39/54

    Accounting Rate of ReturnAccounting Rate of Return

    (Or) Average Rate Of Return(Or) Average Rate Of Return

    (ARR)(ARR)Year Book Value of

    Fixed InvestmentProfit After Tax

    1 90000 20000

    2 80000 22000

    3 70000 24000

    4 60000 26000

    5 50000 28000

    3939

    A ti R t f R tAccounting Rate of Return

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    40/54

    Accounting Rate of ReturnAccounting Rate of Return

    (Or) Average Rate Of Return(Or) Average Rate Of Return

    (ARR)(ARR) 1/ 5 ( 20000+ 22000+ 24000+26000+1/ 5 ( 20000+ 22000+ 24000+26000+

    28000)/ 1/5( 90000+80000+70000+28000)/ 1/5( 90000+80000+70000+

    60000+ 50000)60000+ 50000) = 34 per cent= 34 per cent

    4040

    A ti R t f R tAccounting Rate of Return

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    41/54

    Accounting Rate of ReturnAccounting Rate of Return

    (Or) Average Rate Of Return(Or) Average Rate Of Return

    (ARR)(ARR) Shows ProfitabilityShows Profitability

    This method allows comparison inThis method allows comparison in

    betweenbetween Based on Accounting Profit &Based on Accounting Profit &

    Income streams not time relatedIncome streams not time related

    Doesnt take into account timeDoesnt take into account timevalue of money.value of money.

    4141

    Key considerations forKey considerations for

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    42/54

    Key considerations forKey considerations for

    firms in consideringfirms in considering

    useuse Ease of use/degree of simplicity requiredEase of use/degree of simplicity required

    Degree of accuracy requiredDegree of accuracy required

    Extent to which future cash flows can beExtent to which future cash flows can bemeasured accuratelymeasured accurately

    Extent to which future interest rateExtent to which future interest ratemovements can be factored in andmovements can be factored in and

    predictedpredicted Necessity of factoring in effects of inflationNecessity of factoring in effects of inflation

    4242

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    43/54

    Payback Accounting Net present Internal rate

    period rate of return value of return

    Basis of Cash Actual Cash flows Cash flows

    measurement flows income Profitability Profitability

    Measure Number Percent Rs Percent

    expressed as of years Amount

    Easy to Easy to Considers time Considers time

    Understand Understand value of money value of money

    Strengths Allows Allows Accommodates Allows

    comparison comparison different risk comparisons

    across projects across projects levels over of dissimilar

    a project's life projects

    Doesn't Doesn't Difficult to Doesn't reflect

    consider time consider time compare varying riskvalue of money value of money dissimilar levels over the

    Limitations projects project's life

    Doesn't Doesn't give

    consider cash annual rates

    flows after over the lifepayback period of a project

    Comparing MethodsComparing Methods

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    44/54

    4444

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    45/54

    4545

    WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT

    Working capital management is concerned with the

    problems that arise in managing the current assets,

    current liabilities and the interrelationships between

    them.

    GOAL:

    To manage the firms current assets and liabilities in

    such a way that a satisfactory level of working capital

    is maintained.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    46/54

    4646

    CONCEPTS:

    GROSS WORKING CAPITAL The current assets which

    represent the proportion of investment that circulates

    from one form to another in the ordinary conduct of

    business.

    NET WORKING CAPITAL The portion of current

    assets financed with long term funds orcurrent assets current liabilities

    PURPOSE

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    47/54

    4747

    PURPOSE:

    The NWC is necessary because the cash outflows and inflows do not

    coincide.

    The purpose of NWC is to measure the liquidity of the firm.

    DETERMINING FINANCING MIX:

    Financing mix is the choice of sources of financing of current assets.

    SOURCES OF ASSET FINANCE:

    1. Short term sources (Current liabilities)

    2. Long term sources (Share capital, long term borrowings).

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    48/54

    4848

    INSTRUMENTS OF SHORT TERM

    FINANCING

    Trade Credit

    Bill Discounting

    Inter Corporate Deposits

    Public deposits

    Commercial papers

    Factoring

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    49/54

    4949

    APPROACHES TO DETERMINE

    FINANCING MIX:

    1. Hedging approach

    2. Conservative approach

    3. Trade off between the above

    mentioned two approaches.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    50/54

    5050

    HEDGING APPROACH (MATCHING

    APPROACH):

    This is the process of matching maturities of debt with the

    maturities of financial needs.

    According to Hedging approach, the permanentportion

    of funds required should be financed with long term funds

    and the seasonal portion withshort term funds.

    Under this approach working capital = 0 since CA are not financed

    by long term funds (CA = CL).

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    51/54

    5151

    CONSERVATIVE FINANCING APPROACH:

    This is a strategy by which the firm finances all funds

    requirement, with long term funds and uses short termfunds for emergencies or unexpected outflows.

    TRADE OFF BETWEEN HEDGING ANDCONSERVATIVE APPROACHES:

    One possible trade off could be equal to the average of the

    minimum and maximum monthly requirements of funds

    during the given period of time. This level of requirement

    of funds may be financed through long run sources and

    for any additional financing need, short termfunds may be

    used.

    FACTORS DETERMINING AMOUNT OF WORKING CAPITAL

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    52/54

    5252

    Purchase Payment for Sell product Receive

    resources resource purchase on credit cash

    Inventory Receivableconversion conversion

    period period

    Payables Cash

    period Conversion

    period

    Operating cycle

    The length of the operating cycle is the most

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    53/54

    5353

    The length of the operating cycle is the most

    widely used method to determine working capital need.

    The longer the production cycle, the larger is the

    working capital need or vice versa.

    Manufacturing and trading enterprises require fairly

    large amount of working capital to support their

    production and sales activity. Service enterprises like

    hotels, restaurants etc., need less working capital.

    During boom conditions need for working capital is

    more.

    Growth industries and firms need more workingcapital.

    Working capital requirement are to be determined

    on the basis of cash cost i.e excluding depreciation.

  • 8/22/2019 Capital Budgeting RK 1

    54/54

    5454